Original subtitles

- [Upbeat music] - [Indistinct chatter]

♪ Uh one two one two three oh... ♪

[Indistinct chatter]

That's it, keep moving the ball.

- Hustle it, girls. - All right, dad.

Fantastic.

- Heads up, Stace. - [Tim] Keep the ball moving.

Pass it.

[Indistinct chatter]

[Chuckles]

[Intense music]

Gabriella? Dad!

Dad! Help, dad! Dad!

She's not breathing.

[Tim] Hannah?

- [Eagle screeching] - [Gasping]

[Sighs]

Dad?

- You okay? - Yeah.

Sorry I woke you. Go back to sleep.

- I love you. - I love you, too.

[Doorknob rattling]

[Sighs]

[Dramatic music]

[Birds chirping]

[Sighs] I'm worried about dad. He's having nightmares again.

Mm. You worry about everything.

- Morning, girls. - Hello.

You didn't have to make me breakfast.

Ah, figured you could use the extra sleep.

What are you talking about?

Anyway, what's going on for this weekend, ladies?

Have any plans or do you have time

for a little games night with your old man?

Um, I mean, I could rearrange some stuff.

- What? - [Laughing]

- Yes. We'd love to. - Okay, okay. Who am I kidding?

Of course you have plans, you're 16.

But, hey, at least I get to spend the afternoon with you.

You're all ready to model the winter line?

♪ Don't give up ooh ♪

[Laughs]

[Gabriella groans]

So, what do you think?

Oh, they're great.

It's a little, um, young.

Your mother always had a better eye

for the fashion side of things.

- Mm-hmm. - Well, I like the patterns.

Not everyone wants sexy athletic wear.

- [Tim] Hm. - Oh. Hey, Mike.

Boss, can I grab that check for the laces delivery?

Hm, you know, I really should make you a signatory

on the account, but then again, I'd miss these little visits

every time there was a delivery.

Ah, if you really miss me,

come back to poker night.

Where did I leave my checkbook?

Or we could grab a beer, watch the game?

I think I left it in the car. I'll be right back.

You got it.

I wish dad would talk to Mike. He needs someone other than us.

Shh.

What are you doing?

Finding someone for dad.

Help me fill out his dating profile.

I already added his picture.

- Nice one, right? - [Scoffs]

Online dating, really? I meant a friend or a therapist.

Well, my solution is way more fun.

I don't think dad's ready to date.

Besides, finding someone online is so unromantic.

Well, I'd love for him to meet someone in real life,

but unless gorgeous, single women start falling

from the sky, we work with what we have.

"Loving single father, business owner,

actively involved in the community." Who could resist?

Don't you think he should be in on this decision?

Dad won't even go to poker.

He's not gonna throw himself into dating.

But if we make it happen...

- [Scoffs] Fine. - [Upbeat music]

[Bethany] Mm, no.

Oh...

Oh, no. Hm.

♪ But it's hard to open up and you can't explain ♪

♪ if I let it all out... ♪

[Gasps] Hey.

Get off my car before you dent it.

Guess what? I found you the perfect guy.

[Instrumental music]

[Indistinct chatter]

- How about this one? - [Sighs]

Her only interests are reiki and astrology.

- Sounds flakey. - Okay. Ooh.

This one's a banker.

She looks, uh, too serious.

You are impossible.

Girls, please. Off the phone.

I can't help it! I'm addicted.

Be less addicted to the phone. More addicted to practice.

- Mm, okay. - Let's go. Ah! Welcome.

- You must be Bethany. - Yeah.

So glad you could make it. Come on.

Girls, everybody gather around, please. Gather around.

[Tim] Something very special today.

I would like to introduce you to Ms. Bethany Hargrave.

She just moved here from another district,

so today is going to be her

unofficial tryout with the toffees.

So, girls, please, let's make her feel welcome.

[All cheering]

All right, girls, on the ball, center. Let's warm up.

- Let's go. - Whoo! Come on!

[Instrumental music]

[Tim] Come on, girls.

[Grunts]

Nice tackle. Nice intensity, Bethany.

- Hi. You must be coach Lasky. - Tim.

Tim. I'm, uh, Bethany's mom, Caroline. We-we met over email.

Oh. So nice to finally meet you in person.

Listen, uh, Bethany, wow, she's fitting in perfectly.

Great.

- That's it. Good one. - [Indistinct chatter]

- [Cheering] - Whoo-hoo-hoo.

- All right. - I'm open, all right?

- [Whistle blows] - Girls, take five minutes.

Get some water and set up for the next drill.

- You need to stand your ground. - She was coming right at me.

You have to get used to aggression at this level.

Met your opponent?

Hi. I'm Annabelle.

This is my sister Gabriella. Welcome to the toffees.

- You think I made it? - [Laughs]

Yeah. For sure. You're really good.

But your old team must be sad to lose you.

I'm more sad to lose them, it kinda sucks

switching districts in your senior year.

Where were you before?

Uh, it was in Colorado.

Small private school. I'm sure you've never heard of it.

Where do you go to school now?

I'm starting at browns this week.

That's where we go, we'll make sure

it doesn't suck too bad.

Looks like the coach is making my mom feel pretty welcomed.

- Your mom's a doctor? - Mm-hmm.

And y-your dad...

- Annabelle, jeez. - W-What?

It's okay. Um, I don't know.

He took off when I was a baby.

Oh, that's too bad, but fyi,

the coach that's currently getting along with your mom,

that's our dad.

No way!

I guess the whole family is making us feel pretty welcomed.

- I've always wanted sisters. - [Both laughing]

[Tim] Quite a first practice you had.

Mom, this is, uh, Gabriella and Annabelle.

Annabelle, Gabriella, this is my mom, Caroline.

Hi. Nice to meet you.

I have just got to say, I think it's so awesome

that you came here straight from work.

- Involved mom and doctor. - Yeah.

So are we gonna go for pizza?

I mean, it's a tradition, especially for the newbies.

[Caroline] Well, sounds a lot better than what I was gonna

dig out of the freezer and...

If it's a tradition, well, I guess we have to.

- Mm-hmm. - Great. Somebody grab the balls.

- Let's go. - Ah!

[Indistinct chatter]

[Upbeat music]

♪ Tu-ru-ru-tu-ru-ru ♪

That's so cute. I love that brand.

- Oh, here. - Thank you.

- [Both laughing] - Looks good on you.

Yeah, it's, um, it's super shiny.

[Laughs] Yeah. It's lip gloss.

I'm gonna go get some water.

[Dramatic music]

This is such a lovely coat. Where did your dad get this?

My mom made it.

Hey, you having fun?

They are totally checking you out.

[Bethany] I think you mean checking us out.

- We should go say hi. - No, no, no.

- Come on. Come on, come, come. - No, no, no...

[Tim] I remember when my girls

used to always wanna be around me.

Now they won't even sit with me.

Well, I don't mind having you all to myself.

So, where is Mrs. Lasky this evening?

Um... she's dead.

Uh, I'm sorry, ah, I just

haven't figured out how to work that

into a conversation yet. I...

I'm a doctor. Death doesn't make me uncomfortable.

In fact, I think it's really, it's healthy

to be able to talk about it openly.

But I also know

that it is almost impossible

to find people who are willing to really listen,

you know, and not just offer meaningless platitudes

and move on.

How did she die?

Brain aneurysm.

She was hiking with the girls

and she just collapsed.

By the time the paramedics got there, it was...

That is so, so traumatic for the girls, and you.

You know, there's just, there's no warning.

Well, the doctors said she didn't suffer.

But, yeah, I feel really guilty saying this, but...

I wish that we would have had some time to prepare, you know?

- Like... - Do not feel guilty.

You're thinking about your girls, you know, wishing,

wishing you'd had time for them to say goodbye.

Yeah.

[Indistinct chatter]

[Laughs]

I can't believe you got them to buy us drinks.

We got them to buy us drinks.

The brunette one, he said yes, 'cause he thought you were cute.

- Since when do you drink? - Don't make a big deal about it.

Looks like our parents are really getting along.

- A&g wear for life! - [Laughing]

I can't believe that company is worth over nine mil.

[Bethany gasps]

Mm. I've been monopolizing this whole conversation.

I'm sure that you've had challenges on your own.

Um, you know, I'm a single mom working crazy hours.

It's... it's not easy.

And I feel guilty for, for not being around enough.

What about Bethany's father?

Yeah. He is not in the picture.

I put myself through med school and raised Bethany on my own.

[Caroline] Only hope I didn't scar her too much.

I think she's turned out quite well.

[Sighs] Time to powder my nose.

Did you think it was kind of weird that Bethany...

- Hi. - Hi.

Thank you so much for making Bethany feel so welcome.

Is that alcohol, Gabriella?

Oh. It's not mine. Uh...

Don't worry. I'm not gonna tell your dad.

This is gonna be our little secret. Hm?

[Instrumental music]

So are you gonna ask Caroline out?

She obviously likes you.

I'm not ready to date anyone yet.

Dad, she's amazing, if you wait until you're ready,

she's not gonna be single anymore.

Well, I guess it's not meant to be then.

What, we're going to college soon.

Hopefully, out of state if we get in to Rossmore.

We can't leave you here all alone.

We'll be so worried, we'll fail all our classes.

So I-If you don't date for you, date for us.

- I'll think about it. - [Chuckles]

[Annabelle] You're getting your wish.

I'm deleting dad's dating profile.

Caroline is the one. This is what you wanted.

No, don't you think it was weird

that Bethany knew exactly what a&g was worth?

Not really, if my hot doctor mom

was chatting up some guy, I'd Google his net worth, too.

No. There's something's off about Caroline.

I think I saw her try to take dad's wallet.

Typical Gabi, trying to find problems where there aren't any.

You just don't like the idea of dad dating anyone.

You shot down every online match, too.

Okay. Maybe you're right. Maybe I'm not ready to see dad date.

But... Well, is that so terrible?

I know mom's death was hard on you,

but it was hard on all of us.

Dad put us first for a really long time

because we were struggling so much.

It's time you put him first.

You're right. I'm being selfish.

And delete.

- [Indistinct chatter] - Sure.

- [Chuckles] That's my favorite. - Mm-hmm.

- Hey. - Hey.

I think you should ask out Caroline.

Well, I don't want you to be alone,

and she seems really great.

Okay.

If my girls think I should, I should.

- Good luck. - Hah.

Thanks.

- [Line ringing] - [Sighs]

[Cell phone ringing]

[Chuckles] It's interesting.

I knew he'd call.

[Both laughing]

Hello?

[Sighs]

[Dramatic music]

[Man] Caroline.

[Intense music]

Caroline!

Don't think you can get away from me that easily.

- [Grunts] - Ah! God!

Damn it!

[Exhales]

- Hi. - Hi.

Wow.

[Laughs]

- You look amazing. - Thank you. I, uh...

I don't really feel it, I kinda

just hustled here straight from work.

Well, thank you for making the time. Uh, shall we?

Would you be super disappointed if I suggested

something a little more casual? I just...

It's really hard to get to know someone

when you're worrying about which fork to use.

Disappointed? More like relieved.

[Camera clicks]

- [Chuckles] - Hey.

- You up for a game? - Uh, I'm busy.

[Laughs] Look what Bethany just sent me. She's so funny.

Well, maybe later?

[Dramatic music]

Uh, I guess I'm gonna put this on my card.

- Everything okay? - Yeah.

I, uh, just thought I had some cash on me, that's all.

I do that all the time, I spend money

and totally forget about it.

Please do not judge me for the mess I'm about to make.

'Cause if your hotdog is not a mess,

it's probably not very good.

- [Laughs] Oh, wow. - Oh, yeah.

- That one must be exceptional. - Mm-hmm.

- Yeah. Come here. - Mm, thank you.

[Caroline] I'm really glad that Bethany and Annabelle

are getting along so well.

You know, I just, I worry about her sometimes.

Being an only child can be lonely.

Well, you know, I think it's a parent's prerogative

to be concerned about their children.

When Hannah died, Gabriella took it especially hard.

- And I still worry about her. - I'm sorry.

Oh. She's been doing much better lately.

But she's just so sensitive. Well...

What about you and Bethany? How are you liking it here?

You know, how does it compare to colora...

[Instrumental music]

do.

[Chuckles]

[Dramatic music]

[Gabriella] I'm just saying it's weird her social media

is from the last three weeks.

Is this about the drink? It's not that big of a deal.

Okay, it kind of is. But that's not the point...

Why are you trying to find problems?

I'm sorry I'm making a friend who isn't you

and dad is dating someone who isn't mom, but...

- [Door opens] - [Tim humming]

Listen to how happy he sounds.

- [Whistle blows] - Listen.

I have a couple of main things before we start practice today.

First of all, if you haven't e-transferred me

your tournament fees, you can place cash in the envelope.

It's gonna be over there on the bench. Also...

We're going to be choosing our co-captains today.

So there's a ballot box right over there.

Place your votes and please do not vote for yourself.

We'll be announcing who our co-captains are after practice.

All right? Let's head to the end line and let's warm up.

Let's have a great practice, everybody.

I hope we get voted captains again.

I think we'd make pretty good co-captains, too.

For sure.

♪ Hah hah let's go... ♪

[Tim] Come on, girls.

♪ All right all right ♪

♪ hah hah ♪ ♪ oh oh ♪

♪ all right all right all right all right ♪

♪ ho ho ho ho ♪ ♪ let's go ♪

[Girl 1] Watch your shot! [Girl 2] I'm open!

[Intense music]

- [Grunting] - [Groans]

[Girl 1] Oh! [Girl 2] Gabi!

[Whistle blows]

Hold on.

- Gabi. - You all right?

You should sit out the rest of practice, sweetheart.

- No, I'm fine. - Oh.

Head injuries can be really funny.

Let's take a breather. Let's be safe. Okay?

- Come on, girls, pick it up. - You need to play smart.

That kind of erratic play can cost us a season.

[Girl 1] There we go. Ooh, nice. [Girl 2] I'm open.

All right, girls. Pick it up.

Dad, I saw Caroline taking money

from the registration fees.

Oh, it's all here.

No, she must have put it back. I know what I saw.

I couldn't find an ice pack, but I dug this out of my cooler.

[Tim] Well, that was thoughtful, wasn't it?

- Pass it, pass it! Move it! - [Tim] Go, girls!

- [Girl] Come on, move on! - [Indistinct yelling]

All right, girls, great practice.

- I will see you all tomorrow. - Oh!

- Coach. - I'm kidding. I'm kidding.

We all wanna know who our co-captains are gonna be.

And they are... A quick count here.

- Annabelle. - [All cheering]

And... Bethany.

- Oh, my god! - [Applause]

[Indistinct chatter]

You took the money. You put it back, but I saw you.

[Sighs] Gabriella, sweetheart,

you saw me making change for a hundred.

Your dad told me you were having a hard time.

And I can imagine how difficult it must be

to see Bethany take your spot as co-captain,

you know, while your dad and I are getting close.

Look at how you were hurt today,

worrying about what other people are doing

instead of what's happening right in front of you. You know?

Just remember that for next time, okay?

'Cause I don't wanna see you get hurt again.

[Dramatic music]

- Co-captain selfie? - Oh, yeah.

- [Indistinct chatter] - [Bethany laughs]

Oh, put that on the 'gram, you look hot.

- Oh. - [Indistinct chatter]

How come all your social media is new?

You don't have any posts from before last month.

Like you didn't exist before that.

I had to change schools

because one of my classmates was a total creep.

He was harassing me online, so I deleted all my accounts.

Oh, my gosh. That sounds terrible. Right, gabi?

- I really don't like that. - Okay.

♪ The further I dive ♪

♪ the more I'm alive ♪

[Annabelle] Oh, there's Bethany.

- Bye, dad. - [Tim] Have a great day.

[Both squealing]

I know it must hard for you to see Annabelle get so close

to Bethany.

But remember what mom used to always say,

"a sister is a best friend..."

"You can't get rid of."

I really like Caroline.

I'm hoping you can find a way to all get along.

- Bye. - Bye.

[Instrumental music]

- [Tim laughs] - [Indistinct chatter]

Oh, I can't believe my babies are turning 17.

You should invite Bethany and Caroline

over for our birthday dinner.

You've been dating for, like, two months.

We should do a family thing, all together.

- Sure. - Well...

Okay. If you, if you insist.

- Hello? - [Tim on phone] Hey!

Uh, do you have plans tomorrow night?

We'd love to invite you and Bethany over

for the girls' birthday dinner.

Wow, um, uh...

[Caroline] Yeah, no, that-that-that sounds good.

No stress, if you, if you're busy or something.

No, no, no, it's-it's, it's lovely.

It's just, um, I'm just, I'm a bit stressed.

Uh, a pipe burst at our place

and I-I have to find somewhere to stay.

And everywhere I've tried so far is either a dump

or it's too expensive or it's out of the school district.

- And... - Stay with us.

[Gasps]

[Caroline] Really?

[Tim] Yeah. Come tomorrow.

Um, great. Thank you.

[Tim] See you then. Bye.

Hm.

Are you sure you don't wanna share a room with me instead?

You always say you need quiet to study. Doesn't make sense.

- Hey. - [Gasps]

Cool if I make some room in the closet?

Absolutely, as long as

I get to borrow that some time.

[Chuckles] Deal. You, too, gabi.

Though I'm guessing it's not really your style.

Okay.

- [Indistinct chatter] - [Laughs]

[Humming]

[Instrumental music]

Well...

Thank you so much for having us. Oh.

You are my knight in shining armor.

[Tim] There's plenty of closet space for you now.

[Caroline] Oh, wow. Are you sure?

[Tim] Yes, I want you to feel at home.

Now, I am going to go make dinner.

[Caroline] Okay. Ha-ha.

- Make yourself at home. - Thank you.

[Dramatic music]

[Caroline] Hi.

[Music continues]

[Music continues]

[Rattling]

[Intense music]

[Music continues]

[Door shuts]

[Music continues]

Oh, I'm sorry.

You really should close the door while you're in here.

- Privacy's important. - [Tim] Ladies.

Who wants to help me set the table?

Coming, sweetie.

[Door shuts]

[Indistinct chatter]

Let's check it out.

Uh, tell dad I'll be down in one second.

Okay.

Okay, so for later, um, do you think you could do my makeup?

[Bethany] Yeah, absolutely. [Annabelle] Okay.

[Dramatic music]

[Music continues]

[Groans]

Okay, well, her pupils are responsive.

Do you, do you feel nauseous, sweetie?

No, uh... what happened?

That box of mom's things must have fallen on your head.

What were you looking for in my closet, gabi?

I saw Caroline take mom's pearls.

She-she put them in her suitcase.

I-I-I looked at them.

But I put them back. I swear. You can check.

You put them back after I caught you, uh, j-just like the money.

Okay. This bump might be worse than I thought.

Head injuries can cause paranoia

and there was that hit at the soccer game.

No. I'm-I'm not imagining things. I know what I saw.

[Sighs] My god, this is... This is all my fault.

I put the box back poorly and it fell on you.

- I'm-I'm so sorry, Gabriella. - This is nobody's fault. Okay?

We're just lucky that we have a doctor in the house, right?

Yeah. I'm gonna have to keep a close eye on you, Gabriella.

Mm-hmm. Ah. That's the lasagna.

I'll give you a hand, dad.

- Ah-ah-ah... - Oh.

All right.

Um, do you think that Gabi's gonna be all right with us?

Or is this too much to ask, to have Caroline and Bethany here?

Dad, I love gabi, but we both know she's sensitive.

She's had problems with your dating since day one.

Yeah, but to accuse Caroline of stealing mom's things?

Listen, I think she saw Caroline looking at mom's stuff

and she just freaked out.

She's having a hard time adjusting, but it'll pass.

I should have spoken to the both of you about this

before inviting them, but I just felt so...

Dad, gabi is the one in the wrong here and not you.

She'll get over it. We both want you to be happy.

- [Laughs] - Come here.

I just, I feel so awful, sweetie.

[Bethany] Don't beat yourself up, mom.

Gabi shouldn't have been snooping.

[Humming] Well, we figured gabi should rest,

so we're bringing in the dinner birthday party in here.

- Oh. - And...

[Laughing]

Ah.

That's not mom's chocolate cake.

[Tim] Well, no.

Caroline offered to make a cake.

Doesn't it look amazing?

But we always have mom's chocolate cake for birthdays.

Gabi, we have room for some new traditions here, too.

And we're using mom's special plates.

Oh, wow! These are gorgeous.

Yeah. They're family heirlooms.

They're from the girls' mother's side of the family.

We only use them on special occasions like this.

- What about the silver? - Oh...

I didn't see it. But we can use regular cutlery tonight.

It was all on the table. I-I put it there earlier. I...

You know, Caroline probably stashed it like

she stashed the pearls.

- [Plate shatters] - Oh, my gosh. I am so sorry.

- It's okay. - [Bethany] I'm such an idiot.

I know how much these plates meant to you guys.

[Caroline] It is just a plate. Okay?

Nothing is as important as the new memories we're making.

Okay?

- Let's plate. - Mm-hmm.

That wasn't just a plate.

Look, it was an accident. Okay? Bethany was upset.

Listen, I get it, no one wants to see their kid hurting,

but those memories are very important to us, too.

Honestly, being in this house, around Hannah's things,

it just, it feels like a shrine to your dead wife.

I, I just, I don't think

that you're ready for a new relationship yet.

- Caroline. - Honestly.

It's too much too soon. Okay?

Bethany and I can find a new place to stay tomorrow.

Listen. Stop.

I'm ready. I promise.

And you're right, it's time to start

putting Hannah's things away.

I don't know, have you ever thought about donating?

Maybe just pack away a few things for the girls to keep?

But, I mean, there are some great charitable organizations

that you can give to, instead of just

gathering dust in the basement.

I'd be happy to help.

[Tim] That's very thoughtful.

[Dramatic music]

[Music continues]

Gabriella, you look like you're feeling better.

- Dad, I need to talk to you. - What's up, gabs?

No, I mean, like, alone.

But I just made hot chocolate for everybody.

Can it wait a minute? It's your mom's recipe.

[Tim] Our favorite.

Delicious. Isn't this nice, gabi?

- Dad, listen... - Do me a favor.

Let me say a few words before you launch into anything.

I'm sorry that I asked Caroline to move in.

That was a mistake on my part.

No, dad, this isn't what I wanna talk...

I promise to try and include you

in all decisions made in the future.

But I am your dad...

And ultimately what I say goes.

Okay, listen, I, I was in...

I went to check up on...

[Instrumental music]

[Dramatic music]

[Birds chirping]

She's been asleep for an awfully long time.

Isn't that dangerous when you have concussions?

I checked on her last night, again this morning, she's okay.

And I'm gonna be here all day keeping an eye on her.

- I thought you worked today? - Oh, they change my shifts.

Last minute, all the time.

Oh, I'd feel better if she had an MRI.

I mean, two head injuries that close together...

It's a mild concussion at most.

I think you're projecting, what with how Hannah died,

which is completely understandable.

Mm-mm. I want her...

Babe, I'm a doctor.

I know what I'm doing. Okay?

And somebody needs to get those kids to school.

- Oh. - Bye, mom.

Bye, girls. Have a good day.

She's fine.

[Tim] Call me, please, if anything changes with gabi.

[Caroline] Yeah.

[Dramatic music]

[Camera clicks]

[Gasps]

[Keys jingling]

- What are you doing home? - I was worried about Gabriella.

Oh.

Dad...

I think she drugged me.

I gave her an ibuprofen earlier.

Poor thing is just really agitated.

Sweetheart, you need to lie down.

Tim, she's just gonna make herself worse

if she doesn't rest and let herself heal.

No.

It's been a rough couple of days. Let's get some rest.

[Instrumental music]

[Door shuts]

- [Giggling] - Shh, shh.

[Indistinct chatter]

[Gasping] Hey.

You're awake. Are you feeling better?

I need to talk to you.

We're heading out. Bethany got us invited to a college party.

- I wanna come. - Uh, I don't think so.

Then I'll scream and wake up dad.

Let her come with us. It'll be fun.

- [Chuckles] - Okay.

[Breathing heavily]

Hey, you okay?

Yeah.

Good memory?

This was her favorite spot. Paradise falls.

It was also the spot that...

It was the hike.

I'm making you and the girls a memory book.

That's why I was taking pictures of Hannah's mementos.

That way, you can look at them whenever you want,

but you don't have to have them out all the time.

[Tim] That's a lovely gesture.

First stop, liquor store.

They're not gonna believe that we're 21.

They will when I show them this.

- [Laughs] - Stay put. I'll be right back.

I'm surprised that you wanted to come tonight,

but I'm glad that you did.

- I think Caroline drugged me. - Seriously?

I thought when you said you wanted to come,

you were trying to make an effort to be nice.

You really think I wanna come to some sketchy party?

Yes, I thought for once in your life

you wanted to have a little bit of fun.

I plan on having a good time tonight.

If you can't at least try, go home.

[R&B music playing]

Wow.

This is crazy.

I know, love.

["Say suttin" by Lavine Reindorf playing]

How does Bethany know college guys?

She just moved here.

["Say suttin" by Lavine Reindorf playing]

It's not too late to go home.

Um, I think I'm gonna grab a drink.

["Say suttin" by Lavine Reindorf playing]

- Hi. - What's happening?

I'm Annabelle.

- Hi. - Hi.

["Say suttin" by Lavine Reindorf playing]

[Indistinct chatter]

["Say suttin" by Lavine Reindorf playing]

- Hey, I really wanna go. - Well, I don't.

Okay, well, I'm not leaving you here alone.

That's your call.

- Sorry. - [Scoffs]

[Indistinct chatter]

Come on, let's just get outta here, okay?

I know a nice quiet little spot.

I-I'm-I'm okay here, thanks.

Don't. No, no, no, I'm not, I'm not feeling this.

[Sighs] I need to find my sister.

Come on.

[Annabelle] Stop it!

Look... you're very cute...

But you're also very drunk.

[Bethany] I'm not. I'm not even tipsy.

- [Keys jingling] - Who's there?

Were you spying on me?

[Glass shatters]

I told you I don't like people getting in my business.

Yo, chill!

[Annabelle panting] There you are!

[Chuckles] Relax.

- It was, it was a dumb joke. - [Jesse chuckles]

You should have seen the look on your faces.

[Laughing]

[Tim] As long as you're living under my roof,

this kind of behavior will not be tolerated. Period.

When did you say your house is ready to move back in to?

Um, uh, I-I don't know.

I mean, it's just, it's taking longer than I thought.

Well, as soon as it's done, we're reassessing

this living situation.

Can we just talk about this, please?

[Tim] It's late. Get some rest.

Bethany, can I have a word with you?

[Bethany groans]

Listen, you almost ruined everything.

These are good girls. You need to act like one, too.

I almost ruined everything?

You're the one who got caught stealing.

Yes, but I cleaned up my messes,

I am not gonna clean up your messes, too.

Get it together.

[Sighs]

So that guy ended up being a total creep.

What did he do? Are you okay?

Well, he didn't have a chance to do anything.

But if something had happened...

No one would even know where we were.

Hey, I'm sorry. You're right, okay?

Bethany's behavior was unacceptable.

[Sighs] I just...

I acted defensive because it's a sore spot

for us.

Okay, our life hasn't been perfect like yours.

We'll be out of your hair as soon as the renos are done.

[Exhales sharply]

Let's just see where we're at.

Sorry I didn't listen to you.

For the first time in a long time

dad was happy and I was having fun,

and I thought you were being oversensitive.

[Scoffs] Thanks.

But you are right.

As fun as Bethany is, she's also kinda deranged.

That bottle thing was nuts.

- We should tell dad. - She'll just say it was a joke.

Caroline got super antsy when dad mentioned her place.

And when we went to help her move,

she didn't wanna let us in.

Maybe she's hiding something.

- We could go check it out. - [Sighs]

You said you should have listened to me, right?

Okay. We'll check it out.

Okay.

Gabi, how's your head?

You're sure you're up for school? We could stay home.

- I feel fine. - Yup, I think she's good to go.

Oh, let me know if she starts sounding paranoid again.

It could be a sign the head injury is more serious.

In which case, we might have to rethink soccer.

Hm.

Have a great day, girls.

[Gabriella] Okay, so it's a 50-minute bus ride

or a 40-minute walk.

- Where are you two going? - Um, uh, nowhere.

Really? 'Cause it looks like you're skipping school.

Your poor dad would be so disappointed.

Gabi convinced me to check out, uh, a bookstore.

[Scoffs] That might be the lamest reason

to skip school I've ever heard.

Yeah, an author I like

is signing books.

- Who? - You know what, gabi?

You go on your own, if I'm gonna get in trouble skipping,

it better be worthwhile.

- Let's go have some fun. - Okay.

[Dramatic music]

- What do you think you're doing? - Oh.

I'm sorry. I'm looking for Bethany and Caroline.

- Who? - The people who live here.

I live here. And I've never heard of them.

Maybe it's one of the other town houses.

Do you know who this is?

I know everyone who lives in the complex.

Never seen her in my life.

Okay. Thank you.

[Cell phone ringing]

- Hello? - [Tim] Come home now.

I was just saying the school called.

Said that you all skipped.

How do I make this clear that this kind of behavior

is unacceptable?

I have a good reason.

I went to check on Bethany and Caroline's town house

and I spoke to a woman there.

She never heard of either of them.

[Caroline sighs] Uh...

There are things

that... you don't know...

About me.

I didn't move because of a burst pipe.

I moved because

an abusive ex tracked me down.

I actually saw him outside the restaurant

the night of our first date.

That's why I suggested a change of venue.

He showed up at my house. I-I had to leave.

That woman you met is a friend.

She would never tell a stranger that she knew us.

[Tim] Why didn't you tell me?

We'd only just met. I didn't wanna drag you into my drama.

And, I didn't want you to think less of me.

- [Chuckles] I wouldn't have. - Your daughter hates me already.

It's like she can smell the bad choices on me.

No, she does not hate you.

None of this is your fault.

Just to be honest, I, I wasn't sure about you yet.

I just, I don't have the best track record

when it comes to men.

Bethany's dad didn't leave us.

We escaped from him.

Well, I'm not that type of guy. I would never hurt you.

I know that now.

You're safe here.

[Dramatic music]

Wow, she deserves an Oscar for that performance.

She was telling the truth, I feel horrible for doubting them,

for bringing up all those painful memories.

Bethany said the exact same thing about her social media.

How many stalkers can one family have?

It's like they're living in a soap opera.

Or they've been really unlucky.

- Which you're adding to. - No.

You said it yourself that Bethany was deranged.

She was really drunk. It was probably just a joke that...

No, she was, she was probably drunk

enough to show us who she really is.

Stop it!

Dad is happy, and so was I until I listened to you.

Yeah, well, maybe if you'd listened to me about mom's

headache instead of pushing for a fun hike,

she'd still be alive.

No, I-I didn't mean that, I...

Annabelle?

Annabelle, i-I'm sorry. Please.

[Annabelle] Go away!

[Grunts]

[Sobbing]

[Sniffles]

[Indistinct chatter]

[Chuckles] I have a little surprise for you.

[Tim] You're an angel.

[Exhales sharply]

[Sniffles]

[Dramatic music]

- What are you doing up? - Uh, just having a drink.

I'm not as lame as you and Annabelle think I am.

They'll hear us and I'll get blamed.

Then let's sneak out.

Come on, give me a chance.

I can be fun, too.

Only if you're up for a real adventure.

[Bethany] You're gonna love this place.

[Gabriella] I'm sorry for not making you feel welcome.

Honestly, I was just jealous.

You and Annabelle clicked so easily.

You're kind of uptight.

Would someone uptight do this?

Ah. Your turn.

Um, I'm sorry for what you and your mom have been through.

Did she ever tell you about her ex or, like, your dad?

Just that she took care of them.

It must be hard having to move on so much.

It must be really hard living in your sister's shadow.

[Chuckles] I don't live in my sister's shadow.

Sure you do, goody-two-shoes gabi worrying about

everyone else 'cause her life is so boring.

- Where are we? - Goody-two-shoes gabi.

Who honestly thought she'd get

me drunk and I'd spill all my secrets.

- No, I was just trying to bond... - I'm not stupid.

I may not be a straight-a student like you,

but I am not stupid.

You, on the other hand, seem to have a hard time

learning lessons.

I told you I didn't like

people digging in my stuff!

[Breathing heavily]

Oh, no, your shirt.

You should get Caroline to take care of that.

She's good at taking care of people.

- [Upbeat music] - [People cheering]

[Tim] Come on, girls! Come on! Let's move the ball!

- [Players clamoring] - [Tim] All right.

Great pass. Good job, girls.

♪ All right all right all right all right ♪

- [Whistle blows] - Gabriella...

- Oh, come on! - [All clamoring]

Referee. Substitution, please!

Gabriella! Let's regroup, everybody!

Let's go, girls! Strong in the head! Strong in the head!

What's going on with you? You're not playing your best.

And then you were mouthing off to the referee.

I have proof Caroline drugged me.

Wait, no, I just had them right here. I swear.

Are you hung over, young lady? You smell like booze.

I was just trying to impress Bethany.

She keeps calling me a goody two shoes.

You are benched for the rest of the game,

and the rest of the season if you keep this up.

Dad, Caroline drugged me and Bethany is...

Enough. I raised you better than this.

[Tim] Keep it up, toffees!

You need to play smart.

These wild card moves might cost us the game.

A game's supposed to be fun.

Besides, an erratic move can rattle your opponent.

[Indistinct yelling]

I'm really, really sorry, Annabelle.

I was just frustrated you wouldn't listen.

Why should I? You say Bethany is trouble.

And then you sneak out with her. You don't make any sense.

Oh. You wanted to get her in trouble.

- [Tim] I don't wanna hear it. - Well, that's pretty pathetic.

Caroline, this living arrangement isn't working.

Bethany is a bad influence.

You can't blame Bethany for Gabriella's poor choices.

The problems all started when we met.

But regardless of the cause, I have to put my girls first.

I'll help you and Bethany find a safe place.

I'm pregnant.

That's why Bethany's been acting so out of control.

She's just not taking the news well.

- H-How how far along? - Six weeks.

That's, that's why I didn't say anything.

It's early. And at my age, you just...

I'm sorry. It's the hormones.

And thinking about finding a new place

and just the thought

of raising another child on my own...

You're not on your own.

I just, I don't wanna be a burden.

I don't wanna cause a problem with your girls.

You're not a burden. Please... stay.

Okay, I'll work all this out with gabi.

I'm sure that once she realizes she's going to have

a new sibling, she'll come around.

Bethany, she just needs to know that this really is her home

and-and, and that she's safe.

Oh, you're amazing.

Can I just ask

that maybe you hold off on telling your girls?

It's still early.

- Sure. - Okay.

Anything you need.

[Chuckles] I'm gonna be a father again.

[Both chuckling]

[Instrumental music]

[Birds chirping]

Thank you very much for confirming.

[Laughs] Great news, girls.

Susanne Cole, the scout from Rossmore university

is coming to our next game.

[Annabelle] Oh, awesome! [Bethany] Sweet.

[Tim] Yes! Gabi!

- Ah, yeah, cool, dad. - [Chuckles]

So, uh, we need to be on our best behavior, girls. Okay?

No drinking. No fighting.

And, uh, you know, like, toffee team spirit all the way.

- [Tim] Right? - Okay, I'm off, babe.

Oh.

[Caroline] Bye, girls! [Bethany] Bye, mom.

Bye!

Hey. Uh, dad, could I borrow your car?

I wanna go study at the library.

Studying? Now that's the gabi I remember.

[Chuckles] Can I get a ride to work on the way?

On a beautiful day like this?

The dad I remember would have biked to work.

[Chuckles] Touche.

[Gabriella chuckles]

[Tim chuckles]

[Intense music]

[Engine starts]

[Camera clicking]

Dad...

I'm very disappointed, Gabriella.

That's your handwriting, isn't it?

I know you said you'd get me in trouble

if I told him you stole those checks,

but I had to tell him.

Dad, I did not write those checks.

You have to believe me.

I want to believe you.

But you've really abused my trust.

Bethany said she saw you shopping today

when you told me you were at the library.

Dad, Bethany and Caroline...

Are a part of our lives.

And you will accept it!

[Knocking on door]

Here to tell me off again?

I went to surprise Caroline at work today

and my phone was dead, so I went into the hospital to find her.

No one there had heard of her.

I knew it! She wasn't listed in the state medical records.

- She's not even a doctor. - The hospital's really big.

I totally could have asked the wrong person

or maybe she's using a different name to protect herself.

Then why'd you say anything if you don't think it's anything?

I didn't think mom's headache was anything either.

Neither of us could have done anything.

I know.

But if there is something up with Bethany and Caroline,

maybe we can do something about that.

This is where she was when she said she was working.

Maybe she just needed a day to herself?

They're trying to frame me for stealing those checks.

Why would they do that if they weren't planning something?

You really didn't do it? Promise?

Look at me. We came from the same womb.

You, of all people, should know this.

My favorite purple pen is missing

and you have my chemistry notes in your room.

Bethany or Caroline copied my writing.

I-Is that so hard to believe?

I saw Bethany with a purple pen the other day.

- I didn't think anything of it. - Check if it's still there.

If she still has that pen, that's our proof.

Hey, sweetheart.

[Caroline] Babe, we, uh, we need to tell you something.

Bethany stole those checks from you, not Gabriella.

What?

Dad, Bethany wrote those checks. Look what we found in her room.

And Caroline lied about being at work today.

- See, I followed her and she... - It's all true.

Look...

I haven't been able to work because of the baby.

Baby?

What do you mean you haven't been able to work?

The baby's blood is Rh positive and mine is negative.

I've been Rh sensitized.

It just means the baby has to have frequent transfusions.

So the doctor ordered me off work

when I went in for my first test.

[Sighs] Bethany cashed the checks

because she knew we'd need the money.

I heard you guys fighting about us living here.

So I made it seem like gabi stole those checks

because she's your daughter and you'll always love her.

Look, I thought I protected her from the worst of it,

but she still remembers what it was like

when I was a single mom and out of work.

She made...

She made a mistake,

but she came clean to me and she wants to make it right.

What you did is really serious, Bethany.

What you accused gabi of is-is...

I hate the thought of raising this baby on my own,

but if you want us to leave, I completely understand.

You have to think of your girls first.

No. No, no, no.

We are a family now

and we will deal with this together.

You will not raise this child alone. I promise you that.

[Scoffs] I told you she was framing me.

Which she confessed and explained.

Well, she never explained why no one at the hospital knew her.

Gabi, Caroline and Bethany are gonna be family now.

You have to accept them. We're gonna be big sisters.

- Ha. The baby's obviously a lie. - You saw the sonogram.

But she's a doctor, she could have easily been fak...

Oh, so now she's a doctor?

This morning you were convinced she wasn't.

- Maybe she was a doctor. - [Sighs] I can't with you.

You have to drop this.

What else could her name be?

[Laptop keys clacking]

[Clears throat]

Gabriella.

It's time for things to change around here.

No more snooping. No more accusations.

And if you can't stop yourself, I will.

Are you threatening me?

I'm merely saying you wouldn't

wanna have another accident.

Another head injury would mean no more soccer.

Then you'd be stuck with me.

I'd have to go to a local college.

Or you'd have to go to a clinic

for cognitive rehabilitation.

Hm. Luckily, a good friend of mine runs one.

It is so sad

how many people never fully recover.

They have to stay there indefinitely.

Away from family, friends...

[Sighs] Some of them are so insistent that they're fine

now that they can go home.

But with brain trauma, there are just...

There's so many unknowns.

Anyway, that's not gonna happen with you, right, dear?

Because you're gonna be careful. Gonna avoid risks.

I'm so glad that we had this talk.

[Sighs]

- You're so wonderful. - Mm.

Bethany and I are so lucky.

Well, you and Bethany have been through a lot.

You deserve happiness.

Now from here on out, I want you tell me everything.

And for starters, I wanna be at your next check-up.

- [Both chuckling] - Of course.

I just still feel like this is all gonna go away.

I'm not used to having a man in my life I can depend on.

Well, I'm not going anywhere. I promise you that.

- We are a family now. - Hm.

What if we made it official?

- What, like, get married? - Yeah.

Then I’d, you know, would know you're really committed to me.

And I think it would be helpful, you know,

for the girls to adjust now that this is permanent.

Well, a wedding is a lot to plan

and you have been kind of exhausted with the pregnancy.

What if... we did it tomorrow?

After the big game. Just the two of us.

City hall. Keep it simple.

Tomorrow? That's, that seems a bit rushed.

Hey, well, you don't want to, it's fine. Forget it.

Oh, hon.

I just...

I want this baby to come into the world

with a united family, you know,

knowing it has a mom and a dad it can count on.

You know what, you're absolutely right.

I'd be honored to marry you.

Balls are in the car, okay, remember, just because

a scout is here doesn't mean we play any differently.

Play as a team. And no grand standing, all right?

See you soon, babe.

I'll meet you there.

[Caroline] Get your bag. [Bethany] Mm-hmm.

Okay, Caroline was a doctor, but she had her license revoked.

I didn't see her name before because she went

under a different last name. Thompson.

What did you do, look up every Caroline

until one matched your crazy theory?

No, I d...

Girls, come on, let's go.

No, that's the same last name that was on Bethany's fake ID.

Caroline was writing up fake oxy prescriptions and selling them.

[Sighs] Please, just look at the report.

You can't unload dad on a new family

just 'cause you don't wanna deal with him.

I don't even know who you are anymore.

I hope you mess up in front of the scout.

I don't wanna go to the same college as you.

Hey, Bethany? Help me stretch?

[Indistinct chatter]

Welcome. Our bench is down here.

I am so excited for you to see the team play

and, of course, my girls.

- [Whistle blows] - Whoo-hoo!

[Caroline] Yes! Let's go, girls!

Good job, nice pass!

- [Cheering] - [Whistle blows]

- Yay! - Whoo!

Way to go, toffees!

[Indistinct chatter]

[Caroline laughs]

Gabi! What are you doing?

Uh, nothing. Just looking for your lip gloss.

Where are you going? Game's about to start back up.

Uh, just going to the bathroom. Is that okay with you?

[Indistinct chatter]

[Gasps]

[Cell phone beeps]

Gabi saw my ID.

I finally found a good man.

A man I love who actually loves me.

I'm not gonna let her ruin it.

Time to play the game your way.

[Gabriella] Bethany's real name is Beth-Anne Thompson.

She's not 17, she's 23! She was arrested for assault.

From what I can piece together, it seems like

Caroline was hooking up with some rich guy

and was taking him for everything he was worth.

"He figured out he was being used

when he discovered she'd done this before,

and Beth-Anne was his wife's sister, not her daughter.

She lied to get sympathy as a single mom

and so her sister could live with them."

And when he tried to kick them out, Beth-Anne assaulted him.

They don't name the other woman, but you think it was Caroline?

[Scoffs] Oh, I know it was Caroline.

- We have to tell dad. - We have to be smart about it.

Apparently, the guy needed 18 stitches

when Bethany was done with him.

It was 19, actually.

[Breathing heavily]

[Caroline] Scream, and I'll shoot.

Come on, give me your phone.

- Come on, you, too. - Uh, I left it with my stuff.

Check her.

[Annabelle gasps]

[Intense music]

[Breathing heavily]

I'm sorry I doubted you.

I should have been more dialed in.

[Caroline] I'm sorry, but it's come to this,

but Tim and I belong together, okay?

I'm not gonna let you tear us apart.

- I love him. - Oh you mean you love his money.

[Laughs] Yes.

Yes, I appreciate his money. Just like you.

Well, you like your house a-and your clothes and your life.

You didn't have to work for any of that. Okay?

So why am I so evil for wanting a piece of that?

You know, it's not just the money.

- I love your father. - Okay, okay!

Just, please don't hurt us.

Y-You're a doctor. You-you swore an oath.

You mean I was a doctor

until a goody two shoes like you stuck her nose

where it didn't belong. So I was selling fake prescriptions?

Okay, I needed the money for Beth.

Not everyone gets it handed to 'em like you.

Have a little sympathy for a single mother.

You know, you can drop the single-mom act.

I know you two are sisters.

Oh, when you said you knew what it was like

living in your sister's shadow,

you were talking about Caroline, right?

It must be hard having to pretend you're still a teenager,

having your sister boss you around.

- Shut up. - But I guess it's worth it.

The hardworking single-mom act sure worked on our dad.

[Cell phone ringing]

- Where are you? Hello? - [Muffled rumbling]

[Gabriella] You know, you won't get away with killing us.

[Annabelle] Our dad will figure it out.

[Caroline laughs] Your faith in your dad is so touching.

He wants to see the best in everyone.

He won't believe I had anything to do with your deaths.

[Intense music]

[Gabrielle] Where are you taking us?

[Caroline] To a very special place.

To make some new memories.

[Annabelle] You think you can kill us

and our dad won't suspect anything?

This doesn't end in a happily ever after for anyone.

Sure it does, because Tim is resilient.

Look how he moved on from your dead mother.

But poor gabi, hm,

couldn't accept her new family.

She's been spiraling out of control for months.

Oh, everybody's seen it, she finally cracked

under the pressure of that scout coming to the game,

realizing that soccer was all that she had left,

she wasn't even good enough at that.

[Tires screeching]

[Gasps]

So you came here,

yeah, to where your mom died

and you threw yourself off a cliff. Annabelle figured it out.

But unable to bear it, she joined you.

- You can't get away with this. - Of course.

Your dad is gonna be devastated,

but with me and Bethany by his side, he'll get over it.

- Match your opponent! - [Grunting]

- [Gabriella] Get it, Annabelle! - [Breathing heavily] Get away!

You don't wanna hurt your baby brother.

It's a lie. She's faking it.

She's not pregnant.

[Bethany grunts]

[Caroline] Beth, the gun!

No!

- No. - [Gunshot]

[Gabriella panting]

[Annabelle] You shot my sister!

[Tim] Annabelle! Gabriella! Oh, my god!

[Gabriella breathing heavily]

Hold this, I got 9-1-1 on the line.

[Gabriella] I'm okay. [Annabelle] You're okay.

[Bethany] Caroline, we have to get out of here now!

Okay. You're gonna be okay.

I love you. Everything's gonna be okay.

Listen, you're gonna be okay. Everything's gonna be okay.

I'm gonna carry you out of here and, well, you lead the way.

- Okay. - Okay?

[Instrumental music]

Okay, the suspense is killing me.

Would you just open it already?

Don't get too excited, it's gonna be a no.

You don't know that, the doctor said if you

keep up with your physio and your stretching,

you'll be back on the field in no time.

They haven't seen me play.

Uh... okay, wait, wait, wait. Just...

Look, even if it is by some miracle yes,

I don't know about leaving dad alone.

There are plenty good local options.

Well, not with that kind of soccer program.

And not with your sister.

Dad was willing to believe Caroline's lies

because he didn't have anybody else.

[Sighs] Okay. Open it.

Things are slowly going back to normal

and, uh, I can't tell you how relieved I am.

Um, gotta call that order in. But good talk, man.

Thanks, Mike. You're a great friend.

Oh, and poker?

Thursdays?

- My place this week. You in? - All in.

- All right. - [Chuckles]

I think dad's gonna be okay.

Oh? To what do I owe this surprise visit, girls?

[Clears throat] "In consideration of everything

you've been through and in light of your incredible bravery,

Rossmore university has taken the unusual steps

of reviewing your play via recordings..."

I got a scholarship.

[Gabriella squeals]

[Both chuckling]

♪ One two one two three four ♪

That's my daughter up at bat. Which one is yours?

Whoo! Way to go, Brittney!

[Instrumental music]

♪ We leave home ♪

♪ and we found what we were looking for ♪

♪ oh oh oh ♪

♪ why'd you have to leave me in the dark ♪

♪ brokenhearted? ♪

♪ I can't keep crying over you ♪

♪ ooh ooh ooh ♪

♪ I can't keep crying over you ♪

♪ I can't keep crying over you ♪

♪ ooh ooh ooh ♪

♪ oh oh ooh ooh ♪

♪ no whoa-oh oh-oh ♪

♪ no oh-oh ooh-ooh ♪

♪ no whoa-oh oh-oh ♪

[Upbeat music]

♪ Hands up hands up ♪

♪ shimmy to the left don't give up ♪

♪ hey ♪ ♪ today is my day ♪

♪ ah-ah ♪

♪ hands up put your hands up ♪

♪ shimmy to the right never give up ♪

♪ hey ♪ ♪ today is your day ♪

[Music continues]

♪ Yeah ♪

♪ hands up hands up ♪

♪ shimmy to the left don't give up ♪

♪ ooh ♪

♪ today is my day ♪

♪ yeah gotta put your hands up hands up ♪

♪ shimmy to the left don't give up ♪

♪ ooh ♪

♪ today is your day ♪

♪ today is your day ♪