Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
people are dying entire ecosystems are
collapsing we are in the beginning of a
mass extinction and all you can talk
about is money and fair Tales of Eternal
economic growth how dare
[Applause]
you this is the story of how an
eccentric environmental scare grew into
a powerful Global
industry it's a wonderful business
opportunity okay you want climate we'll
give you climate there's a huge amount
of money involved and this is a huge big
money scam there are not just now
billions but there are trillions of
dollars at stake it's a story of
self-interest and big government funding
people like me our careers depend on
funding of climate research this is what
I've been doing just about my whole
career this is what the other climate
researchers are doing with their whole
career they don't want this to end if
CO2 isn't having the huge negative
impacts that we claimed it was having
originally how are we going to stay in
business a lot of people's livelihoods
depend on it they're not going to give
that up this is a story of the
corruption of science there's no such
thing as a climate emergency happening
on this planet now it's there's no no
evidence of one the climate alarm is
nonsense you know it's it's a hoax I've
never liked hoax I I think scam is a
better word but I'm willing to live with
hoax it's a story about the bullying and
intimidation of anyone who dares to
challenge the climate alarm to speak up
against or about climate change in any
sort of skeptical way was essentially
career
suicide activists are even calling for
any skepticism to be
criminalized it's the story of an
assault on individual Freedom It's a
Wonderful way to uh increase government
power if there's an existential threat
out there it's worldwide well you need a
powerful worldwide government you know
to cope with it we see all these kind of
uh authoritarian measures being adopted
in the name of saving the planet you've
suddenly got the population under
control all over the
world
we called it industrial
progress since the Industrial Revolution
the development of free market
capitalist mass production has made ever
more Goods ever more affordable to ever
larger numbers of people mass production
marched hand inand with mass
consumption in the Modern Age Ordinary
People enjoy a level of prosperity never
before achieved in human
history but all the while we are told we
were destroying the
[Music]
planet computers have calculated what is
in store for us as we produce and
consume ever more the weather will get
worse the planet will boil we greedy
humans must accept limits on our
lifestyle consume less travel less those
who deny the climate crisis are not just
wrong they're dangerous spreading the
poison of Doubt among a gullible
population these denials should be
shunned and shamed and censored for
these climate deniers are flat earthers
they are
anti-science teaching at New York
University is one of these climate
deniers Professor Steven Koonan is one of
America's leading
physicists he was a science adviser to
President Obama and both vice president
and Provost of Caltech one of the most
prestigious scientific institutes in the
world
world I teach climate science to my
students at NYU and I always tell them
check the data or the papers yourself
and they all come out of that course
with their eyes wide
open Professor coan's best-selling book
unsettled argues that mainstream
scientific studies accepted by official
agencies do not support the notion that
there is any kind of climate crisis at
all of course I've been called a denier
uh and my response is tell me what I'm
denying because I'm quoting from you
directly from the official un scientific
reports dick lindsen also dismisses the
claims of climate alarmists he's one of
the world's leading meteorologists was
professor of meteorology at both Harvard
University and MIT and has served on the
un's intergovernmental panel on climate
change or
ipcc even the intergovernmental panel on
climate change if you go to their
section on working one group one which
is the science they don't support any of
these
claims and I assure you having served on
it's
biased but you couldn't get any real
scientists to agree some of the nonsense
that's being
promoted will haer is also a denier and
is another of America's leading
physicists he has been science adviser
to three presidents and professor of
physics at both Columbia and Princeton
University there's this mischievous uh
idea that's promoted that scientific
truth is determined by consensus in real
science you know there are always
arguments no science is ever settled you
know it just uh is absurd when people
say the science of climate is settled
it's not there's no such thing as sett
science especially
climate Dr John clauser is one of the
most respected scientists in the world
in 20122 he was awarded the Nobel Prize
for physics the science that's being
done is appallingly bad in my opinion
there are a large number of scientists
who are in violent disagreement they
refer to themselves as Skeptics since I
am no longer worried about losing
funding or a job whatever I call myself
a climate change denier
these very eminent and respected
scientists and others like them are not
flat earthers they do not deny science
so what's the evidence that has caused
them to dismiss the climate alarm as
[Music]
nonsense we are told that current
temperatures are unprecedented and
dangerously high it's possible to check
if this is true because we have evidence
of Earth's climate history history
dating back hundreds thousands even
millions of
years the Desert of Judea by the Dead
Sea Professor n shavei from The raker
Institute of physics has come here
looking for
Clues thousands of years ago this place
was underwater and etched into the rocks
are lines which if you know how to read
them tell the story of Earth's climate
history and here's the
climate we are at the uh lake bed of
what used to be Lake lisan um it's a
lake that existed until the end of the
last ice age back then the lake level
was maybe 100 m above where we're
located when we want to reconstruct
climates of the past we have to look for
evidence U for Clues and when the lake
existed it had the deposits and by
looking at these uh layers here we can
actually reconstruct how the climate is
changed
warmer water means more life the
accumulation of more shells and Bones
from sea
creatures and other changes that are
reflected in the ancient layers of the
lake bed the lines act as a kind of
thermometer and this is just one way
geologists can reconstruct past climate
in other places we can go to stalagmite
caves and see the annual rings that you
have in the stalite or we can drill cors
from the bottom of the oan and then look
at layers there or many other places but
here I think this is one of the nicest
places because you can actually see you
can actually see how the climate has
changed so when we look back in time
what do we
[Music]
find for 200 million years dinosaurs
roamed the Earth an earth marked by
fertile dense forests teaming with life
and at no time during those 200 million
years were temperatures as cold as they
are
today if you go back let's say 200
million years it was maybe 13ยฐ warmer
than it is now so on the geological
perspective this is not at all
unprecedented for the last 500 million
years temperatures have varied greatly
but for almost all that time the Earth
was much much warmer than
today compared to the last half billion
years the earth right now is
exceptionally cold in fact there are
very few times when it's been this
cold we're relatively cold maybe not
quite the coldest it's been in 500
million years but pretty close to it we
are in a remarkably cool period if we
look over the last 550 million years in
fact only one other time period in that
last 550 million years was the
temperature as cool as it is now the
mammals who now inhabit the Earth began
to evolve around 60 million years ago
when the world was much warmer than
today we just look at the last 65
million years so this is after the
dinosaurs go extinct mammals really
start to take over and our evolutionary
ancestors start to live on the land any
time period within the last 65 million
years was warmer than it is essentially
today the Earth's mammals humans
included appear to thrive when it's warm
warmer than it is now there's no doubt
that warm is better than cold in
geological history we are a tropical
species a human being in the shade naked
dies at 20c from
hypothermia we evolved on the equator in
Africa and the only reason we were able
to get out of there eventually was fire
shelter and
clothing over the last 50 million years
temperatures steadily declined plunging
the earth into what geologists call the
late cazic Ice Age we are still in that
Ice Age the reason there's all that ice
on the poles is because we're in an ice
age everybody knows that who knows
anything about the history of the Earth
this is an Ice Age we're at the tail end
of a 50 million year cooling period and
they're saying it's too
hot if we zoom in on the past few
million years we sea temperatures
sinking and as they do fluctuating
between extremely cold periods and
slightly milder periods the extremely
cold periods are called glacial Maxima
when the planet is mostly covered in ice
and the slightly less cold are called
glacial Minima when there's just ice at
the
poles for the past 10,000 years
fortunately we've been in a slightly
less cold glacial minimum known as the
[Music]
holline with milder weather humans began
to emerge from their caves and several
thousand years ago we see the rise of
the first great civilizations in a
blissful period which according to many
studies was considerably warmer than
today this is known as the hollene
climate
Optimum it was called an Optimum because
people thought that warmer was better
since then temperatures have declined
and began to fluctuate in Roman times
there was a blissfully warm
period followed by brutal cold period in
the Dark
Ages then came the Bain medieval warm
period according to many studies as warm
or warmer than
today followed by an especially cold
period known as the little Ice Age
possibly the coldest in the last 10,000
years and here it is the Roman warm
period the cold Dark Age the medieval
warm period and then the very cold
little ice age from which for the past
300 years or so we've been
recovering
the longest instrumental record of
temperature in the world comes from
Central England and this is what it
shows since the worst of the little ice
age from 1650 the temperature has risen
gently by little more than 1ยฐ
C the central England record of
temperature is a world treasure you know
it's the longest continuous record that
we have and it's certainly not a very
alarming record it began in the depths
of the little Ice Age and so you can see
the slight warming that followed the
little ice age and there's certainly
nothing very alarming that's happening
today at the very end of the record most
of the warming that we're observing
today is the recovery from the little
Ice Age whatever calls that well you
know we're talking over the entire
industrial period of about 1ยฐ
cenr to put this one degree in
perspective let's look at New York
Central Park Records show that there has
been no overall change in temperature
here since
1940 but from one year to the next the
average temperature can vary by 3ยฐ C
without many New Yorkers even noticing
in fact between the warmest year and the
1960s and the coolest in 2000 there's a
difference of 5ยฐ C the average
temperature on this day in this year
might be 5ยฐ different from the average
temperature a year ago or two years you
know when I hear people pontificating
about 1 and a half degrees leading to
the end of civilization I think what
have they been smoking you know are you
crazy right
so according to thermometer readings
since 1880 there's been a very mild
increase in
temperature only by stretching the Y AIS
on this graph is the increase noticeable
this is the rising line used by official
agencies as proof of global warming but
is it it
accurate Professor Ross mckitrick is an
expert in statistical analysis at GF
University he noticed something odd
about modern thermometer records
thermometers even in the same region
give out very different readings
depending on where they're located I was
interested in the question of how do you
explain the spatial pattern of warming
so some places warm a lot some places
don't warm much and it turns out highly
correlated with the spatial pattern of
economics
activity where there are more people and
there is more human activity there's
more heat this is known as the urban
heat island
effect Urban heat island effect is
essentially London right you pick London
with buildings with a lot of activities
tends to be a few degree I mean we're
talking now Celsius right even four five
degree celsus warmer than outskirt this
is a phenomenon of urbanization this day
is the obvious effect is actually
concrete retting retaining
Heat this can be Illustrated with a
satellite heat map of Paris the center
of Paris can be as much as 5ยฐ C warmer
than the surrounding
Countryside Paris London Beijing
Shanghai you name it New Delhi all of
them absolutely demonstrated the
defs so how is this affected the
official temperature record in the early
part of the 20th century it was normal
to erect weather thers just outside
Towns close enough to check every day
but away from the heat of urban life but
over the 20th century those towns have
expanded suburbs have spread there are
more roads more cars thermometers which
were once outside towns are now
surrounded by shopping malls offices
factories and
houses these towns and all the locations
where thermometers are located on
average they've all grown in population
let's say since 1880 you've got
buildings uh growing up around the
thermometers you've got parking lots so
you've got all of these non-climate
influences which are affecting the
temperatures which raises questions
about the quality of thermometer data
for monitoring global
warming to correct for this Corruption
of the data an obvious solution is to
use only records from rural weather
stations which have been less affected
by Urban Development this has now been
done by a team led by Dr Willam soon we
combine all the best rural station any
anything that we can correct for we
correct for and we show if you just
don't use this the and use only rural
you you get a very different kind of
picture according to rural temperature
records temperatures Rose from the 1880s
but peaked in the
1940s then there was a marked cooling
until the
1970s after that temperatures recover
but are still today barely higher than
they were in the 1940s
what we see is that basically you have a
warming from the 1900 18 you know 50s or
so to 1930s and 40s and started to warm
and then cool in a substantial way to
the ' 70s about 76 or so instead of a
longterm systematic warming Trend it has
a variability multi decade or like every
50 60 years or so kind of a
variation it's not just rural
thermometers that show little warming
mer ships and other Naval vessels have
been measuring the temperature of the
sea since the 19th
century in red we see the land
temperature record since the 1860s which
has been inflated by Urban thermometers
but in blue is the ocean temperature
record from around 1900 the two begin to
diverge ocean records show far less
warming in the 20th century and the
pattern more closely resembles the rural
temperature
record sea is not supposed to be good
and contaminated by Urban heat island
effect am I right yes so when we compare
the two record within the range of
uncertainty these Behavior actually
fits scientists have also studied
temperature change by looking at tree
rings which again shows very little
warming there's a gentle rise till the
mid 20th century but cooling to the
1970s followed by a mild recovery once
again it shows temperatures today are
barely different to those of the 1930s
and 40s and the pattern closely
resembles rural
[Music]
temperatures satellites too seem to be
telling a different
story our ability to measure Global
temperature accurately took a Leap
Forward when satellites began to orbit
the
earth one of the scientists who
pioneered the use of satellites to
measure temperature is Dr Roy Spencer
who in the 1980s was senior scientist
for climate at NASA's Marshall space
flight
center we were discussing over lunch
isn't there some way we can use
satellites to monitor global
temperatures because as you know the
temperature network of thermometers is
pretty skimpy around the world so it's
kind of hard to get a global
temperature Dr Spencer's development of
weather satellites was revolutionary he
and his colleague professor John
Christie have been awarded NASA's medal
for exceptional scientific
achievement our satellite data begins in
January of 197 that's when we have
complete Global coverage uh and we have
it right up to the
present there was one critical question
about temperature that satellites were
singularly well equipped to
answer has there been a spous warming
that has crept into the global
temperature record Overland uh that's
just a result of an increase in
population and that's something that
we've been analyzing and working a lot
on lately and we're finding that
especially in urban areas uh it's large
I mean since 1880 most of the warming it
looks like is due to the urban heat
island effect we're lucky to have a few
independent scientists like John
Christie and Roy Spencer with their
satellite measurements of
temperature you know before they uh
started releasing this groundbased
temperature records were going wild they
were going up you know like crazy with
no no bounds but now they have to
contend with the fact that there's this
independent and probably better way of
measuring the whole globe's temperature
which is not alarming at
all evidence from multiple sources now
agree that the official Global
temperature record as used by World
governments and reported in the world's
media is showing far too much warming
over the last 120 years artificially
inflated by urbanization you look at the
weather balloon record the satellite
record the record the ocean record
doesn't warm nearly as much as land all
of these indications show that the like
the big warming pulse in the record is
the Northern Hemisphere land record and
that's also where most of this data
contamination is happening but of the
mild warming that has taken place in the
last 3 to 400 years can any of it be
attributed to human emissions of
[Music]
CO2
Professor Henrik sansar is visiting the
Hebrew University of Jerusalem and
taking a stroll in the evolution Garden
dedicated to preserving the oldest
surviving plant species on
Earth these plants aren't just pleasing
on the eye they can also tell us about
levels of CO2 in the atmosphere in
Earth's geological
past what we have here is a Ginko tree
and it's actually a living fossil in the
sense that this type of tree H first
appeared about 270 million years ago on
the underside of the leave there are
what we call stomer the cells where they
can uptake CO2 so they actually
measuring how much CO2 is in the air and
then they adjust the number of this stom
to how much CO2 there is and by looking
at fossils and measuring how many there
are at a different time it says
something about what was the level of
CO2 back in
time so when we look back in time what
do we find over almost all of the last
500 million years the level of CO2 in
the atmosphere has been far far higher
than it is now even with modern
industry's contribution to CO2 Levels by
geological standards the level of
atmospheric CO2 today is close to being
as low as it has ever
been at present we have about uh 4 400
parts per million 50 million years ago
it might have been 2,000 parts per
million so a much much higher
concentration of
CO2 I think current estimates of global
CO2 is
423 or so parts per million today if we
look through the furoic the last 550
million years we would see CO2 on the
order of 7,000 parts per million CO2 is
plant food and the result of much higher
levels of atmospheric CO2 in the past
was a much much Greener World periods of
elevated CO2 tend to be time periods of
of of a huge biodiversity on on the
planet in fact we're in a CO2 famine if
we look over the last 550 million
years at the depths of the most recent
glacial maximum the amount of CO2 in the
atmosphere sank so low all life on Earth
came close to extinction they say CO2 is
higher than it's been for 100,000 years
but what they don't tell you in that
period they're talking about is that CO2
sank so low that all life on Earth
nearly died 20,000 years ago CO2 is at
the lowest level it has ever been in the
history of the earth 180 parts per
million if it had gone down another 30
parts per million we'd all be
dead there is a low point of CO2 where
photosynthesis becomes so inefficient
that plant life would die then
everything else starts to perish after
that during the last glacial maximum
there's good evidence that in many parts
of the world there was plant starvation
from not enough CO2 so uh we should be
very grateful that CO2 levels are
beginning to go back up we're still far
from the historical Norms which would be
several thousand parts from a million
there's not enough fossil fuel to get
there but at least we're making a
start but has the small increase in CO2
affected the
temperature we would now show you a
picture of CO2 but we can't because it's
invisible CO2 makes up a tiny fraction
of the gases in the atmosphere just 0.04
of a percent it is just one of 25
different greenhouse gases which taken
as a whole form only one part of Earth's
complex climate system so what evidence
is there that this Trace gas is having
any noticeable impact on the climate
if it were true that higher levels of
CO2 caused higher temperatures we should
be able to see that in Earth's climate
history here scientists are drilling
into ancient ice cores these cores tell
us both about past temperatures and CO2
levels scientists have indeed found a
link between temperature and CO2 the
trouble is it's the wrong way
round so it's true over the last few
million years of the Ice Age that we're
in now that CO2 and temperature are
correlated but if CO2 is the driver it
has to change first and the temperature
has to change second in fact when you
start to look at the data very
specifically you see the exact reverse
temperature starts to rise first and
then on the order of a century to a few
centuries later we start to see a a rise
in CO2 it's long been known that uh the
temperature actually moves first so
temperature goes up CO2 goes up after
that temperature goes down CO2 goes down
ice ages start when carbon dioxide is at
its maximum and Ice Ages end when carbon
dioxide is at its minimum which is the
exact opposite of what would occur if
carbon dioxide was controlling the
temperature the question of whether CO2
drives the climate is easily resolved
you can look back in time over hundreds
of millions of years CO2 levels have
changed radically many times did this
cause temperature change no absolutely
not CO2 has never driven temperature
changes in the past
never nor is it clear in recent times
that CO2 is having any effect on
temperature here we see industrial
output of CO2 since
1750 from the mid 19th century to the
mid 20th century there was only a slight
increase it's not until the 1940s that
industrial production of CO2 begins to
take off but this doesn't match the
temperature record according to rural
thermometers most of the warming in the
past 200 years occurred before the 1940s
and have barely changed since
then one of the embarrassments that ipcc
doesn't like to talk about was that the
1930s when human influences were much
smaller were particularly warm that's
the puzzle that the first early part
where we have such a sharp uh warming
from the 1900 to 1930s and 1940s CO2
could never cause that temperature
rise but the 1930s and early 40s were so
hot it's puzzling
more puzzling still is what happened
next by the end of World War II CO2 was
really going up and yet the temperature
was going down from 40 to 70 while the
CO2 continued to rise this thing started
to cool what happened journalists were
writing about the coming Ice Age it was
on the cover of Time Magazine the 1970s
the new Ice Age was the big story and
how about since the 1970s
according to computer climate models
over the past half century Rising CO2
should have led to this increase in
temperature but according to multiple
satellite and balloon measurements what
actually happened was
this well what we found from the
satellite data is that the global
atmosphere is not warming up as fast as
the climate models say it should be uh
there's a couple dozen climate models
now that have been worked on for decades
you know billions of dollars tens of
billions of dollars have been invested
in these climate modeling efforts and we
find that generally speaking virtually
all of the climate models produce too
much warming over this period since 1979
up to the present now even if we say the
surface thermometers are correct they
still don't produce as much warming as
most of the climate models say there
should have been let's say in the last
50 years the models individually and
even collectively when you average over
all of them in so-called
ensembles they don't get it right you
can already see that the main uh
supports of the climate alarm movement
which are these enormous computer models
they're clearly wrong they they don't
agree with what we observe you they uh
they're all running much too hot they
don't get
the geographical distribution of
temperatures anywhere close they don't
get
Lino Cycles they're just nonsense all
climate models are based on the
assumption that CO2 drives temperature
change but actual observations and
historical evidence clearly suggest that
it
doesn't yes I assert that there is no
connection whatsoever between CO2 and
climate change that's all a Coca crap in
my opinion there is no truth to the idea
that the Earth is warmer now than it it
has been in the past it's a lie there is
no truth that CO2 is higher than it
should be that is a
lie Earth's climate has changed many
times over the course of its long
history and will continue to change
without any help from us climate always
changes you know who denies climate
change it's always
changing but if CO2 doesn't drive
climate change what
does
[Music]
in Earth's atmosphere there are powerful
forces at work and perhaps the most
powerful of all are
clouds CO2 is quite unimportant in
controlling the earth's climate what is
important is clouds clouds don't absorb
any energy at all they simply reflect
all of the sunlight back out into space
big bright wide clouds if you look at
the Earth you see lots and lots of them
and they vary dramatically from one day
to the next that is hundreds of times
more powerful than the trivial effects
of
CO2 but what controls the number and
density of clouds on
Earth Professor Henrik fenmar from the
Danish national space Institute is in
Jerusalem with the astrophysicist near
shiv together they've been exploring
Cloud variation and effect on climate
and strangely they found a link between
clouds and exploding supern noi far off
in our
galaxy when you have big stars they
don't live very long uh I mean
relatively only maybe a few million
years up to 40 million years but they
end their life in a huge explosion which
we call the
Supernova an exploding Supernova sends
out vast quantities of debris tiny
charged subatomic particles known as
cosmic rays traveling almost at the
speed of light and as they hit Earth
they develop into seeds which attract
water vapor and form
clouds Professor shiv noticed that the
amount of cloud cover on Earth is
related to our journey around the Milky
Way as our solar system orbits the
Galaxy over millions of years it passes
through the Galaxy spiral arms dense
clusters of stars as it does we are
exposed to more or less Cloud forming
cosmic rays and this corresponds to
Historic temperature changes on
Earth the really mindboggling thing is
that using geology you can reconstruct
the climates on Earth over the past
billion years and you can reconstruct
our Galactic journey and both tell the
same
story but what about temperature change
on shorter time
scales the sun are source of heat and
light a seething mass of gigantic
Magnetic
storms which vary in strength and number
over time and which affect Earth
directly and
indirectly when it is very active the
sun sends giant gusts of solar wind
through the solar
[Music]
system the solar wind warms us
indirectly by acting is a barrier
limiting the number of cloud forming
cosmic rays reaching
Earth so from the sun we have the solar
wind it carries the sun magnetic field
out to a large distance and it works
like a shield uh against cosmic rays
when the sun is more active you have a
stronger solar wind you have less cosmic
rays reaching the inner solar system and
reaching the atmosphere and the clouds
which are then formed are less white
they reflect less of the sunlight uh
which means that it's going to be warmer
here on
Earth here is a proxy reconstruction of
ocean temperatures over thousands of
years and here is one of solar activity
over the same period what is causing the
ocean temperature to change is clearly
variations in solar
activity because ipcc is determined to
go on a narrative that only CO2 can
drive the climate system they turn of
the sun essentially right because the
sun is just a background thing for them
that it doesn't do
anything astrophysicist willly soon
decided to look again at the rural
temperature record for the past 150
years then he looked at a record of
changes in solar activity over the same
period to Dr soon it was obvious that it
was the Sun not CO2 that was driving
temperature as of
2023 ipcc stes that the Sun have
absolutely zero chance in to explain the
changes of the climate system on Broad
scale let's say global warming or
Northern hemosphere we say no we can
easily demate the sign can explain all
of it there's zero for the CO2 100% for
the sun how's
that why are these and other studies
never reported in the mainstream media
and if climate change is natural what
are we to make of the alleged terrifying
increase in extreme weather events of
the heat waves and hurricanes of forest
fires droughts and the
[Music]
rest my first instinct as a scientist
and what I teach my students is well
let's look at the data and when you do
that you discover as you can read in the
ipcc reports themselves that it's pretty
hard to find Trends in extreme events
much less attribute them to human
influences you've now had Decades of
putting the idea in people's heads that
anytime the weather is bad it's climate
change and greenhouse gases so I think
people at this point can't help
themselves if you have a heat wve
immediately everybody's thinking oh what
have we done to the weather if somebody
says in the news this is the warmest day
since 1980 or something well you can
look up the temperature records and see
for yourself whether it was in fact
warmer in the 1930s as it often
is US temperature records are the best
in the world and here is the official US
Government record of heat waves in the
US over the past
Century it shows very clearly that the
1930s were far more prone to heat waves
than we are
today not only were there more heat
waves in the 1930s the heat waves then
were much hotter than those of
today likewise official figures show
that the number of hot days in the US
has markedly
[Music]
declined United States was much hotter
in the 1930s North Dakota reached
121ยฐ um South Dakota was 120ยฐ Wisconsin
was
114ยฐ these sort of temperatures are just
completely out of range of anything
people experience
now a common mistake is to suppose that
higher average temperature will mean
more hot weather but this isn't true
here again is the central England
temperature record the longest
instrumental temperature record in the
world summer temperatures over the past
3 to 400 years since the end of the
little ice age have barely changed at
all it is winter temperatures that have
been slightly Rising the earth's climate
has not been getting hotter it's been
getting
milder that's certainly being observed
all over the world if you look at
temperature records high temperatures
are almost changed but cold temperatures
at night or during the winter are going
up a little bit not very much but you
can measure it when the average goes up
it's really more due to the coldest
temperatures getting warmer so the
temperatur is getting milder rather than
getting
hotter what about the increasing number
of wildfires we're often told about if
you look at the actual number of forest
fires
from satellite observations the actual
numbers going
down here is an estimate of global
wildfires since 1900 it shows a clear
Decline and here is a record of areas
affected by wildfires in the US it shows
that wildfires were far far worse in the
1930s from 1930s and 1920s when you have
data thing was huge five to 10 times
bigger than the current
level how about hurricans
the US has by far the best record of
hurricane activity in the world over the
past 120 years there is no overall
change in fact the trend is slightly
down when you look at the data for
hurricanes technically tropical Cyclones
you see that there is no long-term
Trend how about the rest of the world
here is a chart of global hurricane
activity over the past 40
years hurricanes have been around
forever you know we've got good proxy
records of hurricanes and uh there's
been no change in their frequency even
the ipcc admits that how about melting
ice caps and drought here's a satellite
record of temperature in Antarctica
since the late 1970s it shows no
increase
whatsoever and here is a record of
global drought since 1950 there is no
observable increase at
all
polar bears are meant to be going
extinct but studies suggest their
numbers are
growing the Great Barrier Reef too has
recently reached record
levels there's no such thing as a
climate emergency happening on this
planet now it's there's no no evidence
of one yeah the extreme weather event
story is is just absurd there there's no
basis to it at all it's just based on
propaganda the actual data shows the
opposite I've shown you the official
data
the official science tell me what I'm
denying the climate alarm is nonsense
you know it's it's a hoax as as I I
don't I've never liked hoax I I think
scam is a better word but I'm willing to
live with
hoax but why are we told again and again
that man-made climate chaos is an
Undisputed scientific fact Beyond
question Beyond doubt to answer this we
must examine the so-called consensus on
climate
change thank you very much until the
1980s global warming was little more
than an eccentric scare story put out by
radical
environmentalists but then the cause was
picked up by an ambitious young Senator
Al Gore who would soon become vice
president a billion dollars a year of
public money was made available for
Research into climate change this
quickly Rose to 2 billion up to that
level academic researchers in various
disciplin began to apply for this
climate
[Music]
funding if you want to qualify for money
that's labeled climate well you take
whatever you're doing and you add a
little bit uh of climate speak to it and
Away you go you're dealing with the
sexual habits of cockroaches you'll add
and the in impact of climate so all I
have to do is add a little wrinkle to my
Grant application to explain how well
I'm worried that climate change will
mean the death of all the maple trees
and so right away you qualify for
funding academics of every kind lined up
for climate funding climate became an
exciting new area of interest for
sociologists biologists professors of
English literature lecturers in gender
studies and many more and it also serve
to create a community I mean you know
you've become a climate science I now
even though you know nothing about the
physics of climate thousands of papers
were published on climate change in
prostitution climate change in beer
climate change in the Black Death
climate change in disability climate
change in video games and everything
else imaginable there's an almost
comical list of studies out there just
do a Google search on climate change and
and and everything comes up few of these
papers ever questioned whether climate
change was
true after you've done the research and
you write the paper up sometimes you
find there's no effect at all from
climate but you still have to say in
your papers oh yes climate change is
real and uh we just need to study this
some more since so few of these
so-called climate studies challenged the
idea of climate change it was declared
that there was a scientific consensus
climate change must be
true climate also became a new Focus for
govern government funded research
bodies scientific research in the United
States tends to be dominantly funded by
government
grants uh and so whatever government
grants are offered uh sort of determine
much of the science being done it was
during the Cold War that many Government
research bodies were set
up but the end of the Cold War and
pressure on government spending has left
many of them struggling to justify their
continued
funding United States Congress only
funds problems okay Research into
problems whether it's money that goes to
NASA or Noah or National Science
Foundation or Department of energy or
any other alphabet suit you know
organization it's always been a problem
to support uh your research or your
existence raise on
Detra and so climate was a godsend if
Congress is willing to pay you to find
evidence
of global warming by golly as a
scientist we're going to go find
evidence of it because that's what what
we're being paid to do and guess what if
you don't find evidence or say the
evidence suggests it's not a problem
your funding ends this totally corrupts
the way we look at the science who was
the famous gangster asked why do you rob
banks and he said well cuz that's where
the money
is the climate alarm brought funds and
the bigger the supposed threat the more
funds seem to flow the publicly funded
science establishment now had a direct
financial interest in playing up the
alarm so there's a huge incentive to OV
exaggerate or to speak in hyperboy even
if the data doesn't support exactly what
you're saying because that's what brings
the
funds I was in that boat I was someone
that was defending climate change as a
grad student quite a bit because the is
I didn't give it too much thought but I
I thought well it's getting a ton of
attention it brings a ton of money into
the Earth Sciences even if I don't buy
all the hyperbole what's the
problem by the late 1990s what had
started as an environmental scare story
was gaining
[Music]
momentum Western governments and their
senior civil servants were more than
willing to address the climate problem
problem green taxes were levied green
regulation expanded and this in turn
generated more climate related jobs and
activity take the banking sector for
instance you say to a banker we want you
to file reports with the the Regulatory
Commission on how climate change is
going to affect your bank well a banker
doesn't know anything about this subject
so then they have to commission studies
from
academics and of course the academics
are happy to come and tell them well
it's going to be terrible for your bank
it's going to cause all kinds of
problems and you get you need to give us
money to research this green subsidies
and regulation meant there was now money
to be made in climate Renewables firms
sprouted consultancy firms offered
advice on what they called
sustainability and climate compliance
it's a wonderful business opportunity
okay you want climate we'll give you
climate the Renewables industry alone
now turns over a trillion dollar a year
and that's expected to double in the
next few
years what used to be a cottage industry
has is now blossomed to become a major
part of the world
economy the growth of this climate
industry has seen an explosion of highly
paid green jobs Chief sustainability
officers carbon offset advisers ESG
Consultants climate compliance lawyers
and countless
others students started to come into our
departments as Earth science departments
with a focus on climate that never
happened before but they started to look
at their career prospects and they were
smart and they were looking at who's
hiring and the fact of the matter was is
that everything in the hiring pool had
climate somewhere attached to the name I
started a few years ago seeing programs
like uh a master's degree in climate
finance and I just what on Earth is is
climate I understand what a master's
degree in finance is well now you need a
university that's going to teach this
program you need professors of climate
Finance every single school or
University or business will have a
climate officer or climate officers and
a climate program and you look at any of
these institutions or businesses you
will find they all are signed up to it
and anyone who hasn't signed up will
come under
[Music]
pressure at the last Gathering of the
publicly funded un's PCC 70,000
delegates flew in from around the world
government bureaucrats green NOS carbon
sequestration Consultants environmental
journalists heads of Renewables
companies but this is just the tip of
the iceberg many hundreds of thousands
of jobs worldwide now depend on the
climate crisis you start building this
enormous population whose job is to
manage the crisis and um and
also uh explicitly to make sure that
people are alarmed about the crisis
because this whole industry depends on
the existence of the
crisis but therein lies the one great
threat to this multi-trillion dollar
industry all the jobs all of the funding
are totally dependent on there being a
climate
crisis if CO2 isn't having the huge
negative impacts that we claimed it was
having originally how how are we going
to stay in business how do we justify
our existence if climate change isn't
this existential threat that we claimed
it was over the last four decades or so
people like me our careers depend on
funding of climate research this is what
I've been doing just about my whole
career this is what the other climate
researchers are doing with their whole
career they don't want this to end if
NASA said global warming is not a
problem where does their funding
disappears right um um so they can't say
that I mean you've got the United
Nations intergovernmental panel for
climate change if they said the climate
isn't changing they'd have no reason to
exist the ipcc has a self-preservation
instinct to show that climate change is
an existential threat otherwise there's
no reason for them to be collecting the
money and doing the work in the first
place there are not just now billions
but there are trillions of dollars at
stake there's a huge amount of money
involved this is a huge big money scam a
lot of people's livelihoods depend on it
they're not going to give that up if
suddenly the notion becomes apparent
that this is not such a problem um
you're going to see that as an
existential
threat scientists who studied the
natural causes of climate change began
to be viewed with suspicion as two
Harvard astrophysicists discovered how
much does the Sun change and how does it
change and why does it change and then
we didn't even want to get into the
temperature record climate thing
immediately they will come after because
when we started to estimate that the sun
Changed by quite you know significantly
in terms of climatic sense immediately
the attack is there because it's not
following the narrative because they
need the CO2 to be the only one the only
dominant player when you tried to say
well you were just looking for the
background of natural variability
we C the response would be we can't have
natural changes as an effect it has to
be human
caused and some of that was directly
stated but most of it was indirect your
funding for this kind of project will be
dropped this kind of project doesn't go
anywhere by that time anything that
contradicted The
Narrative of global warming as a serious
ious
problem was not going to get
funded editors of academic journals came
under pressure not to accept papers
which were deemed to be skeptical of the
climate crisis we will not publish
anything that questions
this I mean it's not something
surreptitious scientists who dared to
point out in public that there was no
climate chaos began to be sidelined and
shunned if a scientifically qualified
person stands up and says uh we don't
see an upward Trend in the data on
Pacific
typhoons um well suddenly they lose
standing to address the topic of Pacific
typhoons not because what they said is
wrong but because it's off message they
can marginalize any kind of criticism of
the narrative by saying you're not
qualified to talk about this because you
don't support the narrative that is then
and then having marginalized everyone
who doesn't support the narrative they
can turn around and say well everybody
who counts supports the narrative so we
must be
right environmental journalists ignored
Skeptics and instead offered headlines
to anyone prepared to make the most
outrageous claims and predictions about
a climate
apocalypse it's gotten to where it has
nothing to do with the science anymore
it doesn't matter if your alarmist
prediction doesn't come true you're
still going to retain your status as an
expert and the media is still going to
come and ask you for your opinion even
though you were crazy wrong about your
[Music]
predictions but the consensus on climate
is not only enforced by those in the
climate
industry to explain the broader appeal
of the climate alarm we must look at the
politics behind
[Music]
climate from the start the climate scare
was political it came from the
environmental movement the sworn enemy
of free market industrial
capitalism finally we've got them we can
claim that it is the free markets who
are destroying the planet and we need
big government to save
us the climate problem it is said stems
from the irresponsible actions of greedy
feckless individuals who have too many
babies and drive too much and consume
too many products and of the capitalist
corporations who Pander to their whims
the solution is for government to have
greater power to regulate private
companies but also to guide and reshape
the lives and habits of
individuals policy agenda has sprawled
into micromanaging everybody's lives on
the most minute detail of what kind of
stove you can use what kind of heater
you can have how much you can set the
thermostat out where you can drive what
kind of car you can't according to the
the planners we're not going to have
internal combustion engines an hour from
now all of these things require the
government to get involved right because
the government has to sort of force
changes upon the public if it was up to
the public we wouldn't be buying
electric vehicles because you know
they're
impractical support for the climate
alarm is now virtually synonymous with
disdain for free market capitalism and a
yearning for bigger government it's
liberals versus conservatives in theit
United States and generally speaking
Liberals are worried that we're
destroying the planet and they're also
of course for big government and then
conservatives are are at the other end
of the spectrum where they a lot of them
don't believe that we're destroying the
planet and they don't want government
involved in their personal
lives paying lip service to The Climate
alarm has become almost Universal among
those who depend on government for their
livelihoods this includes those in the
publicly funded education art and
science establishments Tony hel recalls
his time at Los Alamos
labs the entire County of Los alos was
kept going by government money that we
we had the highest incomes in the state
so naturally people who lived in Los Al
supported big government because that
was where their livelihood came from
that was where their good schools came
from you know everything good and Los
alos came from the government so of
course they were all Believers in big
governments among the largely publicly
funded Western intelligencia support for
more government spending and regulation
is almost a defining moral
badge in these circles to question the
climate alarm is socially unacceptable
to be a climate skeptic is
taboo somebody that goes against it that
it really does get met with a lot of
anger and vitriol you know you're called
a denier a science denier and a heretic
your colleagues won't engage with you
anymore uh you don't get invited to
conferences your students uh May desert
you uh this is all really
terrible professors Henrik svensmark and
ni shiv describe what happened when they
published their results on the climatic
effects of solar
activity it was like all Hill had broken
loose because of this work I had no idea
that the things would escalate as they
did and it completely changed my life
once we said that uh people didn't like
hearing it and we became a persona
non I mean I have so many instances of
people doing really uh nasty things
uh when I applied for for a job uh a
group of scientists writes to the
University say they shouldn't hire
me and that's a typical story
uh
unfortunately if you don't agree with a
standard pmic you become an outcast
you're
shun as if you have
leprosy for Professor Sally balunas the
personal attacks became too
much I retired early
and my family said I should have retired
even sooner years sooner so they noticed
the toll or took a toll on them and
me Dr Matthew wicki was an assistant
professor of geology at the University
of Alabama when he decided to speak out
about the climate scare as a result of
the backlash he has decided to leave
teaching to speak up about climate
change in any sort of skeptical way was
essentially career suicide absolutely
there was no possible way that I would
publish in quite a few of the mainstream
journals that I was required to publish
in I essentially isolated myself from
many of the funding institutions this is
one of the reasons you can build a
consensus in a community is because
anybody who is skeptical of that
consensus essentially gets kicked out of
the community speaking out um
in scientific ways that go contrary to
the consensus I would say as a career
killer for people at the early stage of
their careers if I were 30 years old in
a university trying to make a career I I
would certainly keep my mouth shut and
in fact I I went to some effort to keep
my mouth shut when I was younger I I
knew climate was nonsense then but I was
a little bit careful if a young person
person is questioning this they can't
put that in a proposal The Proposal will
be
denied and they can't effectively
publish because the gatekeeper will keep
them out and so it would end their
career you have to go along with with
the global warming story if you don't
you're going to get cut off you're going
to lose funding you're going to get your
career ruined you're going to be trashed
by the community you'll be despised by
your
co-workers the so-called consensus on
climate has itself become a weapon a
form of bullying intimidation and
censorship used against those who refuse
to conform it's a it's a tool that
people use to bludge in their opponents
and the Skeptics and to attack their
character according to its critics far
from being scientific the militant
intolerant climate consensus represents
a devastating assault on free scientific
inquiry I see my job as a scientist as
just laying out the facts and letting
people decide what they want to do when
you can't talk about the facts uh Things
become corrupt if you shut the door on
ideas if you say you're not allowed to
test it you're not allowed to have that
idea you've left the realm of
science I don't think climate
researchers will ever back down from
their claim that increasing CO2 is the
control knob on today's climate system I
I don't think they will ever back down
from that no matter what the evidence is
it's clear it's now a
cult uh that completely divorced from
science but the Apparently Unstoppable
climate scare does not just represent an
attack on science it is starting to
shape for a new kind of
society environmentalists like to pose
as anti-establishment but their demands
are well received and piously echoed by
King Charles and the Archbishop of
Canterbury the BBC the UN the EU by
heads of government the World Bank and
World economic Forum in fact by the
entire state-funded ruling
establishment
global warming is like the perfect
problem that government can get involved
in to grow the influence of government
it's a wonderful way to uh increase
government power and uh if there's an
existential threat out there that's
worldwide well you need a powerful
worldwide government you know to cope
with it if you're a climate activist
you're actually
facilitating a huge uh uh validation of
the government running our Lives Many
environmentalists most environmental all
environmentalists who consider
themselves to be radical Progressive
alternatives are in fact simply
reinforcing the mantras and the
mainstream arguments of the entire
establishment the demands on the
government mean that the government
suddenly gains the authority to
interfere into every knok and cranny of
our lives and how we live everything has
a climate narrative attached to it how
much you consume where you spend your
money how much you travel who you
interact with what types of food you eat
whether you eat meat everything has some
sort of aspect that can be controlled
with a climate lens suppose 20 years ago
somebody had hatched the idea that I
would really like to ban cheap energy
I'd really like to control everybody's
Appliance purchases I'd really like to
tell everybody where they can go and
basically I'd like to have dictatorial
control over everything well it's not
going to fly no everybody would think
you're a nut and would ignore you but
fast forward 20 years that's what's
happening the publicly funded
establishment in the west is so large
and Powerful it is able to impose and
enforce the official consensus on
climate through its control of schools
universities government and much of the
media State broadcasters like the BBC
exclud include climate Skeptics
broadcasting regulatory bodies forbid
private stations from disseminating
skeptical views threatening them with
having their broadcasting licenses
revoked what normally happens in an
emergency is that all normal forms of
openness and democracy have to be
suppressed because how else to deal with
an emergency so we are facing a
situation not unlike lockdown where
basically all normal forms of behavior
normal forms of social communication and
so normal forms of democracy are
essentially ruled
out activists are even calling for any
skepticism to be
criminalized in certain jobs and
professions it is now dangerous to
express dissent on climate it's no
surprise that people uh who are more
skeptical will think twice before uh
voicing their concerns because they
might risk their careers they might risk
their business they might risk being
sacked if you're a professional of any
kind in science or law or medicine if
you belong to a professional association
or you are in a
university uh you can be fired for
saying what you believe the consequence
is a censorious authoritarian regime
that has to control every move every
word everything you want to do because
everything you do is a potential risk to
the survival of
[Music]
mankind climate protesters condemn
capitalism but at their anti- capitalist
rallies it's hard to spot anyone who
looks like a worker like a Docker or
crane driver or steel worker or a
beautician or a trucker
the workers it appears are totally
absent from these rallies and for very
good reason today's climate alarmists
complain not that capitalism isn't
producing enough but that it's producing
too
much the modern capitalist system has
led to Prosperity more and more people
have more and more things the modern
anti- capitalism of the present time is
a critique of capitalism that it gives
us too much they think that the problem
with capitalism now it's actually that
it's giving out too many rewards on mass
to ordinary workers and what they want
Instead This is often very explicit
actually is a much more austere simple
kind of Lifestyle in which the mass
consumption the consumption choices of
the great bulk of the population are
controlled or even prohibited you have
to consume less you have to uh holiday
less you have to drive less you have to
eat less and so
on it seems that what upsets many
environmentalists is not the failure but
rather the success of capitalism in
producing an abundance of affordable
Goods for the
masses ordinary working people for once
we've arrived at a point in history in
the Western World at least where Mass
manufacturers has allowed them cheap
clothes cheap food cheap furniture
therefore you get a clash when affluent
environmentalist
Express their disdain for Mass
consumption people going on those big
huge cruise ships it's like thousands of
it's like what are they doing oh my God
there's all those Cru like ruining
Venice you know ruining all our Beau we
own them don't we they're not what what
are they going there for what you have
here is a classic example of class
hypocrisy and self-interest masquerading
as public spirited concern you could
take these kind of green social this
much more seriously if they lived off
grid they cut their own consumption down
to the minimum they never flew instead
you get constant talk about how human
consumption is destroying the planet but
the people making all this talk show
absolutely no signs of reducing their
own what environmentalists call degrowth
is being achieved by the trashing of our
conventional energy and Transport
Systems and the forced introduction of
expensive and unreliable
Alternatives already this is happen
having the desired effect on Industrial
manufacturing which is straining under
the burden of punitive green taxes and
Regulation and higher energy
prices the people behind the climate
alarm couldn't give a damn about
manufacturing they have nothing to do
with it they don't know people who work
in manufacturing whose jobs and lives
depend on it they're not excited by
industry or industrial progress they
explicitly want to shut it
[Music]
down
Ki Kenya East
Africa according to many leading
environmentalists the world's poorest
people should not aspire to the
lifestyle of people in the first world
the planet will not
cope Grace Nando is one of the many
Africans who do not have electricity or
gas to cook with or heat their
homes the resulting indoor smoke from
burning wood and dried dung is the
deadliest form of pollution in the world
for Millions the cause of lung disease
blindness and early
death it's not just cheap reliable
electricity that Africa needs
agricultural productivity here is
incredibly low increasing it takes
fossil fuels to make fertilizer and
drive tractors and other farm
machinery jper mogu is a
farmer each and every African wants to
develop and increasing improving
agriculture is one of the easiest ways
to do that agriculture is tightly tied
to fossil fuels Fosso fuels that the
Western nations are saying we should not
have access to
around a third of the food produced in
Africa rots before it ever reaches the
mouths of consumers to prevent this
terrible waste Africa needs plastic
packaging refrigerated lorries and good
roads all are opposed by Western
environmentalists all come with
Industrial Development all rely on
affordable fossil fuel
energy diar from drinking dirty water
still kills hundreds of thousands of
African children but clean water water
requires large industrial water
purification plants and a modern water
supply network and this will come only
with cheap energy I think it's pretty
obvious that the West has got what it
has because of fossil fuels when people
say Africa doesn't need fossil fuels I
wonder I don't think they want what's
best for us they don't want us to
develop and that means we continue being
starving we continue being uh poor
most people don't know what climate
change is they don't care they just they
want food on their table they want to
beat poverty they want to beat Hunger
they need money to better their lives
they want to flourish that's just
it when they use the word sustainable
development they're talking about no
development exactly I mean it's the
point is that you know to develop
sustainably means not to use too much
energy not to use too much carbon you
know Net Zero the idea that you mustn't
use too many resources the you mustn't
produce enough consumer goods because
consumption is bad so ultimately you
know the idea of development is out the
window the greens think the Africans
should never use their resources the way
the Europeans or the Americans or the
Canadians or the Australians have used
theirs they are also in favor of
punitive taxes border taxes on any
African country that wants to export
their Goods to Europe if they do use
their resource so that sums up the
ethical
ruthlessness and and depravity of the
green
agenda the climate alarmists have a
problem many countries in Africa and
across Asia are simply ignoring the
environmentalist demands of Western
governments and international agencies
communist China is estimated to be
building an average of two new coal
power plants a week China now uses more
coal than the rest of the world
combined which is one of the reasons why
this whole climate agenda is falling
apart because the rest of the world is
not cutting emissions is not moving to
Renewables in the West too for many
people climate alarmism is wearing
thin Ordinary People are not stupid they
have seen one ridiculous claim after
another fail over and over what this
does is leave people with a profound and
Justified cynicism about what the
scientific establishment says and about
what the government
says to fix the climate crisis we're
told we must give up our
cars we must pay more for fuel heating
clothes food fly less limit where we go
this attack on mass travel Mass tourism
Mass consumption holds little appeal to
the
masses people have started to realize
it's going to cost them a lot of money
to Simply live the lives that they were
leading that they want to lead and as
soon as that started to happen I could
see people in the United Kingdom who had
previously been indifferent to
environmentalism soly think how dare
they do that right how dare they try and
take away what we consider to be not
luxuries but Necessities the whole
policy of sustainability is about
restraint it's about restriction it's
about doing less um and that obviously
for most people is anathema to their
everyday needs the fact that there is
actually an ideological movement of
people who think that cheap mass
production of whether it's houses or
anything else is a problem I mean for
God's sake no wonder people become uh
disdainful of the kind of middle class
Outlook of environmentalism but that is
lit what people say how can we stop
people buying cheap things in
shops when climate protesters climbed
onto an underground train in London's
East End they were not cheered on by
working commuters they were held abuse
pelted angrily dragged off the train and
received rough treatment on the
platform if you were to go into a pub uh
frequented mainly by what the americ
called blue color workers you will find
that uh being skeptical about climate
change policy is not going to get you
thrown out quite the contrary somebody
will probably buy you a drink they can
tell that behind all the talk about
climate emergency climate crisis what
there actually is is an animous and
hostility towards them their lifestyle
their beliefs and a desire to change it
by force if
[Music]
necessary punitive and restrictive
policies carried out both in the name of
climate change and covid have sparked
protests in Britain Canada and other
Western
countries anti-establishment politicians
and movements are gaining
support what they what they
underestimated was the fury that this
would meet uh with ordinary people who
just say you can't do this so you
suddenly get this new
movement many working people and not
merely skeptical but positively angry
about the climate alarm and all that
flows from it there is a suspicion or
perhaps realization that climate change
is an invented scare driven by
self-interest and snobbery cynically
promoted by a parasitic publicly funded
establishment hungry for ever more money
and power an assault on the freedom and
prosperity of the rest of
[Music]
us
[Music]
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.