Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
[ominous sound]
[distant explosions]
Major news.
After days on a razor's edge,
Ukraine is now a nation at war.
This appears to be the worst case scenario
These are Ukrainian territories
which are occupied today,
not by separatists,
but by Russian army.
It's these kind of barrages
that are forcing the Russians to withdraw.
- The liberation of our territories
is significant.
Russian Defense Ministry acknowledged
their troops pulled back.
- They have left their mark.
- Now Ukraine
can begin to recover its dead.
I’m hoping for the best.
Or, at least, to bury my relatives.
I'm Bel Trew,
The Independent’s
International Correspondent,
and in 2022
I was sent to cover
Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
In April, after ferocious battles,
Moscow's forces dramatically withdrew
from around the Ukrainian capital.
My team and I went to the areas
that for weeks
have been occupied by Russian soldiers.
Without phone connection or internet,
they had been completely
cut off from the world.
It was the first time
any of us had had access
to these towns and villages.
Well, we're driving towards Bucha
right now.
It's about 25 kilometers
west of the center of Kyiv.
And here,
Ukrainian officials say
at least 300 people have been killed.
[dog barking]
In a kind of daze,
we wandered through
this man-made hellscape,
talking to the few civilians left
who were emerging from their homes.
Russia denied committing any crimes,
but residents spoke of rape, torture
murder and disappearances.
[low car engine]
On our way back
from a day of reporting,
we stumbled upon
an abandoned Russian camp.
You can see behind me,
that there's trenches,
basically a kind of living quarters.
There's also burnt out
armoured cars everywhere
and tanks.
And also unfortunately,
just to the left of me
is the remains of
what the soldiers here say
is a 16-year-old boy.
His hands have been tied behind his back,
his feet have been tied,
and it's clear
that he's been shot in the back.
Over the last decade of covering conflict,
for me the most devastating legacy
of any war
has been the families left behind
without answers.
Those whose loved ones
have been disappeared,
vanished into jails or killed.
Those people who don't know what happened.
Those who lack closure.
Those presumably
like the family of this young man.
How many bodies are there
like his in Ukraine,
lost and unclaimed?
Well, the enemy positions
were located right here.
There are even fortifications
from which they made observation points
and watched the road.
Yeah, this is... this is the camp.
Yeah, this is the exact location.
It's actually quite eerie
to be back here in this Russian camp
over half a year later.
The area is still covered
in belongings of those Russian soldiers,
everything from military rations
to broken ammunition boxes.
The local Ukrainian police say
they still don't know what happened here,
specifically to the Ukrainian civilians
who are clearly held in this area.
And the sad truth is,
is that they may never know.
When our troops advanced
and liberated the territory of Makariv,
there was horror,
there were bodies lying there.
And judging by the condition
of the corpses at that time,
they had been lying there for weeks.
We had taken measures
to document these crimes,
during the active fighting
but we could not do it
in all areas, obviously,
because of the constant shelling.
BEL: As the months went by,
the Ukrainians uncovered more bodies.
But what haunted me
was that young man,
all alone,
murdered and abandoned
in a lonely patch of wood.
As I said before,
we found this body in April.
He appeared to be quite a young man.
He obviously had been executed
because his hands were tied
and he'd been shot in the back.
And we found him very close
to a Russian trench
and we were wondering, like,
did they ever find out
the identity of this body?
Up until now,
the body has not been identified by us.
BEL: Since the young man
was not local to Makariv,
we asked community leaders
in the neighbouring villages
that were also occupied
if they could help us.
So this is exactly where
we found the body.
Can you talk me through
where this person might have come from?
- We were occupied by Russians
from 22 March.
- The next village, Andriivka,
was also occupied.
- There, it was said that up to 40 people
were disappeared and tortured.
Dozens of civilians
vanished by Russian soldiers
were apparently interrogated and tortured
within these walls.
The classrooms and playgrounds
have been turned
into Russian headquarters.
The young man
may have been held here.
Mostly they were taking young guys.
Many people were also taken away,
if they didn't like them,
if they didn't give them something,
or if they found some kind of
military uniform.
All these people were also taken away.
It’s not someone
from our local community.
There’s no one from here
who looks like this body.
BEL: As we're talking
to more and more people in this area,
it's becoming apparent
this is far more complicated
than we ever could have imagined.
There was Russian soldiers
basically moving around prisoners
that they'd taken
from other areas of the country
to this town we're in right now.
There's also the problem
of internally displaced people
who fled
to these kind of rural areas
thinking it might be safer
than the capital
and obviously that wasn't the case.
So it's literally like
trying to find a needle in a haystack.
SIGN: Careful!
Mine clearing works in progress
BEL: One final option
was trying the regional morgue,
which pre-war
was just a tiny rural facility.
It became the collection point
for all the dead
discovered across the Kyiv region.
It’s been there more than a week of time,
but not for a long period.
[voice trails off]
BEL: The forensic doctor
didn't recognize the body.
Found dumped in a wood without any context
the young man
would be near impossible to identify.
At that time,
the teams here were handling
hundreds of bodies and body parts.
When there is turmoil
there are instances
when previously identified bodies
can be mixed up.
Because bags are torn or
documents get wet,
these identified bodies
can change status to unidentified.
There was one case where,
during transportation
and delivery of some bodies,
they were mixed up.
[music playing]
[pen scrawling]
How many unidentified bodies
have you found, basically,
since the beginning of the invasion?
And of those,
how many have been identified?
- We still have more than 2,000...
2,000 and a half, let’s say.
BEL: Yuri says there are 2,500 bodies
which still need to be identified.
Half of them are civilians.
YURI: But we really don’t know
how many unidentified bodies
are on occupied territory.
Unfortunately,
we think that it could be
10 times more than we think.
The scale of invasion
and the scale of atrocities,
and scale of war crimes,
and the severity of these war crimes,
are really, really serious.
BEL: I hadn't appreciated
how huge
or complicated
this problem was.
I went to the
International Commission
on Missing Persons
that have now set up in Kyiv
because they've spent decades
identifying bodies
and documenting war crimes.
MATTHEW: The issue of the missing
isn't only about
the family's right to know
and right to truth
and to be able to bury
their missing relatives.
It's also very much about justice
and criminal accountability.
Ukraine is quite unique
in the sense that
the authorities have actually launched
an investigation
into missing persons cases
while the conflict is ongoing.
I don't think this has been done
anywhere else before previously.
And this raises
a whole load of different challenges.
BEL: Among those challenges
are bodies being lost or mixed up.
As we talked to Matthew,
next door
a Ukrainian teenager called Vladislav
was having his blood taken
for DNA analysis
to try to find his mother.
MATTHEW: Vladislav has been trying to find
the human remains of his mother.
He actually believed
that he had found his missing mother.
The human remains had already been burnt.
He cremated them
and then sought to bury them.
It was actually somebody else
that he'd actually taken for burial.
My mother and stepfather went to Bucha,
around 22 March,
to the village of Hurovshchyna,
to deliver food donations.
And on the morning of 25 March,
they drove back to Kyiv from there.
And somewhere on the Zhytomyr highway,
this event happened.
We lost contact with them completely.
That’s all.
Since then, we cannot find her.
We published an announcement.
- Did you get any responses to it?
No.
I saw there were truckloads of bodies,
and there was no place to keep them.
Maybe something was lost,
something was signed wrong,
something was taken to the wrong place.
The mess was very bad there.
Vladislav only found out
that he had cremated the wrong body
because lawyers at this law firm
called him out of the blue in the summer.
So there was basically a body mix up.
- Yeah, mixed up body.
One of the lawyers
had been looking for a relative
called Ksenya,
who was also killed
by the Russians.
It turns out
the authorities
had mistakenly given Vladislav
Ksenya’s body.
Ksenya and her husband Maksym
had tried to evacuate
with their six-year-old child
and a female friend.
The couple was shot by Russian soldiers
before they could get to safety.
So Maksym’s uncle
is showing us video footage
apparently of the moment
that Maksym was killed,
which is how
this whole investigation was started.
So you can see this drone footage.
BEL: It was just chance
that a Ukrainian surveillance drone
caught this moment.
Maksym and Ksenya
were desperately trying to flee
Russian occupation along this road
to Kyiv,
which had become a major evacuation route.
The couple did not realise
Russian snipers
were stationed
on both sides of this motorway.
Their car comes under fire.
BEL: So this is the shooting,
the moment of the shooting.
- That's the killer.
He's the person that killed him?
- Yes.
That's the boy, that's the son, right?
That's the child of Maksym.
Absolutely frightening.
Ksenya’s son
and another female passenger survive.
They are led away by a Russian soldier.
VOLODYMR: Here we see
the wounded woman with the child
being led to the ditch for execution.
For some reason
they dragged him away from the car.
Ksenya, Maksym’s wife,
is dead in the car.
[somber music]
When we understood that
the young were dead...
It’s a very hard process to find them.
[somber music]
[clothing flutters in wind]
[truck passes slowly in distance]
BEL: The same day
we found the body in the woods,
we met Vadym.
Marooned by the destroyed remains
of his family home,
he was waiting for rescue workers
to pull out the dead.
[bulldozer engine idling]
I hope for the best,
at least to bury my family.
By chance,
Vadym had been standing
outside the block of flats
that morning the Russian warplane arrived.
He was actually on the phone to his mother
the moment the bomb dropped.
Most of his family were killed
in front of his eyes.
The remains were retrieved
by rescue workers,
and since it was such a clear-cut case,
I assumed
it would be easier
for the bodies to be identified.
[picking through broken ceramic]
BEL: The process has been chaotic.
At one point,
Vadym was handed
a bag of four severed arms
to identify.
The case was transferred
between different districts,
and it seems
his initial file was lost.
The bodies were initially taken
to different morgues.
Five morgues,
in different locations.
Then I had to give DNA samples again,
and testified again,
and the case was reopened.
So far, nothing is clear.
No one has been buried.
BEL: It seems
knowing the time, location,
and circumstances
of the killings have not helped.
And this appears to be a problem
across the area.
The first person we meet
by the side of the road
explained how his cousin
was killed in shelling,
but the body is still formally listed
as unidentified.
Holding his cousin's death certificate,
the elderly resident
said he is not a close enough relative
for his DNA to make a positive match.
Two or three days ago,
he appeared in my dreams,
I think about him all the time.
I have already agreed with my priest
that at least some remains
should be buried.
Because my soul cannot
stand it any longer.
If we could have a funeral,
it would be easier.
BEL: It's obviously a logistical nightmare
for the authorities
to have to try and gather
all of these remains of bodies,
DNA tests
from family members
who may be miles away
or not even in the country,
like this case.
But it's still really hard
for the civilians left behind.
This man's saying it's been,
what, six, seven months
since they tried to bury his cousin.
And at the moment
it looks like the cousin
may never be formally identified
and will just be stuck in that limbo
in a morgue.
FRANTIC MAN: Let’s go, let’s go! Drag him!
Faster, faster, faster!
S**t there is one more.
Come on boys! Move! Faster!
Let’s get out of here! Faster!
BEL: It's one of the most dangerous jobs
in the world.
The authorities are overwhelmed
and that means
across the country
volunteers like these people
are risking their lives
to recover the dead and wounded
from the front lines.
At full capacity,
the morgues have to store the dead
in railway carriages,
refrigerated trucks
and shipping containers.
In this facility in northern Ukraine,
the forensic doctors say they are storing
250 bodies alone.
BEL: And the police are discovering
more bodies every day.
Before Russia's invasion in February,
these officers
would have been handling
traffic violations
and petty crimes.
Now they are on the front line
of war crime evidence gathering
and they're trying to reunite people
with their missing loved ones.
We just got to this village here
with the Izium police
which is completely destroyed.
There isn't a single building
that's standing.
We're following them now
at the moment
as they go to pick up
a body that they've found.
And they've told us
we've got to walk
directly behind them
because this whole area
hasn't been properly demined yet
and they're still finding bodies
even weeks after this area
has been liberated.
BEL: The police have told us
that this man
actually died in March.
He was an elderly man
who was disabled
and unable
to get to the basement in time
when shelling happened.
And that just highlights
the problems
of trying to retrieve the dead.
He's been here
lying outside his house
for eight months
and it's only now
in November
that the security forces
were able to retrieve the body
and bring them back
to his loved ones for burial.
[cordon tape flutters in wind]
BEL: In some cases
they're finding hundreds
of unidentified bodies at once.
Every single one of these neatly dug holes
will be months,
if not years of work,
to formally identify the individuals.
To work out what happened to them.
To potentially
document the crimes committed.
The Ukrainian police
have even opened
mobile DNA labs
with portable testing equipment
provided by Western donors.
With this device we will be able
to speed up our work,
we will be able to go to a crime scene
or a mass grave,
set it up, and conduct
rapid DNA analysis on the spot.
And with the help of this machine,
we will be able
to identify the deceased more quickly,
within 24 hours.
BEL: The bodies which produce
no successful DNA matches
are eventually taken from the morgues
and returned to the earth.
They are buried in special numbered graves
until fresh evidence comes to light
and someone comes to claim them.
Perhaps the body in the woods
we’ve been trying to find is here.
We still don't know if he has any family,
if anyone is searching for him,
except for us.
We’ve counted
78 graves in this site here in Bucha
and bar a single one of them
that has a name,
all of them are unidentified and numbered.
And that means that there's families
across Ukraine
who are looking for these people.
I had the immense privilege
of when my mum passed away
of being able to be present
at her bedside when she died
and the immense privilege
of being present at her burial
and the immense privilege of knowing
where that burial site is.
And anyone who's experienced grief
will know that
there's something about
being able to visit at least a place
to pay your respects
and that has a form of closure
which...
is a form of healing.
And I think that's
the biggest tragedy here.
That will be the
legacy of Ukraine.
That will be
the open wound that will never heal,
people who never get that closure
who never know
what happened to their loved ones.
That's...
That's really hard
to get your head around.
[music playing]
[quiet breeze]
BEL: We're driving along
the Zhytomyr Highway right now.
This was once nicknamed
the Highway of Death.
It was the main evacuation point
for people trying to get out.
A lot of people died on this highway.
At the time, they were shot by Russians
or they were killed in shelling.
Among them was
Maksym and Ksenya,
and also, we believe,
Vladislav’s mother.
BEL: So,
Russian soldiers would have been here
observing the roads?
They were shooting
from the other side, mainly?
- Mainly from the other side.
- I think they have the same on the other.
On the other side,
so it's from both, yeah, yeah.
And you wouldn't be able
to see a soldier at all.
It'd be completely and utterly hidden.
You wouldn't have any idea.
Yeah, because they're all over the place.
There's one over there and here as well.
They found the ID of your stepfather here.
They have the car,
but you still haven't been able
to get hold of the body of your mother.
I mean,
why is that?
VLADISLAV: When they were
collecting the bodies,
it was happening in a strange way.
It was obvious no one was saying
who was doing this and how.
According to the investigator,
someone made a big mess.
After months of no news,
the law firm has agreed to help
Vladislav locate his mother's body.
Orphaned and on his own,
the teenager has even moved in
with one of the lawyers,
called Serhiy,
who has taken on his case
and is now taking care of him.
BEL: You have a hedgehog.
Where is the hedgehog from?
- I bought it here, in Kyiv.
He's so cute.
What's the hedgehog's name?
- Yustia.
Yustia?
Stop it.
He's so cute.
He's very cute.
He's quite spiky though.
They called to say everything was fine.
and they were staying overnight
because they did not have time to return.
It was 24 March.
And that was actually
the last conversation I had with her,
that’s all.
WOMAN’S VOICE: How are you doing?
VLADISLAV: Bad habits have appeared.
Until now I have never smoked at all.
Almost never drank alcohol.
Well...
BEL: Serhiy believes
he has found the location
of Vladislav's mother
in one of the numbered graves.
He thinks she's body number 500.
They hope an exhumation will be imminent,
and then in theory
there can be a DNA match.
But Serhiy says the police
are either overwhelmed
and so unable,
or unwilling to help.
SERHIY: Can you imagine that?
They were mixing up corpses.
- Hello?
We agreed last week
that you would inform us
about the photo evidence,
so that we could find Vladislav’s mother.
- I’m telling you, the moment I was asked,
I immediately called and found out.
SERHIY: I’ve got you.
Okay. Let’s move on with the documents.
- As soon as I find the photo evidence
I will let you know.
SERHIY: Good, because the boy
needs to study.
- I talked to him.
You think I don’t want to help him?
I’ve talked to him,
and I understand the situation.
SERHIY: We need to find the boy’s mother.
She’s in the cemetery, and I know where.
- I will find the initial case
and I will request the materials.
That’s what we agreed,
that’s what I explained.
SERHIY: Okay.
Again, I’m sorry to have bothered you.
Goodbye.
- Goodbye.
Swine. Another one.
[low outboard motor]
VADYM: This is where my soul rests.
This is where I calm down a bit.
I distance myself a little from everything
it is a bit easier for me here.
BEL: The authorities have reopened
Vadym's case file,
but despite having the bodies
of his relatives and his DNA,
The investigators are yet
to make a formal match.
When I am home I get depressed.
I started taking pills yesterday.
Antidepressants.
Because it is really difficult.
BEL: Robbed of a proper burial,
Ksenya’s and Maksym's families
have instead built a little memorial
by the side of the road.
It marks the place where they were killed
on the highway,
where that awful moment
was filmed by the drone.
It’s hard. It’s hard for everyone.
How can we live without our children?
BEL: Last time we were here,
you were trying to get a hold
of some photos
of the crime scene
so that you could move forward
with the DNA process.
What happened?
- I submitted a petition,
attorney requests, addressed the director.
We were finally successful.
With this last corpse,
which is unidentified, number 500,
we will be able to do a DNA test.
BEL: What if it's not grave number 500?
What happens next?
- We will keep searching.
And we will keep going
until in the end we find her.
BEL: How are you coping?
How are you dealing with this situation?
- I live in a depressed mood.
I have a problem
to concentrate on some things.
It’s understandable that we
try to find the answers.
We want to find our relatives.
We should have some answers.
BEL: And it's not only
about finding the missing.
Ukraine and its international partners
are building tens of thousands
of potential war crime cases.
The murder of Vladislav’s mother
may end up being part of that.
PHOTIS: It's extremely important
to get everything accurate
from the scene of the excavation.
BEL: That's an immense job to be doing
when the country is still in conflict.
- Exactly.
If there's a break in this continuity,
that's where you lose
all credibility in a court of law.
BEL: How long could this process take?
I mean, are we talking about
Ukraine looking for its missing
and identifying its bodies
for a few years?
- I would count this in, unfortunately,
decades.
This problem will persist.
Hopefully, the Ukrainian authorities
and the international community could
pour all its resources into this
and make that time even less.
That's a hope.
BEL: Despite searching for months,
we weren't able to get any information
about the body in the woods.
BEL: I mean, so far, we've basically,
we've tried the Makariv police.
We've tried the Kyiv City Police
and the regional police.
- And the SBU.
And the SBU intelligence,
and we've tried the Bucha
and Kyiv prosecutor's office.
- Yeah.
And we've gone to the morgue,
and we've spoken to all
the local authorities,
like mayors of the towns.
- Yeah.
And we just...
- We check all the villages around,
we check everything.
Like, I was asking all the people,
maybe they know something,
nobody's giving any answers.
BEL: I guess if we were family,
we would be putting our DNA
into the system
and hoping that
there was some kind of form of match.
But even that, obviously,
as we're seeing with Vladislav and Vadym,
even that is problematic.
- Yeah.
We can see that even the people who have,
you know, who had matches,
they cannot find their [relatives].
BEL: Yeah, even those with matches,
they can't even...
- Yeah.
Okay.
BEL: When we first stumbled upon
this site in April
and decided to dig into
what had happened here,
I don't think we had any idea
just how difficult
it was going to be
to get answers.
VADYM: Almost a year has passed,
and it remained as it was.
BEL: From what we know,
this young man was likely not a local.
We know that the Russians
were trafficking civilians
that they'd arrested in different parts
of the country
through this area.
We know that they were targeting young men
and according to some locals,
they had been forcing young men
to dig trenches
and then executing them.
But for now,
this young man
remains just a body in the woods.
MAN: Today I came to be with them,
as always,
because when I am here,
I feel that this is their
last place on earth.
And I want to meet them here.
BEL: Exploring his story
has opened up a world
that I didn't realise existed,
despite the fact
that I've been covering war
for nearly 10 years.
We met Vladislav, Serhiy, Volodymr.
We learnt the story of Maksym, Ksenya
and of course
we followed Vadym
through the process of this investigation.
And...
For them,
their lives
have been irreparably torn apart
by this war.
And the lack of answers
about what happened to their loved ones
has meant that their lives
are remaining on hold.
VLADISLAV: It’s clear that for some time,
life basically stops.
Until you somehow
put it all together.
BEL: That means that there are families
across the whole of Ukraine
who are looking for the people
buried here.
And I think that's what is the most
devastating part of all of this,
people like Vladislav,
who are desperately trying
to do the most simple act of all,
which is bury their loved ones.
And that's gonna be the cruelest fate here
for civilians in Ukraine,
is that they're not gonna have
the right to do that,
to have the closure,
to be able to put an end to their grief.
Because these people that are buried here,
these souls may never be identified.
[gentle music]
[quiet forest landscape]
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.