All language subtitles for Call.Her.Ganda.2018.DVDRip.x264-RedBlade

af Afrikaans
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic Download
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani Download
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bn Bengali
bs Bosnian
bg Bulgarian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch Download
en English Download
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian Download
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
km Khmer
ko Korean
ku Kurdish (Kurmanji)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Lao
la Latin
lv Latvian
lt Lithuanian
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
ne Nepali
no Norwegian
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish Download
pt Portuguese Download
pa Punjabi
ro Romanian
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
st Sesotho
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhala
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish Download
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
te Telugu
th Thai
tr Turkish
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu Download
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
or Odia (Oriya)
rw Kinyarwanda
tk Turkmen
tt Tatar
ug Uyghur
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:00:37,524 --> 00:00:42,524 Subtitles by explosiveskull 2 00:04:10,565 --> 00:04:12,441 Witnesses said a white man 3 00:04:12,443 --> 00:04:15,402 with a Marine haircut met Jeffrey Laude, 4 00:04:15,404 --> 00:04:16,861 who was dressed as a woman 5 00:04:16,863 --> 00:04:20,702 at a nightclub in Olongapo City on Saturday night. 6 00:04:35,883 --> 00:04:37,924 The body of 26-year-old Laude 7 00:04:37,926 --> 00:04:40,970 was found in this hotel in Olongapo City. 8 00:04:40,972 --> 00:04:42,929 American troops there were on a break 9 00:04:42,931 --> 00:04:45,892 from military exercises for the Philippines. 10 00:04:48,563 --> 00:04:50,813 I first learned about Jennifer Laude 11 00:04:50,815 --> 00:04:53,857 through social media. 12 00:04:53,859 --> 00:04:58,278 I felt a connection to her immediately, 13 00:04:58,280 --> 00:05:03,118 just as a Filipino trans woman. 14 00:07:29,265 --> 00:07:30,890 Reports out of the Philippines 15 00:07:30,892 --> 00:07:33,893 say the Marine and the victim met in a nightclub. 16 00:07:33,895 --> 00:07:36,311 The two left the club with one of Jennifer's friends 17 00:07:36,313 --> 00:07:37,938 and went to a hotel where they were 18 00:07:37,940 --> 00:07:40,232 captured by security cameras. 19 00:07:40,234 --> 00:07:42,400 Three other Marines are being questioned 20 00:07:42,402 --> 00:07:44,404 as possible witnesses. 21 00:08:45,799 --> 00:08:49,009 She was just a very natural person. 22 00:08:49,011 --> 00:08:51,803 She was a very giving person. 23 00:08:51,805 --> 00:08:56,057 She was kind, friendly to everyone, open-minded. 24 00:08:56,059 --> 00:09:00,021 She was just trying to live a very normal life. 25 00:09:00,023 --> 00:09:02,483 This is not an isolated case. 26 00:09:44,317 --> 00:09:46,776 From day one that we handled this case, 27 00:09:46,778 --> 00:09:49,903 we already know the Laudes' situation. 28 00:09:49,905 --> 00:09:52,156 That's the very reason why Harry and I 29 00:09:52,158 --> 00:09:56,076 offered our services pro bono. 30 00:09:56,078 --> 00:10:00,330 If you don't have money, you don't have access to justice. 31 00:10:00,332 --> 00:10:04,210 What kind of a self-respecting country can we be 32 00:10:04,212 --> 00:10:06,921 if we cannot even implement our laws 33 00:10:06,923 --> 00:10:08,839 when they are breached in our territory 34 00:10:08,841 --> 00:10:12,053 and when a victim is a Filipino? 35 00:10:12,845 --> 00:10:14,552 You know, I ask you one thing. 36 00:10:14,554 --> 00:10:18,431 For who it is more fun in the Philippines 37 00:10:18,433 --> 00:10:21,476 for the Philippine people or for the U.S. soldiers, 38 00:10:21,478 --> 00:10:25,815 who having everything they want with no response taken, 39 00:10:25,817 --> 00:10:28,024 and for the cheapest money they can get? 40 00:10:28,026 --> 00:10:30,404 That's all I wanted to say about that. 41 00:10:36,410 --> 00:10:38,952 - Can you hear me? - Yes, I can hear you. 42 00:10:38,954 --> 00:10:40,454 I guess a good place to start 43 00:10:40,456 --> 00:10:44,332 would be to ask you how your relationship began. 44 00:10:44,334 --> 00:10:46,252 You know, love on the first sight 45 00:10:46,254 --> 00:10:49,754 is something which I have considered unrealistic. 46 00:10:49,756 --> 00:10:54,301 But she was even more adorable, natural person when we met 47 00:10:54,303 --> 00:10:56,595 and after three, four days, 48 00:10:56,597 --> 00:11:00,559 it was clear for me that this was the person of my life. 49 00:11:01,476 --> 00:11:04,436 What do you think happened that night? 50 00:11:04,438 --> 00:11:06,564 The only person who could tell us 51 00:11:06,566 --> 00:11:09,609 what was her intention to be there that evening 52 00:11:09,611 --> 00:11:11,527 is Jennifer herself. 53 00:11:11,529 --> 00:11:14,446 Unlike other ladyboys probably have to work 54 00:11:14,448 --> 00:11:19,784 that way every night, she had different chances than that. 55 00:11:19,786 --> 00:11:22,537 Whatever she did to end up there, 56 00:11:22,539 --> 00:11:24,956 it has nothing to do with what happened inside. 57 00:11:24,958 --> 00:11:27,252 Simply nothing. 58 00:11:27,629 --> 00:11:30,796 You know, she was killed on the 11th of October. 59 00:11:30,798 --> 00:11:32,797 October 1, we got the confirmation 60 00:11:32,799 --> 00:11:34,341 that her visa is granted. 61 00:11:34,343 --> 00:11:39,346 Here in Germany, the official wedding date was set. 62 00:11:39,348 --> 00:11:42,351 Her wedding dress was bought already. 63 00:11:43,226 --> 00:11:45,894 We are just inches away to make 64 00:11:45,896 --> 00:11:49,441 our both dream of life come true. 65 00:12:09,670 --> 00:12:11,836 How the killing of a trans Filipina woman 66 00:12:11,838 --> 00:12:14,923 ignited an international incident. 67 00:12:14,925 --> 00:12:16,676 On October 11 of last year, 68 00:12:16,678 --> 00:12:20,012 the U.S. Marines stationed aboard the USS Peleliu 69 00:12:20,014 --> 00:12:21,555 got their first night of liberty 70 00:12:21,557 --> 00:12:24,683 after their Tarawa-class amphibious assault ship 71 00:12:24,685 --> 00:12:26,687 docked in Subic Bay. 72 00:12:28,271 --> 00:12:30,690 Private First Class Joseph Scott Pemberton, 73 00:12:30,692 --> 00:12:33,692 a 19-year-old from New Bedford, Massachusetts, 74 00:12:33,694 --> 00:12:36,362 eagerly disembarked with his battle buddies 75 00:12:36,364 --> 00:12:40,034 Bennett Dahl, Daniel Pulido, and Jairn Rose. 76 00:12:44,329 --> 00:12:46,162 Jennifer first left her apartment 77 00:12:46,164 --> 00:12:48,206 with her friend, Jamille. 78 00:12:48,208 --> 00:12:51,543 They took a tricycle to Ambyanz Nightclub 79 00:12:51,545 --> 00:12:55,215 and arrived there at approximately 10:30. 80 00:12:57,342 --> 00:12:58,551 The club was a frequent hangout 81 00:12:58,553 --> 00:13:01,553 for sex workers known as Pocahontases, 82 00:13:01,555 --> 00:13:04,764 a riff on pok-pok, a Tagalog term for slut, 83 00:13:04,766 --> 00:13:07,726 which also alludes to the former colonizers 84 00:13:07,728 --> 00:13:10,147 who often patronize them. 85 00:13:11,899 --> 00:13:13,523 The most dogged of these women, 86 00:13:13,525 --> 00:13:15,359 those who quickly latch onto the arms 87 00:13:15,361 --> 00:13:17,737 of the men pouring off the ships, 88 00:13:17,739 --> 00:13:19,321 are usually transgender. 89 00:13:19,323 --> 00:13:22,242 But the foreign soldiers rarely learned that. 90 00:13:23,660 --> 00:13:27,204 Approximately at 10:45, 91 00:13:27,206 --> 00:13:29,623 Private First Class Joseph Scott Pemberton 92 00:13:29,625 --> 00:13:33,087 entered Ambyanz with three other Marines. 93 00:13:33,670 --> 00:13:35,128 The women had been working 94 00:13:35,130 --> 00:13:37,965 since the soldiers went on liberty that afternoon. 95 00:13:37,967 --> 00:13:41,093 And by 10:45, when Laude met Pemberton, 96 00:13:41,095 --> 00:13:43,638 she'd already been with three clients. 97 00:13:43,640 --> 00:13:46,931 "Jennifer was exhausted," said another friend Charis. 98 00:13:46,933 --> 00:13:50,438 "We work as hard as we can when the soldiers are here." 99 00:13:51,356 --> 00:13:53,272 Within a few minute of meeting, 100 00:13:53,274 --> 00:13:56,316 Pemberton and Laude left for the Celzone Lodge, 101 00:13:56,318 --> 00:13:58,277 a motel across the street, 102 00:13:58,279 --> 00:14:01,571 accompanied by Laude's friend, Barbie Gelviro. 103 00:14:01,573 --> 00:14:04,867 According to Elias, the cashier bellboy, 104 00:14:04,869 --> 00:14:07,494 Pemberton, Jennifer, and Barbie 105 00:14:07,496 --> 00:14:12,166 entered Celzone Lodge at approximately 11:05 p.m. 106 00:14:12,168 --> 00:14:14,712 Elias assigned them room number one. 107 00:14:16,923 --> 00:14:19,255 Gelviro stayed with the couple for a minute 108 00:14:19,257 --> 00:14:21,050 to help negotiate a rate. 109 00:14:21,052 --> 00:14:23,594 Laude suggested 5,000 pesos, 110 00:14:23,596 --> 00:14:28,224 but Pemberton only wanted to pay 1,000, about $25. 111 00:14:28,226 --> 00:14:30,558 Laude, nervous that Pemberton might discover 112 00:14:30,560 --> 00:14:33,646 the girls were trans, quickly agree to the lower rate 113 00:14:33,648 --> 00:14:36,401 and rushed her friend out of the room. 114 00:14:37,193 --> 00:14:38,817 About 30 minutes after the group 115 00:14:38,819 --> 00:14:40,360 had arrived at the motel, 116 00:14:40,362 --> 00:14:42,529 Pemberton casually walked out of his room alone, 117 00:14:42,531 --> 00:14:46,200 leaving the door slightly ajar behind him. 118 00:14:46,202 --> 00:14:49,244 He seemed unperturbed as he passed the front desk 119 00:14:49,246 --> 00:14:52,080 and walked down the steps into the night. 120 00:14:52,082 --> 00:14:53,916 His curfew was rapidly approaching 121 00:14:53,918 --> 00:14:57,628 and he and his shipmates needed to return together. 122 00:14:57,630 --> 00:15:01,423 Elias expected that Jennifer would shortly follow. 123 00:15:01,425 --> 00:15:06,179 But 15 minutes have passed, no one came out of the room. 124 00:15:08,057 --> 00:15:09,724 As they were about to go to sleep, 125 00:15:09,726 --> 00:15:11,142 Pemberton approached Rose 126 00:15:11,144 --> 00:15:13,436 and asked to talk to him in private. 127 00:15:13,438 --> 00:15:15,729 They walked over to the front of the ship 128 00:15:15,731 --> 00:15:17,440 far from human ears, 129 00:15:17,442 --> 00:15:20,526 with only the ocean and the sky to listen. 130 00:15:20,528 --> 00:15:24,071 Pemberton said that he saw it had a dick. 131 00:15:24,073 --> 00:15:26,282 He told Rose he got so angry, 132 00:15:26,284 --> 00:15:28,952 that he choked it from behind. 133 00:15:29,911 --> 00:15:33,874 "I think I killed a he-she," Pemberton said. 134 00:15:38,462 --> 00:15:42,840 The medical report would show that Jennifer 135 00:15:42,842 --> 00:15:48,512 died of asphyxia due to strangulation and drowning 136 00:15:48,514 --> 00:15:52,599 and the same is reflected in her death certificate. 137 00:15:52,601 --> 00:15:56,438 Her entire back was black and blue. 138 00:17:54,640 --> 00:17:56,349 In so far as the citizenry, 139 00:17:56,351 --> 00:17:59,060 the Filipino citizenry is concerned, 140 00:17:59,062 --> 00:18:00,477 this is duly served. 141 00:18:00,479 --> 00:18:03,857 The notice is duly served to the person of Pemberton. 142 00:18:30,968 --> 00:18:32,385 You cannot help this case. 143 00:18:32,387 --> 00:18:34,344 You cannot help the Laudes. 144 00:18:34,346 --> 00:18:37,723 If you just know things about the killing, 145 00:18:37,725 --> 00:18:39,975 if you just know things about the murder 146 00:18:39,977 --> 00:18:42,686 because it's not a simple case of murder. 147 00:18:42,688 --> 00:18:45,063 At the police station, then I will have to 148 00:18:45,065 --> 00:18:47,692 check it one-by-one against... 149 00:18:47,694 --> 00:18:50,485 The relationship between the U.S. and the Philippines 150 00:18:50,487 --> 00:18:55,532 is really a relationship between 151 00:18:55,534 --> 00:19:00,081 a colonizer and a colony or a neo-colony. 152 00:19:08,922 --> 00:19:11,006 This is the story of the Philippines, 153 00:19:11,008 --> 00:19:13,091 a nation of islands on the eastern rim 154 00:19:13,093 --> 00:19:15,721 of the vast Pacific Ocean. 155 00:19:21,811 --> 00:19:25,603 Discovered over 400 years ago by the explorer Magellan, 156 00:19:25,605 --> 00:19:27,439 the Philippines were ruled by the Spaniards 157 00:19:27,441 --> 00:19:30,111 for more than 200 years. 158 00:19:39,579 --> 00:19:42,621 We are a colony of the United States. 159 00:19:42,623 --> 00:19:45,625 We were purchased allegedly, from Spain. 160 00:19:45,627 --> 00:19:49,462 We were said to have been granted independence. 161 00:19:49,464 --> 00:19:51,630 But in exchange, we've had to agree 162 00:19:51,632 --> 00:19:54,591 that U.S. bases will remain in the Philippines. 163 00:21:04,956 --> 00:21:09,582 The VFA stands for Visiting Forces Agreement. 164 00:21:09,584 --> 00:21:12,878 This VFA really comes into play in this case 165 00:21:12,880 --> 00:21:16,299 because it reads about how the Philippines 166 00:21:16,301 --> 00:21:18,553 should treat the U.S. soldiers. 167 00:21:28,771 --> 00:21:30,312 What exactly is legal hold? 168 00:21:30,314 --> 00:21:32,898 It may be one of the best things we have in the Philippines. 169 00:21:32,900 --> 00:21:35,400 Legal hold means that if you're charged with a crime 170 00:21:35,402 --> 00:21:38,821 under local laws, you'll be turned over to U.S. authorities 171 00:21:38,823 --> 00:21:41,074 rather than left in a local lock-up. 172 00:21:42,159 --> 00:21:43,242 Put it this way, 173 00:21:43,244 --> 00:21:45,202 it would be unthinkable for a foreign soldier 174 00:21:45,204 --> 00:21:47,746 to commit murder in America 175 00:21:47,748 --> 00:21:49,956 and not be apprehended by U.S. police 176 00:21:49,958 --> 00:21:52,752 and not be tried by U.S. courts. 177 00:21:52,754 --> 00:21:54,253 But what's happened in this case 178 00:21:54,255 --> 00:21:56,964 is we have an instance where an American Marine 179 00:21:56,966 --> 00:21:59,634 committed a non-service related offense. 180 00:21:59,636 --> 00:22:01,676 Number one, he remains in the custody 181 00:22:01,678 --> 00:22:03,012 of American soldiers. 182 00:22:03,014 --> 00:22:05,723 Number two, he was never physically investigated 183 00:22:05,725 --> 00:22:07,183 by Philippine authorities. 184 00:22:07,185 --> 00:22:09,769 Number three, his attendance in court proceedings 185 00:22:09,771 --> 00:22:13,397 is a matter of cooperation with American authorities 186 00:22:13,399 --> 00:22:17,443 rather than as part of mandatory judicial proceedings. 187 00:22:17,445 --> 00:22:20,029 With the VFA, it's like 188 00:22:20,031 --> 00:22:22,990 the Filipinos are being served on a silver platter. 189 00:22:22,992 --> 00:22:24,617 Here are the Philippines, kill them. 190 00:22:24,619 --> 00:22:26,910 Here are the Filipinas, rape them. 191 00:22:26,912 --> 00:22:28,663 Because even if you are convicted, 192 00:22:28,665 --> 00:22:31,456 your custody will be transferred to the U.S. Embassy; 193 00:22:31,458 --> 00:22:33,044 it's like you're free. 194 00:22:34,419 --> 00:22:37,545 It's a wrap for U.S. President Barack Obama. 195 00:22:37,547 --> 00:22:40,006 The U.S. reached a 10-year defense deal 196 00:22:40,008 --> 00:22:42,801 to allow more U.S. troops in the Philippines. 197 00:22:42,803 --> 00:22:44,887 As the U.S. is now trying even to expand 198 00:22:44,889 --> 00:22:46,388 its presence in the Philippines 199 00:22:46,390 --> 00:22:49,433 through the Enhanced Defense Cooperation Agreement, 200 00:22:49,435 --> 00:22:52,811 the bigger question is, "What's in it for the Filipinos?" 201 00:22:52,813 --> 00:22:54,230 To our Filipino Armed Forces, 202 00:22:54,232 --> 00:22:56,314 thank you for being such an outstanding ally. 203 00:22:56,316 --> 00:22:58,192 God bless the Republic of the Philippines. 204 00:22:58,194 --> 00:23:00,360 God bless the United States of America. 205 00:23:00,362 --> 00:23:03,656 God bless the alliance between our great nations. 206 00:23:03,658 --> 00:23:04,823 Thank you. 207 00:26:30,406 --> 00:26:35,283 ♪ If you think that I'm still holdin' on ♪ 208 00:26:35,285 --> 00:26:39,082 ♪ Maybe you should go and love yourself ♪ 209 00:26:52,428 --> 00:26:53,595 Bye! 210 00:28:42,871 --> 00:28:45,705 I mean, that is really not only unjust 211 00:28:45,707 --> 00:28:47,416 to the family of Laude, 212 00:28:47,418 --> 00:28:50,254 but also unjust to the Filipino people. 213 00:29:05,268 --> 00:29:07,188 Let me see the documents. 214 00:29:11,942 --> 00:29:15,445 The entire documents are in there. 215 00:29:20,368 --> 00:29:23,037 The report is very frustrating. 216 00:29:41,555 --> 00:29:44,891 Yeah, was taken by the Americans. 217 00:29:45,184 --> 00:29:47,642 Remember our Filipino police authorities 218 00:29:47,644 --> 00:29:52,566 was unable to get the KamaSutra condom wrapper. 219 00:29:54,026 --> 00:29:56,651 Yeah, it was only the American authorities, 220 00:29:56,653 --> 00:30:00,281 the NCIS agent who got hold the condom, 221 00:30:00,283 --> 00:30:02,073 the KamaSutra condom wrapper, 222 00:30:02,075 --> 00:30:04,703 not our authorities. 223 00:30:05,455 --> 00:30:07,540 That is very interesting to me. 224 00:30:21,888 --> 00:30:26,643 In my family, I'm the only one who's able to finish college. 225 00:30:27,101 --> 00:30:29,601 My father is a tricycle driver 226 00:30:29,603 --> 00:30:32,481 and my mother does not have regular work. 227 00:30:33,107 --> 00:30:35,148 He's a typical father 228 00:30:35,150 --> 00:30:40,321 who thinks that daughters need not go to college. 229 00:30:40,323 --> 00:30:43,450 After all, they'll just get married. 230 00:30:44,284 --> 00:30:47,160 I was telling myself, "No, I have to finish. 231 00:30:47,162 --> 00:30:48,620 "I have to reach college. 232 00:30:48,622 --> 00:30:51,793 I have to be able to do something to help the family." 233 00:30:59,883 --> 00:31:03,010 A lot of people would think that murder is always premeditated. 234 00:31:03,012 --> 00:31:04,844 There are other two elements: 235 00:31:04,846 --> 00:31:07,764 the abuse of superior strength and the cruelty. 236 00:31:07,766 --> 00:31:12,436 That's the reason why they had been saying that 237 00:31:12,438 --> 00:31:16,314 after all Jennifer is a trans, but he is still a man. 238 00:31:16,316 --> 00:31:19,150 The Marines, you know, yes they have training. 239 00:31:19,152 --> 00:31:22,530 But they only spend a few hours 240 00:31:22,532 --> 00:31:25,824 in actual military training. 241 00:31:25,826 --> 00:31:29,160 That is to weaken 242 00:31:29,162 --> 00:31:32,247 our allegation that there is some kind of abuse 243 00:31:32,249 --> 00:31:33,832 of superior strength. 244 00:31:33,834 --> 00:31:38,670 Definitely there is no doubt that a Marine, an elite force, 245 00:31:38,672 --> 00:31:42,300 certainly has the superior strength 246 00:31:42,302 --> 00:31:44,968 over every other individual. 247 00:31:44,970 --> 00:31:49,639 Because if not, what difference does a U.S. Marine soldier make? 248 00:31:49,641 --> 00:31:52,517 If, in this case, 249 00:31:52,519 --> 00:31:56,187 Pemberton gets convicted and then after that, 250 00:31:56,189 --> 00:32:00,443 he will be incarcerated not in the Philippines. 251 00:32:00,445 --> 00:32:03,446 My goodness, that will all the more show 252 00:32:03,448 --> 00:32:06,743 how lopsided this VFA agreement is. 253 00:32:07,869 --> 00:32:09,203 Jennifer is dead. 254 00:32:09,704 --> 00:32:12,204 Nothing can beat that, nothing can change that. 255 00:32:12,206 --> 00:32:13,747 Jennifer is dead. 256 00:32:13,749 --> 00:32:15,457 Who killed Jennifer? 257 00:32:15,459 --> 00:32:18,795 A lot of evidence points to Pemberton. 258 00:32:30,099 --> 00:32:36,438 ♪ Skyfall ♪ 259 00:32:40,776 --> 00:32:44,237 Woo, good job! 260 00:32:45,238 --> 00:32:46,321 What else do you wanna sing? 261 00:32:46,323 --> 00:32:47,865 You wanna do Lady Gaga? 262 00:32:47,867 --> 00:32:48,868 Sure. 263 00:32:49,576 --> 00:32:51,077 "Poker Face", "Born This Way". 264 00:32:51,079 --> 00:32:52,911 Yeah, I like "Poker Face". 265 00:32:52,913 --> 00:32:55,248 When did you arrive? 266 00:32:55,958 --> 00:32:57,457 I can't even remember anymore. 267 00:32:57,459 --> 00:33:00,794 Oh, I didn't tell the Laudes that you interview... 268 00:33:00,796 --> 00:33:03,004 Just actually not thinking not in terms. 269 00:33:03,006 --> 00:33:07,426 You were just like catch up with Jamille, Charis and Barbie. 270 00:33:07,428 --> 00:33:09,261 What's she doing now? 271 00:33:09,263 --> 00:33:11,805 - What is she doing? - She's still in Olongapo. 272 00:33:11,807 --> 00:33:13,933 She doing the same thing. 273 00:33:13,935 --> 00:33:15,850 They call it freelancing. 274 00:33:15,852 --> 00:33:17,811 I think they're still in a lot of ways 275 00:33:17,813 --> 00:33:19,522 processing what happened. 276 00:33:19,524 --> 00:33:22,440 It's the same thing where they have to deal 277 00:33:22,442 --> 00:33:25,403 with their feelings and their fears. 278 00:33:25,405 --> 00:33:28,283 I know that you did attend one of the... 279 00:33:29,199 --> 00:33:32,451 The hearings in Congress or in the Senate. 280 00:33:32,453 --> 00:33:35,079 There's been a lot of movement towards 281 00:33:35,081 --> 00:33:37,415 getting an exhumation order. 282 00:33:37,417 --> 00:33:40,501 They both have this. 283 00:33:40,503 --> 00:33:46,465 Every time the lawyers who's cosponsoring their bills now, 284 00:33:46,467 --> 00:33:49,303 would mention they're doing that for Jennifer Laude. 285 00:33:50,971 --> 00:33:52,681 It's really nice. 286 00:33:53,599 --> 00:33:55,974 This issue put the spotlight on our community. 287 00:33:55,976 --> 00:34:00,146 We actually consider this a watershed moment 288 00:34:00,148 --> 00:34:03,357 in the history of the Philippine transgender movement 289 00:34:03,359 --> 00:34:07,903 because for the first time, people are seeing us. 290 00:34:12,660 --> 00:34:14,285 Transgender people have always been part 291 00:34:14,287 --> 00:34:16,495 of the history of this country 292 00:34:16,497 --> 00:34:19,914 and that goes back through Pre-Colonial times. 293 00:34:19,916 --> 00:34:21,916 We saw that in the Babaylan Chronicles, 294 00:34:21,918 --> 00:34:25,838 which are documents written by Spanish priests. 295 00:34:25,840 --> 00:34:28,841 They took note of male-bodied people 296 00:34:28,843 --> 00:34:31,928 who carried themselves as women. 297 00:34:33,055 --> 00:34:36,349 The work as spiritual leaders of their communities 298 00:34:36,351 --> 00:34:39,019 were known as the Babaylan. 299 00:34:40,146 --> 00:34:41,646 There's always a sermon. 300 00:34:41,648 --> 00:34:44,439 The establishment of religion 301 00:34:44,441 --> 00:34:48,903 were so that my kind of people 302 00:34:48,905 --> 00:34:53,075 were slowly pushed into the margins of society. 303 00:34:54,077 --> 00:34:58,370 How the church vanquished the Babaylan or the Shaman, 304 00:34:58,372 --> 00:35:01,247 it had to make the Babaylan somewhat scary 305 00:35:01,249 --> 00:35:04,419 so called her a witch and a swine. 306 00:35:07,673 --> 00:35:09,631 We were othered by the church. 307 00:35:09,633 --> 00:35:11,425 Our bodies are not acceptable. 308 00:35:11,427 --> 00:35:14,555 Our identities are not acceptable. 309 00:35:15,555 --> 00:35:19,934 We've been forced to be part of niche industries 310 00:35:19,936 --> 00:35:22,979 like the beauty industry or the sex industry. 311 00:35:22,981 --> 00:35:26,691 The transgender movement itself has to work. 312 00:35:26,693 --> 00:35:28,943 They eradicate the notion that you need 313 00:35:28,945 --> 00:35:31,738 to sell your body in order to survive. 314 00:35:33,407 --> 00:35:35,283 In the meantime, a lot of my trans friends 315 00:35:35,285 --> 00:35:36,908 are actually doing sex work. 316 00:35:36,910 --> 00:35:39,370 They're saying that it's survival sex work 317 00:35:39,372 --> 00:35:41,457 and I completely understand that. 318 00:35:54,887 --> 00:35:56,428 Your first time in a foreign country 319 00:35:56,430 --> 00:35:58,763 can be quite an ordeal if you let it. 320 00:35:58,765 --> 00:36:01,350 Here in the Philippines, you'll find a lifestyle 321 00:36:01,352 --> 00:36:03,852 that's different from life in America. 322 00:36:03,854 --> 00:36:06,146 With a little knowledge of what this assignment is like 323 00:36:06,148 --> 00:36:07,439 before you get there though, 324 00:36:07,441 --> 00:36:10,358 it can be a richly-rewarding experience. 325 00:36:18,952 --> 00:36:20,620 We know for a fact that whenever 326 00:36:20,622 --> 00:36:23,247 there's increased military presence in a certain country, 327 00:36:23,249 --> 00:36:28,461 it always encourages the selling of bodies for sexual services. 328 00:36:28,463 --> 00:36:30,629 It encourages the exploitation of women, 329 00:36:30,631 --> 00:36:33,256 girls, female identified. 330 00:36:33,258 --> 00:36:35,469 So that includes transgender women. 331 00:36:38,639 --> 00:36:42,932 If you're a trans woman, all the doors close to you. 332 00:36:42,934 --> 00:36:44,059 I mean... 333 00:36:44,061 --> 00:36:46,437 You're not welcome to certain establishments. 334 00:36:46,439 --> 00:36:48,689 You're discriminated in school. 335 00:36:48,691 --> 00:36:50,816 You're discriminated at work. 336 00:36:50,818 --> 00:36:53,151 You're discriminated in public 337 00:36:53,153 --> 00:36:54,988 and even in your private life. 338 00:36:57,115 --> 00:36:59,658 Whether or not Jennifer Laude was a sex worker 339 00:36:59,660 --> 00:37:03,037 is something that only Jennifer Laude can answer. 340 00:37:12,131 --> 00:37:13,713 The U.S. serviceman accused 341 00:37:13,715 --> 00:37:16,175 of killing transgender woman, Jennifer Laude, 342 00:37:16,177 --> 00:37:19,387 faces prosecutors as his trial begins today. 343 00:37:19,389 --> 00:37:21,555 Pemberton's lawyers didn't confirm 344 00:37:21,557 --> 00:37:24,015 whether their client will take the witness stand 345 00:37:24,017 --> 00:37:27,938 or if a plea bargain agreement is being considered. 346 00:43:20,457 --> 00:43:23,124 There are many differences in our lives, 347 00:43:23,126 --> 00:43:25,461 but the one thing we do have in common 348 00:43:25,463 --> 00:43:27,881 is that trans experience. 349 00:43:28,800 --> 00:43:30,466 If the circumstances were different, 350 00:43:30,468 --> 00:43:33,010 our lives could've totally been reversed 351 00:43:33,012 --> 00:43:35,472 and I could be in her situation. 352 00:43:43,398 --> 00:43:46,106 She had this sort of like habit of putting her arm around me 353 00:43:46,108 --> 00:43:48,360 and we were to talk confidentially together. 354 00:43:53,365 --> 00:43:57,075 In a way, I am kind of a manifestation of 355 00:43:57,077 --> 00:43:59,370 what she hoped for Jennifer. 356 00:43:59,372 --> 00:44:01,914 That I'm the person who is trans, 357 00:44:01,916 --> 00:44:05,084 who has moved to a foreign country 358 00:44:05,086 --> 00:44:09,173 and has made a good life for myself. 359 00:44:15,430 --> 00:44:18,097 She would say something like, "You'd be even more beautiful 360 00:44:18,099 --> 00:44:21,477 if you put on more makeup like Jennifer." 361 00:44:21,769 --> 00:44:23,896 She also called me Ganda. 362 00:48:32,186 --> 00:48:33,644 A day before testifying 363 00:48:33,646 --> 00:48:35,729 in the Olongapo Regional Trial Court, 364 00:48:35,731 --> 00:48:38,024 Lisa Pemberton visited her youngest son, 365 00:48:38,026 --> 00:48:40,151 Lance Corporal Joseph Pemberton. 366 00:48:40,153 --> 00:48:42,613 Very difficult. 367 00:48:42,863 --> 00:48:46,034 He's always been our angel. 368 00:48:46,450 --> 00:48:50,202 I know Joseph would rather die for his country 369 00:48:50,204 --> 00:48:52,204 than be in this situation. 370 00:48:52,206 --> 00:48:53,539 Mrs. Pemberton denies her son 371 00:48:53,541 --> 00:48:55,916 is angry with members of the gay community. 372 00:48:55,918 --> 00:48:58,628 She explains Joseph has been exposed to the issue 373 00:48:58,630 --> 00:49:00,254 since he grew up with a sister 374 00:49:00,256 --> 00:49:02,715 who was a member of the LGBT community. 375 00:49:02,717 --> 00:49:05,925 His own sister is lesbian, getting married next month. 376 00:49:05,927 --> 00:49:08,262 He was supposed to be the best man in the wedding. 377 00:49:08,264 --> 00:49:09,638 She says she can empathize 378 00:49:09,640 --> 00:49:13,017 with the Laude family for the loss of their loved one. 379 00:49:13,019 --> 00:49:15,852 I feel very sorry for their loss 380 00:49:15,854 --> 00:49:19,900 and what they've had to go through. 381 00:50:49,197 --> 00:50:52,115 In this case, there's a 30-minute gap 382 00:50:52,117 --> 00:50:58,079 wherein the room where Laude was, was totally unsecured. 383 00:50:58,081 --> 00:51:01,751 We cannot say that 384 00:51:01,753 --> 00:51:05,588 it was Pemberton who killed Laude. 385 00:51:05,590 --> 00:51:09,758 When he left Laude in the bathroom, Laude was still alive. 386 00:51:09,760 --> 00:51:13,845 So, now, since Laude's dead, probably the question is, 387 00:51:13,847 --> 00:51:15,015 "Who killed Laude?" 388 00:51:58,726 --> 00:52:01,059 Obviously there's somebody on the internet 389 00:52:01,061 --> 00:52:05,398 who's invested in humanizing him in that specific way 390 00:52:05,400 --> 00:52:08,108 and he's presenting him as this all-American guy, 391 00:52:08,110 --> 00:52:10,070 which he is, he has that image. 392 00:52:15,242 --> 00:52:17,158 They know he's from New Bedford. 393 00:52:17,160 --> 00:52:19,452 Pemberton's sister is a lesbian, 394 00:52:19,454 --> 00:52:24,126 so he's not antipathetic towards LGBT people. 395 00:52:28,006 --> 00:52:31,090 Rather than this Marine 396 00:52:31,092 --> 00:52:36,720 who is raised in a culture of LGBT phobia, 397 00:52:36,722 --> 00:52:41,768 it makes him more complex than that. 398 00:52:42,894 --> 00:52:46,731 There's also a lot invested in making 399 00:52:46,733 --> 00:52:49,943 Joseph Scott Pemberton into this monster. 400 00:52:50,778 --> 00:52:54,280 Even if somebody is out really thinking 401 00:52:54,282 --> 00:52:57,283 that they don't have these views against trans people, 402 00:52:57,285 --> 00:52:58,950 especially trans women. 403 00:52:58,952 --> 00:53:00,995 There's all of this sort of like surrounding 404 00:53:00,997 --> 00:53:05,041 environmental and societal messages they're receiving 405 00:53:05,043 --> 00:53:08,963 that would lead them to these types of actions. 406 00:53:16,970 --> 00:53:18,803 Still in the Philippines, the camp of the slain 407 00:53:18,805 --> 00:53:20,805 transgender Filipina, Jennifer Laude, 408 00:53:20,807 --> 00:53:23,892 denied reports that they are pushing for a deal 409 00:53:23,894 --> 00:53:28,356 for 38 million pesos and six U.S. Visas 410 00:53:28,358 --> 00:53:30,106 in exchange for dropping the murder case 411 00:53:30,108 --> 00:53:33,234 against U.S. Marine, Joseph Scott Pemberton. 412 00:53:33,236 --> 00:53:35,988 The denial followed reports that Pemberton's lawyer, 413 00:53:35,990 --> 00:53:39,367 Rowena Flores, received new demands from the Laudes family 414 00:53:39,369 --> 00:53:41,079 in exchange for dropping the case. 415 00:54:45,684 --> 00:54:48,227 - Hey. - I don't really care 416 00:54:48,229 --> 00:54:52,731 that much what happens to Pemberton because, you know, 417 00:54:52,733 --> 00:54:55,151 I accept that what will happen to Pemberton is a 418 00:54:55,153 --> 00:54:56,401 political decision. 419 00:54:56,403 --> 00:54:58,613 But what I can't accept is 420 00:54:58,615 --> 00:55:01,823 that the further humiliation of the family, 421 00:55:01,825 --> 00:55:05,785 the further disrespect, the further dishonoring on Jennifer 422 00:55:05,787 --> 00:55:08,289 because she was not political. 423 00:55:08,291 --> 00:55:11,709 Pemberton probably is political, but Jennifer never was. 424 00:55:11,711 --> 00:55:13,126 It was never her intention 425 00:55:13,128 --> 00:55:18,592 to be part of any political crap like this. 426 00:55:20,177 --> 00:55:21,843 For the first time since being accused 427 00:55:21,845 --> 00:55:23,720 in the killing of Filipino transgender 428 00:55:23,722 --> 00:55:26,765 Jennifer Laude, October 11, 2014, 429 00:55:26,767 --> 00:55:29,100 U.S. Marine Lance Corporal Joseph Pemberton 430 00:55:29,102 --> 00:55:31,437 testified in court as a defense witness 431 00:55:31,439 --> 00:55:33,606 in his own murder trial. 432 00:55:33,608 --> 00:55:35,274 Thinking they were real women, 433 00:55:35,276 --> 00:55:37,651 he said he accepted their offer of checking in 434 00:55:37,653 --> 00:55:40,946 at the Celzone Lodge Motel to have paid sex. 435 00:55:40,948 --> 00:55:43,448 Barbie performed oral sex on Pemberton 436 00:55:43,450 --> 00:55:45,242 then immediately left the room. 437 00:55:45,244 --> 00:55:48,454 After a few minutes, Jennifer did the same to Pemberton. 438 00:55:48,456 --> 00:55:51,624 But when he wanted more, he was surprised to find out 439 00:55:51,626 --> 00:55:54,167 Jennifer was also a man like himself. 440 00:55:54,169 --> 00:55:57,379 He said he felt that he was being raped. 441 00:55:57,381 --> 00:56:00,383 He was so repulsed and so disgusted 442 00:56:00,385 --> 00:56:02,635 because he did not give his consent 443 00:56:02,637 --> 00:56:04,887 to allow a man to do that to him. 444 00:56:04,889 --> 00:56:07,472 Pemberton acted only in defense 445 00:56:07,474 --> 00:56:09,851 of his life and honor. 446 00:57:11,247 --> 00:57:13,830 The verdict is expected tomorrow, the Laude murder case. 447 00:57:13,832 --> 00:57:16,041 If it is a conviction, the Olongapo Court 448 00:57:16,043 --> 00:57:18,711 will have to determine where U.S. Marine serviceman 449 00:57:18,713 --> 00:57:21,046 Joseph Scott Pemberton will be detained. 450 00:57:21,048 --> 00:57:26,301 We are confident that the court will acquit our client. 451 00:57:26,303 --> 00:57:29,972 We believe there is reasonable doubt. 452 00:57:29,974 --> 00:57:32,475 Barbie was not an eyewitness. 453 00:57:32,477 --> 00:57:34,854 She didn't see anybody killed. 454 00:58:31,202 --> 00:58:32,994 Harry will no longer come here. 455 00:58:32,996 --> 00:58:34,912 He'll go stay with the church. 456 00:59:51,157 --> 00:59:55,325 - Justice for Laude! - Justice for Laude! 457 00:59:55,327 --> 01:00:00,372 - Justice for Laude! - Justice for Laude! 458 01:00:00,374 --> 01:00:04,878 - Justice for Laude! - Justice for Laude! 459 01:00:16,974 --> 01:00:18,307 We are an independent country. 460 01:00:18,309 --> 01:00:21,312 Therefore, he should be detained in a Philippine jail. 461 01:03:11,189 --> 01:03:12,981 Oh my goodness. 462 01:03:12,983 --> 01:03:15,401 This is not the voice of complete justice, 463 01:03:15,403 --> 01:03:19,323 but we had to recognize that there is victory here. 464 01:03:25,454 --> 01:03:27,581 He's considered a national prisoner. 465 01:04:26,014 --> 01:04:27,974 Pemberton was surrounded 466 01:04:27,976 --> 01:04:30,309 by two layers of security. 467 01:04:30,311 --> 01:04:33,979 In the inner circle are US servicemen, 468 01:04:33,981 --> 01:04:37,651 while in the outer circle are Philippine authorities. 469 01:04:53,751 --> 01:04:55,334 Just want to get permission from a source 470 01:04:55,336 --> 01:04:58,504 present in the courtroom that the court has called 471 01:04:58,506 --> 01:05:01,423 for a session to hear the motion of the defense 472 01:05:01,425 --> 01:05:05,512 to satisfy the order of the court. 473 01:07:07,635 --> 01:07:11,387 Did the verdict surprise you at all in any way? 474 01:07:11,389 --> 01:07:13,597 You know, it not surprises me. 475 01:07:13,599 --> 01:07:15,557 For me, it was very clear form the beginning that 476 01:07:15,559 --> 01:07:21,229 Pemberton would not serve any day in Philippine trial 477 01:07:21,231 --> 01:07:22,898 whatever counts. 478 01:07:22,900 --> 01:07:28,361 What is the reason to give him a special treatment? 479 01:07:28,363 --> 01:07:31,073 No one else in the world would get... 480 01:07:31,075 --> 01:07:35,410 Obviously the reason is that they know whatever they do 481 01:07:35,412 --> 01:07:38,664 is setting a precedent and they don't want to be put 482 01:07:38,666 --> 01:07:41,834 in a position where American military service members 483 01:07:41,836 --> 01:07:44,378 are in danger when they're overseas. 484 01:07:44,380 --> 01:07:48,173 And so, they're not going to be able to guarantee 485 01:07:48,175 --> 01:07:50,508 his safety in Philippine prison. 486 01:07:50,510 --> 01:07:53,845 If you go to jail in America 487 01:07:53,847 --> 01:07:56,807 regardless of your nationality or whatever, 488 01:07:56,809 --> 01:07:59,894 you go to a regular jail, you don't get a special treatment. 489 01:07:59,896 --> 01:08:02,812 You have to pay the consequence on what you did. 490 01:08:02,814 --> 01:08:08,028 Referring to the location and the law you are under. 491 01:08:24,879 --> 01:08:26,673 Hello! 492 01:08:47,485 --> 01:08:50,735 Then tomorrow, we'll be filing a criminal case 493 01:08:50,737 --> 01:08:55,242 in disobedience through unlawful order of the court. 494 01:08:55,660 --> 01:08:58,454 Then we're planning to file a petition. 495 01:09:31,528 --> 01:09:37,158 Even assuming there is superior strength, 496 01:09:37,160 --> 01:09:38,827 abuse should be proved. 497 01:09:55,637 --> 01:09:57,552 'Cause there's no second degree murder. 498 01:09:57,554 --> 01:09:59,137 - In the Philippines, yeah. - In the Philippines, 499 01:09:59,139 --> 01:10:00,306 which is really weird to me. 500 01:10:00,308 --> 01:10:01,766 Because I think usually in the states 501 01:10:01,768 --> 01:10:03,351 for it to be first degree murder, 502 01:10:03,353 --> 01:10:05,352 it has to be premeditated. 503 01:10:05,354 --> 01:10:06,604 That's true. 504 01:10:06,606 --> 01:10:10,735 So, that's sort of a... Yeah, and it's weird. 505 01:10:12,862 --> 01:10:15,613 Does manslaughter exist in the Philippine? 506 01:10:15,615 --> 01:10:17,489 - No, it's doesn't. - No? 507 01:10:17,491 --> 01:10:20,493 But again, the way the judge wrote the verdict 508 01:10:20,495 --> 01:10:23,703 was such that she was giving all these excuses 509 01:10:23,705 --> 01:10:25,748 in the guise of mitigating circumstances saying, 510 01:10:25,750 --> 01:10:26,873 "Well, he was drunk. 511 01:10:26,875 --> 01:10:28,918 "It was like a crime of passion, 512 01:10:28,920 --> 01:10:32,171 so we can forgive him for that." 513 01:10:32,173 --> 01:10:33,254 It was crazy. 514 01:10:33,256 --> 01:10:35,091 After the verdict was read, 515 01:10:35,093 --> 01:10:38,552 then the Americans refused to give him up to the local police. 516 01:10:38,554 --> 01:10:41,012 It kinda shows that the Americans aren't 517 01:10:41,014 --> 01:10:42,431 running everything. 518 01:10:42,433 --> 01:10:44,182 It's not completely orchestrated then. 519 01:10:44,184 --> 01:10:45,519 Oh please Meredith, come on. 520 01:10:46,896 --> 01:10:48,436 Of course they were running the show. 521 01:10:48,438 --> 01:10:50,898 - I just mean... - That was how I felt. 522 01:10:50,900 --> 01:10:54,694 I mean, the DOJ's, I'm sure it. 523 01:10:54,696 --> 01:10:58,029 All I mean is that it was a surprise 524 01:10:58,031 --> 01:11:01,492 to the Americans that the order was for 525 01:11:01,494 --> 01:11:03,202 him to go to Bilibid. 526 01:11:03,204 --> 01:11:06,038 That's like a capitulation on the part of the judge 527 01:11:06,040 --> 01:11:08,708 because when it was read and the verdict was read, 528 01:11:08,710 --> 01:11:11,836 we felt like the judge was keeping both parties happy. 529 01:11:11,838 --> 01:11:13,421 She convicted him of a crime that was 530 01:11:13,423 --> 01:11:15,463 of a lower degree than murder 531 01:11:15,465 --> 01:11:18,967 when it was so clear as daylight that it was freakin' murder. 532 01:11:18,969 --> 01:11:21,386 The fact that they weren't prepared 533 01:11:21,388 --> 01:11:25,266 for the custody thing to happen 534 01:11:25,268 --> 01:11:29,270 was really fascinating to me from a journalistic perspective. 535 01:11:29,272 --> 01:11:31,939 I would ask you to do some research of that notion 536 01:11:31,941 --> 01:11:36,276 because America as a superpower is in control of this. 537 01:11:36,278 --> 01:11:38,361 I'm so happy that I'm having this conversation with you 538 01:11:38,363 --> 01:11:40,405 because now as an American person 539 01:11:40,407 --> 01:11:43,074 who has Filipino lineage, 540 01:11:43,076 --> 01:11:44,577 you have your foot on the Philippines 541 01:11:44,579 --> 01:11:46,537 and your foot in America. 542 01:11:46,539 --> 01:11:48,748 You are now in a position to tell this story 543 01:11:48,750 --> 01:11:52,376 and to be honest about any court power relations 544 01:11:52,378 --> 01:11:54,169 between our countries. 545 01:11:54,171 --> 01:11:57,465 That's really the culprit, it all goes back to that. 546 01:11:57,467 --> 01:12:00,342 Jennifer's death is a result 547 01:12:00,344 --> 01:12:03,303 of continued American imperialism in the Philippines. 548 01:12:03,305 --> 01:12:05,933 There is no denying that. 549 01:12:06,267 --> 01:12:07,557 Yeah. 550 01:12:07,559 --> 01:12:09,017 At 5:30 tonight, a New Bedford Marine in jail 551 01:12:09,019 --> 01:12:11,102 for killing a transgender Filipino 552 01:12:11,104 --> 01:12:13,814 is asking a judge to overturn his conviction. 553 01:12:13,816 --> 01:12:15,941 The court will start to hear of Pemberton's appeal 554 01:12:15,943 --> 01:12:17,320 on Thursday. 555 01:12:21,741 --> 01:12:23,740 The aftermath of a U.S. Marine's conviction 556 01:12:23,742 --> 01:12:26,662 in the death of a Philippine trans woman. 557 01:12:29,040 --> 01:12:30,789 It's close to midnight in early December 558 01:12:30,791 --> 01:12:33,919 on Waterfront Road in Olongapo, Philippines. 559 01:12:34,795 --> 01:12:37,171 Dimly lit by yellow tungsten lamps, 560 01:12:37,173 --> 01:12:40,298 women's figures in tight clothing walk down the street, 561 01:12:40,300 --> 01:12:42,762 shadows covering their faces. 562 01:12:44,054 --> 01:12:46,931 U.S. service members used to be able to roam around the area 563 01:12:46,933 --> 01:12:49,725 outside the former base during their leisure time. 564 01:12:49,727 --> 01:12:51,810 But since Laude's death last year, 565 01:12:51,812 --> 01:12:54,105 the U.S. Military has confined service members 566 01:12:54,107 --> 01:12:55,358 to the feed port. 567 01:12:56,651 --> 01:12:59,485 A young woman with hair halfway down her back 568 01:12:59,487 --> 01:13:01,611 walks alone in Waterfront. 569 01:13:01,613 --> 01:13:03,114 Her figure is slim and taller 570 01:13:03,116 --> 01:13:05,660 than most of the girls on the street. 571 01:13:11,749 --> 01:13:13,666 "I take my customers here," as she gestures 572 01:13:13,668 --> 01:13:16,211 towards the darkness beyond the road. 573 01:13:17,796 --> 01:13:20,047 Roseanne claims she's 17, 574 01:13:20,049 --> 01:13:22,635 but her voice hasn't noticeably dropped. 575 01:13:23,177 --> 01:13:24,885 Even though Pemberton killed Laude 576 01:13:24,887 --> 01:13:27,053 after finding out she was trans, 577 01:13:27,055 --> 01:13:28,847 Roseanne insists that she needs to keep 578 01:13:28,849 --> 01:13:31,475 her transgender status from U.S. service members 579 01:13:31,477 --> 01:13:33,354 who pay her for sex. 580 01:13:42,030 --> 01:13:44,029 In the verdict's aftermath, local officials 581 01:13:44,031 --> 01:13:46,907 and residents are eager for U.S. troops to come back 582 01:13:46,909 --> 01:13:49,954 and bring money into the city as they once did. 583 01:14:00,048 --> 01:14:01,713 Locals have even accused the Laudes of being 584 01:14:01,715 --> 01:14:04,717 selfish by not settling the case early. 585 01:14:04,719 --> 01:14:06,302 By having gone to trial, 586 01:14:06,304 --> 01:14:09,387 the liberty privileges for U.S. troops remain suspended, 587 01:14:09,389 --> 01:14:11,891 which in turn has directly led to hundreds, 588 01:14:11,893 --> 01:14:15,560 if not thousands of locals losing their sources of income. 589 01:14:15,562 --> 01:14:22,109 Just imagine some businessman lose about 20 million pesos 590 01:14:22,111 --> 01:14:26,404 in business opportunities because Americans are not having 591 01:14:26,406 --> 01:14:30,327 their liberty or their rest and recreational activities. 592 01:14:30,620 --> 01:14:32,078 "We expect liberty will resume 593 01:14:32,080 --> 01:14:35,416 now that Pemberton has been convicted," Cortez says. 594 01:14:36,166 --> 01:14:38,249 Jennifer's mother, Julita Laudes, 595 01:14:38,251 --> 01:14:41,252 sits on her brown-floral print couch. 596 01:14:41,254 --> 01:14:44,424 Despite the conviction, she is far from satisfied. 597 01:14:49,429 --> 01:14:51,763 Other locals express a mixture of sympathy 598 01:14:51,765 --> 01:14:53,599 and rejection when it comes to the presence 599 01:14:53,601 --> 01:14:56,310 of transgender sex workers in Olongapo. 600 01:14:56,312 --> 01:14:58,520 A souvenir vendor on Waterfront Road 601 01:14:58,522 --> 01:15:01,190 says that he is indifferent to the Pemberton verdict 602 01:15:01,192 --> 01:15:03,859 and wishes only that full liberty would resume, 603 01:15:03,861 --> 01:15:07,073 so that ordinary people in Olongapo can have income. 604 01:15:27,509 --> 01:15:29,302 Down the street, a female bystander 605 01:15:29,304 --> 01:15:31,971 sitting on a nearby park bench shouts back, 606 01:15:31,973 --> 01:15:34,806 "Transgenders need to be kicked out of Olongapo." 607 01:15:34,808 --> 01:15:36,891 Another taxi driver replies, 608 01:15:36,893 --> 01:15:38,644 "Their words hurt too much. 609 01:15:38,646 --> 01:15:41,148 Those are our fellow Filipinos." 610 01:15:44,986 --> 01:15:46,985 Roseanne is worried about people identifying her 611 01:15:46,987 --> 01:15:49,531 and finding out she's a sex worker. 612 01:15:50,073 --> 01:15:52,992 Her mother is not aware she is doing sex work. 613 01:15:52,994 --> 01:15:54,409 According to the young woman, 614 01:15:54,411 --> 01:15:56,745 she thinks I'm just looking for a handsome boyfriend 615 01:15:56,747 --> 01:15:58,957 who'll take me to America. 616 01:16:01,001 --> 01:16:02,959 As Roseanne continues to roam the streets 617 01:16:02,961 --> 01:16:05,171 of Olongapo at night, she has to believe 618 01:16:05,173 --> 01:16:08,173 that she will encounter men like Jennifer's fiancé 619 01:16:08,175 --> 01:16:11,845 and not a man like the kind who ended Jennifer's life. 620 01:16:16,433 --> 01:16:20,685 I think all the Filipinos wanted to have that big change. 621 01:16:20,687 --> 01:16:24,190 I think he's the number one candidate 622 01:16:24,192 --> 01:16:25,858 who's running for presidency. 623 01:16:25,860 --> 01:16:28,735 I know he can do what he promise 624 01:16:28,737 --> 01:16:32,364 that substantial changes will happen the next six months. 625 01:16:32,366 --> 01:16:34,699 The headline confirms it: 626 01:16:34,701 --> 01:16:36,159 Rodrigo Duterte will be 627 01:16:36,161 --> 01:16:38,663 the new president of the Philippines. 628 01:16:38,665 --> 01:16:40,413 He captured domestic and international 629 01:16:40,415 --> 01:16:42,958 attention with speeches peppered with obscene jokes 630 01:16:42,960 --> 01:16:44,459 about sex and rape 631 01:16:44,461 --> 01:16:47,003 and for undiplomatic remarks about some key players 632 01:16:47,005 --> 01:16:49,590 in the country's politics including Australia, 633 01:16:49,592 --> 01:16:51,552 the United States and China. 634 01:17:05,983 --> 01:17:11,404 America, prepare to leave the Philippines. 635 01:17:11,406 --> 01:17:14,073 Prepare for the event to a repeal 636 01:17:14,075 --> 01:17:18,454 for the abrogation of the visiting of this country. 637 01:18:38,910 --> 01:18:41,534 On this day two years ago, transgender woman Jennifer Laude 638 01:18:41,536 --> 01:18:44,622 was found dead in a motel room in Subic, Zambales. 639 01:18:44,624 --> 01:18:47,749 Now U.S. Marine Lance Corporal Joseph Scott Pemberton 640 01:18:47,751 --> 01:18:49,168 was found guilty of killing Laude 641 01:18:49,170 --> 01:18:52,587 is detained in a facility in Quezon City. 642 01:18:52,589 --> 01:18:55,173 Behind this fence is a detention facility 643 01:18:55,175 --> 01:18:58,052 for Lance Corporal Joseph Scott Pemberton. 644 01:18:58,054 --> 01:19:00,846 No movement can be detected in the facility. 645 01:19:00,848 --> 01:19:02,722 Space between the two cargo containers 646 01:19:02,724 --> 01:19:06,894 converted into rooms is covered with tarpaulin. 647 01:19:06,896 --> 01:19:08,604 Guards from the Bureau of Corrections 648 01:19:08,606 --> 01:19:11,649 manning the facility are nowhere in sight. 649 01:19:11,651 --> 01:19:14,735 The Court of Appeal still has to rule on Pemberton's appeal. 650 01:19:14,737 --> 01:19:18,780 The Laude family continues to seek justice for Jennifer. 651 01:19:18,782 --> 01:19:22,368 The family would like to put an end to this case also. 652 01:19:22,370 --> 01:19:25,162 Because for as long as there is an appeal, 653 01:19:25,164 --> 01:19:31,170 the appeal prolongs their agony. 654 01:21:43,010 --> 01:21:44,260 The U.S. Government's position 655 01:21:44,262 --> 01:21:47,178 is they will pay if there's finality to the case. 656 01:21:47,180 --> 01:21:49,515 Finality meant Pemberton should be allowed 657 01:21:49,517 --> 01:21:52,142 to go back to the United States. 658 01:21:52,144 --> 01:21:53,769 This was a very clear instance 659 01:21:53,771 --> 01:21:56,730 where the U.S. Government took advantage of poverty 660 01:21:56,732 --> 01:22:00,568 in attempting to release 661 01:22:00,570 --> 01:22:03,361 one of their Marines from incarceration 662 01:22:03,363 --> 01:22:05,700 arising from a criminal conviction. 663 01:22:45,572 --> 01:22:47,949 President Duterte is the very first president 664 01:22:47,951 --> 01:22:50,909 that allocated for an independent foreign policy. 665 01:22:50,911 --> 01:22:54,622 I stand solidly behind him that the presence 666 01:22:54,624 --> 01:22:57,458 of US troops in the Philippines 667 01:22:57,460 --> 01:23:00,168 is a blatant violation of our sovereignty. 668 01:23:00,170 --> 01:23:02,837 It's a hold-over from the Colonial Times 669 01:23:02,839 --> 01:23:04,507 and should finally end. 670 01:23:04,509 --> 01:23:09,302 I am a president of a sovereign state 671 01:23:09,304 --> 01:23:12,767 and we have long-ceased to be a colony. 672 01:23:20,441 --> 01:23:22,443 New England trip: 673 01:23:23,820 --> 01:23:27,240 hot summer day, no one on the road. 674 01:23:28,616 --> 01:23:32,537 Greek restaurant, regulars. 675 01:23:33,745 --> 01:23:36,790 Are these people aware of who Joseph Scott Pemberton is? 676 01:23:39,960 --> 01:23:44,506 Plan for today: go to Robin Street, home address. 677 01:23:47,427 --> 01:23:49,429 It's at a curve in the road. 678 01:23:55,601 --> 01:23:59,731 Simple-wooden fence, very modest house. 679 01:24:01,398 --> 01:24:03,026 Working-class family. 680 01:24:07,487 --> 01:24:11,325 Greater New Bedford Technical Vocational School, 681 01:24:12,492 --> 01:24:15,330 far from the famous schools of Boston. 682 01:24:17,165 --> 01:24:20,043 Boston: Harvard or MIT? 683 01:24:22,629 --> 01:24:24,252 I wonder what this high school 684 01:24:24,254 --> 01:24:27,717 taught Pemberton about LGBT people. 685 01:24:29,509 --> 01:24:33,680 Cement grounds, uniform green grass. 686 01:24:35,933 --> 01:24:38,686 Had Pemberton ever had a girlfriend before? 687 01:24:42,939 --> 01:24:46,652 Fresh, unlike the salty air of Olongapo. 688 01:24:48,821 --> 01:24:51,780 Joseph Scott Pemberton grew up close to the water 689 01:24:51,782 --> 01:24:55,035 and dreamed of being some place open. 690 01:24:56,204 --> 01:24:59,331 Isn't that why so many young men join the military? 691 01:25:03,378 --> 01:25:05,377 Nancy, he did it. 692 01:25:05,379 --> 01:25:07,422 He's guilty, that's it. 693 01:25:11,052 --> 01:25:12,762 Let's think about forgiveness. 694 01:25:13,388 --> 01:25:15,346 If he spends 30 years in jail, 695 01:25:15,348 --> 01:25:18,101 he won't have any life left when he comes back. 696 01:25:23,481 --> 01:25:25,358 Do you happen to live in New Bedford? 697 01:25:27,735 --> 01:25:30,319 I'm doing a story about Joseph Scott Pemberton. 698 01:25:30,321 --> 01:25:32,407 I just wonder if you've heard of the case. 699 01:25:46,295 --> 01:25:49,254 I can see oil trails that remind me 700 01:25:49,256 --> 01:25:52,007 of oil slicks in Olongapo. 701 01:26:50,192 --> 01:26:52,944 The president is winding up his trip to Asia 702 01:26:52,946 --> 01:26:54,819 and the Philippines, his last stop, 703 01:26:54,821 --> 01:26:56,529 before returning home tomorrow. 704 01:26:56,531 --> 01:26:58,324 He appeared to give the country's leader 705 01:26:58,326 --> 01:27:00,659 a pass on human rights. 706 01:27:00,661 --> 01:27:01,993 President Trump grimaced through 707 01:27:01,995 --> 01:27:04,329 the traditional Asia summit handshake, 708 01:27:04,331 --> 01:27:06,039 but did not shy away from praising 709 01:27:06,041 --> 01:27:09,668 controversial Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte. 710 01:27:09,670 --> 01:27:11,962 Duterte's accused of ordering death squads 711 01:27:11,964 --> 01:27:14,715 style killings of thousands of Filipino drug dealers 712 01:27:14,717 --> 01:27:17,133 and users without trial. 713 01:27:17,135 --> 01:27:19,845 His troops have killed more than 7,000 people 714 01:27:19,847 --> 01:27:21,721 since Duterte came into power. 715 01:27:21,723 --> 01:27:25,352 But he's a potential ally in the region on North Korea. 716 01:27:26,187 --> 01:27:28,186 The president's visit sparking protests. 717 01:27:28,188 --> 01:27:31,481 Riot police using water cannons to disperse the crowds. 718 01:27:31,483 --> 01:27:33,359 Mr. Trump winding down his Asian tour 719 01:27:33,361 --> 01:27:35,069 with a toast and a tribute. 720 01:27:38,198 --> 01:27:40,699 Duterte serenading the US Commander-in-Chief 721 01:27:40,701 --> 01:27:43,535 with the lyrics, "You are the light in my world." 722 01:27:43,537 --> 01:27:47,289 No VFA, no fascist U.S.A. 723 01:27:47,291 --> 01:27:51,543 No Trump, no VFA, no fascist U.S.A. 724 01:27:51,545 --> 01:27:55,799 No Trump, no VFA, no fascist U.S.A. 725 01:29:08,872 --> 01:29:11,289 I was just thinking about 726 01:29:11,291 --> 01:29:14,209 how important this spot has been 727 01:29:14,211 --> 01:29:17,212 and how it was the focus in so much media 728 01:29:17,214 --> 01:29:19,967 and, you know, sort of, Jennifer's death. 729 01:29:21,844 --> 01:29:26,305 There's this weird surreal way we just imagined 730 01:29:26,307 --> 01:29:28,807 these past two years. 731 01:29:28,809 --> 01:29:31,312 What does it actually mean? 732 01:29:49,330 --> 01:29:51,872 I always get affected when I hear 733 01:29:51,874 --> 01:29:54,711 of a trans person being murdered. 734 01:29:56,004 --> 01:29:59,841 A year ago, I also lost a friend to violence. 735 01:30:01,759 --> 01:30:03,761 She just become another statistic. 736 01:30:05,595 --> 01:30:08,140 She had more than 20 stab wounds. 737 01:30:09,392 --> 01:30:11,184 She was unrecognizable. 738 01:30:13,562 --> 01:30:18,190 There is the lack of justice in many trans people's lives. 739 01:30:18,192 --> 01:30:22,028 If members of our community are killed every day, 740 01:30:22,030 --> 01:30:24,072 then there is no justice in the world. 741 01:30:37,003 --> 01:30:40,921 If Pemberton is acquitted, 742 01:30:40,923 --> 01:30:46,010 oh my goodness, that would really affect my whole belief 743 01:30:46,012 --> 01:30:50,015 in this judicial, or legal system. 744 01:30:51,643 --> 01:30:53,767 For me it's really more than Laude's case, 745 01:30:53,769 --> 01:30:55,685 it's our sovereignty here. 746 01:30:55,687 --> 01:30:57,896 It's our freedom here. 747 01:30:57,898 --> 01:31:02,193 It's our right to determine our own path 748 01:31:02,195 --> 01:31:05,404 without intervention of a foreign power. 749 01:31:14,624 --> 01:31:16,873 My community has been ravaged 750 01:31:16,875 --> 01:31:21,421 by violence consistently year after year. 751 01:31:23,758 --> 01:31:25,298 Me continuing to do my work, 752 01:31:25,300 --> 01:31:29,928 continuing to strive for justice and acceptance 753 01:31:29,930 --> 01:31:35,476 is somehow a way to commemorate her. 754 01:32:23,153 --> 01:32:28,153 Subtitles by explosiveskull 59537

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.