All language subtitles for Cold.Case.Forensics.S01E02.The.Murder.of.Lynette.White.1080p.HDTV.H264-DARKFLiX

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

NICOLA WALKER: They are the murders that shook the nation.

REPORTER: The savagery of this murder

has shocked even the most hardened detectives.

REPORTER: He was attacked by this bus stop, by a racist mob.

REPORTER: This flat was the scene of a horrific killing.

For decades, the truth lay hidden, and the killers evaded justice.

Until one woman took up the hunt.

Angela has solved some of the biggest cases in British history.

Dr Angela Gallop is a world-leading forensic scientist.

I've clone a lot of work

with forensic scientists, but she's the best.

She led the team and set the standard.

She put the bar where it was.

She's helped solve hundreds of high-profile cold-cases,

finding clues where others have failed.

Without the forensic input,

the murder would never have been solved.

Now, Dr Gallop is opening her extraordinary casebook

to reveal the forensic secrets

behind some of the country's most infamous crimes,

and how they caught the killers

who thought they'd got away with murder.

It's a puzzle that you have to solve.

Every contact leaves a trace.

It's just whether or not we are clever enough to find it.

Tonight, a murder where the traces of the killer went undiscovered

for over a decade.

She was a young girl who was brutally murdered.

How did Angela and her team use ground-breaking forensics

to finally solve one of Britain's most controversial cases?

You talk about A Nightmare On Elm Street,

well, this was a nightmare on James Street.

The murder of Lynette White was a brutal murder.

There was over 50 stab wounds,

and she was left lying in what was pretty much a desolate flat,

in the clocks area.

The crime scene was on top of a betting shop.

Ancl it was a small flat.

It had a dirty mattress on the floor.

It had a cardboard box with used condoms.

Not much else in the room.

There was this arterial spray of blood on the wall.

A sad scene, a sad end.

She was quite a bubbly little girl, very pretty.

Generally nice, nice kid, nice person.

She'd had problems from early childhood,

and there was never guidance in her life.

Lynette White was only 20 years old.

She'd had a difficult upbringing

and was working as a prostitute in the docks area of Cardiff.

It's easy to label people without actually knowing them.

You don't know what has coerced them into doing things.

You don't know anything about their life.

She was a young girl who was brutally murdered.

The investigation into Lynette White's murder

was to be tainted by accusations of racism and corruption.

Witnesses were bullied by police,

and a false confession led to one of the worst miscarriages of justice

in British legal history.

A suspect with bloodstained clothes

who was seen near the flat was white,

but all the men the police arrested were Black.

They would become known by campaigners as the Cardiff Five.

You know, when they're telling you something like this and, you know,

a girl had been stabbed 50 to 70 times...

You know, "Don't put this on me."

But they did. That's what they wanted to do.

There was nothing we could do.

There wasn't a shred of evidence connecting forensically

these people to the murder.

Something had gone wrong.

With their convictions overturned, the failure to catch the real killer

was a stain on South Wales Police

and left a shadow hanging over the community.

In 1999, 11 years after Lynette's murder,

a fresh team of detectives from the force

launched a last-ditch attempt to find the real killer.

That's where we turned to what we saw has been the best in the field.

"Angela Gallop, how can you help us?"

And the work that Angela Gallop and her team would do

to help solve Lynette's murder

was to change the way forensic science is used

to crack seemingly unsolvable crimes.

You learn something new in every case, but, my goodness,

we learnt a lot from this particular one.

I'll never forget the first time

that I walked into a forensic science lab.

I noticed that there was this orangey-red staining

inside a fume cupboard and then on the side wall and bench next to it.

Ancl I remember thinking to myself, "My goodness, is that blood?"

You know, "What is it what they do in here?"

You know, "Do they have body parts in here? What on earth is it?"

Ancl then I noticed that there was a washing line across one corner

at the back of the lab,

on which obviously bloodstained clothing was hanging,

and this sort of kind of made the whole thing worse.

Ancl I, in that laboratory, I was to be the first woman

who actually did the full range of forensic activities,

including going to court.

I don't think my boss was very keen on it at the time.

And I remember the very first clay I was there,

he wasted no time in telling me

that he didn't really believe in women doing this kind of work.

But as ever, I think I just thought to myself,

"Well, I'll show you. I'll show you what I can do."

By 1999, Angela had helped solve hundreds of high-profile crimes,

but the 1988 murder of Lynette White

was to be her first major cold case.

Angela knew that, at its heart,

there was not only an intensely complicated forensic puzzle,

but also the shadow of a terrible miscarriage of justice.

I was very angry with the police investigation

because, initially, when Lynette's body was found,

there was a photo fit.

And there was lots of news articles about...

A man was found outside 7 James Street,

and he was in a dishevelled state with blood on his hands.

Here we are, looking for this white man...

...and then suddenly, I'm in a police station with five Black men.

It was just amazing and unbelievable

how one white man can suddenly turn into five Black men.

In 1990, john Actie and his cousin, Ronnie Actie,

were acquitted of taking part in the killing.

But they had spent almost two years in custody

on remand, awaiting trial.

I am bitter. I am broke.

The Actie cousins were free.

Justice again, justice again.

But the others,

Yusef Abdul la hi, Stephen Miller, and Tony Paris,

were found guilty.

The Cardiff Five, as their supporters had called them,

now became the Cardiff Three.

REPORTER: How do the family feel now?

How do you think they feel? What do you mean how they feel?

Is that justice?

But the convictions stood for just two years.

In 1992, the Court of Appeal ruled

that a gross miscarriage of justice had taken place.

Lacking evidence,

false confessions had been forced by police in bullying interviews.

The Cardiff Three were released.

There's so much anger and upset,

and, yes, it's a sheer miscarriage of justice, sheer miscarriage.

If they had forensic, believe you me, we would've had it.

There wasn't any, and that's it.

This was the case which faced Angela Gallop.

Men wrongly accused, a woman's family without justice,

and from the original investigation,

not a trace of forensics to identify a suspect.

A human tragedy centred on the murder in a flat

in Cardiff's James Street.

I think when I'm getting to grips with a particular case,

particularly a complex one with lots of moving parts in it,

I've sort of a rather pictorial mind, and I love diagrams of things,

and I'm often just sketching out connections between things.

I find it much easier to do that and then, at a glance,

I can bring myself back to the totality of the case.

Cos it's really important when you're doing these cases,

at one level, you're looking down at the case from above.

So, you're looking at all the different component parts of it

and all the different, you know, potential links.

And then the next moment,

you're right down in the weeds, right down actually, saying,

"We'll look for that particular thing, for this particular thing."

So, you're right down there

and all the time, you're swapping between the two,

you're swapping between your diagram, this overarching view...

...and then the minutiae of the work that you're doing

at that particular moment.

I find diagrams a really good way of kind of controlling that process.

In this particular case, the first thing we were asked to do

was to review the original investigation of the case.

Ancl so that's what we did.

We looked at everything that had been clone by the original scientists

and just gave our opinion about that.

Ancl I think, looking back at that, the main thing that struck me

was that they had a sketchy understanding

of the blood patterns at the flat,

and it had told them enough to know where the attack had started

and probably where Lynette's throat had been cut.

Ancl then also the fact that her body had been moved,

where probably the bulk of the attack then took place.

But it didn't really tell you anything

about how the attacker might have got out afterwards.

If you know what happened between a victim and suspect,

and the kind of contact

that they are likely to have had with each other,

it'll tell you where to look for what sorts of traces

of that contact between them.

There was a lot of blood at the murder scene.

Most belonged to Lynette.

There was, though, some which belonged to another person.

It appeared to match a female friend of Lynette's

who had falsely testified to being a witness to the murder.

But there was one test,

which was carried out about a year after the murder,

that suggested that the blood had to belong to someone else.

One of the many DNA type tests

that were clone subsequent to that initial investigation

indicated that this blood, this foreign blood,

looked as though it had come from a man, not a woman.

It gave a result indicating that it contained the Y chromosome,

which you only find in men or males.

That was certainly something that we noticed at an early stage.

If this foreign blood belonged to a man, who was he?

And with more than a decade now passed since the murder,

how would the forensic team find new evidence to track him down?

We knew it wasn't those ones who were arrested.

We were looking for somebody absolutely clean.

Ancl my main goal initially

was to ensure that we developed a DNA profile.

So, the key thing about this case

was to find some more of this foreign blood.

Blood that hadn't come from Lynette, and might conceivably be connected,

and might conceivably have come from the offender

because with so many stab wounds, such a violent and prolonged attack,

it is not that unusual for the offender to injure themselves.

So, that was the natural starting point.

NICOLA WALKER: Forensic scientist Dr Angela Gallop

is an expert in cracking cold-cases.

In 1999, she was asked to find new evidence

in the murder of Lynette White in Cardiff, more than a decade before.

The case files noted that a great deal of Lynette's blood

had been found on the walls of the flat in which she died.

There had also been a small amount of blood

from an unidentified stranger.

But the forensic searches of the crime scene back in 1988

had left Angela's team with a major problem.

The police had clone an excellent job

in looking for fingerprints throughout the flat

and had sprayed a lot of the wallpaper with this chemical,

called ninhydrin, which brings up fingerprints

and it turns them from something you can't really see

to sort of a bright, purplish colour,

so it makes them really visible.

So, they'd sprayed all of the wallpaper

where we had these blood patterns and a lot of the blood.

Ancl unfortunately, ninhydrin completely destroys DNA...

SHE LAUGHS

...so you can't then analyse it properly.

The focus for the original investigation would've been

blood grouping and fingerprints.

DNA wasn't in the game.

To uncover traces of the killer,

the forensic team would have to find blood

which had not been affected by the search for fingerprints.

Although more than a decade had passed since the murder,

the hunt had to begin at the flat.

The first thing you need to do is to understand as much as you can

about what happened at the crime scene...

...and it's very, very useful often to go back to the crime scene

to get that geography and topography of it,

so you can imagine what it was like...

...because sometimes there are clues in there.

There might be little hints of something

which they didn't follow up at the time

because maybe they didn't just notice them,

or maybe they didn't have the techniques

to be able to do it at that time.

We went there in the evening, in the dark...

...so that it would sort of, er, replicate the murder scene.

I had all the crime scene photographs as well,

so I could kind of picture the crime scene.

Ancl even though the place had been painted twice

in the intervening years,

I could picture what the bloodstain had been like

at the time of the crime.

She was looking at it, erm, totally from the science side of it.

There was lots of measurements taken.

When we left that flat, she had a good idea of that scene,

and that was the start of where we went

and discussed on where we thought we could find some evidence.

Angela took her measurements and notes

and used the bloodstained wallpaper from the flat

to reconstruct the crime scene.

So, that's three... This is... This is right by the bed.

OK. This one.

She worked with her colleague, April Robson,

to analyse what the patterns told them about the attack,

and where they might be able to search for fresh evidence.

20 years on, Angela and April are re-enacting their experiment.

When we came along, trying to understand the scene, we thought,

"One of the best ways of doing that is through all the blood patterns

"that are captured on these wallpaper strips.

"So, what if we recreate the crime scene with these wallpaper strips?"

And so April and I got a whole set of office dividers

together in a large room,

and we erected them in roughly the same shape and size

as the original flat had been in.

Ancl then we stuck up the bits of wallpaper on the dividers.

And in this way, we could recreate the crime scene.

Angela is extremely different to any reporting forensic scientist

that I've ever come across before.

Yes, somewhere like that cos we've got to get the other two in as well.

She definitely had ideas for developing new ways of thinking.

Let's just have a look. Ah, this looks like something.

I'd never encountered anything like this before.

When she first talked to us about her interpretation of the scene...

...it was like something from a film.

It was compelling.

By using the scene photographs,

and the position of Lynette's body within the scene,

we tried to sort of identify

how somebody would've maybe moved about within the scene

to decide which areas to target for DNA.

You've got this patch of blood staining,

and then there was that little alcove, wasn't there,

beyond the chimney breast?

I think this was the chimney breast here, wasn't it? Yeah.

Ancl then there was a bed here, the single bed. Yeah.

Ancl that was the only thing that there was in the room.

I think this is where the attack started

and where some of the worst injuries that Lynette received

were inflicted.

When your artery is breached,

you often get these very heavy drops of blood, which are then...

The sort of... The splashes, the stains, are too heavy.

They've got too much blood in them

to remain as distinct sort of shapes, oval shapes,

so you get these runs of blood that come off them.

Ancl that's exactly what happens with arterial spurting.

We know it was quite a frenzied attack

because of Lynette's injuries... Mm.

...and we knew that somebody was bleeding.

So this, all this, could be part of the attacker's blood. Mm.

It's a reflection of the fact it was a very dynamic attack,

and it looks as though she certainly tried to fight him off.

Doing this sort of analysis that Angela Gallop was excellent on,

on describing where the deposits of evidence were

and where the impact of acts would have come to that.

That's crime scene interpretation.

She, by looking at this placement of the blood,

was even to tell the story of what would've happened

with the assailant.

That was extremely powerful.

It's relatively easy,

after the blood from the victim has started to flow

and has coated the knife, the handle, and the blade,

for the offender's hand to slip down off the handle

onto the cutting edge of the blade,

and then their blood can then get scattered around at the scene.

The spots here all look like cast-off blood,

so they've been cast off something which is bleeding

or something with a lot of wet blood on it.

So that would either be Lynette,

but we suspected in this case that, actually, if we were lucky,

we might be able to find some more

of this potentially offender-type blood.

And so anything which could have intercepted a droplet of blood

from him would be great, that hadn't been treated for fingerprints.

It was really critical.

We would look at the crime scene photographs,

we had the crime scene there.

Ancl we knew the position of the body where it was found.

So, it was that context.

"Well, what's near it?" What was near it?

From the scene photographs,

we knew that the right shoe was sort of down in this sort of location.

And, interestingly, that was where the cellophane was recovered.

It was a top of a cigarette packet, which potentially is interesting

because there'd never been any talk of anybody smoking in the flat.

There was one particular stain on that cellophane

amongst all the contact smeared staining,

one particular round stain

that could conceivably be from the offender

because it was cast off blood.

It had been blood created into a droplet

that then flew through the air and landed on the cellophane,

as it can land on the wall and produce a directional splash

or if it lands head-on, it'll produce a round spot.

So, terribly important understanding blood patterns

to give you a clue of what's happened here,

but give you a clue, too, where to look for certain blood stains,

or blood stains from certain people.

The cellophane wrapper showed up in the crime scene photographs,

but had previously been deemed so insignificant

that it had been ignored.

Until now.

"Have we got that? Have we photographed that?"

We had it.

We'd photographed it. We'd never examined it.

Ancl that's where Cellophane Man started.

Angela decided to try and look

to see if there was anything on that cellophane

that could give us a DNA profile.

I remember her showing me the photos

of the blood staining on the cellophane

and her pointing out a particular stain

that she would really like to be DNA-tested.

We DNA-profiled that, and we got a nearly full male profile from it.

Because the foreign blood, our foreign blood,

was first identified on the cellophane,

we called him Cellophane Man.

It was a massive breakthrough.

But of course, life being what it is,

once you get something, you want a bit more, don't you?

I thought, "Right, I want it now. I want to know who this is.

"Cellophane Man. We are looking for Cellophane Man.

"That's the guy!"

NICOLA WALKER: The murder of Lynette White had remained unsolved

for more than a decade

when cold case forensic expert Dr Angela Gallop

was brought in to support a new police investigation.

After reconstructing the crime scene,

the team got its first breakthrough.

Cellophane from a cigarette wrapper found near Lynette's body

had been examined, and revealed the DNA of the prime suspect.

The investigators dubbed him Cellophane Man.

Detectives now had to test the Cellophane Man profile

against the DNA of the five men originally charged with the crime.

This was a difficulty that we... that we had.

They've been affected by this case.

We had to make sure that they didn't think

that we were looking at them again.

South Wales Police are evil. SHOUTING: No justice!

No justice! Evil beyond belief.

We felt that some of the police still felt that

the Cardiff Five could have been responsible for the murder.

Ancl so one of the first things we did

when we got Cellophane Man's profile

was to compare that against their DNA profiles.

But it matched absolutely none of them.

It was nothing to do with them.

INDISTINCT SHOUTING

When I heard about the reinvestigation,

I was, you know, really happy because, erm...

obviously, I wanted them to catch the killer, erm...

for the reason is the guy killed someone.

He shouldn't be on the streets.

Ancl the second reason is to make us righteous again,

you know what I mean?

Because all the fingers was pointing at us.

You know, "They was lucky."

It was, you know, "There's no smoke without fire."

That kind of stuff, you know?

To be able to demonstrate that the DNA could not be from them,

I hope was some sort of relief to them.

But it left us in a slight quandary, if it's not them, well, who is it?

The Cellophane Man DNA provided a partial profile of a man.

While it told the team that the Cardiff Five were innocent,

it did not show them who had killed Lynette.

Angela needed to find more of the killer's blood

to link him directly to the murder.

I had the scenes of crime photographs in front of me,

and we were all thinking about what we could do.

We needed to find a pattern of blood staining

on and around the body and on the exit route.

We knew that there was some foreign blood at the crime scene,

so it wasn't all Lynette's.

So we had to look for new samples of blood staining.

And so one of the things that we decided to do

was to have a look at the skirting board.

Because we could see in the crime scenes,

in these crime scenes, we could see here

that there was some blood on the skirting board itself.

Some of that hadn't been affected by the chemical testing,

and so some of that might actually, if it's still there,

might actually give us a route in to the offender.

Angela had the idea that we would bring the skirting board

into the laboratory and see if that blood was still there.

The whole flat had been renovated.

It had been clone up immaculately.

So, I had to ask the landlord,

"Could we have this piece of skirting board?"

Ancl I remember when he brought it into the lab,

and we started looking under the microscope at the layers of paint.

I think it was maybe even three layers,

so it could have been painted at least three times.

April Robson did it so carefully.

Because if we went too shallow,

we would never have exposed any of the blood

that we hoped would still be there.

But also, not to go too deep when we would have disrupted it all,

and we wouldn't have, you know, been able to collect

a proper sample from it.

There was always the chance that the blood had been wiped away

before it had been repainted.

But it's... it's never say never. You should always try these things.

It took a long time to do that.

You know, clays, if not a couple of weeks.

Ancl all under the microscope.

All incredibly sort of careful work with the scalpel.

Luckily for us, that blood hadn't been washed away,

it had just been painted over.

We were able to swab a bit from there.

And then we noticed that there must have been a point

where the skirting board hadn't met the wall properly,

and there was a little gap between the wall and the skirting board.

Ancl as it so happens,

some blood had dripped down between the gap in the board and the wall.

Ancl so that gave us a little more blood to try.

And so we DNA-profiled both of those.

Ancl we were very pleased to find that they matched

the foreign male blood on the cellophane.

So now we were starting to get somewhere.

It was absolutely amazing. It was fantastic.

Each time they found something extra,

it improved our chances of getting that full profile.

But Angela and April now wanted to know what could be revealed

from the blood patterns left by the killer's escape.

What was very important is that there was no electricity,

so there was no lighting other than street lighting.

So, there was two street lights directly outside the flat.

There was no lighting inside,

and, certainly, on the landing, the bulb had gone.

So whoever was in that room was going to fumble their way around

because it was quite a small space.

When the attacker turned his back on Lynette

and started walking out of the room, he must have been walking,

effectively, into what was pitch black.

Angela and April used the bloodstains on the walls

to trace the killer's escape down the stairs.

A crime scene photo

showed a distinctive smear of blood on the front door.

This, too, had been covered over

when the building had been repainted.

Using the photographs, we could actually determine

where we had to look very specifically. Yeah.

Yeah. And I think it was this darker stain here

that actually gave us the starting point. Yeah.

So, that was a really important finding, that.

Crucially, the mark which the killer had left on the front door

contained both his DNA and Lynette's,

and therefore directly linked Cellophane Man to the murder.

Now what was important was to show

that, actually, there was some of this on Lynette's body itself,

so we were very interested in Lynette's clothing.

But, of course, that was absolutely saturated in her own blood,

so we had to choose some specific areas to test.

We knew by looking at some of the very discreet stains

within the photographs

that there was potentially some foreign blood on Lynette's clothing.

So it was very important for us to determine

where on her clothing it may have been deposited.

Lynette had been manhandled in a particular way,

not only dragged across the room to where she was finally found,

but also manhandled to the extent that her clothing,

her upper clothing, was not in the position you would expect.

One of her arms had come out of the sleeve of the jacket,

and the jacket then pulled across the top of her body

such that the back of the jacket was over...

was covering the front of her body.

In order to do that...

He's gonna have to make contact... I've had to pull on that.

Yeah. So, the right cuff is absolutely somewhere to look at.

Yeah.

'So, this is very classic of Angela.

'She wanted me to wear a very similar sweatshirt and jacket,'

and we carried out experiments to determine how the jacket

sort of got into the position that Lynette was found.

This is the best way to do it,

always to recreate things, reconstruct things.

It's much the best way of understanding what you can do,

what you can't do, what's possible, what's not possible.

OK. That's what he looks like.

That's how it ended up. Ancl then that sitting there.

Yep. Yeah.

Working together, we managed to work out how...

her jacket in particular would have got into the position

that it was found when her body was found.

Ancl that helped us pinpoint the areas that, er...

that we should be looking at in more detail with DNA profiling.

It told us that, actually, a very good place was to look

on one cuff in particular,

and in a particular area on that cuff.

Ancl then I think there are one or two other areas

that we also looked, erm...

and we found the offender DNA profile

on both the sweatshirt and the jacket.

Ancl it was because of this experiment,

because of this reconstruction, this manhandling reconstruction.

Absolutely how that arm is. Mm-hm, yeah.

Brilliant.

Brilliant!

So, now we had Cellophane Man's DNA

on, obviously, the cellophane that we started with,

we had it on the skirting board behind where Lynette's body was.

We had it on her clothing, on her sweatshirt and her jacket,

and we had it just outside the door to the bedroom where she was killed.

And we had it at the top of the staircase,

down which the offender would have to have gone.

Ancl we had it mixed with Lynette's own blood

on the inside of the front door

through which the offender would have had to pass

to get out into the street.

So, in other words, we had enough evidence there.

We had the right sort of pattern to show the Cellophane Man DNA

was intimately connected with Lynette White's death.

So, now the question arose again, who was Cellophane Man?

Ancl how could we find him?

NICOLA WALKER: Forensic scientist Dr Angela Gallop was investigating

the 1988 murder of Lynette White in Cardiff.

Reviewing the murder as a cold case more than a decade later,

Angela and her team had found blood from the killer

and extracted his DNA.

As the blood was first found on wrapping from a cigarette packet,

the murderer had become known to the team as Cellophane Man.

Having the killer's DNA

was the biggest breakthrough in the case for 14 years.

But there was a problem.

The search of the DNA database proved fruitless.

There was nobody on the DNA database

that matched the profile of Cellophane Man.

So, the police decided to hold a mass screen,

which is basically collecting together, erm...

a subset of the local population, a sort of large number of people,

and screening their blood just to see if they could find it that way.

But that didn't work either.

South Wales Police had a...

quite a radical, different way of looking at it

in terms of introducing something called familial DNA testing.

A familial DNA search meant going back to the National Database

and looking for anyone whose DNA suggested

they may be a blood relative of Cellophane Man.

To narrow down the search,

the team looked for people in South Wales

who shared the rarest part of the Cellophane Man DNA...

...a component called FGA 27.

In doing this, the police reported that there were 600 profiles

containing this one component.

So, that was, like, the first time, I've got to be honest, I thought...

"We're gonna get him."

Because if it had been thousands, if it had been tens of thousands,

we would have got to him eventually, but it wasn't tens of thousands.

The team then took the 600 profiles which contained FGA 27

and analysed them for further elements in common

with Cellophane Man.

One match stood out head and shoulders above the rest.

This had come from a 14-year-old boy

who hadn't even been born at the time of Lynette's killing.

Erm, but... And just happened to have got onto the database.

I think it was through some fairly minor misdemeanour.

I mean, he must have had his DNA taken,

but it was nothing major.

It was just amazing that his profile was on the database at all.

So, we hit on this young boy,

we work through his family, and it's not quite a match,

we're not getting it.

The police took a sample from the father.

Erm... He wasn't a match, but he was very close.

Ancl I think all the time,

while we're getting this family and the closeness repeated,

we're getting slightly more confident

that this might well be the family that we need.

And then the police discovered that the father had a brother,

who had been a recluse for a number of years.

I don't think the family had seen much of him.

We go to see him, we get that sample.

Ancl I... I remember these times quite vividly,

and I never thought we'd get to this.

I just... I just...

I'm thinking this is, like... It's incredible.

It was a fantastic feeling. It was so exciting.

So, we had quite a nervous number of hours' wait

whilst the DNA profile was obtained.

And I remember vividly sitting next to the machine,

as his DNA profile was coming through.

And I had Cellophane Man's profile in my hand.

And then I was watching the coloured bands coming through on the machine.

And I could look at those,

and I could work out from the spacing of the bands on the machine

that, yes, this looked as though it was indeed Cellophane Man.

We had got him at last.

Ancl his name was Jeffrey Charles Gafoor.

Jeffrey Gafoor was a security guard living just outside Cardiff.

His DNA matched the killer's, and finally, after 15 years,

there was a face to match the Photofit.

The police put him under surveillance

to give themselves time to prepare for the interviews.

Because there'd been so much criticism

of the original interviews,

we had to have the absolute perfect interview setup.

So we needed time.

Well, time wasn't on our side. It was simple as that.

I remember telling my wife, "We've got him."

Ancl Brent Parry rings me up. He says, erm...

"He's gone into a couple of shops, he's buying paracetamol tablets,

"amongst other things.

"Erm... What are we going to do?"

Either he's got a hell of a headache,

or he's gonna do something.

So, I said, "We've got to move."

So, that's my instructions to the surveillance team.

They arrest him.

And he says, "I've been waiting for this.

"I deserve to be punished."

I think he said, "I deserve to die. I've taken the paracetamol."

I think he said he took 64 paracetamol tablets.

So, he was rushed to hospital.

He was close to death,

but er...

we saved him, and we took him back.

Please state your full name and date of birth.

Jeffrey Charles Gafoor. 28th of the fifth, '65.

The reason for this interview...

...is because you have been arrested for the murder of Lynette White.

'A security guard has been charged with the murder of Lynette White.

'Jeffrey Gafoor was arrested at his home in Llanharan,

'near Bridgend, over the weekend.'

NEWSREEL: 'Gafoor was convicted of killing Lynette White

'15 years after her death.'

NEWSREEL: 'DNA evidence brought a confession from Jeffrey Gafoor

'for Lynette's murder.'

The clay they caught him, and it was just, like, "Oh, my God."

Eh? It was, like, unbelievable, you know?

So, the reinvestigation by South Wales Police,

oh, it was a good thing. It was really good.

The forensic... absolutely top drawer, top drawer.

'Good evening.

'Jeffrey Gafoor murdered prostitute Lynette White

'in what a judge described as, "a terrible and vicious fashion."

'Today, 15 years after Lynette died,

'Gafoor has been jailed for life.'

In July 2003,

Jeffrey Gafoor admitted in court to murdering Lynette White...

...although he never explained why he had killed her.

The painstaking forensic investigation,

which had brought him to justice, had taken four years.

But Angela and her team had finally uncovered the clues

to reveal exactly what happened on that dark Valentine's Day

in Cardiff in 1988.

If it wasn't for Angela and her team,

he wouldn't be in jail.

Do you know what I'm saying?

Because the DNA, without them sorting it out,

he might still be on the road.

He'd still be out there.

In a forensic career stretching back almost 50 years,

Dr Angela Gallop has never had the chance to meet up

with anyone proven innocent by her work.

She's come to Cardiff to meet john Actie.

Nice to meet you. Pleased to meet you.

The clay they said that they got Gafoor, I was so happy.

I was... I can remember...

I can't imagine what it would have been like.

Oh, it was... Yeah, you know. Ancl it was...

"I told you so, by the way." Yeah!

THEY LAUGH

Yeah, well, exactly. I was, like, you know,

"I told you, I told you", you know? Yeah.

It just highlights, you know... Yeah.

...the rots justice we had, you know? Absolutely.

What happened to us. And, er... Absolutely.

The DNA... We're so grateful, and we're so grateful for, erm...

you know, the South Wales Police for reinvestigating it.

Do you still have...

I don't know whether to call them flashbacks

or what to call them, really,

but bad memories about the... Oh, yeah!

I imagine you have... Yeah, yeah, yeah.

I have very bad memories. Yeah, yeah,

You sit in a flat, you know, thinking about it, "Why me?"

Just being back in that moment. Yeah, back in that moment.

You know, all different things, you know, like,

sometimes, I've got to keep my telly on in the night.

Do you know what I mean? Because if the telly goes off, and I wakes up,

I think I'm in a cell.

Do you know? It's that kind of thing.

You release them little... Yeah.

So, it's a sort of life sentence in a way, isn't it?

Oh, definitely. Oh, definitely. But just... Yeah.

It's been a long, long, long...

I really feel...

vindicated now, and everything is, er...

Mm. ..Is a lot better.

It's doubly satisfying when you can find and provide the evidence

which leaves you in no doubt of the guilt of someone,

and, at the same time, exonerates other people

who have previously been convicted of the crime.

The Lynette White case was the first time that's ever happened,

and so it made legal history to that extent.

It made forensic science history

because it's the first time that someone was convicted

on the basis of a familial search of the National DNA Database.

Ancl it's also led to the routine recording of interviews

with suspects in serious cases.

The Lynette White investigation was a cold case

which had broken new ground.

But, most importantly, it had delivered justice for Lynette,

a 20-year-old who had been through hard times,

but had her whole life ahead of her.

I literally still pray for Lynette.

There is no way that I will ever forget.

She didn't need to be murdered. She didn't need to die.

She had her life ahead of her.

Lynette was so young,

and I don't think that anybody could possibly read all about that

and not be moved by it and think what a terrible waste of life.

Subtitles by accessibility@itv.com

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.