Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
VOICEOVER: We acknowledge the many First Nations across the country
and their elders and knowledge-holders,
who have generously shared their stories
and welcomed us onto their country for this series
and we would like to warn Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander viewers
that the following program may contain
images and voices of deceased persons.
ROB COLLINS: No other survival tool on the planet
begins to compare with the human mind.
With our intelligence, we devise strategies for the future.
We manipulate the environment to suit our needs.
But humans can also destroy the very environment
we rely on for our survival.
In our search for solutions,
we must explore all options.
The knowledge systems created by the first inventors
have sustained my ancestors,
the world's oldest living cultures,
for at least 65,000 years.
But the world we live in today couldn't be any more different.
The survival challenges we face...
..are bigger than ever.
In this episode...
(INDISTINCT CONVERSATION)
..an ancient innovation...
You're looking, probably... Yeah, we've got the fire!
..tackling one of the modern world's greatest problems.
Good fire management essentially halves the emissions from fire.
Half?
Traditional knowledge of Australian plants...
How can you tell what you can't eat?
There's a system.
..helping to create new medicine.
We have got a novel molecule no-one has discovered before.
And was the boomerang...
..the world's first flying machine?
There's so much belief went into this, by my people back home.
So for humanity to survive the next hundred...
..let alone thousands of years into the future,
we're gonna need Indigenous knowledge
and Western science working together.
There's your one for throwing.
There's yours for throwing, there's yours for throwing.
There's yours.
Yeah, that's good.
It's a moment repeated countless times over many thousands of years.
So, your...your shot now.
(SPEAKS INDISTINCTLY)
Ooh, look out.
The boomerang is Australia's most iconic invention.
A masterstroke of design,
using aerodynamic lift to create heavier-than-air flight
and a shape which returns it to the thrower.
Something we've been doing for thousands and thousands of years,
learning how to throw them,
so that skill is never lost.
Uncle Moogy Sumner is a Ngarrindjeri Elder and boomerang expert.
What I'm gonna do here
is I'm gonna draw the flight pattern onto the boomerang here,
so that when you throw it, it'll come round and catch that wind,
because the wind is pushing down and lifting this up.
The Ngarrindjeri have direct links
to the oldest boomerang ever found in Australia.
A 10,000-year-old marvel of human invention.
The boomerang may be ancient
but today, its unique design
is challenging how we think
about one of the greatest inventions of modern science.
MAN: In 1903, on the plains of Kitty Hawk, North Carolina,
this history began.
Since its beginnings in the early 20th century,
flight has changed the world.
Aviation history is written in a never-fading book of records.
We now jet across the planet without a second thought.
The technology that makes it possible
is based on a single, very special innovation...
..the aerofoil.
The streamlined wing slices through the air,
reducing pressure above it
while generating excess pressure
on the underside,
lifting it upward into the air.
Aerofoils are the design behind the wings of jets,
propellers,
engine blades
and helicopter rotors.
But was the first aerofoil invented just over a century ago...
..or thousands of years earlier,
in Australia?
The curvature we've been able to see
does suggest that there is camber there.
At the University of New South Wales,
Dr Sonya Brown and student Ahmed Mahgoub
are analysing the boomerang's aerodynamics
to determine whether it is, in fact,
the world's first aerofoil.
In an aerofoil, it has some characteristics,
so it's round, the leading edge,
and then it becomes more tipped toward the trailing edge.
A cross-section profile of the boomerang
closely resembles the cross-section of an aerofoil or wing.
But does it fly the same way?
The simulations are done and now we have some interesting results.
Red shows pockets of high pressure
as the boomerang rotates.
At the bottom of the boomerang, we have higher pressure,
which is what generates lift.
The rotating flight profile of the boomerang
reveals its aerodynamic properties.
In the outer section of the boomerang,
it's acting very similar to an aerofoil.
Yes.
Pressure distribution almost looks identical to an aerofoil at the tip.
This is actually an amazing fact,
given that these devices were invented thousands of years ago.
It's clear that ancient boomerangs and modern aircraft
share very similar design characteristics.
Maybe we can go from an inboard to an outboard, then.
But more evidence is needed
to prove that the boomerang was the world's first aerofoil.
Uncle Moogy's people, the Ngarrindjeri,
can include in their numbers one of Australia's greatest inventors...
..David Unaipon.
He's the man on our $50 note.
UNCLE MOOGY SUMNER: Uncle David Unaipon is special to us here.
When they talk about inventors,
he was one of the best.
He done things before his time.
Unaipon invented the world's first reciprocating sheep clippers.
Shearing 100 times faster than anything else available at the time,
they completely revolutionised the wool industry
and generated an economic windfall for Australia.
But Unaipon also had other ideas...
..including one that may prove once and for all
that the boomerang was the world's first aerofoil.
Unaipon theorised that two boomerangs working together
could generate vertical take-off -
something never achieved before.
In this newspaper story,
Unaipon was conceptualising the modern helicopter...
..long before the first one was built.
But his grand idea never attracted the support it deserved until now.
OK. This is the lab.
More than a century later,
Uncle Moogy Sumner is determined
to bring David Unaipon's concept to life.
Uncle Moogy, I'd like to introduce our student team.
Hello. Yeah, yeah. G'day.
I'm Justin. Justin, yeah. Moogy.
G'day. I'm Conrad. Nice to meet you.
Natalie. Nice to meet you. Natalie.
ROB COLLINS: Over the next six weeks,
these engineering students
will attempt to build an unmanned aerial vehicle, or UAV,
using boomerangs as propellers.
You know the idea of putting the two together
was done back in 1914?
Oh, wow. And done by Uncle David Unaipon.
Wow. Let's make it come true.
Yeah.
(STUDENTS CHATTER)
We're gonna work with the aerodynamics of the boomerang,
which is similar to that of an aerofoil.
Yep.
Good.
I think one of the biggest challenges
is the fact that the boomerang
could generate quite a lot of vibration.
We're gonna print out a whole bunch.
This one is currently the left-handed boomerang
that we have here.
The students will use eight mini-boomerangs
back to back.
In theory, if our calculations are right,
the drone should generate some lift
and should actually lift above the ground.
Hopefully.
Isabella has a personal investment in the project.
With my Indigenous heritage,
this project kind of makes me a little bit more close to the family,
in a way.
I have thought about the ancient boomerang -
how did they think of this, how did they know that it would fly?
Two weeks in and an early prototype is ready for testing.
OK. We're at 70. I'm so scared of ruining it.
Ooh... Oh, my God. There we go.
No, no, no, no. It's fine. It's fine.
Oh, my God!
No, you're short. Go more.
No, no, no, no, no! It's... Stop. Stop.
Oh!
Oh, no! It ruined it!
The students have four weeks
before the final product will be flown outside,
in real-life conditions.
UNCLE MOOGY: I'm nervous,
because there's so much belief went into this by my people back home.
Everyone knows, back home, what Uncle David done.
Historically, Western science has paid little attention
to traditional knowledge.
But today, as we face new and complex challenges,
this is starting to change.
Australia is home to thousands of plant species
that don't exist anywhere else.
My ancestors harnessed this life-giving resource
and it's this knowledge of medicine
that's bringing modern science and traditional knowledge together
in a union that ultimately benefits all of us.
Aunty Fran Bodkin knows the healing power
of thousands of Australian native plants.
Have a feel of those leaves.
Oh, yeah, they are quite spiky.
Yeah - and that's what we used around our camp fires at night.
Journalist Ben Abbatangelo has been investigating
what secrets may be found in the Australian bush.
I've been wondering - how can you tell what you can and can't eat?
Well...there's a system
and it usually starts with a child when it starts to seek its own food.
Firstly, you rub it on the back of the child's hand.
If there's no reaction there,
you rub on the inside of the elbow
and if there's no reaction there, you can start off on the lips.
And if there's no reaction there,
the kid can have a taste of it, swallow it
and if he doesn't bring it back up again...
Good to go. It's good to go.
Pharmacology professor Gerald Muench
is investigating Aunty Fran's work,
which documents the uses of 11,000 native plants.
So, we basically treat those plants
as a pharmaceutical source of compounds
and we test those plants in our cell culture esters.
We lived here for... how many thousands of years,
and we were healthy.
Gerald hopes this information
will lead to the next major pharmaceutical breakthrough.
So, Ben, let's gown you up.
Here are the lab coats. Gowns on.
Mm-hm. Beautiful.
I must admit, Professor, I was looking forward to this moment.
So, the advantage of having the pharmacopoeia
is we don't have to randomly screen all the plants in Australia
and have a higher hit rate to find active plant samples.
So, the objective is to break down the extract
into individual compounds.
Just cut them in bits and pieces.
So, I'm just cutting these. Does it matter...
Yep, many as you can, and grab a second one
and then I'll make them a bit smaller.
This native water gum is traditionally used
to clear sores and ulcers.
Today, it's hoped the chemical compounds in its leaves
may deliver a powerful remedy for inflammation.
Many of the chronic diseases are linked to chronic inflammation,
so the more people we have, the more is the need for a variety,
for an arsenal of different anti-inflammatory drugs.
We have drugs but we need better ones,
which have less side effects.
This is extract full of leaves.
So, what's happening in this moment now?
Yes. So, we have destroyed all the leaves, all the cells of the leaves.
All the compounds are now leaching out.
Incubated for 18 hours,
the solution will then be tested.
Because this plant has been used by Indigenous Australians
for thousands of years,
these active compounds are known to be safe from dangerous side effects.
Gerald's team has already made a notable discovery.
So, Ben, we have found something very exciting -
a novel molecule no-one has discovered before
and it has anti-inflammatory properties.
So, this is the structure, Ben.
You can see the molecule rotating.
These native gum leaves contain an anti-inflammatory compound,
which may have a range of other uses.
The Aunty Fran Pharmacopoeia
is a treasure-trove for medical knowledge.
Yeah, what a time to be in science here, in medicine.
Absolutely.
Using Western medicine to make the scientific discoveries
based on Indigenous knowledge.
That will bring medicinal chemistry a big step forward.
Around 100 plants in Aunty Fran's book are now being analysed.
Aboriginal knowledge, you know, if you share it,
it's your gift to the future.
Most traditional knowledge can't be found on a bookshelf.
Sometimes we must go farther afield.
Arnhem Land, in Australia's Top End,
is a place where ancient knowledge survives as an unbroken tradition.
Today,
knowledge here is helping tackle one of the world's greatest challenges...
..climate change.
Robert. I'm Robert.
Nice to meet you.
My name is Norrie Martin and this is my home.
I'm T.O. of this country.
And this is where me and my old man live.
He's a Dyungkayi for this area.
Yes. I'm Dyungkayi for this land.
Robert Redford is a senior knowledge holder,
responsible for an area of land
around the same size as Wales in Great Britain.
Rob, what's that word - 'djungkayi'? 'Caretaker'?
Yes. Sort of like a caretaker.
Like a policeman, eh? Yeah.
This is a young one.
We're looking for firesticks, essentially.
I think we found it.
So, one stick has to be harder than the other
and the other one has to be softer, to create that friction.
(INDISTINCT CONVERSATION)
Yeah. You look him, coming up.
Yeah. You can smell it too.
At a glance, this hardly looks like a solution to climate change.
There! We got our fire.
(LAUGHTER)
Wow.
But Robert and his family
run one of the world's most respected carbon-reduction programs.
Mission rolling. Mission rolling, eh?
Roger, mate. Thank you.
This is Robert's son,
Mimal ranger Robert Junior.
And today, he's stopping major wildfires from starting in future.
These rangers are dropping fires across acres of country.
Now, this might seem like the wrong thing to be doing
to combat climate change
but trust me -
these carers of country know exactly what they're doing.
Arnhem Land, Northern Territory.
Alright, Junior. What are we doing?
Well, yeah, we'll be burning along here,
so we can make a new break.
The Mimal Rangers are deploying a traditional innovation
to battle climate change.
So, gonna throw some matches up here.
Yep.
Trees are 50% carbon.
When they burn, that carbon is released into our atmosphere,
increasing global warming.
MAN: Don't go into a room you can't get out of.
The blazes that recently ravaged Australia, California and Europe
released close to a billion tons of carbon into the atmosphere.
That's close to the same output of carbon as Japan in a whole year.
Are you ready there? Let's do it.
Wild bushfires need fuel loads on the ground -
dead trees and grasses.
Yeah. Keep going.
Keep going.
And follow this end here. Follow the edge?
Yeah, follow the edge.
For thousands of years, Indigenous Australians have removed fuel loads
to make their land fire-resistant.
It's a case of fighting fire with fire.
Yeah. Ah.
The innovative technique uses low heat
through a special mosaic pattern.
Trees are left untouched.
I find it amazing, when you do the cold burn...
Yeah, yeah.
..how come it doesn't climb up that tree?
Yeah. So if you do it at the wrong time...
Get really hot.
(SPEAKS INDISTINCTLY) Yeah.
For millennia, this was done with just two sticks.
It's now an industrial-scale operation.
Oh, wow!
Today's burn will create a natural fire break
across 40km of land.
So, how many charges altogether do we have?
These small fire pellets ignite flames,
reducing fuel loads on the ground.
Going through here, yeah.
Yep. So they meet, the fire scars. Yeah, yeah.
The Mimal Rangers deploy this technique
across 18,000 square kilometres,
an area similar in size to a small country.
The Mimal Rangers are paid out of carbon credits.
But just how effective is their work?
So, Ben, where are we headed to today?
I'm gonna show you a historic scientific fire plot,
so, these plots are foundational
to the science that underpins the carbon accounting.
Coordinator of the program Ben Lewis calculates the carbon reduction
by measuring every tree, bit of scrub and even the leaves on the ground.
All the trees alongside the plot are measured,
so we know how much carbon is stored in our trees.
You want to have a go at tree-hugging?
Yeah, please!
Since this program became official 25 years ago,
a massive reduction in wildfires has followed.
So, what's been the end result of all this research?
I mean, how effective has it actually been?
With the accounting method, we can show
that our good fire management
essentially halves the emissions from fire.
Half? Yep.
So we've halved our carbon pollution.
Wow. That's quite significant. Yeah, it's a lot.
Deployed right across Australia,
programs like this could save millions of tons of carbon
from entering the atmosphere.
Which is one of the reasons
why First Nations communities around Australia
are seen as part of the solution.
What I've witnessed here today
is Indigenous knowledge and Western science working together
to deliver the kind of solutions that humanity will come to depend on.
Stuff that's been around for thousands of years.
After this, I'm wondering what else is possible.
After six weeks of trial and error...
..it's the day of reckoning for the unmanned aerial vehicle.
Based on a concept developed by Ngarrindjeri inventor David Unaipon,
the UAV uses boomerangs as propellers.
UNCLE MOOGY SUMNER: Back in 1914,
Uncle David Unaipon, he had that idea.
For Uncle Moogy and the Ngarrindjeri people,
this test flight has very special significance.
I mean, you look at Western science,
of how they looked at us as Aboriginal people, you know?
We were what they considered to be a backward people.
And yet we designed something from a piece of wood,
that you can throw away and it'll come back to you.
The aerodynamics of a piece of wood.
David Unaipon never received financial reward
or proper recognition
for inventing the reciprocating sheep shears.
Today, Uncle Moogy hopes to remind us all of Unaipon's brilliance...
That's what they wanted. Yeah.
..and possibly prove the boomerang was the world's first aerofoil.
It's a big day here today.
Not just for everyone but for the Ngarrindjeri People.
My people, Uncle David's people.
Today, it's gonna come to life again
and this is what we want.
Because of him.
Good.
It's the design that changed the world forever.
It made it possible for us to fly.
But was the aerofoil created
some 10,000 years before modern inventors took to the sky?
I'm nervous.
I'm nervous 'cause there's still lots of things that could go wrong,
so definitely nervous.
Good. Ready?
Oh, oh, oh...
Whoa!
Oh, yeah, low. Low. It's going, it's going!
Oh...oh!
Come on, come on!
Yeah! (STUDENTS CHEER)
(CHEERING CONTINUES)
(LAUGHS) Perfect! Whoo!
Merging modern technology with First Nations ingenuity...
..Unaipon was decades ahead of his time.
Well done. Well done.
And...and...well done, everyone.
Oh, and especially you. Thank you for being here, Moogy.
Thank you, mate. Thank you so much for coming.
Thank you so much.
Oh, good on you!
It made me feel like Uncle David Unaipon,
his dream is coming true.
It made me feel like my blood was rushing through my veins
and to feel him...feel him, it's like feeling his spirit here.
I grew up knowing him.
Watching this makes me feel like
his dreams are coming to life.
And he knows it, because his spirit is here with us.
Today's humble flight is the proof
which backdates the invention of the aerofoil
by at least 10,000 years.
It's definitely demonstrated that, you know,
boomerang technology
can lead to propulsion,
particularly vertically taking off and landing on the ground.
And today's well and truly shown that it does work.
More people are gonna study this, younger people are gonna study it
and bring it to life.
It can only get better from here.
In this series, we've revealed innovations
which aren't found anywhere else in the world...
Where you have a machine being used for 7,000 years.
..the world's most effective memory techniques,
recording events from thousands of years ago...
(SPEAKS INDIGENOUS LANGUAGE)
..maps that exist only in the mind
and are learned through song...
..astronomy...
..complex social organisation...
This is a really optimised system.
..communication systems extending thousands of kilometres...
It's amazing how much information is encoded in these objects.
..and superhighways connecting nations.
We ran 125 billion pathways
through Australia.
Now I'm about to tell you how this is all wrong.
Of course, all the information is correct
but to make this a series accessible to all audiences,
it's been divided up and compartmentalised
into history, society, law, communications and so on -
but that's not how First Nations knowledge functions.
See, in my culture,
everything is connected.
In the Northern Territory,
Elder Yidumduma Bill Harney
is offering curator Tui Raven a glimpse
into how all knowledge interconnects.
So, where are you gonna take me now?
At a sacred site, story and art link to the moon...
..and the moon helps Bill to predict the weather.
In the Northern Territory,
Elder Yidumduma Bill Harney
is offering curator Tui Raven a glimpse
into how all knowledge interconnects.
So, where are you taking me now?
This place is sacred to Bill's people,
the Wardaman.
Gundawa? Gundawa.
At first, this story seems to be just that - a story.
Often misunderstood by outsiders,
Dreaming stories are much more than just a good yarn.
This one actually helps Uncle Bill predict the weather,
by indicating when a storm or rain is coming.
This here is a headdress? Yeah, headdress.
The Moon Spirit wears a headdress...
..a symbol of a very real and well-known natural phenomenon
called moon haloes.
Moon haloes are light refracting
through ice crystals in cirrus clouds.
Cirrus clouds often precipitate storms.
Elders examine the position of the halo to the moon...
..how many stars appear within the halo
and the number of haloes present
to predict atmospheric conditions like storms.
(THUNDER RUMBLES)
This story has taught countless generations of Wardaman people
how to predict rain and storms.
Through spiritual beliefs,
First Nations knowledge connects to the physical world.
You know your lore and you know your country and your songlines
and creation time.
Yeah, yeah. You know your country pretty well.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
You're very sprightly. (BOTH LAUGH)
There's enormous value for us all
in Indigenous knowledge.
But first, there are barriers that are yet to be overcome.
Every single Indigenous person featured in this series
bears the impact of colonisation
and its enduring legacy.
This is...not so long ago.
Still fresh in our minds.
(SOFTLY) Just...two seconds.
They, like me, know
that if Western and traditional knowledge are to work together,
to solve the great challenges we face today...
..we all need to better understand the past.
And it starts with conversations like this one.
Hey, Denise. Hi. How are you?
Good. How are you doing? I'm good.
Welcome to Lake Condah Mission.
Hey, Denise. Hi. How are you?
Good. How are you doing? I'm good.
Welcome to Lake Condah Mission.
On Gunditjmara country,
Tui Raven is learning about the brutal war
waged against Denise Lovett's people.
As to what's happened to my grandmother,
my mother, my great-grandmothers,
my grandfathers...
..what happened to them should never happen to them.
Squatters, who started grazing livestock here in the 1830s,
had scant regard for the traditional owners.
(ANGRY SHOUTING, GUNFIRE)
Violence soon erupted.
It was just greed that was doing it.
They just wanted the land
and they didn't want nothing to do with the people,
so they just killed them.
Gunditjmara warriors resisted the squatters
and fought a frontier war that lasted decades.
Eventually, the Gunditjmara were brutally overpowered.
My great-grandmother Hannah,
she had come on the mission with her mother as a toddler.
They'd come down through, um, Budj Bim.
Her mother, Susanna,
hid her and her brother in the reeds.
'Cause a massacre was happening.
Denise's great-grandmother was among the survivors.
And you think...Gunditjmara country had 59 clans.
59 families that lived across our country from the, um...
..Glenelg River to the Hopkins River,
just the other side of Warrnambool.
Through the massacres and the sicknesses
and killing times,
70 people got to be here at one time.
And, um...the rest never made it.
Survivors were forced to live on Lake Condah Mission.
They made it to here.
Susanna died here at Lake Condah Mission
and Hannah and her brother... grew up here.
Traditional knowledge was banned.
So, this was the building that they put the children into.
That was that separation - break that cultural connection.
Yeah. And that's what was happening here.
Despite the most extraordinary adversity imaginable,
traditional knowledge is now regenerating rapidly.
Today, Denise's son Tyson continues Gunditjmara tradition
by managing country.
I see the opportunities.
I've seen how my children and my nieces and nephews and my community
have grown up and been supported.
So it's their time to do things
that they want to do and achieve their dreams.
There's a tremendous wave of cultural revitalisation
that's coming through
and it's an amazing time to witness that.
MAN: It requires making that reconnection,
getting feet on the ground, connecting with country,
understanding what it needs.
Because of when we were colonised,
a lot of our mob have actually forgotten this
but the thing about this system is that you just need one individual
to know where they fit -
so, for example, that may be, like, my mother,
then you can work out where you fit in the system.
You can reseed the entire system,
so it's robust to disruption and colonialism
and we can get it back - it's all there.
WOMAN: What we find, again and again,
is when we bring our Western science to look at a question,
there's invariably an Indigenous science
that's already been thinking about that, into deep time.
MAN: Our teaching's been passed down
through generations, then generations
and those teachings are to be looking after country,
looking after the environment.
The way forward is together.
And I think it's one great thing about Aboriginal people,
is that we are open to moving forward together.
It's how we marry old science and new science
and we get a future for our... for our kids.
The revival and spread of this knowledge
acts as a great beacon of hope
for all Australians...
..and our shared future on this continent.
But I can't help but feel
that we've only just touched the tip of the iceberg.
There's so much more that this country has to reveal.
I guess we just need to be listening.
Captions by Red Bee Media
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.