1
00:00:05,922 --> 00:00:09,759
-You won the popular vote…
-I did.

2
00:00:10,385 --> 00:00:12,595
Yes, I remember that every day.

3
00:00:13,847 --> 00:00:17,559
Hillary Clinton received
65.7 million votes,

4
00:00:17,642 --> 00:00:21,229
and Donald Trump received 62.9 million.

5
00:00:21,312 --> 00:00:23,064
So how is he president?

6
00:00:23,148 --> 00:00:27,277
The Constitution sets up a system
called the Electoral College.

7
00:00:27,360 --> 00:00:30,739
The winning presidential candidate,
in this case, Donald Trump,

8
00:00:30,822 --> 00:00:34,868
has to have a majority,
or 270 electoral votes.

9
00:00:34,951 --> 00:00:39,664
Trump actually has 306 to Clinton's 232.

10
00:00:40,331 --> 00:00:43,626
I remember listening to commentators
from around the world.

11
00:00:44,419 --> 00:00:47,714
A political scientist from France says,
"We don't understand this."

12
00:00:47,797 --> 00:00:51,426
You know, "In our country,
the person who gets the most votes wins."

13
00:00:52,135 --> 00:00:55,013
Donald Trump won the election
without the popular vote

14
00:00:55,096 --> 00:00:58,266
something that only happened
four times before.

15
00:01:00,018 --> 00:01:02,479
We've had, you know, other incidents,

16
00:01:02,562 --> 00:01:06,858
but mine was probably the clearest case
because the margin was significant.

17
00:01:09,986 --> 00:01:12,864
It's a very bizarre feeling

18
00:01:12,947 --> 00:01:15,992
to know that nearly
three million more people

19
00:01:16,076 --> 00:01:17,911
voted for you,

20
00:01:17,994 --> 00:01:24,250
and a relic of compromises
from the Constitutional Convention

21
00:01:24,334 --> 00:01:28,379
are going to prevent you
from becoming president.

22
00:01:28,463 --> 00:01:30,548
What were these guys thinking

23
00:01:30,632 --> 00:01:34,844
when they put together
this constitutional provision?

24
00:01:34,928 --> 00:01:37,222
The Electoral College
is one of the most mysterious

25
00:01:37,305 --> 00:01:39,390
and peculiar parts of the Constitution.

26
00:01:40,683 --> 00:01:43,853
It doesn't really quite work
the way the framers imagined.

27
00:01:44,687 --> 00:01:46,439
There's all kinds of ways

28
00:01:46,523 --> 00:01:49,609
in which America's
own governing institutions

29
00:01:49,692 --> 00:01:52,362
just do not suit
the country that we live in now.

30
00:02:13,508 --> 00:02:16,553
The American founding is a misperception.

31
00:02:17,303 --> 00:02:18,638
There are two foundings.

32
00:02:19,222 --> 00:02:22,559
One, when we declare and win independence.

33
00:02:25,061 --> 00:02:27,730
And the other when we declare nationhood.

34
00:02:27,814 --> 00:02:29,941
That's the Constitutional Convention.

35
00:02:31,526 --> 00:02:33,945
The morning after the revolution,

36
00:02:34,028 --> 00:02:38,449
you discover there are problems
that you hadn't anticipated.

37
00:02:38,533 --> 00:02:42,912
We owed money to France,
to Spain, to the Netherlands,

38
00:02:42,996 --> 00:02:44,706
to the army,

39
00:02:44,789 --> 00:02:47,667
which had almost mutinied
before it was disbanded

40
00:02:47,750 --> 00:02:50,378
because the soldiers weren't being paid.

41
00:02:52,172 --> 00:02:53,798
The Americans won the revolution,

42
00:02:53,882 --> 00:02:56,801
which means they were now able
to squabble with each other.

43
00:02:58,428 --> 00:03:03,141
America is a weak collection of states

44
00:03:03,224 --> 00:03:06,227
in a world of powerful empires.

45
00:03:07,061 --> 00:03:10,481
And it simply isn't going to be able
to last much longer.

46
00:03:11,316 --> 00:03:14,194
It's easy for us now to think
that the war was over,

47
00:03:14,277 --> 00:03:15,778
they created the nation.

48
00:03:15,862 --> 00:03:17,322
That is not how they felt.

49
00:03:18,031 --> 00:03:21,201
The sense that Americans had in 1787,

50
00:03:21,284 --> 00:03:23,369
ten years into independence,

51
00:03:23,453 --> 00:03:25,830
was, "This thing is not working."

52
00:03:26,331 --> 00:03:29,751
They were surrounded
by these European powers

53
00:03:29,834 --> 00:03:33,713
who were like sharks
circling a bleeding man.

54
00:03:34,797 --> 00:03:36,674
So many questions remain.

55
00:03:36,758 --> 00:03:37,884
What do we do now?

56
00:03:37,967 --> 00:03:42,013
Maybe tearing down the old system
was the easy part.

57
00:03:42,513 --> 00:03:46,309
Maybe separating from Britain
was the easy part.

58
00:03:46,392 --> 00:03:48,228
The hard part,

59
00:03:48,311 --> 00:03:54,567
how do you build a government
that can hold this crazy country together?

60
00:03:54,651 --> 00:03:57,612
What gets put in the space
of where the empire was?

61
00:03:57,695 --> 00:03:59,489
What kind of country will be created?

62
00:03:59,572 --> 00:04:00,907
Will a country be created?

63
00:04:00,990 --> 00:04:02,575
Can it hang together?

64
00:04:03,159 --> 00:04:05,703
It's not gonna be a monarchy,
so what will it be?

65
00:04:07,330 --> 00:04:10,500
What's the meaning of America?
What are we striving for?

66
00:04:11,000 --> 00:04:15,421
Could a government based
on the people without a king survive?

67
00:04:16,172 --> 00:04:21,135
Or was this just a temporary experiment,
a fluke of history?

68
00:04:21,761 --> 00:04:24,764
By 1787,

69
00:04:24,847 --> 00:04:31,521
there were a group of men who recognized
that the country was about to fall apart.

70
00:04:31,604 --> 00:04:33,022
And what did they do?

71
00:04:34,107 --> 00:04:39,404
The short answer is that three men decide
to stage a coup d'état.

72
00:04:40,029 --> 00:04:44,951
These men are James Madison,
Alexander Hamilton, and John Jay.

73
00:04:45,702 --> 00:04:49,789
And they recruit
a fourth all-important person,

74
00:04:51,499 --> 00:04:53,418
and that is George Washington.

75
00:04:57,130 --> 00:05:00,466
Washington does not want to do this.

76
00:05:00,550 --> 00:05:02,343
He believes he's retired.

77
00:05:02,427 --> 00:05:05,263
He's 55 years old.

78
00:05:06,055 --> 00:05:08,433
He believes his best days are behind him.

79
00:05:09,726 --> 00:05:12,895
Madison is the one
who's really putting the pressure on him.

80
00:05:12,979 --> 00:05:16,149
If you look at
what Madison is saying to Washington

81
00:05:16,232 --> 00:05:17,859
in their private letters,

82
00:05:17,942 --> 00:05:22,071
it's pretty clear they think the Union
is on the verge of falling apart.

83
00:05:23,990 --> 00:05:26,576
Eventually, Washington agrees to come.

84
00:05:28,411 --> 00:05:31,748
They decide to have
an actual Constitutional Convention.

85
00:05:31,831 --> 00:05:33,333
They'll go back to Philadelphia.

86
00:05:34,876 --> 00:05:37,378
They went because they were scared.

87
00:05:37,462 --> 00:05:38,713
They were scared

88
00:05:38,796 --> 00:05:43,760
that the country that had only been
in existence a few years

89
00:05:44,385 --> 00:05:46,095
was going to vanish.

90
00:05:47,055 --> 00:05:49,015
The experiment is in trouble.

91
00:05:54,604 --> 00:05:56,981
The Constitutional Convention takes place

92
00:05:57,065 --> 00:05:58,900
at Independence Hall in Philadelphia.

93
00:06:00,985 --> 00:06:05,114
And so they're coming back
to a place that is really sacred.

94
00:06:05,698 --> 00:06:07,867
There's a lot of street noise.

95
00:06:07,950 --> 00:06:09,702
And they're right next to the jail.

96
00:06:10,370 --> 00:06:12,163
And so there's noise from the jail.

97
00:06:13,915 --> 00:06:15,875
It's a very busy place.

98
00:06:17,752 --> 00:06:20,588
There is a lot of speculation
about what's going on.

99
00:06:22,006 --> 00:06:26,052
The convention opens
the great field of political speculation.

100
00:06:26,135 --> 00:06:30,306
There seems to be at present
an astonishing variety in the opinion

101
00:06:30,390 --> 00:06:32,100
even of respectable men.

102
00:06:33,017 --> 00:06:36,229
The eyes of friends and enemies
of all Europe,

103
00:06:36,312 --> 00:06:38,147
nay more, of the whole world

104
00:06:38,231 --> 00:06:40,233
are upon the United States.

105
00:06:42,235 --> 00:06:44,654
From the beginning,
the founders saw themselves

106
00:06:44,737 --> 00:06:46,697
as engaged in an experiment.

107
00:06:46,781 --> 00:06:50,201
An experiment designed to show
the viability of Republican government

108
00:06:50,284 --> 00:06:52,245
after thousands of years of failure.

109
00:06:53,538 --> 00:06:55,915
It had never really worked
on a large scale.

110
00:06:56,582 --> 00:07:00,545
One of the foremost fears
in the founding generation,

111
00:07:00,628 --> 00:07:03,840
which they got
from looking back at the past,

112
00:07:03,923 --> 00:07:04,757
ancient Rome,

113
00:07:06,092 --> 00:07:07,343
Ancient Greece,

114
00:07:07,427 --> 00:07:08,886
was demagogues.

115
00:07:10,555 --> 00:07:13,933
Of those men who have
overturned the liberties of republics,

116
00:07:14,016 --> 00:07:16,477
the greatest number
have begun their career

117
00:07:16,561 --> 00:07:19,480
by paying an obsequious court
to the people,

118
00:07:19,564 --> 00:07:23,067
commencing demagogues and ending tyrants.

119
00:07:25,153 --> 00:07:26,529
Over and over again,

120
00:07:26,612 --> 00:07:30,450
they talk about the threat
of demagogues in a republic.

121
00:07:30,533 --> 00:07:33,661
Why? Because republics are grounded
on public opinion.

122
00:07:33,744 --> 00:07:36,956
And what demagogues do is they say
whatever it takes to get power.

123
00:07:38,749 --> 00:07:39,959
And sway the public.

124
00:07:40,042 --> 00:07:42,462
And the public can readily be swayed.

125
00:07:42,545 --> 00:07:45,506
And then once they have power,
they do whatever they want to do

126
00:07:45,590 --> 00:07:46,549
to serve themselves.

127
00:07:47,967 --> 00:07:50,094
It's all about the demagogue

128
00:07:50,178 --> 00:07:53,806
who exploits
the resentments of the masses,

129
00:07:53,890 --> 00:07:58,644
uses that to further his agenda.
And the next thing you know, it's tyranny.

130
00:08:00,229 --> 00:08:02,899
So all the delegates are mindful

131
00:08:02,982 --> 00:08:07,403
that you have to be very careful
about ceding power to government

132
00:08:07,487 --> 00:08:11,282
because tyranny is a constant danger.

133
00:08:11,365 --> 00:08:16,454
Corruption is a problem.
Everyone is potentially corruptible.

134
00:08:31,052 --> 00:08:34,347
There are 55 delegates
at the Constitutional Convention.

135
00:08:35,097 --> 00:08:37,558
So who are the main characters?

136
00:08:40,853 --> 00:08:44,607
George Washington and James Madison
in the front of the room,

137
00:08:46,734 --> 00:08:49,362
one of the tallest
and one of the smallest delegates.

138
00:08:51,280 --> 00:08:53,866
In the back of the room
are two Virginians,

139
00:08:53,950 --> 00:08:56,410
George Mason and Edmund Randolph.

140
00:08:56,911 --> 00:08:59,121
Mason, such a large figure,

141
00:08:59,205 --> 00:09:01,165
he wrote
the Virginia Declaration of Rights,

142
00:09:01,249 --> 00:09:02,833
which Jefferson had by his side

143
00:09:02,917 --> 00:09:05,378
when he wrote
the Declaration of Independence.

144
00:09:05,461 --> 00:09:09,465
Randolph, considered
one of the great lawyers of America,

145
00:09:09,549 --> 00:09:12,802
although Thomas Jefferson
calls him a perfect chameleon

146
00:09:12,885 --> 00:09:15,137
and says he's always
shifting his position.

147
00:09:15,805 --> 00:09:16,931
In addition to Virginia,

148
00:09:17,014 --> 00:09:20,309
the next most important delegation
is from Pennsylvania.

149
00:09:21,018 --> 00:09:24,313
So who's in Pennsylvania?
Well, first, Benjamin Franklin,

150
00:09:24,939 --> 00:09:26,899
the oldest delegate.

151
00:09:26,983 --> 00:09:29,443
He was no longer
at the peak of his career.

152
00:09:30,444 --> 00:09:32,488
He was almost crippled by gout.

153
00:09:32,572 --> 00:09:34,323
When you read through the notes,

154
00:09:34,407 --> 00:09:37,326
he's sometimes treated almost
kind of the crazy uncle in the room.

155
00:09:38,369 --> 00:09:41,372
Next to Franklin is Gouverneur Morris.

156
00:09:42,707 --> 00:09:46,586
He's the most important of the founders
that very few people have ever heard of.

157
00:09:47,169 --> 00:09:50,756
Morris speaks more than anybody
at the Constitutional Convention.

158
00:09:51,841 --> 00:09:55,720
He is a remarkable wordsmith.

159
00:09:55,803 --> 00:09:59,390
And he may have been
the most colorful man in North America.

160
00:10:01,183 --> 00:10:05,396
He was a peg-legged ladies' man
with a really wicked sense of humor.

161
00:10:06,355 --> 00:10:08,274
He's a serial philanderer.

162
00:10:08,357 --> 00:10:11,152
He has endless numbers of affairs.

163
00:10:12,236 --> 00:10:16,866
He had his leg amputated at 28
as the result of a bad carriage accident,

164
00:10:16,949 --> 00:10:19,619
although there were rumors
following him throughout life

165
00:10:19,702 --> 00:10:22,330
that he'd shattered the leg
jumping out a bedroom window

166
00:10:22,413 --> 00:10:24,707
to escape the wrath
of an ill-timed husband.

167
00:10:25,916 --> 00:10:28,836
Next to Gouverneur Morris is James Wilson,

168
00:10:28,919 --> 00:10:33,299
who is the great apostle
of popular sovereignty.

169
00:10:34,342 --> 00:10:35,926
It's his idea that we,

170
00:10:36,010 --> 00:10:38,596
the people in America,
have the sovereign power,

171
00:10:38,679 --> 00:10:40,598
not the king, as in Britain,

172
00:10:40,681 --> 00:10:43,267
or not the king in Parliament,

173
00:10:43,351 --> 00:10:45,478
but the people of the United States.

174
00:10:47,813 --> 00:10:51,400
But Wilson, as a lawyer,
defended loyalists.

175
00:10:52,443 --> 00:10:54,570
He is widely hated.

176
00:10:55,154 --> 00:10:56,989
And the irony of Wilson is

177
00:10:57,073 --> 00:11:01,160
that he's the most democratic
of anybody at the convention.

178
00:11:01,243 --> 00:11:04,205
And yet so many people think he's elitist,

179
00:11:04,288 --> 00:11:06,916
and they really hate him
in a most vicious way.

180
00:11:10,252 --> 00:11:14,882
Alexander Hamilton was
one of only three delegates

181
00:11:14,965 --> 00:11:16,133
from New York State.

182
00:11:17,051 --> 00:11:20,680
Hamilton was
a loud and leading nationalist,

183
00:11:20,763 --> 00:11:22,264
wanting a strong government.

184
00:11:22,932 --> 00:11:27,144
But his two counterparts are not excited
about a stronger national government.

185
00:11:27,228 --> 00:11:28,938
And his state has one vote.

186
00:11:29,021 --> 00:11:32,525
So he's essentially outvoted.
You've got to feel bad for the guy.

187
00:11:39,990 --> 00:11:42,785
Eventually, 12 of the states
are represented there.

188
00:11:42,868 --> 00:11:45,746
Rhode Island chose not to send delegates.

189
00:11:47,164 --> 00:11:51,085
The most notable missing delegates
at the Constitutional Convention

190
00:11:51,168 --> 00:11:53,170
were John Adams and Thomas Jefferson.

191
00:11:54,296 --> 00:11:58,592
Thomas Jefferson was the drafter
of the Declaration of Independence,

192
00:11:58,676 --> 00:12:01,846
but he was
on a diplomatic mission in France.

193
00:12:02,555 --> 00:12:06,350
John Adams, who had written
the Massachusetts Constitution of 1780,

194
00:12:06,434 --> 00:12:08,477
was stationed in England.

195
00:12:11,230 --> 00:12:13,524
George Washington
at the Constitutional Convention

196
00:12:13,607 --> 00:12:16,026
is a great question and an enigma
in many ways.

197
00:12:17,153 --> 00:12:21,532
He doesn't want to get involved.
He's not an attorney. He's not a lawyer.

198
00:12:21,615 --> 00:12:24,785
But he understands
his presence will mean something.

199
00:12:26,245 --> 00:12:30,040
He's nominated
to be the president of the convention.

200
00:12:30,624 --> 00:12:32,501
Fine, he'll do it.

201
00:12:32,585 --> 00:12:37,715
So he sits in a chair on a platform
elevated above everyone else.

202
00:12:37,798 --> 00:12:40,968
And he's pretty quiet
throughout the Constitutional Convention.

203
00:12:42,970 --> 00:12:46,098
People trusted
George Washington with power

204
00:12:46,182 --> 00:12:49,852
because he's never seemed to be
grasping at power.

205
00:12:51,520 --> 00:12:55,566
He made himself a kind of
symbolic figure at the convention.

206
00:12:55,649 --> 00:13:00,279
He took himself out of most of the debates
and very rarely spoke up.

207
00:13:09,872 --> 00:13:13,709
Delegates want to have
a very lively discussion,

208
00:13:13,793 --> 00:13:16,629
and they are mindful
that if things are taken out of context,

209
00:13:16,712 --> 00:13:20,174
if things leak prematurely,
it could kill the convention.

210
00:13:22,968 --> 00:13:27,014
Trust is the glue
that holds democracies together.

211
00:13:27,097 --> 00:13:32,102
Principled compromise
is the necessary approach

212
00:13:32,186 --> 00:13:33,979
to cooling the passions.

213
00:13:34,063 --> 00:13:36,607
Okay, I hear you.
You're passionate about this.

214
00:13:36,690 --> 00:13:38,484
You're passionate about that.

215
00:13:38,567 --> 00:13:41,445
Can we make a little bit of progress
toward common ground?

216
00:13:43,322 --> 00:13:47,034
So they do impose
a pretty strict rule of secrecy.

217
00:13:51,080 --> 00:13:52,623
Nevertheless,

218
00:13:52,706 --> 00:13:56,669
James Madison starts taking notes
on what everybody is saying.

219
00:13:58,546 --> 00:14:00,047
The curiosity I had felt

220
00:14:00,130 --> 00:14:04,343
during my researches into the history
of the most distinguished confederacies

221
00:14:04,426 --> 00:14:06,720
determined me
to preserve as far as I could

222
00:14:06,804 --> 00:14:10,015
an exact account
of what might pass in the convention.

223
00:14:11,016 --> 00:14:15,771
The way we know what happened
day to day at the convention

224
00:14:15,855 --> 00:14:17,982
was from Madison's notes.

225
00:14:18,649 --> 00:14:22,319
But they were not made public
for a long time.

226
00:14:28,659 --> 00:14:30,202
James Madison was scholarly,

227
00:14:30,286 --> 00:14:34,456
and he prepared
for the Constitutional Convention

228
00:14:34,540 --> 00:14:39,378
in part by looking
at confederations over time

229
00:14:39,461 --> 00:14:41,839
and which worked, which didn't work.

230
00:14:43,090 --> 00:14:45,050
He wants a stronger national government.

231
00:14:46,594 --> 00:14:50,639
James Madison gets
the Virginia delegates to show up early

232
00:14:50,723 --> 00:14:53,350
so they can coordinate around a plan.

233
00:14:54,727 --> 00:14:57,354
And it came to be called
the Virginia Plan.

234
00:14:59,231 --> 00:15:03,360
Because Madison was a good politician
and not a great public speaker,

235
00:15:03,444 --> 00:15:06,947
he gave the plan to Edmund Randolph,
the governor of Virginia,

236
00:15:07,031 --> 00:15:09,700
who was a very public politician.

237
00:15:09,783 --> 00:15:13,120
And on the first day
of substantive debates at the convention,

238
00:15:13,203 --> 00:15:16,832
Edmund Randolph introduces
the Virginia Plan.

239
00:15:16,916 --> 00:15:18,751
The Virginia Plan is nationalist,

240
00:15:18,834 --> 00:15:22,963
meaning shifting power from the state
and local level to the national level.

241
00:15:23,756 --> 00:15:26,467
It imagined a three-part government

242
00:15:26,550 --> 00:15:27,843
with legislature,

243
00:15:28,427 --> 00:15:29,637
an executive,

244
00:15:30,137 --> 00:15:31,764
and a judiciary.

245
00:15:32,890 --> 00:15:35,517
The framers believe
that power should be separated,

246
00:15:35,601 --> 00:15:38,979
and they believe that partly
because they're influenced by Montesquieu.

247
00:15:40,105 --> 00:15:41,941
The French philosopher Montesquieu

248
00:15:42,024 --> 00:15:45,069
was the first thinker to separate
the powers into the three branches

249
00:15:45,152 --> 00:15:47,655
that we know and love,
legislative, executive, judicial.

250
00:15:48,989 --> 00:15:50,366
Constant experience shows us

251
00:15:50,449 --> 00:15:54,870
that every man invested with power
is apt to abuse it

252
00:15:54,954 --> 00:15:58,040
and to carry his authority
as far as it will go.

253
00:15:58,123 --> 00:15:59,792
To prevent this abuse,

254
00:15:59,875 --> 00:16:02,670
it is necessary
from the very nature of things

255
00:16:02,753 --> 00:16:05,506
that power should be a check to power.

256
00:16:07,341 --> 00:16:10,469
The point behind separating
powers into the three branches

257
00:16:10,552 --> 00:16:13,931
and instituting checks and balances
among those branches was to ensure

258
00:16:14,014 --> 00:16:18,060
that each branch had an effective way
of checking any missteps or wrongdoing

259
00:16:18,143 --> 00:16:19,687
by the other branches.

260
00:16:31,031 --> 00:16:35,327
All of these men
feared the rise of tyranny.

261
00:16:37,037 --> 00:16:39,498
Checks and balances were no joke.

262
00:16:39,581 --> 00:16:44,878
They were designed to give people power
or branches of government power

263
00:16:44,962 --> 00:16:51,385
and then hedge it around in some way
so that they couldn't have absolute power.

264
00:16:52,886 --> 00:16:55,139
Sometimes people talk about gridlock.

265
00:16:55,222 --> 00:16:58,017
Gridlock is actually…
It's a feature, not a bug.

266
00:16:58,100 --> 00:16:59,810
It is by design.

267
00:16:59,893 --> 00:17:03,355
Our government was not designed
to be fast and efficient

268
00:17:03,439 --> 00:17:06,066
because fast and efficient means

269
00:17:06,150 --> 00:17:09,903
that a tyrant can use it quickly
against the people.

270
00:17:10,696 --> 00:17:13,782
Madison said,
"Ambition will counter ambition."

271
00:17:14,742 --> 00:17:17,036
He assumed the legislative branch,

272
00:17:17,119 --> 00:17:20,622
the executive branch,
and the judicial branch would check

273
00:17:20,706 --> 00:17:22,708
the other branches' ambitions.

274
00:17:25,419 --> 00:17:28,130
If you showed up
to the Philadelphia Convention,

275
00:17:28,213 --> 00:17:29,882
you could be forgiven for thinking

276
00:17:29,965 --> 00:17:33,177
that you were maybe just there
to amend the Articles of Confederation.

277
00:17:34,386 --> 00:17:37,556
When the convention begins,
they do not have a mandate

278
00:17:37,639 --> 00:17:39,975
to write a new form of government at all.

279
00:17:40,893 --> 00:17:44,938
The Constitutional Convention is supposed
to revise the Articles of Confederation.

280
00:17:45,898 --> 00:17:49,568
But the Virginia Plan had
what they call an agenda setting effect.

281
00:17:49,651 --> 00:17:54,823
And so everyone else at the convention
was immediately reacting to that plan.

282
00:17:55,532 --> 00:17:59,620
Once it was on the table,
the message was clear to all the delegates

283
00:17:59,703 --> 00:18:02,372
that they were not just going
to tinker with what existed.

284
00:18:02,456 --> 00:18:05,417
They were going to start something new.

285
00:18:08,545 --> 00:18:11,215
What are the powers of the government
that you're creating?

286
00:18:12,257 --> 00:18:13,717
What can it do?

287
00:18:15,094 --> 00:18:17,012
These are the fundamental questions

288
00:18:17,096 --> 00:18:19,848
that would occupy them
for the next several months.

289
00:18:21,683 --> 00:18:25,687
The American president
is the most creative product

290
00:18:25,771 --> 00:18:27,314
of the convention.

291
00:18:27,397 --> 00:18:28,565
It was truly new.

292
00:18:28,649 --> 00:18:30,192
There had been courts forever.

293
00:18:31,026 --> 00:18:33,654
There had been legislatures for centuries.

294
00:18:33,737 --> 00:18:36,698
There had never really been
an executive who is not a king

295
00:18:36,782 --> 00:18:40,160
in a nation with a powerful legislature.

296
00:18:40,244 --> 00:18:41,620
The framers were worried

297
00:18:41,703 --> 00:18:44,164
that you'd have an executive
who behaves like a king.

298
00:18:44,248 --> 00:18:46,959
And so they wanted
to put limitations in place.

299
00:18:48,001 --> 00:18:50,420
The debate about the executive
in the convention

300
00:18:50,504 --> 00:18:52,631
was between two extreme positions.

301
00:18:52,714 --> 00:18:56,885
Randolph and some of the Virginians
initially did not want

302
00:18:56,969 --> 00:18:59,096
a super powerful president.

303
00:18:59,972 --> 00:19:02,516
Edmund Randolph thought
there should be three people.

304
00:19:03,433 --> 00:19:07,229
He wanted the executive to be modeled
on the Roman triumvirate.

305
00:19:08,188 --> 00:19:12,442
I strenuously oppose a unity
in the executive magistracy.

306
00:19:12,526 --> 00:19:15,404
I regard it as the fetus of monarchy.

307
00:19:15,904 --> 00:19:19,324
I cannot see why the great requisites
for the executive department,

308
00:19:19,408 --> 00:19:22,161
vigor, despatch, and responsibility,

309
00:19:22,244 --> 00:19:25,455
could not be found in three men
as well as in one man.

310
00:19:26,707 --> 00:19:29,918
But then they said, "Wait a minute.
You know what's gonna happen?"

311
00:19:30,002 --> 00:19:32,337
"They're going to argue."

312
00:19:32,421 --> 00:19:35,549
On the other side
were figures like Gouverneur Morris,

313
00:19:35,632 --> 00:19:37,968
James Wilson and Alexander Hamilton,

314
00:19:38,552 --> 00:19:41,680
who actually wanted a president
to be at least as powerful

315
00:19:41,763 --> 00:19:44,975
and maybe even more powerful
than the King of England.

316
00:19:46,560 --> 00:19:50,063
And they thought it was a good idea
to have a more powerful executive

317
00:19:50,147 --> 00:19:53,650
to enable the country
to fight wars effectively

318
00:19:53,734 --> 00:19:57,029
and to enable the country
to become a global empire.

319
00:19:59,198 --> 00:20:01,950
One thing we really have
to recognize about the presidency

320
00:20:02,034 --> 00:20:03,702
as it was created by the convention

321
00:20:03,785 --> 00:20:06,455
was that they were literally looking
at George Washington.

322
00:20:08,832 --> 00:20:11,043
He was sitting there in the big chair,

323
00:20:11,126 --> 00:20:14,671
and the presidency
was tailored to him like a suit.

324
00:20:16,465 --> 00:20:18,675
They're comfortable with Washington.

325
00:20:18,759 --> 00:20:20,636
But once you move beyond Washington,

326
00:20:20,719 --> 00:20:24,681
the other people whose names are famous,
they don't trust.

327
00:20:26,016 --> 00:20:27,935
Washington wouldn't be around forever.

328
00:20:28,018 --> 00:20:30,604
And so they tried to design
the structure of the executive

329
00:20:30,687 --> 00:20:33,106
such that there would be
checks on his power.

330
00:20:33,732 --> 00:20:36,276
They have these debates,
and they're wrapped up together.

331
00:20:36,360 --> 00:20:39,780
Who should choose the president?
What should the president's powers be?

332
00:20:39,863 --> 00:20:42,491
How can the president
be removed from office?

333
00:20:45,327 --> 00:20:47,496
Something they spent the most time on

334
00:20:47,579 --> 00:20:49,790
was how we're gonna elect this individual.

335
00:20:50,374 --> 00:20:53,460
Almost no one in Philadelphia in 1787

336
00:20:53,543 --> 00:20:56,421
wanted the president
to be directly elected

337
00:20:56,505 --> 00:20:58,173
by all of the people.

338
00:20:58,882 --> 00:21:00,884
Most of the delegates found this idea

339
00:21:00,968 --> 00:21:03,011
totally ridiculous and laughable.

340
00:21:04,054 --> 00:21:07,266
They weren't sufficiently
trusting of the general public

341
00:21:07,349 --> 00:21:10,602
to think they should go to that
for the election of a president.

342
00:21:11,144 --> 00:21:14,356
This was really a practical,
technical challenge.

343
00:21:15,983 --> 00:21:21,655
The average farm family
probably never left where they were born.

344
00:21:22,823 --> 00:21:26,535
They certainly didn't have
a newspaper in town.

345
00:21:26,618 --> 00:21:30,455
They didn't have Fox or MSNBC.

346
00:21:31,748 --> 00:21:36,420
The candidates
would have to go from state to state.

347
00:21:36,503 --> 00:21:40,424
It would take, I don't know,
five or six years to meet every farmer

348
00:21:40,507 --> 00:21:42,509
and introduce yourself.

349
00:21:43,510 --> 00:21:46,054
There's also a lot of concern
about a person

350
00:21:46,138 --> 00:21:49,099
who would be popularly elected

351
00:21:49,182 --> 00:21:52,436
and come into power
and never relinquish it.

352
00:21:54,146 --> 00:21:55,897
And Hamilton later says

353
00:21:55,981 --> 00:21:58,275
if there's a Caesar
who's gonna rise in America,

354
00:21:58,358 --> 00:22:01,403
it might be by a demagogue
taking advantage of commotion

355
00:22:01,486 --> 00:22:04,906
and riding in on horseback
and calling off elections

356
00:22:04,990 --> 00:22:06,992
and installing himself as a dictator.

357
00:22:07,826 --> 00:22:10,704
When a man unprincipled in private life,

358
00:22:10,787 --> 00:22:12,748
desperate in his fortune,

359
00:22:12,831 --> 00:22:16,084
bold in his temper,
possessed of considerable talents,

360
00:22:16,752 --> 00:22:19,588
having the advantage of military habits,

361
00:22:19,671 --> 00:22:22,257
despotic in his ordinary demeanor,

362
00:22:22,341 --> 00:22:26,094
known to have scoffed in private
at the principles of liberty.

363
00:22:26,178 --> 00:22:30,140
When such a man is seen to mount
the hobbyhorse of popularity,

364
00:22:30,223 --> 00:22:31,641
to flatter and fall in

365
00:22:31,725 --> 00:22:34,728
with all the nonsense
of the zealots of the day,

366
00:22:34,811 --> 00:22:36,730
it may justly be suspected

367
00:22:36,813 --> 00:22:40,233
that his object is
to throw things into confusion,

368
00:22:40,317 --> 00:22:44,154
that he may ride the storm
and direct the whirlwind.

369
00:22:46,573 --> 00:22:49,076
Alexander Hamilton was one of the people

370
00:22:49,159 --> 00:22:53,580
who warned consistently
about demagogic leaders

371
00:22:53,663 --> 00:22:56,416
who would get into power,
never want to leave,

372
00:22:56,500 --> 00:23:00,587
use the power of the office
to enrich themselves,

373
00:23:00,670 --> 00:23:04,174
use it to promote their own agendas.

374
00:23:04,257 --> 00:23:07,010
They had certain expectations,

375
00:23:07,094 --> 00:23:08,929
even more than powers, in my view,

376
00:23:09,012 --> 00:23:13,100
about how an executive
would faithfully implement the law,

377
00:23:13,183 --> 00:23:15,811
protect and defend the Constitution.

378
00:23:17,145 --> 00:23:21,691
It was the model
that the founders were trying to put forth

379
00:23:21,775 --> 00:23:23,568
and surrounding that model

380
00:23:23,652 --> 00:23:27,072
with all of the warnings
from Hamilton and others

381
00:23:27,155 --> 00:23:28,573
about the alternative.

382
00:23:29,699 --> 00:23:31,785
The framers were not naive.

383
00:23:31,868 --> 00:23:36,164
They understood that people seek power,
that people are self-interested.

384
00:23:36,248 --> 00:23:37,749
They had no delusions

385
00:23:37,833 --> 00:23:41,920
that politicians would be
these self-serving saints.

386
00:23:42,796 --> 00:23:46,633
Our founders were conscious
of two sort of tyrannies that they feared,

387
00:23:46,716 --> 00:23:49,177
tyranny of a dictator or a king,

388
00:23:49,261 --> 00:23:51,012
but also tyranny of the majority.

389
00:23:51,763 --> 00:23:55,475
They were afraid of rule by one,
but they were also afraid of rule by many.

390
00:23:55,976 --> 00:23:58,562
They wanted to be self-ruled.

391
00:23:59,354 --> 00:24:03,942
Hamilton proposes
a president elected for life

392
00:24:04,025 --> 00:24:06,278
on the idea this would make him
above corruption.

393
00:24:06,361 --> 00:24:08,989
He can have the public interest
rather than his interest

394
00:24:09,072 --> 00:24:12,701
and won't be tempted to play politics.

395
00:24:12,784 --> 00:24:16,204
But yet to most people, then and now,

396
00:24:16,288 --> 00:24:19,499
it sounded suspiciously like a king.

397
00:24:19,583 --> 00:24:22,961
And it's a total flop
'cause it's so radical.

398
00:24:24,588 --> 00:24:26,756
This is a government where they've decided

399
00:24:26,840 --> 00:24:29,259
it's about the people, not the king.

400
00:24:29,342 --> 00:24:30,886
And yet most of them think

401
00:24:30,969 --> 00:24:34,556
having popular election for the president
is a terrible idea.

402
00:24:35,098 --> 00:24:37,726
But if Congress elects the president,

403
00:24:37,809 --> 00:24:41,730
they're convinced that Congress
will work deals with the president

404
00:24:41,813 --> 00:24:45,484
to get basically what they want,
personally and politically.

405
00:24:46,818 --> 00:24:50,197
It's an incredibly tricky problem,
and they can't figure it out.

406
00:24:51,615 --> 00:24:54,493
They were deadlocked,
and they said, "Let's move on."

407
00:24:54,576 --> 00:24:56,578
"We'll come back to this later."

408
00:24:56,661 --> 00:24:59,498
"We'll come back
to how to elect the president later."

409
00:25:03,460 --> 00:25:08,006
The order of the Constitution
was important to the founding generation.

410
00:25:09,174 --> 00:25:12,427
Article II created the executive branch.

411
00:25:12,511 --> 00:25:15,639
Article I was the legislative branch.

412
00:25:17,015 --> 00:25:19,392
The Congress was always a place

413
00:25:19,476 --> 00:25:22,854
where the popular will
of the American people

414
00:25:22,938 --> 00:25:24,856
was meant to be expressed.

415
00:25:29,027 --> 00:25:35,742
These men believed that Congress
was the heart and soul of the government.

416
00:25:36,326 --> 00:25:42,457
So the president's job
would be to administer the laws

417
00:25:42,541 --> 00:25:44,834
that the Congress passed.

418
00:25:46,962 --> 00:25:52,300
In Article I, Section 8,
they enumerated the powers of Congress.

419
00:25:52,384 --> 00:25:55,512
I memorized a shortened version of it.

420
00:25:55,595 --> 00:25:58,390
TCC, NCC, PCC, PAWN, MOMMA, WREN.

421
00:25:58,890 --> 00:26:00,642
Taxes, credit, commerce,

422
00:26:00,725 --> 00:26:02,602
naturalization, coinage, counterfeiting,

423
00:26:02,686 --> 00:26:04,729
post office, copyright, courts,

424
00:26:04,813 --> 00:26:08,984
piracy, army, war, navy,
militia, money for militia,

425
00:26:09,067 --> 00:26:12,654
Washington DC, rules,
and necessary and proper.

426
00:26:14,155 --> 00:26:19,911
The image they had of Congress
was a deliberative body of serious people,

427
00:26:19,995 --> 00:26:20,954
of American elites.

428
00:26:25,000 --> 00:26:28,670
But how do you create a system
that allows people to have representation?

429
00:26:31,548 --> 00:26:34,509
The single most contentious issue

430
00:26:34,593 --> 00:26:37,137
at the Constitutional Convention
in Philadelphia was

431
00:26:37,220 --> 00:26:40,640
how many representatives
each state would get.

432
00:26:41,766 --> 00:26:43,518
The Virginia Plan proposed

433
00:26:43,602 --> 00:26:47,564
that there would be
two houses of the legislature,

434
00:26:47,647 --> 00:26:51,318
and both would choose their members
based on population.

435
00:26:52,068 --> 00:26:54,195
So big states would get
more representatives,

436
00:26:54,279 --> 00:26:56,656
and big states would also get
more senators.

437
00:26:57,157 --> 00:27:00,160
The legislature ought to be
the most exact transcript

438
00:27:00,243 --> 00:27:02,120
of the whole society.

439
00:27:03,913 --> 00:27:06,750
This would give
tremendous power to the big states,

440
00:27:06,833 --> 00:27:11,630
and take away an enormous amount of power
from the small states.

441
00:27:12,589 --> 00:27:15,759
James Madison was absolutely adamant

442
00:27:15,842 --> 00:27:18,053
on proportional representation,

443
00:27:18,136 --> 00:27:21,014
that it'd be based on population.

444
00:27:22,307 --> 00:27:25,143
He thought the only way
that a representative democracy,

445
00:27:25,226 --> 00:27:29,481
like, functions well,
is by advancing ideas

446
00:27:29,564 --> 00:27:32,108
that are attractive
to the majority of the people.

447
00:27:33,318 --> 00:27:36,446
Now, Virginia was
the most populous state at the time,

448
00:27:36,529 --> 00:27:41,701
so they obviously had an interest
in proportional representation.

449
00:27:42,702 --> 00:27:46,456
Virginia is ten times the size
of tiny Delaware.

450
00:27:46,539 --> 00:27:51,378
Will Virginia have ten times
the number of representatives?

451
00:27:51,461 --> 00:27:53,588
This alarmed the smaller states,

452
00:27:53,672 --> 00:27:56,800
who countered with what became known
as the New Jersey Plan.

453
00:27:57,467 --> 00:27:58,927
And the New Jersey Plan,

454
00:27:59,010 --> 00:28:02,263
instead of having
two legislative chambers, would have one.

455
00:28:02,347 --> 00:28:06,476
And guess what?
Each state would have one vote.

456
00:28:07,352 --> 00:28:09,104
The states wanted to be sure

457
00:28:09,187 --> 00:28:12,232
they had some power
versus the federal government.

458
00:28:12,315 --> 00:28:14,401
They didn't want to wake up and find

459
00:28:14,484 --> 00:28:18,154
that the federal government
was imposing on them

460
00:28:18,238 --> 00:28:21,241
taxes or laws and regulations

461
00:28:21,324 --> 00:28:24,828
that they found
inimical to their own interests.

462
00:28:25,537 --> 00:28:30,333
And so there was
a lot of tension between the states.

463
00:28:33,044 --> 00:28:34,879
The small states essentially told

464
00:28:34,963 --> 00:28:37,048
the representatives of the large states,

465
00:28:37,132 --> 00:28:38,758
"You have two choices."

466
00:28:39,259 --> 00:28:43,596
"Either you're going to agree
to give us equal representation,

467
00:28:43,680 --> 00:28:45,473
regardless of our size,

468
00:28:45,557 --> 00:28:48,685
the same way we had it
in the Articles of Confederation,

469
00:28:48,768 --> 00:28:50,895
or we're out of here."

470
00:28:50,979 --> 00:28:53,898
"You're not going to get
a constitution at all."

471
00:28:56,693 --> 00:29:00,697
New Jersey will never confederate
on the plan before the committee.

472
00:29:00,780 --> 00:29:02,782
She would be swallowed up.

473
00:29:02,866 --> 00:29:06,828
I had rather submitted to a monarch,
to a despot, than to such a fate.

474
00:29:08,288 --> 00:29:11,249
The large states believed
this would give a disproportionate power

475
00:29:11,332 --> 00:29:12,459
to the smaller states.

476
00:29:13,251 --> 00:29:16,254
It would be in the power then
of less than one third

477
00:29:16,337 --> 00:29:17,881
to overrule two thirds.

478
00:29:20,091 --> 00:29:24,596
The arguments are going on,
and they're growing more intense.

479
00:29:27,640 --> 00:29:30,935
They insist that although
the three great states form

480
00:29:31,019 --> 00:29:33,354
nearly a majority of the people
of America,

481
00:29:33,438 --> 00:29:36,274
they never will hurt or injure
the lesser states.

482
00:29:36,357 --> 00:29:38,777
I do not, gentlemen, trust you.

483
00:29:40,236 --> 00:29:43,239
It was not out of the question
for the states

484
00:29:43,323 --> 00:29:46,701
to simply break up their union.

485
00:29:48,328 --> 00:29:52,165
If a separation must take place,
it could never happen on better grounds.

486
00:29:53,750 --> 00:29:56,044
So tempers were clearly rising.

487
00:29:56,127 --> 00:30:00,673
I think there are times they're not far
from being at blows with one another.

488
00:30:03,551 --> 00:30:06,763
The large states
dare not dissolve the confederation.

489
00:30:06,846 --> 00:30:08,890
If they do, the small ones will find

490
00:30:08,973 --> 00:30:11,726
some foreign ally
of more honor and good faith

491
00:30:11,810 --> 00:30:14,521
who will take them by the hand
and do them justice.

492
00:30:16,606 --> 00:30:18,858
This country must be united.

493
00:30:18,942 --> 00:30:22,445
If persuasion does not unite it,
the sword will.

494
00:30:23,488 --> 00:30:25,949
And that's when the convention
almost fell apart.

495
00:30:32,831 --> 00:30:36,334
Philadelphia summers are hot and humid.

496
00:30:37,544 --> 00:30:42,006
The first thing these men did
when Washington gaveled,

497
00:30:42,090 --> 00:30:47,720
you know, "We're done for the day,"
was rush to the tavern and drink.

498
00:30:49,639 --> 00:30:50,932
I can guarantee you

499
00:30:51,015 --> 00:30:55,019
that an enormous amount of alcohol
was consumed.

500
00:30:55,812 --> 00:31:00,149
An enormous amount of alcohol
was consumed by everybody in America

501
00:31:00,233 --> 00:31:01,109
at the time.

502
00:31:04,737 --> 00:31:08,199
People kept pestering them,
"What's happening? What's going on?"

503
00:31:08,283 --> 00:31:10,785
"What are you doing?
You can tell me, I'm your wife."

504
00:31:10,869 --> 00:31:13,413
"You can tell me, I'm your father."

505
00:31:13,913 --> 00:31:17,417
Mrs. House's, where I am, is very crowded,

506
00:31:17,500 --> 00:31:23,047
and the room I am presently in
so small as not to admit of a second bed.

507
00:31:25,425 --> 00:31:29,596
So it was not a happy experience.

508
00:31:30,555 --> 00:31:33,558
They're all in the same room,
and it's stifling.

509
00:31:33,641 --> 00:31:38,021
As you may know, in the 18th century,
people didn't take showers very often.

510
00:31:39,022 --> 00:31:41,274
And you're basically trapped
with the same guys

511
00:31:41,357 --> 00:31:43,860
until you reach some sort of agreement.

512
00:31:45,445 --> 00:31:48,114
At this point, the small states insisted,

513
00:31:48,197 --> 00:31:51,743
you know,
"Our states will never ratify a document

514
00:31:51,826 --> 00:31:54,871
that deprives them
of their equal representation."

515
00:31:57,498 --> 00:31:59,375
The small staters weren't backing down.

516
00:32:05,840 --> 00:32:08,718
Threats ended up
wearing down the large staters,

517
00:32:08,801 --> 00:32:10,303
or at least some of them.

518
00:32:11,054 --> 00:32:14,933
And a compromise actually came
from some Connecticut delegates.

519
00:32:16,684 --> 00:32:18,436
Roger Sherman and Oliver Ellsworth

520
00:32:18,519 --> 00:32:21,522
are clearly key players in what's called
the Connecticut Compromise

521
00:32:21,606 --> 00:32:23,149
or the Great Compromise.

522
00:32:23,733 --> 00:32:26,069
The Virginia Plan wants
representation by population

523
00:32:26,152 --> 00:32:27,987
in both houses of Congress.

524
00:32:28,071 --> 00:32:31,282
The New Jersey Plan
wants representation by the states.

525
00:32:33,868 --> 00:32:37,038
And the Connecticut Compromise,
like Goldilocks, splits the difference

526
00:32:37,121 --> 00:32:40,041
and has representation
by population in the House

527
00:32:40,124 --> 00:32:41,501
and by states in the Senate.

528
00:32:43,753 --> 00:32:47,799
In the House, representation
is determined by a census every ten years.

529
00:32:47,882 --> 00:32:48,716
And as a result,

530
00:32:48,800 --> 00:32:52,512
the number of total representatives
changes based on population.

531
00:32:52,595 --> 00:32:56,432
In the Senate,
every state gets two representatives.

532
00:32:56,516 --> 00:32:59,227
But the Senate itself,
actually at the American founding,

533
00:32:59,310 --> 00:33:00,687
was not popularly elected.

534
00:33:01,312 --> 00:33:05,066
The states appointed members
to the United States Senate.

535
00:33:05,692 --> 00:33:07,568
It really wasn't until 1913

536
00:33:07,652 --> 00:33:09,153
that the Constitution was amended

537
00:33:09,237 --> 00:33:12,407
to allow for the popular election
of senators.

538
00:33:13,324 --> 00:33:17,662
The convention very narrowly
approved the Connecticut Compromise.

539
00:33:18,329 --> 00:33:22,000
And at the end of the day,
it's mostly a power play.

540
00:33:22,083 --> 00:33:24,752
And the small states
play a good game of poker.

541
00:33:24,836 --> 00:33:27,588
And the status quo advantages them.

542
00:33:28,673 --> 00:33:30,800
The delegates from the big states

543
00:33:30,883 --> 00:33:33,803
ultimately chose compromise.

544
00:33:33,886 --> 00:33:36,639
And that compromise was very remarkable.

545
00:33:37,265 --> 00:33:38,433
Until that moment,

546
00:33:38,516 --> 00:33:41,811
they had fully expected to have
a democratic constitution

547
00:33:41,894 --> 00:33:43,896
where power lay with the people.

548
00:33:46,190 --> 00:33:49,527
What they got
was a constitutional republic

549
00:33:49,610 --> 00:33:52,321
in which the small states,
through the Senate,

550
00:33:52,405 --> 00:33:56,617
could exercise
enormous disproportionate influence.

551
00:33:57,744 --> 00:33:59,912
This was not just a temporary compromise.

552
00:33:59,996 --> 00:34:02,582
It's one of the only clauses
in the Constitution

553
00:34:02,665 --> 00:34:07,712
that the amendment clause, Article V,
expressly says you can't change.

554
00:34:15,887 --> 00:34:17,722
We still have a U.S. Senate

555
00:34:17,805 --> 00:34:22,852
where Wyoming with 550,000 people
gets the same two senators as California

556
00:34:22,935 --> 00:34:24,854
with 39 million people.

557
00:34:25,354 --> 00:34:27,106
That's not fair.

558
00:34:27,190 --> 00:34:30,151
But our founders
could never possibly imagine

559
00:34:30,234 --> 00:34:35,323
a state with 40 million people
versus 1 million or fewer.

560
00:34:35,865 --> 00:34:39,744
They thought that the idea
that Wyoming would have two senators

561
00:34:39,827 --> 00:34:42,914
was a check and a balance
on the force of democracy.

562
00:34:43,664 --> 00:34:47,376
How would Wyoming
ever have its own personality or survive

563
00:34:47,460 --> 00:34:50,296
if they had no senators and had no vote?

564
00:34:50,379 --> 00:34:53,466
They'd be subsumed into California,
God forbid.

565
00:34:53,549 --> 00:34:57,220
And so the only way these small states
are able to have any personalities

566
00:34:57,303 --> 00:34:59,138
is because of the design of the Senate.

567
00:35:07,522 --> 00:35:10,608
At the Philadelphia Convention,
lots of folks thought

568
00:35:10,691 --> 00:35:13,945
that the big debate was going to be
between big states and small states.

569
00:35:14,028 --> 00:35:15,196
And it was.

570
00:35:15,279 --> 00:35:17,406
But the delegates had come to see

571
00:35:17,490 --> 00:35:20,660
that the division
that was more significant in the long run

572
00:35:20,743 --> 00:35:24,497
was going to be
between free states and slave states.

573
00:35:26,040 --> 00:35:28,835
Slavery was the thousand-pound
elephant in the room

574
00:35:28,918 --> 00:35:30,628
because they know it's a dealbreaker.

575
00:35:31,379 --> 00:35:37,093
Slavery was an original sin
of the formation of our nation.

576
00:35:37,176 --> 00:35:42,014
Slavery was at the core
of some of the most difficult,

577
00:35:42,098 --> 00:35:46,686
contentious discussions
within the Constitutional Convention.

578
00:35:47,228 --> 00:35:52,650
There were abolitionists
and there were slave-owning members.

579
00:35:53,901 --> 00:35:58,156
I never will concur
in upholding domestic slavery.

580
00:35:58,239 --> 00:36:00,867
It is a nefarious institution.

581
00:36:01,534 --> 00:36:05,413
Gouverneur Morris was, without question,
the staunchest opponent of slavery

582
00:36:05,496 --> 00:36:06,622
at the convention.

583
00:36:07,290 --> 00:36:11,919
It is the curse of heaven
on the states where it prevails.

584
00:36:12,003 --> 00:36:15,131
He's a Northerner
from a slave-holding family.

585
00:36:15,214 --> 00:36:18,467
His father enslaved several dozen people
when he was a child.

586
00:36:19,135 --> 00:36:21,637
But he was clear-sighted enough
about slavery's evils.

587
00:36:22,513 --> 00:36:23,848
He opposed it way back

588
00:36:23,931 --> 00:36:27,268
at the New York State
Constitutional Convention in 1777

589
00:36:27,351 --> 00:36:29,270
when he's only 25 years old.

590
00:36:29,979 --> 00:36:32,190
A lot of the delegates to the convention,

591
00:36:32,273 --> 00:36:34,233
even a couple of the Southern delegates,

592
00:36:34,317 --> 00:36:38,321
were essentially abolitionists
and thought that allowing the nation

593
00:36:38,404 --> 00:36:40,823
to take form
around the institution of slavery

594
00:36:40,907 --> 00:36:42,283
was a huge mistake.

595
00:36:42,992 --> 00:36:45,578
They also knew how hypocritical it was

596
00:36:45,661 --> 00:36:50,917
to have fought a war in which you claimed
the whole point was liberty and equality

597
00:36:51,000 --> 00:36:52,376
and then deny it to others.

598
00:36:54,378 --> 00:36:56,130
But they decided in the end

599
00:36:56,214 --> 00:36:58,591
that if they didn't put
that question to the side,

600
00:36:58,674 --> 00:37:00,092
they wouldn't have a constitution.

601
00:37:00,718 --> 00:37:03,429
The delegates
from the South would not have signed on

602
00:37:03,512 --> 00:37:06,515
to a constitution
that didn't protect slavery in some way.

603
00:37:06,599 --> 00:37:08,351
Slavery is much more important

604
00:37:08,434 --> 00:37:10,561
to states like Georgia,
South Carolina, and Virginia

605
00:37:10,645 --> 00:37:15,066
than it is to states like New Jersey,
New York, and Massachusetts.

606
00:37:15,149 --> 00:37:16,776
And the presumption is

607
00:37:16,859 --> 00:37:18,653
that in order to hold

608
00:37:18,736 --> 00:37:22,281
this fragile alliance
of 13 states together,

609
00:37:22,365 --> 00:37:24,951
you are going to have
to concede to the interests

610
00:37:25,034 --> 00:37:28,496
of the more slavery-oriented economies.

611
00:37:28,579 --> 00:37:31,540
Not everybody liked it,
but they knew it was essential

612
00:37:31,624 --> 00:37:34,085
to the economic underpinnings
of the country.

613
00:37:34,919 --> 00:37:36,754
So the most famous conflict

614
00:37:36,837 --> 00:37:40,216
between the free states
and the slave states at the convention

615
00:37:40,299 --> 00:37:44,720
was the conflict about
how to count enslaved persons

616
00:37:44,804 --> 00:37:49,225
when they decided how many representatives
each state would get.

617
00:37:50,351 --> 00:37:53,062
The Southern states' position was,

618
00:37:53,145 --> 00:37:56,899
"We want all slaves to be counted

619
00:37:56,983 --> 00:38:00,069
in our population
for purposes of representation."

620
00:38:00,152 --> 00:38:02,154
"We're not going to let them vote."

621
00:38:02,238 --> 00:38:05,950
"We're not going to let them be free,
but they count."

622
00:38:06,534 --> 00:38:08,995
The labor of a slave in South Carolina

623
00:38:09,078 --> 00:38:14,083
is as productive and valuable
as that of a free man in Massachusetts.

624
00:38:14,166 --> 00:38:18,004
Consequently, an equal representation
ought to be allowed for them.

625
00:38:19,297 --> 00:38:21,716
The anti-slavery Northerners
pushed back against that.

626
00:38:22,883 --> 00:38:27,430
Upon what principle is it that the slaves
shall be computed in the representation?

627
00:38:27,513 --> 00:38:31,392
Are they men?
Then make them citizens and let them vote.

628
00:38:31,475 --> 00:38:35,896
Are they property?
Why then is no other property included?

629
00:38:37,481 --> 00:38:39,150
The Northern states also talked

630
00:38:39,233 --> 00:38:42,361
about how you guys are going to have
disproportionate power

631
00:38:42,445 --> 00:38:46,282
because we're counting your slaves,
and there were a lot of slaves,

632
00:38:46,365 --> 00:38:49,201
but those slaves
are never going to vote at all.

633
00:38:49,285 --> 00:38:50,786
The result was

634
00:38:50,870 --> 00:38:54,665
the most famous and shameful compromise
of the Constitutional Convention,

635
00:38:54,749 --> 00:38:57,126
the three-fifths compromise.

636
00:39:00,087 --> 00:39:01,964
It was James Wilson of Pennsylvania

637
00:39:02,048 --> 00:39:05,926
and Charles Pinckney of South Carolina
who proposed the three-fifths clause.

638
00:39:06,927 --> 00:39:12,308
Three-fifths, or 60%,
of the enslaved population

639
00:39:13,142 --> 00:39:16,270
will be counted in the census

640
00:39:16,354 --> 00:39:20,358
as belonging to the state
where they reside.

641
00:39:20,441 --> 00:39:22,860
What that effectively does

642
00:39:23,569 --> 00:39:27,990
is use the bodies of enslaved people

643
00:39:28,074 --> 00:39:34,205
to subsidize the political authority
of the people who are enslaving them,

644
00:39:35,039 --> 00:39:39,460
but they do want them
to be counted as part of the society

645
00:39:39,543 --> 00:39:40,961
when it comes to politics.

646
00:39:42,171 --> 00:39:44,298
What's not being said here

647
00:39:44,382 --> 00:39:49,720
is that the contradiction is
not whether enslaved people should count

648
00:39:49,804 --> 00:39:51,514
or whether they should not count,

649
00:39:52,223 --> 00:39:56,685
but whether you can have a democracy
and have enslaved people simultaneously.

650
00:39:57,311 --> 00:40:02,149
That is the debate that gets sidestepped
in order to come up with the half measure,

651
00:40:02,233 --> 00:40:07,655
or we should say the 60% measure,
of the three-fifths compromise.

652
00:40:08,239 --> 00:40:12,076
People who were excluded
from participating in the politics

653
00:40:12,159 --> 00:40:13,327
of this era

654
00:40:13,411 --> 00:40:16,455
knew they were excluded
and they were angry about it.

655
00:40:19,208 --> 00:40:21,085
When we talk about the people,

656
00:40:21,168 --> 00:40:24,004
we have to distinguish
people who are being counted

657
00:40:24,088 --> 00:40:27,091
for the purposes
of how many representatives you get

658
00:40:27,174 --> 00:40:30,678
and people who are themselves
allowed to elect those representatives.

659
00:40:32,430 --> 00:40:35,933
Enslaved people won't vote
and women won't vote.

660
00:40:37,143 --> 00:40:40,729
The only place
where women can vote is in New Jersey

661
00:40:40,813 --> 00:40:42,481
in a brief period of time.

662
00:40:42,565 --> 00:40:45,067
Some women who were
either widowed or single

663
00:40:45,151 --> 00:40:47,153
and owned property in New Jersey
could vote.

664
00:40:48,237 --> 00:40:50,448
But eventually New Jersey passes a law

665
00:40:50,531 --> 00:40:55,536
that takes the new language
of white male voters

666
00:40:55,619 --> 00:40:58,956
and imposes it
on the New Jersey voting population.

667
00:41:00,124 --> 00:41:03,210
We know that from the notes
we have of the Constitutional Convention,

668
00:41:03,294 --> 00:41:05,379
they never talk about women's rights.

669
00:41:05,963 --> 00:41:09,383
The idea was if a man is voting
on behalf of his whole household,

670
00:41:09,467 --> 00:41:13,804
the woman should be
in conversation with him about politics,

671
00:41:13,888 --> 00:41:16,515
but his vote is supposed to represent
the entire household.

672
00:41:19,226 --> 00:41:21,520
The founding fathers of the Constitution

673
00:41:21,604 --> 00:41:25,941
saw tribal peoples
as citizens of their own government.

674
00:41:26,525 --> 00:41:29,570
They were not state or federal citizens,

675
00:41:29,653 --> 00:41:33,657
so they thought it made perfect sense
not to count that Indian person.

676
00:41:35,201 --> 00:41:38,370
We're not a party to the Constitution.

677
00:41:41,499 --> 00:41:45,711
Tribes are mentioned in the context
of the ability of the federal government

678
00:41:45,794 --> 00:41:49,548
to regulate the relationship
between tribes in the United States.

679
00:41:50,508 --> 00:41:54,470
And yet we're physically
within the United States.

680
00:41:54,553 --> 00:41:57,890
We're dealing with people
that want our land, want our resources,

681
00:41:57,973 --> 00:41:59,767
people that want to go to war.

682
00:42:00,559 --> 00:42:03,354
A federal government
that may want to use its army

683
00:42:03,437 --> 00:42:06,190
to march us across the United States,
which it did.

684
00:42:07,316 --> 00:42:09,527
And so we may not be part
of the Constitution,

685
00:42:09,610 --> 00:42:12,780
but the Constitution is one of the most
consequential instruments

686
00:42:12,863 --> 00:42:14,907
in all of Cherokee history.

687
00:42:21,372 --> 00:42:24,500
The other main debate
around slavery during the convention

688
00:42:24,583 --> 00:42:27,127
was over the continuance
of the overseas slave trade.

689
00:42:27,795 --> 00:42:29,713
South Carolina and Georgia would like

690
00:42:29,797 --> 00:42:33,133
to keep importing slaves from Africa.

691
00:42:33,217 --> 00:42:36,512
The North doesn't want
the slave trade to continue,

692
00:42:36,595 --> 00:42:40,975
partly because the slave trade
is even more reprehensible than slavery.

693
00:42:41,058 --> 00:42:43,769
You're kidnapping people,
tearing away from their families.

694
00:42:43,852 --> 00:42:47,022
A large percentage
are going to die in the Atlantic passage.

695
00:42:48,065 --> 00:42:53,112
I consider it as inadmissible
on every principle of honor and safety

696
00:42:53,195 --> 00:42:56,991
that the importation of slaves
should be authorized to the states

697
00:42:57,074 --> 00:42:58,450
by the Constitution.

698
00:42:59,076 --> 00:43:03,372
And this is a huge division over slavery,
leading to a big clash.

699
00:43:03,998 --> 00:43:05,124
If the convention thinks

700
00:43:05,207 --> 00:43:09,587
that North Carolina, South Carolina,
and Georgia will ever agree to the plan,

701
00:43:09,670 --> 00:43:12,923
unless their rights to import slaves
be untouched,

702
00:43:13,007 --> 00:43:14,925
the expectation is vain.

703
00:43:15,467 --> 00:43:17,678
In another compromise arrangement,

704
00:43:17,761 --> 00:43:20,514
the Constitution
included a provision that said

705
00:43:20,598 --> 00:43:23,934
that for 20 years after ratification,

706
00:43:24,018 --> 00:43:28,522
Congress would not be able
to abolish the slave trade.

707
00:43:30,566 --> 00:43:33,527
After 20 years,
Congress would be able to do it.

708
00:43:34,111 --> 00:43:37,573
And the reason that was sufficient
from the standpoint of the Southerners,

709
00:43:37,656 --> 00:43:39,950
in my view,
was that the Southerners were confident

710
00:43:40,034 --> 00:43:43,162
that if they could import enough slaves
in the intervening 20 years,

711
00:43:43,245 --> 00:43:47,124
that they can continue relying totally
on an internal supply of slaves.

712
00:43:47,207 --> 00:43:50,210
That is the natural reproduction
of enslaved people.

713
00:43:51,503 --> 00:43:52,504
It's really dark.

714
00:43:58,177 --> 00:43:59,637
In return for that,

715
00:43:59,720 --> 00:44:02,598
the North got the power through Congress

716
00:44:02,681 --> 00:44:06,435
to impose laws on trade
by simple majority vote.

717
00:44:06,518 --> 00:44:09,480
The South was afraid of that
because they were afraid

718
00:44:09,563 --> 00:44:13,609
that the North would make everything
cost more in the South.

719
00:44:14,443 --> 00:44:16,445
In a really complicated deal, basically,

720
00:44:16,528 --> 00:44:20,199
South Carolina agrees
to support the New England position

721
00:44:20,282 --> 00:44:22,117
on congressional power over trade

722
00:44:22,201 --> 00:44:26,038
in exchange for protecting
the international slave trade.

723
00:44:27,373 --> 00:44:29,792
That was the so-called dirty compromise.

724
00:44:36,340 --> 00:44:39,218
The last important provision
dealing with slavery

725
00:44:39,301 --> 00:44:41,011
is the Fugitive Slave Clause.

726
00:44:44,223 --> 00:44:46,058
In very sanitized language,

727
00:44:46,141 --> 00:44:52,940
it holds that individuals who are held
in service in one part of the country

728
00:44:53,023 --> 00:44:57,194
could not escape that service
by leaving that part of the country.

729
00:44:57,277 --> 00:44:58,779
In that language,

730
00:44:58,862 --> 00:45:00,114
you would almost not know

731
00:45:00,197 --> 00:45:05,077
that you were talking about human beings
who were being bred, whipped, raped,

732
00:45:05,160 --> 00:45:06,954
abused, bought, sold,

733
00:45:07,746 --> 00:45:09,081
and trafficked.

734
00:45:10,290 --> 00:45:13,377
This clause also forced
the Northern states,

735
00:45:13,460 --> 00:45:15,713
the ones that were
already abolishing slavery,

736
00:45:16,213 --> 00:45:19,383
to acknowledge
the constitutional lawfulness

737
00:45:19,466 --> 00:45:22,636
of the practice of slavery itself.

738
00:45:24,263 --> 00:45:27,099
The framers made a bargain over slavery,

739
00:45:28,058 --> 00:45:30,144
and they didn't think there was a choice.

740
00:45:35,816 --> 00:45:38,652
They decided not to answer the question

741
00:45:38,736 --> 00:45:42,740
of whether this would be
a slave nation or a free nation,

742
00:45:42,823 --> 00:45:45,701
and to allow that question
to be answered differently

743
00:45:45,784 --> 00:45:48,162
in different parts of the country.

744
00:45:48,245 --> 00:45:50,581
Some of the Virginian delegates
to the convention,

745
00:45:51,415 --> 00:45:54,251
like James Madison and George Washington,

746
00:45:54,334 --> 00:45:58,338
deep down, they knew
that slavery was wrong.

747
00:46:01,008 --> 00:46:03,802
What Madison and Washington
were able to tell themselves,

748
00:46:03,886 --> 00:46:05,512
to salve their conscience,

749
00:46:05,596 --> 00:46:10,184
was that slavery was
an old-fashioned anachronism,

750
00:46:10,267 --> 00:46:12,519
and it would eventually end.

751
00:46:13,437 --> 00:46:15,314
And so they were willing to accept

752
00:46:15,397 --> 00:46:18,192
the various compromises on slavery
in the Constitution,

753
00:46:18,275 --> 00:46:22,237
telling themselves that the United States
would not forever be a slave republic.

754
00:46:24,698 --> 00:46:30,078
Morris, who is the strongest
opponent of slavery at the convention,

755
00:46:30,162 --> 00:46:31,205
is horrified.

756
00:46:32,748 --> 00:46:35,959
The inhabitant
of Georgia and South Carolina

757
00:46:36,043 --> 00:46:38,295
who goes to the coast of Africa,

758
00:46:38,378 --> 00:46:41,632
and in the defiance
of the most sacred laws of humanity

759
00:46:41,715 --> 00:46:45,260
tears away his fellow creatures
from his dearest connections

760
00:46:45,344 --> 00:46:48,347
and damns them to the most cruel bondage,

761
00:46:48,972 --> 00:46:53,268
shall have more votes in the government
instituted for the protection

762
00:46:53,352 --> 00:46:55,437
of the rights of mankind

763
00:46:55,521 --> 00:46:59,233
than the citizen of Pennsylvania
or New Jersey

764
00:46:59,316 --> 00:47:03,862
who views with laudable horror
so nefarious a practice.

765
00:47:07,491 --> 00:47:10,994
The Constitutional Convention
makes slavery central

766
00:47:11,078 --> 00:47:12,955
to the American experience.

767
00:47:13,997 --> 00:47:15,499
So in many ways,

768
00:47:15,582 --> 00:47:17,251
it really makes clear

769
00:47:17,334 --> 00:47:22,005
that this is going to be a major divide
in the United States for years to come.

770
00:47:25,592 --> 00:47:28,011
Even when you know that that compromise

771
00:47:28,095 --> 00:47:33,851
was necessary for the very edifice
to come into existence at all,

772
00:47:33,934 --> 00:47:37,271
that doesn't really make
the slavery compromises easier to swallow.

773
00:47:37,855 --> 00:47:40,649
The compromise may have made union
possible in a sense,

774
00:47:40,732 --> 00:47:43,235
but it also made it
fundamentally unstable.

775
00:47:43,819 --> 00:47:45,779
All the solutions are temporary.

776
00:47:46,572 --> 00:47:48,824
Even the permanent solutions
are temporary.

777
00:47:49,533 --> 00:47:54,329
And to varying degrees,
people are aware of that at the time.

778
00:47:55,122 --> 00:47:58,542
It's hard to believe
that this is going to hold.

779
00:48:04,590 --> 00:48:09,386
When you look at the Convention,
the big focus is Congress.

780
00:48:09,469 --> 00:48:11,847
Second focus, the executive.

781
00:48:13,557 --> 00:48:16,268
The judiciary, really, the least.

782
00:48:20,105 --> 00:48:22,232
The Constitution, which I have a copy.

783
00:48:22,316 --> 00:48:23,275
There it is.

784
00:48:23,817 --> 00:48:25,777
Will this work or will it not?

785
00:48:26,653 --> 00:48:28,238
They're facing this question.

786
00:48:28,739 --> 00:48:30,282
We have balanced powers

787
00:48:30,365 --> 00:48:32,576
between a Congress over here,
which legislates,

788
00:48:32,659 --> 00:48:35,412
and a president
and the executive branch under him,

789
00:48:35,495 --> 00:48:36,747
which will execute.

790
00:48:37,748 --> 00:48:39,249
But how do we know

791
00:48:39,333 --> 00:48:42,419
they're not going to misinterpret
the words here?

792
00:48:42,502 --> 00:48:44,504
We need some judges to say

793
00:48:45,339 --> 00:48:46,632
when they've gone too far.

794
00:48:46,715 --> 00:48:48,425
Because this sets boundaries.

795
00:48:50,677 --> 00:48:55,182
They wanted an independent judiciary
separate and apart from the executive.

796
00:48:55,265 --> 00:49:02,022
So they were looking for the popular will
to be expressed, implemented, and judged.

797
00:49:09,029 --> 00:49:12,449
Article III of the Constitution,
of the three major articles

798
00:49:12,532 --> 00:49:15,160
that set up the different branches
of the U.S. government,

799
00:49:15,243 --> 00:49:16,244
it is the shortest.

800
00:49:18,163 --> 00:49:20,624
They actually just say one Supreme Court.

801
00:49:20,707 --> 00:49:23,794
It doesn't tell us
how many people will be on that court.

802
00:49:23,877 --> 00:49:26,797
In fact, that court
originally is six justices.

803
00:49:27,464 --> 00:49:30,509
There's no time limit
with respect to judges.

804
00:49:30,592 --> 00:49:33,261
The only limitation with respect
to their term

805
00:49:33,345 --> 00:49:36,264
is whether they are acting
in good behavior or not,

806
00:49:36,848 --> 00:49:40,268
which has been interpreted
as lifetime appointments.

807
00:49:41,853 --> 00:49:44,856
The original idea
about lifetime appointments was

808
00:49:44,940 --> 00:49:47,693
to maintain the independence
of the judiciary.

809
00:49:47,776 --> 00:49:52,030
Over time, as the parties
have become more polarized,

810
00:49:52,114 --> 00:49:54,491
they've taken advantage
of lifetime appointments

811
00:49:54,574 --> 00:49:57,703
to try to appoint judges very young
and hope for very long tenures

812
00:49:57,786 --> 00:49:59,913
in terms of partisan appointments.

813
00:50:00,414 --> 00:50:02,541
It creates
these kind of strange situations

814
00:50:02,624 --> 00:50:05,168
where you can really lock in
ideological preferences

815
00:50:05,252 --> 00:50:06,253
for a very long time.

816
00:50:08,213 --> 00:50:11,133
Today, neither the president
nor the Congress

817
00:50:11,216 --> 00:50:13,885
really has the ambition to take on
the Supreme Court

818
00:50:14,678 --> 00:50:17,139
in its claims
that it gets to have the last word

819
00:50:17,723 --> 00:50:19,558
on the Constitution.

820
00:50:19,641 --> 00:50:22,602
That would have been foreign
to Washington,

821
00:50:22,686 --> 00:50:24,730
Jefferson, Jackson, and Lincoln.

822
00:50:24,813 --> 00:50:27,941
They all claim that presidents
and congresses had the right

823
00:50:28,025 --> 00:50:31,945
to interpret the Constitution
on the same par as the Supreme Court.

824
00:50:35,991 --> 00:50:39,745
With three branches
of government finally sorted,

825
00:50:39,828 --> 00:50:43,373
everyone can see
how power is going to be distributed.

826
00:50:45,625 --> 00:50:47,627
But to a certain degree,

827
00:50:47,711 --> 00:50:51,965
the framers left unresolved
just how powerful the president would be.

828
00:50:52,799 --> 00:50:57,345
They needed a figure who would be
elevated enough to be a world player,

829
00:50:57,429 --> 00:50:58,972
but also would be accountable

830
00:50:59,056 --> 00:51:01,933
to the public and to the laws
that Congress passed.

831
00:51:02,017 --> 00:51:03,518
…matter of national competition.

832
00:51:03,602 --> 00:51:05,645
The founders thought
people should have a say

833
00:51:05,729 --> 00:51:07,606
in everything about how they're governed,

834
00:51:07,689 --> 00:51:10,859
but most importantly,
on issues of war and peace,

835
00:51:10,942 --> 00:51:12,194
life and death.

836
00:51:13,236 --> 00:51:16,573
Under a monarchy,
the king is responsible for declaring war.

837
00:51:16,656 --> 00:51:18,533
They rejected that system.

838
00:51:18,617 --> 00:51:21,203
So they split the military powers.

839
00:51:21,286 --> 00:51:24,372
They gave Congress
the sole power to declare war,

840
00:51:24,456 --> 00:51:28,043
but they put the president in charge of it
as commander in chief.

841
00:51:32,506 --> 00:51:35,509
They agreed
that no president could start a war

842
00:51:35,592 --> 00:51:37,552
without permission of Congress.

843
00:51:39,221 --> 00:51:40,722
Every one of them said that.

844
00:51:40,806 --> 00:51:42,474
It's in the Constitution,

845
00:51:42,557 --> 00:51:46,353
and yet war is routinely fought now
with an executive order.

846
00:51:46,937 --> 00:51:51,024
In no part of the Constitution
is more wisdom to be found

847
00:51:51,108 --> 00:51:54,611
than in the clause which confides
the question of war or peace

848
00:51:54,694 --> 00:51:58,031
to the legislature
and not to the executive department.

849
00:51:58,115 --> 00:52:02,744
The trust and the temptation
would be too great for any one man.

850
00:52:12,504 --> 00:52:15,465
One of the fears
that was explicitly voiced

851
00:52:15,549 --> 00:52:16,675
at the convention

852
00:52:16,758 --> 00:52:18,969
was what to do about a president

853
00:52:19,052 --> 00:52:21,680
who decided to use
the power of the presidency

854
00:52:21,763 --> 00:52:24,724
to undermine the Constitution
and the rule of law.

855
00:52:26,101 --> 00:52:29,813
So they come up with
a fairly broad definition of impeachment.

856
00:52:31,231 --> 00:52:34,651
The founders weren't very clear
on impeachment,

857
00:52:34,734 --> 00:52:38,697
on what it would decide,
what was a high crime and misdemeanor.

858
00:52:40,782 --> 00:52:43,160
Impeachment ultimately turned out to be

859
00:52:43,243 --> 00:52:48,540
extremely difficult ever
to operationalize in practice.

860
00:52:48,623 --> 00:52:53,753
We've had impeachments
in the United States on four occasions,

861
00:52:53,837 --> 00:52:56,756
but never the conviction of a president.

862
00:52:56,840 --> 00:53:00,927
And only one president, Richard Nixon,
who was not yet impeached,

863
00:53:01,011 --> 00:53:02,429
was about to be impeached,

864
00:53:02,512 --> 00:53:06,516
has ever actually resigned
from the presidency under its threat.

865
00:53:08,059 --> 00:53:11,479
I think there is much less
of a protection against corruption

866
00:53:11,563 --> 00:53:13,315
than they imagined there was.

867
00:53:19,154 --> 00:53:23,283
By late August, they all want
to get home. They all want to be done.

868
00:53:24,117 --> 00:53:26,453
Every article is again argued over

869
00:53:26,536 --> 00:53:30,373
with as much earnestness
and obstinacy as before.

870
00:53:31,208 --> 00:53:33,126
They'd been away from their families.

871
00:53:33,210 --> 00:53:38,131
They'd been away from their businesses,
their farms, their plantations.

872
00:53:39,841 --> 00:53:42,636
What they haven't settled,
they're going to settle by committee

873
00:53:42,719 --> 00:53:43,887
in September.

874
00:53:44,471 --> 00:53:48,516
And the most important thing they do
is they create the Electoral College.

875
00:53:49,100 --> 00:53:52,896
US voters went to the polls
and elected a president last month,

876
00:53:52,979 --> 00:53:55,732
so the one with the most votes
wins, right?

877
00:53:55,815 --> 00:53:57,776
Not quite.

878
00:53:57,859 --> 00:54:02,822
I personally think the Electoral College
is an abomination…

879
00:54:02,906 --> 00:54:04,282
…for obvious reasons.

880
00:54:04,366 --> 00:54:09,204
I know how disappointed you feel
because I feel it too.

881
00:54:09,955 --> 00:54:12,916
And so do tens of millions of Americans

882
00:54:12,999 --> 00:54:16,670
who invested
their hopes and dreams in this effort.

883
00:54:18,296 --> 00:54:22,926
James Wilson
is sort of a shadowy figure to most.

884
00:54:23,009 --> 00:54:27,681
I mean, if you ask 500 Americans,
they would never have heard of him.

885
00:54:27,764 --> 00:54:32,477
He did the one thing that we wish
he hadn't done at the convention.

886
00:54:32,560 --> 00:54:34,938
He came up with the Electoral College.

887
00:54:38,441 --> 00:54:41,569
The Electoral College is a group of people

888
00:54:41,653 --> 00:54:45,615
called together for one purpose,
to decide who's going to be president.

889
00:54:47,742 --> 00:54:49,661
You can think of the Electoral College

890
00:54:49,744 --> 00:54:53,415
as a compromise on top of a compromise
on top of a compromise.

891
00:54:54,958 --> 00:54:57,377
Your number of electors
is your number of senators

892
00:54:57,460 --> 00:54:59,921
plus your number of House members.

893
00:55:00,005 --> 00:55:03,300
So Southerners will get
some slave representation

894
00:55:04,426 --> 00:55:05,343
in the small states.

895
00:55:05,427 --> 00:55:07,762
Because every state gets two senators,

896
00:55:07,846 --> 00:55:10,473
it's going to do a little better
in the Electoral College

897
00:55:10,557 --> 00:55:12,309
than they do in the House.

898
00:55:13,893 --> 00:55:17,522
The founders themselves were not in love
with the Electoral College.

899
00:55:17,605 --> 00:55:19,399
It was defective from the beginning.

900
00:55:20,233 --> 00:55:23,778
We have a problem
that a minority of the population,

901
00:55:23,862 --> 00:55:26,990
because of the structure
of the Electoral College,

902
00:55:27,073 --> 00:55:28,366
in some cases,

903
00:55:28,450 --> 00:55:30,493
over the objections of the majority,

904
00:55:31,119 --> 00:55:32,829
is ruling the majority.

905
00:55:33,747 --> 00:55:36,750
I'm one who finds virtue
in the Electoral College.

906
00:55:36,833 --> 00:55:39,919
It's not just because
I come from a smaller state, Arizona,

907
00:55:40,003 --> 00:55:43,214
that may benefit more
than a larger state like California.

908
00:55:44,007 --> 00:55:46,718
It emphasizes our system of federalism.

909
00:55:47,218 --> 00:55:50,472
We are not a direct democracy,
we're a representative democracy.

910
00:55:51,181 --> 00:55:54,351
The states have considerable power.
The states run elections.

911
00:55:54,434 --> 00:55:57,937
That is a good thing
to decentralize that kind of power.

912
00:56:03,109 --> 00:56:06,738
James Madison always viewed
the Electoral College

913
00:56:06,821 --> 00:56:09,157
as a stopgap measure.

914
00:56:10,283 --> 00:56:13,995
That mode which was judged most expedient
was adopted.

915
00:56:14,079 --> 00:56:17,540
Till experience should point out
one more eligible.

916
00:56:18,875 --> 00:56:20,794
He always assumed

917
00:56:20,877 --> 00:56:26,007
that ultimately someone would come up
with a better idea than that.

918
00:56:31,846 --> 00:56:35,517
Since they had voted randomly,
one thing after another,

919
00:56:35,600 --> 00:56:37,102
in no particular order,

920
00:56:37,185 --> 00:56:40,522
they gave it all to Gouverneur Morris
and say, "Here, Gouve."

921
00:56:40,605 --> 00:56:43,274
They didn't call him that,
but I'm paraphrasing.

922
00:56:43,358 --> 00:56:44,776
"Do something with this."

923
00:56:46,653 --> 00:56:49,114
And he wrote the Constitution.

924
00:56:50,073 --> 00:56:53,076
Morris wrote the Constitution
over three and a half days.

925
00:56:53,159 --> 00:56:54,577
He did his work very quickly.

926
00:56:54,661 --> 00:56:56,830
He took 23 sprawling articles

927
00:56:56,913 --> 00:56:59,666
and pared it down
to a neat seven articles.

928
00:56:59,749 --> 00:57:02,210
He changed or chose
a great deal of the wording

929
00:57:02,293 --> 00:57:05,004
on his own initiative
in consequential ways.

930
00:57:06,297 --> 00:57:09,050
The Fugitive Slave Clause describes

931
00:57:09,134 --> 00:57:13,346
enslaved people going back to the people
who justly owned them.

932
00:57:14,055 --> 00:57:16,766
Gouverneur Morris,
the fiercest opponent of slavery

933
00:57:16,850 --> 00:57:19,894
at the Constitutional Convention,
takes the word justly out.

934
00:57:19,978 --> 00:57:21,271
And that is huge.

935
00:57:24,023 --> 00:57:28,194
The final Constitution
does not ever include the word slave.

936
00:57:28,278 --> 00:57:30,572
And Frederick Douglass in the 19th century

937
00:57:30,655 --> 00:57:32,699
would make this
a large part of his argument

938
00:57:32,782 --> 00:57:35,452
about why the Constitution
could be interpreted

939
00:57:35,535 --> 00:57:37,454
to lean towards liberty.

940
00:57:42,000 --> 00:57:45,336
In the final days
of the Constitutional Convention,

941
00:57:46,379 --> 00:57:50,508
a couple of delegates became gadflies,

942
00:57:50,592 --> 00:57:53,261
making various kinds of demands
for changes

943
00:57:53,344 --> 00:57:55,138
that seemed significant to them.

944
00:57:57,098 --> 00:58:02,520
George Mason spoke out repeatedly
in favor of the need of a bill of rights

945
00:58:02,604 --> 00:58:06,816
that would protect individuals
against government overreach.

946
00:58:06,900 --> 00:58:10,528
I wish the plan had been prefaced
with a bill of rights.

947
00:58:10,612 --> 00:58:13,531
It would give great quiet to the people.

948
00:58:13,615 --> 00:58:16,367
Any free society
has the right to free speech,

949
00:58:16,451 --> 00:58:18,536
or any free society
has the right to assemble.

950
00:58:18,620 --> 00:58:21,748
Any free society has due process right.

951
00:58:21,831 --> 00:58:23,541
You can't have your property taken.

952
00:58:23,625 --> 00:58:27,253
But it's not written down anywhere.
So how do you rely on it?

953
00:58:28,880 --> 00:58:29,839
People would say,

954
00:58:29,923 --> 00:58:33,801
"This is a government that's created
for the purpose of protecting rights,"

955
00:58:33,885 --> 00:58:37,514
but didn't actually say anything
about protecting most rights.

956
00:58:39,015 --> 00:58:41,100
The general feeling in the convention was,

957
00:58:41,184 --> 00:58:42,644
"We don't need a bill of rights."

958
00:58:42,727 --> 00:58:47,106
"Because we haven't conferred
on the central government any powers

959
00:58:47,190 --> 00:58:49,859
that would impinge on individual liberty."

960
00:58:49,943 --> 00:58:52,195
The fundamental rights
were thought to be implied.

961
00:58:54,113 --> 00:58:58,368
And so the Constitutional Convention
on September 17th adjourns

962
00:58:58,451 --> 00:59:02,247
without what we come to know
as a bill of rights being part of it.

963
00:59:05,875 --> 00:59:09,546
By the time
the convention ended in September,

964
00:59:09,629 --> 00:59:11,631
some delegates had already left.

965
00:59:14,259 --> 00:59:17,387
There are three dissenters
who refused to sign the Constitution.

966
00:59:17,470 --> 00:59:20,223
Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts,

967
00:59:20,306 --> 00:59:22,100
George Mason of Virginia,

968
00:59:22,642 --> 00:59:25,144
and Edmund Randolph of Virginia.

969
00:59:26,145 --> 00:59:28,523
They have different reasons
for refusing to sign.

970
00:59:29,440 --> 00:59:31,734
But it's mostly
the lack of a bill of rights.

971
00:59:33,611 --> 00:59:35,446
Everybody else supports it.

972
00:59:37,282 --> 00:59:39,242
And they sign it.

973
00:59:43,580 --> 00:59:45,832
Benjamin Franklin gives a great speech.

974
00:59:46,332 --> 00:59:47,875
When you assemble a number of men

975
00:59:47,959 --> 00:59:50,420
to have the advantage
of their joint wisdom,

976
00:59:50,503 --> 00:59:54,799
you inevitably assemble with those men
all their prejudices, their passions,

977
00:59:54,882 --> 00:59:56,384
their errors of opinion,

978
00:59:56,467 --> 00:59:59,178
their local interests,
and their selfish views.

979
00:59:59,262 --> 01:00:04,058
From such an assembly,
can a perfect production be expected?

980
01:00:04,142 --> 01:00:05,602
It therefore astonishes me, sir,

981
01:00:05,685 --> 01:00:09,814
to find this system approaching
so near to perfection as it does.

982
01:00:09,897 --> 01:00:15,903
Thus, I consent, sir, to this Constitution
because I expect no better.

983
01:00:16,571 --> 01:00:19,282
One of the other things that Franklin says

984
01:00:19,365 --> 01:00:22,243
is that he had looked
at the back of a chair

985
01:00:22,327 --> 01:00:23,911
in Independence Hall.

986
01:00:24,787 --> 01:00:25,997
Franklin says,

987
01:00:26,080 --> 01:00:31,044
"I've been looking during the convention
at the sun on the president's chair."

988
01:00:31,127 --> 01:00:34,505
"And I've wondered, is it a rising sun
or is it a setting sun?"

989
01:00:37,842 --> 01:00:42,513
I have the happiness to know
that it is a rising and not a setting sun.

990
01:00:45,808 --> 01:00:48,269
The thing is full of compromises.

991
01:00:48,353 --> 01:00:49,687
I think we tend to exaggerate

992
01:00:49,771 --> 01:00:52,315
how confident they are
that they quite got it right.

993
01:00:53,107 --> 01:00:56,069
They have a tremendous
and well-earned anxiety

994
01:00:56,152 --> 01:00:58,655
about how this all could go wrong.

995
01:00:59,489 --> 01:01:03,242
Some of the people who do sign
give speeches saying

996
01:01:03,326 --> 01:01:05,870
that they understand
this isn't a perfect document,

997
01:01:05,953 --> 01:01:07,664
that not everybody agreed,

998
01:01:07,747 --> 01:01:08,790
but they think

999
01:01:08,873 --> 01:01:13,002
this is about as good a document
as they could give.

1000
01:01:14,128 --> 01:01:19,300
None of them envisioned
that it would go on for almost 250 years.

1001
01:01:20,426 --> 01:01:25,348
The Constitution is
the greatest legal document ever crafted.

1002
01:01:26,474 --> 01:01:30,311
The oldest national Constitution
still in operation,

1003
01:01:30,395 --> 01:01:32,105
based on the radical premise

1004
01:01:32,188 --> 01:01:35,650
that we the people
as a whole are sovereign,

1005
01:01:35,733 --> 01:01:38,111
not the king and not the legislature,

1006
01:01:38,194 --> 01:01:41,781
and that we parcel power out
to different parts of the government

1007
01:01:42,365 --> 01:01:44,033
in order to protect liberty.

1008
01:01:44,575 --> 01:01:47,453
And the proposition
that it's possible to create a government

1009
01:01:47,537 --> 01:01:49,914
based on the ideas of liberty, equality,

1010
01:01:49,997 --> 01:01:51,541
and government by consent

1011
01:01:52,125 --> 01:01:54,877
is the most inspiring experiment
in world history.

1012
01:01:56,087 --> 01:01:57,588
The initial preamble said,

1013
01:01:57,672 --> 01:02:01,217
"We the people of the states
of New Hampshire and Massachusetts

1014
01:02:01,300 --> 01:02:03,052
and on down the eastern seaboard."

1015
01:02:03,886 --> 01:02:07,515
Gouverneur Morris changed it to,
"We the people of the United States,"

1016
01:02:08,307 --> 01:02:11,185
and wrote the Constitution's
ringing statement of purpose.

1017
01:02:14,647 --> 01:02:21,112
We the people of the United States,
in order to form a more perfect union,

1018
01:02:21,195 --> 01:02:22,822
establish justice,

1019
01:02:22,905 --> 01:02:24,949
ensure domestic tranquility,

1020
01:02:25,032 --> 01:02:27,034
provide for the common defense,

1021
01:02:27,118 --> 01:02:31,664
promote the general welfare,
and secure the blessings of liberty

1022
01:02:31,748 --> 01:02:34,208
to ourselves and our posterity,

1023
01:02:34,292 --> 01:02:38,254
do ordain and establish this constitution.

1024
01:02:40,423 --> 01:02:43,259
I was at the National Archives
not long ago,

1025
01:02:44,719 --> 01:02:50,516
and a lot of the words of the Constitution
under that dark glass in that dimmed room

1026
01:02:50,600 --> 01:02:51,809
are hard to read.

1027
01:02:52,852 --> 01:02:55,521
But there are three
that are not hard to read.

1028
01:02:55,605 --> 01:02:59,025
The top of the first page,
"We the people."

1029
01:03:02,361 --> 01:03:05,573
And those first three words
of the Constitution

1030
01:03:05,656 --> 01:03:08,201
would always define our nation.

1031
01:03:13,289 --> 01:03:18,544
The reason why we're so special
is because of "We the people."

1032
01:03:20,213 --> 01:03:22,799
When the framers talked about
"We the people,"

1033
01:03:22,882 --> 01:03:25,134
"we the people" was
a small group of people

1034
01:03:25,218 --> 01:03:26,886
that they were really talking about.

1035
01:03:28,429 --> 01:03:30,473
There were so many other people
that were here

1036
01:03:30,556 --> 01:03:33,017
that weren't considered
part of the "People."

1037
01:03:33,100 --> 01:03:35,728
But to me,
that's the beauty of the document,

1038
01:03:35,812 --> 01:03:38,064
that it is aspirational.

1039
01:03:39,023 --> 01:03:40,399
We the people.

1040
01:03:41,984 --> 01:03:44,028
Representation does matter.

1041
01:03:44,737 --> 01:03:48,407
Our lived experiences,
our professional experiences,

1042
01:03:48,491 --> 01:03:50,660
add to the richness,

1043
01:03:51,160 --> 01:03:55,039
add to the better quality
of the government.

1044
01:03:56,207 --> 01:03:59,877
The Constitution's
a miraculous document in my view.

1045
01:03:59,961 --> 01:04:01,712
It's a remarkable document.

1046
01:04:02,421 --> 01:04:08,344
It reflects a diverse country
that wants to maintain that diversity,

1047
01:04:08,845 --> 01:04:13,307
but also a dynamic country
that wants to maintain that dynamism.

1048
01:04:16,060 --> 01:04:19,856
Elizabeth Willing Powel,
who was probably the most important

1049
01:04:19,939 --> 01:04:23,192
politically connected woman
in Philadelphia,

1050
01:04:23,276 --> 01:04:27,405
asks Franklin whether the delegates
have given the country

1051
01:04:27,488 --> 01:04:29,282
a republic or a monarchy.

1052
01:04:30,533 --> 01:04:34,245
And he famously says,
"A republic, if you can keep it."

1053
01:04:35,663 --> 01:04:37,540
That really encapsulated

1054
01:04:37,623 --> 01:04:41,210
what many of them, I think, felt
from their writings that,

1055
01:04:41,294 --> 01:04:45,089
"Sure hope this works, and we've set it up
to the best of our ability."

1056
01:04:45,172 --> 01:04:47,717
"But it is still an experiment."

1057
01:05:03,774 --> 01:05:06,819
There clearly is some sense
that it's far from over.

1058
01:05:08,029 --> 01:05:10,031
Now it goes to the states

1059
01:05:10,114 --> 01:05:12,950
and the rule is
nine of them have to ratify

1060
01:05:13,034 --> 01:05:15,202
for the Constitution to go into effect.

1061
01:05:16,787 --> 01:05:20,416
And the passage of the Constitution
is very much in doubt.


