Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
(mellow music)
On April the 15th, 2019,
the world's most famous cathedral was ravaged by fire.
The roof went up in flames,
and the lofty spire collapsed,
crashing down through the vaulted ceiling.
That day, Notre Dame de Paris became a ruin.
(mellow music)
Once the fragile building was stabilized,
the decision was made to rebuild the cathedral
exactly as it was before.
But where to start?
How do you reconstruct a day,
an 800 year old monument
when no one knows how it was originally built?
So began a remarkable challenge
in the very heart of Paris.
For the first time archeologists, historians, geologists,
and specialists in ancient materials,
as well as structural engineers,
and acoustic and digital specialists
explore the cathedrals and trails,
scan its vaults, and probe its foundations.
In the process, they reach spaces
that have been inaccessible for centuries,
rediscovering all the skills and techniques
of Notre Dame's original builders
for they hold the key to its reconstruction.
In their efforts to balance
both the earthly and the sacred,
the actual and the virtual,
the scientists and the architects
both share a single obsession
to bring beloved Notre Dame back to life.
(mellow music)
Built on the Ile de la Cite in the 12th century,
not Notre-Dame de Paris at the time of its construction,
is the tallest cathedral in the world.
Its dimensions, the artistry of its masonry,
and the form of its flying buttresses
show gothic architecture entering a new era.
Notre Dame resembles a gigantic stone vessel
in which the material gives way to the feeling of space.
I don't think there's any other cathedral
in France that's so elegant.
Everything is delicate.
The walls are thin, the highest windows are fine,
ever more light and ever less matter.
It's almost as if the material
has been stretched upwards to its limits,
yet at the same time, it hasn't been deformed.
The flying buttresses and the vaulted roof are all there,
with the wooden framework above,
and for eight centuries it hasn't butched.
This true masterpiece of harmony and balance
is the very essence of gothic architecture.
The cathedral as the result of a system
that makes it possible to hold together opposing forces.
Normally everything should constantly collapse
and that's what's so marvelous.
There's a point of pure harmony,
and that's a rare thing that's difficult to obtain.
It remains fragile,
but it's still a reality and it holds up.
This balance was totally destroyed by the fire
of April the 15th, 2019.
The spire collapsed into the vaults,
completely smashing them above the transept and the nave.
As for the lead roof and the framework
that disappeared in the flames,
they stopped weighing on the walls,
thus disturbing the stability of the whole building.
(mellow music)
Yet despite huge fractures
and much to the surprise of the architects,
the cathedral didn't collapse
in the days following the disaster.
We're very fortunate
that only the vaults are affected.
The flying buttresses held, the walls held,
the fire caused no structural damage at all.
What is the secret of Notre Dame's
exceptional resistance?
How did its builders design its structure,
and how should it be rebuilt
to guarantee the same stability it had before?
These have become the big questions
for the architects in charge of the restoration.
Indeed, it's impossible to rebuild the cathedral
without first solving the equation of the forces
that govern its structure.
A few months after the fire,
the flying buttresses were stabilized
with large wooden arches.
The vault was then incorporated,
now propped up like this
as it was at the time of its construction.
The cathedral looks like a medieval construction site again.
So a vast scientific investigation has begun.
Dozens of wood, metal and stone experts
are all examining the building,
probing its masonry,
analyzing its materials to understand how the vault,
the flying buttresses, the walls, the stones,
and the mortar all fit together,
as well as the frame,
that now vanished wooden architecture
that will have to be completely rebuilt.
Among them, the engineers of the materials
and structural mechanics group
led by Stephane Morel
have the job of unraveling the mysteries
of the forces at work within the building.
We started by separating the idea
of the vault from what supports and maintains it.
Let's say it's supports,
so we could explain particularly to the project manager
how the whole thing works.
The first question
to occur to the architects was,
where does the vault actually begin?
To find the answer Stephane Morel and his team
went to Notre Dame to get as close as possible
to these medieval vaults
that reach up to a height of 32 meters.
Observing just how the medieval vaults broke
following the disaster allowed Stephane Morel
to formulate a new hypothesis
on what he calls the structural limits of gothic vaults.
Wherever a vault has collapsed,
you can see that the lower parts always remain in place
even in a major disaster.
We think of a vault as starting at the level
of the capitals, but that's not really the case.
Mechanically, it starts a lot higher up.
So in Reims Cathedral whose vaults were bombed
during the first World War,
the lower parts, the load bearing piles
also remained in place
as if they were not structurally part of the vault.
(mellow music)
The work of the structure group
has highlighted the ingenious load transfer system
designed by the medieval builders.
A lot of what we think of as the vault
is actually part of the walls,
so the vault in the structural sense of the term
is much smaller.
This helped us to understand more about
how the vault support assembly works,
and especially the role of the load-bearing piles.
From inside the cathedral
they look like part of the vaults,
but in fact they're part of the wall.
The vaults seem to start very low,
but it's actually the wall there
and the vault itself starts much higher up.
(mellow music)
Those geniuses back then
didn't have engineers like we do.
They didn't have software or anything like that.
The fascinating thing is that
when you calculate the load distribution
of the vault pressure,
and the location of the flying buttresses,
they're placed exactly where they should be,
any higher or lower they wouldn't work.
Thanks to this system of flying buttresses
aligned with a load-bearing pile,
the damage was concentrated only on the vault.
(hymnal music)
by modules, by sections.
So each module has a certain autonomy.
If you remove one module,
the whole thing is at risk, but not entirely.
These independent modules
are sections grouping the vaults and flying buttresses.
They're perfectly balanced,
and they're repeated in order to form the backbone
of the building and guarantee its stability.
So we have a system of force runoff
that's incredibly logical and reasoned
so that the force which is very dangerous
and could destroy the whole edifice,
is directed to one side of it from bridge to bridge,
from articulation to articulation
until the whole building has bound together.
This trickle down principle of the forces
allowed gothic architects to slim down the walls,
and drill large openings to let light in,
And that's the marvel of an architecture
in which everything is linked together,
and that's quite a medieval concept
because in the Middle Ages they emphasize
those links of interdependence.
Contrary to our mentality today,
they were valued because they allowed a human being
not to be alone.
Man alone is in danger.
A stone alone is in danger.
So what creates solidity is of course the stone itself,
but especially its links of dependence to other stones.
These links of dependence
between the thousands of stones that make up Notre Dame
have a very concrete form,
the mortar used by masons to bind the stones together.
What role does it really play
in the stability of the building?
That's the question that the researchers
of the stonework group are asking.
They're collecting samples
from different parts of the cathedral,
chemist Jean-Michel Mechling supervises the operation.
A few weeks ago
we drilled just behind there into the walls
of the cathedral to collect mortar samples.
That's the thickness of the joint.
The thickness of the joint? Yes.
And the idea is to get outta the borehole
as much information as possible.
So on site we use an endoscope
to see the entire length of the borehole,
and the initial results we're getting
on the mortars actually show a lot of regularity.
The mortars in the cathedral are very consistent,
so it's certain that these people knew perfectly
how to make mortars,
and always produce them in the same way.
The mortar samples
taken by Jean-Michel Mechling and his team
have been sent to the researchers
from the laboratories of the University of Lorraine,
and the Jean Lamour Institute.
Under the microscope,
the chemist has found both grains of quartz
and lumps of lime.
The 40 or so samples
that we've taken mainly from the vaults
are so far without doubt made from lime,
and that's quite logical and normal for the time.
It was mixed with sand from the sand,
and that's also pretty logical.
We wouldn't expect the sand to come from very far away.
These mixtures are very consistent
both in the lime sand ratio,
and the quality of the sand itself.
At Notre Dame,
the limestone walls are barely 60 centimeters thick.
They're thin, but they have proven to be incredibly strong
for eight centuries now.
So what role has mortar played in their structure?
The exact mechanical function of the mortar
is not yet fully defined.
We have some ideas,
and we're talking them over with some of the specialists
in structural calculations.
During the fire,
the mortar joints cracked at the level
of the medieval vaults.
(mellow music)
This phenomenon is of particular interest
to engineer Stephane Morel.
In his laboratory in Bordeaux, Southwestern France,
he's done experiments to reproduce how those cracks occurred
by exerting pressure on three limestone blocks
held together with mortar
of the same composition as that at Notre Dame.
The blocks are equipped with sensors
that can detect the slightest movement.
Under the action of the press,
cracks in the mortar eventually form.
(sand crackling)
The blocks remain intact,
but the cracking takes place in the interface
between the stone and the joint.
The experiment reveals that the mortar
by cracking protects the integrity of the stone blocks.
It's a major asset of masonry structures
compared to those of ancient times.
With the first structures
back in Roman times,
there was nothing at all between the blocks.
The blocks had what's called dry joints.
They were arranged one on top of the other.
The problem with that
is that when you put a heavy load on them,
the surfaces and their points of contact
are never perfect,
and you pretty soon get breaks in the blocks.
The medieval builders understood
that in the absence of mortar,
it was the stone blocks themselves
that were directly subjected to stress,
and eventually broke with a passage of time.
When you put these blocks together
using a mortar joint,
the most fragile part of the assembly
is at the level of the joint,
and more particularly at the interface
between the joint and the block of stone.
This masonry is made up of materials that are very rigid.
A stone isn't flexible and neither is a joint,
but when you get cracks at these interfaces,
they allow small local displacement.
The combined effect of which taken together
at all the different levels and surfaces
allows the masonry to move quite a bit,
and that gives the overall structure a certain flexibility.
This is undoubtedly one of the explanations
for the durability of these masonry structures
that have been able to withstand several earthquakes
during their history,
and are still standing today.
(mellow music)
The cracks that appeared during the fire
are not so much a sign of weakness
as a proof of the building's resilience to shocks.
(mellow music)
Notre Dame is a relatively flexible cathedral
whose masonry has been moving for eight centuries
as it adapts to bad weather,
the flooding of the sand,
ground movements and the vibrations of the metro.
It's alive, it's dynamic,
it's sensitive, it moves, and then it moves back again.
When I walk around in here,
I can see pushing and pulling,
the forces, the reactions, all of that, it's great.
(mellow music)
So to restore all its mobility
to the cathedral,
the architects have decided to use mortar
instead of cement
using the same recipe as eight centuries ago.
As for the quality and consistency
of the mortars that were used,
in particular by Viollet-le-Duc,
well at one point they decided that cement was fine,
so they put in some cement joints,
and cement is worse than anything
because it not only has salt in it,
but it's harder than stone.
Unfortunately, we've gone back to things
that are more normal.
For the apps, in fact, for the whole restoration,
we'll be using lime and sand, nothing else.
(mellow music)
But using mortar in the joints
won't alone guarantee the stability
of such a towering edifice.
An exceptional discovery in the heart of the masonry
of Notre Dame relaunches the investigation.
With the frame and roof no longer there,
scientists have access to the upper parts of the building
for the first time.
Maxime L'heritier is an archeologist specializing in the use
of metal in gothic cathedrals.
At the top of the walls,
more than 30 meters above the ground,
he finds long metal staples concealed in the masonry
for more than eight centuries,
The frame rested on these staples,
that was one of the discoveries we made
on the use of metal at Notre Dame thanks to the fire.
The two main metals they used were iron and lead.
Scientists have identified several hundred
iron staples that connect the stones together
at the top of the choir, nave, and transect.
They decided to take some of them
from the damaged parts of the building.
One of the surprises
was the sheer quantity of staples
of different series of staples
that were used at all stages of the construction
of the gothic cathedral of Notre Dame.
There are enough in the nave
to hold all the sets of columns
that we found with the metal detector
along with close study of all the masonry
we can get to now with the scaffolding.
By methodically surveying
the different floors of the cathedral,
Maxime L'heritier and his team
have identified other staples in the galleries.
Again, the archeologists took some of them to date them.
He was thus able to understand their purpose,
which dates back to the time
of the construction of the cathedral.
So that's a surprise
to have so much metal in a cathedral
of the second half of the 12th century.
Even if some phases of construction,
especially up at the top
are from the very beginning of the 13th century.
It was quite a discovery
because until now we knew all about the use of metal
in cathedrals of the 13th century,
as in (indistinct) or in shaft.
But the cathedrals and big churches of the 12th century
show quite a limited use of iron,
just a few studs to hold up the columns.
Maxime L'heritier and his colleagues
discovered a veritable metal skeleton
dating back to the time of the cathedral's construction.
Nowadays, we wonder what this metal
is doing in this architecture, so particular to Notre Dame,
where from the 1160s they were planning to raise
very, very high vaults,
much higher than any of the buildings that preceded it,
and not just higher, higher, wider, and thinner.
Notre Dame was therefore
the first gothic cathedral site
where such quantities of iron were used.
It's a discovery that highlights
the little known contribution of blacksmiths and ferries
to this vast stone vessel.
Always working in the shade,
the better to see the color of the heated metal,
they forged one by one these thousands of staples
that are now hidden in the masonry.
(metal clicking)
The staples have been sent to the archeomaterials laboratory
to be analyzed by Maxime L'heritier,
and metal specialist Philippe Dillmann.
They are cut into samples,
then polished for a long time,
until this surface is as smooth as that of a mirror.
Through a microscope,
researchers will finally be able
to observe their structure,
and it's proving to be much more complex than expected.
So we've got these three bands
that have different levels of carbon content.
Here you see we have big deposits of it,
and here we have just as many,
but they're very small and up here there's carbon two.
These bands proved that the staple was forged
by welding together metal bars of different origin.
At this point,
we start to wonder if this is all material
that's been recycled,
and if this staple was made up of lots
of pieces of iron of different origins by a blacksmith
who recovered metal from different places.
What we've usually seen on other sites
is that 10, 20, even 30% of the iron we've analyzed
may have been recycled,
that it might have been welded together
with different compositions on either side of the wealth.
At Notre Dame, we've analyzed five or six staples
that all have welds, six out of six.
So we're going to analyze more of them
and as our study expands, it should confirm these results.
But at the stage we're at,
it's still raising a lot of questions.
(dramatic music)
At Notre Dame, we're finding 100% recycled iron
while this was probably
one of the richest construction sites
in the Kingdom of France at the time.
So what does this tell us?
What's the extent of this recycling,
if it is indeed recycling?
It could be due to faulty links
somewhere in the production chain
that led to the blacksmith
having to assemble several pieces of iron.
Was there a transport problem t
hat meant shipping small lots of one,
or one and a half kilos was easier?
Where did this iron come from?
Observation under an electron microscope
of the composition of the impurities
contained in the samples
and the deposits of slag,
the residues from iron ore smelting
provided a major clue.
The surface of the sample
is just a few square centimeters,
but there are a lot of deposits inside it,
maybe tens or even hundreds of thousands of them.
Here you can see that it's iron.
We've got aluminum, silicon, phosphorus.
There's some iron with a bit of phosphorus in it.
There's not much manganese.
It is then possible
to find in the staples traces of chemical elements
related to the manufacture of the iron
that composes them.
We will be able to compare
these trace element analysis
to the chemical analysis of the waste
found on archeological sites, the slag.
There's the same materials on all archeological sites,
so by comparing the composition of the slag
in all the sites of one particular area
along the send, for example,
which is a major thoroughfare,
or areas that are mentioned in the text,
we can compare them to find out if the iron in Notre Dame
is likely to have come from this region or farther away,
perhaps further along the sand.
(mellow music)
According to the analyses,
these staples were made of metal
from many different sources,
coming from the surrounding region and converging on Paris.
For economic or purely practical reasons,
that remains a mystery.
The structural reasons for using them
were most likely related to the construction phase.
We have this model here
that chose the completed building.
Throughout the construction,
the builders sought to use metal
to stabilize the structure,
and they chose to use staples to prevent displacement
and to counterbalance various forces.
That was probably the case on this peripheral belt
where it was feared that the lateral thrust of the frame
could cause slippage
in the last rows of stones,
more than 30 meters above ground level.
(mellow music)
The staples made it possible
to stabilize the walls of the building
throughout their construction until the last stage
that would fix them definitively,
the installation of the framework.
On these structures,
you really have to have significant vertical loads
for the masonry to work properly.
The joints need to work with significant vertical loads
to create more friction.
So the absence of the framework isn't such a good thing,
but anyway, it's going to be rebuilt.
This wooden super structure
consisting of more than 1000 oaks,
which crowned the entire building has now disappeared.
On the site, workers are preparing to evacuate
the last vestiges of the roof framework of Notre Dame,
known as the forest,
in reference to the 1000 oaks that we use to make it,
and now just a cluster of charred beams.
It'll be rebuilt in wood,
the living material that the medieval builders used
throughout the cathedral's construction.
(metal clinking)
There was wood everywhere
at every stage of construction,
especially in the scaffolding and the bending,
as well as all the devices for hoisting materials.
And then of course, once the building was finished,
the roof had to be made,
and its framework was very important
because it ensured the protection of the building.
We still need this wood framework today.
Many other technologies might be easier to use,
but wood is what's needed,
if the building is to retain its human dimension,
it's human skin.
(mellow music)
How then to rebuild a heritage masterpiece
that's been lost forever?
How to plan it out, and what techniques to use?
Luckily only a few years before the fire,
the framework was the subject of a complete
and precise architectural survey
by two young architecture students.
One of them, Remi Fromont,
is now chief architect of the site,
in charge of the reconstruction of this framework
that he knows better than anyone.
I find it hard to believe
that our surveys become so important.
It was a very objective survey.
We drew everything we saw and we left nothing out.
So in fact, we did an almost archeological survey
of a framework.
They are extremely complete drawings
of each of the assemblies that make up the roof.
Thanks to the survey,
the medieval framework can be reconstructed identically.
But like all the rest of the cathedral,
the frame has undergone many evolutions and restorations
during its eight centuries of existence.
So Remi Fromont has entrusted archeologist, Frederic Epaud,
a specialist in medieval frameworks
with the job of reconstructing the history
of this lost heritage.
What's new about this study
compared to all the other structural studies
I've carried out is that we had to do a postmortem
on the framework.
We were starting from almost nothing
and on something that had disappeared.
We had to reconstitute the framework
to be able to study it.
So at first we were lucky enough
to have the 2015 survey by Remi Fromont
and Cedric Trentesaux.
It's all in there.
You can see the location of the pegs, the assembly marks.
There are a lot of annotations,
so it's a gold mine of information.
We contacted all the carpenters and researchers
who'd actually visited this framework,
and we managed to collect more than 900 photos.
The first objective
was to differentiate the medieval parts
from the great restorations of the 18th and 19th centuries.
Then we had to tell apart in the photos
wood from the 13th century and wood from the 18th century,
the differences are pretty tiny.
Sometimes it's the way the wood was shaped by the axe.
If a piece of wood was sawn,
then that made it easier because back in the 13th century,
all the wood was cut with an axe.
So if it was sawn, we knew it was a fairly recent repair.
And then there's the patina of the wood.
13th century wood doesn't age in the same way
as the wood they used in the 16th or 18th century.
All this information
along with the dating of the beams
carried out in the eighties
allowed a more precise reading
of the framework's eventful history.
(dramatic music)
A first framework was placed over the choir in 1185.
Then a second one was placed over the nave in 1215.
Finally in 1225, the framework over the choir
was completely dismantled,
the walls were raised by two meter 60
to the level of those of the nave,
and then the framework was completely reassembled.
This vast overhaul to raise the roof
puzzle the archeologist.
It's really a complete revision
of the initial project.
The old cornice, that is the upper part
of the 12th century masonry was at about this level.
Then in the 13th century, 30 years later,
they put a new cornice on top of it.
And behind this balustrade, there's even higher masonry.
And this masonry raises the roof
by almost two meters, which is huge.
So why was the whole choir completely redone?
To understand that you have to go
to the Collegiate Church of Mantes-la-Jolie near Paris.
(mellow music)
And more precisely to the attic
where one of the last gothic frameworks
still in place in France is to be found.
(mellow music)
The framework
of the Collegiate Church of Mantes
is almost the little twin sister
of that of the nave in Notre Dame de Paris
since it was built just four years earlier.
(mellow music)
The framework at Mantes is almost identical
with more or less the same dimensions.
Both have spans of 11 meters,
with a height of approximately nine meters 60,
or nine meters 80.
(mellow music)
On some beams, Frederic Epaud
has spotted an important detail
that highlights the relationship between the framework
of Notre Dame and that of Mantes.
Here we've got three marks
gouged in by a chisel with a curved blade.
Here there's five in one, which makes six.
And what's interesting is that at Notre Dame on the nave,
so four years after this framework was made,
we find the same type of brand with the same type of tool.
So that's quite intriguing,
and even makes you wonder
if these were the same carpenters
that made the framework of Notre Dame.
There is however one made a difference
between the two frameworks.
Except that here in Montes
there was a design flaw,
a defect that's not to be found on the framework
of Notre Dame.
This defect was to cause a lot of damage
and would lead repairs that are still visible to this day.
And the big problem is that
we have a lot of weight right here on these beams.
And the beams couldn't take it
because they weren't thick enough.
There was nothing underneath to take up the weight
because there are vaults that are so close to the frame.
(mellow music)
It was because of these extremely domed vaults
that the frame couldn't be reinforced from below.
(mellow music)
These are the same domed vaults as at Notre Dame.
And the builders probably ran into exactly the same problem
when they built the first framework over the choir.
In the first version
of the framework over the choir of Notre Dame,
you can see that this transverse piece
was supposed to form the base of this large triangle,
but that wasn't possible
because of the prominence of the vaults
That's why 30 years later
on the nave and then on the choir,
they went back and raised the masonry
by almost two meters to sit the frame,
in dotted lines here, much higher up.
By raising his frame,
the master carpenter freed himself from the vaults,
and added an essential piece,
a crossbar located at the base of the triangle,
and brace from below with supports
to solidify the structure.
But then he had new challenges to face.
Exposing a frame with a steep slope
and one that at a height of more than 40 meters
is exposed to storms,
is not at all the same thing as building Romanesque frames
with very low slopes,
and that were positioned much lower.
You have to think of adapting the framework to the building.
The carpenters had to design a frame
that was both wind resistant
and compatible with very thin walls,
and they came up with an ingenious solution.
What's different about
the framework at Notre Dame
is that it's an experiment in triangulation,
an innovative technique at the beginning
of the 13th century,
which consists in transforming
the central piece into a spine,
so it will work in traction.
This central piece is compressed laterally
by two other beams,
so suspended like this,
the forces are drawn from the bottom to the top in traction.
Thanks to this suspension,
we will be able to converge a heavy load here at this point,
and that makes this framework that's perfectly balanced.
To achieve this triangulation,
the master carpenter of Notre Dame
will test different assemblies within the framework itself.
There are several ways
to achieve this triangulation in this framework here.
They were searching for the ideal static balance
in all the 13th century frameworks,
but the man in charge will have tested various assemblies
right here in this framework
until he found the most efficient triangulation possible.
So these trial and error experiments
will be reproduced identically
in the future framework of Notre Dame.
And the experiments showed
that over 850 years,
the whole structure has survived very well,
and that actually the basic form was excellent.
And that's really something.
It means that from the very start,
they had the idea of an initial form
that hasn't changed since, and it still works.
We'll be able to use it
when we're putting in the new frameworks.
The architects also decided
to rebuild the original framework of oak,
a material that's solid and long-lasting.
All that remained was to find the 1000 oak trees
they would need to do it.
95% of the wood used
in the frame of Notre Dame
was 25 to 30 centimeters at most in diameter.
These were trees with trunks that were relatively thin.
They were very slender and young as well,
at most 80 years old, on average between 60 and 80 years.
Contrary to popular belief,
the builders of the Middle Ages
didn't use centuries old oaks in their frames.
But on the contrary, young specimens that were tall,
fine and slender.
Rebuilding identically
isn't just reproducing a form.
It's also reusing techniques and know-how,
and it's also knowing how to reuse materials.
And that raises questions about
the quality of the wood that was used,
and what type of trees they were,
and what kind of forestry can produce wood like that?
It was in the forest of (indistinct)
in the south of France
that archeologist, Frederic Epuad
found the traces of a long gone type of forestry
that produced wood that was perfectly adapted
to building cathedrals.
It's like time travel
because this is a very special forest.
The oak composites are, I reckon about 50 or 60 years old.
I've never seen any others like them, it's really unique.
What you see here
is exactly what you would've seen
in a 13th century forest.
Very slender and fine oaks
How to explain this strange distribution?
60 years ago there was a big oak here
that was cut down low to the ground,
and from the stump that remained in the ground,
three shoots grew out,
and they became these three trees.
And these stump shoots grow together,
so they're in competition with each other.
There is no light from the side.
And since the forest here is very dense,
they'll be forced to grow very quickly to find the light.
And because there's no light getting through
into this thicket,
there won't be any side branches.
That's very good because in 50 or 60 years,
there'll be adult trees 10 meters tall
and with no knots in them, ideal for construction.
So the builders of the Middle Ages
knew how to cultivate the right trees
in order to supply their big cathedral construction sites.
With this kind of forestry,
it took three or four hectares at most
to supply a whole cathedral site.
So of course it goes against all the preconceived ideas
such as that we had to raise entire forests
to make cathedral frameworks,
and that it took extremely thick and very old trees.
This just isn't the case.
Forestry in the 13th century was closely linked
to the construction techniques of the day.
Back then, most frameworks were made
with squared off wood cut with an axe.
These very slim trees
were therefore pruned to a minimum,
and the bark was removed,
while preserving the natural shape of the trunk.
Squaring off was kept to a minimum
to preserve the heart of oak at the center of the beam.
And to preserve the wood itself
by following its thread
and leaving in all its sinuous curves.
Each beam in the framework of Notre Dame
corresponded to an entire tree,
and respected its sometimes curved shape.
It's no doubt in reference to the 1000 trees
that composed that frame that it was called the forest.
There's nothing better
in terms of resistance.
And it's also perfectly adapted to the frameworks
of gothic cathedrals.
We have structures like Notre Dame
that are exposed to winds or hurricanes
to a height of 40 meters.
So we need wood that's flexible,
and resistant, and that doesn't break.
And the scans of Notre Dame have clearly demonstrated
that the framework itself has bent.
The trusses have bent like that,
but they haven't broken.
None of the wood has broken.
None of its parts have come undone,
and that's directly linked to how these forests
were managed and how they were pruned.
We really have a perfect match
between the mechanics of the frames
that were intended across the centuries,
an understanding of the forest,
and a technical know-how perfectly adapted to the wood,
a total osmosis between nature, technique,
and the construction itself.
Frederic Epaud's investigation
has revealed the great mastery
shown by the medieval builders
Such an exceptional heritage will
Such an exceptional heritage
will therefore be rebuilt
as closely as possible to the original.
We don't restore identically,
the exact term is that
we make a reconstruction or a restitution.
We will reconstitute the frames
in a state that we think is a coherent state.
as they were back in the 13th century,
And we won't be putting back anything
that's been repaired since.
The final architectural element
that crowned a building, the framework,
also contributed to the overall flexibility
of its structure.
So with buildings like this it's a balance.
I wouldn't say that its unstable
but it's always standing like that.
so there must also be some flexibility above it.
The frames are just laid on the masonry,
they're not sealed to it at all.
The masonry moves and
the frame moves another way
because it's another material.
and all that has its own life.
A fabulous balance of forces
that the builders have created by pushing ever further
the limits of the material.
The tensions were pushed really very far
by the elevation, by the height, by the length.
It is in fact everything possible was exaggerated
to the breaking point,
to the point where if you went any further it wouldn't hold.
There's this extraordinary moment
when you create a work of art,
when you say, let's stop here.
It's still holding, and I won't go any further
because the whole thing's already a miracle.
And perhaps it's all thanks to science and thought,
but let's not tempt the devil.
So for me, harmony isn't a utopian vision,
it's a very concrete experience
of opposing forces in balance with each other.
Notre Dame de Paris
was a masterpiece of structure and proportion.
The builder's quest for evermore space and height
in order to let in the light.
(mellow music)
And we sometimes forget that architecture
isn't limited to its materials,
although they're necessary of course,
for the building to hold,
but art's about using those materials
to create the immaterial.
To produce that empty space
that will be a place of gathering,
a place of welcome, and a place of light
By losing its light and its acoustics
during the fire,
Notre Dame lost its immaterial dimension,
that part of the sacred that the whole world mourned,
a shared emotion that was symbolized by its iconic spire,
which no longer overlooks the rooftops of Paris.
How to restore their light
to these stained glass windows
covered with a thick lead dust,
and restore its acoustics
to a partially collapsed building?
How to restore the iconic status
to the world's most famous cathedral?
In short, how to give back Notre Dame its soul?
(mellow music)
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.