Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Do you affirm the testimony you're about to give before
the committee will be the truth, the whole truth,
and nothing but the truth, so help you God?
Chairman
Durbin, Ranking Member Graham, and members of the Committee.
Every day, teens and young people do amazing things on our services.
They use our apps to create new things, express themselves, explore the world
around them, and feel more connected to the people they care about.
Overall, teens tell us that this is a positive part of their lives.
But some face challenges online, so we work hard to provide
parents and teens support and controls to reduce potential harms.
Being a parent is one of the hardest jobs in the world.
Technology gives us new ways to communicate with our kids
and feel connected to their lives.
But it can also make parenting more complicated.
And it's important to me that our services are positive for everyone who uses them.
We are on the side of parents everywhere, working hard to raise their kids.
Over the last eight years, we've built more than 30 different tools, resources
and features that parents can set time limits for their teens using our apps,
see who they're following, or if they report someone for bullying.
For teens, we've added nudges to remind them
when they've been using Instagram for a while
or if it's getting late and they should go to sleep
as well as ways to hide words or people without those people finding out.
We put special restrictions on teen accounts on Instagram by default.
Accounts for under six teens are set to private,
have the most restrictive content settings and can't be messaged by adults
that they don't follow or people they aren't connected to.
With so much of
our lives spent on mobile devices and social media,
it's important to look into the effects on teen mental health and well-being.
I take this very seriously.
Mental health is a complex issue
and the existing body of scientific work has not shown it.
Causal link between using social media and young people
having more mental health outcomes.
A recent National Academies of Science
report evaluated over 300 studies and found that research, quote,
did not support the conclusion that social media causes
changes in adolescent mental health at the population level, unquote,
and also suggested that social media can provide significant
positive benefits when young people use it to express themselves,
explore and connect with others.
Still, we're going to continue to monitor the research
and use it to inform our roadmap.
Keeping young
people safe online has been a challenge since the Internet began,
and as criminals evolve their tactics, we have to evolve our defenses too.
We work closely
with law enforcement to find bad actors and help bring them to justice.
But the difficult reality is that no matter how much we invest
or how effective our tools are, there are always more.
There's always more to learn and more improvements to make.
But we remain ready to work with members of this committee, industry and parents
to make the Internet safer for everyone.
I'm proud of the work that our teams do to improve online
child safety on our services and across the entire Internet.
We have around 40,000 people overall working on safety and security,
and we've invested more than $20 billion in this since 2016,
including around $5 billion in the last year alone.
We have many teams dedicated to child safety
and teen well-being, and we lead the industry
in a lot of the areas that we're discussing today.
We built technology to tackle the worst online risks
and share it to help our whole industry get better, like Project Lantern,
which helps companies share data about people who break child safety rules.
And we're founding members of Take It Down a platform which helps
young people prevent their nude images from being spread online.
We also go beyond legal requirements
and use sophisticated technology to proactively discover abusive material.
And as a result, we find and report
more inappropriate content than anyone else in the industry.
As the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children put it this week,
media goes, quote, above and beyond to make sure that there are no portions
of their network where this type of activity occurs, end quote.
I hope we can have a substantive discussion today that drives improvements
across the industry,
including legislation that delivers what parents say they want a clear system
for age verification and control over what apps their kids are using.
Three out of four parents
want App store age verification and four out of five
want parental approval of whatever whenever teens download apps.
We support this.
Parents should have the final say on what apps are appropriate
for their children and shouldn't have to upload their ID every time.
That's what app stores are for.
We also support setting industry standards on age appropriate content
and limiting signals for advertising to teens
to age and location and not behavior.
At the end of the day, we want everyone who uses our services
to have safe and positive experiences.
Before we wrap up, I want to recognize the families
who are here today who have lost a loved one or lived through
some some terrible things that no family should have to endure.
These
issues are important for every parent and every platform.
I'm committed to continuing to work in these areas
and I hope we can make progress today.
Okay.
Are there others that support that bill on this?
No. Okay.
Last Mr.
Zuckerberg, in 2021, the Wall Street Journal reported on internal matter
research documents asking why do we care about tweens?
These were internal documents.
I'm quoting the documents and answering its own question
by citing Mehta internal emails.
They are a valuable but untapped audience.
At a Commerce hearing, I'm also on that committee.
I asked Matt as head of Global Safety, why
children age 10 to 12 are so valuable to Marta.
She responded, We do not knowingly attempt to recruit
people who aren't old enough to use our apps.
Well, when the 42 state attorneys general, Democrat and Republican,
brought their case, they said this statement was inaccurate.
Few examples.
In 2021, she received an email, Ms..
Davis from Instagram's research director, saying that Instagram
is investing and experiencing targeting young age roughly 10 to 12.
In a February 20, 21 instant message, one of your employees wrote
that Mata is working to recruit Gen Alpha before they reach teenage years.
A 2018 email that circulated inside Mata says that you were briefed
that children under 13 will be critical for increasing
the rate of acquisition when users turn 13.
Explain that with what I heard
at that testimony at the Commerce hearing that they weren't being targeted.
And I just ask again, as the other witnesses, why your company
does not support the STOP System Act or the SHIELD Act.
Sure, Senator.
I'm happy to talk to both of those.
We had discussions internally about whether we should build
a kid's version of Instagram like that.
I remember that YouTube and other services.
We haven't
actually moved forward with that and we currently have no plans to do so.
So I can't speak directly to the exact emails that you that you cited,
but it sounds to me like they were deliberations
around a project that people internally thought was important
and we didn't end up moving forward with.
Okay.
And the bills, what are you going to say about those two bills?
Sure.
So overall, I mean, my position on the bills is I agree with the the
the goal of all of them.
There are most things that I agree with within them.
There are specific things that I would probably do differently.
We also have our own legislative proposal for what we think
would be most effective in terms of helping the Internet
and the various companies give parents control over the experience.
So I'm happy to go into the detail on any one of them.
But ultimately, I mean.
I just again, I think these parents will tell you that that
this stuff hasn't worked to just give parents control.
They don't know what to do.
It's very, very hard.
And that's why we are coming up with other solutions that we think
are much more helpful to law enforcement,
but also this idea of finally getting something going on liability,
because I just believe with all the resources you have
that you actually would be able to do more than you're doing are these parents
would be sitting behind you right now in this Senate hearing room?
Thank you, Senator.
And I speak to that.
Or do you? I'm going to come back later. Please go ahead.
I don't think that parents should have to upload an I.D.
or prove
that they're the parent of a child in every single app that their children use.
I think the right place to do this and a place where it'd be actually
very easy for it to work is within the app stores themselves,
where my understanding is Apple and Google already, or at least
Apple already requires parental consent when a child does a payment with an app.
So it should be pretty trivial to pass a law
that requires them to make it so that parents have control.
Any time a child downloads an app and offers consent to that,
and the research that we've done we've done shows that
the vast majority of parents want that.
And I think that that's the type of legislation, in addition
to some of the other ideas that you all have
that would make this a lot easier for parents.
Just just to be clear, I remember one mom telling me with all these things
she could maybe do that she can't figure out.
It's like a faucet overflowing in a sink and she's out there with a mop
while her kids are getting addicted
to more and more different apps and being exposed to material.
We've got to make this simpler for parents so they can protect their kids.
And I just don't think this is going to be the way to do it.
I think the answer is what Senator Graham has been talking about,
which is opening up the halls of the courtroom.
So that puts it on you guys to protect these parents and protect these kids
and then also to pass some of these laws that makes it easier for law enforcement.
We pioneered quarterly reporting on our community
standards enforcement across all these different categories of harmful content.
We focus on prevalence, which you you mentioned,
because what we're focused on is what percent of the content that we take down.
So, Mr.
Zuckerberg, I'm going to wrap and you're very talented.
I have very little time left.
I'm trying to get an answer to a question, not as a percentage of the total,
because remember, it's a huge number, so the percentage is small.
But do you report the actual amount of content
and the amount of use self-harm content received?
No, I believe we focus on prevalence.
Correct? You don't.
What's what's. Odd?
What I'm trying to understand is
why it is that Instagram is
only restricting it's
restricting access just to sexually explicit content,
but only for teens ages 13 to 15.
Why not restrict it for 16 and 17 year olds as well?
Senator, my.
Understanding is that we don't allow sexually explicit content
on the service for people of any age.
The the.
How is that going?
you know, our, our,
our prevalence metrics suggest that.
I think it's 99% or so of the content that we remove.
We're able to identify automatically using a system.
So I think that our efforts in this,
while they're not perfect, I think are industry leading.
The other thing that you asked about was self-harm content,
which is what we recently restricted and we made that shift to the the
I think the state of the science is shifting a bit.
Previously we believed
that when people were thinking about self-harm,
it was important for them to be able to express that and get support.
And now more of the the, the thinking in the field is that it's
just better to not show that content at all,
which is why we recently moved to restrict that from showing up for,
for, for those teens at all.
Is there a way for
for parents to make a request on what their kid can see or not
see on your sites?
There are a lot of parental controls.
I'm not sure if there are.
I don't think that we currently have a control around topics,
but we do allow parents to control
the time that the children are on the site.
And also a lot of it is based on kind of monitoring
and understanding what the teens experience is.
Instagram also
display the following warning screen
to individuals who were searching for child
abuse material.
The these results
may contain images of child sexual abuse.
And then you gave users two choices
get resources
or see results anyway.
Mr. Zuckerberg, What the hell were you thinking?
All right, Senator,
the the the basic science behind
that is that when people are searching for something that is problematic,
it's often helpful to rather than just blocking it, to help direct them towards
something that that could be helpful for getting them to get help in.
What also can get resources in what same universe
is there a link for see results anyway?
Or because we might be wrong?
We try to trigger this this warning or we tried to.
When we think that there's any chance that.
Okay, you might be wrong.
Let me ask you, how many times was this warning screen displayed?
I don't know.
But you don't know. Why don't you know?
I, I don't know the answer to that.
I'll stop my head. But you know what, Mr. Zuckerberg?
It's interesting you say you don't know
what off the top of your head because I asked it in June of 2023
in an oversight oversight letter, and your company refused to answer.
Will you commit right now to within five days
answering this question for this committee?
We'll follow up on that. Is that a yes?
Not a will follow up.
I know how lawyers write statements saying we're not going to answer.
Will you tell us how many times this warning screen was displayed, yes or no?
Senator, I'll personally look into it.
I'm not sure. If. Okay.
So you're refusing to answer that. Let me ask you this.
How many times did an Instagram user who got this warning
that you're seeing images of child sexual abuse?
How many times did that user click on see results?
Anyway? I want to see that,
Senator.
I'm not sure if we stored that,
but I'll personally look into this and we'll follow up.
And what follow up to Instagram
do when you have
a potential pedophile clicking on I'd like to see child porn.
What did you do next when that happens, Senator?
I think that an
important piece of context here is that any context that we think is child. So.
Mr. Zuckerberg that's called a question.
What did you do next when someone clicked?
You may be getting child
sexual abuse images and they click see results.
Anyway, what was your next step?
You said you might be wrong.
Did anyone examine was it in fact child sexual abuse material?
Did anyone report that user?
Did anyone go and try to protect that child?
What did you do next?
Senator We take down anything that we think is sexual abuse
material on the service. And we did.
Did anyone verify whether it was in fact child sexual abuse material?
Senator, I don't know if if every single searches or following up on.
But did you report the people who wanted it?
Do you want me to answer your call?
I want you to answer the question I'm asking.
Did you. Report time to.
The people who click see results? Anyway.
That's probably one of the factors that we use in reporting in general.
And we've reported more people and done more reports like this to Nick Mick,
the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children,
than any other company in the industry.
We proactively go out of our way across our services to do this
and have made I think it's more than 26 million reports,
which is more than the whole rest of the industry combined.
Mr. Zuckerberg, let me start with you.
Did I hear you say in your opening statement
that there is no link between mental health and social media use?
Senator, What I said is I think it's important to look at the science.
I know it's people widely talk about this as if that is something
that's already been proven.
And I think that the bulk of the scientific evidence does not support that.
Well, really, let me just remind you of some of the science from your own company.
Instagram studied the effect of your platform on teenagers.
Let me just read you some quotes from The Wall Street
Journal's report on this company.
Researchers found that Instagram is harmful for a sizable percentage
of teenagers, most notably teenage girls.
Here's a quote from your own study.
Quote, We make body image issues worse for one in three teen girls.
Here's another quote Teens blame Instagram.
This is your study for increases in the rate of anxiety and depression.
This reaction was unprompted and consistent across all groups.
That's your study.
Senator.
We try to understand the the feedback and how people feel about the services
we can improve.
Wait a minute.
You're always out of your own
studies says that you make life worse for one in three teenage girls.
You increase anxiety and depression.
That's what it says.
And you're here testifying to us in public that there's no link.
You've been doing this for years.
For years you've been coming in public and testifying under oath
that there's absolutely no link.
Your product is wonderful.
The science is nascent, full speed ahead, while internally you know full
well your product is a disaster for teenagers
and you keep right on doing what you're doing right.
True. That's not true.
Let me let me let me show you some other facts.
I know that you're familiar with a minute. Wait a minute.
That's not a question. That's not a question.
Those are facts, Mr. Zuckerberg.
That's not a question. That's the answer.
Let me tell you some more facts.
Here are some and here's some information from a whistleblower who came before
the Senate testified under oath in public.
He worked for you to senior executive.
Here's what he showed he found when he studied your products.
So, for example, this is girls between the ages of 13 and 15 years old.
37% of them reported that they had been exposed
to nudity on the platform unwanted in the last seven days.
24% said that they had experienced unwanted sexual advances.
They've been propositioned in the last seven days.
17% said they had encountered self-harm content
pushed at them in the last seven days.
Now, I know you're familiar with these stats
because he sent you an email where he lined it all out.
I mean, we've got a copy of it right here.
My question is, who did you fire for this?
Who got fired because of that?
Senator, we study all this because it's important we want to improve our service.
Well, you just told me so long ago you studied that there was no linkage.
Who did you. Fire?
I said you mischaracterized 30.
7% of teenage girls between 13 and 15
were exposed to unwanted nudity in a week on Instagram.
You knew about it. Who did you fire?
Senator. This is why we're building.
Who did you fire?
Senator, That's. I don't think that that's.
Who did you. Fire?
I'm not going to answer that.
That's because you. Didn't fire anybody.
Right.
You didn't take any significant action.
It's appropriate to talk about it.
It's not appropriate. Decisions.
Do you know who's sitting behind you?
You've got families from across the nation
whose children are either severely harmed or gone.
And you don't think it's appropriate to take.
Talk about steps that you took, the fact that you didn't fire a single person.
Let me ask you this.
Let me ask you this. Have you compensated any of the victims?
Sorry?
Have you compensated any of the victims these girls?
Have you compensated them?
I don't believe so.
Why not?
Don't you think they deserve some compensation
for what your platform has done?
Help with counseling services.
Help with dealing with the issues that your your service is cause.
Our job is to make sure that we build tools to help keep you.
Are you going to compensate them?
Senator, our job and what we take seriously is making sure
that we build industry leading tools to find harmful to make money,
take it off the services, to make money, and to build tools that empower parents.
So you didn't take any action.
You didn't take any action, you didn't fire anybody.
You haven't compensated a single victim. Let me ask you this.
Let me ask you this.
There's families of victims here today.
Have you apologized to the victims?
I would you like to do so now?
Well, they're here. You're on national television.
Would you like now to apologize
to the victims who have been harmed by your product?
Show them the pictures.
Would you like to apologize for what you've done to these good people? I,
I, I'm supposed
to go through
the things that your families have suffered.
And this is why we invested so much.
And our hope
is rebuilding efforts to to make sure that
no one has to go through the.
Types of things that your family has suffered.
Will you commit
to reporting measurable child safety data
on your quarterly earnings reports and calls?
Senator, it's a it's a good question.
We actually already have a quarterly report that we issue
and do a call to answer questions for how we're enforcing our community standards.
That includes not just the child safety issues.
So is that a yes?
We have a separate call that we do this on.
But we've I think that,
you know, you have to report we report your earnings to the FCC.
Will you report to them this kind of data And by numbers, by the way,
because Senator Cruz
and others have said percentages don't really tell the full story.
Will you report to the FCC the number of teens?
And sometimes you don't even know where they're teens are,
not because they just claim to be adults.
Will you report the number of underage children on your platforms
who experience unwanted these and other kinds of
messaging
that they that harm them?
Will you commit to
citing those numbers to the FCC when you make your quarterly report?
Well, Senator, I'm not sure it would make as much sense
to include it in the SEC filing,
but we file it publicly so that way everyone can see this.
And we I'd be happy to follow up and talk about what specific metrics.
I think the specific things that some of the ones
that you just mentioned around underage people in our services,
we don't allow people under the age of 13 on our service.
So if we find anyone who's under the age of 13, we remove them from our service.
Now, I'm not saying that people don't lie and that there aren't. Yes.
That's under the age of 13. Who's using it.
But I'm not going to Bill, too.
We're not going to count how many people there are,
because fundamentally, if we identify that someone is underage, we remove them.
I think that's really important that we get actual numbers
because these are real human beings.
That's why all these parents and others are here,
because each time that a person, a young person is exposed
to this kind of unwanted material, they get hooked.
It is a danger to that individual.
So I'm hoping that you are saying that you do report
this kind of information to the if not the FCC, that it is made public.
I think I'm hearing that.
Yes, you do.
So, yes, Senator, I think we report more publicly
on our enforcement than any other company in the industry.
And we're very supportive of transparency.
I'm running out of time, Mr.
Zuckerberg, But so I will follow up with what exactly
it is that you do report.
Again, for you women to automatically
places young people's accounts and you testified to this
on the most restrictive privacy and content sensitivity sessions.
And yet teens are able to opt out of these safeguards.
Isn't that right?
Yeah, It's not mandatory that they remain on these settings.
They can opt out.
Senator?
Yes, we default teens into a private accounts,
so they have a private restricted experience.
But some teens want to be creators and want to have content
that they share more broadly.
And I don't think that that's something that should just blanketly be banned.
You have
you have convinced over 2 billion people
to give up all of
their personal information, every bit of it,
in exchange for getting to see
what their house school friends had for dinner Saturday night
as pretty much your business model, isn't it?
It's not how I would characterize it.
I mean, we give people the ability to connect with the people they care about
and and to engage with the topics that they care about.
And and you take this information,
this abundance of personal information,
and then you develop algorithms
to punch people's hot buttons,
which and some and steer to them information
that punches their hot buttons again and again and again
to keep them coming back and to keep them staying longer.
And as a result, your users see only one side of an issue.
And so to some extent, your
platform has become a killing field for the true, passionate.
I mean, Senator, I disagree with that.
That characterization.
You know, we build ranking and recommendations
because people have a lot of friends and a lot of interests,
and they want to make sure that they see the content that's relevant to them.
We're trying to make a product that's useful to people and make our services
as helpful as possible for people to connect with the people
they care about in the interest they care.
But you don't show them both sides.
You don't give them balanced information.
You just keep punching their hot buttons, punching their hot buttons.
You don't show them balanced information
so people can discern the truth of themselves
and you rev them up so much that that show often your platform and others
becomes just cesspools of
snark where nobody learns anything.
Don't they?
Well, Senator. I disagree with that.
I think people can engage in the things that they're interested in
and learn quite a bit about those.
We have done a handful of different experiments and things in the past around
news and trying to show content on a diverse set of of of perspectives.
I think that there's more that needs to be explored there, but
I don't think that we can solve that by ourselves. We do that.
I think. I'm sorry to cut you off, Mr.
President, but I'm going to run out of time.
Do you think your users really understand
what they're giving to you, all their personal information
and how you how you process it and how you monitor it?
Do you think people really understand.
Senator?
I think people understand the basic terms.
I mean, I think that there's I things that a lot of.
Me put it another way.
We spent a couple of years as we talked about this.
Does your user agreement still suck?
I'm not sure how to answer that.
Senator can deal with that.
Can you still have a dead body and all that legalese
where nobody can find it?
Senator, I'm not I'm not.
Quite sure what you're referring to,
but I think people get the basic deal of using these services.
It's a free service.
You're using it to connect to the people you care about.
If you share something with people,
other people will be able to see your information.
It's inherently,
you know, if you're putting something out there to be shared publicly
or with a private set of people, it's,
you know, you're inherently putting it out there.
So I think people get that basic.
But part of how but let's.
Just talk about you're in the foothills of creeping you
track you track you track people
who aren't even Facebook users.
You track your own people, your own users who are your product, even
even when they're not on Facebook.
I mean, I'm going to land this plane pretty quickly, Mr.
Chairman. I mean, it's creepy.
And I understand you make a lot of money doing it,
but I just wonder if our technology
is greater than our humanity.
I mean, let me ask you this final question.
is harmful
to young people, isn't it.
Senator? I disagree with that.
That's not what the research shows.
On balance, that doesn't mean that individual
people don't have issues and that there aren't things that we need
to do to to help provide the right tools for people.
But across all of the research that we've done internally,
I mean, the survey that the senator previously cited,
you know, there are
12 or 15 different categories of harm that we asked
teens if they felt that Instagram made it worse or better.
And across all of them, except for the one that that that
that Senator Hawley cited, more people said that using.
Instagram, I've got two lands.
Apiece, either positive or.
I would just have to agree to disagree.
If you believe that Instagram, I know I'm not saying it's intentional,
but if you agree that Instagram,
if you think that Instagram is not hurting millions of our young people,
particularly young teens, particularly young women, you shouldn't be driving.
Mr. Zuckerberg, I want to come back to you.
I talked with you about being a parent
to a young child who doesn't have a phone,
doesn't, you know, is not on social media at all.
And one of the things that I am deeply concerned
with as a parent to a young black girl
is the utilization of filters.
On. Your platform.
That would suggest
to young girls utilizing your platform
the evidence that they are not good enough as they are.
I want to
ask more specifically
and refer to some unredacted court documents.
That revealed at your own. Researchers
concluded that these face filters
that mimic plastic surgery
negatively impact youth mental
health, indeed, and well-being.
Why should we. Believe.
Why should we believe that?
Because that you are going to do more to protect young women.
And young girls when it is that you give them the tools to affirm the.
Self-Hate that is.
Spewed across your platforms?
Why is it that we should believe.
That you are committed to doing anything more to keep our children safe?
Sorry, there's a lot to unpack there.
There is a lot of tools to express themselves
in different ways, and people use face filters and different tools
to make media and photos and videos that are fun or interesting
across a lot of the different products that plastic.
Surgery pens are good tools to express creativity. Of.
Senator, I'm not speaking skin.
Lightning tools are tools. To express.
Creativity.
This is the direct thing that I'm asking you about.
Defending any specific one of those.
I think that the ability
to kind of filter and
and edit images is generally a useful tool for expression
for that specifically, I'm not familiar with the study that you're referring to,
but we did make it so that we're not recommending this type of content.
Mr. Zuckerberg, I want to begin by just asking you a simple question,
which is, do you want kids to use your platform more or less?
Well, we don't want people under the age of 13 using do you.
Want teenagers 13 and up to use your platform more or less.
What we would like to build a product
that is useful and that people want to use.
At my time is is going to be limited. So it's just.
Do you want them to use it? More or less?
Teenagers, 13 to 17 years old.
Do you want them using metal products?
More or less.
I'd like them to be useful enough that they want to use them more.
And some of the children from our state, some of the children,
the parents that we have worked with,
just to think whether it is
Becca Schmidt, David Malak,
Sarah Flat, Emily Shout,
Would you say that life is only worth
$270?
What could possibly lead you?
I mean, I listened to that. I know you're a dad.
I'm a mom. I'm a grand mom.
And how could you possibly even have that thought?
It is astounding to me.
And I think this is one of the reasons that
states 42
states are now suing you because of features that they consider
to be addictive, that you are pushing forward.
And in the emails that we've got from 2021
that go from August to November,
there is the staff plan that is being discussed.
And Anthony Davis, Nick Clegg, Sheryl Sandberg, Chris Cox,
Alec Schultz, Adam Mosseri are all on this chain
of emails on the well-being plan and then we get to one.
Nick did email Mark for emphasis to emphasize his support
for the package, but it sounds like it lost out
to various other pressures in
See, this is what bothers us.
Children are not your priority.
Children are your product.
Children you see as a way to make money
and children
protecting children in this virtual space.
You made a conscious decision
even though Nick Clegg
and others
were going through the process of saying, This is what we do,
these documents are really illuminating,
and it just shows me that
growing this business,
expanding your revenue,
what you were going to put on those quarterly filings, that was the priority.
The children were not very clear.
I want to talk with you about a pedophile ring,
because that came up earlier and The Wall Street Journal reported on that.
And one of the things that we found out was after that became evident,
then you didn't take that content down and it was content.
It showed that teens were for sell and were offering themselves to older men.
And you didn't take it down because it didn't violate your community standards.
Do you know how often a child is bought or sold for sex in this country?
Every 2 minutes.
Every 2 minutes a child
is bought or sold for sex?
That's not my stat.
That is a TBI stat
now signed like this content
was taken down after a congressional staffer
went to MED as global head of safety.
So would you please explain to me and to all these parents
why explicit predatory content does not violate
your platform's terms of service or your community standards?
Sure, Senator, let me try to address all of the things that you just said.
It does violate our standards.
We work very hard to take. It didn't take it down.
We've what we've reported,
I think it's more than 26 million examples of this kind of content.
Take it down until a congressional staffer brought it up.
It may be that in this case we made a mistake, missed something.
I think a lot of mistake.
But we have we have a leading one that.
I want to talk with you about, your Instagram
creator's program and about the push.
We found out through these documents that you actually are pushing forward
because you want to bring kids in early.
You see these younger
teenagers as valuable, but an untapped audience.
Quoting from the emails and suggesting teens are actually household influencers
to bring their younger siblings
into your platform, into Instagram.
Now, how can you ensure that
Instagram creators, your product,
your program, does not facilitate illegal activities
when you fail to remove content
pertaining to the sale of minors?
And it is happening once every 2 minutes in this country.
Senator, are
tools for identifying that kind of content or industry leading.
That doesn't mean we're perfect.
There are definitely issues that we have, but we.
Mr.. ZUCKERBERG Yes, there are a lot that is slipping through.
It appears that you're trying to be the premier sex trafficking.
Force in. This country.
That's ridiculous. No, it is not ridiculous.
You we don't.
Want this content on our platforms.
Why don't you take it down? We do.
We are here. Discuss.
We do.
We're working to take it down because.
No, you're not.
You are not.
And the problem is, we've been working on this.
Senator Welch is over there.
We've been working on this stuff for a decade.
You have an army of lawyers and lobbyists that have fought us on this
every step of the way you work with Net Choice, the Cato Institute,
Taxpayers Protection Alliance and Chamber of Progress
to actually fight
our bipartisan legislation to keep kids safe online.
So are you going to stop funding these groups?
Are you going to stop lobbying against this and come to the table
and work with this?
Yes or no?
Senator, We have a yes or no.
Of course we'll work with you one on the ledge.
Okay.
The door is open.
We've got all these bills you need.
You need to come to the table.
Each and every one of you need to come to the table and you need to work with us.
Kids are dying.
Chair Durbin,
Ranking Member Graham, and members of the committee,
I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you today.
My name is Show Chew and I am the CEO of Tik-Tok,
an online community of more than 1 billion people worldwide,
including well over 170 million Americans
who use our app every month to create,
to share, and to discover
that although the average age on TikTok in the U.S.
is over 30, we recognize that special safeguards are required to protect minors,
and especially when it comes to combating all forms of seasonal.
As a father of three young children myself, I know that the issues
that we're discussing today are horrific and the nightmare of every parent.
I am proud of our efforts to address the threats
to young people online, from a commitment to protecting them
to our industry leading policies, use of innovative technology
and significant ongoing investments in trust and safety to achieve this goal.
Tick Tock is vigilant about
its 13 and up age policy and offers an experience for teens
that is much more restrictive than you and I would have as adults.
We make careful product design choices to help
make our app inhospitable to those seeking to harm teens.
Let me give you a few examples of long standing policies that are
unique to tick tock.
We didn't do them last week.
First, direct messaging
is not available to any users under the age of 16.
Second,
accounts for people under 16
are automatically set to private along with their content.
Furthermore, the content cannot be downloaded
and will not be recommended to people they do not know.
Third, every teen under 18 has a screen time limit
automatically automatically set to 60 minutes and fourth,
only people 18 and above are allowed to use our live stream feature.
I'm proud
to say that TikTok was among the first to empower parents
to supervise their teens on our app
with our family pairing tools.
This includes setting screen time limits, filtering out
content from his feet, amongst others.
We made these choices after consulting with doctors
and safety experts who understand the unique stages of teenage development.
To ensure that we have the appropriate safeguards
to prevent harm and minimize risk.
Now, safety is one of the core priorities
that defines tick tock my leadership.
We currently have more than 40,000
trust and safety professionals working to protect our community globally,
and we expect to invest more than $2 billion
in trust and safety efforts this year alone.
A significant part of that, you know, U.S.
operations,
our robust
community guidelines, strictly prohibit content or behavior that puts teenagers
at risk of exploitation or other harm,
and we vigorously enforce them
all technology, moderates, all content uploaded to our app
to help quickly identify potential cesium and other material that breaks our rules.
It automatically removes the content or elevates it
to our safety professionals for further review.
We also moderate direct messages
for season and related material and use third party
tools like photo DNA and take it down to combat system
to prevent content from being uploaded to our platform.
We continually meet with parents, teachers and teens.
In fact, I sat down with a group just a few days ago.
We use their insight to the protections on our platform,
and we also work with leading groups like the Technology Coalition.
The steps that
we're taking to protect teens are a critical part
of a larger trust and safety work as we continue our voluntary
and unprecedented efforts to build a safe and secure data environment for U.S.
users, ensuring that our platform remains free
from outside manipulation and implementing safeguards
on our content recommendation Moderation Tools.
Keeping teens safe online requires
a collaborative effort as well as collective action.
We share the committee's concern and commitment to protect young people online,
and we welcome the opportunity
to work with you on legislation to achieve this goal.
Our commitment is ongoing and unwavering
because there is no finish line when it comes to protecting teens.
Thank you for your time and consideration today.
I'm happy to answer your questions.
Can you explain to us what you are doing particularly
and whether you've seen any evidence of cesium in your business?
Yes, Ed,
we have a strong commitment to invest in trust and safety.
And as I said in my opening statement, I intend to invest
more than $2 billion in trust and safety this year alone.
We have 40,000 safety professionals working on this topic.
We have built a specialized child safety team to help us identify
specialized issues, horrific issues like material like the ones you have mentioned.
If we identify any on our platform and we proactively do do it detection,
we will remove it and we will report to a bank and other authorities.
Why is it tick tock?
Allowing children to be exploited into performing commercialized sex acts?
A Senator.
I respectfully disagree with that characterization.
Our live streaming product is not for anyone below the age of 18.
We have taken action to
to identify anyone who violates that, and we will remove them
from the from using that service.
Mr.. CHIU I'm a co-sponsor of Chair
Dermot Steps System Act of 2023,
along with Senator Hollies, the lead Republican I believe,
which among other things empowers victims by making it easier for them to ask
tech companies to remove the material
and related imagery from their platforms.
Why would you not support this bill?
Senator, We largely support it.
I think the spirit of it is very aligned with what we want to do.
There are questions about implementation that I think companies like us
and some other groups have, and we look forward to asking those.
And of course, if this legislation is law, we will comply.
Mr. Chiu,
I think your company is unique among the ones represented here today
because of its ownership by Bytedance,
a Chinese company.
And I know there have been some steps that you've taken
to wall off the data collected here in the United States.
But the fact of the matter is that under Chinese law
and Chinese national intelligence laws,
all information accumulated by companies in the people's Republic of China
are required to be shared with the Chinese intelligence services.
By Dance,
the initial release of Tik Tok, I understand, was in 2016.
Are these efforts that you made with Oracle
under the so-called project Texas to wall off the U.S.
data was in 2021 that apparently
allegedly fully walled off in March of 23.
What happened to all of the data that TikTok collected
before that?
Senator, thank you.
From American users.
Understand TikTok is owned by Bytedance, which is majority
owned by global investors.
And we have three Americans on the board out of five.
You are right in pointing out that over the last three years,
we have spent billions of dollars building out Project Texas,
which is a plan that is unprecedented in our industry
to all our firewalled off protected us data from the rest of our staff.
We also have I'm.
Asking about all of the data that you collected prior to that, that event.
Yes, Senator, we have studied the data deletion plan.
I talked about this a year ago.
We have finished the first phase of data deletion
through our data centers outside of the Oracle Cloud infrastructure.
And we're beginning phase two where we will not only delete
from the data centers, we will hire a third party to verify that work.
And then we will go into, you know, for example, employees
working laptops to delete data as well.
As all of the data collected by tick tock prior to Project Texas shared
with the Chinese government pursuant to the national intelligence law,
that country.
Senator, we have not been asked for any data
by the Chinese government and we have never provided it.
Your company is unique, again, among the
the ones represented here today because you're currently undergoing
review by the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States.
Is that correct?
Senator, Yes, there are ongoing discussions
and a lot of our project Texas work is informed by the
the discussions with many agencies under the surface umbrella.
Well, Surface is designed specifically to review foreign investments
in the states for national security risks, correct?
Yes, I believe so.
And your company is currently being reviewed by this interagency
committee of the at the Treasury Department
for potential national security risks.
Senator, this review is on a acquisition musically,
which is an acquisition that was done many years ago.
I mean, is this a casual conversation or are you actually providing information
to the Treasury Department about your how your your platform operates
for evaluating a potential national security risk?
Senator, it's been many years across two administrations
and a lot of discussions around how our plans are, how our systems work.
We have a lot a lot of robust discussions about a lot of detail.
63% of teens, I understand, use Tik Tok.
Does that sound about right?
A senator, I cannot verify that.
We know we are popular amongst many age groups.
The average age in the U.S.
today for our userbase is over 30, but we are where we are popular.
And you reside in Singapore with your family, correct?
Yes, I have.
I reside in Singapore and I work here in the United States as well.
And do your children have access to Tik in Singapore?
Senator, if they lived in the United States,
I would give them access to our under 13 experience.
My children are below the age of 13.
My question is in Singapore, do they have access to Tik tok
or is that restricted by by domestic law?
We do not have an under 13 experience in Singapore.
We have that in the United States because we were in a mixed audience app
and we created an experience in response to that.
A Wall Street Journal article published yesterday
directly contradicts what your company has stated publicly.
According to the Journal, Employees under the project, Texas say that U.S.
user data, including user emails,
birthdate IP addresses continue to be shared
with Bytedance's staff, again owned by a Chinese company.
Do you dispute that?
Yes, Senator, there are many things about that article.
They are inaccurate.
Where it gets right is that this is a voluntary project that we built.
We spent billions of dollars.
There are thousands of employees involved and it's very difficult
because it's unprecedented.
Why is
why is it important that the data collected from U.S.
users be stored in the United States?
A Senator this was a project we built in response
to some of the concerns that were raised by members of this committee and others.
And that was because of concerns that the data that was stored
in China could be accessed by the Chinese Communist Party by
and according to the National Intelligence laws.
Correct?
Senator, we are not the only company that does business
that has Chinese employees, for example.
We're not even the only company in this room that hires Chinese nationals.
But in order to address some of these concerns,
we have moved the data into the Oracle Cloud infrastructure.
We built a 2000 person team to oversee the management of the data base here.
We fired, walled it off from the rest of the organization,
and then we opened it up to third parties like Oracle,
and we will onboard others to give them third party validation.
This is unprecedented access.
I think we are unique
in taking even more steps to protect user data in the United States.
Disputed The Wall Street Journal story published yesterday.
Are you going to conduct any sort of investigation to see
whether there is any truth to
the allegations made in the article?
Or are you just going to dismiss them outright?
We're not going to dismiss them.
So we have ongoing security inspections, not only by our own personnel,
but also by third parties to ensure that the system is rigorous and robust.
No system that we, any one of us can build is perfect.
But what we need to do is to make sure
that we are always improving it and testing it against that.
People who may try to bypass it.
And if anyone breaks our policies within our organization,
we will take disciplinary action against them.
Mr. CHU Let's get straight to the chase.
Is tick tock under the influence of the Chinese Communist Party?
No, Senator.
We are private business.
Okay, So you can see that your parent Bytedance
is subject to the 2017 National Security law,
which requires Chinese companies to turn over information
to the Chinese government and conceal it from the rest of the world.
You can see that, correct.
Senator? The Chinese businesses.
You can say that early.
Any company
that does any global businesses does business in China has to follow law.
Isn't it the case that Bytedance
also has an internal Chinese Communist Party committee?
Like I said, all businesses that operate in China have to follow the law.
So your parent company is subject to the national security law
that requires it to answer to the party.
It has its own internal Chinese Communist Party committee.
You answer to that parent company,
but you expect us to believe that you're
not under the influence of the Chinese Communist Party.
I understand this concern, Senator, which is why we built the.
But you used to work for Bytedance, didn't you?
You were the CFO for Bytedance.
That is correct.
In April 2021, while you were the CFO,
the Chinese Communist Party's China Internet Investment Fund purchased
a 1% stake in Bytedance's main Chinese subsidiary, the Bite Technology Company.
In return for that so-called 1% golden share.
The party took one of three board seats at that subsidiary company.
That's correct, doesn't it?
It's for the Chinese business.
Is that correct?
It is for the Chinese that.
That deal was finalized on April 30th, 2021.
Is it true that you were appointed the CEO of Tik Tok?
The very next day on May one, 2021?
Well, this is a coincidence.
It's a coincidence.
It is. The CFO.
Senator of the.
Chinese Communist Party, took its golden chair and its board seat.
And the very next day, you were appointed the CEO of Tik Tok.
That's a hell of a coincidence. It really is, Senator.
It is.
Okay.
And before Bytedance, you were at a Chinese company called Zhao
Me, is that correct?
Yes. I used to work around the world.
Where did you live when you worked at Jamie?
I lived in China like. Many experts.
Where exactly?
In Beijing. In China.
How many years did you live in Beijing?
Senate. I worked there for about five years.
So you lived there five years? Yes.
Is it the case that Zhao Mi was sanctioned by the United States
government in 2021 for being a communist Chinese military company?
I'm here to talk about tech, I think.
I think they then had a lawsuit and it was overturned.
I can't remember that.
No, no.
It's another company by an administration that reversed those sanctions, just like,
by the way, they reversed the terrorist designation on the WHO Houthis in Yemen.
How's that working out for them?
But it was sanctioned as a Chinese communist military company.
So you said today, as you often say, that you live in Singapore.
Of what nation are you? A citizen?
Singapore.
Are you a citizen of any other nation?
No, Senator.
Have you ever applied for Chinese citizenship?
Senator, I serve my nation in Singapore.
No, I did not.
Do you have a Singaporean passport?
Yes. And I served my military for two and a half years in Singapore.
Have any other. Do you have any other passports?
Many other notes.
Your wife is an American citizen.
Your children are American citizens. That's correct.
Have you ever applied for American citizenship?
Not no, not yet. Okay.
Have you ever been a member of the Chinese Communist Party?
Senator. I'm Singaporean. No.
Have you ever been associated or affiliated with the Chinese Communist
Party? No, Senator. Again, I'm Singaporean.
Let me ask you some hopefully simple question.
You said earlier in response to a question about what happened at Tiananmen
Square in June of 1989 was a massive protest.
Anything else happened in Tiananmen Square?
Yes, I think it's well documented. There was a massacre.
There was indiscriminate slaughter of hundreds or thousands of Chinese citizens.
Do you agree with the Trump administration and the Biden administration
that the Chinese government is committing genocide against the weaker people?
Senator, I've said this before.
I think it's really important
that anyone who cares about this topic or any topic can freely express
themselves on TikTok.
It's a very simple question
that unites both parties in our country and governments around the world.
Is the Chinese government committing genocide against the weaker people?
Senator, anyone, including you, can come in to talk about this.
Topic asking you. Any topic.
United States,
cosmopolitan, well-educated man who's expressed many opinions on many topics.
Is the Chinese government committing genocide against the weaker people?
Actually, Senator, I talk about many about my company,
and I'm here to talk about what Trump does. Yes or not, you're here.
We allow you're here to give testimony that's truthful and honest and complete.
Let me ask you this.
Joe Biden last year said that Jinping was a dictator.
Do you agree with Joe Biden, the paying a dictator?
Senator, I'm not going to comment on any world leaders.
Why won't you answer these very simple questions?
Senator, it's not appropriate.
Are you serious and spent to come in a world leader?
Are you scared that you'll lose your job if you say anything
about negative about the Chinese Communist Party?
I disagree that you will find content that is critical of China, and I'll.
Tell you next time you go.
Are you scared that you'll be arrested and disappear
the next time you go to mainland China?
Senator, you will find content that is critical of China
and any other country freely on TikTok.
Okay. Okay.
Let's let let's turn to what Tik Tok, a tool of the Chinese Communist
Party is doing to America's youth.
Does the does the name Mason Edens ring a bell?
Senator, you may have to give me more specifics, if you don't mind.
Yeah.
He was a 16 year old Arkansan after a break up in 2022.
He went on your platform and searched
for things like inspirational quotes and positive affirmations.
Instead, he was served up numerous videos glamorizing suicide
until he killed himself by gun.
What about the name Chase?
NASCAR?
Does that ring a bell?
Would you mind giving me more details?
He was a 16 year old who saw more than a thousand videos
on your platform about violence and suicide
until he took his own life by stepping in front of a plane or train.
Are you aware that his parents, Dean and Michelle, suing
TikTok and Bytedance for pushing their son to take his own life?
Yes, I'm aware of that.
Okay.
Finally, Mr.
Chew, has the Federal Trade Commission sued TikTok
during the Biden administration?
Senator, I cannot talk about whether there's any.
Are you being.
Are you currently being sued by the Federal Trade Commission?
Senator, I cannot talk about any potential lawsuits.
Related to actual you being sued by the Federal Trade Commission.
Senator, I think I've given you my answer.
I cannot talk about no.
Mrs. Jack Company is being sued, I believe.
Mr. Zuckerberg's company is being sued, I believe.
Yet Tik Tok, the agent of the Chinese Communist
Party, is not being sued by the Biden administration.
Are you familiar with
the name Christina Canfora?
You may have to give me more.
Christina Carfora was a paid adviser to Bytedance,
your communist influenced parent company.
She was then hired by the Biden FTC to advise on how to sue Mr.
Zuckerberg's company.
Senator Biden, this is a global company and not a Chinese Communist Party.
The company is owned by global investors.
Public reports indicate
that your lobbyist visited the White House more than 40 times in 2022.
How many times did your company visit?
Did your company's lobbyist visit the White House last year?
I don't know that.
Are you are you aware that the Biden campaign
and the Democratic National Committee is on your platform?
They have Tik Tok accounts.
Senator, we encourage people to come on, which, by the way, they don't.
They won't let their staffers use their personal phones.
They give them separate phones that they only use Tik Tok on.
We encourage everyone to join, including myself, Senator.
So all these companies are being sued by the FTC.
You're not the FTC has a former paid adviser, your parent,
talking about how they can sue Mr.
Zuckerberg's company, Joe Biden's reelection campaign.
The Democratic National Committee is on your platform.
Let me ask you, have you or anyone else at Tik Tok
communicated with or coordinated with the Biden administration,
the Biden campaign or the Democratic National Committee
to influence the flow of information on your platform?
We work with
anyone, any creators who want to use our campaign is all of the same process.
So what we have,
we have a company that is a tool of the Chinese Communist Party that is poisoning
the minds of America's children, in some cases driving to suicide,
and that at best, the Biden administration is taking a pass on.
At worst, may be in collaboration with.
Thank you, Mr. Chu. Mr. Chu.
How many minors on Tik Tok
and how many of them have a caregiver that uses your family tools?
Senator, I need to get back to you on the specific numbers, but
we were one of the first platforms to give what we call family pairing to parents.
You go to settings, you turn on the QR code, your teenagers, Kyoko and yours,
you scan it.
And what it allows you to do is you can set screen time limits,
you can filter out some keywords, you can turn on a more restricted mode.
And we are always talking to parents.
I met a group of parents and teenagers and high school teachers last week
to talk about what more we can provide in the family pairing mode.
Chairman Durbin,
Ranking Member Graham, and members of the Committee,
thank you for convening this hearing and for moving forward.
Important Legislation to Protect Children Online.
I'm Evan SPIEGEL, the co-founder and CEO of SNAP.
We created Snapchat, an online service that is used by more than 800 million
people worldwide to communicate with their friends and family.
I know that many of you have been working
to protect children online since before Snapchat was created,
and we are grateful for your long term dedication to this cause
and your willingness to work together to help keep our community safe.
I want to acknowledge the survivors of online harms and the families
who are here today who have suffered the loss of a loved one.
Words cannot begin to express the profound sorrow.
I feel that a service
we designed to bring people happiness and joy has been abused to cause harm.
I want to be clear that we understand
our responsibility to keep our community safe.
I also want to recognize the many families who have worked to raise awareness
on these issues, pushed for change, and collaborated with lawmakers
on important legislation like, the Cooper Davis Act, which can help save lives.
I started building Snapchat with my co-founder, Bobby Murphy,
when I was 20 years old.
We designed Snapchat to solve some of the problems
that we experienced online when we were teenagers.
We didn't have an alternative to social media that meant pictures shared
online were permanent public and subject to popularity metrics.
It didn't feel very good.
We built Snapchat differently because we wanted a new way
to communicate with our friends.
That was fast, fun and private.
A picture is worth a thousand,
so people communicate with images and videos on Snapchat.
We don't have public likes or comments when you share your story with friends.
Snapchat is private by default, meaning that people need to opt in to add friends
and choose who can contact them.
When we built Snapchat, we chose to have the images
and videos sent through our service delete by default.
Unlike prior generations who've enjoyed like prior generations
who've enjoyed the privacy afforded by phone calls which aren't recorded.
Our generation has benefited from the ability to share moments
through Snapchat
that may not be picture perfect, but instead convey emotion without permanence.
Even those Snapchat messages are deleted by default.
We let everyone know that images and videos can be saved by the recipient.
When we take action on illegal or potentially harmful content,
we also retain the evidence for an extended period which allows us
to support law enforcement and hold criminals accountable
to help prevent the spread of harmful content on Snapchat.
We approve the content that is recommended on our service using a combination
of automated processes and human review.
We apply our content rules consistently and fairly across all accounts.
We run samples of our enforcement actions through quality assurance to verify
that we are getting it right.
We also proactively scan for known child sexual abuse, material,
drug related content, and other types of harmful content.
Remove that content, deactivate and device block accounts,
preserve the evidence for law enforcement, and report certain content
to the relevant authorities for further action.
Last year, we made 690,000 reports.
The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children,
leading to more than 1000 arrests.
We also removed 2.2 million pieces of drug
related content and blocked 705,000 associated accounts.
Even with our strict privacy settings, content moderation efforts,
proactive detection, and law enforcement collaboration.
Bad things can still happen when people use online services.
That's why we believe that people under the age of
13 are not ready to communicate on Snapchat.
We strongly encourage parents to use the device level
parental controls on iPhone and Android.
We use them in our own household.
And my wife's wife approves every app that our 13 year old downloads.
For parents who want more visibility and control,
we build a family center in Snapchat where you can view
who your teen is talking to, review privacy settings and set content limits.
We have worked for years with members of the committee on Legislation
like the Kids Online Safety Act
and the Cooper Davis Act, which we are proud to support.
I want to encourage broader industry
support for legislation protecting children online.
No legislation is perfect, but some rules of the road are better than none.
Much of the work that we do to protect people that use
our service would not be possible without the support of our partners
across the industry, government, nonprofit organizations, NGOs,
and in particular law enforcement and the first responders
who have committed their lives to helping keep people safe.
I am profoundly grateful for the extraordinary efforts across our country
and around the world to prevent criminals from using online services to perpetrate
their crimes.
I feel an overwhelming sense of gratitude
for the opportunities that this country has afforded me and my family.
I feel a deep obligation to give back and to make a positive difference.
And I'm grateful to be here today
as part of this vitally important democratic process.
Members of the committee,
I give you my commitment that we will be part of the solution for online safety.
We will be honest about our shortcomings and we will work continuously to improve.
Thank you.
And I look forward to answering your questions.
It's never been a secret.
The Snapchat Snapchat is used to send
sexually explicit images in 2013.
Earlier in your company's history, you admitted this in an interview.
Do you remember that interview?
Senator, I don't recall the specific interview.
You said that when you were first trying to get people on the app, you would,
quote, go up to the people and be like, Hey, you should try this application.
You can send disappearing photos.
And they would say, for sexting,
Do you remember that interview?
Senator, when we first created the application, it was actually called
Pick a Boo.
And the idea was around disappearing images.
The feedback we received from people using the app
is that they were actually using it to communicate.
So we changed the name of the application to Snapchat
and we found that people were using it to talk visually.
As early as 2017, law enforcement identified Snapchat
as the pedophile go to sexual exploitation to the case
of a 12 year old girl identified in court only as L.W.
shows the danger.
Over two and a half years of predators sexually groomed her,
sending her ex sexually explicit images and videos over Snapchat.
The man admitted that he only used Snapchat with LW
and not any other platforms because he, quote, knew the chats would go away.
Did you or Eric and everyone else at SNAP really fail
to see that the platform was the perfect tool for sexual predators?
Sir, that behavior is disgusting and reprehensible.
We provide in-app reporting tools so that people who are being harassed
or who have been shared inappropriate sexual content
can report it in the case of harassment or sexual content.
We typically respond to those reports
within 15 minutes so that we can provide help.
When LW, the victim sued Snapchat.
Her case was dismissed under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.
Do you have any doubt that head snap face the prospect of civil liability
for facilitating sexual exploitation?
The company would have implemented even better safeguards?
Senator, We already work extensively to proactively detect this type of behavior.
We make it very difficult for predators to find teens on Snapchat.
There are no public friends lists, no public profile photos.
When we recommend friends
for teens, we make sure that they have several mutual friends in common.
Before making that recommendation.
And we believe those safeguards are important
to preventing predators from misusing our platform.
Mr. SPIEGEL.
I know we talked ahead of time.
I do appreciate your company support for the Cooper Davis Act,
which will finally, it's a bill with Senators Shaheen and Marshall,
which will allow law enforcement to do more when it comes to fentanyl.
I think you know what a problem this is.
Devon Narang, teenagers from Hastings.
I mentioned his mom here suffering dental pain and migraines.
So he bought what he thought was a Percocet over snap.
But instead he bought a counterfeit drug laced with a legal
lethal dose of fentanyl.
As his mom, who's here with us today, said, all of the hopes and dreams
we as parents had for Devon were erased in the blink of an eye.
And no mom should have to bury their kid.
Talk about why you support the Cooper Davis act.
Senator, thank you.
We strongly support the Cooper Davis act, and we believe it will help DEA
go after the cartels and get more dealers off the streets to save more lives.
Mr. SPIEGEL, how many minors use Snapchat?
And of those minors, how many have caretakers
that are registered with your family center?
Senator I believe approximately.
In the United States, there are approximately 20 million
teenage users of Snapchat, I believe approximately 200,000 parents
use family center and about 400,000 teens are linked
their account to their parents using family center.
So 20,000 400,000 sounds like a big number,
but small in percentage of the minors using Snapchat.
What are you doing to ensure that young people
or guardians are aware of the tools you offer?
So we create a banner for family center on the users profiles.
So the accounts we believe may be at the age that they could be.
Parents can see the entry point into family center easily.
Mr. SPIEGEL There are a number of parents whose children have been able.
To access.
Illegal drugs. On your platform.
What do you say to those parents
or. Center We are devastated that we cannot.
Tell the parents.
What do you say to those parents? Mr.
SPIEGEL I'm sorry that we have not been able to prevent these tragedies.
We work very hard to block all search terms related to drugs from our platform.
We proactively look for and detect drug related content.
We remove it from our platform, preserve it as evidence,
and then we refer it to law enforcement for action.
We've worked together with nonprofits and with families on education campaigns
because the scale of the fentanyl epidemic is extraordinary.
Over 100,000 people lost their lives last year.
And we believe people need to know that one pill can kill that campaign.
Reach.
More than 200 was viewed more than 260 million times on Snapchat.
My name is Jason Citron
and I am the co-founder and CEO of Discord.
We are an American company
with about 800 employees living and working in 33 states.
Today, discord has grown to more
than 150 million monthly active users.
Discord is a communications platform
where friends hang out and talk online about shared interests
from fantasy sports to writing music to video games.
I've been playing video games since I was five years old, and as a kid
it's how I had fun and found friendship.
Many of my fondest memories are
of playing video games with friends.
We built Discord so that anyone could build friendships.
Playing video games from Minecraft to Will and everything in between.
Games have always brought us together.
And Discord makes that happen. Today
Discord is one of the many services that have revolutionized
how we communicate with each other in the different moments of our lives.
I message Zoom, Gmail and on and on.
They enrich our lives, create communities,
accelerate commerce, health care and education.
Just like with all technology and tools, there are people who exploit
and abuse our platforms for immoral and illegal purposes.
All of us here on the panel today and throughout the tech industry
have a solemn and urgent responsibility to ensure that.
Everyone who uses our. Platforms.
Is protected from these criminals, both online and off.
This court has a special responsibility to do
because a lot of our users are young people.
More than 60% of our active users
are between the ages of 13 and 24.
It's why safety is built into everything we do.
It's essential to our mission and our business.
And most of all, this is deeply personal.
I'm a dad with two kids.
I want this court to be a product that they use
and love, and I want them to be safe.
On Discord.
I Want them to be proud of me for helping
to bring this product to the world.
That's why I am pleased to be here today
to discuss the important topic of the online safety of minors.
My written testimony provides a comprehensive overview of our safety
programs.
Here are a few examples of how we protect
and empower young people.
First, we've put our money into safety.
The tech sector has a reputation of larger companies buying smaller ones
to increase user numbers and boost financial results.
But the largest acquisition we've ever made
at Dischord was a company called Center P.
It didn't help us expand our market share or improve our bottom line.
In fact, because it uses AI to help us identify,
ban and report criminals and bad behavior,
it has actually lowered our user count by getting rid of bad actors.
Second,
you've heard of end encryption that locks anyone,
including the platform itself, from seeing users communications.
It's a feature on dozens of platforms,
but not on discord.
That's a choice we've made.
We don't believe we can fulfill our safety obligations
if the text messages of teens are fully encrypted
because encryption block our ability to investigate a serious situation
and when appropriate, report to law enforcement.
Third, we have a zero tolerance policy
on child sexual abuse, material or csam.
We scan images uploaded to discord to detect
and block the sharing of this abhorrent material.
We've also built an innovative tool Teen Safety assists that blocks explicit
images and helps young people easily report unwelcome conversations.
We've also developed a new semantic hashing technology
for detecting novel forms of CSM called Clip,
and we're sharing technology with other platforms to the tech coalition.
Finally, we recognize that improving online
safety requires all of us to work together.
So we partner with nonprofits, law enforcement and our tech colleagues
to stay ahead of the curve in protecting young people online.
We want to be the platform that empowers our users to have better online
experiences, to build true connections, genuine
friendships, and to have fun.
Senators, I sincerely hope today is the beginning
of an ongoing dialog that results in real improvements in online safety.
I look forward to your questions
and to helping the committee learn more about this court.
What it says is a civil liability.
If you intentionally or knowingly host or store
child sexual abuse materials or make child sex
abuse materials available.
Secondly, intentionally or knowingly promote or aid
and abet a violation of child sexual exploitation laws.
Is there anyone here who believes
you should not be held civilly liable for that type of conduct?
Mr. Citron.
Good morning, Chair.
You know, we very much
believe that this content is disgusting and that
there are many things about the autopsy, Bill, that I think are very encouraging.
And we very much support adding more resources
for the cyber tip line and and modernizing that along with
giving more resources to fact check.
And we're very
open to having conversations with
you and your team to talk through the details of the bill some more.
I sure would like to do that, because if you intentionally or knowingly
post or store cesium, I think you ought to at least civilly liable.
I can't imagine anyone who would disagree with that.
It's disgusting. Content certainly is.
That's why we need you supporting this legislation.
Mr. Citron, according to Discord's website,
it takes a, quote, proactive and automated approach
to safety only on servers with more than 200 members.
Smaller servers rely on
server owners and community moderators to define and enforce behavior.
So how do you defend an approach to safety that relies on groups of fewer than 200
sexual predators to report themselves for things like grooming,
trading a C scam or sextortion?
I'm sure our our goal is to is to get all of that content
off of our platform and ideally prevent it from showing up in the first place
or from people engaging in these kind of horrific activities.
We deploy a wide array of techniques that work
across every surface on our on discord.
And I mentioned we recently launched something called Teen Safety Assist,
which works everywhere, and it's on by default for teen users.
That kind of acts like a buddy that lets them know
if they're in a situation or talking with someone that may be inappropriate
so they can report that to us and block that user.
So we determine if that were working, we wouldn't be here today.
So this is an ongoing challenge for all of us.
That is why we're here today.
But we we do have 50% of our company is focused
on trust and safety, of which this is one of our top issues
that's more people than we have working on marketing and promoting the company.
So we take these issues very seriously,
but we know it's an ongoing challenge and I look forward to working with you
and collaborating with our tech peers and the nonprofits to
to improve our approach.
Mr. Citron, you
we need to start a discussion.
be honest with you.
We've been having this discussion for a very long time.
We need to get a result, not a discussion.
Do you agree with that?
I'm ranking member. I agree.
This is an issue that we've also been very focused on.
We started our company 2013, but this is the first.
Are you familiar with the Earn It Act, authored by myself and Sir and Blumenthal?
A little bit, yes.
Okay. Do you support that?
We like yes or no?
We're not prepared to support it today, but we believe in section.
Support the CSM Act. The stop CSM Act.
We are not prepared to support it.
Would you support. The SHIELD Act?
We we believe that the cyber tip line support it.
Yes or no?
We we believe that the cyber tip line and.
That to be know the Project Safe Childhood Act, you support it.
We believe that.
I'll tell you that if you know the report act do you support it?
Ranking Member Graham We very much look forward to having conversations
with you and your team.
I look forward to passing the bill will solve the problem.
Do you support removing
Section 230 liability protections for social media companies?
I believe that Section 230 is needs to be updated.
It's a very old law.
I do support repealing it so people can sue if they believe they're harmed.
I think that Section 230 as written,
while it has many downsides, has enabled innovation on the Internet,
which I think is largely. Thank you very much.
So I'm going to start with that with you, Mr.
Citron.
My bill was Senator Cornyn.
The Shield Act includes a threat provision that would help protection
and accountability for those that are threatened by these predators.
Yanking kids, get a picture, send it in.
Think they got a new girlfriend or a new boyfriend, ruins their life
or they think it's going to be ruined and they kill themselves.
So could you tell me why you're not supporting the Shield Act?
Senator, we we think it's very important
that teens have a safe experience on our platforms.
I think that the the the the portion to strengthen law enforcement's ability
to investigate crimes against children and hold bad actors accountable is.
So you're holding open that you may support it.
We very much would like to have conversations with you.
We're open to discussing further and we do welcome legislation, regulation.
This is a very important issue for our country
and we've been prioritizing safety for change.
What about you, Mr. Citron, on Discord?
Do you have
to allow kids to have accounts
to access encrypted messaging?
Discord is not allowed to be used by children
under the age of 13, and we do not use end to end encryption for text messages.
You know, we believe that it's very important to be able to respond to
welfare and law enforcement requests, too.
And we're also working on proactively building technology.
We're working with a nonprofit called Thorn
to build a grooming classifier so that our teen Safety forces feature
can actually identify these conversations if they might be happening
so we can intervene and give those teens tools
to get out of that situation or potentially
even report those conversations and those people to law enforcement.
Mr. Citron This discord allows pornography on its site.
Now, reportedly, 17% of minors who use discord has have
had online sexual interactions on your platform, 17% and 10%
have those
interactions with someone that the minor believed
to be an adult to restrict minors from
from accessing servers
that host pornographic material on them.
Senator Yes, we do restrict
minors from accessing content that is marked for adults.
Discord also does not recommend content to people.
Discord As a chat app.
We do not have a feed or an algorithm that boosts content,
so we allow adults to share content with other adults
in adult label spaces and we do not allow teens to access that content.
Okay.
Let me continue with a follow up question for Mr.
Citron.
In addition, keeping parents informed about the nature of various Internet
services is a lot more we obviously need to do for today's purposes.
Well, many companies offer a broad range of quote unquote user empowerment tools.
It's helpful to understand whether young people even find these tools helpful.
So I appreciate you sharing your teen safety
assist and the tools and how you're advertising it.
But have you conducted any assessments
of how these features are impacting minors?
Use of your platform?
Our intention is to is to give teens tools capabilities that they can use
to keep themselves safe and also so our teams can help keep teen safe.
We recently launched Teen Safety Assists last year and we do not have a study
off the top of my head that we'd be happy to follow up with you on that.
Chairman Durbin,
Ranking Member Graham, and esteemed
members of the Committee, thank you for the opportunity
to discuss X's work to protect
the safety of minors online.
Today's hearing is titled A Crisis,
which calls for immediate Action.
As a mother, this is personal,
and I share the sense of urgency.
X is an entirely new company,
an indispensable platform for the world and for democracy.
You have
my personal commitment that X will be active
and a part of this solution.
While I joined X only in June of 2023,
I bring a history of working together with governments
advocates and NGOs to harness
the power of media to protect people.
Before I joined, I was struck the leadership steps
this new company was taking to protect children.
X is not the platform
of choice for, children and teens.
We do not have a line of business dedicated to children,
children under the age of 13
are not allowed to open an account.
Less than 1% of the U.S.
users on X are between the ages of 13 and 17,
and those users are automatically
set to a private default setting
and cannot accept a message from anyone they do not approve.
In the last 14 months,
X has made material changes to protect minors.
Our policy is clear.
X has zero tolerance towards
any material that features or promotes
child sexual exploitation.
My written testimony details
X's extensive policies on content
or actions that are prohibited and include
grooming, blackmail
and identifying alleged victims of CSEA.
We've also strengthened our enforcement with more tools
and technology to prevent those bad actors from distributing.
Searching for and engaging with CSC content.
If CSC content is posted on X, we remove it.
And now we also remove any account
that engages with CSC content, whether it is real
or computer generated.
Last year,
X suspended 12.4 million accounts
for violating our CSC policies.
This is up from 2.3 million accounts
that were removed by Twitter in 2022.
In 2023,
850,000 reports were sent to NECC MC,
including our first ever auto generated report.
This is eight times more than was reported
by Twitter in 2020 to
We've changed our priorities.
We've restructured our trust in safety teams
to remain strong and agile.
We are building a Trust and Safety Center of Excellence
in Austin, Texas, to bring more agents
in-house, to accelerate our impact.
We're applying to the Technology Coalitions project Lantern,
to make further industry wide progress and impact.
We've also opened up our algorithms
for increased transparency.
We want America to lead in solution.
X commends the Senate for passing the Report Act,
and we support the SHIELD Act.
It Is time for a federal standard to criminalize
the sharing of non-consensual intimate material?
Need to
raise the standards across the entire Internet
ecosystem, especially for those tech companies
that are not here today and not stepping up.
X supports the Stop CSM Act.
The Kids Online Safety Act should continue to progress
and we will support the continuation to engage with it
and ensure the protections of the freedom of speech.
There are two additional areas
that require everyone's attention.
First,
as the daughter of a police officer,
law enforcement
must have the critical resources
to bring these bad offenders to justice.
Second, with artificial intelligence
offenders, tactics will continue to sophisticate and evolve.
Industry collaboration is imperative here.
X believes that the freedom of speech
and platform safety can and must coexist.
We agree that now is the time
to act with urgency.
Thank you.
I look forward to answering your questions.
D Report the absolute number of how many images.
Or how often posts and accounts that we've taken down in 2023.
We've taken over almost a million posts down
that in regards to mental health and self-image. Ms.
PERINO Based on your understanding of existing law, what might it take
for a person to have those images remove, say, from x
eye? Senator Lee Thank you.
It sounds like what you're going to introduce into law
in terms of ecosystem wide and use her consent
sounds exactly like part of the philosophy
of why we're supporting the SHIELD Act.
And no one should have to endure non-consensual images.
Being Michelle Carino, how many minors use X
and are you planning to implement safety measures or guidance
for caretakers like you're sure companies have?
Thank you, Senator.
Less 1% of all U.S.
users are between the ages of 13 and 17.
Less than 1%.
How many of 90 million U.S. users?
So still hundreds of thousands continue.
Yes. Yes.
And every single one is very important.
Being a 14 month old company, we have reprioritized child
protection and safety measures and we have just begun to talk about
and discuss how we can enhance those with parental controls.
Michelle Guarino, have you talked to parents
directly, young people, about designing your product
as a new leader of X?
The answer's yes.
I've spoken to them about the behavioral patterns,
even because less than 1% of our users are in that age group.
But you have spoken to them.
A lot of examples of a young person
finding out about an image that is of them
and really compromises them and actually can create suicidal thoughts.
And they want to call up or they want to send an email and say, take it down.
I mean, why is it not possible for that to be responded to immediately?
Well, we all strive to take down any type
of violative content or disturbing content immediately.
At X, we have increased our capability to start reporting process.
I'm a parent or I'm a kid and I want this down.
Shouldn't there be a message in place where it comes down?
You can see what the image is.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.