Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Bittman: THIS IS WHAT WE REMEMBER ABOUT SUPERSTORM SANDY --
THE JERSEY SHORE IN RUINS,
HOMES KNOCKED OFF THEIR FOUNDATIONS...
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Man: LADIES AND GENTLEMEN,
THE GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF NEW JERSEY, CHRIS CHRISTIE!
Bittman: ...AND GOVERNOR CHRISTIE TAKING CHARGE.
Christie: PEOPLE WANT TO REBUILD THEIR HOMES.
THEY WANT TO REBUILD THEIR BUSINESSES.
THEY WANT TO REBUILD THEIR SCHOOLS.
THEY WANT TO REBUILD THEIR STATE.
IT IS TIME FOR US TO TURN THE PAGE
TO MAKE SURE THAT WE GET THIS THING
BACK TO WHERE IT NEEDS TO BE.
THAT IS MY SOLE FOCUS FOR THE NEXT YEAR.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Bittman: CHRIS CHRISTIE BECAME AMERICA'S GOVERNOR...
IN THE EYE OF THE STORM
WAS NEW JERSEY GOVERNOR CHRIS CHRISTIE.
Bittman: ...AND ROSE ABOVE POLITICS.
Christie: I'VE GOT A JOB TO DO HERE IN NEW JERSEY
THAT'S MUCH BIGGER THAN PRESIDENTIAL POLITICS,
AND I COULD CARE LESS ABOUT ANY OF THAT STUFF.
GOVERNOR, GOVERNOR. THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING.
Bittman: GOVERNOR CHRISTIE WAS WIDELY VIEWED
AS THE SAVIOR OF SANDY.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
EVEN NEW YORK REPORTERS LIKE ME WERE IMPRESSED.
I WRITE MAINLY ABOUT FOOD, BUT LIVING HERE,
SANDY WAS A STORY I COULDN'T HELP BUT FOLLOW.
AND AT FIRST, IT SEEMED GREAT
TO HAVE SOMEONE LIKE CHRISTIE IN CHARGE.
BUT ONE THING CAUGHT MY ATTENTION --
HOW EAGER HE WAS TO TALK ABOUT ALL ASPECTS OF THE STORM
EXCEPT ONE.
BEN.
DO YOU THINK CLIMATE CHANGE, RISING SEA LEVELS,
GLOBAL WARMING, HAD ANYTHING TO DO
WITH THE FOCUSING ON THIS TOWN AND ELSEWHERE?
MAYBE, IN THE SUBSEQUENT MONTHS AND YEARS
AFTER I GET DONE WITH TRYING TO REBUILD THE STATE
AND PUT PEOPLE BACK IN THEIR HOMES,
I'LL HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO PONDER
THE ESOTERIC QUESTION OF THE CAUSE OF THIS STORM.
RIGHT NOW, I'M DEALING WITH PEOPLE
WHO ARE OUT OF THEIR HOMES, OUT OF THEIR BUSINESSES,
BECAUSE OF THIS STORM,
AND, CANDIDLY, I DON'T HAVE TIME TO DEAL WITH THIS.
MY MAIN CONCERN IS GETTING THE JOB DONE
THAT THE PEOPLE HAVE ELECTED ME TO DO.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Bittman: BUT IS CLIMATE CHANGE REALLY AN ESOTERIC QUESTION,
OR IS CHRISTIE LEAVING HIS STATE
DANGEROUSLY VULNERABLE TO THE NEXT SANDY?
Man: YOU CAME HERE THIS MORNING TO WITNESS HISTORY.
WELCOME, EVERYONE,
TO THE INAUGURATION OF GOVERNOR JAY INSLEE.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
JAY INSLEE IS THE FIRST POLITICAL CHIEF EXECUTIVE
IN AMERICAN HISTORY
TO BE ELECTED PRINCIPALLY ON A PLATFORM
OF COMBATING CLIMATE DISRUPTION.
I, JAY INSLEE...
WHILE LEADERS IN WASHINGTON, D.C.,
PONTIFICATE AND PROCRASTINATE,
JAY INSLEE SEES AN EXISTENTIAL THREAT
THAT TRANSCENDS POLITICS.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Munn: I'VE NEVER HEARD OF A POLITICIAN
MAKING CLIMATE CHANGE THEIR DEFINING ISSUE AND THEN WINNING.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
THIS WE KNOW --
OUR WORLD IS CHANGING FASTER
AND MORE DRAMATICALLY THAN EVER BEFORE.
AS A PARENT AND AS A GRANDPARENT,
I CANNOT CONSCIOUSLY ACCEPT THE DANGERS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
FOR MY FAMILY OR YOURS.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Munn: IN WASHINGTON, D.C., ACTION ON CLIMATE CHANGE
HAS BEEN STUCK IN A POLITICAL QUAGMIRE.
ARE THINGS REALLY GOING TO BE ANY DIFFERENT
IN WASHINGTON STATE?
[ APPLAUSE ]
IF THE REPUBLICANS' RESPONSE TO HIS SPEECH IS ANY CLUE,
IT LOOKS LIKE THE NEW GOVERNOR HAS A TOUGH ROAD AHEAD.
Woman: THIS REPORT CONSTITUTES AN ALARM-CLOCK MOMENT
FOR THE WORLD,
BECAUSE THIS REPORT WILL TELL US, AGAIN,
THAT EVERYTHING WE THOUGHT WE KNEW ON CLIMATE CHANGE
HAS ACTUALLY BEEN UNDERESTIMATED,
THAT THE EFFECTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE WILL BE UPON US
FASTER AND IN A MORE INTENSE FASHION THAN WE HAD THOUGHT.
President H.W. Bush: WE ALL KNOW THAT HUMAN ACTIVITIES
ARE CHANGING THE ATMOSPHERE
IN UNEXPECTED AND IN UNPRECEDENTED WAYS.
Man: ...THAT THE GREENHOUSE EFFECT HAS BEEN DETECTED,
AND IT IS CHANGING OUR CLIMATE NOW.
Man #2: THE ATMOSPHERE AND OCEAN HAVE WARMED.
THE AMOUNT OF SNOW AND ICE HAVE DIMINISHED.
SEA LEVEL HAS RISEN,
AND THE CONCENTRATIONS OF GREENHOUSE GASES HAVE...
Schwarzenegger: THERE IS NO MORE FIRE SEASON.
WE HAVE WILDFIRES ALL YEAR 'ROUND.
Cuomo: CLIMATE CHANGE, EXTREME WEATHER --
CALL IT WHAT YOU WILL -- AND OUR VULNERABILITY TO IT.
Man #3: ...WHERE 12 YEARS OF DROUGHT HAS LEFT THE LANDSCAPE BONE-DRY.
Man #4: WE GOT ANY PATRIOTS IN THE CROWD?!
Woman #2: A NEW SCIENTIFIC REPORT HAS DETERMINED
THE LAST DECADE WAS THE WARMEST ON RECORD.
Man #5: OUR WORLD IS CHANGING FASTER
AND MORE DRAMATICALLY THAN EVER BEFORE.
Bittman: AS SANDY BARRELED UP THE COAST,
GOVERNOR CHRISTIE MADE IT CLEAR TO EVERYONE
THAT HE WAS IN CHARGE,
THAT HE WOULD LEAD NEW JERSEY
THROUGH WHATEVER BLOW THE STORM WOULD DELIVER.
Christie: MANDATORY EVACUATIONS ARE NOW IN EFFECT
AS OF 4:00 THIS AFTERNOON
FOR THE BARRIER ISLANDS FROM SANDY HOOK
SOUTH TO CAPE MAY.
THE COMBINATION OF THE RAIN, THE FLOODING, AND THE WINDS
ARE GONNA MAKE THIS A VERY, VERY DIFFICULT EVENT TO DEAL WITH.
BUT IF YOU'RE PREPARED,
LET ME ASSURE YOU THAT WE'RE PREPARED,
AND THAT, TOGETHER, WE'LL BE ABLE TO --
WE'RE GONNA WEATHER THROUGH THIS.
[ RADIO CHATTER ]
OKAY. GOOD ENOUGH. THANK YOU.
Man: THESE HOUSES ARE MAYBE FOUR FOOT HIGHER THAN THE RIVER,
AND AS YOU CAN SEE, THEY'RE IN THE RIVER.
Christie: WE'RE AT THE MOMENT NOW
WHERE EVACUATION IS NO LONGER POSSIBLE,
AND WE'RE NO LONGER ABLE TO COME AND RESCUE PEOPLE.
Man: YOU CAN SEE THE SEAWALL HERE.
SEE THE WATER SPRAYING RIGHT OUT THE SIDE?
YEAH, WE SHOULD GET OUT OF HERE.
ALL RIGHT, JUST HEAD BACK -- [ THUNDER CRASHES ]
WHOO!
Christie: I STILL DON'T THINK WE CAN ASSESS
WHAT'S GONNA HAPPEN IN THE NEXT SIX HOURS.
IT'S NOT LIKE THIS IS OVER, OKAY?
WE HAVE THE WORST SIX HOURS OF THE STORM COMING RIGHT NOW.
I KNOW THAT MANY PEOPLE IN OUR STATE
WOKE UP TODAY TO ABSOLUTE DEVASTATION.
Woman: I GOT NOTHING LEFT.
THERE ARE NO WORDS TO DESCRIBE WHAT SO MANY NEW JERSEYANS
EXPERIENCED OVER THE LAST 24 HOURS.
THANK YOU.
WE HAVE A LONG ROAD AHEAD OF US,
BUT I HAVE COMPLETE CONFIDENCE
WE'RE GOING TO COME OUT OF THIS
BETTER AND STRONGER THAN BEFORE.
WE'RE TOUGH. WE'RE TOUGH.
WE'RE TOUGH FOLKS. DON'T YOU WORRY ABOUT THAT.
WE'LL GO THIS WAY.
[ INDISTINCT CONVERSATIONS ]
Bittman: NO TOWN IN NEW JERSEY WAS HIT HARDER THAN UNION BEACH.
SANDY'S STORM SURGE PUT ALMOST THE ENTIRE TOWN UNDERWATER
AND WASHED AWAY 110 HOMES.
OF THE BUILDINGS THAT REMAIN, HUNDREDS MORE ARE UNINHABITABLE.
LOCAL HOTELS ARE CHOKED WITH THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE
WITH NOWHERE TO GO.
Man: ATTENTION, RESIDENTS -- WE HAVE HOT FOOD, BLANKETS.
GOD BLESS YOU ALL. BE SAFE.
YOU TOO, HON. I GIVE YOU ALL MY LOVE AND PRAYERS.
THANK YOU. THANK YOU.
Man: HOLY CRAP.
Bittman: AFTER SUCH AN UNPRECEDENTED STORM,
MANY IN UNION BEACH
ARE WONDERING IF REBUILDING EVEN MAKES SENSE.
Burlew: AND 6 WILL BE 25.
WE HAVE 2,600 PEOPLE
THAT STILL DON'T HAVE A PLACE TO LIVE.
SO, WE'RE WORKING 12 HOURS,
AND IF WE HAVE TO WORK INTO THE NIGHT, WE DO THAT.
[ SIGHS ] NEXT.
Bittman: TOWN ENGINEER BOBBY BURLEW
IS FACING THE BIGGEST JOB OF HIS LIFE.
EVER SINCE SANDY HIT THREE MONTHS AGO,
HE'S BEEN WORKING ALMOST NONSTOP, EVERY DAY OF THE WEEK,
HELPING HIS NEIGHBORS THROUGH THE AFTERMATH.
I CAN'T KEEP GOING BACK TO THE LADY, ASKING FOR MORE MONEY.
MY FATHER HAS GONE DOWNHILL SINCE THIS HURRICANE.
IT'S GONNA BE TOUGH.
HE HAS TO HELP THEM DECIDE -- REBUILD OR MOVE ON.
Burlew: THERE'S YOUR THREE OPTIONS --
ELEVATE YOUR HOME, PICK IT UP AND MOVE IT,
OR DO A DEMOLISH.
Burlew: COACHED FOOTBALL FOR 35 YEARS.
AND, YOU KNOW, EVERYBODY WHO'S HAVING A PROBLEM,
I EITHER HAD THEM IN SCHOOL AT ONE POINT OR ANOTHER,
COACHING FOOTBALL, SO EMOTIONALLY, IT'S DIFFICULT.
THAT'S IT.
Burlew: WE'RE GONNA MAKE A LEFT TURN ONTO BROOK AVENUE.
ALL THE HOMES IN THIS AREA,
THERE'S ONLY ONE STILL STANDING.
AND THERE'S NOBODY LIVING ON THAT STREET, EITHER,
BUT THERE WAS ALL HOMES HERE.
WOW.
AND HOW MUCH WATER WAS IN HERE?
AT LEAST 4 FEET.
WOW.
SO UP TO THE TOP OF THE STEPS OF A LOT OF THESE HOMES.
YEAH, THERE'S ONLY ONE PERSON LIVING HERE.
PRETTY SAD.
AND WE'RE HEADING DOWN TOWARDS --
I GUESS WE LABELED IT AS GROUND ZERO.
WHAT DO YOU THINK MAKES SENSE DOWN IN HERE
WHERE YOU'RE CALLING GROUND ZERO?
DO YOU THINK IT MAKES SENSE TO BUILD OR JUST GIVE UP?
I REALLY DON'T THINK THE PEOPLE ARE GONNA GIVE UP.
BUT IF THERE'S ANOTHER STORM OR A WORSE STORM?
SAME THING COULD HAPPEN ALL OVER AGAIN, YEAH?
WELL...
IT COULD CERTAINLY HAPPEN AGAIN, BUT...
I DON'T KNOW.
[ SNIFFLES ]
I NEED A MOMENT.
YEAH, YOU'VE SEEN A LOT HERE.
Bittman: BUT GOVERNOR CHRISTIE IS UNWAVERING IN HIS MESSAGE.
HE SAYS REBUILD NOW.
HE VOWS TO GET PEOPLE BACK IN THEIR HOMES
AND TO GET THE DEMOLISHED BOARDWALKS REBUILT
BEFORE MEMORIAL DAY.
Christie: TO LET PEOPLE BOTH IN THE REGION
AND ACROSS THE COUNTRY WHO COME HERE FOR VACATION KNOW
WE'RE OPEN FOR BUSINESS.
Bittman: THE STATE'S $38 BILLION TOURIST INDUSTRY
HANGS IN THE BALANCE.
Woman: SO YOU'RE JUST GONNA FOLLOW THE SIDEWALK
ALL THE WAY UP TOP,
AND I'LL MEET YOU IN THERE TO LET YOU IN.
OH, GREAT. THANKS. YOU'RE WELCOME.
Munn: I'M HERE TO MEET
WASHINGTON STATE'S NEW GOVERNOR, JAY INSLEE.
HE'S ALREADY BEING CALLED THE GREENEST GOVERNOR IN AMERICA.
HE'S ONLY BEEN IN OFFICE A FEW MONTHS, THOUGH,
SO WHETHER HE'LL LIVE UP TO THAT REMAINS TO BE SEEN.
JAY.
INSLEE CAMPAIGNED ON TWO ISSUES --
BOOSTING THE ECONOMY AND ADDRESSING CLIMATE CHANGE.
AND HE SEEMS TO THINK THEY GO HAND-IN-HAND --
THAT DOING SOMETHING ABOUT GLOBAL WARMING
WILL CREATE THOUSANDS OF JOBS AND CLEAN ENERGY.
HELLO.
HELLO. JAY. HI. OLIVIA.
HOW ARE YOU? OLIVIA, GOOD TO SEE YOU.
NICE TO SEE YOU, TOO.
HOW THEY TREATING YOU HERE? THEY ARE VERY NICE HERE.
WHEN I CAME UP, THE SOUNDS OF WASHINGTON --
BIRDS CHIRPING.
YEAH. AND THOSE ARE REAL BIRDS, ACTUALLY.
I DON'T BELIEVE IT.
I THINK THAT YOU PUT IN AN AUDIO TRACK.
NO, THAT'S CALIFORNIA. THIS IS WASHINGTON.
WE HAVE REAL BIRDS HERE.
WELL, YOU WANT TO SEE THE PEOPLE'S HOUSE?
I DO.
INSLEE IS STILL SETTLING IN
TO LIFE IN THE GOVERNOR'S MANSION.
HE JUST FINISHED REDECORATING.
THIS IS A PAINTING BY MY MOM.
OH, WOW.
AND HERE'S ONE OF MOUNT RAINIER THAT I DID.
OH, WOW. AND YOU HEAR THAT GEORGE W. IS PAINTING.
DON'T BRING THAT UP.
I JUST -- I DON'T KNOW IF YOU GUYS EXCHANGE PAINT COLORS,
IF HE CALLS YOU AND HE'S LIKE, "YOU KNOW, INSLEE,
I FOUND OUT THAT RED AND BLUE MAKE PURPLE."
SO, THERE'S OUR FAMILY HERE. WE GOT SOME BIKE RIDERS.
OH, THAT'S NICE.
CONNOR HERE IS NUMBER-TWO SON.
AND THEN WE GOT JACK, NUMBER-ONE SON, AND NUMBER-TWO SON.
THIS IS NUMBER-TWO AND NUMBER-THREE BOYS,
CONNOR AND JOE.
PLEASE TELL ME YOU CALL THEM THAT -- "NUMBER THREE, NUMBER TWO!"
YOU CAN TELL THIS GUY IS OBSESSED WITH THE OUTDOORS --
BIRDWATCHING, SKIING, BIKE-RIDING.
SO, THIS IS MY PRIDE AND JOY HERE.
THIS IS MY, UH -- THIS IS MY CINELLI.
SO THIS IS 32 YEARS OLD.
AND THEN I GOT MY NEW LITTLE -- MY CARBON BIKE HERE.
SO THIS IS A CARBON FRAME.
AND MY NEW SLOGAN IS CARBON BELONGS
IN OUR BIKE FRAMES, NOT IN THE ATMOSPHERE.
I LIKE IT.
BUT THAT'S OUR NEW SLOGAN.
SURGING GREENHOUSE GASES ARE WORSE THAN PREDICTED.
Munn: BEFORE HE WAS GOVERNOR,
INSLEE WAS A MEMBER OF CONGRESS FOR ALMOST 20 YEARS,
AND HE WAS OUTSPOKEN ABOUT CLIMATE CHANGE.
WE NEED REAL SCIENCE,
AND WE NEED US TO HAVE A CLEAN-ENERGY POLICY.
THANK YOU.
Munn: BUT HE TELLS ME THAT THAT KIND OF BOLD ACTION
HE HOPED FOR NEVER CAME.
Inslee: WHEN I WAS IN CONGRESS,
I SERVED ON THE CLIMATE-CHANGE COMMITTEE.
THIS IS A COMMITTEE THAT'S DEDICATED
TO FINDING SOLUTIONS TO CLIMATE CHANGE.
WELL, UNFORTUNATELY, PRETTY MUCH ALL OF THE REPUBLICANS
ON THE CLIMATE-CHANGE COMMITTEE
REFUSED TO RECOGNIZE THE SCIENCE OF CLIMATE CHANGE.
LATELY, A LOT OF PEOPLE HAVE BEEN TAKING A SECOND LOOK
AT THE SO-CALLED SETTLED SCIENCE OF CLIMATE CHANGE.
THERE'S CLEARLY A DISPUTE ABOUT THE EVIDENCE.
SCIENCE IS APOLITICAL, AND YET POLITICIANS IN OUR COUNTRY
STARTED TO LOOK THROUGH THIS -- THROUGH A PARTISAN LENS.
YOU KNOW, WHO'S FOR THIS? IS IT DEMOCRATS OR REPUBLICANS?
THE SCIENCE IS CLEAR. I WISH IT WAS OTHERWISE.
LIFE WOULD BE EASIER, BUT THIS IS THE CHALLENGE FOR THE AGES.
THANK YOU.
Munn: WHY DID YOU FEEL THAT YOU COULD GET MORE DONE
AS A GOVERNOR THAN IN CONGRESS?
CONGRESS WAS THIS THING
THAT'S KIND OF GLACIATED AT THE MOMENT,
AND I FELT THE STATE OF WASHINGTON
IS A PLACE WHERE WE COULD ACTUALLY DO THINGS
ON ENERGY, CLEAN ENERGY, AND WE'RE DOING THAT.
WE'RE GETTING THAT STARTED HERE.
PLUS, YOU KNOW, IT'S HOME, RIGHT?
THIS IS -- THIS IS HOME.
RIGHT.
Munn: BUT LATELY, INSLEE SAYS
HIS HOME STATE HAS GOTTEN OFF TRACK.
IN 2008, BEFORE HE WAS GOVERNOR,
THE STATE PASSED A LAW REQUIRING MAJOR REDUCTIONS
IN GREENHOUSE-GAS EMISSIONS BY 2020.
BUT THEY NEVER PUT A PLAN IN PLACE
TO ACTUALLY MEET THOSE REQUIREMENTS.
DO YOU HAVE A COPY OF THE BILL? YES.
INSLEE INTENDS TO FIX THAT
WITH WHAT HE CALLS HIS CLIMATE ACTION BILL.
IT WOULD CREATE A HIGH-LEVEL WORKGROUP
HEADED BY THE GOVERNOR HIMSELF TO COME UP WITH A PLAN.
THE ENVIROS ARE MAKING ONE REQUEST ON THE LANGUAGE,
THE KEY SECTION OF THE LANGUAGE YOU ASKED US TO WRITE.
THEY SUGGESTED "ENSURE ACHIEVEMENT OF EMISSION LIMITS."
I THINK THAT'S PROBABLY BETTER LANGUAGE.
SO, THAT'S GOOD. IF YOU'RE GOOD WITH THE BILL,
I'LL GO AHEAD AND GET IT TO THE CODE ADVISER.
WE'LL START GENERATING SIGNATURES.
ALL RIGHT.
Munn: BUT THERE'S STILL ONE BIG OBSTACLE.
THE BILL HAS TO MAKE IT
THROUGH THE REPUBLICAN-CONTROLLED SENATE,
WHICH IS WHY INSLEE IS TAKING SUCH A CAREFUL APPROACH.
HE'S INVITING MEMBERS OF BOTH PARTIES TO JOIN THE WORKGROUP
AND PUSHING TO FIND A BIPARTISAN SOLUTION
TO CURBING EMISSIONS.
THE GREAT THINGS WE'VE DONE IN OUR COUNTRY
HAVE USUALLY BEEN BIPARTISAN THINGS, ULTIMATELY.
MM-HMM. RIGHT.
AND WE HAVE A HUGE OPPORTUNITY FOR REPUBLICANS
TO STEP UP TO THE PLATE AND BE LEADERS ON THIS RIGHT NOW.
WE NEED A BIPARTISAN SOLUTION.
WE ALL NEED TO WORK TOGETHER TO GET THIS JOB DONE.
BUT WHY DO YOU THINK IT'S SO HARD
TO GET ACTION ON THIS ISSUE?
I GOT TO SHOW YOU SOMETHING. SO, HERE'S TODAY'S OLYMPIAN.
AND THE HEADLINE IS,
"CO2 LEVEL PASSES FEARED MILESTONE."
"REACHING A CONCENTRATION
NOT SEEN ON THE EARTH FOR MILLIONS OF YEARS."
"FOR MILLIONS OF YEARS."
HOW COULD YOU POSSIBLY HAVE A HEADLINE LIKE THIS
AND STILL HAVE POLITICAL RESISTANCE
TO TAKING MEANINGFUL ACTION?
IT'S ALSO ON PAGE 9.
IT'S THERE. IT'S THERE. BUT I THINK THAT'S THE ISSUE.
I'M NOT GIVING THEM A PASS.
I'M SAYING THE ISSUE IS THAT PEOPLE DON'T KNOW
HOW BIG OF A DEAL IT IS.
BUT HERE'S THE PROBLEM THAT I FACE.
EVEN IF I WENT TO A LEGISLATIVE HEARING
AND I HELD THIS UP AND I READ THIS
TO SOME LEGISLATORS HERE IN MY STATE,
THEIR RESPONSE WOULD BE,
"IT'S JUST WRONG. I JUST DON'T BELIEVE IT."
WOMAN: WNYC's Bob Hennelly asked Christie
if the governor was discussing
the increasing severity of storms
with climate-change scientists.
CHRISTIE: Now, that's over my head.
Bittman: IN THE MONTHS AFTER SUPERSTORM SANDY,
GOVERNOR CHRISTIE TREATS CLIMATE CHANGE
AS NOTHING MORE THAN A DISTRACTION.
WOMAN: When he was pressed,
he maintained he's a lawyer, not a scientist.
Bittman: BUT IS IT REALLY SO IRRELEVANT?
JUST 20 MINUTES FROM CHRISTIE'S OFFICE IN THE STATE HOUSE,
PRINCETON UNIVERSITY IS HOME
TO SOME OF THE WORLD'S LEADING CLIMATE SCIENTISTS.
Bittman: CAN A STORM LIKE SANDY, OR SANDY IN PARTICULAR,
HAVE BEEN CAUSED BY CLIMATE CHANGE?
CAN YOU SAY SOMETHING LIKE THAT?
THERE ARE MANY FACTORS THAT GO INTO BUILDING A STORM,
PARTICULARLY AN UNUSUAL STORM LIKE SANDY.
ONE OF THE FACTORS THAT WE'RE SURE
WAS RELATED TO AND CAUSED BY CLIMATE CHANGE
WAS THE HIGHER SEA LEVEL.
Bittman: PRINCETON'S MICHAEL OPPENHEIMER
ADVISES NASA AND THE UNITED NATIONS.
AND BEN STRAUSS IS AN EXPERT
ON SEA-LEVEL RISE IN THE UNITED STATES.
Oppenheimer: THERE'S NO DOUBT IN MY MIND THE DAMAGE FROM SANDY
WAS WORSE THAN IT WOULD HAVE BEEN OTHERWISE
BECAUSE GLOBAL WARMING CAUSED THE SEA LEVEL TO BE HIGHER,
MADE IT EASIER FOR SANDY TO PUSH THE WATER FURTHER INLAND.
SO MORE AND MORE HOMES, MORE AND MORE AREAS
WERE DAMAGED, WERE AFFECTED, THAN WOULD HAVE BEEN
IF THE SAME STORM CAME BY 50 YEARS AGO.
WARMER SEA-SURFACE TEMPERATURES
FROM CLIMATE CHANGE STRENGTHENED SANDY.
THERE'S A REALLY SIMPLE ANALOGY HERE.
IF YOU PUT A POT OF WATER ON THE STOVE AND YOU LIGHT A FLAME,
YOU'RE GOING TO GET A LOT OF TURBULENCE.
THAT'S LIKE HEATING UP THE OCEAN.
YOU HAVE MORE STORMS, MORE MOISTURE IN THE AIR,
MORE ENERGY, AND MORE TURBULENCE.
Bittman: OVER THE PAST HUNDRED YEARS,
THE OCEAN HAS RISEN OVER A FOOT ON THE JERSEY SHORE,
MOSTLY BECAUSE OF MANMADE CLIMATE CHANGE.
WITHOUT THIS INCREASE,
THE WORST FLOODING FROM A STORM LIKE SANDY
WOULD STILL BE SEVERE,
AND WHEN YOU ADD THAT EXTRA FOOT,
THE DIFFERENCES MIGHT SEEM SMALL, AT FIRST,
BUT THESE ARE REAL HOMES AND REAL PEOPLE.
IN NEW JERSEY ALONE,
SEA-LEVEL RISE PUT AT LEAST
AN ADDITIONAL 25 SQUARE MILES OF LAND AND 40,000 PEOPLE
INSIDE SANDY'S FOOTPRINT.
AND SCIENTISTS PROJECT THAT, BY THE END OF THE CENTURY,
THE SEA LEVEL WILL RISE ANOTHER 2 TO 7 FEET,
WHICH MEANS THAT IN PARTS OF THE STATE,
EVEN A NORMAL STORM COULD CAUSE SANDY-LEVEL FLOODING.
Oppenheimer: THERE'S A TENSION BETWEEN REBUILDING AS LIFE WAS
AND RECOGNIZING THE FUTURE RISK AND BUILDING IN A WAY
THAT PROTECTS PROPERTY AND PROTECTS LIVES IN THE FUTURE.
THE REALITY IS THAT WE CAN'T AND WE SHOULDN'T PUT EVERYTHING
BACK WHERE IT WAS IN THE WAY IT WAS.
[ HORNS HONK ]
Bittman: BUT AS NEW JERSEY PREPARES TO SPEND
TENS OF BILLIONS OF DOLLARS REBUILDING,
IT SEEMS LIKE GOVERNOR CHRISTIE
REFUSES TO TAKE ANY OF THIS INTO ACCOUNT.
[ Ringing ]
MAN: Governor's press office.
GOOD MORNING. THIS IS MARK BITTMAN.
I WAS HOPING TO SPEAK WITH MARIE COMELLA.
WE'RE HOPING TO SET UP
AN INTERVIEW WITH GOVERNOR CHRISTIE.
She's not in the office yet.
Um...can I take a message?
YEAH, I SENT HER A COUPLE E-MAILS,
SO, UM...SHE CAN FIND THOSE, I GUESS.
SHOULD I LEAVE MY PHONE NUMBER? Sure.
YOU KNOW, AND HERE'S THE HOUSE THAT WE'RE COMING UP TO.
I'M DOING AN INSPECTION ON THIS ONE RIGHT NOW.
Bittman: SIX MONTHS AFTER THE STORM,
CONSTRUCTION IS UNDER WAY IN UNION BEACH.
HOMES ARE BEING ELEVATED TO COMPLY
WITH NEW BUILDING STANDARDS THAT CHRISTIE RUSHED TO ADOPT.
Christie: I CAN'T WAIT ANOTHER 18 TO 24 MONTHS.
WE'RE GONNA ADOPT THESE NOW AS THE STATE STANDARDS,
AND PEOPLE CAN THEN BEGIN TO MAKE THE ECONOMIC DECISION
REGARDING REBUILDING IMMEDIATELY.
Burlew: GOVERNOR CHRISTIE, HE'S BEEN INSTRUMENTAL.
I THINK HE WANTS THE SHORE TO BE BUILT TODAY COMPLETELY.
HE DOESN'T WANT TO WAIT 10 YEARS.
Mauriello: WHEN YOU GO IN THESE NEIGHBORHOODS NOW,
HOMES ARE BEING ELEVATED ALL OVER THE STATE.
THE PROBLEM IS, THOUGH,
IF THE SEA IS ENCROACHING ON THOSE AREAS,
IT DOESN'T MATTER IF THE HOME IS ELEVATED.
IT CREATES A FALSE SENSE OF SECURITY AMONG THE RESIDENTS
THAT THINGS ARE BETTER
WHEN, OVER THE LONG TERM, THEY'RE REALLY NOT BETTER.
Bittman: MARK MAURIELLO IS A FORMER HEAD
OF NEW JERSEY'S DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION.
HE'S ALSO AN EXPERT IN COASTAL PLANNING,
WITH 30 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE.
AND HE TELLS ME SOMETHING I CAN'T BELIEVE.
GOVERNOR CHRISTIE'S NEW RULES
ARE BASED ONLY ON PAST FLOOD DATA
AND DON'T TAKE INTO ACCOUNT
THAT EXTRA 2 TO 7 FEET OF SEA-LEVEL RISE
PROJECTED BY CLIMATE SCIENTISTS.
YOU CAN BUILD HOUSES BIGGER AND STRONGER,
BUT IF THE HOMES ARE STILL LOCATED
IN VERY VULNERABLE AREAS,
WE SHOULDN'T BE SURPRISED WHEN THEY CONTINUE
TO BE DAMAGED BY SUBSEQUENT EVENTS.
SO WHAT WOULD REBUILDING RIGHT ON THE SHORELINE --
WHAT WOULD REBUILDING SMART LOOK LIKE?
OUR SUGGESTION IS WE INCREMENTALLY PULL BACK.
YOU CAN VOLUNTARILY RELOCATE FOLKS
SO IT CAN BE RESTORED AS A DUNE OR A WETLAND
THAT CAN BE MORE PROTECTIVE.
WE CAN'T SUSTAIN THIS OVER TIME.
IT'S ENVIRONMENTALLY UNSUSTAINABLE
AND FINANCIALLY UNSUSTAINABLE.
PULLING BACK FROM THE SHORE MIGHT SOUND DRASTIC,
BUT I'M ON MY WAY TO A PLACE THAT'S DONE JUST THAT --
A COUNTRY WHERE FLOODING IS A WAY OF LIFE.
Ericksen: WELL, IT'S A DISTINCT HONOR
FOR THE SENATE ENERGY, ENVIRONMENT,
AND TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMITTEE TODAY
TO HAVE THE GOVERNOR OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON,
GOVERNOR INSLEE, HERE.
[ APPLAUSE ]
IN MY MANY YEARS IN THE LEGISLATURE,
I CAN COUNT ON ONE HAND
THE NUMBER OF TIMES THE GOVERNOR HAS COME TO TESTIFY ON A BILL,
AND THAT MIGHT BE THE FIRST TIME THE GOVERNOR CAME
TO TESTIFY ON A BILL AND GOT APPLAUSE, SO...
[ LAUGHTER ] ...WELCOME TO THE COMMITTEE.
IT'S EARLY IN THE SESSION HERE, SO...
Munn: AS THE LEGISLATURE PREPARES
TO DEBATE GOVERNOR INSLEE'S CLIMATE ACTION BILL,
THINGS START OUT PRETTY FRIENDLY.
THE REASON I HAVE PROPOSED THIS BILL AS I HAVE
IS BECAUSE I DO NOT HAVE ALL THE ANSWERS,
EVEN THOUGH I'VE BEEN ELECTED GOVERNOR.
THIS MAY SHOCK YOU. [ LAUGHTER ]
THIS IS AN INVITATION FOR US
TO WORK TOGETHER TO COME UP WITH THOSE ANSWERS.
Munn: BUT THE REPUBLICANS HAVE SOME TOUGH QUESTIONS.
HOW DO WE MOVE FORWARD WHILE NOT LOSING
THE MANUFACTURING JOB BASE THAT WE CURRENTLY HAVE HERE?
HOW CAN YOU ASSURE ME THAT MORE RULES AND REGULATIONS
WON'T CONTINUE TO HURT SMALL BUSINESS IN WASHINGTON?
Man: WASHINGTON STATE ACCOUNTS FOR ABOUT 1/3 OF 1%
OF GLOBAL GREENHOUSE EMISSIONS.
DO YOU HAVE A DIFFERENT NUMBER?
Munn: BUT INSLEE SAYS
THE REAL THREAT TO THE ECONOMY IS IGNORING CLIMATE CHANGE.
Inslee: THE POTENTIAL COST OF CLIMATE CHANGE
HAS BEEN ESTIMATED TO REACH $10 BILLION BY 2020.
THAT'S $10 BILLION.
THESE ARE REAL COSTS TO REAL PEOPLE TO REAL BUSINESSES,
AND IT'S HAPPENING TODAY.
NOW, THIS IS SOMETHING THAT...
Munn: BEHIND THE SCENES, IT'S OBVIOUS HE'S FRUSTRATED.
Man: THIS IS THE BEGINNING OF A CONVERSATION,
WE WANT TO HAVE THIS DIALOGUE,
SO THAT'S THE WAY TO THINK ABOUT THIS.
Inslee: BUT AT SOME POINT, IF SOMEBODY DOES
REALLY WANT TO CHALLENGE THE SCIENCE...
RIGHT. THEN YOU'RE READY.
...THEN I'VE GOT TO SAY, YOU KNOW,
"LET ME TELL YOU WHO YOU'RE ARGUING WITH."
WE'LL GET A PRINTOUT OF THAT RIGHT NOW.
"IT'S NOT ME. IT'S THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES."
KEITH SAID HE HAD IT, SO I THINK THAT -- "IT'S NASA."
Munn: SOME REPUBLICANS MAKE IT CLEAR
THEY DON'T BELIEVE CLIMATE CHANGE IS REAL.
THEY BRING IN THEIR OWN WITNESS TO CHALLENGE THE SCIENCE.
Easterbrook: GLOBAL WARMING ENDED IN 1998.
THAT MAY COME AS A SURPRISE,
BUT I'LL SHOW YOU THE DATA FOR IT.
WHAT ABOUT ALL THE CLAIMS THAT THE TEMPERATURES
ARE WARMER NOW THAN THEY HAVE EVER BEEN?
THESE ARE PATENTLY NOT TRUE.
Munn: DON EASTERBROOK IS A RETIRED GEOLOGY PROFESSOR
FROM WESTERN WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY.
SOON AFTER THIS HEARING, HIS ENTIRE DEPARTMENT
WRITES A LETTER DISAVOWING HIS TESTIMONY.
ALL THE DATA THAT I'VE READ AND I HAVE BEFORE ME
SHOWS THAT, PARTICULARLY IN THE LAST 12 YEARS,
WE'VE SEEN AN INCREASE IN TEMPERATURE,
WE'VE SEEN MORE RECORDS BROKEN.
THIS IS THE ORIGINAL DATA BEFORE THEY MANIPULATED IT.
AND WHAT YOU'RE LOOKING AT IS THE DATA
THAT HAS BEEN TAMPERED WITH BY NOAA AND BY NASA.
IS THIS A CONSPIRACY?
UH, I'M NOT INTO CONSPIRACIES,
SO I HAVE NO COMMENT ON THAT.
[ SIGHS ]
SOON, THE SENATE REPUBLICANS
SETTLE ANY DOUBTS ABOUT WHERE THEY STAND.
THEY PASS AN AMENDMENT
REMOVING ALL MENTIONS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
FROM INSLEE'S CLIMATE-CHANGE BILL.
INSLEE'S BEEN IN OFFICE BARELY TWO MONTHS,
AND HIS CLIMATE-CHANGE AGENDA IS ALREADY FALTERING.
AND REPUBLICANS AREN'T HIS ONLY PROBLEM.
[ TRAIN HORN BLARES ]
I LEARNED THERE'S AN EVEN BIGGER CONTROVERSY BREWING,
ONE THAT'S DIVIDING INSLEE'S OWN PARTY.
Bittman: THE NETHERLANDS
IS ONE OF THE MOST LOW-LYING COUNTRIES IN THE WORLD.
MUCH OF IT IS ACTUALLY BELOW SEA LEVEL.
I CAME HERE TO MEET WITH DR. JEROEN AERTS,
ONE OF THE WORLD'S TOP EXPERTS ON FLOOD RISK,
TO SEE WHAT NEW JERSEY MIGHT BE ABLE TO LEARN
FROM A PLACE WHERE TOO MUCH WATER IS PART OF DAILY LIFE.
WHAT PERCENTAGE OF THE POPULATION OF THE NETHERLANDS
IS REALLY AFFECTED BY WATER?
ONE-THIRD OF THE COUNTRY IS LYING BELOW SEA LEVEL,
AND ABOUT TWO-THIRDS OF THE POPULATION
LIVES IN FLOODPLAINS.
SO, ABOUT TWO-THIRDS OF THE POPULATION
CAN BE POTENTIALLY AFFECTED BY FLOODS.
THE WATER IS COMING FROM THE SEA.
THE WATER IS COMING FROM THE RIVERS.
WE HAVE GROUNDWATER,
AND WE HAVE ALSO PRECIPITATION -- RAIN.
SO, WE HAVE ALL TYPES OF FLOODS OVER HERE.
WE HAD OUR WAKE-UP CALLS. WE HAVE HAD OUR SANDY.
THEIR SANDY CAME IN JANUARY 1953.
THE NORTH SEA FLOOD INUNDATED 10% OF THE COUNTRY'S FARMLAND,
DESTROYING 10,000 BUILDINGS AND KILLING ALMOST 2,000 PEOPLE.
IN THE AFTERMATH OF THIS DISASTER,
THE DUTCH WENT TO WAR WITH WATER.
THEY BUILT THE LARGEST SYSTEM OF DIKES AND LEVEES
IN THE WORLD TO KEEP WATER OUT.
BUT IN THE 1990s, THEY GOT ANOTHER WAKE-UP CALL.
CLIMATE CHANGE WAS CAUSING MORE INTENSE RAINS AND RISING SEAS.
THE RESULT WAS MASSIVE RIVER FLOODING
THAT OVERWHELMED THEIR DEFENSES.
THE DUTCH NEEDED A NEW PLAN.
THEY CALLED IT LIVING WITH THE WATER.
WE THOUGHT, WELL, MAYBE, WE SHOULD GIVE SOME ROOM
BACK TO THE RIVER, ALLOW THE RIVER TO FLOOD,
LIKE IT WAS IN THE PAST
WHEN THERE WERE NO PEOPLE LIVING IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.
HOWEVER, THERE ARE LOCATIONS
WHERE PEOPLE LIVE IN THE FLOODPLAIN.
AND FOR THOSE LOCATIONS,
IT'S REALLY DIFFICULT TO FIND A SOLUTION
THAT BOTH ALLOWS THE RIVER TO FLOOD
BUT ALSO PROTECT THE PEOPLE.
NOW WHEN YOU DRIVE THROUGH THE DUTCH COUNTRYSIDE,
THE LANDSCAPE HAS BEEN TRANSFORMED.
WITH HELP FROM THE GOVERNMENT,
HUNDREDS OF PEOPLE HAVE BEEN RELOCATED.
THE ONES WHO WANTED TO STAY
HAD TO ACCEPT FLOODING AS A FACT OF LIFE.
WHERE WAS YOUR FARM WHEN THE GOVERNMENT CAME?
THIS. LOWER.
THIS PILE OF RUBBLE? YEAH, YEAH.
I'M SORRY. NO.
[ LAUGHTER ]
YEAH, BECAUSE ONLY MAKING THE DIKES BIGGER AND HIGHER,
IT WAS NOT ENOUGH ANYMORE,
SO THEY NEED MORE SPACE TO FLOOD THE WATER.
Bittman: THESE FARMERS BUILT THIS GIANT MOUND OF DIRT
AND MOVED THEIR HOUSE AND BARN ON TOP OF IT.
NOW, DURING A STORM, THE LAND BELOW IS COMPLETELY UNDERWATER.
BY LETTING MORE WATER INTO THE FIELDS,
HOW DOES THIS AFFECT THE AREA AROUND THE FARMS?
TO MASTERMIND THEIR FLOOD STRATEGY,
THE DUTCH CREATED A GROUP CALLED THE DELTA COMMISSION.
IT BRINGS TOGETHER POLITICIANS, ENGINEERS, AND BUSINESS LEADERS,
AND UNLIKE NEW JERSEY,
THEY RECRUITED CLIMATE SCIENTISTS TO HELP.
SOME PEOPLE THINK CLIMATE CHANGE
IS SOMETHING THAT WAS GOING TO HAPPEN IN THE FUTURE,
BUT IT'S ALREADY THERE.
WE ARE THE FIRST ONES
TO SENSE THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE,
BECAUSE WHERE THE OTHERS SAY
THERE ARE QUESTION MARKS OR NOT,
WE ARE SO LOW-LYING, THE IMPACT ON US WILL BE IMMEDIATE,
AND WE CAN'T WAIT,
SO WE WILL HAVE TO DEAL WITH CLIMATE CHANGE.
WE WILL HAVE TO ADAPT.
Bittman: IT SEEMS LIKE NEW JERSEY
NEEDS ITS OWN DELTA COMMISSION.
AND BACK IN THE U.S., I FIND OUT
THAT THEY USED TO HAVE SOMETHING STRIKINGLY SIMILAR.
YEARS BEFORE SANDY, THE STATE FORMED SOMETHING
CALLED THE OFFICE OF CLIMATE ADAPTATION.
SO WHY WASN'T NEW JERSEY BETTER PREPARED?
I FOUND SOMEONE WHO SAYS HE CAN TELL ME.
[ INDISTINCT SHOUTING ]
Man: THIS IS A REGIONAL ISSUE
AND A GLOBAL ISSUE AND A GENERATIONAL ISSUE.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
ARE YOU READY TO POWER PAST COAL?
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Munn: GOVERNOR INSLEE IS ABOUT TO FACE WHAT MIGHT BE
THE BIGGEST CLIMATE-CHANGE DECISION OF HIS ENTIRE TERM,
ONE THAT WILL HAVE GLOBAL IMPLICATIONS.
COAL IS THE SINGLE LARGEST SOURCE
OF GREENHOUSE-GAS EMISSIONS IN THE WORLD.
BUT THESE DAYS,
AMERICANS AREN'T BURNING NEARLY AS MUCH AS THEY USED TO.
THAT'S GOOD NEWS FOR THE CLIMATE,
BUT FOR COAL COMPANIES, IT'S A HUGE PROBLEM.
SO THE INDUSTRY HAS A PLAN --
EXPORT AMERICA'S COAL TO ASIA, WHERE COAL USE IS SKYROCKETING.
THEY JUST NEED A WAY TO GET IT THERE.
AND SO THEY'RE PLANNING TO TRANSPORT IT
OVER A THOUSAND MILES BY TRAIN
TO SPECIALLY BUILT EXPORT TERMINALS ON THE WEST COAST.
AND THE TWO LARGEST ONES WOULD BE IN WASHINGTON STATE.
ALL TOLD, IT WOULD DOUBLE
THE AMOUNT OF COAL THE U.S. EXPORTS EACH YEAR.
THE DEBATE OVER THESE TERMINALS IS ENGULFING THE WHOLE STATE...
WE DON'T NEED THE INCREASED GREENHOUSE GASES
AND OCEAN ACIDIFICATION THESE PROPOSALS WILL BRING.
Munn: ...AND PITTING ENVIRONMENTALISTS AGAINST LABOR GROUPS.
THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO CREATE JOBS.
GOOD, LIVING-WAGE JOBS.
Munn: AT PUBLIC HEARINGS LIKE THIS ONE,
THE TWO SIDES SHOW UP LOOKING LIKE RIVAL SPORTS TEAMS,
IN MATCHING SHIRTS, READY TO SQUARE OFF.
LET'S MOVE FORWARD TOWARD PROSPERITY.
ECONOMIC VALUES DON'T TRUMP ALL THE OTHER VALUES.
Man: TO PUSH FORWARD WOULD BE
TO COMMIT A CRIME AGAINST THE FUTURE.
Woman: THANK YOU.
Munn: ALL THIS POSES A HUGE POLITICAL DILEMMA FOR INSLEE.
ENVIRONMENTALISTS AND ORGANIZED LABOR HAPPEN TO BE
THE TWO GROUPS THAT GOT HIM ELECTED.
THE QUESTION NOW IS, WHICH SIDE IS HE GONNA TAKE?
WHETHER THE EARTH WARMS OR NOT, RIGHT NOW,
WE NEED TO IMPROVE OUR LOCAL ECONOMY, GROW THE JOBS,
PUT PEOPLE BACK TO WORK,
AND I HOPE OUR GOVERNOR AGREES WITH ME
THAT WE SHOULD FOCUS ON WASHINGTON FIRST.
Man: IF YOU LOOK AT WHATCOM COUNTY,
15% OF OUR POPULATION
IS LIVING BELOW THE FEDERAL POVERTY LINE.
Man #2: WE NEED JOBS IN WHATCOM COUNTY.
WE NEED GOOD INDUSTRIAL JOBS.
Munn: THE FIRST BATTLE IN THIS WAR OVER COAL
IS HAPPENING HERE IN WHATCOM COUNTY,
WHERE THEY'RE PLANNING TO BUILD ONE OF THE TERMINALS.
[ DOG BARKING ]
I'M OUT HERE SUPPORTING FOUR CANDIDATES
WHO ARE RUNNING FOR THE WHATCOM COUNTY COUNCIL RACE.
A RACE FOR LOCAL COUNTY COUNCIL
MAY NOT SOUND TERRIBLY EXCITING,
BUT WHEN IT COMES TO CLIMATE CHANGE,
THIS MIGHT JUST BE THE MOST IMPORTANT ELECTION OF THE YEAR.
I'M ON MY WAY TO MEET WITH BRENDON CECHOVIC
FROM THE GROUP WASHINGTON CONSERVATION VOTERS.
HIS SMALL STAFF IS WORKING NONSTOP
TO BLOCK THE COAL TERMINALS.
Cechovic: THE WHOLE POINT OF THIS IS SHOWING THE COUNTRY,
SHOWING THE COAL COMPANIES, SHOWING GOVERNOR INSLEE
THAT THERE'S A POLITICAL FORCE BEHIND THIS ANTI-COAL EFFORT.
WE'RE READY TO COME IN AND WIN ELECTIONS ON CLIMATE.
THIS IS CRAZY, BUT THE FIRST DECISION
OF WHETHER OR NOT WE DO THESE EXPORT PROPOSALS OR NOT
COMES DOWN TO THE COUNTY COUNCIL IN WHATCOM COUNTY.
THIS IS SMALL-TOWN POLITICS, LOCAL STUFF.
NOW, IF WHATCOM COUNTY VOTES TO NOT ALLOW THESE PERMITS,
THAT'S THE END OF THE COAL TERMINALS.
IF WE WIN THESE ELECTIONS IN NOVEMBER,
WHATCOM COUNTY VOTES NO ON THE PROPOSAL,
THAT'S THE END OF COAL EXPORT THROUGH CHERRY POINT.
IT'S GAME OVER.
THERE ARE SOME PEOPLE WHO WORKED ON PRESIDENT OBAMA'S CAMPAIGN...
RIGHT. ...THAT ARE COMING OUT HERE TO THIS LITTLE ELECTION.
RIGHT, WE'VE ACTUALLY HIRED THE PRESIDENT'S DATA TEAM...
WOW. ...THE PEOPLE WHO DO HIS TARGETING,
AND HELP US IDENTIFY WHO TO TALK TO,
WHO NOT TO TALK TO, WHEN TO TALK TO THEM.
I THINK WE'VE BUILT ONE OF THE MOST IMPRESSIVE CAMPAIGN TEAMS
I'VE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE IN POLITICS.
ALL FOR THIS LITTLE ELECTION.
ALL FOR THIS LITTLE ELECTION.
[ INDISTINCT CONVERSATION ]
[ BELL DINGING ]
Krohn: IF THE UNITED STATES
WERE TO HALT ALL COAL EXPORTS TODAY,
IT'S NOT GOING TO STOP THE NATIONS THAT ARE CONSUMING COAL
TO BURN ONE LUMP OF IT.
ALL WE'RE GOING TO DO
IS EXPORT THOSE JOBS TO OTHER PLACES.
HERB KROHN IS HEAD OF THE LOCAL RAILROAD WORKERS' UNION.
HE'S ONE OF THE MOST POWERFUL LEADERS
ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE COAL ISSUE.
YOU CAN COME OUT AND PROTEST, AND YOU CAN FEEL
LIKE YOU'RE DOING SOMETHING FOR THE WORLD.
RIGHT. BUT YOU'RE NOT ACCOMPLISHING ANYTHING
EXCEPT COSTING AMERICAN JOBS.
YOU'RE SAYING THERE IS NO FREE LUNCH,
BUT YOUR BIG CONCERN IS THAT THERE ARE MEN
THAT YOU REPRESENT WHO HAVE NO LUNCH,
AND THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE TRYING TO FOCUS ON.
THERE ARE A LOT OF FAMILIES WITH NO DINNERS. RIGHT.
AND THERE ARE A LOT OF UNEMPLOYED CONSTRUCTION WORKERS.
JOBS CREATE JOBS.
THE BUILDING OF THESE FACILITIES
IS GOING TO EMPLOY THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE
FOR SEVERAL YEARS.
THE RAILROAD JOBS ARE GONNA STRETCH ALL THE WAY BACK
TO THE ORIGINATING POINT OF THE TRAINS.
DID YOU VOTE FOR GOVERNOR INSLEE?
YES. OUR UNION SUPPORTED GOVERNOR INSLEE QUITE WELL.
YEAH, WE TALKED TO HIM ABOUT THESE FACILITIES.
WHAT HAS HE SAID ABOUT IT?
UH, HE SAID THEY HAVE TO BE STUDIED.
I RESPECT GOVERNOR INSLEE, AND, YEAH, WE HOPE
THAT HE'LL KEEP HIS PLEDGE TO KEEP AN OPEN MIND.
MM-HMM.
BUT SO FAR, INSLEE'S AVOIDED
GIVING A STRAIGHT ANSWER ABOUT THE TERMINALS.
Inslee: WE'RE STILL COMING OUT OF THIS RECESSION.
JOB CREATION IS EXTREMELY IMPORTANT TO ME.
BUT I WANT TO REITERATE -- WE HAVE NOT MADE ANY DECISIONS.
THAT'LL BE AN ONGOING PROCESS FOR YEARS TO COME.
Munn: I JUST WONDER HOW LONG
HE'LL BE ABLE TO STAY ON THE SIDELINES.
MEANWHILE, HIS CLIMATE ACTION BILL IS NEARING A VOTE.
AND THE GOVERNOR FACES A TOUGH DECISION --
IS THE BILL WORTH PASSING IF THE WORDS "CLIMATE CHANGE"
AREN'T EVEN IN IT?
THE QUESTION NOW BEFORE US
IS SORT OF A COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS.
DO WE GO WITH THIS BILL THAT IS LESS THAN PERFECT,
OR DO WE CONTINUE TO WORK AND FIGHT OVER THE LANGUAGE?
IF WE WANTED TO GET IT OUT OF THE SENATE,
WE BASICALLY NEEDED TO AVOID THE FIGHT.
Munn: AND IN THE END, THAT'S WHAT INSLEE DOES.
THE BILL GOES TO A VOTE WITHOUT ANY MENTION OF CLIMATE CHANGE,
BUT IN EXCHANGE, THE REPUBLICANS AGREE
TO JOIN INSLEE'S WORKGROUP
TO REDUCE GREENHOUSE-GAS EMISSIONS.
Man: 37 YEAS, 12 NAYS.
SENATE BILL 5802 IS DECLARED PASSED.
Inslee: AND MANY OF THEM THOUGHT THE BILL WOULD DIE
BECAUSE WE'D INSIST ON THE WORD "CLIMATE CHANGE."
WE WENT AHEAD AND JUST PASSED IT ANYWAY.
THIS IS THE START OF SOMETHING BIG HERE.
[ APPLAUSE ]
IT SERVES A PURPOSE,
WHICH IS ASKING REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS
TO COME TO THE TABLE
AND ACCEPT MORAL RESPONSIBILITY FOR FINDING A SOLUTION.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Munn: INSLEE CLAIMS IT AS A VICTORY,
BUT ONCE THE WORKGROUP STARTS MEETING,
I WONDER IF THESE TWO SIDES
WILL ACTUALLY BE ABLE TO AGREE ON ANYTHING.
Bittman: I'M MEETING WITH BILL WOLFE.
OVER MORE THAN TWO DECADES, BILL WORKED INSIDE
THE NEW JERSEY DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION,
STUDYING THREATS TO THE COAST.
HE SAYS THAT, LONG BEFORE SUPERSTORM SANDY,
THERE WERE WARNINGS.
PROFESSIONAL PLANNERS INSIDE D.E.P. FOR YEARS
HAD BEEN TALKING ABOUT COASTAL VULNERABILITY
TO FLOODS AND STORMS AND SEA-LEVEL RISE.
AND THEY WERE BASICALLY REPORTS THAT SAT ON A SHELF
EVERY 2 YEARS FOR DECA-- FOR 15-YEAR PERIODS.
IT'S ABOUT THE MID '90s.
THIS IS THE REACTION TO THEM ACKNOWLEDGING --
THEM ACKNOWLEDGING THAT THE SCIENCE OF CLIMATE CHANGE
PROJECTED SEA-LEVEL RISE, STORM SURGE,
AND INCREASING STORM INTENSITY
THAT, WHEN YOU MAPPED THOSE RISKS ALONG THE SHORE,
THAT WE WERE HIGHLY VULNERABLE.
WERE THOSE WARNINGS BECOMING SHRILLER,
MORE HARSH, MORE WORRISOME,
THAN THEY WERE 20, 30, 40 YEARS AGO?
ABSOLUTELY, AND IT WAS ALMOST AS IF THE PLANNERS
WERE RUNNING AROUND WITH THEIR HAIR ON FIRE.
FOR YEARS, THESE WARNINGS WERE IGNORED,
BUT IN 2005, HURRICANE KATRINA DEVASTATED NEW ORLEANS
AND CHANGED EVERYTHING.
NEW JERSEY LEADERS REALIZED
THEIR COAST COULD BE VULNERABLE TO A SIMILAR STORM,
AND SO GOVERNOR CHRISTIE'S PREDECESSOR, JON CORZINE,
CREATED AN OFFICE OF CLIMATE ADAPTATION
TO DEAL WITH THIS PROBLEM.
IN THE WAKE OF KATRINA,
THERE WAS A WHOLE BURST OF ACTIVITY
DEALING WITH EMISSIONS REDUCTIONS,
COASTAL ADAPTATION,
AND VULNERABILITY ASSESSMENTS FOR THE SHORE.
PROMISE OF ACTUAL... ACTIONS.
...YEAH, ACTIONS, AND THEN...
AND THEN THE CHRISTIE ADMINISTRATION CAME ON BOARD
AND BASICALLY SYSTEMATICALLY --
SYSTEMATICALLY, ACROSS THE BOARD, DISMANTLED THAT.
HIS FIRST HOUR IN OFFICE, HE ISSUED FOUR EXECUTIVE ORDERS,
AND THOSE FOUR ORDERS TARGETED
THE DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION.
AND SO COASTAL-MANAGEMENT POLICIES
AND VULNERABILITY ASSESSMENT AND ADAPTATION POLICIES,
THAT WAS ALL NIXED.
NO ONE KNOWS WHAT WOULD HAVE HAPPENED
IF CHRISTIE HADN'T KILLED THESE PROGRAMS,
BUT WITHOUT THEM,
NEW JERSEY WAS CAUGHT OFF GUARD BY SUPERSTORM SANDY.
AS A RESULT, BILL WOLFE SAYS,
THE REBUILDING PLAN HAD TO BE IMPROVISED,
AND IT'S FATALLY FLAWED.
WHERE WE'RE REBUILDING,
WE ARE VIRTUALLY GUARANTEEING TO GO THROUGH ANOTHER ROUND
OF EXACTLY WHAT WE WENT THROUGH.
BUT IT DIDN'T HAVE TO BE THIS WAY.
Bloomberg: WE CAN RISE BACK FROM THE ASHES,
AND WE CAN BE SMARTER AND STRONGER THAN EVER.
WE CAN MODERNIZE.
Bittman: JUST ACROSS THE HUDSON RIVER FROM NEW JERSEY,
NEW YORK CITY HAS BEEN MAKING PLANS
FOR A NETHERLANDS-STYLE SMART ADAPTATION SINCE 2007.
EARLIER THIS WEEK, MAYOR BLOOMBERG UNVEILED
A $20 BILLION PLAN TO PROTECT...
Man: THE MAYOR LAID OUT A 439-PAGE PLAN TO PROTECT THE CITY.
Bittman: THE CITY EVEN HIRED DUTCH EXPERTS TO HELP.
Man #2: AMONG THE BIGGER PROJECTS ARE REMOVABLE GATES
ALONG LOWER MANHATTAN SHORELINES,
STORM-SURGE BARRIERS IN NEWTOWN CREEK,
THE GOWANUS CANAL, AND ELSEWHERE,
EVEN A NEW NEIGHBORHOOD NEAR THE SOUTH STREET SEAPORT
THAT WOULD ABSORB RISING SEA LEVELS.
THIS IS URGENT WORK, AND IT MUST BEGIN NOW.
Bittman: SO WHY ISN'T CHRIS CHRISTIE
TAKING ANY OF THIS INTO ACCOUNT IN HIS STATE?
KARA, WE'RE CALLING YOU AGAIN.
WOMAN: Governor's press office.
CAN I HAVE KARA WALKER'S OFFICE, PLEASE?
This is Kara. HEY, THIS IS MARK BITTMAN.
I'M JUST FOLLOWING UP, SEEING IF WE CAN GET
THAT INTERVIEW WE'RE TRYING TO GET WITH GOVERNOR CHRISTIE.
Okay. I'll have to follow up with you.
At the moment, I don't have an answer for you just yet,
but I do have your request on hand,
and hopefully we can set a date tomorrow.
THAT WOULD BE GREAT.
YOU WANT ME TO CALL YOU, OR YOU GONNA CALL ME?
Um...I think I've got
all your contact information in the e-mail,
so, you know, I can definitely...
Inslee: OKAY, WE'RE HERE
FOR THE CLIMATE LEGISLATIVE AND EXECUTIVE WORKGROUP.
AS PART OF OUR LEAN MANAGEMENT, WE'VE SOLD THE GAVEL,
SO WE DON'T HAVE A GAVEL TO START WITH,
SO WE'LL JUST START WITH GOOD INTENTIONS.
Munn: AS GOVERNOR INSLEE'S BIPARTISAN WORKGROUP
BEGINS TO MEET, THE CRACKS ARE ALREADY SHOWING
BETWEEN REPUBLICANS CONCERNED
ABOUT THE ECONOMIC IMPACT OF REGULATIONS...
I WANT TO BE AN INNOVATIVE STATE,
BUT I AM NOT GONNA DO IT ON THE BACKS OF WASHINGTON FAMILIES.
Munn: ...AND DEMOCRATS CONCERNED
ABOUT THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ITSELF.
LET'S CONSIDER THE IMPACTS
OF OCEAN ACIDIFICATION IN WASHINGTON STATE
AND THE THOUSANDS OF JOBS THAT DIRECTLY DEPEND UPON IT.
Munn: MEANWHILE, THE FIGHT OVER COAL IN WHATCOM COUNTY
IS CREATING DIVISIONS EVEN AMONG FELLOW DEMOCRATS.
I WANT TO KNOW HOW GOVERNOR INSLEE
IS GONNA HANDLE ALL THIS.
Munn: THIS IS SO BEAUTIFUL HERE.
Inslee: YEAH.
I'VE ACTUALLY NEVER BEEN INSIDE OF A STATE CAPITOL BEFORE.
I WANTED TO CHIP OFF SOME MARBLE TO TAKE HOME AS A SOUVENIR.
WE FROWN ON THAT,
BUT I CAN GET YOU SOME MARBLE FROM SOMEWHERE.
OH, REALLY? JUST NOT HERE.
YOU FROWN ON THAT?
I'LL GET YOU SOME TENINO SANDSTONE.
WHEN WE LAST SAT DOWN,
YOU HAD JUST PASSED A CLIMATE BILL.
MM-HMM.
HOW HAS THAT BEEN WORKING SO FAR?
HOW HAPPY ARE YOU WITH THAT?
SO, WE'VE HAD OUR FIRST SERIES OF MEETINGS,
BUT NOW WE GOT TO ESTABLISH THE PLAN TO MEET THE TARGETS,
AND WE'VE SET THIS UP TO TRY TO DO THIS
ON A BIPARTISAN BASIS, DEMOCRATS AND REPUBLICANS.
ARE YOU STILL AS FRUSTRATED WITH REPUBLICANS
AS YOU WERE BEFORE,
OR DO YOU FEEL THAT THERE HAS BEEN SOME MOVEMENT?
WELL, THE JURY IS OUT,
SO WE'LL SEE IN THE NEXT FEW MONTHS WHETHER THEY ACCEPT.
WE'VE PUT OUR HAND OUT
TO TRY TO ASK THEM TO HELP US DESIGN A SOLUTION,
AND I HOPE THEY DO.
THERE'S A BIG ISSUE GOING ON RIGHT NOW
WITH THE COAL-EXPORT TERMINALS. MM-HMM, YOU BET.
WHEN YOU RAN FOR GOVERNOR,
YOU HAD THE SUPPORT OF MOST OF THE LABOR UNIONS,
AND SO THAT'S PROBABLY GOT TO BE A TRICKY PLACE FOR YOU TO BE IN
BECAUSE YOU WANT TO GET THE PEOPLE OF WASHINGTON JOBS,
AND YOU ALSO CARE ABOUT THE ENVIRONMENT.
SO DO YOU TAKE THAT INTO YOUR DECISION-MAKING PROCESS
WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT HOW MANY JOBS
IT COULD GIVE THE PEOPLE OF WHATCOM COUNTY?
SURE, I DO, AND I'M VERY COMFORTABLE
WITH MY ANALYSIS OF THIS
BECAUSE THERE ARE SOME PLUSES
FROM THE JOB PERSPECTIVE FOR A COAL PORT,
BUT THERE'S ALSO SOME MINUSES.
IN SOLAR, IN WIND,
IN CARBON-FIBER FOR PLANES AND CARS,
IN ENERGY EFFICIENCY --
THIS IS WHERE OUR FUTURE IS, AND WE'RE GONNA SEIZE IT.
YOU HAVEN'T SAID OUT LOUD YET, "I'M AGAINST IT."
WELL, I AM CONFIDENT THE VOTERS OF WHATCOM COUNTY
ARE GONNA KNOW THE RAMIFICATIONS OF THIS.
THIS IS GONNA BE A VERY HOTLY CONTESTED ISSUE.
PEOPLE ARE GONNA KNOW
THE CARBON-DIOXIDE POLLUTION THAT COMES FROM THIS.
IT DOESN'T MATTER WHERE COAL IS BURNED.
THE CARBON-DIOXIDE THAT COMES FROM THE COAL
THAT'S SHIPPED OUT OF WASHINGTON,
BURNED IN CHINA, ENDS UP IN PUGET SOUND
AND ENDS UP CHANGING THE CLIMATE.
AND WHILE INSLEE WON'T TELL ME FLAT-OUT
THAT HE'S AGAINST THE TERMINALS,
I LEARN HE'S DOING SOMETHING BIG,
SOMETHING THAT MAKES HIS POINT OF VIEW CRYSTAL-CLEAR.
HE'S ORDERING WHAT MIGHT BE
THE MOST EXTENSIVE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW EVER CONDUCTED,
NOT JUST IN HIS STATE, BUT ANYWHERE IN THE COUNTRY.
BEFORE THEY CAN GET A BUILDING PERMIT,
THE COAL TERMINALS WILL BE RIGOROUSLY EVALUATED,
NOT JUST FOR THEIR IMPACT ON LOCAL AIR AND WATER QUALITY...
BUT ALSO FOR ALL THE CARBON EMISSIONS
FROM ALL THE COAL THEY PLAN TO SHIP,
WHETHER IT GETS BURNED IN WASHINGTON STATE, CHINA,
OR ANYWHERE ELSE ON THE PLANET.
HEY, THIS IS DICK DONAHUE WITH YOU
THIS SATURDAY MORNING HERE ON KGMI.
THIS MOVE BY INSLEE DOESN'T SIT WELL WITH CRAIG COLE,
A SPOKESMAN FOR THE TERMINAL COMPANY.
THE STATE DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY ANNOUNCED
THAT THEY WANTED A VERY, VERY BROAD SCOPE OF REVIEW
THAT WOULD INCLUDE SUCH THINGS
AS THE IMPACT ON CLIMATE CHANGE
OF PRODUCTS THAT ARE USED IN OTHER COUNTRIES.
YOU KNOW, I DON'T WANT TO BE FACETIOUS ABOUT THIS,
BUT DOES THAT MEAN, IF WE SHIP WHEAT TO CHINA,
THAT WE'VE GOT TO MEASURE THE IMPACT WHEN BREAD IS BAKED?
Woman: ALL I EVER READ IN THE NEWSPAPER, ONLINE, TV
IS, YOU KNOW, WE WANT TO BRING MANUFACTURING AND PRODUCTION
BACK TO THE UNITED STATES, BUT IT SEEMS TO ME
THAT WE ARE DOING EVERYTHING IN OUR POWER TO CHASE IT AWAY.
WE DON'T NEED PEOPLE FROM CALIFORNIA OR SEATTLE
TO TELL US HOW WE OUGHT TO VOTE
IN OUR LOCAL COUNTY COUNCIL RACES.
AS ALL OF YOU KNOW, THIS IS A HUGE RACE.
IT'S NOT ONLY A PRIORITY FOR WHATCOM COUNTY RESIDENTS,
IT'S A PRIORITY FOR ALL OF WASHINGTON STATE,
THE NATION, AND THE WORLD.
THE COAL COMPANIES JUST DUMPED
AN ADDITIONAL $160,000 INTO THEIR PAC.
BUT THERE'S NO AMOUNT OF MONEY
THAT REPLACES WHAT YOU GUYS ARE GONNA DO TODAY.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Munn: AS THE ELECTION IN WHATCOM COUNTY
GETS DOWN TO THE WIRE,
BOTH SIDES ARE MAKING A LAST-DITCH EFFORT
TO WIN PEOPLE OVER.
I'M A VOLUNTEER WITH THE WHATCOM WINS CAMPAIGN
FOR COUNTY COUNCIL.
NOW, THIS NOVEMBER, WE HAVE A REALLY IMPORTANT ELECTION
FOR WHATCOM COUNTY.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH. BYE.
Woman: RUD BROWNE, BARRY BUCHANAN,
KEN MANN, AND CARL WEIMER.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
ALL RIGHT, LET'S GO!
ALL RIGHT. GUYS, COUNT ME DOWN FROM 5, OKAY?
READY? 5...
All: 4, 3, 2, 1!
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Bittman: IT'S MEMORIAL DAY WEEKEND,
AND CHRIS CHRISTIE HAS KEPT HIS PROMISE --
THE SHORE IS OPEN FOR BUSINESS.
CHRISTIE EVEN SETS A NEW GUINNESS WORLD RECORD
FOR LONGEST RIBBON EVER CUT.
HE SURE KNOWS HOW TO MILK THE MEDIA ATTENTION.
BUT HE WON'T TALK TO ME.
WE'RE ON HOLD, NEEDLESS TO SAY.
TWO MINUTES.
THREE.
ALMOST FOUR.
This is Kara. How can I help you?
HEY, THIS IS MARK BITTMAN. WE SPOKE A MONTH OR TWO AGO.
YOU ACTUALLY WERE GONNA GET BACK TO ME WITH AN ANSWER
ABOUT WHETHER WE COULD GET AN INTERVIEW WITH THE GOVERNOR
ABOUT SANDY AND ITS EFFECTS ON THE SHORELINE.
WALKER: Okay. Sure, Mark.
Um, let me go ahead and circle back with our office here,
and I'll touch base with you
hopefully by the end of the week.
BUT IN UNION BEACH, NOT EVERYONE IS SATISFIED
TO SIMPLY GO ON WITH LIFE
WITHOUT GETTING SOME CLEAR ANSWERS
ON WHY THE STORM WAS SO DEVASTATING
AND WHAT THE FUTURE MIGHT BRING.
CLIMATE SCIENTIST MICHAEL OPPENHEIMER
DELIVERS SOME UNWELCOME NEWS.
Oppenheimer: WE'RE UNLUCKY.
IN THIS AREA OF THE WORLD,
THE SEA IS PROJECTED
TO RISE FASTER THAN THE GLOBAL AVERAGE.
IF IT'S 4 FEET HIGHER,
WHICH IS WHAT WE THINK WILL HAPPEN TO THIS AREA
IF SEA-LEVEL RISE IS NOT SLOWED DOWN
BY RATHER STARK EMISSIONS CUTS,
THEN THE 100-YEAR STORM HAPPENS EVERY 5 YEARS.
[ AUDIENCE MURMURING ]
Man: IT IS EYE-OPENING,
AND I DO RESPECT IT, THE SCIENCE BEHIND IT.
YOU KNOW, IT'S FACT.
YOU KNOW, IT'S NOT -- IT'S NOT "THE SKY IS FALLING," FOR SURE.
IT'S REALITY.
AND I AM SO SORRY MY HUSBAND DIDN'T COME,
'CAUSE I WOULD LIKE HIM TO HEAR WHAT THE DOCTOR SAID.
VERY FRIGHTENING. WE DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO.
WE HAVE TO ADAPT TO THE CONDITIONS
THAT WE KNOW WE'RE FACING NOW AND WILL FACE IN OUR LIFETIMES,
IN OUR KIDS' LIFETIMES.
I'M NOT REBUILDING. I DIDN'T GET THE FUNDS TO DO IT.
AFTER LISTENING TO YOU, I'M KIND OF GLAD I'M NOT REBUILDING.
IT SCARES ME A LITTLE BIT MORE.
I FEEL LIKE THE STATE PUT FUNNEL CAKES BEFORE FAMILIES,
AND THAT'S A SHAME. Woman: YEAH.
Oppenheimer: I HOPE YOU TAKE THIS NOT AS A PARTISAN REMARK,
BUT IT'S TRUE ALSO OF MY STATE.
NEW YORK HAS A GOVERNOR THAT WANTS TO BE PRESIDENT.
NEW JERSEY HAS A GOVERNOR THAT WANTS TO BE PRESIDENT.
THESE PEOPLE WILL BE ASKED
WHAT THEY DID TO SAVE PEOPLE AFTER SANDY.
THIS IS ONE WAY YOU CAN BE EFFECTIVE.
YOUR VOICE WILL BE HEARD.
IT MAY NOT DO YOU A DAMN BIT OF GOOD AFTER THE FACT,
BUT THE KNOWLEDGE THAT YOU'LL BE THERE,
CALLING THESE PEOPLE TO ACCOUNT, THEY KNOW THAT.
GOVERNOR CHRISTIE KNOWS THAT. MY GOVERNOR, CUOMO, KNOWS THAT.
BOTH OF THEM ARE TRYING TO STAKE CLAIMS
FOR HAVING HANDLED THIS SITUATION WELL.
YOU'RE THE TEST AS TO WHETHER THEY DID,
AND YOU WILL BE THE WITNESSES. [ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Christie: WELL, WELL, WELL. HOW ABOUT THIS, NEW JERSEY?
Bittman: ON NOVEMBER 6, 2013,
JUST OVER A YEAR AFTER THE STORM,
CHRIS CHRISTIE WINS RE-ELECTION IN A LANDSLIDE.
TONIGHT I STAND HERE AS YOUR GOVERNOR,
AND I AM SO PROUD TO BE YOUR GOVERNOR.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
IT'S A SACRED TRUST THAT WAS THRUST UPON ME AND YOU
ON OCTOBER 29th OF LAST YEAR.
AND ON THE BATTLEFIELD THAT SANDY TURNED THIS STATE INTO,
NEW JERSEYANS WILL NEVER LEAVE ANY NEW JERSEYAN BEHIND.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
Munn: AS THE VOTES FOR THE WHATCOM COUNTY ELECTIONS
START COMING IN...
Woman: BUCHANAN'S UP. Man: UP, YEAH.
KEN MANN'S UP. Woman #2: OH, MY GOD, KEN MANN'S --
CARL WEIMER'S UP.
...IT'S CLEAR THE ENVIRONMENTALISTS
ARE HEADED FOR A BIG WIN.
OH, MY GOD! OH!
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ] Man: MORE, MORE, MORE!
Munn: THE ELECTION RESULTS VIRTUALLY GUARANTEE
THAT A COAL TERMINAL WON'T BE BUILT IN WHATCOM COUNTY.
IT'S A REFRESHING VICTORY
IN WHAT'S OTHERWISE BEEN A TOUGH FIRST YEAR
AS GOVERNOR FOR JAY INSLEE.
Inslee: THE PURPOSE OF THE WORKGROUP
IS TO RECOMMEND A STATE PROGRAM OF ACTIONS AND POLICIES
TO REDUCE GREENHOUSE-GAS EMISSIONS.
Munn: AS THE WORKGROUP CREATED
BY INSLEE'S CLIMATE ACTION BILL COMES TO AN END,
THE REPUBLICANS DON'T EVEN SEEM TO THINK
WASHINGTON STATE SHOULD MEET ITS EMISSIONS-REDUCTION GOALS.
I'VE HEARD TWO MEMBERS OF THESE COMMITTEES SAY
IT'S REALLY NOT THAT IMPORTANT TO MEET THOSE TARGETS,
AND I THINK IT'S GOING TO BE DIFFICULT --
Short: NO, NO, NO. EXCUSE ME.
NO, NO, NO. JUST EXCUSE ME.
NO, NO, YOU STARTED THIS FIGHT.
THOSE NUMBERS WERE PULLED OUT OF THE SKY.
THOSE NUMBERS WERE JUST GOALS TO WORK TOWARD.
WE ARE SUPPOSED TO MEET THESE GOALS.
DOES NOT EVERYBODY AGREE WITH THAT?
I MEAN, SERIOUSLY?
Ericksen: WHAT'S HAPPENING HERE TODAY IS NOT BEING HELPFUL,
AND I WOULD APPRECIATE IT
IF OTHER MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE DID NOT TRY TO SAY
THAT I AM FOR OR AGAINST OR FAVOR NO ACTION.
ANYWAY, I ASKED A QUESTION.
I DIDN'T RECEIVE AN ANSWER, SO WE'LL MOVE ON.
I DON'T FEEL LIKE I HAVE TO ANSWER YOUR QUESTION.
LET ME PUT A MOTION -- [ CLEARS THROAT ]
Munn: IT ENDS WITHOUT THE TWO SIDES
COMING TO AN AGREEMENT ON ANYTHING.
BUT INSTEAD OF BACKING OFF ON THE ISSUE,
INSLEE DECIDES TO CIRCUMVENT THE REPUBLICANS
AND DO WHATEVER HE CAN TO REDUCE EMISSIONS
USING HIS EXECUTIVE POWER AS GOVERNOR.
OKAY, GANG.
Munn: AND HE SETS HIS SIGHTS ON AN EVEN BIGGER GOAL.
Man: OREGON AND CALIFORNIA AND WASHINGTON AND BRITISH COLUMBIA
HAVE GATHERED IN SAN FRANCISCO TO SIGN AN HISTORIC DOCUMENT.
Munn: HE JOINS FORCES WITH OTHER GOVERNORS
AND PLEDGES TO REDUCE EMISSIONS ALONG THE ENTIRE WEST COAST.
Inslee: WE ARE THE FIRST GENERATION
TO FEEL THE STING OF CLIMATE CHANGE,
AND WE ARE THE LAST GENERATION THAT CAN DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT.
SO TODAY WE'RE PLEDGING OUR EXECUTIVE COMMITMENT,
OUR EXECUTIVE POLICIES, AND OUR ENERGIES
TO DEFEAT CLIMATE CHANGE.
[ CHEERS AND APPLAUSE ]
OH! YES!
WE ARE READY, AREN'T WE?
HOW ABOUT THIS ONE? OKAY, LET'S TRY THAT ONE.
OH, THERE HE IS. THERE'S A LITTLE GUY GOING.
HE'S MAKING A GETAWAY.
JUST SEEING THAT LOOK ON HIS FACE,
HE JUST LIGHTS UP.
OKAY, LET'S PUT HIM BACK.
AND I HAVE THE SAME EXPERIENCE,
THE SAME SENSE OF JOY OF JUST SEEING THAT LIFE-FORM.
OKAY, BUDDY. THERE YOU GO. NOW HE'S HOME.
AND I REALLY DO WANT MY GRANDSON'S GRANDSON
TO HAVE THAT SAME EXPERIENCE.
THERE YOU GO.
[ LAUGHS ]
THIS VERY MUCH IS TO ME A LEGACY ISSUE.
THAT'S HOW I THINK OF IT,
AND THAT'S WHY WE'RE GONNA WIN THIS BATTLE.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.