Original subtitles

[ Birds chirping ]

ASHE: People think starlings are ordinary

because they see them every day.

They're not.

Hmm.

I've never noticed those patterns they make.

ASHE: Murmuration.

[ Chuckles ] I love that you know that.

They speak in dialects.

What do you mean?

They mimic speech patterns. Academics study starlings

to learn how language first evolved.

That can't be true.

[ Laughs ]

Okay. It's true. It's true.

If I was a bird, I think I'd be a cuckoo.

I think we'd both be cuckoos.

[ Tense music plays ]

[ Birds chirping ]

[ Theme song plays ]

[ Camera shutter clicking ]

MAN: All done.

KYNASTON: She hasn't been dead longer than 3 to 4 hours.

So approximately 4:00 PM.

The cut would have produced enough blood

to write the graffiti.

It's the left to right slash to her jugular which killed her.

Regina versus Beale?

Venetia Aldridge.

She successfully defended Anthony Beale.

He went on to murder Janet Carpenter's granddaughter.

Why is there blood on the ceiling?

She was standing when her throat was cut.

If she did it herself, she would have written on the wall first.

Which begs the question, why crouch down so low?

She was left-handed, Miles.

I saw her drink a cup of tea yesterday.

She turned the handle around.

She's standing here.

Her throats cut, most probably from behind.

She falls here.

The killer sets her up against the wall,

cuts the wrist, dips her finger in her own blood,

writes, then places the knife.

Pending the PM, this is murder disguised as suicide.

Agreed.

[ Somber music plays ]

No one really knew her except to smile at.

She withdrew 15,000 three weeks ago.

I want to talk through everything we know to be true.

We know that, after her daughter and granddaughter died,

Carpenter moved to London and took the cleaning job

to get closer to Venetia.

And attended all her court cases.

She's got to have held Venetia responsible.

We know she recently withdrew 15,000

from her savings account, a quarter of her savings.

To pay an accomplice? A contract killing?

Possibly, yes.

Maybe that's why she was killed.

Maybe her accomplice was scared. She wasn't solid.

That she might come to us.

It might be nothing, sir. It's in my report.

She went to Temple Church yesterday.

Lamb of God, who takes away the sins of the world,

have mercy on us.

[ Uplifting music plays ]

I'm afraid I don't really know her.

I'd never seen her until yesterday.

But, yes, she was here. She seemed extremely troubled.

I spoke to her, and she asked if I'd hear her confession.

Her name was Janet Carpenter.

I'm sorry to have to tell you that

she died yesterday evening.

How?

She was almost certainly murdered.

We were hoping you might be able to give us

some information, which --

Everything we spoke about

was under the seal of confession.

I'm sorry.

I understand.

Rather what I expected you to say.

A female QC was murdered in chambers on Monday.

I assume you know that.

- Yes, I do. - Could you at least tell us

whether we're right in thinking these deaths are connected?

I can't break the seal of confession.

I think Janet Carpenter would want us to know the truth.

Forgive me, but I don't think she's going to care

if you break faith with her now.

It isn't Janet Carpenter I'd be breaking faith with.

[ Bell tolling ]

Are we going to get a statement from Garry Ashe?

Yes, I've sent Tarrant.

Ashe likes to go to you and he likes to goad me.

It's a distraction.

Tarrant deals with him and with Octavia.

[ Intriguing music plays ]

TARRANT: Where were you yesterday afternoon

between the hours of 3:00 and 6:00?

Wanstead Flats with my fianc e.

TARRANT: Can anyone else vouch for that?

Did you speak to anyone? Buy an ice lolly?

[ Sighs ]

Does the name Janet Carpenter mean anything to you?

Yes. She's a singer.

[ Chuckles ]

You grew up in care, didn't you?

Is that why you feel the need to pretend to be so clever?

Did Kate tell you that?

TARRANT: You know, that seems creepy,

the "Kate" thing.

Just like it seems creepy

you've shacked up with Venetia Aldridge's daughter.

Janet Carpenter.

Dead, is she? Murdered?

You need to pull your finger out.

We're watching you, Mr. Ashe.

Clearly not, or you'd know where I was yesterday afternoon.

Now, if you'll excuse me, I'm going to reacquaint myself

with the laws concerning police harassment.

[ Chuckles ]

[ Ominous music plays ]

- Was she murdered? - We aren't certain yet.

Well, if it was suicide, surely that suggests

that she was also responsible for Ms. Aldridge's death.

DALGLIESH: Because we're awaiting the results of the PM.

But we think it's highly likely that Mrs. Carpenter

- was murdered. - Oh, it's a disaster.

This is a disaster. If the press get hold of this.

No, they can't. And we need you to see to that, Dalgliesh.

And who wants to hire defense counsel from a chambers

where the staff are dropping down dead?

We'll need to take witness statements from you all.

[ Soft music plays ]

[ Telephone ringing ]

Your diary, in case you wish to refer to it.

Where were you yesterday afternoon between

the hours of 3:00 and 6:00?

If you've looked in my diary --

DALGLIESH: I'd like you to tell me, please.

LANGTON: Yes. I had a meeting with the solicitor.

We met at his offices in Hatton Garden.

The meeting was at 3:00 and I left at 3:45 and returned here.

So you arrived here at around...

Quarter past 4:00.

I was here until the usual time -- 6:00.

Who else was here?

Actually, not many yesterday afternoon.

It was quiet.

Any of the partners?

Um, they were in and out, I suppose.

Did Venetia's daughter ever come here

on her own or with anyone else?

CALDWELL: No. At least not since I've worked here.

I've never met her daughter.

How about clients she defended?

Would they ever come here?

CALDWELL: Yes, sometimes.

But only if they're not on remand, of course.

I'd like to ask you about the evening Miss Aldridge died.

You told me you arrived home at half past 7:00,

but your housekeeper has since told us that you

didn't arrive home until 9:00.

Which leaves an hour and a half unaccounted for.

She's mistaken.

I -- I took the newspaper to Venetia.

You told me you didn't take her the paper.

No, I did not.

I'm aware this must be challenging

and difficult for you.

It wouldn't be difficult

if you didn't keep doubting my word.

You establish that he lied to the police

when he was first arrested.

- But he owned up to that. - Look, it doesn't matter.

Remind the court that he is a liar and sit down.

Never give unnecessary detail.

May I speak to you now, please?

Uh, this is an exceptionally important day for Matthew.

It's all right, Dad. I'm sure it won't take long.

[ Tense music plays ]

I was with my dad all afternoon.

We went to the Law Society Library and did some prep.

You seem close. You and your father.

We are.

My mother died when I was 12,

and it's been dad and me ever since.

But you don't live with him?

No, I'm married. Two kids.

People always think I'm younger than I am.

What did you think of Ms. Aldridge?

I thought this was about the cleaning lady.

I didn't like her much.

She didn't exactly encourage me.

In fact, she tried to make me feel stupid.

MISKIN: It was in the drawer of her desk.

I managed to sign it off.

I thought you should have it.

In the drawer.

Not on the desk.

God forbid anyone should see it.

Are you at school then?

Boarding school.

She couldn't wait to pack me off.

When can I have a funeral?

It might be a while yet. So sorry.

New camera?

It's Ashe's. I bought it for him.

Make he's always wanted. We're going bird watching.

Where are you going to do that?

Don't know. Ashe knows lots of places around where he grew up.

Essex.

How do you know that?

You have to learn a lot about someone

when you arrest them for murder.

OCTAVIA: Can you go? He'll be back soon.

Are you scared of him?

[ Scoffs ] No.

MISKIN: Look, I'm going to say my piece, Octavia.

I think it's really strange that he picked you up in a bar

just after your mum defended him.

Think what you like.

And then your mum gets murdered,

and then another woman gets murdered.

Janet Carpenter. Have you heard of her?

No.

Has Garry ever spoken about her?

You're so wrong about him. Look --

Look, that's where he sleeps. He doesn't even try it on.

He said we should wait until we're married.

Well, I think that's pretty strange, as well.

He had nothing to do with Mum's death.

It was probably one of those wankers she works with.

Or one of those married men she's messed around with.

Maybe one of them needed to shut her up.

ULRICK: I was with my son, Matthew Ulrick,

in the library of the Law Society,

researching facts pertaining to the case he's about to lead.

TARRANT: And what time did you leave the library?

ULRICK: 5:00 PM. And then I went home.

I believe you have my address.

I didn't set eyes on Mrs. Carpenter

all day yesterday.

Nor did my son.

DALGLIESH: Are these members of your family?

There have been Ulricks at the bar since George II.

It must be a relief

knowing that Venetia isn't going to be Head of Chambers.

From what I've heard,

she seemed to have a low opinion of your son.

You know, I find this rather disgraceful

that you're treating us as suspects.

Sign here, please.

[ Soft music plays ]

Sir.

Look, Venetia was having an affair with Drysdale Laud.

What?

It was certainly happening a couple of years ago.

I don't know if it still was.

How did you learn this?

I went to see Octavia.

Give us a moment, please.

Look, I know I shouldn't have without telling you,

and I'm sorry.

You disobeyed a direct order.

What's going on, Sergeant?

I just really feel in my gut

that Ashe has got something to do with these killings.

I know it might seem irrational,

and I'm really, really worried about Octavia.

I can't believe we're just letting that situation continue.

- It's not unlawful. - I know.

I wanted to find a link between Ashe and Carpenter.

And did you?

No.

It won't happen again.

At least you've told me now.

Yes, Venetia and I had a brief relationship.

It finished last autumn.

Who finished it?

It was a mutual decision. It was only ever an interlude.

We both knew that.

We'd been friends for 20 years.

TARRANT: You're married, aren't you?

Full marks.

Weren't you worried your wife would find out?

No, actually, we were extremely discreet.

Apart from...

Who told you? Matthew Ulrick, I suppose.

Why would you suppose that?

Because he walked in on us once in Venetia's room.

Were you aware of any other members of chambers

knowing about the affair?

Well, I assumed he probably told his father.

The boy can't sneeze without asking permission.

- You didn't think to tell us? - I am not in the habit

of volunteering unnecessary information to the police.

What theory are you working on here?

That Venetia threatened to tell? She wasn't that vindictive.

The affair was over.

As for Head of Chambers, I would have enjoyed the fight.

[ Car door closes ]

DALGLIESH: Mr. Froggart.

Thank you for the loan of your scrapbooks.

I, um...

I hope they were of assistance.

They were.

Although I prefer the term "chronicle"

with its implications of the passage of time

and recording of days.

Can you tell me why you left the employment

of Venetia's father's school in 1943?

Venetia would have been 16 in that year.

Your implication is not lost on me, Chief Inspector.

I admit that I loved Venetia.

But not in an improper way. I am...

I'm not a sexual person.

I loved her mind and I loved nurturing it.

So why did you leave?

Everybody left.

Venetia's father was a sadist.

He used any excuse to beat the boys,

thrash them, bully them.

One boy...

...Marcus Campbell, he took his own life.

He hanged himself with the cord of his dressing gown.

He was scheduled for a beating the following morning

in front of the whole school.

There was an inquiry.

All the parents finally understood what Aldridge was.

The school shut down.

[ Somber music plays ]

[ Classical music plays ]

[ Doorbell rings ]

Uh, Chief Inspector.

Good evening. May I come in?

I... Not convenient, I'm afraid.

I-I'm expecting Matthew. A little celebration.

Your signature -- Desmond Campbell Ulrick.

Is Campbell a family name?

It was my mother's maiden name. We adopted it for a while.

No one wants to grow up with a name like Ulrick

during the Second World War.

We? Would that be you and your brother, Marcus Campbell?

[ Music stops ]

Were you also a pupil at Aldridge's school?

No, I was older than Marcus.

I was at Cambridge when he died. He was 12 years old.

Daily anticipation of humiliation and pain.

He couldn't take it anymore.

Did you know that Venetia

was Clarence Aldridge's daughter?

Yes. I asked her what part of the country

she was from shortly after meeting her,

and there it was.

We spoke about it briefly,

agreed there was nothing else to be said.

She had no illusion about what her father was.

I pitied her that day.

I wonder what her own childhood was like.

Oh, hey.

ASHE: Where did this come from?

She brought it round.

The woman policeman.

It was in mummy's desk.

What have I told you about that?

- OCTAVIA: What? - Mummy.

Sorry.

You didn't tell me she was here.

- I was going to. - ASHE: When was she here?

A couple of hours ago.

She asked if you knew some woman.

I said you didn't.

I told her you were gorgeous and I love you.

I told her what a gentleman you are.

She couldn't believe it.

You wouldn't lie to me, would you?

No.

Because you know how I hate liars.

I'd never lie to you about anything.

Have you packed?

Not yet.

You won't need much. And bring money.

PRESTEIGN: Thank you both for coming.

The lady who spoke to me about, Janet Carpenter,

she was extremely distressed in the confessional.

She said she believed evil took different forms.

That it drove down country lanes in a van

looking for little girls to steal from their mothers,

and that it also stood up in court

and defended the indefensible.

I didn't fully understand what she was saying,

and she left before I did.

But this arrived today by second post.

She was planning to confess to you, so...

DALGLIESH: Thank you.

I'll leave you in peace.

[ Mysterious music plays ]

Did she kill Venetia?

No. She discovered the body,

then defiled it with the wig and blood.

MISKIN: What is it, sir?

Garry Ashe.

Carpenter had watched Ashe's trial.

She saw something I saw, too.

That look he gave Venetia at the end.

MISKIN: But Venetia got him acquitted.

DALGLIESH: She dismissed him like he didn't matter to her,

which he didn't.

Carpenter approached Ashe and hired him to seduce Octavia.

Her revenge on Venetia.

So he could have killed Carpenter for money or...

Yes.

I think he did.

Oh, God. They're going away.

He's taking her to the country or Essex.

That's what he told her.

Get back to the yard and put out an immediate APB

on Ashe -- he's to be considered dangerous.

Then get on to the children's homes

and find out what sort of parks or country he used to go to.

Yes, sir. Where are you going?

Back to the house in case they're still there.

Be careful.

[ Dog barking distantly ]

You used to live here?

Home sweet home.

Is this where she was murdered?

Your aunt?

Wait here.

[ Footsteps climbing stairs ]

[ Eerie music plays ]

[ Footsteps overhead ]

[ Gasps lightly ]

[ Footsteps descending stairs ]

Never go to the woods without a knife.

[ Mid-tempo music plays ]

[ Telephone rings ]

- Miskin. - DALGLIESH: They're not here.

Housekeeper says they left over an hour ago.

The manager of the home said he used to take Ashe

to some woods just east of Harlow.

I've got 'em here on a map.

He said Ashe used to go on his own sometimes,

- watching the birds. - Good work.

Alert two traffic teams in that area. I'm on my way.

What's happening?

I just heard the call out about Ashe.

[ Telephone rings ] Yes, Miskin.

I think he killed his aunt. There's a photo.

MISKIN: Where are you?

Petrol station.

I have to go.

I don't want to be here.

Help me. He's got a knife.

Play the game. Don't let him know that you know.

I'm going to come and find you. Where are you?

I think he's coming. Help me.

Play the game. [ Receiver clicks ]

[ Door chimes jingle ]

[ Panting ]

[ Sighs ]

[ Ominous music plays ]

- How long will we stay here? - Not long.

If you could live anywhere in the world, where would you live?

Monte Carlo.

Good taste.

We'll sleep here tonight.

Tomorrow we'll go.

We'll get married there.

Would you like that?

Yes, I'd love that.

You're trembling.

MAN: All units mobilized.

We're looking for a red Honda motorcycle.

Registration Golf-Golf-Echo-7-9-2-November.

Second unit

moving into the southwestern corner of the forest.

First unit advanced northwest.

[ Dramatic music plays ]

MAN #2: Sierra-2-3 to control.

We have sighted the suspect vehicle.

[ Birds chirping ]

[ Ominous music plays ]

[ Click ]

I-I-I thought I heard something.

- How did they know? - Who?

- What did you tell the woman? - I --

- You lied to me. - I didn't.

DALGLIESH: Garry, it's Chief Inspector Dalgliesh.

Come out slowly, please, so we can talk.

Garry, come out alone, please, and leave Octavia in there.

We can talk together. You're an intelligent man.

Let's find a way to resolve this.

I didn't lie to you. I-I swear I didn't.

[ Breathing heavily ]

- I promise. - Shh!

I'm here with armed officers, Garry.

Leave Octavia, come out quietly, and drop your weapon.

[ Grunts, panting ]

You make one sound, just one sound...

Let's talk about possibilities,

resolve this together.

[ Breathing heavily ]

When I say go, we go.

Leave me.

I'll tell them you didn't hurt me.

ASHE: Go!

MISKIN: Back door! Back door!

Okay, let's go.

MAN: Armed police! Stop!

MAN #2: Armed police! Stay where you are!

MAN #1: Stay where you are!

MAN #3: Armed police!

[ Officers shouting indistinctly ]

I know this place. I know this place.

You killed my mum! Why did you kill my mum?!

I didn't kill your mummy. I really wish I had.

[ Police radio chatter ]

[ Panting ]

[ Dramatic music plays ]

[ Muffled whimpering ]

Help!

Aah!

[ Groans ]

Armed police! Stop, or I'll shoot!

[ Birds squawking ]

- Come on. - [ Groans ]

Officer down!

[ Dramatic music continues ]

No. [ Muffled whimpering ]

[ Whimpering ]

It's over. Let her go.

It's over when I say it's over, Kate.

MISKIN: Drop the knife.

You bitches are all the same.

- Drop your weapon! - This is on you.

Ashe!

[ Reverberation ringing ]

[ Octavia sobbing ]

[ Somber music plays ]

You're okay. You're okay.

You had to take the shot, okay?

You had to take the shot.

You're okay. You're okay.

[ Octavia sobbing ]

You're okay.

You're okay, Sergeant.

[ Sobs ]

Okay?

Uh...

Yeah. Thanks.

[ Bell tolling ]

I've just been speaking to Valerie Caldwell.

She tells me that your attentions to her are unwanted

and she wishes them to stop.

- What? - I've told her to call me

if you ever make her feel uncomfortable again.

Or if you make trouble for her in any way.

She also told me that, on Monday night,

the night Venetia died,

you were in the church watching her rehearse with the choir.

Yes.

Yes, I -- I remember now.

She said you stayed until almost the end.

20 past 8:00.

Venetia was dead by then.

I didn't kill Venetia?

Oh, thank God.

Thank God.

These great expanses of time that I just...lose.

I'm sorry.

It must be frightening.

You would have been walking through here

at around the time the killer left chambers.

I want to ask you, did you see anyone coming out of chambers,

locking the door, walking hurriedly towards the gates?

Well, yes.

Good Lord.

Thought we'd seen the back of you.

Mrs. Carpenter wrote a confession before she died.

She said she found Venetia dead in her room at 8:00.

She thought she'd died from natural causes.

She couldn't bear it.

She felt cheated out of her vengeance.

And just at the very moment when Garry Ashe

was putting into place her plan to make Venetia suffer,

it was then that she put the wig on Venetia's head

and threw the blood over her -- your blood.

Vengeance.

A very powerful emotion.

After which, she regretted it.

She tried to stop Ashe from moving forwards with the plan,

and that's when he killed her.

You believe that, do you?

That she didn't actually kill Venetia?

Because it seems perfectly obvious to me that she did.

She didn't kill Venetia.

You did.

Why would I want to do that?

As you said,

the desire for vengeance is a powerful thing.

[ Breathes deeply ]

It can be held in check, suppressed by a determined mind,

but it's hard.

A fight, a battle which must be fought every day.

[ Somber music plays ]

Every day, you were confronted by Venetia.

The flesh and blood of the man

who drove your little brother to his death.

You fight to remain civilized, you have to.

But then...

Then the cycle starts all over again

right in front of your eyes.

An Aldridge bullying your son.

And you know it'll only get worse.

She'll become Head of Chambers. You'll be outnumbered.

Laud won't be able to stop her.

She has power over him.

The affair you knew about.

She'll push your son out, ruin his career.

And, so, you go to her rooms and you ask her

to give him a chance.

I imagine she didn't listen. She was already overwrought

after hearing about Ashe and her daughter.

She says harsh things,

dismisses Matthew as a fool.

And the paper knife was right there next to your hand,

and suddenly, it's done.

An interesting theory.

But one which you'll never be able to prove.

I have a witness.

Langton said he saw you leaving chambers

at 20 past 8:00 that night.

An old man with dementia. Really?

He would be destroyed in court.

And then, there's a discrepancy

in your son's witness statement.

He states that you both arrived at the restaurant on time, 8:00.

- Which we did. - But then,

further down, you will see that he talks about

putting his children to bed before he left the house.

He goes into some detail about how they don't like to go to bed

before it gets dark, about how they insisted

on watching a certain television program

before he took them upstairs.

We checked.

The program didn't even start until 8:00 that night, so...

The earliest he could have been at the restaurant

was half past 8:00.

Well, he --

He made a simple mistake.

[ Scoffs ] Not one we're prepared to overlook.

Perverting the course of justice.

Remind me, what tariff does that carry?

You know, the world is better off without her.

And there is a certain justice to it all.

I don't agree.

[ Soft music plays ]

[ Requiem in D minor, Op. 48 plays ]

♪ In paradisum♪

♪ Deducant te angeli♪

♪ In tuo adventu♪

[ Sobbing ]

♪ Suscipiant te martyres♪

♪ Et perducant te♪

♪ In civitatem sanctam♪

♪ Jerusalem♪

♪ Jerusalem♪

♪ Jerusalem♪

[ Melancholy music plays ]

[ Choir continues indistinctly ]