Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
A shotgun had blown through the door.
A hitman shot the dentist
in Edgewater, Florida,
in broad daytime, in the office.
Being a small town, there was a lot
of rumor and speculation.
They alleged incest, inbreeding.
The attorney was snorting cocaine
off toilet seats in a strip club
at the very same time that he's representing people
in a first-degree murder case.
It sounded like something out of a movie,
and now it has come
to a real-life drama in Edgewater,
the little, quiet hometown.
[mysterious music]
♪
[easygoing country music]
♪
We are in Edgewater, Florida,
which is a small coastal town.
It's a very literal name. It is right on the edge
of the Indian River.
It is a community built around life on the water.
It's wonderful here.
We get to watch the dolphin, occasionally a big turtle,
sometimes a manatee.
It's cute.
It is block after block of these ranch homes.
It's one of those places that set out
to be aesthetically pleasing.
It makes you feel like you're in a Tim Burton movie
driving through this town.
Look, there are
the "Edward Scissorhands" topiaries.
Right there!
He's been here.
I know all my neighbors, and it's still
a small town kind of thing,
but no place is immune
from the evils of the world.
Here in Edgewater, a man named Norman Larzelere
set up a very successful dentistry office.
He worked with his wife, Virginia.
She was his office manager,
and they built a beautiful life together.
They had a huge house.
They had a tennis court, yachts,
and a big, beautiful family.
And then, one day in 1991, a masked gunman
comes into their office during their lunch break,
and all of a sudden, everything that they had built together
was gone.
[high clear music]
[line trilling]
Hurry!
Just after 1:00, we received the call at dispatch.
We have a shooting at the dentist's office,
in the north end of town.
Okay.
My detectives responded and determined
the gentleman that had been shot
was the dentist Norman Larzelere.
He was bleeding out,
and they were taking him to the hospital.
They couldn't get any statement from him before he passed.
That afternoon, Virginia Larzelere
was there when the detective arrived,
and Emma, who was working in the office.
We started getting their statements,
and according to Emma, the door opened,
somebody with a shotgun and a mask
came into the dentist's office, and she was terrified.
And Virginia-- she described the shooter.
Came in with a shotgun,
shot her poor husband,
and she tried to grab him as he ran out,
but she didn't know who the shooter was.
♪
Norman Larzelere's murder in 1991
has remained controversial for the last three decades.
And so we're gonna go talk to one person
who has been a constant in this case
since the beginning,
and that's private investigator Gary McDaniel.
Hi, Gary. - Hello.
Hello. - I'm Hilarie.
My pleasure.
Can you give us a little bit of backstory
about the Larzelere family?
Norman Larzelere was an accomplished dentist.
Everyone described Norman as just a sweet, outgoing guy,
but he wasn't much of a businessman.
And when he married Virginia Larzelere,
who was a very accomplished bookkeeper,
they became a very good team,
her being the businessperson she was
and him being the technical expert he was.
She came into the marriage with two children,
Jason and Jessica,
and Norman liked 'em so much that he actually adopted them.
And later, they had David and Ben.
It was a close family. - Yeah?
To anybody that knew them, it was an ideal relationship
with husband and wife running a business together
and both prospering.
What was the official police report
when they got to the scene?
Virginia says she and Norman were going to go to lunch,
but Virginia says, "I have to pay the bills," and so forth.
"Honey, you go."
Norman went to lunch, comes back to his office,
and then we know from witnesses
that Norman heard a noise,
and he went down the hallway to investigate.
He sees an intruder with a gun,
and he runs in the opposite direction of the intruder.
The shotgun blast goes through the door
that Norman has slammed behind him, and hits him,
and he goes down.
Virginia jumps up to go to the aid of Norman.
She steps into a side hallway with an exit door outside,
and she collides with the assailant.
He stumbles. She's clawing at him.
He gets up, and he runs.
She looks out the door,
and she sees the assailant's car leave.
What exactly does she see?
She describes the assailant by approximate height,
approximate weight.
Olive skin.
Dark hair with a ponytail.
Black clothing.
Black shoes. - Okay.
And even down to the body odor.
And she describes the car.
Toyota or a SAAB,
possibly blue, and she gives a partial plate,
and she said it had a motorcycle escort
as the car sped away.
Was it clear from the beginning
whether they thought this was an intentional murder
or if this was a robbery gone wrong?
Initially they thought, "What burglar would burglarize
a place in broad daylight?"
Was there anything missing?
Yes, there was.
In the safe, the door was open.
There was some Valium missing and some gold coins.
What physical evidence did they collect that day?
The Edgewater Police Department brought in
Florida Department of Law Enforcement.
Their forensics included shotgun residual
on the door and, obviously, the pellets
that are found in Norman Larzelere.
But they got limited forensic evidence.
The law enforcement was questioning the Larzeleres
and questioning anyone who was close to the Larzeleres.
My name is David Hendry.
I've been practicing criminal defense work
for 23 years.
The police questioned Steven Heidle several times.
He was an individual who befriended Jason Larzelere,
Virginia's son, and was kind of like a butler
or kind of a family assistant living in the house
and running errands for the Larzelere family.
Steven Heidle was always a suit kind of guy.
Very distinguished. He was a handsome young man,
so he convinced Virginia that he had value in Jason's life.
Jason is Virginia's son from her first marriage.
Right. At the time,
he was about 19 years of age.
He really didn't have his bearings in life.
He wasn't really that responsible.
Jason was in college, and he had some health issues.
I believe he had seizures from time to time,
and if he didn't take the medication,
it was a problem for him.
And so Virginia made a deal.
"Steven, you can be his roommate.
"We'll pay you a couple hundred dollars a week.
"Just make sure he stays on his meds
and make sure he stays in school."
But there's a whole other side of Steven Heidle.
Heidle was under investigation for bank fraud.
After the murder, the police go to Heidle,
but he tells the police, "I didn't know
anything about the murder."
Then there was Kristen Palmieri.
She worked in the dental office,
would run errands, and would do odd jobs
and just kind of, like, hanging on.
Kristen had actually been living part time
in a room at the Larzelere home.
Why?
You have to understand, Virginia was the type
that would help an underdog, 'cause Virginia came up
out of the mobile home kind of environment.
Virginia was trying her best to make a productive employee
out of Kristen Palmieri, but Kristen
had stolen a couple coins out of the safe
and had pawned them.
And eventually, they terminated her,
about seven to ten days before the murder.
Police talked to her, but she denied
that she was terminated.
She, in fact, told the police she was working that day.
She provides that she didn't really see anything.
She had taken lunch off that day from work.
She says she was at the dental office
that she's been fired from? - Correct.
She put herself right in it as an active employee.
She says that she came back to this turmoil
with the ambulance and the police
and everybody else.
So does Kristen speak
with law enforcement that night?
What is it, March 8th?
She has not a whole lot to contribute on March 8th.
About four days after the shooting,
Virginia came into my office and wanted to know
if we were making any progress.
To me, she didn't look like a bereaving widow.
She was well-dressed,
made sure I knew she was well-dressed.
My impression was that Virginia was intent
on being a rich, good-looking woman,
and she just wanted to know
how quickly we could get this done
so her papers could get cleared from the court.
Talking about that she couldn't get her insurance money
until the case was closed.
They looked into the insurance policies,
and they were several life insurance policies,
and the total was approximately $2 million
that would have served as the motive
in law enforcement's eyes
as to why she would have committed this murder.
We did a background on her, of course,
only to find out that she was well-known
in the bars in the area.
She was in the bars, out of the bars, back in the bars,
out of the bars, during the night.
Virginia was sleeping with a lot of people.
She was a player.
So she's been having affairs with these other guys.
Do they go, and they talk to these other guys?
They do.
And what do those guys have--
They admit and validate there were some affairs.
Uh-huh.
They say she talked about having her husband killed.
Talked about money.
Okay, so these guys say Virginia offered
money to kill her husband.
We located at least two boyfriends
who gave us information that Virginia was asking
them to kill her husband.
She promised 'em $100,000, new cars, whatever.
It was just insane.
Did the police believe that any of these guys
were the actual shooter?
- No. - Mm-hmm.
They seemed to be up front with it
and no reason for them to lie.
And Virginia had everything going for her,
except she wanted more.
And her way to get more was marry a rich man
and then get him killed.
[reverberating music]
So Virginia's situation looks bad,
but she obviously was not the gunman.
And so once police start looking at her,
how do they start unraveling who was under that mask?
There was a patient in the waiting room,
and she said, "I heard Norman say, 'Jason, is that you?'"
Jason is Virginia's son from her first marriage.
Right.
And at that point, we didn't know
anything other than the word "Jason" coming up.
We didn't know if he was asking for Jason
or whether Jason was the shooter.
We don't know.
The police knew that Steven Heidle
was a roommate of Jason Larzelere.
So the police go talk to Steven Heidle,
and Steven Heidle modified his statement.
And he says, "I know some things."
And what is it you know?
And he says, "Jason told me I'ma make a lot of money,
"and I'm gonna do real well, and we'll buy
that new car I'm looking at."
And what else does Heidle tell him?
He says Jason had a shotgun in the house,
and he cut off the barrel of a shotgun.
He says there are shavings from his shotgun on the floor.
They must have been so excited.
Oh, they went right to the apartment
with a search warrant, and they collected
the metal shavings, put it in an evidence bag,
and they were all ready.
The detectives put together the statements from witnesses
and said, "Boss, I think Virginia was
"the one responsible for the killing,
and Jason was probably the shooter."
Why would Jason kill his father for his mother?
What's the reasoning there?
Well, their inference was that there was
an unusual relationship between Jason and his mother
in that Jason would do anything for his mother.
And both of them would do anything for money.
The whole town just had this great suspicion
that she's gotta be guilty.
There was a lot of, like, rumor and speculation
that she was a manipulator,
domineering.
They painted a very bad picture of her.
In the course of that investigation,
there were leaks to the media that were unconscionable.
I mean they were slanderous, and they were unsubstantiated.
[somber music]
When Dr. Larzelere was killed,
it was very, very big news.
It was all over the TV stations.
I'm Purvette Bryant, a former court reporter
for the "Orlando Sentinel."
"A Current Affair" reported on an incestuous relationship
that Virginia Larzelere and her son Jason had together.
It was very shocking for those who looked at them
as a perfect family.
How could this take place?
And that only added fuel to the fire
as far as the story and the plot
and the sensationalism of it all,
that she hired her own son to kill her husband.
By this time,
four, five, six days into the investigation,
we were pretty sure of who was responsible for the killing.
This was not a mystery.
Our big problem was, we had to prove it.
The best way we're gonna prove this thing
is to have someone tell us what happened.
♪
What information
do Steven Heidle and Kristen Palmieri
give to law enforcement?
They've already given five to six statements
that really are not concrete, so the police begin
to realize Kristen Palmieri and Steven Heidle knew more.
Okay.
We thought all four of 'em were deeply involved
in this whole scheme.
Now, Palmieri and Heidle got to thinking,
"This is not gonna go good."
Police corner Heidle and Palmieri and say,
"Y'all have not been truthful.
"You know more.
We need to know it all."
Kristen and Steven knew that they needed to cooperate
with law enforcement, provide law enforcement
with whatever information law enforcement wanted,
in order to obtain convictions
against Virginia and Jason.
And ultimately, Heidle and Palmieri pointed the finger
at Virginia and Jason.
They decide to tell the authorities,
"Would it help if I told you where the weapons are?"
So you've got these two young people
working for the Larzelere family
that say, "You know what?
We know where the murder weapon is."
Law enforcement-- what's their take?
Ooh. Bingo.
Lightning flashes.
Heidle and Palmieri told me
they knew where the murder weapon was.
Said, "Well, it's in the next county,
off of Route 95, in a river."
Palmieri and Heidle told law enforcement
that Virginia was controlling them and directing them.
Yes, the weapons were inside Virginia's house,
and yes, Virginia wanted us to just get rid of them.
They mixed up some ready concrete,
poured it in.
They put the weapons in there,
allowed it to harden,
put it in the back of their car.
We got a diver
from the local sheriff's department
to go into the river,
found the piece of cement,
brought that back to the detective bureau.
They x-ray it, and they find out, inside the concrete,
is a shotgun and a pistol.
It's, I mean, potentially the murder weapon.
They've got everything they need,
and what happens next?
They do a search warrant in Virginia's house.
They found a pot of concrete.
Investigatively, it's the best lead they could have.
Virginia maintained her innocence,
but she wouldn't take a lie detector test.
I know she thought she could talk anybody out of anything,
except she didn't this time.
It surprised us that it was Jason,
'cause I didn't think he had the stones to do it,
but that was just my impression when I first saw him.
Here you have a woman conspire with her son
to kill his stepfather.
That was just unheard of.
It really began to explode in the media.
The murder was the first time this type of sensational story
occurred in Edgewater, which is a very small community.
And so it took off like wildfire.
The first case is more intricate and involved
than anything Hollywood could dream up.
It involves drugs and infidelity and bisexuality,
conspiracy, murder, and even a butler.
The media kind of hung her up from day one.
It was like, "Oh, you know, we've gotta find somebody,"
because this thing just doesn't happen,
especially in a small, sleepy town.
[soft pop nocturne]
♪
I looked at what evidence available to me,
which was very little, but on the basics,
I never saw this as a hit
because no hit man would shoot through a door and run away,
and not know whether or not he hit his target.
That's common sense.
♪
When I conduct an investigation,
I try to find something
about the people involved.
I found that there was 30-something witnesses
that were prepared to testify to various subject matters
relevant to the defense of Virginia Larzelere,
which included inconsistent statements
by Kristen and Steven Heidle
and witnesses that would have impeached their veracity.
But I'd had a falling out with the defense counsel
over some ethical choices that they were making,
so I left the investigation the latter part of August.
My defense investigation, by the time
of Virginia Larzelere's trial, is fruitful,
but a long ways from being complete.
And I wrote an extensive memo
of the things they needed to do.
The state called these witnesses
to testify against Virginia Larzelere,
to say, "Yes, I was having an affair with her,
"and yes, she was looking to have
someone kill her husband."
But a lot of people testified that it's just a joke.
Well, we thought that she was just joking around,
but the fact that she had put that out there
was very damaging.
So during Virginia's trial,
the prosecution present her affairs,
they present the insurance policy,
they present these guns found in concrete,
and they present a pot with concrete residue
from her home.
That's right, and I think the prosecutors brought in
about 18- to 20-something witnesses,
but the defense only brought in
two witnesses, and the testimony
lasted maybe an hour.
So Virginia's defense team did not use
the information that you had gathered
in your investigation.
And so what's the verdict?
Guilty. First-degree murder.
In the state of Florida, it carried the death penalty,
and she was ultimately sentenced to death.
I am Virginia Larzelere.
I am incarcerated in the Florida
Department of Corrections.
When they came back saying guilty,
I was devastated,
And he sentenced me to death.
I was taken back to the jail
and transported to Broward
and began serving a death sentence.
I had already lost Norman, and then I've lost my family.
I never got to see my kids again.
I have a strong faith,
and I stayed on my knees for the next 18 months.
Jason called me in fear and said, "You've gotta get me
another attorney."
And I found a competent attorney
I'd worked with before, by the name of William Lasley.
And then Lasley and I met as it related
to the previous evidence that I had acquired
and a strategy that we should evoke going forward.
And what was that strategy?
My strategy was simple--
call the witnesses-- and that's what
Bill Lasley decided to do.
He called in approximately 25 or 28 witnesses.
So they heard all this information
in Jason's trial that they didn't hear in Virginia's?
Right.
What is the outcome of Jason's trial?
Jason is acquitted as the triggerman
that allegedly conspired with his mother
to kill his stepfather.
We were watching television in the Volusia County jail,
and it interrupted the program to show the footage
that he was found not guilty.
I immediately jumped up and down and was ecstatic,
and I was so happy.
So how does the prosecution explain
how Virginia could have hired her son
to be a hitman,
but a jury has found Jason not guilty of being a hitman?
That's a question of law.
It's above my pay grade.
Virginia Larzelere's trial, in my opinion, was a farce.
My name's Shirley Bates, and I'm an attorney
out of Tallahassee, Florida.
Jack Wilkins was Virginia's attorney
who represented her in her trial.
I really hesitate to call him her attorney
because he didn't act like an attorney.
He didn't do his job.
They did not use the evidence available to them
or the witnesses available to them,
and from my perspective,
they were guilty of ineffective assistance.
The prosecution even said that she smelled alcohol
on Jack Wilkins during the trial.
He was supposed to be listening to witness testimony
and preparing cross examinations,
and that's really difficult to do if you're drunk,
or high, or both,
which he apparently was.
We found witnesses that said that he was
basically drinking like a fish,
and he was doing drugs.
He's doing methamphetamine.
He's doing cocaine.
He's going through 2-liter bottles
of vodka every day
at the very same time that he's representing
Virginia Larzelere.
I've been doing this post-conviction work
for 20 years now.
I've never seen anything quite like this case.
He's the worst of the worst.
Jack Wilkins was an alcoholic and drug addict.
Virginia was deprived of a defense
by her own attorneys.
At the time of him
representing Virginia Larzelere,
a lot of complaints were coming in
related to him taking large sums of cash
and not really providing proper representation.
Jack Wilkins' MO
as a criminal defense attorney
was to meet with his clients, like, in a parking lot
and obtain large amounts of cash,
like, $15,000-$20,000,
and then he would go back to his office,
and he would tell his bookkeeper,
"Now report that as I received $5,000."
So after Virginia's trial, he was convicted of tax fraud.
He was convicted of lying to the grand jury,
so he is a convicted perjurer.
Ultimately went to federal prison.
Her attorney was a little less than competent.
In one way, I was glad she didn't have Perry Mason.
On the other hand, I didn't want it to be thrown out
and do the whole thing over again.
[gentle music]
♪
We were challenging the conviction,
and we were challenging the death sentence.
One of the most significant failures
of trial counsel in this case is,
there's not one expert consulted
by the defense at trial.
He failed to challenge the state's case in any way.
No experts to counter their experts,
as far as with the weapons and stuff,
or even making points to prove
that Heidle and Palmieri changed their testimony,
and how it seemed to evolve in the way
that the law enforcement wanted it to evolve.
A couple weeks after the trial,
I receive a phone call from a juror, and she said,
"I feel pretty bad about it,
"because we couldn't believe Palmieri.
"We couldn't believe Heidle.
"We could not believe either one of them,
"but if the defense would have given us
"something to hold onto,
we'd have probably acquitted her."
That shotgun.
It didn't match any of the forensic evidence
at the crime scene.
The weapon in the river
had a full barrel on it.
The whole thing is that Heidle says Jason sawed off
the shotgun in the apartment.
You're telling me that the shotgun that was recovered
was not sawed off?
It was not sawed off, and it was--
fact, it was inoperable.
So there's no shavings to match
the shavings in the apartment.
So the concrete
that the two weapons were found in--
was that ever traced back to Virginia?
No.
When I deposed Detective Gamell,
who was the lead detective on the case,
I asked him, "What was
"the most significant piece of evidence
against Virginia Larzelere?"
And he cited the concrete from Virginia Larzelere's house
matched the concrete that encased
the weapons in Pellicer Creek.
That was very peculiar, because he had it wrong,
because the FBI report said these concretes are different.
These concretes do not match.
The problem is the law enforcement--
they're acting on the premise of what Heidle told them,
that that's the weapon,
that "we were summoned to Virginia's house,"
encased them in concrete, and dumped 'em in the river
within days of the murder.
And it's a lie.
We brought an algae expert that simply said
the guns couldn't have been in the water
shortly after the murder,
as the witnesses Palmieri and Heidle say.
They could have only been there a day or two.
You're dealing in South Florida,
in brackish water,
and there's gonna be slime on it.
If it's in there for more than two or three weeks,
gonna find barnacles on it.
And it was fresh concrete, which was visually obvious.
So the guns did not go into the water in March,
like Kristen and Steven originally said they did?
Those guns could only have been put in the water in early May,
right before they led investigators to go scuba dive
and pick 'em up? - That's right.
[dramatic music]
What do you make of all of that?
It's consistent with the theory
that Heidle and Palmieri are framing Virginia and Jason,
which begs the question, why?
Palmieri and Heidle-- their credibility was zero,
and they were such liars
that the state admitted in their closing argument
that they were obviously lying
and that they obviously had beforehand knowledge
of this murder.
I went looking to find out what else they knew.
As a defense investigator, I wanted
to know about the weapons.
So I discovered weapons were stolen.
Okay, so these are stolen guns.
This isn't a gun that Virginia had before,
or that Norman had before, or that Jason had before.
Correct. The weapons were stolen
from the Oakridge gun shop, in Orlando.
So if you can figure out who stole those guns,
you can figure out who was involved with this shooting.
Exactly.
I gathered a bunch of police reports.
The weapons were stolen
by a group I referred to as the Harvey Gang,
a local group of burglars.
From the police reports, I've gathered
photographs of individuals that were involved
in the gun shop burglary.
And then I peeled back,
who were their known associates?
I found that those burglars are connected
to Heidle and Palmieri.
This one allegedly was a lover of Steven Heidle.
Is there any way that Virginia
was tied to these guys or that Jason was tied to these guys?
I explored all of that, and they're not connected
to Virginia, and they're not connected to Jason.
Then I asked known associates of the Harvey Gang,
"Do you know if they were in the area of Edgewater,
Florida, on March 8th?"
And they said yes.
Every year, this motorcycle event
took place in the area.
They go every year. They go over there
to steal motorcycles and other things,
but this time, associates said they came back--
it was really different. They were scared to death.
So the Harvey Gang comes back the day of the murder...
- Yes. - Acting all weird.
Correct, and I asked, when they came back from there,
did they have any medication?
"Oh, funny you should mention that."
They had a bottle of commercial pills.
What about gold coins?
"Oh, yeah, they had gold coins."
So their associates are telling you
all of these things? - Correct.
So I now know the weapons encased in concrete
are connected to a group of burglars,
and those burglars are connected
to Heidle and Palmieri.
I think this was a planned burglary.
I believe Kristen and Steven
solicited the Harvey Gang to get the job done.
Interesting enough, a bank clerk tells the police
that, before the murder, she saw Kristen Palmieri
circling the block.
I believe she was the lookout, and she told them,
"I can let you in. I can open up the safe.
You guys do the rest."
But they didn't expect Virginia, or Norman,
or anybody to be there, because they routinely went
to lunch during the day.
So the prosecutors--they're saying this was a hit
made to look like a robbery.
And you're saying this was a robbery
that accidentally became a murder.
Exactly.
What did Steven and Kristen stand to gain
by pointing the finger at Virginia and Jason?
They could live, because the people
that actually perpetrated the crime, I think,
were very dangerous people.
And I'm sure, behind the scenes,
they made it very clear, "If we go down, you go down."
Had anybody else followed up on these leads,
they would have arrived at the same place you did.
I did what they did not do,
because they discounted that information
from the onset.
Remember, the first things out of Virginia's mouth was,
"I described the assailant.
"I described the car.
"I gave 'em a partial number.
I don't know why they're coming after me."
They believed initially, right away,
that Virginia's description of the assailant
couldn't be true because it was so detailed.
Yeah.
There's nobody that ever got this type of a statement
from a witness on a murder,
the--the color of the car,
the motorcycles.
Everything was like a movie she saw.
Everything, like, was fantasized or whatever.
So they never believed her, but did anyone
ever corroborate Virginia's story?
Well, in 1994, a TV production team is filming
the Norman Larzelere office, in Edgewater,
and a young man walks up to them and says,
"I saw the murderer leave that day."
They call me immediately on the phone.
I meet this young man, by the name of Danny.
Danny tells a very solid story.
"I was on my motorbike, near the office."
He says, "I was scared.
"When I saw that guy running with a gun,
"I dropped that gear down, I revved that engine up,
and I got out of there." - Yeah.
Suddenly it hits me.
He just confirmed what Virginia thought
was a motorcycle escort.
Now, in the legal business, we call that
newly discovered evidence.
Virginia was convicted based on circumstantial evidence
and statements provided by two people who lied
and on the idea that she was
some sort of sexual manipulator,
with nothing to substantiate their claims.
And the state still chose to sentence her to death.
And now, there's a new witness too.
Our goal in post-conviction
was to show that the conviction and the death sentence
was unreliable.
[tense music]
♪
When your client faces the ultimate penalty of death,
you want to uncover anything and everything
in a client's background.
In this case, we were able to get
into Virginia Larzelere's childhood.
Virginia was the oldest of the children in the family.
Her father was a monster.
He was molesting,
sexually violating, the entire family.
Virginia would step up to protect her sisters
and protect her family.
How noble,
to put herself up,
to protect her younger siblings.
And this is crucial,
to present this type of evidence to a jury,
that she had some value as a human being,
that she was worthy of living and not being executed
at the hands of the state.
This lady has now been in prison for 30 years.
She is gonna be 70 years old.
Almost half of her life in prison.
How do you not give somebody a new trial?
Thank you so much for having us.
You know, there's a lot to dig into in this case.
When were you first aware of Virginia's case?
So I came into the case around the end of 2019.
It doesn't take much in reviewing
to figure out that she didn't get the defense she deserved.
There was a lot of media coverage
and a lot of the sensationalism,
you know, about what a bad person Virginia was:
sex addict,
black widow,
gold digger.
All those names.
- As a woman... - Right.
What is your assessment of how she was portrayed?
They just look at it different
if a woman's sexually active or promiscuous.
A man can be, and then he's masculine,
and he's--you know.
- A conqueror. - Right.
But a woman is--
Right, and they make her out to be an absolute villain.
And it is kinda crazy,
because they were both cheating.
- Really? - Norman Larzelere.
He had outside relationships also, but he's a man.
So was anything made of his affairs?
No. It was not.
You know, men will do what men will do.
What does she do next?
Our goal is essentially to get
her conviction overturned.
The state's theory was that she conspired with Jason.
- Mm-hmm. - Well, Jason was acquitted,
so there is some case law out there
that says that can't happen.
If your coconspirator is acquitted of this crime,
that you cannot then be convicted of it,
because who did you conspire with?
[cell phone chimes]
Virginia, hi.
I'm so happy to see you.
It's very nice to meet you.
So I have to ask you.
Did you conspire to kill your husband?
No.
I never solicited anyone.
I never aided anyone.
I never abetted anyone.
Was there any part of you that wanted him gone?
No. Norman was a great guy.
We were best friends.
He's the father of my children.
I was very promiscuous,
but as long as Norm was okay with what I did,
and as long as I was okay with what he did,
we didn't think it was anyone else's business.
I thought that our private life
was our private life,
and it's not.
I'm sorry that my life choices
put me in a position
to be found guilty when I'm not.
Wipe away the media, innuendo, slander.
All I've ever asked is to look at the facts,
and look at the evidence.
I will continue to fight to clear my name.
Is that why you're still fighting?
Yes.
That's my goal, and I won't stop fighting
until somebody listens.
As a woman, this case
and the media firestorm around it
makes me very uncomfortable.
Virginia did not take the stand.
Her defense mounted no defense.
It just leaves this big, gaping hole
for the prosecutor and the media
to say whatever they want to say about you.
And then it's gospel.
It's so much harder to push back against that
from a cell.
And if she's innocent,
what a horrific situation.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.