Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
(gentle music) (air whooshing)
(bird squawking) (gentle music continues)
On April 15th, 2019,
the world's most famous cathedral was ravaged by fire.
The roof went up in flames,
and the lofty spire collapsed,
crashing down through the vaulted ceiling.
That day, Notre-Dame de Paris became a ruin.
(gentle music continues) (air whooshing)
Once the fragile building was stabilized,
the decision was made to rebuild
the cathedral exactly as it was before.
But where to start?
How do you reconstruct today an 800-year-old monument
when no one knows how it was originally built?
(air whooshing)
So began a remarkable challenge
in the very heart of Paris.
For the first time,
archaeologists, historians, geologists,
and specialists in ancient materials,
(grinder whirring)
as well as structural engineers
and acoustic and digital specialists,
explore the cathedral's entrails,
scan its vaults, and probe its foundations.
In the process, they reached spaces
that had been inaccessible for centuries,
rediscovering all the skills and techniques
of Notre-Dame's original builders,
for they hold the key to its reconstruction.
(dramatic music)
In their efforts to balance both the earthly and the sacred,
the actual and the virtual,
the scientists and the architects both share
a single obsession,
to bring beloved Notre-Dame back to life.
(moves to brooding music)
(wind howling)
(brooding music)
18 months after the fire,
the tragic wounds were finally exposed for all to see.
(brooding music continues)
The roof was a twisted tangle of scorched wood and metal.
Daylight flooded the huge nave in three ruin spots.
(brooding music continues)
The once majestic cathedral
was a fragile ghost of its former glory.
Its symphonic organ was silent.
Its ancient statues were now blind.
(brooding music continues)
The walls and stained glass windows were covered
by thick soot, and even seemed to be in mourning.
Hundreds of tons of damaged stone
had crashed onto the shattered floor.
(brooding music continues)
Iron ornaments, along with beams
that had supported the roof,
had plummeted more than 30 meters.
The entire disastrous mess
had to be carefully removed, piece by piece.
(construction vehicles whirring)
Several days after the fire,
archaeologist Marc Vire filmed inside the cathedral.
(construction droning)
(construction vehicle engine roaring)
When we arrived on the site,
the regional curator of archaeology, Stephane Duchaux,
said to me, "I've just straightened things out.
Up until now, everyone has been talking about rubble.
It isn't rubble.
These are pieces of French heritage.
Henceforth, we will be treating them
as archaeological vestiges."
That changed everything.
(soft dramatic music)
Majestic Notre-Dame was suddenly transformed
into a busy scientific work site.
Tents erected on the forecourt served as research stations.
(brooding music) (construction vehicle beeping)
Picking through the vestiges,
the experts carefully took stock of what remained
after the terrible fire.
Each fragment and every nail was covered with toxic dust.
(brooding music continues)
The cathedral's lead roof had melted
into minuscule particles,
which had found their way into every nook and cranny.
Chief heritage curator Dorothee Chaoui-Derieux supervised
the project since the day after the fire.
No one wanted this fire, this tragedy,
but today we have to try and make the best things.
When we started sifting through the vestiges
and removing them, there was the physical aspect
of the work, that's undeniable.
We spent hours, entire days,
wearing that protective equipment and shoes,
the helmet, but also the mask with the battery on your back,
the sound of the breathing apparatus.
So physically, the conditions weren't easy at all.
Standing all day with your hands in the soot,
sorting for hours.
(rubble clattering)
By preserving all the charred pieces of the framework,
all of the fallen blocks of stone,
today we have a huge amount of data
that had previously been inaccessible.
Thousands of stone blocks,
which had formed the 100-foot-high vaulting,
were classified according to their original position.
The researchers now need to study every detail
to understand the complex process developed
by Notre-Dame's original builders.
Those early architects had managed to raise
the highest vaults throughout Christendom
during the 12th century.
(dramatic music)
The cathedral's medieval vaults must be rebuilt first.
(group speaking French)
Pascal Prunet is one of the chief architects
in charge of the restoration.
And for him, it is an unprecedented challenge,
a first since the Second World War.
I've never rebuilt vaults before.
It's actually been 60 or 70 years
since anyone's repaired a cathedral's roof.
There aren't any craftsmen or architects
with experience of that.
So we had to understand why there was
that irregularity in the shapes.
Why was there that more complex geometry
than the more simple one we'd had gone for?
What route did we need to take in order to rebuild all that?
Anticipating the deformations.
There are so many questions.
(soft dramatic music)
To answer these questions,
the architects need the expertise of geologists,
archaeologists, and materials specialists.
Art historian Yves Gallet oversees
the multidisciplinary group.
(soft dramatic music continues)
The millions of visitors to the cathedral
over the centuries before the fire
had made it difficult to study.
Studying Notre-Dame before the fire of 2019,
even just getting into Notre-Dame,
was really difficult.
So, after the fire,
we had a unique opportunity,
for a limited amount of time, unfortunately.
But a unique opportunity to get a really close look
at the cathedral.
(metal clanking) (people speaking French)
Notre-Dame is a cathedral
which has survived through the centuries.
And since we want to study it as it was conceived
in the 12th century,
we're working our way back from the most recent
to the most ancient parts.
(soft ethereal music)
By the 18th century,
the vaulted transept ceiling was already
in danger of collapsing,
and it was new compared to most of Notre-Dame.
It was rebuilt using new stones
by architect Germain Boffrand in 1728.
(soft ethereal music continues)
Because it was redone once again
during a 19th-century restoration,
this part of the cathedral will be simpler to rebuild.
But the vaulting which collapsed in the nave
was built early in the 13th century
and had survived for over 800 years,
only to be destroyed on April the 15th, 2019.
The stone experts are fascinated by this architectural feat.
(soft ethereal music continues)
Notre-Dame had the highest vaulted roof
of its age.
This is a unique opportunity,
because here we have the elements of the construction,
but we have them disassembled.
(soft ethereal music continues)
A medieval vault,
as a puzzle made of heavy blocks of stone.
The cross-stone arches originally divided
the ceiling into six parts.
(soft ethereal music continues)
Smaller stones filled in spaces between the arches
to form the sexpartite vault.
The stone-working group
has this opportunity of coming to grips
with the very skeleton of the edifice.
So we study the stones,
their geological origin,
the way they'd been cut,
the way they'd been put in place.
Historian Bruno Phalip researched
the techniques and tools used
for Notre-Dame's original construction.
We can try to measure the size
of the tool's blade, its number of teeth,
the space between the teeth,
to work out if it was a big, heavy tool
or something lighter.
The approach we see here was quite physical,
with a heavy tool called a boucharde,
a sort of toothed ax, used at an angle like this.
But you can see that different methods were used
on these other sides.
Here, they wouldn't have used those tools
with the huge impacts.
Here, it was lots and lots of individual blows
to the surface.
(soft ethereal music) (metal clanks)
What you had here were workers who were learning
what to do in situations that were quite exceptional.
You had the immense width of the nave and its height,
which was up to 30, 35 meters.
They were having to confront methods
which required workers who were keen to learn,
who wanted to surpass themselves,
who wanted to tackle this reality,
which they'd never before experienced.
(soft music)
In 1160, Notre-Dame's builders
were competing with the past
and with Noyon Cathedral in northern France,
which had begun construction 10 years earlier.
(soft ethereal music)
According to art historian Arnaud Timbert,
an architectural revolution was born.
Notre-Dame de Paris
shifted Gothic architecture up to gigantic dimensions,
both as regards surface area as to height.
It was a completely different world,
perhaps not in the conception of space,
because space remained that of a basilica,
but in the way you experienced it.
Your body was in a different movement,
a different place than in previous cathedrals.
(soft ethereal music continues)
Ambitious medieval builders
were determined to reach new heights
in their cathedrals' ascent towards heaven.
(ethereal choral singing)
This quest for greater height
is always associated with Gothic architecture.
It is locked into this constant striving for height,
which culminated in Beauvais Cathedral with its 48 meters
to the vaulting.
With Notre-Dame de Paris,
the builders achieved 33 meters up to the vaulting,
which was a colossal leap of the times,
because nowhere had previously got any higher
than 22, 24, or 25 meters.
So this was like a sudden leap of 10 more meters.
(soft ethereal music)
Notre-Dame's architects raised
their vaults 1.5 times higher than those of Noyon.
With this victory,
Notre-Dame de Paris had pioneered
a new trend in architecture.
(soft ethereal music continues)
It was the culmination of 30 years of experimentation
that began at Sens Cathedral in eastern France.
(soft ethereal music continues)
This Gothic structure boasted the first use
of ribbed vaults.
(soft ethereal music) (air whooshing)
Notre-Dame didn't just spring up
from nothing, of course,
it was the fruit of lots of experimenting,
of dozens of years of experimenting beforehand.
From what we can consider the first Gothic cathedral,
Saint-Etienne de Sens,
the construction of which began
in about 1135 to 1140,
to Notre-Dame, which got started in about 1155 to 1160.
So we historians believe the link
is the sexpartite ribbed vault.
(soft ethereal music)
Builders continue to raise
the ribbed vaults higher and higher.
They were able to train men in this new art,
this new style, this new know-how.
(soft ethereal music continues)
Ironically, the fire that consumed Notre-Dame
on April the 15th revealed a hidden expertise
of its stonemasons.
Because there were holes,
the falling spire had smashed through the vaulting,
we discovered that the vaulting was,
in fact, extremely thin,
only about 12 to 15 centimeters thick,
which is nothing at all.
It was a stone veil 14 meters wide.
(soft ethereal music)
Could this be the secret
behind Notre-Dame's extremely high vaulted ceilings?
(soft ethereal music continues)
To answer this question,
historian Yves Gallet needed to examine
the vaulting in Sens Cathedral,
to compare it with that of Notre-Dame.
(soft ethereal music) (birds chirping)
(air whooshing)
At first, the vaulted ceilings of the first Gothic cathedral
resemble upturned boats,
and they're also round like those in Notre-Dame.
But are they similar in other ways?
(soft dramatic music)
So we came here to Sens Cathedral
to carry out measurements using a geo-radar machine.
By sending passes of energy
through the stonework,
the geo-radar machine records data
about its density and thickness.
These measurements had never been taken before.
Here's the surface,
and here's a first reflection,
and here's a second.
So the thickness is about 35 centimeters,
with a 10% margin of error.
We've learned two things from this.
First, the vaulting is between 30 and 35 centimeters thick.
And second, there aren't two layers of masonry
to create that thickness,
it really does consist of blocks
that are 30 centimeters thick.
(soft dramatic music continues)
The vaults were scanned as well,
first from under the roof,
and then from inside the nave,
to confirm the geo-radar's measurements.
The goal of the operation
was to find out if we can measure directly,
if the geo-radar machine works
and gives us the same results as those we get
by indirect measuring via the superimposition
of point clouds.
(soft dramatic music continues)
We have the volume below and the volume above,
and by superimposing the two,
we can calculate in an indirect way
the space between the two.
In other words, the thickness of the vaulting
but also the thickness of the walls,
the thickness of everything that's in between
the inner and the outer.
And so, according to the points collected here,
we got a measurement of about 30 to 35 centimeters,
which is exactly the measurement we got using
the geo-radar machine.
The vaults in Sens
are 30 to 35 centimeters thick,
almost 20 centimeters more than those in Notre-Dame.
The vaulting in Paris is higher up
and it's thinner.
The vaulting of Sens Cathedral, at 24 meters,
is lower and it's thicker.
So there's probably some cause and effect going on here.
You have to take other parameters into account.
It's not just the thickness of the vaulting,
there's also the quality of the stone,
its density, the quality of the mortar used,
the techniques used for the flying buttresses.
But it definitely was a technical challenge,
and one of the major feats
of Notre-Dame's anonymous architect
to have managed to reduce the thickness
of the vaulting enough to beat the height record
and beat it by a significant margin.
(tense music)
For the new restoration of Notre-Dame,
today's architects want to replicate the original work
as closely as possible.
(metal clanking)
First, they need to construct a massive scaffold.
(metal clanking)
(soft ethereal music)
Within a few months,
this would reach the nave's damaged vaulting.
Now the architects must devise a way to construct
the medieval vaults exactly as they were before.
We're working according to a logic
of reconstruction that's,
I don't know if you can call
it archaeological reconstruction,
but let's say faithful reconstruction,
restoring it as far as we're able to,
to the state before the fire.
They begin with a great transverse arch
which forms the skeleton of the vault.
There's about 30 to 35%
of the arch remaining.
That obviously gives us a starting point for the geometry.
Especially since of the 79 arch stones
that fell, we've recovered 70.
One by one, the recovered arch stones
are washed to remove their covering of lead dust.
Damaged by fire and water,
and after falling from a great height,
experts wondered if they could be used again.
The big question the architects
need to answer is, how solid are these blocks?
How well can they sustain the weight of the cathedral?
Several of the stone blocks are analyzed
by geophysicist Thomas Dabat
at the Historical Monuments Research Laboratory
in Champs-sur-Marne.
So, with this selection of 30 blocks
of stone, taken from the three vaults which collapsed,
my work consists of taking cylindrical samples
out of each block.
(drill whirring)
We can study the effects of any damage,
both at the surface and deep inside the block.
(soft celestial music)
So, the aim here is to establish the blocks
that can be used again and those that can't.
(grinder whirring)
This analysis is quite complicated,
because the damage done to the stone blocks
is not consistent.
(celestial music)
Here, I have three samples
from the same block of stone,
and you can clearly see that they look different.
This first one is severely damaged,
it's a dark gray color and it's extremely fissured.
It comes from the surface of the block,
which underwent extreme heat.
So the question now is how its resistance compares
to a sample from an undamaged part of the block?
(celestial music continues)
Thomas Dabat measures how energy moves
through each stone.
The results are sent to Lise Leroux,
who is responsible for monitoring the state
of the cathedral's ancient stones?
(celestial music continues)
There was uncertainty about whether
these arch stones, these blocks,
would have the same mechanical properties
as when they're initially used.
And what we were able to show
was that many could be used again.
Not all of them, but some.
(celestial music continues)
Of the 70 blocks recovered,
only 15 of them seem stable enough to be reused.
But first, the usable stones must be reassembled
on the ground.
Like pieces of a gigantic jigsaw puzzle,
the experts need to work out the correct placement
for each one.
(group speaking French)
We started this trial reassembly hoping
that we'd be able to replace some of these arch stones
in place, because that was one of the major goals,
to preserve the same components
as they were originally used in the edifice.
(group speaking French)
There are critical decisions to be made.
Each of the missing blocks needs to be cut
and then arranged using the original techniques.
(group speaking French)
This experiment was requested
by the architects in charge of the restoration,
and you can understand why,
because architecture is an experimentation with space.
An architect isn't just someone who builds some walls,
it's someone who, using those walls,
creates a space.
And to get a real understanding
of what that arch represented,
they'd have to put it back together for real.
And this has never been attempted before
on a Gothic cathedral.
Never before have all these different skill sets
and specialties of all kinds
been brought together in the service of a national monument.
Well, at least not in France.
It's an incredibly difficult challenge
because there are no blueprints from the Middle Ages
and no model for a transverse arch.
(group speaking French)
The experts are forced to seek answers
from the ruined cathedral itself.
They scan every part of the building stonework
using drones equipped with cameras.
(celestial music) (air whooshing)
Suspended above the vaulting,
rotating scanners digitize the details of what is left
of the roof and its framework.
By combining these two techniques,
they can create a precise virtual copy
of the cathedral after the fire.
Livio De Luca, the research director
at the National Center for Scientific Research in Marseille,
heads the digital team.
In the quest to restore Notre-Dame,
virtual reality becomes a tool
for archaeological investigation for the first time.
You can no longer think
of digital technology as just virtual.
There's a sort of complete symbiosis
between physical reality and digital reality.
What we're composing is a sort of digital memory.
And it's not only the digital memory
of a physical dimension,
it's the digital memory of a scientific adventure.
(celestial music)
The digital team relied on another asset,
a 3D model of the cathedral done in 2010.
It was created by a young American historian
We can superimpose the points cloud,
which was made before the fire by Andrew Tallon, okay?
We have it right there.
And we can fill in the holes with the point cloud from-
Can you turn it around a bit?
Yes, it's perfectly aligned as well.
Can you come back to the post-fire bit,
just to see there.
There. Right there.
That's it.
We gathered, integrated,
and combined data on the different states
of the cathedral before the fire,
during the phase when the vestiges were being recovered,
and of course, after the cleanup of the surfaces.
This 4-dimensional representation
of the cathedral we created
lets us look at everything
in a uniquely geometric framework,
while also traveling through time.
(celestial music)
The combination of data enables
the engineers to establish a plan
to rebuild a part of the arch that has collapsed.
This plan is transposed at full size
on an immense ground sheet.
(celestial music continues)
The team can now determine how to position
the 70 arch stones according to their dimensions.
For archaeologist Cedric Moulis,
seeing the plan laid out reveal
the unique arrangement of the stones.
This plan was a great help,
because we have an arch that isn't standardized.
By that I mean that the arch stones are all different sizes.
The smallest are 10 centimeters thick,
and the biggest are up to 28,
but the sizes don't increase progressively.
It's not necessarily the biggest ones at the bottom
and the smallest at the top.
So the whole idea is to understand the sequence
of how they were organized.
Here you have a stone of 19
in a place that's 18.5,
and one that's 18 in a place that's 19.
The archaeologists continue to be surprised.
Out of 66 recovered arch stones,
49 had thicknesses from 14 to 18 centimeters.
13 had thicknesses from 18.5 to 28 centimeters.
And only four measured from 10.5 to 13.5 centimeters.
The team needs to understand why the thickness varied.
The answer will lie deep underground
in an ancient quarry which had provided stone
for other Parisian monuments.
(soft tense music)
Archaeologist Marc Vire is an expert on quarries.
And he spots clues that Notre-Dame stonemasons
had been there.
(soft tense music continues)
So we have coarse limestone here,
sedimentary rock, which formed on the bed
of a warm and shallow sea,
and which formed into these banks,
these banks of rock.
Why is this?
Because, from time to time,
the sea doesn't deposit the sediment so well,
and so we get these horizontal joints,
which geologists call stratigraphic joints.
And between these joints,
the rock is in one solid piece,
a massive bank of rock.
And this is what determines the height of the blocks
dug out of the quarries.
Here, for example,
this is as high as a block can be,
but down here the bank is deeper,
so the quarry workers would've been able
to dig out much bigger blocks.
Even with the advantage
of stratigraphic joints,
removing the massive blocks
would've required extremely grueling labor.
They inserted iron wedges
and walloped them with a sledgehammer,
and that way cutting out a block from the rock face.
This is what we call the extraction.
Even at the quarry stage,
there was this basic work done on the shape of the block.
The block had to be square,
this was the basic shape.
And this was done right here inside the quarry.
Once this basic shape was extracted,
the block was placed on a cart
and taken from the quarry to the work site.
And there, the stonemason would do the secondary cutting
so it could be used in the cathedral.
As the scientists make progress
with reconstructing the transverse arch,
they discover an ancient
but efficient organizational system.
So a block would come from the quarry,
from which they'd cut two arch stones.
So from a standard block,
they'd cut out two arch stones lengthwise
but to the same thickness.
Is that what you mean?
Yes, the same thickness.
So from a big block this size,
they were able to cut out two arch stones.
We're really learning things here.
We don't know anything anymore.
It's like we're only just starting
to learn about vaulted ceilings.
(person speaking French)
As the puzzle slowly comes together,
a detail on some of the blocks
demands further investigation.
We're finding out more,
for example, from these small cavities
which were cut into this part of the arch stones
at their junction with the rest of the vault.
These notches, which sometimes
go across two stones together,
were slots to fit wooden trusses into,
to stabilize them during the construction phase
while the mortar was drying.
These trusses were a temporary construction
that would then be removed.
(soft brooding music)
Yves Gallet wants to fully understand
what role the notches played
in the cathedral's construction.
The answer might be found at the top of Notre-Dame.
(brooding music)
Notre-Dame has completed the first phase of its restoration.
Over just a few months,
the cathedral of stone has become a cathedral of iron.
(brooding music continues)
Nearly 1500 tons of metals were used to construct a skeleton
over which the restored legend would be rebuilt.
It's a colossal frame,
designed for the massive task ahead.
(brooding music continues)
When the scientists first ascended in the iron cage,
they came face to face with something no one
had seen up close for over 150 years.
The vaulted ceilings of Notre-Dame.
Going up like that in the lift,
when seeing it from that perspective,
the state that the cathedral is in,
you get a shock.
You get a shock.
You think you're prepared for it,
but you still get a shock.
(soft celestial music)
(moves to ethereal music)
Also, seeing the damaged state of the stone,
it's hard to imagine from down below.
This stone has already been doing its job for centuries,
and now water has gotten into the masonry,
the salts have been leaking out,
the skin of the stone is starting to blister,
starting to deform.
Up close, you can see all that.
(soft melancholy music)
Yves Gallet uses this opportunity
to further his investigation into the strange notches
on the fallen blocks.
He had to get close enough to see if they were visible
in the remaining arches.
Can we look over here?
(drone whirring)
That one's wonderfully clear.
You can see the notch perfectly across two arch stones.
(drone whirring)
(person speaking French)
Statistically, they're mostly concentrated
in the upper part of the vault.
Finally, the reason behind the placement
of the mysterious notches was becoming clear.
These notches became more necessary
in the construction of the vault
the more overhanging the arch got.
The closer you got to the summit,
the more pronounced this overhang was,
with, consequently, a greater danger
of collapse without that supporting wooden structure.
There's one at every fourth, fifth,
or sixth lock depending on the thickness of the blocks.
So it's quite a regular distribution.
A temporary wooden structure held
the vault in place during its original construction
and helps archaeologists determine how to assemble the arch.
That's a really good notch.
The idea was that the number of stones
with these notches is precise.
It's exact.
So we divided the number by two
to get the number of notches on the right side of the arch
the same as on the left.
And we saw that the space between the notches,
into which the wooden trusses were placed, was 3.5 feet.
(soft music)
This equals one meter and 10 centimeters.
With the reconstruction of the arch underway,
another detail requires clarification.
(soft music continues)
The experts need to know the significance
of the crosses carved into the blocks.
The crosses had been hidden under mortar for 800 years.
What role did they play in the assembly?
(soft music continues)
Clues are found in Noyon Cathedral's attic space,
where stone fragments that were damaged during World War II
had been stored.
(soft music continues)
Historian Arnaud Timbert finds similar crosses
on some of these pieces.
(soft music continues)
In the 13th century,
there was a sort of production process in the quarry
for turning out standard, prefabricated pieces.
There were men already working the stones at the quarry,
and they had to convey information
by means of certain signs to the men
on the work site who were going to assemble the pieces.
And these men wouldn't know each other.
There will be no other communication between them,
so they'd make this type of mark,
a cross, for example,
to show that this stone was intended to go next
to another stone with the same mark
in the corresponding place.
(gentle music)
The crosses served as guides
for the stonemasons by indicating
which side of the block was to be placed
onto the previous one
and which side would remain visible
until the next block was placed.
What matters here is the cross.
The crosses, the notches,
and the dimensions of the blocks
all have equal importance.
But it seems there may be multiple versions
of how the blocks could have been arranged.
The reassembly presented a monstrous challenge.
(group speaking French) (gentle music continues)
As we tried to position a stone
in such and such a place,
other questions, other problems would pop up,
and we'd suddenly realize that a stone actually went here,
and that would knock all the others out of position.
As the difficulty of the task
became more apparent,
the team reaches out to the digital experts again.
This time they need to scan each piece
of the mammoth puzzle
so that they can attempt to solve it virtually.
(determined music)
Engineer Eloi Gattie invented
a special device for this process.
Under domed lights equipped with four cameras,
the arch stones are photographed from every angle.
These photos are then processed
using photogrammetry software
to create a virtual copy of the object.
Each stone block is captured
as an incredibly precise 3D model.
(determined music)
In Marseille, Livio De Luca and Antoine Gros
begin to reproduce the state of the cathedral
one day after the fire.
(determined music continues)
They organized thousands of photos taken
by the team following the catastrophe.
(camera whirring and snapping)
By repositioning the photographs within the virtual space,
they create 3D models of the fragments
in such detail that it's possible to identify
the digitally scanned arch stones.
So, you see this photo?
We have stone X-001,
and we can go looking for it.
You can clearly see its tours and moldings.
(determined music continues)
(camera snapping and whirring)
The investigation continues.
From the position of the arch stones on the floor,
the scientists can calculate the vertical drop,
locating where they fell from.
(determined music continues)
They pinpoint the stone's original position in the arch.
But it's difficult to reposition every block,
because some were deflected when they fell.
They need a way to confirm the original positions
of all 70 arch stones.
Once all the data and all the observations
have been gathered and processed,
we're able to work through all this information
and make sense of it.
As regards to the assembly of the transverse arch,
we can offer, in parallel to the traditional methods,
a mathematical method.
Livio De Luca's team creates an algorithm
that integrates the pathways
of the arch stones' trajectories
with the discoveries made by the archaeologists.
So we have this tracking criterion
whereby we can work out the position
of a stone from its fall.
And added to this,
the archaeologists have found notches and crosses
in the stones by which they can work out their relation
to each other and reassemble them.
(celestial music)
But there were countless ways the stones might
have been assembled,
and no human brain can accurately process all the data.
They turned to a computer for a review
of the algorithm's information
to produce the most accurate result.
(celestial music continues) (computers whirring)
Here we can see part of the solution
on the screen, where we have the different arch stones
put back inside that envelope.
Let's take N-222 as an example.
Using the algorithm,
we've been able to put that in position R-3.
No, R-4, right there,
and see it next to other arch stones in our solution.
(gentle accomplished music)
The researchers now have a solution
that seems 80% accurate.
But there's still some margin for error.
It's impossible to be certain of the precise position
for each of the 70 arch stones.
The secret code to unlocking this medieval masterpiece
still resists modern technology.
Nonetheless, this incredible process
has provided a wealth of information
about the way in which Notre-Dame's builders
were able to construct an arch over 30 meters high,
a first in the history of Gothic architecture.
The fact of physically attempting
this reassembly helped us to understand things
that we wouldn't have understood any other way.
We've got a real understanding
of the weight of these blocks,
of the methods used for lifting these blocks
over 30 meters above the ground,
and of the difficulties involved in manipulating
such heavy blocks in order to orient them
in the right positions on the wooden centering.
What I'll gain some understanding of here
is how the work site,
the work site of that period, would've functioned.
Pascal Prunet needed that in order to understand
how the arch worked,
but that also helped us to understand
how it had originally been constructed,
which will, in turn, help us to reconstruct it.
(gentle accomplished music continues)
The archaeological investigation was a success
because of the unique and unprecedented collaboration
between the multidisciplinary team and the architects.
(Pascal speaking French)
Now a decision has to be made.
It's unlikely that the salvaged blocks
can be placed into the reconstructed arch
without knowing the precise placement of every stone.
The solution for the reconstruction
is something that came about gradually.
In the beginning, we felt a sort of moral obligation
to put these arch stones back in place.
We wanted to show that what had been recovered
could go back where it belonged.
But we don't know that.
And if we're not sure that it's going back
to its correct position, then in a way,
just placing it in some arbitrary position
isn't necessarily a good thing.
(celestial music)
The exquisite scan of the cathedral
done before the fire will allow it
to be reconstructed identical to the original.
But the arch stones must all be new,
cut to the same dimensions as the medieval blocks.
The team now needs to find the source
for the replacement stones.
(celestial music continues) (hammer knocking)
And search for limestone with the same characteristics
and composition as the cathedral's original stones.
The answer came from examining the transept crossing,
because the architect who rebuilt the vaults
in the 18th century had faced the same problem.
Paris quarries had been stripped clean
during the Middle Ages.
So where did he find his replacement stones?
Geologist Lise Leroux analyzes a sample
from an 18th-century block
at the Historical Monuments Research Laboratory.
The sort of observations a geologist
can make regarding a sample of stone taken
from a building are in the order of determining
what are the principal minerals that can be seen,
that can be recognized,
and also whether there are fossils or not.
It so happens that in this piece
there's a whole series of different microfossils.
The sample contains billions
of fossil skeletons and remains of microorganisms
that have collected over eons
during the formation of the limestone.
On this image in particular,
we can see a tiny bit of debris of a fossil.
It's a fossil of Orbitolites complanatus.
(soft celestial music)
There are also minerals present,
which can give us some clues.
We know in what kind of environment this rock formed,
and it's quite probable that it comes
from the Vexin area of northern France.
(soft celestial music) (lever whirring)
Lise Leroux has access to a rare asset
that allows her to pinpoint the limestone's origin.
Generations of geologists have accumulated
a unique stone collection with more than 6000 samples
from monuments and quarries all over the country.
It's a geological map of the monuments of France.
Amongst these stone samples
from a sculpture on the Pont d'Iena in Paris,
we have exactly the same assortment of fossils
and minerals as in the sample taken
from the arch stone from Notre-Dame.
And it just so happens that for the Pont d'Iena,
we have a written source telling us the actual quarry
that the stone came from,
which is at a place called Sagy in the Val-d'Oise.
So this confirms that for the stones of that arch,
we have a source which is a quarry in the Vexin region.
(dramatic music)
Based on the geological investigation,
the stone for the reconstruction can now be sourced.
Work begins in the Val-d'Oise quarries to extract limestone
from which Notre-Dame's new arch stones will be cut.
(dramatic music continues)
The plan links the past to the future,
ensuring that the majestic arch will once again soar
in the name of Notre-Dame.
(dramatic music continues)
As the work progresses,
today's builders continue to discover
more about the incredible accomplishments
of their medieval predecessors.
It's one of the very first cathedrals,
and it's like they pulled all the materials up
into position to the very limits of their capabilities,
and yet it didn't settle over time.
The flying buttresses remained,
the vaulted ceilings were still there,
with the roof's framework above.
Eight centuries, and it hadn't moved.
Notre-Dame keeps its secrets close,
and the methods builders used for a structure
that survived throughout centuries remain mysterious.
(ethereal music)
It's impossible for the architects
to rebuild the edifice without understanding
and confirming its stability.
When the cathedral's roof was destroyed,
the building's framework
and careful balance was compromised.
The fractured vaulting was dangerously weakened
by fire and water,
yet it continued to support over 500 tons
of damaged lead and wood.
Scientists, along with wood,
metal, and stone specialists unite
to determine how these materials worked together.
They will probe the stone vaults,
burrow into the masonry to examine the metal skeleton,
and investigate the destroyed roof's wooden frame.
Slowly, they will learn the laws of physics
that governed and gave life to this gigantic
but fragile house of cards.
(brooding music)
(air whooshing) (brooding music continues)
(air whooshing)
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.