Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
-You won the popular vote… -I did.
Yes, I remember that every day.
Hillary Clinton received 65.7 million votes,
and Donald Trump received 62.9 million.
So how is he president?
The Constitution sets up a system called the Electoral College.
The winning presidential candidate, in this case, Donald Trump,
has to have a majority, or 270 electoral votes.
Trump actually has 306 to Clinton's 232.
I remember listening to commentators from around the world.
A political scientist from France says, "We don't understand this."
You know, "In our country, the person who gets the most votes wins."
Donald Trump won the election without the popular vote
something that only happened four times before.
We've had, you know, other incidents,
but mine was probably the clearest case because the margin was significant.
It's a very bizarre feeling
to know that nearly three million more people
voted for you,
and a relic of compromises from the Constitutional Convention
are going to prevent you from becoming president.
What were these guys thinking
when they put together this constitutional provision?
The Electoral College is one of the most mysterious
and peculiar parts of the Constitution.
It doesn't really quite work the way the framers imagined.
There's all kinds of ways
in which America's own governing institutions
just do not suit the country that we live in now.
The American founding is a misperception.
There are two foundings.
One, when we declare and win independence.
And the other when we declare nationhood.
That's the Constitutional Convention.
The morning after the revolution,
you discover there are problems that you hadn't anticipated.
We owed money to France, to Spain, to the Netherlands,
to the army,
which had almost mutinied before it was disbanded
because the soldiers weren't being paid.
The Americans won the revolution,
which means they were now able to squabble with each other.
America is a weak collection of states
in a world of powerful empires.
And it simply isn't going to be able to last much longer.
It's easy for us now to think that the war was over,
they created the nation.
That is not how they felt.
The sense that Americans had in 1787,
ten years into independence,
was, "This thing is not working."
They were surrounded by these European powers
who were like sharks circling a bleeding man.
So many questions remain.
What do we do now?
Maybe tearing down the old system was the easy part.
Maybe separating from Britain was the easy part.
The hard part,
how do you build a government that can hold this crazy country together?
What gets put in the space of where the empire was?
What kind of country will be created?
Will a country be created?
Can it hang together?
It's not gonna be a monarchy, so what will it be?
What's the meaning of America? What are we striving for?
Could a government based on the people without a king survive?
Or was this just a temporary experiment, a fluke of history?
By 1787,
there were a group of men who recognized that the country was about to fall apart.
And what did they do?
The short answer is that three men decide to stage a coup d'état.
These men are James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and John Jay.
And they recruit a fourth all-important person,
and that is George Washington.
Washington does not want to do this.
He believes he's retired.
He's 55 years old.
He believes his best days are behind him.
Madison is the one who's really putting the pressure on him.
If you look at what Madison is saying to Washington
in their private letters,
it's pretty clear they think the Union is on the verge of falling apart.
Eventually, Washington agrees to come.
They decide to have an actual Constitutional Convention.
They'll go back to Philadelphia.
They went because they were scared.
They were scared
that the country that had only been in existence a few years
was going to vanish.
The experiment is in trouble.
The Constitutional Convention takes place
at Independence Hall in Philadelphia.
And so they're coming back to a place that is really sacred.
There's a lot of street noise.
And they're right next to the jail.
And so there's noise from the jail.
It's a very busy place.
There is a lot of speculation about what's going on.
The convention opens the great field of political speculation.
There seems to be at present an astonishing variety in the opinion
even of respectable men.
The eyes of friends and enemies of all Europe,
nay more, of the whole world
are upon the United States.
From the beginning, the founders saw themselves
as engaged in an experiment.
An experiment designed to show the viability of Republican government
after thousands of years of failure.
It had never really worked on a large scale.
One of the foremost fears in the founding generation,
which they got from looking back at the past,
ancient Rome,
Ancient Greece,
was demagogues.
Of those men who have overturned the liberties of republics,
the greatest number have begun their career
by paying an obsequious court to the people,
commencing demagogues and ending tyrants.
Over and over again,
they talk about the threat of demagogues in a republic.
Why? Because republics are grounded on public opinion.
And what demagogues do is they say whatever it takes to get power.
And sway the public.
And the public can readily be swayed.
And then once they have power, they do whatever they want to do
to serve themselves.
It's all about the demagogue
who exploits the resentments of the masses,
uses that to further his agenda. And the next thing you know, it's tyranny.
So all the delegates are mindful
that you have to be very careful about ceding power to government
because tyranny is a constant danger.
Corruption is a problem. Everyone is potentially corruptible.
There are 55 delegates at the Constitutional Convention.
So who are the main characters?
George Washington and James Madison in the front of the room,
one of the tallest and one of the smallest delegates.
In the back of the room are two Virginians,
George Mason and Edmund Randolph.
Mason, such a large figure,
he wrote the Virginia Declaration of Rights,
which Jefferson had by his side
when he wrote the Declaration of Independence.
Randolph, considered one of the great lawyers of America,
although Thomas Jefferson calls him a perfect chameleon
and says he's always shifting his position.
In addition to Virginia,
the next most important delegation is from Pennsylvania.
So who's in Pennsylvania? Well, first, Benjamin Franklin,
the oldest delegate.
He was no longer at the peak of his career.
He was almost crippled by gout.
When you read through the notes,
he's sometimes treated almost kind of the crazy uncle in the room.
Next to Franklin is Gouverneur Morris.
He's the most important of the founders that very few people have ever heard of.
Morris speaks more than anybody at the Constitutional Convention.
He is a remarkable wordsmith.
And he may have been the most colorful man in North America.
He was a peg-legged ladies' man with a really wicked sense of humor.
He's a serial philanderer.
He has endless numbers of affairs.
He had his leg amputated at 28 as the result of a bad carriage accident,
although there were rumors following him throughout life
that he'd shattered the leg jumping out a bedroom window
to escape the wrath of an ill-timed husband.
Next to Gouverneur Morris is James Wilson,
who is the great apostle of popular sovereignty.
It's his idea that we,
the people in America, have the sovereign power,
not the king, as in Britain,
or not the king in Parliament,
but the people of the United States.
But Wilson, as a lawyer, defended loyalists.
He is widely hated.
And the irony of Wilson is
that he's the most democratic of anybody at the convention.
And yet so many people think he's elitist,
and they really hate him in a most vicious way.
Alexander Hamilton was one of only three delegates
from New York State.
Hamilton was a loud and leading nationalist,
wanting a strong government.
But his two counterparts are not excited about a stronger national government.
And his state has one vote.
So he's essentially outvoted. You've got to feel bad for the guy.
Eventually, 12 of the states are represented there.
Rhode Island chose not to send delegates.
The most notable missing delegates at the Constitutional Convention
were John Adams and Thomas Jefferson.
Thomas Jefferson was the drafter of the Declaration of Independence,
but he was on a diplomatic mission in France.
John Adams, who had written the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780,
was stationed in England.
George Washington at the Constitutional Convention
is a great question and an enigma in many ways.
He doesn't want to get involved. He's not an attorney. He's not a lawyer.
But he understands his presence will mean something.
He's nominated to be the president of the convention.
Fine, he'll do it.
So he sits in a chair on a platform elevated above everyone else.
And he's pretty quiet throughout the Constitutional Convention.
People trusted George Washington with power
because he's never seemed to be grasping at power.
He made himself a kind of symbolic figure at the convention.
He took himself out of most of the debates and very rarely spoke up.
Delegates want to have a very lively discussion,
and they are mindful that if things are taken out of context,
if things leak prematurely, it could kill the convention.
Trust is the glue that holds democracies together.
Principled compromise is the necessary approach
to cooling the passions.
Okay, I hear you. You're passionate about this.
You're passionate about that.
Can we make a little bit of progress toward common ground?
So they do impose a pretty strict rule of secrecy.
Nevertheless,
James Madison starts taking notes on what everybody is saying.
The curiosity I had felt
during my researches into the history of the most distinguished confederacies
determined me to preserve as far as I could
an exact account of what might pass in the convention.
The way we know what happened day to day at the convention
was from Madison's notes.
But they were not made public for a long time.
James Madison was scholarly,
and he prepared for the Constitutional Convention
in part by looking at confederations over time
and which worked, which didn't work.
He wants a stronger national government.
James Madison gets the Virginia delegates to show up early
so they can coordinate around a plan.
And it came to be called the Virginia Plan.
Because Madison was a good politician and not a great public speaker,
he gave the plan to Edmund Randolph, the governor of Virginia,
who was a very public politician.
And on the first day of substantive debates at the convention,
Edmund Randolph introduces the Virginia Plan.
The Virginia Plan is nationalist,
meaning shifting power from the state and local level to the national level.
It imagined a three-part government
with legislature,
an executive,
and a judiciary.
The framers believe that power should be separated,
and they believe that partly because they're influenced by Montesquieu.
The French philosopher Montesquieu
was the first thinker to separate the powers into the three branches
that we know and love, legislative, executive, judicial.
Constant experience shows us
that every man invested with power is apt to abuse it
and to carry his authority as far as it will go.
To prevent this abuse,
it is necessary from the very nature of things
that power should be a check to power.
The point behind separating powers into the three branches
and instituting checks and balances among those branches was to ensure
that each branch had an effective way of checking any missteps or wrongdoing
by the other branches.
All of these men feared the rise of tyranny.
Checks and balances were no joke.
They were designed to give people power or branches of government power
and then hedge it around in some way so that they couldn't have absolute power.
Sometimes people talk about gridlock.
Gridlock is actually… It's a feature, not a bug.
It is by design.
Our government was not designed to be fast and efficient
because fast and efficient means
that a tyrant can use it quickly against the people.
Madison said, "Ambition will counter ambition."
He assumed the legislative branch,
the executive branch, and the judicial branch would check
the other branches' ambitions.
If you showed up to the Philadelphia Convention,
you could be forgiven for thinking
that you were maybe just there to amend the Articles of Confederation.
When the convention begins, they do not have a mandate
to write a new form of government at all.
The Constitutional Convention is supposed to revise the Articles of Confederation.
But the Virginia Plan had what they call an agenda setting effect.
And so everyone else at the convention was immediately reacting to that plan.
Once it was on the table, the message was clear to all the delegates
that they were not just going to tinker with what existed.
They were going to start something new.
What are the powers of the government that you're creating?
What can it do?
These are the fundamental questions
that would occupy them for the next several months.
The American president is the most creative product
of the convention.
It was truly new.
There had been courts forever.
There had been legislatures for centuries.
There had never really been an executive who is not a king
in a nation with a powerful legislature.
The framers were worried
that you'd have an executive who behaves like a king.
And so they wanted to put limitations in place.
The debate about the executive in the convention
was between two extreme positions.
Randolph and some of the Virginians initially did not want
a super powerful president.
Edmund Randolph thought there should be three people.
He wanted the executive to be modeled on the Roman triumvirate.
I strenuously oppose a unity in the executive magistracy.
I regard it as the fetus of monarchy.
I cannot see why the great requisites for the executive department,
vigor, despatch, and responsibility,
could not be found in three men as well as in one man.
But then they said, "Wait a minute. You know what's gonna happen?"
"They're going to argue."
On the other side were figures like Gouverneur Morris,
James Wilson and Alexander Hamilton,
who actually wanted a president to be at least as powerful
and maybe even more powerful than the King of England.
And they thought it was a good idea to have a more powerful executive
to enable the country to fight wars effectively
and to enable the country to become a global empire.
One thing we really have to recognize about the presidency
as it was created by the convention
was that they were literally looking at George Washington.
He was sitting there in the big chair,
and the presidency was tailored to him like a suit.
They're comfortable with Washington.
But once you move beyond Washington,
the other people whose names are famous, they don't trust.
Washington wouldn't be around forever.
And so they tried to design the structure of the executive
such that there would be checks on his power.
They have these debates, and they're wrapped up together.
Who should choose the president? What should the president's powers be?
How can the president be removed from office?
Something they spent the most time on
was how we're gonna elect this individual.
Almost no one in Philadelphia in 1787
wanted the president to be directly elected
by all of the people.
Most of the delegates found this idea
totally ridiculous and laughable.
They weren't sufficiently trusting of the general public
to think they should go to that for the election of a president.
This was really a practical, technical challenge.
The average farm family probably never left where they were born.
They certainly didn't have a newspaper in town.
They didn't have Fox or MSNBC.
The candidates would have to go from state to state.
It would take, I don't know, five or six years to meet every farmer
and introduce yourself.
There's also a lot of concern about a person
who would be popularly elected
and come into power and never relinquish it.
And Hamilton later says
if there's a Caesar who's gonna rise in America,
it might be by a demagogue taking advantage of commotion
and riding in on horseback and calling off elections
and installing himself as a dictator.
When a man unprincipled in private life,
desperate in his fortune,
bold in his temper, possessed of considerable talents,
having the advantage of military habits,
despotic in his ordinary demeanor,
known to have scoffed in private at the principles of liberty.
When such a man is seen to mount the hobbyhorse of popularity,
to flatter and fall in
with all the nonsense of the zealots of the day,
it may justly be suspected
that his object is to throw things into confusion,
that he may ride the storm and direct the whirlwind.
Alexander Hamilton was one of the people
who warned consistently about demagogic leaders
who would get into power, never want to leave,
use the power of the office to enrich themselves,
use it to promote their own agendas.
They had certain expectations,
even more than powers, in my view,
about how an executive would faithfully implement the law,
protect and defend the Constitution.
It was the model that the founders were trying to put forth
and surrounding that model
with all of the warnings from Hamilton and others
about the alternative.
The framers were not naive.
They understood that people seek power, that people are self-interested.
They had no delusions
that politicians would be these self-serving saints.
Our founders were conscious of two sort of tyrannies that they feared,
tyranny of a dictator or a king,
but also tyranny of the majority.
They were afraid of rule by one, but they were also afraid of rule by many.
They wanted to be self-ruled.
Hamilton proposes a president elected for life
on the idea this would make him above corruption.
He can have the public interest rather than his interest
and won't be tempted to play politics.
But yet to most people, then and now,
it sounded suspiciously like a king.
And it's a total flop 'cause it's so radical.
This is a government where they've decided
it's about the people, not the king.
And yet most of them think
having popular election for the president is a terrible idea.
But if Congress elects the president,
they're convinced that Congress will work deals with the president
to get basically what they want, personally and politically.
It's an incredibly tricky problem, and they can't figure it out.
They were deadlocked, and they said, "Let's move on."
"We'll come back to this later."
"We'll come back to how to elect the president later."
The order of the Constitution was important to the founding generation.
Article II created the executive branch.
Article I was the legislative branch.
The Congress was always a place
where the popular will of the American people
was meant to be expressed.
These men believed that Congress was the heart and soul of the government.
So the president's job would be to administer the laws
that the Congress passed.
In Article I, Section 8, they enumerated the powers of Congress.
I memorized a shortened version of it.
TCC, NCC, PCC, PAWN, MOMMA, WREN.
Taxes, credit, commerce,
naturalization, coinage, counterfeiting,
post office, copyright, courts,
piracy, army, war, navy, militia, money for militia,
Washington DC, rules, and necessary and proper.
The image they had of Congress was a deliberative body of serious people,
of American elites.
But how do you create a system that allows people to have representation?
The single most contentious issue
at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia was
how many representatives each state would get.
The Virginia Plan proposed
that there would be two houses of the legislature,
and both would choose their members based on population.
So big states would get more representatives,
and big states would also get more senators.
The legislature ought to be the most exact transcript
of the whole society.
This would give tremendous power to the big states,
and take away an enormous amount of power from the small states.
James Madison was absolutely adamant
on proportional representation,
that it'd be based on population.
He thought the only way that a representative democracy,
like, functions well, is by advancing ideas
that are attractive to the majority of the people.
Now, Virginia was the most populous state at the time,
so they obviously had an interest in proportional representation.
Virginia is ten times the size of tiny Delaware.
Will Virginia have ten times the number of representatives?
This alarmed the smaller states,
who countered with what became known as the New Jersey Plan.
And the New Jersey Plan,
instead of having two legislative chambers, would have one.
And guess what? Each state would have one vote.
The states wanted to be sure
they had some power versus the federal government.
They didn't want to wake up and find
that the federal government was imposing on them
taxes or laws and regulations
that they found inimical to their own interests.
And so there was a lot of tension between the states.
The small states essentially told
the representatives of the large states,
"You have two choices."
"Either you're going to agree to give us equal representation,
regardless of our size,
the same way we had it in the Articles of Confederation,
or we're out of here."
"You're not going to get a constitution at all."
New Jersey will never confederate on the plan before the committee.
She would be swallowed up.
I had rather submitted to a monarch, to a despot, than to such a fate.
The large states believed this would give a disproportionate power
to the smaller states.
It would be in the power then of less than one third
to overrule two thirds.
The arguments are going on, and they're growing more intense.
They insist that although the three great states form
nearly a majority of the people of America,
they never will hurt or injure the lesser states.
I do not, gentlemen, trust you.
It was not out of the question for the states
to simply break up their union.
If a separation must take place, it could never happen on better grounds.
So tempers were clearly rising.
I think there are times they're not far from being at blows with one another.
The large states dare not dissolve the confederation.
If they do, the small ones will find
some foreign ally of more honor and good faith
who will take them by the hand and do them justice.
This country must be united.
If persuasion does not unite it, the sword will.
And that's when the convention almost fell apart.
Philadelphia summers are hot and humid.
The first thing these men did when Washington gaveled,
you know, "We're done for the day," was rush to the tavern and drink.
I can guarantee you
that an enormous amount of alcohol was consumed.
An enormous amount of alcohol was consumed by everybody in America
at the time.
People kept pestering them, "What's happening? What's going on?"
"What are you doing? You can tell me, I'm your wife."
"You can tell me, I'm your father."
Mrs. House's, where I am, is very crowded,
and the room I am presently in so small as not to admit of a second bed.
So it was not a happy experience.
They're all in the same room, and it's stifling.
As you may know, in the 18th century, people didn't take showers very often.
And you're basically trapped with the same guys
until you reach some sort of agreement.
At this point, the small states insisted,
you know, "Our states will never ratify a document
that deprives them of their equal representation."
The small staters weren't backing down.
Threats ended up wearing down the large staters,
or at least some of them.
And a compromise actually came from some Connecticut delegates.
Roger Sherman and Oliver Ellsworth
are clearly key players in what's called the Connecticut Compromise
or the Great Compromise.
The Virginia Plan wants representation by population
in both houses of Congress.
The New Jersey Plan wants representation by the states.
And the Connecticut Compromise, like Goldilocks, splits the difference
and has representation by population in the House
and by states in the Senate.
In the House, representation is determined by a census every ten years.
And as a result,
the number of total representatives changes based on population.
In the Senate, every state gets two representatives.
But the Senate itself, actually at the American founding,
was not popularly elected.
The states appointed members to the United States Senate.
It really wasn't until 1913
that the Constitution was amended
to allow for the popular election of senators.
The convention very narrowly approved the Connecticut Compromise.
And at the end of the day, it's mostly a power play.
And the small states play a good game of poker.
And the status quo advantages them.
The delegates from the big states
ultimately chose compromise.
And that compromise was very remarkable.
Until that moment,
they had fully expected to have a democratic constitution
where power lay with the people.
What they got was a constitutional republic
in which the small states, through the Senate,
could exercise enormous disproportionate influence.
This was not just a temporary compromise.
It's one of the only clauses in the Constitution
that the amendment clause, Article V, expressly says you can't change.
We still have a U.S. Senate
where Wyoming with 550,000 people gets the same two senators as California
with 39 million people.
That's not fair.
But our founders could never possibly imagine
a state with 40 million people versus 1 million or fewer.
They thought that the idea that Wyoming would have two senators
was a check and a balance on the force of democracy.
How would Wyoming ever have its own personality or survive
if they had no senators and had no vote?
They'd be subsumed into California, God forbid.
And so the only way these small states are able to have any personalities
is because of the design of the Senate.
At the Philadelphia Convention, lots of folks thought
that the big debate was going to be between big states and small states.
And it was.
But the delegates had come to see
that the division that was more significant in the long run
was going to be between free states and slave states.
Slavery was the thousand-pound elephant in the room
because they know it's a dealbreaker.
Slavery was an original sin of the formation of our nation.
Slavery was at the core of some of the most difficult,
contentious discussions within the Constitutional Convention.
There were abolitionists and there were slave-owning members.
I never will concur in upholding domestic slavery.
It is a nefarious institution.
Gouverneur Morris was, without question, the staunchest opponent of slavery
at the convention.
It is the curse of heaven on the states where it prevails.
He's a Northerner from a slave-holding family.
His father enslaved several dozen people when he was a child.
But he was clear-sighted enough about slavery's evils.
He opposed it way back
at the New York State Constitutional Convention in 1777
when he's only 25 years old.
A lot of the delegates to the convention,
even a couple of the Southern delegates,
were essentially abolitionists and thought that allowing the nation
to take form around the institution of slavery
was a huge mistake.
They also knew how hypocritical it was
to have fought a war in which you claimed the whole point was liberty and equality
and then deny it to others.
But they decided in the end
that if they didn't put that question to the side,
they wouldn't have a constitution.
The delegates from the South would not have signed on
to a constitution that didn't protect slavery in some way.
Slavery is much more important
to states like Georgia, South Carolina, and Virginia
than it is to states like New Jersey, New York, and Massachusetts.
And the presumption is
that in order to hold
this fragile alliance of 13 states together,
you are going to have to concede to the interests
of the more slavery-oriented economies.
Not everybody liked it, but they knew it was essential
to the economic underpinnings of the country.
So the most famous conflict
between the free states and the slave states at the convention
was the conflict about how to count enslaved persons
when they decided how many representatives each state would get.
The Southern states' position was,
"We want all slaves to be counted
in our population for purposes of representation."
"We're not going to let them vote."
"We're not going to let them be free, but they count."
The labor of a slave in South Carolina
is as productive and valuable as that of a free man in Massachusetts.
Consequently, an equal representation ought to be allowed for them.
The anti-slavery Northerners pushed back against that.
Upon what principle is it that the slaves shall be computed in the representation?
Are they men? Then make them citizens and let them vote.
Are they property? Why then is no other property included?
The Northern states also talked
about how you guys are going to have disproportionate power
because we're counting your slaves, and there were a lot of slaves,
but those slaves are never going to vote at all.
The result was
the most famous and shameful compromise of the Constitutional Convention,
the three-fifths compromise.
It was James Wilson of Pennsylvania
and Charles Pinckney of South Carolina who proposed the three-fifths clause.
Three-fifths, or 60%, of the enslaved population
will be counted in the census
as belonging to the state where they reside.
What that effectively does
is use the bodies of enslaved people
to subsidize the political authority of the people who are enslaving them,
but they do want them to be counted as part of the society
when it comes to politics.
What's not being said here
is that the contradiction is not whether enslaved people should count
or whether they should not count,
but whether you can have a democracy and have enslaved people simultaneously.
That is the debate that gets sidestepped in order to come up with the half measure,
or we should say the 60% measure, of the three-fifths compromise.
People who were excluded from participating in the politics
of this era
knew they were excluded and they were angry about it.
When we talk about the people,
we have to distinguish people who are being counted
for the purposes of how many representatives you get
and people who are themselves allowed to elect those representatives.
Enslaved people won't vote and women won't vote.
The only place where women can vote is in New Jersey
in a brief period of time.
Some women who were either widowed or single
and owned property in New Jersey could vote.
But eventually New Jersey passes a law
that takes the new language of white male voters
and imposes it on the New Jersey voting population.
We know that from the notes we have of the Constitutional Convention,
they never talk about women's rights.
The idea was if a man is voting on behalf of his whole household,
the woman should be in conversation with him about politics,
but his vote is supposed to represent the entire household.
The founding fathers of the Constitution
saw tribal peoples as citizens of their own government.
They were not state or federal citizens,
so they thought it made perfect sense not to count that Indian person.
We're not a party to the Constitution.
Tribes are mentioned in the context of the ability of the federal government
to regulate the relationship between tribes in the United States.
And yet we're physically within the United States.
We're dealing with people that want our land, want our resources,
people that want to go to war.
A federal government that may want to use its army
to march us across the United States, which it did.
And so we may not be part of the Constitution,
but the Constitution is one of the most consequential instruments
in all of Cherokee history.
The other main debate around slavery during the convention
was over the continuance of the overseas slave trade.
South Carolina and Georgia would like
to keep importing slaves from Africa.
The North doesn't want the slave trade to continue,
partly because the slave trade is even more reprehensible than slavery.
You're kidnapping people, tearing away from their families.
A large percentage are going to die in the Atlantic passage.
I consider it as inadmissible on every principle of honor and safety
that the importation of slaves should be authorized to the states
by the Constitution.
And this is a huge division over slavery, leading to a big clash.
If the convention thinks
that North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia will ever agree to the plan,
unless their rights to import slaves be untouched,
the expectation is vain.
In another compromise arrangement,
the Constitution included a provision that said
that for 20 years after ratification,
Congress would not be able to abolish the slave trade.
After 20 years, Congress would be able to do it.
And the reason that was sufficient from the standpoint of the Southerners,
in my view, was that the Southerners were confident
that if they could import enough slaves in the intervening 20 years,
that they can continue relying totally on an internal supply of slaves.
That is the natural reproduction of enslaved people.
It's really dark.
In return for that,
the North got the power through Congress
to impose laws on trade by simple majority vote.
The South was afraid of that because they were afraid
that the North would make everything cost more in the South.
In a really complicated deal, basically,
South Carolina agrees to support the New England position
on congressional power over trade
in exchange for protecting the international slave trade.
That was the so-called dirty compromise.
The last important provision dealing with slavery
is the Fugitive Slave Clause.
In very sanitized language,
it holds that individuals who are held in service in one part of the country
could not escape that service by leaving that part of the country.
In that language,
you would almost not know
that you were talking about human beings who were being bred, whipped, raped,
abused, bought, sold,
and trafficked.
This clause also forced the Northern states,
the ones that were already abolishing slavery,
to acknowledge the constitutional lawfulness
of the practice of slavery itself.
The framers made a bargain over slavery,
and they didn't think there was a choice.
They decided not to answer the question
of whether this would be a slave nation or a free nation,
and to allow that question to be answered differently
in different parts of the country.
Some of the Virginian delegates to the convention,
like James Madison and George Washington,
deep down, they knew that slavery was wrong.
What Madison and Washington were able to tell themselves,
to salve their conscience,
was that slavery was an old-fashioned anachronism,
and it would eventually end.
And so they were willing to accept
the various compromises on slavery in the Constitution,
telling themselves that the United States would not forever be a slave republic.
Morris, who is the strongest opponent of slavery at the convention,
is horrified.
The inhabitant of Georgia and South Carolina
who goes to the coast of Africa,
and in the defiance of the most sacred laws of humanity
tears away his fellow creatures from his dearest connections
and damns them to the most cruel bondage,
shall have more votes in the government instituted for the protection
of the rights of mankind
than the citizen of Pennsylvania or New Jersey
who views with laudable horror so nefarious a practice.
The Constitutional Convention makes slavery central
to the American experience.
So in many ways,
it really makes clear
that this is going to be a major divide in the United States for years to come.
Even when you know that that compromise
was necessary for the very edifice to come into existence at all,
that doesn't really make the slavery compromises easier to swallow.
The compromise may have made union possible in a sense,
but it also made it fundamentally unstable.
All the solutions are temporary.
Even the permanent solutions are temporary.
And to varying degrees, people are aware of that at the time.
It's hard to believe that this is going to hold.
When you look at the Convention, the big focus is Congress.
Second focus, the executive.
The judiciary, really, the least.
The Constitution, which I have a copy.
There it is.
Will this work or will it not?
They're facing this question.
We have balanced powers
between a Congress over here, which legislates,
and a president and the executive branch under him,
which will execute.
But how do we know
they're not going to misinterpret the words here?
We need some judges to say
when they've gone too far.
Because this sets boundaries.
They wanted an independent judiciary separate and apart from the executive.
So they were looking for the popular will to be expressed, implemented, and judged.
Article III of the Constitution, of the three major articles
that set up the different branches of the U.S. government,
it is the shortest.
They actually just say one Supreme Court.
It doesn't tell us how many people will be on that court.
In fact, that court originally is six justices.
There's no time limit with respect to judges.
The only limitation with respect to their term
is whether they are acting in good behavior or not,
which has been interpreted as lifetime appointments.
The original idea about lifetime appointments was
to maintain the independence of the judiciary.
Over time, as the parties have become more polarized,
they've taken advantage of lifetime appointments
to try to appoint judges very young and hope for very long tenures
in terms of partisan appointments.
It creates these kind of strange situations
where you can really lock in ideological preferences
for a very long time.
Today, neither the president nor the Congress
really has the ambition to take on the Supreme Court
in its claims that it gets to have the last word
on the Constitution.
That would have been foreign to Washington,
Jefferson, Jackson, and Lincoln.
They all claim that presidents and congresses had the right
to interpret the Constitution on the same par as the Supreme Court.
With three branches of government finally sorted,
everyone can see how power is going to be distributed.
But to a certain degree,
the framers left unresolved just how powerful the president would be.
They needed a figure who would be elevated enough to be a world player,
but also would be accountable
to the public and to the laws that Congress passed.
…matter of national competition.
The founders thought people should have a say
in everything about how they're governed,
but most importantly, on issues of war and peace,
life and death.
Under a monarchy, the king is responsible for declaring war.
They rejected that system.
So they split the military powers.
They gave Congress the sole power to declare war,
but they put the president in charge of it as commander in chief.
They agreed that no president could start a war
without permission of Congress.
Every one of them said that.
It's in the Constitution,
and yet war is routinely fought now with an executive order.
In no part of the Constitution is more wisdom to be found
than in the clause which confides the question of war or peace
to the legislature and not to the executive department.
The trust and the temptation would be too great for any one man.
One of the fears that was explicitly voiced
at the convention
was what to do about a president
who decided to use the power of the presidency
to undermine the Constitution and the rule of law.
So they come up with a fairly broad definition of impeachment.
The founders weren't very clear on impeachment,
on what it would decide, what was a high crime and misdemeanor.
Impeachment ultimately turned out to be
extremely difficult ever to operationalize in practice.
We've had impeachments in the United States on four occasions,
but never the conviction of a president.
And only one president, Richard Nixon, who was not yet impeached,
was about to be impeached,
has ever actually resigned from the presidency under its threat.
I think there is much less of a protection against corruption
than they imagined there was.
By late August, they all want to get home. They all want to be done.
Every article is again argued over
with as much earnestness and obstinacy as before.
They'd been away from their families.
They'd been away from their businesses, their farms, their plantations.
What they haven't settled, they're going to settle by committee
in September.
And the most important thing they do is they create the Electoral College.
US voters went to the polls and elected a president last month,
so the one with the most votes wins, right?
Not quite.
I personally think the Electoral College is an abomination…
…for obvious reasons.
I know how disappointed you feel because I feel it too.
And so do tens of millions of Americans
who invested their hopes and dreams in this effort.
James Wilson is sort of a shadowy figure to most.
I mean, if you ask 500 Americans, they would never have heard of him.
He did the one thing that we wish he hadn't done at the convention.
He came up with the Electoral College.
The Electoral College is a group of people
called together for one purpose, to decide who's going to be president.
You can think of the Electoral College
as a compromise on top of a compromise on top of a compromise.
Your number of electors is your number of senators
plus your number of House members.
So Southerners will get some slave representation
in the small states.
Because every state gets two senators,
it's going to do a little better in the Electoral College
than they do in the House.
The founders themselves were not in love with the Electoral College.
It was defective from the beginning.
We have a problem that a minority of the population,
because of the structure of the Electoral College,
in some cases,
over the objections of the majority,
is ruling the majority.
I'm one who finds virtue in the Electoral College.
It's not just because I come from a smaller state, Arizona,
that may benefit more than a larger state like California.
It emphasizes our system of federalism.
We are not a direct democracy, we're a representative democracy.
The states have considerable power. The states run elections.
That is a good thing to decentralize that kind of power.
James Madison always viewed the Electoral College
as a stopgap measure.
That mode which was judged most expedient was adopted.
Till experience should point out one more eligible.
He always assumed
that ultimately someone would come up with a better idea than that.
Since they had voted randomly, one thing after another,
in no particular order,
they gave it all to Gouverneur Morris and say, "Here, Gouve."
They didn't call him that, but I'm paraphrasing.
"Do something with this."
And he wrote the Constitution.
Morris wrote the Constitution over three and a half days.
He did his work very quickly.
He took 23 sprawling articles
and pared it down to a neat seven articles.
He changed or chose a great deal of the wording
on his own initiative in consequential ways.
The Fugitive Slave Clause describes
enslaved people going back to the people who justly owned them.
Gouverneur Morris, the fiercest opponent of slavery
at the Constitutional Convention, takes the word justly out.
And that is huge.
The final Constitution does not ever include the word slave.
And Frederick Douglass in the 19th century
would make this a large part of his argument
about why the Constitution could be interpreted
to lean towards liberty.
In the final days of the Constitutional Convention,
a couple of delegates became gadflies,
making various kinds of demands for changes
that seemed significant to them.
George Mason spoke out repeatedly in favor of the need of a bill of rights
that would protect individuals against government overreach.
I wish the plan had been prefaced with a bill of rights.
It would give great quiet to the people.
Any free society has the right to free speech,
or any free society has the right to assemble.
Any free society has due process right.
You can't have your property taken.
But it's not written down anywhere. So how do you rely on it?
People would say,
"This is a government that's created for the purpose of protecting rights,"
but didn't actually say anything about protecting most rights.
The general feeling in the convention was,
"We don't need a bill of rights."
"Because we haven't conferred on the central government any powers
that would impinge on individual liberty."
The fundamental rights were thought to be implied.
And so the Constitutional Convention on September 17th adjourns
without what we come to know as a bill of rights being part of it.
By the time the convention ended in September,
some delegates had already left.
There are three dissenters who refused to sign the Constitution.
Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts,
George Mason of Virginia,
and Edmund Randolph of Virginia.
They have different reasons for refusing to sign.
But it's mostly the lack of a bill of rights.
Everybody else supports it.
And they sign it.
Benjamin Franklin gives a great speech.
When you assemble a number of men
to have the advantage of their joint wisdom,
you inevitably assemble with those men all their prejudices, their passions,
their errors of opinion,
their local interests, and their selfish views.
From such an assembly, can a perfect production be expected?
It therefore astonishes me, sir,
to find this system approaching so near to perfection as it does.
Thus, I consent, sir, to this Constitution because I expect no better.
One of the other things that Franklin says
is that he had looked at the back of a chair
in Independence Hall.
Franklin says,
"I've been looking during the convention at the sun on the president's chair."
"And I've wondered, is it a rising sun or is it a setting sun?"
I have the happiness to know that it is a rising and not a setting sun.
The thing is full of compromises.
I think we tend to exaggerate
how confident they are that they quite got it right.
They have a tremendous and well-earned anxiety
about how this all could go wrong.
Some of the people who do sign give speeches saying
that they understand this isn't a perfect document,
that not everybody agreed,
but they think
this is about as good a document as they could give.
None of them envisioned that it would go on for almost 250 years.
The Constitution is the greatest legal document ever crafted.
The oldest national Constitution still in operation,
based on the radical premise
that we the people as a whole are sovereign,
not the king and not the legislature,
and that we parcel power out to different parts of the government
in order to protect liberty.
And the proposition that it's possible to create a government
based on the ideas of liberty, equality,
and government by consent
is the most inspiring experiment in world history.
The initial preamble said,
"We the people of the states of New Hampshire and Massachusetts
and on down the eastern seaboard."
Gouverneur Morris changed it to, "We the people of the United States,"
and wrote the Constitution's ringing statement of purpose.
We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union,
establish justice,
ensure domestic tranquility,
provide for the common defense,
promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty
to ourselves and our posterity,
do ordain and establish this constitution.
I was at the National Archives not long ago,
and a lot of the words of the Constitution under that dark glass in that dimmed room
are hard to read.
But there are three that are not hard to read.
The top of the first page, "We the people."
And those first three words of the Constitution
would always define our nation.
The reason why we're so special is because of "We the people."
When the framers talked about "We the people,"
"we the people" was a small group of people
that they were really talking about.
There were so many other people that were here
that weren't considered part of the "People."
But to me, that's the beauty of the document,
that it is aspirational.
We the people.
Representation does matter.
Our lived experiences, our professional experiences,
add to the richness,
add to the better quality of the government.
The Constitution's a miraculous document in my view.
It's a remarkable document.
It reflects a diverse country that wants to maintain that diversity,
but also a dynamic country that wants to maintain that dynamism.
Elizabeth Willing Powel, who was probably the most important
politically connected woman in Philadelphia,
asks Franklin whether the delegates have given the country
a republic or a monarchy.
And he famously says, "A republic, if you can keep it."
That really encapsulated
what many of them, I think, felt from their writings that,
"Sure hope this works, and we've set it up to the best of our ability."
"But it is still an experiment."
There clearly is some sense that it's far from over.
Now it goes to the states
and the rule is nine of them have to ratify
for the Constitution to go into effect.
And the passage of the Constitution is very much in doubt.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.