All language subtitles for Highway to Heaven S04E09 Why Punish the Children_Subtitles01.ENG

[theme music]

[ominous music]

Boy, I tell you, you'd
think they were locking us

up putting us through all that.

Mark, you were a cop.

You, of all people, ought
to know about jail security.

I do.
I do.

It just feels funny,
that's all, being frisked,

fingerprinted, mug shots.

Well, now you know what
it's like on the other side.

Yeah, I hate it.

OK.

Initiation's over.

Time to go to work.

You heard the lady.

[buzzer]

This is great.

I spend my whole life as
a cop, I end up in jail.

Now, don't mind
my friend Mark here.

He's a little nervous.
- Oh?

Yeah.

First day of school jitters.

I've been that my
way whole life, too.

[laughs] Yeah, but
you're the teacher.

Yeah, but we're going into a
classroom filled with strangers

and all, you know.

Don't you mean a classroom
filled with prisoners?

Yeah, I do.

I'm a little nervous
about it, Miss Canner.

Call me Melanie.

And, Mark, trust me.

You're going to do just fine .

These students are receptive.

They're very eager to learn.

How many have you signed up?

Well, only eight so far, but
we'll get more as time goes on.

This is a very
exciting day for us.

MARK: Yeah?

Why is that?

I've been a social
worker for eight years,

and I've spent most
of that time trying

to make things even a little
better for the women in here.

Getting a high school
program was not easy,

but it was worth the fight.

Hey, I'm surprised.

I thought most jails
offered courses

to help train the inmates
for when they got out.

You were wrong.

[chatter]

Ladies, let me introduce
your new teachers.

This is Mr. Smith
and Mr. Gordon.

How are you doing?
CLASS: Hi.

OK, men, you're on your own.

All right, ladies, we
all know why we're here.

Well, I'm here for
writing bad checks.

Why are you here?

[laughter]

Your turn.

All right.

Look, I think the
best way to start

is for us to get
to know each other.

So I'd like each one of you
to introduce yourselves.

And, if you don't mind, tell
us why you'd like to get

your high school diploma.

We can start right in the front.

I am Maria Rojas,
and I would like

to graduate high
school in order to set

a good example for my baby.

That's a very good reason.

When are you due, Maria?

Last month.

[laughter]

It could be at any time.

All right, next.

Evelyn Walker.

I guess I'm here because I want
to make something of myself.

I've got kids, you know?

I'm not going to
be here forever.

I want a decent
job when I get out,

so I can take care of my kids.

That's all.

Patty Duncan.

I just figure, as
long as I'm here

I might as well be
learning something.

JONATHAN: That's good.

Next.

Reba Williams.

I got five kids, and
I thought maybe--

maybe if I was to get
my diploma, then maybe

they could be proud
of me for something.

[chatter]

You know, I hated
studying in high school.

It's kind of funny.

I'm really enjoying this class.

Well, that's because you
know how important it is now.

You're smart.

[laughs]

You know, I know it's
real important to study

grammar and all, Mr. Smith.

And I want to learn
to write better.

But will we be studying
any literature?

You bet we will.

American authors mostly,
and a little English lit.

Shakespeare?

Oh, Shakespeare definitely.

Who would imagine
Lucille Perry

conversing with Shakespeare?

You know, I tried
to read that stuff,

but he don't make a
bit of sense to me.

[laughter]

That's what high
school is for, Lucille.

You know, to broaden your
horizons, open your door.

Open doors-- now we could
definitely use a little

more of that around here.

[laughter]

Here you go.

Have another milk.

Pregnant lady
can't get too much.

Oh, that's sweet
of you, Mr. Gordon.

But I can get my own.

No, no, no.

You stay put now.

Shouldn't be on
your feet too much.

Looks like that baby could make
an appearance at any moment.

[laughs] You're
right about that.

Thank you.

Mind if I ask you a question?

I don't mind.

How did you get yourself in--

you know, in this condition.

You don't know how it happens?

[laughs] I don't mean
how did you get pregnant.

I mean, didn't you
think about your baby

before you committed the crime?

[chatter]

I'm sorry.

I had no right.

That's OK.

I made mistakes.

I admit it.

But I'm going to make
up for those mistakes.

My baby will not
suffer from my sins.

[chatter]

I'd like you to meet
one of our new teachers.

This is Mr. Smith.

This is our warden.

Thomas Inman.

Jonathan Smith.

I hope the women
here appreciate

the opportunity we're affording
them, and take advantage of it.

I'm sure they will.

They've been doing
very well so far.

That's good to hear.

Yes, indeed.

Well, would you care to
finish your lunch with me

in the staff dining room?

You'd probably be
more comfortable.

Actually, I'm very comfortable
right here with my students.

Would you like to
join us for lunch?

No I think not.

Another time, perhaps.

The man is insufferable.

You'd think he was the one who
was responsible for starting

this high school program, when
I fought him for five years

before he consented.

Why?

Why is he so afraid of change?

Oh, it's not
just Thomas Inman.

Its entire penal system.

The system's hardly changed
in the last 200 years.

It's still based on
the notion that society

would rather see offenders
punished than rehabilitated.

JONATHAN: Read chapters one and
two of Using Your Dictionary,

and do the exercises at
the end of each chapter.

Any questions?

Does neatness count?

JONATHAN: Always.

And when you're done with
that, there's something else

I'd like you to do.

I want you to write an essay.

[groans]

All right, take it easy.
Relax.

All I want is a couple of pages.

I just want to get an idea
of your writing skills.

What will we write about?

JONATHAN: Something you
know about, yourselves.

Boring.

Not my life, honey.

I got a bestseller just
waiting to be told.

JONATHAN: Yeah.

Well, like I said,
only two pages.

All right, I know
it's visiting day,

so I'm going to dismiss the
class a little bit early.

I want to thank you
all for your attention.

[chatter]

Mr. Smith, thanks for
letting us go early.

My kids are coming today.

JONATHAN: Have a
nice visit, Evelyn.

Thanks.

[chatter]

That's it.

Nice and easy now, Maria.

That's it.

That's it.

That's it.

Good Maria.

Oh.

Hi, Mr. Smith.

How are you doing, Maria?

Fine.

Mama Eva, this is one of
our new teachers, Mr. Smith.

Well, it's a pleasure
to meet you, Mr. Smith.

High time we got some
teachers in here.

Eva Haskall.

Pleasure to meet you, ma'am.

Everyone calls her Mama.

She may be chief
matron here, but she

is more like a house mother.

Oh.

So you're going for
natural childbirth?

I am going to try it, but
I'm not sure how brave I am.

[laughs]

Oh, you'll do fine.

You just listen to your
nurse, because she's

the most important person
in that delivery room.

The doctor-- he's
only the catcher.

Remember that.

[laughter]

Oh, look at the time. .

My break was over five minutes
ago I got to run, Mr. Smith.

Nice meeting you.

Same here.

You take care.

Seems like a nice lady.

I don't know what I would
have done without Mama Eva.

She has taught me everything
about being pregnant.

I was so frightened.

There was so much I didn't know.

Well, you've seen a doctor.

Only once.

They will only bring a
doctor if you get very ill.

Now, wait a minute.

You're telling me you're
nine months pregnant

and you've seen a
doctor one time?

That is why I'm so
grateful to Mama Eva.

Maria, what's going to
happen with your baby?

That is not a problem, really.

My grandmother is going
to take care of her.

She is a wonderful woman.

She raised me after my mother
died when I was a child.

And I only have seven more
months before my parole,

and then I will
raise my baby myself.

Excuse me.

I'm looking for Miss Canner.

I heard she was down here.
- Yeah.

She's right inside.

You can go on in and wait
for her if you'd like.

Thank you.

[chatter]

Oh, hello Allison.

Allison.

Oh, darling.

Hello, yes.

Oh, yeah, you're getting so big.

So big.

Hi, sweetheart.

Hi.

(SINGING) Hush, little
baby, don't you cry.

Mama's gonna sing you a lullaby.

Hush, little baby,
don't say a word.

Mama's gonna buy
you a mockingbird.

If that mockingbird
don't sing, Mama's

gonna sing you a lullaby.

BABY: [giggles]

Allison, I miss you.

Opens your eyes, doesn't it?

Visiting day is pretty much
of a downer around here.

It's funny, though.

These women look forward
to it every single time.

They can't wait to see
their kids, their families.

It's just so damn hard
for them to say goodbye.

They're usually depressed
for days afterwards.

That's what happens
when you break the law.

You're right, of course.

But the problem is
the kids pay, too.

I have tried so hard to
get contact visitation

rights for these women.

It breaks my heart to see them
trying to reach to each other

through a glass wall.

There's a very good reason for
that glass wall, Miss Canner.

You know it.

I was a cop.

You know what people
will do to try to get

weapons or drugs into a prison.

They'll even use their
own kids to smuggle it in.

Fine.

Then search the women
afterwards if that's a concern.

But, for God's sake, these
women need to touch and hold

and caress their children.

And I guess the children
need it most of all.

I miss you.

I miss you very much.

I love you.

Give me a kiss.

[buzzer]

Well?

Well what?

How was your first day?

You seemed a little worried
about it this morning.

No, no.
I'm over that.

They're good students.

You know, Melanie was right.

These women really
want to learn.

What's wrong, then?

You've hardly said a word.

I saw something today
that really shook me up.

What was it?

I went in the visitation
room to find Melanie.

Boy it was tough--

women talking to their
children through a glass

wall over telephone.

I mean, I was a cop.

Right?

I've been around
prisoners all my life.

I figure most of them
should be locked up

and throw away the key.

I mean, I figured they
gave up their rights when

they committed their crime.

Listening to a mother sing a
lullaby to their children--

boy-- over a telephone.

It doesn't seem right.

Yeah.

Well, like you said,
they're criminals.

Yeah.

But isn't prison
punishment enough?

Do we have to dangle their
children in front of them

and say, hey, you can
look but you can't touch?

I mean, that is cruel
and ought to be stopped.

Yeah.

There's the man to talk to.

All right, I will.

Mr. Inman.

Yes, Mr. Gordon.

What can I do for you?

I'd like to ask
you a question.

Please do.

I'd like to know why
the women in this prison

have to see their children
through a glass wall.

It's a security
measure, standard policy

in most prisons.

Well, then the policy stinks.

Is that your expert opinion?

After all, you've only
been here one day, Gordon.

That's hardly enough
time to understand

the criminal justice system.

Hey, look.

I was a cop for 20 years.

I know the system.

Believe me, I've seen
the lowest of the low,

people who should be locked up
and never see the light of day

again.

But a lot of the
women in this prison

are mothers, so we are dealing
with women and children here.

It seems to me that
should make a difference

in the way we treat them.

Not to me, it doesn't.

I didn't convict those women.

They committed a crime, and the
state says they have to pay.

I'm just here to see they do
their time, and that's all.

But the children of
these women are innocent.

THOMAS: And so
were their victims.

Look, you may as well know,
I never wanted you men here.

You were forced down my throat
by that pushy social worker.

Well, you're here now.

We'll get along just fine,
so long as you do your job

and let me do mine.

James is almost 12.

He's the man in the family.

Then there's Robert.

He's just learning to
write, and he sends

me letters almost every day.

Joel is my baby.

He's only six.

He gets asthma real bad,
and it scares me I can't

be there when he's hurting.

I have two beautiful
daughters also.

Patricia always
wanted to be a dancer.

She's very talented, and I hope
she can have her dream someday.

Martha is my oldest.

She's 14, as her birthday
was only last week.

I haven't seen Martha
since I've been here.

She doesn't write.

But I know that teenagers
are busy and don't

have time for such things.

She must be turning
into quite a lady,

and I'm sorry I can't be
there and watch it happen.

But I am still very proud of
her and love her very much.

All in all, we're
a loving family.

And we're looking
forward to the day

we can all be together again.

Reba, that was very nice.

Thank you.

I think that's about all
we have time for today.

Reba, I'd like to have you stay
after class for a few minutes.

The rest of you are excused.

Reba, are your kids
being well cared for?

Yes, sir, best I can tell.

Miss Tucker, my social
worker, looks in on them

and lets me know how
they're getting on.

Do you ever get to see 'em?

Once in a while.

Robert lives the closest.

His foster mother brought him
to see me a few months ago.

And Miss Tucker gets to
bring Joel sometimes.

And the others write, and
I talk to them on the phone

every now and then.

Why doesn't Martha write?

I hurt her bad, Mr. Smith.

Lord knows I was only trying
to make life better for my kids

when I stole some money.

I knew it was the
wrong thing to do,

but I was real
desperate at the time.

But instead of
making things better,

I made 'em a whole lot worse.

And I don't think Martha will
ever forgive me for tearing

apart our family like I did.

She's ashamed of having
her mama in jail.

I know it.

She's been telling her friends
I'm in a hospital instead.

Have you tried calling her?

I try sometimes.

She wouldn't come to the phone.

Mr. Smith, I thank
you for your concern.

But we're going to manage.

I just got over six months
left, and then we're

going to be a family again.

[music playing]

[laughter and chatter]

Reba's case is typical.

The children of most of these
women live in foster homes

all over the state.

There's nobody
providing means for them

to travel to visit
their mothers.

So if the foster
parents of the families

don't see fit to bring
them, they don't come.

Jonathan, some of
these women don't

see their children the
entire time they're in here.

Must make it pretty hard
to keep the family together.

Tell me about it.

And Thanksgiving's coming.

Holidays are really rough.

I mean, you know,
it's hard enough

being separated from your
family, your loved ones,

any time.

But on holidays--

What happens to these women?

They leave, try and
pick up their lives.

Some of them are successful.

Others have just lost too much.

A lot of them even
lose their children.

What do you mean?

If a woman with a
baby is incarcerated

and she has no
relatives to take over,

the baby is put
in a foster home.

Well, the foster parents
don't have any incentive

to bring the baby for visits.

So the court often
decides that the baby

should remain with the
parents it's bonded with.

It allows them to adopt.

Where does the
law say a crime is

punishable by
fine, imprisonment,

and the loss of your children?

It doesn't, but it
happens every day.

There was this
company over in England.

It was called the
New England Company.

Someone got the
bright idea to send

some people over here, settle
down, and search for gold.

They settled in Jamestown.

Mr. Gordon, I
always thought people

came over here to practice their
religion, not look for gold.

Good point.

Some of them did.

Those were the Puritans.

They came over a little
later, settled in New England,

at the Plymouth Colony
in Massachusetts.

Maria?

Mr. Gordon, I--

I think it's time.

Time for what?

We just got started.

I think she means it's
time to make a baby.

A baby?

A baby!

[music playing]

Isn't she adorable?

She's the spitting
image of Maria.

Look at that little
turned up nose.

I'll tell you, she
looks healthy enough.

Healthy?

You should have heard her
bellow when she came out.

She's got a pair of good,
sturdy lungs in her.

That 'cause Maria took
real good care of herself

while she was pregnant.

Has she got a name yet?

Anita.

Maria named her after
her grandmother.

They're real close.

Oh, Melanie.

Melanie, you're just in time.

You got to look at this.

Well, of course,
the star of the show

has kind of nodded of here, but
at least you can take a look.

Oh, boy, she's beautiful.

How's Maria?

Oh, Maria is fine.

She came through like a trooper.

Yeah, she's sitting on
top of the world right now.

Well, I'm afraid I've
got some bad news for her.

Bad news?

Yeah.

I-- I called the
Children's Welfare

Office this
afternoon to let them

know that Maria had delivered.

And they told me that they'd
just done a field report

on Maria's grandmother,
the one who's

supposed to take care of the
baby until Maria's released.

And?

And they found
the woman to be old,

and semi-invalid,
and in no condition

to care for an infant.

What are they going to do?

I only know what the
courts have done in the past.

They're going to
take Maria's baby.

What are you talking about?

They can't do that.

Yes, they can.

It's the court's opinion
that a baby needs a mother.

This baby has a mother.

Maria is her mother.

But Maria is in jail, Mark.

[ominous music]

Daddy!

[carousel music]

That looks like fun.

Smith, what are
you doing here?

My place is close by.

I like to take walks.

Nice looking family
you got there.

I only wish I could
spend more time with them.

Seems like I leave
for work every day

before my daughter gets
up, and she's in bed asleep

when I get home at night.

I like to take an afternoon
off once in a while

just so we can be
together as a family.

That's a good idea.

It's important for
families to be together.

You didn't just
happen by here, Smith.

You want something.
What is it?

Not much.

I want you to
approve the reforms

that Melanie Canner
has requested

for the last five years.

Oh, is that all?

The woman's a crusader.

She wants the moon.

No, she doesn't.

She wants a
Children's Center, so

mothers can be with their kids.

It's a basic need in
people, Mr. Inman,

to hold, to love, to touch.

Is that too much to ask?

Is it too much to ask that a
boy be able to hug his mother

or that a mother be able to
wipe away a little girl's tears?

Contact visitation
is out of the question.

We want a nursery, so
that babies can be raised

in prison by their mothers--

Keep dreaming.

--so that's Maria
Rojas can keep her baby,

so that Evelyn Walker and
others can raise and nurture

their children at a time in
their lives that's so important

to the development.

There is no way.

It just doesn't happen.

You can make it happen.

You're really
something, you know that?

We have experts who
design our penal systems.

You're just a schoolteacher.

What do you know about it?

It doesn't take an
expert to see what's

happening to these children.

Of course, it's a lot easier
just to forget about them.

Prison is no
place for children.

A child's place
is with its mother.

You can separate these prisoners
from society, Mr. Inman,

but you have no
right to put a wall

between a mother and a child.

You make it sound
like a threat, Smith.

[bell ringing]

I'm not threatening
you, Mr. Inman.

I'm just giving you
something to think about.

I'll let you be
with your family.

[chatter]

That was fun, Daddy.

Can I ride it again?

Sure, honey, all you want.

Who was that man
you were talking to?

No one important.

[music playing]

OPERATOR (ON PHONE): Operator.

I want to make a collect
call from Reba Williams.

I want to talk to
Martha Williams.

OPERATOR (ON PHONE): Thank you.

[phone ringing]

MARTHA (ON PHONE): Hello?

OPERATOR (ON PHONE):
Collect call from Reba

Williams for Martha Williams.

Will you accept the charges?

MARTHA (ON PHONE): No.

Baby, please let
me talk to you.

[dial tone]

[somber music]

[music playing]

CARRIE: Daddy!

Daddy!

Daddy!

Daddy!

Daddy!

What's wrong, baby?

I'm scared.

I'm here, baby.

It's all right.

Sweetheart, what--
sweetheart, I'm here.

It's all right.

Sweetheart, I'm here!

It's all right!

Daddy!

Sweetheart, I'm here!

It's all right.
- Daddy!

Daddy!

Sweetheart, I'm here!
Carrie!

Daddy!

Carrie!

Daddy!

Carrie!

Carrie!

Carrie!

Carrie!

Tom, what is it?

What's the matter?

Nothing.

I'm all right.

Just a nightmare is all.

I'm fine.

Are you sure?

I'm sure.

You go back to sleep.

I'm going downstairs
to get some milk.

[somber music]

[suspenseful music]

[buzzer]

[hopeful music]

[chatter]

Like a nightmare,
isn't it, not

being able to hold your child?

Who are you?

I'm just a teacher.

And you're right, I don't know
much about the penal system.

But I do know something's
very wrong here.

And you're the only
one who can change it.

[chatter]

So, by this time, France
and Great Britain were

arguing over who gets what.

And, of course,
a war breaks out.

- The French and Indian War.
- Right.

Who won?

The English.

They took Canada,
all the territory

East of the Mississippi,
except for New Orleans.

Right again.

Look, why don't you guys
read up on the Stamp Act.

OK?
I'll be right back.

Maria, why don't you join
our school session over here?

We're about to start
the Revolutionary War.

Maria, you're missing a great
chance to get your diploma,

graduate from high school by
the time you get out of here.

I don't care about that.

It just doesn't matter anymore.

[door opens]

[music playing]

My Anita.

She's yours, Maria, forever.

[applause and cheering]

[excited chatter]

[hopeful music]

What happened?

I wish I knew.

Mr. Inman just called and
he said, get the baby.

Bring her to Maria.

Can she keep her here?

Yes.

We are going to have a
prisoners rule for all babies

under one year.

They can live here
with their mothers.

Miss Canner, my
Allison is six months.

Can she come too?

She sure can,
and that's not all.

The warden said that
we can use the dining

hall as a children's center.

That means from now on you
can sit and talk to your kids.

You can hold them,
play games with them,

tell secrets, help them
with their homework.

[laughs] I'm sure they can
help me with my homework.

[laughter]

I have been trying
for years to get

the simplest reforms
established here

and gotten practically nothing.

And now he just gives
all of this overnight.

It's a miracle.

Yeah.

It's a miracle.

[music playing]

How's it going?

Well, it's not
Rembrandt, but it's bright.

I think it looks great.

Yeah, so do I.
It's looking great.

[laughs]

Hey, Reba, it's
Thanksgiving vacation.

You're not going to spend
it doing homework, are you?

Oh, no, sir.

I'm writing letters to my kids.

None of them going
to be here tomorrow?

No, sir.

It's Thanksgiving.

All the foster families
got plans for the day.

When's the last time
you were all together?

Not since I've been here.

Birthdays was missed, holidays--

it's going to be a
long time before we're

together, Mr. Gordon.

Scares me to even
think about it.

I keep wondering if we can
ever be a family again,

or are we just going to be
a house full of strangers.

Well, I'd say about
11 o'clock, Mrs. Eliot.

Yeah.

Well, I'm glad.

OK.

You tell Joel
we'll see him then.

Bye.

Well, that's it.

Four out of five anyway.

Maybe we ought to try
Martha one more time.

I don't think
there's much use.

She made it pretty clear she
doesn't want to see her mother.

You can't force something
like this, Mark.

Yeah, I know.

It'd just be so perfect for Reba
and the whole family, you know?

We had our miracle
with Warden Inman.

Anyway, Reba's
going to be thrilled

to see the rest of her kids.

Yeah, I know.

You're right.

[music playing]

Reba, would you
come with me please?

Is something wrong?

I don't know.

Warden Inman wants to see you.

Do you know what it's about?

He wouldn't say, but I
wouldn't keep him waiting.

[excited chatter]

[music playing]

[crying]

[hopeful music]

Martha Williams?

Yes.

I'm Jonathan Smith.

I work with Melanie
Canner at the prison.

What do you want?

I just wanted to
ask you one more

time if you wouldn't
visit your mother today.

I told the lady no.

I know.

I was hoping you'd reconsider.

Why, because she's my mother?

No.

No, because she loves
you and misses you.

Well, she should
have thought about that

before she wrecked our family.

Don't you think you've
punished your mother enough?

I'm not punishing my mother.

JONATHAN: Well,
what do you call it?

I call it even.

Look what she did to us.

Your mother made
a bad mistake,

and nobody knows it
better than she does.

She's paying for it.

Believe me, she's paying.

And I'm glad.

You know, Martha,
it's all right to hate

what your mother did.

It's even all right to hate her.

But do you love her?

She ruined everything.

But do you love her?

She deserves everything
she gets for hurting us.

But do you love her?

Answer me.

Do you love your mother?

Answer me.

Yes.

[crying] Yes.

[chatter]

Now, let's just
hold on a minute.

What do we always
do before a meal?

Our dear and most
gracious Heavenly Father,

we humbly come before you
on this day of Thanksgiving

to thank you for all that you
have so abundantly provided.

We thank you for this
food we're about to eat--

Mama!

--and we-- hush, Joel, not
when I'm talking to the Lord.

[music playing]

[hopeful music]

[buzzer]

You OK?

Yeah, I'm fine.

I'm just wondering something.

I was wondering
how many families

that are out there
on this Thanksgiving

who can't be together.

Yeah.

I wonder how many families there
are out there who are together

and don't realize
how lucky they are.

[buzzer]

[hopeful music]

[theme music]