All language subtitles for True.Crime.Story.It.Couldnt.Happen.Here.S01E09.720p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP2.0.H.264-NTb_Eng_sdh

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic Download
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American) Download
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

[line trills]

[low dark music]

[line trills]

[line trills]

[suspenseful music]

♪ ♪

[notification chimes]

- Hi, Nicole. - Well, hey. How are you?

I'm really good. It's nice to meet you.

Thank you so much for getting in touch with me.

It's good to see you face-to-face.

[somber music]

After the first season

of "It Couldn't Happen Here,"

I started getting social media messages

from people about cases they felt needed attention.

I'm a eighth grade math teacher, and in 2013,

a really good friend of mine reached out

and said, "Something bad's happened.

It's another one of our kids is gone too soon."

A former student of mine in Angier, North Carolina,

had been shot by his father-in-law

who was a pastor

and it was said it was self-defense.

Why didn't that sit well with you?

Because it did not match the kid that I knew

in eighth grade.

Christian Griggs was a student of mine.

There was zero aggression in Christian.

He never had any type of conflict.

He was one of those students that just always stands out,

intelligent, from a good family,

just really going places, and I haven't seen Christian

since he was in high school.

I'm sure he had changed over time

and maybe he did do something to initiate an argument,

but it just didn't match at all,

and it immediately was a red flag to me

to try to reach out about his case.

This situation is exactly what our show is about.

You know, you've got a school teacher

who, all these years later, is trying to shed light

on her student's death

and all the unanswered questions

that are surrounding that.

♪ ♪

And it's that level of care and compassion

that we know makes small towns so special.

We're just a plain, simple town

with a lot of-- a lot of good people in it.

The people here are generally friendly,

family-oriented.

You don't really meet strangers.

We try to get along

and we make the best of everything.

If it's a good situation, we try to make good of that.

If it's bad, we try to make good of that.

We just live and let live.

[foreboding music]

[line trills]

[melancholy guitar music]

I'm Anthony Griggs.

I'm a father to Christian Griggs.

My name is Dolly Griggs and I'm Christian's mother.

Tony and I met at Fort Carson, Colorado,

in the military.

I did 21 years in the army, retired here at Fort Bragg.

We moved to Angier around 1996.

It seemed like your typical small town.

Uh, everybody knows everybody.

The people seem to be nice.

It seemed like a nice family town.

When we moved to Angier,

Christian was around five years old,

and there was a good school system

and a nice place to raise your kids.

There were a few small things that we had to address

with my son Christian as far as racial issues in town,

but in a small town like this one,

people don't get out and don't know anything different.

Sometimes you have to educate them by way of presence.

In high school Christian started dating

Katie Chisenhall.

Her dad, Pat Chisenhall, was a preacher.

It was Christian's senior year

when he told us that Katie was pregnant.

They had a child and they named her Jaden,

but it didn't work out.

♪ ♪

On October 11th, uh, Christian was on fall break

at North Carolina State,

and he was supposed to have Jaden that night.

So that Friday Christian came in the house

and we thought he would have Jaden with him,

but he was alone.

So my wife asked him, "Where's Jaden?

We thought Jaden would be with you."

He really didn't say anything and he went upstairs.

The next morning, Christian went back

to the Chisenhalls' house to get Jaden.

I looked at my phone.

Had to be about 9:00 in the morning.

I had several missed calls.

It was Christian.

So I call him back.

The line had a lot of static in it and it cut.

The Chisenhalls' house is just a short distance from here,

but the connectivity is poor.

Jumped in my truck and I drove over there.

I pulled in behind Christian.

I said, "What's going on?" He said, "They're not here,

"as usual.

"I'm here to pick up Jaden

and there's nobody here at the house."

I said, "Well, what are you gonna do?"

He said, "Well, I'm gonna hang out

and I'm gonna wait for them to come back."

And he asked me to go ahead and leave.

So I left, as Christian asked me to do.

But I wish I would've stayed.

[ominous music]

And as I walked in the door to my house,

my phone rang again.

It was Christian.

This time he said, "Dad, this guy's over here telling me

to shut the eff up."

I said, "Christian, who?"

He said, "Pat."

I drove over there.

When I arrived at the house,

it was quiet.

It was serene.

I thought, "Something about this is not quite right."

♪ ♪

And as I walked across the yard

and stepped up upon the steps,

and saw the window closest to the door

had been pushed in slightly at the top,

kind of like a double-hung window,

where you would fold it down.

I reached out my right hand to ring the doorbell,

and I looked to my immediate right

and there was Christian laying on the ground facedown.

I did not know what had happened to him.

I kneeled down by his side,

and almost instantaneous,

police cars begin to come from everywhere,

Harnett County Sheriff Department.

The jump out of their vehicles, weapons drawn,

run up on the porch, see me,

say, "We--we've got a call, shots fired.

There's been a shooting."

And I said, "It must be my son."

[dark music]

They immediately push me off the porch.

I then called my wife, Dolly,

and I say, "Christian's been shot."

Dolly screams...

and the phone goes dead.

I just remember dropping the phone

and I told my daughter Krystle that Christian had been shot.

And we just ran out the door.

I didn't have my purse.

I didn't have no shoes on.

When we got there,

the EMT was doing CPR on my son

and one of the deputies came off the porch

and said they were gonna take Christian to WakeMed,

and I said, "Is he still alive?"

And he said, "Yes."

[siren wails]

And we get to the hospital...

And eventually,

the doctor comes in and says...

♪ ♪

"He didn't make it."

"He didn't make it."

[sniffs]

The doctor says, "He didn't make it."

♪ ♪

I fell to the floor.

I couldn't believe it.

Couldn't believe it.

They hadn't told us the magnitude of his injuries

at that point.

But one of the trauma nurses that was in the room

said, "Whatever what happened,

he was trying to get outta there."

[mellow country music]

♪ ♪

We are headed to Angier, North Carolina,

which is a little tiny community outside of Raleigh.

Angier's down here in Harnett County,

North Carolina.

It's a really little town.

It's like a little over 5,000 people.

Of all the places that we've traveled,

this is place that I probably have the most connections.

I have family that lives here.

One of my very best friends from childhood lives here.

You know, I've spent a lot of time

in this part of North Carolina.

This is a case where a local pastor,

Pat Chisenhall,

shot his son-in-law, Christian Griggs

and all these years later, it is still not resolved

for a lot of members of this community.

When this shooting happened,

the media immediately reported on it,

but there is always more to the story

than what you can get out of that initial headline.

And so right now we are meeting

with Robby Jessup.

He is a local attorney who knows all about this town

and this case.

If you could walk me through what happened that day

in October.

Christian has arrived to pick up his daughter,

and somehow this all dominos

into Christian shot by Pat Chisenhall,

his father-in-law.

Yes.

Katie was living immediately next door

to Mr. Chisenhall.

According to Katie,

the night before the shooting,

this is October 11th, 2013,

Christian arrived to pick up Jaden

and discovered Katie's neighbor has taken Jaden

to the zoo that day.

And according to Katie,

Christian gets upset about that and attempts

to enter the home through a window

with an air condition unit.

Mm-hmm. So then what happened?

Christian leaves and then Katie goes that night

and swears out herself with a magistrate

misdemeanor warrants

for damaging an air conditioner and for trespass.

The following morning on the day of the shooting,

Katie and Pat had gone

to try to get a restraining order

against Christian, which they never obtained.

- Mm-hmm. - They are arriving back

at Mr. Chisenhall's house.

Christian showed up and there was an interaction

with Christian for some period of time.

Okay.

When the police interview Pat and Katie,

what is their version of what happened that morning?

The police did a reenactment with Mr. Chisenhall

of how exactly he claimed the shooting took place.

While Katie is on that first 911 call,

another call comes in from Pat Chisenhall.

Chisenhall then says he goes in the residence

and Christian is trying to come into the home.

Pat Chisenhall claims he was in fear of his life.

Mr. Chisenhall claims he shoots

from inside of his living room

at Christian, who is coming through that window.

Okay. That's a scary story.

What is Katie's version of what happened that morning?

Katie says she was hiding in a closet

and didn't see anything.

What does law enforcement see when they get there?

There were some photographs taken

showing the condition of the residence.

[shutter clicking]

There was some fingerprint dusting done

on a window screen.

- Mm-hmm. - And inside of the house...

[shutter clicking]

Three shell casings were found.

Can you tell me a little bit about Pat Chisenhall?

Mr. Chisenhall was a reverend,

operated the Abundant Life Ministry Center.

His family was born and raised Harnett County,

through and through Harnett County.

Mm-hmm, and so the story

that immediately starts circulating

that Pat Chisenhall shot in self-defense...

That narrative was put into the news immediately.

New information tonight about a shooting in Harnett County.

Investigators say no charges have been filed.

They believe the pastor acted in self-defense.

I was an investigative reporter at WRAL News

here in Raleigh, North Carolina.

At the time, we did not have a lot of information directly

from the authorities, but we spoke to members

of Pat's church, people who had talked to Pat

and heard the stories from that day.

His son-in-law had tried to break in the house, uh,

threaten 'em, and, uh,

he had no other recourse to do but what he did.

It was in self-defense.

As a result, the narrative that emerged

was really Pat Chisenhall's narrative,

that this was a case of self-defense,

and that was all there is to it.

[twangy guitar music]

After the shooting, we were home

and we had the TV on,

and the story came up on the news.

And we were just astounded when we saw the photographs

of the crime scene.

The window had been bashed and pushed in and we thought,

"That didn't look like that when we were there.

That window wasn't like that."

We're like, "What is going on here now?"

[soft guitar music]

♪

Right now we are driving over to meet with the parents

of Christian Griggs.

They're an army family

and they moved here to give their kids,

like, a great small-town life.

It sadly went terribly wrong

and it will be good to hear directly from them

how everything unfolded.

Hi. How are you? - Thank you so much...

- Oh, I'm so happy to meet... - For coming.

- You guys. - Thank you so much.

- Thank you guys so much. - Well, come on in.

Yes, I'll follow you.

Oh, wow. Look. - Got some pictures out.

Yeah, I wanna see everything.

Yeah, this one was one of my favorite pictures

from when he was in Iraq.

[melancholy music]

And this is-- [sighs]

this is the flag that, uh...

I did not want to receive

when they take off the coffin and they give it to you.

- The internment. - So...

'Cause he's such a handsome kid.

Thank you so much.

What can you tell me about Christian?

He was a very smart kid.

He was in the National Honor Society,

just always excelled in everything that he did,

and Christian had a lot of friends.

Yeah, Christian could make a friend anywhere.

He never had an enemy.

I was a good friend of Christian Griggs

since elementary school.

Christian was probably one of the most popular people.

Everybody knew Christian Griggs.

He was just really a bubbly personality,

always smiling.

I'm sure anybody would've loved

to be Christian's girlfriend.

Had he dated much in high school?

I was told Christian had a lot of girlfriends,

but he brought very few home,

and then he met Katie.

He was, I would say, almost head over heels,

like, "I found this girl. She's good," you know?

Especially in the beginning.

He saw a lot in Katie.

You know, she was ambitious,

like goal-oriented the same way that he was.

What did he want for his future?

Did he wanna go to school?

What did he want to study?

Because of his academics, he was able to get

a four-year ROTC scholarship. - Wow.

Well, you guys were probably pretty excited about that.

Yes, absolutely.

- It's a win. - Yeah, oh, definitely.

All he had to do was pick a school of choice.

[soft music]

♪ ♪

You know, as he's getting closer to that leave date

for college in senior year,

is Katie a part of his plan?

He never talked about long-term plans,

but it was his senior year when Christian told us

that Katie was pregnant.

But he's already been accepted

at, uh, North Carolina State University,

uh, getting ready to go to school in July.

So it was like wow. [laughs]

It was a lot for him to take on.

We told him that whatever he needed,

we were there to help him, you know?

But the best thing that you can do

for Katie and for your new baby is to stay in school.

When the baby is born,

how did he handle that?

He tried to go to school during the day,

and when he got out of class, he would drive down to Angier

to help her with the baby.

He did this every single day.

How long was he able to sustain that?

Couple months and then he said that he was failing,

couldn't concentrate, his grades was low

and he just felt like the best thing he could do

was just to join the military

so that he could take care of his family.

I don't think I've ever cried so hard in my life

because he's just going through so much

and there's nothing you can do...

- Yeah. - But be there for him.

Does he come back here to live?

He went to go live with the Chisenhalls.

Did he talk about his relationship

with her family?

Did he like them?

He looked up to Pat, you know?

But I don't think Pat was happy that his daughter fell in love

with a Black man and Christian had a Black family.

That's not what he wanted for his child.

Christian had always kind of mentioned,

like "I'm not sure if her dad likes me.

"He's a old white guy, you know?"

Deeply rooted in Harnett County.

I think that was tough for Christian

because he was seeking acceptance

from somebody who didn't want to give it to him,

so there was a lot of things

that were going against Christian and Katie.

But in the beginning, they seemed to make it work

and Katie's father was actually

the--the presiding minister over the wedding.

He was the one who actually married them.

I did want things to work out for Christian,

but I wasn't naive to see that the path

was very challenging for him.

♪ ♪

I was here one evening and the phone rang.

And I picked up the phone and it was Christian's voice

on the other end.

He said, "Dad, our convoy was out

and the vehicle in front of me was hit."

I said, "What do you mean, son, 'hit'?"

He said it was an IED.

♪ ♪

My next question was...

"Is everybody all right?"

He said, "No, Dad.

Some of my friends didn't make it."

Having been in combat

and experiencing that for myself,

I could tell that it had changed the man

in which Christian was.

August 2011,

Christian's ended his tour in Iraq

and he's living with Katie,

but it is clear that there is some turmoil there.

I believe that Christian being deployed

was difficult for Katie too,

and I know Christian had a hard time

when he came home.

One of the things that my colleagues and I

thought was really important with this case

was to try to tell the full story,

to try to, um, understand all of the factors

that were coming into play

that led them to this moment.

[soft tense music]

In May of 2012,

Katie calls 911 and she told dispatchers

that her husband was threatening

to commit suicide,

but the officer says he talked to Christian

who basically said, "You know, I got this gun out of my safe

mostly to scare my wife."

But Christian did admit to being depressed

since he returned home from overseas.

It was serious enough that the officer

took that gun for safekeeping.

About four months later, Katie calls 911 again

to say that Christian Griggs is suicidal,

and when an officer arrives,

Christian says, "I haven't talked to my wife

"in a couple of hours, but we are separated

and that separation has been a little rough."

The very next day Katie calls the authorities again.

And this time what she tells them

is that Christian is outside of her home in Angier

and he's angry about the custody situation.

This is a theme that has begun to emerge in this separation.

There are challenges between Katie and Christian

over custody.

Ultimately, Christian and Katie

had pretty much officially called it quits,

and he decided to get back in school.

So there's been a pattern that's been established

with custody of Jaden.

Can you talk to me a little bit about what that looked like?

He would have Jaden every other weekend.

Did he typically pick her up on Friday nights,

Saturday mornings?

If he couldn't get her on Friday night,

then he would come back the Saturday.

One time he was here until like 7:00 at night Saturday

and I know that he kept calling Katie

just waiting for Jaden to get back.

And so, you know, it's very upsetting

'cause this is supposed to be his time

with his daughter.

That happened a lot.

She made it difficult.

[dark ominous music]

Saturday, October 12, 2013,

what we know about what happened that day

is sort of pieced together based on statements

from people who were there and from these 911 calls.

One of the things that's interesting about

these 911 calls

was that it's not entirely one-sided.

You do hear Christian in the background.

A very interesting and important fact

is during Pat Chisenhall's 911 calls,

Christian himself is on the phone,

trying to reach an attorney and calling his father,

and Christian was communicating to him

he was the one feeling threatened by the Chisenhalls.

♪ ♪

We knew that there was no way

that Christian was trying to break into their home

because Christian's never done anything like that before.

This was a narrative that they put out there.

You talking about a young Black man

being violent and going into someone's home

and it's an interracial marriage.

What's the first thing that's gonna come to your mind?

He's justified.

He should've got shot.

So this is the narrative

that gets put out into the community?

That seems insurmountable.

What happens after that?

So when the autopsy report came in, I looked at it.

It said he was shot four times in the back.

I expected this man was gonna be arrested.

I spoke with the district attorney

Vernon Stewart and I say, "Well,

"Christian was shot in the back.

Why is it this man hasn't been charged?"

He said, "Well, I can't just charge a man

for shooting somebody in the back."

And I say, "Well, under what pretenses

"can you tell me it's acceptable

to shoot a man in the back?"

And his response was, "I'm not gonna fuss with you."

Did they give you a reason why

they're not gonna press charges?

We found out because Pat Chisenhall said

that Christian tried to break into their home.

They were gonna try to use the Castle Doctrine

in Christian's case.

♪ ♪

What that doctrine says

is that if someone's coming into your house,

there is a presumption

that you are in fear of your life

and you have a legal right to use deadly force.

So Pat was largely portrayed as the victim.

And law enforcement were extremely clear

they were considering this self-defense

and that no charges of any sort

were ever going to be brought or pursued.

[country music]

♪ ♪

I believe that people around here rely

on their guns because they have the right to.

It's, uh, their Second Amendment right

to bear arms so they feel like

they can take things into their own hands.

If you come into my home unannounced,

then I have every right to defend myself.

If I see someone else in danger,

absolutely, but I believe it should be the last resort.

When you take it upon yourself to be God for a moment,

now you show me where that's right.

You show me what scripture validates that

and then we'll have another conversation.

♪ ♪

I'm just baffled because someone being shot in the back

is huge red flag.

To not investigate is just a bold decision

for someone to make.

They said that Pat Chisenhall

was an outstanding person in the community

and that he didn't deserve this and that this boy,

Christian, was standing on Pat Chisenhall's front porch.

And that's reason enough to get shot?

That's what they told us.

I mean, what's the definition of that?

Who picks and chooses who the upstanding members

of the community are?

The sheriff department based off only your color

of your skin.

They call it here "prosecutorial discretion."

You are pushing to keep the case open,

to have charges brought.

You are finally told, "This is an upstanding member

of this community,"

meaning a generational son of this community,

also a white member of this community,

also a reverend.

"We are going to side with him."

What's your next step?

We pursue looking for an attorney

and we got private investigators

to look into our case.

When I saw the inconsistencies

with the narrative that had been told

and the physical evidence,

I immediately decided this was a situation

where I wanted to help.

When you first met with Tony and Dolly,

what happened?

They showed me the medical examiner's report.

Christian was shot six times,

once in the shoulder, once in the abdomen,

four times in the back.

So this issue of Christian coming through the window,

being the aggressor, does it make sense

with the medical examiner's report?

- Absolutely not. - Okay.

Common sense, if you're coming face forward

through a window... - Mm-hmm.

How do you get four bullets in your back?

Moreover, the trajectory of those bullets indicate

that he was laying on the ground

facedown at the time the shots were fired.

We also know that the second bullet

to the back paralyzed Christian.

So there's no way he could've crawled from the window

over into that corner?

Where he was found is where he was shot.

No way could he have crawled.

There was no evidence of anybody dragging his body.

No evidence of blood anywhere

except immediately under the body.

There was not blood at the window?

No blood on the window.

♪ ♪

Were the shots to his shoulder

and his abdomen life-threatening?

No, according to the medical examiner,

both those shots were easily survivable.

The fatal shots were the shots to the back.

And was he a threat laying facedown on the porch?

Does the Castle Doctrine apply

to the death of Christian Griggs?

As I see it, absolutely not.

[somber music]

On the surface, this looks like

a right-to-defend-your-home story,

but it takes very little effort

to scratch that veneer and realize

that this case demands a thorough investigation.

Someone who did an extensive amount of digging

in this case is Lee Denney.

I'm Lee Denney. I'm a private investigator,

and I'm a North Carolina concealed carry instructor.

In 2014, I was contacted by Griggs' legal team

asking if I wanted to get involved

in their investigation of the case.

Let's talk about Pat Chisenhall's narrative.

In his walk-through video, he says...

I ran right here.

He went to his closet.

He got his gun.

I grabbed that, and I came running in here.

He came back into the living room,

Christian was coming through the window,

and he fired from behind that couch.

I think I fired from here.

What is the probability of that being true?

Zero.

Pat said he was shooting almost directly at the window,

but there were no holes in the shades, curtains,

or through the lower glass pane.

You see the improbability of Christian being able

to climb in here and then take all the shots that he took

without bullets passing through the bottom part of the window

or anywhere else.

It doesn't add up.

No missed shots?

Right.

To hit a moving target

with all of your shots is difficult.

To stand there and do all that shooting

and not miss, pretty much impossible.

Hmm.

Theoretically,

where could these shots have taken place

where there wouldn't be any stray bullets?

Outside on the front porch.

- Uh-huh. - Which'd be why his body

was laying down in the position that he was laying

and the angle of the bullets in his back.

Then there's the shell casings that were found.

[shutter clicking]

You should be finding six somewhere in here.

We asked law enforcement if they searched

and they said they did and they only found

these three shell casings.

But how long did they search?

I think they were there that day, that evening

and--and left.

Had people been allowed to come on to the scene?

I believe--I believe the Chisenhalls came back

later that night to the house.

While there was still missing evidence?

Yes, apparently so.

Also, the three shell casings were found

within about 12 inches of each other.

- Mm-hmm. - Which is, I would say,

more than highly unusual.

The shell casings come out.

They're ejected to the right.

For three to be found all together like that,

that's not realistic.

My impression, knowing how that firearm operates,

seeing furniture, walls, and all that,

tells me that those were collected

and thrown over there.

That's-- [sighs]

It is the most probable thing,

but it's also damning.

Sure, sure it is because it brings the question:

who did it? - Uh-huh.

♪ ♪

According to the crime scene log,

while police are still on the scene,

Mr. Chisenhall's son, Pat Chisenhall, Jr,

is allowed to come in and out of the crime scene

on two separate occasions.

Certainly under no circumstances

would you want a family member

of a person who had just shot a man

coming in and out of that shooting scene

that is currently under investigation.

All of these pieces put together say what to you?

I'm thinking that this is not a self-defense shooting.

Why aren't we charging Mr. Chisenhall?

I scheduled a meeting with the medical examiner,

Dr. Scott.

She said that she agreed with my theory.

We got to the facts that it was not self-defense,

but they still refused to do the right thing.

I realized that the Harnett County

Sheriff Department and DA wasn't going to do anything,

so I had two choices to make.

I had a choice to sit back and accept it

or I had a choice to fight.

So I decided to fight.

The DA had said pretty explicitly,

"We're not gonna charge."

Sheriff's department said pretty explicitly

that they thought this was a clear-cut case

of self-defense, but there was a civil question

at the heart of this about whether or not

Pat Chisenhall was responsible for the wrongful death

of Christian Griggs.

[soft music]

♪

I wondered, "Could we ever convince the community,

"the jury, to break from the narrative

that was put out there from the very start?"

[tense music]

Over the course of the trial,

we put multiple county employees

in the witness box.

We questioned them about the missing shell casings,

the evidence, and the timing of the 911 calls.

Two seconds after Pat's first 911 call ends,

Katie calls 911 for a second time.

At that point in time,

we know Pat and Christian are out in the yard.

There was no time for Christian

to have broken into that house.

Pat's second 911 call starts

during Katie's second 911 call.

Based upon the overlap,

we know Christian had to have been shot

during Katie's second 911 call.

But on Katie's second 911 call,

you don't hear any gunshots.

That says to me Katie was nowhere close

to the gunfire,

which says to me the shooting had to be outside.

I think the biggest moment in the trial

was when Mr. Chisenhall took the stand.

He blanketly claimed a general lack of recollection

of anything at all

when those four bullets would have been discharged

into Christian's back.

I have no memory of it, so...

At the time of the walk-through

with the police, Pat seems to have a good recollection

of how he contends the shooting occurred.

I think I fired from here.

By the time we get to the civil trial

and I've taken Mr. Chisenhall's deposition,

he can't remember a damn thing.

As far as the shooting goes, the incident itself,

anything after the glass broke, I don't remember anything.

At the end, it was a relatively short

jury deliberation.

The verdict was broadcast on local media.

The jury took an hour and a half

to come back with a decision.

Pat Chisenhall, an Angier pastor,

was not justified when he shot and killed his son-in-law,

Christian Griggs.

[somber music]

♪ ♪

We've proven that it was not self-defense.

We've got a jury verdict.

They've got to arrest this guy now.

They've got to do the right thing.

But they didn't do anything.

The day after the verdict,

the sheriff issued a statement

saying there would be no further investigation

and there would be no criminal charges.

And they still have not done anything.

The new DA that we have has not shown any interest.

We've called her. She hasn't even returned

our phone calls.

Josh Stein, the attorney general,

needs to intervene.

The Department of Justice needs to come down

and investigate the Harnett County Sheriff's Department.

They need to do something.

♪ ♪

I'm supposed to remain impartial

as a storyteller, but it makes me mad

that there's no oversight.

A young man was shot in the back in broad daylight

and no one has ever been held accountable for it.

Thank you guys for bringing me here.

How often do you come out?

Um, I try to come out, um, once a week.

- Is this him? - Mm-hmm.

Mm-hmm.

I just...

You guys put her picture on here with--

both: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.

We also did this bench for him

that Jaden can always have it

to come out and just sit with him.

How important is it to have her know

how much her dad loved her?

To know that the reason that he's not here today

was because he was trying to have her a part of his life.

It's very important.

♪

Nothing's gonna bring Christian Griggs back.

His family has this space.

They've created a beautiful spot

for his daughter to visit one day.

And what they're asking for isn't big.

They're asking for the bare minimum.

They're asking for an investigation.

They're asking for some oversight.

These are people who have served their country.

They've served their community,

and I wanna know who's serving them.

♪ ♪

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.