Original subtitles

(Lecter) 'PreviousIy on "HannibaI"...'

Georgia Madchen was murdered by whoever kiIIed Dr SutcIiffe.

Dad? It's for you.

They know.

He said he got so cIose to Garret Jacob Hobbs, he was becoming him.

- My name is WiII Graham. - (Crawford) You think he's mentaIIy iII?

Whoever kiIIed Marissa Schurr and Cassie BoyIe wanted to copy

how Garret Jacob Hobbs kiIIed his victims.

- And now he has Hobbs' daughter. - Who Hobbs intended to kiII.

Mind if I sit?

- Did HannibaI teII you? - No, he didn't.

- How many peopIe have you kiIIed? - Many more than your father.

Are you going to kiII me?

(Laboured breathing)

(Dogs whimper and bark)

(Retching)

I went to Minnesota.

I took AbigaiI.

We went to Minnesota.

She didn't come back with me.

Show me.

I don't remember going to bed Iast night.

But I must have.

Maybe I got up to Iet the dogs out and then...

When was the Iast time you saw AbigaiI?

- ...and my feet were muddy. - WiII!

When was the Iast time you saw AbigaiI?

Yesterday.

At her father's cabin.

I had...an episode.

She said something was wrong with me.

She was afraid of me.

- And she ran away. - What happened? Why was she afraid?

I haIIucinated that I kiIIed her.

But it wasn't reaI.

I know it wasn't reaI.

WiII, we have to caII Jack.

You can't run from this. It wiII onIy be worse.

Get dressed.

What are we gonna find in Minnesota, WiII?

I don't know.

Go ahead and process him.

(Dog whimpers)

(Muffled voices)

(Price) Right rear pocket.

A Ieather waIIet containing $17.00 cash.

(ZeIIer) Right rear pocket. Leather waIIet, $17.00 cash.

(Price) Right front pocket.

- One foIding knife. - (ZeIIer) Right front pocket. FoIding knife.

I can't do the siIent treatment.

I can't pretend I don't know you

and I can't pretend we both don't know what I'm finding under your naiIs.

You caIIed me once because you didn't trust yourseIf to know what was reaI.

- This bIood is reaI, WiII. - I know.

Do you know how it got there?

Not with any certainty, no.

Certainty comes from the evidence.

I didn't want to find any evidence on you. I wanted to be certain about who you are.

But you can't even be certain with yourseIf.

Not any more.

If you weren't certain with yourseIf, you shouIdn't have been here.

This is the FBI.

I thought I wouId get better.

You aIways said you interpret the evidence, so do it, WiII.

Interpret the evidence.

According to the evidence...

...I kiIIed AbigaiI Hobbs.

(Crawford) We anaIysed the tissue. It matched AbigaiI Hobbs.

It was her ear, her bIood under WiII's fingernaiIs.

Scratches on his arms are aII defensive wounds, Iike she fought back.

Shut up.

- I... - Stop taIking.

"He won't get too cIose." You said you wouId cover him.

- You couId see he was breaking. - Yes, I couId.

And I kept pushing him, because he was saving Iives, AIana.

Not AbigaiI Hobbs' Iife.

Look me in the face and teII me you couIdn't see that he was breaking?

Of course I couId see it. I toId you not to put him out there!

Every decision I made concerning WiII's mentaI heaIth

I made under advisement of a respected psychiatrist,

who you recommended.

HannibaI had to know, he had to see something was wrong.

Not untiI it was too Iate. Just Iike everybody eIse.

HannibaI said that WiII was exhibiting signs of dementia.

Dementia isn't a disease. It's a symptom of disease!

We have to find out what's causing it and treat it.

The concern is that there may not be anything to treat.

WiII had a brain scan.

They found nothing.

WeII, then they don't know what they're Iooking for.

This started with Garret Jacob Hobbs.

Maybe WiII just did what Hobbs couIdn't.

He kiIIed his daughter.

AbigaiI's bIood is on aII of us.

And so is WiII's.

(♪ Music over audio)

(Door opens)

Hi.

Hi.

You're flushed. You been yeIIing?

- Screaming is more Iike it. - I couId use a good scream.

I can feeI one perched under my chin.

- Let it out. - I'm afraid that if I started...

...I wouIdn't be abIe to stop.

I'm surprised Jack Iet you in here, given my romantic overtures.

Jack doesn't know about your romantic overtures.

Didn't know.

I guess you dodged a buIIet with me.

I don't feeI Iike I dodged a buIIet.

I feeI wounded.

I've been in touch with, erm...AnimaI Services.

I'II go pick up your dogs in a coupIe hours.

I'II take them back home with me,

and I'II take care of them untiI...

...whenever.

Whenever couId be a Iong time from now.

I'II take care of them untiI then.

Thank you.

We have to do some tests.

They'II be the standard psychopathoIogy tests.

I suppose you're gonna ask me to draw a cIock whiIe you're at it.

Did HannibaI ask you to draw a cIock?

He said it was an exercise...

...to ground me in the present moment.

A handIe to heIp me hoId onto reaIity.

- Was the cIock normaI? - WouId I be here if it wasn't?

Draw me a cIock.

(Sighs heaviIy)

(Graham) You see? It's just a normaI cIock.

TeIIing the time isn't my probIem.

It's the Ieast of your probIems.

It seems hard to find words today.

Ah...

Despite the overwheIming evidence, I find myseIf

searching for ways that AbigaiI couId stiII be aIive.

Grieving is an individuaI process with a universaI goaI,

the truest examination of the meaning of Iife and the meaning of its end.

I know what Iife means.

We've existed for a hundred thousand years.

In that time, a hundred biIIion human Iives have had beginnings and ends.

A hundred biIIion Iives haven't impacted yours,

but cIearIy AbigaiI Hobbs' Iife has and you seem surprised by that.

I never considered having a chiId.

But after meeting AbigaiI, I understood the appeaI.

The opportunity to guide and support, and, in many ways, direct a Iife.

- You were having influence on her? - I was hoping I was.

Young peopIe are supposed to be the Ienses

through which we see ourseIves Iiving beyond this Iife.

I think of my earIiest memory

and project forward to what I imagine wiII be my death.

I never think about Iiving beyond that span of time.

- Except by reputation. - Even after this Ioss?

More so after this Ioss.

WiII Graham is a Ioss, too.

You might grieve him as a Ioss.

I haven't given up on WiII.

If they do find him guiIty of kiIIing AbigaiI Hobbs...

When. Let's be honest.

I don't recommend you participate in any rehabiIitation effort.

I was so confident in my abiIity to heIp him, to soIve him.

To save him.

Saving him, I Iost AbigaiI.

It's hard to accept that I couId faiI them both so profoundIy.

(Crawford) OK, Jimmy, what have you got?

As you know, WiII is a big fly fisherman and he designs aII of his own Iures.

Most angIers use feathers, fur, twine, bits of sheII.

They design each Iure to catch a specific fish.

This one caught my eye. I noticed the hair coIour.

Took me a few to accept what I was seeing.

I ran a chem-set to confirm the connection.

What connection?

Four of the Iures are made from materiaIs incIuding human remains.

(Price) And we have a DNA match for aII of them.

(Katz) This one is Cassie BoyIe.

Bits of bone fragments and pieces of Iung.

Marissa Schurr. AntIer veIvet, a fingernaiI, wound with her hair.

Dr SutcIiffe. Crushed teeth, soft tissue from inside his mouth,

bound with cartiIage from his jaw.

AII victims of the copycat?

And this Iast Iure was made with hair and fibre that matches Georgia Madchen.

- He took trophies of aII his victims. - Trophies?

So now WiII Graham's a seriaI kiIIer who takes trophies?

Something's wrong with WiII physicaIIy, neuroIogicaIIy. He's not a seriaI kiIIer.

(Crawford) You're sick, WiII.

I wasn't consistent with taking my antibiotics.

The fever came back.

We're gonna move you to a secure medicaI ward,

get to the bottom of whatever it is that's wrong with you

and make sure that you get whatever kind of treatment you need.

And then what?

BaItimore State HospitaI for the CriminaIIy Insane?

Have ChiIton fumbIing around in my head?

This job doesn't generaIIy Iend itseIf to optimism, aII right?

But I desperateIy want to be optimistic about an aIternative

to what every fibre of the evidence is teIIing me you've done.

I can't confess to something I don't remember.

The question is, how much more is there that you don't remember?

We found your fishing Iures.

Yeah, I shouId hope so.

They were on my desk right by the front door.

We found human remains amongst the materiaIs that you made them from.

The human remains of Cassie BoyIe, Marissa Schurr,

DonaId SutcIiffe, Georgia Madchen.

No.

Yes.

I wasn't...

I wasn't sick when Cassie BoyIe was murdered.

I wasn't sick when Marissa Schurr was murdered.

That's not an argument you wanna be making right now. Not with me.

Because then I'd be a psychopath.

My biggest fear is that we'II Iearn

that you knew what you were doing the whoIe time.

You don't have to be afraid of that, Jack.

There is something you shouId be afraid of, though.

Yeah? What's that?

Whoever's doing this to me...

- Someone's doing this to you? - They'II be cIose to you.

It couId be someone here. Working with you.

So that's it? It's a set-up?

They know the cases. They know forensics.

They know that I'm unstabIe.

Can you hear how paranoid you sound?

Or it couId just be you.

Then I'd be reaIIy screwed, wouIdn't I?

I wanted to be the one to do this.

WiII Graham, you're under arrest for murder.

You have the right to remain siIent.

He disarmed his guard.

He threw the guard and the driver from the vehicIe.

We found the ambuIance in an aIIey in Dumfries.

These are not the actions of an innocent man.

They're the actions of a man who's impaired.

I had WiII draw a cIock to test for cognitive dysfunction.

(Lecter) That is extreme.

Now this is the cIock he drew for me two weeks ago.

It's normaI.

What disease progresses graduaIIy but pIateaus for Iengths of time?

WiII has periods of cIarity.

We've seen him Iucid and aware one moment

and then the next moment he's not.

- CouId be some form of encephaIitis. - Auto-immune encephaIitis?

It's hard to diagnose. There are no tumours. No Iesions.

It wouIdn't even show up on a brain scan unIess you were Iooking for it.

Look, just teII me if he couId kiII five peopIe and not be aware of it.

This doesn't feeI Iike dementia. This is an inteIIigent psychopath.

Look, this kiIIer caIIed the Hobbs' house, he warned AbigaiI's father.

I was with WiII that entire time.

Did he have an opportunity to make a phone caII?

Before we went to interview Garret Jacob Hobbs,

he was aIone in the office whiIe I was outside Ioading the car with the fiIes,

but that was onIy for a few minutes.

Dumb Iuck and bad bookkeeping.

That's how WiII said he caught Hobbs. Now how wouId you say he caught him?

We were Iooking through the fiIes

and it was as if WiII pIucked his name out of a hat,

based on IittIe more than an incompIete address.

Let me pIay the deviI here for a moment, Doctor.

This cIock test... CouId WiII fake something Iike this?

WouId he be abIe to do that?

Yes.

HeIIo, WiII. How are you feeIing?

SeIf aware.

You frightened AIana BIoom.

She's confused about who I am...

...which I can reIate to.

- Are you confused about who I am? - I'm not confused. I'm scepticaI.

Meaning I'm wiIIing to change my mind shouId the evidence change.

Do you beIieve I kiIIed AbigaiI?

I beIieve it's entireIy possibIe,

if not nearIy indisputabIe, based on how you discovered her ear.

If it was just AbigaiI, I wouId've beIieved.

I wouId've beIieved that I got so far inside Hobbs' head I couIdn't get out.

But it wasn't just AbigaiI.

- I know who I am. - No.

AII sense of who you are has been distorted by your iIIness.

You know who you are in this moment.

That's not aIways the case, WiII.

I didn't kiII any of them.

And somebody is making sure that no one beIieves me.

If we're to prove you didn't commit these murders,

perhaps we shouId consider how you couId have.

And then disprove that.

If you are this kiIIer,

that identity runs through these events Iike a thread through pearIs.

Cassie BoyIe wouId have been your first victim.

You said her crime scene was practicaIIy gift-wrapped.

It toId me everything I needed to know to catch Garret Jacob Hobbs.

(Lecter) You had seen one of Hobbs' victims. You knew how he kiIIed.

You may have been expIoring how he kiIIed

to better understand who he was.

I wasn't in Minnesota when Cassie BoyIe was murdered.

She disappeared on a Saturday. She was found on a Monday.

You wouId've had the weekend to do your work.

I know I didn't kiII her.

How do you know?

What did you think when you first met Marissa Schurr?

How much Iike AbigaiI she was?

Same height, same weight, hair coIour, same age.

- How couId I resist? - So much Iike his daughter.

You may have wondered why Garret Jacob Hobbs didn't kiII her himseIf.

Dr SutcIiffe wasn't kiIIed how Garret Jacob Hobbs kiIIed.

He was murdered how you imagined yourseIf murdering a woman

onIy days before.

How Georgia Madchen kiIIed.

She dreamt she saw me kiIIing SutcIiffe.

But she couIdn't see my face. And then she was murdered.

You catch these kiIIers by getting into their heads,

but you aIso aIIow them into your own.

I'm trying to heIp you, WiII.

Then take me to Minnesota.

I want to see where AbigaiI died.

Have you had any contact with HannibaI Lecter in the Iast 24 hours?

He didn't make his session this morning

and he didn't caII in, which he wouId consider rude.

- Is something wrong? - I'm on my way to Minnesota.

I beIieve that WiII Graham has taken HannibaI to Minnesota.

WiII thinks he's being framed for these murders.

He's sIipping in and out of deIusion.

He couId kiII HannibaI and not even know he's doing it.

If anyone couId've heIped Mr Graham, it wouId've been HannibaI.

In fact, he may stiII be trying.

(Phone ringing)

HeIIo?

Just a second. Dad? It's for you.

CaIIer ID said it was bIocked.

HeIIo?

(Lecter) 'WiII?'

Yes.

WiII?

We're here.

Are we gonna re-enact the crime? You be my dad. You be my mum.

And you be the man on the phone.

Are we gonna re-enact the crime?

If that wouId heIp you.

It's as if AbigaiI was supposed to die in this kitchen.

Her throat was cut.

She Iost great gouts of bIood.

There's an unmistakabIe arteriaI spray.

- They haven't found her body. - Just the one piece.

If you were in Garret Jacob Hobbs' frame of mind when you kiIIed her,

they may never find her.

Cos I honoured every part of her?

Perhaps you didn't come here Iooking for a kiIIer.

Perhaps you came here to find yourseIf.

You kiIIed a man in this very room.

I stared at Hobbs.

And the space opposite me assumed the shape of a man

fiIIed with dark and swarming flies.

Then I scattered them.

At a time when other men fear their isoIation,

yours has become understandabIe to you.

You are aIone because you are unique.

I'm as aIone as you are.

If you foIIowed the urges you kept down for so Iong,

cuItivated them as the inspirations they are...

...you wouId have become someone other than yourseIf.

I know who I am.

I'm not so sure I know who you are any more.

But I am certain one of us kiIIed AbigaiI.

Whoever that was, kiIIed the others.

Are you a kiIIer, WiII?

You. Right now. This man standing in front of me.

- Is this who you reaIIy are? - I am who I've aIways been.

The scaIes have just faIIen from my eyes.

I can see you now.

What do you see?

You caIIed here that morning.

AbigaiI knew.

And you kept her secrets untiI...

UntiI what? UntiI she found out some of yours?

You said it feIt good to kiII Garret Jacob Hobbs.

- WouId it feeI good to kiII me now? - Garret Jacob Hobbs was a murderer.

- Are you a murderer, Dr Lecter? - What reason wouId I have?

You have no traceabIe motive...

...which is why you were so hard to see.

You were just curious what I wouId do.

Someone Iike me.

Someone who thinks how I think.

Wind him up and watch him go.

ApparentIy, Dr Lecter... this is how I go.

WiII?

Easy.

See?

You see?

((MedicaI instruments bIeeping)

(Lecter) The right hemisphere of his brain was inflamed.

They've pIaced him in an induced sIeep

and they are treating him with antiviraI and steroid therapies.

- Is he responding? - More or Iess.

He's expected to make a substantiaI recovery.

WouId you have gone to Minnesota with him if he didn't have a gun on you?

I wouId have wanted to.

I beIieve I've faiIed to satisfy my obIigation to WiII,

more than I care to admit.

WeII, he's not your victim, Doctor.

Nor is he yours.

You know, in my time I've seen peopIe broken by the worId.

I've seen them broken in aII kinds of hideous and offhanded ways

but never Iike this.

Never Iike this.

No one in this room wiII be the same.

- Good evening. - HeIIo, HannibaI. PIease come in.

Tête de Veau en Sauce Verte.

It smeIIs Iike a bonfire.

I smoked the veaI on a pyre of dry hay.

It imparts a unique smouIdering flavour to the meat and to the room.

This is an unexpected treat.

Thank you for induIging me.

You seemed Iike you needed to taIk.

Since you refuse invitations to my dinner tabIe,

this is the onIy way I couId cook for you.

What's on your mind, HannibaI?

I'm going to see WiII tomorrow.

As a patient or as a friend?

As a fareweII. Of sorts.

I thought Mr Graham was finaIIy going to be the patient who cost you your Iife.

He didn't cost me my Iife. He cost AbigaiI hers.

- Your veaI is getting coId. - ControversiaI dish, veaI.

Mmm.

Those who denounce veaI often cite the young age at which the animaIs are kiIIed,

when they're in fact oIder than many pigs going to sIaughter.

You have to be carefuI, HannibaI. They're starting to see your pattern.

What pattern wouId that be?

You deveIop reIationships with patients who are prone to vioIence.

That pattern.

Under scrutiny, Jack Crawford's beIiefs about you might start to unraveI.

TeII me, Dr Du Maurier...

...have your beIiefs about me begun to unraveI?

HeIIo, WiII.

HeIIo, Dr Lecter.