Original subtitles

Look out!

Move it. Councilwoman? Let's go.

Councilwoman Escalante?

Councilwoman. Get in there, in.

Councilwoman Escalante!

Was she more than a housekeeper? Councilwoman?

What was your husband's relationship

with Abby Sandoval?

Relationship with Abby...

Was she more than a housekeeper?

Councilwoman.

No comment about that.

Councilwoman...

how will your husband's

murder trial affect your reelection campaign?

Stop. Let me go.

I'm going to tell your wife.

( muffled screams )

No!

( starter faltering )

( gunshot )

( glass shattering )

MAN: This shouldn't take long.

BAILIFF: Take your seats.

Court will be in session in five minutes.

WOMAN: Straighten your tie.

( whispering ): Hey, Horatio,

we got a problem.

Speed, I'm under subpoena.

I'm about to testify.

You might want to reconsider that.

Remember that call

I rolled out on this morning?

The Jane Doe?

Mm-hmm.

She was familiar.

How familiar?

Young, pretty Latina.

Single gunshot, close range, left temple.

Okay.

Alexx, Jane Doe?

I just got her, Horatio.

I'll have results within the hour.

Okay, Alex, I need something right now.

Mint leaves in her stomach.

Swallowed whole.

I'm guessing tox will say they're from a mojito,

just like Abby Sandoval.

Okay, thank you.

There's a flag on the play, Don.

I can't testify today.

Why the hell not?

Family emergency.

My grandmother's ill.

You were the last nail in the coffin.

That's why I've been saving you for last.

I understand that, but I need more time.

I've got none to give you.

Don, I need you to make more time.

Your grandma better be bleeding from her eyeballs.

24 hours.

Okay.

Fastest scalp on the east.

I think I just set some kind

of postmortem speed record.

Is she that similar to Abby Sandoval?

Like looking in the mirror.

Both victims in their early 20s.

Pretty, Latina, shot once in the head,

left temple, mint leaves

in the stomach, both worked with their hands.

Now, I'm thinking Jane Doe here may have been a domestic,

just like Abby was.

She couldn't have been killed

by Lorenzo Escalante,

because he was in custody at the time of her death.

How are they different?

Abby Sandoval has glass frag in her wound track.

Not surprising since she was shot

through the window of her car.

Didn't find any glass on Jane Doe.

Where did you find her?

Dumped roadside, no car.

Or maybe we haven't found her car yet.

You thinking we got a serial?

I don't know.

But we better find out

before we send an innocent man to jail for murder.

* Yeah!

Captioning sponsored by CBS

and CSI PRODUCTIONS

* We don't get fooled again

* Don't get fooled again

* No, no!

Hey.

You busy?

Oh, I'm up to my ass in alligators.

There was a big shooting on the Causeway yesterday.

54 expended rounds.

Not to mention, Detective Hagen is riding me

like a Gulfstream Park pony.

John Hagen?

Yeah.

Hmm.

Sure.

Nine mil, hollow point.

It's brass-jacketed.

So my guess is it's a Golden Talon.

Isn't that case on trial right now?

Mm-hmm.

Okay. Quickly and quietly.

Thank you.

What do you got?

Denise, the court reporter, told me

that Escalante's lawyers have been filing motions all morning.

Means they're moving

to get the case thrown out of court,

so we have to work fast.

Here you go. Jane Doe's clothes?

Tape it and scrape it.

You know what we're looking for, right?

Two fibers found on Abby Sandoval.

Worsted wool and tropical weight.

Exactly right.

Just like Escalante's $2,000 suits.

Speed, keep me posted.

Eric.

H.

Listen, sorry to bug you on your day off.

It's not a problem.

I was, uh, thinking of doing some diving anyway.

Might as well do it on the county time, huh?

One question. What's that?

Speedle's Jane Doe-- she wasn't a floater.

Why do you want me to bring my dive gear

to the crime scene?

Abby Sandoval.

Sandoval?

I thought that investigation was closed.

Officially it is.

DON: Horatio?

I'll meet you out there.

Yeah?

How's grandma?

It's too soon to tell.

Still running tests.

Anything you'd like to share?

Not just yet.

Grandma likes her privacy.

You want to know what I really like?

What's that?

I like smoking a Montecristo Number Two

after winning a slam-dunk case.

Your grandma wouldn't be trying to screw me out of a good cigar?

Want to make sure that we find the right guy.

We've got the right guy.

Lorenzo Escalante.

He had an affair with the maid.

He admits to getting rough with her.

Got his semen inside of her, his DNA under her fingernails.

Yes, Don, but we don't have the gun.

Look, Horatio, we're on the same side.

I'd like to think so.

Yeah, well, we are in the middle of the trial.

We've already picked the jury.

We've called our experts.

We spent over a million dollars in taxpayers' money.

We have new evidence.

Yeah, well, that's what appeals are all about.

Listen, this is not about the case anymore.

Now, it's about winning.

Well, you know what then?

We're not on the same side.

( garbled radio transmission )

H.

What do we got?

Park Ranger found our Jane Doe

on the side of the road.

Okay.

Here we go.

All right.

Well, she wasn't killed here.

There's not enough blood for a head shot, right?

Yeah. She could have been dumped.

I've got a couple of guys on the road

preserving some tread marks.

CAINE: Okay. Eric?

Check this out.

All right, blood trail.

Adelle, pull your men

off the road.

We're going to expand the crime scene.

She crawled in here...

probably rested for a moment...

losing a lot of blood...

continued to travel...

and somehow got up.

Fell again right here.

Wait a minute.

Is that a shadow right there?

That's definitely a car.

Looks like a compact.

Never turtled.

The water's too shallow.

So, she crawled from here all the way to the road.

A quarter of a mile on her belly,

with a nine-millimeter round in her head.

All for nothing.

Not if we can help it.

( hydraulic whirring )

The window's spider-webbed.

Could have shattered when Jane Doe got shot,

just like Abby Sandoval.

The difference is Jane Doe had no glass in her wound.

I'll SPR the steering wheel, see if we can lift a print

give her a name.

You know what? Don't bother.

I got her purse here.

Any I.D.?

Hang on.

There's no driver's license, but here's a check-cashing card.

"Bonita Cruz, Southwest Tenth Street."

It's a couple of blocks from my folks.

Abby Sandoval lived in the same neighborhood.

She did.

Southwest 14th Street, right?

Yeah, I know a lot of girls like that.

They come from Cuba, Honduras, Nicaragua

looking for a better life.

They wind up cleaning toilets in Bal Harbour.

It's the "invisible ones."

Perfect victims.

No one gives them a second look.

Somebody gave this one a second look.

Whoop.

Someone also left us a present.

Let's bag that.

Eric, you used to play right field

for the 'Canes, right?

See how far you can throw that.

Nice throw.

Okay, here's what we need to do.

Let's set a grid from the car

to where the rock landed.

In case the guy tossed the gun.

Yup.

Keep in touch.

HAGEN: Duquesne.

Detective Hagen.

You got my results?

Not since you called me an hour ago.

You told me you'd have it done this morning.

John, I have got 54 rounds, and your being down here

isn't going to help me solve it any faster.

Am I bothering you here in your nice, air-conditioned

crime lab, 'cause I'm sweating my butt off

trying to get my causeway shooter

into arraignment.

All right. Your personal hygiene aide, I'm really sorry.

Something came up, and I got backed up.

What kind of something?

I can't tell you, but I promise you

as soon as I get this other thing off my scope

I will finish yours.

Whatever it is better be big.

It's the biggest.

Big like Abby Sandoval?

I heard about what happened in court this morning.

Word is Horatio really stepped in it.

We'll get your shooter.

I just need you to give me some time.

I can't hold him past noon.

Cut him loose.

Re-arrest him again tomorrow.

What if he skips?

Put a radio car on him.

I don't know, John.

I have to do it.

I hope Horatio knows what he's doing.

He's been doing it a long time.

Hope he gets to keep doing it.

Hi. Hey.

I found a whole bunch of fibers on Bonita Cruz's dress.

You get a match?

Yeah. Tropical weight worsted wool.

Seemed like the two we pulled off of Abby Sandoval.

I hate to say it, but I think

we've got the wrong guy in custody.

But you just said you got multiple fibers

off Bonita's dress.

Over 50.

You got two off Abby's.

That doesn't track.

Neither does a serial killer

who wears $2,000 suits and kills maids.

Unless he's not a serial.

I think I figured out how he picks his victims.

Take a look at this.

Did you get something off the purse?

Yeah. Take a look.

Looks like newsprint.

The ink's way too degraded to read.

Okay, let's look deeper.

Freeze-drying.

It's a way to remove the water

without damaging the paper.

Ready?

Now try green with an IR filter.

SPEEDLE: "Empleos domesticos."

These are ads for housekeepers.

Mm-hmm. From a Cuban newspaper.

Diarios Las Americas.

So, Bonita Cruz was looking for a job.

You want me to take this?

Uh, no, I'll take it.

You find Eric.

Yelina.

Horatio. I heard about

the Surfside triple. Nice going.

Well, thank you.

Just came to pick up the final labs.

Okay, let me walk you.

Okay.

Sorry about dinner.

We've been really backlogged.

Yeah, I heard.

Seems like a lot of cases

are been moved to the back burner lately.

Call the City Council

and send me more criminalists

Let's talk about Abby Sandoval instead.

What about her?

Don't, okay?

Word around the department is you've reopened the case.

Mmm, word travels fast.

This is Miami.

There are no secrets, Horatio.

I have some concerns about the case.

Yeah. We've had this conversation before.

Well, then you know how it ends.

How long are we going to keep dancing around in circles?

I don't know.

Someday we have to talk about that, don't we?

Yeah. Someday.

Just be careful, Horatio.

If I did that, it would take all the fun out of it.

I'll call you.

Any trouble?

Hey.

Editor gave the usual First Amendment defense.

How'd you flip him?

I know the publisher.

Hm-hm-hmm. Any matches?

Not yet, unless you're interested in meeting

a 300-pound transvestite.

I'll pass.

Hang on a second. Horatio.

Hey, it's Speed.

We came up empty on the canal.

So, no gun?

Actually, Delko found three guns

and a washing machine, but, uh, no nine-mils.

Any chance that he missed it?

Let me ask him.

Any chance you could have missed it?

It's pretty murky down there.

We did a hand-over-hand rigid-grid search

100 yards downstream.

You get that?

Yeah, have Eric throw another rock.

Uh-huh.

All right, I'll tell him.

What'd he say?

"Throw another rock."

What does that mean?

It means we got a long night ahead of us.

SEVILLA: Looks like Bonita Cruz circled three ads

for domestic work.

Any stand out?

Yeah, this one.

600 bucks a week.

Rates have gone up.

Okay, seems like a good place to start.

The number listed in the ad doesn't answer,

but the prefix strikes me

as one of those prepaid cell phones.

Use it, toss it, you can't trace it.

Looks like that ad you're looking for

was a mail-in.

Printed on your basic laser jet, huh?

Do you have the envelopes

these come in?

Yeah.

We've got mail.

SEVILLA: There's no return address.

But that's a postal code right there.

Councilwoman Mercedes Escalante.

You don't think she had anything to do with it?

I don't know.

Let's find out.

CAINE: Good morning.

Good morning.

I'm Carl Galaz.

I'm special assistant to the councilwoman.

How can we assist Miami's finest today, hmm?

Here's what we need, Carl.

I need to know who has access to your office machines.

Well, that's everyone in this office.

We have six staffers and about a dozen interns.

What's this about?

Two things.

I'm going to need a list of those names,

and I'm going to need to take the machines to my lab.

Hmm. Oh, afraid we can't do that.

Not without our lawyers present.

You want to make that call, please?

MERCEDES: Actually, it's my call.

Lieutenant Caine.

Mercedes Escalante.

I have followed your career for many years.

Likewise, Councilwoman.

You will have our full cooperation.

The sooner we can get to the truth, the sooner

my husband can come home to his family.

Please take anything you need

and we'll be happy

to supply you with a list of everyone

that has worked in the office for the past 12 months.

Carl?

This is very generous of you.

Oh, well,

we're really looking forward

to putting all of this behind us, Lieutenant.

Um...

would you give us a second?

Oh, absolutely.

Thank you, Carl.

Adelle.

Be right there.

The councilwoman knew we were coming.

It's not what you think.

What do I think?

I know Mercedes,

since we were kids at San Juan Bosco

but she runs the community

and when I need information, she gives it to me.

One hand washes the other.

Together they wash the face.

Come on, H., you know that's the way things get done

here in Miami.

I understand that, Adelle.

H., it was

a courtesy heads-up, nothing more.

Nothing more than I would have done

in any other knock-and-talk.

Okay.

Let's not give her any more help, all right?

Okay.

Hey, where's that pistol?

Uh, I checked it into evidence a couple hours ago.

What are you talking about?

You mean it's just been sitting there?

Yeah, I paged you and you never answered.

I turned my pager off when I was on the range.

I tried to get in touch with you.

I've been chained at the lab with a 54-round shooting

that was supposed to be processed 12 hours ago.

Yeah, well I spent the same 12 hours

inhaling sewage at the bottom of the Tamiami Canal,

so everyone's got a sad story.

I'm sorry.

Me, too.

Okay.

We're do in court in two hours,

is there any way to link these two?

Not with the bullets alone.

The rifling on Abby's bullet is good,

but Bonita's is damaged.

But there's no way to match this to Abby or the gun,

but there might be another way.

Cartridge casing we found in Bonita's car.

Exactly.

So if I can get a test-fire on the pistol,

then I get match the rifling on Abby's bullet

to the firing-pin impression

of Bonita's casing.

The gun is the key.

Without it we've got nothing.

We've got to get it.

The clock is ticking.

( cocking gun )

( clicking ) Misfire.

( cocking )

( clicking )

Okay, we've got a problem.

Can't get a test-fire.

Not with this weapon

and not in the amount of time we have left.

What's your Plan B?

Gun vault.

Be still my heart.

( gunshots )

DUQUESNE: Hey.

CAINE: How'd we do?

I did a mix and match from the vault

and finally got a test-fire.

Bottom line?

Bonita Cruz and Abby Sandoval were killed by the same weapon.

We got a match.

We got a match.

Excellent. Nice going.

Thank you.

( whispering ): Based on what I was just given...

It has come to my attention that the Crime Lab

has uncovered new evidence in this case.

Evidence of an exculpatory nature to the defendant.

As such, defense counsel has moved for a mistrial.

So granted.

This court is adjourned.

( gavel bangs )

Horatio, I'm not going to take

the fall with you on this one, I warned you.

It's not an acquittal.

It's a mistrial.

You can re-file.

You got the extra million bucks for the new trial?

I'm about to bring you two defendants.

Yeah, you do that.

In a stunning setback for the Miami-Dade Crime Lab,

and the State Attorney's office,

real-estate developer Lorenzo Escalante

was released today after a mistrial was declared

in the Abby Sandoval...

I can't believe they're letting this jackass walk.

I hope H. knows what he's doing.

You know what they say, no guts, no glory.

What else could we do if you want to catch the killer?

Yeah, killers.

Okay, well, say there's two killers.

How do you explain the same fibers, the same murder weapon,

same taste for mojitos?

Apples and oranges.

We got two fibers you find on Abby,

but over 50 on Bonita.

Abby's killer keeps the gun, Bonita's tosses it in the canal.

Okay, how did the second killer

get their hands on the gun from the first murder?

You talking about the apple or the orange?

Oh, dear God,

I'm hungry.

I'm just saying there's two killers.

The second killer couldn't possibly have

all the details from the first murder.

Maybe he did.

Maybe he did have the details

and that would make him a copycat, wouldn't it?

Right?

So I'm a copycat

and I want to make Bonita Cruz look my second victim.

I've selected Bonita

because she is almost identical to Abby Sandoval.

So you place a want ad

for a young Latino housekeeper.

You offer top salary.

You buy a disposable cell phone so you can't be traced.

DUQUESNE: And like Abby she has to be pretty

so you meet her in person,

someplace public so she doesn't get spooked.

And when you meet Bonita Cruz, you know you have your victim.

Right, so you hire Bonita.

You follow her.

You pull her over, and then you shoot her.

With the gun you procured from your first murder.

Then you plant the fibers.

Push the car into the canal.

And throw the gun in for us to find.

Let's prove that.

CAINE: Alexx...

how tall was Bonita Cruz?

About five six.

And her wound track?

Left to right, angle is downward

an inch below the hairline.

Show me.

They don't line up.

Here's why.

The shot that killed Bonita Cruz

did not go through this window.

Bang at the temple.

Bang at the window.

There were two shots.

CAINE: There were two shots.

Another nine mil.

There you have it.

That means the killer

copied everything down to the smallest detail

including shooting out the driver-side window.

You can't plan detail because events are random.

They can never be perfectly recreated.

One thing he didn't count on

was her rolling down the window.

So he rolled it back up and fired again.

( gunshot )

We know of two people that directly benefit

from the existence of Bonita Cruz, right.

Lorenzo Escalante.

Guy has motive,

he's got connections, so he hires a guy.

DUQUESNE: Well, it doesn't have to be a guy.

Women commit 17% of all homicides

and being connected to a murder conviction

could ruin your political career.

You're still thinking it's the wife?

It seems out of character.

What I hear, she used to run with a pretty rough crowd.

CAINE: She campaigned on it.

But we still have to put her

outside this car.

Horatio.

I have someone you should meet.

SEVILLA: She claims she's more comfortable in Spanish.

This is Carmen Abregon.

She's one of those 43 women we tracked down

via cell phone records.

She responded to that ad in the Diario.

Okay.

Bad feeling?

Do you remember what the man looked like?

SEVILLA: Hey, what's up?

You still got that list Galaz gave us?

Yeah, it's... right here.

I think I've got an idea.

I think I've got an idea.

Speed, see what else you can do with this.

Will do.

It's just a list.

Actually, it may be much more.

CAINE: Writing on a notepad leaves indentations

on the pages beneath.

We should be able to see

what was written up to seven layers above.

How'd we do?

See anybody you know?

Carl Galaz.

Escalante's handler.

Let's see how Carl handles this.

Carl Galaz,

you're under arrest for the murder of Bonita Cruz.

You know what you just did?

Your career is over.

When I'm through with you,

you're going to be doing time cards at County lockup.

( phone ringing )

Still got the phone, Carl.

You still have the phone.

( beeping )

You've got seven dollars

of call time left, Carl.

Seven dollars in exchange for the rest of your life.

Take him.

Carl, I think I understand what's going on here.

You killed Bonita Cruz to get Lorenzo

off the hook for murder.

I understand that part.

What I'm curious about

is whose gun was it?

It was my gun.

I have advised my client not to speak further.

I want that on the record.

Counselor, I'll get you a copy.

How would that be?

Carl, you are about to take the fall.

Now, is that what this is?

I killed them.

I killed them both.

Why, Carl, are you protecting the Escalantes?

The Escalantes gave me their trust

and their friendship.

They gave me respect.

Now I owe them everything.

This is your last chance.

You can either ride their coattails or you can ride mine.

You decide.

Carl...

I killed them.

All right.

MERCEDES: Lieutenant...

Lieutenant Caine.

I just wanted to thank you

for all your hard work on behalf of the city.

You can't imagine

how shocked we all are to learn about Carl.

Councilwoman, I'm certain this has been

a very difficult period for you.

I also wanted to thank you as a... as a wife--

for clearing my husband.

If there's anything I can ever do for you,

for your aspirations...

Right now, Councilwoman, my only aspiration

is to find out who killed these women.

So don't thank me yet.

I'm not done.

( keyboard clacking )

How we doing on the employee list?

It matches

the handwriting sample from Carl Galaz.

It was pretty messy and overlapping,

but I measured the stroke depth

and I managed to isolate the layers.

It was seven pages in all, dating back week by week.

We get to the fifth week, he writes a to-do list.

"Buy gloves, clean gun, disposable cell phone."

Isn't it ironic?

To-do list.

He's not the first to do that,

but it doesn't confirm who killed Abby Sandoval, does it?

No, but that's why I went back to the second week,

and "Barbecue."

I'm thinking that's not a lunch order.

And it's not Galaz's handwriting.

No, it's not. Guess whose it is?

I got this from public records.

A city lease drafted by...

Lorenzo Escalante.

Lorenzo... you're about to lose your lease.

John!

I got the results for your Causeway shooter.

It matches across the aboard.

He's going away.

You got that right.

Patrol picked him up already.

I thought you needed ballistics to file on him.

We got ballistics.

He shot someone else after we cut him loose.

I thought you were going to watch him.

We did.

He got into a beef with street-level dealer;

grabbed his gun and put two rounds in him

before our guys could get out of the car.

God, I am so sorry.

One lowlife pops another.

The streets are safer for it.

Just be glad it wasn't a taxpayer,

for you and Horatio's sake.

Oh, no, that release was my call.

He didn't have anything to do with it.

Listen, I know you look up to the guy...

Sure, I do. I'm just saying,

it's a hell of a lonely road he's walking.

Well, that's why I'm walking it with him.

I don't know what we think we're going to find.

We went over the Escalante place

about eight months ago.

Canine units, metal detectors-- the works.

Now, there's nothing inside.

No hidden safes inside,

and there's nothing buried in this backyard.

Did you check the barbecue?

Three across...

three down.

CAINE: Hmm.

Golden Talon...

just like the one we took out of Abby Sandoval.

( gunshot; glass shatters)

( ball clinks in hole) ( laughing )

Yes! Yes!

Yes! Lock that elbow, Lorenzo.

( chuckles )

Well, we'll have to talk to the Membership Committee.

They're letting anyone in these days.

CAINE: Speaking of which...

Tell him what he's won, Adelle.

It's a new kind of membership:

gated estate,

private room, high security.

And here's the best part:

It's for life.

( chuckles )

Mercedes...

call the lawyer.

This is harassment.

Take him.

You can't do this.

You can't do this.

Mercedes...

( handcuffs clicking )

Mercedes.

Mercedes...

Mercedes!

Mercedes!

Want to take a walk?

So what does Carl get?

A pardon in four years, after you take residency

in the governor's mansion in Tallahassee?

Be very careful, Lieutenant Caine.

False accusations can ruin a career.

Mm-hmm.

I'd hate for that career to be yours.

Councilwoman...

that is a blade; it cuts both ways.

( clamoring voices )

Your public awaits you.

Councilwoman Escalante, do you think he did it?

How will this affect your reelection campaign?

Councilwoman, do you have any comment?

This is a tragedy.

It has affected my family deeply.

I will persevere...

( doorbell rings )

Hi.

Hi.

Are you... hungry for some ropa vieja?

I already ate.

How about dessert?

Finished that too.

Mm.

You should've called.

You're right.

I have, uh...

I've been thinking about Raymond.

I think about him everyday.

I don't want to go there.

Too complicated.

What if I were to say

that you wouldn't have to go there alone?

Do you understand what you're saying?

I do.

I haven't had coffee yet.

Captioning sponsored by CBS

and CSI PRODUCTIONS

Captioned by Media Access Group at WGBH access.wgbh.org