Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Corsican
Czech
Danish
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Look at these two.
They would be great together.
Dresden with...
The Milkmaid.
Buckingham Palace...
Let's leave that down here.
Hasn't been loaned out for ages.
But this exhibition is so important that I think they'll miss something...
if they don't let their baby travel to the party.
Exactly.
The first two Vermeer paintings I ever saw with my own eyes...
was when I visited London as a schoolboy.
The moment I saw the Vermeers I actually fainted.
The National Gallery has Lady Sitting and Lady Standing at a Virginal.
I was just blown away.
The lady is bathed in light.
And the shadows have exactly the right tone.
Leonardo da Vinci said, "Just use black,"
but Vermeer uses color in the shadows.
He seems to know that warm yellow light has cold blue shadows.
The best exhibitions I've ever seen...
didn't just determine my life during the two hours I was there...
Sorry.
This is...
A good exhibition should sweep you away.
It should change the way you look.
Your view of the world changes.
As you're drawn into this other world...
and you're almost floating. Vermeer can really do that.
These painted bricks make me very happy.
Under the microscope they stop being bricks.
They're just dots of paint in different colors.
The fact that so much is left open makes it interesting.
I want to understand...
...how he was able to paint these wonderful pictures.
Take this red shutter, possibly the most beautiful shutter in the history of art.
If you imagine this painting without the red shutter...
it's much less...
captivating. The red shutter stops you...
from leaving the painting here, so you keep looking.
No Vermeer in here!
Wow!
I think it's a really exciting piece, which was attributed to Vermeer...
when it surfaced between 1933 and 1935.
They thought it was a self-portrait? Or just painted by Vermeer?
Both.
There was a huge Vermeer hype going on. Everyone was looking for new Vermeers.
It would be interesting to know what he actually looked like.
What he looked like?
I think we have the need for this "personalโ approach.
Rembrandt has about 80 self-portraits...
and we just have Vermeer's back.
We don't have any letters or diaries by Vermeer.
We know he lived in Delft, had 14 children...
and was only 43 when he died.
That's all. We don't even know where he learned how to paint, or who taught him.
All we have are his paintings.
One thing I've never understood about Vermeer's painting
is that the scale is so small
that even the tiniest bit of dust,
when it falls into the paint, it gathers paint,
it attracts the paint, and really ruins the surface,
where, when you look at Vermeer's paintings,
you never see those little dust particles.
I was 18, and I wanted to be a painter
because I thought I was artistic, you know?
I did a course on Baroque painting.
I just knew Rembrandt, Rubens.
Never heard of Vermeer.
And all of a sudden, a Vermeer came on,
and I said, "That's it."
What is this mysterious object that I've just seen?
It looks like it came from Mars and landed down
and wanted to say something to me.
All I could say, it just seemed right.
Everything just seemed to fall in place, as if by magic.
I have no idea what really makes a Vermeer a Vermeer,
because you could say the light, the perspective,
but there are so many things that, when you add them up,
the composition, you put them all together,
I think then you get a Vermeer.
So 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8...
9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17...
18, 19, 20, 21 are definite.
From very early on people abroad started collecting Vermeers.
France, England, Germany and America.
The United States alone has about one third of his entire oeuvre.
So there's a lot to be brought in from abroad.
So, Pieter, it's your first time here, right,
since we moved to Frick Madison?
Yeah, so I haven't seen your new installation yet.
Then you get into the 17th-century Dutch paintings
which are the three Rembrandts together.
- What a gallery! - Yeah, it's amazing.
This is amazing.
You have these big, grand pictures, you know,
so kind of imposing and life-size,
and then the last room on this floor
is the Vermeer room,
and suddenly you're in this totally different dimension.
This is stunning.
Yeah, no, its pretty great.
This is really well done.
It's really... I very much like
the balance between the two of them,
and then the Mistress and Maid in the center.
I was a little worried because they're quite big walls
and sort of empty walls but small pictures,
but they really hold their place.
I don't think you can do that with every painter,
but I think with Vermeer you can.
- Yeah. - And if you have single walls
in the exhibition or single works,
you can say that the idea came from Frick Madison.
Yeah.
I always find this painting, I mean,
I find it a little menacing as well.
I find, you know, the male figure,
it's so kind of towering over her,
and the idea that he's in shadow,
there's something more dark.
You know, what's the message, what's going on?
And as someone who spends the whole of his life,
his career, painting these scenes
and these rooms over and over again,
you know, why?
This is a painting instead that has had some changes
over time, not necessarily all by Vermeer,
and I'm really happy it's coming to Amsterdam
for analysis ahead of the exhibition.
You know, one big question that I hope we can answer
in Amsterdam is, you know, was the bird cage added?
- Exactly. - And I think
in this specific case, it's going to be very important
to try and answer some of these questions.
I found it very moving, actually
realizing that it's the first time in 200 years
that this picture is in the Netherlands.
And I'm you know, also amazed, you know,
an artist like Vermeer that is so well studied
and people talk about the whole time,
the fact that we're still making discoveries,
the idea of pushing the scholarship and the research
to the next level is what really excites me
about this project.
So here we're looking at some of our XRF scans,
and our research suggests
that the bird cage is probably a later addition.
I think it's extraordinary.
But it's really funny, I mean, how that bird cage
was part of the interpretation of this painting
for quite a long, long time. - Absolutely.
Talking about what he wanted to tell with this.
- Yeah. - And now, well, it's not him.
There are shelves and shelves of literature about Vermeer.
I think organizing a Vermeer exhibition...
without being able to show any new insights, would be a shame.
Yeah.
Vermeer has been called "the Sphinx of Delft" since the 19th century,
because it's a mystery how he achieved this.
Her head, for instance...
looks a little like a 19th-century photograph...
with everything in ochre, Grey, pink.
But that's not the main thing.
Looking at it closely, you see the eye has been done without any lines.
It's purely a shadow of skin color...
which makes the eye and eyelashes visible...
without having been painted in detail.
We have no idea what knowledge he had.
He must have had some kind of optical instrument...
with mirrors and lenses to be able to see this kind of effect.
Wow, take a look.
Hold out your hand again. Wow.
It's only 30 to 50 centimeters, but the difference...
Your hand is all vague, very vague contours.
While your face and your necklace are really well-defined.
Now you're all blurry so I must try to somehow...
get you in focus by changing the distance.
- Watch your step. - I know that step.
It's funny... - How does it work?
A camera obscura is basically a dark box.
When you take off the lid, you see this dark room here.
The lens is here and the image falls on this mirror...
which is at a 45 degree angle.
It reflects the image onto this ground-glass screen.
It's really parchment and should be quite translucent.
When I look through this, I can suddenly see that as an image.
Cool.
What you can see in this way, fascinates me here too.
Particularly with this shadow.
Vermeer has that too. He knows that if there are several window panes...
the curtain no longer throws one shadow, but in this case...
Three.
He didn't paint with the camera obscura, he observed.
He did exactly this and wondered: Wow, what's happening here?
So, do I look like the Girl with a Pearl Earring now?
Almost. - I knew it.
We had one day to have the painting here
up in the studio for photography.
So I had the honor of carrying the Girl.
First of all, I had the honor of unframing the Girl.
So, with my gloved hands taking the painting out of the frame,
that was such an amazing moment for me after a year
of doing this research and preparing for this.
It was the first time I'd seen the back of the painting.
It was the first time I'd seen her out of the frame.
It was my first encounter that was, you know, very different
from what everyone else had experienced before me.
In 1994, they took tiny samples, paint samples,
from the background of the painting,
and this is what they saw,
that the background must have been green.
And that was really revolutionary at the time
to know that the Girl isn't in a, you know, in a black space
but that there must have been some green color there.
Now we have such different
and improved scientific technologies
than they did in 1994 that we could go a step further,
we suddenly notice that there are
some diagonal lines here in the corner.
We expected that the background was flat,
was black, with a greenish glaze on top,
but now were thinking, "Hmm, there's something going on",
brushstrokes going on in a specific direction."
How could I live without... playing cards?
Only $29.95.
Okay, I can deal with that.
I'm gonna do a video on Vermeer merchandise
on my website.
Sort of tongue-in-cheek kind of thing.
I don't want to be too moralistic,
but, you know, point out the fact that there are dangers.
I'm worried that she is going to become too iconic.
And here she is.
Every time I see her, she always looks lighter
than what I've imagined, right?
Well, here's now your chance to get close.
No one around to...
no one around taking their selfies.
Wow.
One of our new findings was...
were these lines in the top-right corner.
Mm-hmm, these look like folds.
Yeah.
That was our conclusion as well
because we know it was green,
and there are these folds with highlights and shadows,
so we think that she's standing in front or sitting in front
of a green curtain.
Oh, right, so that's the curtain that hangs down here.
It would have been very dark.
It wasn't like, you know...
- Bright green, no. - ...bright green or something,
but it would've stayed in the background.
Absolutely.
- That's amazing. - Yeah.
Yeah... and what's this line is black?
Yeah, this line is super interesting.
Yeah, look at that.
The contour of Girl with a Pearl Earring
is where Vermeer left the brown underlayer exposed,
and here is where that dark underlayer is showing through
between these brushstrokes.
Okay, okay, great.
Then, of course, the tiny details,
like the dots on top.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
That's so hard to do.
As a painter, you want to get your highlights
because they make things work, right?
Yeah, otherwise you have a sort of, you know,
the highlight in the eye and the highlights in the...
It's so much fun, right?
You're definitely speaking as someone who's painted
and knows... you are the Vermeer expert.
I mean, even the experts in our field are all going
to Essential Vermeer for the first information
about the painter as well.
Now to move on to the burning question
that revolves around Vermeer always,
"What about the camera obscura?"
Yeah, thank you, Powell.
Something which I found which is new for me
is the presence of the Jesuits next door to Vermeer.
And what I found is that the Jesuits are very, very busy
with the camera obscura and all the other optical instruments.
Here are the drawings, Gregor.
I have to admit I'm pretty excited.
You've never seen it? - No.
Ahh, wow.
I must take off my glasses.
Portrait of an Old Woman as Saint Apollonia.
I think it's very strange.
But she was drawn by Vermeer's neighbor.
Vermeer lived at Oude Langendijk, next to the Jesuits...
So Vermeer knew this artist.
Yes. And you could draw this using a camera obscura, for instance.
So I wondered if this could have been done by tracing a projection.
But then the parchment must have been so translucent...
as to be transparent. - In this case I think that's a bit...
So will your theory be confirmed?
Okay, let's see if this filters through.
Perfect!
You can clearly see it. This is incredible. Wow!
This is what you wanted to see.
Yes, this is evident.
It's easy to trace it now.
This is so important to me!
I mean it. We've never been closer to this theory...
Very close to Vermeer thanks to this neighbor.
We knew Vermeer had some kind of link with the camera obscura...
but we didn't know how or through whom.
But now the riddle has been solved by the neighbor.
There are so many things going on
in a painting like this.
I don't ever have the idea that I'm in front of a canvas, right?
Paintings, even as a painter, you always see a painting
as paint on canvas,
where, this, I don't see the canvas anymore.
I see buildings, I see people waiting,
I see clouds about to move.
Here are all these... the sum of all these little things
that give you one moment, one moment.
I've never really understood
what makes this painting a Vermeer.
It looks like a work of a young painter,
it looks like a work of a not-experienced painter,
in my opinion.
His early paintings are just one big question mark.
Are these Vermeers?
He's doing saints,
he's doing mythological scenes,
hes doing different styles.
I don't understand the first paintings.
He's all over the place.
So, I don't know what he was doing.
Once we get to the Officer and Laughing Girl,
then I start to see Vermeer Vermeer.
Composition the color, the light.
Those effects that no other painter
in Holland would actually get.
He was making these like mini worlds,
mini universes in a corner of a room
where everything is so important.
And then, afterwards,
he has a brief rise in painting
where it becomes extremely ingenious.
These are really complex paintings,
and he really changes.
Compositions just become outrageously interesting.
Even a painting like The Lacemaker,
that's a complex, really complex painting,
and its about this big.
Why would he have put so much time.
So much effort, so much skill
into a painting that would not have got him
a lot of money, right?
It's just too small.
This painting is very "Vermeer-ish."
Some things are very special here, as we know him.
Other things seem a bit more crude.
Like the folds of the yellow shawl.
We know he might have done them a bit more elaborate.
They're not badly done, but they're not exceptional either.
Well, in the Counting Vermeer project
that was done a few years ago
based on x-rays of all of these Vermeer paintings,
they did find a few roll-mates,
so paintings that came from the same roll of fabric.
There's the Young Woman Seated at a Virginal
and The Lacemaker.
They were made from the same roll of fabric,
and they are roll-mates to each other.
And one would assume also all made by Vermeer,
but since Vermeer bought his canvas
probably with the ground already applied on it
from art suppliers in Delft or somewhere around there,
it could also have been bought by somebody from his circle.
There's still a tiny bit of doubt, you never know.
Anyone can buy that piece of canvas.
But I try to also stay away from attribution questions.
The same canvas, apparently.
But The Lacemaker is one of his masterpieces.
It's like a milestone, it sets the standard we expect from Vermeer.
So you think, perhaps he didn't finish this himself or perhaps...
as it was towards the end of his life, he was ill or a bit weary, I don't know.
The issue is that there are some works...
attributed to Vermeer by some experts but not by others.
So there are two camps.
As to this work, does it have a place in the authentic Vermeer canon?
Will we reach the conclusion that it was painted by Vermeer...
or will too many doubts remain?
And it would be wonderful if we would be able
to dive into it a little bit more again.
Yeah.
The first time I saw it,
I was kind of scheming to get hold of it
'cause it absolutely was certain to be Vermeer in my mind,
and then, so...
And then it was with Steve Wynn at that moment.
- Yeah. - Yeah.
Steve Wynn bought it at auction,
and he then had it in his casino,
and I went down there for Tom Kaplan,
so I got the price. I called Tom,
and Tom immediately said, "Well, is it really a Vermeer?"
I said, "Yes." He said, "Buy it."
So, it took seconds.
It's amazing.
And I don't begrudge wealthy people to...
They never really own them anyway.
They only own them in their lifetime.
Rich people do a great thing:
They die,
and when they die, something happens.
The taxes have to be paid, or they are inherited
by somebody else who has a different attitude,
and it's like a big funnel effect.
They all end up in museums.
Sooner or later, they will.
The money is growing
and the art is remaining stable.
There are no Vermeers left, except the one that was stolen.
There's only one thing that could happen:
The price of the paintings have to go up.
And people readily spend
$100 million, $200 million for paintings.
- I think it was wonderful. - I'll give you an example.
At that time, I did not have the... the...
aspirations to acquire a Vermeer.
It was still relatively early in the collecting.
- Well, there was no chance. - Well, there was no chance,
but also, I hadn't, I mean, I just started with Rembrandt,
and the Vermeer looked like a bridge too far,
but the painting had been acquired by Steve Wynn,
and he said,
"Well, if you want the Rembrandt self-portrait,
you have to buy the Vermeer at the same time."
And I thought about that, and, you know,
there's a little expression...
Sorry!
And I thought about that,
and there's a little expression saying,
"You can't threaten me with a good time."
And I said, "He wants to sell them both together?"
I said, "Tell him: Done."
I thought she was beautiful.
I thought she was completely enchanting,
the way that he had captured this... moment
of arrested recognition and, um...
courtship or love, affection,
that is perhaps uniquely characteristic,
in my experience, to Vermeer.
So one of the things that would be really interesting
is to examine that painting,
like we try to examine as many Vermeer paintings as possible,
but it would be wonderful, well,
if your painting could be involved in that.
Well, um, like I said,
you can't threaten me with a good time.
As soon as you want her and you're ready for her,
- she's yours. - Yeah.
Where do you want it? - A bit more to the right...
so we can lower the microscope.
Oh, yeah.
This black here ends at the wall, it doesn't run underneath the hands.
This is strange...
It's so small. - Yes.
Small and subtle.
I wonder what the technicians...
will be able to reveal.
You mean us. Or...?
You're not sure about the shawl.
It's one of the things, like the nose line.
A number of elements that give you a sense...
of how extremely well-considered...
and aesthetically conscious his work can be...
are missing here. I'm not supposed to say this...
but you get the feeling someone else came in to complete this painting.
You mean there might be an original shawl underneath this one?
Yes. - We've found no indications...
of any changes made to the shawl.
- Hi, Jonathan. - Hello, Gregor.
- Nice to meet you. - It's great to see you again.
Wow, we met so long ago. A year, I think.
Yeah, a year ago.
This painting, we have it in the studio in Amsterdam, and...
What was your impression?
I mean, just one-to-one impression.
It is... so difficult to say.
I think it is by him, but it's... sorry...
it is a less successful painting.
Mm-hmm.
Yeah, so the technical researchers found nothing
which is made in another way than Vermeer did it.
But I've spotted quite a number of anomalies.
Number one, if you take this picture,
you could basically cut it out and copy it right on top.
It's the same dimensions.
Number one, why would Vermeer had done a copy and paste?
The face is exactly the same proportions.
The arms are done in the same way.
- There's nothing original. - No.
This is very labored.
Its, uh, it's not a good piece of painting.
I noticed that we have this curl here.
It seems funny to me. Do we have The Lacemaker here?
You've got the same curl here.
The hairdo is supposedly similar to this,
but if you look carefully,
it's as if the painter didn't understand
what was happening here.
Vermeer quotes himself,
but he always adds something original.
There's no story here.
Here, everything he's done,
he's already done better, much better.
Why would he requote himself with so little enthusiasm?
- I totally agree. - Where did it all go?
Yeah, but I have the problem,
how to name, yeah, what's the name?
So do I have to write "Attributed to Vermeer,"
or, "Studio of Vermeer," but had he a studio?
- We don't know, right? - Was it an assistant? And so on.
So this is really a little bit a problem, of course.
Yeah, but maybe we...
Yeah, maybe at the end, Vermeer was not capable
to hold his quality.
Pieter.
Wonderful to see you!
I love how things work out.
- Hi, nice to meet you. - Great to meet you.
Thank you.
- How are you? - Nice to meet you.
- Anna Krekeler. - Tom Kaplan.
- Nice to meet you. - It's a pleasure, thank you.
- Did you miss her? - I did, and, you know,
this is the first time that I've seen her undressed, and...
Without the frame, I mean.
Huh.
It's the enormity of holding a Vermeer.
And the only one in private hands.
Literally, yeah?
Very well put!
That's a great turn of phrase.
The only one in private hands.
Yes!
When I first saw this painting,
and I saw it at Sotheby's the evening it was auctioned,
and I don't know whether you know this,
but I cast... I put up... I was the first bid.
I took the paddle from Johnny van Haeften,
and I said, "Give me that."
And then he saw I was going to continue,
and he took it from me and he said, "Give me that!"
He was afraid that I'll just continue.
Steve Wynn bought it, and then, of course,
we bought it from him.
So, Anna and Annelies made some additional research.
On the right side, we see a shortwave infrared,
and we are showing this because it kind of takes you
to the initial phase of the painting.
In the initial phase, this skirt continued up to the waistline,
and then the shawl was introduced.
So it becomes clear that the skirt
was already sort of covered by the shawl
when the final paint layers were added.
That is very exciting.
I mean, as you can imagine.
There was always that question,
did the shawl come afterwards, was it him?
And what essentially this shows is it was all contemporaneous.
What you've determined here
is really the most important new information,
I mean, in terms of the understanding
of this painting since the determination
that the canvas is the same as The Lacemaker.
I mean, from the same bolt of cloth.
Yeah, so it's inherent to the concept.
Yes, yes.
Yes.
It's him.
It's him, yeah.
Huh.
Um, thank you.
- Thank you, thank you. - Very welcome.
You know, we'll incorporate all of this information.
That is really nice that you're able to do...
Shall we begin? - Alright.
I can't see anything now.
Can you see anything? - No, nothing.
You let people come and tell them they can enter in groups.
Theme parks do that.
More people can watch if they stand further away.
I would add another 50 centimeters.
No! Will you be able to see anything then? - That's the question.
Can we try with 15 people?
This seems fine to me. - Yes, it's not bad.
You want to be able to stand here and look at it.
Yeah.
But not more than 15 people. - No, I saw that too.
Here we are.
Paintings you know well.
It's great to see them again.
Yeah, old friends.
This painting was the gift of Mr. and Mrs. Charles Wrightsman,
but it came with these restrictions
that none of the paintings they gave to us can travel.
They always have to be on view here at the Met.
I think it's stunning.
Absolutely.
And then, the Woman with a Water Pitcher,
which was the first Vermeer to actually comes to America,
is a very fragile painting,
so very unlikely to ever be loaned again.
I feel a kind of sadness in it as well since it's...
I mean, we know that we are never being able
to bring paintings like these back home.
This will be hard.
You're going after this one. - Yes.
Nice, this little breeze. - Yes, it's really hot.
This way or that? - I think it's this way.
Oh, lovely.
They've put the Dutch and the Italians together.
Do you see this? - Yes...
Oops, that was the...
I want to see the elephants. - Here they are.
A collection like this and there's no one here?
Now I'm seeing something totally different.
It's almost like a shock.
All at once you look into this room.
Wow.
This painting shows three figures.
This man is seducing the lady in this gorgeous salmon dress...
with a glass of wine.
An online ranking has this at number five.
Out of 37 Vermeers, that's pretty high.
This painting has a connection with another piece in Berlin...
which is also a seduction scene with a girl in a red dress.
The composition is different, but you can see...
his development, the great strides he made within a few years.
We will also have this piece, from the Frick Collection...
where he returns to the theme, combining it with music.
It's nice to be able to see him make decisions.
So the Braunschweig piece is pivotal to this story.
Was that me? - Sorry.
Hello, Mrs. Gatenbrรถcker. - Good to see you.
Good to see you. - Back in Braunschweig?
Yes, to look up some old friends.
Real old friends and old friends in 2D.
So far we've got 24 Vermeers for this exhibition, which is unprecedented.
Including the German ones: Two from Berlin, two from Dresden, one from Frankfurt.
But not this one from Braunschweig.
This coming year we've got the theme for the Lower Saxony state finals.
All sitting students, for their final art exams, have to write about this Vermeer.
How many students would that be? - I don't know.
About 500 sitting students are doing their final exams in the subject of Art?
No idea. - Or a thousand.
You could bus them to the exhibition in Amsterdam.
They will be bussed here.
We'll have to cast another yearning look at this painting...
swallow hard, and jump off the nearest bridge, I guess.
I don't think you'll drown. - No, the river's water level is too low.
There are plenty of other ways.
It's about the story we want to tell, not the number of paintings.
And for the story, the Braunschweig piece is very...
Yes, really. It will be so... - Gosh, Gregor.
Yeah.
I have reached a certain age and will retire.
Vermeer is the last show I will do at the Rijksmuseum.
This will be my crowning achievement.
I think most art historians have some reason why they do this work.
They can be pure scientists and draw up inventories...
or measure a piece and find that it's exactly 83 by 67 centimeters.
But that's not what it's about.
What is it about? - Well...
Of course it's very easy, really, and very simple...
No, it's not simple.
We are fully focusing on the exhibition,
which is opening already in early '23,
so it's getting a bit exciting now.
So, how many paintings will there be in the show?
Well, it depends, I think. It's...
As a friend and colleague,
I just, you know, I want to support this exhibition
because I think we all gain from that.
But, at the same time, you know,
these are what I always call "pilgrimage paintings,"
you know, the ones that people make a pilgrimage
to the National Gallery just to see.
Yeah, I don't think that all of the paintings
have ever been out of the building
at the same time.
Yeah.
Would there be a possibility of a reciprocal loan?
- Yeah. - Okay.
Of a Vermeer at some point?
- Yeah. - Okay.
We would be absolutely happy to collaborate with you
on a future Vermeer project here.
Great.
So you've examined all four right now.
Yeah.
And what I think is one of the most striking things is,
well, the way you're looking at this painting again.
Yeah, and, you know, as you know,
the attribution of this painting has been questioned.
That's one of the things that we really wanted to dig into
and investigate.
And you see striking differences, then,
to the others.
Um, might be.
The Girl with a Flute,
it's an amazing little piece of painting.
There's this hat that you could...
you could feel you could put your finger under her hat
and flip it off.
You know, you just want to take the hat off
of the woman's head.
It just really sticks out.
It looks pretty good to me,
but it doesn't really look like he finished it.
If this was finished,
this would have been, you know,
one of Vermeer's finest works.
What do you think of this one? They're not sure.
At the moment, I have no doubts at all
that these two were painted by the same artist.
Everything I see here says Vermeer.
The use of this green earth near the eye, no one else does that.
Now, the question is,
why did Vermeer use green earth in the flesh tones?
And so far,
nobody has really been able to come up with an explanation.
When you move into the neck,
you can see it's just fundamentally green.
I think it will be very difficult to gauge exactly.
No one knows how this was done.
Even the slightest amount of green earth here
will just dull down this cheek a little bit better.
Now...
He was the only painter using this technique.
I count at least eight paintings
that are clearly done with green earth
in the flesh tones.
Well, good morning to all of you.
It's quite an impressive moment.
Wonderful to have so much colleagues from abroad,
especially the Washington team in the full strength.
What now to do with Girl with a Flute?
The girl is looking straight at us,
I mean, has anyone ever seen a Vermeer girl
look straight at us?
This raking light image shows you
how lumpy the paint handling is,
which is a little unnerving.
Generally, you get a sense of someone who's really struggling,
who hasn't quite got command of their materials.
The green earth shadows in Vermeer's faces
seem to be unique to Vermeer,
but on the right, you can see how they built up
this big, thick mass of green that almost drips in places.
So, this artist knew that they should be using green earth
in their skin shadows,
but didn't quite have the knack.
So, um, close but no cigar.
So, Alex, you want to...
Yeah, so, you know, with this new body of evidence, you know,
that we've assembled,
we can say that Vermeer was not involved
in the creation of Girl with a Flute.
You know, we know that whoever painted this
had a very close proximity to Vermeer,
was likely observing him as he worked
just as a studio assistant or a student might.
And this is really exciting,
because there is, of course, no documentation about this,
but I think it's an opportunity
to rethink the way in which Vermeer was working,
I mean, the idea that he was possibly a mentor
training a next generation of artists.
That's a little update of what we've been doing for two years.
I was just gonna say, that's how we spent our vacations.
I was so impressed with this painting,
and now I have to hear you doubt...
We do, yeah.
And this is something new and I have to slick it.
Swallow it, yeah.
Swallow it, yeah, it's a big frog now.
You can do it, you can do it.
To hear that, you know,
it might not be by Vermeer after all,
it was kind of, uh, kind of shocking.
Was it? Oh, okay.
Yeah, because I've had my doubts for a long time myself.
So, what do you think?
Do you still want the painting in your show?
Girl with a Flute?
Now I really believe it's opening a door.
Yeah.
So if this is not him, who is it?
But who is it?
Had Vermeer an assistant?
Is it his daughter, Maria Vermeer?
Well, I mean...
Could it be him on a windy day?
- You don't believe. - No, no.
Couldn't it be that it is...
the first try out of this thing...
I... no. Could it be that... okay.
No, I mean, we just... we don't see a scenario
in which this is by Vermeer.
There isn't a single painting in the whole world
which is as closely related to the Girl with a Red Hat as the Girl with a Flute.
They are saying, we can see that he or she makes mistakes
which a trained artist would never make.
So this could have been an amateur who did this only once.
With all my knowledge of the Delft, Dordrecht and Rotterdam Schools...
I can't think of anyone who might have been capable of painting this.
There's big news in the art world.
A painting thought to be by Johannes Vermeer
isn't a Vermeer after all.
That's surprising to me. ...who left behind few works.
You see here the greenish shadows
in the flesh.
There's not the subtlety of transition
that we find in Vermeer.
So what? The neck is green?
If you look at the neck of the woman...
of the guitar player, it's pretty green.
Looks like a lizard.
But there's no doubt that that's a Vermeer.
So if this is not a Vermeer,
there must have been someone in his circle who came awfully close to him
in his or her painting.
And what does that mean?
The whole idea of Vermeer would have to be adjusted.
It's generally assumed that no one around him painted like this.
Or this one? - The Geographer.
These two are interchangeable. I prefer it this way.
No, I would hang The Geographer here.
Pieter, it's better to put these paintings with letters closer together.
I say, put this one here.
I want people to get inside Vermeer's head
to give them the chance to see something they haven't seen before.
I think the Berlin one would be more powerful here.
Yeah, I can tell you right now that we are at this moment
with 27 paintings for the exhibition.
27?
Yeah 27.
That is five more than in The Hague in '95, '96.
Mm.
But we will have the three of the Frick Collection.
Oh, all three of the Frick Collection?
All three of them.
Oh, the Office and Laughing Girl will be there.
Yeah.
I would go just to see that painting.
- You're a painter. - Mm-hm.
An artist.
And you can look like a painter.
Yes, yes, I always do.
Now, um, you have always to make a difference
between paintings you love,
because you think that they are really, really fine,
and then the technicians are coming to you
and they're saying the other way.
So I am a scientist,
so in my heart there are two things bumping,
and so a little bit the art lover
and the other is, of course, the scientist.
There are so many enigmas.
There are so many things
that I think both of us still don't understand.
I think both of us still are very careful, you know,
we don't want to tread on facts
and we don't want to make up our own facts.
I believe that we're both willing to live with doubts.
Mm.
Vermeer has meant something different
to every single generation.
I think I've counted six or seven Vermeers
in the last century.
A long time ago, it was about Vermeer the leftist.
You could say he's painting the people, the common life.
And then afterwards,
Vermeer became an abstract painter, right?
A formalist painter.
Just shapes and colors.
After that, people started thinking about Vermeer
as a story teller,
as an iconographer.
And the most recent development
is a sort of a feminist kind of appeal.
Vermeer, who painted women.
The painter of women,
what their psyche was and he was so near to women.
So, every generation sort of turns over what's there before,
and so it's hard to keep up with it.
The idea that these artists were isolated geniuses
existing in their own world, creating in this void.
It's just not, um, in a way, relevant anymore.
It's not a relevant question.
We really want to know, you know,
tell me about this ambiance that you were in,
and tell me about your wife,
tell me about your mother-in-law,
tell me about your daughters.
Because women are such a central theme to him.
But it must have been a very influential environment
to have all of these women around you.
And we don't often think of their role,
though I think this next generation really is.
Girl with a Flute is by Vermeer after all, the Rijksmuseum says in Het Parool.
Only last month, American researchers claimed the work is not by Vermeer.
But now it is supposed to be a Vermeer again.
Has this painting ever had so much publicity?
No, never.
"Girl with a Flute is actually by Vermeer the Rijksmuseum says."
Okay...
"Pieter Roelofs, Head of Paintings and Sculpture"...
Good photo.
"We believe we are right."
"Our argument is crystal-clear."
You know... - I thought we were still getting there.
"Girl with a Flute will not be loaned out as a Vermeer..."
"but we will put it up as a Vermeer."
"The doubts will evaporate during the flight across the ocean."
What I like about this and what I've been missing in art history for a long time
is that at last we've got two opposing opinions again
and people are trying to exchange ideas
which leads to heated discussions.
Hi. - Good morning.
Pieter is here too.
Yeah.
Nice.
They're on the table, we can start at once.
What I read in the paper was a bit of a surprise to me.
So I thought...
I agree with the content of the newspaper article,
but it's also a matter of having regard for our colleagues.
And I wonder if this went down well. Because you do say...
Basically we expressed what we discussed here.
And it attracted a great deal of publicity,
seeing as it made The New York Times and The Guardian and so on.
It says something about Vermeer's status as an artist.
But it's not an ideal scenario.
Good morning, good to see you.
Perfect.
Good, great.
Okay.
Okay, microphone.
Okay, all right.
Yeah, now good.
It's a pity that it got into the papers like this.
They've expressed their surprise: "Guys, what's this we read in the papers?"
So we shouldn't throw it away, I think.
We thought you had properly communicated
that in your opinion it should still be part of Vermeer's oeuvre.
But you hadn't. So then it's a matter of having it out and moving on.
There you go.
- Thanks, Jon. - You're welcome.
That was fun.
That was real fun, wasn't it?
What a good time.
You could have continued for another two hours I think.
So, whatever it is,
it's quite a convincing composition, I think.
She's leaning at one side, so her weight is over,
that's why she's a little bit diagonal.
I would love to show you something.
Oh.
Is this it?
It is it.
This is the one that Vermeer saw.
- Yep. - Oh...
Yeah, that he saw with his own eyes.
He saw with own eyes and thought it was worthwhile
- to put in his painting. - Yeah.
And very interesting that he cut it in his painting here,
I would say.
So we have here the turban on top, his arm and...
So, what is this light part,
that... this is the lightest,
there's sort of a rectangle here.
- That corresponds to that. - Yeah, to this one.
- It's really exactly that. - Right, yes.
Very funny.
I've always been amazed that you were able
to connect that little sliver of rect...
I always thought,
"We'll never know what was this supposed to be."
- Mm. - And then you discovered this.
Yeah.
I guess I didn't look at it as careful as you did.
So, we have an object that Vermeer actually touched.
Yeah.
Amazing.
Yeah.
Do you mind if I touch it in the corner?
Yeah.
Can I just touch it just slightly, that...
Oh...
Have I seen all the Vermeers?
Yes, I think I've seen them all.
My very last Vermeer was the one in Berlin.
What was it a year ago, yeah.
A little bit more than a year ago.
The Glass of Wine, or The Girl with the Glass of Wine.
And it was good to have put this thing off, you know?
You turn 71 and you see your last Vermeer.
And I was just really moved.
I just walked into the room...
I'm sorry.
And uh...
it was just like the first Vermeer that I'd ever seen.
1.65? - No, 1.67, please.
Nice. Let's do this one too, so we'll have one room done.
Mind the raised edges.
Okay, here we go.
Easy...
It feels very different, the Mauritshuis without Vermeers.
Is your side in? - Yes, almost.
My side is in now.
It really comes alive now. - Yes.
What do you think?
Looks pretty amazing.
I'm looking forward to having people see them,
compare them, and yeah.
Is it strange to see her here? - A little.
This is such a treat!
This looks good. - Yes.
Okay!
Dear colleagues, it's nine o'clock.
The museum is opening to the public.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.