Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
good
evening hello and welcome to this
evening's event titled radical thinkers
the art sex and politics of feminism my
name is Sandra Sova I'm the curator of
public programs here and it's my great
pleasure to introduce this evening which
coincides with the launch of the latest
set of the radical thinkers series
published by
Verso this set has a specific focus on
feminism and is intended as an
intervention into current feminist
discourse with four key texts of
contemporary relevance including books
by Lin sear Juliet Mitchell Sheila Ro
boam Michelle Barrett and Mary
McIntosh tonight we're joined by Lin
Sega whose book straight sex has has
been uh recently republished as part of
this latest series and by Professor
Gisela pollok to critically cons
consider the legacies of feminism in
relation to the feminist politics of art
sex and work and their enduring
relevance to contemporary struggles 40
years ago feminist thinkers and artists
interrogated the role of women as
workers and producers and the
representation of women in art what
happened to the new worlds of
possibility promised by the women's
Liberation and second way feminist
movements of the 20th century these will
be some of the questions that we'll be
exploring this
evening now this evening's chair is
Sonia Boyce Sonia is a British Artist
living and working in London she came to
prominence in the 1980s with works that
spoke about race and gender and has gone
on to have an international reputation
for creating works that encourage
spontaneity and
collaboration Sonia is currently a
professor of Fine Art at middle sex
University and chair of Black Art and
Design at University of the Arts London
I'd also like to introduce our speakers
this
evening uh we are joined by ly sear Who
anniversary professor of psychology and
gender studies in the department of
Psychosocial studies at burbeck College
how many books include out of time the
pleasures and perils of aging and
straight sex rethinking the politics of
pleasure that this event is focusing on
she co-wrote beyond the fragments
feminism and the making of socialism
with Sheila roboam and Hillary Wayne
Wright and uh the first Speaker of this
evening will be grisela pollok who is a
professor of Social and critical
histories of Art and director of the
center for culture analysis Theory and
history at the University of Leeds known
for her consistent exploration of
feminist Theory and culture analysis her
recent Publications include after effect
after image trauma anesthetic
transformation published in
2013 and visual politics of
psychoanalysis also published in
2013 now to mention a few words about
the format of this evening we'll start
with each of our speakers giving about
15 to 20 minute
presentations uh and this will be
followed by an in conversation and at
about 7:40 or so we'll open the floor to
questions from the audience uh after the
event which we aim to conclude at 8
you'll have a chance to purchase books
by both of our speakers and have them
signed so please join us in the adjacent
f for that and finally I'd like to thank
vesto for their ongoing partnership with
us and for making events like this one
happen and possible so thank you and now
please join me in welcoming our first
Speaker this evening which is Gisela poo
thank you
thank you very much and uh it's uh um
thank you to Verso thank you to the Tate
and uh for this opportunity to join in
celebrating the republication of Lynn
seagull's
Book now at what stage does a historical
event become a memory a cultural
memory and therefore become subject to a
politics of
remembrance and also of Mis
remembrance now that I am of an age to
be an individual with memories of
political events that shaped me
intellectual when I was much younger I'm
intensely aware of a disjuncture with
the
present this disconnect Falls between
what feels to me like a continuous
thread that weaves the ever richer cloth
of feminist work and thought and what
what seems to those engaging now with
feminism as an ism as an object lodged
in the past to be an object of contested
memory so here this evening we're in the
middle of this
dilemma there's a substantial audience
interested enough to spend a Monday
evening to witness the relaunch of a
text written in the
1990s so like Freud I am pondering to
myself and wondering what does an
audience
want of me of Lynn of Sonia of art
politics maybe it's because it's got sex
in the title which is always a
winner and is feminism something vivid
enough despite its considerable age to
draw you
here now if we were to imagine ourselves
coming together in 1945 for instance and
looking back to an event that
occurred uh 45 years before we would
find ourselves thinking about what
happened around
1900 a completely different era so if we
imagine from 1970 to
2015 we're similarly straddling half an
era half a century and as far as my
seconde students are concerned at
present their entire lifetime lies
between the moment that Lynn's book was
published and the moment they encounter
my talking about it now such banalities
of time gaps as such
my contribution to this evening's
discussion about radical thinkers in
time concerns a profoundly um urgent
question I'm just going to turn this
timing
on it's not going to work uh a
profoundly important uh problem that
takes two forms one is that feminism has
been delivered to the present as a bad
memory I don't just mean that in the
sense of being something of a nightmare
where people say thank thank God that's
all gone now but it's a poorly
constructed memory and this is part in
part the work of those who actively wish
to get rid of feminism but much more
problematically the bad memory of
feminism is uh the product of feminists
themselves they have created a memory of
feminism through stories narratives
formulations and so forth that I
consider to be destructive of the
present and indeed the future
potentiality of what feminism represents
a struggle for dignity and safety of
those who live variously and differently
and even agonistically under the sign
woman in relation not only to non- women
but also to other women so who else but
feminist teaches their students that
they were generations and waves of
feminism who else endlessly repletes
cliches about essentialism and
constructivism who else plays activism
off against theoretical
institutionalization ation it seems to
me it's time that we analyze and I mean
that
psychoanalytically the deadliness that
this that repeatedly betrays the
radicality of feminism and its attempt
to make the sign woman and the political
collectivity that that word dares to
invoke a radical Force for change in the
world so I choose to counter the
tendency for what I see feminists acting
out phallocentric as destructive form of
feminine difficulties with
intergenerational connection and I'm
going to use two resources tonight
offered by two think uh forms of radical
Thinking by women who preceded or had no
truck with our history of feminism as
radical thinking the first is Hannah
arent writing of the crisis in education
that she witnessed in the United States
in the early
1960s Hannah aren concluded Ed an essay
of that title crisis in education with
the following formulation of what I
understand as
transgenerational thinking that defines
a
nonfamilial relation of older and
younger people who encounter each other
in the field of
Education Hannah arant writes this
education is the point at which we
decide whether we love the world enough
to assume responsibility for it and by
the same token to save it from the ruin
which except for Renewal except for the
coming of the new and the young would be
inevitable an education too is where we
decide whether we love our children
enough not to expel them from our world
and leave them to their own devices nor
to strike from their hands their chance
of undertaking something new something
unforeseen by us but to prepare them in
advance for the task of renewing our
common
world now I want to draw an initial
distinction from this statement between
transgenerational work and political and
education work it is too towards
building a common World whose antithesis
op is oppression Injustice and inclusion
exclusion and on the other hand the
institutionalization of some kind of
canonical
knowledge the latter might be defined in
Raymond Willam terms is a selective
tradition that effectively pre-shaped
the present and hence determines the
limits of the
future if our ambition is the Deep
democratization of just Society through
a long-term historical Endeavor with all
its setbacks and its renewals we
nevertheless need some
institutionalization of our histories of
thought within that endeavor and it's
here I wish to place the issues of
transmission and as it were academic
institutionalization of the project we
call
feminism I suggest that feminism Falls
between trauma and memory between the
shock of its claim for the right to
revolt and the belated and often
inadequate forms of the inscription of
that Revolt Intercultural
memory this includes both the lack of
any inscription and the problem of false
inscription and in that gap between
trauma and cultural memory feminism
always also o Falls between remembrance
a sense that it happened at all back
then and iconography its translation
into images icons narratives
representations gossip representation
always selectively constructs the
insertion of feminism to cultural memory
or Remembrance in ways that continuously
Mark the traumatic nature of feminism to
the culture in which it happens and to
those who call themselves feminists and
to women in general
it is an undigestible force a shocking
force a force for profound change that
takes a de makes a demand of those who
engage with it and its Force passes
through stages of adjustment sometimes
mainstreaming sometimes not without ever
exhausting what I call its everpresent
virtuality so rather than the tired and
debilitating and endlessly repeated
attempts to wash feminism away as a
series of ways aves or to trap it in the
endless stories of angry daughters
protesting against overpowering
generational
mothers an idea actually initially put
forward by Rebecca Walker in writing of
her relationship to her mother Alice
Walker and her
generation I think we should understand
feminism as a project destined to divide
the field of which it is in
effect what does that
mean let me introduce the political
theory of agonism
which
suggests that the struggle for democracy
is constantly fissured by the emergence
of new conflicts that themselves become
possible and creatively so as a result
of the preceding moves without the very
concept of women in the world unite as a
performative invocation of an entirely
new political subjectivity the nature of
the specific divisions between women as
women might have remained foreclosed
behind the political vocabularies that
were indifferent to gender or
sexuality and the gendered specif
specificities of classed and colonized
as well as racialized violence so had we
not first called for this notion of
woman the issues which we now confront
which see that this is a Fed field would
not themselves even have risen to the
level of
acknowledgement agonism posits conflict
as a dynamic and inevitable dimension of
the continuous work for democracy so
instead of plotting generations and
waves we might better read feminist work
as creative and radical precisely in so
far as it continuously throws up
conflicts that become visible precisely
because of working through another one
instead of complaining that euroamerican
women's movement was too white and
middle class or too straight which it
was and actually was not because there
were always women of every uh and class
and sexuality involved so instead of
that and instead of the notion that a
new generation arose to correct the
mistakes of the first generation we
perhaps could understand that um the uh
feminism appeared the agonism of class
sexualities racialized and geopolitical
difference are the Dynamics that became
articulable and necessary on the ground
indifferently opened up by the conflict
that first appeared will be seemingly
undifferentiated called for a movement
in the name of women so what I take from
this is a radical understanding of how
to envisage the nature of the
transformative work for change agitated
by the ever emerging agitating wrongs
and demonstrating disagreements that
generates Politics as new forms and new
modes of
subjectivization this abolishes the idea
that we can divide the political from
the aesthetic the active from the
reflective the social from the
subjective in a vocabulary I borrow from
Jack ra ronier we can understand the
process of democracy is an act of
political
subjectivization that disturbs the
police order by polemically calling into
question the aesthetic coordinates of
perception thought and action this is
how of course art politics sex become
part of
feminism this is not consensual it is a
condition I quote of contention that
implements various forms of dissensus
and dissensus is aisia in the kind of
attempt to moderate to organize social
conflict in a kind of legislative way
and what we have to do instead is
confront I quote the established
framework of perception thought and
action with the inadmissible with a
political subject with a changed form of
subjectivity that resists and also
disturbs and therefore also is a subject
of
Desire now in struggling therefore to
refuse the negative force of famili or
generational thinking and to Foster this
political Dynamic of transgenerational
transmission in Hannah Ain sense of
sharing a love of a common world with a
belief in the inevitable newness of the
natality the novelty of human beings
ever creative as they come forward to
change the world how can we understand
the role of feminist thinking in forging
a democratic
subjectivity so by way of a slightly
long conclusion I want to introduce
Susan Stuart Steinberg's fascinating
reading of the political thought in
psychoanalysis in her reading of Anna
Freud the daughter of a famous father
whose task it was to institutionalize
her father's intellectual Legacy not as
freudianism but as
psychoanalysis Anna Freud was not a
mother she lived a long life in a
long-term relationship with another
woman they both dedicated themselves to
the repair of children whose World
psyches were damaged by political F
Violence by War trauma by separation and
bereavement and Anna Freud's achievement
is defined by Susan Stewart as a
politics sorry as imp
Fidelity to understand this we need an
artwork and a digression into the
politics of fidelity itself writing of
the installation Circa 1968 by in 190 to
2004 by Mary Kelly in which she reworked
an iconic image of 196 68 in the felt
residue from a domestic tumble dryer and
was animated by a pulse of light noise
Rosalyn Deutch
writes in her theater of not forgetting
a reference to the key idea of fidelity
Kelly used a material that serves the
philosopher Alan Badu as a metaphor for
the event light the event says Badu is
like a flashing supplement that happens
to a situation it burs burs forth as if
into flame and gives off light which
disappears leaving a trace in the
situation a kind of after image that
refers back to the vanished event and
guides the subject's
Fidelity so the flash of the event
leaves to a trace that creates an after
image that guides she or he who would
remain faithful to an event an event
that only becomes itself in those
persistent acts of fidelity and she who
is faithful to that that event becomes
through the continuous work with the
event what she to make she becomes what
she becomes and the event itself becomes
what it becomes so far from feminism
being something in the past it is what
we perpetually make it in a f Fidelity
to an event of its traumatic shock
another quotation both Fidelity to the
event and left Melancholy remember the
past and write history but unlike
triumphalist historical narratives in
which emancipation leads to resolution
Kelly's history is written in the tense
of the future anterior an order of time
in which reimagining never ends
theorizing the future anterior as the
time of personal history laon once wrote
what is realized in my history is not
the past definite of what was since it
is no more and even the present perfect
of what has been in what I am but the
future interior of what I shall have
been for what I am in the process of
becoming for Freud the significance of
formative infancy lies in the
unconscious archiving and its potential
for traumatic return traumatic return
sorry flashing up in secondary instances
which become the only actualized and
always the belated sites of formative
events that when they happen happen too
early to be understood and leave
effective after images which then incite
Perpetual Fidelity far from endlessly
locating the present in causes locked in
the past the force of the past enters
into the present which becomes the
moment of the past in its realization
linking instances in conjunctions that
are potentially regressive or
potentially and unpredictably
transformative so finally deuts says
this laon's description of personal
history recalls Walter benin's
philosophy of political history
the historian as Benjamin F famously
wrote does not reconstruct the past as
it really was but bringing the past and
present into a constellation seizes hold
of memory as it flashes up at a moment
of danger Kelly thus mixes Badu and
Benjamin two philosophers of The Flash
and of revolutionary not forgetting for
love songs the work you see there the
woman's Liberation cannot be
distinguished from the Transformations
it under goes in the hands of a new
generation and perhaps most importantly
in both Generations
fantasies now I find this formulation
very helpful those who claim to know
have known the past cannot claim its
Truth for themselves its being is in the
hands who of those who make something of
it afterward Le in a movement of
deferral and Fidelity yet there is a
traffic between different spots in time
a mingling of fantasies projective and
retrospective far from instituting the
fam familiar model of generations that
supersede each other we need to have a
historical understanding of colliding
temporalities and co- inhabited
fantasies that are both alive at the
same time although starting from
different experiences and places the
past is in part framed by fantasies of
the past to which that gives rise these
fantasies are intergenerational edle
inevitably we're formed in that but they
can become politically
transgenerational in the manner that har
Hannah Arin proposed they may be in
Conflict but they are always doubled
themselves for each generation is always
fantasizing about another's missing
past so let me now turn finally to Anna
Freud and impire Fidelity to
close Anna Freud talks about the problem
of envy to get us closer to impire
Fidelity and politics two different
kinds of affects envy and anxiety
underpin the respective formations of
femininity and masculinity according to
Anna's father Freud Sigman Freud the
affect of Envy infamously associated
with the hated concept of penis envy the
affect of Envy which is the fate of
femininity unhappy role in the
patriarchal symbolic can however I would
contest be productive and
creative Envy enables the feminine
subject or any other a pressed subject
to resist the status quo to be
perpetually unhappy with it to want to
be what she is told she is not and to
use the potentialities of cross
identification to have or even be what
she
wants a certain kind of psychic
flexibility a kind of transgendered
imagination becomes possible amongst the
envious when they turn it to political
ends on the other hand I'm afraid to say
the typical masculine subject is Frozen
by anxiety because if he becomes other
than he imagines himself to be he might
be subjected to loss or Worse mutilation
he would become something less woman
Freud remarks however that this limits
the masculine subject in that adopting
I'm quot in a feminine attitude in men
is actually an extremely valuable thing
for many
situations now classical political
Theory considers Politics as a place
free from affect for affect is
considered in itself feminine and placed
apart from the
political what steuart Steinberg will
argue is that which is exiled to the
feminine this affect and particularly
the affect of Envy is paradoxically the
Bas basis for the condition of modern
democratic
subjectivity quote Freud's great
contribution to political theory is to
have reintroduced affect into the
mechanisms of power not simply as that
which must be contained but as the site
where social and political relations
originate Freud posits of the origins of
democratic subth as opposed to
hierarchical subjecthood that's to say
hierarchical would be parents and
children always seeking as opposed to
the Democratic subject Hood which is
everybody's in the nursery together so
Freud posits of the origins of
democratic subject which is modern
subject one effect that he views as
crucial for the social contract Envy
Envy lies at the root of both Freud's
theory of democracy and his theory of
gender construction for Envy in gender's
political subjectivity through a series
of cross
identifications thus in Freudian fantasy
of the social contract the male
Democratic subject I will argue is a
woman who acts like a man the
feminist into this complex argument
comes Anna Freud's own contribution and
her position is one who comes after the
founding gestures of her father who
created new ways of thinking
subjectivity and the political yet she
had to negotiate effectively and
intellectually some of the
contradictions and anxieties that arise
from The Challenge of Fidel ity she had
to secure the spirit of the creative
initiating radical gesture when it
became
institutionalized not merely as her
father's work but as psychoanalysis as a
historic event in the world I'm
shadowing this historical case of the
issues a the of politics affect
institutionalization and continuation
with the as yet unthought memory or
Unwritten histories of feminism in which
I find myself like glin complexly placed
as a woman thinker of a certain age and
a certain historical
formation has feminism be in been
institutionalized th by those who behave
merely as its rebellious daughters and
what is the fate of those who are
imagined now as troubling mothers rather
than merely older thinkers why do we
write out stories in disabling
displacement rather than creative
agonism how might we imagine ways of
relating laterally and generationally
Beyond the idolized and heterosexual
family Paradigm that at once rehearses
the heteronormative modeling modeling of
sexual difference but also theoretically
and psych psychically denies any poit
politicizing or creative space either to
the maternal or to the filial feminine
is all affect edle in the last instance
or are there other resources in psychic
life which we could mobilize for a
politics that's not modeled on the edle
prefigurations of Parental Authority and
catastrophically constituted sexual
difference I other ways to think women's
political
subjectivity that involve that involves
willful
transgendering as opposed to negative or
positive idealization of an imagined
good
mother let us turn to one final return
to Anna
Freud one way into the Nexus of politics
sexual difference in affect is through
Freud's relation to his daughter Anna
Freud who became her father mother's
contested successor did so by becoming
the carrier of a node of problems and
anxieties within the psychoanalytical
movement itself gender and feminine
sexuality the transformation of the
envious child into a democratic subject
but above all the handing down of
authority and knowledge from one
generation to to the next in some ways
we might hear the extraordinary
parallels between the not of tensions
within the psychoanalytical movement and
the KN of tensions within the feminist
movement which with psychoanalysis I
would position as the twin hence related
and perhaps Waring traumatic events of
massive political significance to The
Human Condition that took place in the
20th century both feminism and
psychoanalysis were ruptured and
reshaped by the 20th Century's major
events the enactments of genocidal
racism the invention of a fundamentally
dehumanizing political uh anti-politics
of
totalitarianism and the long and AG
ganizing struggle against colonialism
that produces decolonization and the
postcolonial what is feminism's relation
to debt to forgotten or forgotten
obligation to the memory and Trauma of
colonialism the concentration and the
genocidal was feminism an after effect
effect or after effect of this potential
destruction of humanity that must now
engage in impire Fidelity to its own
evolving projects with an an open and
critical mind towards its endless
virtuality yes I've got one sentence
left that remakes the legacies of the
imperfect but sharable past a basis for
continuous work in a direction that
these of these flawed but create that
these flawed but creative others began
to plot out hence I think we come
together to think once again about art
politics sex and feminism but these are
the questions of life and human life and
Democratic life that feminism is still
in the process of posing not yet with
answers but with your help and
continuation there may be some thank
[Applause]
you let just get rid of this they thanks
for all those wise words Gisela and uh
it's lovely to be here in the Red Room
the star our chamber at the Tate so
thanks to the talks organizers and to
Vero for organizing this and
republishing my book so to feminism and
the politics of pleasure which I talk
about in straight sex following on from
Griselda agonism challenge
contention start talking about sex today
and soon soon enough trouble looms and
looms large unless we stick to jokes or
gender cliche agreement is usually hard
to find and not just amongst
feminists though we certainly face very
special problems trying to tie the
protein complexity and intangible nature
of intimacy and desire to any sort of
feminist sexual politics this was never
just a mother daughter Affair though
it's often enough presented itself as
that we challenged and we fought with
each other all the time from day one
as straight lesbian black Jewish and any
number of other identities um came to
the for particularly with the success of
women's Liberation although it wasn't in
fact feminists but willham Reich who
first talked about sexual politics back
in the
1930s criticizing the repressiveness of
of Bourgeois sexual morality which
doubled a sexual
hypocrisy he talked about that while
watching the rise of fascism in Europe
and seeing he thought some ties between
the two his sex pole papers aimed to
free sexuality from the constraints of
religious moralism and compulsive
patriarchal monogamy while seeing this
as only achievable after the end of
capitalist exploitation with the coming
of
socialism times change and then again as
giselda said its traumas return turn for
certain massive sexual hypocrisy and
double standards if not fortunately then
too much Rising fascism helped
inaugurate women's Liberation at the
close of the
1960s at long last talk of sexual
Liberation not punitive moralism was
bubbling up everywhere especially around
women young women very young women often
suddenly apparently free to FL
our sexuality as never before though in
a rather peculiarly childlike and
frivolous way it
seemed I arrived in London in 1970 when
the optimistic hedonistic Oho resolutely
youthful oriented culture of swinging
London was still evident everywhere that
teenager Twiggy right well Twiggy there
she was looking just like a child in
adult drag displayed mouth open sucking
her thumb or riding her baby scooter had
been lead she'd been the leading fashion
icon for the previous four years in the
1960s though she was now retiring having
reached the grand old age of 20 thus if
to be young then was very Heaven it had
many pitfalls for women youth being so
very fleeting and women above all girls
needing to stay Forever Young keep young
and beautiful as Eddie Canto once cred
we'd soon know how much they meant it
for sure many of us young women then
were eager to partake of the new sexual
Freedom that came along with the
consumer oriented swinging 60s a time of
Full Employment increased wages imagine
all that and by the close of the decade
for some of us youthful Rebellion we
took to the streets or were more more
active between the sheets and were more
active Between the Sheets liberated or
partly so by the marketing of the oral
contraceptives pill having sex and
flating it rather than guiltily hiding
it was the single main way some young
women in the 1960s felt we were
rebelling against parental and middle
class Norms thus fashion entrepreneur
Mary Quant for instance proclaimed in
1969 making lots of money as she was now
that there is the pill women are the sex
in charge she's standing there defiantly
with her legs apart I'm very sexy she's
saying I feel provocative but you're
going to have a job to get me you've got
to be jolly marvelous to attract me of
course she had to be a teenager well I
think Quant was wrong about most women's
sexual confidence back then including
and perhaps especially teenagers
whatever our youth bber miniskirts or
parted legs for despite all the
flaunting of young women's sexuality the
1960s remained overall a
quintessentially male decade once out of
our teens it was the association of
woman with mother and domesticated
Conformity which the radical world I
entered as a young woman abhor I was
already 20 when I arrived here in London
the so-called angry young men the 60s
celebrated were all tough immoral
anarchic male Heroes like those in Alan
sililo Saturday night Sunday morning or
crazy Outsiders as in the film Morgan or
else ethereal love objects like Dylan's
Sade eyed ladies waiting at home for Bob
to return Street Fighting Man
workingclass Heroes were battling women
and any constraints of domestic IC
responsibility along with those other
authorities moreover those of us who
were part of the radical left in student
movements civil rights and anti-vietnam
activities especially at the end of the
1960s confronted an even more explicit
sexism in the underground press with its
Pinups and psychedelic porn which was
can be seen especially in the May 68
graffiti some of it now um
well you can see this one perhaps uh it
was something put out in May 68 um where
women very much Remain the prey of those
male sexual radicals some comrades from
the occupation are going to come and
[ __ ] me violently judging by their
practice that is the violent [ __ ]
presumably their theories must be truly
radical well this was the sort of
atmosphere then which would produce
women's Liberation um Sheila robotm
someone else whose work is um being
published in the radical thinkers series
by um Verso was the only woman on black
dwarf then and she summed up much of the
mood oh yes we've got it much of the
mood of the moment when um she wrote in
the essay in 1969 which was the first
women's issue which black dwarf had
contained she wasn't allowed to edit it
being a woman but um she was allowed to
write a lot for it and um for once she
said the predictions of uh this magazine
came true 1969 really was the year of
the radical woman and as she wrote there
men you have nothing to lose men have
nothing to lose but their chains I won't
read it all out but she's saying you'll
no longer have to um uh creep around
sniggering at women but you'll be able
to have more open and loving and and
free relationships with women that I'm
saying was the mood that was present in
that first surge of women's Liberation
at the close of the 1960s and the first
women's groups be began meeting just
then in Britain in
1969 and women were very much wanting to
talk about sexuality but in all the ways
missing from what was present in the
underground pre underground press what
was there in men's sniggering talk what
they wanted to talk about was the pain
and anxiety still there over our
fertility and right to choose to have or
not to have children in our dislikes of
the pinup saturating the alternative
press in men's fears of women's growing
Independence and particularly our sexual
autonomy and of course in problems
around child care this was the mood that
produced the first commercially
successful British feminist magazine
spare rib in
1972 it was both a product of the
counterculture against as well as a
reaction against it as Marsha r one of
its first editors uh would later
write so as I concluded describing this
moment at the close of the 60s um in my
um opening chapter in straight sex I say
saying yes to sex was still seen as a
part of our Liberation but it had to be
a feminist or liberated type of
sexuality with or without a man thus
women of my generation moved on from
seeing sex as Liberation to seeking
liberated sex so then I had some
pictures of us what all right there that
was the first women's Liberation March I
attended okay
liberated sex there's the difficulty how
on Earth really were we going to talk
about that were we going to find
that it seemed to grow harder not easier
as the years passed women's Liberation
began conf
enough think clitorus was how the
well-known American feminist Alex Kate
Schulman summed up feminist thinking on
sexuality in
1971 it's again and I noted in my second
chapter the liberated orgasm in her
popular book burning questions of 1978
Shan had one young feminist mentioned
the three
non-negotiable conditions for good sex
plenty of dope three hours minimum and
Cony
Lingus so that was her notion of
liberated sex moreover despite the
fearful impediment she herself has faced
Schuman remained largely optimistic and
po positive about her loving
relationships with men ever since
despite her late husband um um getting
early onset dementia and this even
though she would later right of
attending a feminist meeting at the
close of the
1970s where all agreed that sex had
changed for them often for the better
more orgasms for instance um but
nevertheless yes they were often unhappy
in
love so feminists 40 years ago were also
especially skeptical about the idea of
True
Romance seeing it as wedded literally to
men's power in those patriarchal nuclear
families we've been trying to escape
from many of us were searching for
Alternatives however for many feminists
that first flush of feminist confidence
in building a new world closer to our
heart's desire whether in the office the
kitchen or the bedroom was stifled by
many things but especially by Rising
awareness of the prevalence of men's
violence against and sexual Co coercion
of women it was also weakened when we
observed the abiding resilience of the
fellow Centric or male cented nature of
almost all our images and iconography of
sex even once we'd got rid of the
blatant Pinups in left
Publications and it was hard to think
outside of these traditional framings
however much we urgently tried to
rethink and refashion them and introduce
new words and then again any simple
feminist search for Independence parity
and control in our relationships with
men came up against something else which
is the inescapable contrarian of sexual
passion like it or not and we didn't
some level of confusion and contention
was quite inevitable if straight women
were to Wade our way through the Sea of
sexual contradictions we seem to face it
would lead at least some feminists
especially here in the UK to turn to
psychoanalysis in the footsteps of
Juliet Mitchell as we began to explore
sexuality
as a crucible of contradictions and
misunderstandings especially between men
and women I joined that Trend Juliet
Mitchell whose first feminist text is
also being reissued in this series this
Verso series expressed some of this when
she was interviewed by spare rib in the
early 1980s discussing the study group
she attended addressing sexuality and
sexual difference a sort of of panic
starts in the mind she said we found
when we go to talk about it we just
don't know what sexuality is
anymore how difficult is this how
difficult it is if we're not sure
anymore quite how to talk about
sexuality and our own desires When The
World At Large likes to pretend it knows
all too much about what sex is who
should practice it and
how this is all the more crudely evident
in the ever expanding sexual Marketplace
in the commodification of sexuality and
bodies and media Fashions and fix and
fixations targeting precisely sexual
fears and
longings moreover things didn't get
easier for us as the conflicts within
feminism heightened during the so-called
Sex Wars of the
1980s great thank you leading feminist
figures fought over the very meaning of
feminism some wanting to place
heterosexuality at the core of feminist
politics reducing men's power overall to
male sexuality and then reducing male
sexuality to violence thus Katherine
McKinnon like her fellow American
anti-pornography campaigner Andrea Doran
insisted that there was no way even to
imagine
any passionate Harmony between women and
men in the current terms of
intimacy what looks like love and
romance in the liberal view Katherine
McKinnon wrote looks a lot like hatred
and torture in the feminist
view given the still prevailing
iconography of straight sex some found
their views
persuasive and although proposed by a
minority of revolutionary feminists
Rouse over the Primacy to be given given
to men's violence against women as the
not a but the overriding cause of
women's subordination was what dealt the
death nail to any future annual
Gatherings of women's Liberation in
leads in
1977 giving up [ __ ] for a woman is
about taking your politics seriously
they
argued many of us disagreed but we did
stop talking about sexual pleasure if we
were straight women
and it's certainly true that obler
climate was beginning to undermine all
forms of radical politics in the 1980s
under Margaret Thatcher both feminism
and the left there were also these were
also the years when HIV and AIDS began
to return fear and danger to sexual
Arenas especially for gay men and also
when the serial sex murder murderer
Peter suck Cliffe was roaming the
streets in and around Leeds for over a
decade he murdered women on the streets
and the police were completely unable to
find him despite many people pointing
directly to him but he didn't fit the
police's police's notion of who was a
murderer because he was a married man
and looked rather like them thus as the
sex Wars raged during the
1980s it seemed um too dangerous even to
discuss the ways in which sexuality
itself both women's and men's were often
steeped in fantasies involving the
eroticization of power and submission
instead and importantly feminist
research focused on issues of safety
especially for young women which I um
report in that feminist research on
sexuality that comes from a book edited
by um Janet Holland called the man in
the head saying that young women don't
easily have a language around to talk
about sex that helps them in their
relationships with men as well book
after book was published on the cultural
scaffolding of rape the extent of rape
and the way in which coerciveness seems
to be tied in some way to normative
Notions of masculinity assertiveness men
being um being forced by their uh huge
sexual desires into um um needing to
assert themselves in um sexual relations
with with
women meanwhile though while this very
negative um Trend what or pesimistic
trend on uh paying attention to rape and
violence and the difficulties of
transforming the language of sexuality
seem to be totally surrounding the
heterosexual world talk of desire and
pleasure
reappeared but it reappeared somewhere
else with the
renew renewed surge of confidence in
defiant dissident sexuality in gay and
lesbian writing from the
1990s the Vigor and joy so I could have
another um slide now the Vigor and joys
of queer Theory raced in onto academic
platforms throughout the 19
90s aligned at least for a while with
the noisy protests of act up and other
activist campaigns demanding government
action around HIV and AIDS I can
remember when the only big
demonstrations we went on in the 1990s
seemed to be all around and importantly
around HIV and AIDS and all the writing
on sex was being written in particular
by gay men and also by some so-called
sex positive lesbians this time citing
the words of Judith Butler Eve Sedrick
Leo bani and others queer Scholars and
activists could draw upon the lifelong
legacies of Freud's polymorphously
bisexual infant ignoring all the ways or
rejecting rather all the ways in which
psychoanalysis had been used normatively
um by certain psychoanalytic
writers and this use of Freud was added
to Michelle fuko's questioning of there
being any stable or unitary notion of
sexuality at all whatever our gender or
sexual
orientation pleasure has no passport no
identity card Fuko said hoping to detach
the body and its Pleasures from our
understandings of gender and anatomical
difference um that was um slide 13 I
don't know if that was um oh yes we're
not quite up to that yet but we're
getting close to it it's drawing upon
both was drawing upon both
psychoanalytic theory and critical
theory that I dared in straight sex to
return again to all those questions we
had raised in the first passionate years
of women's Liberation to Hope again to
develop a positive sexual politics that
could include women all women St and
lesbian as well as gay men and any other
forms of sexual
dissidence given all we know about the
easily shaken yet solid P centrism of
the symbolic order all we know about the
androcentrism of discourse around
sexuality and
subjectivity given what we had learned
about the problematic ways of men
determined to Shore up their
entitlements to the insecure mantle of
masculinity how was it going to be
possible I ask in straight sex to
develop loving pleasurable and
responsible sexual relationships um
around heterosexuality or indeed any
form of
sexuality well one begins of course by
questioning not by affirming as I saw
McKinnon and dwen and certain um radical
feminists as doing by questioning rather
than affirming all the traditional
assumptions around gender and around the
Absurd active passive divide that
constructs what Judith Butler called the
heterosexual
Matrix it is desire
itself it is desire itself which
threatens um to render any one of us
helpless whether man or woman um however
fragile or secure our hold on power
elsewhere and whatever our gender or
sexual
orientation indeed what happens in
actual consensual sex I suggest in
straight sex looking at fiction looking
at poetry looking indeed at at at
clinical accounts of just all that we
can find about the actual nature of
sexual interactions what we find is that
they don't collapse down into that
binary of male female active passive
everything fitting together in that
normative
way in love relations in sexual
relationships of any uh long imp
passionate sexual relationships we are
all vulnerable as Judith Butler said
says in undoing gender addressing the
Perils of Desire yes we're up to the
Perils of Desire let's face it we're all
undone by each
other and if we're not we're missing
something if we're not it's not such an
exciting and passionate thing after all
if we don't feel endangered by the
potential loss of um the person we
desire if this seems so clearly the case
with grief it is only because it was
already the case with desire okay I am
finishing in two minutes in an earlier
brief meditation on the risks of Love
She suggests love is not a state a
feeling a
disposition but an exchange uneven
fraught with history with ghosts with
longings that are more or less legible
to those who try to see one another with
their own faulty vision and that's what
I feel I pick up when I read anything
that actually turns me on around desire
or sexuality for sure we all need to
face up to the strange unruliness of
Desire surely for instance it's not only
sex workers who know that that what men
want as often as not is to be sexually
passive of course what men do not want
is for women and even less for other men
to know this that's the sort of thing I
write a lot about in straight sex
knowing this however is one thing and
confronting violence in the World At
Large a significant part of it but only
a part of it men's abuse and sexual
coercion of women is another thing I
don't ever want to ignore the latter
just as like Joan Nestle I don't ever
want want to forget the former it is
possible to play with power in fantasy
in erotic
relationships although that was once uh
forbidden to us it is possible um and
that does not need to interfere with our
ways of fighting the systemic violence
in human institutions and Human
Relationships so evident everywhere near
and
far indeed the letter is such hard work
sometimes we need some escape from it in
perhaps our incorrect uh
fantasies and if we don't have some idea
of the difference between the psychic
life of desire and the routine endemic
social violence all around us will not
really know much about either about
either sexuality or about violence
that's what I point out in straight sex
thank
[Applause]
you um a couple of things hi I'm Sonia
by the way um many apologies for running
late not being able to introduce
properly
um so when I was when I was asked to um
whether I might consider chairing this
session um it was one of three or four
requests that I was getting in the same
week about feminism about desire um
about radical thinking and it made me
wonder what's going
on why now what what is it that why why
is this question being kind of thought
through now
um so I wanted to start to for us to
kind of think about that and then the
other thing that um occurred to me when
specifically with with with this with
this talk um uh and discussion a
question of heterosexual sex and I
frowned and thought Oh
no why would we be doing
that um and I it set up all sorts of
questions for me thinking about how the
debates why why is it so difficult to
talk about heterosexual sex as a
feminist um and I I I think we should
really maybe talk about some of those
things
um
history with both of with both of your
talks the question of History looms very
large and I was very taken Gisela with
this question about Fidelity and loyalty
and faithfulness to the Past in some way
and wonder what does that mean for us
now you know you talk about almost
almost like the past as an archive in
which we can project into the future and
I kind of wonder what what future you
you you can see
there is that a good start do you think
you start I start oh why now you know
there's been
a really interesting Resurgence of
feminism for about 10 years for instance
in London in 2004 so exactly 10 years
the radical feem the feminists in London
the feminists in London started to meet
and why I made that slip of radical
feminism actually was because Finn McKai
who's just written a book on radical
feminism was a key voice in that and a
key mover and Shaker in getting that
going and the main thing she wanted to
revive and did revive successfully and
importantly was um the Take Back the
Night marches and that had been very
controversial within um uh late 70s '
80s feminism for many different reasons
but you know what we have seen is a huge
I don't know if it's an upur an upsurge
but what we see is more violence
everywhere with more war um more ethnic
conflict and and inevitably accompanying
that uh more violence against women more
Violence by men against men obviously as
well but more violence against women so
you know we've all become aware once
more if we ever forgot of the extent of
rape and sexual violence and uh so I
think that's one reason to be asking all
these questions and also one reason I
hope um that as I ended we're still
going to be able to try and separate
talk about without desire and the
possibility for loving relations between
people of whatever nature from what we
need to confront which is violence on
our doorstep and further a field so I I
think that um the issue is very much
there in the air and so are all the old
conflicts around the issue which is why
for me we need to talk about straight
sex still and
importantly I'd like to take that up but
in a slightly different direction I
agree with a lot of what what Lynn is
saying and I think it's a absolutely
spot-on question my sense of it and why
I was s of formulating it in the way
that I was formulating it
is sort of two sides of it one is that
it's as if it's not that people are
going back to feminism but in some sense
it becomes a different kind of resource
because I think what women of the
generation of the time today are meeting
is a different configuration of some of
those similar issues so it's not a
continuity there's something else um and
I find the conversations that I have
particularly with young artists and
Young art historians and students sort
of trying to thinking about it at the
form of Education that I encounter which
is that we we kind of Dodge around
things because I'm sort of aware that
the nature of the sexuality the nature
of the bodies the predominant
hairlessness of women you know the whole
uh these kind of shifts um you know
difficult to have that conversation in
one sense you know could just tell me
what's going on here but it does seem to
me that the questions are um a new
configuration of issues around desire
agency safety and the question of men
and women um that draw back to the
archive is what you're sort of
suggesting does this offer us something
and yet the same time I think the
situation is extremely different I think
the issue of the Contemporary media I
think the issue precisely because of
media and pornography that the kinds of
issues against which we protest when you
show the images were
mild right I mean I think in sense some
of the things obviously were more than
that but I mean
certainly you didn't have the level of a
pornographic representation of sexuality
as normal right you you would go and
hunt it out you might you know by some
copies of Penthouse and sort of show
pictures to your students Etc but that
was about as far as not until Andrea
walked ding you know began to publish
some of the you know still relatively M
hardcore
hardcore um porn and that you know issue
I can't read her because she seems so
into it or like well exactly but that's
so that's my feeling which is why now I
think it's not it's come back but I
think a reconfiguration of some of the
challenges are faced
and this is why I'm so stressing how
would you build the conversation between
the historical moment that led to one
articulation of the debate about women
safety and sexuality and
now so I actually I kept writing the
word safe and what what is safe and what
is
unsafe um what is it what is it that we
don't feel we're able to say or able to
do or able to visualize I one of the
things I was really very curious about
is what kinds of imagery you would both
use for your talks and I wonder to what
extent um the question of desire and
visuality for
women is a topic now is a dis is a point
of discussion now in a way that I'm
thinking back to the 80s where there was
a lot of refusal it's like you you're
either you're either in one camp or
you're in another Camp someone like dwar
in for instance um and what is it
possible to visualize now is what I I
was kind of what's safe and what's
unsafe now and I'm talking about beyond
the 9s moment of the bad girl you know
we saw a lot of exhibitions in the '90s
of bad girls and it's like well actually
is is there no other space But the good
and the bad or the safe and the unsafe I
think it comes to um I I think it's a
very good question and you know there is
one line that women particularly young
women are worse s today because it's
thought there's more sexism in the media
um women's bodies are sexualized even
younger and I've often found when
talking to audiences particularly older
women raise this a lot not so much young
women actually unless they're the
feminists I recognize but older women
rais this about you know how actually
usually criticizing young women you know
how they're all displaying their bodies
and wearing high heels and you know
exposing all their flesh and uh
so I have thought very much about the
question where the young women are
actually worse off today and I
absolutely don't think they are first of
all because we have such a language of
safe and responsible sexuality that came
out of the 1980s and 1990s and
discussions around um HIV and AIDS
because surely in sex education today
people are talking about safe
responsible sexual engagement at least I
hope they are not in the US where they
deny uh won't allow any sex education
but in our schools I hope and I think
because sometimes I'm asked along there
there is more talk about that and
so you know that you can't generalize at
all about what the situation would be
for young women if we're talking about
young women but I do um you're not just
talking about young women I'm talking
about now so that's all of us that are
in I think we have a larger language net
to draw upon in trying to discuss it
more openly that's the main thing I'd
say although of course everyday routine
sexism is everywhere but we have these
words we know what sexism is we can at
least discuss
it but I think I think your question
Sonia is really interesting about
Absolut the image and the thing is I
think this for me is there's a
difference between what is what we're
trying to talk about in terms of sex
sexualization when we talk about um
girls and young women and you know the
whole kind of media over sexualizing but
we we're not specifying what concept of
sexuality that represents compared to
what it seems to me the feminist
discourse was actually to say what is it
what would happen if we actually tried
to rethink sexuality from a point of
view in which is not kind of compulsory
heterosexuality for the reproduction of
species you know we've got the wonderful
article by Gail Rubin which you know
argues that the actual repression of
women's sexuality is Central to
constructing the notion of men and women
and the sort of you know the family is
the central prise because you have to
effectively take the sexual agency away
from one part of the sort of sexualized
human condition and say you don't have
the right to choose your part partners
and so so one sense if you go back to
your things the historic trauma of of
the women's movement made possible
because of the contraceptive pill was to
say okay what is women's sexual agency
outside of the notion of the vamp who
always gets killed off or disfigured or
has to be you know married off you know
movies how many movies do you watch you
does an attempted it and then you're
either dead or married as a solution to
the the thing so what is it and of
course we haven't really thought about
this question about you know uh the
whole kind of related to the question of
uh people claiming right to sexual
agency outside of the framework of being
sexualized I.E you know disabled people
who are rep not represented in the
classic Concepts or older people or you
know all sorts of elements of that so it
seems to me that we actually haven't got
very far with a certain thing we've been
sort of brought back and trapped
in a certain kind of image and I think
your your point about how what would be
the images of it so I mean there's a
certain amount of debate in kind of
feminist art and film Theory which would
be something like you know that actually
this um you know lifting your skirts and
saying you know I'm sexual because I'm
showing you my body is actually not a
signifier of of you know women's
sexuality that it might be displaced
into um Rhythm and time and duration and
different ways of signifying it and
that's a certain amount of artistic
exploration
around how you would convey an you know
kind of a feminine
erotics that isn't then either straight
or or queer but is what is it to be a
sexual
agent rather than to be caught in saying
I'm sexually attracted to X or I do y
you know what what is a sexual being in
in in the feminine I and I think that's
still an
open question can I make one small point
though well When We Were Young neither
feminists nor anyone else Ever Raised
the question of sexuality in relation to
disability or what we now call slow
Learners we know what they used to call
them or um or older women we just didn't
we assume that it disappeared you know
and that is being raised you know by
artists in films in writing like my last
book um uh out of time and so again you
I'd say we have more language to discuss
it we have more images to look at even
though of course you know we've got
everywhere to go we've got so far to go
but I I see starts that Beginnings that
make me feel more optimistic that we can
continue the
discussion that's still it's always just
beginning as I say you know where sex is
there trouble looms and and so we just
have to keep working at it I think and
not close it down that's
all I think that might be a good moment
in which to kind of open up the
discussion and see oh straight away can
we get
a
microphone here in the one two three
four hi um thanks for the really
interesting provocations um one thing
that I'm really fascinated by as well is
this um notion of the trans
transgenerational conversations and also
um the ways in which these kinds of
discourses are rearticulated over time
and one thing that I've I've not yet
quite um found out for myself is why
particularly um feminists emerging in
the
1970s um why for them uh why
psychoanalysis because I think that's
something that's changing over time and
it's not something that um I use for
example and um I think it's it's
something that you see less in in in
women emerging post 70s and 80s
particularly so why
psychoanalysis
you taking it separate questions do you
want to answer that
first um I'm quite happy to answer that
I mean um in in a book I edited called
psychoanalysis psychoanalysis and the
image um transition feminist
perspectives um exactly that question
why and I mean there's there's a range
of answers offered to people right I
mean but this in one sense is as I was
trying to suggest I I twin it with with
feminism and since it's a particular
kind of major event of the 20th century
that asks a certain question it's the
discourse in which you can pose
questions in which the object is
subjectivity fantasy desire right you're
not going to find that in Marx you're
not going to find that in durkheim in a
certain sense that's that's the The
crucial thing um certainly as far as the
question of the visual in the image it's
also one of the most powerful discourses
because it poses the question of why we
look what we look for what is the sort
of the the eroticization of the field of
vision as well as the sort of the
anguish of our sense that we're looking
for something in art so I mean it has a
huge implication for what why we even
look and what we're looking for and what
the image does for us so I mean I think
those are just two simple bases that I I
see is you know impossible to proceed
without but it's not exclusive I think
that you're absolutely right to raise it
as a generational issue actually and
there's so much more to say about uh
transgenerational conversation and it's
so wonderful to see people of different
ages here listening to us old ladies uh
just older thinkers and um what I have a
character category you know when we
wanted to complicate our thinking about
sexuality because in the very beginning
women feminists were still reading
Masters and Johnson and that's where we
got Notions of the liberated orgasm and
you know you just had to as I said have
uh you know basically more foreplay and
so on and more canalingus and everything
would be all right you know you had to
get the techniques right and we knew
that just really wasn't enough we might
be having more sex and even having more
orgasms but we were still unhappy in
love uh and you know before fuku was
around and before we were reading
critical theory we were aware of
psychoanalysis and some of the
complexities that Freud brought in and
in particular I mean Juliet Mitchell
from the 60s you know was absolutely
reading Freud putting it out there her
book psychoanalysis and feminism
published in 1974 you know is
introducing us if we hadn't already been
introduced to Freud some of us like me
had been aware of Reich and so on you
know psychoanalysis was in the air both
to be attacked by feminists uh and also
as a possible resource and that's always
been so actually feminism and Freud have
always been somewhere on each other's
minds you know Juliet Mitchell says when
she went to the states people were
throwing darts at um boards with Freud's
head on them uh but meanwhile you know
other people like her were using Freud
Emma Goldman was the same Emma Goldman
back in the 20s when Freud went to the
US 20s maybe the T 10 sorry um said you
know a genius is giant has come to talk
to us you know whereas others thought
that he was diverting the struggle away
from uh women's needs so women's needs
for emancipation so there was always
that tension now I think you're right
that by the '90s and particularly with
Fuko and qu and understanding about that
a lot of people felt that they could get
enough question
of sexuality and and and its
complexities um and and confusions and
contradictions from Fuko but those of us
who had been uh earlier reading Freud
felt no there's something more around
the affect tied to our thoughts here
that take us back to psychoanalysis but
I think there is a slight generational
you know it's fashions in Academia
fashions in Academia as well and and
critical theory did tend partially to
sweep over uh psycho analysis although
people like Judith Butler particularly
via people like Lech you know not to
mention Gisela and others even I try to
try and bring them together you know try
to bring together critical theory and
psychoanalysis but I'd say that the
fashion did swing more away from
psychoanalysis knowing how normative its
uses have often been at the same time
you know as other people like Jonathan
dollmore unlike alen sinfield thinking
that you know there were uses good uses
you could make of psycho analysis so you
know it's for you all to think about
that
further thank you so much I learned so
much from your
presentations um can you put it close to
your mouth Yes I I don't think I can't
think of um a discourse that would take
us to an understanding of for example
the perverse
enjoyment
foreclosed in the violence that's done
in the name of ideals other than through
a
psychoanalysis for instance you know
that the violence that remains invariant
historically and geographically whether
it's against women or humans against
humans or subjects against subjects is
mostly done in the name of
ideals and the Horizon of that the most
extreme ethical Horizon has to be
thought perhaps in relation to a kind of
perverse unconscious
enjoyment at the same time that one's
apparently following ideals and I can't
see how one can come to an understanding
of what I've just said without
psychoanalysis for instance and I think
that has insisted say for instance in
the work of say slav
isek you know I think that is something
that he's continued to really work
on um that's the one question and then
if I can if you don't mind me sort of
coming in with something else um
recently I went to an extraordinary
debate um where two position papers were
given by the by Katherine Malibu I've
actually we've talked about this in the
last week Alan uh Katherine Malibu
talking from a position of cognitive and
um um cognitive and
neurological epen gen
epigenesis um arguing that the subject
is being profoundly
deconstructed and that psychoanalysis is
completely Obsolete and then
psychoanalysts arguing even those that
acknowledge the importance of the new
work in cognitive and neurological
Sciences acknowledge that really the
unconsciousness is and in a process of a
demise the unconsciousness we know it is
is no longer the same and they're new
bodies and new
symptoms and we have to rethink think
everything in relation to all the work
that's going on with the human posthuman
non-human kind of question in relation
to the anthropos scene and the future so
I just wonder whether you you know this
seems in terms of this transgenerational
conversation this seems to be a point of
a contemporary point that I think is
quite important and I wonder what your
take on this might
be can I can I say something to I
mean when I said you know what is the a
want there was a kind of no reaction in
the audience and I was absolutely
perplexed I thought they're going to get
that you still don't get it do you you
said all looking at me like this as if
I'm talking you know but I mean it's you
know it's the classic frauding question
what what does a woman want what do you
want and the central question that psych
analysis poses is to say wait a minute
you know relating to your question of
ideas what what is driving you okay what
is this other Dimension that's driving
you and whether or not psych analysis is
proven to be um displaceable by some
kind of you know neurological chemical
explanation which I don't think it is
the question is the one we have to ask
because it's the question that
ultimately becomes ethical and political
now Freud was a neuroscientist and he
always assumed because there isn't a God
and there isn't some kind of weird thing
you know
there's a little man in the head sort of
operating the unconscious it's got to be
explicable right it has to be something
that has a material neurological basis
all of what is just going on here but
one of the effects of the neurological
app activity is the nature of the
thought and this possibility of being
divided against yourself and asking
thought now at no level can we get rid
of the question of an unconscious either
individually which because it's the
ethical question what do I want what am
I not seeing what can't I hear what am I
failing in the sort of P projection of
myself not to recognize with with the
other and also in one sense it's the
political unconscious right there's no
evidence that I can see that we cannot
we can do without the notion of being
endlessly
Vigilant about what is really happening
that we are not in control of that is
maintained
you know structures of racism structures
of sexism you structures of VI you know
certain kinds of violence they happen
all the time
structurally and that's one of the the
legacies of the psychon analytical mode
of inquiry so I ask all the
posthumanists and the humanists and the
people who want to kind of dissolve the
subject what do you want why why is this
happening to us now now it may be that
they're really the hottest [ __ ] in town
and I'm just an old you know you know
dinosaur worrying away about things that
belong in the 20th century but the kind
of question that I can pose from that
moment of the 20th century is what are
we rushing headlong into why is academic
life and cultural life so fashion
conscious that we think well this is
over let's have something new we are a
bit humanist now we'll be a bit
posthuman what what's at stake here
right I'm happy with people loving their
dogs
absolutely Keen with species being an
all rest of Etc but in a world in which
we have not been able to secure the
safety you know of the millions of
people on this Earth from physical IM
miseration from psychological IM
miseration from the continuing
obscenity of the state that we live in
in relation to the majority of people on
this planet please could we just hang on
to this question about who is doing what
and why with some terms so I see for me
psych analysis is entirely part of the
problem of the political because we
cannot um you know indulge ourselves in
that um you know pursuit of something
that of pleasure whatever it's such a
which doesn't hold on to this ethical
question
about both what we said the sort of the
violence and that's why I was putting
such a stress on the question of how do
we produce a democratic
subjectivity right we can't get
ourselves to
want to desire the well-being of our
whether it's the dogs or but I'm
particularly interested in the human
beings Etc I do see this whole drive to
somehow make us think about neurological
stuff and dissolve the human ethical
political subject as an extremely
problematic Direction even though the
science may be right and even though it
might be extremely interesting for we
could get insight and Freud would always
be with you let's understand how the
mind works I mean when he wrote The
Theory of sexuality in 1905 he said I
know they'll find something which
explains the the the switch and five
months after he published the theory of
sexuality the first lecture was given
when they identified hormones which are
the
chemical Messengers right he always knew
the science would explain it but not
what it means at the level of
human you know agency subjectivity and
that's I think the still the tension for
me which is again posed deeply by
feminism I don't think we're all
academics in the audience so it might be
nice to hear from some who aren't but I
mean it's absolutely true that as
academics we're always in danger of
being caught in yesterday's Fashions and
um you know hobbling around in the wrong
theoretical attire um what I find
interesting is at present even in
Katherine Malibu and other people the
idea seems to be and was certainly
present in Freud that one day neurology
the brain would have the answers to our
questions I think exactly the opposite I
don't think that psychoanalysis so much
needs to rely upon what's coming out of
Neurology I think that whatever is
coming out of Neurology will remain
absolutely meaningless BL without a
language to talk about affect and
emotion which comes of course not just
from psychoanalysis it only comes from
psychoanalysis in so far as it's there
in the case studies and so on it comes
from literature it comes from you know
how on Earth we can find a language Rich
enough to embrace confusion and
contradiction and so on and so of course
J's writing on the perverse enjoyment of
pleasure and relating it to um um you
know the appalling violence in the world
today is very important but I mean of
course you couldn't get anywhere near
that could you from neurology or
anything like that or brain science you
know you you have to keep enriching your
language in thinking about how to
embrace complexity contradiction
confusion how to assert opposing things
at once and so on that's all I'll say
for
now
I'm aware that it's now 8:00 oh but
we've got one we've got a round up of
questions yes maybe we can have or
comments or comments I have an answer I
want to answer one of the questions you
put but I'll waitting to see if we have
any others do we have any other
questions comments there's one at the
back there oh
great always front back front back is
it racing around hello thank um thank
you very much for the the opportunity to
ask a question or um to actually put
forward a a statement um I heard you the
ladies um earlier on talking about how
the kind of reemergence of uh the
thought around feminism and and art sex
and politics and um Talk a bit more
slowly and loudly I'm finding hard sorry
sorry it's probably also an accent thing
um surely uh one of the one of the kind
of principal reasons why uh there's kind
of reemergence of thought around
feminism kind of um is the is the
internet and the and the access to um
thinking and uh and and and writers out
there I know certainly when I was doing
my art degree many many years ago um I
only really had access to certain
writers and and libraries and and women
who were actually writing about feminism
and sexuality whereas these days um you
only need to go on Twitter and in one
day you can massively educate yourself
on um all of the thinkers that are out
there both currently and in the past um
I just wanted to ask what um your
thoughts were on um kind of
intersectional thinking and um kind of
how that is relates to feminism and
certainly um sex and and politics and
art want me okay um yes you know I'm not
quite as convinced by everybody else
about the power of the internet partly
because we use it too we have all our
blogs and there's loads of feminist
blogs out there of course we're not
mainstream in the same way the media
doesn't take up what we say but we do
use it and I think about the everyday
scorn and jokes and everything about
women from my childhood you know my
father was a doctor and when a woman
gave birth to a girl he'd say better
luck next time he thought that was a
terrific joke and I mean there were
jokes everywhere on you know um jokes
and songs you know I about killing your
wife and then you marry your next one
and long for the old one again I mean
there's you know m ory can be easily
expressed in many forms and so I think
that we can be actually um overwhelmed
by the sexism of the visual and forget
you know the impact of just everyday
hideous misogyny just in jokes and
discussion that was one thing but about
the intersection I was worrying of
course thinking I should talk about race
and class and it's so hard to do that in
relation to sexuality I mean so hard
because it's complicated enough to talk
about it all but to talk about the ways
in which working class bodies black
bodies have always been sexualized in
the most demeaning of ways you know and
to say we can't possibly have an
emancipatory language of sex without
taking on board you know the continuing
effects of racism and the and but the
complexities of racism the way in which
you know the um perverse Jewish body the
swali is different from um the um
primitive manual me menial body which
the um African body was seen as you know
all this has to be tackled um as well as
you know workingclass women as as as um
who had to uh engage in uh
prostitution um maybe some of them chose
to but I would say on the whole they
have to um you know their bodies were
you know they could be basically
murdered with impunity still in the
1980s when Peter Su Cliffe was murdering
women on the stre streets the police
said he's made a mistake you know he's
murdered an innocent woman he didn't
murder a prostitute he murdered a woman
who wasn't a prostitute so you know that
all every possible hierarchy intersects
with the demeaning and degrading
language of sex so that absolutely all
has to be in there can I can I can I
also make a plea then for you know CU
one of the things that I I I I kept
thinking about in both of your talks is
yes we live with the structures of those
things but we also try to
maneuver through
around bypass and for me some of the
some of the radicalism of how you
negotiate those structures we also have
to talk about and and speak of what
strategies might we be employing I think
there wasn't you know from in terms of
my own involvement in in in feminist and
black debates was what other images can
we possibly find what other images
without there being a kind of regime the
problem is we probably won't agree of
course and some people will see this as
an empowering image say of a black woman
or a working class woman other people
say no that's a demeaning image
but that but but that we can fight over
the possibility of what something can be
absolutely yes not just how we live
within a structure but how we move
beyond that structure and I you know and
that's what I would like to make a plea
for here and that's what I feel the
question of the radical and the
political is about trying to find
another route through which to express
something that we don't feel is being
expressed I'd like to underline that
because I I just think I mean the
central point of the first book that
Rosie Parker and I wrote when we tried
to think about which which was to say
artists who are women negotiate their
situation and they produce as much
because of as despite their differential
position so it's not to say that they
were oppressed and now they're free but
everybody negotiates and the negotiation
is the complexity of artists thinking
working with materials working with
situation
and that's not predictable you have to
read each instance and you have to allow
it and I think that's the point when you
were saying what what's my sense of the
future it's that um I'm I'm you know
arguing this notion of and you know not
feminism as a past that's coming back
but that feminism is a virtuality that's
to say some element of what it promises
or potentially we can even imagine gets
realized at certain points out of
certain historical situations and people
do certain things with it and then but
that doesn't exhaust it so it's not to
be confined to what it was it's possibly
that that was just one way that it got
actualized under the pressures of both
as you the 60s and 7 and therefore there
was a kind of debate at that point which
produced this notion of what would be a
good image and a bad image and I know I
participated by that and I'm you know
times um you know not appalled or
ashamed sense but it's typical because
you know when I started writing ather
was nothing you know I was just a
graduate student you know and we just
thought we could say what we liked right
we said we said all sorts of things and
now it says you grisela Pollock said and
I said well you know I was like 23 or 24
and there was nothing you know there
were no references we just made these
you know big statements and then you
come back and you say okay no no it's
not quite right like this it's got to be
more complicated and you know people
bashed us and argued and said you've
missed out things Etc and that's what
I'm trying to get hold of this the
dynamic that comes from a sense that
there's much more to this than we have
encountered but also that where art
comes into it is different from the way
that the sort of political Phil because
there's a negotiation
around between the
imaginable and the D and the doable and
what's denounced but also what's created
and that requ requires acute attention
to what is brought into the world as our
actualizes new
virtualities uh and they're not just
instrumental in that and that's where
the sort of the
shock you know that comes from artists
suddenly making something visible for us
or picking up something so I I do think
the the negotiation and it's
not you know it's not just an either or
this is a good but so what images we
produce and you go back and you keep
rereading them you know and you say oh
my goodness now I see this is an
infinitely more powerful image I was
unable to see you know with that and I
think that's partly this constantly
suggesting that it's it's a future in
the making by a certain Act of fidelity
but also a deep criticality and that's
why I think this one F thing about this
intersectionality I think we do an
injustice to ourselves by continuing to
talk talk about race class gender I
think it closes our thinking to the
complexity of all of that and I don't
think they're all of the same
order I mean I I certainly don't because
certain questions raised by feminism
just keep slicing through every other
ones of them in ways that need to be
configured
precisely how we live it so if you just
have races to do with race and genders
to do with G in class nobody lives those
they they live them in their complex
textures and I think artistic activities
allow us to get that sense of the
density in a a certain person saying
this is how I see it from a situated
world I think at that point no more
thank you so much for your for coming
thank you for your
poers
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.