Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Hi, my name is Shai Cherry, and I'm presenting
the introduction to Judaism course for the teaching company.
An introduction to Judaism is not as easy as it sounds
because Judaism itself is more than just a religion.
Judaism incorporates in ethnicity, a culture, a lifestyle.
Some people talk about Judaism as a civilization.
What we're going to be doing in this course is looking
at the specific religious aspects of Judaism as they have changed
and unfolded over a 3000 year period
from the Hebrew Bible or Torah to today.
But we can't totally ignore the historical changes
that serve as the backdrop for some of these political,
theological and religious changes that also track on
to the way that Judaism has unfolded through time.
The Hebrew Bible is Judaism's Foundation text,
but knowing the Hebrew Bible will tell you surprisingly little
about how Judaism is expressed in the modern period.
So we'll begin our course by taking a look at the relationship
between the Hebrew Bible, the Torah, the Old Testament and contemporary
Judaism, what the relationship is between those terms and modern Judaism
will then begin to describe the early varieties of Judaism.
And by early I mean about the time of Jesus about 2000 years ago.
Although Jewish history is not one long
tale of travails, there have been several catastrophes
that powerfully shaped the Jewish consciousness.
So in the second lecture, we'll talk about the history as presented
in the Hebrew Bible from the destruction of the first temple in 586
to the destruction
of the second Temple by the Romans in the year 70 of the Common Era.
That 586 was before the common era.
And we'll talk about why we're not using B.C in AD.
Also, at that point,
in the
wake of the destruction of the second Temple by the Romans,
there were several groups that had been competing for power
for hegemony within that Jewish community.
And the winner was rabbinic Judaism.
So in general, for the rest of this class, for the rest of the course
where I talk about Judaism, I'm really talking about rabbinic Judaism,
unless I specify otherwise.
And so after discussing what we know about those power struggles to assume
leadership in the Jewish world, we'll look at some of the core values and practices
of rabbinic Judaism, specifically Torah, study,
repentance, worship and deeds of loving kindness.
We're going to keep our eyes on how those ideas and values are expressed
in the Hebrew Bible, but also to get a feel for the innovative,
daring ness of the rabbis to see how the rabbis developed
those ideas in a world that no longer had the central
religious institution that characterized biblical Judaism, namely the temple.
Not everything changes once the temple is destroyed,
but many, many things change as a result of the destruction of the temple.
And so we want to be sensitive
to how the changes in the political fortunes of Israel affect
changes in religious practice, as well as the ology.
With the destruction of the
second Temple in Jerusalem in the year 70, holy space
in terms of the temple becomes less important
and holy time or holiness in time becomes more important.
It's promoted.
So we're going to spend several lectures looking at
specific holidays in Judaism that shaped the Jewish calendar
and that really give punctuation to the Jewish year and to Jewish life.
So we'll be looking at the Sabbath
and the high holidays, the New Year and the Day of Atonement, Passover
and Pentecost, as well as some minor holidays.
And we'll be sensitive to the fact that many of these holidays in the Bible
were rooted in the land of Israel
and agricultural holidays in the land of Israel.
But once the Jews were no longer living in the land of Israel,
other aspects of those holidays had to be accentuated
at that point.
We'll take a look.
We'll move into the Middle Ages and take a look
at some of the new expressions of Judaism that we see in the Middle Ages,
specifically Jewish philosophy and Jewish
mysticism starting in the 11th and 12th centuries.
We'll take, as our case studies, the problem of evil,
the creation of the world prayer and the reasons for the commandments,
and see how Jewish philosophy and Jewish mysticism have very different responses
to what the underlying conditions are for creation
or evil or prayer.
Our next five sessions
will be devoted to Judaism as it makes the transition into modernity.
And so we'll be looking at the emergence of the Jewish community
from its insulated medieval corporations, as they were called, how
they lived and govern themselves to emancipation and emancipation.
Everything changed, right?
You can't find an expression of Judaism today
that's just like Jews lived 300 years ago.
Emancipation changed everything.
So we'll be taking a look at ultra orthodoxy and modern orthodoxy and reform
and conservative and reconstructionist Judaism's as a way of understanding
how some of those groups 200 years ago, 100 years ago,
adopted
themselves to the new conditions in Western Europe
and then later on in Eastern Europe of emancipation.
And really for the first time in 2000 years,
we have the opportunity of people identifying themselves with either
the land of Israel, namely this phenomenon of Zionism
that hadn't been possible for 2000 years,
or people identifying themselves with the people of Israel,
people who were cultural Jews and may very well be atheists, right?
You can be a Jewish atheist,
although it's a contradiction in terms to be a Christian atheist.
The reason why you can be a Jewish atheist is precisely because
Judaism incorporates more than just religion.
So you can identify today with the land of Israel,
the people of Israel or the Torah of Israel,
and really relate to Judaism primarily as a religion.
Our last few sessions will take a look at how some sensitive
and controversial topics have unfolded
from the biblical period to today.
Specifically, we'll be looking at the role and status of women in the Jewish world.
We'll also be looking at how Judaism understands Christianity.
Is it an expression of idolatry because of the divine zation of Jesus,
or is it another path to the one guide?
And finally, we'll talk about
the vexing question of Jews as the chosen people.
Were we chosen, if so, by whom, and for what purpose?
In general, this course could just as easily be called an introduction
to Judaism's because we'll see that for every topic we cover,
we have a multiplicity of responses and a multiplicity of answers.
So on the one hand, the course could be an introduction to Judaism.
On the other hand, we want to be sensitive to what is common and what
unites all of the different Judaism's that we discuss.
Okay, so
let's now move into our first topic, which is the relationship
between the Torah, the Hebrew Bible, the Old Testament
and Judaism over here.
Now, the terminology affects how you understand and what we're talking about,
how one designates that corpus of books,
variously known as the Old Testament or the Hebrew Bible or the Tanakh,
often involves ideological assumptions about how the text is to be understood.
The word Tanakh is the Hebrew acronym for Torah,
which in this sense means the five books are the Pentateuch, Genesis,
Exodus, Leviticus, numbers in Deuteronomy, Tanakh that end stands for Nivi,
which is the Hebrew word for prophets and K-2, the team car.
Tanakh The heart in the car in Hebrew have the same letter is the writings.
So the books in the prophetic section we have the historical
the historical books of the prophets like
Joshua and Judges and Samuel L and Kings.
And then we have the big prophets like Ezekiel and Jeremiah
and Isaiah, as well as the minor prophets and the to name the writings.
We have Song of songs and proverbs and Psalms
and Ruth and Esther and Daniel up until Chronicles.
Right? That's the Tanakh, the Old Testament.
It is how some early Christians referred to this text
since it had been superseded in their eyes by the New Testament.
Jews generally don't refer to this book
as the Old Testament because they don't have a New Testament.
So Jews often call the entire book Torah the word Torah
literally means a teaching or an instruction in Hebrew.
The way we say teacher is more or mora.
And in the wisdom of the Hebrew language, the way to say parents is who rhyme,
which has the same roots as Torah, because according to biblical Judaism
anyway, it's your parents who should be the primary teachers in the family, right?
Not shipping them off to to the public or private schools.
So maybe the folks that do homeschooling know this truth about that language,
but the word Torah can mean just an individual teaching.
It can refer to the entire five books.
Torah can also refer to the entire Tanakh and Torah, can also refer to
what happens later and including the whole warehouse
of Jewish thought and expression, including what we do in this room today.
Some contemporary
scholars, in an effort to maintain religious neutrality,
they opt to describe this text by its language, the Hebrew Bible.
Now, it's true that some of the later books like Daniel
also have Aramaic, so the entire book doesn't have Hebrew in it.
But the vast majority of words in the Hebrew
Bible are indeed in Hebrew, even though we've got some Aramaic as well.
But the problem with describing it as the Hebrew Bible
is that faith communities have a very different reading
of the Hebrew Bible, whether we're talking about the Christian faith community
or the Jewish faith community, than do academic scholars of the Hebrew Bible.
I tell my students at Vanderbilt, where I teach,
that I don't know very much about the Hebrew Bible. Why?
Because I didn't get my Ph.D.
in Bible where I would have had to learn Akkadian and UGA, Riddick and
Mesopotamian myths
in order to compare the Hebrew Bible to the other contemporary languages
and literatures that were that were going on at the time.
The authors of the Hebrew Bible composed those texts.
If they want to know something about the Torah, about Jewish
interpretations of the Hebrew Bible, know, I'm happy to try to help.
I know something about that, but that there's a disjunction
between what the academics will tell us about the meaning of the Hebrew Bible
and how Jews and Christians relate to that, to that text.
Furthermore, the assumptions
about the authorship of the text,
often very dramatically between the academic community
and Jews and Christians.
So we're going to talk about some of the differences,
not just in terminology, but the differences in meetings
and the assumptions about the text with case studies
from the creation stories of Genesis one through three,
and that law that appears three different times in the Hebrew Bible
or in the Torah, as I will now refer to it, about not saving a kid.
LAMB Or a baby goat.
In this case, it's mother's milk.
Okay.
So let's talk about the assumptions of the text
before we actually get to these case studies.
Up until about the 17 century,
both Christians and Jews related to the Torah as a divine document,
whether it's divine dictation or whether it's channeling from God to Moses.
But the traditional assumption was that God presented
what is in the Torah to Moses at Mount Sinai.
Additional assumptions about the Hebrew Bible.
Traditional assumptions include that the text was cryptic.
It meant more than it said on the surface.
So you need to read deeply
in order to understand what God had intended in that text.
After all,
if the Torah was written by God, then it should be read differently
than if the Torah was written by human beings.
If it's instruction manual by human beings, you want to follow
the text literally, because human beings don't know how to write
in a kind of encrypted way for an audience.
But both early Christian and early Jewish interpreters of the Torah understood that
the the Torah was cryptic.
It was also perfect.
Now, what does that mean?
That the text was perfect?
It was not filled with contradictions.
It was not filled with misspellings
or with a abnormalities between the gender of the noun
and the gender of the verb, which you have to have consonants
in Hebrew, between the gender of the noun and the gender of the verb.
And that it would be good, right?
It's perfect. It's good, right?
Modern scholars don't share that assumption,
but we'll talk about modern assumptions in a moment.
And finally, the text of the Torah or the Hebrew Bible is relevant.
It's not just an old, dusty history book filled with genealogies with people's
names who you can't pronounce, but it says something to you
and is meaningful to your life today.
And it will be that case for every subsequent generation.
Right?
Because why would God waste God's breath, as it were, on writing history
when we're more concerned
about the present reality than about what happened in hoary antiquity
beginning in the 17th century,
a few Europeans, most notably Baruch Spinoza, who was eventually excommunicated
by the Jewish synagogue in Holland, in the Netherlands, they begin to take
tentative steps towards understanding the Torah
as they might any other text,
So they don't want to project
any of their assumptions about the text
or assumptions in terms of what this text must mean onto the text.
But they want to read the text to see what it says for itself
and not assume anything about the text by the mid-19th century,
biblical criticism was established in Germany and slowly
and painfully made its way to England and the United States.
The assumption of biblical criticism is that the Torah was written by men.
It's got to be men.
Although one author suggests that it may that there may have been
a woman involved in one particular strand of the Hebrew Bible.
But generally the scholarly assumption is that a group of men wrote
the texts that make up the Hebrew Bible over a period of hundreds of years,
and these men didn't always agree.
And if you know anything about synagogue politics or about church politics,
the idea that men don't always agree shouldn't come as a great shock.
And you see these differences of opinion
reflected in the text themselves.
So the idea that the Torah,
the traditional assumption that the Torah was divine,
no, maybe there was a divine element to it, but it was human authorship,
the traditional assumption that the Torah was perfect
and there weren't any contradictions.
No biblical criticism thrives on the contradictions between different
authors or different schools that the scholars tell us
made up the edited text or the redacted
text of the tenor of the Hebrew Bible, and the idea that the traditional idea
that the Bible was cryptic also goes by the wayside
in terms of modern assumptions about the text.
The text means what it says No more, no less.
Okay, so much for our assumptions of modern biblical critics.
Now let's take a look at two episodes in the Torah
and see how different the Old Testament Tanakh Hebrew Bible can be,
especially from contemporary Judaism and also contemporary Christianity.
So let's start by looking at the creation stories in Genesis one, two, three.
The first thing to note is that I said
the creation stories in Genesis one, two, three.
There are two different stories of how God created the heavens
and the earth and everything that is in it.
The seam between these two stories
is Genesis chapter two, verse four,
and many Bibles actually will show you by splitting the verse in half
that the first half of Genesis two four is the coda,
or the conclusion to the first creation story.
And the second half of the verse of Genesis two four
is the Prolog to the second creation story.
Now, these stories are totally different.
They have different names of God and the first creation
story, Elohim, which is usually translated as God, is the actor.
In the second creation story, Adonai Elohim
is the actor, Adonai is the tetra graviton.
That four letter name of God that was usually pronounced
only once a year
by the High priest in the Holy of Holies on the Day of Atonement on Yom Kippur.
It is usually spoken as the low.
It is usually spoken as auto and we don't pronounce that name.
And then the translation is usually Lord.
So the Lord God is the actor.
In the second creation story, the first creation story happens in seven days.
There we go, seven days.
The second creation story happens in one day.
The first creation story in Genesis one
has human beings created very last.
The second creation story has Adam the human being created first.
The first creation story actually
has everything created as an entire species,
including human beings, including human beings,
so that when God creates Adam, the Hebrew word is.
Adam. God creates humanity, male and female.
He created humanity right in the divine image.
It's only when Genesis one gets put before Genesis two
that we get this idea that God created one human being,
and how that one human being can be both male and female.
Perplexed some of the early commentators who suggested that the first human
being might be might have been a hermaphrodite,
because in the second creation story, we have only one human being created.
Adam a man.
And then later
on, a woman is created from his rib or in some understandings from his side.
So the meaning of these stories changes radically
depending on how the editor places them together.
Another thing that's
interesting about the creation stories is that
they're relatively insignificant
in the Hebrew Bible, especially the Garden of Eden story.
The Garden of Eden story gets a couple of mentions and the prophets
not even mentions, but allusions to that first creation story becomes,
All right, prominent in the Decalogue because we're supposed
to keep the Sabbath or keep Shabbat and rest on the seventh day.
According to the Decalogue,
as it is iterated in Exodus, it's reiterated in Deuteronomy.
Why are we supposed to keep the Sabbath on the seventh day?
Because God created the heavens and the earth opens in six days.
And on the seventh day God rested.
Of course, Shabbat becomes much, much, much more important
to rabbinic Judaism than it does to the Bible.
So right, the creation stories are there at the beginning, Right?
It's a good way to begin a story, right.
Especially if you understand or if the editors understand
that this God that we're talking about is the universal God of all humanity.
So you start off with creation, but the importance of the creation stories
is much more important to Pauline.
Christianity and rabbinic Judaism than it was to the redact
or the authors of those stories in the Torah themselves.
So although
Judaism and Christianity read the creation narratives differently,
their readings are deeply influential for both faith communities.
For example, you've got six mentions.
This is the refrain there was evening, there was mourning Day one,
there was evening, there was mourning day two.
Rabbinic Judaism understands that because it says
there was evening, there was mourning day one, that the day begins in the evening.
And this causes much confusion when you're looking at a calendar
that has the Jewish holidays,
because it'll tell you when the first day of the holiday is.
But you start celebrating that holiday on the previous evening
because that's how the rabbis understood the Hebrew Bible.
Well, that's probably not what the Hebrew Bible meant.
And indeed, there was a Jewish scholar in the 13th century
in France whose name whose rabbinic name is Rosh Bom.
Rabbi Shmuel Ben May ear.
The rabbis are very
interested in acronyms.
So everybody,
if you've made it in the Jewish world, you know
you've made it because you have your own acronym.
So Rosh Baum is Rabbi Shmuel.
Ben, My ear
turns out to be Rosh, his grandson, and we'll talk much more about Rashi
in the future.
He should know that the text in Genesis one tells you what God did during the day.
God punches the time clock at 5 a.m.
then it's morning.
I'm sorry. Then it's evening, right?
God doesn't work in the evening.
He keeps regular hours and at the door.
And when there's morning, that's the conclusion of day one.
And now we're going to start to tell you what happened in day two.
So a day is a kind of commonsensical day when the sun rises.
He says that that's what biblical scholars agree with.
But nevertheless, in Judaism, in rabbinic Judaism, you light candles
on Friday night to start the Sabbath night on Saturday morning,
did Rosh Bรถhm want to light candles on Saturday morning?
No, absolutely not.
But he said, look, let's be honest about what the Hebrew Bible means
and then let's do what the rabbis tell us to do
in Christianity.
Pauline Christianity from Saint Paul understands that the human disobedience
in the Garden of Eden by eating from the fruit of the tree,
of knowledge of good and evil, which God had specifically commanded.
Adam not not so explicitly.
Eve, but specifically commanded Adam not to eat from that.
That's sustained all future generations of human beings.
That's the idea of original sin.
Well, you don't get that idea from the Hebrew Bible itself.
Indeed, in Genesis four, you've got the story of Cain and Abel,
where God specifically says to Cain, Right, you've got this tendency
to do evil, this psychological tendency, but you can master it.
Human beings are not depraved and committed to a life of sinning
and transgressing.
You can overcome that through your own free will.
But Pauline, Christianity emphasized this idea of original sin
as a way to explain what Jesus came to atone for.
So Judaism doesn't understand that there is original sin.
Neither do contemporary scholars from the Hebrew Bible itself.
That original sin is something that was an interpretation of the Hebrew Bible
by early Christian communities, just like the day starting in the evening
was an interpretation of the Hebrew Bible or of the Torah by early
rabbinic communities. Right?
So what scholars say about this text is often very much at odds with what
the faith communities of Judaism and Christianity have to say about this text.
Okay.
The next element in the Hebrew Bible we're going to take a look at
is the prohibition of seeding a kid in its mother's milk.
One of my colleagues at Vanderbilt, Professor
Jack Sasson, recently wrote an article saying,
Yeah, we got it wrong.
One of the interesting things about Hebrew in the Torah
is that it doesn't have any vowels,
it doesn't have any punctuation, it doesn't have any capital letters.
So you really have to have an interpretive stance toward
the Torah to know where one word begins and one word ends.
And if it should be read as a declarative or an interrogative
in this case, Load two Vacillated did the IMO,
which is the prohibition against seeding a kitten's mother's milk.
Professor Sasson suggests was misread
that it really should say not collards
in its mother's milk but tentative
right same letters, but different punctuation, different vowels.
So you shouldn't see the kid in its mother's fat.
you didn't see the kid and its mother's fat.
What does that mean?
That you shouldn't kill two generations in one day Because the only way
you can see the kidneys mother's fat is if you kill the mother to get the fat.
And indeed, there's another verse in the Hebrew Bible that says,
You shouldn't kill two generations of an of a species of animal in one day.
So it makes perfect sense.
And then Professor Qassim goes on to cite
other ancient Near Eastern parallels to this idea.
But that's not how the rabbis read it.
The rabbis read that prohibition as you shouldn't
see the kid and it's mother's milk.
Now, I would argue, or at least suggest argue might be a little too strong.
But the reason why the rabbis read the verse that way is
because of their assumption that the Bible was perfect.
The by being perfect, the Bible doesn't repeat itself.
God assumes that people are going to be listening closely and reading closely.
And so you don't need to have two verses that say,
don't kill two generations of species on the same day.
So you've got one verse that says, Don't kill two generations of species
on the same day.
You've got another verse that you read is milk instead of fat, right?
And it gives you a different law.
The problem with this law is that it's repeated three times.
But what about the assumption of perfection
that God doesn't repeat himself?
So the rabbis here assume that each time
the verse is repeated, it's coming to teach us something new.
That's the language of yeshiva, right?
Or Jewish seminary, Right.
And sometimes they use their thumbs in order to illustrate.
So the first time the Bible tells us, do not see the kid and it's mother's
milk, it means do not cook milk and meat together.
Right.
It's a specific example
of that general prohibition of cooking milk and meat together.
The second where I'm on this stuff
the second time, the Bible says, do not see the kid and its mother's milk.
It means that you shouldn't eat
milk and meat together, even if it's cold.
Even if it's cold, right.
That's something it does it say that in the Hebrew Bible
is that the plain contextual meaning of the Hebrew Bible?
Is that what modern scholars say?
The Hebrew Bible means?
No, But with this rabbinic assumption of the perfection
and the fact that the Torah is cryptic, right?
Meaning that you have to read deeply into it.
That's how the rabbis understood the repetition.
Now I'm back on this them and the third instance of
Do not see the kid and it's mother's milk means that you're forbidden
from financially benefiting from the combination of milk and meat.
In other words.
Well, this is a question now, can a Jew that's committed to traditional Jewish law
work at McDonald's where you're selling Big Macs and not Whoppers with cheese?
That's right. Cheeseburgers.
So when I was in yeshiva in Jerusalem
seminary, my teacher asked us that question
and we said, you know, we just learn this line.
No, because if you can't benefit, you're getting paid
for serving milk and meat together.
But it was a trick question because the meat
that McDonald's serves is not kosher meat.
And these laws only apply to kosher meat.
So you can't serve kosher meat and milk together
and you can't benefit from them being served together.
Okay, fair enough.
So we see here that these three rabbinic
re readings or two rabbinic re readings of the second and third
repetitions of that verse vary greatly from what
the Hebrew Bible or scholars of the Hebrew Bible will tell you.
Those verses mean in context.
That's an example of how Judaism often interprets the Hebrew Bible in ways
that are very much intentioned or at odds or in disjunction
with the plain sense of the Hebrew Bible and what we're going to be looking at
for the rest of this course is how Judaism creatively rereads
or creatively misreads, as some people might say, that Hebrew Bible,
in order to keep Judaism current with the needs of the community.
So we'll start next time by taking a look
at Israelite history as presented in the Tenaa.
Thank you.
Hi, my name is Shai Cherry,
and we're continuing with our introduction to Judaism here at the teaching company.
This lecture is entitled From Israelite to Jew.
What we hope to do in this lecture
is to outline the history of the Israelite people.
According to the Tanakh, according to the Hebrew Bible.
I want to emphasize that that the history that we're going to be talking
about for the next 30 minutes is the history or the historiography,
the story of the Israelites
existence and dedication to God, and problems
with keeping dedicated to God and their experiences
in the land of Israel from their own perspective.
For many of these historical events, we don't have external corroboration.
So what I'm not doing here is presenting Jewish history.
I'm presenting the history of the Israelite people
from their own perspective.
And we start at the beginning, as we talked about
in lecture one, with the creation of the world.
That was the point of the creation of human beings.
The rabbis recognized early on
that those first six days of creation really couldn't be technical days
of creation, because for the first three days, the sun wasn't around, right?
The sun wasn't created until day four.
And we generally mark
the passage of a day by the sun, whether the sun goes around us
or we go around the sun, the sun is involved.
So the rabbis started counting time,
not from day one, but from the existence of human beings.
Day six Therefore, there's no problem in Judaism with accepting an age of
the earth is 4.5 billion years old, which is what the scientists tell us.
And also, incidentally,
there's also no problem accepting the transmutation of species,
which is widely accepted within the Jewish community.
From the creation we go to
Cain and Abel and what we call primeval myth or primeval history,
the Tower of Babel stories that try to get at this very complicated
relationship between God and early human beings that seem to keep going downhill.
With Cain and Abel.
We have Cain killing his brother Abel.
Then we've got God wiping out all of humanity in the flood of Noah.
And what is God, say?
This very sad line from Genesis six five that the devising of a human being's
heart are only evil from his youth, this psychological propensity
to commit evil notice it's a psychological propensity to commit evil
and not a kind of ontological which is that big Greek word
that means, in your essence, a necessity to be evil.
But certainly the characters
in the early chapters in Genesis did not act very righteously.
But excuse me, the history then continues with no in his family.
And again, things go downhill with the building of the tower of Babel.
Finally, God decides to select one person and from that one person
to establish a covenant and to see if by having a specific covenant
with a specific person, he can build a righteous society.
And this, of course, is Avram.
His name doesn't become Abraham until a few chapters later.
God tells Abraham or Avram
to leave Iran where he was from,
and to head out toward the land of Israel because he doesn't want to be encumbered
with the baggage of his parents
and his high school buddies and his community.
He really needs to start thinking out of the box and start worshiping
God one God as opposed to a multiplicity of gods
in a new way that will best be done on a solo journey.
Not quite solo.
He takes his wife and he takes his nephew light right?
And they head as long as well as his father actually
Terra
And they head west toward the land of Israel,
which at that point is called the land of Canaan.
Maybe that happened about 2000 B.C.E., something like that.
What is this?
This these initials BCE before the Common
Era is as opposed to before Christ
and then after
the next side of the of the divide is not ad Anno Domini
the year of our Lord because Jews don't recognize Jesus as being the Lord.
So they say the common era.
So on the one hand they're using more academics and Jews
both tend to use this terminology of BCE before the Common era
and see the common era as a way to be more neutral.
On the other hand, they're still using the birth of Jesus
as that which demarcates what came before and what came after.
So that years that I'm going to be talking about are still the same years.
If you just need to convert in your head from BCE to be to BCE or from sea to A.D.
So again,
Abraham, the Patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, that probably happened
around 2000 BCE if it happened again, scholars don't have any evidence outside
of the Hebrew Bible that there were such people as the patriarchs.
This is Jewish history from within the Biblical corpus.
Then we've got the book of Exodus.
It begins with well, it begins with the Israelites
becoming very fruitful and multiplying greatly.
And there seems to be a change of regime, a new pharaoh who doesn't recognize
or who doesn't like perhaps Joseph and his clan.
And so we have this we have this trick really to kill.
It's not a trick. It's a contract.
A contract to kill the male babies and keep the female babies alive.
Because there's a concern that there's going to be some kind of revolt
eventually. The Hebrews,
the Israelites, they're called Hebrews at this point are made slaves.
And Moses, around the year 1250 BCE, succeeds
in letting my people go in freeing the Israelite slaves
from the house of bondage, taking them through the Sea of Reeds.
The Red Sea is actually a mistranslation.
It's not red, it's reed.
There were reeds in those seas, John Suf the sea of reeds,
and then eventually 49 days after the liberation from Egypt,
they get to Mount Sinai and they have a revelatory experience
of God giving the Decalogue, Do you say Decalogue, by the way?
Not the Ten Commandments, because Jews have 613 commandments
and there are actually more than ten that are included in the Decalogue.
For instance, on six days you shall work, on
the seventh day shall be a Sabbath to you. Well,
usually you can't one, that you should have a Sabbath on the seventh day.
But there's also one six days you shall work.
People forget about working for six days, especially in this country.
But it's one of the commandments.
So we say the Decalogue or the ten utterances, the ten words of God.
There's a 40 year sojourn in the desert,
and then finally Moses dies and that whole generation dies.
The only two people from that generation, from the Exodus that actually lived
to make it into the promised land, the land of Canaan at this point
are Joshua and Caleb and Joshua.
Ben One assumes leadership from Moses and he leads the Israelites
across the Jordan River,
and the Jordan River splits just like Moses split the Sea of Reeds.
If we were to make a sequel to the Ten Commandments,
they'd probably use the same set at Universal Studios brings the Israelites,
or at least the Vanguard Storm Troopers, to Jericho conquers Jericho,
and that begins this period of conquest that probably lasts
about 200 years.
And finally, we have
in the 11th century BCE
is a loose confederation of the 12 tribes of Israel.
Jacob, whose name gets changed
to Israel, has 12 sons
and not exactly each of those sons, but basically each of those sons.
And then there are two tribes from Joseph Menashe in a frame.
But Levi, one of the sons, doesn't get a tribal inheritance.
So there are 12 tribes that get land in the land of Israel.
And also in what today is Jordan, just on the other side of the Jordan River.
And they existed in a loose confederacy for about 200 years until around
they would mobilize and get together for external threats,
but otherwise they would conduct their own business, their own governmental
affairs, their own judicial needs as a confederation, sort of the federalist
system, rather than having a strong centralized government.
Around the year ten, 20 BCE, the Israelites demanded a king.
Let us have a king and the prophet Samuel anoints Saul
Saul as the first king of Israel.
But it doesn't go so well for the first 20 years.
Finally, David takes over the kingship from Sol.
David is not king.
Sol's son David becomes the second king of Israel
and at that point the monarchy becomes hereditary
so that any legitimate king of Israel
has to be able to claim Davidic ancestry,
which is why the genealogies in the gospels
of the New Testament, Matthew and Luke all trace
the genius of Jesus who is understood
to be the Messiah or the King of Israel.
Back to David.
Right, because that's how you claim authentic,
authentic entitlement to the crown.
David had many, many, many sons.
And one particular son through Batsheva,
which is an interesting story all by itself.
Solomon assumes the crown around 961
and his reign is marked by internal rebellion.
One of the things about Solomon's reign is that he is successful
in building the temple in Jerusalem,
and here we have
a quote from First Kings eight that describes
that moment of the dedication of the first temple,
then Solomon stood before the altar of the Lord
in the presence of the whole community of Israel.
He spread the palms of his hands toward heaven and said,
Lord God of Israel, in the heavens above and on the earth below,
there is no God like you who keep your gracious covenants
with your servants when they walk before you in wholehearted devotion. I
notice
that Solomon says there is no God like you
at this point in the Israelite religion.
It's not pure monotheism.
The Israelites may only have one God, but that's not to say
that they don't recognize the existence of other gods for other people.
They only have one God.
This is this is either called Hanno theism, right?
Worship of one God or Monogatari worship of one God.
Right. Two words to get at the same idea.
So at this point, the Israelites only worshiped one God, at least officially.
They were only supposed to worship one God.
We see some backsliding periodically in the prophetic books
of the Hebrew Bible, but they recognize the existence and reality
of other gods for the other surrounding peoples.
When King Solomon dies in 1922,
the Kingdom of Israel splits.
You've got the ten northern tribes.
That's called Israel, and you've got two tribes in the south that's called Judah.
So you've got the Kingdom of Israel.
In the Kingdom of Judah, Jerusalem is in Judah.
It's actually in the tribal allotment of Benjamin.
The ten northern tribes were ruled by Jeroboam,
and the southern tribes were ruled by Solomon's son, Rehoboam.
Now, in 1721, you've got the great power at that point of the ancient
near East Assyria coming in and destroying the Northern Kingdom.
The Israelites are exhausted.
The Israelites in the North, the northern kingdom of Israel,
they're exiled that at that point and they're decimated.
So one out of every ten was killed.
That's what decimated means, right?
Decimal and the other nine were spread out all over the Assyrian
kingdom, which was quite, quite extensive at that point.
Those are the ten lost tribes of Israel.
It's not that they were lost.
They didn't know where they were, but they lost their national identity
or their corporate identity because they weren't exiled in mass.
So they assimilated and acculturated into the surrounding regions.
That happened in 721 BCE.
The Kingdom of Judah fared a little bit better,
and so they actually didn't experience the wrath
of the leading power of the day until 150 years or so later.
At that point, the way power politics works, the Assyrians were no longer
the hegemonic in the region, but the Babylonians were and in 597
the Babylonians conquered Judah, the two southern tribes
in that southern kingdom, and they exiled its leaders.
And then in 586, the final blow came the temple in Jerusalem that King Solomon had.
That that King Solomon had built was destroyed by the Babylonians
and the Judaea in the Judaea in population
was exiled to Babylonia in Mass.
So they maintained their corporate identity.
So they were Judeans outside of Judah.
This is the first time in Jewish history where people that later become called Jews
have to deal with having this kind of identity
that's linked to the land that they're no longer living on,
that they're no longer living on.
Let me read to you one of the Psalms, some 137
that gets it, this feeling of being displaced and disoriented
by the river is of Babylon.
There we sat, sat and wept as we thought of Zion.
There on the poplars, we hunger liars for our captors
asked us there for songs, our tormentors for amusement.
Sing this one of the songs of Zion.
How can we sing a song of the Lord on alien soil If I forget you Jerusalem.
Let my right hand wither, Let my tongue stick to my palate.
If I cease to think of you, If I do not keep Jerusalem in my memory,
even at my happiest hour,
they were tormented by their Babylonian captors.
And one of the things that the Jordanians respond is
how can we sing a song of the Lord on alien soil?
Perhaps what's going on here
is that their understanding, even in the sixth century BCE,
is that the God of Israel only works when they're in the land of Israel
and that when they're on alien soil, God either can't hear or God is not powerful.
But there seems to be a suggestion anyway that we haven't yet
reached, which we will in the next century.
This idea of there being one God for all the world that is powerful
all over the world, that can hear people's prayers all over the world.
And that is the one God for all the peoples in the world.
So we see stages in development of Israelite theology.
Again,
we have a switch in the power politics of the region.
Babylon goes down and Persia comes up.
The Persians under King Cyrus.
The second conquered Babylon in 539,
and they allow the Jordanians to return to what is now called Yehud.
The way to say Jew in Hebrew is Yehuda, someone who comes from Yehud,
right from Judea is a Jew day in or in English.
We now say a Jew, right?
We think of Judah ism as a religion, but it was certainly attached
intrinsically to this geology
geography of place in the land of Israel.
Judah,
the Jew Dayan's who return, which is only about 10%
of the exiled population to Babylonia.
They engage in the rebuilding of the temple.
This now becomes the second temple, which was dedicated in 516.
So 516 is when they dedicated it.
586 is when it was destroyed.
There was a 70 year span when the temple didn't exist.
Keep that 70 years in mind.
We will come back to it 70 years after the second Temple is destroyed.
It's a preview of coming attractions.
The next major
movement in Israelite history is when Alexander the Great conquers
the ancient Near East goes very, very, very far East.
Alexander the Great, He's he brings Hellenism.
He was a student, legend has it, of Aristotle,
and he brings Hellenistic culture, philosophy, literature, drama
into the regions under his occupation,
the empire that he has conquered upon his death.
That Kingdom of Alexander the Great was divided into three parts,
and the land of Israel was controlled initially
by the ptolemies of Egypt and the Ptolemies of Egypt.
They encouraged Hellenism, but they didn't aggressively push Hellenism
so that those people living in Judea who wanted to maintain their ancestral
ways, their ancestral religions,
could do so without harassment, without interference.
That changed in the year 200, when the land of Israel changed
hands from the Ptolemies from Egypt to the solutions of Syria
and the Seleucids began spreading Hellenistic ideas and philosophy
and religion more aggressively throughout the land of Israel.
This is where the history might become a little more familiar
to some of you, because around the year 168, we have the first war
for religious freedom recorded in history,
and that was initiated by Judah and his sons, The Maccabees.
Right. Otherwise known as the Hasmonean is
the name
Maccabee, by the way, means Hammer in Hebrew.
And that might be why they got their name, because they hammered the Syrians.
Or it might be an acronym for verse that we have in Exodus chapter 15.
It says Mika Moka by Hรฉlene Adonai.
If you take the first letters of those four words, Meek Homolka, the Alien,
and then Otto Knight is begins with a good or the Y that spells out Maccabee.
And what do those four words mean?
Who is like you? Lord, amongst the gods
or amongst the mighty is how it's traditionally translated.
And that may have been what the Maccabees put on their shields
as they went to war against the Syrian Greeks or the Syrian Seleucids.
So we're not sure exactly what Maccabees refers to
this war that we
celebrate today as the holiday of Hanukkah
was certainly a war against the Hellenism of the Syrian Greeks.
But you also have to remember that it was a civil war.
It was a civil war between those Jews who were less Hellenistic
and those Jews who were more Hellenistic and the Maccabees represent tradition,
the customs of the ancestors is their right.
They were Hellenism to a degree, but they didn't want to become as Helen ized,
as many other people in the land of Israel did, who thought,
Great, We can be cosmopolitan, we can be like Alexander the Great.
Why maintain these particular mystic distinctions?
Let's join the world culture of Hellenism.
Let's start engaging in traditional Jewish law.
Let's stop circumcising our kids.
Let's stop this allegiance to the Torah and let's become good Hellenistic
citizens, right?
That was too much for the Maccabees and a whole group
of more traditional conservative conservative with a small C Jews
that really went to war against those more Hellenistic elements.
The reign of the Hasmonean has expanded the territory
of the Kingdom of Israel, but the dynasty quickly became corrupt.
About 100 years later, there was a struggle between two brothers
within the Hasmonean dynasty, and one brother actually invited Rome.
That was now the new power, right?
The Greeks had been the the power.
Now Rome takes over as the great power.
And one of the brothers invited Rome in to the land of Israel in 63 BCE.
And once Rome had a toehold in the land,
they slowly established control of the land.
First they had native born rulers to represent them and to collect taxes.
And finally they appointed their own pro curators
in order to control the masses and collect taxes.
One of the things that they're particularly interested in
was the collection of taxes.
At this point, things were
bad for the people living in the land of Israel.
Taxation was burdensome.
They didn't have political freedom.
They didn't have the religious freedom that they had experienced under
under the Hasmonean dynasty.
And so apocalyptic visions of the end of time start to proliferate
and people begin suggesting, maybe he's the one to fight the Romans
and to kick them out of the land and to be the messiah.
Right? We'll have a whole session on the Messiah.
But the fundamental idea of the Messiah is the idea of a Jewish king
related to king David, who reestablishes Jewish political sovereignty
for Jews in the land of Israel.
So there began to be messianic speculation at this point.
And finally, in the year 66, this tinderbox explodes.
And we have what's called the Great Revolt from 66 to 70,
The Great Revolt is started by Jewish zealots, sort of right wing
nationalists
who want who believe that only Jews should be
in political control of the land of Israel and of the temple.
So they initiate the great revolt against the Romans.
The occasion for the revolt
was when the Roman Procurator, Jesse Floris, expropriated
gold from the temple treasury, which could only be used for holy things.
And so this provided a pretext for the war.
So although it took several years, the Great Revolt is eventually quashed
and the second Temple is destroyed by the Romans in the year 70,
according to rabbinic sources.
Rabbinic Legend One member who represents the
accommodationist party in Judaism, the Doves, the Liberals,
Rabbi Yohanan Ben Zaki during the Great Revolt
before the temple is destroyed, he is spirited out of Jerusalem
in a coffin by his disciples and is allowed by the Roman War,
by the Roman General who was prosecuting the war to establish
what becomes the seed of rabbinic Judaism.
An Academy of rabbinic sages at Yavne.
Some scholars suggest this was really a P.O.W.
camp for some of the people captured.
We don't really know
historically what Yoav note was, but what the rabbinic sources tell us
is that it was the seed of rabbinic Judaism founded by Rabbi Yohanan.
Ben Zaki.
What happened to these zealots, by the way?
The zealots that started the Great Revolt to begin with in 66,
they managed to escape the Old City before it was destroyed.
And Josephus, who is a historian of this period,
he started out as a Jewish soldier and then surrendered
to Roman forces in the north of Israel
and sort of bargained his way into a nice villa and pension in Rome.
And he would agree to write the history of the Jews
during this period, which he did in Greek.
He describes lives
how sanguinary this revolts end was that blood was flowing through
the streets of Israel, blood was flowing through
the streets of Jerusalem.
At that point, the zealots figured out that the writing,
the blood was on the wall.
They managed to escape from Jerusalem and they went up to one of the
one of the last king of Israel's mountain fortresses
at Masada and were able to survive there until around the year 74,
when the Romans finally succeeded in breaching the walls of Masada.
There's a great miniseries that describes those events.
The Jews on the mountain decided to commit suicide
rather than to be captured and enslaved by the Romans.
Okay, on one foot, as we say, that's the history of the Jews.
For about 2000 years, from the patriarchs to the destruction of the second Temple.
Now what I want to do is outline what some of the Jewish sects
were at the eve of the destruction of the temple.
One group that we know about from from the New Testament
and from Josephus, as well as from rabbinic literature, are the Sadducees.
The sadnesses didn't have an oral tradition
that interpreted the Torah that we have the Pentateuch.
Therefore, they denied resurrection of the dead because resurrection
isn't mentioned at all in the Torah, In the Pentateuch,
we have references to resurrection in later books, but
because it doesn't appear in the Torah, the subjects rejected it.
They also denied divine omniscience.
Since free will is a necessary assumption of the Torah,
God lays out all kinds of laws and commands and says Choose life.
Choose to follow the commandments.
That didn't make sense to the sad disease.
If God knew ahead of time what the Jews were going to decide to do.
The sandwiches were also connected with the aristocracy in the priesthood.
They tended to be the more Helen ized members of society.
Another group in Second Temple Judaism were called The Scenes,
and the scenes were widely associated with a group living around the Dead
Sea and are held to be responsible for the Dead Sea Scrolls,
which were found in 1947 by a little Bedouin boy.
The scenes were in a set a community
with an apocalyptic theology that was also dualistic,
so they understood the world was coming to an end.
And how would that world come to an end?
The Sons of Light and the Sons of Darkness would battle each other with the sons
of light prevailing.
The seams reject freewill totally and claim
that divine providence controls everything.
Another group were followers, early followers
of Jesus outside the land of Israel.
They're called Christians.
Inside the land of Israel.
They're called Nazarene because Jesus lived for them
for the majority of his life.
In Nazareth, they claimed that Jesus was the Messiah,
although Jewish sovereignty had not yet been restored to Israel.
Thus there was the prophecy of an imminent second coming in order to fulfill those
earlier expectations of what a messiah would do outside the land of Israel.
We have Saint Paul, who is known as the Apostle to the Gentiles,
and he spreads the good news the Gospel
throughout the Roman Empire and was incredibly successful in doing so.
The last group that really
had the most Israelites of that time
affectionate toward were the Pharisees.
The Pharisees have gotten a terrible reputation, a tragic reputation
from the New Testament.
But the Pharisees were the most popular group amongst all these groups.
Before the temple was destroyed in the year 70,
they claimed an oral tradition which interpreted the Torah.
So unlike the Sadducees, the Pharisees believed in resurrection,
and they also believed in the world to come that people would get
rewarded or punished in the next world upon death,
depending on what their actions were in this world.
The Pharisees promoted
the priestly purity laws that were only obligatory for the priests
as a way for all of Israel to attain holiness.
They really were interested in democratizing Judaism,
in taking the Temple Judaism that's described in the Bible
and making it accessible and obligatory for all of Israel.
The Pharisees can be viewed as the spiritual descendants
of the spiritual ancestors of the rabbis.
Whenever the rabbis talk about a dispute between the Pharisees and the say this is
without exception, they always agree with the Pharisees
that oral tradition of the Pharisees
becomes the oral Torah of the rabbis, so that by the time
we get to our next lecture that talks about the value
of the preeminent value of town, the Torah, it's actually in two lectures.
The oral traditions have become an oral Torah
that have the same authority and the same origin as the written Torah.
So that, according to the rabbis at Mt.
Sinai, God gave to Moses, not just the written tours
that we have in the Pentateuch, but also the oral Torah.
That includes all of the interpretations for those parts of the Torah
that aren't so clear or weren't included in any case.
So we'll talk about more about the oral Torah in the future
when the destruction happens in the year 70,
we see that two of those four groups lose their
lose their existence.
The Sadducees had been associated with the temple, and so once
the temple is destroyed, they lose their institutional power base
and the scenes were wiped out.
They were physically killed during the Great Revolt.
So the only two groups left from Second Temple Judaism
were the Nazarene slash Christians, and it took a couple of hundred years.
But the Jewish Christians who still maintain fidelity to Jewish law
and thought that Jesus was the Messiah, they eventually sort of fell
by the wayside.
But Gentile Christianity that no longer felt obligated to the commandments.
That was an incredible success story for Christianity.
And then the Pharisees morphing into rabbinic Judaism,
then become the one kind of Judaism for hundreds of years that dominates
the Jewish world, and they achieve hegemony within the Jewish world.
Now, the next lecture that we're going to look at focuses on what the central
religious concept of these rabbinic Jews was in the post Temple Reality.
Thank you.
Hi, my name is Shai Cherry, and this is the third lecture
in the teaching company's introduction to Judaism on repentance.
Or I will be using the Hebrew tissue.
So let us talk about what that word tissue means.
Literally, it means to return or to respond.
You can understand perhaps both meanings
to return to a place that you had been to or to respond to someone
who had been speaking to you and you return that person's words.
In rabbinic Judaism, the idea of repentance or to Shiva
is the central concept of rabbinic Judaism, because rabbinic Judaism emerges
after the second Temple has been destroyed by the Romans in the year
70 of the Common Era, one of the primary functions of the temple
was to achieve atonement for one's sins
by usually bringing an animal sacrifice to the priests, and the priest would serve
as an intermediary and would slit the throat of the animal.
Usually, and you would theoretically pledge
not to do whatever you had done before.
But it was that animal sacrifice that effected atonement.
Well, once the temple has been destroyed, your address for atonement disappears.
So how do you get clean?
How do you get pure before God from those transgression ones
that we all through the course of living, most of us anyway commit.
So the idea of tissue var
although it appears in the Bible and we'll take a look at those instances,
becomes absolutely central in the rabbinic mind and in rabbinic religion
tissue. The
the return
or responding the idea of returning to be in right
relationship with God and responding to God's call
for us to heed the divine commandments that were revealed at Mt.
Sinai and that subsequently went through a process of interpretation.
We'll talk more about that process of interpretation in the next lecture.
But a process of interpretation with the Pharisees,
with the scribes before that, and then finally with the rabbis.
So now that we have a definition, a working definition of tissue, var
let's begin chronologically unpacking the concept.
So let's start at the beginning.
The rabbis say that tissue that preceded creation,
tissue that preceded creation,
in other words, the world couldn't exist
without some way for the people that inhabit this world
to rectify their transgressions or to feel as though
they're now back again in right relationship with God.
So before even creation again, this is according to the rabbis
in a midrash, a text,
a midrash is a rabbinic idea that's connected to a biblical verse.
And we'll explain more about midrash in the next lecture.
But in the midrash imagination of the rabbis, the world couldn't exist
without the Shiva.
So it preceded creation
because whenever we inevitably falter
or stumble, we need a way to write ourselves
and we need the possibility of writing ourselves.
And here, of course, the assumption is that God wants us to write ourselves
to do tissue VA and we have the ability to do tissue VA
So those are the presuppositions of this idea of tissue. But
when we think about the
biblical paradigms of tissue, VA although the word itself, tissue VA
doesn't appear in the Hebrew Bible, the verb does.
But I would say that the primary biblical character
to exhibit the characteristics of a
all tissue VA of someone who engages in this act of tissue.
VA is King David.
King David.
King David, as I mentioned in previous classes,
had a dalliance with Batsheva.
He sees her from his rooftop.
He's got a nice a nice roof garden
on his in his castle in the old city of Jerusalem.
He sees Batsheva takes a liking to her, but she hears husband is away at war.
Has Batsheva came in, brought into his house
where they engage in sexual relations, which is a capital a capital crime, right?
Because that is adultery, because she is a married woman
and they have a child or
she gets pregnant, the child actually ends up dying
as a punishment for both by his act of adultery,
although how much say she had in the matter
when the king wants you to do something, she probably didn't
have that much to say about it, but also as a punishment to King David.
But when King David is faced with what
he's done by Nathan, his prophet, Right.
All the kings had prophets.
One of my teachers at Brandeis, where I received my Dr.
Reuben Kimmelman, he said that the prophets in the biblical
period served the same function as today's free press.
Right?
They tell the King
what the king needs to hear in order to keep him on the straight and narrow.
So when Nathan challenges King, David's
despicable behavior with Bite Shiver, King David immediately
confesses, I stand guilty before the Lord, right?
He doesn't say using that Mel Brooks line, It's good to be the king,
and I can do whatever I want to do because I'm
the king and who's to tell me otherwise?
He said, I stand guilty before the Lord.
He took responsibility. He cut to it.
He regretted his action.
He never did anything like that again.
He is the model of the Shiva and King David.
You also need to remember, in the span of biblical
history, he is the ancestor of the Messiah.
The Messiah is going to be part of that Davidic line.
So already in the Hebrew Bible, there's this connection between two Shiva
and redemption, the redemption that the other only the Messiah can bring.
I mentioned that the word itself, the shoe doesn't appear in the Tanakh,
but the root, the shoe to return or to respond does appear.
And in one case in First Kings chapter eight,
verse 48, it talks about the person return,
the person who has transgressed, returning directly to God.
So it's this sense of return to God being in right relationship to God
attendant to that return an
was also the animal sacrifice that when the temple stood
was a necessary condition in order to effect that atonement.
Leviticus four and Leviticus five have lots of examples
of different kinds of sacrifices that the person who realizes
they've transgressed is responsible for bringing to the priest and Leviticus.
It's not the temple that the sacrifices are brought to, but the tabernacle,
the prototype of the temple, the tabernacle is kind of a portable
temple in the desert.
But then later on one would go to the temple in Jerusalem
and bring an animal sacrifice to have that final if
effecting moment of atonement.
Already in the prophetic books,
there is what is called a prophetic critique of the priesthood
that involved emphasizing that just behavior,
righteous behavior was a required element to be in right relationship to God.
It wasn't enough to just bring the animal sacrifices,
but if you brought them with dirty hands, then that wasn't good to Shiva, right?
You had to.
You had to still
bring the animal sacrifice, but you also had to change your evil ways.
When we move in to the
rabbinic period, the question then becomes, what do we do?
We can change our evil ways, but we can't bring that animal sacrifice.
The early Jewish Christians answered that problem of not having the temple
anymore through the vicarious atonement of Christ
who died on behalf of our sins.
That wasn't the option that the Rabbinic Jews took.
Let me read to you from Moses my mind at ease.
My mind at ease is someone
that will spend a whole session on when we get into the medieval period.
But he's summarizing rabbinic Judaism's approach
toward tissue VA, he says as follows
At the present time, when the temple no longer exists
and we have no altar for atonement, nothing is left but to Shiva.
To Shiva atones for all transgressions
to shuba atones for old transgressions.
One of the distinctions that we find in the Bible
but is made much clearer within rabbinic Judaism
is this idea that you've got two different kinds of transgressions.
You've got transgressions between myself and other human beings,
and you've got transgressions that happened between myself and God
where other human beings aren't involved.
The next section that I want to read is from the first product,
the first literary product of Rabbinic Judaism, a codex of Jewish law.
I called the Mishnah again in the very next section.
I know I keep saying that,
but in the very next section we'll talk about what the missioner is.
But this comes from the first, second, third century of the Common era.
Certainly post the temple,
the one who
says, I will stray, I will transgress and I will return.
I will do Tuva, I will transgress, and I will do to Shiva
that is insufficient int to effect tissue Shuba the one who says I will straight.
You're
the one who says I will stray
and Yom Kippur will atone for my transgressions.
Yom Kippur God will not atone transgressions
by humans against God for those transgressions.
Yom Kippur will atone,
but transgressions by humans against their fellow human beings.
Yom Kippur does not atone until he appeases his fellow.
Just like in the Bible, when you harm someone,
you need to make restitution in order to effect tissue via
that involved transgression with another person.
You can't just say that you're going to do to Shiva and that's it.
Or go through Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement, and that's it.
If you've wronged someone, you need to apologize.
If you stolen from one, you need to restore their lost property.
In other words, you need to you need to get closure
on the issue so that no one else is holding onto bad feelings.
The rabbis develop this idea of tissue VA
and it has incredible power for the rabbis.
The rabbis distinguished to shove off from fear,
which is on a relatively low level, and to Shiva
through love, love of God and wanting to do right
as opposed to fear of punishment that in the afterlife, if we don't do too
shiva in this world, we are going to be punished.
What the idea of the Shiva is for the rabbis is not necessarily
or not primarily a return to God, as we saw in the Hebrew Bible,
but a return to God's will as expressed through Jewish law,
so that there are specific lists of things that we're not supposed
to do and specific lists of things that we are supposed to do.
And when we violate either of those lists, whether it refers to God
or refers to other human beings in order to do to Shiva,
we don't return to God, but we write our ways.
It's about deeds rather than devotional posture or piety.
Being in the presence of God once the temple is
destroyed, it's no longer about being in God's presence.
The temple was God's address,
but for rabbinic Judaism, it's more about following God's ways
or following God's will as it is mediated no longer through a priest,
but through Jewish law, which is called Halacha.
Halacha literally means the way
like the door, the path, the way in which we walk.
And it emphasizes the idea of deeds and what people should be doing
to maintain themselves in being right in right relationship with God.
One of the statements in the Talmud
about the power of the Shiva is as follows
We're able to shuba one who is engaged in tissue by stands
a totally righteous person, by which they mean
one who is never transgressed cannot stand right.
So I can't stand there because what the bulk Shiva has gone through,
someone who's never succumbed to temptation, can't possibly know.
I don't know about her. Right.
That the person that is completely righteous and who has never transgressed
doesn't know the exhilarating thrill
of giving in, whether it's to women or
men or drugs or fill in the blank, whatever someone might
be committing their transgression with, there is a kind of zip to it.
And if the person that is completely righteous
hasn't experienced that draw or that temptation,
they according to the Talmud, they're on a lower level.
The person that has experienced that temptation and is strong enough
to know that zip that exhilaration and to overcome it, to manifest
self-restraint and self-control for the rabbis there at a higher level.
Another statement in the Talmud
by racial quiche
is that tissue that is so great
that pre-meditated transgressions are accounted
in the great ledger of your deeds
as though they were merits
that premeditated sins in the past, once that person has done to Shiva,
are counted as though they were merits.
In other words, this is transformative to Shiva is transformative
because now as someone that has gone through the process of tissue, VA,
I can benefit from that experience.
And not only am I stronger, but I can help other people
who haven't yet gone through the process of tissue.
VA I can shepherd them through the process because I've got more credibility
in their eyes than the person who is never transgressed.
And in that process of, you know, I committed a premeditated sin,
but I also then realized the error of my ways
and now through to Shiva, I'm using that experience in order to
right the wrongs that other people are committing.
It's sort of like someone who was arrested for breaking into a car.
He goes through the prison system and he repents, he atones,
and then he becomes a locksmith. Right.
And he helps the industry figure out ways to make more ingenious locks
that can't be picked.
And he's helping other people in a roundabout sort of way avoid that
profession.
So the idea of the Shiva is both
transformative and creative.
One of the great religious thinkers of the 20th century,
one of the great Jewish Talmudic figures in the 20th century, Robert Joseph Baer
Soloveitchik, said that repentance is an act of creation
of self creation.
Right.
Jean-Paul Sartre, a French existentialist, said
a similar thing that your future is virgin,
your future deeds shouldn't be predicated on your past deeds.
You always have an opportunity to recreate yourself.
I went to school in San Mateo, California,
the same little private school from fourth grade to eighth grade.
There were 13 to 18 kids in my class.
All the kids in my eighth grade class when they graduated from this junior
high school,
they went to other private schools or Catholic schools that I didn't go to,
but I was the only one that went to my public high school,
and it was a chance for me to reinvent myself.
Nobody knew what kind of kid I had been.
From fourth to eighth grade, I had a blank slate.
My future was virgin, and it was this incredibly powerful moment
where I didn't have any baggage and I could make my future
fresh from the ground up. Right?
That's the idea of recreating yourself and the liturgy.
Jewish liturgy every morning says that God recreates nature every day anew.
So just like God recreates the world on a daily basis, we have that power.
So often we get stuck in inertia
and in our same patterns and in a rut rather than in a groove.
And we don't take advantage of that opportunity to recreate ourselves.
But the Jewish tradition and the emphasis on tissue emphasizes that as an ideal.
An ideal possibility.
Okay, now let's move into
the medieval period and we have a code of law by Moses.
My mind at ease.
He wrote this in 1180 and he asks the question, what defines tissue?
But his answer, when the string one leaves his error.
Right, you've got it right.
Stop doing it and removes it from his thoughts.
You don't even think about doing it and resolves
in his heart never to repeat it
resolves in his heart. Right?
I'm not going to do this ever, ever again.
He needs to make all confession
and say that these matters are finished from his heart.
It's important that it's oral.
We need to hear ourselves say it to have maximum impact.
It's not just about thinking it, but it's saying it out loud.
Does it have to be to somebody else? Oral confession.
No, You can say it out loud to yourself in a sealed room,
but you have to hear yourself articulate the words because words have power.
God created the world through words, through speech.
According to Genesis one
and for the rabbinic tradition, words are very powerful.
We need to hear those words that we are leaving this forever.
He needs to make
oral confession and say that these matters are finished from his heart.
So we've got those conditions that let you know that right.
That person has done tissue.
But then there's a second condition.
My mind at ease goes on to say, One knows that one has successfully accomplished
tissue by when he's in the same situation where he'd previously transgressed
and there is no fear of being caught
or lack of power to commit the transgression.
And he refrains from transgressing. Right.
When you're in the same situation that you had previously gone astray
and you're not worried about getting caught,
and you're not worried that that you don't have the power,
you might not be able to go through with it
and you still refrain from doing it, then you know that you are successful
penitent or tissue of someone who has gone through that process
in the modern period.
The idea of the Shiva of return gets additional ideas.
It's no longer only about returning to God's will, as expressed
through Jewish law, through the Halacha, for instance,
there is a Zionist pioneer by the name of all of Adi
Gordon, all of Dullard Gordon, who left Eastern Europe
when he was a mature man in his late forties or early fifties
and went to Palestine in order to help rebuild the land of Israel
in the early 20th century and he also was very concerned
about the Jewish alienation from the soil because of the way
Jewish history unfolded in certain church laws and certain
prudent vocations the Jews went into.
Jews tended not to be farmers or agronomists,
but Adi Gordon felt as though the Jews needed to return to nature, right,
Not only in terms of returning to those occupations
that the biblical patriarchs engaged in shepherds and farmers,
but also in terms of having that sense of linkage to the earth
and to another one of God's creations,
that that needed to be healed, that rupture of alienation
between the individual and nature in the soil needed to be healed.
He did that in the land of Israel, and he talks about the tissue
or the sense of returning to nature.
Other were all affected.
Gordon wasn't particularly religious, but there were other early
religious Zionists who folded in the notion of return to Shiva
to the land of Israel as part of Discover.
So it's now not only about returning to God's will, but it's returning to nature.
It's returning to the land of Israel, which at that point was called Palestine.
All of these ideas get conflated in the concept or the term of tissue.
Var By the beginning of the 20th century
there is a relat, tively
long quote by Roth Avraham Cooke.
Roth Cooke was the first Chief Rabbi
of Palestine, the first Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi of Palestine.
He wrote this actually during World War One, when he was trapped in Switzerland.
Not a bad place to be trapped, actually, if you're going to be trapped.
But he was traveling away
from the land of Israel during World War One and he couldn't get back.
So he spent the years of World War One in Switzerland,
and he wrote a kind of mystical diary.
Ron Cooke is known for very poetic, mystical language.
He writes as follows
When one forgets the essence of one soul,
when one distracts his mind from attending to the substantive
content of his own inner life, everything becomes dark and uncertain.
The primary role of the Shiva,
which at once sheds light on the darkened zone, is for the person
to return to himself, to the root of his soul.
Then he will at once return to God
the soul of all souls.
It is only through the great truth of returning to one's self
that the person and the people
community, so the whole society,
the world and all the worlds, the whole of existence
will return to their creator to be illumined by the light of life.
This is the mystical meaning of the light of the Messiah,
the manifestation of the soul of the universe
by whose illumination the world will return to the source of its being
in very beautiful language.
What Robb Cooke has done is wrapped in all those
previously historical sensitive to Shiva in a mystical way.
So not only are we returning to our self and to God, going back to that biblical
idea of returning to God, the soul of all souls, once we return to our soul.
But the hope the person and the people, the people return
to the land of Israel and then all of creation returns.
We have to return to creation, to nature, all of the old Gordon's idea
and then all of that.
This is the mystical innovation.
All of that returns to God, right.
In recognition that all of us are part and parcel of the divine reality.
And once we change our consciousness
by changing our deeds, doing too
Shiva is just the the first step in
having a different kind of view of reality
so that we expand our consciousness,
expand our consciousness to perceive the divinity in all reality.
That's what defines redemption
or the messianic light, the Messianic era for Rav Cooke.
So what has he done?
He's gone back to this biblical idea of linking to Shiva and redemption.
We start with King David in the Bible, and what I've cooked now takes
3000 years of Jewish thought and Jewish history,
including Zionism, and wraps it back into his understanding
of the power, the transformative force of tissue of
Rabbi Joni Mitchell
said, We are stardust, we are golden,
and we have to get ourselves back to the garden.
We are stardust,
we are golden, and we have to get ourselves back to the garden, right?
I don't know if she was reading Roth Cooke, but perhaps he was.
Perhaps he is translated into English.
We are stardust.
We are connected to the world, to nature,
and we've got to get ourselves back to the garden.
Right? Is it the garden of goodness?
Is it the Garden of Eden?
We need to get back to being in right?
Relationship to God.
Okay, so as a 30 something
Jewish studies person, right?
I hear Joni Mitchell when I read the Garden of Eden story,
but because I'm a Jewish studies person, I also hear the Garden of Eden story.
And in the Garden of Eden story, it says in Genesis chapter three, verse 24
that God drove
the man out from the Garden of Eden as a result of the transgression
and stationed east of the Garden of Eden, the cherubim, these angels
and the fiery ever turning sword all right,
going back and forth to guard the way to the Tree of Life.
So I would say that my academic colleagues at Vanderbilt
Bible studies, people would say that the cherubim, those angels
that have that fiery ever turning sword, are there in order to prevent human beings
from getting back to the garden and eating from the tree of life.
Because then we will have eaten from the tree of life
and from the tree of knowledge of good and evil.
And God, for some reason, doesn't want us to taste both of those.
So that was apparently the reason
why we were exiled from the Garden of Eden to begin with.
But there is a rabbinic interpretation that those fiery, ever returning swords
aren't there to protect the tree from us returning.
But they're to alert us, right?
The verse says, to guard the way to the Tree of Life.
Well, it doesn't have to be about preventing human beings from getting back,
but letting people know that this is where the tree of life is.
Right?
This is the sign, this is the flag, this is the symbol.
So perhaps that is not the contextual meaning,
but it is one rabbinic understanding of of
how we know where to look for the garden, that fiery every turning sword
and the light of that flaming sword.
I would suggest that's always present to lead us back to the garden
is to Shiva to return us to that garden.
So we've taken an opportunity now to look at one of the central
values and virtues and ideals of rabbinic Judaism, namely to Shiva.
This idea of return.
In our next lecture, we're going to look at the central activity
of rabbinic Judaism, which is Talmud Torah.
One way to actually help you engage in the process of tissue
by to know what to do and what not to do is tell mature the study of Torah.
So that's where we will be turning to next.
Thank you.
Welcome back to lecture four of the Introductory Judaism course,
which is on Talmud Torah or studying learning.
Actually, the definition of Talmud Torah is very
cute because Talmud
means learning or studying, and Torah means teaching.
So tell me Torah, it can be translated as learning teaching, right?
But it's the idea of study
and it turns out to be the central commandment or mitzvah.
In rabbinic Judaism,
we already have the idea within the Torah itself, within the Pentateuch itself,
of speaking about these words day and night that is familiar to some Jews,
because it is enshrined in the liturgy of the Shamma.
Schmear comes from the first word of Deuteronomy six four here
Israel smile means listen up, hearken here it is real.
The Lord, our God, the Lord is one
You shall love the Lord our God with all of our heart, soul,
and it should probably be translated as property.
It's usually translated as might.
And you shall speak about these words, probably referring back to the Decalogue
that had been given in Deuteronomy Chapter five.
But rabbinic tradition accepts those those words as all of the Torah.
You shall speak about those words
all the time when you're walking along the way,
when you're sitting in your house,
when you lie down at night, when you rise up in the morning.
So the idea of speaking of the words, the going over the repetition
of God's words or God's ways, God's midst votes, the plural of mitzvot,
God's commandments is already enshrined in the Torah itself,
at least according to the rabbinic rereading of the Torah.
We also have some 119, which is a pean
to the idea of loving Torah, of talking about Torah all the time.
What do we have here?
From verse 97 to 98, somewhere 19 is a very long psalm.
how I love your teaching.
Teaching is Torah.
how I love your teaching.
It is my study all day long.
Your commandments make me wiser than my enemies.
They always stand by me.
They always stand by me.
So all of Psalm 119, all hundred and however many verses
it is, it's actually the in acrostic, the Hebrew alphabet has 22 letters
and it repeats that Hebrew alphabet four times going A through Z,
all of three Toth four times.
And so you've got this big long psalm that's all about how wonderful
the Torah is.
So even within the two, not itself, the Torah and studying the Torah,
relating to it as a source of wisdom and commandments to guide
your life, are promoted.
By the time we get to the rabbinic period
after the temple has been destroyed, the value of Talmud Torah shoots up
because so many other values drop off the radar screen.
Because once the temple has been destroyed,
all of those priestly functions are no longer obtainable.
And anything that you would do in the temple, you can no longer do so.
The value of studying the Torah as a way of communicating, communing
with God and knowing the divine mind
is characteristic of rabbinic Judaism.
That one of the
statements that gets at the central city of Talmud
Torah, is by Shimon the Righteous,
Shimon Hassidic, who says that the world stands on
three things on Torah, on worship, and on acts of love and kindness.
So I took that statement by Shimon the Righteous
for this lecture and our next two lectures.
So this lecture is dedicated to the world standing on Torah
that does he mean that the world really stands, that it's that the world
is resting on a pillar, a tripod, and that one leg of that tripod is Torah.
And if people were to stop studying Torah, then
the world could no longer be held up or maintained.
I think there's a sense in which he does mean that we have a rabbinic statement
that says without Torah,
the world would sink back
into the watery chaos of the beginning,
the watery chaos of the beginning,
and the first verses of the Hebrew Bible
in the King James translation say something like In the beginning,
God created the heaven and the earth and the Earth looked like this.
The earth was formless and void.
The idea, the picture that you get from the King
James translation is when the curtain goes up on the
on the stage of creation, there's the stage is black.
There's nothing there.
Boom.
God creates
heaven and earth and heaven and earth are in this inchoate, incipient form.
And God orders the creation. God orders.
God takes chaos and moves it towards cosmos chaos to order.
But the Hebrews suggests something else.
And so the new Jewish Publication Society translation of the Tanakh has as follows
When God began creating the heavens and the Earth,
the Earth was formless and void.
What's the difference when the curtain goes up on the screen of creation there
on the screen, on that stage of creation,
what you're seeing is this kind of watery, chaotic swirl already there.
And God takes those elements that existed
before the curtain went up and orders that.
So what the rabbis here are saying and the rabbis were okay with that idea
that God took pre existent matter
and made a kind of divine order
out of that pre existent chaos.
By the time we get to the Middle Ages, they have problems with that idea.
But the rabbis in the rabbinic period from the first century
to the seventh century say they were fine with that idea.
But, but what they say about Torah is that without Torah
the world would revert to this watery, primeval chaos.
I think the idea there is actually fairly easy to understand,
namely that without laws to govern our society,
we would revert to a state of nature that the rabbis understand,
much like Thomas Hobbes understood was nasty, short and brutish,
and that things would become complete anarchy and complete chaos
without the laws that the Torah gives us to organize our societies and our lives.
It's more,
though, Talmud Torah, than about ordering your life.
It's also where to find God.
God's exclusive address in the post Temple Reality
Divine Access is now available only through the study of God's Word.
For my undergraduates, I do a little skit called Theocracy Geography.
B My wife doesn't like the term because she thinks
it should be about theology and writing graffiti.
But the way I'm using the term geography, it's about theology and geography.
So the question is where to find God.
If you think about the early books of the Hebrew Bible in this
Theia graphic skit that I'm going to now lay out for you,
the way you find God, the place you find God is in nature.
Walking through the Garden of Eden in the breezy time of the day and in history,
God appears to Abraham, God appears to Moses in the form of a burning bush.
Right?
That's where you encounter God in this world, in nature or in history.
God leads the Israelites out of eat, out of Egypt with a strong hand.
By the time we get into the middle books of the Hebrew Bible,
God's presence is accessed no longer
in nature, in history, but in the tabernacle,
which then becomes the prototype for the temple in Jerusalem.
So once we get into the land of Israel, the place that you go
to access the divine presence is the temple in Jerusalem.
Once the temple is destroyed, where do you go to get God's presence?
How do you access that?
So the rabbinic answer was the only the closest thing to God that we have is
God's will as represented in the Torah, in the five books of Moses.
And what is so nice about the Torah is that God can be access to the Torah.
24 seven It's not like you need a priestly intermediary
anymore at the temple to get to God.
Anybody
in this kind of democratization of piety,
anyone can access the Torah.
Moreover, it doesn't matter who your momma was or who your daddy was.
In order to be a priest, you had to be of the priestly line,
which was one of Aaron's grandsons, like Phineas or Pinchas,
in order to have that position of power and prestige
and influence in the community, it was pedigree.
But now anyone in this move toward democratization
who has the intellectual power of mastering the traditions of the Torah,
they can establish themselves as the pious, as the leaders,
and also as the ones that represent a kind of purity,
both in terms of ritual purity that the Pharisees
emphasized and moral purity that the rabbis emphasized.
So we see this democratization process of the leadership in the Jewish community
as a result of the destruction of the temple right.
Some Jews say, thank God the Romans destroyed the temple
because it allowed rabbinic Judaism to emerge in ways that are much more in
keeping with modern Jewish sensibilities of a more egalitarian access.
Women could study Torah, but we don't have too many.
We have a few, but we don't have too many.
We don't have too many examples in rabbinic history of women actually
being literate at all or mastering the traditions of the Torah.
One statement by
the rabbis in the Talmud is as follows
Rabbi here
Barber says, I'm sorry, Rabbi, here on me.
The son of Ami said,
Since the day the temple was destroyed, the Holy one has in this world
nothing other than the four cubits or arm
lengths of the Halacha of Jewish law.
In other words, you access God.
Now that the temple is destroyed, you access God through the Halacha.
I view this statement personally
as sad, but the way you access God is through Jewish law.
And there were Jewish
there were
people that disagreed with that statement when it was said in the rabbinic period.
And there were movements in Judaism in the Middle Ages
and in the early modern period and in the modern period
that were dedicated to finding God outside of the Halacha as well.
But we see that one prominent posture
of how to get to God is through not just Torah
and all the stories that we have, but the Halacha through Jewish law.
So telling the Torah
is a function of intelligence and discipline that's open to everyone.
And some of the rabbis anyway, emphasized the halachic
or the legal aspects of Torah as the way
to commune with God and translate
God's will into the realities of the present political
and social structure of the Jewish community.
Now, there's also an aspect
of Talmud Torah that is very erotic,
and many rabbis talk about wishing they had two mouths
so that they could talk Torah all day long with one mouth
and then with the other mouth when they needed to conduct their business
affairs, their private affairs, their personal affairs,
they would still have access to that.
There's something about Talmud Torah, and I speak from personal experience
here, having been in the Shiva world for a few years in Jerusalem,
in the seminar
in the world of Jewish seminary, there's something that's addicting and
obsessive about
it, where once you get into this mode, into this
not right, but into this groove of studying Torah,
you just want to keep doing it and keep doing it and keep doing it
at the exclusion of all the other things that we should be doing.
The Rabbinic Judaism commands us to be doing.
So one of the we know that this was a problem
for the early rabbis because so many rabbinic statements
are dedicated to saying don't neglect your other responsibilities.
Well, they wouldn't need to say don't neglect your other responsibilities
unless people were neglecting their other responsibilities.
So for instance, there's a statement in Pakeha votes,
which is part of the mission.
It's an appendix of the missioner, which we'll talk about in the next section
that says Talmud Torah should be combined with worldly concerns
and that someone that just does study but doesn't translate that into practice.
It's as if they have no God.
Harsh words. The rabbi is very
hyperbolic.
They used exaggeration whenever they wrote a God like statements.
I get duh.
We talked about halacha as Jewish law and God is everything else I get.
That literally means telling or recounting,
and the exotic sections of rabbinic literature
can deal with theology or folklore is or magic what we would call
superstition stories about the rabbis and the disciples.
Anything that doesn't specifically have to do with the Jewish law is called agenda.
And in the agenda, the rabbis were very freewheeling about,
you know, someone that just studies Torah and doesn't engage in worldly pursuits
is as if they have no God's sight, very dramatic
and bold in their language.
So there was this kind of passionate love affair
that many of the rabbis had to the Torah,
and they had to be reminded not to neglect worldly concerns.
But there was also a sense that the goal of Talmud Torah wasn't
just to commune with God, but should also be transformative.
There's a lovely passage
that says
that the Torah has 613 commandments.
We mention that number 613, which is divided into 365 negative commandments.
You shall not commit murder, you shall not commit adultery
and 248 positive commandments.
Remember the Sabbath day
or eat Mott's unleavened bread on Passover.
And in the Talmud itself, it links those numbers.
365 and 248
to the 365 days of the solar year
and the 248
parts of the human body.
Now, there are about 365 days in a solar year.
I've asked my medical friends if they know of the number 248,
and they said, you know, that's a stretch.
But the idea behind the midrash of 365 days
and 248 parts of the body,
is that what studying Torah should be
is this transformative experience of making our entire body
reflect the will of God
all the time, every moment of every day.
We should be walking pause with our entire body all of the time.
This may be and I say this speculatively,
this may be a little bit of a polemic with Christianity, where in Christianity
you've got Jesus who is the embodiment of God, one person.
Whereas the ideal for rabbinic Judaism is that all Jews,
all rabbinic Jews, should not be the embodiment of God,
but the embodiment of God's will, as expressed through the Torah.
Okay, now we're going to move from talking about the central
leaning importance of the mitzva of Talmud Torah to a brief
description of some of the books on the rabbinic bookshelf.
Again, rabbinic literature.
Let's let's push it way back.
The source is for rabbinic literature may start
in the first or even second century BCE
and probably go till the seventh eighth century of the common Era.
The books themselves begin in the third century,
but a third century book that was redacted and edited
and didn't really have two covers, but it was sealed.
It has a beginning and an end.
A third century book may have traditions
that are several centuries older than the book itself.
The first literary production
of rabbinic Judaism that I want to talk about is the Mishnah.
The Mishnah literally means repetition because you repeat when you learn
something, you do it by repeating it over and over, through memorization, right?
You have to remember that we're talking about 2000 years ago
when they didn't have computer texts, computers at all.
And the process of learning in an oral culture was through the repetition.
The mission is a codex of Jewish law that was compiled by Yehuda
Hennessy or due to the prince around the year 220 of the Common Era.
Judah, the Prince, the person who redacted this text
was the leader, both in a religious sense and in a political sense
of that community of Jews that was still in the land of Israel.
The mission is a codex of Jewish law, and it's not a law book.
What's the difference?
A law book has The law is it tells you what to do X, Y, and Z.
What's distinctive about the Mishnah is that it retains
minority opinions and dissenting opinions every once in a while.
It also throws in some stories, but very infrequently
the mission is much more halachic than a gothic.
Okay, the Mishnah
retains
these minority opinions and dissenting opinions
because it says explicitly that maybe sometime in the future
there may arise a court whose justices are
intelligent and have greater intelligence than they are
and of greater number than they are, perhaps, And they'll want to rely
on the minority opinions or even on the dissenting opinions,
because as tradition, as historic, will circumstances change?
Sometimes laws also need to change
in order to address the needs of that present population.
The mission itself is arranged conceptually,
unlike the appearance of many of the laws throughout the Torah,
so that you've got six orders of the Mishnah,
There's a song that is sung after the Passover Seder, one who knows,
and it goes through one, two, three, four, all the way up to 13,
apparently this started out as a wedding song, as a drinking song.
And so people would go around the table and say, okay, I've got the number one.
There's one guy, okay, the next person has two.
Okay, There are two tablets, right?
In the Decalogue, you've got two tablets.
And the person that couldn't think of the next number would have to drink.
So when they got
to six, it was the six orders of the Mishnah.
They have to do with sacrificial issues in the temple.
Purity issues, criminal law laws related to women,
what laws related to agriculture and laws related to the holidays.
So those are the six general divisions of the Mishnah when the law is
in, the Mishnah are recorded, they're not usually recorded
with the biblical verse that justifies the law.
So we call this unjustified ID law doesn't mean that there is no reason.
It just means that there is no reason that is attached to the mission itself.
The mission just tells you what to do and what it tells you what to do,
and then it tells you what the other rabbi who disagrees with the first rabbi,
which is very common, right, suggests you should do instead
around 250.
There was an appendix to the Mishnah that was
put at the end of the fourth Division, which was about criminal law torts.
If the very conclusion you've got this section called a vote
or the father is the founders, Abba is father in Hebrew,
in Aramaic, actually, and a vote in Hebrew is fathers.
That section called fathers or founders
is exclusively agnostic.
That statement that I started with at the beginning, that's.
SIMON Shimon, the righteous one said that the world stands on
three things on Torah, on worship, and on acts of loving kindness.
That is, again, dot found in, per quote, the chapters of our Fathers
that served a vote served
as a kind of introduction to the Mishnah, the mission that just presents the laws.
But it doesn't give you any justification
for the authority of the rabbis to be promoting those laws.
So the way that a vote opens up
is by saying that Moses received the Torah.
And here they mean the oral Torah, what's being included in the Mishnah.
So Moses received that Torah at Mt.
Sinai, and Moses transmitted it to Joshua and Joshua
transmitted it to Pallone, and Pallone transmitted it to our Moni, Right.
Joe Schmo.
Pallone Moni is Joe Schmo in Hebrew?
And eventually it came down to site
Shimon the righteous one, and then to Hillel,
who will talk about at some point in our in our lecture and Ramban
Shimon Ben Gamliel and the rabbis who make up rabbinic Judaism.
So there is an unbroken chain of tradition from Sinai
all the way down to rabbinic Jews that provides the authority
for their interpretation of the Torah
about things that seem to not sit quite so well with a plain sense
reading of the Torah, as well as issues that the Torah doesn't even talk about.
For instance, the Torah doesn't talk about how to kill an animal
according to the laws of keeping kosher or kashrut.
So if you need to write, we know that we're only supposed
to eat certain kinds of animals.
Well, you have to eat them once they're dead
and once the blood has been drained out to them.
How do you do it?
That information is found in the Mishnah.
It fills in the spaces where the Bible doesn't
seem to be so interested in giving you,
in fleshing out the details, fleshing out, so to speak.
Okay, so the Hebrew Bible is relatively small.
The mission is much bigger, much bigger.
And what the function of for a vote is, is to link this idea of the oral
Torah back to the same source and divine authority as the written Torah
in hoary antiquity at Mt.
Sinai.
When the Israelites left Egypt,
the Mishnah,
the mission is that first layer, and it was the curriculum
that students who were studying to become masters of the tradition first learned.
But in the process of learning the mission, new questions came up,
new ways of looking at the law or looking at the text came up,
and those conversations about how to understand the mission
and why this law
is authoritative and what biblical verse does this law stemmed from.
Those conversations were recorded and later
edited into what is called the Gomorrah.
The Gomorrah is an Aramaic word that means learning.
Mishnah is a Hebrew word. That means learning.
Gomorrah is an Aramaic word, which was the common language
of the land of Israel for hundreds and hundreds of years during this period.
It also means learning The mission of plus the Gomorrah equals the Talmud.
The Talmud is a big bookshelf of the Mishnah at its base,
and then conversations that start about the Mishnah,
but then go off in a kind of stream of consciousness, stream of consciousness
way to all kinds of different ideas and different topics.
For instance, if we have a law in the Mishnah
about how to slit an animal from the front
so that it bleeds quickly and not from the back, you can then go
the Gomorrah might then ask, okay, well, what biblical verse does this come from?
So Rabbi Yossi says, It comes from the biblical verse, such and such.
but Rabbi Yehuda disagrees.
Okay. And then we'll resolve that problem.
And since we introduced Rabbi Yehuda, you know what, Rabbi Yehuda was known
for wearing pink and purple on the Sabbath for these reasons.
So then we'll go into a whole series of traditions
about what these individual rabbis did on the Sabbath.
That's totally idiosyncratic and has nothing to do with the laws
of where to slice an animal's throat in order for kosher butchering.
So it's this kind of stream of consciousness, unique literature,
and that's part of the reason why it's so engrossing.
It pulls you in because you want to know where it's going to go
because you can't ever see around the corner in a Talmudic
suja or Talmudic passage.
There are two guimaras
There were two
sets of conversations that happened around the Mishna.
One set of conversations happened in the land of Israel,
probably in Tiberius and in northern Israel,
but that Gomorrah is called, or that Talmud is called that.
You show me the Jerusalem Talmud and it's called the Jerusalem Talmud
because of the centrality and importance
and holiness of Jerusalem to the entire Jewish people.
So there's the Jerusalem Talmud.
But the more authoritative Talmud, for purposes of deciding
the halacha was created in Babylonia
after the Great Revolt in 78.
There were many Jews that left the land of Israel,
and even more so 70 years later.
When we talk about messianism, we're going to talk about the bar Kokhba Revolt.
The Bar Kokhba revolt happened.
It started in 132, about 62 years after the destruction
of the second temple, because about 60 years after
there was this notion that just like 70 years after
the first temple had been destroyed, it was rebuilt.
So to God will somehow create a situation
where 70 years after the second temple, the third Temple will be rebuilt.
And so one
a few
rabbis, but one particularly prominent rabbi, Rabbi Akiba, supported Bar Kokhba
as as a messiah, as the person to militarily lead
the Jews against the Roman occupation didn't work out so well,
and as a result of this failed revolt, the bar
kokhba revolt from 132 to 135, even more Jews left the land of Israel
and emigrated to the Jewish community in Babylonia that had been there
since the destruction of the first temple and the exile,
the Babylonian exile already back in the sixth century BCE.
So there was a long Babylonian, a long standing Babylonian community, by the way.
It was at that point during the bar Kokhba revolt that the Romans got so fed up
with the Jews that they decided to change the name of the land of Israel
in Judea to echo the Israelites, ancient enemies, the Philistines.
That's how that landmass got the name Palestine.
City of Palestina is what the Romans called it, just to upset,
to erase any trace of a Jewish presence and to kind of dig it into the Jews.
They were naming it
after the biblical Israelites, ancient enemies, the Philistines.
So you've got the Jerusalem Talmud
and the Babylonian Talmud.
In terms of quantity,
my thumbnail represents the amount of quality
of the amount of quantity of the Mishnah and the rest of my wingspan is Gomorrah.
There's much, much, much, much, much more Gomorrah than there is to the Mishnah.
The mission I can hold in my hand.
Okay, it's bigger than the Hebrew Bible, but I can still hold it in my hand.
I'm not nearly big enough or strong enough to hold the entire Talmud.
There's one final genre of literature that typifies
what the rabbis were doing in this period, and that is called midrash.
The word midrash means to seek or inquire the first person in the Hebrew Bible
to engage in this process of seeking or inquiring or drawing is Rebecca
Isaac's wife, Rebecca Desroches. God.
And the rabbis subsequently dropped God's word.
They no longer can go to the temple or can go to Oracles,
as perhaps Rebecca did, and go immediately to the source to God.
So the rabbis take this activity and apply it not to God, but to gods.
Text the Torah.
A midrash is an idea linked to a biblical verse.
Actually, my own theory is that midrash also relates to the word to weave.
In the last chapter of proverbs, we have the the phrase Darkseid,
Samuel fish, Tim the righteous woman, the the the wife of valor.
She weaves together or she draws wool and flax.
And I think what a midrash is, is weaving the text of the Torah
to in up to a current idea that you want to
then communicate to your own to your own congregation.
Midrash compilations are usually categorized as either halachic or exotic.
The earliest halachic compilations
come from the land of Israel in the third century.
The exotic compilations also come from the land of Israel,
but they're dated to the fifth century Midrash compilations.
Unlike the Mishna, they're arranged according to the biblical verses
upon which they comment.
So if you're trying to do a sermon on a particular chapter
of the Torah, it's easy to find it in midrash because it goes
according to what comes before and what comes after in the Tanakh.
It's very difficult to find anything in the Mishnah.
You have to know conceptually where it falls.
We will
continue with our next lecture on the second of the tripod of Shimon,
of Shimon, the Righteous tripod of the things that the world stands on.
On worship.
Thank you.
Hi. Welcome back.
We are now going to be looking at the second of Shimoni,
the righteous tripod of what the world stands on.
The first leg of the tripod was Torah.
And so we talked about how the Torah, the study of Torah.
Last session Now we're going to be talking about Alvo Dah,
which should properly be translated as worship or service.
But we're really going to be talking about prayer and the development of prayer
from the biblical period to the rabbinic period.
Looking at some modern reformulations
of prayers in the 19th and 20th century as well.
And in between, we'll talk about the rise of the prayer house or the synagogue.
The reason why I
said the prayer that Abu Dei should really be translated
as worship or service is because in the Bible, Aboagye
is almost always referring to animal sacrifice.
The animal sacrifices that happened either in the tabernacle,
according to the first
five books of the Bible or later on in the temple in Jerusalem.
But there is one verse in Deuteronomy
that talks about the worship of the heart.
So we're not talking about open heart surgery here.
So the rabbi is understand that worship of the heart must be talking
about something other than animal sacrifice.
Therefore, it's talking about prayer.
So although there's that one portion of the Torah that talks
that seems to be referring to worship of the heart
as opposed to sacrificial worship generally in the Hebrew Bible,
that term of Adar refers to worship, sacrificial worship.
But that doesn't mean that the idea of prayer isn't widespread in the Torah.
Indeed, it is. Very frequently in the Bible
we have prayer that involves a request or a petition.
For instance, we have a motif throughout the Hebrew Bible of the women
being barren and needing to pray to God in order to open up their womb.
In the first instance that I'm going to mention, Isaac, who's married to Rebecca,
sees that Rebecca is barren and pleads
with God to open up his wife's womb, a nice thing for a husband to do.
He steps up to the plate and praise to God for his wife.
We also see that Moses prays for his sister
Miriam, when she is afflicted with some kind of strange,
strange disease, and he prays for her full healing.
I don't want to give you the impression that only men
in the Hebrew Bible pray hand in first.
Samuel also prays she's another barren woman
to continue this motif, and she prays for a child.
And she says that if she gets this child, she will dedicate it to the Lord
and hand his child actually becomes the first prophet.
Samuel.
Other prayers in the
Hebrew Bible aren't specifically about petition,
but they're about praising God and God's work.
For instance, some 92 begins.
It is good to praise the Lord to sing hymns to your name almost high.
So it's a song of celebration.
Many of the Psalms originally were set to music
and they still have musical notations in them, like Sela.
Sela is a popular word.
It's also a not uncommon name
for girls that usually not stellar.
Sela And the idea of the musical notation has been lost.
We know that it had something to do with conducting the music,
but we don't know exactly what it means.
Other songs are for individual worship,
like,
I am in distress, or what is good for me to praise you
and your works and the mountain should sing and the hills
should leap in order to acclaim God's greatness.
Other songs seem to clearly be communal, where it's the entire community
like Psalm 105, for instance, that is singing God's praises.
There's also a series
of Psalms Psalm 122 134 that begins with the Super Scripture,
and it begins with the first few words Share a lot, a song of a sense.
Now, this is very interesting because what scholars speculate
is that the Levites would stand on the steps of the temple
and there were 15 steps and you have 15 psalms
that begin with that super scripture in a song of a sense.
So they would stand on the steps, not exactly like the Mormon
Tabernacle Choir, but sort of like the Israelite temple Choir.
And they would sing.
And in many cases the singing would be communal or antiphonal.
So they would sing a verse.
And then the congregants in the courtyard, the Israelites in the courtyard,
would then sing back, a reframe, a refrain.
And so we see this in, say, Psalm 136, where you've got different verses,
and then the refrain is for God's kili olam hasto for God's mercy is everlasting.
One of
the interesting things about the rise of synagogue's synagogue is a Greek word
that means a house of worship or a house, not a house of worship.
A house of assembly, house of gathering
is that we see the rise of the first synagogues
already in Egypt in the third century BCE, that these buildings seem to have been
more prevalent in the diaspora outside of the land of Israel
than inside the land of Israel until about the third century.
By the third century, you have synagogues all over the land of Israel as well.
The earliest synagogues were communal, communal
meeting houses in addition to prayer houses.
So they filled all kinds of community needs.
Now, this is important because as synagogues develop
before the temple is destroyed, they're not necessarily challenging
the exclusive centralization of worship in Jerusalem, at least those synagogues
that we see in the land of Israel, outside the land of Israel.
You certainly have more prayers happening in the synagogues
because they simply don't have the kind of
convenient access to the temple in Jerusalem
that the folks who were living in the land of Israel have.
One of the things that's also interesting about the synagogues
is that we have pretty good evidence that the Pharisees who, as I said before,
were the most popular of the sects of late Second Temple Judaism,
weren't involved in the leadership of the synagogues.
And then after the temple was destroyed, the rabbis also were not involved
in the leadership of the early synagogues.
Why do we know this?
Because contemporary archeologists in their digs, in these sites,
both in the land of Israel
and outside the land of Israel, have found gorgeous mosaics
of representational art in the synagogues,
including depictions of biblical scenes like Abraham
sacrificing his son, Isaac, not quite sacrificing, but
excuse me, but having the knife in his hand,
as well as constellations
and different kinds of astrological representations.
In the synagogue itself, we know that the Pharisees and the rabbis
would have been uncomfortable with that because of their commitment
to a rather strict interpretation of one of the commandments
in the Decalogue, which prohibits representational art.
So whoever was the leadership of these synagogues
in the land of Israel and outside the land of Israel must have been
at least strong enough to override that Pharisee a concern.
One interesting note is that also that
the constructions of the synagogue
don't suggest that there was any separate seating for women.
And we have names of women
who were actually leaders of their congregations.
Now, we know from the Talmud that the rabbis had some problems
with women leading services, although technically there there isn't a problem.
But on the practical level, there would be some problems.
And that has continued into orthodoxy under this day where women don't
participate in the leadership roles during the prayer service itself.
But we find
in the earliest synagogues that women.
There certainly isn't a separate women's section.
So one piece of speculation is that women might not have been there at all.
I doubt that, but it's always a possibility.
And certainly there were some women
who were leaders within their own synagogue communities
as the temple is destroyed.
What we have at Job and I remember Yavne is where Rabbi and Yohanan Ben
Zaki was spirited out from the burning city of Jerusalem, too,
and he established that first academy at Yavne.
What they did it yavne was to create a kind of template
of what each prayer service should contain. Up
until that point, prayer was spontaneous and it was individual,
and it had to do with whatever spoke
to the individual, pray or at that moment, whether it was praise
or whether it was petition or whether it was Thanksgiving.
Right after having done really well on an exam.
You want to give thanks to the Lord because after all, you would pray to do
really well in your petition to prepare before you took the exam.
So what
the sages of Yavne it did was to fix a general order for the central prayer,
which is called the Amida, the only literally means of standing up.
And Jews say this prayer in in a standing posture.
And the first prayer book
that we really know about comes at the earliest in the eighth century,
probably the ninth century of the common era.
So what the prayer book has are not just a fixed order of the prayers,
but actually fixed words for each blessing
in the in the Army in that central prayer.
There are 19 different blessings.
And we'll talk about what some of those blessings are in just a moment.
But at the very earliest stage of prayer development in Yavne,
if there wasn't that fixed formula for each blessing,
but just a general sequence of how the prayers should unfold, how
about
DAH worship had generally been performed
through the sacrificial system during temple times, as I mentioned,
but worship of the heart was interpreted by the rabbis to mean prayer.
Now, the rabbis in the Talmud dispute whether or not
the prayer services were instituted by the patriarch
or as a replacement to the now defunct sacrificial system.
Right.
And there they present arguments on both sides.
Abraham instituted the morning service and Isaac instituted
the afternoon service, and Jacob instituted the evening service.
And they say no note.
Or the other side of the argument says, No, no, no, no, no.
There's a morning service and an afternoon service that involved animal sacrifices.
And prayer is just coming to substitute for that.
Their conclusion is very interesting because what
they're not really arguing about history.
The rabbis in the Talmud, right.
They're not so plugged into history.
That's not what motivates them.
They're arguing about whether or not prayer
is personal, individual and spontaneous.
Right.
Coming from the patriarchs or whether like the sacrifices
their communal and institutionalized
their answer in a way, is both.
But they claim that prayer was originated by the patriarchs.
So the ideal for prayer is to be personal, spontaneous, individual.
But then it was instituted, nationalized in order
to correspond to the sacrifices in the temple
as a memory, as a reminder of those sacrifices in the temple.
So it's
important as we move into that medieval period,
in the modern period, to remember that the ideal kind of prayer
for the rabbis was indeed coming from the pray or his heart,
rather than something that was found to be
in a fixed text in the prayer book.
Okay.
If we open up the traditional Orthodox prayer book today
that goes back to the eighth century, that first prayer book that we talked about.
And those ideas themselves go back to the Talmud.
One of the first things
that we see in the morning service is a description of creation.
And there is a repeated line
that God daily renews creation.
God daily renews creation.
Now, if you think back to Genesis one, Genesis
one presents the creation of the world as a fait accompli.
God created the world in six days.
On the seventh day, God rested and that was it.
Creation was historical.
But for the rabbis, for the poets of the liturgy,
creation is ongoing because what the poet is trying to get
the creator to buy into
is this idea that God's providence and activity in the world
is not merely historical, but it's ongoing.
And so by saying that God daily renews creation, we're supposed to see the sun
rising in the morning and reflect on God's creation of the sun
at that moment in order to feel closer to God's activity on a daily basis.
There's another section of the morning prayer service
that alludes to Isaiah
chapter 45, verse seven.
The liturgy just takes that verse and tweaks it a little bit.
What the verse actually says is that God
forms light and creates darkness,
makes peace and creates evil, creates evil.
Now, why would second Isaiah say this?
Right.
There are two or three different people's books that went into Isaiah.
Isaiah was writing the second
Isaiah due to Isaiah was writing during the Babylonian exile
when the Jewish community in Babylonia was coming into contact for the first time
with these dualistic myths of a God of good and a God of evil.
And so this later stage of Jewish development
understands that no, there's only one God for everything.
And this guide creates the good stuff or God creates the good stuff.
And creates the bad stuff.
This now we see we are moving into a kind of universal monotheism.
Unlike the head of Theism or Monogatari that we discussed several lectures ago.
So that verse is
taken by the poet of the liturgy, and it is slightly adjusted
to not emphasize the evilness, but emphasize God's creation of the light.
So the way the prayer service adopts the line is God forms
light and creates darkness, makes peace and creates everything.
They change the word evil to everything so that you don't have to
dwell on the negative.
But again, it's this idea that God is continually making light.
It's not something that happened in the remote past.
Now, in the Hebrew Bible, as well as in the liturgy,
there are polemics against other religious systems.
And we see this in the evening service as well.
The evening service says that God arranges
the stars in their heavenly rotations, according to his will.
So it's nighttime.
When you say the evening service,
you see the stars and God arranges them all according to the divine will.
What is this?
A polemic against Babylonian astrology?
The Babylonians understood that the stars were gods and they controlled our fate.
So the rabbis in the Talmud were willing to say, okay,
maybe the stars do control your fate, but who controls the stars?
God controls the stars. Right.
You also see this in the opening chapter of Genesis,
where you have light created on day one
and the sun isn't created until day four.
Well, for the Babylonians, the sun was a god.
But when the creation story gets reworked in its Jewish version or its Israelite
version, the sun is just another one of God's creations.
And indeed, our God can create light even without a sun.
So you see these subtle or not so subtle with the time
polemics against other religious systems and religious ideologies.
Okay, let's move into the central prayer
that Jews say three times a day in the morning
service, the afternoon service and the evening service.
We're going to focus specifically on the daily amid
that daily central prayer as opposed to the other
amid don't plural for me does the plural for ami dah
that are recited either on the Sabbath or on holidays.
So the prayer begins.
The only begins by praising God.
It's a good way to.
It's a good way to butter somebody up.
Before you ask a series of ask for a series of requests
and invoking the notion of the merit of our ancestors.
Now, if you remember Tom Wolfe's book, Bonfire of the Vanities,
he had something called a favor bank, so that if I do somebody a favor,
if I do somebody a favor in 1980, I can wait even until the year
2000 to cash in my favor, and that person owes me one.
Well, what the merit of our fathers does is to make that intergenerational.
Abraham and Isaac and Jacob and in the modern movement of reform
and conservative and reconstruction ism, we say, and their wives, Sarah, Rebecca,
Leah and Rachel, they did such great things.
They were such righteous people.
God, you owe them one.
but you know what? They're not around.
So we're their descendants.
So we'll be happy to take the pay back ourselves.
Right. It's an intergenerational favor bank.
The second blessing in the Army.
It praises God's power and includes the power to resurrect the dead.
Remember that?
Something to distinguish the Pharisees from the sad disease.
And we'll have a session coming up on the world to come.
And resurrection of the dead.
But it becomes a central component of rabbinic Judaism,
even though it's a late and marginal idea within the Hebrew Bible itself.
The third blessing of the Amida has Israel imitating the angelic choir
and coordinating God is king. Right.
This is what we can do for God.
We can coronate God because there is no king without a people.
Right.
You can't be a king of a kingdom if your kingdom has no population.
So we're willing to recognize, as we're happy to recognize,
we sing in joy, to recognize God as our king.
And then we go into the petition requests.
The middle section of the daily on B contains the petitions
which some scholars understand to be a road map to redemption.
The very first petitioner in prayer
begins with a request for the wisdom
to know the wisdom for knowledge.
Right.
It might be part of this intellectual, elite wisdom
that promotes Talmud Torah over all other commandments.
But more likely, it's a request to know God's will, because changing our ways
to reflect God's will will then prompt God
to forgive our past transgressions.
And redemption will naturally ensue.
And those indeed, are the subsequent blessings.
What redemption will then look like as outlined in the remaining blessings.
Pain and suffering will cease.
Economic prosperity will prevail.
And there will be an ingathering of the exiles to the land of Israel.
Justice will flow like a mighty river
with punishment meted out to heretics and reward for the righteous.
Jerusalem and the temple will be rebuilt.
And finally, the icing on the cake is that the Messiah will come.
The concluding blessings
of this section serve as an exclamation point, asking God to hear our prayers.
That's actually the concluding blessing of that middle petitioner section.
It's important and we'll come back to this idea
that all the work of
this road map to redemption happens.
All the work happens before we ask for the Messiah to come.
All right.
So the Messiah culminates the process of redemption
rather than initiates the process of redemption.
And that's very important to understand the psychology
of rabbinic Judaism,
that redemption
involves Jewish sovereignty in the land of Israel.
So the role of the Messiah is relegated to the end of that process.
All the work has been done prior to his appearance,
and that reflects the rabbinic discomfort with messianic speculation
because the rabbis are creating the sequence of these blessings
where in Yavne, after the destruction of the second temple
and probably the final
sequence doesn't happen until after the failed bar Kokhba revolt.
And so the rabbis were burned on messianic speculation
because every time they think that they're about to regain
political sovereignty from Rome, it turns out very, very bad for them.
So they they retain the idea of the Messiah,
but they relegate it to the distant future, to the very end of the process
of redemption, to try to quash contemporary messianic speculation
and not get into trouble in the future like they had in their very recent past.
The final three blessings of all of the Army does
serve as a conclusion, asking God to accept our prayer
and thanking God for the miracles that are daily with us.
That's actually my favorite blessing of the Army day,
because miracles are understood by the rabbis,
not only to be those supernatural occurrences of the parting
of the Red Sea and the plagues and all the other
lights
and bells and whistles that we see in the Hebrew Bible.
But the sun coming up and the lightning and the formation
of mountains, all of those things that are daily with us.
They're also evidence of God's providence shall activity in this world,
and they're considered by the rabbis to be miracles as well.
The final blessing, of course,
has to be beseeching God to bless us with peace.
Peace is the ultimate hallmark of redemption
as we jump 1500 years.
There are certain modern reformulations
of the traditional prayer that I want to mention here.
The reform movement that begins in the early 19th century.
Say by 1818, you have the beginnings of the reform movement in Germany.
They rejected the idea of the resurrection of the dead,
and specifically in their 1885 Pittsburgh platform when they got here
to the United States, they said that the immortality of the soul.
That's that's fine. We totally buy that.
But they rejected the idea
of a resurrection of the dead as not being Jewish in origin.
And they really thought that it was
not in
keeping with modern sensibilities to talk about this kind
of zombie action of folks being resurrected from the dead.
So they changed that word dead
in most of their prayers to God.
God resurrect God creates
all life, the quickening of all life.
So God enlivens everything,
not just resurrecting the dead, not just giving life to the dead.
Also, reform prayer books in a way that is very much
in keeping with the flow of the sequence of the blessings.
They reject the idea of an individual messiah
so no longer for the reform movement.
Is the Messiah going to be a male.
It's not egalitarian, all right?
It's not gender inclusive.
Nor will the Messiah necessarily be from the Davidic line.
That's also about your pedigree rather than about your personal status.
And so just like the blessings, the sequence of the blessings
and the traditional prayer build up to a messianic era, that the Messiah just
caps off, what the reform movement does is they cap off the Messiah, right.
And bracket him.
Once you've got the Messianic era, that's all the reform movement is looking for.
So they change their sensitive to the Hebrew, although there's far
less Hebrew in traditional in classic reform services
than in traditional services.
But they change the word redeemer to redemption,
or they change the word in Hebrew.
Go L to Geula.
Right.
A subtle change, but it gets at a theological conviction.
Reform
and conservative prayer books have generally been uncomfortable
with praying for the reestablishment of animal sacrifices
in the traditional prayer book.
You pray to rebuild the temple and the fires of Israel.
Well, those fires of Israel refer to the fires of the animal sacrifices.
So even in the conservative movement, which is far more conservative
with a small say than reform or reconstruction
or the Reconstructionist movement, they've been uncomfortable.
And so they've modified the language to talk about the
animal sacrifices in the past, and that it's not necessarily
going to be resurrected or it's not going to be continued in the future.
So the temple may very well be rebuilt, but there will be different
ways of worshiping than had been the case in the past.
Among the many
reforms that
the reconstructionists have made, and in this case reform and conservative
Judaism as well, is to make the liturgy more gender inclusive, as I mentioned.
So in general, when the patriarchs are mentioned,
the matriarchs are also invoked a further modification
that Reconstructionist Judaism has made in its prayer book.
Colonna Shamar is to not exclusively
refer to God in the male gender so very frequently,
and it's somewhat
unsettling for the traditional prayer that's not used to this kind of language,
but it's not.
It doesn't take you so long to get used to either.
God is referred to as the source
of all being or as the womb of all life.
And then the pronoun because Hebrew requires gendered pronouns.
Hebrew doesn't have the neutered pronoun it the way English does.
So God is referred to in the feminine.
And again, that's something that is very modern,
very new, and has not crossed the denominational lines
into mainstream reform or mainstream conservative Judaism.
I want to finish that lecture
with a quote from the Talmud
that gets at
perhaps a justification for liturgical modification.
A prayer that doesn't innovate
is not a prayer of supplication.
Now, the rabbis and the Halacha Jewish law,
they have problems with changing the fixed text of the blessings.
But we also see a voice that says, Look, if there's no innovation,
if it doesn't mean something new or say something new, then it's not a genuine
prayer of supplication.
And so perhaps this is the motivation for contemporary denominations
within Judaism to experiment with new forms of the liturgy.
Okay.
So we will next examine the third leg of Shimon, the righteous
tripod of what the world stands on, Deeds of loving kindness.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.