All language subtitles for VICE.News.Tonight.2019.04.05.WEBRip.x264-ION10

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish Download
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

♪ ♪

>> TONIGHT...

>> THE SYSTEM IS FULL. CAN'T TAKE YOU ANYMORE.

CAN'T TAKE YOU ANYMORE. I'M SORRY.

>> LEFT IS A DIRTY WORD IN ISRAEL.

>> DO I THINK ART CAN SAVE THE PLANET?

I DO, ACTUALLY.

>> IN FORMER VICE PRESIDENT JOE BIDEN'S FIRST PUBLIC

APPEARANCE SINCE SEVEN WOMEN SAID HE TOUCHED THEM

INAPPROPRIATELY, HE SPOKE TO A MOSTLY MALE AUDIENCE

OF ELECTRICAL WORKERS.

>> I JUST WANT YOU TO KNOW I HAD PERMISSION TO HUG LONNIE.

>> AFTER HINTING AT AN APOLOGY WITHOUT ACTUALLY APOLOGIZING,

BIDEN HINTED AT 2020 WITHOUT ACTUALLY DECLARING.

>> THIS WHOLE EPISODE OF THE PAST WEEK, IS THIS GOING TO

CHANGE HOW YOU CAMPAIGN?

>> WELL, I THINK IT'S GOING TO HAVE TO CHANGE SOMEWHAT

HOW I CAMPAIGN.

>> MOTEL 6 WILL PAY $12 MILLION TO SETTLE A LAWSUIT FILED BY

WASHINGTON STATE, WHICH ALLEGES THE COMPANY SHARED INFORMATION

ON 80,000 GUESTS WITH IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS

ENFORCEMENT. THE SUIT SAYS I.C.E. TARGETED

CUSTOMERS WITH LATINO‐SOUNDING NAMES, LEADING TO AT LEAST

NINE ARRESTS. AFTER PRIME MINISTER

THERESA MAY'S BREXIT PLAN WAS REJECTED THREE TIMES

BY BRITAIN'S PARLIAMENT, SHE DECIDED TO CONTINUE

HER WINNING STRATEGY OF ASKING FOR THE SAME THING

AND HOPING FOR A NEW RESULT. TODAY MAY ASKED THE E. U.

TO EXTEND THE BREXIT DEADLINE FOR THE SECOND TIME TO JUNE 30.

SHE'LL GET HER ANSWER NEXT WEDNESDAY.

DEFAMATION LAWSUITS FILED BY SEVEN WOMEN AGAINST BILL COSBY

HAVE BEEN SETTLED IN FEDERAL COURT BUT APPARENTLY NOT

BY COSBY. HIS ATTORNEY SAYS HIS INSURER

SETTLED WITHOUT HIS CLIENT'S CONSENT AND THAT COSBY'S STILL

PURSUING HIS COUNTERCLAIMS OF

DEFAMATION AGAINST THE WOMEN.

>> GAZA! GAZA STRIP.

>> ISRAEL IS IN THE HOMESTRETCH

OF A CRITICAL GENERAL ELECTION, SET FOR THIS COMING TUESDAY.

BUT LIKE A LOT OF ISRAELIS, EYAL HAJBI HAS ALREADY

MADE UP HIS MIND. HE'S VOTING FOR THE PARTY

OF FOUR‐TERM PRIME MINISTER BENJAMIN NETANYAHU.

>> LIKUD. WHY?

>> WHAT IS IT?

>> IT'S SNIPER FIRE.

>> IT ISN'T JUST ISRAELIS WITHIN

RANGE OF GAZA WHO OVERWHELMINGLY SUPPORT NETANYAHU.

POLLS SHOW NETANYAHU AS THE FAVORITE TO BE PRIME MINISTER

ONCE MORE. WHICH MIGHT BE SURPRISING,

CONSIDERING THAT HE'S FACING INDICTMENT ON THREE CORRUPTION

CHARGES. SOME VOTERS HERE JUST DON'T SEEM

TO CARE.

>> WHO YOU VOTING FOR IN THE ELECTIONS?

>> BUT WHAT DO YOU CARE ABOUT? DO YOU CARE ABOUT SECURITY?

DO YOU CARE ABOUT THE ECONOMY? WHAT ARE THE BIGGEST ISSUES?

>> THIS IS MY FATHER AND THIS IS NETANYAHU.

>> HE WAS FRIEND OF HIS.

>> AND YOU, DO YOU SUPPORT NETANYAHU?

>> YES.

>> WHAT IS IT THAT YOU LIKE ABOUT HIM?

>> HE'S A TOUGH MAN.

>> TOUGH MAN. LIKUD'S ONLY REAL CHALLENGE

IS FROM A NEWLY FORMED CENTRIST ALLIANCE, CALLING ITSELF BLUE

AND WHITE, WHICH IS TRYING TO POSITION ITSELF AS A UNIFIER,

NETANYAHU WITHOUT THE BAGGAGE.

>> I WAS RAISED IN A VILLAGE WHERE RELIGIOUS AND SECULAR

PEOPLE LIVED SIDE BY SIDE AND IT

WAS NEVER A PROBLEM AND I WILL

‐‐ WE KNOW HOW TO LIVE ONE BESIDE THE OTHER.

I WILL DO IT ON THE NATIONAL LEVEL AS WELL.

>> BLUE AND WHITE IS LED BY THREE FORMER CHIEFS OF THE

ISRAELI DEFENSE FORCES. AND IT'S LEANING HEAVILY

ON THOSE MILITARY CREDENTIALS TO CHIP AWAY AT LIKUD'S CONTROL.

IN THIS CAMPAIGN AD, PARTY LEADER BENNY GANTZ COUNTS THE

NUMBER OF PALESTINIANS HE'S KILLED.

AT A PARTY EVENT, GANTZ SUGGESTED THAT BLUE AND

WHITE WOULD TRY TO COPY NETANYAHU'S STRATEGY, AND

PARTNER WITH HARDLINE RIGHT‐WING RELIGIOUS PARTIES TO FORM

A GOVERNING MAJORITY.

>> WE HAVE LEFT ASPECTS IN OUR PARTY, WE HAVE RIGHT ASPECTS IN

OUR PARTY, SO IF WE ARE THE BIGGEST PARTY, I THINK WE WILL

HAVE SUFFICIENT BASE TO START THE DIALOGUE FROM THERE AND WE

CAN DO IT.

>> ULTRA‐ORTHODOX PARTIES, POSSIBLY?

>> ALL OF THEM ARE POSSIBLE.

>> ARAB PARTIES?

>> I BASICALLY EXCLUDE NO ONE. THEY HAVE TO SUPPORT THE ZIONIST

IDEA AND THEY HAVE TO BE DEMOCRATIC AND THEY CANNOT BE

RACIST.

>> DO YOU NOT THINK BY SAYING THAT YOU'RE HAPPY TO WORK WITH

RIGHT‐WING PARTIES BUT HINTING THAT YOU MOST LIKELY WOULDN'T

WORK WITH LEFT‐WING POLITICIANS ARE ARAB POLITICIANS COME IN THE

LONG TERM YOU COULD POTENTIALLY FEED INTO HATRED, DIVIDE, AND

INSTABILITY?

>> DEFINITELY NOT. WE HAVE BEEN MEETING

WITH ALL OF THEM. SO I THINK WE WILL BE ABLE TO

UNIFY THE COUNTRY. FAR MORE THAN WHAT NETANYAHU IS

DOING RIGHT NOW.

>> ONE REASON BIGGER PARTIES AREN'T CATERING TO THE LEFT IS

BECAUSE IT'S SHRUNK SO DRASTICALLY.

TODAY, ONLY 12% OF ISRAELIS IDENTIFY AS LEFT‐WING.

A DEVELOPMENT WATCHED WITH FRUSTRATION BY FORMER PRIME

MINISTER EHUD BARAK, WHO OUSTED NETANYAHU IN 1999 AND WHO,

AS LEADER OF THE LIBERAL LABOR PARTY, PUSHED FOR MAKING PEACE

WITH THE PALESTINIANS. THESE DAYS, LABOR, AND THE

POLITICAL WILL FOR A NEGOTIATED PEACE HAVE ALL BUT VANISHED.

>> EVERYBODY WILL REMEMBER 2000

AND CAMP DAVID AND YOUR INABILITY TO GIVE THE

PALESTINIANS A STATE THAT THEY WANTED. DO YOU BEAR SOME OF THE

RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE FACT THAT PEOPLE IN ISRAEL PERHAPS NO

LONGER BELIEVE IN A PEACE PROCESS?

>> I DON'T THINK IT'S ABOUT RESPONSIBILITY.

I WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED UNDER MY COMMAND

WHEN I WAS PRIME MINISTERI DID WHAT I THOUGHT WAS RIGHT FOR THE

COUNTRY.

>> DO YOU THINK BENJAMIN NETANYAHU SHOULD LEAD

THE GOVERNMENT?

>> NO, I THINK NOT. HE DIVED RECENTLY INTO UNHOLY

ALLIANCES BETWEEN HIMSELF AND OTHERS WHO ARE BOTH CORRUPT AND

CORRUPTING. THOSE ZEALOTS, CRAZY RACIST

ZEALOTS ARE DICTATING TO HIM HOW TO OPERATE.

AND THEY ARE BLOCKING THE DEMOCRATIC LIFE OF ISRAEL,

AND THAT SHOULD BE REJECTED BY THE PEOPLE.

>> WHY IS IT THEN, PEOPLE IN ISRAEL AT THE

MOMENT, ACCORDING TO POLLS, STILL THINK THAT HE IS THE BEST

MAN TO LEAD THE COUNTRY INTO THE NEXT GOVERNMENT?

>> PROBABLY THE PEOPLE ARE WRONG.

SOMEONE HAS TO HELP THEM TO OPEN THEIR EYES.

IT IS USUALLY THE OPPOSITION.

>> BUT RIGHT NOW LABOR IS ‐‐ CENTER LEFT IS NOWHERE TO BE

SEEN.

>> EVEN NOW 5 DAYS BEFORE THE ELECTION, IF THEY

JUST WAKE UP AND CHARGE ON EVERY ARENA.

>> A SUCCESSFUL CHARGE FROM THE LEFT WOULD REQUIRE UNITY, AND

FEW JEWISH PARTIES ARE WILLING TO THROW THEIR LOT IN WITH THOSE

WHO COULD TIP THE BALANCE AGAINST NETANYAHU:

THE ISRAELI ARABS.

>> OFER CASSIF

FROM HADASH‐TA'AL, A COALITION OF COMMUNISTS AND

SECULAR ARABS IS ONE OF THE ONLY CANDIDATES OPENLY CANVASSING THE

ISOLATED COMMUNITY WHICH MAKES UP 20% OF THE POPULATION.

>> WE ARE NOT AN ARAB PARTY. WE ARE A JEWISH ARAB PARTY.

THEY CALL US EVERYONE HERE ARAB PARTIES.

>> IT'S A DIRTY WORD HERE?

>> YES, LIKE LEFT. LEFT NOW IS A DIRTY WORD

HERE IN ISRAEL. THAT'S ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE

ARE TRYING VERY HARD TO CHALLENGE.

IN MY VIEW, THE LABOUR PARTY IS

CONTINUOUSLY SINKING BECAUSE IT'S AFRAID.

AFRAID OF BEING A LEFTIST PARTY. YOU SHOULD PRESENT AN

ALTERNATIVE AND THEY DON'T. NOT A SERIOUS ONE, NOT A DEEP

ONE, JUST A COSMETIC ONE. CHICKENS.

THOSE CHICKENS ARE GOING TO THE

SLAUGHTER NAMED LIKUD.

>> TODAY PRESIDENT TRUMP PULLED

HIS OWN NOMINEE FOR DIRECTOR OF IMMIGRATION AND CUSTOMS

ENFORCEMENT.

>> RON'S A GOOD MAN, BUT WE'RE GOING IN A TOUGHER DIRECTION.

WE WANT TO GO IN A TOUGHER DIRECTION.

>> A FEW HOURS LATER, AT A MEETING WITH BORDER PATROL

IN CALIFORNIA, TRUMP REPEATED THREATS TO SHUT DOWN THE BORDER

AND IMPOSE NEW TARIFFS ON MEXICO THAT WOULD SUPERCEDE

A BRAND‐NEW TRADE DEAL. HE SEEMS TO BE TESTING OUT

POLICIES ON THE FLY.

>> THIS IS OUR NEW STATEMENT. THE SYSTEM IS FULL.

WE CAN'T TAKE YOU ANYMORE. CAN'T TAKE YOU ANYMORE.

I'M SORRY. LOOK, I INHERITED THIS STUFF

AND WE'RE GOING TO GET IT FIXED. WE HAVE TO.

>> IF HE INHERITED THIS "STUFF" FROM ANYONE, IT WAS OBAMA'S LAST

HOMELAND SECURITY SECRETARY, JEH JOHNSON, WHO FACED A SURGE

AT THE BORDER IN 2014, WHEN MORE THAN 68,000 UNACCOMPANIED

MINORS, MOSTLY FROM CENTRAL AMERICA, CROSSED ILLEGALLY.

>> SO TELL ME WHAT YOU SAID THAT PIQUED THE INTEREST OF THE

PRESIDENT ‐‐ ACTUALLY TWEETED ABOUT YOUR TV APPEARANCE.

>> I SAID THAT 4,000 ARRESTS ON OUR SOUTHERN BORDER, 100,000

IN A MONTH IS TRULY A CRISIS. I THEN WENT ON, TO IN THE SAME

INTERVIEW, DESCRIBE ALL THE THINGS THAT I THINK SHOULD BE

DONE TO DEAL WITH THE CRISIS AND WHAT WE SEEM TO BE DOING WRONG.

THE ONE SENTENCE, "IT IS TRULY A CRISIS," BASICALLY WENT VIRAL.

>> AND THE REASON FOR THIS OF COURSE IS THAT PEOPLE IN THE

ADMINISTRATION, THE PRESIDENT HIMSELF, AND HIS ALLIES

BASICALLY SAY SEE EVEN THE OBAMA GUY SAYS IT'S A CRISIS.

YOU HAVE TO BELIEVE US.

>> WELL, 4,000 IN A DAY, 100,000 IN A MONTH.

BY ANY MEASURE, BY ANY DEFINITION, IS A CRISIS.

THE FACT THAT PEOPLE AT THOSE LEVELS ARE LEAVING THOSE

COUNTRIES, IT'S A CRISIS IN TERMS OF OUR BORDER PERSONNEL'S

ABILITY TO HANDLE IT AND PROCESS ALL THOSE PEOPLE.

AND IT'S A CRISIS IN TERMS OF THE COMMUNITIES ALONG THE BORDER

THAT HAVE TO SOMEHOW ABSORB THOSE NUMBERS.

>> LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT THE CURRENT ADMINISTRATION.

ARE THEY DOING A GOOD JOB?

>> AS LONG AS YOU FAIL TO ADDRESS THE UNDERLYING

CONDITIONS THAT LEAD PEOPLE TO FLEE THE BURNING BUILDING IN THE

FIRST PLACE, IT'S GOING TO REVERT BACK TO ITS LONGER TERM

PATTERNS. AND THAT'S EXACTLY WHAT'S

HAPPENING. THAT'S HAPPENING ALL THROUGHOUT 2018.

BUT NOW IN MARCH, APRIL 2019, WE'RE SEEING LEVELS WE HAVEN'T

SEEN IN 12 YEARS SO PLAINLY WHAT WE ARE DOING TO ENFORCE OUR

IS NOT WORKING. PEOPLE IN WASHINGTON WANT

SIMPLE SOLUTIONS THEY WANT SOME LEGAL LEVER TO PULL LIKE CLOSE

THE BORDER OR DECLARE AN EMERGENCY TO SOLVE ILLEGAL

IMMIGRATION.

>> BUILD A WALL.

>> WE WANT QUICK FIXES. BUILD A WALL.

WE WANT QUICK FIXES. DEALING WITH ILLEGAL MIGRATION

FROM CENTRAL AMERICA REQUIRES A LONG TERM INVESTMENT AND A

SUSTAINED POLITICAL COMMITMENT IN ADDRESSING THE POVERTY

AND VIOLENCE IN THE NORTHERN TRIANGLE. WE'VE DONE THIS BEFORE.

IT CAN WORK IF DONE SMARTLY. SUSPENDING AID TO CENTRAL

AMERICA IS THE EXACT WRONG THING TO DO.

>> SO WHEN YOU WERE AT DHS, YOU'RE RUNNING DHS.

THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION, AS YOU WELL KNOW, WAS HEAVILY

CRITICIZED FOR ITS IMMIGRATION POLICY.

WHAT WAS IT THAT YOU DID THAT YOU THINK WAS SUCCESSFUL OVER

THAT PERIOD OF TIME AT MINIMIZING THE NUMBER OF PEOPLE

COMING OVER ILLEGALLY?

>> I WOULD SAY THREE THINGS CONTRIBUTED TO THE RATHER SHARP

DOWNTURN WE SAW IN SUMMER 2014 ONE: MESSAGING ABOUT THE DANGERS

OF THE JOURNEY. TWO: WE EXPANDED FAMILY

DETENTION, WHICH WAS CONTROVERSIAL.

AND THREE: WE GOT THE MEXICAN GOVERNMENT TO HELP US ON THEIR

SOUTHERN BORDER. THE MEXICANS STEPPED UP AND PUT

MORE BORDER SECURITY RESOURCES ON THEIR SOUTHERN BORDER WITH

CENTRAL AMERICA. AND THE COMBINATION OF THOSE

THREE THINGS I THINK CONTRIBUTED PRETTY QUICKLY AND PRETTY

SIGNIFICANTLY TO A DOWNTURN SUCH THAT BY 2015, WE SAW THE SECOND

LOWEST NUMBER OF APPREHENSIONS

SINCE 1972.

>> YOU LOOK AT THE WHERE WASHINGTON, D. C., IS TALKING

ABOUT THESE GOVERNMENTS AND TALKING ABOUT WHAT THEY WILL DO

TO ALLEVIATE THESE PROBLEMS. WHAT'S YOUR REACTION?

>> WHEN SOMEONE, THROUGH THEIR RHETORIC, CONTINUES TO DEMEAN

YOU AND DEMEAN WHO YOU ARE AS A GUATEMALAN, A HONDURAN,

A MEXICAN, IT BECOMES A MATTER OF NATIONAL HONOR.

THERE IS A WAY TO ACHIEVE OUR OWN INTEREST WITHOUT INSULTING

OUR NEIGHBORS.

>> BUT YOU KIND OF HAVE TO ADMIT, YOU KNOW, IT'S NOT EVEN

THAT MUCH OF A HETERODOX OPINION THAT YOU KIND OF HAVE TO ADMIT

IT WORKS. BUT DONALD TRUMP SAYS DOMESTICALLY WORKS.

PEOPLE VOTED FOR HIM. PEOPLE WANTED THAT WALL.

CHANTING THAT WALL. WORKS IN THIS COUNTRY.

>> NOW ON HIS WATCH IS THE HIGHEST IT'S BEEN IN 12 YEARS.

SO PLAINLY WHAT WE ARE DOING TO ENFORCE OUR BORDER SECURITY NOW

FOR THE LAST TWO YEARS IS NOT WORKING.

>> THE DAY TO START SOMETHING LIKE THIS, THE LIGHTS AREN'T

GOING TO COME ALL THE WAY ON. MOOD LIGHTING.

>> ELLIOT CRUMP IS THE SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENT IN SHELBY,

MONTANA, ONE OF THE COUNTLESS SMALL TOWNS

THAT'S RUN OUT OF TEACHERS.

>> THE KIDS THAT COME OUT OF BOZEMAN AND MISSOULA, THEY TEND

TO FOCUS ON LARGER CITIES. IT'S GOING TO BE NICE TO GET

THEM OUT HERE TO SEE WHAT IT'S LIKE AND HOPEFULLY GET THEM TO

JOIN THE RURAL TEACHING COMMUNITY.

>> 250 MILES AWAY AND BOZEMAN, 13 ASPIRING TEACHERS FROM

MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY HEADED OUT FOR SHELBY.

>> WHAT A GOOD MORNING.

>> SHALL BE MONTANA, I DON'T KNOW MUCH ABOUT IT.

I LOOKED IT UP ON GOOGLE MAPS. I ZOOMED IN.

IT LOOKED PRETTY BROWN. IT'S OKAY.

I'M NOT THERE FOR THE LANDSCAPE. I'M THERE FOR THE PEOPLE.

>> I LOVE SMALL TOWNS. I CAME FROM A SMALL TOWN AND

I'VE ALWAYS WANTED TO TEACH IN A SMALL SCHOOL. I AM SUPER STOKED.

>> YOU ARE APPROACHING YOUR DESTINATION.

>> GOOD MORNING. GOOD MORNING.

>> I WILL GO FIRST. I AM THE SUPERINTENDENT.

I USED TO TEACH SOCIAL STUDIES. I AM ORIGINALLY FROM THE SEATTLE

AREA.

>> I AM JAKE, ORIGINALLY FROM PLAINS MONTANA, GRADUATED THERE

IN 2016. I'M STUDYING ENGLISH TEACHING.

I WANT TO BE AN ENGLISH TEACHER.

>> MY NAME IS NED. I WHEN I GROW UP, I WANT TO BE

AN ART TEACHER.

>> I WOULD LOVE THE PRACTICUM STUDENTS TO GO THROUGH THIS

PROGRAM, ENJOY BEING HERE IN SHELBY.

WHEN I HAVE AN OPENING NEXT YEAR, THE YEAR AFTER THAT, THE

YEAR AFTER THAT, THINKING IT WOULD BE NICE TO BE ABLE TO GO

BACK TO SHELBY AND BE PART OF THAT COMMUNITY AND AT SCHOOL.

>> I DON'T KNOW IF IT'S GOING TO

WORK BUT I HOPE IT DOES.

>> SHALL BE MONTANA SPANNED SIX SQUARE MILES AND IS HOME TO

ABOUT 700 FAMILIES, ONE K‐12 SCHOOL, AND ONE

MAIN STREET THAT RUNS ONLY A FEW BLOCKS.

IT'S AN HOUR AND A HALF FROM THE NEAREST WALMART, THREE HOURS TO

THE NEAREST COSTCO, AND FOUR HOURS FROM THE NEAREST MAJOR

AIRPORT.

>> THERE ARE SOME DISTRICTS IN MONTANA THAT DON'T

GET AN APPLICANT FOR A JOB. EVEN 10 YEARS AGO, THEY WERE

STILL PULLING IN PEOPLE, GETTING APPLICATIONS, BEING MORE

SELECTIVE ABOUT WHO WE CAN HIRE. NOW IT'S JUST FIND SOMEONE.

>> DR. TENA VERSLAND RESEARCHES RURAL EDUCATION.

FOR THE LAST THREE YEARS, SHE'S HELPED RUN THE PROGRAM

THAT SENDS FUTURE TEACHERS ON A WEEK‐LONG DATE WITH

THE TOWNS THAT NEED THEM THE MOST.

>> IF YOU ARE A SCHOOL AND YOU CAN'T FILL POSITIONS, WHAT ENDS

UP HAPPENING TO YOUR OFFERINGS IN YOUR SCHOOL, YOUR STUDENTS?

>> YOUNG PARENTS START TO PULL THEIR KIDS OUT OF SCHOOL, START

SENDING THEM TO NEIGHBORING SCHOOLS.

MAYBE THEY LEAVE THAT AREA. SCHOOLS CAN'T FIND TEACHERS.

SCHOOLS DIED.

THE COMMUNITY DIES.

>> SHELBY ISN'T DEAD BUT IN SMALL TOWNS THROUGHOUT MONTANA,

THIS IS ALREADY AN EMERGENCY. NEARLY HALF OF ALL SCHOOLS IN

THE STATE NOW EMPLOY TEACHERS WHO AREN'T CERTIFIED.

AND ALMOST ALL OF THEM ARE IN

RURAL COMMUNITIES.

>> WHAT WAS YOUR TEMPERATURE?

>> 400. I THINK IT'S COOKED.

>> SO WE MET IN NEW YORK. WE STARTED DATING IN NEW YORK.

>> I WAS A CITY GIRL. I NEVER THOUGHT I WOULD BE,

LIKE, IN MONTANA WHEN I TOLD MY PARENTS

AND THEY'RE LIKE WHERE IS THAT? YOU'RE MOVING TO THE MOUNTAINS?

>> IT'S A STATE.

>> SO YOU'VE BEEN HERE FOR FIVE YEARS.

YOU'VE SEEN PEOPLE COME AND GO.

>> YEP. WHEN I FIRST MOVED HERE WE

HIRED 10 TEACHERS, AND I LOST 8 OF THEM WITHIN A YEAR OR TWO.

I HAVEN'T HEARD OF THINGS THAT I HAVEN'T TRIED.

IF I HEARD ABOUT IT, I WOULD HAVE TRIED IT.

>> ONE OF THE THINGS ELLIOT HAS PIONEERED: LOOKING OUTSIDE

OF THE COUNTRY FOR TEACHERS, IN PLACES WHERE $35,000 A YEAR

IS A SMALL FORTUNE. FOUR YEARS AGO, HE HIRED HIS

FIRST TEACHER FROM THE PHILIPPINES.

HE'S SINCE HIRED FOUR MORE.

>> IT'S LIKE OH, MY GOD. THIS IS REALLY A SMALL TOWN,

I DIDN'T EVEN SEE PEOPLE WALKING ON THE STREETS.

OH, MY GOSH. THIS IS KIND OF, YOU KNOW,

IT'S LIKE A GHOST TOWN OR SOMETHING.

>> I IMAGINE YOU WEREN'T LIKE "I'M GOING TO GO TEACH

IN SHELBY, MONTANA.

>> NO, NO. IT'S SHELBY WHO CHOSE ME.

EVEN THOUGH WE DON'T HAVE THAT MUCH OF SHOPPING MALLS

AND ALL THAT STUFF, WE LIKE THE SIMPLICITY OF SHELBY.

I COULD SEND MONEY TO MY FAMILY IN THE PHILIPPINES AND I COULD

ALSO SAVE MONEY. IT'S REALLY, REALLY HELPFUL.

>> SO BRINGING THE FILIPINO TEACHERS HERE HAS WORKED.

THEY'VE COME. THEY'VE WANTED TO STAY.

HOW IT WORKS IN THE LONG RUN, I'M NOT SURE.

THEIR VISA IS GOING TO BE AFTER FIVE ‐‐ WELL, THREE YEARS

AND THEN GET A TWO‐YEAR EXTENSION.

AFTER THAT, THEY'LL BE HEADING BACK TO THE PHILIPPINES.

>> IT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE A LONG‐TERM SOLUTION.

>> IT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE

A LONG‐TERM SOLUTION.

>> THAT'S WHY ELLIOT ‐‐ THE WHOLE TOWN,

ROLLED OUT THE RED CARPET FOR THE MSU STUDENTS.

>> WELCOME TO YOUR FAVORITE CLASS.

>> HOW ARE YOU ALL DOING?

>> WHEN THEY WEREN'T IN CLASSROOMS TEACHING, THEY WERE

GIVEN THIS STAR TREATMENT. THEY TOOK SHELBY'S FIRETRUCKS

OUT FOR A JOYRIDE. THEY SHOT GUNS.

AND THEY WENT BOWLING.

20‐SOMETHINGS WANT TO KNOW WHAT HAPPENS AFTER

8:00 P. M. ON A SCHOOL NIGHT.

>> OKAY, LET'S SEE THE FIRST ONE WE GET. OH, COME ON.

> HOW DO YOU UP YOUR AGE? I THINK I'M GONNA NEED

TO DO THAT.

>> OH, YEAH, DEFINITELY DO THAT.

>> I DON'T HAVE MANY OPTIONS. MOVE IT TO 50.

>> YOU COULD BE A BIG FISH IN A SMALL POND.

>> THAT'S TRUE. MAYBE.

>> HELLO.

>> I'M RACHELLE.

>> I'M JOSH.

>> SO FOR SOMEONE IN THEIR 20s, WHAT ARE THE SORT OF THINGS

THAT YOU END UP DOING?

>> WELL, OTHER THAN GOING OUT ON A COUNTY ROAD AND JUST SHOOTING

GOPHERS OR SHOOTING BASICALLY ANYTHING, I MEAN, AS FAR AS THE

COMMUNITY GOES, WE HAVE POOL LEAGUE, DART LEAGUE,

BOWLING LEAGUE.

WHEN YOU'RE BORED, YOU'RE BORED.

>> WHO HERE WOULD MOVE TO THIS AREA IF THEY WERE OFFERED A JOB

TODAY?

>> I'D HAVE TO TALK TO MY FIANCE.

I CAN'T TOTALLY PUT OUT MY HAND.

>> JAKE, YOU ARE DOWN TO MOVE HERE.

YOU WOULD MOVE HERE NOW BUT YOUR IMMEDIATE RESPONSE WAS IF I

CONVINCE MY FIANCE.

>> IT'D BE A HARD SELL. SHE'S AN INTERIOR DESIGNER

AND THERE'S PROBABLY NOT MANY INTERIOR DESIGN JOBS

AROUND SHELBY.

>> I THINK THE ISSUE IS A SOCIAL LIFE.

SO LIKE, THE SCHOOL'S GREAT. BUT WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO

OUTSIDE OF SCHOOL?

>> BOWLING LEAGUE.

[LAUGHTER]

>> SMALL TOWNS ARE PROBABLY NOT FOR EVERYBODY BUT YOU OWE IT TO

YOURSELF TO GIVE IT A CHANCE, TO DO MORE THAN DRIVE THROUGH IT.

EXPERIENCE IT FOR YOURSELF.

>> I DON'T KNOW HOW LONG I COULD STAY.

AND THAT'S, I THINK THAT'S THE PROBLEM WE'RE FACING.

AND I DON'T KNOW HOW I COULD HELP THAT.

>> WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE LED LIGHTS?

>> VERY FUTURISTIC.

>> DO YOU GUYS KNOW WHAT IT'S ABOUT?

>> NO.

>> NO.

>> JUST FOR LOOKS, I THOUGHT.

>> WHERE THAT LIGHT IS IT'S SUPPOSED TO SHOW HOW MUCH

SEA LEVELS WILL RISE, ACCORDING TO WHAT SCIENTISTS ARE

PREDICTING RIGHT NOW.

>> THAT'S HIGH.

>> VERY HIGH.

>> THE WORK, CALLED LINES, WAS INSTALLED BY FINNISH ARTISTS

TIMO AHO AND PEKKA NIITTYVIRTA A YEAR AGO ON THE SCOTTISH

ISLAND OF NORTH UIST, POPULATION 1,200.

THEY WRAP AROUND AN ART CENTER AND A DISUSED DAIRY AND SLICE

ACROSS THE FIELD THAT SEPARATES THE VILLAGE FROM THE OPEN OCEAN.

>> HOW DO THE LIGHTS WORK? WHAT TURNS THEM ON?

>> THE LIGHTS ARE TURNED ON WHEN THE TIDE COMES IN.

WE HAVE FOUR SWITCHES IN THE BAY, WHICH WHEN THE TIDE COMES

IN, THE FLOATS POP UP.

>> HOW DO PEOPLE UNDERSTAND CLIMATE CHANGE AROUND HERE?

>> I THINK PEOPLE ARE DEFINITELY AWARE OF CLIMATE CHANGE TO

REALLY AFFECT LIFE HERE. VERY LOW‐LYING ISLANDS

WHICH ARE EVEN NOW PRONE TO FLOODING.

>> DO YOU THINK ART INSTALLATIONS LIKE THIS ONE

MIGHT CHANGE A PERSON'S MIND OR MAKE THEM THINK ABOUT IT MORE?

>> DO I THINK ART CAN SAVE THE PLANET?

I DO, ACTUALLY. THAT'S WHAT ART DOES.

I THINK IT CAN CREATE A DEBATE AROUND LOTS OF ISSUES

AND MAKE US ASK QUESTIONS. WHAT IS THIS ABOUT?

WHAT ARE WE DOING?

>> LOCHMADDY IS SMALL, BUT IT'S HOME TO A VIBRANT ARTS

COMMUNITY, WHICH INCLUDES THE MUSEUM AND A COHORT OF STUDENTS

TAKING UNIVERSITY ART CLASSES.

>> INITIALLY, NOBODY REALLY KNEW WHAT IT WAS.

THEY THOUGHT MAYBE IT WAS A MARKER FOR SHIPS.

SO I THINK WE STARTED HANDED OUT, LIKE LITTLE LEAFLETS AND

THINGS LIKE THAT TO PEOPLE GOING, "IT'S ACTUALLY ART."

IT'S KIND OF HIGHLIGHTED THE ISSUE A WEE BIT MORE.

VISUALLY DRASTIC. QUITE A STRIKING IMAGE.

>> YOU'RE WALKING AROUND THE BUILDING AND YOU'RE REALIZING

THAT THE LIGHTS AT YOUR NECK. I GO, "OH, I'D BE VERY WET."

>> LINES IS ROOTED IN SCIENCE, BUT IT SHOWCASES THE MOST

EXTREME PREDICTIONS FOR THE NOT‐SO‐DISTANT FUTURE, WHERE THE

HIGHEST STORM SURGE PROJECTIONS COMBINE WITH THE HIGH TIDE.

NOW WHETHER OR NOT THE LINES INSTALLATION IS GOOD ART IS FOR

SOMEONE ELSE TO DECIDE, BUT IT DOES SEEM TO BE EFFECTIVE.

>> WHAT DID YOU THINK ONCE YOU REALIZED WHAT IT SYMBOLIZED?

>> QUITE SHOCKED, BECAUSE IT WOULD MEAN FOR THAT PART OF

LOCHMADDY WOULD BE LOST TO, THE FIELD, THE WHOLE LOT.

WE'RE FACING THE EFFECTS ON THE PLANET AND REALLY NOTHING NEAR

HERE HAS BEEN DONE TO COMBAT IT.

>> IF THAT SCENARIO OF CLIMATE CHANGE ACTUALLY OCCURS,

THIS ENTIRE AREA IS GOING TO BE UNLIVABLE.

HAS ANYBODY REACTED NEGATIVELY TO THIS?

>> I HAVEN'T HEARD ANY KIND OF NEGATIVE REACTIONS.

THERE'S A POSSIBILITY THAT IT WOULD FRIGHTEN PEOPLE.

I THINK WE NEED TO BE FRIGHTENED. IT'S ABOUT FACING REALITY.

THIS IS WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN IF WE DON'T CHANGE.

[LINE RINGING]

>> WE ALL KNOW THAT WE DON'T GO AROUND EXPRESSING AFFECTION AND

SUPPORT BY SMELLING HAIR, TOUCHING SOFTLY AND INTIMATELY.

YOU ONLY DO THAT WITH CLOSE FRIENDS.

>> THAT MIGHT BE NORMAL IN HIS WORLD. NOT IN OUR WORLD, AMERICA.

>> THE WOMEN WHO HAVE VOICED THEIR CONCERNS ABOUT JOE BIDEN,

THEY SAY THEY WEREN'T COMFORTABLE BY HIS ACTIONS AND

FELT WHAT HE WAS ‐‐ DIDN'T FEEL LIKE HIS ACTIONS WAS

SEXUAL ASSAULT. EVERYTHING COMPARING IT TO THE

ME TOO MOVEMENT. IT CHEAPENS THE ME TOO MOVEMENT.

>> IT'S NOT IDEAL BUT HE DOES IT BECAUSE HE'S A CARING,

COMPASSIONATE MAN AND HE COMES FROM A DIFFERENT TIME.

>> JOE BIDEN IS A BIG OLD FUCKING CUNT.

I HOPE Y'ALL HAVE A NICE DAY.

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.