Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
[Music]
it is a great honor to welcome the 2020
holbrook laureate
griselda pollock to the holberg
conversation welcome
thank you very much i'm delighted to be
here
are professor of social and critical
histories of art and the founding
director of the center for cultural
analysis
theory in history at the university of
leeds
first of all i would like to
congratulate you on receiving the
holberg prize this year
as the hallberg committee expresses in
their statement of motivation
you have received the price for your and
i quote groundbreaking contributions to
feminist history of art
and cultural studies your work has not
only helped to transform the discipline
of art history and the art historical
canine
but your scholarly practices also
exercised a profound influence
on numerous other fields including
cinema studies
psychoanalysis histories of modernism
and modernity
theories of trauma memory and affect to
mention only a few
your work is marked by this forceful
investment in challenging received
wisdoms
and hierarchies of value from a feminist
perspective
this critical orientation runs through
your close to 30 monographs
more than 20 edited collections and
several 100 scholarly articles and
essays
publications which indeed has led you to
become as the holbrook committee writes
a beacon for generations of art
historians and cultural analysts
such as myself perhaps we can start by
going back to your arrival in academia
as a student in the late 1960s and early
1970s
what was the discipline of art history
like at that time and what compelled you
to start working with a history of art
from a feminist perspective
well thank you very much for such a
lovely generous
uh introduction i i'm always alarmed
when i hear these sorts of things
because just
as a an everyday scholar i have been
teaching i've been writing i've been
doing what academics
um are meant to do and i am so honored
that someone nominated me and that this
prize has been awarded
not just to me but precisely for this
relationship between feminism and art
history so i think it's a very
good place to start i did not know
that there was such a subject as art
history i went to university to study
law because i'd been inspired by tv
programs like perry mason and i thought
i was going to bring the world to rights
by becoming
you know an advocate or a lawyer and
then i was too young to go to university
ask me
they ended offered me a place at oxford
but said go away and think about it and
i came back and decided i would do
history
which was my mother's subject so i have
a very very solid historical basis
from my my first degree but during my
final year
i listened to some lectures by the great
art historian francis haskell
on 19th century napoleonic
and romantic painting which i would have
walked past if i'd been in an art
gallery because i'd have had no way
of understanding it but he gave these
astonishing lectures about
the whole meaning of napoleon the
revolution the disappointment the
formation of empire the melancholy of
the defeat of napoleon
and i suddenly saw these works were
doing something
in this complex history of the french
revolution but in a dramatic
theatricalized and
passionate way so i took a the only
option for art history my history degree
was introduced that very year
and i studied the 19th century with
francis haskell called baudelaire and
the artists of his time
now we must understand that art history
has a history
and in the 1960s there was very little
in the way of an art history of the 19th
century
there were some very important french
studies and some
very important fact danish studies
trying to give us the beginning of a
shape
of what happened in the 19th century of
realism impressionism post-impressionism
john rieveldt's book the history of
impressions in the first attempt at a
documentary history
only appeared in 1947 and the great sort
of
blockbuster exhibitions the sort of
celebrity status
of manny and duggar and pizarro and sura
which
came in the 80s and 90s with all these
big blockbuster exhibitions
it didn't exist so it was a very fragile
space to go into
and so i went to the courthouse to do my
m.a and
found not something that i want to
dismiss as conservative i want to
situate it so if you'll bear with me i
just need to
help the listeners to understand a bit
of this so art history
has a history we have classical writings
from you know from the greek classical
world like aristotle and
pliny from the latin world we have
medieval writings when we then get
visari and the idea that you study
artists by
art by studying artists the biographical
model
then we get the 18th century they hook
up with philosophy and say what is
beauty how are we going to say
is art all about beauty and we get the
first history of classical art
and then the 19th century the art
history becomes part of the humboldt
university this model that we still have
in most of europe
with all these new disciplines philology
theology linguistics literature history
and art history becomes part of that and
you know forms part of the university
and we get the beginnings of
a form of art history which is what did
each nation do
so french school german school italian
school
spanish school nobody studies the
british school because there isn't any
british art
they borrow it from everybody else apart
from medieval embroidery
etc so we get the first thing which is
art history becomes associated with
nation building
and art is seen to be the spirit of the
nation so if you're german that's
lutheran christianity you know if it's
italian it's catholic christianity so
there's already a racism being built
into
who is going to represent the nation and
it is not exclusively but largely these
great men
the vazari model and then when we get to
modern art
we are going to encounter a movement in
modern art which will change the terms
of the study of art that's theological
and historical
because it's going to be our everyday
life and new forms from new
consciousness
but we also get people like virflin
saying what makes
art history or the history of art
different from the history of literature
or culture in general so they come up
with the idea of form
that the internal autonomous
transformation of form
which takes the mode of styles is what
makes art history
specific this is great we absolutely
needed it
but then what happens in the 20th
century as i inherited art history
is if you were a renaissance scholar or
medieval scholar you studied iconography
and if you were looking at the modern
the 19th 20th century
it was purely formalist which means art
is autonomous it just
develops out of its own internal
purposes
so as a historian and uh interested in
what drove
people to find new forms why were there
napoleonic paintings
why did they become romantically
melancholy it's
in that imprecation of artistic
forms and practices and artistic
thinking with historical urgency
now there was a tradition of social
history of art
in europe very influenced by marxism
particularly associated with
budapest with antal and hauser and all
these great
thinkers in in the sunni circle
uh in in budapest in the 1920s but that
kind of got repressed because
in the during the 20th century fascism
the third reich particularly and
communism
took art over and used it
for its very overtly ideological
purposes
so in the 1950s as a reaction against
fascism and communism
using art the west
created a notion that art in the west
was
free democratic and that was the sign of
that was
individual and absolutely no political
or historical agenda
so if we understand that situation and
then i arrive
along with a whole generation of people
of the generation of 68
and i think it's worth putting to people
that the generation of 68 are the people
who grew up as the children of those
who'd lived through
and witnessed the holocaust auschwitz
hiroshima in some sense the legacy of
both
both world wars and our generation
was is i would say post-traumatic
which is a way to understand this wasn't
just any old rebellion
it was a sense in which we were being
delivered a world of modernity that
promised us progress and everything was
better
when all we were seeing was modernity
had delivered us
unspeakable political and human
catastrophe
and so the the revolt of this generation
the demand for civil rights to say
the unfinished business of racism in the
united states
the unfinished business of
decolonization
and the violence with which the attempts
to be free were met
and also obviously the two great other
movements
are the gay and lesbian movement to say
why should we be instead socially police
criminalized in our desire
and then we have the particular
phenomenon of the women's movement
so you've got these negative
legacies and these dynamic forces of
civil rights
gay and lesbian rights women's movement
rights and a whole kind of sense that we
had to remake the world
against in the face of totalitarianism
both fascist and communist
and also a growing sense that while
post-war capitalism gave us all these
goods and all this shiny american
pop culture it was soulless and empty
and heartless and poverty wasn't going
away and cruelty wasn't going away
and so in the pursuit of sort of a sense
of
urgency as a generation as an
as a historian i then turn to thinking
what does that mean for art history
i can't accept it's pure autonomy it's
pure individualism
because the minute i looked at it i
realized that that story of art
was absolutely itself eurocentric
white christiano-centric racist
heterocratic and sexist now we didn't
have all those lovely terms yet
but we had a very strong sense that
these things were all
intimately related but i could speak
in my own voice as a feminist
right we could be part of you know
marxist groups we could part of
civil rights groups but the women's
movement was what gave
me a sense that i belonged to a
collectivity that had launched itself
onto the stage of history
as women and created a concept
gender just as there was class created
by marx
race created by the decolonizing
thinkers
the women's movement gave us the
category of gender
and a system and my
exploration of this was not only what
does it mean for
art history if i'm studying art to think
about these kinds of
intimacies between culture and history
and
its ways of telling itself but also
how on earth would i unpick this legacy
what would i have to do to create a new
kind of work so
it's very important that feminist art
history isn't a sort of
subset there's you know stylistic
history and formalist history and
iconographic history
you know an anti-racist history and you
know everybody and then we've just got a
little
you can have a panel at a conference
let's have the feminists
it was part of this kind of crystal
of um youthful rejections
of a dream of modernity which had been
betrayed
that is a wonderful answer that brings
up many central aspects of your early
work
which on the one hand has been marked by
investment and thinking critically
about the social history of art which
was drawing on marx's thinking
while on the other hand your
participation in the women's movement
that was so central to your work on
developing feminist approaches to the
history of art
together with groups such as the women's
art history collective
how did you work on bringing these two
important critical perspectives in
productive exchange with each other
well yeah thank you for that that
question um
what is very important to convey to
people was
um one of my first kind of um
i suppose realizations was that
well art history has a history and we
could begin to say
where what is what is the current point
that's being dominant and how could we
reach back and examine this history and
think differently about it
but we could also understand it's it's
sort of central shape
these arguments about you know nation
period movement style great master i was
also
being able through this encounter with
different kinds of new theoretical
formulations that were part of the
revolutions of the 50s and 60s
i'd say is understanding art history as
a discourse
that art history itself
is a pattern of statements that are
producing particular meanings while
excluding others
privileging certain ways of thinking
while making others seem to be
non-art historical outside that's
sociology
which i was often told you know you can
do sociology if you want but you won't
do art history
you have to not do these sort of social
history questions
so um we knew there was something wrong
and i was beginning to see the shape of
that problem
of centered on the great white male
artist and the
consistent exclusion in modern art
history and the art history of the
modern of women
we didn't have any formal classes
so everything happened outside academy
we set up reading groups
we wanted to read marks or we wanted to
read freud or we wanted to read foucault
or we wanted to explore psychoanalysis
there were little magazines there were
ad hoc symposia there were people
sharing and teaching each other
and the women's art history collective
was part of that sense where
some artists some designers some art
writers some art historians got together
and said
how do we do this now we had linda
nachland's essay
why have there been no great women
artists i had
um jan merdal i think it's janmer del
not guna madel
a book about ankle vat which he'd
visited
with the vietnam war 100 just a hundred
miles away
and he was asking himself what is it to
go and look at angkor vat why this is
happening the bombing of cambodia and
the vietnam war so
we would we had that and we had john
burgess ways of seeing
so we were kind of putting things
together and becoming aware
that something amazing was happening in
paris
which was being imported and translated
largely through
film theory and largely through what it
ultimately emerged as cultural studies
so it's not as if these theories were on
the shelf
i didn't even know such a thing called
theory existed
i knew that there were problems that
different
thinkers were thinking about
and for which they were giving us
concepts with which to think
so understanding you know the
relay social relations of production if
you in class if you were studying
marx but also how to think through
complex totalities
fuco was giving us the sense of um
the archaeology of knowledge the
formation of the terms in which we study
things and the notion that um
our objects of study are produced by the
way we do it
and this produces the expert and the
object and none of us are intending to
be
you know cruel to disabled or mad
or criminal people but expertise makes
you
the the agent of a system
and the object in the person who's ill
or
you know afflicted psychologically
becomes a mad person or a criminal
person
and as he began to write about sexuality
we began to think about the body who's
controlling the body who's
what discourses there about the body and
it seemed art history
needed to be in conversation with all of
this
and i would like to just say one thing
which is
my sort of insight into this which is
in 1905 we get this incredible moment of
five revolutions
einstein says what's the physical world
socio says what is language
husel husserl asks what is being and
founds
phenomenology and that tradition freud
asks what is the mind
and bergson is asking could we have a
material foundation for
imagination and memory now
these we know happened in 1905 this
extraordinary
tradition or explosion of revolutions i
think it took until the 50s and 60s
for those events to kind of percolate
and
change the arts and humanities
so as i just went to university 67
there's a translate publication of la
casa
there's um the beginning of foucault's
publication and then we're going to get
christian mets and various writers in
film theory
and so it's really is a generational
moment
of intense investigation and the
legacies of these great modern questions
what is the mind
you know the psyche psych analysis what
is being phenomenology what is language
semiotics structuralism
post-structuralism
what is difference these big questions
and i see that's my my formation so it's
not a
bricolage of let's go to the supermarket
and borrow a bit of these theories
we knew that these were all interrelated
challenges to a certain uh facile
humanistic idea that is represented
whether it's by the great writer the
great thinker the national canon
know the great artist and we could use
those to burrow into this question of
how does what the way we say it the
concepts we have to think with
and the concepts that we don't yet have
how do they
limit our ability to understand these
human
and social processes as they
form themselves into complex
relationships and not simple ones
your workers from the start been
characterized by an attempt to develop
languages and concepts
that enable us to pose new questions to
art and society
this is also the case in your phd
dissertation which centered on the work
of vincent van gogh
this is an artist whose work you've
continued to write about both together
with fred orton
as well as alone up until today as one
of the most well-known artists in the
world
van gogh his work is surrounded by these
endless and
quite conservative mythologies of genius
gender masculinity and death
how did your interest in funko come
about okay that that's a lovely question
and i'm going to sort of
i'd like perhaps to sort of give this
sort of
janus-like figure that for anybody
trying to think a kind of feminist what
i came to call a feminist intervention
in arts histories
so this phrase is to say there are many
more histories than the one that is
official and given
and canonized in the museums or
canonized in sort of academic teaching
and the histories are more plural
because there are different
centers to different histories centers
from people from
outside the west centers for people who
are queer
centers for people who are women trying
to think through this and obviously
there are queer women
and queer women queer women from the
outside
europe so i mean these great
conversations etc so
as we um were kind of exploring those
um multiple histories the idea is not to
make a new
sub-category but to intervene and
explore them and my question was from
feminism
and feminism has two sides one is to
critique sexism
which is therefore we are against sexism
we pick it out we identify it
the other is for feminism because we
have never had
a world explored through uh
women's perspectives in women's voices
in this intellectual revolution that we
call feminism
was the first time women in large
numbers went to university and
studied in their own name they didn't
become
intellectual transvestites and
patriarchal ventriloquists
speaking the sort of authoritative that
we questioned and so
every discipline in the university
curriculum has been
challenged by feminism from genetics
through to philosophy
so in my art historical project there's
two sides as well
one is you have to deconstruct the myth
of the great artist
you you can't just simply say well add
women to it because the great artist is
not just
just a fact of somebody who's an artist
it's it's already a mythic figure
there's a life story that goes with it
it's compounded by the ways people
interview
artists it's the way that they are are
celebrated and and
treated and and um discussed and spoken
about
and then you have the woman artist and
the minute i say woman artist the word
woman
is an adjective it qualifies the term
artist
which means she's not an artist she's a
woman artist or a black artist or a
queer artist
which means the normative artist is
white and masculine
and heterosexual and probably western
everything that you have to add a
qualifier to you've already
disqualified from being part of the
automatic
thing that the concept you hear when
somebody says artist
so you have to deconstruct that and you
have to understand what is the nature of
the myth and van gogh is the perfect
myth
for the 20th century because he is
uh inheritor of a great
tradition of the notion of the suffering
artist
of the sort of artist as mad the artist
is genius the artist is
isolated but he becomes a perfect figure
for the artist in capitalism because it
says
you just had you know you will be
rewarded after your death because we'll
love your work
even though you suffered now
that's one side and so van gogh will
come there hold on to him for a moment
but the other side then was i had to
deconstruct equally
the myth of the woman artist i had to
reveal
that anytime somebody wrote about an
artist who was a woman
they spoke of her with certain feminine
stereotypes
her work was weaker it was lyrical it
was not epic it was pastoral
right she wasn't an innovator she was a
follower
and i found that actually when you
studied art history
although 20th century art history more
or less wipes women out
it leaves a few in there in order to
function
as this negative foil you'll mention
somebody you'll mention david this
neoclassical
you know uh french artist of the great
revolutionary period
and then you might say and then there's
the sweet softness of elizabeth vijay
lebron
you know and we'll show a picture of her
with her daughter so
the domestication whereas you'll see
david's self-portrait you know with his
terrible injury and his palette
and i did a beautiful comparison of
elizabeth vijay lebron
representation of uber a romantic artist
who's
looking away you know and looking at his
palette you know and then
her self-portrait borrows from rubens's
portrait of the woman and the straw hat
his wife
and appears therefore even though she
has a palette
to have a completely different
iconography for even what is the body of
woman
and the body of man the artist now to go
back to van gogh
what i felt was
that i had been taken in 1961 as a child
to an exhibition and i think now in
retrospect as i worked on this it was
the first
exhibition i went to and i remember
vividly going through
the dark dark rooms with his paintings
when he's in
holland of impoverished miserated
emaciated peasants and bent bodies
and angled outlines of their bodies and
lump and faces and huge hands and then
suddenly it gets a bit lighter when he
goes to paris and then there's this
absolutely ecstatic you know arrival in
the south
you know just like just northerners when
we go on holiday to the south
you know we are in sunshine you know as
opposed to this lovely gray northern
lights we have
and then of course you take you get
taken
to his death all of a sudden you
you come along and then they say he's
committed suicide and i i find this
narrative traumatic
i find it christological and when i
studied lust for life the film by
minelli
he uh van gogh shoots himself in a kind
of crucifixion scene
this evocation of the notion of this
artist's sacrifice but i was so
shocked at being led through this
in an exhibition during the death and i
encountered it again in the next
van gogh exhibition in 69 that i saw and
i i felt troubled by this narrative
on two levels if someone kills
themselves which we now know
and we now think he suffered from um
bipolar disorder
and that it's a terrible level of
anguish that depression produces such
that you want it
you don't want to live you don't want to
be dead but you don't want to feel
anymore and we have a would have a very
different view
of the illness but rather than this
story that
inevitably he was unloved and he was
things so he's driven to this
this point and i thought well maybe
there's another narrative
which is much more interesting which is
van gogh is a highly
intelligent amateur he's self-taught
he never goes to art things he reminds
me a little bit of my father
and other people i know who didn't go to
university who are hungry for knowledge
they read
incredibly widely they are very
knowledgeable but what happens when you
do go to university is you get
disciplined you have a method of saying
this is you know let's argue over it
that but this is serious stuff oh this
is a major stuff
van gaal consumed everything english
literature
german literature russian literature
dutch literature
um french literature he was a passionate
reader of dickens he was a passionate
reader of zola
these are the great novels of 19th
century exploration of the
city right these are
dickens gave us the concept of what the
city is as a place of darkness and crime
and
mystery that requires a detective zola
it's the place of
darkness and crime and and degradation
but so i looked at van gaal and said
what would happen if you thought about
him in terms of the city
and the country you saw him as an artist
struggling
with modernity in terms of
under thinking the city is the place
where i'll i'll be able to discern the
character of modernity
or know i will go back to the country
where i will be safe from modernity and
we will
idolize the peasants and misrecognize
their
unbelievably harsh life for a simple
life
and then as he you can begin to see how
van gogh's career bounces backwards and
forwards
but then i discovered that when he went
to france
all he is talking about is holland but
not
holland the netherlands of the 19th
century
but of the 17th century he says i'm
i'm in the land of ricedale i'm in the
land of hoberma
he writes to gogar and bernard these
key figures in the development of what
we think of post-impressionism who are
pushing ahead after impressionism he
says go to the louvre and look at
rembrandt
so this is a complicated story to argue
but
it's it's justifiable in all sorts of
ways and that's documentable
so i i wanted to sort of both do an
analysis of the myth of van gaal
which is in everybody's mind the artist
everybody's heard of
a celebrity created by a whole series of
exhibitions after the first second world
war
and what was it that that story served
and what would it be
if i said let's have
a kind of a much more complex rich and
perplexing sense
of an artist who is self-taught
struggling with modernity and missing
what everybody else the gauguins and the
suzannes he doesn't understand what
they're doing he doesn't understand
manet
he doesn't understand that but he
arrives at the point at which
modern art did arrive which is to say we
actually can't manage modernity we
are going to flee it and we'll flee into
abstraction
so i think it's a very interesting thing
to say
how do you undo this tight
structure of the legend which makes him
the representation of the
the artist the suffering artist the
masculine artist
and if i can undo that and produce a
more historical account of this
absolutely iconic artist i can also
invite people
to undo the stereotype of the woman
artist
and produce an argument which says
actually when you study it
men and women co-created art
and particularly co-created modernism
and
impressionism is the first egalitarian
art movement
with mary cassatt morisso if gonzalez
and marie brachman absolutely there in
the organization and if we could get
there
i don't have to make a special case for
women the case is historical
there they were everywhere you looked
in 1981 you published the book old
mistresses women art and ideology
together with the art historian
psychotherapist rosica parker
this landmark book has been republished
in several editions including this year
and in the book you develop a structural
critique of sexism in the art world
and you argue for the importance of
changing the rules of the game as you
say of art history
including how we understand the notion
of art the subject of the artists
and concepts of value and quality
the title of the book reads in itself as
a kind of a conceptual intervention that
troubles established terms in art
history
such as old masters what was the impetus
for you and parker's work on this
seminal book
the title comes from an exhibition that
um
two american art historians um
and i'm having a little a moment which
is elizabeth brown and
her colleague created at the baltimore
museum of arts because
they were part of this early movement
amongst curators and art historians
who discovered works by artists who are
women in the basements
of their museums and the term old
masters in art history
or in fact the old the art market refers
to art from the 16th to the 18th century
so they wanted to show that
the term four artists great artists of
the past of this great era
was already gender specific and you
couldn't have a feminine equivalent
because if you say old mistresses
it doesn't have the sense of master it
has the hence sense of being a sexual
a kept woman or in fact it's the origin
of mrs the mistress of
somebody so they already said look it's
it's their
language we don't even have a way to
speak this so
there were a number of books in the
1970s 60s and 70s which were you know
our hidden heritage
you know women artists from this to that
there's a lot of documentation that
simply because it was very easy to find
them
i think it's very important for the
public to understand although no art
historians were teaching
an art history of the west with women in
it it was very easy for us to find the
dictionaries to find the archives to
find the paintings
so when rosie parker and i decided we
would write our book
based on conversations we've done with
the women's art history collective
we asked ourselves two questions what
did we have to add
to this existing rediscovery model
putting women back on show organizing
exhibitions
making survey histories of women artists
and the other was that we both had a
supervisor
at the courthole institute later the
director of the tate gallery alan bones
who laughed at me he said get on with
your thesis
don't worry about this trivial subject
it's ridiculous
and you're wasting your intelligence on
something that has no
value and so we wanted to know
why alan bernese could laugh at us
studying women artists it's not the same
as saying oh they're no good
it was you know it was beneath contempt
it was ridiculous
and we thought if we could understand
why that's possible
we would have not just been rediscovery
and returning our hidden heritage to the
bookshelves where it will stay
we would be able to understand what the
structural function of art historical
discourse is to produce
an art history without women to produce
an art history in which it is
normal for the artist to be a man and a
straight man
and to suppress all other complexity and
to suppress
women specifically except in so far as
you reference them as i said before to
be
this stereotype of lack
so what we wanted to do was to analyze
the discourse the pattern
and we opened this by saying the
quotation from virginia woolf who says
if you go to the british museum you'll
find that there's
hundreds of books telling women what
they are
but very few written by women exploring
so you have to critique the the the the
old master model
and reveal it for what it is reveal
which is the great discovery when we
studied it
that women artists are recorded in
all the forms of art history including
vasari
including pliny you know went back to
all these these great people we have
classical art we know their names
right up to the formation of these big
dictionaries of all the artists of the
world
created by the germans at the beginning
of the 20th century
and 20th century art history modern art
history the one that was being published
by feiden and thames and hudson and was
being taught
they erased women absolutely so when i
was studying
no woman was taught to me no artist
woman was ever mentioned
and yet artists that i write about now
were living then
side by side they were in the height of
their careers
but they were being disappeared in their
lifetimes so we had to analyze art
history
we had to analyze the feminine
stereotype
we showed also the hierarchy between art
made in
oil and canvas versus textiles
needlework that particular what we
called crafty women
we then had looked at the ways in which
women negotiated this contradiction
between the image of the artist as the
masculine
and the image of the woman in the form
of the self-portraiture
and explored their diaries and writings
and then in the final
chapter we wanted to argue
explore the ways in which women what we
said negotiated
their situations of difference and they
made art as much because of the
specificity or the difference of their
situation
as despite it now normally people say
women were discriminated against so
linda nachland argues
women artists were discriminated against
and as a result there never were any
great women artists but once we get rid
of discrimination they'll be free
and i think our argument has won out
because women have not been
any more systematically recognized and
integrated
once we removed overt discrimination
i not been given access to education art
education
or not being chosen we still have a
minute number of women
being exhibited their art being bought
the museums are still three-quarters
empty as far as i'm concerned
and at the same time we don't have a
language to say how women
negotiated difference now this is the
really crucial thing because it's not
there are women and i say that this is
what women are and this is what men
are we're talking about not having a
unitary solitary
hegemonic ideal but exploring how
difference
is creative sometimes difficult
but it's negotiated so in the final
chapter
we were looking at artists of the 20th
century particularly in surrealism
but my favorite which i i've come back
to because i've just re
gone back to this question is to compare
jackson pollock's painting method with
the painting method of helen frankentala
so we've got two
abstract artists for whom the manner in
which you put
paint on canvas is the process
and is the effect and you ask yourself
the question not
do men have men things in their minds
and they drop it on canvas and women
have women things on their mind and they
bleed it into their canvas
but how does an art practice that
involves the body in its own movements
involves a certain kind of revery as you
engage in a kind of almost a ritual
practice of moving paint
is there a way in which that is
inscribing
something that comes from different ways
in which we live our embodied lives
live our psychic lives live the time
lines of our lives to live the sort of
time space
of masculinities and femininities
because
we also can't ask you know ignore the
question
that you know the the kind of image of
van gaal and the image of jackson
pollock are these very
heterosexual images which also silence
the question of queer subjectivities let
alone black queer subjectivities black
subjectivities
so my idea for what i model for old
mistresses works for
ex you know exploring artists of
color artists of different sexualities
and genders
and we were constantly aware that we
could not simply
propose a kind of question of gender
over these others
but what feminists meant was to ask the
question of
difference as simultaneously sometimes a
constraint
there are obstacles and limitations but
there are also possibilities
and in you know contributions to the
world
so reading artists like artemisia
gentileschi or
elizabeth vijay lebron or rosa bonner or
mary cassatt or helen frankenthal or lee
krasner
this becomes not a matter of saying here
are the women artists you've missed out
but here are situations in art making
for instance the 1950s the mccarthyite
era the cold war
all these elements and i've just
finished a book based on a long
chapter that i i wrote many in the 1990s
called killing men and dying women which
is trying to explore
how to imagine the
questions of sexual difference and
abstract painting
in this particular moment without kind
of
using gender man and woman but
exploring masculinities femininities
issues of class issues of jewishness all
of these are complex forms of difference
which will be negotiated
and it's my job as an art historian to
to read them
not just to celebrate the greatness and
give you the reasons why you should find
great
but to read the artwork as a piece of
work as a working
and this kind of project coming from old
mistresses
has led me as i look back as to what i
subsequently wrote
you'll see i don't often write
monographs i have written on mary kasat
and on charlotte solomon and i'm trying
to write my book on van gogh which i've
failed to write for generations but lots
and lots of pieces on the way
but what i tend to do is to take
problems so my books are
old mistresses women art and ideology
and then
vision and difference so this is
absolutely what i'm talking about how
does that
question of visuality of the image and
difference how can we read that
um then gender and the color of art
history
how do you unpick the implicit racism in
art history
and then on the other hand the next one
was how do you deal with the
postcolonial
that artists don't come from europe but
we don't want to have
ethnic nationalism to say they're
japanese or chinese or korean
so i came up with this concept of
generations and geographies in which
each artist is understood in a kind of
familial
biographical history but also a kind of
a timeline of the history of their own
society
and they're also in a sort of
geographical space line because they may
have been
you know born in in taipei but live in
new york and practice in berlin
right so you need these double axes
which are not confining artists as
representatives of nations or
ethnicities or
genders or classes but are dynamically
living
in these different ways and then the
next big one which was an answer to old
mistresses was
in the 1990s i said given what i wrote
we wrote in old mistresses why has the
cannon not
disappeared so what do we do with the
cannon why is it
in place how does feminism deal with it
and i came up with this sort of deridian
concept of differencing the canon
which brings us back to van gogh bit
which is there's an essay
in that book on van gogh and also on
toulouse la trek
to show that a feminist interest
in the questions of the sort of the
psychoanalytical and the psychosocial
condition of an artist in relation to
the question of
the mother right and question of of
uh how the mother figures for
all subjects i could read that in van
gogh and i couldn't read it in van gaal
if some part of that psychosocial
formation was not available to me as
well
so i was both differencing the canon by
introducing him to a feminist reading
at the same time situating myself as the
reader
in terms of this shared question of the
psychosocial formation of subjectivity
and then my most recent concept is
called the virtual feminist museum and
this comes
about because um i think
i always said to myself that the the
curators the keepers of the canon
the people who are the gatekeepers of
museums and
and and indeed academic publishing do
not think i'm a real art historian
because i mix up psychoanalysis and
sociology and philosophy
but you can see i'm i'm always focused
on reading the work that is about art
history i
am an artistry but they wouldn't trust
me right because you might mislead the
public because you might come along and
ask them to
think something which is not canonical
and official knowledge
so i never got to do any exhibitions and
yet i think
the exhibition is this lovely form where
you
you have a certain proposition made to
you by somebody who chooses a group of
works to be there
and then individually we wander in and
we make our own conversations we see a
relationship between this or that
we bring our own lives and say this
means a lot to me where's that one you
say it's great but it doesn't mean a lot
to me
so i wanted a form in which i wasn't
going to be authoritatively
writing about artworks and illustrating
them
as the subset to my story i wanted
people to have a sense that here's a
collection of things that i think
talk to each other in non-canonical ways
breaking through different medium you
know sometimes a film shot sometimes a
drawing a painting
sometimes a poster something like that
which indicates this
cultural conversation across all the
media and then
my text is not illustrated it's my
proposition it's my reading
but it means that i'm i found myself
getting close
to abby vargok who's an early 20th
century
art historian that we sort of recently
recovered
who made these great panels and put art
together
in ways that defied the story of nation
period movement style master
he he had an idea of images migrating
and their meanings changing
in relation to different times so i
don't then look like someone who's done
the big book on michelangelo or the big
book on
artemisia gentileschi i have created
concepts with which to think a feminist
project
exploring difference and diversity
i think your work on the virtual
feminist museum is a key example and
have you worked to develop
new forms of practice after all you're
parker's critique of the flawed logic
behind the attempt to write
artist women into the established canine
in old mistresses
is now almost 40 years old yet we see
the art museums today keep throwing
shows after shows
that centers on bringing rediscovered
artist women into the canine
there's a kind of cruel optimism at play
here for while these shows seem to
suggest that something is changing
the logic of the canine seems to secure
that everything remains the same
but the virtual feminist museum offers a
different alternative here it seems
to these kind of add-on histories
offered by rediscovery shows
as it seems to create not just a
different context for revisioning art
history
but also a different kind of encounter
with art itself
to me there seems to be a political and
i'm almost tempted to say utopian
gesture at play in your work on creating
these new forms of encounter
thank you so much for bringing that up
because that the the encounters in the
virtual famous museum is the the
the full title of the book time space
and the archive and that the concept of
encounter i i take from my
kind of sublet sort of you know the work
that goes on beside of i've very long
been interested in the work of an artist
who's also a psychoanalytical theorist
bracha
littenbergberg ettinger known as bracha
ettinger now
and i encountered her work in in the
1990s and i was absolutely compelled by
her painting primarily that's what i
encountered first at her as an artist
but then i discovered that she had sort
of translated the
discoveries she was making in her own
painting as
a child born into the double catastrophe
of uh the nachbar and the holocaust
and trying to negotiate again like my
generation the 68 this sort of traumatic
legacy
of unsolved nationalisms and ethnicisms
and the legacies of
european genocide so um and she
offers a particular theory of
subjectivity
as encounter of
understanding the term encounter is a
term which is
i think so perfect for our thinking
about art history
and the experience we have of art
because so much of art history
has become a kind of master discourse
this is
i do the historic research i tell you
what it means i tell you what's great
this is the canon this is why you should
be studying this
and the museum uh lays this out
spatially tells you the story leads you
through the minor works to the great
works
doesn't give you a freedom to i mean
obviously you have a freedom to wander
but actually there is a logic
in that and i wanted this uh notion that
you cannot predict what comes out of the
encounter
i am not the master artist or in telling
you what these works mean or why women
are important
i'm trying to find out how to bring to
other people's attention things that
require all of my skill all of my
intelligence all of my learning to
enable me to fragilize myself to
sensitize myself
to what might be happening in this work
what is this work
doing and so the idea of the encounter
is as you say precisely a kind of
political
mode that challenges the authoritative
the hegemonic
the official the canonized the exclusive
dominant story that is given to you as
knowledge as history
as the story of art while at the same
time
offering very serious and very deep
propositions arguments
right that there's something there so in
my book
on uh um encounters in the virtual
museum
i have a section called visions of sex
which is
exploring the kind of whole in
kind of interest in the question of the
body and desire
and sexuality in the beginning of 20th
century that that echoes with
um d.h lawrence's novels it echoes with
obviously the impact of freud and
psychoanalysis
it echoes with women
entering modernism and you know not
painting venuses but beginning to
explore how would the representation of
their bodies
and one of my key chapters is about
josephine baker
african-american dancer who's known for
performing these very erotic semi-nude
images that people see as completely
exploitative racist and exploitative and
that she's subject to the colonializing
gays
but when i studied her talking about
what it meant
as a woman a black an african-american
woman whose history is that of
sexual abuse as a race a piece of
property
in the in era of enslavement and bearing
the the mark of being seen as a sort of
dark and and and sort of degenerate
race by racist society what it meant for
her
to discover her own beauty as a dancing
body as a black body
and that her dancing was as it were her
authoring her own musicality
knowingly in defiance of a gaze that
could easily
treat her in its to a racist view
but she was not succumbing to it at the
same time i went on to look at what
happened to the body
after the holocaust because what we
witnessed being done
in the real through the concentration
camps and through the
extermination camps has meant we no
longer can pretend that the tradition
of the christian body or raphael's
three graces these bodies of beauty or
giorgione's lovely nude lying in the
landscape
once you see women lying in a landscape
you've been shot to death just for being
jewish
in the photograph there is a rupture and
i want it in the book to show that art
history
has ignored this it fails to understand
the depth of the rupture
of what happened in the 20th century and
we are on two sides of it
and this brought me to a chapter in my
book on charlotte solomon
whom i've now written an entire book
about
because she comes to us on the other
side of the rupture because she was
murdered in auschwitz
but her work was made before that was
conceivable
in this period i call before auschwitz
so i'm also rewriting or rethinking the
the epochs right so the normal art
history you'll get in a museum would be
um you know modernism we'll have some
cubism and fauvism and then we'll have
some dish style and then we'll
you know move on to some of the sort of
surrealism and then we'll get to
abstract expressionism
and then they don't know what happened
they'll probably get pop art and
minimalism
and then they have to have just
contemporary art
right but they still try to give you
that map well
you know where is the first world war
where is the second world war
where is the depression where is the
first flights
you know where are the um uh the the
sort of um
obviously the holocaust where is the
sense of the
nuclear cold war the threat of the cold
war
so if you just have a chronological
survey and that
you you miss this sense that art is
shaped by these historical events but
also gives a form
to them and the transformation of art
is that so my second installation of the
virtual feminist museum is called after
affects after images
trauma and aesthetic transformation
because the big question then is
what can art do in the face of
um in sense the defeat of modernity the
the kind of
the the understanding that its promise
was betrayed
still has the promise democracy freedom
justice rights
but we witness these terrible betrayals
and we have to come to terms with
them but at the same time art now
deals with that and so much of our 20th
late 20th early 21st century art is
now not suddenly conceptual because it
stopped being formal
it still has to transform produce
formulations
right and i think museums are
unable to understand
what the social history what feminist
art history um
would require of it as a form
in order to enable people to see that so
that
that's why i've used the book form to
say here are some of the
the terms we might think about once you
put them in play you will see the work
for what it's doing and forming for us
as a transport station of trauma
that not everybody will encounter and
meet it's the encounter
is not predictable right because there
isn't
a right story and you're not learning
the right story
you're opening yourself up to what
artists
ask of us through the forms that they've
created
for formulating suffering
joy ecstasy pleasure
desire all these death life all these
big questions and i think people would
have
a much greater engagement with art and
and and experience art not as something
to be consumed
as a fashionable item or go and stand in
front of museums and sort of
you know you know whenever they film
people in museums they're always
standing in sort of semi
religious or right because
many people don't have enough to say oh
i see that's what's going on
oh maybe that's interesting no i don't
agree with you but i do see something
going on
so i think there is a change you're
right absolutely and i
i think um i was forced into as it were
a book form and i've in terms of my own
curation
i've learned another thing which is i
curated an exhibition of bracha
ettinger's
work and then i had to write the book
afterwards
because i realized
bringing the work together paying the
fees you know
getting the taxes getting the delivery
isn't what has happened when the work
actually comes into
encounter itself encountering the space
encountering people
so i wrote this book called art writing
after the event
as a model for in a sense of not
thinking the curator
formulates and puts on the walls and
then we just have a few catalogs with
illustrations
it is a work of art itself for artists
to produce an exhibition
yeah your latest book charlotte solomon
theater of memory from 2018 is also
relevant to this regard
as it addresses the question of how we
encounter works of art in other ways
the book grows out of a more than 25
year long attempt of trying to
understand
what this specific artwork is really
about the piece called
leben orateata life question mark or
theater question mark
that charlotte solomon worked on in the
first years of the 1940s
in berlin and later in southern france
leading up to her deportation
and murder in auschwitz i wonder if you
could say something about the process
of writing this book as i think it
brings together so many important
strands of your work
not only the engagement with history of
art modernism
and the position of women and jewish
women in particular herein
but also your way of staying close to
the material in this case the more than
700 paintings
that constitute this work by solomon the
work you also read as a philosophical
inquiry
and as a document of social political
and historical
moment that can teach us something
important about trauma memory
and subjectivity in quite extraordinary
ways
absolutely i mean um you've described
the
the the project of labor no detail life
or theater beautifully there matthias
because
it's an art historical anomaly
most people to be considered an artist
have to be exhibited written about
documented their work has to be lots of
it it has to have a beginning a middle
and late career and it has to be in a
museum
and charlotte solomon who was murdered
when she was 26
began at the age of about 24 23 24
this monumental cycle which she produced
784 in fact she produced over a thousand
paintings
in possibly about a year and
we don't know what it is we don't know
entirely
why she made it there's nothing like it
in the history of
of art and yet it's completely conscious
of the history of art
it's very knowing it knows about opera
it knows about music it knows about
cabaret
it knows about um you know it's almost
sort of walter benjamin-esque in its
interest in in the sort of city and
memory
uh it's clearly influenced by a concept
nature there's a great engagement with
the first world war and a survivor of
the trenches and there's
all these issues and it's witness to the
rise of nazism
and she goes to art school in the third
reich
watching all her jewish professors
disappear being allowed to be there
because her father was a veteran of the
first world war and she's the only
jewish student in her class
she witnesses the degenerate art show
that was
all the modern art that hitler got
together in order to say it's jewish and
it's bolshevik and degenerate and will
be exiled from the new
you know aryan third reich uh so she got
a whole history of modern art
as a gift of of hitler very interesting
but she made this work
and so many of us when we discovered it
particularly in the feminist community
particularly in the kind of jewish
studies community particularly those of
us working
in and around the issue of the holocaust
immediately said
we must work on this and
most people have taken it as an
autobiography
have made it a kind of a visual and
frank
she's another woman victim of you know
young girl young woman victim of the
holocaust who left us this sort of
account of her life and i knew it wasn't
i you know in a kind of pig-headed sort
of way i said i just don't think this
is adequate to this there's too many
complexities to it
so what you you've been saying with us
is quite right the only thing i had to
do was to say
i have to be an artist or if i can do an
art historical analysis
i have to start what am i looking at
how would i describe it and i always
teach my students this
which is you must always start your work
with looking at things and i remember
when i was first
doing my 19th century work going back to
the beginning of this conversation the
courthold i went to the
um the the poem that was where the
modern paintings were and i remember
standing in front of
mane's olympia and saying
i don't think i know what to do so i
wrote it's very large
right there are two people in it you
know
there's a cat i just made myself start
with the stupidest
simplest what am i seeing and making
myself by describing it
begin to see it and i when i do my van
gogh research i was sent
to to the crawler muller which has this
wonderful collection of van gogh
drawings
and they put me in a little glass box
with all these incredibly precious boxes
and i looked at them and i thought
i don't have the first clue what is
because i'm you know i'm just a rookie
artist or in this point and so i take my
pencil and says
i didn't expect them to be so large
because they're these great
drawings that are imperial size and then
i noticed
that he pressed very heavily on the
outlines
and then i you know that was when that
led me to make and
he's copying he's these drawings are
like you copy
you know when you are not trained drawer
you when you're trained in draftsman
you're looking at space and volume and
you do all sorts of interesting ways to
get it no he just drew an outline so i
thought ah
copy book apprentice this is why he
could never do anything
because he never learned to draw volumes
so that's
that sense of how you make a discovery
is by just
what am i looking at you know what's it
made of
so with the labor not a tayata i taught
myself gouache painting and i copied
some of her paintings to say
how long would it take to do this what
does it feel
with this kind of material to make these
marks
what kind of brushes did she use how did
she establish things and i had to get
into this
process and then by analyzing
the different works with my refusal to
accept it's autobiographical
i concluded as you said that it's an
investigation if you have a
work which has two question marks
it's life or death right living or dying
life or theater two question marks
what is you know how did this come about
what what are the stakes involved
and so the the book is designed and
going back to the question we had before
i i knew how i would want that book
designed
because i want the reader not to get
this work follows this work this fault
works but what i realized is
if i treated it like a detective fiction
like a mystery something happens as a
crime
starts with a crime a woman kills
herself
not a crime but it is a crime in sense
because she kills herself because of
something
and it ends with the work where the
woman is
the image of the painter is painting her
first
painting so it and
it sort of ends where it's starting so
it's reverse time
and if you study detective fiction you
get all sorts of clues put in
all of which sort of make you think this
is what's going on oh it's him no it's
her
oh that's what's happening okay but
eventually
the idea is to bring it together in such
a way as you say
oh right that's what it is
so i wanted to treat this work as
a mystery it's asking questions
it's a philosophy of should i die
or should i kill someone or have some
did somebody die you know this is the
thing and once you do that
the paintings come to life and again
going back to what was saying before
about exhibitions they always exhibit it
um chronologically so people think
they're following a story
but i thought in a book i could go
backwards and forwards i could say
we're not going to do that logic i'm
going to have eight
paintings which will be keys and then i
can
open each work to a whole sequence
around it
so that i begin to plot out as as you're
saying the
the historical because it's the rise of
nazism but it's also the story
of three women and then
for ultimately four women one who kills
herself
another one who kills herself another
one um
well then there's three there's a
grandmother who also does and then
there's a singer
and then there's a professor and then
there's an artist and if i
treated it like a brestian play which we
all were characters
i wouldn't fall into this
autobiographical over personalizing
because people then when they write
about women they immediately talk about
charlotta
frieda merit louise
now we don't talk about pablo or ori or
gerhart
right the author name the patronym is
the artist's name
and then women are automatically things
and the first publications on charlotte
solomon were
charlotte a diary in pictures that's
fair enough they thought that but
my book is designed so as the reader
goes through each chapter
they meet the key painting these eight
key paintings
and then all the supplementary
enrichment
and the complementary images etc
enable me to build a story about
a work that is what i call it suspended
between the
event and the everyday and the event
covers in sense the grand historical
landscape
of the 20s 30s and 40s weimar
the end of weimar the rise of the third
reich and then of course the
the the the war and the occupation of
france and her
her jeopardy as a jewish rep refugee in
france
but at the same time the everyday is
entirely this question that
feminism has made us ask about that what
seems to be not historical and not
political and not
social the everyday is the world of
intimacy domesticity uh indeed sexual
abuse
desire fantasy um
and and a different set of relations so
this is in a sense the culmination of
it's the only it's the book i could only
write
after 50 years of being an art historian
it needed all the things we've talked
about today
understanding art history understanding
the discourse understanding the problems
understanding the exclusions developing
concepts becoming aware like in
modernity in the spaces of femininity
this sense of how
different spaces in impressionist
painting allow us to understand
psychosocial existence embodiment desire
what is important or different or
indifferent to different groups
um why sexuality and commercial
sexuality is this big
area but why the relationships between
women or children
and adults becomes a sort of place for
mary cassette so when i came also with
having
dedicated all of the 90s to developing
courses on
the formation of the cultural memory of
the holocaust
and the entry of the holocaust into
cultural representation museums
films visual art literature philosophy
theology i was able to sort of you know
prepare myself and then because of the
work with
bracha ettinger and the interest in
psychoanalysis that i originally got
from
film theory as it passed into feminist
psychoanalysis
and trauma theory i had the tools with
which
to do this close reading
and hopefully make this work
something other than an autobiography in
pictures
of a tragic set of stories and i have an
argument
which was then confirmed and we got a
lost document came back
but i did re-read this book in
anticipation
of this conversation knowing it as i did
when i wrote it
i advised no one to read it in bed it's
too heavy it would fall on your nose and
break it if you're reading it
the only way i think to read it is to
take it chapter by chapter to take these
little sweets
and have us an experience between it of
how
how it's building this architecture
to enable people to um
arrive at the sense of the shocking
the wonderful things she did the
philosophical thing this artist did like
no other
but also how those realities of the
event and every day
might have led to something
which i won't reveal to you because
you'll discover it if you read the book
but it is
absolutely shattered everybody in the
charlotte salomon world
to discover that she could say do i die
or does he die do i kill or do i live
and that really takes us to the depths
of
his when we talk about trauma or
historic
um events that are so unimaginable
as living on the cusp of imprisonment
and death at the hands of the nazis then
that's what i want people to feel not
the banal smoothed over
but the intensity and the brilliance and
the depth
that art takes us to if we prepare
ourselves
adequately to encounter it
this brings us to your work with a
large-scale research project on
concentrationary memories
that you've developed with max silverman
over the last 15 years or so
this project really exemplifies how you
develop concepts
that allow us to work across statical
social and political histories
in new ways the concept of the
concentrationary invites us to consider
practices of dehumanization not only
as these extraordinary events but as
processes that are sparing on the
everyday
in totalitarian regimes and contexts
it offers an approach to analyze and
theorize the destruction of humanity
also beside and beyond the concentration
camps in world war
ii and today where new forms of fascism
seem to be on the rise where populations
are relegated to
slow deaths and detention camps this
concept of the concentration area seems
to have much to offer
how did the project on the concentration
or memory develop
thank you very much that's it's a really
important part so um
the center cathode is a
transdisciplinary and that's not an
interdisciplinary
it means that we bring different
disciplines together around a shared
concept
and so we look at it from these
different very specific i do
understand disciplinary ways of thinking
are it's not a mishmash
concentration memories followed on from
the fact that both max
and i were um deeply influenced by
sigmund bowman
who was the professor of sociology at
leeds and then emeritus at leeds and
in 1989 his book holocaust and modernity
shattered the world
by making this connection that the
holocaust
intensifies not the product of modernity
was made a possibility by
the rationality the logic of modernity
and we were both teaching holocaust
studies and he was in french literature
and i'm one of the first people to do a
course in
holocaust studies in in cultural studies
and and and visual arts history of art
um
but we increasingly became aware that
there was a confusion
between extermination genocidal
extermination which happens
in four or five key sites
in poland during thing called operation
reinhardt
it extends a little bit later at
auschwitz most of those sites are
destroyed and gone and most the people
who were sent to extermination camps
were jewish and died within one to two
hours of being there
the concentration camp predates
extermination
and is a form which we find not only in
used by people in you know cuba
and british and south africa and
uh other and other societies beforehand
but it becomes an instrument of a terror
of a society that is going to be ruled
by terror
and the political deportees from france
many of them left wing that's why they
were opposed to the third reich
when they survived they came back and
they gave us this kind of anatomy of
what they called luniver consultation
that this is a society created within a
society
to erode it from within and
post-war the man who wrote the universe
concentrating david will say
learned about the gulags that stalin was
setting up
and learned about the use of the old
concentration camp
sites in germany by the east german
communist regime and so we're suddenly
going to realize that this wasn't
finished as you know the extermination
did destroy six million people and is is
finished but the concentrationary
is a phenomenon of of totalitarianism
which
societies i mean you could look at the
dictatorships in latin america you could
look at apartheid that's a
concentrational society
and increasingly we can see the elements
of that
in our way of dealing with asylum
seekers we are creating camps
we are depriving people of the rights to
have rights
in all sorts of ways our society uh
is permeate a bit but so we wanted to
look at this
holocaust memory is a memory in which
you mourn
the devastation and destruction of the
jewish civilization of europe
and the six million people who were
destroyed and all the
philosophers and the laughters and the
artists like charlotte solomon who never
lived to be themselves because of that
we also mourn and we mourn at the
everyday
but concentrationary memory is one
that's meant to agitate
us to say look about you this virus
they even call it the plague la peste
this
disease of the concentrationary doesn't
lie
buried under the ruins of auschwitz it's
alive and well
and permeates our society so
concentration manary
is a way of asking ourselves to be
vigilant to know its signs and to be
vigilant for all aspects of it
that are present and concentrationary
imaginaries
which is an element of that is i became
aware that
elements of what we had understood as
the concentration rate permeates popular
culture
it's a condition of so much of the
increasingly
violent nature of cinema
the nature in which every film i go to
in which i know and accept that somebody
won't make it to the end
who are the casualties go back to my
vanguard thing who who do we allow to
do do we sacrifice now
they're always the lower paid actors you
know if he's a high paid he'll probably
make it to the end of the movie etc
but we do not mourn the deaths
of many of them who pass through a movie
a black man will be shot
you know a woman will be raped as the
condition or murdered or
you know mutilated as the condition for
the story we don't
mourn it we're not affected by it so
one of myself and benjamin hanover
cousin
we worked on this kind of concentration
imaginaries how is it
seeped into percolated into reshaped
normalized our expectations of a world
in which we are indifferent to the abuse
of the humanity of another
now that's very intimate with the
feminist project
the ettinger project of what makes me
unable not to share so there's the
impossibility of not sharing
the pain of the other is the feminist
position
and how do we get to an ethical politics
in which we cannot
tolerate the diminution of human
beings as human beings so i think
concentration remember coming out of a
historical
sort of a distinction and a framing of
the two different elements of
totalitarianism and genocidal racism
comes to something that we now have to
say it seeps into our culture it's
normalized itself we have to be
vigilant and wary of all these
um kind of softening of the edges of our
own acute
ethical compassion
and uh in we have also just published
the third one which we did
one on concentrational film
concentration memories concentrationary
imaginaries which is about pop terrorist
terror and popular culture
and now concentrationary art which
bridges between the notion of what is it
to return
from the camp with the figure of lazarus
the returner who carries the dead and
now
you know we think about all those men
and women who served in all the wars
that everybody says you know they never
spoke right they didn't my father didn't
speak they didn't say what they went
through
um i think this weekend they're marking
the
uh end of the war in japan in europe
that they're and of course many of the
people there said might
they lived in the the camps of the
japanese they never spoke of it
you know and that silence then gets
passed on and generations
don't know what it was that their
fathers or their mothers
endured and then it but it's passed on
so this question of trauma and
transmission
or memory in the failure of memory or
the failure of vigilance
and why in the the heart of this is
hannah arendt that we
whose argument about totalitarianism and
the human condition
suddenly became so urgent for me as
a framing that although she was never a
feminist
actually led me to um you know a
question if i can just read this that i
really
do want to say which is how can feminist
thought break the cycle of crimes
against humanity
that are so symbolically bound up with
both the negation of humanity
to the feminine to women an
identification of death
and the face of horror like the medusa
with women
who are seen as threatening or killing
or the killed why is gender the
repressed question
of the analysis of contemporary violence
so they all weave in together
as different facets of a kind of
expanded transdisciplinary
cultural studies but in each of the
books
the core of what i contribute is this
close close reading of art
working what art does the work of art
as something doing something producing
something
wanting to be read in complex ways in
order to have its effect
and not just to be celebrated as
now as an object which has a huge price
tag
or the thing the the exhibition you must
see
the artist you must know the name
you know the celebrity and all those
things are now
worse than when i started because
they're entirely financialized
and the market is the thing determining
uh
sales and and artists now entertainment
on television with these same old
stories these heroic stories
and all of what we've done for the last
50 years as feminists
and cultural analysts is you know not
taken into the world not given to the
public
in the terms that can give them a sense
of being enabled to understand their
world
your work testifies to the ways in which
art history and cultural analysis can
enable people to better understand the
world that we live in
in the face of many urgencies of our
times we are dependent on critical tools
to help us
identify and describe the problems as
well as to find ways to responding to
them
i'm thinking here for instance the
ongoing corona pandemic
which is the reason why we're talking to
each other unsafe social distance
between leeds and copenhagen
and around us different social movements
from me too to black lives matter
are fighting structural sexism racism
and discrimination
in society as well as in cultural
institutions such as the university and
the art museum
what do you think that we art historians
and cultural analysts can offer in
response to these urgencies of our time
yeah i think i'd answer that by saying
two things one is um
we are probably going to look to artists
and writers and even
philosophers and psychologists to help
us
understand what we're actually living
through because we are
in the midst of it and we don't have
terms so i looked up some of the stuff
about the spanish flu
to see whether or not there are traces
of that in literature did it reshape and
some people even argue
that the fracturing and the fragmentary
and the devastated quality of modernism
was itself a register not only of the
first world war but of the pandemic
and this terrifying encounter with this
sort of viral death
uh that came with the spanish flu um i
think we will be
asking ourselves huge questions because
we don't know how long will this will
last
we live in an age with things oh it's
going to be over soon it's not we will
never go back to normal
we will never have the same trust um
because
this virus will come and they have been
warning like bill gates
in 2015 said the next big danger in the
world
he gave a great talk a ted talk 2015 you
must prepare
for a pandemic a viral pandemic so i
think this
is a huge issue and what we need to do
is it's not
um art history it's we we need to know
how to read art as having already talked
to its own history
given forms to the the formless
sense of menace or fear or panic or
uncertainty
or anger or rage and also we need to
i think bring art and and cultural
analysis
and the the rigors and disciplines of
ways of
thinking conceptualization testing
concepts against evidence
because we also live in an era of the
social media in which the platform
is now binaristic to a degree
i'm for you i'm against you i'm
canceling you you're right you're not
right
you say something about this and you are
absolutely will send you death threats
this is a cultural phenomenon that we
are passively
allowing to occur at the price of a
quality of humanity
which is not let's be reasonable in an
old-fashioned you know
this is just you know badly behaved what
is that this is a culture and i will
you know put it online i think social
media and particularly some of those
platforms
will prove in the future to have been
historically devastating
for humanity i think this is of a
seriousness that we should
take it and we learn this fry we are
always 50 years too late
right just as i said at the beginning i
you know i'm you know post
a post talk you know post traumatic
generation 68
you know the 1989 us but now it's not
the 1989ers
you know but the kids who are born you
know after the beginning of the 20th
you know my students you know were
probably three when you know
9 11 happened you know and they don't
even notice that 2007 the smartphone
changed the world right
all of this is just normal to them but i
think this
is a a a challenge for education it's a
challenge for us in the arts and
humanities
and the one thing i always say to people
about art history
is if it is the art history that makes
you analyze the cultural and the visual
and the
image and these processes
of of that that shape our very sense of
what reality
is more so than even the literary or the
philosophical or theological or the
day people are exposed to images we can
teach people to read their own culture
and find a distance within it to
negotiate it
they probably won't be as critical as i
am because i'm
another generation and i am not a
millennial but
we need to speak to them not as to say
but
we have tools that might enable you to
find the space
to make the decisions about which part
of your culture
is dehumanizing totalitarian
in its way and which is for justice and
freedom
and will make us unable to tolerate
the levels of human suffering that are
the reality of our world and have just
been
made infinitely worse by
the pandemic because natural disasters
are human disasters and they
impact in terms of class race
ability all the key factors and gender
all of them make the pandemic infinitely
worse
perhaps i could convince you to share
some of the work you're currently
engaged in
and perhaps also some of the work that
the holberg price might enable you to
undertake
if you already have started making plans
i i have um i have four books that i
have to write
one is feminism a bad memory to recover
the memory of feminism explain it
holocaust and cultural memory um
the van gogh book and a book on uh
marilyn monroe which is a book about the
1950s america and the 1950s and
the interface between high culture and
popular culture so i've got lots
lined up i've also got lots of artists
that i have to help
one of the things i i feel in the
pandemic is
lots of young artists have come out of
art school and have
not only very little opportunity to work
as artists but not any
very little opportunity to to work
because they would support themselves as
being baristas and
you know museum guards and all these
kinds of casual places which keep
the the emerging artists so i i'm
working
with a project in leeds to do something
at least directly for
the the first of four generations of
students who've just left that
emerging group in their twenties as well
as older artists because lots of women
become artists later in their lives so
there's those um
i i want to create some continuity of
somebody who will teach
feminist theory in the way that i feel
it needs to be taught with this level
of understood it's not just a little
somebody to teach a few women
artists it's it's feminist theory for
most art history um
i i want to do some scholarships and i i
think there are
a number of um projects that will
be specific to my research developing
supporting mentoring
um in in the future so i'm in the
beginnings of processes but the pandemic
has also made
not only that this is virtual but has
hit
a particular community of artists uh
very seriously and that's
that i'm going to do that quite locally
in leeds because
encouraging other people to do the same
for each of their cities
thank you so much grisola pollock for
engaging in conversation today
and congratulations once more on the
hubbard praise
well thank you very much yourself
because i know you've done a great deal
of work to understand it
and shape this and it's been an absolute
delight
to talk with you and since this is
actually so far the only
moment of really feeling that i'm part
of the holberg community
i can't thank you enough for having done
it so profoundly and so intelligently
and it's been a delight to talk with you
[Music]
[Music]
you
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.