All language subtitles for Keep.Sweet.Pray.and.Obey.S01E01.Part.One.1080p.NF.WEB-DL.DDP5.1.Atmos.x264-SMURF-HI

[spiritual music playing]

[motorcycle engine revving]

[tense music playing]

[woman 1] When I was 14 years old,

they forced me to marry my cousin.

I asked Warren,

begged him,

"Please don't make me get married."

And he said, "Do you believe
that you know better than the Prophet?"

"That if you're questioning me,
you're questioning God."

[reporter] Warren Jeffs is the leader
of a secretive religious cult

called the Fundamentalist Church
of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

[man] Known as "FLDS."

It's a far offshoot of the Mormon church
and supports the practice of polygamy.

[woman 2] The more wives and children
you have, the higher in heaven you'll be.

[tense music continues]

[woman 2] We were so scared, you know?

That we're gonna be condemned to hell
if we did anything different.

You have to submit yourself.

Because it was for our salvation.

You did whatever it took,
even if it was wrong. You just did it.

[tense music continues]

[man 2] I saw this picture
of Warren kissing this girl.

That's when I said, "I'm done."

I have followed my heart
and I've spoken the truth.

[motorcycle accelerating]

[woman 3] To stand up against
a multi-million-dollar church,

you're going up against
a lifetime of conditioning.

A lifetime of fear.

- [tense music continues]
- [motorbike engine revving]

[woman 1] The other people
of the FLDS would say,

"Why are you challenging
the Prophet's word?"

"Why aren't you being obedient?"

You don't know any better
until you get away from it.

And getting away from it is the hard part.

[engine continues revving]

It happens to everybody eventually.

You will come around and see the light

and go, "What the fuck?"

["Feel More" by Michelle Gurevich playing]

♪ I was born for the road ♪

♪ Only after a storm ♪

♪ Can you feel the sun ♪

♪ Ooh, I wanna feel ♪

♪ More ♪

♪ Ecstasy
In the shadow of ecstasy ♪

♪ In the shadow of ecstasy ♪

♪ Ooh, I wanna feel ♪

♪ More ♪

[children's music playing]

[indistinct chatter]

[woman 1] This is July 4th.
This is our happy day.

[girl] Rebecca's on TV!

[girl] Mother!

Ma, don't do that!

[woman 2] Even though I grew up
in the United States...

we knew we were different.

The way that we dressed
was obviously different.

And, in my family,

and in the culture I grew up in,

I was taught that we were
the one and only true people of God

on the whole face of the Earth.

And we believed in polygamy.

What we called plural marriage.

- [indistinct conversations]
- [woman 1] Kyle!

[woman 3] For those of us
who remember life prior to Warren Jeffs...

[woman 1] Lacey.

...we remember the good times.

People who cared about each other,
that were working together

to live the FLDS way
and continue to grow this community.

[upbeat music playing]

[Elissa] I was a part
of the younger set of kids.

[girls vocalizing]

[Elissa] I know I was my mom's eleventh,

but I never remember exactly
which structure in my family.

I think I was the nineteenth.

Yes, I was the nineteenth child.

[upbeat music continues]

[Elissa] My dad had two wives.

My mother was my father's second wife.

And Myrna was my dad's first wife.

Lloyd was my high school sweetheart.

How could I share him with anybody else?

But I got my mind all in tune

with accepting another woman
in the family.

A unique aspect of my dad is,
he was a convert,

and he was trying to find a way
to create a life for himself

that he couldn't find
in the mainstream Mormon church.

[producer] It's unusual to convert
to the FLDS, isn't it?

- Yes.
- [Myrna] It is.

You gotta make a commitment.
A real commitment.

Yeah.

["Valley" by Kevin Morby playing]

[Lloyd] In those days,
it wasn't even called FLDS.

[Myrna] When we joined,
it was just called The Fundamentalists.

[acoustic guitar continues]

♪ In the valley below me ♪

♪ In the valley... ♪

[reporter] They call themselves
fundamentalist Mormons.

They were forced out
of mainstream Mormonism

when the church outlawed polygamy
over 100 years ago.

♪ In the sky above me ♪

My brother, he joined it, and he'd say,

"You guys, you're drinking skim milk,

you really need to have the meat."

- There are a jillion polygamist groups.
- Yeah, there are a lot of them.

But none of them were
trying to adhere to fundamentalism

like the FLDS,
and that's what intrigued me.

["Valley" continues playing]

♪ In the valley below me ♪

♪ In the valley below ♪

[reporter] These polygamists
trace the religious justification

for plural marriage

back to the first prophet
of Mormonism, Joseph Smith.

If you want to obtain
the highest degree of salvation,

you must live this law.

[Lloyd] According to my understanding
of the Gospel,

plural wives was the whole picture
that Christ was after.

[indistinct conversations]

[Lloyd] And, one day at a Sunday meeting,

the Prophet pulled me in real close
and he said to me,

"Sharon belongs in your family."

"Now let's get with it
and we'll get it taken care of tonight."

[Myrna] That was the first time
he ever met her.

- [Lloyd] Yeah.
- [Myrna] Or her him.

And we took her home.
We took her home that night.

[folk music playing]

[Myrna] Sharon had fourteen
and I had nine beautiful children.

[folk music continues]

We had 30 good years together.

- [producer] They were good years?
- For me.

Oh, they were rocky, you know?

Two women in... [chuckles]
...one house?

Yeah, they were rocky.

[indistinct]

[woman] Let's go! We're gonna go pray
downstairs. Here we go.

[Rebecca] We were the downstairs kids.

We would sleep in the downstairs,

my mom and her children.

[girl] Mama, turn over here
and smile real cute and then I'll...

[speaking indistinctly]

[Rebecca] And then his first wife
and her kids were the upstairs kids.

[kids shouting]

[Rebecca] We were well aware
that plural marriage was illegal.

And on my birth certificate, my dad lied.

Instead of writing, "Lloyd Wall,"

he filled in the father's space
as "Lewis Wilson."

And my name was Rebecca Wilson
on my original birth certificate.

It was just a made-up name.

[indistinct conversations]

[woman] We didn't really leave
our property in Salt Lake City.

We didn't go to movies.

We didn't go to theme parks
or any kind of large gathering places.

So, there wasn't a lot of exposure
to the outside world.

Our activities were within our own group.

[young Rebecca] There's the parade!

[patriotic music playing]

[Elissa] As time went on...

Hi, camera.

[Elissa] ...we definitely got further
and further away from society,

and all of us knew that our way of life
had to be concealed.

[suspenseful music playing]

[man] People are entitled
to believe what they want,

but the law currently in the United States

is that polygamy is not
a protected constitutional right.

Plural marriage, polygamy, it's illegal.

But as a practical matter,
it is almost never prosecuted.

It's hard to prove,

and law-enforcement and politicians

are not very interested
in disrupting families.

[suspenseful music continues]

[Roger] I think most people in Utah,

the mainstream Mormons, people like me,

see polygamy as an embarrassment.

But polygamy is really
not the problem anyway.

It's the secondary crimes that occur

in a closed religious society
controlled by men.

That's when all sorts of mischief
can take place.

And that's what happened with the FLDS.

[cows mooing]

[cows continue mooing]

[man] I think most of the men in the FLDS

just regard women as chattel.

They were property.

[cows continue mooing]

When you're taught something from birth
from your mother and father,

you believe them
'cause they're your parents.

[tractor whirring]

[Wallace] And it's your family.

I was doing what I was taught to do.

Crazy cows.

But someday we get to eat them.

We were taught from birth
that in order to get what they called,

"the highest degree"
of the celestial kingdom,

[ethereal music playing]

...you had to have at least three wives

while you lived on Earth.

And if you did not,

you could not reach that highest degree.

If you reach the highest degree,

you will be able
to create spirit children.

You'll be able to create worlds,

galaxies,

universes.

Basically become a god.

[producer] And what happens to the women?
Do they become gods?

[laughing]

That is kind of a gray area.

We were never taught...

...what a woman becomes
on the other side other than a wife.

[girls singing]
♪ My dad is American made ♪

♪ Born and raised in the USA ♪

♪ From his hard-working hands ♪

♪ To his big-loving heart ♪

♪ My dad is American made ♪

[Rebecca] A man's status depends on
how many wives he has.

[gloomy music playing]

[Rebecca] My dad, he had two wives,

and he couldn't figure out why other men
were getting more wives and he was not.

[gloomy music continues]

[Rebecca] So my dad always felt
like he was jilted.

He built a very successful business.

And he'd given money to the church.

He'd given, you know,
his expertise as an engineer.

I want the universe!

[Myrna and Lloyd laughing]

[Rebecca] And he was always
kind of frustrated.

- But he also had this host of daughters...
- [gloomy music continues]

that could be given to other men.

And it's kind of like,
"I'll give you some if you give me some."

Even though it's never spoken that way,
I think that's the general understanding.

[marching band music playing]

[marching band music continues]

[Elissa] In the FLDS, you had the Prophet.

The Prophet is a representation
of God on Earth.

[eerie music playing]

The best way to explain the Prophet
would be like the Catholic Pope.

They've... They've got a Pope,
pretty much... pretty much runs everything.

[Elissa] We were told that our Prophet,
Rulon Jeffs, would never die.

That he would be renewed
to be young again.

We believed that the Prophet
knew everything we did,

knew every thought we had,
knew our dreams,

knew our wishes, our desires.

He also was the one
that created all arranged marriages.

[eerie music continues]

[Wallace] It's what's called
"The placement principle."

You didn't court and decide
who you would marry.

Only the Prophet could choose
who you married.

[eerie music continues]

[Rebecca] It was a big deal
in our culture,

when a girl is ready to get married

to "turn her in" to the Prophet,

and that was to go to the Prophet and say,

"Here is my daughter,
do with her as you will,

whatever is God's will."

And so, when I turned 19,

my father,

he brought me to Rulon Jeffs.

[women laughing]

[Rebecca] It had become known
that there was a specific handshake

that he would give to girls
that would then later become his wife.

And that day, he shook my hand,

and he squeezed it three times,

and it meant I was supposed to marry him.

And my dad was so excited.

For any man in the FLDS,

to have their daughter marry
into the Prophet's family

was a massive honor,

and I think my dad felt like finally

he was getting the respect
that he was entitled to

and that he deserved.

But I was just like, ' "Ew!"

[eerie music continues]

Rulon Jeffs was 85 when I married him.

And I was 19.

So, I got married.

And then my father got his third wife.

[intriguing music playing]

[woman] Ever since I was a little girl,

all I wanted was to be a really good wife

and I was going to raise
a whole bunch of children

and... do like everybody else was doing.

So, after I got out of high school,

I was just constantly going to my father

and saying, "I want to turn myself in."

When you turn yourself in,

you wanna be married,
is what you're saying.

And so, my mother and father
took me to the Prophet.

We sat across from Rulon,
and, without hesitation,

he said, "Well then, will you marry me?"
And I'm like...

I was shocked a little,

but, that night, we were married.

I believe he was 86 when I married him.

I think he had 23 wives already.

Or maybe I was his 23rd wife.

[intriguing music continues]

After the ceremony,

he gave me one heck of a smacker.

I felt I was getting sucked in
and I was just trying to pull away.

It was a lot for me
to take in all at once.

I was 20 years old.

That was my first kiss.

And, you know, a young girl dreams
of fairy tales and all that kind of stuff.

Your brain runs away with you
and you think it's gonna be magical.

Yeah, it wasn't magical.

[eerie music playing]

[Rebecca] They didn't let us work.
They didn't let us go to school.

All our sole purpose was

to be with Rulon Jeffs,

pray,

and to be obedient.

To be...

[sucking teeth]
...uh, adoring at all times.

[unsettling music playing]

[Alicia] In Rulon's house,
on the wall in the dining room,

is a picture of all the ladies
in the order he married them.

Every night, every woman was
in a line outside his door,

and each woman took their turn
to go say good night to him.

And I'm telling you,
these lines were so bloody long.

And it was such a pain.

I was just like,
"It's just a freaking kiss."

[unsettling music continues]

I hated kissing the man
after he kissed other women.

I used a lot of Listerine
is all I'm going to say.

So, it was my turn to go in
and say good night to him,

and he says, "I want you to stay with me
and we'll do a little lovemaking."

And I'm like, "Lovemaking?
What the... What does that mean?"

[hesitates] You do not know anything.

I did not know how babies were born.

I just thought that you made 'em
when you kissed.

[unsettling music continues]

[Rebecca] At 19, I did not know

what it took to physically

get pregnant.

I did not expect Rulon Jeffs to touch me
in any way, shape, or form.

Um...

You got undressed and then you went down
to his bedroom and...

[unsettling music continues]

[Rebecca] I remember him rolling
on top of me

and saying, "Spread your legs."

I felt like, this is everything
that we were told was bad.

Why... Why is a man doing this,

let alone the Prophet of God
doing this to me?

[Alicia] He went to sleep
for a few minutes after that,

and the next thing I know,

he's hitting me with his elbow,
and waking me up

and saying,
"I need... I need to go to the bathroom."

He can't walk, you know.
He's holding on to you.

We went into the bathroom,
and he didn't quite make it,

and that was my first introduction
to the blow dryer.

[blow dryer whirring]

[Alicia] You'd have to dry it
and clean him up and...

uh, you know, one time
I stepped on his oxygen cord

and that yanked his face
and he got pretty angry.

[air hissing]

[Rebecca] I... was clever.

[chuckling] I knew he was tired,
so I'd have him get in bed

and I'd rub his feet and get him to sleep.

I'd do anything I could
to make him fall asleep.

And then I would pass by another night
without having him touch me.

And...

um,

it worked for a while

until it didn't.

[Rulan] Keep sweet,

no matter what.

That's the road to perfection.

[girls singing] ♪ ...girls for you ♪

♪ Keep sweet, keep sweet ♪

♪ It's the motto, tried and true ♪

♪ Keep sweet, keep sweet ♪

♪ When you grow up good and kind... ♪

[Alicia] "Keep sweet" was
Rulon saying to the people,

"Keep sweet, no matter what,"

and "For heaven's sakes, keep sweet,"
is what he would always say.

[girls continue singing]

[Myrna] Everybody had little stickers.

"Keep Sweet. Keep Sweet. Keep Sweet."

And he had shoes that had "Keep Sweet"

on the bottoms of his shoes. [chuckling]

I thought that was pretty cute.

[Elissa] It meant to be in control
of your emotions.

And you didn't display things
like anger or resentment or frustration,

especially towards
the fathers and the husbands.

[girls continue singing]

[Charlene] Keep sweet no matter what.

And it became more
and more drilled into us,

the keep sweet.

[somber music playing]

But it wasn't Uncle Rulon that did it.

It was Warren.

[somber music continues]

Warren is eight years older than I am.

No, six, six years.

[producer] How many siblings
did you have growing up?

Sixty-two.

Thirty... Thirty-two brothers
and 30 sisters.

Not all of them I knew.

There were... some sisters
that had grown up and gotten married

before I even knew who they were,

but there was 62 that we were aware of.

[somber music continues]

Marilyn, Mother Marilyn as we called her,

she was Warren's mother.

And she really pushed her sons

to be close... to our dad

to make them the next leaders
of the church after my dad.

[producer] And she had
a special relationship with Warren

even though he wasn't her oldest son.

Oh boy.
That's a whole 'nother story. [chuckling]

Mother Marilyn felt
that Warren was special

because Warren was born...

I believe it was eight weeks premature.

And Mother Marilyn always
told the story about how...

Warren was close to death at birth,

and that previous prophets came to her

and revealed to her that he would survive...

and that Warren
would be "a very special" person.

My dad also believed that.

[somber music continues]

[Wallace] You couldn't get close
to Warren.

You know, he had
this holier-than-thou attitude.

And even though he could be funny,
he came across kind of abrasive.

[microphone rumbling]

[Rebecca] I don't think he was liked much.

[Warren clears throat]

He was the awkward son

of a man who had power.

[piano playing]

♪ I desire here today ♪

♪ To sincerely point the way... ♪

[Rebecca] Warren,
compared to his brothers,

he was not anything to write home about.

I mean, pretty smart. He could do math.

I learned to do algebra from him.

[Warren continues singing]

Did he in the beginning foresee
what he would become?

I don't think so.

[Warren continues singing]

[Rebecca] I think that he was keenly aware

of how to pick up on
what is important to people

and how to use that to manipulate them.

♪ He will lead us to Zion's shore ♪

[producer] When did you begin to see signs
of Warren's eventual character growing up?

[audience applauding]

[Wallace] When I was 16,

Warren started getting very cozy...

with... the sisters...

of the family.

[unsettling music playing]

[Wallace] Uh, uncomfortably cozy...

with the sisters.

And it was seen by a lot of us brothers,

and we reported it to our dad.

Or at least I did.

My dad's response was, "Drop it."

"Don't talk about it. I'm handling it."

"Forget about it.
Don't ever talk about it again."

[ominous music playing]

[drums playing]

[footsteps marching]

[Roger] One of the things
the Jeffs family did in Salt Lake

was they operated
what was known as the Alta Academy.

[joyful music playing]

- [all singing]
- [audience laughing]

Alta Academy trained and educated

a large number of the FLDS people
in the FLDS way.

Everything just had
a religious content to it.

And, uh, you know, the...

some things were omitted.

[Rulan] I deeply appreciate the efforts
of these young people

putting on this fine program.

[Wallace] My dad,

he didn't want the world's teachings
to be given to his children.

He wanted them to get
what we called priesthood teachings.

[tense music playing]

[Wallace] Somebody had to be
the principal.

And I remember my dad
very forcefully pushing Warren into that.

It was almost like...

[tense music continues]

...this was the beginning of his calling,

and this was going to be what taught him

how to become
what my dad wanted him to become.

So, as soon as he became Principal
and realized he had this authority,

he started exercising it vigorously.

"I'm the boss. Obey me at all costs."

[eerie music playing]

[Elissa] Warren had a saying,

"Perfect obedience is led by a hair."

Meaning, hair is so thin,

and true obedience

meant that you could be led by a hair
and you would not break it.

So there could be absolutely no resistance

to that obedience

because any resistance
would pop that hair.

[eerie music continues]

[Rebecca] In the early days
of the Alta Academy,

we had books from the outside world.

And I remember Library Day,
Like, I loved it.

My favorite books were
the Encyclopedia Brown books,

and then the Nancy Drew books.

They were so clever.
I wanted to be clever like that.

[eerie music continues]

[Rebecca] And then they took
all those books away.

Anything that had
an outside influence was purged.

The school libraries, they would take
any book that wasn't specifically approved

by Warren himself.

Those were completely banned
and taken out.

[Rebecca] They would cut sections out
of our science books.

[Elissa] Just razor it.
Like, cut whole sections out of them.

Reproduction, the solar system,
or things like that.

[eerie music continues]

Warren created a curriculum

that was specifically for women
of the FLDS that he would teach in school.

[Alicia] Warren had a book called

Purity in the New
and Everlasting Covenant of Marriage,

and we were all required
to study and learn it.

It taught us to basically have
nothing in your brain

except to do the Prophet's will.

To have a thought of a boy, to like a boy,

to even think of a boy,
would cloud that channel.

[eerie music continues]

[producer] Did you ever have
a crush on a boy?

Oh, yeah. I'm human.

Even when I went to marry Rulon, I still
had a crush on a boy. He didn't catch it.

That... I guess the channel was
clogged or something.

[chuckling]

[Rebecca] It was an August afternoon.

Rulon was sitting on the sofa speaking,

and we were just listening,

and... he was talking and, um...

all of a sudden,
he just slumped over like this.

Almost like he fell asleep.

And one of my sister wives kind of
shook him and said, "Father, Father?"

He kind of came to
and just was like, "Where am I?"

And he was really disoriented.

And it turned out
he had had a massive stroke.

[tense music playing]

[Alicia] And they got him to the hospital,

and when I saw him,
he just was very weak, limp.

He could hardly walk or keep his balance.

He was very unsteady.

And he could not remember
any of our names.

He would just look at me
and point his finger and go,

"That's snicklefritz right there."

[tense music intensifies]

[Rebecca] After Rulon's stroke,
that's when things really took a turn.

That's when Warren started taking over.

[Charlene] Warren pretty much
removed everybody

out of Rulon's life.

After the stroke,

he said that Uncle Rulon needed to heal.

[Wallace] From the time he had his stroke,

Warren never left my father's side.

He controlled everything

that my father did, who saw my father.

He controlled his appointments,
controlled everything he did.

[Myrna] Warren acted like it was
Uncle Rulon telling him what to say.

And yet... it wasn't.

It wasn't Uncle Rulon.

[ominous music playing]

[Alicia] That's when Warren's teachings
got so scary.

The meetings were always just
fire and damnation and Joe Smith's dream

of blood running down the gutters
of the Salt Lake streets,

and things just pounded into our brains.

Torch of the Prophets, in whom we believe...

[Alicia] He was a great speaker.

They have lighted the way.

[Alicia] He knew how to tell us we were
all gonna be destroyed very vividly.

There's going to be a great purging,
a great cleansing of the Earth.

[Elissa] Warren had a lot of revelations
that the end of the world was coming.

We'd been prepared for that for...

hundreds of years 'cause it was always,
"Time is short."

That's been part
of the Mormon narrative and theology.

[ominous music continues]

[Warren] Prepare ye, for the great day
of judgment is upon us.

And those judgments
are going to be furious.

All of you are not going to survive.

We grew up under that belief system

that any year now it was gonna happen.

- [dramatic whoosh]
- [suspenseful music intensifies]

[Wallace] That the whole Earth
would be on fire.

[fire crackling]

[Wallace] Everybody would die by fire...

and the only way to be saved from that

is a piece of the Earth being lifted up...

[dramatic whoosh]

...while the Earth gets burned.

So if we're faithful enough,
we would be worthy

to be on that piece of land

that gets lifted up off of the Earth

so that we would not die with the wicked.

[fire crackling]

We were told
that anyone who didn't subscribe

to the FLDS belief system
would be wiped off the face of the Earth...

[birds chirping]

...so that it would be clean
and pure for the righteous.

[water flowing]

- [orchestral music playing]
- [crowd screaming]

[reporter] The Olympic torch has arrived
in Salt Lake City.

[orchestral music continues]

The Olympics. Oh boy.

That's when things really became...

[orchestral music continues]

...screwed up.

Warren said, "If the Olympics come here,
it's gonna be the end of the world."

[orchestral music continues]

[Myrna] And he said, "We've got
to get everybody out of here."

[crowd cheering]

[fireworks bursting]

[Wallace] Warren said that Salt Lake was
gonna be destroyed during the Olympics.

[fire crackling]

[Wallace] And if we didn't go
down to Short Creek,

we would not get lifted up.

[Roger] The FLDS were really located
primarily in two places:

the Salt Lake area,

and Short Creek
on the Utah-Arizona Border.

[intriguing music playing]

[Roger] Short Creek dates
back to the 1930s.

When Mormon fundamentalists no longer
had a place in the mainstream LDS church,

uh, one of the groups
started to homestead down there.

[intriguing music continues]

[Roger] The reason
I think it was picked is,

it was just so far from... civilization

and very hard to reach.

That remoteness was a big deal
and very important to them.

So, in 2002,

Warren Jeffs ordered the FLDS people

to gather to Short Creek.

[engine whirring]

[Roger] They sold their homes,
they gave up their businesses,

because the end of the world was coming.

"Sell everything you can."

"Sell your houses and move down."

We had two houses. We sold them both.

[intriguing music continues]

[woman] The crick went
from a small community,

I'd say 1,000, 2,000 people, to...

- what do you think it grew to, 8,000?
- [Jeff] Mm-hmm.

10,000. Probably about 10,000 people.

[horns honking]

That was the biggest migration of people

in our history that I knew of.

[Wallace] I believe that Warren,
he thought,

"I need to gather the people into
one place so that I can control them."

[birds chirping]

[Roger] So... they were all
gathered in Short Creek,

ready for the destruction to come
and to be lifted up.

[tense music playing]

[Wallace] We were all scared to death.

Just total fear that
this is the beginning of the end.

We all kinda just waited
and just waited... [chuckles]

...and it never came.

[tense music continues]

[Wallace] Warren couldn't explain why
it didn't happen the way he said it would,

and I think he panicked.

People are gonna wise up.

It was very... confusing.

There was no logical rhyme or reason.

[man] Warren said it was just a test,

and that God had granted us
a little more time.

He said it was a gift to us,

that God wants you to be more righteous,
so he's gonna gift you more time.

That meant we needed to be more perfect,
we needed to be more obedient.

And it was never enough.

We were never good enough.

[children singing]

[children continue singing]

[Rebecca] And then, one afternoon,

Warren called over the intercom
and he said,

"Come sing to Father.
He's not feeling well."

[children continue singing]

[Rebecca] So we all gathered
in the Prophet's room.

Rulon was on his bed,

and there was myself
and all of my sister wives.

- [children continue singing]
- [Rebecca] And we were singing,

and I will never forget
how gray he looked.

Translucent and gray.

[singing stops]

[Rebecca] And then, the next day, he died.

It was very confusing.

He was not supposed to die.

We were always told he was
supposed to be the last prophet

that would bring us into the millennium.

We were taught that, if we had the faith,

he would suddenly, just
like Jesus walked out of the tomb,

that he would come in the door a young man

and give us all children.

[eerie music playing]

Of the many options
that could've happened,

him dying was not on the table.

[indistinct conversations]

[Alicia] Before the funeral, Warren said
that we all needed to be in white dresses.

And so, all the women
that were great seamstresses

came forward and made
brand new dresses, like in two days.

[eerie music continues]

[Rebecca] It was this sea of white,

all these young and old women.

All of his wives.

Sixty-five of us.

[eerie music intensifies]

[Warren] Our Father, who art in heaven,

we rejoice in You in the privilege
of being under our Prophet's direction.

In the privilege of being taught
how to come to You through him...

[Wallace] The funeral was
very, very somber.

I would say more of a spirit
of confusion than sorrow.

What's going to happen now?

So, here, our last prophet has died...
Is the Earth gonna come apart?

It was... just a lot of

apprehension and confusion.

[Elissa] I truly believed that,
any minute, he was going to sit up

and be renewed.

They closed the casket and there was
this overwhelming fear inside of me.

If they... put him in the ground,

how is he gonna get out?

[casket descending]

[Erna] I believed as clear as day
that he was gonna be lifted up.

And so I'm thinking,

"So what is this you've been giving us
all these years?"

And then... I... I think I may have
voiced it slightly to Jeff

and I think I remember you said,
"I don't understand."

"You just gonna have
put this on the shelf."

'Cause that's what we were always told,

"If you don't understand it,
put it on the shelf."

[suspenseful music playing]

[Wallace] My dad's funeral was
controlled 100% by Warren.

He stood

right next to my dad's coffin
during the viewing.

Wouldn't let any of the other sons
stand next to him. He was the only son.

That's what really
started showing Warren's true colors.

[soft music playing]

[Elissa] In the weeks
after Rulon's funeral,

Warren was speaking
as though he was his father renewed

and his father had assumed his body

and was still leading the people
through Warren.

And then it became, "I am my father."

[Alicia] Then one day, he was sitting
in the office and he said, real quiet,

"Who do you think the next prophet is?"

And I... I was a people pleaser

and I wanted to please him,
and I basically said, "I think you are,"

and he just beamed at me.

[ominous music playing]

A lot of people didn't see that.

So, yeah, he still had to convince people,

but he couldn't come right out and say it.

He couldn't come right out and say,
"I'm the next prophet."

He had to make up a story to justify it.

[ominous music continues]

[Alicia] At the general meetings
where everybody gathered,

he would call on certain of Rulon's wives

to come and tell what they dreamed of and
who they felt like was the next prophet.

He had people step to the pulpit and

validate his claims
that he was the new prophet

and that we were to get behind him.

[Warren] I now call upon
one of father's wives,

Mother Naomi.

[ominous music continues]

[Naomi] I first will ask a question.

Do we really believe in Uncle Rulon?

'Cause if we do, we believe

that Warren Jeffs is the Prophet of God,

and I need him to guide me.

[ominous music continues]

[Elissa] Looking back,
I see he was very smart.

It was all done
very strategically and methodically.

Once Warren became the Prophet,

we were all just instruments
in the machine

that was at his disposal.

- [eerie music continues]
- [Elissa] The religion.

[girls singing]
♪ What can we give to him? ♪

♪ What can we do? ♪

♪ All he asks of us is our faith... ♪

[Roger] He was the man
who could take them into heaven.

[eerie music continues]

And so the stakes for them are eternal,

and, to make a mistake

and lose the favor of the Prophet
is just unthinkable.

[all singing] ♪ If we believe in him... ♪

[Roger] And so, Warren Jeffs
took over this religion

with thousands of loyal followers,

and he manipulated their beliefs

and turned it into money
and power and sex.

[eerie music intensifies]

[children singing]
♪ Our lives will all be blessed ♪

♪ Our faith will grow... ♪

And they ended up
following him right off the cliff.

[singing] ♪ Our faith will grow ♪

[audience applauding]

[emotional music playing]