Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
I liked the oil industry. I liked it because of its scale.
I like the huge, vast, wide open spaces that you work on.
Huge processes.
That's what I liked, thatโs what was interesting
and brought pleasure to me.
He made this decision himself. He decided to say it.
I am sure he didn't believe that Putin was so...
...petty.
He had already decided for himself
that he wouldn't be going anywhere, and if he were arrested, he'd do his time.
He's strange that way.
You need to speak in short sound bites.
They're gonna cut it, so you have to hurry.
My first phrase was...
please forgive me for quoting myself here...
What I've seen
allows me to claim that, obviously,
with 100% certainty,
this is an absolutely political case.
Khodorkovsky is accused of fraud and tax evasion.
Because he didn't hand himself in this morning, he has been summoned.
The richest man in Russia, Mikhail Khodorkovsky,
seized at gunpoint by Russian Special Forces...
US Khodorkovsky is locked up in an overcrowded Russian prison...
So, to stay out of prison, why didn't you leave the country?
I don't value my life that much
to exchange it for losing respect.
As for Khodorkovsky,
I have expressed my opinion on this on many occasions.
But if you want me to say more, I will.
I believe that a thief should sit in jail.
Khodorkovsky has been convicted of embezzlement by a court.
We're talking about tax evasion and fraud involving billions of rubles.
Let me remind you the Yukos security chief
is currently serving time for murder.
Do you think the security chief decided to carry out these crimes all by himself?
To hear Vladimir Putin tell it,
Mikhail Khodorkovsky is a villain in a real-life gangster movie.
But to Putin's opponents,
Khodorkovsky's ten years in a Siberian prison made him a hero
for the cause of human rights and democracy.
Now out of prison, Khodorkovsky is looking for a third act.
That drew my interest at a time
when we all seem haunted by Russia's role in the world.
So, I started a film about him.
Okay, Mikhail, any time.
While I could go to Russia, he could not.
He's wanted there for murder.
So, like so many stories about Russia these days, this one started in London.
If there were some opportunity for me to return today I would return.
London is nice but I'm a guest here, and I feel like a guest here.
I live Russia.
All that I do has to do with Russia.
Putin and Khodorkovsky, they are both very strong.
Right.
-Everyone else, weaker. -Yes.
But Putin...
respects Khodorkovsky as a rival.
He really respects him because he is strong.
What event in your life influenced you most?
An event in my life?
Yes.
I will try to respond seriously.
Perhaps... perhaps it was...
the collapse of the Soviet Union.
This is an adult answer, sorry, but you asked me an adult question.
I don't know to what extent you can imagine
the life of an ordinary Soviet person, an ordinary Soviet family.
My parents worked at the caliper plant.
My father was a design engineer and my mother was a technologist.
By Soviet standards, a family where both parents were engineers was very poor.
Up until I started earning money myself,
I understood perfectly well what it was like
to live without any money at all.
When I earned my first paycheck, I was 14 years old.
A team of young toughs stepped to me,
wanting to take my money.
It didn't even cross my mind to give them the money.
And to this day, I've got a scar on my arm
from when they tried to stab me with a knife.
I did not give my money.
I got into a supplementary chemistry school.
At home, I tried to create a little chemical lab myself.
I lived on Cosmonaut Street and right next to us was Rocket Boulevard.
And on Rocket Boulevard my father and I launched a rocket that I had built.
My dad was lucky he didn't get hit, but he was impressed.
All my life, I've been interested
in things that explode.
Why are you filming me without my permission?
Stalin?
What do you need Stalin for? He will have you shot!
Understand?
Just behind Red Square, there's a shopping mall
where actors get paid for posing in tourist photos
playing Russia's past leaders.
In the winter of 2018, I was told that the number of Stalins was multiplying.
The local joke was that this was a sign.
Russia was nearing the pageantry of election season.
18 MARCH 2018
There are contestants on the reality show Dom-2 that behave better than you!
Shut up stupid woman, shut up.
How are you talking to me?
How should I talk to her if she's dumb? She's got no brains!
Did you see that? She's an idiot! Get her out of here!
Well there is no election season.
There's election theater.
Calm down!
Who gave her the right to throw water at me?
The Kremlin has to create their own counter-candidates
because no one wants to be a candidate against Putin
because you will lose anyway.
Today's election theater is what has become
of Russia's experiment in democracy.
A bold attempt to shift from years of communist rule
to free-market capitalism.
In 1991, the Soviet Union was convulsed in a struggle over its future.
While old-guard communists clung to an empire
and a system of centralized government control,
a new generation demanded economic and political freedoms.
Their charismatic leader was Boris Yeltsin.
Yeltsin! Yeltsin! Yeltsin!
Boris Yeltsin has become the one rallying point
for opposition to the hardliners.
I was there as the BBC Moscow correspondent
from '88 through to the end of '91.
This is Martin Sixsmith.
Martin Sixsmith.
Martin Sixsmith.
BBC News Moscow.
Yeltsin was a very, very inspirational figure.
Back in 1991, he was the man for the moment.
Yeltsin! Yeltsin! Yeltsin!
It just felt like, you know,
a sort of sea change in the fortunes of a country.
The democratic process in the country
is becoming increasingly broad and irreversible.
The people of Russia are becoming masters of their destiny.
Let's stay strong!
Thank you.
I remember writing all these sort of great optimistic articles
about how decades of communism had come to an end
and now we were going to have a new Russia,
a new Russia with democracy and freedom and openness.
And looking back, I'm a little ashamed that I wrote all of that,
because the signs were there,
even then, I think, that it wasn't going to work out.
I still remember the shock.
The flag isn't red, there's a tricolor hanging there.
At that point, I realized that everything had changed.
We knew practically nothing about capitalism.
It was a jump off the cliff.
I had to consciously understand
whether I want to go with the path of the Old World,
or I reject it, and take the risk with Khodorkovsky.
Khodorkovsky was a man of great intelligence and great vision.
He was also a very decisive man.
As soon as a door opened, he was straight through it.
He'd been a member of the young communist organization, the Komsomol.
Not because he believed in communism,
but because Gorbachev in the perestroika era
started to relax the ban on private enterprise,
starting with the Komsomol.
By the time the collapse of the Soviet Union happened in 1991,
he had some cash in his pocket.
He created the first commercial bank in Russia.
I found a book: Commercial Banks of Capitalist Countries.
A fabulous book!
It described in great detail, on a simple level,
how a banking system works.
I said, "Hey, I like this."
"Okay. How can I create a bank?"
Are you a greedy person?
Definitely, definitely. Definitely.
I used to be less greedy, now I'm greedier.
It's a professional trait.
I have the personality of a banker. I'm greedy with money.
I just don't understand how people can exchange those pretty bills
for some crappy goods.
I think one must save, store, and multiply money.
For me, business was just a game.
Who wants to play, plays.
Who doesn't want to play does something else.
Khodorkovsky said: "I thought of this all as a game.
And I was good at playing the game."
Exactly! He was good at playing the game
but most people were very bad at playing the game.
Moving from the Soviet Union into capitalist Russia,
most Russians were completely naive
because they had read all this propaganda
for all these years that capitalists were people with, you know,
big cigars and money coming out of their pockets.
And they imagined that you would get rich automatically.
When they grew up, everything was taken care of by the state.
You know, free economy sounds nice,
but you have to make choices every five minutes.
In the early '90s, Russians faced lots of choices
they didn't really understand.
Egged on by American free market boosters,
the Russian government announced a program
to hand out a chit worth around 40 dollars to every citizen.
The chits were called vouchers and could be traded, sold for cash,
or exchanged for shares in smaller state-owned enterprises.
They were sold as golden tickets to escape the dead end of communism.
You aren't hurt? What's the rush?
What is this?
Oh, my, you're rich!
Voucher!
Friend of privatization measures!
At first sight it's modest, simple, but really it's gold!
Mine!
Vow-ow-ow-ow
Vow-ow you are my love.
Now I, a naughty boy,
am not afraid of ruble rate changes!
The meaning is simple!
Vow-ow-ow-ow my darling!
The last three vouchers, 4.50.
Vouchers for sale.
We started buying up these vouchers because they were in free circulation.
Then, with these vouchers, we would take part in auctions
for the sale of enterprise shares.
That's how privatization worked.
It was a time of great economic hardship
and the ordinary people didn't realize what this piece of paper was worth.
But the people who did sent out people with suitcases full of cash
and they said: "Look, you don't need that piece of paper!
Here, we'll give you ten dollars and you can go and buy some bread."
I wasn't saying, "I'll give you three rubles,"
and then I give you one instead.
That's not what happened.
I said, "I'll give you three rubles. It's up to you to sell or not.
If you can sell it right now for the price of a Volga car, great!
If you can't, I've only got three rubles for you."
So a beggar person
is a beggar only because they don't want to work, am I understanding correctly?
Well, let's say that the society doesn't react to it that much yet,
but mainly because beggars consider it a more advantageous occupation.
Mikhail Borisovich asked us to attract people of high professional caliber.
That is how we acquired Platon Lebedev.
He was a young but prominent economist.
We bought about 100 substantial enterprises.
We had to fight for each of them, as the competition was high.
We stood firm on our feet by then.
The more Khodorkovsky made,
the more vouchers and companies he could buy,
either on the open market or in backroom deals.
It was gangster capitalism,
with a rule of law as weak and bendy as a rubber band.
Under communism, the absence of personal wealth
meant that there were few targets for violent criminals.
Now, organized crime groups prey on the new rich of the capitalist era.
Moscow has become the murder capital of Europe.
If you were rich, and people knew you were rich, you were a target.
It was Wild West capitalism.
In America, Wild West lasted for many decades.
In our country, we managed to fit it into seven years.
Now watch closely.
I got it. I got the shot on camera.
In '92, we launched The Moscow Times and we had a lot of news.
A lot of people got killed and many, many companies were looking for protection.
The Moscow Times developed pretty well
and then two years later, I launched Cosmopolitan,
which from day one was an enormous commercial success
and that attracted a lot of shady people.
I thought, you know, maybe it's better
to get one of these rising oligarchs as a shareholder.
There was one guy in particular that I got interested in.
And that was Mikhail Khodorkovsky.
He moved to a very fancy castle in Moscow.
Machine guns all over the place.
He had former KGB colonels running his security.
This was not Russia. This was Khodorkovsky land, you know.
Lebedev had a nice house.
Nevzlin was next door.
And then there was Khodorkovsky.
I said, " The Moscow Times is a fiercely independent newspaper.
And if we sell ten percent of our shares,
we want to remain a fiercely independent newspaper."
And he thought about it, and he said yes.
He was an extremely intelligent person,
but of course, using every trick in the book available to him.
And at that time,
this transition from communism to capitalism,
was so fast that it was impossible for the legal structure to keep up.
In Russia, laws are kind of an iffy question.
There is even a popular saying in our country.
The strictness of Russian laws is compensated for
by the lack of obligation to follow them.
Boris Berezovsky, who was one of the big seven oligarchs,
very famously said,
"The seven of us controlled 50 percent
of the whole Russian economy."
Two of the Oligarchs placed big bets on the future of television.
Boris Berezovsky bought a national network called Channel 1.
He thought he would cash in by turning a Soviet propaganda vehicle
into a selling machine.
Vladimir Gusinsky set his sights on starting a new network called NTV.
NTV PRESENTS
The original concept of NTV was a TV channel
which is not controlled by the government.
An investor was found who was Vladimir Gusinsky.
He didn't know anything about TV at all but there was a benefit.
He badly underestimated how much it would cost.
Gusinsky spent hundreds of millions of dollars buying movies,
launching game shows
and building an independent news division from scratch.
Thanks to the Soviets, almost everyone in Russia had TV sets
so the money started rolling in.
The oligarchs organized between themselves,
"I do the oil, you do the telecommunications,
you do the real estate." So, it was one big scam.
For the oligarchs, the scam of Russian capitalism was only possible
as long as there was a political system
that protected private property and individual rights.
Call it democracy.
But if the communists returned to power,
well, that would have been bad for business.
Yeltsin was up for re-election,
but the country was in a really, really, bad state.
People looked around,
"If this is, you know, the capitalism that they promised,
we don't want anything to do with it."
The government coffers were empty,
so people's salaries weren't being paid, pensions weren't being paid,
and if you imagine, as a president,
who's not paying people's pensions and people's salaries,
you're not going to be very popular.
It really did look as if Gennady Zyuganov, the communist leader,
was going to beat Yeltsin hands down at the election.
At that time, I was speaking to Zyuganov, and he said,
"Mikhail Borisovich, we respect you,
and if we win, you will become a general director.
But the ownership of the enterprise, excuse me,
is going to be state ownership."
I said, "Okay, Gennady Andreyevich.
We'll work to ensure that you don't become president."
The problem was that Yeltsin at that point was so weak.
He was at a three percent approval rate.
He was sick, he had all these heart attacks, he was down and out!
One of the very new things which NTV started doing
was a puppet show called "Kukly."
It was a really scathing, satirical-- Satirical show.
Kiss me
Kiss me a lot
In one of the shows, Mr. Yeltsin was portrayed as Don Quixote
and the head of his security was portrayed as his Sancho Panza.
It's not Russian tradition to laugh at the president.
Laughing at, at the tsar , so to say,
at the emperor, was something unheard-- unheard of.
Let's drink for the most deserving to win in the election!
Yeltsin was in a very difficult situation.
We'd film him and he'd be staggering across the room,
barely able to stand upright.
It was clear that he was quite ill,
but, of course, there was a natural sympathy
and support for Yeltsin from Russian TV.
Yes, probably it was not very fair but his opponent was a communist
who openly was saying that no such thing as freedom of the press
would exist under his rule.
Openly supporting Yeltsin,
NTV hatched an elaborate plan to hide the President's ill health.
Malashenko sent a crew to Yeltsin's country home
where he was secretly confined to bed rest after a major heart attack.
We had to demonstrate that Yeltsin is still alive, at least.
He was too seriously ill to travel to Moscow,
so, we took some furniture from his Kremlin office
and we reproduced it at his country house.
So, at this set, he was visited by Prime Minister Chernomyrdin
and Yeltsin spoke with him for 30 seconds,
signed some paper and it was shown on TV.
Many times I was told that it's a thing I shouldn't do
My response is very simple, it was and it is.
That I would rather elect a corpse of Yeltsin than a live Zyuganov.
We had suddenly this amazing, new Yeltsin
and, you know, maybe the doctors had given him a shot of adrenaline or something,
but I think what had really reinvigorated him
was the deal he'd cut with the oligarchs.
They struck a Faustian bargain,
which has become known as "loans-for-shares."
In every Faustian bargain, the devil is in the details.
On the verge of collapse,
Yeltsin's government desperately needed cash
to pay salaries and pensions.
The oligarchs agreed to funnel money to the state
by making a series of loans the government couldn't afford to repay.
When the loans did default, the oligarchs got the right
to buy Russia's biggest state enterprises
in sham auctions run by the oligarchs themselves.
On TV, the deals played like arms-length banking transactions.
In reality, the oligarchs had cut inside deals
to pay bargain basement prices for Russia's most valuable assets.
Khodorkovsky was interested in a massive state oil company called Yukos.
His bank, Menatep, was the only bidder at the auction,
which was run byโฆ Menatep.
At the time, Yukos was valued at five billion dollars.
Menatep offered and paid what it had on hand, 310 million.
A steal.
It was all conflict of interest.
There was no transparency. It was just one big mess.
You know, we wrote about this stuff,
and Menatep was a shareholder of The Moscow Times.
Khodorkovsky himself was not sitting on our board,
but Leonid Nevzlin, his right-hand man was.
So this Nevzlin was, you know, fuming.
Was there ever any pressure on you
to write something that was kind of pro Yukos?
Of course!
I was at the press conference given by the winners after the auction.
I asked him a question about Yukos,
and Khodorkovsky suddenly
started to answer me, formally, that he was managing the bank,
that the bank was not managing the oil company,
this was such utter bullshit that I couldn't hide my disappointment
and I made this face,
and, suddenly, after the press conference, Khodorkovsky came up to me.
He approached me to explain,
almost to apologize for his lie to me.
He was not comfortable lying.
Naturally, of course, it wasn't fair.
But, I don't think this was a bad deal for the state.
Oil production started dropping, precipitously, in the country.
Plus, the employees weren't getting paid for six months at a time.
It was proposed to us that we give all the money that we had.
These companies actually resumed normal operation quite quickly.
The political problem disappeared.
The workers started being paid their salaries before the elections.
This was the biggest mistake of the oligarchs,
and the journalists, and the liberals.
I blame them as much as the communists or any other forces, even more.
Because they were the people with the vision and the will to change
and they were going to create a new Russia.
And what do they do, the first time they get into trouble
in, you know, in '96, their candidate may lose?
They just throw out the whole idea of normal democratic process.
Today it's hard to say did Yeltsin really win or not.
I personally think he did actually win, because he was ready for power.
Power in any country,
and especially in Russia,
is always a projection of people's readiness
to defend it with arms in hand.
If you aren't ready to defend your position with arms in hand,
you're not interesting anymore.
Just not interesting.
Putin is also a product of the '90s.
Vladimir Putin came from nowhere.
He'd been a minor official in the KGB in East Germany
when the Wall collapsed and found himself out of a job.
He found a post up in Leningrad
with the then mayor, a man called Anatoly Sobchak.
If you worked your whole life with Sobchak,
the most liberal mayor in Russia, you must be an okay guy.
That's what I thought.
In fact, Putin was accused of launching a kickback scheme
to embezzle money meant for food for St. Petersburg
which was facing a famine.
When members of the city council raised the issue, Sobchak did not fire Putin.
He promoted him to deputy mayor.
As if to commemorate the moment,
Putin commissioned this documentary about himself.
He kept the title simple.
POWER
Are you a lucky person?
Until this day, I couldn't complain about my destiny,
which can lead to a conclusion that I am lucky.
What happened in 1996 - can one say that it opened up the way for Putin?
Of course, no, no, of course.
De facto, everything that was happening back then
was opening up the way to the future dictatorship.
When Putin's boss failed to win re-election in 1996,
Putin and some friends flew to Moscow
where they landed low-level jobs at the Kremlin.
Goodbye.
Putin held six jobs in three years.
By 1999, he was prime minister and Yeltsin's likely successor.
But Putin didn't get to the top all by himself.
The oligarchs were, in fact, the force,
that in many ways, brought Vladimir Putin to power.
Putin was put there very much to carry on Yeltsin's rule,
with the help of ultimately four people.
Yeltsin's daughter and her husband,
and two of the oligarchs who were close to Yeltsin,
Boris Berezovsky and Roman Abramovich.
They were looking for a successor
who would, basically, guarantee their safety and guarantee their wealth.
I've never gotten into any conflicts with any of the so-called oligarchs.
One of the so-called oligarchs set about selling Putin to the public.
Boris Berezovsky used his TV channel to mock Putin's political rivals
and promote his image as a tough leader.
When a series of explosions killed hundreds in Moscow,
some suspected Putin himself might have been involved.
But at the time, TV news footage highlighted Putin's tough response
to the bombings which he blamed on Chechen terrorists.
We'll chase terrorists everywhere.
If they are in the airport, we'll get them in the airport.
If we catch them - I beg your pardon - in the toilet,
we'll rub them out in the outhouse.
That's it, question closed.
He's tough. And I think this is the thing
that we need in this country at the moment, some toughness.
I...
I... am leaving.
Yeltsin left office on December 31st, 1999
and appointed Putin acting president.
Putin, in turn, promise to forgive Yeltsin
for any sins or crimes he may have committed.
It was another inside deal, sealed by a new election a few months later.
Putin, running as an incumbent, won easily.
Eighteen years later, he's still in the same office.
Yes, I am listening. Good evening.
Yes, please.
Bye.
Putinism is a way to restore pride in your country.
Putinism in itself, there's nothing wrong with it.
When Putin started, he did a lot of good things for the country
because it was a mess.
People were completely dispirited.
People longed to...
to be part of something.
You know, if you grew up in a world power
and then the rest of the world sees you as a joke,
as a banana republic, it's very humiliating.
So, people really needed such a figure.
It seemed to me that, ideologically, he was one of our people.
A man of our generation
who gets it, who wants to push Russia in the same direction that we want for it,
that is towards openness, towards democracy.
Boy, was I mistaken.
He's a very talented KGB guy.
Very talented.
You like leftists?
Putin will behave around you
in a way that you will be convinced that he's a leftist.
You like nationalists?
Putin is going to act around you
in a way that you'll think that he's a bit of a nationalist.
You like conservatives?
Talk to him and you will get an impression that he's a conservative.
That's a talent.
Putin had declared that he supported the liberal views of Yeltsin
and that he was going to keep Russia on a course of liberty and openness.
But even then you could see that Putin was looking for a way
to re-calibrate this relationship
between political power and the oligarchs.
You're the ones who shaped this government,
mainly through controlled political and semi-political structures.
At first, he said, "Look, we'll do a deal.
I'm not going to question the results of the privatization process,
which meant, I'm not going to try and take back your business empires
that you've got through the loans-for-shares auctions
as long as you keep out of politics."
For the moment, that separation of business and politics
served Khodorkovsky's interest.
For Khodorkovsky, business had been hard enough.
He left banking to focus on Yukos.
He traveled to remote regions of Siberia
to learn how to pull oil out of the ground, move it and sell it.
And he had to motivate workers and managers
who never needed to care about efficiency or competition.
All these shitty local oil companies
that, you know, just lost money and were totally inefficient.
He turned that around. He started streamlining these companies.
Khodorkovsky, from a business perspective, did an amazing job.
But in those small towns in Siberia,
a lot of the people who work there, they lost their job.
Many local mayors were very unhappy
and some mayors died.
One of those Mayor's was Vladimir Petukhov of Nefteyugansk, a major Yukos hub.
Petukhov was furious with Khodorkovsky for laying off nearly 15,000 workers,
delays in payroll and battles overpaying local taxes.
Khodorkovsky claimed that Petukhov was in the grip of Chechen gangsters
and using taxes to pay bribes.
So Khodorkovsky flew to Nefteyugansk with bags of cash
to make direct payments to teachers, nurses and city workers.
In protest, the mayor embarked on a hunger strike
until, finally, a deal was cut.
But four days later, the mayor was shot.
I got a call. I remember I asked, "Is he alive?"
He replied and I'll remember his words forever,
"What do you mean alive, there's a glass full of brains that spilled out."
Khodorkovsky killed him! Khodorkovsky!
Petukhov? During the wild '90s he stood up for the town
and paid a high price.
We have a monument for him.
I first went to Nefteyugansk to look at the oil industry
weeks after the murder of the mayor.
And Khodorkovsky was hated there
because Khodorkovsky was already, by that time, a billionaire
and these were the people who were, basically, unable to get food.
I got angry, as a young journalist and I wrote what I saw.
I don't know whether Khodorkovsky's men or he himself were involved
in the death of the mayor. I wouldn't put it past them.
Petukhov, the mayor, was murdered on Khodorkovsky's birthday.
Birthdays have been interesting.
The other famous case is Anna Politkovskaya,
the crusading journalist who was investigating a lot of Kremlin corruption
and she was murdered on Putin's birthday.
If I had thought that this would end the way it did
I would have made much more of an effort to investigate this case.
This was 1998 and so, I was very busy with completely different things.
And I just simply didn't have time to deal with this.
Some observers called it a meltdown.
Russian stocks are at their lowest levels
since President Boris Yeltsin had heart surgery in 1996.
The biggest concern now is that the Russian government
will be forced to devalue the ruble.
The ruble collapsed.
The situation was a hot mess.
So I came out to our regions.
Out in the regions, the situation was absolutely dramatic.
In one day, prices on all groceries tripled.
I still remember in Nefteyugansk...
700 people were sitting there,
they were representatives of all the work units,
and by law they are required to vote to reduce their own salaries.
And I addressed the people. I said, "This is the situation.
You need to vote for a salary reduction of 30%."
People are asking, "When are you going to give it back to us?"
And I said, "In one year."
And they voted for the reduction.
I still had to do very drastic staff reductions.
You can't imagine what it's like to lay off
literally tens of thousands of people.
That's, well... it's real heavy.
People who worked for me...
They would stand at their workplace, expecting that I pay them.
But if I don't have money, they would simply faint...
Faint from hunger.
And you look at this and you understand.
"That's my responsibility. That's my responsibility.
Either I'm going to figure a way out
or I don't even know what to do."
At that moment, you understand that business is not a game,
not in the least bit a game.
I understood that I owed people a lot.
And that I needed somehow to give it back to them.
He was opening schools. You know, his foundation was doing a lot.
He was the entrepreneur with the vision.
The type of entrepreneur that Russia needed
to create this new economy.
And he immediately brought in Western know-how, new technology,
and, in a few years, built one of the best oil companies in the world.
Khodorkovsky's work at Yukos paid off when the ruble rose along with oil prices.
Just after the turn of the century, the Russian economy was booming,
powered in large part, by oil.
That was a business victory, but it was also a moment of political opportunity.
Who would take credit for the turnaround?
The former KGB agent-turned-politician?
Or the ruthless oligarch whose attention was quickly turning to politics?
I did not expect to see in him this interest in politics.
Even today, all other Russian oligarchs
they all distance themselves from politics, saying,
"No no, no, no way, we aren't interested in politics,
just business, just business, we're just interested in money."
And Khodorkovsky suddenly began to talk about politics.
Modern society can only be built on the basis of democracy.
Although democracy has a hard time taking hold in our country
because we didn't have democracy for 500 years.
It seems like some fantasy to us but in reality it's not.
Khodorkovsky is an interesting man, because now he has all this money...
he started thinking about, you know,
what's next, what is my role in society?
And this is where he clashes with Putin.
His intolerance for personal criticism has been growing
with each passing year.
You could say the government is bad.
You might say that communism is better than capitalism.
He couldn't care less.
But say that Putin is ridiculous,
and you'll have serious problems.
Rub them out in the outhouse! Rub them out in the outhouse!
There are rumors that Putin in particular didn't like one program
where he was portrayed as a midget man who became the ruler of the country
due to the power of magic.
At some point, magic disappear
and people see this midget man for what he is.
Yeltsin could be angry at some program but there were no reprisals.
Putin and his people had an entirely different attitude towards TV.
Putin was the product of television. They made him.
He was absolutely nobody, I mean, nobody ever heard of Vladimir Putin.
The fact that television could actually help make him into president
within six months...
I think was enough for him to understand the real power.
If TV could make his reputation, it could also break it.
We've swum to the hatch.
Seven months after Putin became president,
a terrible underwater explosion ripped apart the Kursk,
a Russian nuclear submarine.
As the nation anxiously watched the efforts to rescue a few survivors,
Putin was photographed hosting a barbeque at a seaside resort.
For ten days, relentless TV news reports shredded Putin's reputation
by chronicling the incompetence and dishonesty of the government.
To recover, Putin rushed to talk to the widows of the sailors.
But rather than take responsibility,
he looked to administer blame on television.
There are people on TV today who are shouting more than everybody else
and for the past ten years have been destroying this army and fleet
where people die today.
Putin, as somebody who was both born and bred in the Soviet Union,
but more importantly, bred by the KGB,
has this very conspiratorial view of the world,
and that view of the world suggests that people don't have any free will.
And history, therefore, doesn't have any free will,
that everything is pre-planned, plotted by somebody,
and so, he immediately assumed that this was a plot to subvert him.
That was a very emotional, I think, genuine outburst.
Vladimir Putin, President of Russia. There's lots...
We remember to this day his participation in Larry King's TV show.
What happened with the submarine?
When he was asked what happened with the submarine, he said...
"It sank."
...and he smiled.
When he felt those were serious blows to his reputation,
he decided that it would be much more efficient
to force the mass media to work for him.
-Thank you, Mr. President. -Thank you, Larry.
Putin's command of the media was quickly evident.
Even in the TV images of one of the grieving relatives
whose voice was silenced with eerie efficiency.
I can't say anything!
Yes, I'm saying it all openly and in front of the whole world.
Bastards!
Putin and his people have a KGB background.
I am talking about control.
What you don't control is a potential threat.
What you control is safe.
Everything should be controlled.
The first thing they did was to establish control over TV
because uncontrolled TV was a threat.
After the Kursk episode,
Putin's government took over the two major TV networks controlled by oligarchs.
Facing the prospect of prison,
Gusinsky and his chief executive, Malashenko, fled the country.
Berezovsky soon followed.
When Boris Berezovsky fell out with Putin in such a spectacular and public way,
he fled to London and I had quite a lot to do with him.
He asked me if I would write his biography for him.
So I spoke to him over the years, you know, socially,
and at times, I recorded the conversations, as well.
I remember well my last meeting with Vladimir Putin,
after the tragedy of the Kursk submarine.
And the most terrible for me, during our meeting,
he told me that I tried to destroy him.
After that I recognize that he is really... not good man.
The first time I recognized him not as my friend.
But as a wrong man.
Well, he kicked Berezovsky out and took control of the first channel.
He kicked Gusinsky out of the country and took control of NTV.
He had the airwaves.
This was a successful year for Russia,
both in domestic affairs and foreign policy.
Russia is being treated with more trust and respect in the world.
Once he controlled the narrative and the image,
which is everything in Russia, he could take then control
of the commanding heights of the economy, the oil and take on the biggest tycoon.
Putin had a very valid point.
Half of the parliament is on the payroll of Khodorkovsky.
Many of the top people in the oil ministry are people appointed by the oligarchs.
He thinks, you know, "What is this?
If I want to be a real president, I need to have my own people
and I need to get these people out of politics."
It was said at the time that you were busy courting,
or even buying influence in the, in the Duma.
We only dealt with our industry-related problems.
Did this require buying MPs?
It was exactly as it happens in the United States Congress.
"Will you support our campaign in the next election?"
We felt that the country should gradually develop
in the direction of openness.
Business should develop from the point of view of greater transparency.
We thought that if Putin decides to proceed in this direction,
then we would get serious competitive advantages
on international markets.
Khodorkovsky decided to make Yukos a public company
after realizing it would be worth more.
He will get richer and
he had this idea about merging with some oil major.
They were negotiating with Exxon.
Khodorkovsky invited in the head of Exxon Mobil and said,
"Look, my company is open, transparent, why don't we have a partnership,
we can be a massive player on the world market."
If you are Vladimir Putin sitting in the Kremlin at a time
when the world is going to war over oil,
and you have your least favorite oligarch saying to the Americans,
"I've got lots of oil, do you want to come and share it?"
You know, it's like a slap in the face.
The authorities must have seen him as a threat at some point,
because the man has political views, he has goals, he's got some vision,
and he also has the money.
He's dangerous.
The struggle for power surfaced with an oil deal.
A small company, Northern Oil, paid seven million dollars
for the rights to an oil field which it sold soon after
for 600 million dollars to a government company, Rosneft.
The man at the center of the deal was Igor Sechin,
a close friend of Vladimir Putin.
Were kickbacks involved?
Khodorkovsky wanted to make an issue of the deal
at an upcoming nationally televised forum on corruption.
The night before the meeting,
he dragged me outside to talk about Northern Oil.
He asked me, "How do you think Putin is going to react to this?"
I said that he would react calmly if he had nothing to do with it,
and terribly if he had gotten a part of the bribe.
I understood it was a big risk.
But this isn't the first risk I have taken in my life at that point.
Putin had asked Russia's biggest businessmen
to a roundtable discussion on television on the theme of corruption.
Most of the guys who took part had the wisdom
to figure out that it was a little bit of a fig leaf.
Look - Putin shakes hands with each person one by one.
But Khodorkovsky came armed with a whole pile of slides,
which reported that Russians felt that corruption existed
at the highest levels of government.
I couldn't bring myself to watch it.
...the scale of corruption in Russia ....
I said, "Vladimir Vladimirovich.
Does it mean anything to you that 25% of the population believe
that you are among those taking bribes?"
That was, of course, edited out.
There are probably other factors.
And they then got into the discussion
of what Khodorkovsky thought was a dodgy deal.
Now you've mentioned Rosneft and the deal with Sibneft...
This Northern Oil deal was Putin happy that you mentioned it?
Oh, he was thrilled.
This was the first time he went for a head-to-head conflict.
He wouldn't discuss the transaction.
He started with,
"And you?
I know that you have excess reserves."
There are state companies that need to increase their reserves,
that don't have enough reserves.
While some other oil companies like, for example, Yukos, have extra reserves.
How it got them is the question within the scope of today's discussion.
"And you had problems with the tax authorities,
though you did resolve them."
...including the questions
of paying and not paying taxes.
We've already discussed that at one point, right? Recently.
That was unexpected.
But these issues came to be somehow.
You saw from the facial expression of Putin,
he was really, really angry.
Especially, coming from Khodorkovsky.
That is why I pass the puck back to you.
In my life, I had overstepped so many different lines
that for me,
this wasn't something out of the ordinary.
Well, okay. So the guy's not happy.
So what?
There were all these warning signs. Many of his people were arrested.
It had happened with Gusinsky before me, and with Berezovsky.
It's really standard practice.
It was hard for me to understand why Khodorkovsky was smiling
or how he could say that what was happening was standard practice.
Just four months after the TV battle with Putin,
a top security official at Yukos, Alexei Pichugin, was arrested
and tried in secret in connection with a series of contract killings,
which would include the murder of mayor Petukhov.
That was strange because five years earlier,
the case had been dropped when the likely killers,
two Chechen gangsters, had been murdered.
Now the Kremlin was pushing a fresh story.
The Chechens were replaced with new killers who suddenly confessed
and testified that Pichugin ordered the hit.
When Pichugin refused to implicate Khodorkovsky,
Pichugin claimed he was dosed with psychotropic drugs.
When that didn't work, the new trigger men claimed
the order to kill the mayor had come from Pichugin's boss, Leonid Nevzlin.
Then Pichugin was arrested.
We didn't even understand at first that this had anything to do with us.
It made me tense. I started looking into the issue,
I couldn't get any results. And then - Lebedev.
Then it all became clear.
Khodorkovsky didn't want to give in,
and he didn't want to leave his people behind.
As for me, I did warn him that I wasn't up to it,
and it would be best for me to leave.
And he agreed.
If they want...
that I go to prison,
given the system of behavior that has just been demonstrated to us,
this is easy, they are welcome.
They can do it.
Nastya, this is not supposed to be eaten. There's a good one...
The investigators and the prosecutors have let me down so far.
They can't dig up anything.
As soon as I finish my trips to the regions,
I will start congratulating the company with the new year.
One evening I visited him at home, at his request.
I consulted him about what he should do if he were to be summoned for questioning.
I told him then, "Mikhail Borisovich...
They're going to arrest you. You've got to leave."
And he answered me then,
"Anton, you can't even imagine what you have just said,
what you are offering to me.
This is just unacceptable for me."
I understood by then that the masks had been cast off
and I had very little time to appeal to the people.
I believe that it's possible to build a normal democratic society in our country
but for that, someone needs to be the first not to be afraid.
I am not afraid.
I took a trip around the country to tell the people what was happening.
And to urge them to take part in the election
in favor of the democratic forces.
So we flew into Novosibirsk, landed, for refueling.
I look out and I see that the entire airfield
is surrounded by men in black uniforms.
I'm thinking to myself, "Here we are. Very well. Okay."
...Mikhail Khodorkovsky seized at gunpoint
by Russian special forces...
...Khodorkovsky is locked up in an overcrowded Russian prison.
After I was arrested I was told that my colleague, partner,
Platon Lebedev,
had been thrown in the dungeon and told that he would never leave there.
So I said, "All right, then you're going to have
two corpses on your hands.
Until you let Platon Lebedev out from the dungeon,
I'm going to go on a dry hunger strike."
A dry hunger strike is when you refuse not only food, but water as well.
What's important about such a hunger strike is that it's very quick.
Either they fulfill your demands quickly or that's it.
Did your hunger strike succeed? Was Lebedev let out of the dungeon?
If they hadn't released him, I wouldn't be sitting here talking with you.
I don't joke around.
I remember calling my editor and said, they just arrested Khodorkovsky.
And the response from London was,
"Ah, well, it couldn't have happened to a better man."
I don't want to paint Khodorkovsky as an angel, he wasn't.
But I was rather horrified when I saw Vladimir Putin
holding a copy of my story,
saying, "Look, even the Western press said he was a terrible man."
It was very clear that this is not about finding the truth
or finding what happened. It was about putting papers together,
so that it looks like it's a real case, but in fact it's not a real case.
Can I give you the letter?
Look - Maria Logan.
As someone with a legal background in Russia,
I had to try to interpret and explain this to American lawyers.
Khodorkovsky and Lebedev were put in a cage
to show everyone who is the boss here.
Khodorkovsky was accused of tax evasion, embezzlement, all these things.
But, it's particularly hard to say whether or not he's guilty
because the law was in such a fluid state in those years.
All the other oligarchs did exactly the same things,
and they were free to keep doing it.
During the first trial, the Russian attorneys were trying to pretend
like they're defending an ordinary case.
That was a mistake.
I demonstrated that I was participating in a legal procedure.
But it was not a legal procedure.
The state prosecution...
The Russian prosecutors think the more papers they put together,
the more it looks legitimate.
There were, like, hundreds of volumes of material of basically nothing.
For example, they used company telephone directory
as an evidence of the criminal enterprise.
There were two lines of attack, if you will.
One line was on Khodorkovsky.
On top of that, they mounted an attack on the Yukos company.
Yukos as a company was accused of not paying taxes for six years.
Khodorkovsky was discussing payment of back taxes
that would settle Yukos's debts to the state.
And when Yukos agreed to that, then another demand would come in.
The demand would be higher this time.
So it wasn't a case of wanting to recoup the taxes that hadn't been paid.
It was a case of wanting to destroy Yukos.
There was a bankruptcy auction.
And I was denied access to it with no basically legitimate reason.
Can I show you the letter? No?
...recognize as participants of the auction,
the LLC, Baikal Finance Group...
A mysterious newly created company, Baikal Finance Group,
suddenly emerged to bid for Yukos.
But Baikal had no assets
and its headquarters turned out to be a vodka bar two hours outside of Moscow.
When Baikal won the auction,
it sold Yukos to the government controlled, Rosneft.
ROSNEFT
Rosneft is the state oil company and it is run
by one of Putin's closest friends, Igor Sechin.
Sechin was Putin's man
and when Putin renationalized a lot of companies,
he created a new class.
Oligarch 2.0.
You all know perfectly well
how privatization took place in the early '90s.
Many market players of that time received state property
worth many billions.
Today, the state, using absolutely legal market tools,
establishes its interests.
I think this is quite normal.
ROSNEFT
In most countries in the world, oil companies are owned by the state.
Nothing wrong with that.
Good news for the Russians.
Yeah. That's how 99 percent of the people saw it.
KHORDOVSKY, GO TO PRISON!
He stole from the state, not from me. From the state.
And we are the state.
PUTIN, PROTECT US FROM PEOPLE LIKE KHODORKOVSKY
I swear, that in exercising the powers
of the President of the Russian Federation...
The fact that the oligarchs were so reviled
and resented by the Russian people
was a fantastically useful tool for Putin.
Putin very famously and publicly declared,
"I'm going to destroy the oligarchs as a class."
And every Russian would know where that quotation came from
because Stalin said, very famously,
"I'm going to destroy the rich peasants as a class."
And when he did bring the oligarchs to heel,
it was incredibly popular.
What he said to Khodorkovsky and to the country,
is that nothing belongs to you.
That you have no legitimate right to it.
We control everything and we can take it away from you, if you cross us.
In the first trial, they could have given him a maximum of ten.
The prosecution asked for ten. The court gave him nine.
-Have you lost faith in this country? -I lost it the day we elected Putin.
We will fight to free him because he was imprisoned for God knows what.
We still can't understand what they were saying.
They put me into a rail car.
And off we went.
Based on the number of lunch boxes,
you can have an idea of where they're taking you,
because you get one lunch box per day.
I counted seven lunches in there.
Where?!?
This was a heavy place, right on the border of the Chinese desert.
It felt like Mars.
"Rise at 6:45.
Breakfast is what time is left. I have an hour to pack up,
including exercise, the inevitable shaving
and listening to official news on state channels.
It's just that every morning I think of my children.
They would be getting ready to go to their "work" just as I was.
And your kids grow up...
My son got married, my daughter is starting college.
The younger ones just started school and all that without me around.
I'm afraid they'll finish it without me as well.
My wife promises me she'll know how to explain that to them.
My parents are not getting younger.
The hardest thing in prison routine is being unable to predict one's future.
The guards are well aware of that
and they use it for psychological pressure."
Do you think that being in prison gave you special insight into Putin
and the people around him?
Yes.
The way that the criminals think
is exactly the way that the criminal group around Putin thinks.
It's a criminal mentality.
In the criminal world, building relations starts with the use of force,
because everything is built on force.
I use force against you, and I see how you react.
If you resist, if we're of equal force,
now we can talk.
If you want to achieve something in prison,
you've got to put your life on the line.
My people told me that
the head of my legal department at Yukos, Vasily Aleksanyan,
had been put in jail, too.
He spent a year there and it turned out he was HIV-positive.
Have I blown up a train? Have I killed 200 people?
What the...?
How can you justify what is going on here?
People from the prosecutor's office came to him and told him,
"We know that you're gravely ill.
Testify against Khodorkovsky and we will release you."
He said no, that would be false testimony.
We demanded that he be transferred to a civilian hospital.
They refused.
And I said, "I announce a hunger strike
until a decision is made on his transfer to a normal civilian hospital."
People need to understand that you're ready to croak.
If you're ready to croak, you can get something out of them.
They satisfied my demand after ten days.
In the end he got full blown AIDS.
From stage 1 to stage 4 in one year.
They released him and he died soon after.
Of course, this was murder.
Former oil tycoon, Mikhail Khodorkovsky,
who was jailed for embezzlement and tax evasion in 2003,
is back in court.
New charges brought against him could see his term extended until 2017.
The second trial was announced
when Khodorkovsky was coming up to the point where he might get parole.
It seems fairly clear Putin did not want him to get parole.
As for Khodorkovsky,
I believe that a thief should sit in jail.
They accused me of stealing all the oil that Yukos had produced
in the entire time that I had worked at Yukos,
plus another 70 million tons.
The second trial was a sequel in black comedy.
In the first trial, the government convicted Khodorkovsky
for not paying taxes on the oil he sold.
In the second, the government claimed he had never sold the oil.
He had stolen it.
But if he had stolen it, where did he put it?
And if he never sold it, why did he owe the taxes?
The idea that Yukos stole from themselves all the oil that was mined was just wild.
Being accused of physically stealing 350 million tons of oil
is not only something that is impossible to prove,
but something that is impossible to even imagine.
It's a set of railroad cars that encircles the Earth three times on the equator.
So, even people who aren't lawyers understood it.
-Is it not clear? -Yes, it is.
What I did in the second trial was, I said, "Guys!
We understand that there's me and there's you - you are actors!
You look like a court, but you aren't a court.
You look like a prosecutor, but you're not a prosecutor.
And I will troll you,
mock you, as much as procedure allows me to do.
I'm going to show that you're idiots. You are puppets.
You are nobodies."
The prosecutor, Lakhtin -
I told my lawyers, "No need to interrupt him -
just let him talk, and let us laugh our heads off."
He was creating a good mood in us.
He is just
a fantastic idiot.
The number of people who became his supporters
increased by geometric progression.
Maybe that's a traditional Russian historical habit:
When the power starts trampling on him, people resent it and sympathize.
Freedom! Freedom!
Shame!
Freedom to Mikhail Khodorkovsky!
Freedom to Khodorkovsky!
Shame!
It's very important for me how this trial will finish
because according to it,
I'll know which country me and my children will live in.
Putin is very afraid of Khodorkovsky.
And he wants him to be in the prison forever.
And this is against Russia.
This is against Russia future.
And it means that this is not a country of law.
This is a country of dictatorship.
I remember, a few days or weeks after my arrest
I was informed that President Putin had decided that I would have to,
as I was told, "eat prison slop" for eight years.
Now seven years have passed.
Nonetheless, I'd like to speak about hope...
Hope that Russia can become a country of laws and freedom.
I am far from an ideal person, but I am a person with ideals.
And like anyone, it is difficult for me to live in prison,
and I don't want to die here.
But if I have to, I will not hesitate.
The things I believe in are worth dying for.
When he was in jail, he suddenly gained, through his stamina, through his calm,
through his resolution that moral authority
and respect of the people--
I wouldn't say he has legitimacy as a political figure,
but I think the perception of him
has made sort of 180-degree turn.
It's not nice to say, but prison changed him for the better.
He developed a certain degree of compassion and humanity.
"Following the footsteps of many prisoners, known and unknown,
I must say thank you to the prison.
It gave me time to form a new outlook on many aspects of life.
As a co-owner of Yukos, I had to make enormous efforts to protect this property.
I had to close my eyes and put up with many things,
all for the sake of my personal wealth, preserving and increasing it.
I did not control this wealth alone - it controlled me as well.
I'm becoming a common person to whom what matters is being, not having.
This is probably the only right choice possible, the choice of freedom.
Prison is a place of anti-culture, of anti-civilization.
Here, good is bad, lies are truth.
Here, good people feel deeply unhappy
because they can't do a thing inside this hideous system.
The most important thing is self-discipline.
Either you develop, or you deteriorate."
If you break, then there's nothing for us to talk about.
Just lie down and be a footstool before the throne.
There was a period when Putin,
because of the constitution, had to step down as president
and become prime minister,
and his colleague, Dmitry Medvedev, became president.
And there was a lot of talk at that time that perhaps Medvedev might be a rival...
power base to Putin's.
It turned out to be completely incorrect
because at the end of Medvedev's term as president,
he simply stepped down and Putin came back into power.
Until 2008, I think Russia was on the right track,
and Putin was okay.
Then Putin decided to become more authoritarian.
He also decided that the country could not live without him.
That's what power does to you.
You think you are the country,
and the country thinks without Putin, there is no Russia.
Russia without Putin!
More than a hundred thousand protesters flooded Moscow's Bolotnaya Square
to protest Putin's return to the presidency.
The protesters, at least, could imagine Russia without Putin.
Fascists!
Fight! Fight and don't disperse! Russia will be free!
If those people had decided to march on the Kremlin,
Putin wouldn't have had a chance.
At that moment, that crowd was not ready to do that.
I felt that I was in prison forever.
I have to admit, my friends thought so too.
The only way we could potentially get him out of jail
is not through judicial system in Russia but through some sort of negotiations
involving Western leaders putting pressure on Putin.
How can we make it so Khodorkovsky being in prison is worse for Putin?
So it reaches the boiling point?
To turn him from a domestic issue into an international one.
The Winter Olympic Games in Sochi...
The host nation of Russia
is continuing a well-timed release of high-profile prisoners.
Pussy Riot band member, Nadezhda Tolokonnikova,
has been freed as part of President Putin's amnesty.
Putin really wanted to see Western leadership coming to Sochi.
And that pardon was his gesture
in anticipation of gesture back from the Western leaders.
How did you find out that you were going to be released?
On TV.
Will Khodorkovsky remain in prison?
Putin was speaking and he said, "I'm going to sign an edict."
He's already spent more than ten years in prison.
This is a serious punishment.
He's citing humanitarian reasons, his mother is ill.
It was crucial for him that as a result, I go abroad.
He had a certain sentimentality about the situation
that I had with my mom.
That my mom had been told in August of 2013 that she had a year left to live.
We did have that time together and that's important.
I hadn't met him until he was released from prison.
We had some vodka.
It was-- it was really unreal.
I ask you to regard me as a symbol that the efforts of civil society
can bring about the release of even those people
that nobody imagined could ever be released.
Can you forgive all of those people who took away ten years of your life?
It would probably be a sin against the truth to say that...
...that I don't have any feelings about it at all.
But I've worked very seriously on myself.
One has to look forward.
He was really thinking what his next public step
in that fight should be.
And then he said that I'm ready to make the public move.
And he wanted to go to Kiev.
In Kiev hundreds of thousands of demonstrators
who demanded the government resign
for rejecting closer ties with the EU in favor of better relations with Russia.
Demonstrators pulled back under a hail of bullets
fired by government forces.
Mikhail Khodorkovsky.
I was shown and told what the authorities did here.
They did it with the consent of the Russian authorities.
I wanted to cry.
This is horrifying.
Thank you! Thank you!
Fight and you will overcome. Godspeed.
Thank you.
In 2014, Khodorkovsky moved to London and founded Open Russia,
an umbrella group that funds anti-Putin efforts
and invests in long range visions for democracy in Russia.
The money for Open Russia comes from Khodorkovsky.
Somehow, even while serving hard time in Siberia,
he or his friends managed to protect some of his fortune.
I've got several hundred million dollars, around 400 million.
I got another 100 million or so that was recently released in Ireland.
So I've got enough money.
While in Moscow, I spent a bit of time with Open Russia.
On the ground, their efforts were less than effective.
Volunteers didn't have strong enough glue to paste up their posters.
And Open Russia teleconferences in which Khodorkovsky beamed himself into Moscow
only attracted the interest of a few dozen supporters.
Khodorkovsky is not a forgotten figure.
But you can't touch him.
So he becomes more and more, a TV image.
Okay, not TV, he is not shown on TV. Computer generated image, okay?
And it's not good, of course, for a politician.
-Virtual Khodorkovsky? -Virtual-- virtual Khodorkovsky, exactly.
Being outside of Russia, he really cannot influence the situation here.
He wants to be Jesus Christ but, you know, he has a past.
Over time, complicated stories become more simple.
Shades of grey separate into pools of black and white.
That simplicity can serve a political purpose.
In 1998, there were many suspects in the brutal killing of Mayor Petukhov.
From Chechen gangsters to the mayor's wife.
Today, in Nefteyugansk, there is only one.
Who killed him?
According to one of the versions, Khodorkovsky,
by the order of Khodorkovsky.
-Are there any other versions? -I haven't heard any.
Such a person... and they shot him.
Unbelievable.
And who shot him?
A true thief!
He was shot.
By the order of Khodorkovsky.
We know about it.
Khodorkovsky shot him himself?
You know... He ordered it.
Because...
That day I watched a report...
Murder as a Present. Coming up next.
Why did Petukhov cross the oil giant?
He was shot and killed 15 years ago.
On the same day, in Moscow
the head of Yukos, Mikhail Khodorkovsky,
celebrated his 35th birthday.
After I came to Great Britain,
they charged me with organizing Petukhov's murder.
They figured that they would use the last card they had.
That is, if I do return, I would certainly immediately,
in the airport, be arrested.
And then life imprisonment, guaranteed, no question.
Khodorkovsky's story marks the beginning of a journey
which ultimately will result in violence.
And this is where we are today,
where violence is the only tool at your disposal
for resolving social contradictions or political conflicts.
I'd like to issue a warning:
The job of a traitor is one of the most dangerous in the world.
Those who choose it rarely survive until senior age.
A second piece of advice, a more general one:
Don't choose England as your next country of residence.
Maybe it's the climate,
but there have been too many strange incidents
with grave outcomes there in recent years.
People hang themselves, get poisoned,
have helicopter crashes and fall out of windows simply on an industrial scale.
In England, over the past 15 years,
there have been a growing number of mysterious deaths related to Russia.
Khodorkovsky's lawyer was killed in a helicopter crash.
The anti-Putin Russian spy, Alexander Litvinenko,
was poisoned to death six months after he delivered an affidavit
that Russian secret services had paid
for the murder of the mayor of Nefteyugansk.
Boris Berezovsky was found dead,
his neck suspended by his own cashmere scarf.
But the coroner was unable to conclude
whether the hanging was a suicide or murder.
Berezovsky became consumed by this obsession
that he was going to bring down Putin from London.
I would be very sad if Khodorkovsky went the same way that Boris Berezovsky went.
I mean, your life may be at risk in London.
Did you have a conversation with your wife
about continuing to speak out?
I have talks like that with my wife all the time.
To say that she is happy with what I'm doing,
that's something I can't say.
We've been together for 30 years, she respects what I do
and takes on the consequences of my activity
together with me.
Can you hear me?
I have invited you here tonight, my friends,
to tell you about the projects,
some long-term, some short-term,
but in short, this is what we have been doing.
The current speaker of the Russian Duma,
and one of the top Kremlin political aides, said publicly
"There's no Russia without Putin." End of quote.
Probably the most insulting thing I've ever heard said about my country.
At the end of the day all of our...
Vladimir Kara-Murza is a former journalist and anti-Putin political warrior.
He was close to John McCain
who asked him to be among those who carried his coffin.
Kara-Murza was poisoned twice,
while on assignment for Khodorkovsky in Russia.
He played a key role in passing the Magnitsky Act
which sanctioned certain Russian individuals
for human rights abuses.
Kara-Murza now works with Khodorkovsky to provide research and offer advice
to those considering sanctions on members of Putin's inner circle.
It would have been great for us,
if those who want to introduce the sanctions
had introduced them all at once, and as soon as possible.
This would have untied our hands to protect our national interests
by the means that we consider the most efficient.
Detectives came into the Open Russia office on Tuesday morning.
Money, credit cards were seized together with computers.
The Prosecutor General's office gave the command
to shut down our organization's website,
and all the websites that are mentioned on our website,
including my personal website, which I have as a Russian citizen.
And sends a letter to Twitter that says,
if Twitter doesn't shut down our organization's account,
they will shut down Twitter in Russia.
Open Russia has been recognized as an "undesirable organization"
and according to the Prosecutor General, it has no place in the online world.
When I see my arrows hitting their target
I understand that we're doing our work fairly well
and we need to keep on doing even more.
We do have a new project of Open Russia, called Dossier.
It takes the investigative journalism done in Russia or outside of Russia
and builds on that.
A key focus is the circle of new oligarchs surrounding Putin.
One of them is Yevgeny Prigozhin, nicknamed Putin's chef.
Following a recipe of coverts ops,
the chef cooks up missions for Putin all over the world.
Special counsel Robert Mueller accused Prigozhin
of launching cyber-attacks during the 2016 presidential election.
Others accused him of running off the books
military operations from Ukraine to Africa.
When Khodorkovsky funded a group of journalists to look into the matter,
they were murdered,
reportedly by people working for the chef.
We are dealing with officials' involvement
in the murder of journalists.
Back in Russia, state-controlled TV turned the story upside down,
blaming Khodorkovsky for not doing more to protect the journalists.
Let's reiterate that the person who gave the assignment
should have shown some responsibility.
That's what we think. Khodorkovsky, oh well.
Open Russia also helped to expose a plot
to kill a Russian double agent in Salisbury, England.
The attack deployed a military chemical weapon
which badly poisoned two people and killed an innocent bystander.
Two members of the assassination team
were spotted by British surveillance cameras
and traced back through their drivers licenses to the GRU,
Russian Military Intelligence.
With a perfume bottle full of novichok, a deadly nerve agent,
they traveled to Salisbury on the day of the attack
and then fled quickly back to Russia.
President Putin announced, "We know these people,
and if I were them, I'd come to the journalists
and tell them about myself."
I assure you that there is nothing special or criminal here.
We will see shortly.
Are they civilians?
-What? -Are they civilians?
Civilians, of course.
They're officers and if there's an order from the Commander in Chief,
you have to comply.
What were you doing there?
There's a famous... Famous cathedral there...
...the Salisbury Cathedral.
It's all funny, but on the other hand, this isn't funny at all.
It's all insanity: first, the person who gave the order,
then the insanity of Putin, who approved the order,
and then put those people on-air
thinking it would improve the situation.
It's famous for its 123-meter spire.
It's famous for its clock.
That interview was sort of a double message saying nothing is true,
and, of course, we are lying, and two fingers up to the West.
But we are still doing it, and it's okay to lie.
It's negation of facts, a negation of truth, a negation of reality.
How should I talk to her if she's dumb? She's got no brains!
Calm down!
Who gave her the right to throw water at me? Crazy woman!
What kind of campaign is Sobchak running?
Have you meet her? And what do you think of her?
We know each other quite well.
She was the first journalist who interviewed me
after I was released from jail.
I fully support her because she talks about democratic values.
The mass media are under Putin's control
but Putin does not regard Sobchak as dangerous
so he allows her to use the mass media that he controls.
How's the campaign going?
There is no campaign.
I understand.
Ms. Sobchak just invited me to... to take part in her campaign.
Russia will be free!
She's doing things which make her very few friends in the Kremlin.
On the other hand, we should understand that all we see
all this so-called campaign is a Kremlin game.
Everybody understands that there can only be one winner in these elections.
We're not talking about actually winning the elections.
Sobchak is going to force yet another
few million people in Russia to start thinking
about that path along which the country needs to be developing,
that there is an alternative to Putin. And I fully support her in this.
After years in prison, Khodorkovsky had learned how to play the long game.
RUSSIA WITHOUT PUTIN!
During the run of election theater,
he wasn't trying to back a winner in the here and now.
He was offering support to a number of political actors
who could amplify democratic principles over time.
It's not such big money.
If we're talking about the activity in Russia,
we're talking about hundreds of thousands, maybe low millions of dollars.
I've got enough money to support that.
Khodorkovsky wanted to speak by proxy
to a younger generation who'd be ready for Russia after Putin.
They don't watch so much TV, they surf the web,
a domain the state has either been unwilling or unable to control.
One web warrior, Alexey Navalny, is supported by Khodorkovsky.
Navalny is banned from TV or running for office
but he can get more than 20 million views on his YouTube channel.
Bribes, yachts, my election campaign HQs, oligarchs, prostitutes,
and even Russia's interference in the American election.
Did that make you intrigued? Alright.
Why do you think that Putin finds you so dangerous or threatening?
I think Putin is scared; he realizes that there won't be a calm, normal election
with 70 percent of the vote for him, if I participate.
Now I get arrested at every protest I go to.
We can say that it can't be called election,
and we call people to boycott it and take an active position
so we're not calling it a boycott, but a voter strike.
Strike!
Nemtsov! Nemtsov! Nemtsov!
During election season, there was a march in honor of Boris Nemtsov,
an opposition politician who had been murdered by mysterious gunmen
in front of the Kremlin,
just a few days before he was to release evidence
of Russia's involvement in violence in Ukraine.
Boris Nemtsov was killed, as you know, because he called Putin "fucked up."
And somebody adopted a decision that the punishment for such a thing is death.
KILLED FOR FREEDOM
Preparations and government rules for the march
made it more protest theater than protest.
Only certain signs were allowed,
and the tiny contingent from Open Russia was not permitted
to bring along its posters.
Wait, it doesn't say "Open Russia" or anything...
This is an emblem of an organization
considered undesirable in the Russian Federation.
Considered by whom?
Still, all the politicians showed up in the bitter cold.
The most important thing for the country's democratic development
is polyphony. Political polyphony.
I supported Ksenia Sobchak, as well as Alexey Navalny.
Although they sometimes had arguments between themselves.
Let's try to sit at a negotiation table. Let's try to join forces.
Because the main problem, shown by this election as well,
is the divisions within the opposition.
You were a part of this scam.
You are participating in this, I don't know why,
for money, for a position...
Ksenia Sobchak's family history haunted her campaign.
Her father was the mayor of St. Petersburg who first hired Putin.
Many believe Ksenia is a secret agent of the Kremlin,
maybe even Putin's goddaughter.
In Russia, where visions of the future are blocked
by an unchanging present under Putin, conversations turn quickly to the past.
Putin looks back to days of empire and wants to make Russia great again.
Russian liberals are nostalgic for the democratic freedoms of the '90s.
But it's hard for them to argue in favor of a time
when a handful of men controlled the economy,
and so many lived in fear of hunger, violence and economic chaos.
With such a past, wouldn't most people settle for a present under Vladimir Putin?
In the precious land of birches
To the tender whisper of rain
I embroidered the beloved name of the leader with pink beads
I embroidered Volodya's name not hiding my dearest dream
Listen, my dear motherland, my song is about Putin
Putin, Putin - we all want to marry Putin!
Tell us when will we finally get a chance to marry...
Putin!
Yes... Vladimir Vladimirovich....
Alexey Navalny is not allowed at the election.
My question is why?
Are those in power afraid of the honest competition?
Is this a democracy or not?
Let's ask ourselves: what is democracy?
It's a subject of serious and deep discussion.
But I can assure you that the power has never been afraid of anyone
and isn't afraid of anyone.
Our take on the pseudo-election on March 18 is simple: action.
Any active stand. But not on your sofa.
I'm used to practicing what I preach.
I can't really walk onto the territory of a Russian Embassy,
because that can result in some unnecessary scandal.
So we found a place where the election takes place outside the embassy.
I ruined my ballot,
saying there was no choice.
#SICKANDTIRED OF PUTIN
In Russia's election theater, everyone knows how the story will end.
Some actors play along and others improvise off the script.
But for now, outside of the big cities,
audiences seem happy enough with the fairy tale promoted by Putin.
STRONG PRESIDENT STRONG RUSSIA!
No one else can replace him. Putin, only Putin.
We want stability.
We don't want revolutions.
Definitely! And only for Putin!
He managed to drag such a country out of such a dump!
Darya, you're my soulmate Darya, you're so beautiful
I took a shot of vodka and started dancing
In far off Krasnokamensk,
where Khodorkovsky spent so many years in prison,
election theater has the folksy flair of a high school musical.
Everyone roots for a happy ending in a story scripted
by the self-appointed man of the moment,
who claims to have saved them from the villains of the past.
The entire country will vote for Putin. It will definitely be him.
Because... after...
Boris Nikolayevich Yeltsin screwed up so much.
Horror.
So much to put back in order.
And Gorbachev started it.
Thank you!
You are our common team.
And I am a member of your team.
And everybody who voted today is our big national team.
It is very important to preserve this unity, my dear friends.
It is very important to win over those who might have voted for other candidates.
After Putin's next term, can you imagine that he will step down
or do you think he will just keep going forever?
Who knows?
Russia! Russia!
Russia!
Putin is now 18 years in power.
He has this group of friends around him who are now fabulously rich
and, of course, they don't want to see him go.
Their whole wealth comes only from him.
It's very hard to get out of this.
What do you think is Putin's worst nightmare?
He's walking the halls of the Kremlin Palace.
The telephones are turned off.
Nobody picks them up.
And in the reception office there is a secretary,
but the secretary's telephone is also turned off.
And he knows that any second they're going to come.
I think that is his most terrifying
and in fact, his most real nightmare.
It's a gangster model of capitalism.
For Putin there is a horrible feeling
that at any moment the system might fall apart.
Putin today, in the eyes of the people around him,
as Bulgakov once said in the famous Master and Margarita,
"He is not only mortal, he is potentially mortal at any moment."
I wondered how Khodorkovsky could think that Putin was weak or fearful.
After all, in the struggle between the two men,
Khodorkovsky had lost.
But while in prison, Khodorkovsky learned that you can sometimes win
when you are willing to lose everything.
The darker the night, the brighter the stars.
What I noticed myself, as a result of my years in prison,
I now have a different sense of time.
Nowadays, I end up misunderstood
when I say something will happen "soon."
People start to say, "Khodorkovsky said it would happen this year."
No, soon means in five years, maybe ten. That's what soon is.
I live in the future.
I want to go back and change things in Russia.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.