Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Ferrera: I WAS BORN IN CALIFORNIA.
NOW I LIVE IN NEW YORK.
AND BETWEEN SUPERSTORM SANDY HERE
AND THE RAGING WILDFIRES AND THE RECORD DROUGHTS THERE,
IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO IGNORE GLOBAL WARMING.
IT WORRIES ME A LOT.
SO WHEN I GET A CHANCE TO MEET A TOP ENERGY EXECUTIVE
WHOSE COMPANY BURNS A LOT OF COAL, OIL, AND GAS,
I'M EAGER TO ASK HIM SOME TOUGH QUESTIONS.
THE SINGLE-LARGEST SOURCE OF CARBON EMISSIONS
IN THE UNITED STATES, IN THE WORLD,
COMES FROM POWER PLANTS. MM-HMM.
AND WE OWN POWER PLANTS. MM-HMM.
DAVID CRANE IS THE C.E.O.
OF AMERICA'S SECOND-LARGEST ENERGY GENERATION COMPANY --
NRG.
WHEN IT COMES TO CLIMATE CHANGE AND CARBON EMISSIONS,
SO MANY PEOPLE WOULD SAY YOU'RE THE BAD GUY.
WE MAKE ENOUGH POWER TO LIGHT UP 40 MILLION AMERICAN HOMES.
MM-HMM.
BUT IN ORDER TO DO THAT, RIGHT NOW,
WE'RE EMITTING ABOUT 60 MILLION TONS OF CARBON
INTO THE ATMOSPHERE A YEAR.
WE'RE THE BAD GUY BECAUSE WE'RE KEEPING THE LIGHTS ON
IN EVERYONE'S HOME,
AND THIS IS THE WAY THE LIGHTS HAVE BEEN KEPT ON
FOR THE LAST 100 YEARS. AND SO...
BUT THEN HE TELLS ME SOMETHING I WASN'T EXPECTING.
HE'S TRYING TO MOVE AWAY FROM OIL AND COAL,
AND AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE.
IN TEXAS, HIS COMPANY IS ALREADY
ONE OF THE BIGGEST PROVIDERS OF WIND ENERGY.
SO THEN, IS YOUR INTEREST IN SUSTAINABLE ENERGY
PURELY PERSONAL AND MORAL, OR DO YOU SEE --
DOES IT MAKE BUSINESS SENSE?
OH, NO, IT MAKES TOTAL BUSINESS SENSE.
YOU KNOW, WHEN WE STARTED,
WE SORT OF LOOKED AROUND TO OUR LEFT AND TO OUR RIGHT,
THINKING THAT, YOU KNOW,
OURS IS A PRETTY COMPETITIVE INDUSTRY,
WHERE, YOU KNOW, ALL OUR COMPETITORS ARE GONNA BE THERE
AND WE'RE GONNA HAVE TO FIGHT THEM.
AND WE WERE ALONE. WHY?
[ LAUGHS ] I DON'T KNOW.
I CAN'T ASK THAT QUESTION.
AND DAVID CRANE ISN'T THE ONLY SURPRISING PERSON
WHO'S PUSHING FOR CLEAN ENERGY THESE DAYS.
ABOUT AN HOUR FROM WHERE I GREW UP,
I MEET THE MAYOR OF LANCASTER, CALIFORNIA,
A TOUGH-ON-CRIME REPUBLICAN
WHO'S TRYING TO POWER HIS ENTIRE CITY WITH SOLAR ENERGY.
HALF THE PEOPLE THINK I'M NUTS WHEN I SAY THESE THINGS,
HALF THE PEOPLE BELIEVE ME, AND THEN IT HAPPENS.
MM-HMM. YOU KNOW, NOBODY BELIEVED
97% OF THE CITY BUILDINGS WOULD BE NET ZERO.
EXPLAIN. WHAT IS NET ZERO?
NET ZERO IS,
WE ARE NOT CREATING A CARBON FOOTPRINT AT ALL.
THAT'S ATTAINABLE NOW.
AND IT'S NOT JUST COMPANIES AND CITIES
THAT ARE TURNING TO RENEWABLES.
ENTIRE COUNTRIES ARE, TOO.
PEOPLE HAVE BEEN TALKING ABOUT SOLAR AND WIND
SINCE 1970s WHEN, YOU KNOW,
JIMMY CARTER WAS TALKING ABOUT THIS STUFF.
SO IT'S BEEN AROUND FOR A WHILE.
BUT WHAT'S DIFFERENT NOW IS
THAT YOU'VE GOT GERMANY, JAPAN, DENMARK --
REALLY LARGE, SOPHISTICATED ECONOMIES
THAT ARE NOW SPRINTING TOWARDS RENEWABLE ENERGY,
BECAUSE WE'RE COST-EFFECTIVE,
WE CREATE HUGE AMOUNT OF JOBS, WE'RE LOCAL,
SO YOU DON'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT IMPORTING FOREIGN OIL
OR DOING ALL OF THOSE THINGS.
SO WHAT'S STOPPING OUR COUNTRY FROM DOING THE SAME THING?
RENEWABLE ENERGY SEEMS TO BE MORE VIABLE THAN EVER.
BUT I'M ALSO LEARNING
THERE ARE SOME POWERFUL FORCES STANDING IN ITS WAY.
President Obama: OUR PLANET IS CHANGING IN WAYS
THAT WILL HAVE PROFOUND IMPACTS ON ALL OF HUMANKIND.
I'M HERE TO SAY WE NEED TO ACT.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Bittman: ON A HOT DAY LAST SUMMER,
THE PRESIDENT LAID OUT A NEW, MORE AGGRESSIVE PLAN
TO REIGN IN CLIMATE CHANGE.
THESE ARE FACTS.
Bittman: OBAMA CLAIMED TO SEE A PATH FORWARD
FROM THE DIRTY ENERGY OF THE PAST
TO THE CLEAN ENERGY OF THE FUTURE.
BUT THE ENERGY SOURCE THE PRESIDENT TALKED ABOUT THE MOST
WASN'T WIND OR SOLAR OR EVEN NUCLEAR.
IT WAS NATURAL GAS.
WE'RE ALSO PRODUCING MORE CLEANER-BURNING NATURAL GAS
THAN ANY OTHER COUNTRY ON EARTH.
Bittman: HE CALLED IT CLEAN, AFFORDABLE,
AND CRITICAL TO STOPPING GLOBAL WARMING.
IT CAN ALSO HELP REDUCE OUR CARBON EMISSIONS.
Bittman: THESE DAYS, A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE SAYING
THAT NATURAL GAS IS TH SOLUTION
TO BOTH OUR ENERGY AND CLIMATE WOES.
BUT I DISCOVERED THAT A HANDFUL OF SCIENTISTS
HAVE SOME PROBLEMS WITH THAT CLAIM,
INCLUDING ONE WHO USED TO WORK FOR THE GAS INDUSTRY.
Ingraffea: THE INDUSTRY
REALLY WANTS THE AMERICAN PEOPLE TO BELIEVE.
THEY REALLY WANT
THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES TO BELIEVE.
THEY WANT ALL THE STATE REGULATORS
AND STATE LEGISLATORS TO BELIEVE WHAT THEY'RE SAYING,
WHICH IS, "SHALE GAS IS OUR SAVIOR.
MERRY CHRISTMAS, AMERICA."
[ CHUCKLES ]
"IT'S GONNA MAKE US ENERGY-INDEPENDENT,
ENERGY-SECURE, IT'S GONNA KEEP PRICES LOW,
IT'S GONNA KILL COAL."
WELL, ALL THOSE THINGS DEPEND UPON
SHALE GAS BEING "CLEAN."
AND WE QUESTION THAT.
Woman: THIS REPORT CONSTITUTES AN ALARM-CLOCK MOMENT
FOR THE WORLD,
BECAUSE THIS REPORT WILL TELL US, AGAIN,
THAT EVERYTHING WE THOUGHT WE KNEW ON CLIMATE CHANGE
HAS ACTUALLY BEEN UNDERESTIMATED,
THAT THE EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE WILL BE UPON US
FASTER AND IN A MORE INTENSE FASHION THAN WE HAD THOUGHT.
President H.W. Bush: WE ALL KNOW THAT HUMAN ACTIVITIES
ARE CHANGING THE ATMOSPHERE
IN UNEXPECTED AND IN UNPRECEDENTED WAYS.
Man: ...THAT THE GREENHOUSE EFFECT HAS BEEN DETECTED,
AND IT IS CHANGING OUR CLIMATE NOW.
Man #2: THE ATMOSPHERE AND OCEAN HAVE WARMED.
THE AMOUNT OF SNOW AND ICE HAVE DIMINISHED.
SEA LEVEL HAS RISEN,
AND THE CONCENTRATIONS OF GREENHOUSE GASES HAVE...
Schwarzenegger: THERE IS NO MORE FIRE SEASON.
WE HAVE WILDFIRES ALL YEAR 'ROUND.
Man #3: CLIMATE CHANGE, EXTREME WEATHER...
Man #3: ...AND OUR VULNERABILITY TO IT.
Man #5: ...WHERE 12 YEARS OF DROUGHT HAS LEFT THE LANDSCAPE BONE-DRY.
Man #6: WE GOT ANY PATRIOTS IN THE CROWD?!
Woman #2: A NEW SCIENTIFIC REPORT HAS DETERMINED
THE LAST DECADE WAS THE WARMEST ON RECORD.
Man #7: OUR WORLD IS CHANGING FASTER
AND MORE DRAMATICALLY THAN EVER BEFORE.
Ferrera: WHEN I STARTED LOOKING INTO
THE STATE OF CLEAN ENERGY IN AMERICA,
EVERYONE TOLD ME TO GO TO KANSAS.
TO THE NATIVE AMERICANS WHO ONCE LIVED HERE,
KANSAS MEANS "PEOPLE OF THE SOUTH WIND."
THEY SAY THAT IN SOME PARTS OF THE STATE,
IT NEVER STOPS BLOWING.
TODAY, MORE AND MORE PEOPLE IN KANSAS
ARE TRYING TO HARNESS THAT NATURAL RESOURCE.
WOW. LOOK AT THAT.
IT'S HUGE.
I'M HERE TO MEET WITH ONE OF THE PIONEERS,
A RANCHER NAMED PETE FERRELL.
Ferrell: I USED TO CUSS THE WIND. [ LAUGHS ]
THERE WERE DAYS I'D COME IN WITH A HEADACHE
FROM HAVING TO CLAMP MY HAT ON SO TIGHT OVER MY HEAD.
SO AT WHAT POINT
DID YOUR RELATIONSHIP TO THE WIND CHANGE?
IT WAS OUT OF STRATEGIC NECESSITY.
I REALIZED A NUMBER OF YEARS AGO,
THAT I WAS GONNA JOIN THE OLD, DEAD RANCHERS SOCIETY.
THAT'S WHERE YOU WORK 24/7, 365 DAYS A YEAR
UNTIL YOU FALL OVER DEAD,
AND THEN A BUNCH OF PEOPLE GATHER AROUND
AND CONGRATULATE YOU FOR WHAT A FINE JOB YOU DID.
"YEAH, BOY.
BOY, HE PUT AWAY THE HOURS, DIDN'T HE?"
AND I'VE SEEN GUYS JUST WORK THEMSELVES INTO THE GRAVE,
AND I DECIDED I DIDN'T WANT TO BE A MEMBER OF THAT SOCIETY.
I WANTED TO FIND A DIFFERENT WAY.
BUT WHEN HE FIRST PUT UP THESE TURBINES,
HE HAD NO IDEA THEY WOULD END UP SAVING HIS RANCH
WHEN DISASTER STRUCK.
Woman: THE WORST DROUGHT IN DECADES
IS CAUSING PAIN ACROSS MORE THAN HALF THE NATION.
TODAY, THE U.S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE REPORTS
ALMOST HALF OF ALL THE NATION'S COUNTIES
HAVE BEEN DECLARED DISASTERS BECAUSE OF THIS YEAR'S DROUGHT.
WE'VE HAD DROUGHTS BEFORE.
WE COULD MEASURE THEM IN MONTHS.
SO THE FIRST TIME IN MY LIFE
THAT I GOT TO EXPERIENCE A THREE-YEAR DROUGHT --
AND A DROUGHT IS LIKE A PIECE OF SAND
YOU CAN NEVER GET OUT OF YOUR EYE.
IT'S ALWAYS THERE.
IT ALWAYS REMINDS YOU EVERY DAY
WHEN YOU LOOK OUT AND YOU SEE THE LANDSCAPE DYING.
I DON'T KNOW WHAT MY FELLOW RANCHERS --
WELL, I DO KNOW WHAT THEY'RE DOING.
I KNOW THEY'RE QUITTING.
AND THEY'RE LOSING THEIR LAND AND THEIR LIVELIHOODS.
AND, OF COURSE, MY ACE UP MY SLEEVE
IS THAT I HAVE A WIND FARM, WHICH ALLOWS ME
TO GAIN AN ADDITIONAL TRACK OF REVENUE
IN SPITE OF A DROUGHT.
WIND IS MY BEST CASH CROP IN A DROUGHT,
BECAUSE WIND BLOWS EVEN DURING A DROUGHT.
SO, PETE, TALK TO ME ABOUT THE HISTORY OF THIS RANCH.
HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN HERE?
MY GREAT-GRANDFATHER FOUNDED THIS RANCH IN 1888.
THIS IS WHERE HE SPENT HIS FINAL YEARS.
HE BUILT THIS HOUSE AS A 70-YEAR-OLD,
JUST FIVE YEARS BEFORE HE DIED.
THIS VERY HOUSE?
THIS VERY HOUSE, BUILT 90 YEARS AGO BY HIM.
SO I'M LIVING IN MY GREAT-GRANDFATHER'S HOME,
AND IT'S SACRED GROUND.
PETE SAYS THAT, AT FIRST,
PEOPLE WERE SKEPTICAL OF HIS WIND TURBINES.
BUT A FEW YEARS AFTER HE PUT THEM UP,
THE WHOLE STATE GOT BEHIND WIND ENERGY IN A BIG WAY.
KANSAS PASSED A LAW REQUIRING THAT 20% OF ALL ELECTRICITY
COME FROM RENEWABLES BY 2020.
NOW MORE THAN HALF THE STATES IN THE COUNTRY HAVE SIMILAR LAWS.
THEY'RE KNOWN AS RENEWABLE ENERGY STANDARDS.
AND IT'S THANKS, IN PART, TO THESE LAWS THAT IN 2012,
WIND AND SOLAR IN THE U.S. GREW FASTER
THAN ANY OTHER ENERGY SOURCE --
FASTER THAN COAL OR EVEN NATURAL GAS.
KANSAS NOW HAS ENOUGH TURBINES TO POWER NEARLY A MILLION HOMES.
AND IT'S NOT JUST LEFTIES WHO ARE HAPPY ABOUT THIS.
KANSAS' REPUBLICAN GOVERNOR,
ONE OF THE MOST CONSERVATIVE IN THE COUNTRY,
IS A HUGE SUPPORTER.
IF WE DO THIS RIGHT,
WE WILL SEE THE DEVELOPMENT OF RENEWABLE ENERGY CORRIDOR
THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF KANSAS
THAT WILL PROVIDE JOBS FOR RURAL KANSAS
AND CLEAN ENERGY FOR THE WORLD.
I WANT KANSAS TO NOT ONLY BE KNOWN AS THE WHEAT STATE,
BUT ALSO THE RENEWABLE STATE, AND WE CAN DO IT.
BUT NOT EVERYONE IS HAPPY ABOUT ALL THE GROWTH IN RENEWABLES,
AND SOME GROUPS ARE WORKING VERY HARD TO CONVINCE PEOPLE
THAT WIND AND SOLAR ARE A BAD BET.
[ BLOWS ]
WE ARE AT THE WORLD SERIES OF POKER
IN THE RIO HOTEL AND CASINO.
PROBABLY ABOUT 2,000 PLAYERS --
MOSTLY POKER PROFESSIONALS, A FEW AMATEURS LIKE MYSELF.
THE GAME -- IT'S SO COMPLEX.
THERE'S PATIENCE, SELF-CONTROL, SELF-DISCIPLINE.
THEN IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT TO BE ABLE TO READ PEOPLE,
UNDERSTANDING, YOU KNOW, WHO THEY ARE, HOW THEY'RE PLAYING.
AND FOR MY JOB AS AN ANALYST
FOR ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENT ISSUES AND POLICY,
LIKE I WOULD AT THE POKER TABLE, I NEED TO KNOW ALL THE DATA,
I NEED TO KNOW ALL THE STUDIES,
I NEED TO DISCERN WHAT EACH PIECE OF DATA OR STUDY MEANS,
FIT IT INTO THE OVERALL PICTURE.
THE MERE NOTION THAT CLIMATE IS CHANGING
DOES NOT MEAN "A" -- THAT WE'RE FACING A CRISIS --
OR "B" -- THAT WE NEED TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT.
Ferrera: JAMES TAYLOR SPENDS MUCH OF HIS TIME ON THE ROAD...
GOOD MORNING.
...GOING FROM STATE TO STATE TO STATE,
TRYING TO SHUT DOWN
ANY GOVERNMENT EFFORTS TO PROMOTE RENEWABLES.
Taylor: I'VE BEEN TO MOST OF THE STATE CAPITALS
TO MEET WITH LEGISLATORS OR STATE OFFICIALS OR TO TESTIFY.
FOR TODAY'S HEARINGS, WOULD YOU PREFER
THAT I EMPHASIZE MORE THE ECONOMICS,
MORE THE ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES?
Woman: EMPHASIZE THE ECONOMICS SIDE.
I DON'T THINK WE'RE GONNA WIN THE ENVIRONMENTAL ARGUMENT.
THESE ARE WHERE THE BATTLES ARE FOUGHT REGARDING GLOBAL WARMING
AND ALL SORTS OF OTHER ISSUES.
THE OBJECTIVE FACT IS THAT RENEWABLE POWER
IS SUBSTANTIALLY MORE EXPENSIVE THAN CONVENTIONAL POWER.
NATURAL GAS --
REGARDING THE SIX PRINCIPLE POLLUTANTS TRACKED BY E.P.A.,
NATURAL GAS CUTS THOSE POLLUTANTS BY 90%-PLUS.
IT'S ESSENTIALLY AN EMISSIONS-FREE POWER SOURCE.
YOU ARE ALMOST A WHOLLY OWNED SUBSIDIARY
OF EXXON MOBIL, ARE YOU NOT?
[ CHUCKLES ] WELL, THAT'S WHAT
THE GLOBAL-WARMING ALARMISTS OF THE WORLD
WOULD LIKE YOU TO BELIEVE.
Ferrera: TAYLOR SEEMS TO BE PART OF A VOCAL MINORITY.
I FIND A GALLUP POLL SAYING THAT THREE OUT OF FOUR AMERICANS
WANT THE COUNTRY TO PUSH HARDER ON WIND AND SOLAR.
WHY IS TAYLOR SO INTENT ON STOPPING THAT?
YOU'LL WIN THEM BACK. DON'T WORRY. TRUST ME.
WHO IS THIS GUY?
Holton: GOT TO KEEP AN EYE OUT FOR GOLFERS.
HOPEFULLY, THEY'RE SENDING THEM OFF THE OTHER WAY.
[ LAUGHS ]
I DON'T WANT TO GET HIT IN THE BACK OF THE HEAD.
IT WOULD TAKE A VERY WEIRD SHOT
FOR US TO GET HIT IN THE BACK OF THE HEAD. [ CHUCKLES ]
Bittman: I'M A COLUMNIST FOR "THE NEW YORK TIMES,"
AND I WRITE A LOT ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE.
IN THE LAST FEW YEARS, THERE'S BEEN GROWING EXCITEMENT
ABOUT NATURAL GAS AS A CLEAN ALTERNATIVE TO COAL AND OIL.
AND IN CITIES LIKE FORT LUPTON,
THERE'S ANOTHER REASON TO BE EXCITED --
ALL THE MONEY THAT'S FLOWING.
Holton: THIS IS AN OIL-AND-GAS OPERATIONS AREA.
IT'S WITHIN 400 FEET, 300 FEET OF RESIDENTIAL HOMES --
ON THE GOLF COURSE.
NO COMPLAINTS, NO PROBLEMS?
"THIS IS THE WAY IT IS," AND PEOPLE ARE OKAY WITH THAT?
IF THERE WERE ANY COMPLAINTS,
I CAN GUARANTEE YOU THAT THEY'D BE CALLING THE MAYOR.
[ LAUGHS ] SO I WOULD HEAR THAT.
WHEN I FIRST GOT ELECTED,
WE WERE HAVING FORECLOSURES LEFT AND RIGHT,
JUST LIKE IT WAS ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
2008, 2009? YEAH.
AND WHEN I GOT IN, THE OIL AND GAS CAME.
AND WHEN THAT CAME, WE STARTED ADDING JOBS.
AND SO, IT MADE A HUGE DIFFERENCE.
I MEAN, EVERYBODY'S UP AT LEAST 20% IN THEIR BUSINESS --
20% TO 30%.
WE'RE THE SAUDI ARABIA OF NATURAL GAS.
JUST A FEW YEARS AGO, AMERICA'S ENERGY FUTURE LOOKED UNCERTAIN.
THEN FRACKING CAME ALONG.
IT'S AN INTENSIVE PROCESS
WHERE MILLIONS OF GALLONS OF WATER AND CHEMICALS
ARE INJECTED UNDERGROUND TO BREAK UP THE ROCK
AND FREE COUNTLESS, TINY POCKETS OF NATURAL GAS.
FOR THE FIRST TIME, FRACKING MADE IT POSSIBLE
TO EXTRACT THE GAS FROM A TYPE OF ROCK CALLED SHALE.
AROUND THE SAME TIME,
MASSIVE NEW SHALE FORMATIONS WERE DISCOVERED.
SUDDENLY, AMERICA HAD A NEW DOMESTIC ENERGY SOURCE,
WORTH MORE THAN $10 TRILLION.
SOON, WE ARE FRACKING AT AN ALMOST INCONCEIVABLE RATE,
DRILLING MORE THAN 35,000 NEW WELLS A YEAR.
I'VE HEARD LOTS OF COMPLAINTS ABOUT FRACKING --
WATER CATCHING ON FIRE, TOXIC CHEMICALS, EVEN EARTHQUAKES.
BUT, TO ME, IT SEEMED LIKE MAYBE THE PROS OUTWEIGHED THE CONS.
NATURAL GAS, I LEARNED,
PRODUCES JUST HALF AS MUCH CARBON DIOXIDE AS COAL.
AND WHEN IT COMES TO CLIMATE CHANGE, THAT'S A BIG DIFFERENCE.
BUT NOT FAR FROM THE NATURAL-GAS FIELDS OF FORT LUPTON,
A SCIENTIST WAS MAKING A SURPRISING DISCOVERY
THAT WOULD CHALLENGE THE CONVENTIONAL WISDOM
ABOUT NATURAL GAS.
Petron: WE STARTED DOING MEASUREMENTS IN THE DENVER BASIN,
NORTH OF DENVER, IN 2008.
WE HAD EQUIPPED A TOWER
WITH INSTRUMENTS TO MEASURE METHANE,
CARBON DIOXIDE, AND A FEW OTHER GASES,
AND WE NOTICED INTERESTING READINGS.
WE HAD A SIGNAL THERE WE HAD NEVER SEEN BEFORE.
WOW. DRAMATIC.
YEAH, VERY. VERY FAST.
Bittman: IN 2008, GABBY PETRON, A TOP GOVERNMENT SCIENTIST
AT THE NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION,
COULDN'T BELIEVE WHAT SHE WAS SEEING --
HIGH LEVELS OF METHANE, A GREENHOUSE GAS
UP TO 80 TIMES MORE POWERFUL THAN CARBON DIOXIDE.
Petron: ENHANCED METHANE, PROPANE, BUTANE --
ALMOST IN EVERY SAMPLE.
METHANE IS A STRONG GREENHOUSE GAS.
AND I HAD NEVER SEEN THESE KIND OF MEASUREMENTS.
SO WE'RE LIKE, "OKAY, LET'S TRY TO UNDERSTAND BETTER
WHAT THIS TOWER'S TELLING US."
AND WE STARTED DRIVING AROUND.
PETRON NEEDED TO FIND OUT WHERE THE METHANE WAS COMING FROM,
SO SHE TURNED THIS OLD VAN
INTO A HIGH-TECH MOBILE METHANE DETECTOR.
SOON, SHE WAS CRISSCROSSING
VAST STRETCHES OF NORTHEASTERN COLORADO,
TAKING THOUSANDS OF MEASUREMENTS.
Petron: CLEAR.
SHE THOUGHT THE METHANE MIGHT BE COMING FROM LANDFILLS
OR THE 2.6 MILLION COWS IN THE AREA.
BUT THE SOURCE TURNED OUT TO BE SOMETHING SHE DIDN'T EXPECT.
METHANE...
METHANE IS RIGHT THERE.
BUT LOOK AT THESE LEVELS.
THERE'S NO QUESTIONING WHERE THE METHANE IS COMING FROM.
IT'S NATURAL GAS. OKAY. DEFINITELY.
Petron: WE SAW A LOT OF EMITTERS IN THESE OIL AND GAS FIELDS.
EVERY WELL PAD HAD SOME KIND OF SIGNATURE.
Bittman: WHAT SHE WAS FINDING WAS ALARMING.
BUT WAS ENOUGH METHANE LEAKING TO MAKE IT A SERIOUS PROBLEM?
TO FIND OUT, SHE NEEDED MORE DATA.
[ AIRPLANE WHIRS ]
Ferrera: JAMES TAYLOR IS A SENIOR FELLOW
AT THE HEARTLAND INSTITUTE, A LIBERTARIAN THINK TANK.
THEY PROMOTE RIGHT-WING VIEWS ON ALL KINDS OF ISSUES.
BUT WHAT THEY'RE REALLY FAMOUS FOR
IS DENYING MAN-MADE CLIMATE CHANGE.
RIGHT NOW, TAYLOR'S FOCUS
IS TRYING TO REPEAL RENEWABLE-ENERGY LAWS
ALL OVER THE COUNTRY.
BUT HOW DOES SOMEONE LIKE HIM
INFLUENCE LEGISLATION IN DOZENS OF STATES?
I FOUND OUT TAYLOR IS WORKING WITH A POWERFUL GROUP
CALLED THE AMERICAN LEGISLATIVE EXCHANGE COUNCIL -- OR A.L.E.C.
THE NAME SOUNDS DULL, BUT A.L.E.C.'s MEMBERS HAVE INCLUDED
SOME OF THE BIGGEST FOSSIL-FUEL COMPANIES IN THE WORLD,
AS WELL AS THOUSANDS OF MOSTLY REPUBLICAN STATE LEGISLATORS.
TOGETHER, BEHIND CLOSED DOORS, THEY WRITE BILLS
THAT THE LEGISLATORS THEN TAKE HOME TO THEIR INDIVIDUAL STATES
AND TRY TO GET PASSED.
A.L.E.C. BOASTS THAT MORE THAN 100 OF ITS BILLS
BECOME REAL LAWS EVERY YEAR.
ARIZONA'S HARSH IMMIGRATION LAW STARTED ITS LIFE
AS AN A.L.E.C. BILL.
SO DID THE CONTROVERSIAL "STAND YOUR GROUND" LAW
THAT WAS ENACTED IN MORE THAN TWO DOZEN STATES.
AND WE'RE GOING TO THE STATE CAPITAL, PLEASE.
AND THEN, THERE'S THE ELECTRICITY FREEDOM ACT,
CO-WRITTEN BY JAMES TAYLOR.
IT SEEKS TO REPEAL RENEWABLE-ENERGY STANDARDS
ALL OVER THE COUNTRY.
TODAY, HE'S IN KANSAS.
Taylor: MANY STATES ARE ON THE VERGE
OF ROLLING BACK THEIR RENEWABLE-POWER MANDATES.
THEY'RE VERY CLOSE, ESPECIALLY SINCE THE FRACKING REVOLUTION,
WHERE WE'VE BEEN ABLE TO PRODUCE MORE NATURAL GAS.
AND, OFTENTIMES, WHEN ONE STATE TAKES THAT FIRST STEP,
THAT ENABLES OTHERS TO FOLLOW.
I THINK KANSAS IS GOING TO BE ONE OF THOSE STATES
THAT IS GOING TO SET THE TONE IN THE NEXT FEW YEARS.
Ferrera: AND WITH HEARTLAND AND A.L.E.C. AT HIS BACK,
TAYLOR HAS DIRECT ACCESS TO LAWMAKERS ACROSS THE COUNTRY.
Taylor: SO MY FRIENDS DENNIS HEDKE AND FORREST KNOX
HERE IN THE KANSAS LEGISLATURE,
WE SHARE IDEAS ON A FREQUENT BASIS,
AND WE'RE MEETING TOGETHER TO DISCUSS THOSE ISSUES.
GOOD TO SEE YOU AGAIN.
Ferrera: DENNIS HEDKE IS THE CHAIRMAN
OF THE HOUSE ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE
AND A MEMBER OF A.L.E.C.
HE'S TRYING TO PUT A STOP TO KANSAS' RENEWABLE-ENERGY MANDATE
WITH A BILL INSPIRED BY TAYLOR'S ELECTRICITY FREEDOM ACT.
THESE RENEWABLE-POWER MANDATES, HERE IN KANSAS AND ELSEWHERE,
THEY'RE REQUIRING YOU TO DISMANTLE POWER PLANTS
THAT ARE IN EXISTENCE.
ELECTRICITY DEMAND -- IT'S ONLY GROWING AT ABOUT 1% PER YEAR.
SO IF YOU WERE TO GET TO 20% BY 2020,
IT MEANS YOU HAVE TO TAKE OUT EXISTING,
PERFECTLY GOOD POWER FACILITIES
IN ORDER TO BUILD MORE OF THE WIND AND SOLAR TO MAKE THE 20%.
A LOT OF FOLKS REALLY JUST CAN'T HANDLE THE TRUTH.
THAT'S THE WAY IT IS, BUT WE GOT TO TRY OUR BEST.
THAT'S A GREAT POINT.
Hedke: HEARTLAND INTRODUCES ME TO IDEAS AND CONCEPTS
THAT I WOULDN'T GENERALLY HAVE KNOWN.
THEY HAVE STUDIED THE ISSUES IN SIGNIFICANT DETAIL,
AND SO, THEY MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS
TO POLICY MAKERS LIKE MYSELF.
SO THAT'S THE VALUE TO ME IS,
IT SAVES ME TIME -- BIG SAVINGS OF TIME.
Taylor: ANYTHING I CAN DO TO HELP
IN TERMS OF PROVIDING INFORMATION
OR REACHING OUT TO PEOPLE, JUST LET ME KNOW.
HAPPY TO DO IT.
YEAH. THANK YOU.
Ferrera: SO, IF FORCES SUCCEED
IN ROLLING BACK THE RENEWABLE-ENERGY STANDARD,
WHAT DOES THAT MEAN FOR WIND FARMERS?
THE ROLLBACK WOULD HAVE HUGE EFFECT
ON FARMERS AND RANCHERS
WHO THEN WOULD NO LONGER HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY
THAT I HAD TO HAVE A WIND FARM ON THEIR PROPERTY.
THEY HAVE A DROUGHT. THEY HAVE NO OTHER OPTION.
THEY'RE JUST DONE.
Bittman: AROUND THE SAME TIME
THAT GABBY PETRON WAS DRIVING HER VAN ACROSS COLORADO,
ANOTHER SCIENTIST AT CORNELL UNIVERSITY IN NEW YORK
WAS STARTING AN INVESTIGATION OF HIS OWN.
Ingraffea: OF COURSE, WE WANT TO MAKE SURE
THAT WE'RE ACCOUNTING FOR
ALL THE METHANE THAT MIGHT BE FLOWING
INTO THE VOLUME OVER THAT AREA.
Bittman: TONY INGRAFFEA
IS A PROFESSOR OF STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING
AND AN EXPERT AT ROCK-FRACTURE MECHANICS.
HE SPENT MANY YEARS CONSULTING FOR THE OIL AND GAS INDUSTRY,
BUT NOW HE'S ONE OF THE INDUSTRY'S BIGGEST CRITICS.
IT ALL STARTED A FEW YEARS AGO,
WHEN HE DECIDED TO TAKE A CLOSER LOOK
AT WHAT HAPPENS TO NATURAL GAS WHEN IT LEAKS INTO THE AIR.
NATURAL GAS IS, ESSENTIALLY, METHANE -- CH4 --
THE SIMPLEST OF ALL OF THE HYDROCARBONS.
IT'S COLORLESS, IT'S ODORLESS, IT'S TASTELESS.
METHANE, WHEN IT'S BURNED, PRODUCES LESS CARBON DIOXIDE
PER UNIT OF ENERGY PRODUCED THAN COAL OR OIL.
IT'S LESS DIRTY. OKAY.
IT'S LESS DIRTY THAN COAL OR OIL BY FAR.
NO QUESTION ABOUT THAT.
BUT THE PROBLEM WITH METHANE IS THAT
IF IT GETS INTO THE ATMOSPHERE WITHOUT BEING BURNED,
IT BECOMES A VERY POTENT GREENHOUSE GAS --
WORSE THAN CARBON DIOXIDE BY FAR.
HOW MANY TIMES WORSE?
ASK THIS QUESTION.
I PUT A POUND OF CARBON DIOXIDE IN THE ATMOSPHERE.
I PUT A POUND OF METHANE INTO THE ATMOSPHERE.
IF YOU WAIT 20 YEARS, METHANE IS ANYWHERE
FROM 72 TIMES AND 105 TIMES MORE POTENT
THAN CARBON DIOXIDE.
WOW.
SO YOU'D HAVE TO LEAK 80 POUNDS OF CARBON DIOXIDE
TO DO THE SAME HARM AS ONE POUND OF METHANE.
IT MAKES FOR A THICKER BLANKET
THAN AN EQUIVALENT AMOUNT OF CARBON DIOXIDE.
YES. OKAY.
MAKES THE EARTH'S ATMOSPHERE A BETTER GREENHOUSE.
THEREFORE, WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE
WE DON'T LEAK VERY MUCH METHANE.
ANY LEAKS MAKE NATURAL GAS LESS CLEAN THAN ADVERTISED.
AND THE MORE IT LEAKS, THE DIRTIER IT GETS.
THE QUESTION IS, HOW MUCH METHANE CAN LEAK
BEFORE NATURAL GAS STARTS TO GET AS BAD AS COAL,
THE DIRTIEST FOSSIL FUEL?
MOST EXPERTS SAY THE THRESHOLD IS ABOUT 3%.
AS LONG AS NO MORE THAN 3% OF THE NATURAL GAS WE PRODUCE
ENDS UP LEAKING INTO THE ATMOSPHERE,
IT'S NOT NECESSARILY GOOD, BUT IT'S STILL BETTER THAN COAL.
INGRAFFEA AND HIS TEAM WANTED TO COLLECT
ALL THE DATA THEY COULD GET THEIR HANDS ON
TO ESTIMATE JUST HOW MUCH METHANE WAS LEAKING
ACROSS THE ENTIRE COUNTRY.
AND OVER A PERIOD OF TWO YEARS,
WE GATHERED THE INFORMATION WE COULD FROM THE E.P.A.,
FROM THE DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY,
FROM INDUSTRY SOURCES.
WE PICK UP THE PHONE AND CALL PEOPLE AT GAS COMPANIES
AND OIL COMPANIES AND ASK THEM.
AND IN MOST CASES, THEY WERE QUITE WILLING TO SAY,
"YEAH, HERE'S THE INFORMATION. HERE'S THE DATA."
NO ONE HAD PIECED ALL THIS TOGETHER BEFORE,
AND WHAT THEY FOUND LOOKED LIKE VERY BAD NEWS.
WE PUBLISHED OUR PAPER, AND WE SAID,
"LOOK, WE CONCLUDED THAT AS AN UPPER BOUND,
"7.9% OF ALL THE GAS PRODUCED BY A SHALE GAS WELL
"DURING ITS LIFETIME WOULD NOT GET BURNED,
BUT WOULD GET EMITTED."
AT THE LOWER END, WE SAID ABOUT 3.6%.
THAT'S THE RANGE.
IT COULD BE THIS MUCH.
BUT EVEN IF IT'S ONLY THIS MUCH,
NATURAL GAS IS NOT ANY BETTER THAN COAL OR OIL.
AND IF IT'S THIS MUCH, IT'S WAY WORSE.
EVEN AT THE LOW END OF THE RANGE, THE NEWS WAS BAD.
YES.
BUT, I EMPHASIZE,
WE WEREN'T GOING OUT AND MEASURING ANYTHING.
WE DON'T HAVE THE RESOURCES TO DO THAT.
YOU WERE REALLY GUESSING
AT THE AMOUNT OF METHANE THAT WAS LEAKING.
YOU REALLY DIDN'T KNOW AT THAT TIME.
WE REALLY DIDN'T KNOW, BUT I OBJECT TO THE WORD "GUESS."
WE WERE USING BEST-AVAILABLE SCIENTIFIC-ESTIMATION METHODS
TO ESTIMATE, BUT WE DIDN'T KNOW.
WE DON'T KNOW NOW. NO ONE KNOWS.
EVEN SO, THE NATURAL-GAS INDUSTRY MAINTAINS
THAT THE LEAK RATE IS ONLY ABOUT 1%.
AND THEY DIDN'T TAKE KINDLY TO INGRAFFEA'S RESULTS.
Ferrera: AS I INVESTIGATE THE FUTURE
OF WIND AND SOLAR POWER IN AMERICA,
I'M REALIZING THAT MANY OF THE BIGGEST DECISIONS
AREN'T MADE IN WASHINGTON, D.C.
THEY'RE MADE IN STATE HOUSES, LIKE THIS ONE.
THIS IS WHERE JAMES TAYLOR HAS BEEN FOCUSING HIS ENERGY,
TRYING TO CONVINCE LOCAL LAWMAKERS
THAT RENEWABLE ENERGY IS TOO EXPENSIVE.
TODAY, I'M MEETING KIMBERLY SWATTI.
SHE'S A CONSULTANT FOR THE WIND INDUSTRY HERE IN KANSAS,
AND SHE'S BEEN ON THE FRONT LINES OF THIS LOCAL BATTLE.
SO, ONE OF THE BIGGEST THINGS THAT I HEAR IS THAT,
"IF MY STATE DECIDES TO SWITCH TO WIND OR SOLAR,
ULTIMATELY, I'M GONNA END UP PAYING FOR IT.
MY UTILITY BILL IS GONNA GO THROUGH THE ROOF."
IS THAT TRUE?
WE HAVE SEEN, IN THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS,
AS THE UTILITIES HAVE BOUGHT MORE RENEWABLE ENERGY
AND THEY'VE INTEGRATED ONTO THEIR SYSTEM,
THE PRICE IMPACT HAS BEEN "DE MINIMIS" IS WHAT THEY SAY --
0% TO 1.7% IMPACT.
SO NOT IN KANSAS.
YOUR RATES WILL NOT GO UP IN KANSAS.
IT'S NO SURPRISE
THAT SWATTI WOULD SAY GOOD THINGS ABOUT WIND,
BUT A REPORT BY THE STATE OF KANSAS ITSELF BACKS HER UP.
AND WHILE IT'S TRUE THAT IN SOME STATES,
RENEWABLE ENERGY ISN'T AS CHEAP AS FOSSIL FUELS,
PRICES ARE FALLING INCREDIBLY FAST.
WIND AND SOLAR DROPPED BY MORE THAN 50%
JUST BETWEEN 2008 AND 2012.
AND HERE IN KANSAS, WIND HAS ALSO GENERATED
TENS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS FOR LANDOWNERS,
BROUGHT IN BILLIONS IN INVESTMENT,
AND HELPED CREATE OVER 12,000 JOBS.
THE FORCES THAT ARE INTERESTED IN PULLING BACK
ARE PRIMARILY EXTERNAL FORCES.
AND WHO ARE THEY?
WE'VE SEEN ORGANIZATIONS LIKE THE HEARTLAND INSTITUTE
THAT HAS COME INTO KANSAS
AND PUT OUT INFORMATION THAT IS MISLEADING
ABOUT THE COST OF WIND AND RENEWABLES.
AND WHAT IS IT THAT THEY'RE SAYING
ABOUT THE COST OF RENEWABLE?
THEY'RE SAYING THAT RENEWABLE ENERGY COSTS A LOT MORE
THAN WHAT IT REALLY DOES IN KANSAS.
AND I'M SEVENTH-GENERATION KANSAN,
AND THIS IS A VERY IMPORTANT PLACE FOR ME.
WE HAVE GOOD THINGS HAPPENING HERE RIGHT NOW.
AND IT'S VERY FRUSTRATING TO SEE PEOPLE COME IN
AND PROVIDE INFORMATION
THAT'S NOT ACCURATE FOR OUR STATE,
TO TRY AND UNDERMINE POLICIES
THAT HAVE ABSOLUTELY WORKED FOR OUR STATE.
Taylor: WE'D LIKE TO PRESENT THE FACTS ON VARIOUS TOPICS --
ENERGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT, BUDGET AND TAX --
TO PEOPLE WHO ARE INFLUENTIAL.
IF YOU ARE A STATE LEGISLATOR HERE IN COLORADO
OR YOU HAVE BEEN A STATE LEGISLATOR,
COULD YOU JUST RAISE YOUR HAND OR...?
[ APPLAUSE ]
THERE ARE A FEW MORE.
IT'S OUR PRIVILEGE TO HAVE WITH US IN PERSON,
THE REAL JAMES TAYLOR.
[ APPLAUSE ]
Ferrera: GOING TO A HEARTLAND EVENT
FEELS LIKE ENTERING AN ALTERNATE UNIVERSE.
Taylor: THERE ARE HUNDREDS UPON HUNDREDS OF PEER-REVIEWED STUDIES
THAT SHOW THAT HUMANS ARE NOT CAUSING --
GLOBAL WARMING IS NOT CAUSING AN INCREASE
IN EXTREME-WEATHER EVENTS.
DON'T LET ANYBODY TELL YOU DIFFERENTLY.
Ferrera: IN REALITY,
THE SCIENTIFIC CONSENSUS ON CLIMATE CHANGE
IS EFFECTIVELY UNANIMOUS.
Man: IT IS EXTREMELY LIKELY THAT HUMANS ARE MOSTLY TO BLAME
FOR TEMPERATURES THAT HAVE BEEN CLIMBING NOW FOR DECADES.
HOW SURE ARE THESE SCIENTISTS? THEY SAY ABOUT 95% CERTAIN.
AND, IN SCIENCE, 95% IS PRETTY DARN CERTAIN.
Ferrera: THE INTERGOVERNMENTAL PANEL ON CLIMATE CHANGE, OR IPCC,
BRINGS TOGETHER THOUSANDS OF SCIENTISTS
FROM MORE THAN 50 COUNTRIES.
THEIR LATEST REPORT MIGHT BE
THE MOST COMPREHENSIVE SCIENTIFIC ASSESSMENT
IN HISTORY, AND ITS CONCLUSIONS ARE DIRE.
BUT TO CHALLENGE THE FINDINGS OF THE IPCC,
HEARTLAND AND OTHERS SET UP THEIR OWN GROUP, THE NIPCC.
WE ARE PRODUCING. LOOK FOR IT --
THE NONGOVERNMENTAL INTERNATIONAL PANEL
ON CLIMATE CHANGE, THE UPDATED REPORT,
"CLIMATE CHANGE RECONSIDERED," EXPLAINING WHAT'S GOING ON.
Ferrera: HEARTLAND EVEN CAME UP
WITH A BILLBOARD CAMPAIGN IN 2012,
OVER A BUSY CHICAGO HIGHWAY
THAT EQUATED PEOPLE WHO BELIEVE IN GLOBAL WARMING
WITH TERRORISTS.
I'M STARTING TO WONDER, WHO'S BEHIND THE HEARTLAND INSTITUTE?
SO I'M HEADING TO CALIFORNIA
TO MEET TWO PEOPLE WHO HAVE STUDIED HEARTLAND FOR YEARS.
Bittman: I'M ON MY WAY TO MEET WITH MARK BOLING,
A TOP EXECUTIVE WITH SOUTHWESTERN ENERGY,
THE FIFTH-LARGEST NATURAL-GAS PRODUCER IN THE NATION.
I WANT TO ASK HIM ABOUT DR. INGRAFFEA'S PAPER,
WHICH ESTIMATED THAT MORE THAN 3%
OF ALL THE NATURAL GAS PRODUCED IN THE U.S. IS LEAKING.
WE ARE NOT GOING TO LET THOSE PROFITS GO UP IN THE AIR.
SO THAT'S PART -- I'M NOT SURE
WHETHER THAT'S THE REAL ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION,
BUT IT'S -- FROM OUR PERSPECTIVE,
FROM INDUSTRY'S PERSPECTIVE, IT WAS,
"WELL, OF COURSE, IT CAN'T BE THAT HIGH.
"WE'D BE FIRED
IF WE ALLOWED OUR LEAK RATE TO BE THAT HIGH."
IT'S OBVIOUSLY A TOUCHY SUBJECT,
BECAUSE HE'S THE ONLY INDUSTRY OFFICIAL
WHO WOULD AGREE TO TALK ON CAMERA.
AND HE WANTS TO SHOW ME HOW PREVENTING LEAKS
IS JUST SMART BUSINESS.
THAT'S WHERE WE CAPTURE ALL OF THE GAS
FROM THE MINUTE THAT IT COMES BACK
FROM A HYDRAULIC FRACTURING FLOWBACK
AND PUT IT RIGHT INTO THE SALES LINE.
SEVERAL YEARS AGO,
SOUTHWESTERN STARTED DOING WHAT IT CALLED "GREEN COMPLETIONS"
TO CAPTURE GASES, INCLUDING METHANE,
THAT WOULD OTHERWISE ESCAPE INTO THE AIR.
THE OLD WAY WE USED TO DO IT, LIKE THIS,
WE WOULD VENT PROBABLY 16 MILLION CUBIC FEET OF GAS
ON AVERAGE FROM EACH WELL THAT WE ARE NOW CAPTURING.
MULTIPLY THAT BY THE AMOUNT OF MONEY YOU MAKE
PER THOUSAND CUBIC FEET -- IT PAYS FOR ITSELF.
Bittman: SO YOU'RE MAKING MONEY ON IT,
'CAUSE YOU'RE SELLING THE 16 MILLION CUBIC FEET
THAT YOU'RE CAPTURING. ABSOLUTELY.
AIR COMBINED WITH FRESH SNOW, AND YOU KIND OF...
BOLING SAYS INGRAFFEA'S RESEARCH
JUST FOCUSED ON THE DIRTIEST WELLS.
WHEN I LOOKED AT SOME OF THE ASSUMPTIONS THEY USED
TO COME UP WITH THEIR NUMBERS, AND I GO, "OH, WELL..."
THE STUDY LOST CREDIBILITY WITH ME IN THAT REGARD.
AND THE KIND OF WORK THAT WAS PUT INTO IT
WAS REALLY WASN'T WHAT IT SHOULD BE
TO COME OUT AND MAKE THOSE STATEMENTS LIKE,
"HEY, NATURAL GAS IS DIRTIER THAN COAL."
THAT JUST DIDN'T SEEM RIGHT TO ME.
AFTER TALKING TO BOLING, I TRY TO FIND OUT
HOW MANY OTHER COMPANIES
ARE ACTUALLY DOING GREEN COMPLETIONS.
NO ONE SEEMS TO KNOW, NOT EVEN THE GOVERNMENT.
NEVERTHELESS, WHEN IT COMES TO METHANE LEAKS,
THE GOVERNMENT MORE OR LESS AGREES
WITH THE INDUSTRY ESTIMATES.
THE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY SAYS THE LEAK RATE
IS JUST 1.5% -- WELL BELOW THE 3% THRESHOLD.
I WANTED TO FIND OUT HOW THEY GET THAT NUMBER,
BUT FOR SOME REASON,
THE E.P.A. DECLINED TO TALK TO ME ON CAMERA.
[ CELLPHONE RINGS ]
BUT THEN I FOUND A FORMER E.P.A. OFFICIAL
WHO W WILLING TO TALK,
AND HE EXPLAINED HOW THE AGENCY COMES UP WITH ITS ESTIMATES,
WHICH ARE OFFICIALLY CALLED "EMISSION INVENTORIES."
I'VE WORKED 38 YEARS WITH E.P.A.,
AND ACTUALLY FORMULATED THE TECHNIQUES
FOR DEVELOPING EMISSION INVENTORIES.
I WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR THEM RIGHT FROM THE START.
THEY'RE, OF NECESSITY, GUESSES.
THAT'S BECAUSE THE E.P.A.
DOESN'T DO COMPREHENSIVE MEASUREMENTS.
AS CRAZY AS IT SOUNDS, WHEN THE E.P.A. SAYS
METHANE EMISSIONS ARE GOING DOWN IN THE U.S.,
THEY'RE PRETTY MUCH TAKING THE GAS INDUSTRY'S WORD FOR IT.
ALL THESE EMISSION INVENTORIES, BY THE WAY,
ARE DERIVED FROM INDUSTRY-SUPPORTED DATA.
SO WHEN E.P.A. PUBLISHES ESTIMATES OF LEAKS OF METHANE,
THAT DATA IS COMING FROM INDUSTRY?
INDUSTRY, RIGHT.
IS IT AT ALL INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED?
NO. NO.
YOU KNOW, MARK, IN MY EXPERIENCE
DEVELOPING AND MAINTAINING EMISSION INVENTORIES
NATIONALLY FOR MANY YEARS,
EVERY TIME WE LOOKED FURTHER, WE FOUND MORE EMISSIONS.
AND EVERY TIME THERE WAS SOME SORT OF LARGE GROWTH
AT A PARTICULAR INDUSTRY,
THERE WERE UNFORESEEN EMISSIONS.
AND WE'RE IN THE SAME SITUATION TODAY, CERTAINLY,
WITH THE GAS DRILLING THAT'S GOING ON NOW.
THE EXTENSIVENESS OF IT IS UNBELIEVABLE.
BUT E.P.A.'s RECENTLY LOWERED THEIR ESTIMATE
OF METHANE-LEAK RATE.
WELL, WHERE DID THE DATA COME FROM?
[ CHUCKLES ]
THE DATA CAME FROM THE INDUSTRY. RIGHT.
NOW, THAT'S LIKE FARMER JOHN SENDS THE FOX OUT TO SAY,
"HOW MANY CHICKENS DO I HAVE?"
AND HE COMES BACK AND SAYS,
"YOU GOT 10 LESS CHICKENS THIS YEAR
THAN YOU HAD LAST YEAR."
[ CHUCKLES ] YES.
IT SEEMED LIKE EVERYONE WAS GUESSING ABOUT METHANE LEAKS.
BUT IN COLORADO, GABBY PETRON'S RESEARCH
WAS FINALLY YIELDING SOME CONCRETE RESULTS.
Ferrera: I'VE COME TO CALIFORNIA TO MEET WITH LISA GRAVES,
THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR THE CENTER FOR MEDIA AND DEMOCRACY,
AND BRENDAN DeMELLE,
WHO RUNS AN INVESTIGATIVE WEBSITE CALLED DeSmogBlog.
THEY'VE MADE IT THEIR BUSINESS TO LEARN AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE
ABOUT THE HEARTLAND INSTITUTE
AND OTHER GROUPS THAT DENY CLIMATE CHANGE.
DeMelle: HEARTLAND HAS THIS STORIED HISTORY
OF ATTACKING CLIMATE CHANGE.
THEY'VE SORT OF MOLDED THEIR POSITION
TO FIT THE TIMES.
ORIGINALLY, THEY STARTED OUT AS OUTRIGHT DENIERS,
SAYING, "IT'S NOT HAPPENING. IT'S A HOAX."
AND WHEN THE SCIENCE WAS CLEAR, YOU KNOW,
THEY SORT OF SHIFTED TO, "WELL, IF IT'S HAPPENING,
IT'S NOT THAT BIG OF A DEAL,"
TO, "ACTUALLY, IT MIGHT BE GOOD FOR US.
IT MIGHT BE BENEFICIAL."
AND THAT'S WHERE JAMES TAYLOR REALLY --
YOU KNOW, HIS POSITION IS THAT
GLOBAL WARMING WILL BE BENEFICIAL FOR HUMANS.
THE SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE IS REALLY AGAINST THEM,
BUT THEY SAY THINGS SO BOLDLY AND STRIDENTLY
THAT IT MAKES SOME PEOPLE BELIEVE
THAT THEY MUST BE TELLING THE TRUTH.
SO, WHO ARE HEARTLAND'S SUPPORTERS?
WHERE DO THEY GET THEIR FUNDING?
WELL, THERE'S A NUMBER OF THINGS WE KNOW
ABOUT THE HEARTLAND'S FUNDING
AND SOME THAT WE DON'T, BECAUSE AS OF 2007,
THEY DON'T DISCLOSE THEIR DONORS.
ONE THING THEY DO KNOW IS THAT HEARTLAND IS JUST A SMALL PART
OF A VAST CLIMATE-DENIAL NETWORK
WITH HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS OF DOLLARS BEHIND IT.
THROUGH A COMBINATION OF PUBLIC TAX RECORDS
AND LEAKED INTERNAL DOCUMENTS,
A LOT OF THE MONEY HAS BEEN TRACKED BACK
TO TWO MAJOR SOURCES --
EXXON MOBIL, THE WORLD'S LARGEST OIL COMPANY,
GAVE AT LEAST $27.4 MILLION TO CLIMATE-DENIAL GROUPS
BETWEEN 1998 AND 2010,
INCLUDING HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS TO HEARTLAND,
AND FOSSIL-FUEL BILLIONAIRES CHARLES AND DAVID KOCH,
WHO OWN KOCH INDUSTRIES,
HAVE FUNNELED MORE THAN $72 MILLION TO THE CAUSE
THROUGH A DIZZYING ARRAY OF FOUNDATIONS AND FRONT GROUPS.
BUT RECENTLY, THE MONEY TRAIL HAS GONE COLD.
FOUNDATIONS OR COMPANIES THAT GAVE MONEY DIRECTLY
ARE NOW, THROUGH THIS MECHANISM CALLED DONORS TRUST
AND THE DONORS CAPITAL FUND, ABLE TO SHIELD THEIR DONORS.
WHICH MAKES IT HARDER FOR THE PUBLIC
TO PUT PRESSURE ON THOSE FUNDERS TO NOT SUPPORT --
HOW DO YOU HOLD SOMEONE ACCOUNTABLE
IF YOU DON'T KNOW WHO THEY ARE?
DONORS TRUST AND DONORS CAPITAL FUND
ACT AS MIDDLEMEN BETWEEN WEALTHY DONORS
AND GROUPS THEY WANT TO SECRETLY FUND.
THE DONORS ARE ABLE TO REMAIN ANONYMOUS.
MUCH OF HEARTLAND'S FUNDING
NOW COMES FROM A SINGLE, ANONYMOUS DONOR.
AND WITH THE HELP OF DONORS TRUST,
MORE MONEY IS POURING INTO CLIMATE DENIAL
THAN EVER BEFORE --
A STAGGERING $558 MILLION JUST BETWEEN 2003 AND 2010.
AND BRENDAN AND LISA TELL ME THAT CLIMATE CHANGE
ISN'T THE ONLY ISSUE
WHERE HEARTLAND HAS BEEN ON THE WRONG SIDE OF SCIENCE.
ONE OF THE THINGS WE'VE SEEN WITH HEARTLAND
AND WITH THE OTHER GROUPS IS A REAL EFFORT TO MUDDY THE WATERS,
AND THAT'S RIGHT OUT
OF THE TOBACCO COMPANIES' BIG PR PLAYBOOK.
IN 1969, A TOBACCO EXECUTIVE WROTE A MEMO
IN WHICH HE SAID THAT "DOUBT IS OUR PRODUCT."
IF THEY WERE GONNA CONFUSE THE PUBLIC,
THEY NEEDED TO SUGGEST TO THEM
THAT THERE'S NO LINK BETWEEN TOBACCO AND CANCER.
"SO WE'RE GONNA SELL THIS IDEA
"THAT THERE'S CONFUSION AMONG SCIENTISTS
AND CONTINUE TO PERPETUATE DOUBT IN THE PUBLIC MIND."
AND HEARTLAND WAS ONE OF THE KEY PLAYERS IN THAT.
Ferrera: IN THE '90s, WITH FUNDING FROM PHILIP MORRIS,
HEARTLAND TRIED TO DISCREDIT THE SCIENCE
LINKING SECONDHAND SMOKE TO CANCER.
IN A FUNDRAISING LETTER, HEARTLAND'S PRESIDENT BOASTED
ABOUT HOW VALUABLE THE ORGANIZATION WAS
TO TOBACCO COMPANIES.
AND MANY OF THE SAME SCIENTISTS NOW DENYING CLIMATE CHANGE
GOT THEIR START DEFENDING CIGARETTES.
BRENDAN, CAN YOU TELL US MORE ABOUT WHO JAMES TAYLOR IS?
SURE. SO JAMES TAYLOR --
HIS EXPERTISE IS IN THE LAW.
YOU KNOW, HE'S A LAWYER. HE'S A GREAT TALKER.
YOU KNOW, HE'S A VERY PERSONABLE GUY.
BUT IT'S KIND OF SHOCKING TO ME
THAT ANYONE WOULD RELY ON A LAWYER
TO GIVE THEM ADVICE ABOUT SCIENCE MATTERS.
YOU KNOW, IT'S KIND OF LIKE ASKING YOUR DENTIST
WHAT TO DO ABOUT YOUR HEART CONDITION.
YOU KNOW, HE MIGHT HAVE
SOME INTERESTING THINGS TO SAY ABOUT IT,
BUT HE'S PROBABLY NOT THE SPECIALIST
YOU SHOULD BE LISTENING TO.
EVER SINCE I STARTED FOLLOWING THIS BATTLE OVER RENEWABLES,
I'VE WANTED TO MEET JAMES TAYLOR FACE-TO-FACE.
I GET MY CHANCE WHEN HE AGREES TO MEET IN NEW YORK.
Bittman: AFTER MORE THAN TWO YEARS,
DRIVING AROUND COLLECTING SAMPLES,
GABBY PETRON HAD A WEALTH OF DATA SHOWING LEAKS
THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE NATURAL-GAS SYSTEM
IN THE DENVER BASIN.
Bittman: WHAT'D YOU DO WITH THAT INFORMATION?
WHERE DID THAT GO?
WE WROTE A PAPER,
AND WE ESTIMATED AT THE TIME THAT, ON AVERAGE,
4% OF THE GAS THAT WAS EXTRACTED FROM THE GROUND
ENDED UP IN THE ATMOSPHERE INSTEAD OF IN THE PIPELINE.
YOU'RE SHOWING A LEAK RATE
THAT'S MUCH, MUCH HIGHER THAN E.P.A. ESTIMATES,
AND MINIMUM OF FOUR TIMES AS HIGH
AS WHAT THE INDUSTRY SAYS THERE IS.
THAT'S RIGHT.
BUT THIS IS REAL INFORMATION... RIGHT.
...PRODUCED BY SCIENTISTS, USING REAL INSTRUMENTS.
AND PEER-REVIEWED.
PEER-REVIEWED, IMPARTIAL, ET CETERA.
YOU PRESENT THIS INFORMATION TO THE INDUSTRY,
AND THEY SAY WHAT?
THEY HAVE A LOT OF QUESTIONS.
I DON'T THINK THAT EVERYBODY'S HAPPY WITH WHAT WE FOUND.
HERE WAS AN INDEPENDENT STUDY
PRODUCED BY TOP GOVERNMENT SCIENTISTS,
SUGGESTING THAT, AT LEAST IN THE DENVER BASIN,
NATURAL GAS IS FAR FROM CLEAN.
NOT SURPRISINGLY, THE INDUSTRY ARGUED
THAT PETRON'S RESULTS WERE JUST AN OUTLIER,
A SINGLE SNAPSHOT OF A VAST NATURAL-GAS SYSTEM.
Man: THAT'S WHERE WE'RE GOING.
IT'S MAKING MEASUREMENTS EVERY ONE SECOND.
Bittman: PRACTICALLY,
AS SOON AS WE STARTED TO LEAVE VERNAL,
IT WENT UP.
YEAH, IT'S STARTING TO GO UP.
THE UINTA BASIN IN EASTERN UTAH
IS HOME TO THOUSANDS OF NATURAL GAS AND OIL WELLS
AND NOT MUCH ELSE.
I'M HERE WITH A TEAM FROM PICARRO,
A COMPANY THAT'S WORKING ON CUTTING-EDGE TECHNOLOGY
FOR MEASURING METHANE EMISSIONS.
NORMALLY, THESE GUYS ARE HIRED BY THE GAS COMPANIES THEMSELVES
TO FIND AND FIX LEAKS.
THIS TIME, THOUGH, THEY'RE HEADING OUT ON THEIR OWN DIME.
THEY WANT TO KNOW IF THE METHANE PROBLEM COULD POSSIBLY BE
AS BAD AS PETRON'S NUMBERS SUGGEST.
AND TO FIND OUT, THEY BROUGHT THE BIG GUNS --
EQUIPMENT THAT'S 1,000 TIMES MORE SENSITIVE
THAN WHAT MOST COMPANIES USE TO DETECT METHANE.
THE BLUE DOTS ARE NATURAL-GAS WELLS?
YES, OR NATURAL-GAS FACILITIES OF ONE TYPE OR ANOTHER.
IT'S INSANE.
WE'RE DRIVING DOWN THIS ROAD,
AND WE TOOK THAT RIGHT TURN... MM-HMM.
AND THEN, WITHIN MINUTES, FIRST, IT DOUBLED.
NOW IT'S CLOSE TO TRIPLE, ISN'T IT?
NOW IT'S SITTING AT TRIPLE. YEAH, THAT'S CORRECT.
IT TAKES TWO WEEKS TO FULLY COVER THE AREA.
THEY FIND LEAKS EVERYWHERE.
THERE'S SO MUCH GAS IN THE AIR
THAT METHANE READINGS ARE SKY-HIGH
OVER THE ENTIRE 700 SQUARE-MILE BASIN.
I WAS SURPRISED
BY WHAT GABBY PETRON SHOWED ME IN COLORADO.
IT'S STARTING TO LOOK LIKE UTAH IS EVEN WORSE.
Ferrera: WHAT IS YOUR POINT OF VIEW?
WHERE DO YOU STAND ON CLIMATE CHANGE?
WELL, WE KNOW THAT CARBON DIOXIDE'S A GREENHOUSE GAS.
IF YOU ADD MORE TO THE ATMOSPHERE,
YOU'RE GOING TO GET SOME GLOBAL WARMING.
SO, YOU KNOW, IT'S HUMAN NATURE
TO SEE CHANGE AND FEAR CHANGE.
BUT THE BEST EVIDENCE OUT THERE,
THE BEST SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE AND DATA
SHOW THAT THE MODERATE WARMING THAT IS OCCURRING
IS BENEFICIAL TO HUMAN WELFARE,
AS IT ALWAYS HAS BEEN THROUGHOUT HUMAN HISTORY.
CAN YOU TALK TO ME ABOUT WHO SUPPORTS YOU
AND THE HEARTLAND INSTITUTE, WHO YOUR FUNDERS ARE?
YEAH, FIRST OF ALL, WORKING ON POLICY ISSUES,
I MAKE IT A POINT NOT TO KNOW.
I DON'T WANT THAT TO INFLUENCE, YOU KNOW,
WHAT I WRITE AND THINK.
AND EVEN IF I WANTED TO KNOW,
THE HEARTLAND INSTITUTE PREVENTS ME FROM KNOWING IT.
YOU DON'T KNOW WHO YOUR FUNDERS ARE?
I HAVE A GENERAL IDEA OF SOME, OFTENTIMES,
BECAUSE SOME GLOBAL-WARMING ACTIVIST
OR PEOPLE THAT DON'T LIKE THE HEARTLAND INSTITUTE,
THEY ALL, YOU KNOW, ASSERT
THAT WE RECEIVED MONEY FROM THIS GROUP OR THAT.
IN GENERAL TERMS, WHAT I DO KNOW
IS THAT THE VAST MAJORITY OF OUR FUNDING
COMES FROM PRIVATE INDIVIDUALS AND FROM FOUNDATIONS.
AND IF YOU LOOK AT CORPORATIONS
THAT HAVE A STAKE IN THE ENERGY DEBATE --
ESPECIALLY FOSSIL-FUEL COMPANIES --
THAT WOULD BE A VERY SMALL PERCENTAGE.
WHY IS THIS SOMETHING WORTH FIGHTING?
WHY IS RENEWABLE ENERGY BAD?
YEAH.
PEOPLE LIKE TO TALK ABOUT CARBON DIOXIDE
AND GLOBAL WARMING,
BUT THEY DON'T TALK ABOUT THE 1.4 MILLION BIRDS AND BATS,
INCLUDING MANY ENDANGERED SPECIES
THAT ARE KILLED EACH YEAR BY WIND TURBINES.
ALSO, ACCORDING TO THE WIND ENERGY INDUSTRY ITSELF,
IT REQUIRES 300 TO 600 SQUARE MILES OF WIND TURBINES
TO REPLACE A SINGLE CONVENTIONAL POWER PLANT.
DON'T WE NEED THOSE THINGS
TO HELP US JUMP-START A NEW ECONOMY
OR A NEW SOLUTION TO FIGHTING A MODERN PROBLEM
LIKE CLIMATE CHANGE?
WELL, IF GLOBAL WARMING WERE A VERY SERIOUS PROBLEM,
THEN, CERTAINLY, WE WOULD BE WISE TO LOOK INTO THAT.
BUT THE SCIENCE INDICATES
THAT IT'S NOT A VERY SERIOUS PROBLEM.
BUT, JAMES, I'M REALLY CONFUSED,
BECAUSE 97% OF CLIMATE SCIENTISTS SAY
THAT IT'S REAL AND THAT IT'S A PROBLEM
AND THAT IT'S MAN-MADE.
AND YOU, WITH ALL DUE RESPECT, YOU'RE A LAWYER, RIGHT?
I'M A LAWYER BY TRAINING. I DON'T PRACTICE.
YOU'RE A LAWYER BY TRAINING,
BUT YOU'RE NOT A SCIENTIST BY TRAINING.
I'M A SCIENTIST BY TRAINING, AS WELL.
YOU'RE A SCIENTIST?
I SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
IVY LEAGUE ATMOSPHERIC-SCIENCE COURSES,
SO I'M A SCIENTIST BY TRAINING.
OKAY.
BUT LET'S GET TO YOUR QUESTION.
WELL, MY QUESTION IS THAT I'M CONFUSED,
BECAUSE THERE'S, OVER HERE, KIND OF A MOUNTAIN OF EVIDENCE
THAT SUGGESTS IT'S A PROBLEM,
IT'S MAN-MADE, PEOPLE WILL SUFFER.
SO WHY FOCUS ON THE SMALLER EVIDENCE
VERSUS THE MOUNTING EVIDENCE?
WELL, I THINK YOUR PREMISE IS WRONG.
IN FACT, MORE THAN 31,000 SCIENTISTS
SIGNED ON TO A LETTER,
A SUMMARY OF THE SCIENCE, EXPLAINING WHY GLOBAL WARMING
IS NOT A HUMAN-CAUSED CRISIS.
THAT LETTER YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT,
THAT'S THE OREGON PETITION? YES, INDEED.
Ferrera: I'D HEARD ABOUT THIS FROM BRENDAN AND LISA IN L.A.
THE OREGON PETITION. Ferrera: RIGHT.
THAT'S, YOU KNOW, ONE OF THE ORIGINAL SORT OF EFFORTS
BY THE DENIAL INDUSTRY TO SUGGEST
THAT THEY HAD THOUSANDS OF SCIENTISTS ON THEIR SIDE
THAT WOULD SAY THAT GLOBAL WARMING IS NOT A PROBLEM. RIGHT.
BUT THEN, AS YOU LOOK THROUGH THOSE LISTS,
THERE WERE FICTITIOUS NAMES.
EVERYONE FROM "STAR WARS" CHARACTERS
TO A MEMBER OF THE SPICE GIRLS HAVE SHOWN UP ON THAT LIST.
THERE CERTAINLY ARE SOME SCIENTISTS.
YOU KNOW, THEY'RE METEOROLOGISTS,
THEY'RE GEOLOGISTS, THEY'RE BIOLOGISTS.
YOU KNOW, CERTAINLY PEOPLE WITH EXPERTISE IN THEIR AREA,
BUT THEY'RE FAR OUTSIDE THEIR SPECIALIZATION.
MOST OF THESE PEOPLE, THEY'RE NOT CLIMATE SCIENTISTS.
AND THERE WAS A NAME ON IT
THAT WAS ONE OF THE SPICE GIRLS.
WHO TOLD YOU THAT?
YOU'RE GETTING BAD INFORMATION, AMERICA. THERE WERE NAMES ON IT LIKE --
IF YOU LOOK AT THE PETITION ITSELF,
IF YOU CONTACT THE SCIENTISTS WHO PUT IT TOGETHER,
THEY WILL PRESENT DOCUMENTATION.
THEY HAVE IT ON THEIR WEBSITE.
MORE THAN 31,000 SCIENTISTS HAVE SIGNED IT
AND IT'S DOCUMENTED.
IT'S DOCUMENTED.
[ CHUCKLES ] OKAY.
AFTER MEETING JAMES, I DID SOME MORE RESEARCH.
HIS "SCIENCE TRAINING" CONSISTS OF A FEW UNDERGRADUATE CLASSES
HE TOOK OVER 25 YEARS AGO.
AS FOR THE OREGON PETITION, IT TURNS OUT
ANYONE WITH AN UNDERGRADUATE SCIENCE DEGREE
CAN ADD THEIR NAME.
THE WEBSITE BRAGS ABOUT THE NUMBER OF SIGNATURES,
BUT LESS THAN 1% EVEN CLAIM
TO HAVE AN EXPERTISE IN CLIMATE SCIENCE.
THE WHOLE THING SEEMS KIND OF RIDICULOUS TO ME.
BUT WITH ALL THE MONEY POURING IN,
THE DENIAL CAMPAIGN SEEMS HARD TO COUNTER.
AND I WONDER HOW ALL THIS WILL PLAY OUT IN KANSAS,
WHERE THE VOTE ON RENEWABLE ENERGY IS ABOUT TO HAPPEN.
Crosson: WHEN WE GOT TO UTAH, I WAS SHOCKED.
I HAVE NEVER -- AND I HAVE DONE MEASUREMENTS ALL OVER THE WORLD.
I HAVE NEVER SEEN THAT SITUATION EVER,
OVER HUNDREDS OF SQUARE MILES.
THE NUMBER OF LEAKS IN UINTA IS STAGGERING.
Bittman: A FEW WEEKS AFTER OUR TRIP TO UTAH,
ERIC CROSSON FROM PICARRO WAS ANALYZING THE DATA WE COLLECTED.
WHAT HE'S FINDING IS HARD TO FATHOM.
Crosson: WE DID A BACK-OF-THE-ENVELOPE CALCULATION
AND CAME TO THE CONCLUSION
THAT THE LEAK RATE COMING OUT OF THE UINTA BASIN WAS ABOUT 11%.
Bittman: UTAH, IN OTHER WORDS, IS EVEN WORSE THAN COLORADO.
AND ON THE HEELS OF PICARRO'S FINDINGS,
ANOTHER GROUP OF N.O.A. SCIENTISTS
LOOKS AT METHANE EMISSIONS
COMING FROM A MIXTURE OF OIL AND GAS WELLS
IN THE LOS ANGELES BASIN.
THEIR NUMBER...
17%.
Bittman: WE HEAR INDUSTRY SAY,
"THERE'S JUST NOT THAT MUCH IN THE WAY OF LEAKS.
"MAYBE WE'RE LOSING 1%. IT'S NOT THAT HIGH.
IT'S NOT THAT BIG OF A PROBLEM."
WHAT DO YOU SAY TO THAT?
THEY'RE WRONG. THEY'RE JUST FLAT-OUT WRONG,
IN TERMS OF WHAT THESE EMISSIONS ARE.
THE E.P.A. IS FLAT-OUT WRONG, AS WELL.
BUT IT'S LIKE SO MANY OTHER INACCURACIES IN LIFE.
IF YOU REPEAT THEM OFTEN ENOUGH,
AND IF YOU REPEAT THEM LOUD ENOUGH
AND YOU DEFEND THEM VOCIFEROUSLY,
THEN THAT KIND OF BECOMES ACCEPTED AS TRUTH.
LOS ANGELES BASIN -- UP TO 17%.
NOW, GRANTED, THAT'S ONE BASIN.
UTAH WAS ANOTHER BASIN.
COLORADO WAS ANOTHER BASIN.
BUT THESE BASINS ARE STARTING TO LINE UP.
[ CHUCKLES ] ALL THE DATA COMES OUT.
SO FAR...
DOESN'T BODE WELL FOR THE FINAL ANSWER
LOOKING LIKE IT'S WAY LOW,
LIKE THE INDUSTRY SAYS, "OH, LESS THAN 1%."
IMPOSSIBLE. ABSOLUTELY IMPOSSIBLE.
N.O.A. MEASURED --
GOT LEVELS OF 17% IN THE LOS ANGELES BASIN.
YOU KNOW, IT TAKES A LOT OF 1% EMISSIONS
TO BRING THAT AVERAGE BACK DOWN.
I CAN TELL YOU
THAT I LOOKED AT THE STUDIES THAT N.O.A. DID,
AND I KNOW SOMETHING ABOUT THE PICARRO INSTRUMENTATION.
AND I THINK SOME OF THOSE NUMBERS,
THEY CERTAINLY CONCERN ME.
HOW COULD YOU SAY
THAT THAT METHANE EMISSION RATE WAS 1.5%?
VERY, VERY DIFFICULT TO GET THERE FROM HERE FOR THAT.
AFTER WHAT I'VE SEEN IN WORKING ON THIS STORY FOR MONTHS,
THE 1% LEAK RATE INDUSTRY-WIDE, COUNTRY-WIDE,
THAT REALLY SEEMS LAUGHABLE.
NO QUESTION. THERE'S WORK TO BE DONE.
BUT WE CAN ALL WASTE OUR TIME ABOUT,
"IS IT 4%? IS IT 8%? IS IT 1%?"
OR WE CAN ALL JUST SAY,
"I DON'T CARE WHAT ANYONE THINKS IT IS.
LET'S GO OUT AND FIX THE PROBLEM."
IT'S NICE TO HEAR SOMEONE FROM THE INDUSTRY
AT LEAST ACKNOWLEDGE THERE'S A PROBLEM.
PRESIDENT OBAMA HAS ACKNOWLEDGED IT, TOO,
AND PROMISED TO STUDY IT.
AND, IN COLORADO, THE ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND
SUCCESSFULLY CAMPAIGNED
FOR TOUGHER REGULATIONS ON METHANE LEAKS.
BUT ACTUALLY FIXING THE PROBLEM MIGHT NOT BE THAT EASY.
SOME SAY TECHNOLOGY LIKE THE KIND I SAW
IN MARK BOLING'S FACILITY IS THE ANSWER.
AND A STUDY LAST YEAR BY THE ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE FUND
SHOWED THAT THESE SO-CALLED GREEN COMPLETIONS
CAN HELP QUITE A BIT.
BUT IN COLORADO,
WHERE MORE AND MORE WELLS ARE DOING GREEN COMPLETIONS,
GABBY PETRON STILL HASN'T SEEN METHANE EMISSIONS GO DOWN.
THEN I STARTED THINKING ABOUT
ALL THE PLACES ACROSS THE COUNTRY WHERE GAS CAN LEAK.
NOT JUST THE HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF WELLS,
BUT A PIPELINE SYSTEM 1.5 MILLION MILES LONG
WITH TENS OF THOUSANDS OF COMPRESSOR STATIONS,
COUNTLESS VALVES, AND CORRODED PIPES
RUNNING UNDER TOWNS AND CITIES EVERYWHERE --
EVEN UNDER THE VERY CITY
WHERE THE FUTURE OF NATURAL GAS WILL BE DECIDED.
Jackson: WE'LL CHECK THESE FIRST.
THIS ONE, WE CAN SMELL IT.
YEAH, YOU CAN SMELL IT JUST WALKING UP.
[ METER BEEPING ]
OH, YEAH.
I THINK IT'S ANSWERING MY INSTRUMENT.
11%.
THAT'S A DANGEROUS CONCENTRATION.
IF THAT SPARKED, THAT WOULD BLOW UP.
ROB JACKSON IS A SCIENTIST WITH DUKE UNIVERSITY.
HE'S BEEN USING PICARRO TECHNOLOGY
TO FIND METHANE LEAKS IN CITIES.
HE JUST FINISHED A STUDY IN BOSTON
WHERE HE FOUND THOUSANDS OF THEM,
AND NOW HE'S FINDING THE SAME THING HERE.
THIS IS A PARTIAL MAP OF THE CITY.
THE RED IS ALL THE ROAD MILES IN THE CITY.
THE YELLOW ARE THE LEAKS,
AND YOU LITERALLY HAVE THOUSANDS OF VERY SMALL LEAKS
SPREAD OUT ALL ACROSS THE CITY.
IT'S DEATH BY 1,000 CUTS.
[ METER BEEPING ]
SO THAT'S 45% GAS.
THAT'S ALMOST PURE METHANE COMING OUT OF THE GROUND.
THERE'S SO MUCH METHANE THERE
THAT YOU ACTUALLY COULDN'T LIGHT THAT,
BECAUSE THERE'S NOT ENOUGH OXYGEN.
NOT THAT THAT'S MUCH CONSOLATION.
Bittman: THERE'S A LOT MORE WE STILL DON'T KNOW,
BUT FROM EVERYTHING I'VE SEEN, IT SEEMS LIKE RIGHT NOW,
NATURAL GAS COULD BE MAKING OUR CLIMATE PROBLEM WORSE
RATHER THAN BETTER.
I THINK WE NEED TO ASK OURSELVES IF THAT'S A RISK WORTH TAKING,
BECAUSE THE NATURAL-GAS BOOM IN THIS COUNTRY
IS JUST GETTING STARTED.
Ferrera: THE BILL THAT WOULD DISMANTLE
KANSAS' CLEAN-ENERGY LAW IS UP FOR A VOTE TODAY,
AND PETE FERRELL IS ON HIS WAY TO LISTEN IN.
Man: IN APRIL 2009, THIS LEGISLATURE PASSED MANDATES
TO "PROTECT" U.S. CITIZENS
FROM THE DANGERS OF A COLORLESS, ODORLESS, TASTELESS
AND I SUBMIT TO YOU, HARMLESS GAS KNOWN AS CO2.
THE EXISTING MANDATES ARE WHY WE'RE HERE TODAY.
Rep. Garber: POLITICAL WINDS SHIFT,
THE COMPOSITION OF THE LEGISLATOR SHIFTS,
AND MAYBE IT SHIFTS BECAUSE OF BAD DECISIONS
THAT WERE MADE BEFORE.
THIS IS ABOUT GENERATIONS OF KANSANS TO COME.
Ferrera: IF THE VOTE IS A "YES,"
KANSAS' RENEWABLE-ENERGY LAW WILL BE REPEALED.
I'M IN SUPPORT OF THIS AMENDMENT.
I JUST CANNOT SUPPORT THIS BILL.
WHAT ARE WE DOING HERE? WHAT ARE WE DOING?
I WILL MOVE FORWARD THIS MOTION.
THIS IS STARTING TO GET A LITTLE RIDICULOUS.
I WILL NOT SUPPORT THIS, AND I, TOO, QUESTION
WHY WE'RE JUST PLAYING WITH NUMBERS.
I DISAGREE. AND SO, I WOULD SUGGEST
THAT THIS LEGISLATION DOES ADVANCE REASONABLE POLICY
FOR THE CITIZENS OF KANSAS.
ALL RIGHT, WE'LL CALL FOR A VOTE ON THE AMENDMENT.
ALL IN FAVOR, SAY, "AYE."
AYE. AYE.AYE.
ALL OPPOSED, SAY, "NAY."
NAY. NAY.NAY.
CHAIR'S IN DOUBT.
WE'LL CALL FOR A RAISE OF HANDS TO CLARIFY THE VOTE.
ALL IN FAVOR, RAISE YOUR RIGHT HAND, PLEASE.
SO NINE.
OKAY. ALL OPPOSED?
9, 10. THE MOTION FAILS.
THIS MEETING IS ADJOURNED. THANK YOU.
Ferrell: WE SURVIVED BY ONE VOTE.
ONE VOTE KEPT US FROM DESTROYING
THE RENEWABLE-ENERGY STANDARD IN KANSAS.
SO IT WASN'T LIKE IT WAS A SLAM DUNK OR ANYTHING.
Ferrera: AND DID THEY REALLY THINK
THAT THAT'S IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE PEOPLE IN KANSAS?
NO, I DON'T THINK THEY THINK IT'S THE BEST INTEREST
IN THE PEOPLE OF KANSAS.
I THINK IT'S THE BEST INTEREST OF POWERFUL CORPORATIONS.
AMERICA, THIS IS ABSOLUTELY MY FAVORITE SPOT.
NOT ONLY IS THIS WHERE THE ASHES OF MY PARENTS
AND MY SISTER AND LOVED ONES ARE,
BUT IT'S THE BEST VIEW OF THE WORLD, IN MY OPINION.
IT'S BEAUTIFUL. I MEAN, WE'VE GOT EVERYTHING UP HERE.
WE'VE GOT THE MOST GORGEOUS TALLGRASS PRAIRIE IN THE WORLD,
AND WE HAVE A STATE-OF-THE-ART WIND FARM AS A BACKDROP.
BUT I HEARD YOU SAY THAT YOU THINK THEY'RE BEAUTIFUL
BUT BECAUSE OF WHAT THEY SYMBOLIZE.
YEAH, WHAT THEY REPRESENT --
THE ABILITY TO GENERATE ELECTRICITY
WITHOUT PUTTING CARBON IN THE AIR,
AND THAT'S ALWAYS BEEN A CENTRAL POINT FOR ME.
YOU KNOW, WE'RE GONNA RUN OUT OF OIL AND COAL.
DO WE WANT A HARD LANDING OR A SOFT LANDING?
AND I THINK MOVING TO RENEWABLES
PROVIDES A SOFT LANDING FOR US.
Ferrera: IN THE END, DESPITE THE EFFORTS OF HEARTLAND,
A.L.E.C., AND OTHERS,
NOT A SINGLE STATE VOTED TO REPEAL ITS CLEAN-ENERGY LAW
IN 2013.
INSTEAD, FOUR STATES
ACTUALLY INCREASE THEIR GOALS FOR RENEWABLES.
BUT TAYLOR IS PLANNING TO CONTINUE THE FIGHT.
Taylor: I'M VERY OPTIMISTIC.
I'M VERY PLEASED WITH THE WAY
EVENTS HAVE BEEN UNFOLDING IN THE STATES.
SURE, I WOULD'VE LIKED TO HAVE HAD
SOME RENEWABLE-POWER MANDATES ROLLED BACK BY NOW.
WHEN I SAY, "BY NOW," IT'S ONLY BEEN A COUPLE YEARS
THAT WE'VE REALLY TURNED THE MOMENTUM.
BUT I REALLY THINK THAT I HAVE A STRONG HAND
IN TERMS OF WHAT I'M ADVOCATING IN THE CLIMATE DEBATE.
AND I'M VERY COMFORTABLE IN MY OWN SKIN IN THAT DEBATE
JUST LIKE I AM AT THE POKER TABLE.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.