Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
-Me Chouraqui is here.
-Thank you.
-Good morning, Mr. Kiejman. -Good morning, Mr. Kiejman.
Thank you for coming so quickly.
I need to read you something that concerns you too.
"Me Kiejman,
"you are hereby relinquished of my defense in favor
"of Messrs Bartoli and Chouraqui who will do it without you.
"You would have insured it excellently and would have used all your value
"to obtain my acquittal, but I am convinced
"that you rejoice in that which causes me damage
"and disempowers me.
"You experience a subtle pleasure.
"And however little inclined to the dialectic
"of the relationship between defendant and lawyer, this decision
"of which I am aware a week before my trial
"is my way of asserting my freedom in the face of your attitude.
"Thank you for everything you've done for me.
"Pierre Goldman."
Did you know about this?
-Yes, he did. He wrote to me a few days ago.
-Why didn't you tell me?
-I didn't take his letter seriously.
-Do you have it with you? -No, I left it at the office.
-Can someone make us wear it?
-I'm not sure it'll be crowded at this hour.
-I think it's important. I'd like to read it.
Call us.
-If you like.
I'll just read you a few extracts.
"Francis, I would like to explain calmly
"my great hostility against Kiejman.
"When someone declares his friendship in writing
"and that I give mine in return, that implies a genuine relationship.
"But Kiej stays in the fucking rotten worldliness.
"It doesn't matter, I still think
"that he can defend me very well,
"but I swear I can't take this guy anymore."
Shall I continue? -Yes, you go on.
-One: he is responsible for the fact that the errors in my book
"in the 1st edition have not been corrected
"on the 2nd and 3rd prints.
"He had to find something to keep my money from being fucked.
"Everything he's found has been ineffective.
"Two: he was to intervene to the Nouvel Obs
"to find me a job.
"He didn't and he laughed and said:
"'They'll always have a place for you.
"Three: he didn't answer me
"on Christiane's Christiane's presence at the trial.
"There's no way that she testify and be subjected
"the disgusting voyeurism of justice.
"Four: he tells me the 1st private Python 357
"with Signoret and Montand, or that he goes to Amsterdam
"find Depardieu and Adjani, I don't give a shit."
I'll spare you the rest.
-No, not at all, you go on.
-I can't stand his irony, his frivolity
"and his parlor Jew pettiness.
"He went out of his way
"and used my friend Régis Debray to get into this affair
"by pretending not to go in.
"It disgusts me.
"It may sound crass by my prison paranoia,
"but it's the truth.
"Kiejman did the trick sincerity.
"I'm just an opportunity for him
"to take center stage of the legal news.
"What an exceptional scene for him.
"He possessed me. I hate it. It demoralizes me.
"It's no good for me to arrive demoralized.
"Contact with him is unbearable.
"My desire is to throw it away,
"but I don't want to make without your opinion.
"Answer me quickly. Your friend, Pierre."
-What did you answer?
-That a week before the trial, it was a mistake.
-He didn't listen to you.
-Yes, I just got out of the visiting room.
He will write to you to ignore his letter.
-Salon Jew"?
Unbearable. Who does he think I am?
He doesn't know what I've done. Nothing was given to me.
I come from a more than his.
My mother could neither read nor write. She brought us up alone.
He's the armchair Jew!
With his literary success and his leftist fans.
-Don't pay any attention to him. The trial makes him feverish.
-It's just too easy. Who isn't feverish?
The stakes are colossal for me. I've only done a few sit-downs.
For weeks I've been working
for this trial!
Sending a man to the scaffold makes me sick.
It makes me nauseous, I can't sleep at night.
All this to be insulted?
I want to drop everything, I'm sick of it.
-Please don't, don't let him down.
-Why should I? Give me a reason.
-Without you, he won't make it!
I know how important it is to you
you won't miss it.
-Why defend a man who wants so little to get by?
He's suicidal.
-He saw his accusation as a curse,
associates his ordeal with the fate of his family,
lives as a martyr without knowing the difference.
-The excuse for not answering to the facts.
-No, on the contrary, he wants to answer everything.
But he wants to keep control over his defense
and believes he's his own best lawyer.
-We saw what happened at the 1st trial.
-Try to understand him. He feels he's the victim of an injustice.
-As far as you're concerned, he's innocent. Don't you wonder?
-I refuse to ask myself. It's like a friend in trouble.
A brother. I want to help him. -A brother?
-Yes, a brother. A Jewish brother.
He's the scapegoat, we've got to get him back
of the desert. -Please...
Did you meet at Talmud?
-No, karate.
-When you come from a good family,
it's rare to come across a specimen like him.
-So, what do you you going to do?
-I'll defend it,
but not only for the reasons he thinks.
But help me contain it.
If we don't work calmly, we won't make it.
Hubbub
-Madame Signoret! -Come this way!
-Madame Signoret! -Madame Signoret!
-Mme Signoret! -Please!
-Mme Signoret! -To your right.
-Madame Signoret! -Madame Signoret!
-Madame Signoret! -Madame Signoret!
-Mr. Debray? Please!
-Mr. Debray? -Mr. Debray!
-Mr. Debray, this way.
Hubbub -Hi, there. How are ya?
-Good morning to you. -Good morning to you.
-Mr. Goldman?
Mr. Goldman? Mrs. Goldman? -Come this way!
-To the right! Right there!
Yes, this way! -Mademoiselle?
-Look there. To the right! -Young man?
-Watch me. -Young man?
-Turn right! -Watch me. Look at me again!
-Me Garaud! -Me Garaud?
-Please, Mr. Garaud! -Please, Mr. Garaud!
-Over here! -This way!
-This way. -To your right!
-Master, please? -Master! Master! This way, please!
-This is the bench for the plaintiff. Please have a seat here.
We open a door.
-Goldman innocent! -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
Cheers and applause
The applause dies down.
Camera clicks -The trial is about to begin.
Please leave the room.
Ring
Please stand up.
Court and jury.
We open a door.
-Sir, please stand up and confirm your full name,
date and place of birth, profession and address.
-Goldman Pierre Bernard.
Born in Lyon on June 22, 1944.
No profession, no fixed abode and detained in Fresnes prison.
-You may sit back down.
We will now proceed to the indictment.
Pierre Goldman, the facts with which you are charged
are as follows.
On December 4, 1969 around 8 p.m,
fraudulently took approximately 2,500 francs
to the detriment of the Farmachi couple
to the closure of their drugstore, 25 rue de la Butte aux Cailles
in Paris's 13th arrondissement.
To have December 19, 1969 at 8:10 p.m.
armed robbery of a pharmacy at 6 boulevard Richard-Lenoir
in Paris's 11th arrondissement.
Intentional homicide
on Simone Delaunay and Jeanine Aubert,
the 2 pharmacists.
Attempted homicide on Raymond Trocard
and Gérard Quinet, both wounded shot at point-blank range.
On December 20, 1969 around 7:30 p.m,
attacked the company VOG, located 34 rue Tronchet
in the 8th arrondissement, Paris by 3 men, 2 of them black
for the sum of 22,675 francs.
To have January 16, 1970, at 7:45 a.m., passage Ramey,
in the 18th arrondissement, stolen from the cash register
family allowance a sum valued at 7,800 francs
also with a black accomplice black accomplice.
I would point out to the Court that Pierre Goldman
acknowledges all the facts with which he is charged
except those of the pharmacy on boulevard Richard-Lenoir.
In this case, he has an alibi.
He says that on December 19, from 7 p.m. to 9 p.m,
he was at a friend's house, Joël Lautric,
47 rue de Turenne in the 4th arrondissement, Paris.
It should be noted that his criminal record up to that point
a single conviction
for insubordination military service
and that the defense did not wish to call
character witnesses.
Lawyers, will you
explain this point?
-It's our customer's choice, Mr. Chairman.
-Mr. Goldman, would you care explain yourself on this point?
-I have not called any witnesses in my defense
because I consider myself totally innocent in the pharmacy affair.
I stand before you with this innocence alone,
without any of the traditional means of these trials
which increase the pump's capacity,
the theatrical aspect and everything else that repels me.
-BRAVO! Cheers and applause
-Please!
Please!
-And furthermore, as far as my morality is concerned,
it's obvious that, in terms law and social morality,
I don't have one because I committed 3 armed robberies.
Laughter from the audience It would therefore be ridiculous
people, prestigious and honorable,
declare to the Court that I would be overwhelmed with qualities.
I am innocent because I am innocent
and not because various people
emphasize such and such a trait of my character
or my behavior.
It is well known that many murderers
were very nice men,
of excellent moral character and peaceful nature.
I want this case to be judged on its merits
and on substance only
and I intend to contribute this trial
from any artifice that would obscure its essence.
Cheers and applause
-Thank you!
The president taps his fist.
Thank you!
Mr. Goldman, we're going to tell the story of your life.
-My life?
All my life? -Yes.
-It may take a while.
Laughs -We've got plenty of time.
You were born
June 22, 1944 in Lyon
of a Polish Jewish couple, resistance fighters and communists.
In 1945, following suspicions of espionage
to the Soviet Union, your mother is expelled from France
and moved back to Poland.
You stay with your father, he entrusts you to your aunt
and gets you back a year later, when he gets married
to Mrs. Ambrunn Ruth.
Your father and stepmother officially recognize you
in 1949 and you will never see your biological mother
10 years later, on your 1st trip to Poland.
Your family and friends describe you as having had a troubled childhood.
Can you tell us more?
-I refuse to express myself on this intimate subject in public.
-To put it another way, your biological mother
would she have lived for her ideas?
-No. The proof is in the pudding. Laughter from the audience
-Your schooling up to the end of primary school
runs smoothly.
You do your college in a boarding school.
You say in your book premonitory:
"I liked that warmth warmth."
In high school, things become more chaotic.
In 1re, you take part in a student revolt.
You're the animator.
-I was 10 years early. Laughs
-You are enrolling at the Sorbonne in social sciences.
In 1962, you joined at the Union of Communist Students
for which you are head of security.
Everyone describes you as active and feisty.
At the same time, you're experiencing depressive episodes.
You have several stays in a psychiatric hospital.
We have some letters from psychiatrists
about electroshock sessions you may have undergone.
Can you tell us more about these depressive episodes?
-I refuse to comment on that. I want to stick to the facts.
-Very well, then. Let's get back to the facts.
At the end of this period,
you are avoiding your military obligations.
-Yes.
-You're an "insoumis". -Yes, I am.
-What exactly happened?
-I took my suitcase to go to the barracks in Nancy.
And I changed my mind. I joined my mother in Poland.
-You stay longer than for summer vacations
you spent with her?
-I'm making up for lost time. I'm making up for lost time.
I want to get to know with my parents' country.
Its history fascinates me, the war
the holocaust...
My mother takes me everywhere.
I'm going to the cemetery of the last ghetto battles.
I'm going back to Auschwitz. My mother took me there when I was 13.
-You say that at this time, you finally meet her.
-Yes, that's it.
I'm old enough for us to talk.
I discovered that despite the misery Stalinism, the gulags,
she remained true to herself.
An activist, a revolutionary at heart.
I ask her about the resistance, about the war with my father.
I'm haunted by their story.
I'd like to be like them.
Relive that atmosphere of revolt, feel that pride.
I want to be a Jewish warrior.
-A Jewish warrior? How about that?
-Yes.
To free myself from the pain of being Jewish.
-So you wanted to join the guerrillas?
-Absolutely.
-Your mother introduces you to Cuban revolutionaries.
-Yes, but at first she refuses.
She's afraid for me, thinks it's crazy.
-And yet it does.
-I'm so insistent that she gives in.
She writes to them that I want to meet them.
I'm off to Havana to see them.
I return to Paris to leave at their 1st signal.
-In Paris, you took part in the events of May 68.
-Yes, but by a long way.
It's all an imaginary power grab,
a parody of urban guerrilla warfare
where everyone returns after throwing down their paving stones.
It's grotesque.
Laughs I want to go back to Latin America.
-That's right, in June 68, you left
to Venezuela, where you join an armed group of 6 fighters.
How does it work?
-It's the most beautiful time of my life.
Combat training, camaraderie, clandestine life.
I have everything I dreamed of.
-How do you survive? With what money?
-We sleep outside,
we eat what we're given, we live on nothing.
-The leader of your group is Oswaldo Baretto.
A highly erudite Francophile, with a degree in sociology,
but also a man
with a troubled past, experienced in armed combat
and the use of weapons.
In your book, you seem to be fascinated fascinated by him. Why?
-He was the greatest writer Latin America for me,
even though he hasn't written anything. Laughter and applause
-You returned with him to Paris in September 1969
and with 2 comrades from your armed group.
Why this sudden return? -We had other plans.
-Rumor has it that you were involved there,
with your armed group, in a major robbery.
You would have robbed the country's largest bank
and would all be wanted by the police.
Could this explain your your hasty return?
-You name it, it's a rumor.
It's flattering, but unfortunately false.
-We're wondering whether Venezuela's
that you've abandoned your ideals. -No, I haven't.
-And you've turned into banditry.
-Certainly not.
-However, back in Paris, you do nothing more.
You neither study nor work.
-I still want to make a revolution.
I buy guns,
I'm writing a manual for urban guerrilla warfare.
My old friends think I'm crazy,
but I believe in it.
-Your old pals, as you call them,
described you at the time as a stubborn man,
profiteering and temperamental.
-That's true, but the penal code doesn't provide for that.
-Above all, you've become totally idle.
You don't do anything anymore, sleep all day,
go out every night
in West Indian music clubs and drink a lot.
-It's true, I wasn't a gift, but I don't deny it.
I don't see the link between these undeniable facts
and the central case, the heinous murders I'm accused of.
-It's the context in which at the time of the event.
-Look... It's true, I used to be like that.
But I never thought opening fire on 2 unarmed women
who hadn't done anything to me.
-We'll ask you about this later.
According to these same friends, you had expensive tastes.
-Yes, if you like.
-You spend all your money. You're a high roller.
-Yes!
I pay for a lot of tours. Laughs
I spend a lot of money with prostitutes.
I buy a lot of shirts because I sweat
and I hate washing.
Because of this, I'm forced to become a thief.
-There was no other way
to earn a living?
-Yes, of course. -Less easy?
-It's not easy being a thief. There are risks.
-Which ones? -The death penalty, for example.
-Did you know that the death penalty
for assault with a deadly weapon?
-Absolutely. -Didn't that scare you?
-Much less than prison.
-Were you afraid of prison?
-A terrible fear.
-Isn't it contradictory to choose a career as a criminal
when you fear prison? -Yes, I do.
-So please explain.
-I was desperate.
I...
I felt in a political void.
And I needed money, that's all!
And...
I don't want to dwell on the subject.
-Why is that? -I'm not particularly proud.
-Mr. Goldman, would you call yourself call you a gangster?
-Yes. -And a murderer?
-No, certainly not!
If I'd robbed the pharmacy on boulevard Richard-Lenoir,
I would never opened fire on 2 women
who had never done anything to me, ever!
It goes against everything I stand for.
-GOLDMAN, INNOCENT! Cheers
GOLDMAN, INNOCENT! -Thank you!
The president taps his fist.
Cheers Please!
The cheering stops. Thank you for your time.
We're done with your résumé.
You can sit back down.
I quote Pierre Goldman in his book.
"To my surprise, I had with the various psychiatrists
"excellent relations.
"Notably, one of them, a woman, Mme Boitel.
"We talked a lot, she made me feel good.
"During an interview, I understood about my robberies
"that it was a delusion,
"that I had been the abyss of madness.
"I made a trivial but important discovery.
"I was inflicting a relentless punishment.
"A tribunal within me was governed by a merciless law.
"I was only struck in front of my dreams and ideals.
"Justice could not punish me because in my crimes,
"I had already punished myself.
"These crimes were not about armed robbery.
"I had punished myself for not being like my father.
"A partisan. Not to have been shot.
"For not fighting with Che.
"For not seeking out Nazis to suppress them."
Madame, can you confirm that Pierre Goldman entrusted you with this?
-Not exactly those terms, but yes.
-What do these these phrases about self-judgment?
-They look just like her.
-Would you interpret them as an admission of guilt?
-No, it's just a sign of its complexity.
He thinks a lot about what's happening to him.
-What was your impression
when you met Pierre Goldman in prison?
-He was in deep solitude.
Unable to relate with others.
His thoughts were incoherent. He was out of control.
He showed signs of anxiety.
I had a hard time to get in touch with him.
-According to your 1st report,
you would have hesitated to declare him schizophrenic.
-That's right.
-Why didn't you?
-I wasn't sure.
-But in these 1st reports, you describe it as dangerous.
-Yes.
-Why?
-Given his psychological fragility,
I thought in certain circumstances,
he could be dangerous.
Over time, my opinion has evolved.
My initial conclusions can no longer be taken literally.
-Would you say that he was fulfilled in prison?
-Yes.
-Would you say he's happy in prison?
-Prison is a reassuring environment.
-What about you, Goldman? What do you think?
-In a way, I like prison.
-Earlier you were telling us the opposite.
-That was before I went.
I'm I'm almost afraid to leave.
-Does Goldman's personality seems compatible
with the alleged facts?
-I can't answer that directly.
But through interviews with him,
I didn't detect any particular aggressiveness
as described in the pharmacy.
-What about the assaults he admitted to?
-That they are of a different nature. -In what way?
-From what I've observed
of my work with prisoners,
the act is preceded by a violent family history,
mental imbalance imbalance.
Not so for Mr. Goldman.
-Thank you, Madame. -Mr. Chairman?
-Go ahead, Me Garaud.
-Madam, is it true that before his 1st trial,
to express the esteem in which he held you,
Goldman would have given you flowers picked in prison?
-That's true, but I don't see the connection.
-I can see that.
You might think that Goldman seduced you
and loses your objectivity.
Booing -Please!
Me Garaud, please.
-Mr. Chairman?
Allow me to read a letter from Dr Oury,
which hosted Pierre Goldman for several months
in his psychiatric clinic de Laborde at the age of 18.
-You're welcome.
-Pierre Goldman presented on his arrival
"a dissociative state with elements of anxiety
"manifesting by impressive raptures
"and thoughts of suicide.
"It seemed to be an episodic psychotic state
"having started when he was young with depressive phases
"against a background of paranoid tendencies
"and an unstructured personality.
"He should have been followed for a long time,
"but it was difficult to intervene
"so distrustful was he and felt persecuted."
Unlike you, Dr Oury does not rule out psychosis.
-No, I didn't. Like you, I read this letter.
Dr Oury speaks of psychotic episodes.
No psychosis.
I'm in complete with him.
-So Pierre Goldman cannot be be declared irresponsible?
-Absolutely.
-Thank you very much.
-Miss, confirm to the clerk
your full name, date and place of birth,
profession and address.
-Miss Sucab Christiane, 30, born in Guadeloupe,
currently unemployed
and residing 66 rue Daguerre, Paris.
-You have a relationship with the accused so you don't have to take an oath.
-Yes.
-Tell us how you met,
Pierre Goldman and you.
-In the early winter of '69, at a West Indian party.
A friend of mine introduced us.
-Joël Lautric? -Yes.
-Mr. Goldman's alibi? -Yes, Mr. Goldman's alibi.
-How did this meeting go?
-We danced a little and then...
We left the party, walked through Paris and...
We didn't leave each other's side for several weeks.
-And then?
-He disappeared overnight.
I never heard from her again. I went back to Guadeloupe.
-In Guadeloupe where you got married?
-Yes.
-You have renewed contact with Pierre Goldman
when you heard he'd been arrested.
-Yes.
-How did you get back in touch?
-We wrote to each other and...
When I returned to Paris, I went to see him in prison.
-What did you tell him in your letters?
-Do I have to answer? -No, you don't.
-No. Sigh
Mr. Goldman talks about your relationship in his book.
"I was overcome with a violent love for this woman
"which arose of a decisive time in my past.
"I was fighting to destroy this love, to annihilate it,
"I wanted to get it out of my flesh and soul, but I couldn't.
"I told him on December 21, 1969
"that one day I would reach the end and see his eyes.
"I had come to the end and I could see his eyes,
"I hadn't forgotten them.
"I wrote to her that I wanted to marry her,
"live with her, live at all, that we would have children.
"They wouldn't be swarthy Jews with Negro blood,
"but negroes with Jewish blood."
How do you explain Pierre Goldman's passion
for Caribbean culture?
-I can't explain it.
-Goldman, how do you explain this?
-That's because I am too, I'm a nigger.
-Bah voyons...
-A Jew and a black man, are the same thing.
-Mr. Chairman? -Mr. General Counsel.
-Madam, in your 1st police statement to the police,
you stated in the days following the crime,
the accused showed an interest in what the newspapers
reported on the case.
-I don't remember saying that.
-This is noted in black and white in the PV.
Can you confirm this?
-Come in, mademoiselle.
-I'll say it again,
I have no recollection saying that.
-Goldman, you read all the articles
on the boulevard Richard-Lenoir
in the days following the crime? -Yes, that's right.
-Why this interest in this case?
-Probably because I had the desire to be accused.
-You've been granted your wish.
Booing -At last, Goldman!
You can't content with this formula.
Answer truthfully.
-I was driven in spite of myself towards this double homicide.
I can't explain explain why,
but a strange breath drew me towards these 2 murders.
-To the point of committing them? -Not at all!
Booing -Me Garaud,
you will speak when it's your turn!
-I'm still quoting you.
You describe Pierre Goldman at the time of your meeting as
"unbalanced, drinking a lot
"and dreaming of dying with weapons in hand,
"after shooting police officers,
"supposed to represent bourgeois society."
Would you describe it the same way?
-Certainly not. -Why not?
Because you became his companion?
-It's nothing to do with that. -Why did you say that?
-The police forced me to say it.
-Are you accusing the police of suborning your answers?
This is serious. -This is outrageous!
-It's the truth!
-Madame is not the only one to have made such remarks.
At that time,
all of Pierre Goldman's of Pierre Goldman describe him
as violent, rowdy, dangerous
and unsavory.
I quote Mr. Caprice, Mr. Lautric's brother-in-law.
"I had the opportunity to see him
"to express his political views and in his words,
"it was clear that he had no worries
"for human lives
"if it got in the way his objectives.
"He was an extremist."
-If everyone you mentioned said anything bad about me to the police,
it's for the same reasons as Christiane.
I point out that they are all black
and that's the only reason
that they were manhandled by the police as soon as they arrived!
Applause
Cheers -Please!
Please! The president bangs his fist.
-Are you implying that the police are racist?
-I imply it
and I affirm it.
Cheers -It's a disgrace!
-Please!
-Mr. Chairman... The cheering stops.
My client wanted to say that some police officers
are racist, not the entire police force.
-No, the police are racist. All the police.
Cheers
-Please! The president bangs his fist.
Cheers
-Please!
Take your seats!
The president taps his fist.
Thank you, mademoiselle. You may sit back down.
-Alter Moïse Goldman.
Born in Poland on November 30, 1909.
Residing at 36 rue Pierre Valette in Montrouge.
Shopkeeper. -You are the father of the accused.
You were born in a poor shtetl family.
You immigrated to France in 1927 to escape discrimination
and pogroms against Jews.
During the war, you became a hero of the resistance.
-Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
-Let's talk a little about your childhood in Poland.
-Do you think my case is interesting?
It's about my son we're talking about.
-Very good.
Tell us about the 1st years of your son's life.
-The conditions in which his mother and I lived in Lyon...
were trying, dreadful, even.
We didn't get along very well.
We argued.
-What were the reasons?
-Mostly politics.
But in reality, we argued about everything.
-You're talking about of Janca Sochaczewska,
the accused's biological mother? -Yes.
-She fights in Lyon in the same cell as you?
-Yes, she is the secretary of the resistance
for the entire Lyon region.
-You're falling in love.
It's against this backdrop of war that you make a child.
-She's the one who wants it more than anything.
For her, it's a challenge to death.
She believes that this child will continue the fight
and sing for the oppressed.
-Tell us a little more about this woman.
-Janca is Polish, like me.
She grew up in a more religious background than I did.
His father studied Torah, he was a fanatic.
She rebelled against him.
She became communist militant,
despite his father's prediction that communism
would bring misfortune everywhere.
As communists were hunted down,
she got arrested.
Her mother came to find her in prison and said:
"Easter is coming, we would like you to accept
"unleavened bread."
Janca got up without answering,
leaving her mother alone in the visiting room.
When she came home, her father chased her away.
The next day, she left Poland for France.
-I quote your son in his book.
"At liberation, my father left my mother,
"or she leaves him, or they separate.
"I stay with my mother, who works at the Polish Embassy.
In 47, for various reasons she had to leave France.
"I remember, we were about to leave for Poland,
"but taking advantage my mother's absence,
"my father, with fellow resistance fighters
"came to take me away.
"My mother couldn't do anything.
"She couldn't provide proof that I was her son
"because she had to give birth under a false identity.
"She went back to Poland without me.
"I don't know if my father kept me because he loved me.
"He didn't want his son to live in a country
"where Jews had been exterminated.
"An anti-Semitic country. Antisemitic and Stalinist.
"A cursed country, he says.
"That's all I know.
"My father never expresses his feelings."
Is your son telling the truth?
-I admit I may have said about the Poles.
I've always wanted the good of my son
and made sure that he had everything he needed.
When I remarried
with Ruth, we took him back with us.
My wife recognized him and raised him as her own child.
-He has never
posed any problems?
-The problems came late, in adolescence.
He was expelled from several high schools.
He was undisciplined.
At home, we sometimes had arguments too.
But I swear...
that he has never laid a hand on anyone.
Not his brothers, not his sister let alone his mother-in-law.
My son is incapable of shooting a woman.
But if he had, the bond between us would no longer exist.
I would never have gone to see him in prison.
-But it took you 2 years to visit him.
-Why?
You were waiting to be convinced of his innocence?
How did he convince you?
-He wrote me a letter.
He swore his innocence on my head
of one of our comrades beheaded by the Vichy police in '44.
-And you believed him? -Yes, I did.
-Before he wrote to you, did you think he could do it?
-No, because I know that even in the worst of times, my son
couldn't give up respect for life.
-But that's enough!
It doesn't matter, my father thinks what he wants!
What's the difference?
It's not a question of whether I am capable of these crimes.
I'm not guilty!
I'm not guilty! -Goldman, shut up.
Let's start again.
Other assaults, you thought he was capable of?
-No, I haven't either.
-He recognized them all. -Yes, I know he did.
-How do you explain them?
-Perhaps it's a kind of suicide.
At age 16, for example, at boarding school, after an argument with a classmate,
he threw himself into the void, went through a glass roof.
He suffered serious head injuries.
Maybe it's all my fault.
I'm sorry I didn't understand you.
You know, before I read your book...
Sigh
I didn't know you.
-Do you have any questions?
-I'd like to ask you a question.
Why didn't the defendant's mother not appear?
-She wanted to come, but didn't get a visa.
-How could this happen? Her son is facing the death penalty.
-In the eyes of the law, she's not his mother.
She was unable to justify her trip.
-It's a defense strategy to put away
the sulphurous reputation of the accused's mother.
Suspicions of espionage, prison in Poland,
calls for insurrection, abandonment of family responsibilities...
Booing In aid of genealogy
more glorious than his father, resistance fighter, patriot...
What a beautiful picture!
-But stop, who are you to talk about my parents?
What have you done in your life?
What have you experienced? Not a thing!
My parents are exemplary and courageous.
They're heroes.
They have been through exceptional trials.
I wanted to be worthy of them, but I've gone astray,
I fell into partying, drinking, hold-ups.
It's up to me to ask their forgiveness.
-Thank you, sir. We're finished now.
15-minute suspension.
-I didn't want Christiane to testify.
Why did you let this happen?
-The public prosecutor summonsed her to appear.
-And my father?
Forced to justify himself. What a humiliation for him!
I'll never forgive you.
Why does my family have to go through all this?
-Your fault! You're the one to blame!
Now sit down.
The witness part will be the trickiest part for you.
-Is it? -Yes.
Leave it to us.
We're going to discredit them with method...
-I've already done it in my book. -Is this a joke?
You were alone in your cell!
The game was easy. Now they'll be ahead of you.
You were without a contradiction, this will be different.
I would ask you not to make things difficult for us.
Control your moods, resist your good words.
Stop talking about police conspiracies
or machination.
We don't know what's in the minds of jurors.
It can be disastrous for you.
And resist Garaud's provocations.
This guy's smart, he's treacherous.
He wants to get you off we've seen.
If he succeeds, he will have won.
Do you understand me?
-Mr Jobard, at the time of the events, you were commissioner
to the 4th territorial brigade.
You have received the confidences from a certain "X2".
Remind the Court under what conditions
you took his testimony.
-March 1970, 3 months after the event,
one of our indicators reported to us
that a certain "Goldi" was the perpetrator of assaults
including boulevard Richard-Lenoir.
The afternoon of the tragedy, he had a drink with Goldman
in the Odéon district.
He confided in her that he had planned an attack on a creamery
on the same day in the Saint-Paul district.
He would have shown him 2 weapons, a Herstal and a P38.
-But how did this this indicator become convinced
that Pierre Goldman was responsible for the murders?
-Goldman is said to have told her
a few days later. -It's not true!
I never saw him again after that drink.
-Why is this man accusing you?
-He's a moron ready to say anything
to make themselves look good.
(-Why does he keep going?) (-I don't know.)
-His mind is so simple
that he did a little synthesis disastrous for me.
-A brief summary?
-He compiled articles
on the news.
He learned that a Herstal had fired into the pharmacy
and that the murderer had the same satchel as me.
It was so beautiful! It all fit together.
He convinced himself that I was the culprit.
This guy's a moron.
-I thought you said he was a friend of yours?
-By using with quotation marks.
Laughter from the audience -And because he's a friend of yours,
you refuse to give his name?
-No.
When I was a kid, my father told me never to tell on anyone.
The only one of his commandments I obey.
-But you gave
the names of your friends you thought
that they would provide you with an alibi.
What's the difference?
-Nothing to see. It's not denunciation.
-I don't understand why
you insist on protecting this X2.
By giving us his name, he would appear
and would be confronted his "lies".
-I'll say it again, I will never give anyone away.
-Goldman, that's enough!
Give us the name of this informant.
Your future is at stake.
-No, I can't.
-Please, Mr. Chairman?
-Mr. Goldman, put yourself in our shoes.
We don't understand this indicator thing.
-It's so simple!
Because of his outlandish testimony, the law is stacked against me.
This man is the source of all my misfortunes.
-Wouldn't it be simpler to have him testify?
-Yes, surely! But I won't give it away.
My morals completely forbid it.
I was arrested for heinous acts
and sordid hold-ups I recognized.
But in this rot,
I reserved for myself a share of heroism
and I took an oath never to give anyone away.
-Unless it's for a less noble reason.
Booing in the audience -What are you implying?
-It can be assumed that it does not give X2
because his testimony overwhelms her.
-Her testimony doesn't overwhelm me, on the contrary!
He exonerates me!
X2 was wrong about my weapons, my clothes, my satchel...
Absolutely everything! It's absurd.
Assembly hubbub
-Can I get back to the facts?
-Please go ahead. -Thank you for your time.
Mr. Jobard, when X2 denounced Goldman,
he indicated a hideout in Belleville
where police found weapons,
but not the ones who shot in the pharmacy?
-True, but the weapons described were compatible.
-But as my client states,
Did X2 make a mistake on weapon identification?
-Yes.
-If he could have been wrong about that, he could have been wrong about Goldman.
This does not mean that Goldman was not at the scene of the crime
with other pistols, but not that it was there either.
-Yes.
-So there is no material proof
of Goldman's presence at the scene of the crime?
-That's right.
-No, no! Applause
Let's be serious,
Mr. Chairman!
Never mind X2's lack of precision.
His information enabled police officers
back to the witnesses, all of them,
recognized Goldman. Booing
We tap our fists.
-Thank you, Commissioner.
-As I entered the pharmacy, my 1st surprise
is that the safety system is triggered.
Despite the alarm, I make my way to the counter.
Here, feet appear in the back room.
They are those of Mlle Delaunay, my wife's boss.
She's lying on her back.
His coat fully buttoned.
Her scarf tied around her neck.
Inanimate.
I walk around the counter,
and then the horror struck.
My wife is lying on the floor in front of me.
She wears leather gloves
and the ¾ wool black and white check
that I had just offered her.
At first, I thought she'd asphyxiated.
I smelled something strange.
Back in the back room, I see Mlle Delaunay's face
bathed in a pool of blood.
And I understand everything.
Near her, a man lies on the ground.
Blood drips from his face, but he's still breathing.
Sigh
Always that deafening ringing.
I run out, calling for help.
I'll send for a doctor, but...
I know that for Jeanine and her boss, it's too late.
Every evening, I would pick up my wife
to bring her home and find our little Florence,
aged 28 months at the time.
-Goldman, murderer!
-As I entered, I saw the 2 pharmacists
"in the back room.
"They had their coats on them, ready to go.
"I noticed a man in front of the 2 women,
"obviously frightened.
"He came at me, his pistol in his hand.
"He put the barrel to my stomach and said:
"'You go that way too.'
"As he looked at the women,
"I've unloaded of my wallet
"by throwing it against the wall.
"It was supposed to contain 500 francs.
"He had us put in the back of the store
"by holding us at gunpoint.
"Addressing me, he said: 'And you, give what you have.'
"I replied that I didn't have any money,
"just a 5-franc coin to buy my medicine.
"I added:
"'You're the king of the suckers, you're going to get caught.
"I made the gesture to show him the coin
"and the man shot me.
"I fell into a closet next door.
"I heard the 2 women shout:
"'No! No! No!'
"Another shot and I lost consciousness.
"The killer looked about 30, a little taller than me.
"His face was elongated, thin,
"very swarthy complexion, Mediterranean type,
"Spanish or Portuguese.
"He was wearing a cap made of leather or waxed cloth
"and a dark grey raincoat.
"He expressed himself very well in French.
"In all certainty,
"I recognized Goldman among those I was presented to the police.
"I also recognized his voice.
"I have no doubt."
This is the deposition of Mr. Raymond Trocard,
former resistance fighter and survivor of the massacre
boulevard Richard-Lenoir,
who has since died in a car accident.
Mrs. Carel, you stopped by with your husband
in front of the pharmacy at the time of the incident.
You prevented your husband from intervening.
You went to raise the alarm at the Jean Bart café.
Before you ran away, did you have time to see the assailant?
-Yes, from behind... -You can't hear anything!
-Speak a little louder.
-Yes, from the back.
-How would you describe the man you saw that day?
-A dark silhouette, very drawn,
holding a pistol in his right hand.
-Have you seen these details from the back?
-No, it was ¾, almost in profile.
-Goldman, stand up, stand ¾ profile.
-Which way, Mr. Chairman?
-Which side, ma'am? -Right side.
-Turn towards the wall.
Laughter in the audience
Do you recognize the man seen in the pharmacy
December 19, 1969?
Take your time, your answer is important.
-Now I don't know.
His face was perhaps more angular.
But when I into the room
and I saw it, I felt the same way
than in the pharmacy.
-What do you mean by by "felt"?
-I had the same feeling.
-It is possible to judge a man for facts so serious
on a feeling?
Are you aware the consequences?
-Don't intimidate witnesses, it's too easy.
-Excuse me.
You say you feel the same feeling.
What do you mean by this word?
-I want to say that when I entered the room
and I saw him, I was afraid of him
like the day of the pharmacy.
-Did his appearance frighten you? -Yes, it did.
-It is close to that of the man in the pharmacy?
-Stop blowing answers.
-Me Kiejman, be more neutral.
-Good.
You say you were afraid of him. What do you mean by this?
-That when I saw him just now...
That it did the same to me...
It grabbed me in the gut.
-All the while thinking he doesn't look like him?
-Yes, it does.
-Here we are.
Madame has just shared with us, more than 6 years later.
She adds that this man looks like the one in the pharmacy.
She doesn't say it's him, but that it looks like him.
I'm not surprised.
Mr. Goldman fits her image of a murderer.
Her fantasies override her memories.
Who are we kidding?
We all know that the killer is not a tall blond man.
This trial, for lack of material evidence,
is based on testimonials alone.
We should condemn who looks like the murderer?
No, this isn't justice! We must find this man!
Applause -The process is unbearable!
Me Kiejman extorts answers from witnesses
to place his prepared monologue.
Booing Pre-prepared and grotesque.
If he looks like the killer, why look for another?
Laughs -Are we done here?
-Almost.
Francis, the photo.
Thank you.
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, do you recognize Pierre Goldman?
-Yes, it's him. -Yes, it is.
-That's the one.
-No, it's not him.
I would have liked to please you, but he's a comedian.
Here's what I think about the objectivity of witnesses.
-I was having an aperitif at the Jean Bart with my cousin.
A man and a woman shouted: "We're shooting at the pharmacy!"
I'm not hesitating, I'm going.
As I run, I can still hear one or 2 gunshots.
I stumble into the pharmacy and behind the counter,
a man shouts at me: "Don't move or I'll kill you."
He shoots at me but his gun jams.
He turns to leave and I try to intercept him.
But because of his raincoat, it slips through my hands.
I set off in pursuit, catch up with him on the median strip
and tackles it to the ground.
The moment I immobilize him, the bastard pulls out a 2nd pistol
and shoots me at point-blank range.
I collapse to the ground.
I hear passers-by come to my rescue
and I lose consciousness.
-Mr. Quinet, you're a policeman, but you weren't on duty tonight.
You acted in good conscience.
On behalf of the entire Court, I salute your courage.
-Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I've only done my duty.
-Can you confirm
that the man in the cubicle to your left
is the one who shot you
boulevard Richard-Lenoir on December 19, 1969?
-Yes, it's him. Hubbub in the audience
-Are you sure? -Absolutely sure.
-Mr,
if I may say so,
I remind you that M. Quinet, since the beginning of the affair,
never ceases to contradict itself.
He first describes the assailant as a mulatto.
The next day, to the police, that he's a Mediterranean type,
wearing a jacket,
then he'll talk about a raincoat brown or navy blue.
Well, a gabardine.
He gives her 35 years, then 30, then 25.
He says he entered the pharmacy,
even though witnesses confirm that he never crossed the threshold.
Furthermore, witnesses say that the assailant
had a cap, he never talks about it.
If we choose arithmetic, the many others are right
and M. Quinet, alone, is wrong.
We are told that M. Quinet is a key witness.
What are these statements worth?
Nobody doubts that, least of all me,
your heroism and good faith, but there are too many contradictions
to make Mr. Goldman the man who shot you.
-My lawyer talks about the good faith of agent Quinet.
I'd call it his bad faith.
It may even be biased.
-What do you mean by that?
-My lawyer disagrees with me,
but there was a police plot against me
and that agent Quinet was their instrument.
Hubbub As soon as I was arrested,
I was designated as the ideal culprit.
Agent Quinet was guided to recognize me.
-Mr. Goldman is talking nonsense.
I was brought in front of the two-way mirror,
I recognized him immediately, even his voice.
I'd recognized him from a photo a few days before.
I had no hesitation.
But I made it clear to the police that my attacker was older.
-No, this photo
is proof that everything was arranged.
The police have chosen a cliché
on which it is impossible to recognize me.
But Agent Quinet,
who would have seen me for a few seconds at nightfall
recognized me in this photo
without hesitation?
-M. Quinet, immediately after the tragedy,
at 8:15 p.m, to a passer-by who came to rescue you,
You would have declared: "Manure's got me.
"I've got a bullet in my gut, I'm screwed.
"He's a mulatto."
You confirm you said that?
-It could be. It went fast, I don't remember.
Booing and laughter -Hush!
-What do you by the term "mulatto"?
-Someone with a matte or tanned complexion.
-What would you say Mr. Goldman's complexion?
-He's less tanned than... Than before.
Laughter in the audience
Applause -Hear, hear!
-Hush! -I read the definition
of "mulâtre" in the Littré.
"Born of a Negro and a white woman.
"Derived from the Spanish 'mulo', meaning 'mule'."
I'll let anyone be the judge.
-I don't remember saying "mulatto".
Hubbub On the other hand...
On the other hand!
I remember what what I told the police
the next day at the hospital.
That he was a Mediterranean type,
that he spoke French and that he wasn't Arab.
-It matches the defendant,
but also thousands of men in Paris.
-No! No! Cheers
Mr. Chairman!
-Quiet! Quiet! -Let's get serious!
-Quiet! -Don't! Don't!
We're not here to quibble to quibble over definitions.
I remind you that 2 women lost their lives
and that this man almost lost his.
This is very serious!
Booing -We don't argue
the seriousness of the facts, but we show how
prejudice alters testimony.
-Prejudice, it's Mr. Goldman who thinks
that the police are racist.
He wrote it in his book! I quote it from memory.
He writes of M. Quinet that he manifests
"clear racist hilarity of a policeman."
He adds "natural". What a shame!
A disgrace! -BRAVO!
Cheers and boos
-Quiet! Quiet! Be seated!
The hubbub ceases. Mr. Quinet...
Do you admit to having uttered the term "mulatto"?
-Just listen...
I don't know what I said. I know what I saw.
Laughter -Quiet!
-I saw him in full light in the pharmacy.
Then face to face on the median strip.
Mr. Chairman, a man shooting at you,
we never forget it.
-Mlle Lecoq, the day of the tragedy, you come out of a hairdressing salon
at 27 boulevard Richard-Lenoir, walk towards the Bastille
and you see a fight between 2 men.
One collapses to the ground. The other flees, jostling you.
Is that it? -Yes, that's right.
-The police won't hear from you 23 days after the event.
Why so late?
-I went home, I was emotional.
-Emotional?
Slight laughter -Yes.
-To have seen a fight between 2 men?
-Yes.
-The next day, you didn't think to go to the police?
-No, it wasn't. For me, it was just a fight.
-Why did you go 23 days later?
-I heard there were deaths. -Did they?
Who told you that?
-I can't remember.
-Make an effort, it's important.
-Probably my hairdresser friend. That was a long time ago.
-Would you say that the man who pushed you
on the boulevard that evening
is the one in the cubicle to your left?
-Yes, it is. -Take your time.
Take a good look. Your answer is important.
-I don't need to take my time.
I'm sure it's him.
-How to be so sure of yourself
whereas in your deposition, you claim to have seen
agent Quinet in uniform without hearing gunshots?
-What's your answer, mademoiselle?
-I don't know what what monsieur is talking about.
-In your statement
January 11, 70, you said you were present
to a fight on the median strip
between a man in civilian clothes and a police officer.
So in uniform? -Yes, in uniform.
-However, agent Quinet was off duty, in civilian clothes.
-I saw an agent in uniform.
-Still in your deposition,
you say you didn't hear shots.
Can you confirm this? -Yes, I can.
-How could you have seen this fight and hear nothing
when the facts occurred at the same time and place?
-I don't know, but I'll say it again, he's the one who pushed me.
-All right, then...
How would you describe the man who pushed you?
-He was weird, like a madman.
-What do you mean by "a madman"? -Well, a madman.
-Would you have declared to this madman:
"You can't apologize, you louse?"
-Yes, I said that.
-Why did you say that?
-I thought he was an Arab.
-You agree that the man in the booth
is not an Arab?
-Yes, but he looks like an Arab.
-What do you mean by "an Arab face"?
-I mean, he's got a long nose, dull complexion, like the Arabs.
-Plus, I'm circumcised.
-What do you say, Goldman?
-On top of that, I'm circumcised, like the Arabs.
Laughter in the audience
-Madame...
Where did the man came from?
-From the median strip. -Where was he going?
-To the metro.
-Where did the impact take place? On the sidewalk? On the pavement?
-On the sidewalk. I've said it 100 times.
-Was he running? -No, he was walking at an angle.
-At an angle? Isn't that you?
-Not at all, I was walking straight!
-It's a way of saying you're talking nonsense.
-I'm not talking nonsense!
-Mr. Chairman, please call Mr. Kiejman to order,
he influences and demeans witnesses to get answers.
-Noted. Mr. Kiejman, please continue, but stop this process.
-Where do you think the man was going when he ran away
after you've been pushed around?
-To the metro, I told you. -What subway?
-Bastille metro station. -Are you sure?
-Absolutely. -I note to the Court
than according to other testimonials,
the man fled towards the Bréguet-Sabin metro station.
Madame saw a policeman, but in uniform.
She didn't hear any gunshots.
She saw the man running away, but not to the right subway station.
It's enough to drive you crazy.
Madam, I'll ask the question again.
Did you see the man fleeing towards the Place de la Bastille?
-Yes, absolutely.
-And yet, I've explained, it's not true.
What to do with your insurance
when you say that it's Pierre Goldman?
-It's not the same thing. It's not the same thing.
-Very interesting.
Are there 2 types of certainty?
One that would lead us to the truth
and the other that would mislead us?
You're an empiricist, subjectivity is all that counts.
That silhouette you saw, because it's your conviction,
contains more truth than the objective world?
-Please, someone will devote themselves
to stop my colleague in this philosophy class?
-Let me finish. -Please don't!
Assembly hubbub
-Such violence. -I won't let you finish.
You weren't there, ma'am, yes, I was.
Your interpretations are further from the truth
than its approximations.
Shocked and unsure of her whereabouts where she is,
she may have been mistaken about the direction of the runaway
but tell the truth about the rest.
No one claims that witnesses are infallible.
-I'm done, thank you.
-M. Pluvinage, you are a retired doctor
and live on the 4th floor of 6 boulevard Richard-Lenoir,
the same building as the pharmacy.
Describe what you saw and heard
from your windows that evening.
-I heard gunshots.
I've done some shooting in the past.
I realized it was a big gun.
I rushed to my window
and I saw a man coming out of the pharmacy
and another, to pursue it.
The 2nd caught up with him on the median strip,
knocked him to the ground and a 2nd shot went off.
The pursuer collapsed. The assassin ran towards the subway.
-What time was it?
-A little before 8 pm, I was about to sit down to dinner.
-Describe the man who ran away.
-Tall, athletic,
dark hair, dull complexion, deep-set eyes.
-All at night,
with fog and from a distance.
I checked the distance between your windows and the sidewalk.
You have an eagle eye, bravo.
-Thank you.
I'm a microscopy specialist.
It requires precise vision.
-Allow me your precision.
You've been varying your statements for the past 6 years.
The man described is worthy
metamorphoses of Descartes' wax piece.
It's Pierre Goldman for you.
So much so that you remember signing your deposition
to the criminal brigade before a judge
seated next to her was a lawyer identified as Gisèle Halimi.
Everyone knows that there are neither lawyer nor judge
to the criminal brigade and that if Pierre Goldman
has had many supporters, I know,
Gisèle Halimi was never one of them.
And your courage, don't brag about it.
You've been gossiping your concierge and neighbors
rather than rescue the man down
or call the police. -No! Mr. President?
Let's stop this massacre!
We are inclined to judge the morality of the witnesses.
That's not the point!
It's a technique to divert us from the case.
Booing Mr. Goldman theorized it
in his book.
He says, from memory, that we should delve into the past
and political opinions of Mr. Pluvinage.
-I've said it and I stand by it.
The past and political opinions of witnesses
should be surveyed insofar as mine
under the microscope.
-It's not... Let's just talk about anti-Semitism!
Is this witness anti-Semitic?
-I don't see what that has to do with anything. -Yes, it's important to know.
As important as my biography.
The same goes for police officers and their political opinions.
Booing Inspector Goussard, yes,
during an interrogation... -Pierre, shut up!
-Just a moment.
He told me he had nothing against the Israelites.
And that he knew very well.
I thought he was going to tell me
that he had saved some. -But no!
Laughter -No! Mr. Chairman,
such misleading statements cannot be uttered
in a court of law, it's scandalous!
It's an insult to the search and to the institution!
-I'm the one who's insulted, right from the start!
All the witnesses are racists!
All of them!
Applause -All racists!
-Quiet! -Stop! Stop! Stop! It's all over.
-I'm doing something! -It's all over!
-Mr. Chairman, we are reduced
to judge the supposed opinions of honest people,
for some traumatized by the events.
If it can be proven that such and such a witness
is racist or anti-Semitic, it remains credible.
That makes Mr. Goldman Mr. Goldman a murderer!
-You racist! -Let me finish!
-You're a racist! A rotter, a fascist!
A racist! Cheers
I can smell them, the racists! -Stop it, Pierre!
-Fuck you! -Goldman, shut up!
-Fuck you! -Stop it! Stop it!
-You have no right! -I'm innocent!
That gives me every right!
-I request that you to notify the insults
of which I am the subject.
-Goldman, apologize to Me Garaud.
-Out of the question! -Pierre! Pierre!
-This guy is a fascist and a racist!
He's defending a racist police force! Hubbub
-Assassin!
-Come and tell me to my face, Goussard!
Let me go, you dirty cop! Let me go! Let me go! Let me go!
-Calm down! Calm down! -Let me go! Let me go! Let me go!
Fascists! -Be quiet!
-I'm innocent!
Brouhaha -Stop it, Pierre!
Stop...
-Meeting adjourned!
-FASCIST POLICE! -Let go of me!
-FASCIST POLICE!
JUSTICE COMPLICIT! -Bunch of racists!
Let go of me! -FASCIST POLICE!
-I'm innocent! -FASCIST POLICE,
JUSTICE ACCOMPLICE! -I am innocent!
-FASCIST POLICE! JUSTICE ACCOMPLICE!
FASCIST POLICE! JUSTICE COMPLICIT!
FASCIST POLICE! -Quiet! Quiet!
-JUSTICE ACCOMPLICE!
FASCIST POLICE! -Quiet! Quiet!
-FASCIST POLICE! JUSTICE ACCOMPLICE!
-Silence! -FASCIST POLICE!
Hubbub
-GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
Someone is approaching.
-What's happened is disastrous. You've ruined all our efforts.
Garaud has you right where he wants you. How naive.
You're a simpleton.
Keep going and you'll hit the wall.
Your loads are extremely heavy!
Witnesses recognize you! You're risking your life!
-If this is the sentence, it will be in accordance with my destiny.
-I beg your pardon?
-I was born and died on June 22, 44.
-Continue with your formulas, it doesn't work for me!
-It's the truth. -Be quiet!
I'm the only one who can get you out of this, shut up!
-I don't need you. -What's that?
-I'm innocent, there's nothing we can do about it,
not even you, it's ontological.
-It would be a divine innocence, that escapes all judgment?
No! No! No!
Your innocence must be clear from the file.
If you don't agree, you'll finish this trial on your own!
Me Kiejman moves away.
He taps on the grid.
We lock the door.
Ring
-Commissaire Leclerc, you were at the PJ
on April 8 and 9, 1970 when Pierre Goldman was arrested.
Let's look back at the conditions of his custody.
How did he seem to you when he arrived at the police station?
-Rather quiet. -With 2 buttons
who had jumped off my lap. -What do you mean, "jumped"?
-The cops began their work in the van.
They insulted me and even
beaten up.
-Can you confirm? -No, I don't.
Never heard of it.
This is the 1st time he's mentioned it.
Coming from someone and fastidious,
it's amazing.
-It's the truth. -On the evening of April 8,
you conduct his 1st interrogation.
How does it work?
-We asked him general questions.
His social circle, his favorite neighborhoods.
But he immediately the murders.
We hadn't even started. -I was on high alert!
-On alert? -Yes.
-Can you explain?
-Before being questioned, I hear one cop say to another:
"We've got the killer of the boulevard Richard-Lenoir."
Another cop comes in, looks at me and says:
"Are you the pharmacists? I never pictured you like that."
I was in a panic!
As soon as I was asked if I frequented the Bastille,
I denied the crimes we were trying
to get on my back. -Shut him up.
-And what happened?
-He denied everything. The 4 robberies.
Around one o'clock in the morning, he admitted to the 3 assaults
by continuing to deny boulevard Richard-Lenoir.
He took his head in his hands and said...
"It's possible to commit a horrible act
"in a moment of madness and not remember it?"
I didn't take it as a confession, but I thought he was going over the edge.
-Did you really say that?
-Possibly, yes. -What do you mean, possible?
It's a big deal. Did you say so?
-Yes, but the next day!
Once the confrontations have begun.
-Why did you say that?
-When I arrived at PJ,
I was convinced that my innocence would come out.
But the next day, all the witnesses recognized me.
Okay, I admit it, I was completely disoriented.
I didn't understand anything anymore.
I asked this question that didn't make sense,
it was absurd.
-When you said that, you didn't mean
that you were not responsible for your actions at the time?
-No! You don't understand. I'm innocent!
-As an innocent,
you were wondering if you were guilty?
-I'll do him... Stop him... Hubbub
-Hush!
Mr. Leclerc,
Goldman did say this when he joined the PJ?
-Yes, I'm positive.
-Why isn't it in the interrogation report?
-It was between us during a break.
-It's word for word. -Yes.
-Then what happened?
-Nothing more, it was 2 a.m, we were rinsed,
we sent him to sleep.
-The next morning, you proceeded
recognition by witnesses.
Why so quickly?
-Some witnesses recognized him from a photo.
He had to confront them as soon as possible.
-Under what conditions under what conditions?
-We brought in colleagues of the same age as him.
They have removed all distinctive signs.
Watches, ties, jewelry.
They put on a raincoat
to be less recognizable. -Mr. President!
Without wishing to dispute the word Commissioner Leclerc's word,
it must be said that I was unshaven and unkempt
among clean-cut guys. -That's just not true.
-No!
I was given an old electric razor razor with a single head.
I've never been able to shave with an electric razor.
My beard is too hard.
-I'm Inspector Goussard.
I was in charge of Goldman this morning and the razor was working.
-He's lying!
I told him I couldn't, he told me to try anyway.
And he said to me: "It doesn't matter."
That's when I realized it was a police plot.
-I never said that and I certify that he shaved.
-Get an electric razor. I'll get the flu right away.
-He shaved in front of me, I swear!
-Inspector, please sit down.
We offer you a shave,
you don't succeed and give up.
I don't quite understand.
It's strange that you didn't insist.
Why didn't you demand to be washed and shaved?
-Because I was convinced that no one would recognize me.
-Let's face it.
When you were recognized, why didn't you protest?
-Because
I was devastated, it was a catastrophe.
I was losing my mind, understood nothing.
I had more willpower, except to become a guilty man.
-Superintendent, you maintain that Goldman was shaved?
-Absolutely. -It's not true.
-All this would not be debatable
if we had of the reconnaissance photos.
Can you remind the Court
why are they missing in this dossier?
-We had a technical incident.
-Tell us which one.
-We wanted to have the camera the camera.
The guys forgot to put in film.
-The camera didn't work.
So maybe the razor didn't work either.
Applause from the audience
We tap our fists. -Commissioner,
you admit that Goldman's coat was missing 2 buttons on Goldman's coat,
that his clothes were dirty
and that he had only slept a few hours?
-And that I had a thick black beard.
-I don't remember that.
Mr. Goldman reread all the minutes.
If the reconnaissance had been rigged,
he would have had it noted.
But he hasn't said a word about it.
He knew he had been recognized by 5 witnesses.
-Unless he thought that these malfunctions
would come in handy later on.
Booing -Certainly not!
Not everyone is deceitful.
-Your customer apparently does.
-Commissioner?
Why weren't reconstituted?
-It was too late.
-Say you were convinced
that your business was done!
Madam, everything has been done to designate me.
Agent Quinet was in the hallway when I was brought in.
-It's not true! -Yes, it is!
-You're lying! -Yes, I am!
He looked at me and said to his colleague:
"He's the one who gave me in the stomach.
"What a mug." -He's lying!
We've never met.
-He's the one lying.
He was the only white guy among my black friends.
We looked at each other straight into each other's eyes.
He called me a little bastard and added to his colleague
that he no longer went out without his caliber.
-He's a liar!
I saw him behind the two-way mirror.
I swear I'm telling the truth! -Thank you! Thank you so much!
Booing Sit back down.
Hush! -Mr. Chairman,
it's unpleasant to be attacked as we are.
In 25 years of business, this is the 1st time someone has questioned
the recognition system recognition system.
I'll say it again, everything has been done by the book.
-I'm adamant about not shaving
as on agent Quinet in the corridor.
I'm not saying the commissioner,
whose professionalism professionalism,
has plotted against me,
but that he was convinced of my guilt.
Since guilty parties often escape justice,
you wanted to make your move by staging my presentation.
-I'll say it again,
it's impossible for them to have crossed paths.
-Mr. Goldman has a profound contempt for police work.
He talks about their lack of intelligence, incompetence, vulgarity...
-What's more, it's not true! Goldman lies through his teeth!
That day, I went straight to the commissioner's office.
Just say it, that I was in your office!
-The office next door
the one for reconnaissance, right?
You confirm that your office is contiguous
to the one in which the presentations took place?
-Yes. -And that you can see
through one-way glass in the other room?
-Yes. -But then,
according to M. Quinet, he spent many long minutes
waiting for his colleagues to settle in.
They were expecting Goldman's arrival any minute.
It's obvious that M. Quinet may have seen things in this room.
Do you recognize it? -It's a possibility.
-Mr. Quinet, you confirm that you went straight to the office
of the commissioner?
-No, not directly.
Booing -So where have you been?
In the corridor, as Mr. Goldman says?
-No, I wasn't in the corridor!
-Commissioner, we don't understand a thing.
Are there several corridors in your PJ?
-There's only one.
-Mr. Goldman is right. He may have crossed paths with Mr. Quinet.
Cheers
Hubbub -Mr. Quinet...
-INNOCENT! INNOCENT! -Silence!
-GOLDMAN, INNOCENT! -Quiet! Quiet!
Quiet!
-GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
-Take your seats!
-GOLDMAN, INNOCENT! -Take your seats!
Have a seat.
Mr. Quinet, where were you just before the reconnaissance?
-He was with me in the corridor!
-He stubbornly denies the obvious. -This is a travesty of justice!
The jurors interrupt the proceedings.
The defense pleads at every turn...
The Code of Criminal Procedure provides for a bar association.
Jurors may not ask questions
without notifying the president.
-No!
I remind you of article 310 on the power of the president
which authorizes jurors
to ask as many questions as they like
without expressing their opinion. -Yes...
Juries, please,
ask for the floor before you speak.
Gentlemen of the defense, please wait until the prosecution
before speaking. -Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
-Me Kiejman, we're done here
with this story recognition.
-We haven't finished at all. Please excuse me. Mr. Bailiff...
Step right up, gentlemen.
We look forward to seeing you.
These 5 men are the 5 police officers aligned with Pierre Goldman
on reconnaissance day.
And this is a life-size enlargement
anthropometric photography by Pierre Goldman
taken on April 11, 1970 at the end of his police custody.
That is, the day after of the reconnaissance.
If the police did not produce photo, it may be
because she was hiding something.
-Mr. Oswaldo Baretto, you have been an opponent
to the Venezuelan dictatorship dictatorship.
It earned you years in prison and several months in hiding
before fleeing to Paris to Paris in the late 50s,
where you continued your studies and earn a doctorate in sociology.
Even though you're an intellectual,
you continue to devote your life to armed struggle.
You joined Ben Bella in Algeria in 1964,
then you go to to Czechoslovakia
where you take part student events
of the Prague Spring.
You return to Cuba, where you meet up your friend Régis Debray,
you met during years of study.
It's also in Cuba, a few years later,
you meet Pierre Goldman.
How did you convince him to join the guerrillas?
-I didn't convince him. He insisted.
On the contrary, I thought I thought a Frenchman
would have no place among us.
-Oh yeah, why?
-Because of what had Régis in Bolivia.
Prison, torture...
I tried to dissuade him from coming, but he couldn't be bothered.
-How did you try to to dissuade him?
-I asked him if he was ready to die
under torture or an enemy bullet
for a cause that was not his own.
He replied that he was ready and that was all he wanted.
-In September 1969, you left Venezuela
with Goldman to move back to Paris.
Why such a rush
to leave your country?
-Because it's all over.
The tanks stopped the revolt in Prague.
Che's dead, Cuba's gone.
The revolution is over.
-In Paris, you have a large sum of money
which could have come from a robbery in Venezuela?
-I have nothing. -What do you live on?
-I manage. -But the first few months,
Pierre Goldman hosts you in his studio.
-That's right, but...
What does this have to do with the case?
-We're wondering about the exact nature of the ties that bound you
to Pierre Goldman at the time of the incident.
-He's a friend, that's all.
-Just friends?
Didn't you have any activities in common?
-No.
Nothing.
-Joël Lautric, Pierre Goldman's alibi,
told police officers on December 24, 1969,
5 days after the event,
you would have asked him if Goldman had done it
pharmacists.
Can you confirm this?
-Yes.
-Why this concern
when no one suspected?
-I had read in the press the events at the pharmacy.
I knew that at the time, Pierre was having money problems.
He occasionally committed a few petty thefts.
It just crossed my mind, that's all.
-I have a completely different hypothesis.
You are a South American opponent experienced in illegal activities
and underground
not wanting the police sticking their noses into his business.
If Goldman had the murders on his back,
you had to leave his apartment and cut all ties.
-Mr. Chairman,
I've never let a friend down.
Whatever he did.
-You never saw each other again until today.
So why did you ask Joël Lautric the question?
if you didn't think he could do it?
Here we go again, why would you want to know
if Goldman was the author of the murders
with Mr. Lautric from December 24, 1969
when neither X2 had spoken nor the police suspected him.
-Just to reassure myself.
-And M. Lautric reassured you?
-Yes.
-Confirm to the clerk your full name, date
and place of birth, profession and address.
-Lautric Joël, born August 18, 44 in Pointe-à-Pitre,
living in Trois-Rivières in Guadeloupe,
substitute teacher.
-Before giving evidence, the court must take your oath.
Do you swear to speak without hatred, without fear,
to tell the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?
-Yes, I swear.
-Goldman asserted that on December 19, 1969,
he surrendered
directly to your home, at 47 rue de Turenne,
after abandoning his plan to attack a creamery
and left after 8 pm, exactly at the time of the crime.
According to him, your sister Annick, at your home today
with her boyfriend Alain Caprice would have opened the door for her.
Your 3 testimonies are important, but since your 1st deposition,
you and the other 2 witnesses do not
to contradict you on the time and day of Goldman's presence.
-I understand that, but today, I'm positive.
-Let me finish.
At your 1st hearing with the police on April 9, 1970,
you said Goldman came to your house on a December evening,
but did not give day or time.
A few days later, you specify the date,
but without being able to specify the time.
At the 1st trial, you will specify the time
without being able to specify the date.
-And that's just a summary.
-OH... -Shhh!
Mr. Lautric...
Was Goldman at your house on December 19, 1969?
-Yes, Pierre Goldman was at home.
-Can you tell us the time?
-He arrived at 7:30 pm and left at 8:30pm.
-M. Lautric, you are speaking under oath.
Your testimony is vital.
Are you sure of the day and time?
-Yes, I'm sure.
-Congratulations, your memory is more and more precise
the more time passes, you defy the laws of nature.
We could give you as a scientific guinea pig.
Booing -Aberrant!
-Ladies and gentlemen of the jury,
at the 1st trial, Mr. Lautric confirmed that Pierre Goldman
was at home on December 19, the day of the double murder.
But for the hours, he seemed less precise.
He said he came around 7 pm,
and then left again just before or just after 8 p.m,
5 minutes before the double murder.
Pierre Goldman has always acknowledged that day,
he was suffering from a toothache,
that he had gone to hospital the day before
be given a sedative,
the following day, the effect having ceased,
the pain had returned with a vengeance,
to the point of insanity,
that he had gone to M. Lautric's for an aspirin
but he didn't have one.
Given the proximity of Mr. Lautric's apartment and the pharmacy
and if Goldman has left the apartment
5 minutes before the robbery...
That's how long it took him to get to the pharmacy.
Given his urgent need to find aspirin,
everything leads us to the scene of the crime.
Applause from the audience
-Hush!
Hush... The applause stops.
What's your answer?
Mr. Lautric?
-Today, I'm certain that Pierre Goldman
was at my place that day until 8.30pm.
I give you my word as an officer.
-Officer? How about that?
-I'm a reserve officer in the French army.
-Let's say so. -Can I go now?
-Do you have any questions?
-Yes, Mr. Chairman.
According to your 1st statements to the police,
you would have told Oswaldo Baretto that Pierre Goldman was in your home
when pharmacists were murdered.
At the time, it wasn't to cover up for him with the police,
who didn't know it yet,
but only to this friend? -Yes.
-You did it without hesitation? -Yes, sir, I did.
-Why should I? Did Goldman ask you?
-He didn't ask me.
-Did you do it spontaneously? -Yes, I did.
-My question is very simple.
You covered for Goldman with this comrade.
Why didn't you to the police?
In a word, you cleared his name.
During your 1st deposition, you let go of Goldman
by claiming he wasn't at your place,
and even overwhelmed, describing it as dangerous and violent.
-Come in, Mr. Lautric.
-After Pierre's arrest, the police came to my house.
They turned the apartment upside down and took me away by force.
On the way, they shouted at me
and made it clear that Pierre was...
suspected of the of the pharmacists.
They told me of a mulatto accomplice.
I panicked, I was afraid of going to prison,
I said anything.
I thought of myself first. I wanted to get out of trouble.
I'm ashamed.
Terribly ashamed.
Pierre, my friend, I beg your pardon.
-Thank you, Mr Lautric.
The debates are over.
We'll move on to the closing arguments. Recess.
-To get out of the ghetto, to escape obscurantism,
there was only Zionism or communism.
This is a fundamental aspect of Judaism.
Not the religious aspect, but the link with universalism and historicity.
That of the emblematic story of revolutionary Jews,
Bund, FTP-MOI, Mensheviks.
A joke ran in their circles:
"Why don't we speak Yiddish in the JCR office?"
The answer was always the same:
"So that Rachid can take part in the debate."
You can't understand Pierre Goldman if you don't understand
the impact of his family history on his personality
and its struggles.
What's up?
What do you think?
-You're not going to plead. 3 pleadings is too many.
Emile, do you agree? -Yes, we do.
By the way, I think it's best
if I plead last. -What do you mean, last? No. Why can't I?
-Report to your report.
-What do you mean?
-Well... How can I put it... I...
It's better if it's not the Israelite lawyer
who speaks last.
-I've based my whole case on doubt.
We'll end with this.
My Jewishness won't show anywhere.
-Well, I won't insist.
-I think it's a shame that your Jewishness doesn't shine through.
-Why?
-You and Pierre are 2 Polish Jews born in France,
raised by parents who had lived through the war.
You're bound by it, why hide it?
-It has nothing to do with the case.
-But it has something to do with you.
It's this emotion that the court and the jury must feel!
-I'm not comfortable with that. I'll stick to the facts.
-I think you're wrong.
-They call it the "trial of the century".
It would century to be over.
The institution of the jury has been criticized, indicting
the little notables that you would be, the jurors.
The accused should, according to some be judged by his peers.
A singular conception of justice
that would give more appalling results
than those of our institution
which has the merit of being unambiguous.
I want to speak on behalf of France.
The real one, that of the workers,
that of honest people.
The one in whose name justice must be done.
What do they say about us? That it's all a fake.
That it comes from above, that we've been given orders.
That the powers that be want to look good with its intelligentsia,
even if it means sabotaging the police
and justice.
Pierre Goldman...
Your packages in plain sight
betray an unbearable sense of impunity.
You dreamed of yourself as an urban guerrilla able to get lost in the crowd,
but the revolution has also become a consumer good.
You sold yourself as an insurgent,
a rebel ready for any fight,
but you have integrated a capitalist system
that you wanted to destroy and became a notable.
A notable among notables, who wrote a book,
which sells very well indeed.
You have become
the darling of a small intellectual milieu
and literary circles who rave about your misdeeds.
We wrote that you are condemned as a Jew and a leftist.
But will they dare to write that you have been acquitted
because he's Jewish and leftist?
False trial!
Trial of justice.
We are here
to judge a man, not an institution.
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, don't be fooled.
Pierre Goldman was sentenced in 1st instance
to life imprisonment for a single reason,
he's guilty!
-The role of the public prosecutor
is not to support the accusation at all costs.
I'm going to stick to the facts and rigorously examine
the circumstances that establish the guilt of the accused.
Several witnesses saw the perpetrator of the double murder.
Agent Quinet, who fought against him
and was shot, fired at point-blank range.
And Mr. Trocard, who has since died in an accident,
who receives a ball within one metre
for offering 5 francs to the assailant.
These two are formal.
Why make a mistake when Mr. Goldman admits
than those who recognized him for other assaults
were right?
The accused asked this troubling question
to Commissaire Leclerc:
"Is it possible, in a moment of madness,
"to commit a terrible act and not remember it?"
This does not mean that the accused no longer remembers
of the act reproached, but does not correspond
to his real personality and that he doesn't want
take responsibility for them.
Pierre Goldman is not a killer.
We could all agree.
And yet, he killed.
Pierre Goldman,
the facts of which you are accused have nothing to do
with your political activity and your visits to Latin America,
but are a solution
for an insubordinate to find work and money.
I think that's how you saw things.
Probably with the painful feeling
a kind of personal suicide, seeing the man you wanted to be
be diluted in common law acts.
I said to disregard your political action,
but that's not entirely true.
Your assault failed.
Just like in the drugstore, you thought you were alone
in this pharmacy that was closing.
You weren't expecting
poor Mr. Trocard and his unfortunate gesture,
his 5-franc coin which he throws at you.
At this very moment
that your guerrilla past plays a role.
You're used to to difficult situations.
You're on the lookout.
Mr Trocard's gesture you by surprise and reflex,
you shoot him.
You think you've killed him and then everything changes.
You no longer have a choice. You have to delete the cookies.
When Quinet intervenes, you aim your gun at him,
but it's empty.
You escape, he catches you, slams you to the ground.
You take out your 2nd pistol and fire
on him again.
Mr. Goldman, of course, you shot Mr. Trocard
an involuntary gesture, but afterwards, you killed the witnesses
to erase the traces of your 1st shot.
It's more than serious.
I don't know if a gangster would have been so cold-blooded.
It's all part of your your cold intelligence,
of your icy, bloodthirsty and bloodthirsty intelligence.
An intelligence that, in other circumstances,
I would have paid tribute with no ulterior motive.
At certain points in this long trial,
even impressed me impressed me several times,
even touched.
Don't let yourself be led astray, into sentimentality.
This intelligence gives you obligations.
You're not a killer, but you have killed.
That makes you a murderer. You're unforgivable.
I must, given the horror of the crime,
demand a sanction that satisfies justice.
It's a penalty
not less than life imprisonment life imprisonment
I request against you.
-Mr. General Counsel has the religion of the witnesses.
Good for him.
What I have to tell you is that a witness
is the most fragile most fragile thing in the world.
A child, a newborn.
Some witnesses see well, others, badly,
hear well, are deaf, distracted or forgetful.
But they always act in good faith,
while the accused is accused of lying.
They testify under oath, they say.
Big deal!
You need a license to drive a car,
but everyone can testify in court?
Do you find this normal?
Pierre Goldman, you said that your father had acquitted you,
your friends too.
But there's one man you didn't ask.
And that's me. Me talking right now.
As far as I'm concerned, you're innocent of the murders of which you are accused.
Never in my 40-year career have I been so convinced
of my client's innocence.
If I'm wrong,
is that I've been wrong all my life.
My job, my friends, the ones I love.
Ruth and Alter Goldman, I'm thinking of you.
My heart sinks when I think of the pain you feel
in front of this sad spectacle.
You, Ruth, who raised him as her son,
expected every evening in the Montrouge house,
the place setting for him at your table.
His half-brothers and sisters have always loved and admired
this epic big brother, whimsical, brilliant big brother.
Exemplary family.
A model of integration, like mine.
A family that has lived for years in anguish and grief
to know their son and brother in prison forever.
Lieutenant Alter Goldman...
Lieutenant Alter Goldman!
Tonight, France, the country you have chosen,
will give you back your child.
We owe you.
I owe you, Lieutenant Alter Goldman!
I, who have not had weapons in my hand,
while you, were fighting for us.
Yes.
I've come to plead for all Jews,
half-Jews, quarter-Jews, gypsies, dagos.
Lieutenant Alter Goldman,
your son, I promise you,
will walk free from the courtroom this evening.
-No reconstruction has taken place since December 19, 1969,
the day of the crime.
No physical evidence has been obtained
during the 4 years of the judicial investigation
and no new evidence has established guilt
of Pierre Goldman in the massacre on boulevard Richard-Lenoir
in this new trial.
The police investigation was therefore reduced
during police custody.
We relied on the misleading information,
to police questioning only
and poorly executed witnesses.
I'm not saying, as my client is, that there was police machination,
but I do say that a malfunction
of the police machine, then judicial,
crushed lies and manufactured
of doubt.
We can't suspect the good faith of the witnesses, but...
They contradicted each other. Over and over again.
How is this possible?
It's a simple matter.
The mechanism of testimony is a frightening thing.
We're in demand.
We think we've seen or we want to have seen.
In the end, we saw nothing.
The prosecution is at pains to point out Joël Lautric's contradictions,
to whom memory returns as time goes by.
Well...
But I'm asking you,
if this alibi was fabricated, would my client have chosen it
in the Saint-Paul district?
Why talk about this neighborhood, so close to boulevard Richard-Lenoir
when no one asked him anything?
You can't sentence a man to life imprisonment
on the basis of evidence
also uncertain.
For me,
for lack of sufficient evidence,
the prosecution fell back on on hypotheses.
You tell us that you do not scientific credit
to Pierre Goldman's alibi.
But how can you dare
give scientific value to such approximate evidence
when the burden of proof on the prosecution?
Over to you!
This means
that the presumption of innocence no longer exists?
Who should be condemned with the benefit of the doubt?
A state governed by the rule of law must respect its principles,
including an essential founder,
the presumption of innocence.
But I wanted to, too,
understand why this trial fascinates us,
why it's impossible to turn away.
Is it because of the defendant's personality of the accused?
It's tempting to think of him a Dostoyevskian hero.
Crime and Punishment , The Idiot...
The possessed.
Everyone could come up with their own title, but unfortunately...
Pierre Goldman is the fruit of a true tragedy,
first and foremost.
The tragedy of the Jewish people of Eastern Europe.
Ladies and gentlemen of the jury,
I'm not saying that Pierre Goldman is exceptional,
but that it is exceptionally tortured.
He belongs to this close-knit community,
like me, Polish Jews,
who are integrated into French society,
but which have kept from this origin the anxious quiver
and deep wounds.
I'm asking if it's possible, please,
forget the effect his personality may have had on you.
Not to judge him by his appearance.
I tell you from the bottom of my heart, you can never get over your childhood.
I adjure you, tonight, to put an end to his nightmare.
-Thank you, Me Kiejman.
We've finished the closing arguments.
Before the Court retires to deliberate,
Pierre Goldman, would you like to add anything?
-I hope I haven't appeared demonic or Machiavellian,
able to deceive or conceal
or have used intolerable manner
the spectre of a miscarriage of justice inspired by racism.
I wouldn't want it said of me that I acted like a Jew,
declaring that those who are not Jewish
cannot think that a Jew is a killer
and if they think so, they're anti-Semitic.
-Please stand up.
The assembly rises.
-To the question: "Is Goldman Pierre is he guilty of,
"Paris, December 8, 1969,
"Fraudulently removed 2,500 francs
"to the detriment of Mr. Farmachi Serge
"and his wife, née Chaminand Jacqueline?"
The court answered "yes" by a majority of 8 votes.
To the question: "Was the said fraudulent been committed
"the culprit carrying a weapon?"
The court answered "yes" by a majority of 8 votes.
To the question: "Goldman Pierre
"is he guilty of, Paris, December 20, 1969,
"Fraudulently subtracted 22,675 francs
"to the detriment of the VOG company?"
The Court
answered "yes" by a majority of 8 votes.
To the question: "Is Goldman Pierre guilty of having, in Paris,
"January 16, 1970, fraudulently removed
"7897 francs 35 to the detriment
"of the Caisse Centrale d'allocations familiales
"from the Paris region?"
The court answered "yes" by a majority of 8 votes.
To the question: "Is Goldman Pierre guilty of having, in Paris,
"December 19, 1969, voluntarily gave his life
"to Delaunay Simone, pharmacist, at 6 boulevard Richard-Lenoir?"
The Court answered "no" by a majority of 8 votes.
Light applause Hush!
To the question: "Is Goldman Pierre guilty of having, in Paris,
"December 19, 1969, voluntarily gave his life
"Durcot Jeanine, wife Aubert, pharmacy dispenser
"at 6 boulevard Richard-Lenoir?"
The Court answered "no" to the... Cheers
Cheers and continuation of the judgment inaudible
-9 mm calibre, an automatic pistol
"Walter P38561..." Cheers
-"...calibre 9 mm, 2 cartridges,
"arms and ammunition of the 1st category?"
The court answered "yes".
unanimously.
To the question:
"Is Goldman Pierre guilty of having
"during the years 1969 and 1970... -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
GOLDMAN, INNOCENT! -on French territory,
"uses documents
"issued by the authorities..." -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
-"...in order to ascertain..." -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
-"...and an identity card..." -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
-"...counterfeit, falsified..." -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
-"...knowing their falseness..." -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
-The Court answered "yes unanimously.
As a result of the declaration... -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
-... the court and the jury, after deliberation,
in accordance with the law, decide... -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
-... to sentence Goldman Pierre to life imprisonment
for a period of 12 years. -GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
Cheers GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
GOLDMAN, INNOCENT!
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.