Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
If there's one word in the oil patch which makes everyone sit
up and pay attention, it's the word "blowout."
A blowout is simply an uncontrolled flow of gas or oil.
The gas begins to expand and work its way upward.
If not controlled, the gas bubble could cause a blowout.
Radio channel 1: Welcome to Good Morning West Texas with Betty King, brought to you by ...
Radio channel 2: The International Energy Agency says
the United States is going to pass Russia as the world's
top oil producer by the end of this year.
And a lot of that oil and natural gas as well comes from
West Texas, the Permian Basin it's called, where output has
tripled in the last three years."
Jerry Morales: Midland is on fire again.
It's definitely the land of opportunity as I've been saying lately.
We are seeing just about everything that's operable in Midland at capacity.
I have two restaurants, and at 11 o'clock, your staff, your
restaurant better be ready because those doors start swinging.
Today's definitely another boom, but we want this
one to be a sustainable, strong, thriving economy.
And we believe that that can be based on what we've been hearing
from the CEOs of the oil companies.
Convenience stores, hotels, the mall, everybody is busting at the seams.
Zach Toombs: So, the United States is in the middle of
really a new kind of fossil fuel boom.
And we're just starting to understand the impact that has.
I'm Zach Toombs. I'm a reporter at Newsy.
Over the past few years, we've seen oil and gas drilling in the
U.S. breaking all kinds of records, going way up.
The amount of oil produced in the U.S. has been climbing pretty consistently.
It just became the top producer in the world, over Russia, over Saudi Arabia.
On natural gas production, the U.S. has been at
the top for a while, and that's only going up from there,
just steadily rising.
That ramp up in production is partly due to new technology
in something called "hydraulic fracturing" or "fracking."
That's helped companies unlock this whole new
layer of oil and gas trapped inside shale rock.
Now once they get into that shale layer, they basically
inject water and chemicals to create cracks in the rock that
lets them pull up the oil and gas they find there.
That's helped create a new surge for oil and gas that the
industry calls the "Shale Revolution."
So it was fracking that made this boom possible,
but for the first time, it's really foreign demand and
exports, not U.S. demand, that's been driving all this new drilling.
More oil and gas has meant more money for the industry,
and in many places, it means more jobs and more tax
revenue for local governments.
But in places where drilling overlaps with where
people live, we know there's a health risk.
What we don't know is just how big of a risk it is, and for how many people.
This new fossil fuel boom brings up a lot of questions
about public health, about profits, and about the climate.
Our goal was to follow this oil and gas from
where it's pulled up out of the ground, to wherever it ends up
and see what the impact is.
But Newsy is just one of a few newsrooms, including
The Center for Public Integrity,
The Associated Press,
and The Texas Tribune,
all teaming up to dig into this fossil fuel boom to see what
caused it and what it means for the U.S. and for the world.
So I'm Kiah Collier.
I'm a reporter at The Texas Tribune.
I focus on energy and environmental issues.
We're trying to tell people about amassive oil boom
that's going on in West Texas and New Mexico in
an oil play called the Permian Basin.
This oil boom is by many measurements bigger than any oil boom before it."
Sharon: West Texas, our last frontier,
they're turning it into an industrial zone.
Zach: Oh yeah, I see it.
So you can't see it with the human eye, but through this
camera you can see through infrared.
So, that black plume that I'm seeing is methane. What else?
Sharon: Volatile organic compounds
like benzene, toluene, harmful chemicals that we don't
want to be standing here breathing.
Zach: So if we stand here long enough,
or for the people who live around sites like this,
what does that mean? What does that do?
Sharon: Well, it's going to be harmful to their health.
They could have upper respiratory issues, asthma.
I mean, it's the same health issues we see everywhere.
Zach: So just in the past year, what changes have you seen
from the oil and gas industry?
Sharon: They're just poking holes everywhere at a very frenzied pace.
And a lot of this is going to be exported to other countries.
We're sacrificing our air, people's health, their quality of life,
so that the oil and gas industry can ship overseas the
oil and gas and make a profit.
Industry can go into an area and put an oil and gas facility literally in someone's backyard.
And when they start having health impacts or they just
complain about these horrible odors all the time, we can take
this camera and show them that it actually is the oil and gas
industry, and they can't deny it, because seeing is believing.
So we're holding the industry and the regulatory agencies accountable.
Zach: Environmental organizers like Sharon Wilson
take that footage and show it to state regulators
to try and get them to take some action around these emissions.
Wherever we see these underground layers of shale oil
and gas, we see more drilling and emissions. That's the case
in Texas, but also in states like New Mexico and Colorado.
And state air monitoring across all of them is pretty spotty.
So, as this new drilling boom has ramped up,
we're seeing citizens like Sharon Wilson going out into the field to monitor,
but we're also seeing some scientists at federal agencies,
like NOAA, which studies the atmosphere,
also going out into the field and really filling in
the gaps in monitoring emissions.
OK, well this is the notch.
So, are we are ready to roll?
Gaby Petron: We are like detectives.
We drive around the oil and gas field and we are looking at
real time readings of benzene. And when we see very big hits,
we investigate and look at what's upwind of us.
And that will tell us where there's a source of benzene.
So, my name is Gaby Petron. I work at NOAA
in the global monitoring division where we study
greenhouse gases globally, but we also look at regional
emissions of greenhouse gases and specifically in the past few
years have looked at methane emissions and volatile organic
compounds emissions from oil and gas operations.
From earlier work, aerial work, that we did in 2012,
we noticed that there's a lot of benzene over the oil and gas
field that's not accounted for in the state inventory.
So what we've been looking at in the past year is monitoring
levels of methane and other natural gas markers like ethane as well as air toxics.
As we are looking at well pads that are being drilled,
fracked and in early production phases.
So we saw definitely a plume from this pad with the flare.
Here we're going to be able to see the pollution
probably pooling and accumulating near the site.
We're looking at different types of gases that have different impacts.
When we look at a greenhouse gas like methane,
we're looking at decade-old to century to millennia impacts on climate.
That's the methane story. And when we look at even
smaller scales, closer to operations, we are interested in
understanding health impacts that are related to air toxics emissions.
Benzene is a known carcinogen. Some of the other gases
can be irritants to the lungs or the eyes and the throat,
so we have experts that are working with us that are
better able than us to relate the atmospheric ambient levels
that we detect with what the potential impacts are on
people's health.
Lisa Mckenzie: Colorado is one of the most prolific areas
of oil and gas development in the country.
One of our most active areas of oil and gas development is just
to the northeast of Denver.
I'm Lisa Mckenzie.
I've been studying the health effects and the health
implications of developing oil and gas resources
in residential areas for about 9 years now.
We now have quite a bit of data showing that the
oil and gas sites can emit hazardous air pollutants
like benzene, and there are quite a few studies out now that
show people with certain health effects are more likely to be
living near these oil and gas sites.
And some of these health effects are associated with these chemicals.
They include things like childhood leukemia
and pre-term births and some other adverse birth outcomes.
The data on the health effects of benzene in human populations is pretty clear.
That's from occupational studies that have been done.
What we found was that people living closest to the well sites
and within 500 feet of the well sites
had a higher risk for chronic and acute health effects.
Respiratory effects and neurological effects are the
main health effects that we would expect to be associated with these air pollutants.
Their cancer risk was eight times EPA's upper threshold for cancer risk.
So what we'd like to know is really what the level of
benzene is that people are being exposed to in their homes.
Zach: Now we know these emissions are coming
off of any site that's actively pulling up oil and gas,
like a rig, or a pumpjack, or a site that's flaring.
And we know these emissions can make people sick.
So the big question for us was, if we take the research on
high-health-risk areas around drilling and compare that to
U.S. Census data on where people live, how many people could be at risk?
We found data on where these wells are across the country.
Now this is the first time that anyone has compared the growing
research on health risks around drilling to population data at this scale.
The studies we're looking at show the health risks start to
increase for people living within 2,000 feet of a drill site.
Then there's that higher-risk zone for cancer within 500 feet.
Our new analysis estimates more than 1.4 million people
live in that zone nationwide.
We see that drilling overlaps with population in states all over the country.
That includes Texas, where we estimate as many as 480,000
people live within that 500-foot high-risk zone.
And it includes Colorado, where we estimate 27,000 people live in that zone.
Now, there are rules that are supposed to protect people from this kind of thing.
They're called "setback" rules, and they
determine how close drilling can come to where people live.
But they're set at the state and local level, so they're
different all over the country.
Now both Midland, Texas and the state of Colorado
have setback rules that are supposed to keep drilling
at least 500 feet away from where people live.
But there are loopholes.
So for example, a company can get an exception from a local
government that lets them drill closer.
Or old wells can be grandfathered in.
So that's part of the reason why there could be more than
1 million people nationwide living in that high-risk zone.
Basically, the "Shale Revolution" has changed drilling
and put a lot of new drills into residential areas.
But from state to state, the rules on setbacks and other
safety measures haven't changed with the times.
And that can put people in a dangerous spot.
Tearsa Larson: It was a beautiful home on a corner lot
with mountain views.
Kyle Larson: We were a little hesitant at first because we
hadn't lived out of town before like that and once we got up
there I think we really enjoyed that feeling of being out of
town, not so much in the congestion that goes on.
Tearsa: So we were all living up there.
Myself and Kyle and Juan and Amber and Gabriella, my
grandbaby, who was, when she moved in, almost 2.
When we moved up to Frederick, we actually had Amber's baby shower up there.
It was really beautiful and small town, really quiet, peaceful.
Then we started getting notices about them fracking up there.
And that's kind of where it all started.
And that fracking site went up so fast. It was really fast.
We thought, "Wow, it's really close to our house,"
but, you know, we really didn't think that much about it.
Kyle: Tearsa would call me almost every night and tell me
just how absolutely miserable it was to live across the street
from an active fracking site.
Tearsa: There'd be this really strong smell in the air
and it would make me have headaches.
I don't know if you've ever smelt like really strong nail polish remover?
That's kind of how it smelled. Just like a really strong, sweet
kind of smell. It was weird.
So Amber, she had been calling in at work because she was having headaches a lot.
That was in September because she was diagnosed September 9th of 2014.
They had us all come in and they said she had 2 weeks to live.
Her bone marrow was 90% full of Leukemia cells.
And I just walked out and I went outside of the hospital, and I
just sobbed because I knew it was bad.
Amber Gonzalez: It was kind of hard to really just kind of
let any of that sit in, because you know, I thought, I have a
really young daughter, you know that's all I really thought about.
Is my kid going to grow up without a mom?
And that's not what I wanted.
Sorry.
That's where they decided to do their fracking,
and this is where we lived right across the street from it.
We moved in September 2013. And then we lived up there until
about September of 2014.
So my health problems started in early September if not later August.
I started noticing more things, like I was getting bruises,
and I was becoming really tired. My bones really hurt.
I was 29 when I was diagnosed.
And the doctor up there said it was, you know, interesting
because this is an old man's cancer. You know?
That's what they call it. Because it's AML. It's Acute Myeloid Leukemia.
Tearsa: It was a couple nights, I think,
after she was diagnosed. I was sitting up at night,
and I just Googled AML. And benzene came up.
And I was just like, I knew. I don't think I could have anybody
convince me anything else other than that it was where we lived.
Amber: I never felt sick or anything until this came around.
I've been back at my job for a year and a half now.
I still have a lot of somewhat issues.
And there's things that can pop up at any time,
but I feel way better than what I did before.
And I'll take it. You know? I'll take it.
Kyle: Nobody knows anything about how many people are getting sick.
That to me is one of the biggest tragedies here is that nobody
knows for sure on any of this.
So not knowing, you grab what you can.
OK, let's make them be further away until we do know.
Amber: I really do think they should be set back.
They shouldn't be in our neighborhoods. It's just too much of a risk.
Tearsa: They should have to be 2500 feet back.
I don't even know if that's far enough.
Zach: Following American fossil fuel means following this
expanding network of pipelines across the country.
And a lot of those pipelines end up at the Gulf Coast.
Now, the production boom has been big, but the boom in
exports has been even bigger.
Out of the increase in U.S. oil and gas production over the
past few years, virtually all of that has been sold and shipped abroad.
Terminals along the coast that used to be for importing
have switched to exporting.
So that makes the Gulf Coast really a launching
point for American fossil fuels headed overseas.
Eddie Martinez: Now, what you're going to see behind you here is
what we call Refinery Row. You got 3 major refineries here.
You have Valero, you have Citgo and you have Flint Hills,
part of the Koch family.
Zach: So this port is playing a big role in the global changes
in the energy market right now.
Eddie: We are. You know, our customers are
setting the stage to be global players.
Matthew Garcia: As far as raw crude oil, the Port of
Corpus Christi is number 1 by a significant margin.
Eddie: Not since the 1950s have we been a net exporter of energy
in the America. Now this port alone is producing over half its
volume of export crude to international markets.
So we're, you know, creating not only a numerous amount of jobs
but sending all our energy to overseas markets.
Zach: Cheniere is building a facility here.
Can you talk about that shift from import facilities to export
facilities over the past couple years?
Matthew: The demand for natural gas across the world is
tremendous and it's only going to keep getting bigger.
When the LNG facility, Cheniere, comes online here in the next
coming several months, we're going to be able to actually
start moving those LNG to those markets, into Europe into Asia.
Eddie: So the region you see here is kind of this blank canvas if you will.
This is where most of the major entities, energy companies,
mid-streamers are looking to develop. In this particular area.
Zach: So just like in West Texas, the fossil fuel boom here
brings a lot of new jobs, almost 800 just in Corpus Christi alone.
And then there are thousands of temporary jobs
to build out all these new facilities.
But just like around drilling, there's really another side to the success story.
Because for decades, refineries and processing plants all along
the Gulf Coast have put out a similar mixture of greenhouse gases and air toxics.
And as exports have ramped up, so has activity at these refineries.
Port Arthur is one of the towns surrounded by these refineries,
and here the health impact is well-known.
It has a cancer rate 40% higher than the rest of Texas.
Hilton Kelley: "This was Burger King.
This is the Burger King structure. Old school Burger King.
Let me have 10 shrimp. The boiled shrimp. And two crab.
And what else come with that? That about it?
Yeah, let me have the corn and sausage. Alright, see that.
Look at that. Don't that look good?
Zach: That looks great.
Hilton: Very tasty.
Zach: So you grew up in Port Arthur?
Hilton: Grew up here. Born and raised. Right here in Port Arthur.
Grew up going crabbing. I remember what it smelled like here.
It always smelled like rotten eggs.
You know, the odors.
Zach: So you grew up with those emissions?
Hilton: Oh yeah.
Zach: With that rotten egg smell?
Hilton: Mhmm.
But we didn't think twice about it because it was just the norm.
When I came back home from the military after I got out in 1984
downtown Port Arthur was dilapidated.
We had white flight out of Port Arthur I think in the late '70s.
Zach: Did you notice something was off when you saw people
with cancer, people with respiratory problems?
Hilton: Oh yeah. Once I met Mister Alfred Dominic
and I had went to a couple meetings he had invited me to
that was dealing with environmental justice, he said
'What these plants are dumping into the air is impacting our air quality, it's killing us.
Because they're dumping sulfur dioxide into the air,
they're dumping benzene.'
And I told him, I said, Well I always knew that it stunk,
that it didn't smell good. But I didn't know just how bad it was.
And he said, 'Yeah, what you smell is poison.'
So you're telling me benzene is a carcinogen?
1,3-Butadiene is a carcinogen?
And yet it's all in our air in tons every day.
Alright, we're going to go ahead and hook it up now.
Alright, it's the one that goes inside this one. You got it?
Every chemical has a fingerprint,
and the computer that it's hooked up to is able to identify
exactly what that particle is and how many parts per million
is coming through that light at any given time.
Ordinarily, what we would pick up on the UV Hound is
sulfur dioxide, that's always a big one,
benzene, which is a known carcinogen.
This helped me to raise the alarm and show that
we at least have a problem whenever I'm able to pick up
some readings and then it puts the state into high gear to come
in and either prove me right or prove me wrong.
That's Prince Hall housing project.
Zach: And just a few hundred feet behind us,
industry row.
Hilton: Right, thousands and thousands of barrels
of oil per day have been produced there since the '60s.
Zach: And this refinery is one of the biggest?
Hilton: That is the largest oil refinery
in the northern hemisphere, Motiva.
Once that bitumen is processed here,
it's processed to be sent overseas.
It's not processed here to benefit U.S. citizens whatsoever.
Many of the people in this area are moderate to low income,
and that's rightfully so because there's not a lot of folks
that want to live next to oil and gas productions.
Because it stinks, it's not healthy, and we all know it.
If you're gonna have clean-burning gasoline,
and the only way you get gasoline is from crude oil,
all the impurities that came out of that crude oil has to go somewhere.
We're the sacrifice zone.
Those impurities are going into my air, my grandkids air,
my grandmother's air. And everybody in this town.
Port Arthur, Texas is considered the sacrifice zone.
Zach: So on the drilling side of this fossil fuel boom,
it was really new technology that helped kick that off.
But it's a different kind of innovation that's allowed
companies to start exporting all this natural gas overseas.
That's the process of turning natural gas, which is,
obviously, a gas, into a liquid.
Basically by making the gas really cold, they're able to
liquify it and pack a lot more of it into containers that can
be sold and shipped abroad as Liquefied Natural Gas, or LNG.
Now, when people talk about the oil and gas industry's impact on
climate, they're usually talking about carbon dioxide, or CO2.
Natural gas puts out a lot less CO2 than other fossil fuels,
which is something that the companies producing and selling
natural gas and LNG like to talk about, a lot.
Ad 1: This energy source carries tremendous benefits for
consumers and the environment.
Ad 2: It's plentiful, secure, and all-American.
Ad 3: Think of gas molecules as tiny, powerful, transparent wizards.
Zach: But natural gas is not magic.
Yes, it produces less CO2 than coal,
and less than gasoline from crude oil.
But it puts out a lot more of a different kind of greenhouse gas
called methane, which natural gas is almost entirely made out of.
Methane only makes up about one-tenth of
global greenhouse gases, but it's 25 times more powerful than
CO2 at trapping heat.
And a 2018 study actually showed that methane leaks from
natural gas production were 60 percent higher
than the U.S. government thought they were.
And that can have a big effect on the world's climate.
Gaby Petron: Greenhouse gases are gases that are in the
atmosphere, and they are able to absorb heat and re-emit heat.
So they act like a blanket that you put around the earth
and the more greenhouse gases that you
have in the atmosphere, the thicker the blanket.
They are trapping the heat that the earth's surface
is emitting towards space.
Since pre-industrial times, CO2 levels have increased
in the atmosphere by almost 50% so we've gone from
280 ppm pre-industrial to 406 ppm in 2018.
When you look at Methane it's even a bigger increase.
We've gone from less than a ppm to around 2 ppm methane now.
The levels we are seeing now, especially in terms of CO2,
have not been seen since 3.6 million years ago.
We can say that you know about 3 quarters of the climate change
we are experiencing today and will experience can be
attributed to an energy system that is reliable on fossil energy.
2016, just 2 years ago, was the warmest year on record.
The past 4 decades have been the warmest in modern times and
we've seen that every decade in the recent past has been warmer
than the previous one.
We have optimistic scenarios in terms of climate change
mitigation which call for a quick reduction in greenhouse gases,
especially CO2 emissions.
And there are some scenarios that are business as usuasl
where the emissions are kept unabated and we see that
there's a very big difference in what the final result will be.
So in this next scenario, that's business as usual where there is
no abatement in greenhouse gas emissions at all, we are way
beyond 10 degrees Fahrenheit.
And these are huge increases for society and ecosystem to
react to and adapt to in such a short time.
So everything is pretty much getting very, very dark here.
Announcer: Ladies and gentlemen,
welcome to the 27th World Gas Conference!
U.S. Energy Secretary Rick Perry: We're bearing witness to
this astonishing energy miracle.
Jie Jenny Zou: This huge boom is unique in that it's really,
you know, about this new market place.
When you're really looking at places like West Texas, the
Permian Basin, also New Mexico, you're really talking about a
boom that is serving exports.
This is oil and gas that is being sent abroad, overseas.
I'm Jenny Zou. I'm a reporter at The Center for Public Integrity.
I report on the environment, specifically climate change,
and the fossil fuel industry.
So it's, you know, 1973.
You've got the Arab Oil Embargo Crisis.
And basically what this led to was a shortage of
fuel in the United States.
You had gas prices surging. You had these long lines at the gas stations.
It basically leads to this whole movement to conserve crude oil.
So by 1975, you've got Congress essentially putting in place a
ban on crude oil exports.
It was all about conserving what you have
for the American people.
And for decades it kind of went unchallenged until around 2008
when fracking really took off.
And that's the only time when you start to hear the oil and
gas groups like the American Petroleum Institute start to
suggest that this old ban that was put in place back in the
1970s, maybe you should throw it out.
So around 2013, you see maybe under a dozen companies lobbying
on the crude oil export ban.
And then a year to two years later, that number grows
to 300 lobbyists on this, sort of converging on Capitol Hill.
But you also had a lot of people in the Obama administration who
also pushed for it.
Energy Secretary Ernest Moniz, which was an Obama appointment,
you know, he was one of the first people after the
American Petroleum Institute to also say the crude oil export
ban was, you know, this old relic of the past,
and it's sort of outdated, and shouldn't we rethink this policy.
They wanted to keep their climate legacy, but they
also still wanted to keep the drilling going, because the
Obama administration was so gung ho about natural gas.
And in order to get natural gas, you also get oil.
So you kind of had to have both.
People on the Hill, you know, Senator Murkowski,
Senator Heitkamp, both from oil drilling states,
insert a provision in that year's budget that would
essentially undo decades of this ban on crude oil exports.
And it makes the U.S. part of the global energy marketplace
in a way that it's never been before.
And it's also a great business opportunity
because you're talking about profits, and you're talking
about a handful of companies that are able to
export this stuff to countries abroad.
The U.S. government has essentially become a pitchman
for the global natural gas industry.
And you've got folks like
Energy Secretary Rick Perry visiting India,
visiting Poland, and going to these countries and
essentially telling them, 'You should buy American natural
gas,' helping essentially a handful of companies that are
the only ones right now that can actually export natural gas.
And the company that benefits a lot from this is Cheniere."
Tyson Slocum: Its largest shareholder is
a billionaire named Carl Icahn.
Hi, I'm Tyson Slocum. I'm the director of the energy
program with Public Citizen.
Carl Icahn not only is an active investor and owner of critical
fossil fuel infrastructure, but for almost a year
served as a top adviser to the president of the United States
on energy and regulatory policy.
So there is a lot of financial benefit to Carl Icahn's LNG
export company to the initiatives that Trump has announced.
We've seen Carl Icahn's company join Trump administration
officials on excursions to China,
where an agreement was made to facilitate
more liquefied natural gas exports from Louisiana to China.
By emboldening the oil and gas industries, you're increasing
their ability to finance more lobbyists and make sure that
U.S. energy policies are oriented towards the
self-interest of the oil and gas industry.
The fear that I have is that we are looking at investment and
government policy decisions today to build out natural gas
infrastructure to stick around for the next 40 or 50 years.
And once you build new pipelines, the owners of those
new pipelines do not want to see those pipelines become
irrelevant in just a few years.
Zach: So it was the Obama administration that lifted the
export ban and opened the door for U.S. oil and gas being sold abroad.
But it's truly been the Trump administration that has
taken this fossil fuel boom to a whole other level.
President Donald Trump: We're here today to usher in a new
American energy policy. One that unlocks millions and millions of
jobs and trillions of dollars in wealth.
Powered by new innovation and technology we are now on the
cusp of a true energy revolution.
Zach: From the start Trump surrounded himself
with energy advisers who owned parts of the oil and gas
industry and stood to profit from weaker regulations.
People like Carl Icahn and Harold Hamm.
And the administration just started going through all these
regulations the industry didn't like,
either pushing them off or getting rid of them completely.
One of the biggest changes was that they made it a lot easier
for energy companies to release methane
and other emissions into the air.
Now that saves companies time and money because they
don't have to monitor their emissions as much, but it
also ups the risk for problems with public health and climate.
The Trump administration has also been aggressively selling
oil and gas abroad, especially from Cheniere, whose profits are
up more than 10 times over the past few years.
And as more money comes in for the oil and gas industry,
these companies put more money out into political battles
all across the country.
At the federal and state level, these companies are putting a
lot of money into fighting regulations.
And usually, they win.
John Elway: Colorado's all about people.
Friends and neighbors, family and community.
We're all together in making this a great place to live.
Proposition 112 is going to hurt everyone acrossed our state.
It will eliminate as many as 43,000 jobs in the first year alone.
Let's come together to protect Colorado.
Join me in voting no on 112.
Heidi Henkel: Hello! How are you?
Neighbor: Good!
Heidi: Hey Chris!
Hey, Bob! How are you?
Bob: I'm doing fine. How are you?
Heidi: We can just stay out here really quick.
We're just stopping by.
We're just walking around letting people know
about the setbacks for oil and gas
that's going to be on the ballot.
Have you heard of the?
Neighbor: The 2500 foot?
Heidi: Yeah, 2500-foot setbacks.
Today, I believe I have 38 doors to hit.
Proposition 112 provides a 2500-foot buffer between
homes, schools, and water sources and any new oil and gas
drilling in the state of Colorado.
We made it a statewide ballot initiative to protect all people,
not just here in Broomfield, not just in Weld County,
not just in Eerie but statewide.
Neighbor: You know I've thought something about the
health aspects but I guess the economic side is the part
where things are a bit more wishy washy.
So I want to make sure I have the facts on that part.
Neighbor 2: You have the full support of this household
and we will vote.
Heidi: Thank you. Awesome. Thank you.
Neighbor 3: When does voting start?
Heidi: Umm, early October.
Thank you! Bye.
Neighbor 4: Go Broncos!
Heidi: Yes! Woo!
Heidi: You ready to rock your Tuesday?
Gonna do your spelling test today?
Maybe right before your test look at the ones you had a
hard time on?
Alright, you go ahead, bean. It's exhausting
fighting a billion-dollar industry.
I'm hoping that we're serving not just Coloradans
but those around the world.
You know, fossil fuels needs a clear boundary put around them.
Otherwise they won't put boundaries on themselves.
Anchor 1: I'm Mitch Jelniker with the latest from Denver 7.
The polls are open for this year's midterm election.
Voters in Colorado will be deciding on 13 initiatives.
Anchor 2: Oil and gas development is one of the
bigger items on this year's ballot.
112 in particular would increase the distance new drill
rigs need to be from homes and schools.
Anchor 3: Let's break this down for you.
A yes vote on Prop 112 means you want to increase the setback for
new wells to 2500 feet from homes, schools,
hospital buildings and also "vulnerable" areas.
A no vote keeps these regulations the same.
Heidi: It is a long one this year.
Yes on 112 for safer setbacks for oil and gas.
I've been waiting quite a few months to fill that bubble out.
How's that feel?
Heidi: That felt really good.
Are you going in to vote?
Voter: Trying to drop off a ballot somewhere.
Heidi: Oh yeah. OK. Here's this too, in case.
Ryan Luby: So we are at the No Against Proposition 112 event.
Millions of dollars have been spent by largely this group of
people to try to defeat this proposition.
I think this is a referendum on the oil and gas industry, at
least in this state and how it interacts with our communities.
Oil and gas is in a lot of ways the backbone, or at least
historically one of the backbones of Colorado's industry.
Dany Haley: If Proposition 112 were to pass,
what's at stake economically are good paying jobs,
up to 147,000 jobs possibly lost over the next 11 years.
Ryan: It would create half mile setbacks in every direction
around anything that's considered vulnerable,
basically preventing new oil and gas development on more than
80 percent of non-federal land here in Colorado.
Dan: So, I think this is one of the biggest issues our industry
faces in the coming years.
It's really incumbent upon our industry to make sure that
communities and neighborhoods understand our commitment to
safety and to develop this resource cleaner and better and
safer than anywhere in the country.
Ryan: Talking with some of the industry folks
who are here, they acknowledge that even if they win tonight
and this proposition is defeated,
there are going to have to be some hard conversations
within the industry of how do we prevent something like this
from happening again?
What do we need to do to be a better neighbor for our state?
Heidi: Do we know the numbers for 112, John?
Patty would you mind looking up 112? Do you know the numbers?
I know we're not winning. The measure needed 50% to pass.
We made it to 42. 16-point difference.
It looks like we're losing, which is to be expected I think
with how many millions of dollars they had.
But I was just telling someone else that this is just the beginning.
I'm hoping that they'll take a closer look as to
what can actually happen.
It's not as safe as they think it is.
Right now I know I'm sad we lost but at the same time
it's a huge win for Colorado and the awareness that we have.
Zach: All this new oil and gas is moving out of the Gulf Coast
at a record-breaking pace.
And that's actually led the Panama Canal to open up a whole
new set of locks, basically expanding this U.S.-to-Asia
trade route to make room for more liquified natural gas.
Silvia de Marucci: Do you see any crocodiles today?
Zach: Any what?
Silvia: Any crocodiles?
Zach : No, I haven't seen any crocodiles.
Silvia: Sometimes we get some alligators in there.
Zach: Really? They want to go from the Atlantic to the Pacific? Or vice versa?
Silvia: Yes, and they don't want to pay tolls.
They go for free.
We were not in an oil-producing area until the U.S. discovered
this Shale Revolution and all these techniques to extract
the gas from the rocks.
I would say that now we are very relevant for that particular
trade between the US and Asia.
Zach: What are the trends that you've seen in
LNG coming through the Panama Canal?
Silvia: After the contracts with the Asian companies began to
kick in, then we saw a lot of volumes going to South Korea,
which is probably the major destination through the Panama Canal,
Japan, and we see China surging, buying more and more each time.
So I would say main destinations South Korea, China, Japan.
Just to give you an idea, in 2017, I think we had about
6 million tons of natural gas transiting the canal.
And we haven't finished 2018 yet,
but we are probably going to double that volume this year.
Zach: The path of American oil and gas
now stretches all over the world.
Outside of North America, most of the biggest buyers
are in Asia.
That includes South Korea, China, Japan, and India,
where US Energy Secretary Rick Perry helped close a deal to
send Cheniere's natural gas for the next 20 years.
So here's why these global gas shipments really matter.
Long-term, the world's top polluters have to curb their
greenhouse gases to avoid the worst impacts of climate change.
Moving to renewable energy could do that.
And supporters of natural gas say that can be a sort of
"bridge" to that renewable shift.
But natural gas is still a fossil fuel,
and it still puts out these heat-trapping gases.
So if the world is going to hit its targets for curbing
greenhouse gases, that bridge can't be too long.
So now the countries trying to cut their greenhouse gases
have a choice: either a fast transition to renewable energy,
or the natural gas "bridge."
Shrikant Sabre: You can see the 4 arms directed toward the cargo.
Zach: So there are four arms connecting the jetty to the tanker.
So three for the liquid, and one for the vapor.
Shrikant: Yes, 1 for the vapor.
Zach: So here, tankers are coming in.
LNG is coming off the tankers.
Shrikant: We can say 3 to 4 cargo comes in a month.
Zach: Is that more than it used to be?
Shrikant: Yes.
Unloading activity has already started.
You can see they're decoupling the bolts.
Shrikant: We have reached it at the right time.
Zach: We're here at the right time, yeah.
They are right in the process of disconnecting the arms.
They've got two of them off.
Shrikant: This is the first time, I think, some media person
is capturing this moment.
Zach: Really?
Shrikant: Yeah.
Zach: So after the liquified natural gas is taken off
the tanker, it's put into your tanks here, you turn it
back into a gas and push it off to the rest of India basically?
Shrikant: Basically, we are sending a gas.
We are unloading LNG, liquified natural gas,
and we are sending gas to GAIL network.
Zach: So once it's converted back into a gas, then it's ready
to be sent through the pipelines to cities across the country.
Shrikant: Yes.
Zach: So it was about a 24-hour process to get the liquified
natural gas off the tanker. Now that's done.
Shrikant: Yes. The activity's over right now.
The next ship will be coming after a week.
Zach: India is buying American oil and gas and carrying
it across the country through pipelines, but the
government here is also doing something the U.S. isn't doing.
It's laying the groundwork for this huge buildup of solar energy.
Basically, India is betting on renewables for its future,
while the U.S. is building out all this new fossil fuel production.
But India has a population of 1.3 billion people and growing.
and it needs a quick alternative to the coal
that's polluting its largest cities.
So both the U.S. government and the global fossil fuel industry
is offering up natural gas as a solution.
Narendra Taneja: When it comes to power, electricity,
67% of electricity that we produce comes from coal.
Zach: Wow, so two-thirds?
Narendra: Is coming from coal, yes.
Natural gas in big cities in India is emerging as an alternative.
We are moving in the direction of LNG,
which means we're going to use LNG to fire our power plants,
we need LNG to run buses, public transport system.
A city like Delhi, Delhi's already running only on
natural gas, CNG, compressed natural gas.
Zach: So the buses that we see running around here.
Narendra: All buses, all three-wheelers,
all taxis are running on natural gas.
Zach: And more likely than not, that's imported natural gas.
Narendra: Yes. Let me put it this way.
Today when you look at India's energy mix,
it is roughly 90% fossil fuel.
67% of electricity that we consume is coming from coal.
But we know that by 2040, 2050, probably 50% of our energy
requirements are going to be met by renewables.
Zach: In a sense, it seems like natural gas is becoming the last fossil fuel.
Narendra: Yes, I think that's the right way to look at it.
Zach: So India is preparing for a sort of renewable future right now.
And how is it doing that? How is it incentivizing renewables?
Narendra: You see, very good question.
I think you know, we are a more complex country, but
we are very blessed when it comes to solar.
India's got the most aggressive, most ambitious renewable energy
plan, you know, in the world. Most ambitious.
Government has taken the lead.
So I expect that in 10 years from now this revolution,
which is a grassroots revolution,
the solar revolution, is going to surprise the world.
Zach: That's very different than what we're
seeing from U.S. political leaders right now.
Has India noticed the shift from the U.S. and how it's
approaching energy production? And how it's approaching
setting goals on emissions curbing and that sort of thing.
Narendra: Well, very good question.
You see, we used to look at the US,
but the developments in the US over the past few years
have been a bit disappointing.
For instance, shale is a game changer.
But the fact is that shale contaminates.
Zach: The air and the water.
Narendra: The air and the water, and the Earth.
It contaminates. When it comes to climate deal.
Paris Climate deal.
The United States has moved out of it, and India is
extremely disappointed by what President Trump has done.
We are committed to it for the sake,
simply because we care for the health of our people.
Zach: In recent years the US has really doubled down
on oil and gas production.
India's buying some of it, but what contrast do
you see there between how the US is building its energy future
and how India is building its energy future?
Narendra: You see, let's not forget one thing.
Energy, ever since the First World War, is 90% politics.
You can't take politics out of energy.
So there are no black and white pictures.
When I say that you know I'm disappointed with what the US is
doing in terms of pulling out of the climate deal or shale gas
contaminating air, water, earth and everything.
But at the same time the fact that the US is able to produce
more oil, more natural gas is good for us.
Good for emerging economies like India.
But at the same time in terms of carbon emissions and all that, it's bad.
But as I said, there is no black and white answer.
It's a mixed answer.
India needs every single source of energy you can think of.
India needs every source of energy you have available today.
India needs every source of energy that is going to come
on the table 5 years from now, 10 years from now.
Whether it is energy from space or is energy from gravity
or is energy from just sheer thought or whatever.
Zach: We saw American oil and gas drilled in Texas,
processed at the Gulf Coast,
shipped through the Panama Canal, and burned off in India.
But the path of fossil fuels doesn't end there.
The pipelines and terminals that the industry is building around
the world are meant to take oil and gas use
well into the 21st century.
Emissions are put into the atmosphere,
and global temperatures keep rising, which means
the next step in this process has the biggest impact.
Gaby: So there's a clear trend of warming around the world.
Over the ocean and over land.
Tropical storms and hurricanes feed on heat from the oceans.
And as the ocean is warming we see increased energy available
for tropical storms to grow in size but also in intensity of rainfall.
So as we are moving towards a warmer world
we expect more intense storms.
One key consequence of global warming is sea level rise.
So through thermal expansion, warm water takes more
space than cold water.
If emissions are not reduced fast we could see
a 1 meter to 2 meter increase in the sea level by the end of this
century without climate actions.
By 2100 with a middle of the road scenario emissions for
greenhouse gas emissions we are looking at 150 million people
being climate refugees due to their land and their homes
being now covered by the ocean.
Tasneem Siddiqui: "Bangladesh is identified as one of the most
affected countries of climate change related events.
In Bangladesh, already 4.7 million people has been
displaced due to effect of climate change.
From 2011 to 2050, 16 to 26 million people will be migrating
due to coastal erosion, riverbank erosion, flood,
drought and cyclone.
Our research found that 60% of those who move internally, due
to climate change or otherwise, they all come to Dhaka.
So when you think of this many people coming into Dhaka,
the main problem here is, the government or the state
doesn't have places to accommodate them.
Then their living condition if you think,
and their personal security, their family security,
all these things are in a mess.
Abu Siddique: The name of this neighborhood is Rupnagar Duaripara.
Not exactly downtown. It's a suburb.
Zach: Siddique can you tell me a little about this neighborhood?
Abu Siddique: Most of the people who are living here,
they are basically rickshaw pullers or some sort of
low-income job they are doing.
Zach: So it could be construction, it could be any
kind of manual labor work?
Abu Siddique: Yes manual labor.
Zach: So it's a lot of low-income people.
A lot of them moved here for environmental reasons?
Abu Siddique: Yes, this sort of neighborhood you'll find
in many parts of the city.
The number of people living in a slum in Bangladesh has increased
by 370-something percent.
Zach: So the number of people living in these
neighborhoods in Dhaka has grown by almost four times
what it was over 15 years. What are the big factors behind so
many people moving to these neighborhoods?
Abu Siddique: Basically, unemployment in their own hometown.
Her name is Kohinoor.
She along with her family came here from a coastal district, Bagerhat.
Zach: So how long have you lived in this neighborhood?
Zach: Salt water had basically covered the land that they were on.
Abu Siddique: Yes. Agricultural lands are totally barren.
Now there is no agriculture production.
No agriculture production means all their living means have been destroyed.
That's why they are now here, like many others.
Zach: A lot of the countries contributing the least to
climate change will feel the biggest impact.
But climate change will be felt by everyone,
including the top emitters of greenhouse gasses.
Sea level rise might seem like a slow-moving threat,
but scientists point to another effect of warmer oceans
one that's already being felt in the U.S.
Anchor: Hurricane Maria.
Anchor: Hurricane Florence.
Anchor: Hurricane Harvey.
Anchor: Hurricane Michael.
One of the worst hurricanes in American history.
The worst hurricane to ever hit the Florida panhandle.
Zach: More sirens.
Ralph Boone: Yeah, I hear that all night long.
Zach: So, this is where you work?
Ralph: Yeah. This is my job.
Zach: When did you find it like this? You walk over after the --
Ralph: Well we knew it was coming but we didn't
know what extent the damage was going to be.
And when I came up here, this is what we get.
I had another driver, one of my other drivers, he had to
leave his trailer because his trailer got blown away.
He came up here, him and his wife, and they go to the
back, the whole building on the backside collapses on them.
So they got out and went in their truck and sat down
and stayed there the whole night.
Zach: How long have you lived here?
Ralph: All my life. I'm 45 years old.
Zach: Is this as bad as you've seen it?
Ralph: This is the worst I've seen it.
This is the first time we ever had a storm this strong and this catastrophic.
This is the worst one I've ever been through in my lifetime so far.
Zach: Hurricane Michael hit 3 days ago and still
for almost 100 miles around there's no cell service, no
electricity, people are without gas.
We still don't know what the true death count is and all
along this section of the Florida panhandle there's just devastation.
Firefighter 1: Sir, I'm holding whats up?
Firefighter 2: I'm gonna check the second floor and see if it's clear.
Firefighter 1: Got it copy.
Firefighter 2: I don't see anything.
We've got to search every single thing.
Firefighter 1: I understand that.
Betty Rich: It was scary. Horrible.
The wind and the rain, I thought we were going to be gone.
It came so quick, people were just so thankful for us to be
able to open because they weren't prepared for this storm.
They're saying we may not get electricity for like a month.
Zach: And what do you think it's going to be like 2 or 3 weeks
from now when there's not electricity?
Betty: Huh, I don't know.
Zach: There's so much to deal with between the destruction
and the loss of electricity.
Some people are trying to rebuild what they have,
some people kinda just cut their losses and move.
What kind of reaction have you heard from people on both sides of that?
Betty: It's really going to be bad.
The two hospitals in Panama City are going to be down for 2
or 3 months and a lot of people here in Duff County work there
and in Panama City, and it's going to be devastating because
they're not going to have a job.
So they're gonna have to move or I don't know.
Zach: If we trust the scientific consensus,
in this century, we're on a path to 150 million climate refugees,
13 million just in the U.S. -- with jobs or homes destroyed,
whether it's by sea level rise, or more powerful wildfires, or storms.
And most of that climate change comes from how we produce energy.
Jenny: Climate has just kind of taken
a back seat to all of this.
This is coming at a time when you know we are supposed
to be trying as a global society to reach zero emissions.
Meanwhile you're building all this infrastructure
to support decades of natural gas and oil development, and
that pushes us way past 2050.
So we're kind of going in one direction, and all the
science tells us to go in the opposite direction.
Gaby: There's a wakeup call that needs to happen.
It seems that we've lost momentum.
The energy system that has brought us to where we are
today, that has given us a lot of improvements to our quality
of life is probably not the system we want to rely on to
make sure that our kids and our grandkids have a planet
they can live in down the road and for the generations to come.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.