Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
IN THE NORTH ATLANTIC,
A MASSIVE BULK CARRIER SUDDENLY SNAPS IN TWO.
THIS HAPPENED VERY, VERY QUICKLY.
LITERALLY, AT THE SPEED OF SOUND.
25 MEN ARE IN A FIGHT FOR THEIR LIVES.
IT WAS SO SCARY.
THE SHIP WAS DEFINITELY GOING TO SINK.
WHY DID WE LOSE SO MANY PEOPLE?
WELL WHY IN THE FIRST PLACE
WOULD THIS SHIP EVEN BREAK IN TWO?
THE SEARCH FOR ANSWERS WILL LEAD
TO THE BOTTOM OF THE OCEAN.
WELL LOOK AT THAT.
AND A STRING OF MYSTERIOUS SINKINGS
AROUND THE WORLD.
ALL OF THESE ARE BULK CARRIERS.
NO ONE KNOWS WHAT HAPPENED TO THOSE VESSELS.
THAT'S INSANE.
THEY JUST DISAPPEARED.
ABANDON SHIP!
GO!
WINTER IN THE NORTH ATLANTIC.
THE 590-FOOT BULK CARRIER FLARE IS HEADING WEST.
BULK CARRIERS ARE DESIGNED
TO DO HEAVY LIFTING AND HEAVY WORK.
THROUGHOUT THEIR LIFETIME, THEY CARRY VERY DENSE,
HEAVY CARGOES AND THEY TRADE ALL OVER THE WORLD.
CHIEF, INCREASING SPEED TO 12 KNOTS.
ABOARD IS THE CAPTAIN AND 24 CREW.
THEY'VE JUST COME OUT OF A POWERFUL WINTER STORM
AND ANOTHER IS ON ITS WAY.
HOLD COURSE.
HOLDING COURSE.
23 YEAR-OLD CYRUS FERRAREN IS AT THE HELM.
NEW TO THE SHIP, HE SIGNED ON JUST A WEEK BEFORE DEPARTURE.
MY JOB ON THE FLARE WAS ABLE BODIED SEAMAN.
I WAS IN CHARGE OF THE MANUAL STEERING ON THE SHIP.
I WANTED TO BE A SAILOR BECAUSE MY UNCLE WAS A SAILOR.
AND WHEN I WAS A KID, HE WAS ALWAYS COMING HOME
FROM HIS TRIPS, HAPPY, AND WITH LOTS OF MONEY.
THAT'S WHY I THOUGHT I'D LIKE TO DO IT, TOO.
THE FLARE IS MORE THAN HALFWAY
ON AN APPROXIMATE 3,700 MILE VOYAGE FROM ROTTERDAM
TO MONTREAL TO PICK UP A CARGO OF GRAIN.
THE BULK-CARRIER IS EQUIPPED
WITH MASSIVE CRANES THAT CAN FILL ITS SEVEN HOLDS
WITH ALMOST 50,000 CUBIC YARDS OF CARGO.
RIGHT NOW, THE HOLDS ARE EMPTY.
BELOW DECK, FOURTH ENGINEER, REMARLO NAPA,
IS BUSY HELPING WITH REPAIRS TO ONE
OF THE SHIP'S BALLAST TANKS.
WE WERE ACTUALLY INSIDE THE TOP SIDE TANK.
IT TOOK US ALMOST A WHOLE DAY TO WORK
ON THE ISSUE WITH THE WELDER.
LIKE CYRUS, REMARLO IS ALSO NEW TO THE SHIP.
WEEKS EARLIER, WHEN THEY JOINED THE CREW,
THEY WERE WELCOMED BY A SHIP'S VETERAN, TITO NOCES.
HE WAS REALLY HELPFUL FROM THE MOMENT
WE CAME ON BOARD.
I WAS STILL YOUNG,
AND HE WAS THERE TO TEACH ME.
IT'S JUST THE KINDA GUY HE WAS.
THE FLARE IS HEADING FOR
THE CANADIAN SHIPPING CHANNEL, THE CABOT STRAIT.
IT'S AN AREA KNOWN FOR BAD WEATHER.
CHIEF, DECREASING SPEEDS TO FIVE KNOTS.
CAPTAIN CHRIS HEARN
IS A MASTER MARINER FROM NEWFOUNDLAND.
HE KNOWS HOW ROUGH THESE SEAS CAN GET.
THE CABOT STRAIT IS BETWEEN TWO LAND MASSES
THAT HAVE WEATHER PATTERNS THAT ARE DIFFERENT.
SO THIS FASTER MOVING WATER ON TOP OF SLOWER MOVING WATER,
BUILDING ALL THIS ENERGY, IT WHIPS THE WAVES UP VERY HIGH.
THE CREW SECURES THE LIFEBOATS TO KEEP THEM
FROM BEING TORN FROM THE SHIP DURING THE STORM.
THE WAVES WERE STRONG, AND THE WIND WAS LOUD.
YOU COULD REALLY HEAR IT.
KEEP HER ON THE STARBOARD BOW.
THE SHIP IS NOT LOADED AND SHE'S MORE EXPOSED
TO THE ELEMENTS AND TO STORMS.
THAT SHIP WAS SLAMMING AND POUNDING
YOU CAN FEEL THAT VIBRATION BECAUSE THE ENERGY
HAS TO TRAVEL ALONG THE LENGTH OF THE HULL.
YOU COULD ACTUALLY SEE THE SHIP
BENDING IN THE BIG WAVES.
THE BENDING AND TWISTING CAN BE
AN UNNERVING EXPERIENCE, BUT FLARE WAS BUILT TO HANDLE THIS.
ALL SHIPS, THEY'RE DESIGNED TO FLEX,
AND PARTICULARLY REALLY LONG SHIPS.
SHE'S FLEXING AND MOVING ALL THE TIME.
THE WAVES ARE REACHING 30 FEET HIGH,
AS TALL AS A THREE-STORY BUILDING.
IT WAS REALLY LOUD WHEN THE WAVES
SPLASHED ON THE BRIDGE.
-GOOD NIGHT, SIR. -GOOD NIGHT.
AT 2:00 A.M., CYRUS'S SHIFT IS OVER.
HE HEADS BELOW TO TRY AND GET SOME REST.
BUT IN A STORM LIKE THIS, IT WON'T BE EASY.
YOU COULDN'T SLEEP BECAUSE
OF THE WAVES AND THE WEATHER.
I COULDN'T SEE IT BUT I COULD FEEL IT SHAKING AND SLAMMING.
IT'S OVER-SPEEDING TOO MUCH.
HOLD IT.
IN THE ENGINE ROOM, REMARLO,
AND HIS ASSISTANT STRUGGLE TO KEEP
THE SHIP'S ENGINE FROM BURNING OUT.
WE HAD TO CONSTANTLY ADJUST THE SPEED
OF THE ENGINES FROM LOW SPEED TO HIGH SPEED BECAUSE
WHEN THE SHIP GOES THROUGH THE WAVES,
THE STERN TENDS TO RISE UP OUT OF THE WATER.
AS THE VESSEL IS SLAMMING UP AND DOWN,
AS IT'S MOVING THROUGH THESE WAVES,
SOMETIMES THE PROPELLER IS PARTIALLY EXPOSED.
AND WHEN THEY COME OUT OF THE WATER, THERE'S NO RESISTANCE,
THAT OVER-SPEED CAN DAMAGE YOUR ENGINE.
WE COULDN'T TAKE OUR EYES
OFF THE ENGINES FOR A SECOND.
IT WAS LIKE THAT FOR THE WHOLE SHIFT.
SUDDENLY, AROUND 4:30 IN THE MORNING...
THERE WAS A LOUD BANG.
WHAT HAPPENED?
DID WE HIT SOMETHING?
THEN THE ALARM WENT OFF.
ABANDON SHIP!
WE'RE SINKING! WAIT, WAIT!
PUT ON YOUR LIFE JACKETS NOW!
SOMEONE BANGED ON MY DOOR
AND TOLD ME TO PUT ON MY LIFE JACKET.
I PUT ON TWO PAIRS OF PANTS AND THREE PAIRS OF SOCKS.
I HAD A HARD TIME WITH THE STAIRS
BECAUSE THE SHIP WAS TILTING.
OUTSIDE, IT'S FREEZING
AND THE CREW IS TERRIFIED.
MOST AREN'T EVEN DRESSED FOR THE COLD.
I SAW REMARLO AND HE WAS IN HIS PAJAMAS.
NO SOCKS, JUST HIS PAJAMAS AND A T-SHIRT.
IT'S NOT JUST THE COLD THEY'RE WORRIED ABOUT,
IT'S THE SHOCK OF WHAT'S RIGHT IN FRONT OF THEM.
THE ENTIRE FRONT HALF OF THE SHIP IS GONE.
THE SHIP HAS JUST BROKEN IN HALF.
IT'S ALMOST TOO IMPOSSIBLE TO BELIEVE.
I COULD SEE MY CREWMATES WERE TERRIFIED.
SOME WERE CRYING, OTHERS WERE PRAYING.
IT WAS SO SCARY BECAUSE WE ALL SAW
THAT THE SHIP WAS DEFINITELY GONNA SINK.
THE ONLY THING WE COULD DO THEN
WAS FIGURE OUT HOW TO SURVIVE.
25 MEN ARE TRAPPED ON A BROKEN SHIP
THAT'S GOING DOWN FAST.
THE QUESTION NOW. CAN ANY OF THEM SURVIVE
THE ICY OCEAN THAT AWAITS THEM?
THE MASSIVE 590-FOOT BULK CARRIER,
FLARE, HAS BROKEN IN HALF.
THE SHIP'S 25 CREW ARE IN A DESPERATE FIGHT FOR THEIR LIVES.
THEY'RE TRAPPED ON THE STERN, AND IT'S SINKING FAST.
IT WAS JUST CHAOS.
EVERYONE WAS IN A PANIC.
THE CAPTAIN WAS NOWHERE TO BE SEEN.
WE ASSUMED HE HAD ALREADY GONE OVER THE SIDE.
SO WE JUST WENT AHEAD ON OUR OWN.
WE MADE FOR THE LIFEBOAT, BUT WE COULDN'T GET IT TO LAUNCH.
THEY HAD PUT ADDITIONAL LASHINGS ON THE LIFEBOAT
TO TRY AND PREVENT IT FROM BEING LOST DURING THE STORM
AND THEY CAN'T GET THE LASHINGS TO RELEASE.
THE CREW ARE STRUGGLING WITH LIFE AND DEATH.
WE KEPT ASKING EACH OTHER,
WHAT ARE WE GONNA DO?
UNABLE TO LAUNCH THE LIFEBOATS,
ALL EYES TURN TO THE SHIP'S RADIO OPERATOR.
HEY, DID YOU SEND THE MAYDAY?
WE ASKED HIM IF HE CALLED THE SOS.
-NO! -WHY NOT?
-I DIDN'T HAVE THE CHANCE! -WHAT?
THEY'RE STUNNED TO HEAR NO CALL HAS BEEN SENT.
AT LEAST, IF HE'D CALLED,
THERE MIGHT BE A POSSIBILITY WE'D BE RESCUED.
DESPERATE, THE RADIO OPERATOR RACES BACK
TO THE BRIDGE IN A LAST DITCH EFFORT TO MAKE THE CALL.
THE STERN SECTION IS SINKING AND IT'S LISTING,
SO THE RADIO OFFICER HAS TO MAKE HIS WAY UP,
HOLDING ONTO THE LADDERS,
AND UP THE STAIRWELLS TO TRY AND GET TO THE BRIDGE.
THE FACT THAT HE MANAGED TO DO IT AT ALL IS AMAZING.
AT THE MCTS, THE TRAFFIC STATION IN STEPHENVILLE,
THEY RECEIVED A VERY FAINT, INCOMPLETE MAYDAY
BY VHF; VERY HIGH FREQUENCY RADIO.
CANADIAN AUTHORITIES LAUNCH
A MASSIVE HUNT FOR THE FLARE.
BUT WITH ONLY PARTIAL COORDINATES,
THE SEARCH AREA IS ENORMOUS.
SHIPS, FIXED WING AIRCRAFT AND HELICOPTERS,
OVER AN AREA OF 6,000 SQUARE NAUTICAL MILES
TO TRY AND FIND WHERE THE FLARE IS, OR WAS,
AND WHERE, HOPEFULLY, SOME SURVIVORS MIGHT BE.
JUST AFTER THE MAYDAY,
CREW MEMBERS ARE STILL CLINGING
TO THE RAILINGS AS THE SHIP GOES DOWN.
TITO, ME AND THE OTHER GUYS,
WE WERE ALL ON ONE SIDE OF THE SHIP.
WE WERE ALL TOGETHER JUST HANGING ONTO THE RAILS.
WE WERE REALLY SCARED.
THEN, I SAW TITO LET GO OF THE RAILING.
MOMENTS LATER, THE REST OF THE CREW
HAVE NO CHOICE BUT TO FOLLOW.
THEY JUMP JUST AS THE STERN GOES UNDER.
THE PHYSICAL SHOCK OF THAT KIND
OF COLD WATER IS UNBELIEVABLE.
IT COMPLETELY TAKES YOUR BREATH AWAY.
GASPING FOR AIR,
CYRUS SEES AN OVERTURNED LIFEBOAT.
IT'S HIS ONLY HOPE.
THE WATER WAS COLD.
IT WAS REALLY PAINFUL AND HARD TO SWIM.
IT WAS REALLY COLD.
BUT WHAT MADE ME EVEN MORE SCARED THAN THAT
IS WE WERE OFF THE SHIP; WE WERE IN THE WATER.
CYRUS, REMARLO, AND TWO OTHERS
HAVE MADE IT TO THE LIFEBOAT.
BUT WITH TEMPERATURES BELOW FREEZING,
JUST HOW LONG CAN THEY LAST?
HYPOTHERMIA SETS IN.
YOU START TO LOSE THE ABILITY TO USE YOUR FINGERS
AND BE ABLE TO MOVE YOUR ARMS AND LEGS.
TWO OTHER CREWMEN ALSO MAKE IT TO THE LIFEBOAT,
THE RADIO OPERATOR AND REMARLO'S ENGINE ROOM ASSISTANT.
THEY TRY BUT THEY CAN'T HOLD ON TO THE OVERTURNED HULL.
I JUST DIDN'T HAVE ENOUGH STRENGTH
TO PULL HIM UP TO THE LIFEBOAT.
I TOLD HIM, I'M REALLY SORRY,
WE HAVE TO GO OUR OWN SEPARATE WAYS.
DRIFTING IN THE BITTER COLD,
THEIR CHANCES SEEM HOPELESS, THEN SUDDENLY,
THEY SEE THE BOW OF A SHIP.
IT APPEARS TO BE COMING THEIR WAY.
ONE OF US EVEN SAID, WE'RE RESCUED!
WE ALL HUGGED EACH OTHER,
MY COMPANIONS AND I, AND SAID, WE'RE ALIVE!
THE RESCUERS ARE HERE!
I COULDN'T BELIEVE IT.
THEN, AS THE VESSEL COMES CLOSER,
THEY DISCOVER IT'S NOT A RESCUE SHIP.
IT'S THE FLARE'S BROKEN BOW STILL AFLOAT.
THE FLARE BROKE IN SUCH A WAY THAT
THE WATERTIGHT BULKHEADS WERE STILL INTACT.
SO NOW WE'VE GOT THESE EMPTY SPACES THAT
ARE HELPING THIS BOW SECTION STAY AFLOAT.
IT MUST'VE BEEN AN INCREDIBLY EERIE SITUATION.
WE WERE SO HOPEFUL,
BUT WHEN WE FIGURED OUT THAT IT WAS JUST THE FORWARD PART
OF THE SHIP, THAT'S WHEN OUR HOPE WAS LOST.
DELTA VICTOR THAT IS A NEGATIVE ON ANY CONTACT.
I REPEAT, A NEGATIVE ON CONTACT.
BY SUNRISE, THE SEARCH HAS YET TO FIND ANY TRACE
OF THE SHIP OR POSSIBLE SURVIVORS.
SEARCH AND RESCUE TECHNICIANS, TONY ISAACS AND PAUL JACKMAN,
KNOW IT'S A BAD SIGN.
WE KNOW IT'S COLD.
AND WE'RE IN THE NORTH ATLANTIC.
AND THERE'S PEOPLE OUT THERE THAT ARE GONNA NEED US.
WHETHER THEY'RE IN A LIFE RAFT, IN THE WATER,
OR ON A BOAT, IT'S GOING TO BE COLD.
THERE'S DAYLIGHT SO WE WERE KIND OF WONDERING
WHY THEY HAVEN'T BEEN FOUND YET BECAUSE
IT'S A FAIRLY BIG ASSET ON THE WATER.
SO IT WAS KIND OF TROUBLING THAT NOBODY
HAS SEEN ANYTHING YET.
AFTER MORE THAN FIVE HOURS IN THE FRIGID WATER,
THE MEN ARE FADING FAST.
I PRAYED TO THE LORD.
I SAID, PLEASE GIVE ME A CHANCE TO SEE MY FAMILY AGAIN.
THEN ON THE HORIZON,
THE SEARCH TEAM SPOTS SOMETHING.
LOOK, A TARGET, 2:00!
INCREDIBLY, THE FLARE'S BOW SECTION
IS STILL FLOATING.
THE WRECKAGE IS FOUND, BUT CAN THE SEARCH TEAM LOCATE
ANY SURVIVORS BEFORE THEIR TIME RUNS OUT?
NEARLY SIX HOURS AFTER RECEIVING
AN INCOMPLETE MAYDAY CALL,
RESCUERS HAVE SPOTTED THE FLARE'S BOW SECTION ADRIFT
IN THE NORTH ATLANTIC.
WE SAW THE BOW QUITE A WAYS AWAY,
'CAUSE OBVIOUSLY IT WAS QUITE LARGE.
THE WAVES WERE CRASHING AROUND IT.
AND TO ME, IT WAS SORT OF, KIND OF A LITTLE EERIE.
OUT THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE AIRCRAFT,
WE COULD SEE THE OIL SLICK.
THERE'S NO SIGN OF ANYONE ON BOARD.
BUT EXPERIENCE TELLS THEM IF THERE ARE SURVIVORS,
THEY WON'T BE FAR AWAY.
WE HAD A FAIRLY DEFINED DEBRIS LINE,
SO WE JUST FOLLOWED THAT DOWN FLYING IN A VERY SLOW HOVER.
MOMENTS LATER, WE COULD SEE THE UH, THE OVERTURNED BOAT.
FOUR PEOPLE BARELY CLINGING TO IT.
AND ONE OF THEM JUST BARELY RAISING HIS HAND.
WE HEARD A HELICOPTER.
AND WE ALL STARTED SAYING, WE'RE GONNA MAKE IT,
WE'RE GONNA MAKE IT.
WHEN I GOT TO THE LIFEBOAT,
THEY'RE ALL HANGING ON TO ROPES,
AND WERE VERY RELUCTANT TO LET GO OF THAT ROPE.
TONY'S BELLY-TO-BELLY WHEN THEY'RE HOISTING UP
AND COMING THROUGH THE DOOR.
ONE BY ONE, THE SURVIVORS ARE LIFTED TO SAFETY.
IT WAS BASICALLY, I GOTCHA AND WE'RE GONE.
WHEN I BROUGHT THE FINAL SURVIVOR UP,
AND HE'S BASICALLY WEARING LIKE BOXER SHORTS,
I WAS AMAZED BECAUSE I ACTUALLY THOUGHT
THAT HE'S WEARING PANTS OR SOMETHING.
BUT NO, THAT'S WHAT THIS GUY'S WEARING.
THAT'S HOW TOUGH HE WAS.
AFTER SIX HOURS IN THE DEADLY COLD,
CYRUS, REMARLO, AND TWO OTHERS ARE LUCKY TO BE ALIVE.
THEY'RE TAKEN TO THE NEARBY ISLAND OF ST. PIERRE
FOR EMERGENCY MEDICAL ATTENTION.
THE NEXT THING I KNEW,
WE WERE BEING WHEELED OFF THE HELICOPTER.
THERE WERE AMBULANCES THERE.
ONE OF THE RESCUERS
GAVE ME THE PATCH FROM HIS UNIFORM.
I WAS VERY THANKFUL TO HIM.
IT WAS MY SECOND LIFE.
WHILE THE CREW RECEIVES MEDICAL ATTENTION,
THE SEARCH TEAM SCOURS THE AREA FOR ANOTHER DAY,
BUT NO OTHER SURVIVORS ARE FOUND.
21 MEN ARE DEAD.
FOR THE FAMILY OF TITO NOCES,
THE NEWS COMES AS A TERRIBLE SHOCK
SO VERY HARD.
BUT WE NEED TO BE STRONG BECAUSE I KNOW
HE SACRIFICED A LOT FOR OUR CHILDREN.
AS A CHILD I ASKED LIKE, "WHY ARE YOU CRYING?"
AND THEN SHE TOLD ME THAT, YOU KNOW,
YOUR DAD ALREADY PASSED AWAY.
I JUST KNEW THAT MY DAD DIED IN AN ACCIDENT,
BUT NOT KNOWING HOW IT HAPPENED.
AS THE FLARE'S BOW CONTINUES TO DRIFT AT SEA,
INVESTIGATORS WITH THE TRANSPORTATION
SAFETY BOARD OF CANADA
LAUNCH AN INVESTIGATION TO FIND OUT WHAT CAUSED THE SHIP
TO BREAK APART, AND WHY SO MANY CREWMEN DIED.
OKAY GENTLEMEN,
I'VE GOT SOME AERIAL FOOTAGE OF THE INCIDENT HERE.
THE FIRST THOUGHTS ARE, OF COURSE, TO THE CREW.
YOUR MIND GOES TO WHAT COULD HAVE HAPPENED.
IT WAS PRETTY REMARKABLE WHEN WE HEARD THE DETAILS
OF WHAT HAD HAPPENED TO, TO THE VESSEL.
I GUESS IT'S SURREAL THAT YOU'VE GOT THIS HALF
A SHIP SORT OF DRIFTING ALONG.
WHY DID WE LOSE SO MANY PEOPLE?
WHY AREN'T THERE MORE SURVIVORS?
WHY IN THE FIRST PLACE WOULD THIS SHIP EVEN BREAK IN TWO?
INVESTIGATOR LEO DONATI HAS COME TO NEWFOUNDLAND
TO JOIN FORMER SEA CAPTAIN, BILL MCCONIE,
THE INVESTIGATOR IN CHARGE.
LET'S SEE WHAT THESE GUYS CAN TELL US.
THEY'RE HOPING THE SURVIVORS
CAN TELL THEM WHAT CAUSED THE WRECK.
TAKE US THROUGH WHAT YOU SAW ON THE SHIP THAT DAY.
YOU WANT TO INTERVIEW SURVIVORS AS SOON AS POSSIBLE
BECAUSE OUR MEMORIES AREN'T STATIC;
THEY CAN CHANGE OVER TIME.
WE WERE IN VERY HIGH WATERS THE WHOLE TIME.
THEY FIND OUT THE SHIP FACED TWO WEEKS
OF NEARLY CONSTANT EXTREME WINDS AND HEAVY SEAS.
WE COULDN'T EAT.
WE COULDN'T SLEEP.
THE WAVES, THEY ARE VERY BIG.
THEIR TESTIMONY IS BACKED BY WEATHER REPORTS
OF WAVES AS HIGH AS 50 FEET,
A HEIGHT OF A FIVE-STORY BUILDING.
YOU KNOW, THE SHIP IS, IS BENDING LIKE, LIKE THIS.
YOU CAPTURE AS MUCH INFORMATION AS YOU CAN.
YOU REALLY TRY AND GET A CLEAR PICTURE OF,
OF ALL THE FACTS, ALL THE DETAILS.
WHAT DID YOU SEE, WHAT DID YOU HEAR?
WAS THERE ANY SORT OF A SOUND OMITTED WHEN THIS HAPPENED?
IT'S LIKE A BIG, BIG BOOM!
DURING THE NIGHT OF THE ACCIDENT,
THEY HEARD A REALLY LOUD BANG.
CLEARLY, THAT'S WHEN THE VESSEL SPLIT APART.
SURVIVORS HEARD THE SAME EAR-SPLITTING SOUND,
BUT NONE OF THEM SAW WHAT CAUSED IT.
HOW CAN A SHIP THAT BIG SIMPLY BREAK IN HALF?
THAT'S WHAT WE'RE HERE TO FIND OUT.
INVESTIGATORS HAVE A DEADLY MYSTERY
ON THEIR HANDS.
THEY ALSO HAVE UNUSUAL EVIDENCE.
IMAGERY OF THE FLARE'S BROKEN BOW TAKEN
OVER A FOUR-DAY PERIOD BEFORE IT EVENTUALLY SANK.
UNBELIEVABLE.
WE DEFINITELY NEED TO TAKE A CLOSER LOOK AT THIS.
JOHN GARSTANG IS A MECHANICAL ENGINEER
AND EXPERT IN METAL FAILURE ANALYSIS.
HE BELIEVES THE IMAGERY MAY HOLD CLUES
TO WHY THE MASSIVE SHIP SNAPPED IN HALF.
YOU CAN ACTUALLY PULL OUT A TREMENDOUS AMOUNT
OF INFORMATION FROM IMAGERY.
PHOTOGRAPHS AND VIDEO ARE VERY VALUABLE
FROM AN INVESTIGATIVE POINT OF VIEW.
IT'S A REALLY CLEAN FRACTURE.
AS HE EXAMINES THE EDGE OF THE BREAK,
GARSTANG MAKES A SURPRISING DISCOVERY-
IT'S ALMOST LIKE I HAD A KNIFE AND A SCALPEL,
AND I CUT, QUITE PRECISELY, AND IT JUST CAME APART.
THIS TYPE OF BREAK IS KNOWN
AS A BRITTLE FRACTURE.
A BRITTLE FRACTURE IS SOMETHING LIKE HOW GLASS BREAKS.
WHEN IT BREAKS, IT BREAKS BUT IT DOESN'T DEFORM MUCH,
TWIST OR BEND.
IT BREAKS QUICKLY.
THE THEORY MATCHES THE SURVIVORS' ACCOUNTS.
BUT TO INVESTIGATORS, IT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE.
IT SAYS HERE THIS IS MADE WITH GRADE D STEEL.
WHICH MEANS, IT'S NOT SUPPOSED TO SNAP.
LIKE MANY BULK CARRIERS,
FLARE'S DECK AND UPPER HULL ARE CONSTRUCTED
FROM FRACTURE RESISTANT STEEL.
IT'S MADE TO BE FLEXIBLE, NOT BRITTLE,
SO IT CAN BEND AND TWIST TO ABSORB
THE PUNISHMENT OF HEAVY SEAS.
THIS SHIP HAS GOT METAL THAT SHOULD BE BEHAVING
IN A DUCTILE MANNER ABSORBING MORE ENERGY.
IT'S SOMETHING LIKE, IF I HAD A PIECE OF LICORICE
AND I PULLED ON IT AND BENT, IT WOULD DEFORM,
NARROW DOWN BEFORE IT BREAKS.
SO, WE'RE SEEING THINGS THAT ARE UNEXPECTED;
THAT WE DON'T UNDERSTAND.
DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE.
INVESTIGATORS FIND THEMSELVES
WITH A DEEPER MYSTERY TO SOLVE.
KEEP IT ON THE STARBOARD BOW.
WHY DID A SHIP, DESIGNED TO FLEX AND BEND,
FAIL WHEN THE CREW NEEDED IT MOST?
THE INVESTIGATION INTO THE BREAK-UP OF THE FLARE
IS NOW FOCUSED ON THE SHIP'S FLEXIBLE STEEL STRUCTURE,
THAT SHOULD HAVE ENABLED IT TO RIDE OUT THE STORM.
HOW CAN THIS DUCTILE MATERIAL BEHAVE BRITTLELY?
WE'RE STILL TRYING TO FIGURE THIS OUT.
THERE'S SOMETHING ELSE GOING ON.
LOOKING FOR ANSWERS,
INVESTIGATORS EXAMINE THE SHIP'S HISTORY
AND HOW IT WAS OPERATED.
THE FLARE WAS BUILT IN 1972.
SO, AT THE TIME OF THE OCCURRENCE,
IT WAS 26 YEARS OLD WHICH,
FOR A BULK CARRIER, IS PROBABLY ABOUT EIGHT YEARS PAST
ITS NORMAL SERVICE LIFE.
PRETTY OLD FOR A BULK CARRIER.
INVESTIGATOR KEN POTTER
IS A MARINE SAFETY ANALYST ON THE TEAM.
BULK CARRIERS DO LEAD A TOUGH LIFE AND SOME
OF THE MATERIALS THEY'RE CARRYING CAN
BE VERY HARD ON THE VESSEL.
FOR EXAMPLE, IRON ORE COMES ON BOARD IN PELLETS
THAT ARE OFTEN VERY HOT,
AND THEY'RE DISCHARGED WITH BIG GRAB BUCKETS THAT ACTUALLY
CAN DAMAGE THE VESSEL ITSELF.
THE FLARE HAS HAD A LONG
AND BRUTAL SERVICE LIFE.
HERE'S SOMETHING.
WHAT HAVE YOU GOT?
IT TURNS OUT THAT BULK CARRIERS
LIKE FLARE ALSO HAVE A DEADLY HISTORY.
OVER THE PREVIOUS SEVEN YEARS,
A TOTAL OF 99 BULK CARRIERS WERE LOST,
TAKING WITH THEM OVER 650 LIVES.
ALL OF THESE ARE BULK CARRIERS.
THAT'S INSANE.
THE NUMBERS ARE SHOCKING.
ON AVERAGE, THAT'S ROUGHLY ONE BULK CARRIER
WOULD BE LOST A MONTH.
THEY WOULD OCCUR SO SUDDENLY,
SOMETIMES THERE WAS NO MAYDAYS.
THE INVESTIGATORS CONSIDER
A TERRIFYING POSSIBILITY,
OTHER BULK CARRIERS MAY ALSO HAVE SNAPPED IN HALF.
NO ONE KNOWS WHAT HAPPENED TO THOSE VESSELS.
THE CREW DIDN'T SURVIVE.
THEY JUST, THEY DISAPPEARED.
IF THEY'RE RIGHT,
OTHER BULK CARRIERS MAY BE IN DANGER.
SEARCHING FOR A NEW LEAD, INVESTIGATORS FIND ONE
IN THE PORT OF ROTTERDAM IN THE NETHERLANDS.
IT'S HERE WHERE THE FLARE'S FINAL VOYAGE BEGAN.
WE HAD TO TALK TO THE PILOT IN ROTTERDAM
THAT HAD GUIDED THE SHIP OUT OF ROTTERDAM.
BILL MCCONIE.
THANKS FOR TAKING THE TIME TO TALK TO ME.
ABSOLUTELY, HOW CAN I ASSIST YOU?
THE ROLE OF THE PILOT IS TO SAFELY GUIDE
THE VESSEL OUT OF PORT.
HE WAS AN IMPORTANT SOURCE OF INFORMATION.
I KNOW IT WAS A WHILE AGO.
HARBOUR PILOTS NAVIGATE THOUSANDS OF SHIPS OUT
OF THIS PORT EACH YEAR.
BUT SOMETHING ABOUT THE FLARE STOOD OUT.
THE FLARE, YES, I DO REMEMBER THIS SHIP.
SHE WAS EMPTY.
I ALSO REMEMBER SHE HAD A LIGHT FORWARD DRAFT ON HER.
A LIGHT FORWARD DRAFT,
MEANS THE BOW OF THE SHIP FLOATS HIGH OUT OF THE WATER -
PERFECTLY SAFE WHEN SEAS ARE CALM,
BUT IN A STORM, IT CAN CAUSE SERIOUS PROBLEMS.
PICTURE A VESSEL AS A TEETER-TOTTER,
AND IN THIS CASE, A 700-FOOT-LONG TEETER-TOTTER,
AND THE BOW TEETER TOTTERS OR TIPS FORWARD INTO THE TROUGH.
IT COMES DOWN WITH A BANG.
OVER TIME, THIS CAN DAMAGE THE SHIP.
WITH THE CONTINUAL POUNDING THROUGH THE WAVES,
YOU GET BENDING THIS WAY THEN BENDING BACK THAT WAY,
BENDING THIS WAY, BENDING BACK THAT WAY.
MUCH LIKE A PAPERCLIP BEING BENT BACK AND FORTH,
IT CAN START TO FATIGUE AND THEN CRACK AND FAIL.
INVESTIGATORS WONDER IF FLARE'S BOW
WAS RIDING TOO HIGH IN HEAVY SEAS.
CHIEF, DECREASING SPEED TO FIVE KNOTS.
AND DID THE CONTINUAL POUNDING
ULTIMATELY CAUSE IT TO SNAP?
TO REDUCE STRESSES TO THE HULL IN BIG WAVES,
SEAWATER IS PUMPED INTO A SHIPS BALLAST TANKS.
THE WEIGHT MAKES IT SIT LOWER IN THE WATER
TO PROVIDE A SMOOTHER RIDE IN THE WAVES.
KEEP HER ON THE STARBOARD BOW.
INVESTIGATORS KNOW THE FLARE LEFT PORT
IN AN EXTREMELY LIGHT CONDITION.
WHAT THEY DON'T KNOW IS HOW MUCH BALLAST THE CAPTAIN
HAD ADDED TO THE TANKS JUST BEFORE THE SHIP BROKE IN HALF.
WE KNEW SHE WAS EMPTY SO HOW MUCH BALLAST,
WHERE IT WAS PLACED WAS VERY IMPORTANT FOR US TO FIND OUT.
THEY COME UP WITH AN INGENIOUS WAY TO FIND OUT.
LOOK AT HOW THE ICE IS FORMED.
BY LOOKING AT IMAGES OF THE FLARE'S MAIN DECK.
YOU SEE THOSE SQUARE EDGES?
YOU COULD SEE WHERE THERE IS SNOW AND ICE PATTERNS,
AND THAT WAS VERY VALUABLE TO ASSIST US
IN DETERMINING BALLAST.
BECAUSE IF YOU HAVE WATER BALLAST,
IT CONTAINS HEAT LONGER THAN AN EMPTY AIR TANK.
A BALLAST TANK FULL OF SEAWATER RETAINS
ENOUGH HEAT TO MELT SNOW THAT LANDS ON ITS SURFACE.
EMPTY TANKS WILL GET COLDER AND ALLOW SNOW
AND EVEN ICE TO BUILD UP ON THE DECKS ABOVE.
THERE'S NOT ENOUGH SEAWATER IN THESE TANKS.
YOU CAN SEE ON THE IMAGERY WHERE THERE IS SNOW
AND ICE BECAUSE THAT TANK WAS MOST LIKELY EMPTY.
WHY GO INTO A STORM WITH EMPTY TANKS?
THAT DOESN'T MAKE SENSE.
AS THEY SEARCH FOR AN ANSWER,
SOMETHING CATCHES THEIR ATTENTION.
IN FLARE'S LAST SURVEY, MOST OF THE SHIP'S BALLAST TANKS
WERE FOUND TO BE SEVERELY CORRODED AND IN NEED OF REPAIR.
IN PARTICULAR, THERE WERE SOME REPAIRS
THAT WERE BEING DONE IN SOME OF THE UPPER WING TANKS,
AND THAT WOULD REQUIRE THEM TO REMOVE THE BALLAST WATER
IN ORDER TO EFFECT THOSE REPAIRS.
THEY'D BEEN GIVEN WHAT'S KNOWN AS A CONDITION OF CLASS.
THAT IS A SPECIFIC PERIOD OF TIME IN WHICH THEY'RE ALLOWED
TO CONTINUE TO SAIL BUT MUST HAVE THE REPAIRS DONE.
THEY'VE ONLY GOT WEEKS TO GET THE REPAIRS DONE.
THAT'S A LOT OF PRESSURE.
YEAH.
WITH TIME RUNNING OUT,
SOME REPAIRS WERE TO BE DONE AT SEA.
BUT THE NORTH ATLANTIC HAD OTHER IDEAS.
THE WEATHER CONDITIONS THEY EXPERIENCED,
THE HEAVY SEAS,
THE STORM AND A NEAR HURRICANE FORCE WINDS,
WOULD HAVE MADE IT VERY,
VERY DIFFICULT TO CONDUCT ANY REPAIRS ON THE VOYAGE.
IT'S POSSIBLE UNFINISHED REPAIRS MEANT
SOME BALLAST TANKS COULDN'T BE FILLED AND LEFT
THE ALREADY EMPTY SHIP POUNDING HEAVILY THROUGH RAGING SEAS.
DID THE FORCE OF A MASSIVE WAVE SIMPLY RIP THE SHIP APART?
A CLOSER LOOK AT FLARE'S PLANS SHOWS IT WAS BUILT
TO TAKE THE WORST ANY OCEAN HAS TO OFFER.
IT WAS STRENGTHENED,
ITS HULL WAS STRENGTHENED TO TAKE ORE.
SO, THIS VESSEL WAS STRONGER THAN OTHER BULK CARRIERS
AT THE TIME,
YET IT CATASTROPHICALLY FAILED WHILE EMPTY.
SEARCHING FOR ANSWERS,
INVESTIGATORS DIG DEEPER INTO THE SHIP'S STRUCTURE
MAYBE THERE WAS A PROBLEM THAT
WE COULDN'T SEE ON THE IMAGERY.
SO, WE REALLY ARE IN A POSITION NOW YOU CAN'T ANSWER THIS
UNLESS YOU GET EYES ON THE WRECKAGE ITSELF AND ANALYZE IT.
INVESTIGATOR JOHN GARSTANG BOARDS
THE CANADIAN COAST GUARD VESSEL, EARL GRAY,
AND VENTURES OUT TO THE SUNKEN WRECK OF THE FLARE'S BOW,
ABOUT 90 MILES OFF THE COAST OF CAPE BRETON.
HE HAS AN ROV EQUIPPED
WITH A HIGH RESOLUTION VIDEO CAMERA
TO SCAN THE WRECKAGE FOR CLUES.
WE'VE ONLY GOT A LIMITED
WEATHER WINDOW AND WE HAVE
TO MAKE THE BEST OF EVERY MINUTE WE'VE GOT.
AS THE ROV GOES INTO THE WATER,
GARSTANG KNOWS THIS MAY BE THE INVESTIGATION'S LAST CHANCE
TO FIND OUT WHAT CAUSED THE FLARE TO BREAK APART.
INVESTIGATOR JOHN GARSTANG WATCHES THE ROV DESCEND
TOWARDS THE WRECKAGE OF FLARE'S BOW SECTION
MONTHS OF INVESTIGATION HINGE
ON WHATEVER PHYSICAL EVIDENCE HE CAN FIND.
THIS IS A RISKY OPERATION
BECAUSE YOU'RE GOING ON A WRECK
AND THERE'S CABLES AND TWISTED METAL
AND EVERYTHING YOU CAN ENTANGLE ON.
WE MAY ALL OF A SUDDEN LOSE $100,000 VEHICLE,
IN ADDITION TO ACCOMPLISHING NOTHING.
250 FEET BELOW THE SURFACE,
FLARE'S BOW LOOMS INTO VIEW.
YOU NEVER DO GET USED TO COMING UP ON A WRECK
OUT OF THE DIM AND DARK AND THEN SEEING
THIS MASSIVE STRUCTURE.
YOU CANNOT HELP BUT NOT BE PERSONALLY AFFECTED.
BASICALLY, YOU'RE AT A GRAVE SITE
OF THOSE WHO DIDN'T MAKE IT.
THE SUNKEN BOW HAS LANDED
ON THE SEAFLOOR NEARLY UPSIDE DOWN.
IT ACTUALLY ROLLED AND WAS UPSIDE DOWN TO SHOW US
THE STUFF WE COULDN'T SEE WHEN IT WAS FLOATING.
OKAY, MOVE IN.
RIGHT THERE!
AS THE HULL FRACTURE COMES INTO VIEW EDGE-ON,
GARSTANG SEES A SERIES OF TELL-TALE MARKINGS
WITHIN THE THICKNESS OF THE STEEL.
TO OUR SURPRISE,
WE START ENCOUNTERING CLAM SHELL MARKS,
WHICH ARE CHARACTERISTIC OR INDICATIVE OF FATIGUE CRACKS.
THESE SMALL FATIGUE CRACKS HAVE
AN IDENTIFIABLE CLAMSHELL PATTERN THAT CAN BE CAUSED
BY THE CONTINUED FLEXING OF STEEL OVER TIME.
THOSE LINES THAT MAKE UP
THAT SERIES OF CONCENTRIC MARKS
ARE ACTUALLY CRACK AND REST LINES WHERE THE CRACK
WOULD ADVANCE, STOP, ADVANCE, STOP, ADVANCE,
STOP IN LITTLE INCREMENTS SO IT'S SLOWLY GROWING.
THIS COULD BE WHERE IT ALL STARTED.
GROWING INSIDE THE STEEL,
THESE FATIGUE CRACKS WERE ALL BUT INVISIBLE
TO FLARE'S CAPTAIN AND CREW.
THEY'RE SMALL, BUT THOSE CRACK PATTERNS AND CRACKS
ARE TICKING TIME BOMBS.
ALL THESE CRACKS ARE STARTING GETTING BIGGER,
JOINING, EVENTUALLY JOINING TO THE POINT
THAT THEY'RE CRITICAL IN SIZE.
ONCE YOU HAVE THAT, IF YOU THEN HAVE A SHOCK LOADING,
WHICH IS THE POUNDING OF THE WAVES, THIS SUDDEN BENDING,
THAT COMBINATION CAN THEN SUDDENLY CREATE
A RAPID, FAST FRACTURE, SO RAPID THAT IT'S CATASTROPHIC.
THE ACTUAL CRACK ON BOARD THE FLARE
WOULD HAVE STARTED
AND PROPAGATED ALL THE WAY AROUND THE HULL IN FRACTIONS
OF A SECOND, LITERALLY AT THE SPEED OF SOUND.
SIX MONTHS AFTER THE SINKING OF THE BULK CARRIER,
FLARE, INVESTIGATORS HAVE FOUND THEIR SMOKING GUN.
AND SIGNS OF CORROSION ON SOME FATIGUE CRACKS
REVEAL THEY MAY HAVE BEEN GROWING FOR YEARS.
MAYBE IT MIGHT TAKE A YEAR, TWO YEARS,
THOSE CRACKS SLOWLY PROGRESSING.
THE RIGHT CIRCUMSTANCES AND THEN CATASTROPHIC FAILURE
AS WE SAW ON THE FLARE.
THE FLARE'S CREW DIDN'T KNOW IT,
BUT THEY LEFT ROTTERDAM ON A SHIP THAT
WAS ALREADY PRIMED TO BREAK APART.
DECREASING SPEED TO FIVE KNOTS.
THE POUNDING TRANS-ATLANTIC VOYAGE WEAKENED
IT FURTHER, BEFORE THE FINAL STORM NEAR THE CABOT STRAIT
PROVED TO BE THE KNOCKOUT PUNCH.
THE SHIP WAS INSPECTED, AND IT PASSED.
FLARE HAD ULTRASONIC TESTS DONE ON ITS HULL,
BUT THE DEADLY FATIGUE CRACKS WERE NEVER DETECTED.
NOW IT BRINGS INTO QUESTION WHO DID THE INSPECTION?
HOW WELL IS THE INSPECTION BEING DONE?
MAYBE IT'S A PERSON WHOSE EQUIPMENT
ISN'T WHAT IT SHOULD BE.
SO, THIS TRIGGERS A SAFETY RESPONSE, WITH URGENCY.
THERE'S OTHER VESSELS ALL OVER THE WORLD
THAT MAY BE IN DANGER.
WE GOTTA WARN THOSE OTHER SHIPS.
THOSE CRACKS ARE LIKE TICKING TIME BOMBS.
THE SAME TYPE OF HIDDEN FATIGUE CRACKS
THAT BROKE THE FLARE COULD SINK
ANOTHER BULK CARRIER AT ANY MOMENT.
THE FLARE INVESTIGATORS SEND AN ALERT TO FLAG STATES
ALL OVER THE WORLD WARNING OF THE DANGER POSED
BY FATIGUE CRACKS IN BULK CARRIERS.
THE CRACKS ARE SO SMALL,
THEY CAN EASILY BE MISSED BY INSPECTION.
THERE'S A VERY LARGE FLEET
OF SIMILAR DESIGNED VESSELS.
DO THEY HAVE CRACKS, AND WE CAN TELL THEM
THAT LOCATIONS THAT WE'RE FINDING THESE.
THE RESPONSE IS ALARMING.
14 BULK CARRIERS SIMILAR TO FLARE
ARE IMMEDIATELY FLAGGED AS HIGH RISK.
TWO VESSELS OF SIMILAR DESIGN
THAT COME INTO CANADIAN WATERS,
ONE OF WHICH WAS INSPECTED, HAD CRACKS LIKE THE FLARE.
IF THEY WERE NOT FOUND,
JUST AS THEY WERE NOT FOUND IN THE FLARE,
THE SAME CATASTROPHIC THING
COULD HAVE HAPPENED TO THAT VESSEL.
SO, THIS WAS A, FOR ME PERSONALLY,
AND I KNOW WITH THE OTHER TEAM MEMBERS, THIS WAS A BIG DEAL.
THE NEED TO IMPROVE INSPECTIONS
ISN'T THE INDUSTRY'S ONLY WAKE-UP CALL.
THE NIGHT OF THE DISASTER,
NONE OF THE CREW WERE SEEN WEARING IMMERSION SUITS
WHEN THEY ABANDONED SHIP.
THE INSULATED NEOPRENE SUITS ARE DESIGNED
TO HELP VICTIMS SURVIVE ON THE OPEN OCEAN.
IT'S NOT UNCOMMON FOR SEAMEN OR CREW ON SHIPS
TO ACTUALLY PREPARE THEMSELVES FOR AN EMERGENCY LIKE THAT.
AND I WILL SAY MYSELF, I HAVE BEEN IN SITUATIONS
WHERE I'VE HAD MY SURVIVAL SUIT OUT OF THE CLOSET
JUST IN CASE SOMETHING HAPPENED.
IMMERSION SUITS ARE STANDARD ISSUE
ON CANADIAN SHIPS, BUT OTHER COUNTRIES HAVE DIFFERENT RULES.
THANK YOU FOR MEETING WITH ME.
CHIEF INVESTIGATOR, BILL MCCONNIE,
TRAVELS TO GREECE TO QUESTION THE FLARE'S OWNERS.
I'D LIKE TO TALK TO YOU ABOUT THE FLARE.
IN PARTICULAR, I'D LIKE TO TALK ABOUT
THE NUMBER OF IMMERSION SUITS.
THERE WERE SIX SURVIVAL SUITS ON BOARD
AS REQUIRED BY LAW.
25 GUYS; WHAT ARE THEY SUPPOSED TO DO, DRAW STRAWS?
IT WAS A BIT OF A SHOCKER FOR ME TO LEARN
THAT INTERNATIONAL REGULATIONS DID NOT CALL
FOR SURVIVAL SUITS FOR ALL OF THE CREW.
WE'RE GOING TO HAVE TO WORK ON THE LAW,
AND I'M HOPING THAT YOU'LL HELP ME OUT.
WITH THOUSANDS OF SHIPS
WORKING BITTERLY COLD OCEANS EVERY DAY,
INVESTIGATORS KNOW THE RULES HAVE TO CHANGE
OR MORE SEAFARERS WILL DIE.
I'LL BE IN TOUCH.
TO MAKE THEIR CASE,
THEY USE DATA ON COLD WATER SURVIVAL DEVELOPED
FOR THE CANADIAN MILITARY.
WE USE A COMPUTER MODEL
THAT CAN SIMULATE THE VARIOUS SCENARIOS.
WE CAN PUT INFORMATION ABOUT WATER TEMPERATURES,
AIR TEMPERATURES, THE TYPE OF CLOTHING THAT WAS WORN,
WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAD LIFE JACKETS.
WOULD THESE INDIVIDUALS HAVE SURVIVED
HAD THEY BEEN GIVEN IMMERSION SUITS?
THEY THEN COMPARE THE PREDICTED SURVIVAL TIMES
WITH OR WITHOUT A SURVIVAL SUIT.
THE INDIVIDUALS WITH LIGHTER CLOTHING WOULD
HAVE SURVIVED AROUND TWO TO TWO AND A HALF HOURS.
WHEN WE RAN THE MODEL WITH IMMERSION SUITS,
SURVIVAL TIMES INCREASED BY 12 TO 14 HOURS.
THE RESULTS ARE NO SURPRISE.
WITH IMMERSION SUITS, MORE OF THE FLARE'S CREW
WOULD PROBABLY HAVE SURVIVED.
YOU ALWAYS HOPE THAT YOU CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE.
OF COURSE, THERE'S THE FAMILIES TOO, CLOSURE.
LIKE WHAT HAPPENED?
WHY DID THIS HAPPEN?
THE INVESTIGATION AND RESULTS
OF THE SURVIVABILITY MODEL ARE PRESENTED
TO THE INTERNATIONAL MARITIME ORGANIZATION,
DEMANDING CHANGE.
THE IMO AND THE 150 MEMBER NATIONS AGREED WITH US
AND THE RULES WERE CHANGED
REQUIRING ONE SURVIVAL SUIT PER CREW MEMBER.
SADLY, IN TOO MANY CASES,
YOU NEED A VERY TRAGIC EVENT WITH FATALITIES
TO CREATE TRUE CHANGE.
THE FLARE IS PART OF A LEGACY OF TRAGIC EVENTS.
21 YEARS AFTER THE TRAGEDY,
REMARLO AND CYRUS MEET ONCE AGAIN.
THE TWO MEN SURVIVED
A TRAUMA THEY'LL NEVER FORGET,
AND IT CHANGED THEIR LIVES FOREVER
MY GOAL WAS, BY AGE 35,
I WANTED TO BE A CHIEF ENGINEER BECAUSE THAT WAS MY DREAM.
NOT ANYMORE.
I NEVER WENT ABOARD A SHIP EVER AGAIN.
SINCE THEN,
THEY'VE ENJOYED WATCHING THEIR FAMILIES GROW.
BUT MOST OF THEIR CREWMATES WEREN'T SO LUCKY.
IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN AVOIDED.
SO, I'M HOPING THAT AFTER THE ACCIDENT ON THE FLARE,
THE MARITIME INDUSTRY SHOULD HAVE HAD A LESSON.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.