Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
(eerie music)
(coughing)
- [Voiceover] What happened?
- It collapsed.
The top floors collapsed down.
- We was in an explosion.
We was in the lobby and the third explosion
the whole lobby collapsed on us.
- [Voiceover] What was it like, what was it like?
- Horrible, horrible.
The whole building just collapsed on us
inside the lobby.
- [Voiceover] Was that a secondary explosion?
- Yes it was
It was like three explosions after that.
We came in after the fire, we came when the fire
was going on already.
We was in the staging area inside the building.
Waiting to go upstairs.
The whole lobby collapsed on the lobby inside.
- When the first of the towers actually started
falling down, I just said this can't happen.
It can't happen.
And then the other tower came down
and I said this violates the laws of physics.
It can't happen.
Those aircraft and those fires could not cause
those buildings to come down in that way.
- I am the highest ranking officer I believe
that has ever gone public
that whatever that story was, the official story
was not true.
When you look at the tower coming down,
what you see are at each floor,
successive puffs of smoke.
Puff, puff, puff, puff, puff, all the way down.
What are the puffs of smoke coming from?
Well, they claim they're from the collapsing floors.
Uh uh, uh uh, no no no.
Those puffs of smoke are controlled demolitions.
That's exactly what they are
because that's exactly how they work.
- The most obvious hypothesis for anyone looking
at the films and that was a lot of people,
is that the buildings came down because
there was very carefully controlled demolition
with high explosives that had been planted many
weeks if not months before.
- [Tyrone] Nothing no more is worse than this.
You're in the building trying to help people
and it's exploding on you inside the building
So I don't think it could get any worse than this.
(dramatic music)
(heartbeat)
- Looking anew at 9/11 is a lot like watching
a great movie that at the end you find out a detail
that transforms the whole experience of the movie.
That the characters, the scenes, all have a different
meaning that need to be reprocessed.
Sometimes we go to see the movie again
to understand what was actually happening
that we didn't the first time.
Reprocessing 9/11 will inevitably stir up new hurts.
We've already been through the trauma,
but now realizing that there's a different meaning
cuts in a different way, and we have to be willing
to endure those pains, those hurts, and those fears
that are required there.
And in some way we have to relive 9/11 anew.
- I think we can all relate to the initial shock and awe
of the planes approaching the World Trade Center,
going into them, we were terrified, we thought
the country was under attack, and then we were given
an explanation within 24 to 48 hours
that this was forces from the Mid East, 19 Arabs,
and that flashbulb memory, that traumatic event
has stayed with us ever since.
It's been called shock and awe in another context
with Iraq, but there was a shock and awe definitely in that
case and the media theory says that the first story
is the one that sticks with you.
- September 11 the world experienced a shock
and especially the American people
and then we got disoriented in a state of what is called
cognitive dissonance where we had two different ideas
that did not go together.
For example, in America we thought we were safe.
And yet now we were not.
Where were those military airplanes
that are supposed to protect us?
We saw the airplanes flying into the towers
and then the towers collapsing.
The explanation was somewhere it was a structural failure.
Then later on we heard from architects and engineer
that it was not possible.
It did not follow the principle of physical laws.
- People continue to be either oblivious to the fact
that this information exists or completely resistant
to looking at this information.
So the question becomes why?
Why is it that people have so much trouble hearing
this information?
Now as we know the horrors of what happened on 9/11
were televised all over the world,
and they were televised in fact live so that millions
of people witnessed that, and millions of Americans
witnessed what was happening, we witnessed the deaths
of almost 3,000 of our fellow Americans.
We know this had a very severe and traumatic impact
on a large majority of the population.
I myself cried for weeks after September 11th.
So I think it's safe to say that collectively as a nation,
because of what happened on September 11th,
we experienced trauma.
Specifically, if we thought the world was a safe place,
after we've experienced or witnessed a trauma
we often think the world is not a very safe place anymore.
And so it very much changes our beliefs about the world,
it changes our ability to trust other people
and to trust other entities.
(melancholy music)
- Many people have rightly commented that 9/11
is a religious issue.
As a theologian I agree with that.
I accept the definition of religion given by Paul Tillich
many years ago saying that religion deals with
matters of ultimate concern.
Now theologian John Cobb has stated that
starting in the 15th and 16th century
we had a major shift in the understanding of
religious concern.
That prior to that time, people were Christians or Jews
and or some other religion, and that was their
primary identity, that was their ultimate concern.
But it shifted in the 15th century
to nationalism, and nationalism in various countries
became the new religion.
This is certainly true in the United States
where Americanism trumps Christianity for many Christians.
I gave a lecture a few years ago called
9/11 and Nationalist Faith.
And in that I argued that even though people who are
Christians or Jews and then if they're Christians
some particular type of Christianity like
the Presbyterian church or Methodist church
or the Catholic church that they actually tend to
subordinate that to their concern for America,
for their devotion to America.
I was interviewed by one of the well-known
talk show hosts on television and they came to the home
and interviewed me and it was going very well
from my point of view but the talk show host
got very upset and finally just blurted out,
"That's blasphemy!"
- It is wrong, blasphemous and sinful for you to suggest,
imply, or help other people come to the conclusion
that the US government killed 3,000 of its own citizens
because--
- And blasphemy is a religious issue.
He was treating Bush and Cheney as if they were
religious figures, as if, frankly, they were
members of the Holy Trinity.
So that was another great revelation to me
that for many people their devotion to the country
or even the political representative of the country
are more important and of religious importance than
claims about what really happened on 9/11.
So I think people need to think seriously through their own
religious commitment, whether they're Christians or Jews
or Muslims or Hindus or Buddhists, think about what it is
they are truly most ultimately concerned about
and if that is God, then they would say
truth is the most important thing.
So I need to be open to the possible truth
of the 9/11 truth movement, even if that is very
threatening to me (rumbling)
and to my commitment to my nation.
- A lens through which to understand the resistance
that we all have against hearing information
that contradicts our worldview, our information
about the official story of 9/11 is what social
psychologists call cognitive dissonance.
For example, with 9/11 we have one cognition
which is the official story of 9/11,
what our government told us, what our media
repeated to us over and over, that 19 Muslims
attacked us.
On the other hand we have what scientists, researchers,
architects, engineers are now beginning to tell us
which is that there is evidence that shows
that the official story cannot be true,
that 9/11 was most likely a false flag operation.
So now we've lost our sense of security.
We are starting to feel vulnerable.
Now we're confused.
Now we have a choice, and we all have this choice
and what some of us will tend to do is
deny the evidence that's coming our way
and stick to the original story, the official story,
and to try to regain our equilibrium in that way.
Another thing we can do is decide to look at the conflicting
evidence and be sincere and be open-minded and look at
both sides of the issue and then make up our own mind
about what reality is.
- One thing I would like people to know is that you don't
need to be an engineer or an architect to see
what happened to those buildings.
I'm asked all the time why should we not believe
the experts and what they've told us?
And I always answer with this simple story.
One day when I was driving my truck down the road,
my truck quit suddenly.
And as I was waiting for the tow truck to come,
I thought to myself well don't just sit here
like a stool pigeon, get out of your truck,
open the hood and look underneath the hood
for anything that's obviously broken.
And I did that and I checked everything,
I checked the oil, I checked the oil temperature,
I looked for fan belt broken, anything, obvious things.
Nothing was wrong.
But when the mechanic called me and told me
that I needed a new engine because it had overheated
and because it had dropped its oil and overheated,
I knew he was lying because I had opened the hood
and looked for myself and thought for myself.
And it turned out it was just a cam sensor
and I was able to fix it myself, I was able to
get the part on Ebay and stick it on
and watch a YouTube on how to fix it and stick it on
and drive away.
But the comparison is this.
Unless you're willing, we all have to be willing
to look at the videos of the buildings coming down.
You have to be willing to look for the obvious evidence.
The symmetry is the smoking gun.
Those buildings could not have fallen in perfectly level.
It's as if you take a level with a bubble in the center
and watch those buildings come down
and that bubble will stay centered the whole way down.
And that cannot happen with an airplane
hitting one side of the building.
It cannot happen that when you have asymmetric damage
you will get a perfectly symmetrical collapse.
And all you need to do is look at the videos and see that.
Then you have to be willing to trust what you saw
and call out the lie.
- [Voiceover] This is an orange.
If you were told it was something else,
you wouldn't believe it, would you?
This is called visual identification
based on experience.
This building is about to be destroyed in what is called
a controlled demolition.
Buildings do not do this spontaneously.
(crowd chanting countdown)
Successful demolitions require that all structural support
columns collapse at virtually the same time.
If they don't, or if something else goes wrong,
the result will look something like this.
This is World Trade Center 7 just before it collapsed
on September the 11th, 2001.
It had not been hit by an aircraft.
It had been damaged by falling debris and minor fires,
but by 5:20pm, the fires were still not a threat.
Although the building was 47 stories high,
it doesn't fall sideways, nor collapse unevenly.
For this to have happened, all of the building's
vertical supports must have given way
at almost exactly the same time.
Yet the Federal Emergency Management Agency reported
that the collapse was due primarily to fire.
But what does it look like to you?
The National Institute of Standards and Technology
still rules out a controlled demolition.
- Some 3,000 members of the families who were lost on 9/11
have been trying for years to get justice
through our system for the losses that they have suffered.
At virtually every step of the judicial process
when the United States government was called upon
to take a position it has been a position adverse
to the interest of United States citizens seeking justice.
This is a very important issue.
It may seem stale to some but it as current as
the headlines that we will read today.
It is an issue that goes to the core of the United States'
contract with its people, that it is highly improbable
that the 19 people could have acted alone.
Yet the official position of the United States government
has been that they did act alone and that there is
no necessity for further inquiry into the question
of whether there was a support network.
President Lincoln had a policy throughout the war
that every message that came into the government,
specifically into the State Department,
was a matter of public record.
On a daily basis his feeling was that if the support
of the American people were gonna be maintained
in a war which was increasingly bloody,
many loss of lives and loss of treasure,
that it took the confidence of the American people
that their government was conducting itself
in an appropriate manner at that the key to that confidence
was disclosure.
I wish we applied the Lincolnesque standard
to what happened in 9/11.
(ominous music)
- World Trade Center 7 collapsed because of fires
fueled by office furnishings.
It did not collapse from explosives
or from fuel oil fires.
Alternative theories are really none of them
have been found to be credible in terms of why
these buildings collapsed.
- Neither NIST or FEMA followed standard protocol
for fire and explosion investigations.
Or just fire investigations for that matter.
National Fire Protection Association Guide number 921
calls for saving the evidence and being prepared
to justify why you wouldn't.
It also calls for testing for accelerants and explosives
when high order damage is involved.
NIST did not do this.
- In an office fire you cannot generate enough heat
to melt steel, and yet we have evidence of molten iron.
In the microspheres, in the rubble pile,
and the metal pouring out of the side of the tower.
- We have found no evidence that would suggest
any kind of an explosive material that caused
the buildings to collapse.
- [Voiceover] I'm wondering did you do any explosive
residue testing on any item out of the building
just to lay these ideas to rest?
- Answer to that is no, we did not do it.
- So the preconceived notion of NIST is that
there's no evidence for explosives and so there's no point
in looking.
That is the most unscientific thing that you can
possibly think of, not to look because
you don't expect to find evidence
and in fact the evidence is overwhelming.
I claim they're not doing science at all,
they're doing propaganda or publicity or whatever they're
doing, but it's not science.
It's not playing by the rules of science.
(eerie music)
- If we lived in a parallel universe that would be
a very different universe but there's, in our view,
not a lot of evidence that that universe
is actually connected to this one.
Now there are actually about 2,000 allegations of this kind
which we saw a lot and we didn't try to knock down
every, we took on a few of the most important ones
in the Report but there are so many incredible allegations
of this kind that we did not, it would have taken us
hundreds of pages in the Report,
which is already a pretty long report
to say and here's why that's bogus, here's why that's bogus,
here's why that's bogus
and we could have gone on like that for a long time.
But we don't actually believe that there is
the kind of controlled demolition scenario
that you have hypothesized.
We don't find any persuasive, affirmative evidence
that that scenario actually is true.
- [Voiceover] 6.5 seconds it dropped in 6.5 seconds.
How do you account for that when it wasn't
hit by a plane?
- It is absolutely obvious to me that we've been lied to,
that the government's official story as put forward
by the Bush Administration and their 9/11 commission
run by Zelikow, a White House flack, and NIST,
the whole stuff is garbage from one end to the other.
It is physically impossible.
- [Voiceover] So the question is, do you believe
what you can see with your own eyes,
or do you believe what you are told?
- People differ in their ability to question authority.
Stanley Milgram did a famous psychological experiment
about 50 years ago and in this experiment 65% of subjects
administered the final, massive, 450 volt shock
to a participant that they believed had a heart condition,
who was screaming and pounding on the wall.
- 375 volts.
- Now they've done a number of replications of this study
and have found that 61 to 66% of people
were prepared to inflict what they believed
was a fatal shock at the bidding of an authority figure.
So roughly two thirds of the public can show
blind obedience to authority.
(dramatic music)
- In the councils of government we must guard against
the acquisition of unwarranted influence,
whether sought or unsought,
by the military industrial complex.
The potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power
exists and will persist.
We must never let the weight of this combination
endanger our liberties or democratic processes.
We should take nothing for granted.
Only an alert and knowledgeable citizenry
can compel the proper meshing of the huge industrial
and military machinery of defense with our
peaceful methods and goals.
- [Voiceover] For we are opposed around the world
by a monolithic and ruthless conspiracy that relies
primarily on covert means for expanding
its sphere of influence.
On infiltration instead of invasion.
On subversion instead of elections.
On intimidation instead of free choice.
On guerrillas by night instead of armies by day.
It is a system which has conscripted
vast human and material resources into the building
of a tightly-knit, highly-efficient machine
that combines military, diplomatic, intelligence, economic,
scientific, and political operations.
Its preparations are concealed, not published.
Its mistakes are buried, not headlined.
Its dissenters are silenced, not praised.
- [Voiceover] In Dallas three shots were fired
at President Kennedy's motorcade in downtown Dallas.
- I can't honestly say that I've ever been
completely relieved of the fact that
there might have been international connections.
- [Voiceover] You mean you still feel that there
might have been?
- Well I have not completely discounted it.
- We have before us the opportunity to forge
for ourselves and for future generations a new world order.
When we are successful, and we will be, we have
a real chance at this new world order.
- What is at stake is more than one small country.
It is a big idea.
A new world order.
Now we can see a new world coming into view.
A world in which there is the very real prospect
of a new world order.
- What happened in 9/11 is we didn't have a strategy,
we didn't have bipartisan agreement, we didn't have
American understanding of it, and we had instead
a policy coup in this country, a coup.
A policy coup.
Some hard-nosed people took over the direction
of American policy, and they never bothered
to inform the rest of us.
I went downstairs, I was leaving the Pentagon
and an officer from the Joint Staff called me
into his office and said, "I want you to know," he said,
"Sir, we're gonna attack Iraq."
And I said, "Why?"
He said, "We don't know."
I said, "Well did they tie Saddam to 9/11?"
He said, "No, but I guess they don't know what to do
"about terrorism, but they can attack states,
"and they want to look strong and so I guess they think
"if they take down a state it will intimidate
"the terrorists.
"It's like that old saying," he said.
"If the only tool you have is a hammer,
"then every problem has to be a nail."
And then I came back to the Pentagon about six weeks later,
I saw the same officer, I said,
"Why haven't we attacked Iraq?
"We still gonna attack Iraq?"
He said, "Oh sir, it's worse than that."
He said, he pulled up a piece of paper off his desk
he said, "I just got this memo from the
"Secretary of Defense's office, it says we're gonna
"attack and destroy the governments in seven countries
"in five years.
"We're gonna start with Iraq and then we're gonna
"move to Syria, Lebanon, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and Iran."
Now did anybody ever tell you that?
Was there a national dialogue on this?
Did senators and congressmen stand up and denounce
this plan?
Was there a full-fledged American debate on it?
Absolutely not, and there still isn't.
Wolfowitz and Cheney and Rumsfeld and
you could name a half dozen other collaborators
from the Project for a New American Century.
They wanted us to destabilize the Middle East.
Turn it upside down.
Make it under our control.
- They told us why they had to do it.
They said we need to occupy Iraq permanently
in order to dominate Iran, Syria, Saudi Arabia,
and the southern Russian republics around the Caspian Sea.
We need to control the entire Middle East
and all its oil.
This war in Iraq has nothing to do with national security
or freedom or democracy or human rights
or protecting our allies or weapons of mass destruction
or defeating terrorism or disarming Iraq,
it has to do with money, it has to do with oil,
and it has to do with raw imperial power.
(military drumming)
- What I found to be very helpful in understanding
our current situation are names.
Names can help us get our mind around
certain concepts.
For example, the term false flag operation.
A false flag operation is usually a violent act
perpetrated by one's own government or group
and scapegoating another group of people
for the purpose of convincing the population
to go to war abroad and to restrict liberties at home.
When we do some research into false flag operations
we find that they are probably government's
most dependable way of getting support for war.
- [Voiceover] In naval warfare, a false flag
refers to an attack where a vessel flies a flag
other than their true battle flag
before engaging their enemy.
It is a trick designed to deceive the enemy
about the true nature and origin of an attack.
In the democratic era, where governments require
at least a plausible pretext before sending their nation
to war, it has been adapted as a psychological warfare
tactic to deceive a government's own population
into believing that an enemy nation has attacked them.
In 1931, Japan was looking for a pretext
to invade Manchuria.
On September 18th of that year, a lieutenant
in the Imperial Japanese Army detonated a small amount
of TNT along a Japanese-owned railway in the Manchurian
city of Mukden.
The act was blamed on Chinese dissidents
and used to justify the occupation of Manchuria
just six months later.
When the deception was later exposed,
Japan was diplomatically shunned and forced to withdraw
from the League of Nations.
In 1962, the US Joint Chiefs of Staff authored
a document called Operation Northwoods, calling for
the US government to stage a series of fake attacks,
including the shooting down of military or civilian
US aircraft, the destruction of a US ship,
sniper attacks in Washington, and other atrocities
to blame on the Cubans as an excuse for launching
an invasion.
In August 1964, the USS Maddox, a US destroyer
on patrol in the Gulf of Tonkin, believed it had
come under attack from North Vietnamese navy torpedo boats,
engaging in evasive action and returning fire.
The incident led to the Gulf of Tonkin Resolution,
authorizing President Johnson to begin open warfare
in Vietnam.
It was later admitted that no attack had occurred
and in 2005 it was revealed that the NSA had manipulated
their information to make it look like an attack
had taken place.
- Johnson said we may have to escalate,
I'm not gonna do it without congressional authority,
and he put forward a resolution the language of which
gave complete authority to the president
to take the nation to war.
The Tonkin Gulf Resolution.
And events afterwards showed that our judgment
that we had been attacked that day was wrong.
It didn't happen.
- [Voiceover] In 2001, attacks in New York and Washington
we blamed on Al Qaeda as a pretext for invading
Afghanistan.
These are but a few of the hundreds of such incidents
that have been staged over the centuries to blame
political enemies for attacks that they did not commit.
The tactic remains in common use today,
and will continue to be employed as long as populations
still blindly believe whatever their governments tell them
about the origins of spectacular terror incidents.
- We're also very fortunate to have the term "deep state".
This term was coined by Professor Peter Dale Scott.
- The public state is the one we're taught about
in school and it's true as far as it goes but all over
the world, particularly since World War Two but even before,
public states have little escape hatches for
when they want to do something illegal.
And in this country the most visible but not the only
sign of it is the CIA, which was actually charged
quite early on in 1948 to start committing crimes
against governments in other parts of the world.
So we do have a deep state in America
and the thesis of my book is it's secret, it's not
properly controlled, it gets involved in larger and larger
enterprises which were never envisaged, by the way,
when the CIA was first created.
Which become more and more disastrous for everybody
including the United States and the balance between
the public state and the deep state has been shifting
more and more towards the deep state
because there are checks and balances on the public state
and nothing that works by way of checks and balances
with the CIA, DIA, and the Drug Enforcement Administration,
the various components of the deep state.
(eerie music)
- And we have more recently been given another phrase,
state crimes against democracy or SCADs, S-C-A-D-S.
The social scientist, through the very prominent
and well-regarded journal The American Behavior Scientist
devoted their entire February 2010 issue to this study
of state crimes against democracy.
What these social scientists are telling us is that
they are seeing patterns.
They are seeing patterns for many state crimes
against democracy, they have looked at
the John F. Kennedy assassination, the Martin Luther King
assassination, the Bobby Kennedy assassination,
the Iran Contra conspiracy, the Watergate conspiracy
and what they're seeing is that there are patterns
and they're telling us that as social scientists they
need to study these patterns.
How these events took place, who benefited from them.
- I remember getting a call from the
fire department commander telling me that they were
not sure they were gonna be able to contain the fire.
I said you know, we've had such terrible loss of life.
Maybe the smartest thing to do is pull it.
And they made that decision to pull and then we watched
the building collapse.
- What were the resulting policy changes?
They need to study these criminal patterns by the deep state
just as they would study any other social issue.
- Numerous false flag events have been used to justify
wars in the past, possibly the Iraq and Afghanistan wars
can be connected to a false flag event in this case.
That would fit into the psychologist's explanation.
Somebody generated a new Pearl Harbor
and that was used to turn public opinion
into the support of war.
- A number of senior congressional figures
are calling this America's Pearl Harbor.
- [Voiceover] This is comparable to an attack
on Pearl Harbor.
- This is an act, when they compare this to Pearl Harbor,
I don't think they're wrong.
- Senator Dodd earlier today compared this
to the equivalent of the bombing of Pearl Harbor.
- In my youth, the Gulf of Tonkin
has been exposed as the false flag non-incident
which was used to get congress to vote to go into Vietnam.
If you look into the history of other wars,
in almost every case you find public opinion was manipulated
to get us into the war and this may be no exception.
So rather than be afraid of the possibility
that we were manipulated into the perception
that we had been attacked, perhaps we should summon
the courage to allow experts to weigh in
and have a public process to get out the truth.
So that's why I have joined the 9/11 truth movement
to allow the light of day to shine on a traumatic event
and hope that out of that can come a national healing.
- When I was first presented with the idea
that 9/11 was an inside job, that 9/11
was a false flag operation, I said well,
give me the evidence.
So he sent me some evidence, some websites,
I looked at them, and didn't find the evidence convincing.
So I went back to the work I was doing.
Six months later somebody else sent me information
so I looked at it and this time it clicked.
I saw stories that were in the mainstream press,
New York Times, nothing in the left-wing press,
nothing unusual, only mainstream press stories
and yet I saw there were dozens, even hundreds
of such stories that conflicted with some aspect
of the official story about 9/11.
Now I've written about, there are different types of people.
You have empirical people who will simply say
look at the evidence and if it's convincing
I will change my mind.
Other people are paradigmatic people.
They have a paradigm.
They say this is the way the world works,
and I'm convinced this is the right way the world works.
9/11 doesn't fit into that paradigm.
So I don't need to look at the evidence, it's paradigmatic.
And then there's a third type of person that we often call
wishful thinkers.
I call it wishful and fearful thinking.
So they simply will not believe something that they fear
to be the truth and I've found that maybe to be
the most powerful factor of people rejecting 9/11 truth
and not even entertaining the evidence.
I had one woman, after I presented what I thought
was a very convincing lecture, she came up to me
and she said, "I simply refuse to believe what you've said,
"because I do not want to live in a country
"where the leaders would do such a thing."
That is fearful thinking with a vengeance.
And it's very common.
So and that fits into this nationalism.
This is the fear that the country that I thought we had,
this country that's better than other countries,
you're telling me that's not true.
That is frightening, I simply refuse to believe it,
I will not listen to any more evidence, whatever it is.
- Now I've noticed as I've spoken with people about 9/11
that I get some very interesting spontaneous reactions
from people.
I believe that every one of us will be able to relate
to these reactions because most of us bought the
official story about what happened on 9/11 completely,
and then we were shocked when we discovered evidence
to the contrary.
Fran.
I refuse to believe that that many Americans could be
that satanically treasonous.
Someone would have talked.
Now this reaction's very interesting because it contains
two assumptions.
Number one, that if 9/11 is a false flag operation
orchestrated by elements within our government,
that it would have required a large number of people
to have pulled it off.
The second assumption is that somebody would have had
a conscience, and would have talked.
But these are beliefs, they are not scientific facts.
But these beliefs do keep us from looking
at the empirical evidence.
Whenever we say I refuse to believe, we can be sure
that the evidence that's coming our way is not bearable,
and it's conflicting with our worldview much too much.
Another reaction.
Fran, you can't expect someone to let in information
that turns their world upside down.
If this were true, up would be down and down would be up.
My life would never be the same.
Another said, have you lost friends
talking about this issue?
And by the way, that's a very important statement.
I think that is at bottom what most of us fear
is being ostracized and by the way the answer to this is
no I have not lost any real friends, but I have had
very good friendships severely strained,
and that's the nature of this subject.
When we introduce an idea that is paradigm-shifting
to a person, this is to be expected.
Here are some very honest responses that I've heard.
I must admit that I seriously resist anyone messing
with my worldview.
I wouldn't want to live in a world where such a thing
could be true.
And finally, here's the most honest response
I have ever received.
If what you're saying is true, I don't want to know,
because I would become very negative, my life would go
downhill, I'd take a turn for the worse.
So as I thought about all of these responses,
I realized that what is common to every one of them
is the emotion of fear.
People are afraid of being ostracized,
they're afraid of being alienated, they're afraid
of being shunned, they're afraid of
their lives being inconvenienced, they'd have to change
their lives, they're afraid of being confused,
they're afraid of psychological deterioration.
They're afraid of feeling helpless and vulnerable.
And they're afraid that they won't be able to handle
the feelings that are coming up.
So really fear is at the bottom of each of these feelings
and when we feel vulnerable and helpless,
it's a very terrible feeling.
None of us want to feel helpless and vulnerable.
So we want to defend ourselves, and the way we often do that
is with anger.
So then we become angry, and when we become angry
then we become indignant, we become offended.
We want to ridicule the messenger.
We want to pathologize the messenger,
and we want to censor the messenger.
- On the day of 9/11 I saw the second plane
crash into the south tower, I got to the TV
just in time to witness that.
And then later in the day I was standing alone
in my kitchen and was suddenly hit with what I think
of now as Jewish paralysis.
As a person of Jewish heritage I suddenly got
the extremely frightening sense that this was a very
coordinated attack by the Arab world on the Jewish people
and there was no particularly rational reason
for me to be thinking that, I just remember that I felt that
very strongly on that day.
After 9/11 we seemed to talk about nothing else
at our office and with my friends and I remember
in a reevaluation counseling session just crying,
crying my heart out as I thought about the children who
were orphaned on that day and thinking about the people
who were forced to jump out of the towers
and the terror they must have felt and I just couldn't
get my head around how people could have been so mean,
so hostile to do that knowing how it would affect people.
- What's critical here is that acts of terrorism
and political terrorism are also considered
traumatic events.
And there's something, what's different about trauma
versus daily stress or situational stress are a few things.
First of all there is a perceived or real threat
to bodily harm or life.
There's also a feeling of being completely helpless
and overwhelmed by a force beyond the individual's control.
There, another characteristic is that resistance or escape
is not possible so these are the characteristics
of traumatic stress.
Now what's very interesting about that, about trauma,
is that actually witnessing a traumatic event
can have the same psychological impact as actually being
in the event.
- Well fear is kind of the beginning of everything.
Goering, at Nuremberg, gave an interview, off the record,
and somebody, bright journalist said how on earth
did you pull it off, you Nazis, to get the Germans
who were a civilized people for several hundred years
to turn into the bloody Huns and go to war?
Make, create concentration camps?
And Goering said well, no sensible man is ever going
to join your army and risk getting killed
unless there's a strong reason, and that's fear.
And we knew how to create it.
The Bolsheviks are coming, or whichever enemy of the week
it was, the Poles are coming, the Czechs are killing
the Sudeten Germans and they'll try and kill you too.
Well just look what's been done now in the name of freedom
and liberty.
The fear is constant, and it's just, for instance,
every child of nine outside the United States
knows that Saddam Hussein had nothing to do with Al Qaeda
and nothing to do with Osama bin Laden.
As a matter of fact the two men despised each other.
Every day for months, one day it'd be the vice president,
next day it'd be the president.
We gotta take care of evil all over the world,
bring 'em back dead or alive.
Now if the people hear that from what they assume
is their president, elected president,
they're bound to believe it, there's some residue
that stays in people's heads, they can't keep lying
that much.
And so with terror they have been able to come up
with the USA Patriot Act which nobody seems to be able
to get their hands on, I can't find it.
Which shreds our civil liberties, and we're now at war
with just about everybody, we're talking about possible
strikes against Iran, North Korea, Syria.
We've gone barbarous, we have gone back two,
three thousand years in human history
to almost pre-Roman times and the rationale among themselves
is we've gotta have that oil.
Well the money we spend on war we could develop
an alternative to fossil fuels.
It's not that far away in the future.
But we don't, we prefer the wars.
(light music)
- I think as a psychologist to overcome our fear of
the traumatic event with new information would be
the best, healthiest route to our collective recovery
from the trauma of 9/11.
That, by the way, is a psychotherapeutic insight
that to gradually uncover the truth in your own life,
the sources of anxiety, to make them conscious,
is the royal road to recovery.
Healing comes through facing the truth, experiencing it,
allowing the feelings to come in
so that if there are feelings of fear that perhaps
these events were caused by something that we haven't
thought about yet, dark elements within our society,
for example, we'll let that come in and explore it.
Let the light shine on whatever happened.
This will be the most healing process.
The Germans did this after their war.
The South Africans did this after apartheid.
Reconciliation through the truth
is what is a deep path to psychologic recovery
from the myths and lies around which this historical event
has been cloaked in the official view.
But some of us find it comforting if we believe
an enemy attacked us.
Most people take that route.
That explanation was given to us by the news media
within hours of the so-called attacks.
That's extraordinary, to identify the perpetrators
on the first day without any forensic examination,
without any investigation of the crime scene.
For example there was another World Trade tower that went
down, World Trade Center 7, and no one's explaining that.
So we waited and we got the 9/11 Commission Report.
We thought that would bring some harmony, some consonance,
but for us there was dissonance.
The official story didn't make enough sense,
we had this discrepant information.
We kept looking and finally we found something
that did produce consonance which was that there was
fairly a demolition in all three buildings.
That's where the Richard Gage explanation
appeals to a wide spectrum of professionals in many
disciplines.
So dissonance is reduced by finding a scientific
explanation and most people find comfort in believing
that we were attacked.
A smaller minority of us feel that it would be
more comforting to understand this in terms of science.
- The thing that's most important about science is
that it's a way of knowing, it's a way of knowing
that anyone can participate, of course they have to have
some background and they all have to develop more,
but it's a way of knowing about anything
and it's at the end of any kind of science activity,
people will agree that they have collected evidence
that illustrates a hypothesis and if the evidence
is contradictory to the hypothesis, one has to abandon
that hypothesis and look for another one.
And one must, in testing any hypothesis or trying to
establish it, consider all of the relevant evidence
which may come from all kinds of places.
Observations, measurements, and so on.
And insofar as people can be objective at all,
they will come to the same sorts of conclusions.
So science is a fundamentally useful and accurate
and universal way of finding out about the world.
- [Voiceover] NIST received 20 million dollars
of taxpayers' money to determine why and how
World Trade Center 1 and World Trade Center 2 collapsed
following the initial impacts of the aircraft.
And to this day, they have not done so.
This is why architects and engineers has kept
pressing NIST, asking them to publish their data
in regards to the potential energy released during
the downwards movement of the upper stories,
and the absortive capacity of the intact structure
below the collapsed zone.
- Structural engineers do this every day.
This is not rocket science.
You have the known weight of this building mass.
You have what are known columns below it
in order to resist it.
You let it go in your models and you calculate
what the resistance is.
Why didn't they do it?
Could it be because they knew darn well
that it would not have collapsed at all?
- [Voiceover] In fact, it could be suggested that NIST
never explained the collapses by gravity alone
because it would be impossible to do so
without violating at least two of the most
fundamental laws of physics.
One is Newton's third law of motion which states
that for every action there is an equal
and opposite reaction.
This means that two opposing forces will neutralize
each other.
In a head-on collision, the two cars absorb
each other's kinetic energy and transform it
into physical deformation or damage.
After that, the system comes to a rest
as there is no more energy to be dissipated.
- The top section pushing on the bottom section,
it's gonna meet equal forces as it goes.
Both sections are gonna be demolished at the same rate
so by the time you've crushed up 15 stories below it,
the top 15 stories are also gonna be crushed.
And so there's nothing left now
to crush the rest of the building.
- [Voiceover] Something of this kind
is what we should have seen
when the top sections of the tower
collapsed onto the lower one.
The upper and lower sections should have mutually
destroyed each other until all the energy is dissipated
and the system comes to a rest.
Alternatively, as shown in this experiment
with two towers made of snow, the top section
could have fallen off to the side
after the initial collapse.
What could not have happened is this.
- Little tiny chunk of the building can't possibly
fall and crush the entire structure below it.
- [Voiceover] This is such a simple, fundamental concept
that architects and engineers were astonished in seeing it
totally ignored by NIST.
- This is high school physics.
And our whole society is being led to believe
that these fundamental laws of physics, hard science,
don't apply anymore.
- [Voiceover] But even if we assume that the top section
of the tower had enough potential energy to destroy
the rest of the structure below, it could not have done so
at the speed it did, which was near freefall speed.
That would have violated an even more important
principle in physics,
known as the law of momentum conservation.
This law states that the total energy within
an isolated system must always remain the same.
As we have seen, the energy can be transformed
within the system, from motion to physical deformation,
but for the deformation to begin, the velocity must decrease
in order for one kind of energy to be transformed
into the other.
No new energy can be added to the system.
One particular example of momentum conservation is freefall.
Freefall happens when the only force applied on an object
is gravity.
This means that all the potential energy contained
by the object is converted into vertical motion.
As soon as the falling object hits an obstacle
and breakage occurs, the speed must decrease
because some of its energy needs now to be converted
into physical breakage.
It takes energy to break things apart,
and that energy must come from within the system.
Thus the falling rock cannot keep falling
at freefall speed and break apart at the same time
because it doesn't have enough energy to do both.
Let's go now to the Twin Towers, and ask a simple question.
Assuming that the top section on the left
contains enough potential energy to destroy
the rest of the tower, and assuming we dropped both
upper sections at the same time, which one would
hit the ground first?
It would be the second, of course.
As it finds no obstacles in its path,
the section on the right would quickly accelerate
to freefall speed and maintain it all the way
to the ground.
The section on the left instead needs to use
some of its energy to destroy the structure below,
so it could never achieve freefall speed.
In the case of the Twin Towers, however,
both upper sections fell with an acceleration
close to freefall speed, as if their path
had been practically free from obstacles.
It took each tower between 10 and 12 seconds
to collapse to the ground, while an absolute freefall time
would have been 9.2 seconds.
In other words, both upper sections of the towers
found enough energy to destroy 80,000 tons
of healthy structure below while accelerating
to near freefall speed.
This is, as we have said, absolutely impossible
by gravity alone.
The law of momentum conservation won't allow it.
- A building cannot do freefall with huge structural
steel structural system in place to support it.
- The Twin Towers could not have come straight down
through the resistance of 80,000 tons of structural steel
at the speed of practically freefall.
That just would not happen.
- If in fact it actually hit and made an impact,
was effectively crushing anything, pushing hard
on this core structure below it, the core structure
is gonna push back equally hard and that's
what's gonna cause the top section of the building
to slow down.
- As energy is drained away from the system
to deform those members, it would slow down
the descending mass and cause a descent at less-than
freefall speed.
- [Voiceover] There is only one way for those buildings
to have collapsed at the speed they did.
- The buildings fall at a speed which can only occur
if the structure has been removed, the vertical structure.
- [Voiceover] The same Shyam Sunder from NIST
has acknowledged that freefall can only be achieved
with the absence of a structure below.
- Freefall time would be an object that has no
structural components below it.
- [Voiceover] But what could have removed
the supporting structure below, since the falling section
didn't have any extra energy to do so?
- The fact that it's coming down at freefall
says all of the energy is being used to just make it
go straight down, which means it's coming down
through itself and not breaking up the building as it goes.
Something else has to be clearing the way.
- [Voiceover] There is only one known way to allow
that kind of acceleration while removing the supporting
structure.
- A building cannot do freefall without it being blown up.
That's the only way it could come down at freefall.
- The only way that a building can accelerate
as it collapses is by having preengineered,
precisely timed, and precisely placed explosives.
In other words, controlled demolition.
(small explosion)
(eerie music)
- In March of 2004 I went with my brother
on a protest march commemorating the first anniversary
of our invasion of Iraq and at that time my brother
told me that there were people who had suspicions
that the United States government or people within
the government had been responsible for the 9/11 attacks.
And when my brother told me this, I immediately felt
such a sense of revulsion and distaste,
it was as if he had exposed himself to me.
And I felt that it was completely beyond the bounds
of decency and good taste for him to have said
something like that and so I changed the subject,
I did not ask any questions about it, I just didn't want
to hear about it.
In May of 2006 my husband asked me to read a book review
of two of Professor David Ray Griffin's books about 9/11.
And by this time I had seen Michael Moore's movie
Fahrenheit 9/11 and I had, I guess I had been
softened up to taking in new information.
So I read this book review and thought oh my gosh,
there is a lot here that I haven't known
and I need to find out more about.
So about a week later after I had read that book review
I went online and I read a lengthy article by Dr. Griffin.
I think it was called Why the Official Account of 9/11
Cannot Be True.
And it was very well documented, very highly footnoted,
lengthy article, very precise and specific and very well
backed up and I got to the end of the article
and I sat there, I was in my office at the time,
I sat there and I felt my stomach churning.
I thought maybe I was going to be sick.
And I leaped out of my chair and ran out the door
and took a long walk around the block,
around several blocks, and just broke down.
I understand now that what was happening was my worldview
about my government being in some way my protector,
almost like a parent, had been dashed
and it was like being cast out into the wilderness
I think is the closest way to describe that feeling
and I sobbed and I sobbed, felt like the ground
had completely disappeared beneath my feet and
I knew at some point during the walk that I knew
that I was going to have to become active
in educating other people about this,
that there was, that for me to retain any sense of integrity
I was going to have to take some action.
I couldn't just let something like this go.
- We are experiencing a public reaction to our quest
for the truth.
What we experience, almost universally, is marginalization.
We're told you don't represent the mainstream,
you're a bit kooky, we're going to scapegoat you,
we're going to dismiss you.
- Psychological terms can be used to hurt people
as well as to help people.
And we can marginalize people.
We can call them, we can say that they're nuts
if they believe something that the majority of us
do not believe.
This has been happening with people who have been
learning about 9/11 and are trying to do something
about it.
We get called things like conspiracy theorists.
It can be a very difficult thing to be called.
People call your sanity into question.
They call your common sense into question.
They call your judgment into question.
You may be much better versed on a subject than they are
but if their views are in line with the majority opinion,
they feel that they have grounds to judge you
and to marginalize you and as a society it's not just
person to person that we marginalize people,
our media will marginalize people,
the government will marginalize people for having
unpopular views and so this is something that people
who are looking at 9/11 are very much up against.
- Another thing that happens is that we human beings
tend to have a need for closure, and simply not knowing
is uncomfortable, we're taught that we're supposed to know
and we don't wanna appear stupid and we wanna have
an opinion for everything and so when there's this
social, societal pressure to not only have an opinion,
but to reach closure about something
and then once we have come to our opinion,
whatever that is, it can be very difficult to challenge it.
And there's something that goes on with people,
it's this phenomenon of scapegoating, and scapegoating
goes back to the ritual back in the Old Testament
when the rabbis would recite the sins of the people
over the heads of goats and then send them out
to the desert where presumably they would be
attacked or killed or whatever but it was a ritualistic
way of transferring the guilt or the blame of the people
onto these goats who were then called of course scapegoats.
And when something bad happens, especially something that's
just terrible or preposterous or very, very evil,
there's an immediate need to find out who did it,
find fault, adjudicate the fault, adjudicate the blame,
and then punish the transgressor.
And so what happened right after 9/11 is that
this was our country and even though most of us, of course,
are not New Yorkers, we took it personally.
This is something that happened to us,
it wasn't just something that happened to the 3,000 people
who died, this was something that happened to me
and to my country and people identify with that.
And so there's this sense of fear and oh my God,
it could have happened here and I remember people
in San Francisco and even Kansas were afraid
that they might be bombed.
In the next couple weeks there was the idea
that America is under attack and we've got to do something,
and one of these things that we need to do
is we need to identify the enemy and punish them
or fight against them or do something about it
and so there was this scapegoating of Osama bin Laden first
and Arabs and "terrorists" later and then we got into
this whole thing on the war on terrorism
and so once this connection with an identified scapegoat
has been made and he becomes a channel for our fear
and anger and even fury and hostility,
then that becomes difficult to dislodge and people become
comfortable in knowing that we have found the enemy,
we have found the problem and we are doing something
about it.
- We start to ask question and we hear worse rumor,
the government, our own government, may be involved.
And we start to be disoriented, we don't know what
to think about it.
It's like having hot and cold at the same time.
Something cannot be hot and cold at the same time.
It cannot be Al Qaeda did it,
the American government did it,
the airplane made the building collapse,
there were explosive.
It makes us very, very uncomfortable and we go back
to every time we hear some more news like that
we go back in the state of shock.
It's easier to just go in front of the television,
have barbecues, have friends over, have parties,
and forget about this whole mess.
However, doing that doesn't help really because
our body, our minds know something is going on
and when we deny it, we push something down
and it starts to gnaw on our bones,
on our organs, pretty soon we will experience
aches and pains.
It is believed that 96% of the aches and pains
and physical trauma we experience within
catastrophic illnesses stem from a trauma
that has not been dealt with.
So it is very important to deal with a trauma
in the best possible way.
One of the ways to deal with a trauma is to find
the answers.
(dramatic music)
- A lot of people have been wondering why there's been
this massive level of denial of people around,
the incidents surrounding 9/11.
And I think there are several reasons for this.
One is that we tend to be creatures of habit
and beliefs are habits just like eating, drinking,
or sleeping, and we tend to believe and then become
attached to and even identify with our personal beliefs
and then we'll defend them if they're challenged in any way.
There's a wonderful quotation from the American humorist
Will Durant where he once said that
it's not what we know that gets us in trouble,
it's what we think we know that ain't so.
One of our most cherished beliefs is the belief
in American goodness.
We've been taught since the time we were little kids
that America is the leader of the free world,
that this is the land of the free and the home of the brave.
You know, we wave the flag, I remember growing up
watching Superman, at the end of every episode,
they would talk about the fight for truth, justice,
and the American way.
This is something that all of us, is very close to
in our hearts.
- [Voiceover] Fights a neverending battle for truth,
justice, and the American way.
- So when any information comes up that might challenge
this belief in American goodness, a lot of people
experience this phenomenon of cognitive dissonance
and simply cannot deal with it, intend to either deny it
or push it away and for some people they just do not even
wanna go there just because it's too uncomfortable.
- We face a lot of difficulty looking at 9/11 objectively.
We've all been raised to believe that we're in
the greatest country that ever existed.
That this couldn't happen here.
Our founders, founding fathers did not make the same
mistakes, they were perhaps excellent psychologists.
They knew human nature, they knew that man was capable of
great harm, great evil.
They also knew man had great good.
They knew that they could create a system
based upon values.
Liberty, democracy, freedom, freedom from
cruel and unusual punishment.
They never made the mistake of trusting individuals
or individual systems.
They knew, with a healthy skepticism, that people were,
and power would always seek to undermine democracy.
- 9/11 truth challenges some of our most
fundamental beliefs about our government
and about our country.
We are indoctrinated from an early age to believe
that America is good at that we are exceptional.
We are the shining beacon in the darkness,
a voice for freedom and justice.
This patriotic indoctrination is carried out by schools,
the military, churches, the media, and other institutions.
It's repeatedly hammered home throughout our lives.
Over and over and over again.
No wonder Americans go into denial at the suggestion
that our government committed a crime
against its own people.
Many people respond to these truths in a very deep way.
Some have a visceral reaction like they've been
punched in the stomach.
To begin to accept the possibility that the government
was involved is like opening Pandora's box.
If you open the lid and peek in a little bit,
it's gonna challenge some of your fundamental beliefs
about the world.
- Some people might think that if you believe in
9/11 truth or question the official story that it means
you can't love your country or that we would
feel bad about our country.
Our country does have phenomenal ideals.
Those ideals transcend any government or individuals.
Those ideals the founders set up so for us to practice
and to fight for.
Our system was never designed to provide a free ride
for us to loaf and not continue to safeguard liberty
and freedom.
But the ideals of our country are great and
they are still possible for us.
And we should continue to fight for those.
9/11 is central to marshaling the public will
to move in a direction that it doesn't want to go.
To become a different kind of country.
Not the country that we grew up in,
but a foreign country that, with foreign values
of torture, illegal wars, threats, threats to our emotions,
threats to our sense of safety.
This is terrorism.
It's terrorism by our government.
These things should not be tolerated
unless we want to tolerate being led in a direction
on false information then we need to be
closer to the truth.
- I thought that it was a matter of real concern
that planted stories intended to serve
a national purpose abroad came home and were
circulated here and believed here
because this would mean that the CIA could manipulate
the news in the United States by channeling it
through some foreign country.
And we're looking at that very carefully.
- [Voiceover] Do you have any people being paid by the CIA
who are contributing to a major circulation
American journal?
- We do have people who submit pieces to American journals.
- [Voiceover] Do you have any people paid by the CIA
who are working for television networks?
- This I think gets into the kind of, getting into
the details, Mr. Chairman, that I'd like to get into
in executive session.
- At CBS we have been contacted by the CIA,
as a matter of fact by the time I became the head
of the whole news and public affairs operation in 1954
relationships had been established and I was told about them
and asked if I'd carry on with them.
- [Voiceover] Do you have any people being paid by the CIA
who are contributing to the national news services?
AP and UPI.
- Well again I think we're getting into the kind of detail,
Mr. Chairman, that I'd prefer to handle
in executive session.
(eerie music)
- The media seems to function as the prime
enabler of the 9/11 events.
That you can almost see the media as a kind of
a national mind or a global mind, that it's hard to
think outside of what we see on television
and in newspapers.
And if they're presenting repeatedly one version,
they are very convincing and so the media is part
of the problem and if we knew the media better
we would have known this before 9/11 so when the media
told us who it was and didn't question, we would have
questioned the media.
But that's another part of our system
that we have not faced
is that our media really does not serve the people
the way that we think it does.
It does serve government, it serves business interest,
and it is blocked out like a mind guard
against the 9/11 truth, the truth of what happened.
So if we're waiting for people in the media
to come forward, it's probably not going to be happening.
The Catholic church has had a terrible crisis
with priests that abused young children sexually,
and it was hard for anyone to believe
that this could happen.
It was hard for the priests, I'm sure, who knew.
So when we ask, well wouldn't somebody have come forward?
I don't know that there were any, or many, priests
that came forward and confronted the Catholic church
on the sexual abuse.
These were good men.
Many good men had to have known and stayed silent
and allowed this to go on, allowed it to be covered up.
To paraphrase Upton Sinclair, it's hard to get a man
to understand something that his livelihood depends on
him not understanding.
Likewise, it's hard to get a man to disbelieve something
that his livelihood depends on him believing.
And so we have multiple portrayals in this situation
with people with power with knowledge.
Some of whom like to kid themselves,
some of them protect themselves from the knowledge,
most of them are scared.
And so we need to know that the people that are approached
about 9/11 truth are scared too.
They may get angry, but this is very disturbing.
One of the great flaws that the Greeks told us about
and warned us was excessive pride.
The thinking that we're above such things,
that it could happen in other countries
but it couldn't happen here, that's a lack of humility,
and that's excessive pride.
And so not being able to see our dark side
or our weaknesses is the most dangerous thing.
When we can see them, we can deal with them,
we can interpret, and that's a strength.
The woman that doesn't know that her husband
has had affairs before or doesn't know that he's abusive
is worse off for not having known, for being in denial.
Knowing the truth is empowering, and we can cope with that.
We've coped with the Great Depression,
we've coped with World War Two, we've coped with
a great number of things and it would get our country
back on track in the values that we believe in,
and there wouldn't be anything stopping us from being
the kind of country that we believe we are.
- The observation that pride is one of the basic human
flaws is absolutely correct.
This is especially true for Americans because
we for a long time looked at other nations and say oh,
they're in such bad shape but luckily we don't
have those problems, we don't have leaders who would
do those things that were done in the Soviet Union
or done in Germany or done in Japan and on down the list.
So this is a type of pride.
A feature of American history that makes us particularly
liable to this pride is this notion that's called
exceptionalism, that America is the exceptional nation.
And that began from the beginning as this country
was formed the people would say well, there was so much
evil in the European countries, so much cheating,
so much lying, so much using the people for the ruler's
purposes, but not in America.
We have leaders that are free from those sins.
So I think this has made 9/11 particularly difficult for
Americans.
We find that the Europeans in the 9/11 movement
don't have such a problem.
We found that the Japanese don't have a problem.
They do not believe that the United States
is the exceptional nation in this sense,
that we are somehow, our leaders are above the sins
that affect other leaders.
Now most people are very convinced that we're going
the wrong direction.
The polls show that.
We have a terrible debt, we didn't move out of it the way
that we should have because the people who were in charge
did not have that as the primary priority,
that is to help the ordinary people.
We also see that the constitution has been gutted.
We're doing many things that prior to 9/11 were
inconceivable, that we would just accuse someone
of a crime and put them in prison indefinitely
without a trial and this happens, this has happened
to many people including many Americans.
We have this, what's called extraordinary rendition
where people have been taken out of the United States
or some other country and taken to a third country
where they will be tortured.
We know there has been an enormous amount of torture.
No one has been brought to trial for that.
So we are now as many commentators are saying
we are now living in a post-legal society.
We're living in an unlawful society where is it lawful,
that question no longer counts.
What happened with the killing of bin Laden?
Most commentators say it was murder.
No one will be punished for that,
in fact the president's poll ratings will go up,
have gone up.
So there are many things that people would say
in the last 10 years, this country has gone way downhill,
not only economically and militarily, but legally,
spiritually, our own self-respect is being undermined,
is being destroyed, by the things that the government
is doing and nobody is held accountable.
We have these two wars, both of them illegal,
both of them based on lies, both of them killing,
we don't have exact figures but they're in
the millions of people.
Countries that had no attack planned for us.
Everyone agrees now.
Afghanistan was not planning to attack America,
Iraq was not going to attack America, and yet we have killed
millions of the people.
How can we have any self-respect if this continues?
So that's the approach I would take, try to help people
make the connection between the ruin of our nation
with 9/11.
- The point is that the story we are telling
is painful because once you have seen 7 going down
you get a sensation that there's something wrong here
and your immediate reaction is maybe I shouldn't
look into this because this may lead me to places
where I do not want to go.
Fact is that we do not want to be lied to.
And we do not want to lie ourselves, both.
So as you realize that the people who we have selected
have lied to us to an extent that is so beyond imagination
to ordinary people is very painful, actually.
But as a consequence since now we have something
that we are not supposed to talk about
it is downright destructive to our Western civilization.
You can blow up any good company by either start to
discussing politics, religion, or 9/11.
Yeah, then it's not fun anymore because usually people
divide on this subject and there's something here
we cannot talk about.
That means the language is deteriorating
and this is what you've seen observed with Western culture
in the last 12 years, we're ending up like Eastern Europe
was 20 years ago, gray and gray and gray,
absolutely nothing's happening because if you have
the secret police sitting next to you in the bus
there are some thing you do not talk about.
Which means that everybody knows that everybody knows
that everybody knows that everybody knows
that we should not talk about this, and particularly
in the mainstream media.
As a consequence, it's true, marriages are breaking up,
families are breaking up, parents are not talking
with their children, children are not talking with
their parents because of this.
So you end up with a society which is soaked with fear
and lies, we accept the lies.
Downright lies for going into the war in Afghanistan
and Denmark has been involved in a total of seven wars
in 2001
So we have society of lies and fear and all power
is based on fear, and all wars are based on deception,
and wars is the most profitable business of all.
- Until we completely destroy the government's
official myth and get some real truth told out there,
all the evils that have happened since 9/11
are going to continue.
The corporate wars of aggression, the taking away
of our constitutional rights,
the destruction of this country.
- If we're a part of a collective, part of a nation,
then we will also have a dysfunctional nation
if we don't know the truth.
We can't have a functional nation
if we're operating on lies.
(haunting music)
- I've come across a song by a performer named
Weird Al Yankovic which sort of sums up what I was feeling,
what I've heard other people talk about when they
had to deal with the 9/11 information, and the lyrics go
"everything you know is wrong, black is white, up is down,
"and short is long, and everything you thought
"was so important doesn't matter".
That was what it was like, it was like a very sudden
shift in my priorities and what I thought I needed
to be doing with my life and just how I regarded
the entire world and how I regarded the people in it.
If we can think of our worldview as being sort of
our mental and emotional home, on the day that I learned
that 9/11 was probably an inside job was the day
I lost that home and was sort of cast out
into the wilderness, an extremely uncomfortable feeling.
And when I've tried to talk with people in the past
few years about 9/11 I see that sort of discomfort
come up with them many times, to the point where they will,
I think all of us will do just about anything
to defend our homes, to defend our families,
and so I see that with people and I saw that with myself
when my brother tried to talk with me about it.
Don't mess with me, don't mess with my home,
don't mess with my comfort with how things are.
So that was very difficult.
- When 9/11 happened, a lot of things
were taken away.
Lives were lost, fears were instilled, hatreds
were stirred up.
Those are some of the most intimate parts of one's psyche,
what makes one human.
More was taken away from us than those lives,
as tragic as they were.
Our right to form objective opinions,
our right to have our own feelings about
objective reality was taken away.
We were psychologically abused on September 11th and since.
The psychological abuse has continued.
We need to stop the psychological abuse and the manipulation
of the American people.
If we don't then we are participating in it.
None of us were trained to look at the possibility
that the government could do this.
There was no class in graduate school about
government operations as such.
We were never taught to entertain the possibility,
even though we now know these things have been going on
for a very long time.
9/11 and facing the truth about it is important
to the soul of America.
And the values that have come from the official story
corrupt us emotionally, mentally, and spiritually.
We don't deserve to be corrupted.
- Later on as I researched and integrated
more of the information I also had to come to terms
with the very uncomfortable feeling of being a dupe,
of being a sucker, of believing what the government told me
without checking it out for myself first.
I consider myself to be a well-educated, mature adult
and to realize that I had just absorbed the government's
story lock stock and barrel without really questioning it
was very humbling, it was not fun,
it really made me question my own intelligence
and my own integrity for having jumped so quickly
on the bandwagon in a way that was very harmful and racist
towards people in the Middle East.
So I spent actually a very lonely summer with
every night insomnia, nightmares.
Knowing that I wanted to become active in exposing
this information and feeling like if I did so
the government or people within the government might
hunt me down and kill me.
Just general sense of paranoia about having this information
and doing something with it.
And so it was a very long, very difficult summer for me,
but during that summer I also spent a huge amount of time
reading everything I could get my hands on about 9/11
and becoming more and more sure that the official account
was a complete lie and that something needed to be done
about it.
- In this case the people that we rely on to gather
the evidence aren't.
It's sort of like calling the police and the police
won't investigate and then you find out oh, one of the
police officers did it and is covering it up.
- We know we've been lied to about 9/11.
We don't know for sure who did it.
We don't know exactly how they did everything,
and that's why we need a new investigation to find out.
Regardless of what anyone thinks about how it happened
or who caused it, there's no question that
the Bush Administration took advantage of that
to deceive the Congress and the American people into
unnecessary and illegal wars of aggression
and to cramming down our throats the Patriot Act
and the Military Commissions Act.
And these evils are going on now even under a different
administration and so it's obvious that whichever party
is in power, the American people absolutely need the truth
of 9/11.
(foreboding music)
- If we don't want greater deceptions, if we don't want
more war based on these deceptions, then we need to know
the truth and the way to find the truth is an investigation
and in holding those responsible legally accountable.
- We need an impartial, scientific, and legal investigation
as required by law of any crime scene.
And we should not be treating 9/11 as a excuse to go to war
but rather as a criminal act for which we have yet
to do the forensic analysis, the scientific analysis,
all the disciplines working together.
I know that's what we do in our police department
in my home town, that's what we expect in our
state government, law enforcement, we expect
the international level, international law.
I think that by putting science together with the law
we will have a psychological healing around the
impossible cognition that has been produced on that day.
- Never forget that this country is based on
only one thing, due process of law.
And that just has stayed with me ever since.
And the other day when they got rid of habeas corpus,
which took some doing but it was done after 700 years
we lost it and I kept thinking of my grandfather
and I could hear his voice in my head, due process of law.
Without that we are nothing.
- The cycle we're going through right now
is the same cycle as victim of domestic violence
are going through.
We feel helpless, we feel hopeless, we need answers,
we need to get out of this control zone that we are in.
And I think it's of utmost importance to have a thorough
investigation by neutral professional to give a serious
answer both from the scientific and the legal point of view.
- I think at first glance the truth about 9/11
can be retraumatizing and people are afraid to look at it.
But if handled with empathy and with compassion,
I think the truth about 9/11 allows us to connect
with people, it empowers us as survivors of this in going
through and taking actions about it, it can help us
overcome our own feelings of helplessness
and loss of control about what is going on
with our government.
It really can help set us free.
People have lived through trauma and traumatic events
throughout history, and they will continue to do that.
I think the resiliency of the human spirit
in overcoming tragedy cannot be overestimated.
- I want to give people a sense of hope.
Eventually I was able to realize that 9/11 presents
an opportunity for us to find our sense of integrity again,
to find our sense of courage, our sense of optimism.
That now that we know a little bit more about how things
actually work, how wars are actually created by governments,
how governments get people to go to war,
we have an opportunity now, a wonderful opportunity
which fills me with great joy to do something about it,
to find a way to stop this from occurring again.
- There will always be people who cannot accept
the truths of 9/11.
Even if the perpetrators publicly confessed,
but for most people the truth can be accessed.
The 9/11 truth movement is changing our country,
one person at a time.
- One of the leaders of the 9/11 truth movement
has said something that I sort of hold close to my heart,
it kinda keeps me going when things get rough.
There is no greater joy than coming together
with people of conscience, and standing up together
for what's right.
(haunting music)
- Psychology professionals are concerned about
silence in America.
The silence about what happened about September 11th, 2001.
Secrets make us sick, they tell us.
Secrets make us psychologically unhealthy.
Whether held in silence within us as individuals,
or held in silence by an entire nation.
These psychologists say that we're ignoring
the elephant in the room.
What they mean is in our national living room
we are ignoring the abundance of hard facts that prove
we have not been told the truth about what happened
on September 11th.
Actually, professionals from many different fields
decry our media for parroting their government sources.
Rather than asking hard questions, rather than investigating
official claims and honestly reporting their
independent findings.
Because of this parroting by the media, we the people
have readily accepted the story we've been told
about what happened on that horrific day.
That horrific day.
A day that drastically changed our world.
We'd have learned that if we label those who question
our government's account of that tragedy as conspiracy
theorists, we can quickly silence honest discussion
of what really happened on 9/11.
Yet if we listened closely to their questions
instead of silencing or ignoring them,
we'd notice that a number of serious researchers
are bringing hard scientific evidence to our attention.
If we study this evidence, we can easily see the truth
has been demolished in our country.
That's why this film has been titled
Demolition of Truth.
To be healthy as a nation, we must be willing to open
our eyes and our hearts.
We must find the courage not only to ask the difficult
questions, but to listen to what may be challenging answers.
Since 9/11, thousands of soldiers and millions of
innocent civilians have been killed.
The war on terror keeps escalating with no end in sight.
Because of 9/11, precious civil liberties have been lost.
In the US and around the globe.
We Americans can be subject to searches and seizures
without a warrant.
We can be detained or imprisoned indefinitely
without charge, without evidence, without a lawyer,
without a trial.
The psychology professionals in this film tell us
that looking at the truth of 9/11 isn't easy.
9/11 was traumatic and looking anew at 9/11,
looking anew at 9/11 is tough and even scary.
But we are resilient.
If we acknowledge our fear and then decide
not to let that fear control us, we can break the silence
and find healing in the truth.
Not only for ourselves, but for our country and the world.
(twangy music)
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.