Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
THE LOSS OF A MAMMOTH CONTAINER SHIP
BAFFLES INVESTIGATORS.
ONE OF THE BIGGEST QUESTIONS WE HAD WAS
WHY WAS THIS SHIP SO CLOSE TO THE EYE OF THE HURRICANE?
THE SEARCH FOR ANSWERS TAKES THEM
TO THE BOTTOM OF THE OCEAN.
WAIT, WAIT, WAIT, WHAT'S THAT?
I HONESTLY COULDN'T BELIEVE WHAT WE WERE SEEING.
THREE-FIVE-ZERO!
WHY DID AN EXPERIENCED CREW...
DAMN IT!
END UP ON A DEADLY COURSE?
RING THE ABANDON SHIP!
AND DID SOMETHING HAPPEN
TO TIP THEM OVER THE EDGE?
MY FEET ARE SLIPPING!
I'M GOING DOWN!
NO, YOU'RE NOT, COME ON!
GO, GO, GO.
YOU KNOW THEY'RE GOING THROUGH SOMETHING.
YOU KNOW THEY'RE IN PAIN.
-HELP ME! -YOU GOTTA GET UP!
THEY'RE IN TROUBLE.
AND THEY WERE.
HURRICANE ALLEY IN THE NORTH ATLANTIC
IS FAMOUS FOR ITS STORMS.
AND RIGHT NOW, THE CREW OF THE 790-FOOT CONTAINER SHIP,
EL FARO, HAS ALREADY CHANGED COURSE
TO AVOID A BIG ONE, TROPICAL STORM JOAQUIN.
IN COMMAND OF THE SHIP AND ALL 32 CREW MEMBERS ON BOARD
IS CAPTAIN MICHAEL DAVIDSON.
RIGHT NOW, IT'S AN EASTERLY SWELL.
WE'RE JUST GONNA HAVE TO WATCH IT.
THE WEATHER PATTERN IS CRAZY ERRATIC.
THE CAPTAIN, HE HAD OVER 24 YEARS AT SEA.
HE'D SAILED ON THE NORTH ATLANTIC AND THE ALASKAN RUNS.
HE WAS EXPERIENCED WITH HEAVY WEATHER.
AND HE KNEW THIS SHIP.
EL FARO IS ABOUT HALFWAY
INTO A TWO AND A HALF DAY, WEEKLY RUN
FROM JACKSONVILLE, FLORIDA TO SAN JUAN, PUERTO RICO.
THE MASSIVE SHIP IS CARRYING
391 SHIPPING CONTAINERS ON DECK
AND 505 TRACTOR TRAILERS AND CARS IN HER HOLDS.
JACK HEARN IS A FORMER CAPTAIN OF THE EL FARO.
HE KNOWS THE SHIP AND WORKED WITH MANY OF HER CREW.
AT THAT POINT, SHE WASROUGHLY 40 YEARS OLD,
AND STILL IN GOOD CONDITION.
THE STEEL WAS THICK, THE FRAMING WAS CLOSE,
AND SHE WAS A POWERFULLY BUILT SHIP,
AND POWERFULLY ENGINEERED SHIP.
EXCELLENT IN ROUGH WEATHER.
BUT THAT'S ABOUT TO BE PUT TO THE TEST.
LESS THAN 12 HOURS INTO EL FARO'S JOURNEY,
THE NATIONAL HURRICANE CENTER UPGRADES JOAQUIN
TO A FULL CATEGORY 1 HURRICANE.
BY TWO O'CLOCK, SO ON YOUR WATCH,
YOU SHOULD BE SOUTH OF THIS MONSTER.
YEAH.
IT'S MORE IMPORTANT THAN EVER TO AVOID JOAQUIN,
SO THE CAPTAIN'S CHARTED A COURSE
TO KEEP A SAFE DISTANCE FROM THE EYE OF THE STORM.
THE CAPTAIN THOUGHT THAT HIS SPEED AND THE COURSE
WOULD PLACE HIM FARTHER TO THE SOUTH OF THE HURRICANE.
IT'D BE A ROUGH NIGHT BUT ULTIMATELY, THE STORM
WOULD STILL BE FARTHER TO THE NORTH OF THEM.
WELL, I'M GONNA WATCHA LITTLE TELEVISION, I THINK.
SECOND MATE AND SHIP'S NAVIGATOR,
DANIELLE RANDOLPH, WILL STAND WATCH OVERNIGHT.
THE 34-YEAR-OLD BRIDGE OFFICER
IS ONE OF ONLY TWO WOMEN ON BOARD.
SHE'S JUST RETURNED FROM A VACATION VISITING HER MOTHER.
RIGHT FROM KINDERGARTEN ON,
SHE WANTED TO WORK ON BOATS, AS SHE PUT IT.
SHE WANTED TO BE OUT TO SEA,
SHE WANTED TO BE A SAILOR,
SHE WANTED TO GO ON A BIG SHIP.
AND LOVED IT.
AND TO HER, THE OCEAN WAS HOME.
WHOA, IT'S GONNA BE A BUMPY ONE.
YEAH.
THE PLAN TO OUTRUN THE STORM MAKES SENSE.
EL FARO'S MAIN ENGINE CANDELIVER UP TO 30,000 HORSEPOWER.
THIS WAS A VESSEL THAT WAS CAPABLE OF DOING
UP TO 20 KNOTS
AND THE CAPTAIN WAS COUNTING ON HIS SPEED AS PART OF HIS,
YOU KNOW, OPTIONS FOR KEEPING AWAY OR CLEAR OF THE STORM.
BUT BY ONE IN THE MORNING,
THEY'RE HITTING THE EDGES OF THE STORM,
AND IT'S TAKING A TOLL ON THE CREW'S NERVES.
YOU'LL FEEL THE BOW OF THE SHIP
IN A HEAVY WAVE AS A STORM STARTS TO BUILD.
YOU'LL FEEL THE LURCH AND THE SUDDENNESS OF SHOCK.
IT STOPS EVERYTHING, AND IT'S STUNNING,
AND YOU WONDER IF IT'S GONNA COME RIGHT THROUGH.
THEN, IT GETS WORSE.
PLEASE BE ADVISED HURRICANE JOAQUIN
HAS BEEN UPGRADED TO A CATEGORY 3 STORM.
IN LESS THAN 24 HOURS,
JOAQUIN HAS GROWN FROM A CATEGORY 1
TO A POWERFUL CATEGORY 3 HURRICANE.
NEAR ITS CENTER, IT'S PRODUCING SUSTAINED WINDS
OF 115 MILES AN HOUR.
OH, MY GOD.
HURRICANE EXPERT DAVID NOLAN
TRACKED THE STORM'S UNUSUAL BEHAVIOR.
JOAQUIN DID SOMETHING THAT WE CALL
RAPID INTENSIFICATION,
WHICH IS A, YOU KNOW, A LARGE INCREASE IN STRENGTH
OVER A RELATIVELY SHORT PERIOD OF TIME.
AS THE WIND PICKS UP, SO DOES THE SEA.
WAVES BEGIN REACHING HEIGHTS OF 26 FEET OR MORE,
WITH EXTREME WAVES ALMOST TWICE THAT HIGH.
IT'S A SEA STATE THAT MOST PEOPLE NEVER GET TO SEE
OR EXPERIENCE IN ANY WAY, WHATSOEVER.
IT'S EVEN WORSE AT NIGHT
BECAUSE YOU CAN'T SEE ANYTHING,
AND ALL YOU'RE DOING IS FEELING THE MOTION OF THE SHIP
AND FEELING AND HEARING THE WAVES HIT YOU.
WHOA!
WHOA!
IT ACTUALLY DOES BECOME FRIGHTENING.
I'M GONNA GIVE THE CAPTAIN A CALL
AND SEE IF HE WANTS TO COME UP.
IN THESE WORSENING CONDITIONS,
THE SECOND MATE FEARS THEIR PRESENT COURSE
IS NO LONGER SAFE.
THIS IS THE CAPTAIN.
CAPTAIN, IT ISN'T LOOKING GOOD UP HERE.
SHE WANTS TO CHANGE THEIR HEADING
TO STEER EVEN FARTHER AWAY FROM THE HURRICANE.
FROM MY TRACK LINE, I'VE GOT ZERO-TWO HUNDRED.
ALTER COURSE STRAIGHT SOUTH AND TURN.
HER ALTERNATE COURSE WOULD TAKE THEM
THROUGH A CHANNEL BETWEEN CUBA AND THE BAHAMAS,
SHELTERING THEM FROM THE WORST OF THE STORM.
NO, THIS IS LOOKING GOOD.
STAY WITH THE COURSE AS WE PLANNED IT.
OKAY.
AND THE CAPTAIN SAYS "NO,
"I THINK WE'RE GOING TO BE OKAY.
"FROM THE INFORMATION I'M LOOKING AT,
"WE'RE GOING TO CONTINUE ON."
HE SAID TO RUN IT.
ON SHORE, METEOROLOGISTS
ARE TRACKING THE STORM CLOSELY.
IT'S BECOMING CLEAR JOAQUIN IS NOT ONLY GETTING STRONGER,
IT'S NO LONGER FOLLOWING THE PROJECTED COURSE.
MOST OF THE COMPUTER MODEL FORECASTS
ORIGINALLY TOOK JOAQUIN TO THE NORTH.
I THINK THAT'S WHAT A LOT OF US EXPECTED IT TO DO.
THE FACT THAT IT CONTINUED TO MOVE SOUTHWEST
WAS REALLY A SURPRISE.
ON BOARD,DANIELLE HAS FINISHED HER SHIFT
AND SENDS A WORRIED EMAIL TO HER MOTHER.
SHE SAID, "I'M NOT SURE
"IF YOU'VE BEEN WATCHING THE WEATHER,
"BUT WE'RE IN A HURRICANE."
AND FOR HER TO SAY THAT, IT WAS UNUSUAL
BECAUSE SHE NEVER WANTED TO WORRY ME.
SHE WROTE, "LOVE TO EVERYONE."
SHE NEVER EVER SIGNED HER EMAILS LIKE THAT.
AT 4:00 A.M., CHIEF MATE STEVE SCHULTZ
IS STANDING WATCH ON THE BRIDGE,
AND ABLE SEAMAN FRANK HAMM IS AT THE HELM.
THE INTENSITY OF THE STORM HAS HIM ON EDGE.
CAPTAIN, I KNEW BY 1:00 A.M. THE STORM WAS COMING IN.
WELL, THIS IS EVERY DAY IN ALASKA.
THIS IS WHAT IT'S LIKE.
THE CAPTAIN CALLS ON HIS LONG EXPERIENCE
IN ALASKA TO REASSURE HIM.
BUT SOMETHING ISN'T RIGHT.
THE SHIP HAS STARTED HEELING OVER TO ONE SIDE.
THE CREW AND THE CAPTAIN CAN FEEL IT.
WE'RE SETTING, SIR.
GOING LIKE THIS.
SHE'S BEING HEELED OVER TO THAT STARBOARD SIDE
BECAUSE ALL THIS WIND AND ALL THE WAVES
ARE NOW ACTING ON HER PORT SIDE.
AND ALL THESE CONTAINERS, ALL THIS SURFACE
THAT THE WIND AND THE WAVES CAN PUSH AGAINST,
ARE PUSHING US OVER ONTO OUR STARBOARD SIDE.
SO, WE'VE GOT THIS WIND HEEL THAT'S GOING ON.
IN THE ENORMOUS 26-FOOT SEAS,
THE MAIN ENGINE IS HAVING TROUBLE KEEPING UP.
THE SHIP IS SLOWING DOWN,
AND THE WIND IS BLOWING THEM OFF COURSE.
WE'RE POUNDING A BIT
BECAUSE WE'RE GOING MORE EASTERLY.
WE NEED TO LET HER GET UP TO SPEED,
GET A LITTLE MORE ON OUR COURSE.
IT'S AN ALARMING DEVELOPMENT.
THE CAPTAIN IS DEPENDING ON THEIR SPEED
TO HELP KEEP THEM OUT OF THE WORST OF THE STORM.
THE VESSEL DROPPED SPEED OVER A PERIOD OF TIME,
THAT'S PRETTY SIGNIFICANT.
AND THAT INDICATES THAT
THEY'RE REALLY NEAR THE CENTER OF THE STORM,
WHICH IS NOT THE PLACE YOU WANT TO BE.
YOU CAN ACTUALLY FEELTHE PRESSURE CHANGING
AS YOU GET CLOSER TO THE CENTER OF A STORM.
YOUR EARS WILL POP.
HARD RIGHT, RUDDER.
HARD RIGHT.
IT'S A STRUGGLE
JUST TO HOLD THE SHIP ON COURSE.
AND THINGS ARE ABOUT TO GET MUCH WORSE.
BRIDGE, CAPTAIN.
CAPTAIN, WE GOT FLOODING IN NUMBER THREE.
GO DOWN TO THREE HOLD,START THE PUMPS RIGHT NOW.
YES, SIR.
THE CAPTAIN IS CONCERNED.
HE HAS TO BE CONCERNED
BECAUSE, NOT ONLY IS HE IN BAD WEATHER
AND WHAT LOOKS TO BE AN INCREASINGLY WORSE SITUATION,
NOW HE'S GOT FLOODING IN HIS NUMBER THREE HOLD.
AN HOUR BEFORE DAWN,
IN THE JAWS OF A HURRICANE,
THE EL FARO IS IN TROUBLE.
DESPITE HAVING ALTERED COURSE,
THE MASSIVE CONTAINER SHIP EL FARO,
IS CLOSER THAN EXPECTED TO HURRICANE JOAQUIN.
NOW, THEY'RE FACING A CRISIS.
THE SHIP IS TAKING ON WATER.
THE FIRST THING IS THAT,
WHERE HAS THE WATER COME FROM?
AND HOW DO WE STOP IT FROM COMING IN?
THAT'S THE FIRST PRIORITY.
CHIEF MATE, WHEN HE GOES DOWN TO HAVE A LOOK,
THE WATER IS COMING IN THROUGH AN OPEN SCUTTLE.
THE WATER IS RUNNING DOWN THROUGH THIS
AND IT'S NOW DOWN IN THE HOLD.
THE SCUTTLE IS A PASSAGEWAY LEADING FROM A DECK
OPEN TO THE WEATHER, DOWN INTO THE SHIP'S HOLD.
ITS HATCH SHOULD BE CLOSED TIGHT, BUT IT'S COME OPEN.
CAPTAIN, IT'S THE CHIEF.
LOOKS LIKE AN OPEN SCUTTLE.
SOMEHOW THAT SCUTTLE LEAKED, OPENED, VIBRATED OPEN,
OR WAS POUNDED OPEN IN ROUGH WEATHER,
AND STARTED TAKING ON WATER.
WITH WIND BLOWING THE SHIP TO STARBOARD,
WATER IS POOLING OVER THE OPEN SCUTTLE,
AND BEING FUNNELED INTO A HOLD
PACKED WITH CARS AND TRACTOR TRAILERS.
THE PUMPS CAN'T KEEP UP WITH THE FLOODING.
AND IT'S TOO DANGEROUS FOR THE CREW
TO TRY AND SHUT THE HATCH.
RIGHT NEXT TO THAT LOCATION
IS A VERY LARGE HULL OPENING
THAT IS ACTUALLY BUILT FOR CARGO TRANSFER
AND A TRUCK TO DRIVE RIGHT THROUGH IT.
SO, YOU CAN IMAGINE A DOOR AS LARGE AS A TRACTOR TRAILER
AND OPEN TO THE SEA WITH WATER COMING IN CHEST-HIGH.
CARGO COULD MOVE ONTO YOU AND CRUSH YOU.
IT'S A CRITICAL SITUATION AND YOU'VE GOT TO FIX IT.
CAPTAIN DAVIDSON COMES UP WITH A PLAN.
HE'LL USE THE HURRICANE ITSELF TO HELP STOP THE FLOODING.
I'M GONNA TURN THE SHIP.
GIVE US A PORT LIST SO WE GET A BETTER LOOK AT IT.
THE CAPTAIN DECIDED WE'RE GOING TO TURN THE SHIP
SO THAT THE WIND IS NOW ON THE OTHER SIDE,
ON OUR STARBOARD SIDE, TO TRY TO INDUCE MORE OF A PORT LIST,
DRY OUT THE WATER ON THE STARBOARD SIDE
AND WE'RE GONNA FIX THIS.
OKAY, I'M GONNA START THE TURN.
LEFT 20!
LEFT 20.
JUST BEFORE SIX IN THE MORNING,
THE CAPTAIN TURNS THE EL FARO INTO HEAVY, ONCOMING SEAS.
STEER: THREE-FIVE-ZERO.
THREE-FIVE-ZERO.
IT TAKES A FEW MINUTESTO TURN A BIG, SLOW-MOVING SHIP
'CAUSE IN THOSE HEAVY SEAS AND SWELLS,
THE SHIP ISN'T MOVING LIKE A RACE CAR.
THE SHIP'S GOING TO TAKE MUCH HARDER ROLLS
AND THEN YOU'RE GOING TO TURN AND HEAD INTO THESE HIGH SEAS.
SO, IT'S A VERY DANGEROUS MANEUVER, BUT
IT'S ALL YOU CAN DO
THREE-FIVE-ZERO.
OKAY, WE'VE GOT A NICE PORT LIST.
AS THE WIND PUSHES THE SHIP
OVER ONTO HER PORT SIDE,
THE WATER DRAINS OFF THE OPEN HATCH,
AND THE CREW CAN SEAL IT SHUT.
IT SHOULD STOP THE FLOODING FROM GETTING ANY WORSE.
BUT NOW, THERE'S A NEW PROBLEM.
DOWN IN THE ENGINE ROOM, ALARMS ARE GOING OFF.
DAMMIT!
I THINK WE JUST LOST THE PLANT.
AT THE WORST POSSIBLE TIME,
THE SHIP'S MAIN ENGINE SPUTTERS AND SHUTS DOWN.
THE SOUND OF LOSING YOUR MAIN ENGINES
IS NOT A SOUND THAT YOU WANT TO HEAR.
MANUAL PUMP!
THE ENGINEERS NEED TO RESTORE THE OIL PRESSURE,
IF THEY ARE TO HAVE ANY HOPE OF RESTARTING THE ENGINE.
THE ENGINE ROOM IS THE HEART,
LIVER AND LUNGS OF THE SHIP.
ONCE THE ENGINE ROOM IS QUIET,
EVERYTHING ELSE ON THE SHIP CEASES TO OPERATE.
WITHOUT POWER, EL FARO IS AT THE MERCY
OF THE HURRICANE'S ENORMOUS WAVES.
THE SITUATION IS CRITICAL.
THE SHIP IS ROLLING AND IT'S PITCHING,
AND THE ENGINEERS ARE DOWN THERE SCRAMBLING AROUND,
"WE GOT TO DO THIS.
"WE GOT TO GET THE ENGINE GOING."
I NEED THAT OIL PRESSURE BACK UP NOW!
WITH A DEAD SHIP IN A VIOLENT STORM,
STARTING THE ENGINE IS THEIR ONLY HOPE TO SURVIVE.
YOU'RE IN A FIGHT WITH A STORM,
AND YOU NEED THAT PROPULSION SYSTEM
TO MOVE THAT SHIP AWAY FROM THE DANGERS
AND DEAL WITH EACH ONCOMING WAVE.
NO MATTER WHAT THEY DO,
THE ENGINEERS CAN'T GET THE ENGINE BACK ON-LINE.
THE EL FARO IS NOW STARTING TO DRIFT.
SHE'S STARTING TO TURN,
BECAUSE THE WAVES ARE HITTING HER NOW
AND SHE'S STARTING TO DRIFT SIDE ON.
AND THIS IS THE ONE POSITION
BEAM-ON, EXPOSED ALONG HER ENTIRE LENGTH.
IT IS A HUNDRED-KNOT WINDS AND SEAS OF OVER 35 FEET.
EL FARO COULD CAPSIZE ANY MOMENT.
THE CAPTAIN HAS NO CHOICE BUT TO ACTIVATE
THE AUTOMATED MAYDAY SIGNAL.
ALRIGHT, LET'S PUSH THE BUTTON.
DISTRESS BUTTON'S BEEN ACTIVATED.
IT'S THE LAST SIGNAL
EVER RECEIVED FROM EL FARO.
THE SHIP IS NOW BEAM-ON TO THE SEAS.
WE'RE ROLLING, WE'RE UNCONTROLLABLY ROLLING.
RING THE ABANDON SHIP.
THE GENERAL ALARM HAS BEEN SOUNDED.
PREPARE EVERYTHING TO GET READY TO GET OFF.
EVERYTHING IS BREAKING LOOSE.
-YOU OKAY? -YEAH, YOU GOOD?
-YEAH, I THINK SO. -THERE YOU GO, FOCUS.
YOU KNOW THEY'RE GOING THROUGH SOMETHING.
YOU KNOW THAT THEY'RE...
THEY'RE IN TROUBLE.
AND THEY WERE.
GO, GO, GO.
HOURS LATER, HURRICANE JOAQUIN SLAMS
INTO THE BAHAMAS, LEAVING DEVASTATION IN ITS PATH.
SEARCH AND RESCUE RECEIVE EL FARO'S DISTRESS SIGNAL,
BUT THE RAGING STORM HINDERS THE SEARCH.
AS HOPE DWINDLES, FRIENDS AND FAMILIES
OF THE MISSING CREW HOLD VIGIL.
WE NEVER TALKED ABOUT
HIM NEVER COMING HOME FROM A SHIP.
IT'S JUST BEEN A LOT OF AGONY,
BUT THEN WE ALSO POOL IN ALL OUR HOPE AND OUR LOVE TOGETHER
AND THAT'S ALL WE'RE RUNNING ON NOW, IT'S JUST HOPE.
WE WERE GLUED TO THETV LIKE EVERYONE ELSE, YOU KNOW,
HOPING FOR GOOD NEWS.
IS THERE A CHANCE THAT THERE COULD BE A SURVIVOR?
YOU HANG ON, HOPE LIKE EVERYONE ELSE.
SEVEN DAYS AFTER EL FARO'S LAST SIGNAL,
THE LAST SHREDS OF HOPE ARE GONE.
SEARCH AND RESCUE FIND FLOATING DEBRIS
CONTAINERS,
A LIFE RING,
A CRUSHED LIFE BOAT,
BUT NO SIGN OF ANY SURVIVORS.
ALL 33 CREW ON THE EL FARO ARE PRESUMED LOST AT SEA.
IT'S THE DEADLIEST U.S. MARITIME DISASTER
IN ALMOST 40 YEARS.
SHE ALWAYS SAID TO ME,
"IF ANYTHING HAPPENS TO ME OUT AT SEA, MOM,
"IT'S OKAY, I DIED DOING WHAT I WANT TO DO."
THE U.S. COAST GUARD
AND THE NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD
LAUNCH AN INVESTIGATION TO FINDOUT WHAT HAPPENED, AND WHY.
WE KNOW THAT THERE ARE REPORTS
THAT THIS VESSEL HAS SUNK IN DEEP WATER.
IT WAS A U.S. FLAG VESSEL
THAT THE COAST GUARD OVERSEES.
AND THEY'RE U.S. LIVES, THE MARINERS
AND A LARGE NUMBER, 33, LOST.
YOU KNOW, THERE WAS A DEFINITE SINCERE DESIRE
TO FIGURE OUT WHAT HAPPENED AND TO NOT SPARE ANY EXPENSE.
FINDING ANSWERS WON'T BE EASY.
THE WRECK IS LOST IN WATERS MORE THAN 15,000 FEET DEEP.
FIVE DAYS AFTER THE SINKING OF THE EL FARO,
INVESTIGATORS BEGIN SEARCHING FOR ANSWERS.
BRIAN YOUNG IS LEAD INVESTIGATOR
FOR THE NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD.
EL FARO WAS ONE OF THE BIGGEST CASES, I THINK,
N.T.S.B. HAS EVER DEALT WITH, ESPECIALLY IN THE MARINE MODE.
AND WE HADN'T LOST AN AMERICAN SHIP
AND THE ENTIRE CREW IN DECADES.
CAPTAIN JASONNEUBAUER OF THE U.S. COAST GUARD
IS ALSO ASSIGNED TO THE CASE.
FROM A COAST GUARD STANDPOINT,
WE LOOK AT ALL THE ASPECTS, LIKE ALSO ACCOUNTABILITY,
BEYOND JUST WHAT CAUSED THE ACCIDENT.
WE'RE LOOKING AT PERFORMANCE OF ALL THE PEOPLE,
INCLUDING THE MARINERS, THE MARINE INSPECTORS
THAT LOOKED AT THE SHIP.
THAT'S OUR CHARGE.
SO, DEBRIS WAS FOUND HERE AND HERE.
SO, THIS IS WHAT WE'RE WORKING WITH.
30 DAYS AFTER THE SINKING,
THE WRECK IS LOCATED BY NAVY SONAR.
SOMEWHERE AMONG THE SCATTERED DEBRIS
IS THE MOST VITAL PIECE OF EVIDENCE,
THE VOYAGE DATA RECORDER.
ITS MICROPHONES CAPTURE CONVERSATIONS
ON THE SHIP'S BRIDGE
AND ITS SENSORS RECORD VALUABLE PERFORMANCE DATA.
THE INFORMATION'S THEN FED TO A WATERTIGHT CAPSULE
MOUNTED ON TOP OF THE BRIDGE.
FINDING IT WON'T BE EASY.
THE VDR IS EQUIPPED WITH A LOCATOR BEACON,
BUT IT'S NOT WORKING.
AND EL FARO'S TWISTED WRECKAGE IS SCATTERED
ACROSS NEARLY A SQUARE MILE.
INVESTIGATORS SCAN THE WRECKAGE
BY USING CAMERAS MOUNTED ON AN ROV.
BUT AFTER WEEKS OF SEARCHING, THERE'S NO SIGN OF THE VDR.
WE TRIED TO PUT TOGETHER THE PIECES
OF WHAT MAY HAVE POSSIBLY HAPPENED,
AND IT WAS VERY DIFFICULT, ESPECIALLY WITHOUT THE VDR,
TO HAVE ANY IDEA AS TO WHAT THE CREW EXPERIENCED
IN THE LAST FEW HOURS.
WHY DID A SHIP
RECEIVING UP-TO-THE-MINUTE WEATHER DATA
END UP IN SUCH A DEADLY POSITION?
SO, EL FARO IS THERE,
AND THIS IS THE EYE OF THE STORM.
HOW DID THEY END UP 20 MILES
FROM THE EYE OF A HURRICANE?
THAT'S THE MILLION-DOLLAR QUESTION.
WE KNEW THE CAPTAIN HADMADE A PHONE CALL TO THE COMPANY
SAYING THAT HE WAS IN THE HURRICANE,
THE SHIP WAS IN TROUBLE.
SO, WHAT WE TRIED TO DO WAS
SPEAK WITH THE COMPANY REPRESENTATIVE
WHO HAD RECEIVED THE PHONE CALL,
TO SEE IF WE CAN GET ANY MORE DETAILS ON THAT PHONE CALL.
SO, THE CAPTAIN SAID THE SHIP WAS FLOODING
AND THAT IT WAS IN TROUBLE?
THEY HAD SOME WATER COMING INTO THE SHIP,
AND THAT THEY HAD LOST PROPULSION.
THANKS FOR COMING BY.
BUT THE CAPTAIN DIDN'T KNOW
WHAT SET OFF THEIR ENGINE PROBLEMS,
OR WHY THEY COULDN'T RESTART IT.
LOOKING FOR INSIGHTS, INVESTIGATORS INSPECT
EL FARO'S SISTER SHIP, THE EL YUNQUE.
INVESTIGATING A SHIP UNDERWATER
THAT IS VIRTUALLY UNREACHABLE
IS A CHALLENGE IN ITSELF.
AND WE WERE LUCKY TO HAVE A VERY SIMILAR DESIGNED VESSEL,
EL YUNQUE, TO SEE IF THERE WAS ANY MAINTENANCE ISSUES.
IT'S ABOUT THE SAME AGE AND WE WANTED TO SEE
WHAT THE LAYOUT OF THE VESSEL WAS,
AND ALSO, WERE THERE ANY PROBLEM AREAS
FROM A WATERTIGHT INTEGRITY STANDPOINT?
IT DOESN'T TAKE THEM LONG
TO FIND A TROUBLING CLUE.
TAKE A LOOK AT THIS.
EACH VEHICLE IS SUPPOSED TO BE SECURED
DIRECTLY TO FASTENERS WELDED TO THE DECK.
BUT ABOARD EL YUNQUE, CARS ARE ATTACHED TO LONG CHAINS
THAT RUN ACROSS THE WIDTH OF THE CARGO HOLD.
IT'S MUCH LESS SECURE.
ON EL FARO, WITH THEINCREASED WEATHER AND A WET DECK
AND THE CARS ONLY SECURED TO A LONG CHAIN,
IT WOULD HAVE BEEN EASIER FOR THE CARS TO BREAK FREE
IN THEIR LASHINGS AND MOVE ABOUT THE CARGO HOLD,
WHICH WAS SUBJECT TO IMMENSE FORCES.
LOOSE CARGO CAN MAKE A SHIP UNSTABLE,
ESPECIALLY IN A VIOLENT STORM.
THE ONLY WAY TO KNOW IF THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED ON EL FARO
IS TO GO BACK TO THE WRECKAGE
AND FIND THE VOYAGE DATA RECORDER.
THE QUESTION WAS, WHERE WAS THE VOYAGE DATA RECORDER?
ANDY BOWEN IS A PRINCIPAL ENGINEER
AT THE WOODS HOLE OCEANOGRAPHIC INSTITUTION.
LEADERS IN DEEP SEA EXPLORATION, THEIR SHIP,
THE ATLANTIS, IS EQUIPPED WITH HIGH DEFINITION SONAR,
AND AN ROV THAT CAN HUNT FOR SMALL OBJECTS AT GREAT DEPTH.
IT WAS A PARTICULARLY CHALLENGING OBJECTIVE.
ANY LUCK YET?
EL FARO LIES VERY DEEP IN THE OCEAN,
OVER 4,000 METERS DOWN,
BECAUSE LOOKING FOR SOMETHING
THE SIZE OF A LARGE CAN OF COFFEE,
WHICH IS ABOUT WHAT THE VDR IS,
AMONGST THOUSANDS OF TONS OF SHIP,
IS A LITTLE BIT LIKE A NEEDLE IN A HAYSTACK.
TO MAKE MATTERS WORSE,
THE WRECK HAS BEEN TORN APART.
THE MAST, AND WITH IT THE VDR, IS STILL MISSING.
THE BRIDGE WAS NOT ON THE TOP OF THE SHIP
WHERE YOU EXPECTED IT TO BE.
WAIT, WAIT, WAIT, WHAT'S THAT?
THEY ACTUALLY FOUND THE BRIDGE
SEVERAL HUNDRED METERS FROM THE WRECKAGE,
AND UNFORTUNATELY, THE MAST, WHICH WOULD NORMALLY
HAVE BEEN ATTACHED TO THE TOP OF THE BRIDGE,
HAD BEEN SEPARATED, AND THAT'S WHERE THE VDR WAS.
IS THERE ANYTHING?
NO.
SO, IF WE COULD FIND THEMAST, WHICH WAS A LARGE OBJECT,
IT WAS QUITE LIKELY THAT WE MIGHT FIND
THE VOYAGE DATA RECORDER CONNECTED TO IT.
THAT WAS SORT OF THE IDEAL SCENARIO FOR US.
SO, DOES THAT BRING US TO THE END OF THIS SECTION?
NOT QUITE.
INVESTIGATORS CHART THE LOCATION
OF EVERY PIECE OF DEBRIS,
AND USE THE PATTERN TO TARGET THEIR SEARCH.
HOW'S IT GOING?
IF THEY'D GUESSED WRONG,
THE ENTIRE EXPEDITION COULD END IN FAILURE.
NTSB INVESTIGATOR SEAN PAYNE WAS PART OF THE SEARCH TEAM.
AT THAT POINT, WE WERE BASICALLY
WORKING OFF OF ADRENALINE.
OKAY, I'M GONNA GET SOME SLEEP.
I HAD THIS FEELING THAT IF WE DIDN'T FIND IT
IN EITHER MY WATCH, OR THE NEXT WATCH,
IF IT WASN'T IN THAT AREA,
THAT OUR HUNCH THAT THIS THING WAS LAID OUT
IN A WRECKAGE DEBRIS FIELD THAT MADE SENSE,
LIKE ANY OTHER ACCIDENT, WAS INCORRECT.
SO, THERE WAS A LOT OFPRESSURE GOING INTO THAT NIGHT.
A FEW HOURS INTO HIS SHIFT,
SOMETHING CATCHES HIS EYE.
OH, MY GOD, GO BACK, GO BACK, GO BACK.
I HONESTLY CAN'T BELIEVE WHAT WE WERE SEEING,
WHEN IT CAME OUT OF THE DARKNESS OF THE SEA,
WAS FINALLY THE SHAPE OF THE MAST.
AND EVEN BETTER, A FEW CABLES
WERE STILL HOLDING THE VDR TO THE BASE.
THAT'S IT.
THE NAVYSALVAGE TEAM IS BROUGHT BACK
TO RECOVER THE CAPSULE.
ITS WIRES ARE ENTANGLED,
AND NEED SPECIAL EQUIPMENT TO CUT THEM FREE.
INVESTIGATORS MAY FINALLY HAVE THE EVIDENCE THEY NEED
TO EXPLAIN WHY THE EL FARO SANK,
KILLING ALL 33 PEOPLE ON BOARD.
AT NTSB HEADQUARTERS IN WASHINGTON,
INVESTIGATORS BEGIN THE MAMMOTH TASK
OF ANALYZING THE CONVERSATIONS CAPTURED ON THE BRIDGE
WHILE THE DISASTER WAS ACTUALLY UNFOLDING.
THE VDR ACTUALLY RECORDED 26 HOURS
OF THE EL FARO'S FINAL VOYAGE.
IT STARTED SOMEWHERE OFF THE COAST OF FLORIDA,
CONTINUED ON UNTIL ABOUT 7:40 A.M.
WHEN THE SHIP SANK OFF THE COAST OF THE BAHAMAS.
IT'S THE LONGEST RECORDING THE NTSB
HAS EVER HAD TO ANALYZE.
HOW'S IT COMING?
SLOW PROGRESS, BUT WE'RE GETTING THERE.
HAVE A SEAT.
THE INVESTIGATORS LISTEN FOR CLUES
HOPING TO PIECE TOGETHER WHAT LED TO THE DISASTER.
A LOT OF PEOPLE TALK ABOUT THE LAST WORDS,
BUT REALLY, IT'S THE WORDS THATARE SPOKEN WELL BEFORE THAT
THAT OFTEN REVEAL WHAT HAPPENED IN AN ACCIDENT.
VERY DIFFICULT TO LISTENTO THE ENTIRE 26 HOURS OF AUDIO.
AND THE HARDEST PART IS WE KNEW
HOW THAT ENDING WAS GONNA HAPPEN,
WHEREAS WE KNEW THEY DIDN'T KNOW THAT.
AS THE RECORDING BEGINS,
THE CREW IS ALREADY TRACKING THE DEVELOPING STORM.
RIGHT NOW, IT'S AN EASTERLY SWELL.
WE'RE JUST GONNA HAVE TO WATCH IT.
THE WEATHER PATTERN IS CRAZY ERRATIC.
YEAH.
WE WANTED TO KNOW IF THE SHIP WAS SEAWORTHY.
WAS THERE A PROBLEM WITH THE WATERTIGHT INTEGRITY
OF THE VESSEL?
AND ALSO, WAS THE CREW,
DID THEY COMPETENTLY HANDLE THE SITUATION?
BRIDGE, CAPTAIN.
THEY ZERO IN ON THE CAPTAIN'S ATTEMPTS
TO DEAL WITH FLOODING IN CARGO HOLD NUMBER THREE.
GO DOWN TO THREE HOLD.
START THE PUMPS RIGHT NOW.
YES, SIR.
THE CAPTAIN WAS FOCUSING ON TRYING TO CLOSE
THE STARBOARD SCUTTLE THAT HAD BEEN VERIFIED
TO BE A SOURCE OF FLOODING BY THE CREW.
CAPTAIN, IT'S THE CHIEF.
LOOKS LIKE AN OPEN SCUTTLE.
OKAY, I'M GONNA TURN THE SHIP AROUND.
GIVE US A PORT LIST.
SEE IF WE CAN GET A BETTER LOOK AT IT.
SO, IN THE BRIDGE, YOUCAN HEAR THAT THEY MADE
A DECISION TO TURN THE VESSEL TO PORT.
WE GOT A NICE PORT LIST.
SO, THE CREW GAINED ACCESS
TO THE SCUTTLE ON THE STARBOARD SIDE,
IS ABLE TO CLOSE IT.
THEREFORE, NO MORE WATER IS ENTERING
THE CARGO HOLD VIA THE SCUTTLE.
THE CAPTAIN'S MANEUVER SOLVED ONE PROBLEM,
BUT AS INVESTIGATORS LISTEN, THEY DISCOVER THE SCUTTLE
WASN'T THE ONLY SOURCE OF THE FLOODING.
WE KNOW FROM THE VDR THAT THEY
EXPERIENCED SEVERE FLOODING
EVEN AFTER CLOSING THE STARBOARD SCUTTLE.
CAPTAIN.
I THINK THE WATER LEVEL'S RISING.
SOMETHING HIT THE FIRE MAIN, GOT IT RUPTURED.
I SAW CARS BOBBING AROUND.
PLAY THAT AGAIN.
SOMETHING HIT THE FIRE MAIN,
GOT IT RUPTURED.
INVESTIGATORS ALREADY KNOW CARS
WEREN'T SECURED PROPERLY ON EL FARO'S SISTER SHIP.
NOW, THEY HEAR HOW DANGEROUS THAT CAN BE.
THERE'S A GOOD POSSIBILITY
THAT THE EMERGENCY FIRE MAIN,
WHICH WAS IN HOLD THREE, WAS DAMAGED BY FLOATING VEHICLES
AND SOME OTHER DEBRIS IN THAT AREA.
THE FIRESUPPRESSION SYSTEM USES SEAWATER
THAT IS DRAWN INTO THE SHIP THROUGH PIPES.
IF A CAR HAD STRUCK THE INCOMING PIPE
AT THE BOTTOM OF THE SHIP
THAT ALLOWS SEA WATER TO ENTER INTO THE PIPING SYSTEM,
THERE'S NO WAY TO STOP IT.
THE UNCONTROLLED FLOODING
IN CARGO HOLD NUMBER THREE WAS DEADLY SERIOUS.
BUT IT DOESN'T EXPLAIN WHAT HAPPENED NEXT.
DAMMIT!
I THINK WE JUST LOST THE PLANT.
THE MAIN ENGINE SHUT DOWN.
I NEED THAT BACK UP NOW.
AND DESPITE THE CREW'S FRANTIC EFFORTS,
THEY COULDN'T RESTART IT.
WITHOUT ENGINES, IT'S DEAD IN THE WATER.
BUT WHY DID THEY LOSE POWER?
AND WHY COULDN'T THEY GET IT BACK?
INVESTIGATORS SUSPECT SOMETHING CATASTROPHIC
HAPPENED WHEN THE CAPTAIN TURNED THE SHIP.
DAMMIT!
THE QUESTION IS, WHAT WAS IT?
STEER: THREE-FIVE-ZERO.
INVESTIGATORS WANT TO KNOW WHY EL FARO
LOST HER MAIN ENGINE AT THE WORST POSSIBLE TIME,
IN THE MIDDLE OF A HURRICANE.
I THINK WE JUST LOST THE PLANT.
IF THE MAIN ENGINE CONTINUED TO OPERATE,
THE SHIP WOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO MANEUVER
AND PUT THE HEAD OF THE SHIP INTO THE WIND
AND POSSIBLY BEEN ABLE TO MANEUVER OUT OF HARM'S WAY.
IT'S GOTTA BE SOMETHING ABOUT THE TURN.
THEY LOSE POWER RIGHT AFTER THE TURN.
BRIDGE, CAPTAIN.
ON THE VDR, THEY HEAR THE CREW
DISCUSSING A PROBLEM WITH LOW PRESSURE
IN THE ENGINE'S LUBE OIL SYSTEM.
WE'RE GONNA GET THAT BOILER BACK UP IN A SECOND.
THEY'RE JUST GETTING THE LUBE OIL PRESSURE UP.
I NEED THAT OIL PRESSURE BACK UP NOW!
LUBE OIL IS ESSENTIAL.
WITHOUT IT, THE SHIP'SENORMOUS MAIN ENGINE WON'T RUN.
AND AS INVESTIGATORS STUDY THE SYSTEM,
THEY NOTICE A QUIRK IN THE DESIGN
THAT COULD EXPLAIN THE FAILURE.
WE HAD THE PLANS OF THE INTERNAL PARTS
OF THE LUBE OIL SUMP,
WHICH IS THE TANK THAT PROVIDES THE OIL
TO LUBRICATE THE MAIN TURBINE.
INVESTIGATORS NOTICE THE VALVE
THAT FEEDS LUBE OIL TO THE ENGINE
IS OFFSET TO ONE SIDE.
THE LOPSIDED DESIGN MEANS IF THE SHIP LISTS
TO PORT BY MORE THAN 15 DEGREES,
THE FLOW OF OIL TO THE MAIN ENGINE IS CUT OFF.
THE TIMING OF THE DISASTER SUPPORTS THE THEORY.
16 MINUTES AFTER THE CAPTAIN TURNED THE SHIP,
EL FARO BEGAN LISTING BY AS MUCH AS 18 DEGREES
ONTO HER PORT SIDE.
I'M NOT LIKING THAT LIST.
WITH DEADLY RESULTS.
AT THAT POINT,
THE TURBINE WOULD SHUT DOWN AUTOMATICALLY.
THE PORT LIST WAS LIKELY MORE EXTREME
THAN THE CAPTAIN WAS EXPECTING.
THE REASON WHY TAKES INVESTIGATORS BACK
TO THE PROBLEM THAT MADE THE CAPTAIN TURN THE SHIP
IN THE FIRST PLACE, THE FLOODING IN THE HOLD.
NOW THAT THERE'S WATER IN THE HOLD,
YOU HAVE AN EFFECT CALLED FREE SURFACE EFFECT.
AND THIS HAPPENS WHEN VOLUMES OF WATER
ARE ABLE TO SHIFT FROM SIDE-TO-SIDE IN AN OPEN SPACE.
IT ADDS MORE ROLL, IT ADDS INCREASING POWER,
THE SHIP'S ROLLING.
CARS HAVE COME LOOSE.
THAT'S ADDING TO THE WEIGHT THAT'S MOVING AROUND.
THE SHIFTINGWEIGHT HAS TRAGIC CONSEQUENCES.
IT HELPS PUSH THE SHIP FARTHER TO PORT,
WHICH NOT ONLY TRIGGERS THE ENGINE SHUTDOWN,
IT ALSO MAKES IT IMPOSSIBLE TO RESTART.
WE BELIEVE THAT THE CREW WAS NOT AWARE
OF THE LIMITATIONS OF THE ENGINE BEING EXPOSED
TO SUCH A HEAVY PORT LIST.
AND IN TERMS OF THE ENGINE ROOM,
IT WAS THE WORST CASE SCENARIO.
THE ENGINEERS NEEDED THE SHIP TO BE ON AN EVEN KEEL,
TO GET THE OIL PRESSURE BACK,
BUT THE CAPTAIN NEEDED THE ENGINE,
IN ORDER TO GET THE SHIP TO AN EVEN KEEL.
WITHOUT ENGINES, IT'S ONLY A MATTER OF TIME
BEFORE THE WIND AND WAVES OF HURRICANE JOAQUIN
CAPSIZE THE SHIP, TAKING WITH HER
THE LIVES OF ALL 33 PEOPLE ON BOARD.
BUT THERE'S ONE FINAL MYSTERY.
EL FARO SOMEHOW ENDED UP JUST 22 MILES
FROM THE EYE OF THE STORM.
INVESTIGATORS NEED TO KNOW WHY.
ONE OF THE BIGGEST QUESTIONS WE HAD WAS
WHY WAS THIS SHIP SO CLOSE TO THE EYE OF THE HURRICANE?
WHY HE DECIDED TO CONTINUE ON HIS COURSE?
PART OF THE EXPLANATION COULD BE
THE UNUSUAL NATURE OF HURRICANE JOAQUIN.
NOT ONLY DID IT STRENGTHEN MORE QUICKLY THAN PREDICTED,
IT ALSO CHANGED DIRECTION.
AFTER FIRST HEADING NORTH, IT TURNED TO THE SOUTHWEST,
STRAIGHT INTO EL FARO'S PATH.
INVESTIGATORS NEED TO KNOW
IF THAT INFORMATION EVER REACHED THE CREW.
BIT BY BIT, THE CONVERSATIONS ON THE BRIDGE
SUGGEST A TRAGIC ANSWER.
THAT IS ODD.
HEY, BRIAN?
THE TRANSCRIPTS SHOW THE CREW KNEW THE STORM
HAD CHANGED DIRECTION, BUT THE CAPTAIN DIDN'T.
-LOOK AT THIS. -WHAT'VE YOU GOT?
SO RIGHT THERE,
I CAN TELL THEY HAVE THE LATEST WEATHER.
THE CAPTAIN IS NOT LOOKING AT IT.
OH.
PLEASE BE ADVISED HURRICANE JOAQUIN
HAS BEEN UPGRADED TO A CATEGORY 3 STORM.
DURING THE SECOND MATE'S WATCH,
SHE HAD A SATELLITE RADIO ON
AND SHE HAD UPDATES FROM SAT-C,
WHICH IS A SATELLITE SIGNAL THAT'S SENT
FROM THE NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE.
SO, THE CREW WAS RECEIVING MULTIPLE,
UPDATED WEATHER REPORTS.
THAT BRINGS US RIGHT
INTO THE STORM AT 4:00 A.M.
THEY'RE AWARE THAT THEY ARE GONNA BE SAILING
VERY CLOSE TO THE HURRICANE.
CAPTAIN, IT ISN'T LOOKING GOOD UP HERE.
THEY HEAR THESECOND MATE CALLING THE CAPTAIN
WITH AN URGENT REQUEST TO STEER FARTHER AWAY FROM THE STORM.
FROM MY TRACK LINE, I'VE GOT ZERO-TWO HUNDRED.
ALTER COURSE STRAIGHT SOUTH AND TURN.
WHEN THE SECOND MATE CALLED THE CAPTAIN,
SHE HAD SUGGESTED A COURSE CHANGE TO GO DIRECTLY SOUTH
TO ESCAPE THE WORST PART OF THE WEATHER.
BUT THE CAPTAIN WAS CONFIDENT
HIS COURSE WAS THE RIGHT ONE.
NO, THIS IS LOOKING GOOD.
STAY WITH THE COURSE AS WE PLANNED IT.
OKAY.
HE SAID TO RUN IT.
WE DO KNOW THAT SHE WAS GIVEN AN ORDER
TO RUN THE ORIGINAL COURSE,
WHICH PUT THEM CLOSE TO THE EYE OF THE STORM.
THE SECOND MATE TRIED TO WARN
THE CAPTAIN OF THE DANGER.
WHY DIDN'T HE LISTEN TO HIS CREW?
INVESTIGATORS EXAMINING THE LOSS
OF THE EL FARO
NEED TO KNOW WHY THE CAPTAIN DIDN'T REALIZE
HIS SHIP WAS HEADING FOR THE EYE OF A HURRICANE.
INFORMATION IS VITAL.
IT'S VITAL TO ANY DECISION-MAKING.
YOU CAN ONLY MAKE A DECISION BASED ON
AS ACCURATE INFORMATION AS YOU CAN GET.
THE EL FARO HAD RECEIVED WEATHER UPDATES
FROM A VARIETY OF SOURCES.
BUT INVESTIGATORS NOW SUSPECT THE CAPTAIN
WAS ONLY LOOKING AT ONE,
A SUBSCRIPTION SERVICE THAT USES EASY-TO-READ GRAPHICS.
IT'S VERY EASY TO UNDERSTAND.
IT'S A VERY GRAPHIC DEPICTION OF THE WEATHER SYSTEM
RELATIVE TO THE SHIP'S POSITION,
AND THAT WAS ONLY EMAILED TO THE CAPTAIN'S EMAIL ADDRESS.
ALTHOUGH EASIERTO READ THAN SATELLITE REPORTS,
IT'S UPDATED LESS FREQUENTLY.
BY THE TIME IT'S EMAILED TO THE CAPTAIN,
THE FORECAST IS ALREADY SIX HOURS OLD.
IT STILL SHOWS JOAQUIN NORTH OF THEIR PLANNED ROUTE.
HE THINKS THE STORM IS HERE,
BUT IT'S REALLY HERE.
THE WEATHER REPORTS THAT HE WAS LOOKING AT
THAT INDICATED HIS POSITION
WAS TO THE BETTER SIDE OF THE STORM,
WHEREAS IN REALITY, THE SHIP
WAS IN THE WORST QUADRANT OF THE HURRICANE.
BRIAN, THE CREW KNEW THEY'RE IN TROUBLE.
BUT THE CAPTAIN DIDN'T LISTEN.
IT'S LIKELY NEITHER CAPTAIN NOR CREW
REALIZED HE WAS RELYING ON A FORECAST
THAT WAS DANGEROUSLY OUT OF DATE.
IN THE END, IT IS THE CAPTAIN'S DECISION.
WHEN THEY WERE FACED WITH THE CAPTAIN'S ANSWER,
THEY FOLLOWED ORDERS.
HE SAID TO RUN IT.
I'M SURE, KNOWING DANIELLE, SHE WAS INFURIATED
BECAUSE SHE KNEW THAT THAT WAS NOT A GOOD OPTION.
YOU'RE A CAPTAIN, YOU'RE NOT GOD,
LISTEN TO YOUR CREW MEMBERS.
FOR THE CAPTAIN, IT'S IMPORTANT
TO COUNT ON SUGGESTIONS AND CONCERNS
THAT WERE COMING FROM MEMBERS OF HIS OFFICERS.
TWO YEARS AFTER THE SINKING,
INVESTIGATORS ISSUE THEIR FINAL REPORT INTO THE TRAGEDY.
THERE WAS A RIPPLE EFFECT
FLOODING, PROPULSION AND STORM.
THEY CALL THIS SOMETIMES AN ERROR CHAIN,
WHERE THERE'S A CHAIN OF EVENTS THAT ARE LINKED,
AND IF ANY ONE OF THOSE THINGS HAD NOT HAPPENED,
POSSIBLY THEY WOULD HAVE SURVIVED THE STORM.
THIS IS THE CAPTAIN.
CAPTAIN, IT ISN'T LOOKING GOOD UP HERE.
IT BEGINS WITHTHE CAPTAIN'S MISTAKEN DECISION
TO IGNORE HIS CREW AND STAY ON HIS COURSE.
NO, THIS IS LOOKING GOOD.
STAY WITH THE COURSE AS WE PLANNED IT.
OKAY.
HE SAID TO RUN IT.
ONCE EL FARO WAS CAUGHT IN THE STORM,
SHE BEGAN TO FLOOD.
THE ATTEMPT TO FIX IT...
I'M GONNA TURN THE SHIP.
GIVE US A PORT LIST SO WE GET A BETTER LOOK AT IT.
CAUSED A PORT LIST THAT WAS SO EXTREME,
IT CUT OFF THE OIL SUPPLY,
AND SHUT DOWN THE MAIN ENGINE.
I THINK WE JUST LOST THE PLANT.
IT WAS IMPOSSIBLE TO RESTART.
DAMMIT!
BY THE TIME THEY REALIZED WHAT HAD HAPPENED,
IT'S ALREADY TOO LATE.
RING THE ABANDON SHIP.
IN THOSE CONDITIONS, THERE'S NO WAY
TO LAUNCH ONE OF THE LIFEBOATS THAT THEY HAVE.
THE CREW KNEW AT THAT POINT,
THEIR ODDS OF SURVIVABILITY WERE ALMOST ZERO.
THE FINAL MOMENTS OF THE RECORDING
ARE HEART-WRENCHING.
IT WAS EXTREMELYEMOTIONAL TO LISTEN TO THE VDR.
WE'RE WATCHIN' THE CLOCK TICKIN' DOWN TO THE END.
ARGH.
HELP ME!
YOU'RE OKAY, COME ON.
DON'T FREEZE UP.
CAP!
CAP!
YOU GOOD?
YEAH.
THERE YOU GO, FOCUS.
YOU GOTTA GET UP!
HELP ME!
YOU GOTTA SNAP OUT OF IT.
-I GOT IT. -YOU CAN DO THIS.
-YEAH. -GO, GO, GO.
YOU NEED TO MAKE YOUR WAY UP HERE.
I CAN'T!
THE VESSEL'S LEANING OVER SO MUCH.
I DON'T THINK THAT HE CAN EVEN CLIMB UP
TO GET OUT OF THE BRIDGE.
THEY'RE LOSING HER NOW.
MY FEET ARE SLIPPING!
I'M GOING DOWN!
NO, YOU'RE NOT, COME ON!
YOU GONNA LEAVE ME?
I'M NOT GONNA LEAVE YOU, LET'S GO!
WATER IS NOW PASSINGFREELY DOWN INTO THE LOWER HOLD.
THE VESSEL IS ON HER PORT SIDE.
THE VOICES OF THE CAPTAIN AND THE HELMSMAN
ARE THE LAST ONES RECORDED.
-I'M A GONER! -NO, YOU'RE NOT!
THE SHIP JUST CONTINUED TO GO.
AND THERE'S NO STOPPING IT AT THAT POINT.
IN THEIR FINAL REPORTS, THE COAST GUARD
AND THE NTSB MAKE MORE THAN 63 RECOMMENDATIONS,
INCLUDING BETTER TRAINING ABOUT THE WORKING
OF THE SHIP'S ENGINES, AND BETTER CREW COMMUNICATION.
I KNOW THAT CHANGES WILL BE MADE
AS A RESULT OF THESE RECOMMENDATIONS,
AND WE ARE SEEING SOME ALREADY.
IT'S COMING FOR THE NEXT GENERATION OF MARINERS,
THE SONS, THE DAUGHTERS,
PEOPLE THAT ARE STILL GOING OUT THERE,
TO LEARN HOW WE CAN PREVENT THESE ACCIDENTS
FROM HAPPENING TO US THAT WORK OUT THERE,
AND TO OTHER PEOPLE THAT RELY ON US TO DO THIS JOB RIGHT.
AS A CAPTAIN,
IT'S ONE THING TO BE IN CHARGE OF EVERYONE,
AND BE SURE OF YOURSELF,
BUT IT'S ANOTHER THING TO ALSO BE SURE OF YOURSELF
TO BE ABLE TO BE OPEN TO SUGGESTION.
WE ARE AT DAMES POINTAT THE EL FARO MEMORIAL.
THIS LIGHTHOUSE, THEY HAD BUILT
ESPECIALLY FOR THIS MEMORIAL.
IT'S A BEAUTIFUL PARK.
AND THIS IS DANIELLE.
SO, ALL THESE ROCKS WERE DONE BY FAMILY FRIENDS IN MAINE.
THIS IS ONE OF MY FAVORITE PICTURES OF DANIELLE.
AND I HAD HER SAYING WHAT SHE TOLD ME
JUST BEFORE SHE LEFT,
"AT SEA IS WHERE I ALWAYS WANT TO BE."
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.