All language subtitles for 25-07-2023trdery

"It's not clear exactly yet, but it's likely
to be bad news for the Russian navy," is the

opinion of Anders Nielsen, a military analyst
at the Royal Danish Defense College, about

the end of the grain deal.

The grain deal was originally signed for 120
days and then extended several times despite

the Russian leadership threatening to withdraw
from it each time.

At the time it was signed, the Russian leadership
hoped that by the time the first 120 days

expired, Ukraine would have already lost,
so it was seen as a PR exercise for developing

countries dependent on grain supplies, but
cannot help Ukraine in the war.

In the end, the "grain deal" significantly
benefited Ukraine, while Russia found itself

in a predicament where withdrawal was no longer
feasible due to increasing international isolation.

Russia feared being blamed by African nations
for causing a food crisis.

Also, the Russian navy is not in a position
to run a full-fledged blockade of Ukrainian

ports.

They can shell Ukrainian ports or sink this
or that ship with submarine torpedoes, but

a real blockade requires the navy to be present
in the area where the ships are traveling

and inspect them.

And Ukraine now has land-based anti-ship missiles
and fairly technologically advanced maritime

drones.

In a sense, during the "grain deal" the Russians
controlled the Ukrainian navy by not allowing

anything but grain to be smuggled in, and
by delaying their inspections, thus creating

a traffic jam of ships.

Many, including Nielsen himself, believed
that the Russian leadership would go along

with the grain deal, as withdrawing from it
would be even worse for Russia than continuing.

However, on July 17, there was an explosion
on the Crimean Bridge, which created serious

delays in Russian logistics (as well as a
personal insult to Putin, so he couldn't just

renegotiate the deal).

As a result, the Russians responded with a
series of unrealistic demands to reopen the

grain deal, including lifting some of the
sanctions, which of course no one would go

for, as they could put forward lifting even
more for the next grain deal.

It looks like the Russian leadership was not
prepared for the possibility of undermining

the bridge and did not know how to react.

Their response has not been very consistent.

The statement that any ship would be seen
as potentially carrying military cargo is

pretty vague.

Then one Kremlin official did clarify that
ships would be inspected.

Conducting a naval blockade has clear rules.

It must be announced in advance and then warn
passing ships about inspections, you can't

just shoot at them.

The Russians can naturally spit on international
laws, but they still need to come in close

to know exactly where the ships are.

This, in turn, will bring the Russian navy
into range of Ukrainian missiles and drones.

The Russian Armed Forces will probably continue
shelling ports in the near future, in the

hope that this will scare the shipowners enough.

However, in the long run, the Russian leadership
faces a number of unpleasant dilemmas.

At the moment everyone is accusing them specifically
of using food as a weapon.

If they send a fleet to enforce the blockade
- they risk losing ships.

If they don't, they look like losers.

Russian Armed Forces are also forced to spend
expensive missiles to destroy grain.

It is possible that the timing of the Crimean
Bridge attack was calculated by Ukraine as

a trap for Russia.

The Ukrainian leadership may have decided
to raise the stakes by pushing through the

expansion of the "grain deal" to other commodities.

From Ukraine's position, the "grain deal"
was a permission for Russia to "blockade at

a discount" where the Russians controlled
the passage of ships through inspections.

And from this position, the Ukrainian leadership
decided to disrupt this partial blockade by

taking advantage of the weakness of the Russian
navy.

What do you think, I look forward to your
options in the comments ? Oh yeah, I almost

forgot, thank you all so much for everyone's
comments under the video before last, I'll

have a little more free time now.