Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
When I lied on the application
I just thought
I was doing what was
in the best interests
of my daughters.
I was like
the big man on campus.
It kind of got a little
easier with each one
that I did after that,
to the point where
it started to feel
a little bit comfortable
and there was nothing
wrong with doing it.
I knew it was wrong.
I didn't know
how illegal it was.
I figured it was illegal.
I just didn't think
I was gonna get caught.
When you have that mindset
or when you think
that everybody else
is doing it,
it makes it lot easier
to consider what
you've done as legitimate.
I'm pretty sure
I convinced myself
that I wasn't harming
anything or anyone.
A white lie now became
a huge black lie.
You know, "She's such a liar."
I wasn't the slut,
I wasn't the partier,
I wasn't the bad girl,
I wasn't the druggy.
I was a liar.
At a certain point,
the monster's so big
that it doesn't
need you anymore
and you can't control it
and you just hope
that it doesn't eat you.
I even asked my lawyer,
I mean, "I'm certainly
not gonna go
to jail for this?"
(CHUCKLES) I mean,
"What do they do
with guys like me?
"They don't send me to jail.
"Can I pick a paper
on the road?
I mean, what am I gonna do?"
And he says,
"No. They send guys
like you to jail."
While I wished
I didn't have to
go through that
I understand now,
"Oh, okay,
I'm not the only one."
You know?
This is a deeply
human experience.
(BIRDS CHIRPING)
(INDISTINCT CHATTER)
My name is Dan Ariely
and I'm interested
in human behavior.
I'm interested in rationality
and irrationality.
I'm interested
in the cases in which
we make good decisions,
and the cases
in which we make
bad decisions.
Together with
colleagues and students,
we run hundreds of experiments
to try and understand
human behavior.
And in the last few years,
we've been focusing
on dishonesty.
I find myself,
especially here at school,
um, lying a lot
about, I guess
not really lying,
but, um, I guess...
I don't know.
Oh. Sometimes I, like,
put on fake accents.
I've convinced several people
that I'm from Russia.
Well, I guess I've lied
to my parents before.
I had a girlfriend
in high school.
It's hard to find time
with your girlfriend.
So, I've done
that whole thing.
I think we all have,
a few times.
DAN ARIELY:
My research falls within
the field called
behavioral economics.
And behavioral
economics challenges
many of the assumptions
of standard economics.
In standard economics,
we assume that people are
perfect decision makers.
That we can compare
all the options,
that we don't have
any limitations
of cognitive capacity.
Behavioral economics
doesn't make any assumptions.
Instead, what we do is,
we put people in
different situations
and we just see
how they behave.
And what we see happening
in those experiments is that,
often, people
don't think long-term.
People are
myopic and vindictive.
We find that people
are not able to consider
all the options
and we also find that
they don't always
behave in a perfectly
rational way.
I first became interested
in irrationality
as a result of
a tragic accident.
When I was a teenager,
I participated in the
Youth Movement in Israel.
And we were preparing
for a celebration
and we had these
magnesium flares
that were supposed
to light up the arena.
But instead,
one of them
exploded next to me.
And, as a consequence,
I was burnt on over
70% of my body
and I spent
the next three years
in hospital.
The worst part of my day
was the process of
removing my bandages.
The nurses believed
that the right
approach would be
to rip the bandages off,
one after the other
as quickly as possible
to get it over with.
And I, as somebody
who suffered this
excruciating pain,
wanted them to
do things slower.
Take more time.
Give me a break
from time to time.
But, of course,
they ended up doing
what they thought is
the right thing to do.
And the longer I stayed
in hospital, the more
frustrated I became.
And the more examples
of irrationalities
I would see all around me.
The study of irrationality
became my profession, my hobby
and the focus of my life.
When I left the hospital,
I started studying
at the university.
I didn't have much
money for research.
So I went to
a hardware store
and I bought
a carpenters' vise.
And I set it up in the lab
and I asked people to come
and put two fingers
in this vise.
(LAUGHTER)
And I would crunch
people's fingers
just a little bit
for different durations
and intensity
and patterns over time
and I would check
their preferences.
"How painful was this?"
"Which pattern would
you prefer?" and so on.
I learned that
the nurses were wrong
in systematic and
predictable ways.
They were focusing on
shortening the duration
when, in fact,
they should have tried
to minimize the intensity.
And from that point on,
I started looking
at all kinds of ways
to think about
irrational behavior.
How we think about money
and health and savings,
and how we procrastinate,
and all kinds of things.
And among one of those
was the question
of dishonesty.
When we started
looking at dishonesty,
my colleagues and I
thought this was just
another example of
human irrationality.
Another example
of the mistakes
that we all make
that we don't
understand very well.
But the world around us
seemed to be telling us
that this is actually
a more important
topic to study.
We watch corporate
scandals everywhere.
Enron, WorldCom,
the financial crisis of 2008.
We saw an increase in cheating
in professional sports.
INTERVIEWER: Have you
ever used steroids?
No.
I have never used steroids.
I have never doped.
We witnessed
political deception
and its huge repercussions.
Well, we don't torture people.
Let me say that again to you,
we don't torture people.
It appears that there
were not weapons of
mass destruction there.
MAN: You said you
knew where they were.
I did not.
I said I knew where
suspect sights were.
Does the NSA collect
any type of data at all
on millions or hundreds
of millions of Americans?
No, sir.
WYDEN: It does not?
Not wittingly.
ARIELY: All of a sudden,
the world was telling us
that it's more important
to understand dishonesty.
And not just to understand
what's causing it,
but also to understand
what we can do
to try and curb it
and reduce it.
How many people here
have lied at least once
since the beginning
of 2014?
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
How many people here
think of yourself,
in general,
as honest,
wonderful people?
(LAUGHTER)
The same group.
How can it be?
How can it be that
at the same time
we think of
ourselves as honest
and then we recognize
that we are dishonest?
It turns out it's
all about rationalization.
On one hand, we want
to look in the mirror
and think that
we're good, honest,
wonderful people.
On the other hand,
we want to benefit selfishly
from being dishonest.
As long as we cheat just
a little bit, we don't
have to pay any price
in terms of the image and
the way we view ourselves.
And we call this
the fudge factor.
So this is the ability
to misbehave
and think of ourselves
as good people.
And you can think about
all kinds of ways
in which, in your own life,
you have a fudge factor.
The speed limit.
May be it says 55,
but are you okay
in driving 60?
What about cheating
a little bit on taxes?
What about exaggerating
their online dating profile?
(LAUGHTER)
Across many studies,
we find that
everything that changes
the fudge factor
also changes people's ability
to be dishonest.
There are dozens
of elements that can
change the magnitude
of the fudge factor.
And we've been able
to observe many
of them in the lab.
For example, if you
can say to yourself,
"Everybody's doing it,"
it's easier for you
to rationalize to yourself
that this is actually
an okay thing to do
and cheat to a higher degree.
My name is Joe Papp
and I was born
in Cleveland, Ohio.
And I was
a professional cyclist.
I was utterly crazy
for cycling. I loved it.
Hey, now get the...
Watch the tire compress.
I started bike racing
my first year
of high school.
There we go.
BOY: Come on, Joe.
GIRL: Come on, Joe.
I competed
for the University
of Pittsburgh's team
when I was
an undergraduate there.
And then, I took two
and a half years off
to compete for
the US national team
all over the world.
COMMENTATOR: And for
the sprint for the bronze,
moving into second
and it's Joe Papp.
(PEOPLE CHEERING)
PAPP: I had a really
successful season
and I went
to the Olympic trials,
actually.
But then,
the academic year was
starting in the fall
and there was a deadline
to register for classes
and I felt the need
to return to my studies.
So I stayed in school,
uh, through 2000,
when I graduated with
my undergraduate degree.
But couldn't get rid
of the bike bug
and I went back to cycling.
And so, I started
cycling again full-time
at that point,
and I'm not Lance Armstrong,
but I had been successful
at the professional level
for five or six years
before that.
And when I got
back into the races,
things were different.
Basically,
the races were faster.
There was one race
in particular
that I remember
in Massachusetts.
It was an event
that I would have
typically thought
that I had a chance
of winning
and, instead,
it took everything I had
just to be able to
stay in the field.
And that had never
happened before.
I remember crying.
Feeling like I was a failure
and how could this be and...
It took a couple of days
to process what had
happened really.
And I remember talking
to one of my
teammates on the phone,
and I remember him chuckling,
as if he was in on a joke
that I didn't know about.
And that was the point
when I learned about doping.
My teammate said,
"You should go see
doctor so-and-so.
"She'll take care of you."
And I met with this
doctor and I said,
"I'm a cyclist
and I can't match
"the performance of
these other athletes."
So she looked at my blood work
and, uh, she said,
"Yeah, we can
prescribe you EPL,"
which is a drug
that is given to
cancer patients
who're going through
chemotherapy.
It basically
forces their kidneys
to produce more
red blood cells.
But for an elite
endurance athlete,
once it manifests itself
it's phenomenal.
It's like night
and day, the change.
I can tell you exactly
how much this drug
improved my performance
and it was upwards
of 12 to 13 percent,
which is
a gargantuan improvement
in a sport that is decided
in terms of seconds.
(PEOPLE CHEERING)
PAPP: Not only did
I move up a level
in the sporting context,
but the doping
practices increased
in their sophistication,
and, uh,
and, uh, pervasiveness,
as well.
2006 is when I moved
to an Italian team
and I remember, many times,
the team manager's brother
coming to the hotel
with a small
stainless steel Thermos
and would start parceling out
to each rider
their own, uh, ampule,
their own pre-filled syringe
or their own pills.
And then the riders discussing
between themselves
what they were gonna use,
when, for and how.
Everyone was complicit in it.
You all have a shared interest
in keeping it quiet
and actually supporting
one another in it.
MALE REPORTER:
Professional cyclist
Joseph Papp said he felt
he couldn't win
without using
performance enhancing drugs
because so many
others were doping.
PAPP: I never would have
imagined myself doping.
But when you have that mindset
or when you think
that everybody else
is doing it,
or 70% of the other
people are doing it,
even if you don't
know that to be true,
it makes it lot easier
to consider what you've
done as legitimate.
ARIELY: In order
to study dishonesty,
we need to be able
to measure,
hopefully precisely,
the extent to which
people are dishonest.
So we have all kinds
of methods.
I'll describe one of them.
Thank you very much.
Uh, we're going to start.
Let's go to the lab.
You can just have
a seat anywhere
with a packet and
a pen in front of it.
We gave people 20
simple math problems.
WOMAN: Find the two numbers
that add up to 10.
These are problems that
everybody could solve
if they had enough time,
but we don't give
people enough time.
We're going to give you
five minutes to solve
as many as possible.
At the end of the five
minutes, please stop,
put your pencil down
and count how many
questions you got correct.
And now that you know
how many questions
you got correctly,
take the sheet of paper,
go to the front of the room,
and shred it.
People do that.
They come to the front,
they say they
solved six problems,
we pay them six dollars,
they go home.
Here you go. Thank you
for participating.
What the people
in the experiment
don't know
is that we played
with the shredder.
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
The shredder shredded
the sides of the page,
but the body of the page
remained intact.
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
And what do we find?
On an average, people
solve four problems
and report to be
solving six.
I solved six.
I don't know if
this is embarrassing
or not, but I got six.
I believe I got
seven right.
ARIELY:
We've run this experiment
on 40,000 people.
And so far,
we found about
20 big cheaters.
Those are people who
cheated all the way,
said they solved 20 problems,
and they stole
$400 from us.
And we also found
about 20-some-thousand
little cheaters.
And they stole about
$50,000 from us.
And I think this is not
a bad reflection of reality.
Yes, there's some
big cheaters out there,
but they're very rare.
And because of that,
their overall
economic impact
is relatively low.
On the other hand,
we have a ton of
little cheaters.
And because there
are so many of us,
the economic impact
of small cheating
is actually incredibly,
incredibly high.
I never told my kids
that there was a Santa Claus,
or an Easter Bunny,
or a tooth fairy.
I just refused to do that.
Because when
I was very young,
I went out to hide
in this little
chest of drawers
at the base of the stairs
to catch Santa Claus.
And saw that my parents
would put out
Christmas presents.
I was just shocked
that they had been
systematically
deceiving me
for years and years
and years,
and I don't think
I ever trusted them again.
GABRIELLA: My mother
makes a very special
cake for my father's birthday
called a dobos torte
which is
a Hungarian vanilla cake
with chocolate cream
going up nine layers
and then, at the very top
is this crunchy caramel.
And it is amazing.
(CHUCKLES)
Last year,
she gave the cake for me
to share with my children.
And I hid the cake
and ate it by myself.
(INHALES DEEPLY)
In second grade,
I had a little friend
named Irving.
And Irving was a big liar.
One day at lunch,
he's telling all
the kids at the table
that his father
owns a bazooka.
(CHUCKLES)
I was a little kid,
you know.
A bazooka was the biggest gun
that you could imagine.
And people at the table
said, "No, he doesn't".
And he turns to me
and says, "Yeah, he does.
"David, you've been
to my house.
"You saw the bazooka."
And I said, "Yeah, totally.
I've been to your house.
"Your dad totally
owns a bazooka."
And then I realized that
I had just told a lie
and I felt so bad,
but then I also thought,
"Wow, you really can't
trust people." (LAUGHS)
FRANCESCA:
Dan and I were sitting
in his office one day,
and in that
particular meeting
we were reflecting
on this idea
of the evil genius,
and the fact that
oftentimes it seems
that, uh, creativity
and dishonesty
come together.
(CAMERA SHUTTERS CLICKING)
At that time,
we were reading
news about the fact
that Bernie Madoff
was very creative
with his Ponzi scheme.
And so we started wondering
what creativity
does to people.
We ended up going into the lab
and studying that further.
We created situations
where people would be asked
to be creative,
or where creativity
was primed.
And then we asked the people
to use the matrix task.
And what we found was that
when people are in
a creative mindset,
they're more likely
to come up with lots
of justifications for why
what they're about
to do is morally okay
and is justifiable.
PR and marketing,
almost by their very nature,
involve the step on
to the slippery slope.
What do you do?
You have to create
something from nothing.
And because of that,
I kind of just made
it up as I went along.
I'd been reading this blog,
I thought it was really funny.
The blogger's name
was Tucker Max.
And the blog was stories
about drinking and hooking up.
It's this gonzo style
of storytelling
where this guy's going around
doing crazy things,
getting in all sorts
of trouble.
They're really
funny and hilarious,
but controversial
and messed up
and evil and awful,
all at the same time.
And, uh, I was attracted
to something in this writing
and I think
it was the honesty
and the authenticity
of the way
the author was
presenting himself
I was just sort of
fascinated by him.
I ended up
e-mailing the blogger,
and I say, like,
"I wanna work for you.
I'll do whatever you need."
There was talk that
he would do a book
and he didn't have
a publicist or anything.
I ended up working
on that campaign.
It was like, "Okay,
we have this book,
"I think people would like it.
"How would we get people
to know about it?"
And because we had nothing,
we could try anything.
I knew this one blog
linked to him a lot
and I was like,
"How've you got that?"
And he was like,
"Oh, I just send them
fake e-mails
"pretending to be
either a fan of my stuff
"or hating my stuff,
and I trick them
into linking about me."
So, it's like, "Okay, if that
worked with this site,
"would it work with
these bigger sites,
"would it work
with newspapers,
"would it work
with television?"
The book is called
I Hope They
Serve Beer in Hell.
And frankly,
there is not much in it
that can be repeated
on a nice family
show like yours.
Tucker Max, author of
I Hope They
Serve Beer in Hell.
Classy.
And so, we tried
all this new stuff
and it ended up working.
The book sold close
to two million copies.
After his book became
this big bestseller,
he ended up producing a movie
based on the book.
We'd seen how
effective controversy
had been with driving
sales of the book.
So it was like,
why don't we make this
one of those movies
that people boycott
and say, "Don't go see,"
because we knew
that our audience
would go see it
precisely because of that.
We ended up trying
these tactics of,
"Let's get people to protest.
"Let's make people horrified
so they talk about it more."
We would send
anonymous e-mails
to LGBT groups on campus,
women's groups on campus.
We designed these
really offensive ads.
There was jokes about midgets,
strippers, blind people.
I went out and I
vandalized these ads.
Um, I put these
offensive stickers
all over them.
Then I took photos and then
I leaked those photos
to these two small
blogs in Los Angeles.
They run this big story.
And then that
starts to get more
and more media coverage.
And then, people
started vandalizing
the billboards for real
in all these other cities.
(TYPING)
HOLIDAY:
My staff began calling
the Chicago Transit Authority
to protest about
these offensive ads.
(PHONE RINGING)
WOMAN:
Chicago Transit Authority.
HOLIDAY: They put out
an announcement that
they were banning
the ads from the city
and they were
pulling them off
from the buses.
Which is exactly
what we wanted
because now this
is a news story.
The Chicago Tribune
actually ran an editorial
lauding the CTA's decision
to pull the ads.
And now, it was this
sort of full-fledged
massive controversy.
(PROTESTERS CHANTING)
HOLIDAY: In New York City,
this group organized
a city-wide
protest/vandalization
of the billboards
and they invited
the media along,
so we got more press there.
It became difficult
for me to know
where the line was.
She wants me to
sign her underwear.
HOLIDAY: What we were
doing was generating
chatter about the movie.
But if you step back
and you look at it,
it's like you're deceiving
more and more people,
and then once it started,
it couldn't stop,
and it just carried on
under its own power.
ARIELY:
There's another version
of the fudge factor
in which we
convince ourselves
on all kinds of things that
are not perfectly true.
For example,
the vast majority
of people believe
that they're better drivers
than the average.
The vast majority
of people believe that
they have less chance
of dying from a heart attack
and cancer and
all kinds of things.
We have these
over-optimistic beliefs
about ourselves.
And we convince ourselves
that this is
actually the truth.
Self-deception starts off as,
we know we're
lying to ourselves.
Or we are aware
that we're engaging
in rationalization,
for example.
And after a while
we just believe
what it is that
we're telling ourselves.
So that is basically
the optimism bias
and we see it
in 80 percent
of the population.
Self-deception
has both positive
and negative consequences.
I think, on average,
the positive must have
outweighed the negative
for us to evolve
to be able to self-deceive
and do it quite a lot.
MICHAEL NORTON:
So we have
people take this test,
and, um, some people
don't have the answers and
we see how well they do.
And these are hard questions,
so they don't do very well.
Other people,
we give them the test,
and we give them
the answers at the bottom.
We say, "Check them
if you want. Up to you."
They do terrific
on the test.
But we give them
another test. So we say,
"Here's some new questions
"and, by the way,
there's no answers
at the bottom this time.
"How well do you think
you're gonna do?"
And they don't
correct at all.
They just think that
they're amazing
test-takers now,
and we can even pay them.
We can say, "Look,
if you guess how many
you're gonna get right,
"we'll give you
a lot of money."
No change at all.
They just believe.
They've deceived
themselves into thinking,
(LAUGHS) "I'm
the greatest test-taker
in the world,"
and we can't get them
to stop doing it.
This process of
deceiving ourselves
is so strong,
and it happens to us
so quickly, where
we have a twinge of,
"Maybe I cheated," and then,
"No, I didn't. I'm a genius."
And then, "I'm a genius
for the rest of my life."
It's so powerful
and so strong in us,
this impulse.
I can tell immediately
when someone's not
being honest with me.
It made me an excellent
admissions officer.
I expelled one person
because he had somebody else
take all his SATs for him.
And it was pretty
clear that was true
because he couldn't
pass anything.
What I see happening
in the world
is that children
are more and more
being encouraged to be
something other than
who they truly are.
The college admission process
is definitely
a big offender here.
So,
um,
when I'd first applied
for the job at MIT
I wrote then that
I had gone to this
other school where I was
actually taking classes
instead of my college.
I was taking classes
at RPI in Troy.
And I said,
I just sort of
morphed that into,
"Oh, I went there for
undergraduate school,"
I just sort of morphed it.
I felt that,
at a place like MIT,
they wouldn't accept me
if I'd come from, you know,
a Catholic girls' school.
I kept getting promoted.
And I got a call from someone
from the American
Academy of Pediatrics.
Would I join him
in writing a book?
Yeah, absolutely.
I was on television,
I was on the radio,
I was in newspapers,
I was in a lot of places.
I want us to start
another revolution tonight
because I want us
to be able to give
our childhood back
to our children.
Often, you know, you...
People would get a bio
or they'll introduce you
a certain way,
you know, and things just...
Some people think
you have a Masters,
some people think
you have PhDs,
some people this,
some people that,
and, you know, whatever.
For me it was just,
"Okay, well,
"they're saying
what they're saying,
I don't care. Here I am."
They frequently
called me "Doctor," 'cause
that's just how it was.
It seems that
someone had said,
"Oh, she was passing
herself as a PhD."
Well, then things began
to unravel pretty hard.
Marilee Jones resigned today
as Dean of Admissions at MIT
after 28 years at that
prestigious school.
In a statement today she said,
"I am deeply sorry for
disappointing so many
"in the MIT community
and beyond."
MARILEE:
I wasn't allowed to see
any of my staff members.
I was like a persona
non grata on campus,
and I kept thinking,
"This is me."
I kept saying, "People,
it's me. It's me.
"You've known me for years.
I'm the same person."
And suddenly,
I was on the other
side of the wall.
What just happened to me?
Who am I?
It sent me right down.
Right down deep, where
I'd never really been.
(CHATTERING)
I think a really
important skill is
to be good at lying.
(LAUGHTER)
If you do it in a really
good way, then you
don't have to worry
about them catching you.
So that's why I
think it's good
to be good at lying.
Sometimes you also
have to lie, in a way,
because you are
making somebody happy.
Like, if you're throwing
a surprise birthday party,
then that means
you're obviously trying
to help and get ready
or do something.
And so, you're lying
to your friend
to help them have
a good birthday.
All creatures,
uh, big or small,
uh, have deception as part
of their armamentary.
Oftentimes it's just survival.
A plant or a bird
might change color
and camouflage itself,
which is a form of deception.
The bigger the brain,
the larger
the capacity to lie.
Chimpanzees, for example,
have been known
to lie where they
may lead their group
away from where the food is,
so that that one
particular chimpanzee
can come back
to the food later on
and find that food.
It's very common for
younger children to fib.
And for them,
it gives them pleasure,
it helps them imagine things
and it helps them
build their brain
and helps them build what
is called the theory of mind.
A psychological theory
by which,
as our brains mature,
we're able to
predict and imagine
what the other person's
thinking about.
And unless children lie
and unless children
imagine and dream big,
they may not have
the full capacity
to develop the theory of mind.
A lie is like a knife.
So if you use the knife
to stab somebody, it's wrong.
If you use a knife
to put some butter
on your bread,
there's nothing
wrong with it.
Once I flew from
Berlin to Milano.
We got into many
kind of, like...
Air pockets... I don't know.
It was very,
very bad kind of flight.
At some stage,
I hear this woman
start crying
and shouting in Italian.
She was about 50 years old.
She had a big cross
on her neck.
And I look back to
the flight attendant
because I expected
somebody to go to her.
When I looked back I saw
the two flight attendants
sitting in the back
and crying.
And this woman kept shouting
in Italian and crying.
And I said to myself,
"Something must be
done about this woman."
And there's
an empty seat
next to her.
So I unfastened
my seat belt,
I get next to her
and I fastened my seat belt.
I hold her hand
and I said to her,
"Look at me,
do I look scared?"
And she said, "No,
why aren't you scared?"
And I said, "Because
from all the people
in this plane,
"I'm the only one
who is
an aeronautics engineer.
"I'm only one that knows
"that we are on the safest
passenger airplane on Earth,
"and it doesn't feel right
but nothing bad is
gonna happen to us."
And she looks at me
and takes some breath,
but she's still kind
of crying, actually.
(PANTS) And she
starts breathing
and she still holds my hand
and she said,
"Jesus sent you to me."
She said to me,
"What's the probability
"that from all
the people on Earth
"an aeronautic engineer
would sit next to me." So...
So this is
the kind of lies that
I have no moral
problem lying about.
Because I think that
even if we would have died,
I think dying
while you're hysterical
is less fun
than dying while
somebody next to you
tells you a nice lie.
We grow up in this
social world in which
our parents teach us
about how to have manners,
and how to care
about other people,
and how not to
point at people,
how not to say
all kinds of things.
And we learn that
a little bit
of lying is okay.
In an experiment
we're conducting right now,
we get people to lie
and we connect them
to a lie detector.
Lie detectors basically
detect emotional arousal
when we feel uncomfortable.
And when people
cheat for themselves,
the lie detector tells us
that they're lying.
There's no problem
detecting it.
But sometimes we ask people
to cheat for a charity.
And then the lie detector
is silent.
The lie detector
doesn't catch anything.
Why?
Because if we
could justify that
we're doing something
for a good cause,
there's really no arousal,
there's no conflict,
there's no
emotional problem.
My name is
Kelley Williams-Bolar,
and I'm from Akron, Ohio.
When my oldest daughter
was in junior high
and my youngest daughter
was in second grade,
I had concerns with
the quality of education.
The schools were not
at the academic level
that they needed to be.
My father and I lived
in two different
school district areas
no more than three miles
away from each other.
I made a decision,
me and my father,
that I would enroll my kids
in his school district.
And as I was
filling out the paperwork,
I do remember just thinking
"What's the possibility
"that I will get into
serious trouble?"
My daughters
loved that school.
They taught the children
how to be
focused academically.
They were there
for a full year.
And then the treasurer
of the school called
my dad's house,
and I answered the phone.
He asked me,
"If I was to come there
"right now, would you
be sitting there?
"Would you be there?"
And it just so happened
I was there.
So I was like, "Yeah, come.
"If you need to come
to see if I'm here,
then I'm here."
I received a letter
from the treasurer
and the superintendent,
"We have clear and
convincing evidence
"that you do not
live or reside
"at 1373 Black Pond,
Copley, Ohio
"and we have a meeting for you
"and we would like for you
to come to the meeting."
And I remember
going to the meeting.
I don't know how
many men it was.
Four men.
Superintendent, treasurer...
To solve this problem.
KELLEY:
And they had attorneys there.
I did some things wrong,
but I love my kids.
And I remember
still trying to say,
"No, they live there,
they live there."
And that became difficult.
Because it's like
you bury yourself more.
Deep inside I was
thinking, "Golly, this is...
"This is just too much."
They were pretty upset.
Basically,
"You can take your children
and go to another school."
I said, "Okay, that's fine."
They don't want them there.
I just took the kids out.
Roughly two years later
I get an indictment
to go to court.
BAILIFF:
The court of common pleas
is now in session.
KELLEY: They wanted
criminal charges.
I need to be
there for my kids.
I need to be
a supporter for them.
Unfortunately,
the means don't
justify the end.
The verdict was guilty.
BAILIFF: All rise.
(KELLEY SOBBING)
KELLEY: My daughters knew,
I explained to them
what happened.
Because I wanted them
to see the effect of lying.
You have a small
twist in a story
and it can become...
It can become, uh,
a huge impact in your life.
ARIELY: I own
a vending machine.
I set it up to
a price of zero.
So what would happen?
You would put your money,
you would press on
the candy you want,
you would get the candy
and the money.
First of all, I put
a big sign that says,
"Here's the number to call
in case the machine
is not working."
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
How many people called?
Zero. That's right.
How many candies
did people take?
Nobody took
more than four.
(AUDIENCE LAUGHS)
The majority took
three or four, like
five would be cheating.
Three or four
is kind of okay.
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
I think that what people
were basically doing is
rationalizing
their vending karma.
What people were saying
is, "I remember some
vending machine
"that took my money before,
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
"and that vending machine
has to be a close
relative of this one."
So the other thing
that people did was
to call their friends.
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
And I think you can see
the intuition, right?
So, if one of my
friends is coming
and doing it as well
it's more
socially acceptable
all of a sudden.
In one set of experiments,
we got people to
work as a team.
So, imagine you and I
are working as a team.
And when I cheat,
you get some of it.
Then when you cheat,
I get some of it.
What happened now?
Cheating goes up.
(HORNS HONKING)
My name is Garrett Bauer,
44 years old.
And I used to be
a professional
stock trader.
I loved trading.
It was more fun
than almost anything.
Doing a really smart trade
was more important to me
than even making money.
When I first
moved to New York,
uh, I met my first friend
and his name was Ken.
I knew he knew a lawyer.
I'm Matthew Kluger.
I worked at a very
prestigious firm
that represented some
of the biggest names
in corporate America.
I had known Ken Robinson
for a couple of years.
We talked to each other
on the phone.
He said, "So you're working
on these high-profile deals?"
And I said, "Yes."
He said, "So let me
get this straight.
"You kind of get to read
tomorrow's paper today."
And he said, "You know,
that information could be
valuable to someone."
And I said. "Yeah,
but it's very risky.
It's highly illegal."
Ken said, "I have a friend
who's a big day trader.
"Who could take
that information
"and use it to
a great advantage,
"but could probably
avoid detection
"because he does
a lot of day trading."
We set up a meeting
on the street corner
and talked for maybe an hour.
By just entering
into a discussion
of the possibility
of doing this,
I was crossing the line,
but it didn't feel like
that at that point.
Bauer put me at ease
that what we were doing,
the wrong,
was "A," common,
and "B," not really
hurting anybody.
Insider trading information
is passed around,
if it's not daily,
it's weekly.
KLUGER: There are a lot
of people out there
who are becoming privy
to inside information
and using it to trade.
BAUER: Everyone's
trading on this stuff.
There wasn't one
person in my office
that wasn't.
I passed information
and the scheme gelled.
BAUER: Matt would
call Ken with
information somewhat like,
"We think IBM is buying
Sun Microsystems."
Then they would tell me
how many shares.
We'd subtract the tax rate,
I'd pay the taxes,
and then we
would get the cash.
I did not expect it to
take on a life of its own,
and then it took on
a life of its own.
(SIREN WAILING)
One night,
Ken called me and said
his house had been raided.
I don't remember everything
he said on that call,
but I remember thinking
that some of what he said
was a little suspicious
and was wondering,
"Is it possible
someone is listening,"
but I dismissed that
as being paranoia.
And I was arrested
the next morning.
I sit up out of bed and
I hear someone say, uh,
Garrett Bauer, where are you?
Clearly, I'm thinking
it's pretty serious
when you have that many
FBI agents in your apartment.
WOMAN: Federal
prosecutors have charged
two men with an
insider trading scheme
that went on for 17 years.
Our investigation
has documented
more than $109 million
in illegal trades.
FEMALE REPORTER:
Bauer and Kluger
pleaded guilty to
securities fraud,
conspiracy to
commit money laundering
and obstructing justice.
I was curious.
Are there more men,
over-represented
in large cheaters
than women?
Yeah, so first of all,
this is a great question.
So the question is,
are there
gender differences
between cheating
in men and women,
and there are
huge differences.
Huge differences.
And the difference
is that only women
ask this question.
(LAUGHTER AND CLAPPING)
But in terms of cheating,
there's no difference. Now...
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
MIRIAM NOVALLE: I was
sitting in the lounge,
charging my phone,
and all of a sudden
you hear the announcement,
"Your flight's
about to take off."
So I run out,
and I get to my flight,
and I sit in my seat,
and I realize as
the door is closing
my phone is in
the charger in the lounge.
I run up to the girls
in the front,
the stewardess, but she said,
"You must sit down, Miss.
We're just taking off..."
"No, you can't.
My phone is in the lounge.
"I'm sorry. Listen,
I work for CNN News.
"I'm on the air tomorrow,
and I need to have my phone
"because everything that
I've just worked on
is sitting in this phone."
Guess what?
The plane went back,
they got my phone,
a woman hands me my phone,
and everyone in the place
looks at me and goes,
"Who the fuck is that?"
FRANCESCA: In one project,
Dan and Shahar Ayal and I
decided to look at
what's the influence of
others' unethical behavior
on our own
decisions to cheat.
So we designed an experiment
with different
types of conditions.
So imagine the same experiment
I described to you before,
but with one
main difference.
We hired an acting student.
And 30 seconds
into the experiment,
he raises his hand.
Yeah, I got all of them.
What do I do?
And they say,
"I solved everything.
What do I do next?"
WOMAN: You should
come up here and...
ARIELY:
Now, this is 30 seconds
into the experiment,
you're still on
question number one.
(AUDIENCE LAUGHS)
There's no question
in your mind that
that person is cheating
and the experimenter said,
"You finished everything.
You're free to go."
And you see
that person taking
all the amount of money
and going home.
What would happen
to your own morality?
Well, lots more
people cheat.
But it could be two
explanations here.
One explanation is
we just proved to people
that in this experiment,
there's no downside
for cheating.
The second
possibility is that
it's not about the fact
that they wouldn't catch you,
it's about the fact
that it's actually
socially okay.
WOMAN: Thank you
for participating.
And so we decided
to study this
by looking at whether
the person cheating
is somebody like us,
or somebody we
feel similar to,
or somebody who's
very different from us.
ARIELY:
We ran this experiment
at Carnegie Mellon.
Everybody was
a Carnegie Mellon student,
the acting student
was a Carnegie Mellon student.
We dressed the acting student
in a University
of Pittsburgh sweatshirt.
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
Now what happens if
you're a University
of Carnegie Mellon student
and the Pittsburgh
student cheats?
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
You still know that
you can get away with it.
Here's the proof that
somebody goes home
with all the money,
but you don't think
that people like
you are doing it.
And what happens now?
Cheating goes down.
So, it's not about
the probability
of being caught.
It's about the question
of what is
socially acceptable
in our circle.
My name is Erika Nelson.
I am from Florida.
I'm married to
my husband Kenny.
And we have a total
of six children,
and him and I have
two children together.
He has a really good heart,
and we had a really
good relationship.
But to go from nothing
to having six children,
you know, was a lot.
So, he kind of, like,
dove into his work,
and we weren't having sex,
we weren't, um...
We weren't even talking.
It was all about the kids
and then his work,
and that was really it.
And I was just
kind of, you know,
wiping butts from
the moment I got up
to the moment I went to bed,
and that was kind of my life.
You're just gonna
change, too.
(FROLICKING)
(LAUGHS) A good day,
I had a bra on.
It was my dress-up day.
I kind of just
got lost in that.
But I really loved my husband,
and I wanted to make it work.
So, I would try
to talk to him,
and no matter what I say,
it doesn't seem to
get through to him.
Nothing changes.
I even went to him
crying the last time,
and I said, "Look,
I need more than this,
you know, in my life.
"And I love you enough
to tell you this
"because I don't
wanna ruin this."
And, um, he's like...
(SHRUGS)
(LAUGHING)
Not that he was indifferent.
I just think that he thought,
"We'll get through it."
I didn't take it like that.
I took it as
a slap in the face.
Ashley Madison is a website
for married people
or people that are
in a committed relationship
that want to have
random sex,
or hook-ups, or whatever.
I think that that's an appeal
to Ashley Madison.
You know that everybody
knows that you're married.
So there's not
that awkwardness.
You check your area,
and we live in a small,
little community
and there's like, hundreds
of people on there.
And it's easy to kind of mask
um, the reality of
what you're doing, too,
'cause you're behind
a computer screen.
I talked to one guy.
We had, actually, a really,
pretty good friendship
um, for a few months.
And then it got
more into, like,
intimate conversations,
and talks, and then,
"Let's meet up."
He would take me
to fancy restaurants,
I would get dressed up,
and I'm thinking, "Wow,
this should be awesome.
"I can have, like,
this whole home life
and I can be the good parent,
"be the good mom,
and then I can have
this whole other life
"of jet setting
and wearing bras
and dressing up,
"and wearing makeup
and doing your hair."
Polar opposite of what
I had going on at home.
And I think I almost
was more attracted to that
than anything else.
And I would lie and
say that I was just
gonna go to hang out
with my friend,
or I was gonna
visit my parents
or whatever, to see him.
So, I think...
I think that
even when you know
it's wrong, the immediate
gratification suffocates
what you know is right.
So, I came home one night
and I asked my husband,
"Are you going out of town
this week at all?"
And he said, "Why?
So you can talk
"to him on the phone
while I'm not here?"
And I just said,
"How did you find out?"
And he kind of walked away,
and I followed him upstairs.
I didn't know how long
he had known,
I didn't know what he knew,
so all these questions
were in my head.
And he said,
"You left up an e-mail."
And he said,
"I came in the office,
"and the e-mail was up
from the night before
and I read all of them."
And I said,
"Look, I was gonna
"get attention or whatever
from somebody else,
"as messed up as that is,
that's how I am,
"and I don't know
how to get over that.
"So I need your help
or I need somebody's help,"
I said, "But I don't wanna
mess this up between us."
I saw how hurt he was.
And my husband
didn't deserve it.
Um...
I deleted my account that day.
ARIELY: So as I told you,
I was badly burnt,
and when I came
back to the hospital
maybe four or five years
after I was released,
the head of the burn
department finds me
and he said,
"Dan, I have a new,
fantastic treatment
for you.
"Come with me."
I go with him and
he explains to me
that when I shave,
I have little black dots
on the left side
of my face, stubble,
the right side of
my face is burnt,
there's no hair,
there's no stubble.
And he can fix
this asymmetry.
How? He's going to tattoo
the right side of my face,
(AUDIENCE LAUGHS)
until it would fit
the left side of my face.
And he says,
"Go home, shave,
come back tomorrow,
"by noon you'll
be symmetrical."
So I drive home and
I think to myself,
what kind of shave
should I aim for?
What would give me
the most hours of symmetry?
The early morning shave,
the afternoon shadow
what's the right shave?
Anyway, I shave,
I get to his office,
and I say, "You know,
I'm not so sure I want this.
"I'm not so sure
it's for me."
And then he looks
at me and says, "Dan,
what's wrong with you?
"Do you enjoy
looking non-symmetrical?
"Do you get some
depraved pleasure
from looking different?"
Anyway, I left
and I went to his
deputy and I said,
"What's going on?
Where's this guilt
trip coming from?"
He says, "Well,
we've done it on two
patients already,
"and we need a third
for an academic paper."
(AUDIENCE LAUGHS)
And I'm kind of
an ideal client, right?
Half the face burnt, half not
would come out
really good in his paper.
Now, here's the thing.
It's really easy to think
about this physician
as being evil.
But this guy was
an amazing physician.
I really loved him,
I owe him a lot.
But, nevertheless,
at that moment he had
a conflict of interest.
On the computer screen,
you'll see a square.
It'll be divided into two.
There'll be a right half
and a left half.
We're going to flash
some dots in the square
just for half a second.
Your task,
if you're a participant
in the experiment,
is just to tell me
which side of
the line has more dots.
And it's usually
pretty obvious which side,
there's like a lot here
and not very many here.
ARIELY: Now,
there's one more thing,
we're not going to
pay you the same amount
for the right
and for the left.
But regardless
of the amount,
your task is to, basically,
be as accurate
and truthful as possible.
Ready? Go.
The dot task is
a basic experiment
in conflicts of interest.
Very, very few people start
by lying egregiously.
But if the dots
are kind of similar,
just slightly more
to the left,
they would say "Right."
Almost any moral conflict
you can think of as,
there's a line and
you have to decide
whether you're gonna
cross it or not.
You kind of want to
go to the other side
and you kind of know
what the right side is.
Maybe I'll go
to the other side
sometimes.
My name is Tim Donaghy,
I grew up in Havertown,
Pennsylvania.
My father
was a college
basketball official,
and because of that
and because of
my love of sports,
I followed in his footsteps
and pursued a career as
an NBA basketball referee.
The NBA's a much
different game,
if you will,
from high school and college,
even though a lot of the rules
are written the same,
they're not enforced the same.
I started to referee
based on the rules
and how they're written
in the rule book.
MALE COMMENTATOR:
Tim Donaghy,
the rookie official,
is calling it very tight
here in the early going,
a lot of offensive
fouls and picks,
so, they're calling it
by the rule book.
TIM: Unfortunately,
I saw some people
that were moving up
a little bit quicker than me.
I'd learned from the veterans,
if there's a certain craft
and a certain way that
you have to do things
in order to advance,
and they'll tell you.
Certain players
are given the benefit
of maybe traveling
with the basketball
rather than other players.
Certain players are
getting the benefit
of not having
that critical foul
called on them
that would send
them to the bench.
MALE COMMENTATOR 1:
Rubio, gets a look,
good if it goes...
MALE COMMENTATOR 2:
Oh, my gosh,
that's just a horrible
call by Jason Phillips
who did not have
the courage to call that
against Kobe Bryant.
Wow. Awful no-call.
It's probably about
50-50 when you look at
calls that are enforced
by the rule book
and then calls that
are made or not made
based on star treatment,
pressure from coaches
at certain times.
What changed those
last few minutes
for your guys?
The guys with the whistles.
TIM:
I've never had conversations
with the commissioner
about what to call
in a game and what
not to call in a game.
But from
the operations department,
they clearly dictate.
Through video,
through e-mails,
through meetings,
what they want called
and what they
don't want called.
And it always seems to revolve
around the star players
or the big market teams.
Kobe Bryant's
a star in this league.
He puts a lot of people
in the stands,
he sells a lot of sneakers
and he sells a lot of jerseys.
And the fans pay
an enormous amount of money
to sit in those,
uh, courtside seats
and they want those type
of players on the floor,
that's who they came to see.
The bottom line is
it's more of
a form of entertainment
than an actual
athletic competition.
I don't think
the officials feel
that they're not
doing something
that's not right.
Because in their minds,
they're being told what to do
from the league office.
And if they're gonna
continue to advance
and get those big
playoff bonus checks,
you're gonna do what
the league wants.
MALE COMMENTATOR:
And Reggie Miller
who is a 90%...
TIM: Being an NBA referee
and being involved
in the planning
of how the game
was gonna be called
that night,
I knew certain teams were
gonna be at an advantage
or a disadvantage.
And it was just a situation
where I crossed a line
that I shouldn't
have been near.
I'll never forget
when the first
situation arose.
A friend of mine was
looking at the lines
in the NBA games
and he just asked me
to help him pick
some winners
and I remember
I was looking at
the master schedule
of referees that night
and I knew who was
refereeing certain games,
and I picked
some games for him
and the games did very well.
And he called me the next day
and we just had
a frank conversation.
I knew a certain line
was way off or I knew
a certain referee
was, uh, gonna give
special treatment
to a certain owner,
team or individual player.
So, I passed that information
along to my buddy
and he was shocked
that I could predict
the outcome of a game.
(AUDIENCE CHEERING)
(COMMENTATOR ANNOUNCING)
We would discuss
certain games
that we both liked
and, because of my
contract with the NBA,
I wasn't allowed to place
a bet of any kind.
So, he would
contact the bookies
and put everything
under his name
for both of us.
It got to the point
where we were gambling
probably three or four games
a week in the NBA.
As time went on,
I started to feel
guilty about doing it
and, basically,
I wanted to stop.
What I didn't realize
is my good friend
was passing this
information along
to people that were associated
with organized crime.
And they were,
basically, betting
an enormous amount of money
based on the information
that I was giving him.
They picked me up
outside a hotel
in Philadelphia
and, basically,
took me for a ride
in a car
and made it known
that they had been
getting that information
and it was going
to continue to come
and if not,
somebody would visit
my wife and kids,
down in Florida.
So, my quick thoughts
were to play ball
with them a little bit
and, hopefully, at the end
of this coming season
they would release me
from their grips and make
enough money to where
we could all just
wash our hands of this
and be done with it
and never do it again.
And I could continue
to keep my job
and just move in
a different direction.
MALE COMMENTATOR:
The San Antonio Spurs
are NBA World Champions!
TIM: What happens is,
as the season ends,
I'm back home
in Sarasota, Florida
getting ready to play golf.
And I get a call
from a friend of mine
who tells me that
the FBI's been knocking
on a lot of people's doors
and that the whole
scheme was discovered
over a Gambino wiretap.
And that they were asking
a lot of questions.
FEMALE REPORTER: Today,
former NBA referee,
Tim Donaghy
is expected to plead guilty
in federal court
in connection
with allegations that
he bet on games
in which he officiated.
(CAMERA SHUTTERS CLICKING)
We kind of
anecdotally know
that once you lie,
you're more likely
to lie again.
And probably the second lie
will be bigger than the first.
What we find in
the brain is that,
at the beginning,
if you lie a little bit,
there's a huge response
in regions
involved in emotion
such as the amygdala
and the insula.
The tenth time you lie,
even if you lie
the same amount,
the response
is not that high.
So while the lying
goes up over time,
the response in
your brain goes down.
We think that
the reason that
this happens
is because of
a very basic principle
of the brain.
Which is,
the brain adapts.
For example, if you're
listening to music
and it's quite low volume
and I turn it up,
like, two notches,
it will feel like
a really big difference,
right.
But if you're listening
to the radio and it's
really high volume,
and then I put
it up two notches,
you won't even feel it.
The brain is coding
everything relative to what
the base line is.
The same goes
with dishonesty.
If we're pretty much
honest people
and we haven't lied
and now we're
telling a lie,
the brain is coding this
as a really big difference
relative to our baseline.
But if we're dishonest
and we lie quite a lot,
the brain doesn't
respond so much.
After a while,
the negative value
of lying,
the negative feeling,
is just not there so much.
Which kind of
makes you just lie
more and more and more.
My parents, uh, they
grew up in the Bronx
and they placed
a lot of emphasis
on getting me
and my two brothers
around the kitchen table,
every night, for dinner.
The role that I grew into
was an insane fabulist.
I just lied constantly.
I was down at
the basketball court
and, uh, Karim Abdul-Jabbar
showed up
and I smacked his
shot away and I said,
"Get that sky-hook trash
out of my face, Karim."
My family would
roll their eyes.
Until one night,
I talked about how
there was a pickup game
and we're tied,
next basket's
gonna win the game.
Someone from my team
puts up a shot,
I went up to rebound it,
the ball bounced
off my head,
arced in the air,
swish, into the basket.
I win the game.
And everyone in my family,
all at once,
they had finally had it.
"Stop lying to us,
that is ridiculous,
that did not happen."
But here's the thing about it,
I, to this day, I can see
the texture of the basketball.
And I can feel
myself doing this
and the ball going in
and the exultation, like,
lives in me still.
In my head I know it's a lie,
in my heart, I can't let go.
ARIELY: We did a study
with 12,000 golf players.
We said, "Imagine
the ball fell
"on the rough,
not a good place,
"and you really,
really wanted it to be
four inches to the left.
"Would you pick it up
and move it four inches?"
And people said,
"Heaven forbid."
It was in the nature
of the game, how
people feel about it,
nobody would do that.
Fine, nobody does that.
What about
kicking the ball?
No problem, whatsoever.
(LAUGHTER)
What about
hitting it with a club,
it's even easier.
And you know
what's the easiest?
If you're not looking,
like you look up
and then you
kick a little bit...
(LAUGHTER)
But I think you can
feel the intuition
that if you
picked something up
and you moved it,
the act would feel
incredibly deliberate.
But if there was
some distance,
you kicked it,
something happened,
all of a sudden,
this distance would
allow people to have
a bit more ambiguity
in the connection
between them
and the final act.
So, imagine
the same experiment
I described earlier.
You fill in your sheets,
you solve these
little problems,
you shred the piece of paper
and you come to
the experimenter.
You tell them how much
money you deserve.
You tell it in tokens,
"I solved X problems,
I deserve X tokens."
So, now you pay them
in pieces of plastic.
They take this
piece of plastic,
walk 12 feet to the side
and change it for dollars.
So, when somebody
looked you in the eyes
and they lie,
they don't lie for money,
they lie for something else
but that thing
becomes money very quickly.
What happened?
In our experiment, people
doubled their cheating.
WOMAN: There you go.
MAN: Thank you.
This, by the way,
is the most troubling
result I think we got.
Think about it, as a society
we're moving away from money.
Credit cards, stock,
stock options, derivatives,
dealing with people
over great distances.
Could it be that
as these distances
in all of their versions
are increasing,
people find it easier
to misbehave and still
think of themselves,
or of ourselves,
as good people.
And I think the answer
is absolutely,
absolutely yes.
My name is Walt Pavlo,
I grew up in Savannah,
Georgia.
I was the first one
on either side of my family
to ever go to college.
I worked for MCI,
a very large
telecommunications company.
I was a bill collector.
And they weren't
telephone bills you and I
open up each month.
They were for large companies.
While I was managing
customers that were paying
their bill on time,
I was getting a small
number of customers
that were involved in things
like 900 business.
Those types of companies
aren't exactly
good business people.
One company owed MCI
in excess of $50 million.
And I took this
to my management
and said, "What do I
do with this guy?"
He owes us $50 million,
we have to,
in accounting terms,
do a write-off.
Just really tell
our shareholders
that $50 million
that we were expecting
from this customer,
it's not gonna come in.
And instead, I was told,
"We're not gonna
tell anybody about it."
We're gonna leave it
on MCI's accounting records
and we're going
to do some, uh,
cooking of the books,
if you will,
to allow this debt
to be put off
into the future.
So it looks like
it's gonna be collected
at some other time.
The ability for me
to move numbers around
was something that
I knew that was wrong
but, at the same time,
it took a lot of
pressure off of me.
And before I knew it
I had moved around
or not told shareholders
about probably $100 million
worth of debt that
wasn't on MCI's books.
It really is that simple.
I mean, it's just
an accounting entry,
it's just a number.
I felt a sense that
it wasn't gonna be
very much longer
that there are ways
to undo this and
turn the clock backwards
in a few months,
and then I realized that
this isn't gonna happen.
Customers still
aren't paying us.
The amount of money
that I've manipulated
is getting larger.
I'm working for a company
that doesn't care
the pressure that
they've put me under.
So, I confided in somebody
outside of MCI and said,
"Hey, I'm looking
for some advice.
"What do I do in
this situation?"
He says,
"Walt, I have an idea.
I think that there's a way
"that we can get
some of these customers
to pay MCI's debts.
"That solves
your other problem
"in that you're
actually gonna see
money coming in again.
"And then third, Walt,
I think I can make you and I
"a hell of a lot of
money doing this."
(CHUCKLES) And I was like,
"What was number three again?"
I felt a sense
of empowerment,
really, cockiness.
You know, "If there's
money involved,
"yeah, I'm doing this, yeah,
this is the way this
is supposed to work."
WOMAN: Hi, Walt.
Hi.
Is this pretty cool?
Real cool.
I can tell you, that feeling
didn't last very long.
I went down to
the Cayman Islands.
I went on a private jet
and a guy
hands me a lot of money.
And I'm like, "Oh, my God.
What is this?
"What have I done?
How far have I
taken this thing?
"No more,
I don't want to
do this anymore."
Six months after that,
um, I received
a call from my boss.
"Somebody from
accounting has called me
and told me
"something's wrong
with one of
the accounting entries.
"And they need
an explanation for it."
For a split second,
I said, "I can fix this."
And then the totality
of what I had done,
it was just coming
crashing down.
There was no way
that I could fix it.
I've been caught.
FEMALE REPORTER:
Worldcom said last night
that an internal investigation
has uncovered massive
accounting fraud,
almost $4 billion,
in disguised expenses
in what could become one of
the biggest accounting
scandals in US history.
(CAMERA SHUTTERS CLICKING)
ARIELY:
Now, when we run
these experiments,
we run them either
at universities
or in bars.
We went to a bar
in Washington, D.C.
where congressional
staffers hang out.
And we went to
a bar in New York City,
where bankers hang out.
So, who cheats more,
the bankers or
the politicians?
(LAUGHTER)
Who votes for bankers?
Who votes for politicians?
Okay, many more
for politicians.
The bankers cheated
twice as much.
(LAUGHTER AND CLAPPING)
You can't be happy
with this result.
(CHUCKLES) Like,
there's no way that
this is a good result.
If we took all the elements
that we studied
and we combined them
into one environment,
we would get
an environment that is
very similar to the one
that operated in
the financial crisis
of 2008.
MALE REPORTER:
Not in generations,
has Wall Street absorbed
the number of body blows
it took today.
Three of the five biggest
investment banks are gone.
The country's biggest
mortgage lender is gone.
ARIELY: We had politicians,
bank regulators
and even investors,
all influenced
by many factors.
Self-deception, social norms,
distance from money,
lying for the benefits
of other
and, of course,
conflicts of interest.
And this is what I think
corruption is all about.
It's about that when
you get into a system,
and something in the system
tells you that things
are wrong there,
all of a sudden,
you abandon your
own moral fiber.
And because of that,
we really need
to figure out
what can we do about it?
How can we get people
to behave better?
Because if we don't,
we're just going to get
more and more disasters
like the one we've
just experienced.
(CRICKETS CHIRPING)
(MANGALAVATHY
SPEAKING IN ENGLISH)
Our founder
was always very keen
about character formation,
uh, for children,
more than making
them score marks.
Because when we sow that seed
when they're very young,
when they grow up,
it blossoms.
(CHILDREN CHATTERING)
So if anybody
wants to purchase
any stationery
or other things,
the first things is, uh,
they'll come and look
at the price list.
And they'll pick whatever
they wish to take.
And they'll put the rupees
inside that bowl,
and there will
be no monitoring.
They'll get it by themselves.
(SPEAKING TAMIL)
At first, people took
things without paying.
They took things like
pencils and erasers
But then the principal
repeatedly told us
during assemblies that
it would actually
create a big loss
in the future
and would hurt us.
(TILAGAVATHI IN ENGLISH)
This honesty is happening
everywhere in our
school environment now.
From the children
in higher grades,
the children in lower grades
also came to know
what is meant by honesty.
(SPEAKING TAMIL)
For people looking
at it superficially,
it appears to be
a shop for things.
But if you look deeply,
it teaches us honesty.
And it is an example of
the trust madam has in us
and the trust students
have in each other.
(SPEAKING TAMIL)
Even though
I know I can pick up
what I want without paying
I don't because
if we live without stealing,
without cheating,
without lying,
we can win in life.
Many of the experiments
that we have conducted
are about trying to find
ways to curb dishonesty.
We went to UCLA
and we asked
about 500 undergrads
to try and recall
the 10 Commandments.
NINA: We asked people
to write down as many
of the 10 Commandments
as they could remember.
And then we put
them in a situation
where they could cheat
with the matrix task.
How many of them
do you think recalled
all 10 Commandments?
MAN: Zero.
Zero, that's right.
(CHUCKLES)
By the way,
they invented lots
of interesting ones.
(AUDIENCE LAUGHING)
What happened after
people tried to recall
the 10 Commandments,
even if they
were unsuccessful,
nobody cheated.
It wasn't as if
the people who remembered
more commandments,
the people who are
presumably more religious,
cheated less,
and the people who
remembered almost none
of them, cheated more.
Nobody cheated.
NINA: It didn't matter
what religion
the participants had.
You know what the 10
Commandments are about.
They are about moral code,
they are about
proper behavior,
and just knowing that
and being reminded of that
decreases dishonesty.
In fact, even when we take
self-declared atheists
and asked them to
swear on the Bible,
they stopped cheating.
It is not about
heaven and hell
and being caught.
It's about reminding
ourselves about
our own moral fiber.
We found this result
to be very promising.
But we wanted to test it
in a non-religious context.
So, we went to MIT
and we did a similar
experiment with honor codes.
So we got students at MIT
to sign the honor code,
"I understand
that this short study
"falls under
the MIT Honor Code."
They did it, shredded
the piece of paper,
what happened?
No cheating whatsoever.
And no cheating
whatsoever
despite the fact
that MIT doesn't
have an honor code.
(LAUGHTER)
Then we replicated
the experiment
at Princeton.
Princeton has a very
strong honor code.
In fact, the freshmen
get a whole week of
a crash course on morality,
lectures, discussion.
Their a cappella
group has a song
on the honor code.
(SINGING)
It's an awful song,
by the way,
but they have it.
So we took
the Princeton students
signing the honor code
and not signing
the honor code,
the MIT students
signing the honor code
and not.
Was there any
difference? No.
When they did not
sign the honor codes
they both cheated
to the same level.
When they signed
the honor code,
none of them cheated.
I think this is
kind of a mixture
of good news and bad news.
The bad news is that
the crash course on morality,
particularly
the Princeton version,
doesn't seem to
have any effect
two weeks down the road.
The good news is that even
without a crash course
reminding people about
their own moral fiber,
does change
how people behave.
The fact that
we can change you
with these tiny,
tiny interventions
is actually at the heart
of behavioral economics.
It's this idea
that we think that
to change people's behavior
we need to
change a society
or change a culture.
And in fact, sometimes,
little, tiny tweaks
around the edges
can have big impacts
on what we do.
I feel that both,
in collaborating
with organization
as well as government,
we could make
a difference as scientists.
I think we could
design intervention
that would be helpful
in reducing
unethical behavior
at work as well as
in society, more broadly.
The Behavioural
Insights Team was set up
by the British government,
by Prime Minister
David Cameron in 2010
with the new
coalition government.
And the idea was to introduce
a more realistic model,
into, um, how people
actually make decisions,
and, um, what drives
their behavior,
and if we did that,
we'd make better policy.
It turns out a lot of
both tax and benefits
actually rest on honesty.
When we add one line into
our tax letter saying,
"Most people pay
their tax on time,"
it turns out,
not only is it effective,
it's also a nicer way
of encouraging
people to pay their tax
than just to threaten them.
We increased payment rates
from about 30% to about 35%.
Now, you could say
that's not very much.
No, it's not going
from 30% to 100%.
Or you could say,
"This is literally
just one line of text."
And suddenly
you're talking about
hundreds of millions
of pounds of revenue
brought forward to
your tax authority.
Once you start
turning the needle
in lots of different
places simultaneously,
you start to see the effects
build upon one another
and it starts to add up
to something quite profound.
Dishonesty is
sort of contagious
and we see this
in many contexts,
both in the real world
and in lab experiments.
It has an even wider
ramification which is,
how do you feel about
other people around you?
In the Scandinavian countries,
more than 60% of people
will generally say
most people can be trusted.
In other countries,
much of Africa
and South America,
it's often below 10%.
It's an enormous advantage
to live in a country
where there's
high social trust.
It turns out it boosts
economic growth.
When you build it
into an equation,
it's more important,
for example,
than levels of skills
in the economy.
We've been kind of
stumbling in the dark
with really naive models
of human behavior
built into policy.
Imagine what we can do
if we put even
a half-decent model
of how people behave
into, um,
what we do and how we design
our economies and societies.
How many people here
grew up in countries
outside of the US?
Please raise your hands.
Keep your hands up,
outside of the US.
Okay. And how many of you
think that people
in your country of origin
cheat less than Americans?
Less than Americans,
keep your hands up.
Canadian?
(LAUGHTER)
British?
British.
Yeah, of course.
(LAUGHTER)
British.
Anybody else thought
that they cheat less?
MAN: Tanzania.
ARIELY: Tanzania?
Are you joking?
(LAUGHTER)
I think you didn't
hear the question.
(LAUGHTER)
So, I grew up in Israel,
so the first place
I went to test was Israel.
I was sure
that the Israelis
would cheat more.
No, they cheat
just the same.
We tried Turkey,
China, Colombia,
South Africa, Portugal.
We tried Germany.
And in all of those
countries, we don't find
any real difference.
Now, how can it be?
We've all traveled,
we've all been to
different places,
and we all get
the feeling
that cheating
feels differently
in different places.
And here's the thing.
Our experiments are
general and abstract.
And because of that,
they capture
the basic human
ability to cheat
and feel good
about ourselves.
And from that perspective,
we're not different.
We're the same
the world over.
And for me this
is the big lesson.
It's not about being bad,
it's about being human.
And because of that,
it means that we all
need to think about
how do we protect ourselves
against our own bad behavior
and the bad behavior
of other people.
(SCREAMING)
We have much more to learn
and a lot to gain
from understanding
our ethical shortcomings.
When it comes to building
the physical world,
we seem to understand
our limitations.
We build things
like roads and bridges
to help us with
the things that
we can't do
perfectly on our own.
But when it comes
to the mental world,
we somehow forget the idea
that we're limited,
that we're fallible.
Science has some
starting points to help us
think about this.
It's not going to be simple,
but we all have
the capacity to build
a better, more ethical,
more honest world.
It took me a long time
to come to grips
with the fact that
I was gonna go to prison.
And it wasn't because
I didn't know
that I was guilty.
I mean, I knew
for sure that I was.
I knew that what I
had done is wrong,
and I wanted to make it right,
but what I couldn't
come to face with
was the consequences.
I had to fall on a sword
and let everybody know that
I'd basically screwed up
and I'd made some
terrible, terrible choices.
It really... I mean,
it destroyed my life,
to be honest with you.
I'm pretty honest now.
I'm about
like Honest Abe,
but I'm... (LAUGHS)
I try to tell the truth
about everything.
It's not like
there was one thing
where I said like,
"That was so wrong.
I'm never gonna do
that ever again. I'm done."
It's more like,
on everything that I did,
there were parts
that I didn't like
that bothered me
and those added up over time.
I regret it all.
I mean, because
I would like to be
honest with my girls
and tell them that I went
the higher route and
that I didn't cheat,
and that one wrong
doesn't make a right
and preach all that
to them, but I can't.
I mean, if my girls ask me
about my infidelity,
I'm gonna be honest with them
because it's who I am,
and I need to own it.
I used to think of
the world in terms of
good people and bad people.
And now I think of
the world as people.
(LAUGHS)
When I do
get out of jail,
my brother said
he will help me,
but I just don't know what
I'm gonna do at all. Uh...
I figured I'll have a lot
of time to think about that.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.