Original subtitles

دانلود شده از وب سایت پرشین دانلود - PerDL.info سایت زیرنویس Persub.xyz Have you thought about

there must be a reason why

you met each other again?

Not everyone can have the chance to start over.

Guang Xi.

I really don't want to see you turn out like me.

Regretting for the rest of your life.

Like you?

Regret for the rest of my life?

I'm nothing like you.

Don't compare me with what you and Dad had.

I let Mu Cheng go,

for her own good.

I didn't do it to push her over the edge.

Guang Xi.

I really don't want to see you turn out like me.

Regretting for the rest of your life.

Like you?

Regret for the rest of my life?

I'm nothing like you.

Don't compare me with what you and Dad had.

I let Mu Cheng go,

for her own good.

I didn't do it to push her over the edge.

I don't want to get off! I want Daddy!

I'll take him.

No!

No need. Xiao Lin is waiting for us with the car.

Let's go.

I don't want to go in his car! I want Daddy!

I don't want Guang Xi's childhood to be

filled with dirty memories.

Take your dirty hand off of me.

Don't look, Guang Xi.

Go away!

Guang Xi.

It's all your fault Daddy died!

You're right.

I couldn't even take care of my own marriage.

What right do I have to talk to you?

But...

But if I told you...

I regret it?

What do you mean?

Not only do I regret,

I realized I was wrong too.

If I had another chance,

I would not have allowed things to happen this way.

I would have tried harder.

So,

I only realized recently,

you can give up many things in life,

as long as the people you love are with you.

Then it's enough.

That's what makes you happy.

Maybe because I'm at that age.

I only realized this simple truth,

while I was with Xiao Le.

I should get going.

You have your own choices.

But I'll tell you honestly that I really like that child.

I hope,

I will have the privilege to keep being his family.

Bye.

Gary.

I need you to look up something for me.

It's about my Dad's suicide 20 years ago.

Okay.

Closed Indefinitely. See Mu Cheng if anything. Hua Tian Xi Shi.

It's been two weeks.

Even though Hua Feng Fung is in a coma,

the witnesses Hua Chi Xin and Yang Tian Fu

insist that Hua Tuo Ye intended to kill.

In addition,

Hua Tuo Ye has a strong motive.

And he already confessed to the killing.

So the prosecutor has charged

him with murder.

Murder?

But Chi Xin said,

Fung attacked Tuo Ye first.

Tuo Ye tried to defend himself, leading to the killing.

Would this statement from Chi Xin help Tuo Ye?

I can only argue that he acted out of self defense.

But none of this is important.

What's important is does Hua Tuo Ye want me to defend him?

The trial starts at the end of the month.

Time is running out.

Not to mention, at the station,

he did not want to explain his actions at all.

That is dangerous.

I don't even know what this silly child is thinking.

Attorney Ren,

I don't understand anything.

I'm hoping you can talk to him.

My husband passed away early.

And Hua Chi Xin is in rehab now.

I cannot lose him.

Please.

Don't worry, Auntie Hua.

I'm about to go see Hua Tuo Ye.

You just make sure you take care of yourself now.

Otherwise, it'll be meaningless for Hua Tuo Ye to come home.

Don't worry, Auntie Hua will stay with me until Chi Xin comes home.

I will take care of her.

I will ask you to be a witness at the trial.

Since you were the first person Hua Tuo Ye

contacted after the incident.

Plus you know his reasons to turn himself in.

Not to mention your relationship,

maybe you can provide some statements that will help him.

Since you're here,

Want to stay until Xiao Le comes home?

Since you're here,

Want to stay until Xiao Le comes home?

Xiao Le went to Tong Tong's house.

It's Tong Tong's birthday today.

So her mom is having a party for her.

He will be back soon.

You haven't seen each other for a while,

he will be so happy to see you.

Sorry.

I want to see Xiao Le too.

But I have to go see Hua Tuo Ye first.

Visiting hours are ending soon.

Let's wait until the trial is over.

It's okay then.

Daddy!

Xiao Le.

Daddy, I've missed you!

Me too!

Mu Cheng said you will rescue Big Bro right?

You are Mu Cheng's hero.

I will do my best.

And you have to be a good boy too.

Mu Cheng will be busy taking care of Auntie Hua.

So you can't be a bad boy and let her worry.

Xiao Le,

be a good boy, wait until Daddy's finished with the trial,

I will make the carrot-less beef stew for you two, ok?

Yay! Eat beef stew with me, okay, Daddy?

Okay.

We'll see.

Alright, Daddy is going to see Big Bro now.

Daddy is so busy, but don't forget Mu Cheng and I love you.

I love you too.

Daddy bye bye!

Your mom asked me to be your lawyer.

I just need your consent.

I don't need a lawyer.

I agreed to see you because,

I want to know about Chi Xin.

She's been sent to rehab.

I went to see her.

I asked her what happened that night.

Why did you ask her that kind of question?

You don't think she's hurting enough?

Can you stop harassing her?

I'm just worried that

Chi Xin has already been hurt enough by Hua Feng Fung.

You asking her all these questions...

Making her relive that night...

Do you think she can handle it?

Don't worry.

I know what to ask and what not to.

Your case is more important now.

I don't need you to be on my case.

I can tell the judge you acted out of self defense.

Or accidentally, to reduce your sentence.

You just need to tell me what happened.

It's very simple.

I killed him.

Nothing to do with anyone else.

If you don't explain yourself,

you're confessing sooner.

And saying nobody else is involved,

your attitude makes me think it's not as simple as you say.

I did kill Hua Feng Fung.

I'm not explaining, because that's a fact.

There's nothing I can say to change it.

Unless you want me to lie?

Saying I didn't kill him?

That's perjury.

I hate people like you.

Big lawyer.

You are right.

But I never thought you'd be so vicious.

Besides the fatal wound on Fung's neck...

there's also tearing behind his ears.

Looks like you really wanted to kill him when you did it.

I'm counting to three.

I'm really going to cut her!

Get down on your knees!

He deserved to die.

Are you done?

Can I go now?

I made a promise to Xiao Le.

I would get you out.

I don't want to see Xiao Le sad.

Because of his Big Bro...

being called a murderer.

I don't want to see the happy Auntie Hua

fall down because she's worried about you.

What's wrong with my mom?

She's worried about you.

When she heard the case against you was not good...

her body couldn't handle it.

I made her worry again.

How is she now?

Don't worry. Mu Cheng is looking after her.

Thank God Mu Cheng is there.

Don't think too much.

I simply appreciate her help.

You don't need to explain.

I know exactly how important you are to Mu Cheng.

- You've got it wrong. - No I don't.

She told me so herself.

You are very important to her.

If something happened to you...

she would never leave you alone.

So how can you let her down?

When she cares about you so much?

If I were you...

I'd rather lose everything

than lose this kind of relationship.

So...

Hua Tuo Ye.

Are you going to throw away your mom's worries?

Mu Cheng's heart?

And Xiao Le's caring?

Are you helping me out...

and defending me...

simply because my mom asked you to?

Or because Mu Cheng did?

I already told you.

I'm doing it for Xiao Le.

Is that the truth?

In any case...

I'm confident I will get you out early.

So you can reunite with those that care about you.

As long as you agree.

What do I have to do?

Boss.

Did you get Hua Tuo Ye to agree?

He said yes.

But his attitude was weird.

I purposely said Fung had a wound behind his ears.

Hua Tuo Ye admitted doing it without thinking at all.

But the problem is...

Fung did not have a wound behind his ears.

In other words, he lied.

Based on previous cases...

when a person holds back things about the case...

he is usually not looking to go free.

But is hiding something.

Hua Tuo Ye is not looking to go free.

So what is his motive?

That's what we have to find out.

There were only four people at the crime scene.

Hua Tuo Ye is not willing to tell the truth.

Hua Feng Fung is in a coma.

There's only Fung's sidekicks, Yang Tian Fu and Hua Chi Xin.

But Yang Tian Fu's statement obviously sides with Hua Feng Fung.

What's more strange is

Tuo Ye doesn't seem to want us to go after Hua Chi Xin.

I think the key

lies with Hua Chi Xin.

So we have to question Hua Chi Xin again?

That's right.

Collect evidence first and find any contradicting things.

We will question her for the last time when she's out of rehab.

Don't forget. Keep an eye on the prosecutor.

Report back to me anytime.

[Taiwan Local Court Filing]

Boss, the prosecution side is reviewing all evidence.

The prosecutor is Tao Da Yi, from Banqiao City.

He's handled many sensational cases before.

People who get off on lack of evidence at first

are still caught by him and sent to jail later on.

He's gained the nickname The Executioner.

[Taiwan Local Court Filing]

Boss, the prosecution side is reviewing all evidence.

The prosecutor is Tao Da Yi, from Banqiao City.

He's handled many sensational cases before.

People who get off on lack of evidence at first

are still caught by him and sent to jail later on.

He's gained the nickname The Executioner.

Mr. Tao, we've confirmed the defense attorney for Hua Tuo Ye.

It's Ren Guang Xi.

I know him.

This is where Hua Tuo Ye tossed the weapon.

This proves he is a flight risk.

Why throw away the weapon

if he really planned on turning himself in?

Also, I asked you to look into call records between Hua Tuo Ye and Fung.

How's that going?

Yes, according to Yang Tian Fu, Fung's sidekick,

Hua Feng Fung and Hua Tuo Ye have been feuding over the years.

There's records of them both hurting each other.

This proves that your assessment is correct.

I believe the accused was well prepared for this conflict.

Even though we found the weapon...

if there are none of Hua Tuo Ye's fingerprints on it

it can't be used as evidence.

Let me see what data you have.

When we examined the crime scene last time

we did find evidence of a fight there.

Based on the accused and the witness Hua Chi Xin

I predict Ren Guang Xi will use self-defense as a strategy.

But Yang Tian Fu's statement

can prove that the accused, Hua Tuo Ye

had the motive to get revenge.

This prompts me to believe this was premeditated murder.

But I believe...

Ren Guang Xi is not easy to deal with.

This time... I want to see if the rumored

lawyer who plays with the law and works with the rich

is really as good as they say he is.

Grandma!

Grandma!

Why are you running away?

Didn't you come to see us?

I didn't run, I just.... I...

Xiao Le.

Grandma wasn't running.

She was hoping you'd show her the way.

Show her our backyard.

President Fung.

Welcome.

I just came to bring him the pictures from the other day.

So he can turn in his homework.

I also brought sugar-free milk candy.

Xiao Le can eat them safely.

Yay, Grandma!

Come!

We have a big yard.

So pretty!

This crab has really big hands!

Look, Grandma! So big!

Grandma, where are you looking? You're not paying attention.

Grandma is looking at the place you grew up in.

Look, isn't it pretty?

Pretty like you.

Cute and warm.

President Fung, dinner's ready.

Grandma.

Mu Cheng made the best beef rice today.

Let's go wash our hands.

Soup is coming, watch out.

Liang Xiao Le!

What's rule number 8 in Liang household?

When eating with adults

I have to wait until the adults eat, then I can eat.

But I'm hungry! Grandma!

Be a good boy, Xiao Le.

Your mother is right.

Let's eat!

President Fung, help yourself.

Here, Xiao Le, celery, your favorite.

And this too.

Just leave it, let me.

Oh it's ok, I can still use this.

I heard from Xiao Le

that it was very tough living here before.

It wasn't tough.

When I was little my dad passed away.

My family became poor.

So Auntie always taught us not to be wasteful.

I've gotten used to it.

It's not tough at all.

I'm sorry.

I'm sorry.

I used to say you didn't have manners...

but after seeing Xiao Le

I think your parents must've taught you well.

That's how you're able to teach Xiao Le so well.

Thank you.

After spending time with Xiao Le...

maybe it's because of his innocent smile...

or maybe I am getting older.

I'm often reminded of the past.

When Guang Xi was little...

he wasn't happy like Xiao Le.

He never even smiled.

He was forced to go to school.

And after-school activities.

He was never happy.

Because of my interference.

I realize it now.

But it's already too late.

We're both single mothers.

From looking at you

I see a lot of things I should improve on

and learn from.

No. We are the same.

We both love our children.

It's just...

we have different ways.

No one loves Guang Xi more than you do.

But I took away Guang Xi's childhood.

And interfered with your relationship.

I made you...

Guang Xi...

and even Yi Qian...

all very unhappy.

But Guang Xi was able to live because of your decision.

Isn't that the most important thing?

I realized what I should treasure most

after we went though all of that.

Even if Guang Xi and I didn't go through all this

there's no guarantee we'd be together forever.

No one knows what will happen in the next second.

So we can only seize the moment with the people we love

and make the best decision

and put in our best effort.

I understand.

Like you said...

I hope...

that you don't give up on this marriage.

For the people you care about make the most effort.

I don't want to give up.

But Guang Xi...

already pushed me away.

Just like a stranger.

I really don't know how to get close to him now.

Just get close like this!

Grandma, don't you just get close like this?

Liang Xiao Le

you eavesdropped on an adult's conversation again.

You were the ones acting weird.

It's so simple anyways.

Also, my name is Ren Xiao Le.

Okay.

Ren Xiao Le.

You have to be a cherub and help your parents.

And... don't let Mu Cheng give up.

That's all I can remember.

I've already told you so many times.

It's what I told the prosecutor, too.

It's not going to be different if you ask me again.

You're right.

You were very clear.

But I just want to ask you again.

Did you see Hua Tuo Ye stick that candle holder into Fung's neck?

I remember...

I saw Fung was bleeding a lot.

He was lying on the floor.

Tuo Ye was holding the candle holder.

So

you didn't see Hua Tuo Ye kill Fung?

I...

I...

I...

I'm so stupid!

- Why can't I remember? - Calm down, Chi Xin.

If I remember, that could help Tuo Ye, right?

Attorney Ren

Tuo Ye only did this to rescue me.

- Please help me. - Calm down, calm down.

I will.

Where's my charm?

My charm...

It's on your neck.

What do you think?

A lot of witnesses make mistakes describing the crime

after experiencing horrible crimes

or not being able to remember key moments of the crime.

Her condition is a classic post-traumatic reaction.

Did you see how she kept touching her charm?

The charm is on her neck

but she kept rubbing it.

If my suspicions are right...

there is another possibility.

The trial is about to start, we don't have much time.

Contact Dr. Chen from the Psychiatric dept. at T. University.

What do you see in this one?

It's Fung's blood on the floor.

I think your assumptions were correct.

According to her results in the Rorschach test

they all point back to the experience from the crime.

This shows that...

she is still deeply traumatized by the incident.

The reason why she can't recall key moments from the crime

is because she's suppressed them all.

This is classic amnesia.

Dr. Chen.

If she's really lost her memory

what are her chances of recovering?

The trial starts tomorrow.

Is there any way for her to remember faster?

I will monitor her sleep pattern and brain activity overnight tonight.

Including trying other methods.

There might be hope. But I can't make any promises.

That charm seems to be pretty important to her.

Would that help her remember?

I'll give it a try.

The truth lies in her suppressed memory.

I can only take a chance.

If my guess is right

perhaps I already know what Hua Tuo Ye is hiding.

All that's missing now is the puzzle that is Chi Xin.

Dr. Chen.

Please try your best to recover her memory.

Prosecutor Tao.

I've heard so much about you.

Attorney Ren.

I look forward to our trial today.

We both know this trial is not in favor of the accused.

The chances of him getting off are really not high.

I would really like to see how the famous Attorney Ren

will make the impossible into possible.

There's no probability in law.

There's only the truth.

We will know in court

if Hua Tuo Ye really committed murder.

Any time before a verdict is reached

my client still remains innocent.

I'll see you in court then.

Dr. Chen.

How is Chi Xin doing?

She still can't remember.

But I will keep trying.

Ok, thank you.

Guang Xi.

Boss, I'm going to work on the files.

Did you need something? The trial is about to start.

Are you worried about the questions they will ask later?

You look really tired.

We haven't seen each other for a while.

Have you been pulling all-nighters for the case lately?

I know this case is very tough.

And you've prepared a lot.

No matter the outcome I want to thank you.

For helping Tuo Ye so much.

You don't have to thank me on his behalf.

I will do my best since I agreed to help him.

I don't want to see him indicted neither.

Because Xiao Le wouldn't be happy then either.

No matter how hard this case is

I will fight hard to reach the best result for him.

When the trial is over can you give me some time?

There are some things I'd like to talk to you about.

We'll see.

Trial first.

Boss, the trial is about to start!

Let's go.

Big Bro!

Sit down!