Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
A CAR FERRY
HEADS BACK ACROSS THE ENGLISH CHANNEL.
WE'D HAD A GOOD DAY OUT AND WE WERE LOOKING FORWARD
TO HAVING A NEW ADVENTURE ON THE SHIP ON THE WAY HOME.
JUST OUTSIDE THE HARBOR, DISASTER STRIKES.
WATER ABSOLUTELY PLOWED IN.
AND JUST HIT ME LIKE A BULLDOZER.
EVERYDAY HEROES SCRAMBLE TO THE SCENE.
PEOPLE INSIDE THE SHIP,
SCREAMING AND SHOUTING, CRYING.
IT'S ABSOLUTE CHAOS AND CONFUSION.
THE WORST PART OF IT,
HAVING TO SEE THE CHILDREN FLOATING IN THE WATER.
THE INVESTIGATION REVEALS
A DEADLY MISCALCULATION.
WE DID HAVE TO SCRATCH OUR HEADS
AT HOW ON EARTH THIS VESSEL SANK.
SHE SHOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO MAKE IT ACROSS THE CHANNEL.
SPEED WAS ALL IMPORTANT AND SAFETY WAS NOT.
IT WAS ALL MADNESS REALLY.
MARCH 6TH, 1987.
ZEEBRUGGE HARBOR, BELGIUM.
TANKERS, CONTAINER SHIPS AND FERRIES
ALL CONVERGE AT THIS BUSY EUROPEAN PORT,
A VITAL HUB FOR SHIPPING AND TRANSPORTATION.
ROGER THAT.
WE'VE BEGUN LOADING, CAPTAIN.
EXCELLENT.
THANK YOU.
AS DAYLIGHT BEGINS TO FADE,
THE CREW OF THE 430-FOOT FERRY,
THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE,
STARTS LOADING THEIR MASSIVE SHIP.
SHE WAS A VERY MODERN AND VERY EFFICIENT
ROLL ON ROLL OFF FERRY.
SHE WAS DESIGNED BOTH FOR SPEED AND FOR VOLUME.
SO CALLED RO-RO FERRIES, LIKE THE HERALD,
LET CARS AND TRUCKS DRIVE STRAIGHT THROUGH THE SHIP.
RAMPS AT THE FRONT AND BACK HELP LOADING AND UNLOADING
HAPPEN AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE.
THE SPEED SAVES TIME,
AND TIME IS MONEY IN THE FERRY BUSINESS.
THE TIME PRESSURES CAN BE QUITE EXACTING.
IN ORDER TO ACHIEVE OPTIMUM EFFICIENCY,
YOU'VE GOT TO GET CARGO ONBOARD AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE.
IT'S AN UNRELENTING PACE
FOR CREW MEMBERS LIKE ASSISTANT BOATSWAIN MARK STANLEY.
THEIR WORKDAY STARTED HOURS EARLIER IN DOVER, ENGLAND.
A CREW WILL HAVE AN ASSISTANT BOATSWAIN,
RESPONSIBLE FOR DIRECTING THE TRAFFIC
INTO THE PROPER PLACES.
YOU CAN GET TRAILERS, YOU CAN GET LORRIES,
YOU CAN GET COACHES,
AND THEN YOU CAN GET CARS AND CARAVANS.
KEEP IT MOVING.
KEEP IT MOVING.
THE 9,000-TON FERRY HAS TWO DECKS
FOR LOADING VEHICLES.
ALSO ON BOARD ARE DUTY-FREE SHOPS, RESTAURANTS,
CAFETERIAS AND A LOUNGE THAT SHOWS MOVIES.
KEEP IT MOVING!
THE 100-MILE TRIP ACROSS THE ENGLISH CHANNEL
SHOULD TAKE ABOUT FOUR HOURS.
IT'S THE LAST SCHEDULED RUN OF THE DAY.
THIS IS A BIG SHIP.
16 YEAR-OLD GILLIAN BADDELEY AND HER FAMILY
ARE RETURNING HOME FROM A DAY TRIP TO BELGIUM.
THERE WAS A, A DEAL ON IN THE "SUN" NEWSPAPER
AND IT WAS A POUND
TO GO TO THESE DIFFERENT PLACES VIA FERRY.
AND WHEREVER THE TRIP WAS,
THAT WAS WHERE WE WOULD BE TAKEN.
WE'D HAD A GOOD DAY OUT AND WE WERE LOOKING FORWARD
TO HAVING A NEW ADVENTURE ON THE SHIP ON THE WAY HOME.
MARK, YOU KEEP AN EYE ON YOUR BROTHER.
WE GOT ONTO THE FERRY;
ALL THE KIDS KIND OF DEPARTED,
THEY ALL WENT THEIR SEPARATE WAYS TO THE CINEMAS
AND RESTAURANTS AND OTHER THINGS TO KEEP US ALL ENTERTAINED.
DEAR, ALRIGHT.
COME ON.
NOW, NOT TOO MANY SWEETS, LOVE.
-THANKS, MUM. -OKAY, LOVE.
SEE YOU IN A MINUTE. YEAH.
-18 YEAR - OLD MARTIN BARNES
WORKS IN ONE OF THE SHIP'S CAFETERIAS.
OH, IT WAS A GREAT SOCIAL, SOCIAL CIRCLE OF CREW.
WHOA MATE!
WE SOCIALIZED TOGETHER; WE HAD PLAYED FOOTBALL TOGETHER.
MANY OF US WERE SORTA GOOD FRIENDS,
YOU KNOW, SOCIALIZING AND DRINKING OUTSIDE OF WORK.
I'LL SEE YOU TOMORROW, YEAH?
IT WAS A FRIDAY.
ONE OF OUR FRIENDS WAS HAVING AN ENGAGEMENT PARTY
ON THE SATURDAY, SO WE WAS ALL LOOKING FORWARD
TO GETTING OFF ON THAT SATURDAY.
TRUCKER, LARRY O'BRIEN, IS HEADING BACK HOME
TO IRELAND WITH A LOAD OF MEDICAL SUPPLIES.
FOR TRANSPORT DRIVERS USING THE CROSS-CHANNEL FERRY
IS A ROUTINE PART OF THE JOB.
I'M SORRY, MATE, YOU'RE TOO LATE.
OH NO, PLEASE.
I PULL IN AND THE SECURITY MAN SAID,
"YOU'RE TOO LATE."
PLEASE, MY PAPERS ARE DONE, PLEASE.
LET ME SEE YOUR PAPERS, PLEASE.
WELL, I WAS IN TRANSIT,
MY LOAD WAS SIGNED FROM GERMANY DIRECT TO IRELAND,
SO I HAD NO CUSTOMS TO DEAL WITH, IT WAS DIRECT.
YEAH, WE'VE GOT A BIG LORRY HERE.
SO HE SAID, "OKAY, GO AHEAD, YOU'RE LUCKY."
IT'S YOUR LUCKY DAY, MATE.
-OH, THANK YOU. -ALL RIGHT.
SO I DROVE STRAIGHT DOWN, AND A MAN JUST BECKONED ME
STRAIGHT IN ON THE BOAT AND I WAS THE LAST TO LOAD.
O'BRIEN'S GLAD HE GOT ON BOARD.
HE HAS A YOUNG DAUGHTER AND A PREGNANT WIFE
WAITING FOR HIM AT HOME.
CREW TO HARBOR STATIONS.
CREW TO HARBOR STATIONS.
ON MY WAY.
WITH THE LAST PASSENGERS AND VEHICLES LOADED,
THE HERALD IS READY TO LEAVE PORT.
-OKAY, TAKE HER OUT. -TAKE HER OUT!
TONIGHT, THE HUSTLE OF THE CREW PAYS OFF.
THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE
DEPARTS JUST A FEW MINUTES BEHIND SCHEDULE.
I WENT OFF TO THE RESTAURANT
TO GET SOMETHING TO EAT.
I WAS LOOKING AROUND, SO MANY PEOPLE, FAMILIES AND KIDS.
I COULDN'T FIGURE OUT WHY SO MANY PEOPLE ON THE BOAT.
YOU KNOW, NORMALLY THAT TIME OF YEAR
THERE'D BE ONLY JUST TRUCK DRIVERS AND NO ONE ELSE ON IT.
QUITE A LOT OF THE FAMILIES
USED TO MAKE IT A DAY OUT ON THE FERRY.
AND WE HAD THE RETURN LEG FROM ZEEBRUGGE ON THAT NIGHT.
SO, IT WAS PARTICULARLY BUSY.
I DECIDED TO GO OUTSIDE
AND HAVE A LOOK AT THE VIEW
AS WE WERE LEAVING PORT, WHICH WAS QUITE AMAZING.
I WAS THE ONLY ONE ON THE OUTSIDE OF THE SHIP.
LESS THAN 25 MINUTES INTO THE VOYAGE,
WITH THE HARBOR STILL IN SIGHT,
THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE SUDDENLY LURCHES TO THE LEFT.
IT LOOKED LIKE THE BOAT WAS GOING UNDER THE WATER.
I THOUGHT, WELL, IT MUST BE LIKE A MIRAGE.
I WAS IMAGINING IT.
BUT IT WAS ACTUALLY HAPPENING.
MUMMY, WE'RE SINKING!
BELOW DECKS, WHERE THE VEHICLES ARE PARKED,
MORE PROOF THAT SOMETHING IS HORRIBLY WRONG.
THERE'S WATER COMING DOWN THE STAIRS!
WHAT ON EARTH IS GOING ON HERE?
THE HERALD RIGHTS ITSELF.
SHE CAME BACK OUT OF THAT AND KIND OF STRAIGHTENED.
BUT WITHIN SECONDS,
THE CREW REALIZES THE CRISIS IS FAR FROM OVER.
ONCE AGAIN, THE HERALD LISTS DANGEROUSLY TO ONE SIDE.
BUT SHE DIDN'T COME BACK FROM THIS ONE,
SHE WENT STRAIGHT OVER.
HAPPENED SO QUICKLY,
COULDN'T BELIEVE IT HAPPENED SO QUICKLY.
PLATES AND PEOPLE STARTED FALLING.
ANYTHING THAT WASN'T STRAPPED DOWN OR TIED DOWN
WAS GOING THROUGH THE AIR, INCLUDING PEOPLE.
DIDN'T REALIZE EXACTLY WHAT WAS HAPPENING.
I FELL AGAINST THE WINDOW AT THE SIDE OF THE SHIP.
THE HERALD HAS ROLLED OVER IN JUST 90 SECONDS.
539 PEOPLE ARE TRAPPED ON BOARD.
AND THE ICE COLD SEA WATER
IS ABOUT TO MAKE THE TERRIFYING SITUATION MUCH WORSE.
THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE HAS CAPSIZED
IN THE FRIGID WATERS
JUST OUTSIDE OF BELGIUM'S ZEEBRUGGE HARBOR
WITH 539 PEOPLE ON BOARD.
THROUGHOUT THE SHIP,
PASSENGERS AND CREW ARE STRUGGLING TO SURVIVE.
AND THE SITUATION IS ABOUT TO GET EVEN WORSE.
THERE WAS A MASSIVE WINDOW AND WHEN IT BURST,
THE WATER ABSOLUTELY PLOWED IN.
PORTHOLE WINDOWS, EXIT DOORS, ENTRY DOORS,
CAME UP THROUGH DECKS, CAME IN EVERYWHERE.
THE WATER HAD COME UP FROM THE CAR DECK,
UP THE LIFT SHAFT AND RUSHED AND THEN JUST HIT ME
LIKE A BULLDOZER.
WHERE I WAS, COMPLETELY UNDER WATER,
THE LIGHTS SORT OF STARTED APPEARING AS IF I'D GONE.
I CAN REMEMBER THINKING ALMOST THAT WAS IT.
GAME OVER.
I WAS STILL HOLDING THE TABLE AND I SAID TO MYSELF,
WHAT AM I DOING HERE?
THERE WAS ONLY ONE WAY OUT AND THAT WAS UP.
NOW TO GO UP, IF YOU CAN IMAGINE A SHIP
THAT'S COMPLETELY GONE ON ITS SIDE,
TO GET UP WAS GOING TO BE A PROBLEM.
FELT LIKE A TRUE, A NIGHTMARE.
I JUST DIDN'T KNOW WHAT WAS HAPPENING
TIL I POPPED UP OUT OF THE WATER AND I THOUGHT,
SUDDENLY THOUGHT, THIS IS, THIS IS REAL.
GILLIAN BADDELEY WAS UP ON DECK
WHEN SHE WAS KNOCKED OUT.
AND, WHEN I AWOKE,
THEN I REALIZED THEN THE BOAT HAD CAPSIZED,
AND I NEEDED TO GET BACK INTO THE SHIP
TO ACTUALLY FIND MY PARENTS.
THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT I HAD TO DO.
I HAD TO GO BACK AND FIND MY PARENTS.
I REALIZED I COULDN'T PHYSICALLY DO IT
BECAUSE THE WATER WAS RISING ON THE INSIDE
AND IT WAS GETTING HIGHER AND HIGHER.
THAT'S WHEN I KNEW THAT I HAD TO JUMP INTO THE SEA,
OTHERWISE I MIGHT HAVE DROWNED ON THE ACTUAL SHIP.
AND I KNEW I HAD TO FIGHT FOR MY LIFE.
MOM HAD TAUGHT ME HOW TO SWIM AS A YOUNG CHILD,
OTHERWISE I WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ABLE
TO SAVE MY OWN LIFE THAT NIGHT.
IT WAS FREEZING COLD AND THE SEA WAS REALLY ROUGH.
I JUST DIDN'T KNOW WHAT TO DO,
AND I THOUGHT I COULD ACTUALLY SWIM BACK TO SHORE.
AND THEN I REALIZED OF COURSE I WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO
BECAUSE IT WAS TOO ROUGH.
INSIDE THE SHIP,
O'BRIEN AND HUNDREDS OF OTHER PASSENGERS
ARE LOOKING FOR A WAY OUT
AS THE ICE-COLD WATERS CONTINUE TO RISE.
THE WORST PART FOR ME,
TO HEAR THE PEOPLE SCREAMING AND SHOUTING.
AS THE CRISIS WORSENS ON BOARD THE HERALD,
PORT CONTROLLERS IN ZEEBRUGGE HARBOR
RECEIVE AN URGENT RADIO CALL FROM A NEARBY SHIP.
A CAR FERRY HAS JUST ROLLED OVER
NEAR THE ENTRANCE TO THE HARBOR.
THE PORT CONTROLLER ISSUES A MAYDAY.
MALCOLM SHAKESBY IS CHIEF OFFICER
ON BOARD THE DUKE OF ANGLIA.
WHAT'S THIS ABOUT THE FERRY?
HIS CREW HEARS THE CALL AS THEY NEAR THE HARBOR
AND THEY IMMEDIATELY BEGIN LOOKING FOR THE VESSEL.
THERE WAS A MAYDAY,
WILL ALL VESSELS PROCEED IN THE AREA
TO LOOK FOR THE BLOODY FERRY?
ON THE HERALD,
PASSENGERS CAN'T WAIT FOR HELP TO ARRIVE.
THERE'S ONLY ONE THING THAT CAME INTO MY MIND
WAS ABOUT ME SURVIVING AND ME TRYING TO LIVE.
I FOUND A HOSE REEL, A FIREHOSE REEL,
AND I THREW IT UP TO GET AROUND A CHAIR
AND I MISSED, OF COURSE, AND I TRIED IT AGAIN.
I GOT AROUND IT SO I SAID NOW, COULD I PULL MYSELF UP?
IN ANOTHER PART OF THE SHIP,
MARTIN BARNES IS STILL ALIVE, BUT HE HAS NO WAY OUT
AS THE FRIGID NORTH SEA CONTINUES TO POUR IN.
THE BACKS OF THE SEATS,
THEY'RE ALL FIXED TO THE DECK,
SO THE BACKS OF THE SEATS THEN BECAME A LADDER SYSTEM.
SO, I CAN REMEMBER LIKE,
PULLING MYSELF UP THE BACKS OF THESE SEATS,
FALLING BACK OFF AGAIN, 'CAUSE I WAS WET, I WAS COLD.
I WAS HEAVIER WITH THE WATER ALL SOAKING IN MY CLOTHES.
USING THE FIREHOSE, LARRY O'BRIEN
HAS MANAGED TO PULL HIMSELF CLEAR OF THE WATER.
HE SCALES THE CHAIRS,
BUT NOW THERE'S ANOTHER CHALLENGE.
I CLIMBED UP AND THE WINDOW WAS IN FRONT OF ME.
THERE'S NO WAY TO OPEN THE WINDOW.
O'BRIEN IS TRAPPED.
I TOOK OFF MY BOOT.
I KEPT BEATING IT WITH A BOOT
AND EVENTUALLY BROKE OUT OF IT.
I PUT MY HAND IN MY POCKET AND I TOOK OUT 20 WET CIGARETTES.
SO WE WEREN'T GOING TO HAVE A SMOKE.
I SAID, I HAVE TO GET SOMEONE'S ATTENTION.
SO I TOOK OUT MY CIGARETTE LIGHTER, OUT OF MY POCKET,
AND I STARTED TO FLASH IT,
FLICKING IT LIKE THIS, LIGHT AT THE SEA.
COULD THE SHIP TWO OR THREE MILES AWAY--
HEY! O'Brien:--SEE ME DOING THIS
TO GET THEIR ATTENTION?
THAT WAS ONLY A MOMENT OF PANIC.
THAT DIDN'T HAPPEN.
WITH MORE PEOPLE
STILL TRAPPED INSIDE THE FERRY, O'BRIEN GETS TO WORK.
SO I GOT THE BIG ROPE AND I THREW IT BACK DOWN.
PEOPLE STARTED COMING UP.
COME ON, COME ON.
PUT THEM IN THE LIFEBOAT, RIGHT.
ON THE DUKE OF ANGLIA,
MALCOLM SHAKESBY AND THE CREW SWING INTO ACTION.
-ALRIGHT. -BUT THE WATERS
ARE TOO SHALLOW FOR THE SHIP TO GET CLOSE ENOUGH
TO THE CAPSIZED FERRY.
WE CAN'T STEAM AROUND HERE BECAUSE OF THE BANKS.
COME ON BOYS, LET'S MOVE IT!
WE LAUNCHED THE LIFEBOAT
AND OFF WE WENT IN THE DARK.
I MEAN, WHEN I THINK ABOUT IT,
IT WAS ALL MADNESS REALLY.
GILLIAN BADDELEY IS STRUGGLING
TO STAY ABOVE THE WATER IN THE COLD NORTH SEA.
SHE THOUGHT GETTING AWAY FROM THE HERALD
WAS THE RIGHT DECISION.
NOW SHE'S NOT SO SURE.
I LOOKED BACK AT THE SHIP
AND I COULD SEE HOW IT WAS CAPSIZED ONTO ONE SIDE.
AND IT WAS REALLY ALMOST SURREAL.
IT WAS SUCH A ROUGH NIGHT THAT NIGHT,
THE SEA WAS BATTLING AGAINST ME.
IT WAS SO COLD.
I'D LOST THE FEELING IN MY LEGS,
WITH HYPOTHERMIA COMING IN.
INSIDE THE HERALD,
HUNDREDS OF PASSENGERS ARE STILL TRAPPED.
TIME IS RUNNING OUT AS THE FREEZING WATER
STARTS TO TAKE ITS TOLL.
SUDDENLY, THE DARKNESS IS PIERCED
BY THE FLASHLIGHTS OF THE RESCUERS.
WE SAW ALL THE LIGHTS AT THE TOP OF THE STARBOARD SIDE.
THE ONLY WAY THAT WE COULD GET PEOPLE OUT
WAS BY SMASHING THE WINDOWS WITH FIRE AXES.
THAT WAS WHEN WE HEARD ALL THE BIG HEAVY SMASHING.
ALL YOU HEARD WAS THIS GLASS BREAKING AND "WATCH OUT BELOW."
THERE'S PEOPLE INSIDE THE SHIP,
STILL SCREAMING AND SHOUTING.
I MEAN, YOU KNOW IT'S, IT'S ABSOLUTE CHAOS AND CONFUSION.
-RIGHT! -WE SAW THE ROPES
COMING DOWN IN A, IN A LOOP TYPE THING.
THEY WERE SHOUTING, "PUT IT UNDER YOUR ARMS."
COME ON!
GRIP ONTO THE ROPE LIKE SO,
AND THEN WE'LL LIFT.
AND I CAN REMEMBER LOOKING UP AND THEY WERE JUST SAYING,
OBVIOUSLY, "HOLD ON, HOLD ON, WE'RE PULLING."
HELICOPTERS HOVER OVER THE CAPSIZED FERRY
AS MORE RESCUE BOATS ARRIVE ON THE SCENE.
I SAW THE LIFEBOAT.
IT WAS JUST A LOCAL FISHERMAN.
HELP!
HELP ME!
I WAVED MY ARMS AT HIM LIKE THIS
AND THEY POINTED OVER AT ME AND THEN CAME OVER.
HELP ME!
OVER HERE, PLEASE!
AND PULLED ME UP ON THE BOAT.
THE FEELING, KNOWING THAT I'D SURVIVED,
AND I WAS GOING TO LIVE
WAS JUST SO OVERWHELMING, THE RELIEF.
BY SEA AND AIR
RESCUE EFFORTS CONTINUE FOR HOURS.
THERE WAS BODIES FLOATING IN FRONT OF ME.
THERE WAS SO MUCH DESTRUCTION, DEATH, THAT NIGHT.
BY EARLY MORNING,
IT'S CLEAR THERE ARE NO MORE SURVIVORS.
BY THE END OF THE NIGHT,
WE'D RESCUED 300 AND SOMETHING ODD PASSENGERS.
WE MANAGED TO RECOVER 58 BODIES,
AND THEN WE COULDN'T FIND ANYBODY ELSE.
GILLIAN BADDELEY IS LUCKY TO BE ALIVE.
BUT SHE DOESN'T KNOW WHAT HAPPENED
TO THE REST OF HER FAMILY.
A COUPLE OF MORE SURVIVORS CAME IN.
AND THEN IT WAS MY BROTHER MARK.
MARK, MARK!
-GILLIAN, GILLIAN! -MARK!
WE HAD A LOVELY REUNION.
WE HUGGED AND CRIED.
MARK!
GILLIAN'S OTHER STEP-BROTHER,
COLIN, ALSO SURVIVES.
OH, EXCUSE ME.
EXCUSE ME.
I'M GILLIAN BADDELEY.
MARK BADDELEY, AND MY BROTHER COLIN,
WE'RE LOOKING FOR OUR PARENTS.
OH, AND UNCLE DAVID.
THE LADY FROM THE RED CROSS CAME OVER,
WITH LIKE A CLIPBOARD IN HER HAND,
AND SAW OUR NAMES ON THE LIST
AND SHE LOOKED UP AT US AND SAID,
YOU DO KNOW THAT YOUR PARENTS ARE DEAD, DON'T YOU?
AND THAT WAS HOW THE NEWS GOT BROKE TO US.
AS THE NUMBER OF DEAD CLIMBS TO 193,
THE QUESTIONS BEGIN.
HOW HAD SUCH A MASSIVE VESSEL CAPSIZED SO QUICKLY?
AND WHO WAS TO BLAME?
THE ACCIDENT THAT KILLED 193
ON THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE
IS BRITAIN'S WORST MARITIME DISASTER IN DECADES.
FROM THE BEGINNING, THE NATION IS RIVETED.
THERE ARE CONFLICTING REPORTS OF WHAT HAPPENED.
ONE ACCOUNT SAYS IT HIT THE HARBOR WALL.
ANOTHER THAT IT RAN ONTO A SANDBANK.
THE GOVERNMENT ORDERS A FORMAL INVESTIGATION.
DAVID STEEL IS A LAWYER AND SENIOR MEMBER OF THE TEAM.
IT WAS SUCH AN ASTONISHINGLY AWFUL DISASTER
WHICH CAUGHT THE ATTENTION OF THE BRITISH PEOPLE.
HOW COULD IT HAVE HAPPENED?
WE EXAMINE THE THEORIES THAT WILL NOW BE INVESTIGATED.
THE PRIME MINISTER HAS FLOWN TO THE SCENE.
AH, GENTLEMEN.
PLEASE TAKE A SEAT.
TO ASSIST WITH THE INQUIRY,
A TEAM OF EXPERTS IS ASSEMBLED.
NAVAL ARCHITECT, TOM ALLAN,
WORKED ON THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE SHIP.
AT THE TIME THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE WAS BUILT
SHE WAS ONE OF THREE SISTERS.
THEY WERE GONNA BE THE BIGGEST AND THE FASTEST SHIPS
GOING ACROSS FROM DOVER TO CALAIS.
HOW HAD THIS STATE-OF-THE-ART SHIP
COME TO SUCH A TRAGIC END?
THE HERALD REMAINS BEACHED JUST OUTSIDE THE HARBOR.
A PAINFUL REMINDER OF THE TERRIFYING NIGHT IT SANK.
IT WAS QUITE REMARKABLE TO SEE THIS PRETTY BIG SHIP
LYING ON ITS BEAM ENDS WITH HALF THE HULL ABOVE THE WATER.
THE POSITION OF THE HERALD ALLOWS INVESTIGATORS
TO CHECK FOR OBVIOUS DAMAGE TO THE SHIP'S STARBOARD HULL.
YOUR FIRST THOUGHT WOULD BE THAT IT WAS A COLLISION.
AND IT IS A VERY BUSY ROUTE.
IF THE HERALD HAD COLLIDED WITH ANOTHER VESSEL,
IT MIGHT EXPLAIN THE SUDDEN DRAMATIC TILT
PASSENGERS AND CREW EXPERIENCED.
A HOLE UNDER THE WATER LINE
WOULD ALSO EXPLAIN THE SPEED WITH WHICH THE BOAT CAPSIZED.
BUT FROM THEIR VANTAGE POINT,
INVESTIGATORS CAN'T SEE ANYTHING LIKE THAT.
WHEN THEY GET TO THE FRONT OF THE BOAT HOWEVER,
THEY SEE SOMETHING TROUBLING.
THE HUGE, 16-FOOT BOW DOORS ARE WIDE OPEN.
YOU COULD SEE ALL AROUND THE SHIP
AND YOU COULD SEE THAT THE DOORS WERE OPEN.
SO THAT WAS THE SURPRISE.
AS INVESTIGATORS INTERVIEW EYEWITNESSES,
THEY LEARN THAT THE DOORS AT THE FRONT OF THE SHIP
WEREN'T CLOSED WHEN THE HERALD SAILED OUT OF ZEEBRUGGE.
THE SHIP SHOULD NOT HAVE SAILED WITH THOSE DOORS OPEN.
AS A SHIP IS MOVING FORWARD,
SHE BUILDS UP A WAVE AT THE FORWARD END OF THE SHIP.
AS YOU'RE MOVING FORWARD,
THAT WAVE CAN THEN INCREASE IN SIZE.
IT'S PURELY A PRESSURE WAVE
OF THE SHIP GOING THROUGH THE WATER,
IT JUST PUSHES THE WATER UP
AND THEN IT CAN PUSH IT BACK INTO THE SHIP.
BUT FERRIES LIKE THE HERALD
ARE DESIGNED TO KEEP WATER OUT EVEN IF THE DOORS ARE OPEN.
IN HARBOR, THERE'S NORMALLY EIGHT-FEET
BETWEEN THE SHIP'S DECK AND THE WATER LINE.
IT'S CALLED THE FREEBOARD
AND IT'S KEPT SHIPS SAFE IN THE PAST.
THERE WAS ANOTHER EXAMPLE OF A VESSEL
THAT ACTUALLY SAILED WITH THE DOORS OPEN.
IN OCTOBER 1983, THE HERALD'S SISTER SHIP,
THE PRIDE OF FREE ENTERPRISE,
SAILED FROM DOVER TO CALAIS WITHOUT INCIDENT
EVEN THOUGH ITS BOW AND STERN DOORS WERE LEFT OPEN.
SEE, SHE SAILED ACROSS AND NOBODY KNEW.
BUT IT COULD HAVE BEEN DISASTROUS,
SO THE CAPTAIN OF THAT SHIP ASKED FOR CHANGES
TO MAKE SURE IT COULDN'T HAPPEN AGAIN.
BUT WITH NO DAMAGE TO THE VESSEL,
THE FERRY COMPANY DECIDED NO CHANGES WERE NECESSARY.
INVESTIGATORS DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY THE PRIDE CROSSED SAFELY,
BUT THE HERALD DIDN'T.
WE DID HAVE TO SCRATCH OUR HEADS
AT HOW ON EARTH THIS VESSEL SANK.
EVEN WITH THE BOW DOORS OPEN,
SHE SHOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO MAKE IT ACROSS THE CHANNEL.
ARE WE CLOSE YET?
ALMOST READY HERE.
TO UNDERSTAND HOW, INVESTIGATORS REPLICATE,
AS CLOSELY AS POSSIBLE, THE LAST MINUTES OF THE DOOMED SHIP.
THEY RE-ENACT THE VOYAGE USING THE HERALD'S SISTER SHIP,
THE PRIDE OF FREE ENTERPRISE.
THE TWO FERRIES HAVE THE EXACT SAME DESIGN
AND INVESTIGATORS LOAD THE PRIDE TO ITS MAXIMUM TONNAGE.
USING A SERIES OF CAMERAS MOUNTED ON THE SHIP,
THEY MONITOR EVERY STAGE OF THE EXPERIMENT.
-CAMERA'S MOUNTED. -OKAY, LET'S GET STARTED.
TONY MORRALL COORDINATED THE TEST.
ON BOARD WE HAD DEVICES
TO MEASURE THE POWER OF THE SHIP AND SPEED.
WE HAD PEOPLE TRACKING THE SHIP FROM THE SHORE.
WE WANTED TO TAKE OVER THE SHIP, IF YOU LIKE,
AND HAVE A DEPARTURE AT THE SAME TYPE OF CONDITIONS,
AT THE SAME TIME OF DAY, AS THE HERALD LEFT ZEEBRUGGE.
OKAY, WE'RE READY.
THE ONLY CRUCIAL DIFFERENCE,
THIS TIME, THE BOW DOORS ARE CLOSED.
THE INVESTIGATORS ARE MOST INTERESTED IN THE FREEBOARD,
THE DISTANCE FROM THE WATERLINE TO THE CAR DECK.
HOW HAD THE HARBOR WATERS LEAPT 10 FEET ONTO THE HERALD?
FIRST, THEY TURN THEIR ATTENTION
TO THE LOADING PROCESS AT ZEEBRUGGE.
HOW ARE THE BALLAST TANKS?
NUMBER 14, 268 TONS.
TANK THREE IS AT 42 TONS, SIR.
VERY GOOD.
WHILE THE HERALD IS DESIGNED
TO BE LOADED ON TWO LEVELS AT THE SAME TIME,
ZEEBRUGGE HARBOR ONLY HAS A SINGLE LOADING RAMP.
THE PROCEDURE WAS TO USE THE SAME RAMP
FOR LOADING THE LOWER DECK AND THE HIGHER DECK.
AND THE ONLY WAY TO ACTUALLY FACILITATE THIS
WAS TO BALLAST THE BOW DOWN SO THAT THE RAMP
COULD TOUCH ONTO THE TOP DECK
AND THEN LOADING COULD PROCEED.
BEFORE THE HERALD LEFT HARBOR,
THE CREW BEGAN THE TWO-HOUR LONG PROCESS
OF EMPTYING THE TANKS.
BUT IT WAS STILL CARRYING TONS OF BALLAST
AT THE TIME OF THE ACCIDENT.
FOR THE TEST, INVESTIGATORS MAKE SURE
THE PRIDE OF FREE ENTERPRISE HAS A SIMILAR AMOUNT ON BOARD.
BALLASTS 14 AND THREE AT 260 TONS.
WHAT'S THE FREEBOARD? THAT'LL BRING THE BOW DOWN
HALF A METER.
DID THE EXTRA BALLAST
CAUSE THE FLOODING OF THE CAR DECKS?
IT REDUCED THE FREEBOARD,
THE DISTANCE BETWEEN THE WATERLINE AT THE BOW
AND THE VEHICLE DECK ITSELF.
SO AT THE START, WHEN IT LEFT ZEEBRUGGE,
THAT FREEBOARD WAS ALREADY REDUCED.
WITH THE FREEBOARD NOW REDUCED
BY NEARLY TWO FEET, INVESTIGATORS KEEP A CLOSE WATCH
AS THE SHIP SAILS THROUGH THE HARBOR.
THE INTENTION WAS LOOKING AT THE BOW WAVE
USING A WHOLE HOST OF CAMERAS,
INCLUDING ONE LOOKING VERTICALLY DOWN AT THE BOW WAVE.
BUT EVEN WITH THE BALLAST TANKS FILLED
AND THE FERRY LOADED THE CAMERAS SHOW
THAT THE WATER STILL ISN'T REACHING THE BOW DOORS.
INVESTIGATORS BELIEVE THE HARBOR ITSELF
MAY HAVE PLAYED A ROLE IN THE DISASTER.
AT JUST 52-FEET DEEP,
ZEEBRUGGE HARBOUR IS RELATIVELY SHALLOW.
THE PRIDE'S HULL SINKS ALMOST 20-FEET INTO IT.
AS IT LEAVES ZEEBRUGGE, THE NARROW GAP BETWEEN THE HULL
AND THE HARBOR FLOOR PULLS THE SHIP EVEN DEEPER.
BECAUSE OF THE RESTRICTED AMOUNT OF WATER
BENEATH THE KEEL, THE SEABED, THE WATER SPEEDS UP,
AND THAT HAS A CONSEQUENCE OF ALLOWING THE SHIP TO SINK.
IT'S CALLED THE SQUAT EFFECT
AND IT DROPS THE BOW ANOTHER FOOT AND A HALF INTO THE WATER.
BUT EVEN AS THE SHIP SAILS THROUGH THE SHALLOW HARBOR,
INVESTIGATORS STILL CAN'T GET THE WATER ONTO THE BOW DECK.
IT WAS STILL A REASONABLE,
EVEN THOUGH SMALL, SMALL FREEBOARD.
CAPTAIN, CAN WE TAKE IT TO FULL SPEED, PLEASE?
INVESTIGATORS GET THE CREW TO MATCH THE SPEED
OF THE HERALD AS IT LEFT THE HARBOR.
WHEN THEY DO, THEY FINALLY FIND
THE LAST PIECE OF THE PUZZLE.
HEY, LOOK AT THIS.
LOOK AT THIS.
THE WATER THAT WAS LURKING JUST BELOW
NOW REACHES THE BOW DOORS.
THE CAMERAS SHOWED VERY CLEARLY
THAT AT A CRITICAL SPEED,
WATER ROSE HIGH ENOUGH TO ENGULF THAT DECK,
IF THE BOW DOORS WERE OPEN.
FOR THE HERALD,
THIS WAS THE BEGINNING OF THE END.
WITH TONS OF BALLAST IN THE BOW TANKS,
A SHALLOW HARBOR AND AN INCREASED SPEED
THE FREEBOARD SHRANK TO A CRITICAL LEVEL.
THE RATE OF FLOW, WATER COMING IN,
WAS 40 TONS A SECOND IN THE FIRST 15 SECONDS.
ONCE THE WATER CAME IN
IT HAD FREE ACCESS ONTO THE CAR DECK.
SO, IT WOULD HAVE MADE ITS WAY
AROUND ALL OF THE FREIGHT THAT WAS ABOARD.
THEN THE VESSEL WOULD CAPSIZE WITHIN ONE MINUTE.
WITHIN ONE MINUTE.
I MEAN, SO THIS WAS DRASTIC STUFF.
ONE REASON THE HERALD WENT OVER SO QUICKLY
WAS THE DESIGN OF THE SHIP ITSELF.
LIKE MOST RO-RO FERRIES,
ITS CAR DECKS WEREN'T BUILT WITH DIVIDING BULKHEADS.
IF THERE'S ANY FLOODING IT CAN SPREAD RAPIDLY.
THE EXTREME MOVEMENT OF WATER ACROSS A DECK
IS CALLED THE FREE SURFACE EFFECT.
AND IT CAN BE DEADLY.
IF YOU TAKE A NORMAL TRAY AND YOU PUT WATER IN IT,
NOW, WHILE YOU'RE HOLDING IT THE WATER IS STILL.
YOU MOVE SLIGHTLY ALL THE WATER MOVES TO ONE END.
NOW IF YOU CAN IMAGINE ON A SHIP WHICH IS 50 METERS WIDE,
AND YOU HAVE A METER OF WATER,
THEN AS YOU HEEL TO ONE SIDE,
IT'S THE WEIGHT OF THE WATERS MOVING,
THAT IS WHAT'S CALLED FREE-SURFACE.
IT'S ACTUALLY A MOVEMENT OF WEIGHT FROM ONE SIDE OF THE SHIP
TO THE OTHER AS THE SHIP HEELS.
THAT MOVEMENT OF WEIGHT
WAS WHAT CAUSED THE SHIP TO TILT,
AND RIGHT ITSELF, THE FIRST TIME.
BUT IF THE WEIGHT GETS TOO GREAT,
THE INHERENT STABILITY IN THE SHIP
WILL NOT HOLD IT AND SHE WILL HEEL OVER.
YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT A COUPLE OF THOUSAND TONS OF WATER
WHICH IS ACTUALLY MOVING
FROM ONE SIDE OF THE SHIP TO THE OTHER.
AND THAT HAS A BIG IMPACT.
IT TAKES JUST SECONDS
FOR THE HERALD TO CAPSIZE.
THE OPEN BOW DOORS LED TO THE FLOODING OF THE HERALD
AND TO THE DEATH OF 193 PEOPLE.
BUT WHO WAS RESPONSIBLE FOR CLOSING THE SHIP'S BOW DOORS,
AND WHY HADN'T THEY?
THE CAPSIZE OF THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE
TOOK THE LIVES OF 193 PEOPLE.
INVESTIGATORS UNDERSTAND THE MECHANICS OF THE DISASTER,
BUT THE REASON THE FERRY'S BOW DOORS WERE OPEN
IS ANOTHER STARTLING DISCOVERY.
THE FOCUS OF ATTENTION
WAS OF COURSE ON WHY THEY WERE OPEN
AS THEY OBVIOUSLY SHOULDN'T HAVE BEEN.
THE SHIP'S CAPTAIN
COMES UNDER INTENSE SCRUTINY.
WHY HAD HE LEFT HARBOR WITHOUT SECURING THOSE DOORS?
NOW YOU GOTTA REMEMBER THE BOW DOORS ON THE HERALD
ARE DIFFERENT FROM MOST OF THE OTHER FERRIES AT THE TIME.
MOST OF THE OTHER FERRIES, THE BOW DOOR CAME UP AND OVER
SO THAT YOU COULDN'T ACTUALLY SEE OUT OF THE BRIDGE
BECAUSE YOU HAD THE DOOR SITTING UP ABOVE YOUR HEAD.
WITH THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE THEY WERE CLAM DOORS,
SO THEY CAME 'ROUND THE SIDE.
SO IT WASN'T IMMEDIATELY OBVIOUS THAT THE DOORS WERE OPEN.
INVESTIGATORS DISCOVER
THAT THERE WAS NO WARNING LIGHT
TO TELL THE CAPTAIN THE DOORS HADN'T BEEN CLOSED.
ISOLATED ON THE BRIDGE,
HE HAD NO WAY OF KNOWING HE WAS SAILING INTO DISASTER.
AN INQUIRY IS ASSEMBLED TO GET ANSWERS.
THE CENTRAL WITNESS IS THE SHIP'S CAPTAIN, DAVID LEWRY.
BUT HE WAS BADLY INJURED IN THE DISASTER,
AND HIS MEMORY IS UNCLEAR.
HOW DID YOU TRAVEL WITH THE BOW DOORS OPEN?
I REALLY DON'T REMEMBER.
I HAD ASSUMED IT WAS IMPOSSIBLE.
-TAKE HER OUT. -TAKE HER OUT!
WHAT LEWRY CAN SAY
IS THAT NO ONE TOLD HIM THERE WAS A PROBLEM.
ONE OF THE THINGS WHICH WE FIND
DURING THE INVESTIGATION
WAS THAT THEY OPERATED A NEGATIVE REPORTING SYSTEM.
NOW WITH A NEGATIVE REPORTING SYSTEM,
THE CAPTAIN ASSUMES THAT EVERYTHING'S OKAY
UNLESS SOMEBODY TELLS THAT HIM THAT IT'S WRONG.
ONE OF THE THINGS WE HAD TO INSTIGATE AFTER
WAS TO HAVE A POSITIVE REPORTING SYSTEM.
SO THAT THE CHIEF OFFICER OR THE OFFICER ON THE DECK
HAS TO CONFIRM TO THE BRIDGE, RIGHT, THE DOORS ARE CLOSED,
AND YOU CAN NOW SAIL.
THE INQUIRY LEARNS THAT THE CAPTAIN
DIDN'T ENSURE THE BOW DOORS WERE CLOSED BEFORE DEPARTURE.
WHAT ABOUT HIS CHIEF OFFICER?
LESLIE SABEL, CHIEF OFFICER,
HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE.
IT'S SABEL'S JOB TO OVERSEE
THE LOADING AND UNLOADING OF THE SHIP.
KEEP IT MOVING.
KEEP IT MOVING.
WHEN SABEL TELLS HIS STORY,
INVESTIGATORS MAKE AN UNSETTLING DISCOVERY.
I FAILED TO STAY AT THE CONTROLS
THAT OPERATED THE BOW DOORS.
CREW TO HARBOR STATIONS.
CREW TO HARBOR STATIONS.
ON MY WAY.
JUST MINUTES BEFORE
THE HERALD'S SCHEDULED DEPARTURE TIME,
SABEL LEAVES THE LOADING DECK
EVEN THOUGH THE BOW DOORS ARE STILL OPEN.
THE INQUIRY HEARS THAT LEAVING EARLY WAS THE ONLY WAY
FOR SABEL TO SATISFY ANOTHER REQUIREMENT
OF HIS STANDING ORDERS...
-OKAY, TAKE HER OUT. -TAKE HER OUT, PLEASE
TAKING HER OUT.
BEING ON THE BRIDGE FOR DEPARTURE.
THE REQUIREMENT THAT THE CHIEF OFFICER
BE ON THE CAR DECK,
TO SEE THE DOORS CLOSED, WAS OBVIOUSLY WHOLLY INCONSISTENT
WITH HIS NEED TO BE ON THE BRIDGE TO ASSIST IN DEPARTURE.
YOU'VE GOT A SITUATION HERE THE OFFICER
IS PULLED BETWEEN ENSURING SAFETY DOWN ON THE CAR DECK
AND ACTUALLY SAFETY UP ON THE BRIDGE.
THE INQUIRY LEARNS THAT IF THE CHIEF OFFICER
WAITED TO CONFIRM THE BOW DOORS WERE CLOSED,
DEPARTURE WOULD BE DELAYED BY SEVERAL MINUTES.
IN FACT, IN A MEMO ISSUED SEVEN MONTHS BEFORE THE ACCIDENT,
THE COMPANY THAT OPERATED THE FERRY
URGED THAT IT LEAVE 15 MINUTES EARLY
AND THAT PRESSURE BE PUT ON THE FIRST OFFICER
TO ENSURE PROMPT DEPARTURE.
THIS MEMO WAS SO SHOCKING.
AND THAT ANY MANAGER WOULD PUT IT IN WRITING
THAT SPEED WAS ALL IMPORTANT AND SAFETY WAS NOT.
THE CAPTAIN DIDN'T NOTICE ANYTHING IRREGULAR
AND THE CHIEF OFFICER WAS TOO BUSY TO CHECK.
THE INQUIRY HEARS FROM ASSISTANT BOSUN MARK STANLEY.
THE BOSUN HAS MANY TASKS, NO DOUBT,
BUT HIS PRIMARY TASK ON DEPARTURE FROM A PORT
WAS TO CLOSE THE DOORS.
THANK YOU FOR APPEARING HERE TODAY.
DID YOU CLOSE THE BOW DOORS?
NO.
MARK STANLEY ADMITS THAT ON MARCH 6TH, 1987
HE FAILED TO DO HIS JOB.
THE PERSON RESPONSIBLE FOR CLOSING THE DOORS
CONCEDED THAT HE HADN'T DONE SO.
-TIME FOR TEA. -SURE.
MARK STANLEY ADMITS HE LEFT HIS POST
FOR HIS BREAK.
HIS SHIFT STARTED HOURS EARLIER
ON THE OTHER SIDE OF THE ENGLISH CHANNEL.
HUMANS WILL MAKE MISTAKES.
HOWEVER WELL DISCIPLINED, HOWEVER WELL TRAINED,
THEY GET TIRED.
AND TIRED HUMANS CAN MAKE MISTAKES.
WHEN STANLEY RETURNS TO HIS CABIN FOR TEA,
HE FALLS ASLEEP.
CREW TO HARBOR STATIONS.
CREW TO HARBOR STATIONS.
IT'S A NAP HE WON'T WAKE UP FROM
UNTIL THE SHIP CAPSIZES.
STANLEY'S TESTIMONY SHOCKS BRITAIN.
THE INQUIRY FINDS THE BOW DOORS WERE LEFT OPEN
BECAUSE A SINGLE CREW MEMBER WAS ASLEEP.
AND THE HERALD HAD NO ADEQUATE BACK-UPS
TO CATCH HIS MISTAKE.
THERE WAS NO REDUNDANCY HERE.
IF ONE MAN FAILED, THERE WAS NOBODY THERE TO STEP IN.
A TIRED CREW AND A RUSH TO SAVE A FEW MINUTES
COST THE LIVES OF NEARLY 200 PEOPLE.
IT'S A SOBERING WAKE UP CALL FOR FERRY OPERATORS.
CHANGES WERE REQUIRED TO PREVENT A DISASTER LIKE THIS
FROM EVER HAPPENING AGAIN.
AFTER MONTHS OF INVESTIGATION,
THE REPORT ON THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE DISASTER
IS FINALLY RELEASED.
MEMBERS OF THE CREW AND FERRY MANAGEMENT ARE BLAMED.
MR. JUSTICE SHEEHAN SAID OF THE TOWNSEND COMPANY
THAT, FROM TOP TO BOTTOM,
IT WAS RIDDLED WITH THE DISEASE OF SLOVENLINESS.
THERE'D BEEN A LAMENTABLE LACK OF DIRECTION
AND A VACUUM AT THE CENTER.
CHANGES ARE MADE TO THE REPORTING SYSTEM
AND THE STANDING ORDERS.
BUT THE REPORT ALSO CALLS FOR ROLL-ON-ROLL-OFF FERRIES
TO BE REDESIGNED.
WE WERE LOOKING AT IMPROVING THE SURVIVABILITY
SO THERE WAS LESS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR THIS TO HAPPEN AGAIN.
THERE'S ONE SIMPLE FIX
THAT WOULD HAVE PREVENTED THE TRAGEDY.
THEY COULD HAVE PUT AN INDICATOR ON BOARD
WHICH SHOWED THAT THE DOORS WERE CLOSED.
THIS TRIBUNAL RECOMMENDED THAT THERE BE LIGHTS
ON THE BRIDGE FOR JUST THAT PURPOSE.
THE LACK OF INDICATOR LIGHTS
ISN'T THE ONLY DESIGN FLAW
THAT CONTRIBUTED TO THE CAPSIZING OF THE HERALD.
IN ORDER TO ATTRACT CUSTOMERS IN A COMPETITIVE INDUSTRY,
RO-RO FERRIES ARE BUILT TO ALLOW CARS
TO DRIVE ON AND OFF THE SHIPS AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE.
THAT CONVENIENCE COMES WITH A STEEP PRICE.
WHAT YOU'VE GOT TO DO IS TO LOOK
AT THE TYPE OF VESSEL ITSELF
AND THEY ARE EXTREMELY VULNERABLE.
THEY'RE DESIGNED FOR OPTIMUM EFFICIENCY.
BUT YOU'RE ACTUALLY BUILDING IN POTENTIAL HAZARDS,
PARTICULARLY THE OPEN CAR DECKS
WHICH EXTEND FROM FORWARD TO AFT OF THE SHIP
AND FROM SIDE TO SIDE.
THE REPORT SUGGESTS THAT BULKHEADS BE BUILT
WITHIN CAR DECKS TO REDUCE THE FREE SURFACE EFFECT.
THERE WAS CONSIDERABLE PRESSURE
FROM SOME QUARTERS OF THE MARITIME COMMUNITY
TO BRING TO AN END THE USE OF OPEN DECKED FERRIES.
BUT IT'S A DESIGN CHANGE
THAT MEETS STIFF RESISTANCE FROM THE INDUSTRY.
THE WHOLE CONCEPT OF RO-RO FERRIES
IS SPEED OF TURNAROUND.
YOU CAN GO IN FROM ONE END
AND YOU JUST DRIVE STRAIGHT OFF FROM THE OTHER END.
SO AN OPEN DECK IS ALMOST ESSENTIAL.
AS THE INDUSTRY STRUGGLES
TO BALANCE THE COMPETING DEMANDS OF SPEED AND SAFETY,
THE SHADOW OF THE TRAGEDY STILL LINGERS
FOR MANY OF THE SURVIVORS OF THE DISASTER.
I SPENT ABOUT FOUR MONTHS DRIVING,
JUST TO PROVE TO MYSELF THAT I COULD DO IT.
MY FAMILY WEREN'T VERY IMPRESSED WITH ME,
BUT WE GOT OVER THAT ISSUE.
AND I SAID, I HAD TO DO THIS.
I HAD TO DO IT.
THERE WAS NO WAY BACK FOR ME GOING BACK TO SEA.
I TRIED TO IN THE FOLLOWING YEAR.
THE ANXIETY GOT HOLD OF ME AND I THOUGHT NO MORE,
I CAN'T DO THIS ANYMORE.
SO UM, YEAH, I CALLED IT A DAY.
IT'LL BE WITH ME 'TIL THE DAY I GO.
ONCE YOU'VE SEEN TRAUMA, YOU DON'T FORGET IT.
WE WERE TOLD
WE WERE GOING TO HAVE TO IDENTIFY THE BODIES.
AND WE WERE TAKEN TO A GYMNASIUM
AND THEN I SAW ME MOM LYING THERE.
AND THEY SAID I COULDN'T TOUCH HER,
BUT I DID ANYWAY.
I PUT MY HAND ON HER SHOULDER TO SAY GOODBYE
AND THAT I LOVE YOU.
I SUPPOSE THE WORST PART OF IT FOR ME
WAS TO SEE THE CHILDREN FLOATING IN THE WATER.
YOU KNOW, AND THAT PUT ME
THINKING OF MY LITTLE GIRL AT HOME,
YOU KNOW, AND HOW LUCKY I WAS THAT SHE WAS AT HOME.
LARRY O'BRIEN HELPED SAVE
AS MANY AS 40 PEOPLE THAT NIGHT.
IF NOT FOR HIM AND THE DOZENS OF PASSENGERS AND CREWMEMBERS
THAT SUDDENLY BECAME RESCUERS,
THE DISASTER COULD HAVE BEEN FAR MORE DEADLY.
THERE'S GREAT CRITICISM
ABOUT THE CREW OF THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE.
NO.
THE CREW OF THE HERALD OF FREE ENTERPRISE
WENT BEYOND THE CALL OF DUTY.
SOME OF THE CREW LOST THEIR LIVES RESCUING PEOPLE
AND THAT SHOULD NEVER BE FORGOTTEN.
WHAT I DID, ANYONE ELSE WOULD DO THE SAME THING.
YOU KNOW, IT'S JUST THE WAY IT TAKES YOU.
IF I WAS BACK TOMORROW MORNING
OR THIS HAPPENED THE NEXT DAY,
YOU DON'T KNOW HOW YOU'RE GOING TO REACT.
YOU JUST DON'T KNOW HOW YOU'RE GOING TO REACT.
IT TOOK ME, I'D SAY TWO YEARS
TO BE ABLE TO LIVE AGAIN,
TO BE ABLE TO LIVE A NORMAL DAY WITHOUT NOT HURTING
AND THINKING ABOUT IT ALL THE TIME
AND HOW LIFE COULD HAVE BEEN SO DIFFERENT.
I'D LOST MY WHOLE FAMILY IN THE ONE DAY.
I'D LEFT AS A CHILD AND THEN CAME BACK AS AN ADULT
AND I KNEW MY LIFE WAS GOING TO CHANGE FOREVER.
IT WOULD NEVER BE QUITE THE SAME.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.