Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
[Suspenseful Music]
[Ellisor] What the?
[John Cox] This flight became a life-threatening crisis...
in seconds.
[Narrator] An explosion rocks Southwest flight 1380.
The vibration was so severe I was not able
to see any of the instruments.
Throughout the airplane, it was just screams of terror.
[Narrator] The cabin depressurizes.
I could feel the air being sucked out of my lungs.
Everything became very, very hot then very, very cold
at the same time.
[Narrator] As the pilots fight
to regain control of their airplane.
[Captain Shults] You've still got it!
[Narrator] Flight attendants make a horrifying discovery.
[Wind Whooshing]
-[Plane Whooshing] -[Suspenseful Music]
[Flight Attendant] Ladies and gentlemen,
we are starting our approach.
[Pilot] We lost both engines!
[Flight Attendant] Put the mask over your nose.
-Emergency descent. -[Pilot] Mayday, mayday!
[Flight Attendant] Brace for impact!
[Dramatic Music]
[Pilot] It's gonna crash!
[Melancholy Music]
[Narrator] Southwest Airlines flight 1380
is boarding for a trip to Dallas, Texas.
Andrew Needum is a firefighter
and paramedic on his way home
after a family vacation in New York City.
We took a trip kinda as a year end
to the completion of my paramedic certification school.
And so we decided that it would be a family getaway.
-Row 14, just on the right. -Thank you.
[Narrator] Jennifer Riordan is returning home
from a business trip to New York.
144 passengers settle in to this sold-out flight.
[Suspenseful Music]
In the cockpit,
the flight crew prepares the Boeing 737 for departure.
Let's start the pre-flight procedures.
[Ellisor] I'm on it.
[Narrator] Captain Tammie Jo Shults
has been flying 737s for 24 years.
Homeward bound.
[Narrator] She's no ordinary flight commander.
[John Cox] Tammie Jo Shults.
She is a formal Naval Aviator.
Flew during the Gulf War,
Operation Desert Storm,
and also flew aerial firefighting aircraft
before joining Southwest.
[Narrator] First officer Darren Ellisor
has been with Southwest for ten years.
He's a former Air Force Major.
[Ellisor] I love to fly.
We get to see the most amazing sights
and be in a different place every time you go fly.
-Your leg? -This one's mine.
[Narrator] It's the second day of a four day pairing
for the crew.
First Officer Ellisor will be the pilot flying this leg.
[Ellisor] I was starting my day in the cockpit,
ready to go fly.
It was a beautiful day in LaGuardia actually.
The weather was fantastic.
[Narrator] The crew flew in earlier today from Nashville.
The four hour trip to Dallas
will be their second and final flight today.
[Flight Attendant] In front of you, you'll find
a flight safety information card. Please take it out...
[Narrator] Flight attendant Rachel Fernheimer
started with Southwest Airlines just two years ago.
[Rachel Fernheimer] I love my job.
I would have to say it's the people.
My favorite thing is to just kind of just be there for them
and talk them through what they need me to
or even just to have a laugh with them or cry with them.
[Narrator] Rachel is working with her colleague,
Seanique Mallory.
[Peaceful Music]
[Plane Whooshing]
At 10:42 AM, flight 1380 takes off on time.
[Captain Shults] V-1.
Rotate.
[Narrator] Two turbofan engines power
the Boeing 737 into the sky.
[Ellisor] The airplane was
almost to maximum weight.
The gas tanks were near
full capacity.
And when you're in a heavy airplane,
it does affect your performance.
It makes the airplane
less responsive.
[Narrator] As flight 1380 climbs to cruising altitude,
controllers at LaGuardia hand the flight over
to New York area controllers.
[Laguardia Atc] Southwest 1380,
contact New York Center, 133.47.
Copy that, 1380.
[Suspenseful Music]
[Plane Whooshing]
[Narrator] Twenty minutes after takeoff.
Thank you.
[Plane Rattling]
[Plane Whooshing]
Everything changed.
What the?
We had a...
very large bang.
We had multiple warnings going off in the cockpit
and a very severe
vibration throughout the entire plane.
[Cox] This flight went from being
an absolutely routine flight into Dallas,
into a life-threatening
crisis in seconds.
[Narrator] The plane depressurizes.
I could feel the air being sucked out of my lungs.
Immediately,
it was very disorienting.
It was something that I've never had
in my entire flying career.
[Narrator] First Officer Ellisor struggles
to control the aircraft as it banks steeply to the left.
I immediately grabbed the yoke to stop the roll.
You still got it!
I was not able to see any of the engine instruments
because the vibration was so severe.
It was just a blur of colors.
And so I can't see anything.
Still got it.
Luckily it was a clear day,
a very clear horizon,
and I was able to roll out of the bank
and recover the airplane.
Okay, wings are back to level. You're looking good.
[Narrator] At 32,000 feet,
the pilots need to determine what's wrong with their plane.
[Cox] There's a lot of vibration.
The climb rate decreases.
The engine RPM was rolling back.
They very quickly knew that they had an engine problem.
Emergency descent.
[Narrator] First Officer Ellisor reduces engine power
and begins a steep descent.
I know that we have a pressurization problem.
I know we have some sort of engine problem.
I don't know what else is going on,
but I know we need to start on our way down.
[Captain Shults] Southwest 1380 has an engine fire
and is descending
[Narrator] Captain Shults updates
New York Air Traffic Control.
Smoke in the cockpit could indicate an engine fire.
[Ellisor] Tammie Jo thought it was smoke.
I did not think it was smoke at the time.
Explosive decompression causes a condensation in the air,
which basically looks like a fog.
[Atc New York Center] All right, Southwest 1380.
Okay, where would you like to go?
To which airport?
[Captain Shults] Give us a vector to your nearest airfield.
[Atc New York Center] Okay.
We knew we needed to land the airplane
as soon as practical,
I looked on my map display
and saw two airfield circles
that were very close,
except they were very small airports.
They may not have the appropriate fire
and rescue crews there.
They may not have a long enough runway for us.
[Dramatic Music]
[Narrator] First Officer Ellisor
sees another option 70 miles away.
It's an airport he knows well.
I just pointed on my map
to Philadelphia
and she saw it immediately.
[Captain Shults] Philadelphia.
[Narrator] Flight 1380 is now falling fast.
Unsure of what's wrong with their aircraft,
the pilots update the passengers.
[Captain Shults] Ladies and gentlemen.
This is your captain. We're going into Philadelphia.
Remain seated. Thank you.
I'll tell you what, I'm going to take it.
[Ellisor] All right.
[Narrator] As commander of the flight,
Captain Shults takes control.
[Ellisor] Whatever she told me to do, I was going to do.
She wanted to fly and wanted me to run the checklist
and I was fine with that.
[Narrator] First Officer Ellisor begins checklists
for a severe engine failure or fire.
The problem engine, engine one on the left side,
must be shut down before it can do any more damage.
[Ellisor] Auto throttle, if engaged, disengage.
That checklist calls for multiple steps.
[Captain Shults] Disengaged.
[Ellisor] You retard the throttle
for the affected engine
and then you have a fire warning switch
which you will pull.
[Cox] It's too easy to have something get overlooked
in an emergency.
Checklists are designed to be very efficient.
Also ensure that the airplane remains in a safe state.
[Narrator] Flight 1380 is ten minutes away
from Philadelphia International Airport
and closing fast.
Controllers in Philadelphia
try to guide the flight to safety.
Southwest 1380, are you coming right in or extended final?
[Narrator] And as the plane drops below 10,000 feet,
the crew no longer needs oxygen masks to breathe.
Extended final.
[Narrator] The captain requests a longer approach
so she and Ellisor have time to finish their checklists.
We got a couple of checklists to run.
I wanna talk to the girls as well.
We don't know what happened back there.
You go talk to the girls. I've got everything here.
You guys there? Hello?
[Suspenseful Music]
I rang the flight attendants and I didn't get any answer.
I didn't know what was going on back there.
I got no reply from the back.
I'm really starting to get worried.
And I was so concerned that I was ready to get up
to see what's going on back there.
[Narrator] Before First Officer Ellisor can investigate,
there's a call from the cabin.
Hello?
[Seanique] A window is open and somebody is out the window!
[Plane Whooshing]
-[Suspenseful Music] -[Plane Whooshing]
[Narrator] Flight 1380 is just 20 minutes
into a four hour flight from New York to Dallas, Texas.
Suddenly,
crisis strikes.
There's a very, very loud noise
that is repeating over and over again,
like a big loud pounding of the aircraft.
I didn't know what was happening.
[Andrew Needum] Just metal on metal, shearing grinding,
a noise that I hope I never have to hear again.
[Fernheimer] I didn't know if it was going
to be heavy turbulence,
if it was something wrong with the plane.
And I knew that something was not right.
[Narrator] The cabin is rapidly decompressing
as the pressurized air inside the cabin rushes to escape
to the low pressure atmosphere outside.
What happens is the air in your lungs
gets pulled out as well.
So you exhale a lot
and it's very surprising to you.
[Narrator] Passengers and crew need oxygen masks
-to help them breathe. -[People Screaming]
One passenger uses his phone
to film the chaos in the cabin.
It was just screams of terror
throughout the cabin of the airplane.
[People Screaming]
The noise was just immense
and the shaking was violent.
[Plane Rattling]
-[Seanique] What's happening? -Jump seats.
[Fernheimer] And I see Seanique.
I didn't have time to really take a moment
to look around before I was telling her
to quickly take the jump seat.
My eyes got very heavy.
Everything became very, very hot,
then very, very cold at the same time.
As the warm air that the airplane was making is evacuated
and the fact that it's now 50 below zero outside,
it gets very cold very, very quickly.
[Fernheimer] I could just feel
a lack of oxygen surrounding me.
You just have to make sure that you are getting oxygen.
I was able to take my first good breath of oxygen
before going out into the cabin without even thinking.
[Narrator] The cabin crew checks on the passengers,
row by row.
[Plane Whooshing]
It's so noisy that it's nearly impossible to communicate.
[Fernheimer] I looked every single one of them in the eye
and I just said,
"You're going to be okay.
We are going to make it. I'm here."
And at that point, we didn't even know if that was true.
[Narrator] At row 14,
the flight attendant is stopped cold.
We had a passenger that was partially out of the aircraft.
Her seat belt was the only thing that was holding her
into the plane at that point,
because everything from the waist up
was outside of the plane.
We're gonna be okay. It's okay.
[Cox] When an aircraft depressurizes,
all of that air is going to come out
this now hole that was a window in the side of the airplane.
And it's an immense amount of force.
We're gonna be okay.
[Narrator] Passenger Jennifer Riordan
has been pulled part way out of the plane.
I was trying to pull Jennifer back into the plane.
I remember saying out loud, "It's okay."
We have you. You're gonna be okay.
I just wanted her to somehow
know that we were with her.
It's okay.
It's okay, you're gonna be okay.
Help me!
[Narrator] Passenger Andrew Needum,
a firefighter and paramedic, acts instinctively.
The thought process that was going through my head
was that there was a passenger in need
and I was there to provide assistance.
[Narrator] Andrew Needum joins fellow passenger,
Tim McGinty, in the struggle to pull Jennifer Riordan in.
My immediate reaction was to just reach in
and grab for whatever I could
and I was able to grab onto Mrs. Riordan's pants.
I was unable to get any leverage.
[Narrator] As passengers struggle
to save Jennifer Riordan,
the pilots are unaware of what's happening in the cabin.
You guys there, hello?
-[Plane Whooshing] -[Suspenseful Music]
They were actually trying to call us,
but we were unable to hear that they were trying to do so.
I got no reply from the back.
[Narrator] Finally,
flight attendant Seanique Mallory tries
to make contact with the pilots.
[Ellisor] Hello?
A window is open
and somebody is out the window!
Everything pretty much just stopped.
[Suspenseful Music]
It's not something that you're prepared to hear at all.
Tammie Jo and I just looked at each other
in basically shock and disbelief.
Okay, we're coming down.
-[Suspenseful Music] -[Plane Whooshing]
[Narrator] The life of a passenger is in grave danger.
You want the airplane on the ground,
you want it stopped,
and you want medical people on board to help.
[Narrator] The pilots must get flight 1380
on the ground as soon as possible.
-[Suspenseful Music] -[Plane Whooshing]
[Narrator] 6,000 feet over Pennsylvania,
Southwest flight 1380 has lost its left engine
and suffered a rapid decompression.
Is everyone else still in a seat, strapped down?
Everybody is still in their seats.
[Narrator] But now the pilots face
another terrifying problem.
We've tried to help get her in.
I don't know what her situation is.
But the window is completely out.
[Narrator] Passengers are still struggling
to pull Jennifer Riordan inside the cabin.
We were pulling with everything we had.
We weren't getting anywhere.
[Cox] The big factor for the passenger was
that they went into very high energy air.
It's a 300 plus mile an hour wind.
They would be subjected to brutal forces.
Slow it down to 210 knots right now.
[Narrator] In the cockpit,
First Officer Ellisor has thought of a way
he can help with Riordan's rescue.
I turned to Tammie Jo and I said,
we need to slow down to 210 knots.
I knew that the speed of the aircraft
was actually the thing
that was preventing the people in the back
from getting that passenger back in the plane.
[Dramatic Music]
We got her!
We got her!
[Narrator] First Officer Ellisor's hunch
pays off.
The slower speed allows rescuers to pull
the passenger back in.
The pilots reduced speed
and it was only at that point where
we were able to pull her back in.
[Narrator] Jennifer Riordan's condition is dire.
There was no signs of life.
I felt for a pulse
and started chest compressions.
It was never a sense of, "Is she still with us?"
It was a
"She's with us.
What can we continue to do to try to keep it this way?"
Let's get her turned in.
[Narrator] The pilots are doing everything they can
to save Riordan.
Philadelphia International Airport is still 30 miles away.
We knew that we needed to get on the ground
as fast as we could.
Everything was time critical.
[Fernheimer] I see a lady come help us, a nurse,
and Andrew, who is a EMT and firefighter,
was starting to do compressions.
I knew that they were able to handle the situation.
Can we have medical meet us at the runway.
We have injured passengers.
Injured passengers, okay.
And is your plane physically on fire?
No, it's not on fire, but parts of it are missing.
They say there's a hole and someone went out.
Sorry, there was a hole on someone went out?
[Ellisor] Yes.
Southwest 1380.
It doesn't matter. We'll work it out there.
The airport's just off to your right.
[Suspenseful Music]
[Narrator] Flight 1380 descends to 3000 feet.
All right, set flaps to five.
[Narrator] Still 20 miles away from the airport,
the pilots prepare for landing.
You fly at a higher speed with flaps five.
She had less drag and less lift
being produced out of the flaps.
[Narrator] As an ex fighter pilot,
Captain Shults knows how speed will give her more control.
The captain elected to use a reduced flap setting
and a higher approach speed
so that she was guaranteed,
in her mind, a higher level of controllability.
Flaps five, are you sure? How about just 15?
That's something we know.
Tammie Jo initially asked for a flaps five landing.
I questioned this because a flaps 15 landing
is what we normally would do
in a single engine situation.
[Cox] The captain is the final authority.
She had been flying the airplane,
so she knew how the airplane felt.
And so she said, well, we're gonna land with flaps five.
-Give me a speed for flaps five. -148.
[Narrator] There's no guidance in the manuals
for a flaps five single-engine landing.
The pilots need to calculate
the right airspeed for the maneuver.
148, 160 plus 20.
180!
[Ellisor] The only thing I knew was a flaps 15 speed
and I added 20 knots.
Probably that was too much,
but a little bit of extra speed is better than being slow.
[Plane Whooshing]
[Narrator] At an altitude of just 1000 feet
and three miles from
Philadelphia International Airport,
the pilots prepare for an emergency landing.
In the cabin,
two passengers are still trying
to revive Jennifer Riordan.
[Fernheimer] I start seeing, you know,
trees and grass very, very quickly.
I realized that we were landing soon
and we were landing very fast.
Keep going.
The thought that crossed my mind was, why am I not bracing?
But at the same time, I didn't wanna give up.
[Fernheimer] Andrew continued to do compressions.
I just remember looking outside,
turning around,
and just screaming.
Everybody heads down, stay down!
And I walked a few rows at a time
and showed the passengers their brace positions.
Then once I realized we were landing,
you know, much sooner than anticipated,
I started very quickly running to the front of the plane
to try to get in my jump seat.
[Philadelphia Tower] Southwest 1380, runway 27 left.
Cleared to land.
27 left cleared to land, Southwest 1380.
[Narrator] It's seconds before touchdown.
Flight 1380 is flying towards the runway
at breakneck speed.
The approach speed was about 50 miles an hour faster
than a traditional 737 landing,
because of the reduced flap setting.
[Suspenseful Music]
Speed brake?
Armed with a green light.
[Narrator] The pilots are unsure
of the damage to the plane.
They're making a high-speed approach with a reverse thrust
from only one engine to slow them down.
They might not have enough runway to stop safely.
[Ellisor] 50 feet.
[Narrator] The fate of 144 passengers
hangs in the balance.
We were coming in much faster than normal.
I anticipated the landing was gonna be rough.
[Suspenseful Music]
[Fernheimer] Anything could happen to this plane right now.
We don't know the damage.
Is there going to be an explosion?
-[Suspenseful Music] -[Plane Whooshing]
[Narrator] Flight 1380 races towards an emergency landing
at Philadelphia International Airport.
30 feet.
[Narrator] Captain Shults is a veteran Navy pilot.
She's landed F-18 Hornets in war zones,
but this is a landing unlike any other.
Ten.
We did not wanna do a go around.
We wanted to make sure we were on the ground as fast
as possible so that we could get medical attention
to our injured passengers.
[Fernheimer] I was not able to make it to a jump seat
before I could feel the wheels touching down.
I braced myself with the passengers help
of holding on to me.
[Dramatic Music]
[Ellisor] Speed brakes up.
[Narrator] The thrust reverser
on their only engine deploys.
If the reverser doesn't work,
the plane could overshoot the runway.
[Fernheimer] We just had to be prepared
for absolutely anything.
In my mind, I had to say,
"Okay, these are my exits. These are my people."
We touched down.
It was a great landing.
Thank you Lord, thank you.
Thank you, thank you, Lord.
[Melancholy Music]
Just gonna pull her around here to the fire trucks.
[Narrator] Flight 1380 rolls to a stop.
I knew in that moment that, okay, we made it.
We survived.
[Narrator] But the crisis isn't over.
The critically injured passenger
needs urgent medical attention.
Okay, listen up, listen up. This is the flight deck.
Please stay in your seats.
Emergency equipment is pulling up.
Please stay in your seats.
[Ellisor] I really didn't have much of a sense of relief.
I was still trying to maintain communications
with the flight attendants,
as well as the crash and fire crew.
[Narrator] Rescuers rush onto the plane.
They try to help Jennifer Riordan,
but it's too late.
[Melancholy Music]
Jennifer Riordan is the first fatality
on an American airliner in more than nine years.
With the tragic loss of one passenger,
this would have been a major event,
but investigative agencies look
at a major failure of this nature,
with or without a fatality, as being very serious.
[Narrator] The National Transportation Safety Board,
the NTSB, dispatches a team to Philadelphia.
Structures team, start on that window.
Come with me.
[Narrator] The lead investigator coordinates a team
of air crash experts.
Flashlight, please.
[Cox] They were quite surprised to see the amount of damage.
I think it was very surprising to everyone.
[Narrator] Investigators quickly determined
why the window in row 14 burst.
The left engine close by is blown to pieces.
[Cox] It almost looked as though there had been an explosion
in the front of the engine.
You don't typically see this sort of damage
and it was extensive.
[Narrator] The investigators closely examine
the destroyed engine.
There's no sooting in the engine
so it's clear there was no in-flight fire.
It's quickly obvious to investigators
what tore the engine apart.
-Fan blade did this. -[Suspenseful Music]
[Narrator] During normal operation,
a fan at the front of the engine
rotates approximately 5,000 times per minute.
24 fan blades force air backwards
to feed the engine's turbines.
It's a crucial part of a jet engine.
The fan at the front of the engine is responsible
for 90% of the thrust of the engine.
[Plane Whooshing]
[Narrator] But one of the 24 blades
of the fan on the left side broke off mid-flight.
[Investigator] Got impact markings here.
[Narrator] When investigators look closely
at the remains of the broken fan blade,
they find markings they recognize.
You got beach marks here.
They're called beach marks because it's like
the marks left by a tide on the beach.
They're the most obvious things to see.
[Narrator] The beach marks at the base
of where the fan blade broke off can only mean one thing.
[Jim Wildey] This is most likely fatigue cracking.
Fatigue cracking is insidious.
It starts at a very small location, very small crack,
and it continues to grow over time
and unless this crack is detected,
it's gonna lead to the failure of the part.
Get me the maintenance records for the left engine,
as far back as you can go.
[Narrator] A metal fatigue crack on a fan blade
can grow slowly over time.
Airlines are supposed to make periodic checks
so that no plane flies with a weakened fan blade.
Fan blades are routinely removed
and inspected on all aircraft.
And if they're damaged in any way, they're replaced.
And they're also checked
to make sure that the metal fatigue
has not set in and that there's cracks.
This is an ongoing process.
-[Plane Whooshing] -[Suspenseful Music]
[Narrator] But a fatigue crack in a single fan blade
caused catastrophic damage to flight 1380,
resulting in the death of passenger.
How could that have happened?
[Suspenseful Music]
NTSB investigators wondered if engineers were doing
the proper maintenance to prevent a fan blade
from breaking mid-flight.
Which blade is it?
Thirteen.
[Moss] Catching a fatigue crack at an early stage
is absolutely critical
because it will only get longer and longer
as the engine continues operating.
Eventually, the crack will become so long
that the part is no longer able to hold itself together.
And that's when failure occurs.
[Narrator] Airlines execute inspections
during scheduled maintenance
to look for any defects in the fan blades.
Investigators study the inspection history
for the fan blades in the left engine to flight 1380.
They did a full overhaul in 2012.
Let me see.
[Narrator] They learn that all the fan blades,
including fan blade 13,
were inspected during a major overhaul in 2012,
six years before the incident on Southwest 1380.
During the overhaul, the protective coating
on each of the blades is stripped.
Then a fluorescent dye is used
to help identify any fatigue cracking.
[Moss] The fluorescent dye penetrates into the crack
and the crack is visible as a sort of thin
glowing line under ultraviolet light.
[Narrator] Investigators review the work orders done
on the fan blades during the 2012 overhaul.
This checks out.
Says they did a full inspection of blade 13.
[Wildey] Fan blades on this engine were overhauled in 2012
and that means they were all removed.
The coatings were stripped, they were inspected,
and then everything was reapplied
and they were reinserted.
[Narrator] Investigators determine that
at the time of the 2012 overhaul,
all the fan blades were found to be in good condition.
But how were the fan blades maintained
by Southwest Airlines after the overhaul?
They're supposed to be lubricated
and visually inspected between 1500 and 3000 flights.
There's seven more routine checks here.
They're all comprehensive, all done on time.
[Suspenseful Music]
[Cox] This was the appropriate
and approved maintenance process
that all technicians used at that time.
[Suspenseful Music]
[Narrator] If fan blade 13 was checked routinely
for six years and passed all its inspections,
investigators wonder when the crack began.
So what do you got?
Have a look.
[Narrator] A microscopic examination
of the fracture surface might tell them more
about when the metal fatigue started.
I see.
A crack was growing.
A fatigue crack is a brittle fracture mechanism.
The part looks perfectly good in terms of it's not deformed,
it's not bent, but there's a small defect growing.
[Suspenseful Music]
During the life of these fan blades,
they're subjected to stress.
The engine is started up.
The stress is increased to full power.
The fan blade is being pulled apart
as it tries to go centrifugally outward.
This puts a lot of stress on the root.
The engine is shut down, the stresses go away.
This is one cycle of loading
and it's equitable to one flight cycle.
How long was the crack growing?
Can you tell?
Yeah.
Let's take this up a notch.
Here, look.
[Narrator] Using high magnifications,
investigators can see tiny tracings called striations.
There's thousands of them.
Investigators determined that each striation corresponded
with one flight cycle of the engine.
Therefore, the number of striations matched a number
of flights that had been done by the engine.
[Narrator] Investigators tally the striations
on the fractured blade.
That means counting tens of thousands
of microscopic marks on a tiny piece of metal.
There's over 32,000 striations.
What's that tell you?
[Narrator] By counting the striations
on the base of fan blade number 13,
investigators are able to date the beginnings of the crack.
This crack could've started more than six years ago.
[Narrator] It's an important development.
The fatigue crack on fan blade 13
likely began before the engine overhaul in 2012,
when the blades were under close inspection.
The investigators concluded that the crack was present,
but had been missed at its last overhaul
and during the subsequent visual inspections.
-[Suspenseful Music] -[Plane Buzzing]
[Narrator] The pressure on investigators mounts.
There are more than 4,000 Boeing 737s in service,
using the same type of fan blades.
The same inspection regime
that missed the growing crack is also used
throughout the aviation industry.
[Plane Rattling]
The catastrophe that struck flight 1380 could happen again.
Once a fatigue crack has started or initiated,
you could liken it to a ticking time bomb.
[Suspenseful Music]
[Narrator] Investigators need to know
why engineers didn't find the crack
on the fan blade that caused the tragedy on Southwest 1308.
The last major inspection that was done was
with a dye penetrant check
that was the approved and appropriate test
at that time.
[Narrator] The NTSB discoveries that industry regulators
were slow to adopt new, more powerful technologies.
It's unfortunate that technologies existed that time
but they weren't used.
And it's arguable whether had they been used,
the crack would definitely have been picked up before failure.
[Narrator] Ultrasonic probes allow inspectors
to detect growing fatigue cracks far more effectively.
An ultrasonic inspection shoots a sound wave
into the part and this sound wave can reflect off
of any kind of defect that might be there.
So this can detect internal defects,
as well as surface defects.
[Narrator] If a fatigue crack in fan blade 13
had been detected by inspectors using this new technology,
the catastrophe on flight 1380 could have been prevented.
[Wildey] Whether another inspection would've
found the crack,
it's possible, but this wasn't approved at the time
and it wasn't applied.
[Narrator] But the missed crack
doesn't explain why the shattered fan blade
caused so much damage to the engine.
To have a fan blade fail is not an impossible condition.
It doesn't happen very often,
but it does happen
and typically what will occur is the engine contains it
and the airplane lands normally.
[Narrator] The accident on flight 1380 reveals a weakness
in the Boeing 737's turbofan engines.
When the fan blade departed, it damaged the cowl latches.
[Narrator] There are three latches on the underside
of the cowlings that secure it to the engine.
The latches are what maintenance needs access
to work on the engine.
So these cowlings will actually open up.
[Narrator] Investigators determine
that when the 11-pound fan blade broke off,
it was propelled downward,
striking the underside of the latches.
One of the most vulnerable places of the engine.
The impact opened the cowl enough for the incoming air
to rip the housing from the engine,
sending shrapnel everywhere.
[Cox] One of the questions was, why didn't we see
this sort of failure during certification testing?
This engine was certified in 1997.
The computer modeling available in those days
never predicted that this sort of failure could happen.
[Narrator] Investigators now understand what happened
on Southwest flight 1380.
[Suspenseful Music]
Row 14, just on the right.
[Narrator] A small fracture in fan blade 13
had been slowly growing for more than six years.
When flight 1380 reaches cruising altitude,
the fan blade finally breaks.
It strikes a weak spot in the casing
and starts a chain reaction
that tears the engine apart,
sending a piece of the engine cowl
into the window at row 14.
It causes a rapid decompression in the cabin.
[Plane Whooshing]
Jennifer Riordan sitting in seat 14A
is sucked out the window.
It's okay.
You're gonna be okay, it's okay.
[Fernheimer] When I first saw a passenger out the window,
it was a shock.
It's not anything that I ever
in a million years thought I would see.
Help me!
[Needum] I said, you know, to myself,
"It's time to go to work."
And so I positioned myself accordingly
and I had another passenger in row 15 who was assisting me.
And the two of us were pulling with everything we had.
Fifty feet.
[Narrator] Years of training
and experience help Captain Tammie Jo Shults
and First Officer Darren Ellisor
get their badly-damaged plane safely on the ground.
This entire flight crew performed extremely well.
Everyone did their job and did it well.
A lot of good aviation techniques,
a lot of training came into play.
[Ellisor] I definitely had a lot of anxiety
from the time that the engine exploded
and it really didn't even stop
once we got the airplane on the runway.
[Narrator] A high pressure emergency landing
saves the plane,
but the accident takes Jennifer Riordan's life.
[Melancholy Music]
[Suspenseful Music]
The NTSB's report recommends
that Boeing redesign engine cases
so a detached fan blade can't cause a catastrophic accident.
The aviation industry expands the use of ultrasonic testing.
With the implementation of this new technology,
similar incidents are averted.
[Tool Beeps]
Technicians found 23 fan blades
that exhibited some form of potential cracking
and they were removed from service.
[Narrator] The skilled airmanship
of Captain Tammie Jo Shults
and First Officer Darren Ellisor
is recognized around the world.
We're not heroes, no.
Tammie Jo and I, we were only doing our jobs.
Everything that we were trained to do.
I do consider the passengers
and the flight attendants heroes.
They put their own lives on the line,
that is being a hero right there.
[Narrator] The actions of the flight attendants
are also honored.
That day in April,
it was our very last day we were going home
so it was "Go Home Day," as we call it.
In my mind, that day was going to go very differently.
I did what I needed to do.
That day was definitely not the day that we had expected.
It's okay, you're gonna be okay.
As humans, when things are at their worst,
we are at our best.
The flight attendants and the passengers.
When it was really the darkest of times,
they rose to the occasion.
We did everything we could with what we had.
There's people around us that are willing to help
and want to help.
You know, we're all here for a reason.
And for some of us,
that is to serve.
[Melancholy Music]
[Fernheimer] I was able to really learn about Jennifer
and learn who she is as a person
and learn how wonderful she is in the community
and the foundation that she has in her name.
The one thing that she wanted to do
in this world was to spread kindness.
And even though she's no longer with us,
she's still doing that through other people.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.