All language subtitles for Ukraine On Fire-1-35-44-eng Subs corr1

af Afrikaans
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bn Bengali
bs Bosnian
bg Bulgarian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified) Download
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian Download
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch Download
en English Download
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
tl Filipino
fi Finnish Download
fr French Download
fy Frisian
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek Download
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian Download
ga Irish
it Italian Download
ja Japanese Download
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh Download
km Khmer
ko Korean
ku Kurdish (Kurmanji)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Lao
la Latin
lv Latvian
lt Lithuanian
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
ne Nepali
no Norwegian
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt Portuguese Download
pa Punjabi
ro Romanian
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian Download
st Sesotho
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhala
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish Download
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
te Telugu
th Thai
tr Turkish
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
or Odia (Oriya)
rw Kinyarwanda
tk Turkmen
tt Tatar
ug Uyghur
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:00:02,672 --> 00:00:04,470 warning : cigarette smoking scenes present 2 00:00:07,623 --> 00:00:09,894 narrator: here in Kiev in recent days 3 00:00:09,894 --> 00:00:12,266 the Maidan - the independence square 4 00:00:12,266 --> 00:00:14,413 has turned into a full-scale war zone 5 00:00:16,974 --> 00:00:19,044 more clashes in Ukraine's capital Kiev 6 00:00:27,484 --> 00:00:29,914 there is absolutely no doubt that snipers 7 00:00:30,004 --> 00:00:32,524 are working here. I counted 10 bodies 8 00:00:32,643 --> 00:00:35,207 Viktor Yanukovich: even today we don't know 9 00:00:35,207 --> 00:00:37,518 who shot those people. that is the problem 10 00:00:38,247 --> 00:00:40,476 reporter: now on the brink of civil war 11 00:00:40,476 --> 00:00:42,016 at least 70 dead so far 12 00:00:42,017 --> 00:00:43,717 and the death toll is rising 13 00:00:44,256 --> 00:00:46,867 Vitaliy Zaharchenko: these technologies 14 00:00:46,868 --> 00:00:49,398 I repeat, no country is safe from them 15 00:00:50,338 --> 00:00:52,669 reporter: what we saw here today was a revolution 16 00:00:53,240 --> 00:00:54,758 a scream in the crowd: hail to Ukraine 17 00:00:55,097 --> 00:00:57,021 Putin: want to know what's happening in Ukraine? 18 00:00:57,021 --> 00:01:00,410 Victoria Nuland: we have spent over 5 billion dollars to assist Ukraine 19 00:01:01,784 --> 00:01:03,885 Vitaliy Zaharchenko: in big politics 20 00:01:03,886 --> 00:01:05,796 whatever they're talking about 21 00:01:05,796 --> 00:01:08,046 they are talking about money 22 00:01:08,046 --> 00:01:10,985 Oliver Stone: NATO has expanded by 13 countries 23 00:01:10,984 --> 00:01:13,355 up to the borders of Russia. 13 countries 24 00:01:13,995 --> 00:01:16,566 narrator: the focus has to be not allowing 25 00:01:17,143 --> 00:01:18,802 this crisis to turn into a hot war 26 00:01:19,183 --> 00:01:21,215 between Ukraine and Russia 27 00:01:25,867 --> 00:01:27,671 Viktor Yanukovich: this is a dangerous topic 28 00:01:27,819 --> 00:01:29,513 we're talking about war 29 00:01:29,513 --> 00:01:32,225 no one should feel safe today 30 00:02:38,799 --> 00:02:40,104 narrator: Ukraine 31 00:02:42,512 --> 00:02:44,722 it's an ancient and proud land 32 00:02:46,152 --> 00:02:47,502 with a rich history 33 00:02:48,302 --> 00:02:49,855 filled with much beauty 34 00:02:49,855 --> 00:02:52,705 heroism and sacrifice 35 00:02:55,496 --> 00:02:57,716 Ukraine is a border land 36 00:02:57,716 --> 00:03:00,225 a place where east meets west 37 00:03:01,496 --> 00:03:03,544 this is the flag of Ukraine 38 00:03:03,544 --> 00:03:05,585 the blue represents the sky 39 00:03:06,003 --> 00:03:09,024 the gold is seeming endless fields of wheat 40 00:03:11,900 --> 00:03:14,263 Ukraine is a prize many have sought 41 00:03:16,372 --> 00:03:19,622 and much blood was spilled in a quest to posess it 42 00:03:24,735 --> 00:03:27,933 Ukraine has been the path for the western countries 43 00:03:27,932 --> 00:03:30,572 as they attempted to conquer the east 44 00:03:31,872 --> 00:03:32,944 in world war I 45 00:03:35,698 --> 00:03:37,026 and in world war II 46 00:03:40,781 --> 00:03:43,379 and every time the ukrainian people payed 47 00:03:43,379 --> 00:03:48,359 the highest price for this grand games of power 48 00:03:50,461 --> 00:03:52,924 history doesn't repeat but it surely rhymes 49 00:03:52,925 --> 00:03:55,175 said mark twain 50 00:03:55,764 --> 00:03:58,560 looking closely to the history of Ukraine 51 00:03:58,561 --> 00:04:00,531 one will notice many rhymes 52 00:04:01,950 --> 00:04:04,162 being surrounded by stronger powers 53 00:04:04,162 --> 00:04:07,831 ukrainians needed a lot of cunning to survive 54 00:04:08,442 --> 00:04:10,995 the art they truly mastered in time 55 00:04:10,995 --> 00:04:13,745 was the art of changing sides 56 00:04:14,465 --> 00:04:16,420 In the middle of the 17th century 57 00:04:17,514 --> 00:04:19,730 ukrainian leader Bogdan Khmelnitskiy 58 00:04:20,848 --> 00:04:22,730 broke the peace they made with Poland 59 00:04:23,565 --> 00:04:25,751 and sided with more powerful Russia 60 00:04:27,521 --> 00:04:29,092 just over 50 years later 61 00:04:29,091 --> 00:04:31,461 as the Russian-swedish war was raging 62 00:04:31,461 --> 00:04:34,317 another ukrainian leader Ivan Mazepa 63 00:04:34,317 --> 00:04:37,038 broke the union with Russia and switched sides 64 00:04:37,038 --> 00:04:40,254 joining forces with the swedish invaders 65 00:04:41,485 --> 00:04:43,418 many times ukrainian history 66 00:04:43,418 --> 00:04:45,578 was written by third parties 67 00:04:45,577 --> 00:04:48,880 seeking to keep the gains of the revolution 68 00:04:48,880 --> 00:04:55,450 Russia agreed to the humiliating Brest-Litovsky peace of 1918 69 00:04:55,451 --> 00:04:58,321 which turned Ukraine into a german protectorate 70 00:04:58,488 --> 00:05:00,440 another historical document 71 00:05:00,440 --> 00:05:02,550 that changed the fate of Ukraine 72 00:05:02,550 --> 00:05:05,091 was the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact of 1939 73 00:05:05,860 --> 00:05:08,539 one of many such agreements being signed 74 00:05:08,540 --> 00:05:11,700 between european countries and rising Germany 75 00:05:13,279 --> 00:05:15,460 attempting to protect his nation 76 00:05:15,461 --> 00:05:17,581 from the approaching Nazi threat 77 00:05:17,581 --> 00:05:19,785 Joseph Stalin negotiated a treaty 78 00:05:19,785 --> 00:05:22,105 of non-aggression with Adolf Hitler 79 00:05:22,454 --> 00:05:24,557 while promising each other peace 80 00:05:24,557 --> 00:05:26,778 soviet and german foreign ministers 81 00:05:26,778 --> 00:05:28,456 molotov and ribbentrop 82 00:05:28,456 --> 00:05:30,598 divided the map of eastern Europe splitting it 83 00:05:30,598 --> 00:05:34,348 into german and soviet spheres of influence 84 00:05:37,509 --> 00:05:40,287 as soon as the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact was signed 85 00:05:40,569 --> 00:05:41,847 Poland was split 86 00:05:42,889 --> 00:05:45,078 and in September of 1939 87 00:05:45,077 --> 00:05:47,787 eastern Poland became the western Ukraine 88 00:05:47,788 --> 00:05:50,576 and a part of the family of the soviet republics 89 00:05:50,576 --> 00:05:52,566 and the USSR 90 00:05:57,367 --> 00:05:59,447 but even this bold dividing of land 91 00:05:59,447 --> 00:06:01,507 only delayed the war 92 00:06:01,507 --> 00:06:05,829 Germany broke its promise to the USSR 93 00:06:09,951 --> 00:06:13,742 on June 22nd 1941 Germany invaded the USSR 94 00:06:13,742 --> 00:06:15,973 and launched 'Barbarossa' 95 00:06:15,973 --> 00:06:19,477 the largest military operation in world history 96 00:06:25,129 --> 00:06:26,958 barbarossa was aiming for 97 00:06:26,958 --> 00:06:30,868 Saint-Petersburg, Moscow and Kiev, Ukraine 98 00:06:30,867 --> 00:06:34,327 three destinations of major significance 99 00:06:34,831 --> 00:06:37,943 Ukraine with its rich land and resources 100 00:06:38,430 --> 00:06:40,901 was an important industrial and economic 101 00:06:40,901 --> 00:06:42,694 source for the USSR 102 00:06:42,694 --> 00:06:45,072 to cut it from the soviet union 103 00:06:45,072 --> 00:06:47,362 would be a great success 104 00:06:49,836 --> 00:06:52,115 for most of those in the soviet union 105 00:06:52,115 --> 00:06:53,705 the second world war 106 00:06:53,706 --> 00:06:56,706 was about fighting the invaders of their land 107 00:06:56,706 --> 00:06:58,918 but it wasn't so simple for Ukraine 108 00:06:59,845 --> 00:07:02,930 the truth is Ukraine has never been one country 109 00:07:04,369 --> 00:07:05,701 when world war II began 110 00:07:06,706 --> 00:07:08,883 a large part of western Ukraine 111 00:07:08,882 --> 00:07:11,293 welcomed the german soldiers 112 00:07:11,293 --> 00:07:13,442 as liberators from the recently enforced 113 00:07:13,442 --> 00:07:15,323 soviet rule 114 00:07:15,324 --> 00:07:17,552 and openly collaborated with the germans 115 00:07:18,781 --> 00:07:20,694 true scale of this collaboration 116 00:07:20,694 --> 00:07:23,654 was not announced for many decades after the war 117 00:07:23,654 --> 00:07:25,967 but we now know that whole divisions 118 00:07:25,968 --> 00:07:28,798 and battalions were formed 119 00:07:28,798 --> 00:07:32,759 such as ss galizien, nachtigal and roland 120 00:07:34,752 --> 00:07:37,561 just in the beginning of the war more than 121 00:07:37,560 --> 00:07:39,940 80 thousand people from the galizien region 122 00:07:39,940 --> 00:07:43,930 volunteered for the ss galizien 123 00:07:43,930 --> 00:07:46,725 later known for its extreme cruelty towards 124 00:07:46,725 --> 00:07:49,956 polish, jewish and Russian people 125 00:07:49,956 --> 00:07:52,306 on the territory of Ukraine 126 00:07:53,305 --> 00:07:56,002 members of these military groups came mostly 127 00:07:56,002 --> 00:07:58,512 from organization of ukrainian nationalists 128 00:07:58,512 --> 00:07:59,983 the OUN 129 00:07:59,983 --> 00:08:01,682 founded in 1929 130 00:08:01,682 --> 00:08:04,392 this organization had the ultimate goal 131 00:08:04,392 --> 00:08:06,942 of an ethnically pure Ukraine 132 00:08:06,942 --> 00:08:09,574 and considered terror as acceptable measure 133 00:08:09,574 --> 00:08:12,064 for achieving their ends 134 00:08:12,634 --> 00:08:14,834 their official flag was black and red 135 00:08:14,834 --> 00:08:16,894 land and blood 136 00:08:16,894 --> 00:08:19,373 it will remain in Ukraine's history long after 137 00:08:19,374 --> 00:08:22,084 the OUN ceases to exist 138 00:08:22,084 --> 00:08:23,670 in early 1940 139 00:08:23,670 --> 00:08:27,900 the organization of ukrainian nationalists 140 00:08:27,899 --> 00:08:30,039 got its own leader - Stepan Bandera 141 00:08:30,040 --> 00:08:32,769 [for Ukraine, for freedom, for honor, for glory] 142 00:08:32,769 --> 00:08:34,606 severely anti-semitic and anti-communist 143 00:08:34,606 --> 00:08:38,206 he proclaimed a free Ukraine in 1941 144 00:08:40,136 --> 00:08:43,148 his german allies found such an act of self-will 145 00:08:43,149 --> 00:08:45,068 unacceptable and they put him in prison 146 00:08:45,068 --> 00:08:47,788 for nearly all 2nd world war 147 00:08:47,788 --> 00:08:50,240 not participating in person Bandera still 148 00:08:50,240 --> 00:08:54,941 managed to successfully spread his ideology 149 00:08:54,941 --> 00:08:57,575 many independent historians state that 150 00:08:57,575 --> 00:09:00,025 the OUN militia exterminated from 150 151 00:09:00,024 --> 00:09:02,554 to 200 thousand jews 152 00:09:02,554 --> 00:09:05,389 on the ukrainian territory occupied by germans 153 00:09:05,389 --> 00:09:07,949 by the end of 1941 154 00:09:12,750 --> 00:09:15,730 the most notorious and outrageous massacre 155 00:09:15,730 --> 00:09:18,730 took place on September 29 of 1941 156 00:09:18,730 --> 00:09:21,570 in Бабий Яр, Kiev 157 00:09:23,129 --> 00:09:25,528 all kikes of the city of Kiev and its vicinity 158 00:09:25,528 --> 00:09:28,198 must appear on monday, September 29 159 00:09:28,198 --> 00:09:30,108 by 8 o'clock in the morning 160 00:09:32,369 --> 00:09:35,211 bring documents, money and valuables 161 00:09:35,211 --> 00:09:38,192 and also hand clothing, linen, etc 162 00:09:39,182 --> 00:09:41,596 any kikes who do not follow this order 163 00:09:41,596 --> 00:09:45,015 and are found elsewhere will be shot 164 00:09:45,485 --> 00:09:48,660 33.771 jews were killed by the Nazis 165 00:09:48,660 --> 00:09:53,620 and the ukrainian militia 166 00:09:55,071 --> 00:09:57,965 another outrageous massacre was carried out 167 00:09:57,965 --> 00:10:01,475 by the ukrainian rebels army and the OUN 168 00:10:01,475 --> 00:10:03,670 it happened on the territory of 169 00:10:03,669 --> 00:10:05,849 the german occupied polish wolyn 170 00:10:05,850 --> 00:10:11,610 and eastern galicia in 1943 and 1944 171 00:10:12,509 --> 00:10:17,207 this genocide of poles was lead by mикола Лебідь 172 00:10:17,207 --> 00:10:20,947 35 to 60 thousand people in wolyn and 173 00:10:20,947 --> 00:10:24,168 25 to 40 thousand people in eastern galicia 174 00:10:24,168 --> 00:10:26,272 became the victims of this massive 175 00:10:26,272 --> 00:10:28,272 ethnic cleansing operation 176 00:10:28,731 --> 00:10:31,204 sensing the inevitable loss of the german troops 177 00:10:31,703 --> 00:10:35,464 the OUN betrayed its former ally 178 00:10:35,465 --> 00:10:41,425 and began fighting against german and soviet forces 179 00:10:42,735 --> 00:10:44,741 in January of 1943 180 00:10:44,741 --> 00:10:48,261 the USSR army began pushing back the german troops 181 00:10:48,261 --> 00:10:51,691 liberating one part of Ukraine after another 182 00:10:52,511 --> 00:10:56,265 western Ukraine was the region held by the germans the longest 183 00:10:56,265 --> 00:11:00,775 and was finally liberated on October of 1944 184 00:11:02,735 --> 00:11:05,797 Bandera's gangs continued their guerrilla war 185 00:11:05,797 --> 00:11:08,797 against soviets, carrying out bloody attacks 186 00:11:08,797 --> 00:11:11,338 on ukrainian villages and towns 187 00:11:11,854 --> 00:11:15,218 leaving chaos and victims among civilians 188 00:11:15,533 --> 00:11:18,782 this war went on till the mid 1950s 189 00:11:18,782 --> 00:11:21,772 when the last collaborators were eliminated 190 00:11:21,772 --> 00:11:24,442 or fled the country 191 00:11:25,532 --> 00:11:27,634 on May 7 of 1945 192 00:11:27,634 --> 00:11:30,332 Germany unconditionally surrendered 193 00:11:30,332 --> 00:11:32,962 and Ukraine remained a part of the USSR 194 00:11:38,503 --> 00:11:41,774 peace after the second world war was short-lived 195 00:11:45,636 --> 00:11:47,964 the USA and the USSR 196 00:11:48,186 --> 00:11:50,312 nations who allied together 197 00:11:50,312 --> 00:11:52,461 along with england against the Nazis 198 00:11:52,461 --> 00:11:54,341 later tragically became foes 199 00:11:54,341 --> 00:11:56,052 as the cold war began 200 00:11:59,881 --> 00:12:02,386 the era of political and military tension 201 00:12:02,386 --> 00:12:04,446 between the USA and the USSR 202 00:12:04,447 --> 00:12:06,147 lasted for nearly 45 years 203 00:12:06,147 --> 00:12:09,936 keeping humanity under constant threat 204 00:12:09,936 --> 00:12:11,706 of nuclear war. 205 00:12:17,958 --> 00:12:20,232 in this battle the USA never took its 206 00:12:20,232 --> 00:12:22,842 sights off Ukraine because of its importance 207 00:12:24,072 --> 00:12:26,596 US intelligences were closely cooperating 208 00:12:26,596 --> 00:12:29,206 with ukrainian nationalistic organizations 209 00:12:29,206 --> 00:12:31,780 as a valuable source of counter-intelligence 210 00:12:31,780 --> 00:12:33,950 against the USSR 211 00:12:34,292 --> 00:12:37,413 cia documents just recently declassified 212 00:12:37,413 --> 00:12:40,305 show strong ties between US intelligence 213 00:12:40,304 --> 00:12:44,544 and ukrainian nationalists since 1946 214 00:12:45,488 --> 00:12:47,920 from the cia reports it's obvious that 215 00:12:48,144 --> 00:12:50,837 they weren't mistaken about the ukrainian nationalists 216 00:12:50,961 --> 00:12:52,568 and Stepan Bandera 217 00:12:54,486 --> 00:12:58,522 according to the oss report of September 1945 218 00:12:59,066 --> 00:13:01,742 Bandera had earned a fierce reputation 219 00:13:01,922 --> 00:13:04,144 for conducting a reign of terror 220 00:13:04,195 --> 00:13:05,600 during world war II 221 00:13:06,078 --> 00:13:08,003 after the second world war 222 00:13:08,004 --> 00:13:10,293 Bandera and other nationalist leaders 223 00:13:10,293 --> 00:13:12,824 fled to Europe where the cia covered them 224 00:13:13,549 --> 00:13:16,000 the cia later informed the immigration 225 00:13:16,000 --> 00:13:18,671 and naturalization service it had concealed 226 00:13:18,671 --> 00:13:21,819 Stepan Bandera and other ukrainians from soviets 227 00:13:23,927 --> 00:13:26,066 the operations involving ukrainians 228 00:13:26,066 --> 00:13:27,677 continued for many years 229 00:13:27,857 --> 00:13:31,291 the nurenberg trials of 1945 and 1946 230 00:13:31,292 --> 00:13:34,152 had put the political, economic and military 231 00:13:34,152 --> 00:13:36,879 leaders of fascist Germany to justice 232 00:13:36,879 --> 00:13:40,057 showing the whole world the face of nazism 233 00:13:40,057 --> 00:13:42,471 and the crimes they committed 234 00:13:42,606 --> 00:13:46,026 but the ukrainian Nazis were spared of such fate 235 00:13:46,027 --> 00:13:48,778 and some were even granted amnesty by the CIA 236 00:13:49,427 --> 00:13:52,509 by 1951 the agency excused the illegal 237 00:13:52,509 --> 00:13:54,743 activities of oun's security branch 238 00:13:54,743 --> 00:13:57,833 in the name of cold war necessity 239 00:13:58,243 --> 00:14:01,207 in 1949 mикола Лебідь, the man responsible 240 00:14:01,206 --> 00:14:03,539 for the mass massacres in wolyn 241 00:14:03,539 --> 00:14:07,170 was moved to the USA where he died in 1989 242 00:14:07,330 --> 00:14:10,355 without ever being investigated for his crimes 243 00:14:12,135 --> 00:14:15,226 protecting the ukrainian nationalist mикола Лебідь 244 00:14:15,269 --> 00:14:18,440 the CIA stopped criminal investigation of the 245 00:14:18,495 --> 00:14:21,145 immigration and naturalization service 246 00:14:22,291 --> 00:14:24,890 perhaps Bandera lost his use to the USA 247 00:14:24,889 --> 00:14:27,458 or maybe the KGB agency outplayed the CIA 248 00:14:27,458 --> 00:14:30,407 but in 1959 Stepan Bandera was killed in munich 249 00:14:30,408 --> 00:14:35,577 where he was hiding under the name of Stepan popel 250 00:14:36,985 --> 00:14:39,331 i0t's fair to say that by sheer coincidence 251 00:14:39,331 --> 00:14:41,503 Bandera became the main symbol of 252 00:14:41,791 --> 00:14:43,842 ukrainian nationalism because he wasn't neither 253 00:14:44,101 --> 00:14:46,889 its only nor its most powerful leader 254 00:14:48,371 --> 00:14:50,093 dmitriy dontsov was the father of the far right 255 00:14:50,366 --> 00:14:51,858 totalitarian doctrine in Ukraine 256 00:14:51,859 --> 00:14:56,062 andriy melnik the leader of another fraction of the oun 257 00:14:56,062 --> 00:15:00,193 roman shuhevich the leader of the ukrainian rebel's army 258 00:15:00,475 --> 00:15:02,333 and many others 259 00:15:02,683 --> 00:15:04,583 Bandera's dangerous ideology 260 00:15:04,583 --> 00:15:06,798 suppressed by the soviet government 261 00:15:06,798 --> 00:15:09,217 but supported by external forces 262 00:15:09,217 --> 00:15:11,094 was never completely eliminated 263 00:15:11,460 --> 00:15:13,586 the seeds of ukrainian nationalism 264 00:15:13,586 --> 00:15:16,129 were passed from generation to generation 265 00:15:16,142 --> 00:15:18,894 unfortunately not many years had gone by 266 00:15:18,894 --> 00:15:21,114 before they once again grew 267 00:15:21,274 --> 00:15:24,850 in 1954 Ukraine's territory was expanded once more 268 00:15:24,850 --> 00:15:27,869 when nikita khrushev, leader of the USSR 269 00:15:27,869 --> 00:15:29,963 and an ukrainian himself 270 00:15:29,962 --> 00:15:33,351 generously gave the crimean region to Ukraine 271 00:15:34,346 --> 00:15:37,167 historians will debate for many years 272 00:15:37,167 --> 00:15:40,173 about this being legal and 60 years later 273 00:15:40,643 --> 00:15:42,827 another series of dramatic events 274 00:15:42,827 --> 00:15:44,837 were taking place in crimea 275 00:15:44,837 --> 00:15:47,384 reporter: the eyes of the world are on Ukraine 276 00:15:47,640 --> 00:15:49,783 as the crisis in crimea continues 277 00:15:49,926 --> 00:15:52,376 several dozens of well armed people 278 00:15:52,375 --> 00:15:55,275 have captured the government in crimea 279 00:15:55,365 --> 00:15:57,552 should Ukraine just shrug its shoulders 280 00:15:57,552 --> 00:15:59,644 and say 'ok, crimea is lost'? 281 00:15:59,730 --> 00:16:02,797 narrator: the old argument would repeat once again 282 00:16:05,567 --> 00:16:08,221 the cold war was going up and down 283 00:16:08,221 --> 00:16:11,530 while both rivals were obsessed 284 00:16:11,530 --> 00:16:14,802 with growing their military capacity 285 00:16:14,802 --> 00:16:19,001 the turning point came with the Perestroyka 286 00:16:19,001 --> 00:16:21,952 when the USSR got its new leader 287 00:16:21,952 --> 00:16:24,817 Michael Gorbachev, in the middle of 1980 288 00:16:24,817 --> 00:16:27,419 Perestroyka means restructuring towards 289 00:16:27,419 --> 00:16:30,021 democratization and modernization 290 00:16:30,022 --> 00:16:32,155 it certainly had a positive impact 291 00:16:32,154 --> 00:16:34,040 on the international situation 292 00:16:34,140 --> 00:16:36,697 reporter: astonishing news from Berlin 293 00:16:36,697 --> 00:16:39,135 where the german authorities announced 294 00:16:39,135 --> 00:16:42,065 that the Berlin wall doesn't mean anything anymore 295 00:16:46,096 --> 00:16:48,096 narrator: but inside the USSR 296 00:16:48,096 --> 00:16:51,260 the weakening of the Kremlin control had different consequences 297 00:16:51,673 --> 00:16:54,590 the ukrainian nationalistic political organization 298 00:16:54,610 --> 00:16:57,893 called Narodniy Ruh or the National Movement 299 00:16:57,893 --> 00:17:00,992 was established in 1989 300 00:17:00,991 --> 00:17:03,871 Viacheslav Chernovol: I congratulate all of us in this 301 00:17:03,871 --> 00:17:06,830 remarkable event, the creation of our movement 302 00:17:06,830 --> 00:17:09,899 narrator: they advocated for independence of Ukraine 303 00:17:09,900 --> 00:17:12,791 from the USSR and became the starting point 304 00:17:12,790 --> 00:17:15,080 for many of the ukrainian nationalistic 305 00:17:15,080 --> 00:17:16,750 and neo-Nazi leaders 306 00:17:16,750 --> 00:17:19,282 in 1991 one of them, oleg tyagnibok 307 00:17:19,282 --> 00:17:22,282 founded 'cвобода' 308 00:17:22,282 --> 00:17:24,966 or 'freedom' radical nationalistic party 309 00:17:24,967 --> 00:17:28,416 openly following the good old principles of Bandera 310 00:17:28,415 --> 00:17:32,120 oleg tyagnibok: they were prepared and fought against Russians 311 00:17:32,121 --> 00:17:35,242 fought against germans, fought against kikes 312 00:17:35,241 --> 00:17:39,711 and all other scum trying to take our ukrainian country from us 313 00:17:39,993 --> 00:17:42,933 narrator: purge Ukraine from jews and Russians 314 00:17:42,933 --> 00:17:45,962 Ukraine for ukrainians and so on 315 00:17:45,962 --> 00:17:48,450 these statements got him the 5th place 316 00:17:48,450 --> 00:17:51,196 on the list of top 10 anti-semites in the world 317 00:17:51,195 --> 00:17:54,105 according to the simon wiesenthal center 318 00:17:54,105 --> 00:17:56,473 oleg tyagnibok: hail to Ukraine crowd: hail to the heroes 319 00:17:56,473 --> 00:18:00,463 narrator: sadly such statements attracted numerous followers 320 00:18:00,463 --> 00:18:05,192 dmitriy yarosh founded another extreme right organization 321 00:18:05,192 --> 00:18:08,511 'tризуб' or 'trident' in 1994 322 00:18:09,761 --> 00:18:14,821 in April of 2013 yarosh became the assistant to a deputy from “udar” 323 00:18:14,821 --> 00:18:18,831 or strike party lead by vitaly klitchko 324 00:18:18,832 --> 00:18:23,162 later that year he founded another far right ukrainian neo-Nazi group 325 00:18:23,162 --> 00:18:25,231 the right sector 326 00:18:27,491 --> 00:18:31,791 andriy parubiy would soon lead the whole army 327 00:18:31,791 --> 00:18:34,261 of the ultra-nationalistic warriors 328 00:18:34,261 --> 00:18:36,945 and the torch marches will once again 329 00:18:36,945 --> 00:18:39,646 lighting the streets of ukrainian cities 330 00:18:39,646 --> 00:18:41,297 [heroes never die] 331 00:18:55,423 --> 00:18:58,336 the world drastically changed in August of 1991 332 00:18:59,646 --> 00:19:02,436 when the USSR de-facto ceased to exist 333 00:19:02,527 --> 00:19:06,612 and many new political formations appeared on the world map 334 00:19:06,612 --> 00:19:08,402 Ukraine one of them 335 00:19:08,402 --> 00:19:10,882 for the first time in modern history 336 00:19:10,882 --> 00:19:13,741 it was truly independent and all on itself 337 00:19:19,925 --> 00:19:22,321 reporter: the red flag above the Kremlin 338 00:19:22,321 --> 00:19:25,441 came down today when president Горбачёв resigned 339 00:19:25,442 --> 00:19:28,162 ending 70 years of communist rule in the USSR 340 00:19:29,946 --> 00:19:32,849 narrator: the years after the fall of the USSR 341 00:19:32,849 --> 00:19:35,658 were known as crazy 90s on all 342 00:19:35,659 --> 00:19:37,778 post-soviet territories 343 00:19:39,317 --> 00:19:42,479 reporter: he's leaving behind 15 individual states 344 00:19:42,479 --> 00:19:44,946 that share only a disaster economy 345 00:19:44,945 --> 00:19:46,909 and an uncertain future 346 00:19:47,339 --> 00:19:50,324 narrator: after the planned economy of the USSR 347 00:19:50,325 --> 00:19:53,448 the free market changed the rules of the game 348 00:19:53,448 --> 00:19:55,537 new businesses emerged quickly 349 00:19:55,537 --> 00:19:57,757 and soon the first oligarchs appeared 350 00:19:57,757 --> 00:20:00,297 a former country without class division 351 00:20:00,467 --> 00:20:02,617 became divided into unequal parts 352 00:20:02,757 --> 00:20:04,667 a few chosen ones became rich 353 00:20:04,777 --> 00:20:07,557 while the rest had to fight to survive 354 00:20:09,776 --> 00:20:14,115 Putin: right after gaining independence 355 00:20:14,568 --> 00:20:18,759 a wild privatization of the state property began 356 00:20:19,614 --> 00:20:23,784 lowering the life quality of the people 357 00:20:24,483 --> 00:20:28,603 right after the independence 358 00:20:29,229 --> 00:20:33,409 and what is interesting, whoever was coming to power 359 00:20:33,962 --> 00:20:36,702 nothing changed for the people 360 00:20:36,702 --> 00:20:40,153 a constant robbery of the people was happening 361 00:20:40,153 --> 00:20:42,822 a constant robbery of the ukrainian people 362 00:20:42,821 --> 00:20:45,411 of course the people grew tired of this 363 00:20:45,412 --> 00:20:47,102 of this growing corruption 364 00:20:47,547 --> 00:20:50,133 narrator: the disappointment of the people 365 00:20:50,133 --> 00:20:52,605 made Ukraine vulnerable to outside forces 366 00:20:52,605 --> 00:20:55,605 and soon people were to know the new kind of war 367 00:20:55,605 --> 00:20:58,704 one had never known before - the color revolutions 368 00:21:01,855 --> 00:21:04,874 reporter: the protesters are confronting the police 369 00:21:04,874 --> 00:21:08,004 while the result of the elections are being questioned 370 00:21:08,003 --> 00:21:10,303 and they are calling for a new vote 371 00:21:11,623 --> 00:21:14,090 narrator: for 24 years of its independence 372 00:21:14,089 --> 00:21:16,173 Ukraine got through 2 revolutions 373 00:21:16,173 --> 00:21:19,132 in 2004 people came on the streets of Kiev 374 00:21:19,132 --> 00:21:22,991 and started the orange revolution 375 00:21:25,191 --> 00:21:29,517 at that time Ukraine once again became the battlefield of two forces 376 00:21:29,517 --> 00:21:32,178 Russia and western countries 377 00:21:32,178 --> 00:21:37,648 the confrontation reached its peak during the presidential election of 2004 378 00:21:39,923 --> 00:21:42,055 two major candidates 379 00:21:42,055 --> 00:21:44,111 western-backed Viktor Ushenko 380 00:21:44,111 --> 00:21:46,676 and Russia-oriented Viktor Yanukovich 381 00:21:46,675 --> 00:21:49,932 almost equally shared the votes of the ukrainian people 382 00:21:49,932 --> 00:21:53,076 by the way - calling Viktor Ushenko western-backed 383 00:21:53,076 --> 00:21:54,891 was not an exaggeration 384 00:21:54,891 --> 00:21:57,125 his wife - kатерина Viktor Ushenko 385 00:21:57,125 --> 00:21:59,413 is a former US state department official 386 00:21:59,413 --> 00:22:02,893 and worked in the white house during Reagan's administration 387 00:22:03,297 --> 00:22:06,084 the votes were split in a geographic principle 388 00:22:06,084 --> 00:22:08,523 traditionally pro-Russia eastern Ukraine 389 00:22:08,522 --> 00:22:10,355 voted for Viktor Yanukovich 390 00:22:10,355 --> 00:22:13,404 while western Ukraine voted for Viktor Ushenko 391 00:22:13,728 --> 00:22:15,567 by the announced results 392 00:22:15,567 --> 00:22:17,957 Viktor Ushenko lost to Viktor Yanukovich 393 00:22:18,046 --> 00:22:20,823 but thousands of people didn't agree with that 394 00:22:20,823 --> 00:22:23,048 and came to the central square of Kiev 395 00:22:23,048 --> 00:22:24,853 on November 22nd of 2004 396 00:22:24,992 --> 00:22:27,842 the situation got wide press coverage 397 00:22:28,651 --> 00:22:31,465 reporter: the government election commission 398 00:22:31,464 --> 00:22:35,494 ignored the fraud accusations and declared Viktor Yanukovich president 399 00:22:35,542 --> 00:22:37,865 narrator: the international politicians 400 00:22:37,865 --> 00:22:40,519 such as former secretary of NATO javier solana 401 00:22:40,519 --> 00:22:42,471 became frequent guests in Kiev 402 00:22:42,471 --> 00:22:45,821 initiating negotiations between the parties 403 00:22:46,347 --> 00:22:48,975 javier solana: i'm hoping that together 404 00:22:48,976 --> 00:22:51,676 we can overcome these difficulties 405 00:22:52,385 --> 00:22:54,924 narrator: the results of the negotiations 406 00:22:54,924 --> 00:22:57,080 were often reached only on paper 407 00:22:57,080 --> 00:23:00,105 for example Viktor Ushenko never told his supporters 408 00:23:00,115 --> 00:23:03,695 to stop blocking the government institutions in the center of Kiev 409 00:23:03,898 --> 00:23:08,618 therefore these non-violent protests lasted for a month 410 00:23:08,833 --> 00:23:12,601 during which the result of the previous election were canceled 411 00:23:12,601 --> 00:23:16,231 and new elections were announced 412 00:23:16,665 --> 00:23:18,256 the important nuance 413 00:23:18,257 --> 00:23:19,705 just 3 months before 414 00:23:19,704 --> 00:23:21,891 Viktor Ushenko suffered a mysterious 415 00:23:21,892 --> 00:23:24,192 still unsolved poisoning 416 00:23:24,848 --> 00:23:26,500 but it didn't prevent him 417 00:23:26,500 --> 00:23:28,420 from winning the new election 418 00:23:28,769 --> 00:23:30,885 but as we shall soon see 419 00:23:30,885 --> 00:23:32,803 there was much more than just 420 00:23:32,804 --> 00:23:34,844 the people's will to this victory 421 00:23:34,844 --> 00:23:37,317 this peaceful revolution and its leaders 422 00:23:37,317 --> 00:23:40,636 were warmly welcomed by the international community 423 00:23:41,442 --> 00:23:43,407 but the euphoria didn't last long 424 00:23:43,407 --> 00:23:46,155 Viktor Ushenko's government failed the reforms 425 00:23:46,155 --> 00:23:48,688 and lost its chance to establish democracy 426 00:23:48,689 --> 00:23:51,396 instead of setting into internal fighting 427 00:23:51,395 --> 00:23:54,651 Viktor Ushenko was not reelected for a second term 428 00:23:54,651 --> 00:23:56,871 but in the end of his presidency 429 00:23:56,871 --> 00:23:58,913 he had time to give one last gift 430 00:23:58,913 --> 00:24:01,443 to his supporters from western Ukraine 431 00:24:01,923 --> 00:24:06,042 Ushenko: in conclusion I would like to say 432 00:24:06,176 --> 00:24:10,236 something that is long awaited 433 00:24:10,496 --> 00:24:14,636 by the ukrainian patriots for many years 434 00:24:15,001 --> 00:24:19,061 I have signed a decree 435 00:24:19,819 --> 00:24:23,230 for the unbroken spirit 436 00:24:24,029 --> 00:24:26,369 and standing for the idea 437 00:24:27,000 --> 00:24:29,490 of fighting for independent Ukraine 438 00:24:30,700 --> 00:24:32,690 I declare Stepan Bandera 439 00:24:32,690 --> 00:24:34,570 a national hero of Ukraine 440 00:24:34,569 --> 00:24:36,009 hail to Ukraine 441 00:24:38,365 --> 00:24:41,724 narrator: the hero status of Stepan Bandera was short-lived 442 00:24:42,125 --> 00:24:46,086 in 2010 Viktor Yanukovich was elected president 443 00:24:46,161 --> 00:24:49,270 and this time the international community 444 00:24:49,313 --> 00:24:52,323 had no doubts about the legitimacy of the elections 445 00:24:52,596 --> 00:24:57,496 in January 2011 Viktor Yanukovich repealed the hero title of Bandera 446 00:24:59,476 --> 00:25:02,493 and after almost 4 years of his presidency 447 00:25:02,492 --> 00:25:04,792 another revolution shook Ukraine 448 00:25:05,358 --> 00:25:08,818 unfortunately this one was anything but peaceful 449 00:25:21,491 --> 00:25:24,136 Oliver Stone: Mr. Yanukovich, I am an american 450 00:25:24,136 --> 00:25:27,517 i'm an outsider in this situation and it's very complicated 451 00:25:28,288 --> 00:25:31,453 but I would like, as a filmmaker 452 00:25:31,453 --> 00:25:33,525 to just jump into the action 453 00:25:33,526 --> 00:25:38,202 and go to those moments in November 2013 454 00:25:38,202 --> 00:25:42,430 you're president of Ukraine, been president for 3 years 455 00:25:42,430 --> 00:25:45,767 at this point the country is in a bad economic shape 456 00:25:45,767 --> 00:25:48,678 you have a trade agreement with Russia and now 457 00:25:48,678 --> 00:25:54,828 you're seeking making a better agreement with EU and you're negotiating 458 00:25:55,181 --> 00:25:58,411 can you tell me at that moment what you were thinking? 459 00:25:58,891 --> 00:26:02,531 Yanukovich: this was truly a very complicated period for Ukraine 460 00:26:02,932 --> 00:26:07,221 and wee needed to find a solution for the problems of 2013 461 00:26:07,674 --> 00:26:10,013 so we had 2 partners first of all 462 00:26:10,013 --> 00:26:15,803 we were relying on the international monetary found 463 00:26:15,895 --> 00:26:20,286 but the IMF for a year of negotiations was proposing US options that were unacceptable 464 00:26:20,914 --> 00:26:25,434 a significant rise of energy resources prices for the people, natural gas first of all 465 00:26:26,153 --> 00:26:29,190 that meant a significant rise of the people's expenses 466 00:26:30,160 --> 00:26:34,410 while their income would stay at the same level 467 00:26:35,393 --> 00:26:40,229 we wouldn't agree with that 468 00:26:40,989 --> 00:26:46,169 we proposed another option and we officially got rejected by the IMF in November of 2013 469 00:26:48,259 --> 00:26:51,990 the other option was Russia 470 00:26:58,849 --> 00:27:06,009 Russia said - we're ready to work with you as partners 471 00:27:07,188 --> 00:27:11,628 if you take our interests in consideration 472 00:27:13,138 --> 00:27:16,938 Putin: because the economy of Russia and Ukraine 473 00:27:18,640 --> 00:27:21,610 were established as one 474 00:27:22,234 --> 00:27:26,294 absolutely unique economical relations were born 475 00:27:27,538 --> 00:27:31,647 the Russian market was completely open for ukrainian 476 00:27:32,579 --> 00:27:36,669 products and our customs border with Ukraine is completely open 477 00:27:37,588 --> 00:27:41,678 in that way the EU would enter our market with its products without any negotiations 478 00:27:41,810 --> 00:27:45,130 Yanukovich: and so when we began calculating the balances 479 00:27:45,223 --> 00:27:49,673 we saw the agreement prepared by the EU for Ukraine 480 00:27:50,089 --> 00:27:54,250 requires a lot of economic efforts and losses 481 00:27:55,166 --> 00:27:59,297 and the EU wouldn't compensate any of it 482 00:28:01,872 --> 00:28:06,042 and the Russian market would drastically reduce 483 00:28:08,042 --> 00:28:11,992 Putin: we said - of course, if Ukraine decided to do that 484 00:28:11,992 --> 00:28:15,071 than it's their decision and we respect it 485 00:28:15,071 --> 00:28:17,551 but we mustn't be the ones to pay for it 486 00:28:19,721 --> 00:28:22,511 Yanukovich: our negotiations with the eu 487 00:28:22,902 --> 00:28:24,862 didn't succeed and that's why 488 00:28:25,172 --> 00:28:28,172 we proposed to make a break 489 00:28:30,928 --> 00:28:33,558 reporter: violent clashes are happening in Kiev 490 00:28:33,557 --> 00:28:36,715 where about 100 thousand people came on the streets 491 00:28:36,715 --> 00:28:39,245 to protest against the government's decision 492 00:28:39,246 --> 00:28:42,426 to delay the signing of the association agreement with eu 493 00:28:43,413 --> 00:28:46,586 Oliver Stone: Vitaliy, you were the minister of inner affairs 494 00:28:46,586 --> 00:28:48,227 of Ukraine in that period 495 00:28:48,227 --> 00:28:51,406 so basically you were the head of Ukraine's police 496 00:28:51,405 --> 00:28:55,745 so tell me your vision on the protests happened in November through February 497 00:28:56,722 --> 00:28:59,913 Vitaliy Zaharchenko: we had the information 498 00:29:00,301 --> 00:29:04,121 that these mass protests were being planned anyway 499 00:29:04,301 --> 00:29:08,391 and they were to start in 2015 500 00:29:08,507 --> 00:29:12,071 but the opposition used the fact 501 00:29:12,070 --> 00:29:14,778 that the government decided to delay 502 00:29:14,778 --> 00:29:17,617 the signing of the association agreement with eu 503 00:29:18,044 --> 00:29:19,903 narrator: arseniy yatsenuk 504 00:29:19,903 --> 00:29:22,819 the leader of the opposition block “the fatherland” 505 00:29:22,849 --> 00:29:25,659 oleg tyagnibok, the leader of the oppositional 506 00:29:25,720 --> 00:29:27,740 far right radical party “cвобода” 507 00:29:28,082 --> 00:29:31,332 Vitaliy klitchko, the leader of the opposition party “udar” 508 00:29:31,805 --> 00:29:33,210 reporter: on thursday 509 00:29:33,210 --> 00:29:35,326 leaders of the EU and Ukraine stated 510 00:29:35,326 --> 00:29:38,186 that the negotiation on the association agreement 511 00:29:38,186 --> 00:29:40,630 can be resumed after the 2 day consulting 512 00:29:40,631 --> 00:29:43,561 but now the association agreement is of the table 513 00:29:43,663 --> 00:29:46,544 angela merkel: we expected more from you 514 00:29:49,536 --> 00:29:52,546 Yanukovich: I want you to hear me 515 00:29:52,665 --> 00:29:57,046 3 and a half years i've been working on this question 1 on 1 with strong Russia 516 00:30:02,298 --> 00:30:05,877 reporter: pro-EU protests on the streets of Kiev enter the 2nd day 517 00:30:06,162 --> 00:30:09,792 the protesters are now joined by the leader of the opposition 518 00:30:10,073 --> 00:30:12,812 ukranian world boxing champion Vitaliy klitchko 519 00:30:12,811 --> 00:30:16,545 he called the protesters to maintain pressure on the government 520 00:30:16,546 --> 00:30:19,776 after it's refusal to sign a major trade deal with eu 521 00:30:20,423 --> 00:30:22,426 Oliver Stone: you go back to Kiev the next day 522 00:30:22,426 --> 00:30:24,312 after the interview with merkel 523 00:30:24,313 --> 00:30:25,953 and protests are on, am I right? 524 00:30:25,952 --> 00:30:27,962 can you tell me about that period? 525 00:30:27,962 --> 00:30:30,730 Yanukovich: in the beginning of this 526 00:30:31,044 --> 00:30:34,324 I had an understanding that these are peaceful actions 527 00:30:34,471 --> 00:30:37,566 and you can negotiate with peaceful protesters 528 00:30:38,135 --> 00:30:40,925 and I was willing to do that 529 00:30:47,566 --> 00:30:51,615 Vitaliy Zaharchenko: talking about protests of November through February 530 00:30:51,778 --> 00:30:55,278 one has to account the dynamics of their development that happened beforehand 531 00:30:58,548 --> 00:31:01,500 in Ukraine there are many public organizations that are being funded from abroad 532 00:31:01,625 --> 00:31:04,694 a huge number of journalists getting foreign grants 533 00:31:05,248 --> 00:31:10,577 narrator: Robert Perry is an investigative journalist working in Washington dc 534 00:31:11,232 --> 00:31:15,472 best know for his disclosure of the iran-contra in 1980s 535 00:31:17,340 --> 00:31:20,160 he's a founder of consortiumnews.com 536 00:31:20,161 --> 00:31:23,113 and he's reported extensively on the crisis in Ukraine 537 00:31:23,113 --> 00:31:24,696 and what stands behind it 538 00:31:25,036 --> 00:31:28,395 Robert Perry: a ngo is a non-governmental organization 539 00:31:28,407 --> 00:31:31,907 and many ngo's are quite legit and working for good purposes 540 00:31:32,868 --> 00:31:36,808 trying to help people, solving medical and water problems 541 00:31:40,339 --> 00:31:44,659 but there are some ngo's that are funded by the government services 542 00:31:46,021 --> 00:31:48,998 and serve more the purpose of that government 543 00:31:48,998 --> 00:31:51,688 rather than trying to serve the people that they're supposed to work with 544 00:31:52,577 --> 00:31:54,827 one thing we saw in the 1980s 545 00:31:55,271 --> 00:31:56,755 at that point the CIA 546 00:31:56,955 --> 00:31:58,440 had been largely discredited 547 00:31:58,441 --> 00:32:01,581 because of the scandals that were exposed in the 1970s 548 00:32:02,042 --> 00:32:04,883 narrator: for 15 years the CIA had secretly financed 549 00:32:05,443 --> 00:32:08,653 the overseas national students activities and associations 550 00:32:09,143 --> 00:32:12,293 but then it came light of a big web of CIA penetrations 551 00:32:13,606 --> 00:32:15,462 Robert Perry: so, when the Reagan administration came in 552 00:32:15,903 --> 00:32:18,873 there was this concept that instead of having the CIA 553 00:32:19,761 --> 00:32:22,531 that would traditionally go into these countries 554 00:32:22,974 --> 00:32:26,834 funding their media, ngo's and different political operations 555 00:32:27,589 --> 00:32:30,579 that was essentially passed to a new organization 556 00:32:31,367 --> 00:32:34,727 called national endowment for democracy created in 1983 557 00:32:35,369 --> 00:32:38,609 and it would do pretty much what the CIA would do 558 00:32:39,924 --> 00:32:44,034 penetrate the country, support different political groups 559 00:32:44,342 --> 00:32:48,624 preparing activists, journalists, business groups 560 00:32:48,644 --> 00:32:52,412 and pushing the interests of USA foreign policy 561 00:32:52,412 --> 00:32:56,392 sometimes against the interests of the host countrie’s government 562 00:32:56,392 --> 00:33:00,900 they were also supplying an organizational and financial support 563 00:33:00,900 --> 00:33:03,995 and help in trainings of activists 564 00:33:03,994 --> 00:33:05,737 on their work with journalists 565 00:33:06,607 --> 00:33:10,087 to be able to present their view in the best way 566 00:33:10,234 --> 00:33:13,164 they worked on things like how to get popularity 567 00:33:13,701 --> 00:33:18,881 how to make things viral, how to use it to get support for your ideas 568 00:33:19,414 --> 00:33:22,089 narrator: and the support was granted 569 00:33:22,089 --> 00:33:25,857 mустафа hаем, a founder of one of Ukraine's new media 570 00:33:25,857 --> 00:33:28,778 muatafa naem: good evening or better good night 571 00:33:29,093 --> 00:33:33,413 narrator: Громадське tv knew very well how to make something go viral 572 00:33:33,646 --> 00:33:37,966 it was his notorious post on facebook on November 21st of 2013 573 00:33:39,951 --> 00:33:42,362 that have lead the first crowd to Maidan 574 00:33:42,732 --> 00:33:45,312 muatafa naem: I made this post just to check 575 00:33:45,313 --> 00:33:48,273 if there are any willing people or we were just talking 576 00:33:51,545 --> 00:33:54,413 narrator: if you don't read the newspaper, you're uninformed 577 00:33:54,413 --> 00:33:57,075 if you read the newspaper, you're misinformed 578 00:33:57,075 --> 00:33:58,245 mark twain 579 00:33:59,643 --> 00:34:03,153 to be heard in this modern world of media and social networks 580 00:34:04,598 --> 00:34:06,318 you got to embrace them all 581 00:34:06,888 --> 00:34:10,838 as the disturbing events of euroMaidan started on November 21 of 2013 582 00:34:12,487 --> 00:34:14,677 3 new tv channels went on the air 583 00:34:15,811 --> 00:34:18,152 and immediately gained great popularity 584 00:34:18,740 --> 00:34:21,061 spilno tv found on November 21st 2013 585 00:34:24,240 --> 00:34:27,130 hromadske tv found on November 22nd 2013 586 00:34:27,989 --> 00:34:30,418 espresso tv found on November 24th 2013 587 00:34:30,681 --> 00:34:33,461 broadcasting directly from opposition protests 588 00:34:33,664 --> 00:34:35,334 these channels went viral 589 00:34:35,474 --> 00:34:37,143 openly supporting protests 590 00:34:37,193 --> 00:34:40,533 and encouraging more and more people to come to Maidan 591 00:34:40,771 --> 00:34:44,677 Vitaliy Zaharchenko: the first mass actions began November 21st 2013 592 00:34:44,896 --> 00:34:46,860 at first they were peaceful actions 593 00:34:46,960 --> 00:34:49,610 a lot of different types of people were coming 594 00:34:50,041 --> 00:34:52,771 young and old, some of them brought children 595 00:34:55,139 --> 00:34:58,689 it was clear that they trust the government and the police also 596 00:35:00,389 --> 00:35:05,159 they were walking free and there were no hints that any force will be used against them 597 00:35:09,864 --> 00:35:14,904 so the law enforcement officers were doing their job of protecting the order without firearms 598 00:35:17,949 --> 00:35:21,500 but among those protesters some radicals were already spotted 599 00:35:28,568 --> 00:35:32,378 they were connected with far-right parties and neo-Nazi organizations 600 00:35:39,784 --> 00:35:42,954 so on November 24th they did the first aggressive action 601 00:35:47,065 --> 00:35:50,764 on November 24-th the first attack on government office was made 602 00:35:51,224 --> 00:35:55,005 and also the first attack on the police officers that were guarding it 603 00:36:00,885 --> 00:36:04,206 the second attack on the ukrainian security service officers 604 00:36:04,373 --> 00:36:06,213 happened on November 25th 605 00:36:06,356 --> 00:36:08,967 then the notorious events of November 30th 606 00:36:10,190 --> 00:36:14,470 narrator: November 30th of 2013 became the first turning point of the Maidan 607 00:36:14,469 --> 00:36:17,839 though the events of that night were widely covered in press 608 00:36:17,840 --> 00:36:20,280 the truth about what exactly happened is still uncertain 609 00:36:20,505 --> 00:36:24,205 Vitaliy Zaharchenko: I will tell you how I personally saw these events 610 00:36:24,534 --> 00:36:26,004 I got a call from Popov 611 00:36:26,726 --> 00:36:28,926 the head of the Kiev administration 612 00:36:29,759 --> 00:36:33,829 he said that they would like to begin installing the equipment for the christmas tree on the square 613 00:36:36,664 --> 00:36:40,684 I explained him that while people are on the square it shouldn't be done 614 00:36:43,144 --> 00:36:46,204 at about 1am when people began to leave the square 615 00:36:48,260 --> 00:36:51,510 I had a talk with the head of the ukrainian security service 616 00:36:52,967 --> 00:36:56,047 I asked his opinion on the current situation and he said 617 00:36:58,833 --> 00:37:02,933 “I suppose, thank God, it's over. we have an information that it is over.” 618 00:37:04,626 --> 00:37:08,746 because since November 21st I was literally living and sleeping in my office 619 00:37:09,675 --> 00:37:12,576 if I was lucky to have couple of hours a day to sleep 620 00:37:13,206 --> 00:37:16,706 at about 3am I came to my home, set-up my alarm for 6:30am 621 00:37:18,681 --> 00:37:21,151 first thing in the morning I turned on my tv 622 00:37:22,653 --> 00:37:24,114 it was set to channel 5 623 00:37:27,425 --> 00:37:29,686 and it showed a lot of ambulance cars 624 00:37:31,487 --> 00:37:33,147 and a lot of injured people 625 00:37:33,331 --> 00:37:35,342 reporter: armed with rubber bats 626 00:37:35,342 --> 00:37:37,372 police officers were attacking the protesters 627 00:37:37,371 --> 00:37:39,533 it happened early in the morning 628 00:37:39,534 --> 00:37:42,574 the witnesses say that the police were indeed using the rubber bats 629 00:37:42,574 --> 00:37:45,914 Vitaliy Zaharchenko: honestly it just hit me with a cold sweat 630 00:37:47,362 --> 00:37:50,252 Yanukovich: my first reaction on Maidan protesters 631 00:37:50,641 --> 00:37:52,741 being hurt by the police was instant 632 00:37:54,416 --> 00:37:57,796 we had to investigate who ordered to disperse the protesters 633 00:37:58,947 --> 00:38:00,547 to use force against them 634 00:38:02,483 --> 00:38:04,054 I was against using force 635 00:38:05,489 --> 00:38:07,969 against violating the human rights 636 00:38:10,913 --> 00:38:15,072 Zaharchenko: there is no way Popov could make such a decision by himself 637 00:38:16,974 --> 00:38:19,403 and who was the highest official for him? 638 00:38:20,737 --> 00:38:24,797 the highest official for Popov was a head of the president's administration 639 00:38:27,139 --> 00:38:28,278 Sergei Liovochkin 640 00:38:29,762 --> 00:38:32,188 narrator: coincidentally, Sergei Liovochkin 641 00:38:32,188 --> 00:38:34,738 was a close associate of many US politicians 642 00:38:36,057 --> 00:38:39,487 the ukrainian security service had evidence that on that night 643 00:38:40,036 --> 00:38:43,266 Лёвочкин contacted with the opposition leader Яенюк 644 00:38:44,289 --> 00:38:48,860 and discussed the disperse of Maidan with installing the christmas tree as an excuse 645 00:38:50,885 --> 00:38:56,516 the news media reported that the police cold-blooded attacked students peacefully sleeping in their tents 646 00:38:57,085 --> 00:39:00,397 but scenes from the event seem to tell a different story 647 00:39:00,983 --> 00:39:04,094 it appears that the protesters were expecting the police 648 00:39:05,253 --> 00:39:09,953 there were dozens of journalists, and cameras from the new tv channels already there 649 00:39:11,155 --> 00:39:17,225 but the most suspicious was a group of well trained young men that arrived practically at the same time as police 650 00:39:19,744 --> 00:39:24,601 they spread in the crowd and began provoking the police with insults, stones and torches 651 00:39:27,949 --> 00:39:30,309 Robert Perry: the right sector in Ukraine 652 00:39:30,543 --> 00:39:33,183 represents the far-right ukrainian population 653 00:39:34,702 --> 00:39:37,972 they often had their militias that were coming to Maidan 654 00:39:43,505 --> 00:39:47,056 some squads were shipped into Kiev as muscle for the demonstrations 655 00:39:51,833 --> 00:39:54,393 the demonstrations ran from being peaceful 656 00:39:54,516 --> 00:39:56,326 to being increasingly violent 657 00:39:56,978 --> 00:39:59,448 narrator: the first step in any investigation 658 00:39:59,612 --> 00:40:01,152 is to to find the motive 659 00:40:02,860 --> 00:40:05,070 it is now known that Sergei Liovochkin 660 00:40:05,300 --> 00:40:07,830 has the highest favor among his US friends 661 00:40:09,791 --> 00:40:12,541 outraged about what was reported on the news 662 00:40:13,643 --> 00:40:15,623 people came out the next day 663 00:40:16,068 --> 00:40:18,958 to express their disturbance by the actions of police 664 00:40:19,431 --> 00:40:21,971 Stone: the violence started to take off when? 665 00:40:22,153 --> 00:40:26,134 Yanukovich: unlawful actions practically began on December of 2013 666 00:40:30,657 --> 00:40:34,197 the events taking place at that time in Kiev were very radical 667 00:40:36,313 --> 00:40:38,913 neo-Nazi organizations took part in them 668 00:40:39,356 --> 00:40:42,927 young men that were armed with different improvised weapons 669 00:40:44,052 --> 00:40:47,462 such as iron bars, baseball bats and even vehicles were used 670 00:40:50,865 --> 00:40:54,416 like tractors, they were using tractors to attack the police officers 671 00:40:56,581 --> 00:41:01,581 that were defending the government institutions and the president's administration building 672 00:41:03,730 --> 00:41:07,730 how could a president come out to talk to such an uncontrollable crowd? 673 00:41:11,108 --> 00:41:12,378 whom to talk to? 674 00:41:14,603 --> 00:41:19,072 the technologies used at that time, they were planned beforehand 675 00:41:25,740 --> 00:41:29,280 narrator: as veiled and masked as the color revolutions may be 676 00:41:29,409 --> 00:41:33,289 an attentive viewer can see a subtle pattern revealing their true nature 677 00:41:37,617 --> 00:41:42,207 to make crowds act like one group you have to unite them on the subconscious level 678 00:41:43,447 --> 00:41:47,567 masterminds of the color revolutions know that well and mastered this art 679 00:41:51,925 --> 00:41:55,516 symbolism is one of the most powerful tools to achieve this goal 680 00:41:55,822 --> 00:41:57,942 revolutionary political organizations 681 00:41:59,240 --> 00:42:02,760 with surprisingly similar names and even more similar symbols 682 00:42:03,382 --> 00:42:06,962 appear in those countries that are soon to be hit by revolutions 683 00:42:11,539 --> 00:42:14,479 they are often described as being aware and active 684 00:42:15,501 --> 00:42:17,361 but actually trained and radical 685 00:42:17,777 --> 00:42:20,617 they are the ones who take the first shot, literally 686 00:42:21,277 --> 00:42:23,307 to convert protests into outrage 687 00:42:27,838 --> 00:42:31,949 their fingerprints can be found everywhere on the map of color revolutions 688 00:42:34,768 --> 00:42:37,298 using all the experience of past generations 689 00:42:38,219 --> 00:42:39,779 simple but effective tools 690 00:42:41,038 --> 00:42:42,757 like chanting, do a great job 691 00:42:43,134 --> 00:42:46,054 crowd: together we are strong 692 00:42:46,505 --> 00:42:48,945 narrator: well know for exciting the crowd 693 00:42:49,547 --> 00:42:51,407 and creating a group identity 694 00:42:51,704 --> 00:42:53,704 they depersonalize the individuals 695 00:42:53,728 --> 00:42:56,248 and create a group that’s easily manipulated 696 00:42:56,371 --> 00:42:59,260 crowd: if you're not hopping then you're Russian 697 00:42:59,610 --> 00:43:02,391 man on stage: thank you friends hail to Ukraine 698 00:43:03,068 --> 00:43:04,759 crowd: hail to the heroes 699 00:43:06,409 --> 00:43:09,690 Zaharchenko: of course it couldn't be done without money 700 00:43:11,963 --> 00:43:13,123 so many ngo's 701 00:43:13,963 --> 00:43:16,063 grants given to Ukraine 702 00:43:17,423 --> 00:43:18,804 and it's not a secret 703 00:43:19,938 --> 00:43:22,708 narrator: incidentally, one of such organizations 704 00:43:22,947 --> 00:43:25,447 Hromadske TV received generous donations 705 00:43:26,025 --> 00:43:28,005 from the dutch and US embassies 706 00:43:28,288 --> 00:43:31,788 as well as the renaissance foundation founded by george soros 707 00:43:33,420 --> 00:43:36,250 george soros: i've set up a foundation in Ukraine 708 00:43:36,907 --> 00:43:40,097 before Ukraine even became independent from Russia 709 00:43:42,911 --> 00:43:46,001 and the foundation has been functioning ever since 710 00:43:47,327 --> 00:43:50,378 it played a significant role in the ukrainian events now 711 00:43:54,489 --> 00:43:55,918 narrator: I like criticism 712 00:43:55,918 --> 00:43:57,298 but it must be my way 713 00:43:57,298 --> 00:43:58,119 mark twain 714 00:43:58,543 --> 00:44:01,663 Stone: did you see any evidence that the US is involved? 715 00:44:01,762 --> 00:44:03,893 did you feel the presence of the US? 716 00:44:04,309 --> 00:44:06,989 Yanukovich: the US officials were often guests 717 00:44:07,088 --> 00:44:08,638 there were congressmen 718 00:44:09,663 --> 00:44:11,682 Victoria Nuland came very often 719 00:44:13,467 --> 00:44:15,447 we were discussing with her 720 00:44:17,110 --> 00:44:20,050 but after those discussions she was going to Maidan 721 00:44:20,780 --> 00:44:24,190 to support the protesters and accuse the police of using force 722 00:44:27,393 --> 00:44:30,163 actually we saw all of those messages on Maidan 723 00:44:31,090 --> 00:44:33,830 chris murphy: we will come here, at this square 724 00:44:34,190 --> 00:44:36,240 to celebrate with you and Ukraine 725 00:44:37,458 --> 00:44:39,888 that stands together with the EU and US 726 00:44:42,251 --> 00:44:45,321 Perry: well members of congress were visiting Ukraine 727 00:44:45,556 --> 00:44:48,426 one of the most known was senator John McCain 728 00:44:49,012 --> 00:44:50,862 so the high US official 729 00:44:51,204 --> 00:44:53,594 the person who had run for president 730 00:44:53,804 --> 00:44:55,463 was talking to the people 731 00:44:55,621 --> 00:44:59,231 that were acting against their democratically elected government 732 00:44:59,320 --> 00:45:01,250 saying that the US is with them 733 00:45:01,739 --> 00:45:05,929 McCain: i'm senator John McCain and it's always a pleasure to be back in Ukraine 734 00:45:06,456 --> 00:45:09,446 Perry: senator McCain was giving people the feeling 735 00:45:10,338 --> 00:45:14,159 that they are being supported by the most powerful country on earth 736 00:45:14,556 --> 00:45:17,836 McCain: this is not about the future you want for your country 737 00:45:18,635 --> 00:45:20,755 this is about the future you deserve 738 00:45:22,056 --> 00:45:24,596 Yanukovich: a lot of delegates were coming 739 00:45:25,407 --> 00:45:27,418 I was saying that one shouldn't 740 00:45:28,648 --> 00:45:30,528 first of all, say what isn't true 741 00:45:32,735 --> 00:45:35,725 one shouldn't take the side of the protesters 742 00:45:37,490 --> 00:45:40,880 and protect their rights and making the conflict worse with it 743 00:45:42,146 --> 00:45:45,385 when the protesters capture the government institutions 744 00:45:45,742 --> 00:45:48,253 tell me is it acceptable in any other country 745 00:45:48,887 --> 00:45:51,398 for instance if an ambassador of Ukraine 746 00:45:52,190 --> 00:45:54,470 went to see the protesters in ferguson 747 00:45:55,521 --> 00:45:58,871 and give out cookies or pies and accuse the police of the US 748 00:46:00,152 --> 00:46:03,112 I consider this unacceptable in any country of the EU 749 00:46:04,550 --> 00:46:07,039 so why then Ukraine was treated that way? 750 00:46:07,489 --> 00:46:10,559 Stone: who was your highest level contact at that time? 751 00:46:10,838 --> 00:46:14,508 Yanukovich: I was constantly in contact with Mr. Biden 752 00:46:16,389 --> 00:46:18,659 I had regular phone talks with him 753 00:46:19,759 --> 00:46:22,949 but the thing is that Mr. Biden was saying one thing 754 00:46:24,505 --> 00:46:27,885 and what was happening in Ukraine was completely another 755 00:46:27,931 --> 00:46:29,840 Stone: and the US ambassador? 756 00:46:29,900 --> 00:46:32,380 Yanukovich: the US ambassador in Ukraine 757 00:46:32,847 --> 00:46:36,267 was constantly receiving the Maidan delegates in his embassy 758 00:46:37,190 --> 00:46:38,520 we knew it very well 759 00:46:39,739 --> 00:46:41,438 we were tracking this 760 00:46:42,577 --> 00:46:45,148 and we had the impression that there was 761 00:46:45,681 --> 00:46:48,971 a headquarters of this process inside of the US embassy 762 00:46:52,847 --> 00:46:54,807 Perry: in early February of 2014 763 00:46:55,164 --> 00:46:57,704 as the Maidan crisis became more violent 764 00:46:57,920 --> 00:47:00,869 there was a phone call that was intercepted between 765 00:47:01,152 --> 00:47:04,332 the assistant secretary of state in Europe Victoria Nuland 766 00:47:04,333 --> 00:47:07,072 and the US ambassador in Ukraine geoffrey Pyatt 767 00:47:07,163 --> 00:47:10,432 reporter: one should question the credibility of ukrainians 768 00:47:10,507 --> 00:47:13,086 after a private chat of the top US ambassador 769 00:47:13,202 --> 00:47:14,532 was leaked online 770 00:47:14,746 --> 00:47:18,485 Nuland: I think yats is the guy who's got the economic experience 771 00:47:18,659 --> 00:47:20,260 the governing experience 772 00:47:20,260 --> 00:47:23,823 he's the… what he needs is klitsch and tyahnybok on the outside 773 00:47:23,822 --> 00:47:25,572 I just think klitsch going in… 774 00:47:25,653 --> 00:47:28,594 he's going to be at that level working for yatseniuk 775 00:47:28,708 --> 00:47:30,328 it's just not going to work 776 00:47:30,563 --> 00:47:32,913 Pyatt: yeah, no, I think that's right. ok 777 00:47:33,041 --> 00:47:36,541 good, do you want us to set up a call with him as the next step? 778 00:47:36,614 --> 00:47:38,844 Nuland: Sullivan's come back to me 779 00:47:38,887 --> 00:47:40,866 vfr [direct to me] saying you need Biden 780 00:47:40,867 --> 00:47:42,517 and I said probably tomorrow 781 00:47:42,516 --> 00:47:44,668 for an atta-boy and to get the details to stick 782 00:47:44,668 --> 00:47:45,638 so Biden's willing 783 00:47:46,333 --> 00:47:48,876 Perry: so you had this remarkable phone call 784 00:47:48,876 --> 00:47:51,467 where two high officials in the US government 785 00:47:51,574 --> 00:47:53,334 are openly talking about coup 786 00:47:53,333 --> 00:47:56,550 and about how they're planning to dysfunction the government of Ukraine 787 00:47:56,550 --> 00:47:57,838 Nuland: fuck the EU 788 00:47:57,838 --> 00:47:58,867 Pyatt: no, exactly 789 00:47:58,867 --> 00:48:02,061 Perry: i'm not saying the whole US government is like this 790 00:48:02,061 --> 00:48:03,291 there is a division 791 00:48:03,889 --> 00:48:08,339 but for neocons it is very important to change the dynamics in the eastern Europe 792 00:48:12,291 --> 00:48:13,591 they are very smart 793 00:48:14,010 --> 00:48:16,710 the neocons are highly skilled in propaganda 794 00:48:17,141 --> 00:48:20,610 they know well all of the push points of the american people 795 00:48:21,666 --> 00:48:26,697 they had this experience when they were heating things up around central america in 1980s 796 00:48:27,358 --> 00:48:33,158 reporter: the sandinista ground forces are now armed with Russian artillery 797 00:48:33,335 --> 00:48:36,684 Perry: they've been applying the same strategies ever since 798 00:48:36,958 --> 00:48:40,028 they were being very dedicated to achieving their goals 799 00:48:40,027 --> 00:48:42,707 they still want to get rid of certain governments 800 00:48:42,708 --> 00:48:45,157 they want a regime change in syria, in iran 801 00:48:46,208 --> 00:48:47,788 they're very skilled at this 802 00:48:47,936 --> 00:48:50,956 they have a lot of allies in the media and government 803 00:48:51,460 --> 00:48:55,270 and that means they have a lot of influence on creating the narrative 804 00:48:55,534 --> 00:48:58,014 Robert kagan: I think in america these days 805 00:48:58,193 --> 00:49:00,253 we have somehow sold ourselves 806 00:49:00,481 --> 00:49:01,751 that there are a lot of ways of dealing with this problem 807 00:49:01,751 --> 00:49:03,215 other than hard power 808 00:49:03,215 --> 00:49:06,434 vladimir Putin cares about hard power 809 00:49:06,686 --> 00:49:10,306 Perry: the neocons are now demonizing the leader of the country 810 00:49:10,893 --> 00:49:12,953 that sells to the american people 811 00:49:13,581 --> 00:49:16,672 so you don't just argue the policy, you attack the leader 812 00:49:17,648 --> 00:49:21,115 the neocons are very skilled at picking out leaders features 813 00:49:23,175 --> 00:49:24,925 and then highlighting them 814 00:49:25,746 --> 00:49:29,166 for Yanukovich you can say that he is a hulking political leader 815 00:49:29,760 --> 00:49:31,900 but he was turned into a devil 816 00:49:32,532 --> 00:49:36,322 he is thoroughly corrupt, evil that wants to kill people on Maidan 817 00:49:36,351 --> 00:49:38,771 those innocent wonderful demonstrators 818 00:49:38,771 --> 00:49:41,341 in that way we now have the villain and the victim 819 00:49:41,340 --> 00:49:43,601 and then you keep repeating that basic scenario 820 00:49:43,601 --> 00:49:44,957 and it works with american people 821 00:49:44,956 --> 00:49:47,596 McCain: you got to realize who vladimir Putin is 822 00:49:47,596 --> 00:49:51,255 he's an old kgb that wants to restore the Russian empire 823 00:49:52,364 --> 00:49:54,394 perrt: you make them demons 824 00:49:54,503 --> 00:49:57,824 and the american people find that this way they can understand the world 825 00:49:57,824 --> 00:50:01,634 once that happens the journalists or someone else find it hard to say 826 00:50:01,963 --> 00:50:06,726 'now hold on, there is no certain white hat and black hat it's all very complicated' 827 00:50:06,726 --> 00:50:11,136 and if you say that you're instantly branded as an apologist of yanukivich or Putin 828 00:50:11,159 --> 00:50:13,079 the one, who dared to say that 829 00:50:13,079 --> 00:50:16,489 is now under attack no matter who it is - a journalist, academic or whatever 830 00:50:18,882 --> 00:50:21,192 narrator: any good director will tell you 831 00:50:21,329 --> 00:50:24,129 that tempo and rhythm are the main instruments 832 00:50:24,297 --> 00:50:26,246 to hold an audience's attention 833 00:50:28,327 --> 00:50:30,417 Zaharchenko: the technology itself 834 00:50:30,679 --> 00:50:32,440 that was used in the Maidan 835 00:50:33,222 --> 00:50:36,522 consisted of the necessity of the sacral victims, the sacrifice 836 00:50:37,222 --> 00:50:38,762 it's a part of technology 837 00:50:40,043 --> 00:50:41,782 narrator: it can also be called 838 00:50:41,782 --> 00:50:43,121 a method of betrayal 839 00:50:43,141 --> 00:50:46,221 when the allies are thrown into the revolutionary flame 840 00:50:49,893 --> 00:50:51,052 the idea is simple 841 00:50:51,365 --> 00:50:53,166 when the preparation is done 842 00:50:53,922 --> 00:50:56,003 all you need is a trigger to be pulled 843 00:50:56,083 --> 00:50:57,723 to set the chain on motion 844 00:50:59,914 --> 00:51:01,954 the murder of politician rafik hariri 845 00:51:02,686 --> 00:51:04,476 triggered the cedar revolution 846 00:51:06,438 --> 00:51:09,704 looking back at the mysterious poisoning of Viktor Ushenko 847 00:51:09,704 --> 00:51:12,124 right before the orange revolution in 2004 848 00:51:13,501 --> 00:51:16,501 we now see that he became the sacred victim himself 849 00:51:17,219 --> 00:51:18,959 most political analysts agree 850 00:51:19,137 --> 00:51:21,668 that the compassion of the ukrainian people 851 00:51:21,958 --> 00:51:24,259 tilted the scales towards his presidency 852 00:51:30,266 --> 00:51:34,527 the number of victims among protesters during euroMaidan totalled over 100 853 00:51:36,565 --> 00:51:38,835 they were called the heavenly hundred 854 00:51:40,181 --> 00:51:42,340 and were immediately mythologized 855 00:51:46,514 --> 00:51:51,264 the beating of students on November 30 of 2013 was an obvious trigger for euroMaidan 856 00:51:53,498 --> 00:51:56,467 those who sent trained provocateurs on the square 857 00:51:56,784 --> 00:52:01,173 very well realized that peaceful protesters were the ones to get hurt the most 858 00:52:03,146 --> 00:52:06,166 it's hard to keep the protests going for months on end 859 00:52:06,885 --> 00:52:09,135 the tension weakens, people get tired 860 00:52:11,005 --> 00:52:14,205 holidays are also big danger for revolution masterminds 861 00:52:15,030 --> 00:52:17,956 people want to get home to their family and friends 862 00:52:17,956 --> 00:52:21,366 and one needs to be inventive to keep them in the cold tents 863 00:52:36,744 --> 00:52:39,714 on December 25 of 2013 journalist tatiana Chernovol 864 00:52:41,797 --> 00:52:44,517 was chosen to be a tool to fire up Maidan again 865 00:52:46,628 --> 00:52:49,498 reporter: investigative journalist tatiana Chernovol 866 00:52:49,679 --> 00:52:53,429 known for her investigations of corruption in ukrainian government 867 00:52:53,429 --> 00:52:55,829 was found beaten near Kiev on christmas 868 00:52:56,373 --> 00:52:59,523 narrator: her heroic deeds look more like small crimes 869 00:53:00,266 --> 00:53:02,626 trespassing of the presidential residence 870 00:53:04,925 --> 00:53:07,105 the siege of Kiev city's administration 871 00:53:08,143 --> 00:53:10,893 breaking into the car of Ukraine's security service 872 00:53:12,139 --> 00:53:16,079 it looked like tatiana was willing to make the news rather than reporting them 873 00:53:17,737 --> 00:53:23,077 and gain the popularity that could be transformed into votes for her political party “the fatherland” 874 00:53:26,416 --> 00:53:30,536 the beating of tatiana Chernovol became a real christmas gift for the media 875 00:53:31,576 --> 00:53:35,215 despite the fact that in just 3 days all the suspects were arrested 876 00:53:35,588 --> 00:53:38,009 and confessed that it was a road accident 877 00:53:39,686 --> 00:53:43,566 the world media kept insisting on a political background for that crime 878 00:53:45,304 --> 00:53:47,724 instantly tatiana became a heroic martyr 879 00:53:48,181 --> 00:53:50,150 uniting people around her image 880 00:53:50,387 --> 00:53:52,478 reporter: the beating of a journalist 881 00:53:52,478 --> 00:53:55,197 among the political turmoil caused protests 882 00:53:55,896 --> 00:53:59,067 narrator: the euroMaidan was once again a center stage 883 00:53:59,300 --> 00:54:01,300 and tatiana in less than 2 months 884 00:54:01,548 --> 00:54:03,259 was already healthy enough 885 00:54:03,512 --> 00:54:05,893 to attack the office of “the regions party” 886 00:54:05,945 --> 00:54:08,175 the political party of Viktor Yanukovich 887 00:54:08,268 --> 00:54:09,978 tatiana Chernovol: this is the place 888 00:54:09,978 --> 00:54:11,609 where the people that beat me came from 889 00:54:11,610 --> 00:54:13,150 this is the nest of this criminal mafia government 890 00:54:13,150 --> 00:54:14,760 the death squads are also being controlled from here 891 00:54:15,172 --> 00:54:16,693 narrator: one of the staff 892 00:54:16,693 --> 00:54:18,990 65-year old it specialist vladimir zaharov 893 00:54:19,981 --> 00:54:21,641 was killed during the attack 894 00:54:23,760 --> 00:54:25,291 so, where is tatiana now? 895 00:54:26,710 --> 00:54:30,340 well, she finally got her position of power in the new government 896 00:54:32,036 --> 00:54:34,695 one month later the time came for another act 897 00:54:36,063 --> 00:54:38,614 armenian ukrainian protester Sergei Nigoyan 898 00:54:39,262 --> 00:54:41,542 was one of the first to arrive on Maidan 899 00:54:42,117 --> 00:54:43,777 he wasn't radical or violent 900 00:54:43,980 --> 00:54:46,710 but instead was full of hope for the better future 901 00:54:47,036 --> 00:54:49,317 watching Sergei read the patriotic poem 902 00:54:49,414 --> 00:54:52,554 is like watching a casting for the role of the sacred victim 903 00:54:52,893 --> 00:54:54,633 Sergei Nigoyan: keep fighting 904 00:54:54,666 --> 00:54:57,306 you are sure to win God helps you in your fight 905 00:54:57,391 --> 00:55:00,531 for fame and freedom march with you right at your side 906 00:55:01,840 --> 00:55:04,040 narrator: unfortunately Sergei got the part 907 00:55:07,981 --> 00:55:10,362 the video went viral after Sergei was killed 908 00:55:10,407 --> 00:55:12,847 early in the morning on January 22 of 2014 909 00:55:15,929 --> 00:55:19,219 the circumstances of his death remain unknown to this day 910 00:55:20,342 --> 00:55:23,232 even though the whole event was constantly filmed 911 00:55:25,197 --> 00:55:28,557 there were no records or witnesses to help the investigation 912 00:55:29,378 --> 00:55:32,827 and his body was removed immediately from the crime scene 913 00:55:33,568 --> 00:55:36,168 Sergei became the first martyr of euroMaidan 914 00:55:38,570 --> 00:55:41,016 police officers were appointed as his killers 915 00:55:41,155 --> 00:55:44,635 almost 2 years later the official investigation still has no results 916 00:55:48,253 --> 00:55:53,583 now it's widely believed that he was killed by provocateurs to escalate the conflict 917 00:56:00,255 --> 00:56:02,865 God speaks to people in the language of signs 918 00:56:03,590 --> 00:56:06,560 on January 26 2014 Pope Francis prayed for Ukraine 919 00:56:08,085 --> 00:56:11,215 addressing thousands of people on saint peter's square 920 00:56:17,846 --> 00:56:21,445 after the prayer two white doves were released from the window 921 00:56:21,798 --> 00:56:24,884 and were immediately attacked by a crow and a seagull 922 00:56:25,284 --> 00:56:27,484 those who understand the symbolism 923 00:56:27,677 --> 00:56:30,597 easily read this event as that soon two great powers 924 00:56:31,472 --> 00:56:33,603 represented by a crow and a seagull 925 00:56:34,284 --> 00:56:37,414 will be tearing apart two slavic nations - the white doves 926 00:56:37,715 --> 00:56:40,265 this omen gave hope to the ukrainian people 927 00:56:40,630 --> 00:56:43,340 saying that by God's will two doves will be saved 928 00:56:44,246 --> 00:56:47,336 but it also predicted severe hardship and many victims 929 00:56:51,795 --> 00:56:57,005 the events, that made the history of color revolutions as the most massive in human sacrifice yet 930 00:56:58,710 --> 00:57:01,210 arrived right on schedule - one month later 931 00:57:05,806 --> 00:57:07,666 reporter: during the last weeks 932 00:57:08,018 --> 00:57:11,038 this european capital was caught in a violent uprising 933 00:57:11,384 --> 00:57:13,193 today is the bloodiest day yet 934 00:57:13,710 --> 00:57:17,710 the protesters are advancing towards the government region of the city 935 00:57:19,922 --> 00:57:22,161 they are armed with molotov cocktails 936 00:57:22,623 --> 00:57:24,813 we also saw handguns and shotguns 937 00:57:24,983 --> 00:57:27,113 there are casualties from both sides 938 00:57:27,583 --> 00:57:30,432 she just said that there are 6 dead people up there 939 00:57:30,760 --> 00:57:32,990 not just injured, dead, shot by snipers 940 00:57:33,293 --> 00:57:36,983 Zaharchenko: on February 20 the police officers were being shot at 941 00:57:39,385 --> 00:57:42,666 Yanukovich: I got this information that snipers are shooting 942 00:57:43,184 --> 00:57:45,514 and there are casualties from both sides 943 00:57:46,585 --> 00:57:50,175 Zaharchenko: the conservatory is where the first shots were from 944 00:57:50,510 --> 00:57:53,310 this place was under control of the Maidan forces 945 00:57:54,530 --> 00:57:59,000 narrator: and here again we see our old friend from “narodniy ruh” andriy parubiy 946 00:58:00,143 --> 00:58:02,072 who was at the peak of his glory 947 00:58:02,072 --> 00:58:04,492 as a self-proclaimed Maidan commandant 948 00:58:05,864 --> 00:58:08,864 which in fact means - leader of the radical opposition 949 00:58:10,108 --> 00:58:11,948 Парубій: we had warned them 950 00:58:12,637 --> 00:58:14,668 that Maidan may take more action 951 00:58:15,289 --> 00:58:18,099 if our demands aren't fulfilled in the next days 952 00:58:21,623 --> 00:58:23,383 Putin: it was to spread chaos 953 00:58:24,134 --> 00:58:27,623 and certainly Yanukovich wouldn't benefit from growing chaos 954 00:58:32,039 --> 00:58:34,730 reporter: here you can see protesters escorting 955 00:58:34,730 --> 00:58:36,516 a line of special forces officers 956 00:58:36,516 --> 00:58:38,772 it's still not clear where they are taking them 957 00:58:38,773 --> 00:58:41,103 67 officers are officially declared missing 958 00:58:41,139 --> 00:58:43,619 Stone: 14 officers dead, 43 wounded, right? 959 00:58:44,963 --> 00:58:48,744 Zaharchenko: 20 people dead and more than 150 with gun wounds 960 00:58:53,278 --> 00:58:55,998 Yanukovich: then it was clear, on February 20-21 961 00:58:57,523 --> 00:58:59,893 that an armed overthrow was happening 962 00:59:04,318 --> 00:59:06,739 reporter: opposition leader Vitaliy klitchko 963 00:59:07,608 --> 00:59:09,489 called his followers to stay alert 964 00:59:10,856 --> 00:59:13,056 each of you here should stand strong, he said 965 00:59:14,552 --> 00:59:17,032 because we're not going anywhere 966 00:59:20,226 --> 00:59:22,226 Yanukovich: at that same period 967 00:59:23,202 --> 00:59:25,502 we were negotiating with the opposition 968 00:59:25,864 --> 00:59:27,684 and very often we agreed, but 969 00:59:28,570 --> 00:59:30,810 as I found out later, it was just a game 970 00:59:31,324 --> 00:59:34,884 the part of the opposition that didn't take part in the negotiation 971 00:59:35,507 --> 00:59:37,407 the radical one, they didn't care 972 00:59:37,407 --> 00:59:38,836 and listened to no one 973 00:59:39,681 --> 00:59:41,221 they were doing their job 974 00:59:46,978 --> 00:59:49,818 narrator: like in 2004 during the orange revolution 975 00:59:50,262 --> 00:59:52,782 the international leaders felt that it was time 976 00:59:53,541 --> 00:59:56,302 to interfere and put both sides of the negotiation 977 00:59:56,681 --> 00:59:59,641 Putin: three european foreign ministers came to Kiev 978 01:00:10,182 --> 01:00:14,882 Putin: they took part in the meeting between president Yanukovich and the opposition 979 01:00:15,344 --> 01:00:18,784 agreed on carrying out a presidential election before schedule 980 01:00:19,021 --> 01:00:23,501 agreed on the ways of building relations between the president and the opposition 981 01:00:26,514 --> 01:00:30,954 the ukrainian president and the leaders of the opposition have agreed on a truce 982 01:00:36,088 --> 01:00:39,239 just like in 2004 the opposition or at least its radical faction 983 01:00:41,478 --> 01:00:43,848 the right sector, lead by dmitriy yarosh 984 01:00:44,733 --> 01:00:47,673 had no intention of fulfilling his part of the bargain 985 01:00:48,942 --> 01:00:52,942 dmitriy yarosh: the achieved agreements do not comply with our expectations 986 01:00:53,556 --> 01:00:56,056 the right sector will not lower the weapons 987 01:00:57,403 --> 01:01:01,074 the right sector will not unblock any of the government institutions 988 01:01:02,413 --> 01:01:04,423 until our main demand is fulfilled 989 01:01:04,893 --> 01:01:07,003 the resignation of Viktor Yanukovich 990 01:01:10,559 --> 01:01:12,949 Yanukovich: I have signed such document 991 01:01:14,782 --> 01:01:18,472 but a bit later I understood that whatever document we are to sign 992 01:01:18,835 --> 01:01:22,085 the overthrow scenario was planned and it was imminent 993 01:01:26,804 --> 01:01:29,264 so, basically none of our actions mattered 994 01:01:30,182 --> 01:01:32,402 radoslaw sikorski: if you don't sign this 995 01:01:32,423 --> 01:01:33,963 you will have martial law 996 01:01:33,963 --> 01:01:35,614 the army, you'll all be dead 997 01:01:35,724 --> 01:01:37,454 the opposition leaders said 998 01:01:37,454 --> 01:01:40,214 that they have found a way to end the bloodshed 999 01:01:40,213 --> 01:01:43,974 but first they wanted to announce the conclusion of the negotiations 1000 01:01:45,713 --> 01:01:48,563 it was soon clear that the protesters weren't happy 1001 01:01:50,101 --> 01:01:52,590 Putin: so the next day Mr. Viktor Yanukovich 1002 01:01:53,644 --> 01:01:56,675 left to visit the second largest city in Ukraine, xарьков 1003 01:01:58,012 --> 01:02:01,103 as soon as he left his office it was taken using weapons 1004 01:02:04,277 --> 01:02:05,667 what do you call that? 1005 01:02:07,635 --> 01:02:10,395 Yanukovich: the thing is I flew there by helicopter 1006 01:02:11,903 --> 01:02:14,253 the escorting cars were going separately 1007 01:02:16,554 --> 01:02:18,134 but no one knew about it 1008 01:02:20,786 --> 01:02:24,146 so the escorting cars were going and they got under gunfire 1009 01:02:26,835 --> 01:02:31,035 also our intelligence had an information that there were special mercenaries 1010 01:02:34,086 --> 01:02:37,376 who's objective was not to capture the president, but to kill 1011 01:02:40,942 --> 01:02:43,882 so I asked for Mr. Putin's permission to go to Russia 1012 01:02:46,601 --> 01:02:49,442 the permission was granted and also I was helped 1013 01:02:52,501 --> 01:02:54,891 on February 24th I got on Russian territory 1014 01:03:02,510 --> 01:03:03,690 at the same time 1015 01:03:03,851 --> 01:03:07,340 Kiev was saying the last goodbye to the victims of the massacre 1016 01:03:14,951 --> 01:03:18,951 it was also welcoming those who came to power on the cost of their lives 1017 01:03:20,012 --> 01:03:22,532 Ukraine's parliament has voted for assigning 1018 01:03:22,666 --> 01:03:25,106 Alexander Turchinov as an acting president 1019 01:03:25,204 --> 01:03:28,824 he called the lawmakers to form the new government by tuesday 1020 01:03:30,206 --> 01:03:34,446 this event followed the dismount of president Viktor Yanukovich on saturday 1021 01:03:35,119 --> 01:03:37,239 Perry: and they removed Yanukovich 1022 01:03:37,239 --> 01:03:40,789 without following the constitutional procedure for impeachment 1023 01:03:40,978 --> 01:03:44,178 Yanukovich: the impeachment procedure wasn't followed 1024 01:03:44,179 --> 01:03:46,608 the constitutional court had to be involved 1025 01:03:46,608 --> 01:03:48,798 the supreme court and it wasn't done 1026 01:03:48,983 --> 01:03:52,134 and ¾ of the deputies had to be voting in the parliament 1027 01:03:53,922 --> 01:03:56,772 the parliament of Ukraine consists of 450 deputies 1028 01:03:57,637 --> 01:03:59,268 the constitution of Ukraine 1029 01:03:59,331 --> 01:04:02,581 requires at least a ¾ majority of 338 deputies vote in favor 1030 01:04:05,487 --> 01:04:07,356 but only 328 deputies voted yes 1031 01:04:08,429 --> 01:04:10,859 they didn't have the ¾ of parliament votes 1032 01:04:11,599 --> 01:04:15,599 the US state department immediately called the new government legit 1033 01:04:15,985 --> 01:04:18,195 and it was a part of the coup scenario 1034 01:04:19,173 --> 01:04:21,543 in this way they eliminated the possibility 1035 01:04:21,943 --> 01:04:26,614 to revive the agreement of February 22 that could get Viktor Yanukovich back in power 1036 01:04:27,534 --> 01:04:29,854 then you had eastern Ukraine resisting 1037 01:04:30,286 --> 01:04:33,856 crimea wanted to separate and the situation came out of control 1038 01:04:38,465 --> 01:04:43,135 on sunday the people are to decide whether they want to leave Ukraine and join Russia 1039 01:04:43,168 --> 01:04:47,168 the campaign with slogan 'together with Russia' is being carried by Moscow 1040 01:04:47,597 --> 01:04:51,297 the crimean referendum situation was also happening at that time 1041 01:04:51,940 --> 01:04:55,390 the crimean referendum was initiated by the people of crimea 1042 01:04:56,481 --> 01:05:01,621 it was their response to the Maidan representatives' attempts to make the same coup in crimea 1043 01:05:04,643 --> 01:05:08,403 it is not a secret that the population of crimea was always pro-Russia 1044 01:05:11,157 --> 01:05:13,947 crimean authorities, agreeing with the populace 1045 01:05:14,952 --> 01:05:17,523 fully supported Viktor Yanukovich's decision 1046 01:05:18,123 --> 01:05:21,262 to stall the signing of the 2013 trade agreement with eu 1047 01:05:26,048 --> 01:05:27,918 as the event in Kiev took place 1048 01:05:28,235 --> 01:05:30,575 crimean authorities made a declaration: 1049 01:05:33,632 --> 01:05:36,822 “based on the will of the crimean people who elected us 1050 01:05:36,822 --> 01:05:40,572 we declare that we will not give crimea to extremists and neo-Nazis 1051 01:05:40,608 --> 01:05:42,639 seeking to seize power in Ukraine 1052 01:05:42,875 --> 01:05:45,925 at the cost of the blood of the country and its citizens” 1053 01:05:46,706 --> 01:05:48,586 after the regime change in Kiev 1054 01:05:49,106 --> 01:05:51,166 rumors began spreading in crimea 1055 01:05:51,166 --> 01:05:54,817 that new authorities will be ruthless to the ones who oppose them 1056 01:05:54,817 --> 01:05:56,177 dmitriy yarosh: hail to Ukraine 1057 01:05:56,177 --> 01:05:57,707 crowd: hail to the heroes 1058 01:05:57,706 --> 01:06:00,116 this lead to the pro-Russia demonstrations 1059 01:06:00,117 --> 01:06:04,027 of the people that aren't in agreement with the new government in Kiev 1060 01:06:04,027 --> 01:06:07,666 on February 27 the government institution in the capital of crimea 1061 01:06:07,666 --> 01:06:09,797 was seized by pro-Russia protesters 1062 01:06:11,532 --> 01:06:13,862 the crimean government was dismissed 1063 01:06:14,608 --> 01:06:16,748 and the new leader cергей aксёнов 1064 01:06:17,094 --> 01:06:20,614 was assigned as the leader of the crimean autonomous republic 1065 01:06:23,074 --> 01:06:27,253 they certainly were hoping and asking the Russian government for protection 1066 01:06:29,750 --> 01:06:32,429 on March 16 the crimean referendum was held 1067 01:06:33,431 --> 01:06:35,791 and the people voted for leaving Ukraine 1068 01:06:36,373 --> 01:06:38,443 and entering the Russian federation 1069 01:06:39,471 --> 01:06:42,960 the situation in crimea has been presented as Russian invasion 1070 01:06:44,016 --> 01:06:46,115 and again, nobody takes it seriously 1071 01:06:46,115 --> 01:06:47,626 look at the poll numbers 1072 01:06:47,626 --> 01:06:50,786 some of them were done by the US agencies themselves 1073 01:06:50,786 --> 01:06:53,615 showing that people of crimea want to join Russia 1074 01:06:53,615 --> 01:06:56,576 but in the US news media it's all been presented as 1075 01:06:57,239 --> 01:06:59,378 Russian invading and faking this vote 1076 01:07:00,425 --> 01:07:03,076 where people were voting literally at gun point 1077 01:07:03,677 --> 01:07:07,018 and that's how they got 96% of the votes for joining Russia 1078 01:07:09,110 --> 01:07:12,820 the idea of referendum in crimea is quite simply unconstitutional 1079 01:07:14,128 --> 01:07:17,509 there are questions whether this vote was really free and fair 1080 01:07:18,119 --> 01:07:21,880 especially considering the military presence of Russia in crimea now 1081 01:07:22,306 --> 01:07:25,036 so that's how it's shown to the american people 1082 01:07:25,036 --> 01:07:26,646 the reality is very different 1083 01:07:27,432 --> 01:07:30,063 the atmosphere here is certainly remarkable 1084 01:07:30,135 --> 01:07:33,206 thousands of people gathered in the capital of crimea 1085 01:07:33,206 --> 01:07:35,385 this is happening after last sunday 1086 01:07:36,885 --> 01:07:41,346 when the referendum was held where the majority voted for reuniting with Russia 1087 01:07:44,000 --> 01:07:45,360 crowd: Russia, Russia 1088 01:07:46,146 --> 01:07:47,326 i'd like to ask you 1089 01:07:47,327 --> 01:07:48,607 what is democracy? 1090 01:07:48,699 --> 01:07:51,668 democracy is a policy based on the will of the people 1091 01:07:53,286 --> 01:07:55,615 how do you know the will of the people? 1092 01:07:57,590 --> 01:07:59,950 in the modern world it's done by voting 1093 01:08:01,659 --> 01:08:05,959 over 90% of people came and over 90% of those people voted for joining Russia 1094 01:08:07,507 --> 01:08:09,897 the will of the people has to be respected 1095 01:08:11,405 --> 01:08:14,485 don't bend international law and democracy principles 1096 01:08:14,485 --> 01:08:17,715 according to your current geopolitical interests every time 1097 01:08:21,831 --> 01:08:25,011 we had no combats there, no shooting, no one was killed 1098 01:08:30,462 --> 01:08:33,752 what is described by the west as Russian invasion in crimea 1099 01:08:34,869 --> 01:08:37,140 is in fact a presence of Russian soldiers 1100 01:08:38,595 --> 01:08:39,875 can you clarify that? 1101 01:08:40,224 --> 01:08:42,644 Russian soldiers in crimea, as it is known 1102 01:08:43,899 --> 01:08:47,628 were there for ages, because the black sea naval base was in crimea 1103 01:08:49,268 --> 01:08:52,597 as long as 1804 the cевастополь naval base 1104 01:08:53,337 --> 01:08:57,337 became the main naval base of the Russian empire on the black sea 1105 01:08:59,131 --> 01:09:03,431 during the 2nd world war heroic defense of cевастополь lasted almost a year 1106 01:09:04,340 --> 01:09:06,730 and took hundreds of thousands of lives 1107 01:09:10,610 --> 01:09:12,671 therefore the naval base in crimea 1108 01:09:12,751 --> 01:09:16,101 has a legacy of historical pride for the Russian black sea fleet 1109 01:09:16,764 --> 01:09:19,904 as well as being of huge strategic importance 1110 01:09:20,278 --> 01:09:22,507 in 1962 during the ongoing arms race 1111 01:09:23,042 --> 01:09:25,442 the USSR began sending rockets to Cuba 1112 01:09:28,032 --> 01:09:30,362 those of us alive at that time remember 1113 01:09:31,341 --> 01:09:34,031 how frightened and angry we were by that fact 1114 01:09:35,534 --> 01:09:38,114 and how it nearly grew into a nuclear conflict 1115 01:09:38,694 --> 01:09:42,334 because the weapon of such power was based that close to the US 1116 01:09:47,056 --> 01:09:49,556 if the US considers Cuba to be its backyard 1117 01:09:51,947 --> 01:09:54,407 then crimea is merely at Russia's doorstep 1118 01:09:55,921 --> 01:09:59,921 what are the consequences of the US or NATO capturing that naval base? 1119 01:10:00,055 --> 01:10:01,045 very dramatic 1120 01:10:02,118 --> 01:10:04,208 because base itself means nothing 1121 01:10:06,503 --> 01:10:08,913 but there is one thing i'd like to focus on 1122 01:10:10,561 --> 01:10:13,961 why do you think we are reacting on growth of NATO so much 1123 01:10:14,810 --> 01:10:17,380 we're worried by its decision making practice 1124 01:10:18,412 --> 01:10:19,772 I know how it's done 1125 01:10:20,860 --> 01:10:23,260 when countries become a NATO member 1126 01:10:24,609 --> 01:10:28,609 it's very hard for them to resist the pressure from such a large country 1127 01:10:28,930 --> 01:10:31,240 which is the leader of NATO, the USA 1128 01:10:31,417 --> 01:10:34,106 and than anything can appear there very easily 1129 01:10:34,226 --> 01:10:38,226 missile defense systems, new bases, new offensive systems, if needed 1130 01:10:38,615 --> 01:10:40,145 and what should we do? 1131 01:10:41,972 --> 01:10:43,632 we're forced to counteract 1132 01:10:44,009 --> 01:10:48,779 meaning putting those objects that are threatening us on the aim of our missile systems 1133 01:10:50,158 --> 01:10:51,638 the situation is stressful 1134 01:10:51,863 --> 01:10:55,323 Sergei Lavrov: if we're being attacked we will definitely respond 1135 01:10:56,146 --> 01:10:57,966 you know, it seems to me that 1136 01:10:58,869 --> 01:11:01,739 I don't always understand the logic of our partners 1137 01:11:02,269 --> 01:11:04,479 sometimes I have the impression that 1138 01:11:05,283 --> 01:11:07,263 they need to set better discipline 1139 01:11:09,559 --> 01:11:11,989 set things straight in their atlantic enclave 1140 01:11:13,030 --> 01:11:14,610 and it requires an enemy 1141 01:11:15,577 --> 01:11:17,427 iran does not fit this part at all 1142 01:11:18,889 --> 01:11:22,279 I am concerned about the expansion of NATO 1143 01:11:22,511 --> 01:11:25,811 it has expanded by 13 countries up to the borders of Russia 1144 01:11:25,859 --> 01:11:26,809 13 countries 1145 01:11:27,684 --> 01:11:29,564 this is a very dangerous topic 1146 01:11:29,739 --> 01:11:31,279 we are talking about war 1147 01:11:32,110 --> 01:11:33,951 war between Russia and the US 1148 01:11:35,127 --> 01:11:36,407 it's sheer madness 1149 01:11:44,109 --> 01:11:45,519 in early spring of 2014 1150 01:11:46,579 --> 01:11:48,417 eastern Ukraine had also risen 1151 01:11:48,927 --> 01:11:51,177 against the new ukrainian government 1152 01:11:52,148 --> 01:11:53,688 this region's population 1153 01:11:53,948 --> 01:11:56,798 both culturally and geographically close to Russia 1154 01:11:57,240 --> 01:12:00,211 feared that the newly formed ultra-right government 1155 01:12:01,131 --> 01:12:03,451 would cause the growth of nationalism 1156 01:12:03,582 --> 01:12:05,542 and they had reasons to worry 1157 01:12:07,230 --> 01:12:11,780 the status of the Russian language in Ukraine was one of the key questions for years 1158 01:12:12,954 --> 01:12:15,904 declaring the Russian language as the second official 1159 01:12:15,904 --> 01:12:19,904 was one of the key points of Viktor Yanukovich's presidential campaign 1160 01:12:20,630 --> 01:12:23,390 in 2012 Yanukovich's government passed a law 1161 01:12:23,456 --> 01:12:27,136 that declared Russian the second official language in those regions 1162 01:12:27,136 --> 01:12:30,826 where more than 10% of the population consider it as their native 1163 01:12:30,826 --> 01:12:33,185 mostly on the east and south of Ukraine 1164 01:12:33,185 --> 01:12:37,185 the ukrainian nationalists initiated massive protests opposing the law 1165 01:12:37,948 --> 01:12:41,228 and an attentive observer can see here a few familiar faces 1166 01:12:41,444 --> 01:12:44,354 oleg tyagnibok: we have shown that those bastards 1167 01:12:44,354 --> 01:12:46,134 those gangs can be defeated 1168 01:12:47,639 --> 01:12:49,199 on February 23rd of 2014 1169 01:12:50,265 --> 01:12:52,675 the very next day after the regime change 1170 01:12:53,484 --> 01:12:57,484 the new government voted to denote the official status of the Russian language 1171 01:12:58,805 --> 01:13:04,034 and even though later acting president Alexander Turchinov vetoed this act, it still sent a message 1172 01:13:07,425 --> 01:13:09,885 this alarmed the Russian-speaking regions 1173 01:13:10,780 --> 01:13:13,270 and they went on the streets to protest 1174 01:13:15,847 --> 01:13:19,847 in response the Maidan supporters carried out their own demonstrations 1175 01:13:20,666 --> 01:13:23,676 when the two parties met the tension was growing 1176 01:13:23,738 --> 01:13:25,118 and it lead to tragedy 1177 01:13:28,452 --> 01:13:30,992 one person died and about 50 were injured 1178 01:13:31,055 --> 01:13:35,655 in clashes during the pro-Russian march to protest against the new Kiev government 1179 01:13:38,500 --> 01:13:42,500 on April 6 the crimean scenario began repeating in eastern Ukraine 1180 01:13:43,373 --> 01:13:47,373 the protesters seized the government institutions and the next day 1181 01:13:48,525 --> 01:13:51,666 April 7 they proclaimed the people's republic of donetsk 1182 01:13:52,871 --> 01:13:56,871 Kiev replied by announcing an anti-terrorist operation in eastern Ukraine 1183 01:14:01,835 --> 01:14:06,614 by that time the international media was screaming about a Russian invasion in Ukraine 1184 01:14:07,530 --> 01:14:10,270 Russia could be on the verge of invading Ukraine 1185 01:14:11,293 --> 01:14:14,104 but disregarding such strong words in the media 1186 01:14:14,265 --> 01:14:17,215 the ukrainian authorities never declared a war state 1187 01:14:17,381 --> 01:14:17,981 why? 1188 01:14:18,072 --> 01:14:21,492 IMF cannot give money to countries engaged in ongoing war 1189 01:14:22,493 --> 01:14:24,693 Zaharchenko: you know, in big politics 1190 01:14:24,693 --> 01:14:26,493 whatever they're talking about 1191 01:14:26,493 --> 01:14:28,023 they are talking about money 1192 01:14:28,100 --> 01:14:31,720 too much money was already invested in Ukraine to stop half way 1193 01:14:31,777 --> 01:14:34,686 Victoria Nuland: we've invested over 5 billion dollars 1194 01:14:34,686 --> 01:14:40,096 to assist Ukraine in its course to assure secure, prosperous and democratic Ukraine 1195 01:14:41,595 --> 01:14:45,015 on developing what kind of democracy was this money spent? 1196 01:14:45,015 --> 01:14:47,965 installing a democratic regime, as they were calling it 1197 01:14:47,965 --> 01:14:51,895 I guess they meant the kind of regime that is now happening in Donbass 1198 01:14:52,479 --> 01:14:54,699 obviously the funding was continued 1199 01:14:55,105 --> 01:14:57,135 and the conflict had to keep going 1200 01:15:01,474 --> 01:15:03,324 getting more and more deadly 1201 01:15:07,404 --> 01:15:11,114 as parties on both sides were using more and more lethal weapons 1202 01:15:15,212 --> 01:15:17,782 Mr. Turchinov, who practically started a war 1203 01:15:19,608 --> 01:15:22,778 is responsible for it, he started a war on his own people 1204 01:15:24,970 --> 01:15:26,630 he sent troops to Donbass 1205 01:15:27,939 --> 01:15:30,919 they did what I didn't do, they started the bloodshed 1206 01:15:39,648 --> 01:15:43,648 the world seemed too busy with greeting the new democracy in Kiev 1207 01:15:45,581 --> 01:15:49,801 to notice what was being done as it was spreading its wings over the country 1208 01:15:50,127 --> 01:15:53,947 many in southern Ukraine were watching the revolution with concern 1209 01:16:00,720 --> 01:16:04,720 and an anti-Maidan movement was formed in Odessa in January of 2014 1210 01:16:05,805 --> 01:16:09,284 the protesters set up camp in front of the trade union house 1211 01:16:10,582 --> 01:16:14,582 a building that would soon become a monument of a massacre itself 1212 01:16:15,019 --> 01:16:18,029 it is difficult to overestimate the importance of Odessa 1213 01:16:19,204 --> 01:16:21,595 it is strategically located on the black sea 1214 01:16:21,595 --> 01:16:23,744 and is the largest sea port of Ukraine 1215 01:16:23,744 --> 01:16:26,465 it's not surprising that Ukraine's new authorities 1216 01:16:26,465 --> 01:16:29,694 were watching this situation unfold with growing concern 1217 01:16:30,716 --> 01:16:33,846 more and more protesters were joining the anti-Maidan 1218 01:16:34,291 --> 01:16:36,911 while the situation in the east was heating up 1219 01:16:38,515 --> 01:16:42,865 the new ukrainian government didn't have the power to go to war on two fronts 1220 01:16:43,828 --> 01:16:45,838 if Odessa were to join the uprising 1221 01:16:47,439 --> 01:16:49,899 it would seriously complicate the situation 1222 01:16:50,945 --> 01:16:54,595 this rebellion had to be extinguished immediately and by any cost 1223 01:16:55,599 --> 01:16:57,019 and that cost was high 1224 01:16:58,430 --> 01:17:01,850 on May 2nd 2014 soccer fans flocked to the center of the city 1225 01:17:03,487 --> 01:17:06,636 the excuse was a ukrainian soccer championship match 1226 01:17:06,636 --> 01:17:10,907 surprisingly a number of those fans that came to Odessa just before the match 1227 01:17:10,907 --> 01:17:14,364 also turned out to be fighters for Maidan's self-defense militia 1228 01:17:14,932 --> 01:17:18,733 along with members of radical organizations from all parts of Ukraine 1229 01:17:19,268 --> 01:17:23,268 crowd: hail to the nation, death to the enemies, Ukraine, above everything, Ukraine, above everything 1230 01:17:24,949 --> 01:17:26,399 these fans wore masks 1231 01:17:26,902 --> 01:17:29,292 armed and shouting nationalistic slogans 1232 01:17:29,368 --> 01:17:31,188 began a disturbance in the city 1233 01:17:32,051 --> 01:17:34,042 marched to the anti-Maidan tents 1234 01:17:34,671 --> 01:17:35,891 and attacked them 1235 01:17:37,051 --> 01:17:40,741 the anti-Maidan protesters sought shelter in the trade union house 1236 01:17:41,128 --> 01:17:42,198 but it was a trap 1237 01:17:42,849 --> 01:17:46,689 Maidan supporters started throwing molotov cocktails to the building 1238 01:17:47,185 --> 01:17:48,515 until it caught on fire 1239 01:17:50,359 --> 01:17:51,779 people burnt inside or 1240 01:17:52,913 --> 01:17:54,003 trying to escape 1241 01:17:54,403 --> 01:17:55,713 jumped through the windows 1242 01:17:56,509 --> 01:17:58,819 although the fire station was less than a mile away 1243 01:17:59,615 --> 01:18:02,176 it took almost half an hour for them to arrive 1244 01:18:03,376 --> 01:18:05,735 and by then the damage had been done 1245 01:18:11,265 --> 01:18:13,076 but here is an interesting fact 1246 01:18:13,076 --> 01:18:15,105 just a few days before the tragedy 1247 01:18:15,975 --> 01:18:17,605 a messenger from Maidan 1248 01:18:18,167 --> 01:18:20,347 andriy parubiy made a visit to Odessa 1249 01:18:20,880 --> 01:18:22,579 interesting coincidence that 1250 01:18:22,801 --> 01:18:24,921 some of those he was meeting with 1251 01:18:24,993 --> 01:18:27,873 were seen as active participants on that fateful day 1252 01:18:34,560 --> 01:18:36,470 but not everyone was mourning 1253 01:18:36,759 --> 01:18:39,349 on the popular political talk-show shuster live 1254 01:18:40,239 --> 01:18:42,969 the news about the people burnt alive in Odessa 1255 01:18:43,296 --> 01:18:45,876 was welcomed with a long round of applause 1256 01:18:46,443 --> 01:18:48,722 oleg liashko: among the dead in Odessa 1257 01:18:48,722 --> 01:18:50,222 were 15 Russian citizens 1258 01:18:50,222 --> 01:18:52,342 10 were from transdnestria republic 1259 01:18:52,342 --> 01:18:53,863 and no one from Odessa 1260 01:18:55,740 --> 01:18:57,060 on its facebook page 1261 01:18:57,670 --> 01:19:00,500 the right sector announced the events of May 2nd 1262 01:19:00,815 --> 01:19:03,055 as a proud moment of national history 1263 01:19:04,141 --> 01:19:07,452 an official investigation is going on now for nearly two years 1264 01:19:08,798 --> 01:19:10,418 and still has no conclusion 1265 01:19:10,572 --> 01:19:14,742 but it seems that experts had all the information needed from the beginning 1266 01:19:15,586 --> 01:19:18,615 andriy parubiy: of course the provocation was started 1267 01:19:18,615 --> 01:19:20,975 by Putin's agents that attacked the ukrainian demonstration 1268 01:19:27,474 --> 01:19:29,354 the great importance of Odessa 1269 01:19:29,573 --> 01:19:32,093 can be seen in the fact that on May 30 2015 1270 01:19:32,336 --> 01:19:35,096 it was honored with a very special new governor 1271 01:19:40,592 --> 01:19:42,052 an old friend of the US 1272 01:19:43,489 --> 01:19:46,239 born and raised in Ukraine's neighboring country 1273 01:19:46,273 --> 01:19:46,903 Georgia 1274 01:19:48,581 --> 01:19:50,301 a quick look at his biography 1275 01:19:50,520 --> 01:19:54,250 gives one understanding that he was prepared for a special mission 1276 01:19:54,385 --> 01:19:56,905 Michael Saakashvili: i'm a peaceful protester 1277 01:19:56,904 --> 01:19:58,354 take your hands off me 1278 01:19:58,354 --> 01:20:02,014 Mister Saakashvili was receiving a US state department scholarship 1279 01:20:02,496 --> 01:20:05,565 and later worked at the new york organization “Kmara” 1280 01:20:07,520 --> 01:20:10,440 a group we heard about in color revolutions history 1281 01:20:10,744 --> 01:20:14,385 Saakashvili: what we have here is democratic bloodless revolution 1282 01:20:15,341 --> 01:20:17,141 this is the revolution of roses 1283 01:20:17,780 --> 01:20:20,251 and this is Michael Saakashvili with “kmara” 1284 01:20:21,505 --> 01:20:25,364 overthrowing the legitimately elected president edward schewarnadze 1285 01:20:26,350 --> 01:20:29,201 Saakashvili: changing the government by peaceful methods 1286 01:20:29,201 --> 01:20:30,501 is the european way 1287 01:20:30,501 --> 01:20:31,490 i'm proud of it 1288 01:20:32,041 --> 01:20:34,681 soon after the rose revolution blossomed fully 1289 01:20:34,838 --> 01:20:37,418 Georgia announced its intentions to join NATO 1290 01:20:38,284 --> 01:20:40,234 and to build a NATO military base 1291 01:20:40,422 --> 01:20:41,882 on fertile Georgian land 1292 01:20:42,012 --> 01:20:43,752 right on the border of Russia 1293 01:20:43,810 --> 01:20:46,680 Saakashvili: we will never give our freedom and independence 1294 01:20:46,680 --> 01:20:48,690 we will never give a piece of our territory 1295 01:20:48,690 --> 01:20:51,001 Saakashvili's mission was accomplished 1296 01:20:51,252 --> 01:20:53,063 at least to his friends and NATO 1297 01:20:53,965 --> 01:20:56,465 the Georgian populace wasn't quite as happy 1298 01:20:57,957 --> 01:20:59,907 in 2007 they took it to the streets 1299 01:21:01,112 --> 01:21:03,481 and Mr. Saakashvili responded with force 1300 01:21:05,740 --> 01:21:07,850 the people's discontent was growing 1301 01:21:09,893 --> 01:21:12,533 Saakashvili's party lost parliamentary elections 1302 01:21:12,636 --> 01:21:14,526 and the opposition took control 1303 01:21:14,743 --> 01:21:17,123 he said that according to the constitution 1304 01:21:17,247 --> 01:21:19,077 the new parliament's majority 1305 01:21:19,511 --> 01:21:22,581 has to form a new government with him as a president 1306 01:21:22,628 --> 01:21:24,318 Michael decided not to wait 1307 01:21:24,345 --> 01:21:26,855 the results of the new presidential elections 1308 01:21:26,927 --> 01:21:29,137 and fled the country on October 2013 1309 01:21:29,993 --> 01:21:33,273 in 2014 Saakashvili refused the summon to appear in court 1310 01:21:34,576 --> 01:21:36,626 as a witness in some criminal cases 1311 01:21:37,585 --> 01:21:41,685 later that same year he was accused of abuse of power and embezzlement 1312 01:21:43,871 --> 01:21:45,681 Saakashvili wound up in the US 1313 01:21:46,368 --> 01:21:49,938 and soon his friends in Washington found him a new assignment 1314 01:21:50,488 --> 01:21:52,758 Michael actively supported the Maidan 1315 01:21:53,588 --> 01:21:56,359 and very soon was rewarded with a high position 1316 01:21:56,359 --> 01:21:58,309 in the new ukrainian government 1317 01:21:58,309 --> 01:22:00,329 first as a the president's counselor 1318 01:22:00,328 --> 01:22:02,408 and then as the governor of Odessa 1319 01:22:03,783 --> 01:22:05,833 the day before taking this position 1320 01:22:06,000 --> 01:22:08,260 he renounced his citizenship in Georgia 1321 01:22:09,733 --> 01:22:11,592 and became a ukrainian citizen 1322 01:22:13,087 --> 01:22:15,527 Saakashvili: I will always be a proud citizen 1323 01:22:17,980 --> 01:22:19,430 of my proud homeland 1324 01:22:22,275 --> 01:22:24,635 as they say the battle is worth the blood 1325 01:22:25,829 --> 01:22:27,539 both literally and figuratively 1326 01:22:29,356 --> 01:22:33,356 hино Бурджанадзе: I know well the true price of Mr. Saakashvilli's reforms 1327 01:22:34,172 --> 01:22:37,112 he is actually a part of the ongoing in Ukraine project 1328 01:22:37,530 --> 01:22:39,890 that is being carried out by certain forces 1329 01:22:43,032 --> 01:22:45,601 Geoffrey Pyatt, the US ambassador to Ukraine 1330 01:22:45,987 --> 01:22:48,047 had visited Saakashvili just a month 1331 01:22:48,074 --> 01:22:50,114 after he took his position in Odessa 1332 01:22:50,501 --> 01:22:54,240 geoffrey Pyatt: as long as the Odessa administration delivers results 1333 01:22:55,190 --> 01:22:57,180 you're going to see a steady flow 1334 01:22:58,703 --> 01:23:00,804 of Washington visitors coming here 1335 01:23:01,664 --> 01:23:03,364 the meeting was productive 1336 01:23:03,364 --> 01:23:05,024 and geoffrey was generous 1337 01:23:08,396 --> 01:23:10,766 no matter how well Saakashvili did his job 1338 01:23:12,023 --> 01:23:14,863 it seemed like he needn't worry about his finances 1339 01:23:14,863 --> 01:23:17,842 on his facebook page he posted an official document 1340 01:23:18,182 --> 01:23:22,853 showing the new governor of Odessa gets salary of almost 200 thousand dollars a year 1341 01:23:24,771 --> 01:23:28,702 for comparison, the governor of maine gets 70 thousand dollars a year 1342 01:23:29,194 --> 01:23:31,034 so if Odessa became a US state 1343 01:23:31,319 --> 01:23:33,250 he would be at the top of the list 1344 01:23:33,420 --> 01:23:36,390 Mr. Saakashvili must have felt good in his new home 1345 01:23:37,565 --> 01:23:41,395 since he is an old fellow from the orange revolution of Viktor Ushenko 1346 01:23:42,810 --> 01:23:44,661 who is the godfather of his son 1347 01:23:48,903 --> 01:23:51,393 ex-president of Georgia Michael Saakashvili 1348 01:23:51,912 --> 01:23:54,052 was assigned the governor of Odessa 1349 01:23:54,561 --> 01:23:55,721 it is literally a spit 1350 01:23:56,091 --> 01:23:58,031 an insult to the people of Odessa 1351 01:23:58,372 --> 01:24:00,002 to all the ukrainian people 1352 01:24:00,261 --> 01:24:02,641 he wasn't even granted a US working visa 1353 01:24:02,971 --> 01:24:06,001 in the universities where they tried to put him to work 1354 01:24:06,532 --> 01:24:07,842 they didn't want him 1355 01:24:08,502 --> 01:24:10,312 but he was considered worthy 1356 01:24:11,902 --> 01:24:13,811 of being the governor of Odessa 1357 01:24:14,662 --> 01:24:15,932 are there no honest 1358 01:24:16,795 --> 01:24:19,324 professional, able Ukrainians to do that job? 1359 01:24:25,761 --> 01:24:27,091 a war, once launched 1360 01:24:27,729 --> 01:24:29,309 doesn't choose its victims 1361 01:24:30,382 --> 01:24:32,252 we are just learning at this hour 1362 01:24:32,432 --> 01:24:33,853 that Malaysia Airlines 1363 01:24:33,957 --> 01:24:36,137 has lost contact with one of its planes 1364 01:24:37,579 --> 01:24:40,109 the plane was indeed shot down by a missile 1365 01:24:40,851 --> 01:24:43,622 while flying over Ukraine near the Russian border 1366 01:24:45,646 --> 01:24:47,287 298 people were on board 1367 01:24:48,208 --> 01:24:49,429 no survivors found 1368 01:24:50,162 --> 01:24:52,061 Perry: it was a murder, a crime 1369 01:24:52,555 --> 01:24:55,365 and this odd carelessness about the investigation 1370 01:24:58,011 --> 01:25:00,371 there was a report, a very limited report 1371 01:25:00,748 --> 01:25:02,398 two months after the event 1372 01:25:02,993 --> 01:25:05,054 and it was said that the next report 1373 01:25:05,054 --> 01:25:07,434 would be on the anniversary of the event 1374 01:25:08,168 --> 01:25:10,708 if you're dealing with a criminal investigation 1375 01:25:10,765 --> 01:25:13,485 you need to work while the traces are still warm 1376 01:25:15,215 --> 01:25:16,725 and one should wonder 1377 01:25:17,646 --> 01:25:20,426 about the media's disinterest in this investigation 1378 01:25:22,716 --> 01:25:24,356 but even without answers 1379 01:25:24,474 --> 01:25:26,474 fingers were pointed immediately 1380 01:25:27,003 --> 01:25:28,384 that's not an accident 1381 01:25:28,384 --> 01:25:31,003 that is happening because of Russia's support 1382 01:25:31,003 --> 01:25:34,384 evidence indicates that the plain was shot down by a missile 1383 01:25:35,572 --> 01:25:37,681 that was launched from the territory 1384 01:25:38,162 --> 01:25:41,502 controlled by the Russia-backed separatists inside of Ukraine 1385 01:25:42,171 --> 01:25:43,251 without a doubt 1386 01:25:43,394 --> 01:25:45,864 the country in which territory it happened 1387 01:25:46,171 --> 01:25:48,391 is responsible for this horrible tragedy 1388 01:25:49,726 --> 01:25:52,186 the malaysian boeing wasn't the first plane 1389 01:25:52,265 --> 01:25:54,895 to play a big part in Russian-american relations 1390 01:25:55,240 --> 01:25:56,680 on September 1st 1983 1391 01:25:58,332 --> 01:26:00,742 korean airlines flight 007 new york - seoul 1392 01:26:02,483 --> 01:26:07,243 was shot down by a soviet interceptor aircraft over territory of USSR in the sea of Japan 1393 01:26:09,356 --> 01:26:11,766 Reagan: there is absolutely no justification 1394 01:26:11,939 --> 01:26:14,479 either legal or moral for what the soviets did 1395 01:26:15,826 --> 01:26:17,805 the tragedy of the korean boeing 1396 01:26:17,841 --> 01:26:19,791 was considered a perfect excuse 1397 01:26:19,811 --> 01:26:22,101 to demonstrate the NATO military power 1398 01:26:22,778 --> 01:26:25,298 within dangerous proximity to USSR borders 1399 01:26:25,582 --> 01:26:27,032 on November 2nd 1983 1400 01:26:27,569 --> 01:26:29,289 NATO launched massive drills 1401 01:26:30,869 --> 01:26:33,121 working on the scenario of response 1402 01:26:33,121 --> 01:26:35,350 to an escalation causing nuclear war 1403 01:26:37,001 --> 01:26:40,261 followed by placing a Pershing-2 ballistic missile in Europe 1404 01:26:41,530 --> 01:26:42,701 what Reagan did 1405 01:26:44,572 --> 01:26:47,402 could cause a paranoic overreaction of the soviets 1406 01:26:47,536 --> 01:26:48,515 and start war 1407 01:26:49,725 --> 01:26:52,865 a recently declassified US intelligence report shows that 1408 01:26:53,426 --> 01:26:56,066 for the first time since the Cuban missile crisis 1409 01:26:57,233 --> 01:26:59,512 the world got close to nuclear war 1410 01:27:02,724 --> 01:27:03,864 just like in 1983 1411 01:27:04,668 --> 01:27:07,158 the catastrophe with the malaysian aircraft 1412 01:27:07,158 --> 01:27:08,978 is leverage to push the enemy 1413 01:27:09,470 --> 01:27:12,949 a new wave of sanctions fell upon Russia immediately after that 1414 01:27:15,453 --> 01:27:18,682 the US is declaring new sanctions against Russian economy 1415 01:27:18,802 --> 01:27:20,762 almost a year and 3 months later 1416 01:27:20,900 --> 01:27:23,530 the dutch safety council published the report 1417 01:27:23,599 --> 01:27:25,838 man on a stage: ladies and gentlemen 1418 01:27:26,274 --> 01:27:27,954 the MH17 crash was caused 1419 01:27:28,666 --> 01:27:30,846 by the explosion of a 9H314M missile 1420 01:27:31,198 --> 01:27:33,768 launched from an air defense missile system 1421 01:27:33,967 --> 01:27:36,597 that exploded outside of the aircraft's cockpit 1422 01:27:37,671 --> 01:27:40,601 the report didn't blame any specific group or person 1423 01:27:41,073 --> 01:27:44,143 it estimated a very wide area of 300 square kilometers 1424 01:27:45,105 --> 01:27:47,405 as the zone where the missile was fired 1425 01:27:47,632 --> 01:27:48,782 at the same time 1426 01:27:49,074 --> 01:27:52,804 the Russian missile systems manufacturing company “aлмаз-aнтей” 1427 01:27:53,412 --> 01:27:55,292 conducted its own investigation 1428 01:27:55,362 --> 01:27:57,801 Ian Novikov: the results of our experiment 1429 01:27:57,801 --> 01:27:59,902 completely disprove the conclusions 1430 01:27:59,902 --> 01:28:01,881 of the dutch commission about the missile type 1431 01:28:01,881 --> 01:28:02,921 and the launch place 1432 01:28:03,076 --> 01:28:04,475 during the experiment 1433 01:28:04,712 --> 01:28:07,652 they blew up an entire airliner cockpit with a missile 1434 01:28:07,978 --> 01:28:09,698 and came to the conclusion 1435 01:28:09,739 --> 01:28:10,739 that the malaysian plane was shot down 1436 01:28:10,739 --> 01:28:12,349 by an old 9M38M1 missile 1437 01:28:12,349 --> 01:28:14,099 not used any more by Russia 1438 01:28:14,099 --> 01:28:15,619 but still used by Ukraine 1439 01:28:16,578 --> 01:28:19,408 the company claims that the missile was launched 1440 01:28:19,462 --> 01:28:22,502 from the territory controlled by the ukrainian military 1441 01:28:24,873 --> 01:28:27,644 one would expect that these controversial results 1442 01:28:27,997 --> 01:28:30,667 would cause the rise of interest on this incident 1443 01:28:30,904 --> 01:28:32,934 but the malaysian boeing tragedy 1444 01:28:34,158 --> 01:28:36,438 had already fulfilled its geopolitical role 1445 01:28:37,306 --> 01:28:38,987 and so was soon forgotten 1446 01:28:39,306 --> 01:28:40,726 the goal was achieved 1447 01:28:41,407 --> 01:28:44,067 after the third wave of sanctions against Russia 1448 01:28:44,387 --> 01:28:47,307 the tension between the two countries skyrocketed 1449 01:28:47,390 --> 01:28:49,250 and the question now becomes 1450 01:28:49,279 --> 01:28:51,289 are we truly witnessing cold war II 1451 01:28:52,692 --> 01:28:55,252 and if so what are the chances of surviving it 1452 01:29:12,854 --> 01:29:15,134 in 1947 the bulletin of atomic scientists 1453 01:29:16,395 --> 01:29:18,605 launched the doomsday clock project 1454 01:29:21,427 --> 01:29:24,297 it represents the time-line to the annihilation of life 1455 01:29:27,520 --> 01:29:29,630 in 1953 at the peak of the cold war 1456 01:29:31,541 --> 01:29:33,081 it was closest to midnight 1457 01:29:34,060 --> 01:29:37,390 as the superpowers were creating massive nuclear arsenals 1458 01:29:37,439 --> 01:29:40,329 this is the story of ever expanding nuclear weapons 1459 01:29:41,457 --> 01:29:45,087 as the world began to grasp the insane danger of nuclear warfare 1460 01:29:45,908 --> 01:29:48,418 and took measures to control the arms race 1461 01:29:48,537 --> 01:29:50,967 the situation was constantly getting better 1462 01:29:53,212 --> 01:29:55,402 in 1991 the clock was its furthest ever 1463 01:29:58,162 --> 01:29:59,682 17 minutes to midnight 1464 01:30:00,904 --> 01:30:02,854 that time of hope was short-lived 1465 01:30:03,738 --> 01:30:06,688 as the world was becoming more and more unstable 1466 01:30:08,845 --> 01:30:11,985 in 2015 the bulletin of atomic scientists moved the clock 1467 01:30:13,244 --> 01:30:14,854 to 3 minutes to midnight 1468 01:30:16,018 --> 01:30:17,898 today uncertain climate change 1469 01:30:18,072 --> 01:30:20,391 the modernization of nuclear weapons 1470 01:30:20,578 --> 01:30:21,758 and huge arsenals 1471 01:30:22,278 --> 01:30:23,927 present undeniable threat 1472 01:30:25,190 --> 01:30:26,961 to the existence of humanity 1473 01:30:28,935 --> 01:30:30,095 the US and Russia 1474 01:30:30,261 --> 01:30:33,321 launched massive nuclear weapons upgrade programs 1475 01:30:34,422 --> 01:30:38,422 which violates the existing agreements on reduction of nuclear potential 1476 01:30:46,824 --> 01:30:49,295 the clock is now just 3 minutes to midnight 1477 01:30:49,630 --> 01:30:53,930 because international leaders are failing to perform their most important duty 1478 01:30:54,787 --> 01:30:58,527 ensuring and preserving the health and vitality of human civilization 1479 01:31:36,628 --> 01:31:38,918 Perry: the role of an american journalist 1480 01:31:39,319 --> 01:31:42,130 is to inform the american people the best you can 1481 01:31:43,082 --> 01:31:45,072 in what you were able to find out 1482 01:31:45,451 --> 01:31:48,871 and to not be afraid of any kind of attacks that come with that 1483 01:31:49,081 --> 01:31:50,631 Nuland: the vast majority 1484 01:31:50,720 --> 01:31:52,850 of those who participated in Maidan 1485 01:31:52,899 --> 01:31:54,479 were peaceful protesters 1486 01:31:56,260 --> 01:31:58,730 uhh if you had a chance to see the pictures 1487 01:31:59,270 --> 01:32:00,770 many of us participated 1488 01:32:01,399 --> 01:32:02,250 I was there 1489 01:32:02,770 --> 01:32:05,340 there were mothers, grandmothers, veterans 1490 01:32:05,552 --> 01:32:07,632 congressman: before you proceed 1491 01:32:07,694 --> 01:32:08,864 i'd like to ask you 1492 01:32:08,993 --> 01:32:11,173 were there neo Nazi groups involved? 1493 01:32:12,162 --> 01:32:13,872 Nuland: there were, as I said 1494 01:32:13,872 --> 01:32:16,702 almost every color of ukrainian represented there 1495 01:32:16,702 --> 01:32:18,507 including not the best of them 1496 01:32:18,506 --> 01:32:20,567 congressman: so the answer is yes 1497 01:32:21,337 --> 01:32:24,667 Perry: and that's the patriotic role of a democratic journalist 1498 01:32:25,426 --> 01:32:28,406 is to give the public as much information as possible 1499 01:32:28,462 --> 01:32:31,362 so they can operate their role of responsible citizen 1500 01:32:32,329 --> 01:32:34,220 and to control the government 1501 01:32:36,106 --> 01:32:38,636 or at least to be aware of what is happening 1502 01:32:40,439 --> 01:32:42,869 we truly believe that there is only one way 1503 01:32:43,042 --> 01:32:45,892 to protect yourself from this game of manipulation 1504 01:32:46,475 --> 01:32:47,265 awareness 1505 01:32:47,787 --> 01:32:49,057 knowledge is power 1506 01:32:49,652 --> 01:32:51,742 the ability to recognize the red flags 1507 01:32:54,119 --> 01:32:58,119 and save your country from being dragged in all this chaos and mayhem 1508 01:32:59,064 --> 01:33:01,324 this relates to each and everyone of us 1509 01:33:01,981 --> 01:33:05,442 because war today does not only come with tanks and bombs 1510 01:33:05,484 --> 01:33:07,963 it comes with the manipulative mass media 1511 01:33:07,972 --> 01:33:09,403 the journalism that lies 1512 01:33:09,511 --> 01:33:11,111 and hides and twists facts 1513 01:33:11,694 --> 01:33:14,154 that are more focused on making the news 1514 01:33:14,268 --> 01:33:16,087 rather than on reporting them 1515 01:33:16,185 --> 01:33:18,239 Zaharchenko: I want to believe that 1516 01:33:20,088 --> 01:33:21,889 there will be peace in Ukraine 1517 01:33:23,599 --> 01:33:25,269 there will be law and order 1518 01:33:28,280 --> 01:33:29,780 there will be democracy 1519 01:33:31,636 --> 01:33:33,286 I wish the best for Ukraine 1520 01:33:39,360 --> 01:33:42,701 Yanukovich: I pray to God that the people in Ukraine reunite 1521 01:33:44,317 --> 01:33:46,796 for all the hate that now exists to disappear 1522 01:33:49,447 --> 01:33:51,827 I wish that there will be peace in Ukraine 1523 01:33:56,551 --> 01:33:59,011 we understand that the world has changed 1524 01:34:00,184 --> 01:34:03,204 you can't keep everything frozen in a state of cold war 1525 01:34:04,929 --> 01:34:06,748 you need to look to the future 1526 01:34:14,962 --> 01:34:16,412 many times in our film 1527 01:34:16,774 --> 01:34:18,844 we have shown the spiral of history 1528 01:34:19,173 --> 01:34:21,283 while we often repeat our mistakes 1529 01:34:21,947 --> 01:34:24,157 it also always gives us another chance 1530 01:34:24,922 --> 01:34:25,712 and hope 128034

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.