Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,001 --> 00:00:01,978
In the criminal justice system,
2
00:00:02,024 --> 00:00:05,473
sexually based offensesare considered especially heinous.
3
00:00:05,508 --> 00:00:07,459
In New York City,the dedicated detectives
4
00:00:07,528 --> 00:00:09,261
who investigatethese vicious felonies
5
00:00:09,330 --> 00:00:12,798
are members of an elite squadknown as the Special Victims Unit.
6
00:00:12,866 --> 00:00:15,267
These are their stories.
7
00:00:18,238 --> 00:00:20,339
[line trills]
Hi. You've reached Nicole.
8
00:00:20,407 --> 00:00:22,341
Please leave a messageafter the tone. Thanks.
9
00:00:22,409 --> 00:00:25,310
[line beep] Mom, it's me again.
10
00:00:25,379 --> 00:00:27,179
Where are you?
11
00:00:27,247 --> 00:00:30,315
I keep calling and calling.
12
00:00:30,584 --> 00:00:33,985
Dad and I got in a fight.
13
00:00:34,054 --> 00:00:35,687
I'm almost home.
14
00:00:35,756 --> 00:00:38,690
Why aren't you picking up?
15
00:00:42,629 --> 00:00:44,296
Thank you.
16
00:00:55,375 --> 00:00:56,508
Mom?
17
00:00:56,577 --> 00:00:58,677
[glass shatters]
18
00:00:58,745 --> 00:01:00,679
[woman cries out]
19
00:01:04,518 --> 00:01:06,518
[woman cries out]
20
00:01:06,587 --> 00:01:08,553
[phone beeps three times]
21
00:01:14,595 --> 00:01:16,194
[woman cries out]
22
00:01:17,431 --> 00:01:20,432
[suspenseful music]
23
00:01:20,500 --> 00:01:24,569
♪ ♪
24
00:01:24,638 --> 00:01:27,639
[dark music]
25
00:01:27,708 --> 00:01:28,640
♪ ♪
26
00:01:28,709 --> 00:01:31,643
[gun loading]
27
00:01:31,712 --> 00:01:34,746
[woman moaning]
28
00:01:45,058 --> 00:01:46,424
[woman cries out]
29
00:01:50,430 --> 00:01:53,565
[woman moaning]
30
00:02:00,774 --> 00:02:04,109
[moaning and grunting]
31
00:02:06,580 --> 00:02:08,313
[breathing heavily]
32
00:02:08,382 --> 00:02:11,750
Help! He's raping me!
33
00:02:11,818 --> 00:02:13,518
[gunshot]
34
00:02:13,587 --> 00:02:14,487
[siren wails]
35
00:02:15,155 --> 00:02:16,254
- Detective Perry, Homicide?
- Yeah.
36
00:02:16,323 --> 00:02:17,489
Lieutenant Benson, SVU.
37
00:02:17,557 --> 00:02:18,878
Thanks for getting here so fast.
38
00:02:18,926 --> 00:02:20,191
So, what we looking at?
39
00:02:20,260 --> 00:02:22,360
DOA is Trey Franklin, 15.
40
00:02:22,429 --> 00:02:24,296
Rifle shot to the head, close range.
41
00:02:24,364 --> 00:02:26,798
You said the shooter interrupted a rape?
42
00:02:26,867 --> 00:02:28,667
Yeah. Luke Keller, also 15.
43
00:02:28,735 --> 00:02:31,703
Saw Franklin assaulting
his mother, Nicole Keller...
44
00:02:31,772 --> 00:02:33,705
Dr. Nicole Keller, 45.
45
00:02:33,774 --> 00:02:34,974
Did you keep them separated?
46
00:02:35,309 --> 00:02:36,441
Yep. We secured the scene
and the weapon,
47
00:02:36,510 --> 00:02:37,871
took the kid's initial statements.
48
00:02:38,345 --> 00:02:39,311
He's upstairs.
The mother's in the living room.
49
00:02:39,379 --> 00:02:40,645
Okay, so we'll take the disclosure.
50
00:02:40,714 --> 00:02:41,874
That's why I called you guys.
51
00:02:41,882 --> 00:02:43,648
All right.
Rollins, you're with me.
52
00:02:43,717 --> 00:02:46,785
- Fin, Carisi.
- We'll take the son.
53
00:02:48,188 --> 00:02:51,323
Luke, I'm Detective Carisi.
This is Detective Tutuola.
54
00:02:51,391 --> 00:02:52,712
I already told the other police.
55
00:02:52,726 --> 00:02:54,459
I had to do it. He was raping my mom.
56
00:02:54,528 --> 00:02:57,462
Okay, just breathe. We just
want to know what happened.
57
00:02:57,531 --> 00:02:59,798
I was supposed
to spend the night at my dad's,
58
00:02:59,866 --> 00:03:01,833
but we got in a fight, so I came home.
59
00:03:01,902 --> 00:03:05,503
- What time did you leave?
- I left my dad's about 9:00.
60
00:03:05,572 --> 00:03:07,305
I really wanted to talk to my mom.
61
00:03:07,374 --> 00:03:09,174
I tried calling. She wasn't answering.
62
00:03:09,242 --> 00:03:11,309
Luke, now, did your mother
have plans tonight?
63
00:03:11,378 --> 00:03:13,645
Staying home, doing paperwork.
64
00:03:13,714 --> 00:03:14,846
She's a psychiatrist.
65
00:03:14,915 --> 00:03:16,348
What time did you get home?
66
00:03:16,416 --> 00:03:17,615
About 10:00. It was dark.
67
00:03:17,617 --> 00:03:20,485
I heard a noise downstairs,
thought someone was breaking in,
68
00:03:20,554 --> 00:03:23,655
so I called 911, and then went
to the closet to get my rifle.
69
00:03:23,724 --> 00:03:25,657
Your rifle?
70
00:03:25,726 --> 00:03:28,840
Yeah. My dad gave it to me.
He likes to go hunting.
71
00:03:28,842 --> 00:03:30,662
- Then what happened?
- I walked into the kitchen,
72
00:03:30,731 --> 00:03:32,564
and he was attacking my mom.
73
00:03:32,632 --> 00:03:34,566
- What did you see?
- She was staring at me.
74
00:03:34,634 --> 00:03:37,836
She was so scared. Then she
screamed "Help! He's raping me!"
75
00:03:37,904 --> 00:03:39,704
so I pulled the trigger.
76
00:03:39,773 --> 00:03:41,673
I didn't think I was
actually gonna hit him.
77
00:03:41,742 --> 00:03:42,774
[sobs]
78
00:03:42,843 --> 00:03:43,908
I have to see my son.
79
00:03:43,977 --> 00:03:47,226
He can't handle this stress.
He's got a lot of generalized anxiety.
80
00:03:47,228 --> 00:03:48,713
And I understand that,
but right now we need
81
00:03:48,782 --> 00:03:49,948
to speak to both of you separately.
82
00:03:50,017 --> 00:03:51,883
Right. Okay.
83
00:03:51,952 --> 00:03:53,351
- Okay.
- I understand.
84
00:03:53,420 --> 00:03:55,520
So, Dr. Keller, I need to know
85
00:03:55,589 --> 00:03:59,524
exactly what happened
from your perspective.
86
00:03:59,593 --> 00:04:02,293
Okay. Um, right.
87
00:04:02,362 --> 00:04:04,696
I was in the kitchen.
88
00:04:04,765 --> 00:04:06,531
I was... I was getting some wine.
89
00:04:06,600 --> 00:04:09,534
And he... I was there,
and I turn around,
90
00:04:09,603 --> 00:04:10,902
and... and he was right there.
91
00:04:10,971 --> 00:04:12,871
And I tried to get away.
92
00:04:12,939 --> 00:04:15,740
I did. I tried.
And he... he overpowered me.
93
00:04:15,809 --> 00:04:18,276
Was this a break-in?
Or maybe he followed you home?
94
00:04:18,345 --> 00:04:20,445
No. No. I let him in.
95
00:04:22,883 --> 00:04:24,482
You let him in?
96
00:04:24,551 --> 00:04:26,718
So you knew him?
97
00:04:26,787 --> 00:04:28,286
Yes.
98
00:04:28,355 --> 00:04:30,388
He was my son's best friend.
99
00:04:30,457 --> 00:04:35,457
♪ ♪
100
00:04:38,398 --> 00:04:41,433
[dramatic music]
101
00:04:41,501 --> 00:04:46,501
♪ ♪
102
00:05:16,797 --> 00:05:20,797
- sync and corrections by Zac -
- www.addic7ed.com -
103
00:05:25,834 --> 00:05:30,171
The mother let him in voluntarily.
She said he was the son's best friend.
104
00:05:30,239 --> 00:05:32,540
Explains why there's no signs
of forced entry.
105
00:05:34,110 --> 00:05:36,377
Okay, if Luke wasn't home,
why did she let him in?
106
00:05:36,445 --> 00:05:39,180
[sighs] He asked to come in
to do his homework.
107
00:05:39,248 --> 00:05:41,248
Apparently he's been having
a rough time at home.
108
00:05:41,317 --> 00:05:43,484
So, he just hung out in the house
while she was upstairs working?
109
00:05:43,553 --> 00:05:45,119
That's what she said.
110
00:05:45,188 --> 00:05:47,154
Okay, so, Luke walks in unexpectedly,
111
00:05:47,223 --> 00:05:49,183
hears his mother screaming
that she's being raped,
112
00:05:49,225 --> 00:05:51,158
and he fires.
113
00:05:51,227 --> 00:05:53,260
We're not thinking
premeditation at all?
114
00:05:53,329 --> 00:05:54,929
He called 911.
115
00:05:54,997 --> 00:05:57,198
The rifle was locked up.
Registered to his father,
116
00:05:57,266 --> 00:05:58,899
so technically not legal,
117
00:05:58,968 --> 00:06:01,602
but the shooting still sounds
justifiable to me.
118
00:06:01,671 --> 00:06:02,951
But I'm a cop, not a prosecutor.
119
00:06:04,040 --> 00:06:07,908
Okay, what about the DOA?
I mean, Trey Franklin's parents.
120
00:06:07,977 --> 00:06:10,044
On their way to the ME's office.
121
00:06:10,112 --> 00:06:11,992
How about if I meet
one of your guys over there?
122
00:06:12,048 --> 00:06:13,781
Good idea. Thanks.
123
00:06:14,600 --> 00:06:16,951
_
124
00:06:16,953 --> 00:06:18,786
Is it okay if we pick up
where we left off?
125
00:06:18,854 --> 00:06:20,588
Yeah. Sure.
126
00:06:20,656 --> 00:06:22,923
Dr. Keller,
you said that you knew
127
00:06:22,992 --> 00:06:24,692
that you shouldn't have let Trey in.
128
00:06:24,760 --> 00:06:27,261
I had an instinct.
Something was wrong.
129
00:06:27,330 --> 00:06:31,565
The way he looked at me,
you know? Made me uneasy.
130
00:06:31,634 --> 00:06:33,795
But you were okay with him
being friends with your son?
131
00:06:33,836 --> 00:06:36,470
Yes. I didn't want to shut Trey out.
132
00:06:36,539 --> 00:06:37,638
I felt badly for him.
133
00:06:37,707 --> 00:06:40,474
His family life was very unstable.
134
00:06:40,543 --> 00:06:44,078
So, Trey came to your door
at what time?
135
00:06:44,146 --> 00:06:46,480
Uh, it was around 9:00.
136
00:06:46,549 --> 00:06:48,315
Nine o'clock.
137
00:06:48,384 --> 00:06:51,318
Uh, I put my work away for the night.
138
00:06:51,387 --> 00:06:55,422
And he asked where Luke was,
said they were supposed to study.
139
00:06:55,491 --> 00:06:57,358
And I said,
"There must be a mix-up,
140
00:06:57,426 --> 00:07:00,027
'cause Luke's at his father's
house in Westport."
141
00:07:00,096 --> 00:07:04,598
Okay. Go on.
142
00:07:04,667 --> 00:07:08,168
Then he asked if he could...
if he could come in anyway,
143
00:07:08,237 --> 00:07:09,336
do his homework.
144
00:07:09,405 --> 00:07:11,038
And... [sighs]
145
00:07:11,107 --> 00:07:12,072
I said yes.
146
00:07:12,908 --> 00:07:14,709
And then I went upstairs
to get ready for bed.
147
00:07:14,710 --> 00:07:16,443
So, that's when you changed
into your nightgown?
148
00:07:16,512 --> 00:07:17,912
No. I already had my nightgown on,
149
00:07:17,913 --> 00:07:19,847
and I'd already started
getting ready for bed
150
00:07:19,915 --> 00:07:20,955
when he rang the doorbell.
151
00:07:20,957 --> 00:07:22,764
Okay, so, you answered the door
152
00:07:22,766 --> 00:07:24,952
in your nightgown,
and then you went back upstairs.
153
00:07:25,021 --> 00:07:28,589
Yes. I-I went upstairs
for about an hour.
154
00:07:28,658 --> 00:07:30,758
It started getting late,
155
00:07:30,826 --> 00:07:33,861
so I-I went back downstairs
156
00:07:33,929 --> 00:07:37,898
and I told Trey... I told him
it was time to go home.
157
00:07:37,967 --> 00:07:41,435
So, during that time,
your son was calling you.
158
00:07:41,504 --> 00:07:44,505
Um, why didn't you pick up?
159
00:07:44,573 --> 00:07:47,675
No, I didn't get the message.
I didn't get any messages.
160
00:07:47,743 --> 00:07:50,477
I... when I work sometimes
I don't even look at my phone,
161
00:07:50,546 --> 00:07:51,586
and Luke was with his dad.
162
00:07:51,588 --> 00:07:54,075
Right, but you weren't
working then, right?
163
00:07:54,077 --> 00:07:57,017
Because he started to call
I think at 9:30 to 10:00, right?
164
00:07:57,086 --> 00:07:59,253
You had already put your work
down for the night?
165
00:07:59,322 --> 00:08:02,156
Right. Yes, I had. I went
downstairs for a glass of wine.
166
00:08:02,224 --> 00:08:03,290
- Oh.
- Okay? To relax.
167
00:08:04,427 --> 00:08:08,862
And that's when I felt him...
I felt his presence behind me,
168
00:08:08,931 --> 00:08:10,831
and I turned around, and it was Trey.
169
00:08:10,900 --> 00:08:11,832
He was right there.
170
00:08:11,901 --> 00:08:13,267
And he put his hands on me.
171
00:08:13,336 --> 00:08:16,103
- So, what did you do?
- I tried to stop it.
172
00:08:16,172 --> 00:08:18,205
I tried to tell him I understood.
173
00:08:18,274 --> 00:08:21,975
I understood sexual impulses and urges.
174
00:08:22,044 --> 00:08:23,477
Believe me. I'm a psychiatrist.
175
00:08:23,546 --> 00:08:26,046
I've dealt with this issue
many, many times.
176
00:08:26,115 --> 00:08:28,115
But he...
177
00:08:28,184 --> 00:08:32,453
put me up against
the kitchen counter, and...
178
00:08:32,521 --> 00:08:34,722
he lifted up my nightgown.
179
00:08:35,991 --> 00:08:38,025
Okay. Take your time.
180
00:08:40,496 --> 00:08:43,530
I, uh...
[stammering]
181
00:08:46,836 --> 00:08:48,502
He forced himself inside me,
182
00:08:48,571 --> 00:08:50,371
and, um,
183
00:08:50,439 --> 00:08:52,239
I-I tried to scream,
184
00:08:52,308 --> 00:08:54,341
and he put his hand on my mouth.
185
00:08:54,410 --> 00:08:57,511
And I... [sobs]
There was a kitchen knife,
186
00:08:57,580 --> 00:09:01,548
and I tried to reach it,
but it was too far away.
187
00:09:01,617 --> 00:09:04,485
So I just closed my eyes,
and I tried to survive.
188
00:09:04,553 --> 00:09:07,354
And I thought about my son.
189
00:09:07,423 --> 00:09:08,455
I thought about Luke,
190
00:09:08,524 --> 00:09:12,459
and I needed to stay alive for him.
191
00:09:12,528 --> 00:09:14,294
And then... and then I looked up,
and he was there,
192
00:09:14,363 --> 00:09:16,864
and I yelled help: "Help!"
193
00:09:16,932 --> 00:09:19,299
Mm. Mm-hmm.
194
00:09:19,368 --> 00:09:20,868
And then I heard the gunshot.
195
00:09:20,936 --> 00:09:24,238
So, Mrs. Keller,
did you know that your son
196
00:09:24,306 --> 00:09:25,306
had a rifle in the house?
197
00:09:25,307 --> 00:09:29,176
Yes. In a locked safe. Yes.
198
00:09:29,245 --> 00:09:31,512
It was a gift... it was a gift
from his father.
199
00:09:31,614 --> 00:09:32,646
He's a hunter.
200
00:09:32,715 --> 00:09:34,248
Okay. Is Luke a hunter, too?
201
00:09:34,316 --> 00:09:38,152
No. He... he's so sensitive.
202
00:09:40,589 --> 00:09:43,023
He actually hated the idea
of having a gun in the house.
203
00:09:43,092 --> 00:09:45,926
Hated it.
204
00:09:45,995 --> 00:09:50,995
He went hunting, and there was
a deer in his sight,
205
00:09:51,634 --> 00:09:53,600
and he couldn't even
pull the trigger.
206
00:09:56,739 --> 00:09:58,240
I...
207
00:10:00,309 --> 00:10:01,675
it doesn't...
208
00:10:01,744 --> 00:10:03,210
it doesn't make sense.
209
00:10:03,279 --> 00:10:05,379
It... it doesn't make sense.
210
00:10:05,448 --> 00:10:09,516
That's why it's so...
211
00:10:09,585 --> 00:10:12,519
I want to see him.
212
00:10:12,588 --> 00:10:15,055
Is my mom gonna be okay?
213
00:10:15,124 --> 00:10:17,157
Yeah.
Yeah, she's at the hospital.
214
00:10:17,226 --> 00:10:19,526
She's... she's getting
checked out now. Come on.
215
00:10:19,595 --> 00:10:22,229
I know what you went through.
216
00:10:22,298 --> 00:10:24,097
I know it's tough, all right?
217
00:10:24,166 --> 00:10:25,833
Have a seat.
218
00:10:25,901 --> 00:10:28,469
But we need to go over it again,
step by step.
219
00:10:28,537 --> 00:10:30,170
Can you do that?
220
00:10:30,239 --> 00:10:31,839
Think so.
221
00:10:31,907 --> 00:10:33,006
Okay.
222
00:10:33,075 --> 00:10:34,808
So, you said you walked
into your house,
223
00:10:34,877 --> 00:10:37,978
you heard noises, you called 911,
you grabbed your rifle,
224
00:10:38,047 --> 00:10:39,847
walked down to the kitchen, right?
225
00:10:39,915 --> 00:10:41,648
- Mm-hmm.
- Okay, Luke.
226
00:10:41,717 --> 00:10:44,184
Before you fired, did you say
"stop" or "get off of her,"
227
00:10:44,253 --> 00:10:45,452
or anything like that?
228
00:10:45,521 --> 00:10:49,189
I don't think so. I just reacted.
229
00:10:49,258 --> 00:10:52,159
When did you realize it was Trey?
230
00:10:52,228 --> 00:10:53,794
Not until after.
231
00:10:53,863 --> 00:10:56,797
I thought it was just some man
who broke in, not Trey.
232
00:10:56,866 --> 00:10:58,565
How well did you guys
know each other?
233
00:10:58,634 --> 00:11:01,301
We're best friends.
234
00:11:03,339 --> 00:11:04,905
We were.
235
00:11:07,776 --> 00:11:09,776
I killed my best friend.
236
00:11:09,845 --> 00:11:11,378
Okay.
We're gonna take a break.
237
00:11:11,447 --> 00:11:13,146
We'll get you some water.
238
00:11:13,215 --> 00:11:15,349
Luke's dad is here.
239
00:11:15,417 --> 00:11:17,351
Luke, you all right?
240
00:11:17,419 --> 00:11:19,119
[crying] Dad!
241
00:11:19,188 --> 00:11:21,488
- Hey, hey, hey.
- He was hurting Mom. I swear.
242
00:11:21,590 --> 00:11:23,524
It's okay. It's okay.
I'm here now.
243
00:11:26,328 --> 00:11:28,829
Uh, do I need a lawyer?
244
00:11:28,898 --> 00:11:31,298
We're still investigating,
but it seems like Luke fired
245
00:11:31,367 --> 00:11:33,934
to save his mother
from a sexual assault.
246
00:11:34,003 --> 00:11:35,836
That being said,
these cases can get tricky.
247
00:11:35,905 --> 00:11:37,371
Appreciate your honesty.
We're done talking.
248
00:11:37,439 --> 00:11:39,339
It's all right, buddy.
Come here.
249
00:11:39,408 --> 00:11:41,008
It's all right.
250
00:11:41,076 --> 00:11:43,377
Everything's gonna be okay,
all right?
251
00:11:44,448 --> 00:11:47,281
_
252
00:11:47,283 --> 00:11:49,550
Yeah, that's his bracelet.
253
00:11:49,618 --> 00:11:54,488
And the scar. He burnt his hand
on a camping trip when he was ten.
254
00:11:54,557 --> 00:11:57,190
[crying] I want to see him.
I want to see my son's body.
255
00:11:57,259 --> 00:11:58,859
Mrs. Franklin, ma'am.
256
00:11:58,928 --> 00:12:01,495
It's better that you don't.
257
00:12:01,564 --> 00:12:03,084
I still don't understand
what happened.
258
00:12:03,098 --> 00:12:07,000
A classmate of his, Luke Keller,
he fired a weapon.
259
00:12:07,069 --> 00:12:08,735
The bullet struck and killed him.
260
00:12:08,804 --> 00:12:11,638
Luke? That doesn't make any sense.
261
00:12:11,707 --> 00:12:13,707
- They're... they're friends.
- Was it an accident?
262
00:12:13,776 --> 00:12:15,342
We're still looking into it.
263
00:12:15,411 --> 00:12:19,246
But Luke's mother says your son
was sexually assaulting her.
264
00:12:19,315 --> 00:12:20,747
What?
265
00:12:20,816 --> 00:12:23,317
- And that's why Luke shot him?
- It's possible.
266
00:12:23,319 --> 00:12:26,287
No. No. It's not possible!
267
00:12:26,756 --> 00:12:29,290
Trey would never assault anyone.
Ever.
268
00:12:29,358 --> 00:12:32,326
You may be right. It's obviously
very early in the investigation.
269
00:12:32,395 --> 00:12:34,061
Is Luke under arrest?
270
00:12:34,130 --> 00:12:36,764
- Not yet.
- Oh, I see.
271
00:12:36,832 --> 00:12:39,192
White kid shoots black kid,
got to be the black kid's fault.
272
00:12:39,235 --> 00:12:40,534
That's what you're saying?
273
00:12:40,603 --> 00:12:41,635
No. Not even close.
274
00:12:41,704 --> 00:12:44,038
We're just trying to figure out
what happened.
275
00:12:44,106 --> 00:12:48,832
Yeah, well, me too,
'cause my son was a good kid.
276
00:12:49,945 --> 00:12:53,814
No. A great kid.
277
00:12:53,883 --> 00:12:57,551
I want to see my son. Now.
278
00:12:58,788 --> 00:13:00,387
Okay.
279
00:13:04,760 --> 00:13:09,596
♪ ♪
280
00:13:09,665 --> 00:13:10,831
[knocks on glass]
281
00:13:12,168 --> 00:13:17,168
♪ ♪
282
00:13:34,123 --> 00:13:35,756
What do we know about Trey Franklin?
283
00:13:35,825 --> 00:13:39,159
Only son of Charles
and Regina Franklin.
284
00:13:39,228 --> 00:13:42,162
Father's an English professor.
Mother is an oncology nurse.
285
00:13:42,231 --> 00:13:44,098
No priors. Good student.
286
00:13:44,166 --> 00:13:46,200
He started high school
at Manor Hill in September.
287
00:13:46,268 --> 00:13:48,168
- Rape kit?
- There's no semen.
288
00:13:48,237 --> 00:13:50,170
Just a few minor abrasions.
289
00:13:50,239 --> 00:13:51,805
How long did the mother know Trey?
290
00:13:51,874 --> 00:13:53,541
A few months.
She said she didn't mind
291
00:13:53,609 --> 00:13:54,889
her son being friends with Trey,
292
00:13:54,891 --> 00:13:56,877
but she had a bad feeling
about him from the beginning,
293
00:13:56,946 --> 00:13:58,345
whatever that means.
294
00:13:58,414 --> 00:13:59,713
Because he's black?
295
00:13:59,782 --> 00:14:02,316
No. I didn't get a sense
that it was racial.
296
00:14:02,385 --> 00:14:04,418
And Luke.
Do you believe his story?
297
00:14:04,487 --> 00:14:06,253
I do.
He's taking this hard.
298
00:14:06,322 --> 00:14:08,522
He had no clue the alleged
rapist was his friend.
299
00:14:08,624 --> 00:14:11,659
But firing the rifle was the
only way to stop the assault?
300
00:14:11,727 --> 00:14:14,769
He panicked. He was trying to scare
whoever he thought it was away.
301
00:14:14,771 --> 00:14:17,898
Okay, so they were friends.
Any recent problems?
302
00:14:17,967 --> 00:14:19,533
Not that we can find.
303
00:14:19,602 --> 00:14:22,503
So, Trey came over to study with Luke,
but Luke wasn't there.
304
00:14:22,572 --> 00:14:24,471
If Trey knew
that Luke wasn't gonna be home,
305
00:14:24,540 --> 00:14:25,806
that would help to establish
his mindset.
306
00:14:25,908 --> 00:14:29,843
Then he went to Nicole's house
knowing she was gonna be alone.
307
00:14:29,912 --> 00:14:31,392
But we already checked Luke's phone.
308
00:14:31,447 --> 00:14:33,948
There's no texts or emails
between him and Trey.
309
00:14:34,016 --> 00:14:36,150
Okay, so let's dig in
to their social media account,
310
00:14:36,219 --> 00:14:38,152
talk to the friends,
see if we can find anything out.
311
00:14:38,221 --> 00:14:40,387
We should search his locker
and his bedroom, too.
312
00:14:40,456 --> 00:14:42,056
I'll get some warrants.
313
00:14:42,124 --> 00:14:43,290
Thanks.
314
00:14:43,695 --> 00:14:45,826
_
315
00:14:45,828 --> 00:14:49,763
- You want Trey's computer?
- All electronic devices.
316
00:14:49,832 --> 00:14:52,132
And what about Luke?
Have you arrested him yet?
317
00:14:52,201 --> 00:14:53,767
We're still investigating,
Mr. Franklin.
318
00:14:53,836 --> 00:14:55,035
That's why we're here.
319
00:14:55,104 --> 00:14:57,304
We're also gonna need
to search Trey's room.
320
00:14:57,373 --> 00:14:59,473
You're acting like my son's the killer.
321
00:14:59,542 --> 00:15:00,941
This is outrageous!
322
00:15:01,010 --> 00:15:02,743
Just let them go.
323
00:15:02,812 --> 00:15:04,511
They're not gonna find anything.
324
00:15:06,015 --> 00:15:07,815
Fifteen's a crazy age.
325
00:15:07,883 --> 00:15:09,683
Testosterone, impulses.
326
00:15:09,752 --> 00:15:13,721
Yeah, but you don't just wake
up one morning out of the blue
327
00:15:13,789 --> 00:15:16,557
and decide to rape your buddy's mom.
328
00:15:16,626 --> 00:15:19,460
I don't know. There's...
329
00:15:19,528 --> 00:15:21,495
there's something else going on here.
330
00:15:21,564 --> 00:15:24,431
I don't know. Everything here,
though, looks good.
331
00:15:24,500 --> 00:15:28,335
There's no weed. No booze.
332
00:15:28,404 --> 00:15:32,539
The only thing wrong is maybe
a couple of dirty socks.
333
00:15:32,608 --> 00:15:35,242
Check this out.
334
00:15:37,113 --> 00:15:40,047
That's the mother?
335
00:15:40,116 --> 00:15:41,715
Dr. Keller?
336
00:15:41,784 --> 00:15:44,251
Definitely more wrong here
than dirty socks.
337
00:15:48,409 --> 00:15:50,668
Imagine our surprise.
338
00:15:50,703 --> 00:15:52,637
Imagine my surprise.
339
00:15:52,672 --> 00:15:54,959
I had a sense Trey was
stalking me, but now I know.
340
00:15:54,961 --> 00:15:58,129
You had a sense
Trey was stalking you?
341
00:15:58,197 --> 00:16:01,365
Well, that's very different
from having a bad feeling.
342
00:16:01,434 --> 00:16:04,335
I wasn't sure, but I am now.
343
00:16:04,404 --> 00:16:06,337
That's you in the photo, correct?
344
00:16:06,406 --> 00:16:09,440
Yes! Eyes closed. Asleep.
345
00:16:09,509 --> 00:16:12,710
Unaware this adult teenager was
taking pictures.
346
00:16:12,779 --> 00:16:14,140
You mind if we take a look around?
347
00:16:14,147 --> 00:16:15,446
Of course not.
348
00:16:17,050 --> 00:16:19,116
So, just to be clear,
349
00:16:19,185 --> 00:16:21,953
you're saying that Trey walked
up these stairs,
350
00:16:22,021 --> 00:16:24,789
he hopped onto your bed
while you were sleeping,
351
00:16:24,858 --> 00:16:26,891
and he took these photos.
352
00:16:26,960 --> 00:16:28,860
Well, that's the only thing
that makes sense.
353
00:16:28,928 --> 00:16:33,164
No. There are other
plausible explanations.
354
00:16:33,233 --> 00:16:35,066
Do you always sleep naked?
355
00:16:35,134 --> 00:16:36,234
Sometimes.
356
00:16:36,703 --> 00:16:38,903
Sometimes I sleep in a nightgown.
357
00:16:38,972 --> 00:16:41,138
Sometimes I sleep
in a Rolling Stones t-shirt.
358
00:16:42,809 --> 00:16:45,176
Are you suggesting I had sex
with that boy?
359
00:16:45,245 --> 00:16:46,566
Oh, I'm not suggesting anything.
360
00:16:46,568 --> 00:16:49,947
I'm simply asking why you
and Trey were in bed together,
361
00:16:50,016 --> 00:16:51,949
naked.
362
00:16:52,018 --> 00:16:54,886
Because he was obsessed with me
and snuck into my bed.
363
00:16:54,954 --> 00:16:58,422
And you didn't wake up?
You must be a sound sleeper.
364
00:16:58,491 --> 00:17:02,193
I am. Last few months, anyway.
I've been on sleep medication.
365
00:17:02,262 --> 00:17:04,161
You said you thought
Trey was stalking you.
366
00:17:04,230 --> 00:17:05,670
If that's true, why did you give him
367
00:17:05,672 --> 00:17:08,366
so much access to your house,
invite him in at 9:00 p.m.?
368
00:17:08,434 --> 00:17:11,502
Like I said,
I was trying to help him.
369
00:17:11,571 --> 00:17:12,971
Because of his troubled home life?
370
00:17:12,973 --> 00:17:16,300
Well, we talked to his parents.
There's no evidence of that.
371
00:17:18,278 --> 00:17:20,978
Some of my patients are
victims of rape,
372
00:17:21,047 --> 00:17:24,282
and the first thing I tell them is,
"Don't blame yourself."
373
00:17:24,350 --> 00:17:26,417
Well, that's a lot easier said
than done.
374
00:17:26,486 --> 00:17:28,319
You didn't answer her question.
375
00:17:28,388 --> 00:17:30,288
I'm sorry. What question was that?
376
00:17:31,491 --> 00:17:34,992
Okay. Dr. Keller,
the night of the shooting,
377
00:17:35,061 --> 00:17:37,595
you were upstairs here
in your bedroom,
378
00:17:37,664 --> 00:17:38,896
in your nightgown.
379
00:17:38,965 --> 00:17:40,898
Trey was downstairs
in the family room,
380
00:17:40,967 --> 00:17:42,099
and nobody else was in the house?
381
00:17:42,168 --> 00:17:43,701
That's correct.
382
00:17:43,770 --> 00:17:45,970
And he didn't try and sneak
up here into your room?
383
00:17:47,140 --> 00:17:51,142
I'm sorry, lieutenant. I think it's best
if you and your colleague here leave.
384
00:17:51,210 --> 00:17:55,212
I'm sensing some underlying hostility,
and it's making me very uncomfortable.
385
00:17:55,281 --> 00:17:58,883
Yeah? And the naked selfies
of you and Trey
386
00:17:58,952 --> 00:18:00,985
are making me very uncomfortable.
387
00:18:03,656 --> 00:18:06,624
[tense music]
388
00:18:06,693 --> 00:18:08,288
♪ ♪
389
00:18:08,290 --> 00:18:11,095
_
390
00:18:11,097 --> 00:18:13,998
Trey was cool.
He was only here since September,
391
00:18:14,067 --> 00:18:15,700
but we were friends.
392
00:18:15,768 --> 00:18:17,668
Were you friends with Luke Keller, too?
393
00:18:17,737 --> 00:18:21,072
Yeah. Luke and I have known
each other since kindergarten.
394
00:18:21,140 --> 00:18:24,442
He's a good guy. A little...
395
00:18:24,510 --> 00:18:26,043
You can say it. He's a bit of a nerd.
396
00:18:26,112 --> 00:18:27,912
Yeah. But he's okay.
397
00:18:27,981 --> 00:18:29,981
But Luke and Trey were close?
398
00:18:30,049 --> 00:18:33,284
Yeah. Tight.
Trey kind of looked out for him.
399
00:18:33,353 --> 00:18:34,618
And Luke liked Trey?
400
00:18:34,687 --> 00:18:36,821
- He idolized Trey.
- Hm.
401
00:18:36,889 --> 00:18:39,457
Thought he was a god.
402
00:18:39,525 --> 00:18:41,726
I don't know... it's sort of
crazy, if you think about it,
403
00:18:41,794 --> 00:18:45,796
that Luke ended up killing his god.
404
00:18:45,865 --> 00:18:48,232
- Thank you, Ethan.
- Yeah.
405
00:18:50,236 --> 00:18:54,638
I never heard rumors
about Trey and Luke's mother.
406
00:18:54,707 --> 00:18:57,341
Is that really
what you think happened?
407
00:18:57,410 --> 00:18:58,776
We're not thinking anything yet.
408
00:18:58,845 --> 00:19:02,346
Right.
Well, the answer is no.
409
00:19:02,415 --> 00:19:06,684
I never heard anyone suggest
that Trey and Dr. Keller were...
410
00:19:06,753 --> 00:19:09,554
Okay. Anything else about Trey
you can tell us?
411
00:19:09,622 --> 00:19:12,190
No. He's a good kid.
412
00:19:12,258 --> 00:19:13,724
For the most part.
413
00:19:13,793 --> 00:19:17,261
For the most part?
What do you mean by that?
414
00:19:18,765 --> 00:19:20,765
My son has already told
the police everything he knows.
415
00:19:20,834 --> 00:19:23,067
Okay, well, we just need
to follow up on a few things
416
00:19:23,136 --> 00:19:25,169
about his relationship
with Trey Franklin.
417
00:19:25,238 --> 00:19:28,372
Now, Ethan, you told me
that Trey was cool.
418
00:19:28,441 --> 00:19:29,807
Here, have a seat.
419
00:19:29,876 --> 00:19:32,543
- That's right.
- So, there's been no issues
420
00:19:32,612 --> 00:19:34,946
or problems between the two of you?
421
00:19:35,014 --> 00:19:36,581
- None.
- None?
422
00:19:36,649 --> 00:19:38,716
Okay, well, here's the thing, Ethan.
423
00:19:38,785 --> 00:19:41,419
We just found out
that you and Trey got suspended
424
00:19:41,487 --> 00:19:43,688
for getting into a fight a week ago.
425
00:19:43,756 --> 00:19:46,257
Wait. What's going on here?
426
00:19:46,326 --> 00:19:49,460
Lying to the police
in a homicide investigation
427
00:19:49,529 --> 00:19:51,429
is a very serious matter.
428
00:19:51,497 --> 00:19:53,865
Serious enough to derail that
lacrosse scholarship I heard about.
429
00:19:53,933 --> 00:19:56,100
Okay, okay. Just...
430
00:19:57,704 --> 00:19:59,437
Tell them what happened.
431
00:20:02,942 --> 00:20:04,709
Can you leave?
432
00:20:06,312 --> 00:20:10,214
I don't want to talk about this
with you here.
433
00:20:10,283 --> 00:20:13,517
No. I'm not going anywhere.
434
00:20:13,586 --> 00:20:17,421
Okay. But what I did...
435
00:20:17,490 --> 00:20:19,557
the reason we fought...
436
00:20:22,528 --> 00:20:23,928
[sighs]
437
00:20:23,997 --> 00:20:25,162
I can't tell you.
438
00:20:25,231 --> 00:20:27,198
- Ethan.
- You don't understand.
439
00:20:27,267 --> 00:20:29,967
Just tell the truth. Now.
440
00:20:32,805 --> 00:20:35,072
Your father's right.
441
00:20:35,141 --> 00:20:38,209
Just tell us why you and Trey
got into a fight.
442
00:20:45,018 --> 00:20:47,518
We need to talk to you
down at the station.
443
00:20:47,587 --> 00:20:49,887
I already told you everything I know.
444
00:20:49,956 --> 00:20:51,689
Yeah? Well,
we talked to Ethan Miller.
445
00:20:51,758 --> 00:20:53,838
- You know him, right?
- Sure. He's a friend of Luke's.
446
00:20:53,893 --> 00:20:56,527
He said that you sexually
assaulted him
447
00:20:56,596 --> 00:20:57,895
10 times, maybe 11.
448
00:20:57,964 --> 00:21:01,098
- That's preposterous.
- Then you moved onto Trey.
449
00:21:01,167 --> 00:21:03,968
Ethan got upset, punched him.
450
00:21:04,037 --> 00:21:06,771
They both got suspended from school.
451
00:21:06,839 --> 00:21:10,841
They're kids. They fantasize
about older women.
452
00:21:10,910 --> 00:21:12,810
It's a natural, healthy fantasy.
453
00:21:12,879 --> 00:21:16,681
Nope. There's nothing natural
or healthy about statutory rape.
454
00:21:16,749 --> 00:21:18,716
Let's go. You're coming with us.
455
00:21:18,785 --> 00:21:21,319
♪ ♪
456
00:21:21,387 --> 00:21:23,387
This is ridiculous.
457
00:21:27,802 --> 00:21:31,730
Were you having a sexual
relationship with Trey Franklin
458
00:21:31,765 --> 00:21:34,132
prior to the night
he was shot and killed?
459
00:21:34,167 --> 00:21:37,477
Like I've been trying to tell you,
he was obsessed with me.
460
00:21:37,546 --> 00:21:38,612
That's a yes?
461
00:21:38,680 --> 00:21:41,348
It's an absolute, unequivocal no.
462
00:21:41,416 --> 00:21:44,651
What about Ethan? That's an absolute,
unequivocal no, too?
463
00:21:44,720 --> 00:21:46,620
Correct.
464
00:21:47,956 --> 00:21:49,823
So, Ethan was lying?
465
00:21:49,891 --> 00:21:51,424
Of course he's lying!
466
00:21:51,493 --> 00:21:53,893
Okay. Well, when he told me
what happened,
467
00:21:53,962 --> 00:21:55,762
he started to cry.
468
00:21:55,831 --> 00:21:57,152
And then he turned to his father,
469
00:21:57,265 --> 00:21:58,998
and he begged him not to hate him.
470
00:22:00,802 --> 00:22:03,603
We have a believable
15-year-old boy in there
471
00:22:03,672 --> 00:22:07,407
who is claiming that you
sexually assaulted him
472
00:22:07,476 --> 00:22:08,708
and Trey Franklin.
473
00:22:08,777 --> 00:22:10,610
Making things worse, Trey is dead.
474
00:22:10,679 --> 00:22:13,546
Because you told your son
that he was raping you,
475
00:22:13,615 --> 00:22:16,182
when, in fact, you were raping him.
476
00:22:16,284 --> 00:22:18,518
- You're making this up.
- The sooner you tell us
477
00:22:18,587 --> 00:22:20,753
the truth, the better this is
gonna be for you.
478
00:22:22,591 --> 00:22:27,060
And more importantly, Luke.
479
00:22:27,128 --> 00:22:30,396
Don't you presume to tell me
what's best for my son.
480
00:22:30,465 --> 00:22:33,533
I'm not presuming anything.
I'm just stating facts.
481
00:22:33,602 --> 00:22:35,435
[scoffs]
My understanding of the law is
482
00:22:35,504 --> 00:22:38,571
unless I'm under arrest, I'm free to go.
483
00:22:40,475 --> 00:22:42,041
I'll be calling my lawyer.
484
00:22:42,110 --> 00:22:44,310
That's your right. We'll be in touch.
485
00:22:44,379 --> 00:22:46,279
I'm sure we'll have a lot
to talk about.
486
00:22:46,348 --> 00:22:49,249
[dramatic music]
487
00:22:49,317 --> 00:22:54,317
♪ ♪
488
00:22:54,489 --> 00:22:56,189
She's a stone-cold liar.
489
00:22:56,258 --> 00:22:58,157
A psychiatrist...
490
00:22:58,226 --> 00:23:00,026
who's abusing teenage boys,
491
00:23:00,095 --> 00:23:03,796
emotionally damaging her own son.
492
00:23:03,865 --> 00:23:07,967
That is deeper than lying, man.
That is pathological.
493
00:23:08,036 --> 00:23:09,202
And we just let her walk out of here?
494
00:23:09,271 --> 00:23:13,640
Look. I want to track her phone.
I need to vet Ethan's story.
495
00:23:13,708 --> 00:23:16,843
She's smart. And a liar like
that... she covers her tracks.
496
00:23:16,912 --> 00:23:19,812
That's why we need hard evidence
that she cannot lie her way out of.
497
00:23:19,881 --> 00:23:22,415
But first we need
to make absolutely sure
498
00:23:22,484 --> 00:23:23,764
that Luke had no prior knowledge
499
00:23:24,386 --> 00:23:26,853
of what was going on
with his mother and Trey.
500
00:23:28,557 --> 00:23:32,025
That's crazy.
No way would my mom and Ethan...
501
00:23:32,093 --> 00:23:33,693
he's a liar... he's lying.
502
00:23:33,762 --> 00:23:35,428
Listen.
I know this is hard to hear...
503
00:23:35,497 --> 00:23:36,457
Because it's not true.
504
00:23:36,459 --> 00:23:38,431
My mom told me you
were gonna say this.
505
00:23:38,500 --> 00:23:40,300
Just listen to what they say, Luke.
506
00:23:40,368 --> 00:23:42,602
I'm sorry to have to tell you this.
507
00:23:42,704 --> 00:23:44,904
But it's not just Ethan.
We also believe
508
00:23:44,973 --> 00:23:46,253
Trey and your mom were having...
509
00:23:46,255 --> 00:23:48,508
She said you were gonna say that, too!
510
00:23:48,577 --> 00:23:52,178
There's no way that... that...
511
00:23:54,416 --> 00:23:56,382
It's just not true.
512
00:23:58,520 --> 00:24:01,354
My mom would never do that.
513
00:24:01,423 --> 00:24:02,589
Okay.
514
00:24:06,161 --> 00:24:09,195
I think Luke is being
completely honest.
515
00:24:09,264 --> 00:24:12,165
Well, of course he is.
He's a good kid.
516
00:24:12,233 --> 00:24:13,333
His mother, on the other hand, is...
517
00:24:13,401 --> 00:24:14,867
Is what?
518
00:24:14,936 --> 00:24:16,803
Complicated.
519
00:24:16,871 --> 00:24:21,074
Dr. Keller, is there anything
in Nicole's past or your relationship
520
00:24:21,142 --> 00:24:25,778
that might help explain this...
this type of behavior?
521
00:24:25,880 --> 00:24:27,981
She is a malignant narcissist,
522
00:24:28,049 --> 00:24:30,116
probably borderline.
523
00:24:30,986 --> 00:24:32,952
I'm a psychiatrist as well.
524
00:24:34,022 --> 00:24:36,889
So, this lying, manipulating,
525
00:24:36,958 --> 00:24:39,959
abusive pattern of behavior's
been going on for a long time?
526
00:24:40,028 --> 00:24:42,495
Since the day I met her.
527
00:24:42,564 --> 00:24:45,198
Nicole is like the best
and worst woman you've ever met
528
00:24:45,266 --> 00:24:46,499
wrapped in one.
529
00:24:46,568 --> 00:24:47,934
Yeah, we've been getting that.
530
00:24:48,003 --> 00:24:49,836
Well, when we first met,
she's... she's charming.
531
00:24:49,904 --> 00:24:51,537
She's brilliant.
532
00:24:51,606 --> 00:24:54,741
But gradually, her sickness
began to reveal itself.
533
00:24:54,809 --> 00:24:56,843
How do you mean?
534
00:24:56,911 --> 00:24:58,311
[sighs]
535
00:24:58,380 --> 00:25:00,647
Look, with Nicole...
536
00:25:00,715 --> 00:25:02,582
this woman truly believes
that she's special,
537
00:25:02,651 --> 00:25:05,885
that she deserves this unique
and constant admiration.
538
00:25:07,422 --> 00:25:10,657
She lacks compassion, empathy.
539
00:25:10,725 --> 00:25:14,661
Yet, at the same time,
she is remarkably fragile.
540
00:25:15,664 --> 00:25:17,830
She has no true sense of self,
541
00:25:17,899 --> 00:25:19,565
and I... I just...
I couldn't take it.
542
00:25:19,634 --> 00:25:22,368
- So you left her.
- Yes.
543
00:25:22,437 --> 00:25:24,003
Yes. Look, but I tried
to make it work.
544
00:25:24,072 --> 00:25:25,505
I-I couldn't.
545
00:25:25,573 --> 00:25:29,375
You just let Luke stay there,
live with her,
546
00:25:29,444 --> 00:25:31,444
knowing Nicole has all these issues?
547
00:25:31,513 --> 00:25:33,579
No. I fought like hell for custody,
548
00:25:33,648 --> 00:25:35,314
but the judge sided with her,
because, I'm telling you,
549
00:25:35,383 --> 00:25:39,318
this woman... she is incredibly
charming and persuasive.
550
00:25:45,760 --> 00:25:47,927
I never thought
she'd destroy her own son.
551
00:25:51,933 --> 00:25:53,766
Just tell me you're not gonna
charge Luke with a crime.
552
00:25:53,835 --> 00:25:55,768
Your ex-wife is the criminal here.
553
00:25:55,837 --> 00:25:57,203
We're gonna speak with the ADA.
554
00:25:57,272 --> 00:25:58,999
♪ ♪
555
00:25:59,001 --> 00:26:01,741
_
556
00:26:01,743 --> 00:26:04,143
I don't think that Luke
intentionally shot Trey.
557
00:26:04,212 --> 00:26:06,879
He truly believes that his
mother was being assaulted.
558
00:26:06,948 --> 00:26:08,147
I agree. Council, look.
559
00:26:08,149 --> 00:26:11,150
Luke had no clue that his mother
was using his friends sexually.
560
00:26:11,219 --> 00:26:12,819
He just happened to walk in.
I mean, if he hadn't
561
00:26:12,887 --> 00:26:14,654
gotten into an argument
with his father that night,
562
00:26:14,723 --> 00:26:16,489
he never would've been there
in the first place.
563
00:26:16,558 --> 00:26:18,558
Nicole is the one who's lying,
not Luke.
564
00:26:18,626 --> 00:26:20,059
And this proves it.
565
00:26:20,128 --> 00:26:23,029
Lab results are back.
Traces of fresh semen were found
566
00:26:23,098 --> 00:26:25,031
on a towel in Nicole's bedroom
upstairs.
567
00:26:25,100 --> 00:26:26,369
DNA matches Trey's.
568
00:26:26,901 --> 00:26:27,967
She said Trey was upstairs
that night?
569
00:26:28,036 --> 00:26:30,703
We asked her point blank,
and she denied it.
570
00:26:30,772 --> 00:26:34,006
- Arrest her.
- Statutory rape?
571
00:26:34,075 --> 00:26:35,875
Oh, I'm thinking a lot more than that.
572
00:26:39,280 --> 00:26:41,581
- Let's talk about that.
- Okay, time's up.
573
00:26:41,649 --> 00:26:42,715
- What?
- I'm sorry, sir.
574
00:26:42,784 --> 00:26:44,283
NYPD. We're gonna need the room.
575
00:26:44,352 --> 00:26:45,473
- Are you kidding me?
- Nope.
576
00:26:45,987 --> 00:26:47,553
Look,
just get out of here, man. Go.
577
00:26:49,390 --> 00:26:51,357
First, you lie to my son.
578
00:26:51,426 --> 00:26:53,359
Now you harass me
in my place of business?
579
00:26:53,428 --> 00:26:55,161
Stop talking. You're under arrest.
580
00:26:55,230 --> 00:26:56,295
On what charges?
581
00:26:56,364 --> 00:26:58,197
Third degree rape of a minor.
582
00:26:58,266 --> 00:27:00,366
- I'm the victim here.
- And murder.
583
00:27:00,435 --> 00:27:03,069
Murder? I didn't murder anyone.
584
00:27:03,138 --> 00:27:05,304
Look, lady. Turn around. Come on.
585
00:27:05,373 --> 00:27:07,006
Get her out of here.
586
00:27:07,909 --> 00:27:09,876
[handcuffs clicking]
587
00:27:09,944 --> 00:27:11,344
Let's go.
588
00:27:14,829 --> 00:27:17,087
[overlapping shouts]
Okay, look, look, look.
589
00:27:17,122 --> 00:27:18,641
Our only goal was
to follow the evidence
590
00:27:18,676 --> 00:27:20,971
and bring the person responsible
for Trey Franklin's death
591
00:27:21,006 --> 00:27:23,807
to justice, and that person is
Nicole Keller.
592
00:27:24,214 --> 00:27:27,182
To cry rape while she herself
was sexually assaulting a teenage boy
593
00:27:27,251 --> 00:27:29,251
with her son ten feet away,
holding a rifle,
594
00:27:29,319 --> 00:27:31,720
shows such depraved indifference
to Trey Franklin's life
595
00:27:31,788 --> 00:27:34,990
that the DA's office feels
compelled to punish this woman
596
00:27:35,058 --> 00:27:36,258
to the fullest extent of the law.
597
00:27:36,326 --> 00:27:37,792
Thank you.
598
00:27:37,861 --> 00:27:41,263
We applaud Mr. Barba's courage
in taking on this case.
599
00:27:41,331 --> 00:27:44,666
Our 15-year-old son, Trey,
was abused by a manipulative
600
00:27:44,735 --> 00:27:47,002
and remorseless 45-year-old
psychiatrist.
601
00:27:47,070 --> 00:27:49,070
Because of her, he's dead.
602
00:27:50,807 --> 00:27:52,440
Let's go.
603
00:27:52,509 --> 00:27:55,410
Last Tuesday night,
Dr. Nicole Keller
604
00:27:55,479 --> 00:27:57,812
was the victim of a sexual assault,
605
00:27:57,881 --> 00:27:59,681
and if it weren't for
the actions of her son, Luke,
606
00:27:59,750 --> 00:28:01,550
she might have been killed.
607
00:28:01,618 --> 00:28:04,386
Dr. Keller is a respected
and empathetic psychiatrist
608
00:28:04,454 --> 00:28:06,588
who was simply trying
to help Trey Franklin,
609
00:28:06,657 --> 00:28:08,790
and despite the fact
that he sexually assaulted her,
610
00:28:08,859 --> 00:28:11,927
she is devastated
by his tragic death.
611
00:28:11,995 --> 00:28:14,663
And to suggest that she had
anything to do with this
612
00:28:14,731 --> 00:28:17,465
is absolutely outrageous.
613
00:28:17,534 --> 00:28:19,458
[reporters all speaking at once]
614
00:28:19,460 --> 00:28:21,670
_
615
00:28:21,672 --> 00:28:23,672
Lieutenant Benson, this towel,
marked exhibit D,
616
00:28:23,740 --> 00:28:25,440
was taken from the home
of the defendant.
617
00:28:25,509 --> 00:28:27,309
- Are you familiar with this item?
- Yes.
618
00:28:27,377 --> 00:28:29,658
Can you tell us which part
of the house it was taken from?
619
00:28:29,680 --> 00:28:31,546
- The master bedroom.
- Where is that located?
620
00:28:31,615 --> 00:28:33,315
On the top floor of the brownstone.
621
00:28:33,383 --> 00:28:35,884
Did you receive a report from
the crime lab about this towel?
622
00:28:35,953 --> 00:28:39,254
Yes. Trace evidence of fresh
semen was found on the towel.
623
00:28:39,323 --> 00:28:41,523
The DNA was a match to Trey Franklin.
624
00:28:41,592 --> 00:28:43,858
When you questioned the defendant
625
00:28:43,927 --> 00:28:45,207
in the aftermath of the shooting,
626
00:28:45,229 --> 00:28:48,063
did she mention that Trey had been
in the top floor of the brownstone?
627
00:28:48,131 --> 00:28:52,434
No. She specifically stated that
he was downstairs the entire time,
628
00:28:52,502 --> 00:28:54,936
and then, in a subsequent
interview, restated it.
629
00:28:55,005 --> 00:28:56,738
Thank you. Nothing further.
630
00:28:58,242 --> 00:29:00,041
No questions, Your Honor.
631
00:29:03,680 --> 00:29:05,947
Prosecution calls Luke Keller.
632
00:29:06,016 --> 00:29:08,917
When you walked into the downstairs
kitchen, what did you see?
633
00:29:08,986 --> 00:29:13,788
My mother bent over
with a man behind her, on top of her.
634
00:29:13,857 --> 00:29:15,457
Did you know it was Trey?
635
00:29:15,525 --> 00:29:17,859
- No!
- Then what happened?
636
00:29:21,431 --> 00:29:23,265
My mother looked at me and screamed,
637
00:29:23,333 --> 00:29:24,733
"Help! He's raping me."
638
00:29:24,801 --> 00:29:26,334
Did she make eye contact with you?
639
00:29:26,403 --> 00:29:27,669
- Yes.
- Did she see the rifle?
640
00:29:27,738 --> 00:29:29,971
Objection. Speculation.
641
00:29:30,040 --> 00:29:31,473
- Sustained.
- Rephrase:
642
00:29:31,541 --> 00:29:33,408
did she ever look down at your hands?
643
00:29:33,477 --> 00:29:34,809
Yes.
644
00:29:39,616 --> 00:29:41,650
I think so.
645
00:29:41,718 --> 00:29:43,351
After your mother looked down
at your hands and yelled,
646
00:29:43,420 --> 00:29:45,553
"Help! He's raping me,"
what did you do?
647
00:29:47,224 --> 00:29:48,523
I pulled the trigger.
648
00:29:48,592 --> 00:29:51,092
But I was just trying to scare him away.
649
00:29:51,161 --> 00:29:53,628
I just wanted to save my mom
from what was happening.
650
00:29:54,998 --> 00:29:56,364
Nothing further.
651
00:29:58,068 --> 00:30:01,202
That must have been traumatic,
652
00:30:01,271 --> 00:30:03,505
walking in on your mother like that.
653
00:30:03,573 --> 00:30:05,340
- Yes.
- And you're young.
654
00:30:05,409 --> 00:30:07,108
You don't know a lot about sex.
655
00:30:07,177 --> 00:30:11,246
Must have looked to you
like she was very frightened.
656
00:30:11,315 --> 00:30:12,747
Right?
657
00:30:12,816 --> 00:30:15,216
Yeah. I mean, it looked bad.
658
00:30:15,285 --> 00:30:19,521
So, when she yelled,
"Help! He's raping me,"
659
00:30:19,589 --> 00:30:20,755
you believed her.
660
00:30:20,824 --> 00:30:22,957
Yes. At the time.
661
00:30:23,026 --> 00:30:26,061
But Lieutenant Benson told me
about what they found.
662
00:30:26,129 --> 00:30:28,596
Yes, but at the time, in your mind,
663
00:30:28,665 --> 00:30:30,665
Trey was sexually assaulting
your mother?
664
00:30:30,734 --> 00:30:32,934
Yes, but it was all happening
so fast.
665
00:30:33,003 --> 00:30:34,769
I... I just reacted.
666
00:30:34,838 --> 00:30:37,872
Right. You reacted to what you saw:
667
00:30:37,941 --> 00:30:40,909
a man attacking your mother.
668
00:30:40,977 --> 00:30:45,513
As for the rifle, you have
no idea if your mother saw it.
669
00:30:45,582 --> 00:30:47,882
I mean, you have no way of knowing
670
00:30:47,951 --> 00:30:51,753
what her eyes were actually focused on.
671
00:30:51,822 --> 00:30:53,321
Yeah. I... I guess.
672
00:30:53,390 --> 00:30:55,223
Especially since she was being raped.
673
00:30:55,292 --> 00:30:59,361
- Objection.
- Withdrawn.
674
00:30:59,429 --> 00:31:01,563
One other thing, Luke.
675
00:31:04,701 --> 00:31:08,403
The prosecutor, Mr. Barba,
676
00:31:08,472 --> 00:31:10,372
made a deal with you
677
00:31:10,440 --> 00:31:14,209
including no jail time
for testifying against your mother...
678
00:31:16,947 --> 00:31:19,247
Even though you're the one
679
00:31:19,316 --> 00:31:22,183
who killed Trey Franklin, correct?
680
00:31:24,555 --> 00:31:26,888
Yes.
681
00:31:26,957 --> 00:31:28,957
Nothing further.
682
00:31:32,896 --> 00:31:34,896
You may step down.
683
00:31:46,376 --> 00:31:47,476
It's okay.
684
00:31:47,644 --> 00:31:49,411
It's okay.
685
00:31:49,479 --> 00:31:50,879
Come on. Let's get you out of here.
686
00:31:50,948 --> 00:31:55,948
♪ ♪
687
00:31:59,156 --> 00:32:02,657
I tried my best,
but this is all my fault.
688
00:32:02,726 --> 00:32:04,426
I didn't have to pull the trigger.
689
00:32:04,528 --> 00:32:08,163
It took a lot of courage
to get up on that stand.
690
00:32:08,232 --> 00:32:09,331
Come on, Luke. Let's go.
691
00:32:09,399 --> 00:32:11,399
I'll walk you out.
692
00:32:13,337 --> 00:32:16,037
- Luke. Luke.
- Mom.
693
00:32:19,243 --> 00:32:24,243
♪ ♪
694
00:32:32,089 --> 00:32:35,190
Poor kid doesn't know
whether to hate her or love her.
695
00:32:35,259 --> 00:32:38,159
It's hard to give up on your mother,
696
00:32:38,228 --> 00:32:40,028
no matter how sick she may be.
697
00:32:40,365 --> 00:32:42,097
_
698
00:32:42,099 --> 00:32:44,132
So, what happened?
699
00:32:44,201 --> 00:32:46,801
I was in the kitchen,
pouring a glass of wine.
700
00:32:46,870 --> 00:32:48,803
Then I saw Trey walking toward me.
701
00:32:48,872 --> 00:32:53,642
He grabbed me and kissed me,
hard, aggressive.
702
00:32:53,710 --> 00:32:56,711
I told him to stop,
but he pulled up my nightgown
703
00:32:56,780 --> 00:32:59,914
and put his penis inside me.
704
00:32:59,983 --> 00:33:02,017
- Then what happened?
- I started to scream.
705
00:33:02,085 --> 00:33:05,186
He put his hand over my mouth,
told me to shut up
706
00:33:05,255 --> 00:33:06,921
or he'd kill me.
707
00:33:06,990 --> 00:33:09,624
A few minutes later, I saw Luke.
708
00:33:09,693 --> 00:33:11,226
What did you say to him?
709
00:33:11,295 --> 00:33:13,495
Well, I screamed, "Help!"
710
00:33:13,563 --> 00:33:15,397
I screamed, "I'm being raped!"
711
00:33:15,465 --> 00:33:17,832
Did you know he had a gun
in his hand?
712
00:33:17,901 --> 00:33:20,435
No. I was in shock.
713
00:33:20,504 --> 00:33:21,703
I was being attacked.
714
00:33:21,772 --> 00:33:24,205
What happened
after you yelled "rape"?
715
00:33:24,274 --> 00:33:26,241
I heard a loud,
716
00:33:26,310 --> 00:33:29,911
horrible gunshot,
717
00:33:29,980 --> 00:33:31,980
and then it was over.
718
00:33:34,217 --> 00:33:36,251
Nothing further.
719
00:33:38,088 --> 00:33:41,156
Trey showed up at your house
at 9:00 at night.
720
00:33:41,224 --> 00:33:43,158
Your son wasn't home,
but you let him in anyway?
721
00:33:43,226 --> 00:33:46,061
I felt empathy
for his turbulent home life.
722
00:33:46,129 --> 00:33:48,830
You kept telling the police
that... "his turbulent home life,"
723
00:33:48,899 --> 00:33:50,699
even though his parents are
happily married
724
00:33:50,767 --> 00:33:51,967
and he's a straight-A student.
725
00:33:52,569 --> 00:33:53,968
Grades are not indicative
of psychological
726
00:33:54,037 --> 00:33:55,170
or emotional problems.
727
00:33:55,172 --> 00:33:57,005
We're not interested in your
psycho-babble for the moment,
728
00:33:57,007 --> 00:33:59,641
but thank you so much for sharing.
Um, you also told the police
729
00:33:59,710 --> 00:34:02,210
that Trey stayed downstairs
all night,
730
00:34:02,279 --> 00:34:07,015
and yet his semen was found
on a towel in your bedroom,
731
00:34:07,084 --> 00:34:08,850
on the top floor of your brownstone.
732
00:34:08,919 --> 00:34:10,485
Is there a question here, Your Honor?
733
00:34:10,554 --> 00:34:12,454
Yes. How did it get there?
734
00:34:12,522 --> 00:34:15,256
I have no idea.
Maybe he snuck up to my room
735
00:34:15,325 --> 00:34:16,991
and masturbated that night.
736
00:34:17,060 --> 00:34:19,828
Or maybe you had an initial
sexual encounter with Trey
737
00:34:19,896 --> 00:34:21,696
in your room, then brought him
down to the kitchen
738
00:34:21,765 --> 00:34:23,231
- to have more sex.
- Objection.
739
00:34:23,300 --> 00:34:25,533
- I'll allow.
- That's not what happened.
740
00:34:25,602 --> 00:34:26,842
That's exactly what happened.
741
00:34:26,870 --> 00:34:28,503
You let him into your home
late at night
742
00:34:28,572 --> 00:34:30,572
while wearing lingerie.
743
00:34:30,640 --> 00:34:34,275
- It was a nightgown.
- We're not gonna argue about semantics.
744
00:34:34,344 --> 00:34:35,777
This is what you were wearing.
745
00:34:35,846 --> 00:34:37,379
Yes. But I was ready for bed.
746
00:34:37,447 --> 00:34:40,648
Or maybe you were ready
to sexually assault a 15-year-old boy.
747
00:34:42,185 --> 00:34:45,987
You let him into your house
while wearing only a nightgown.
748
00:34:46,056 --> 00:34:49,391
An hour later, your son interrupted
you and Trey in the kitchen.
749
00:34:49,393 --> 00:34:53,094
Even though you saw a rifle
in his hand, you cried "rape"
750
00:34:53,163 --> 00:34:55,163
to cover up the fact that you
were abusing his friend.
751
00:34:55,232 --> 00:34:57,732
- Trey raped me.
- No. You raped him.
752
00:34:57,801 --> 00:34:59,801
- Objection.
- Withdrawn.
753
00:35:02,105 --> 00:35:07,105
♪ ♪
754
00:35:10,814 --> 00:35:14,082
Your Honor, I'd like to testify again.
755
00:35:15,919 --> 00:35:17,719
I need to change my defense.
756
00:35:17,788 --> 00:35:19,788
What?
757
00:35:21,691 --> 00:35:23,892
I've been lying.
758
00:35:23,960 --> 00:35:25,860
I just want to tell the truth.
759
00:35:25,929 --> 00:35:28,797
The real truth.
760
00:35:28,865 --> 00:35:31,666
Uh, Your Honor, we should
discuss this matter in private.
761
00:35:31,735 --> 00:35:33,067
Agreed.
762
00:35:33,136 --> 00:35:35,303
Counsel, my chambers, now.
763
00:35:42,456 --> 00:35:44,864
She's had a change of heart,
Your Honor.
764
00:35:44,899 --> 00:35:46,586
She wants to tell the truth.
765
00:35:46,621 --> 00:35:47,876
What the hell does that even mean?
766
00:35:47,883 --> 00:35:49,049
You don't get
to suddenly tell the truth
767
00:35:49,118 --> 00:35:50,784
because the jury isn't
buying your lies.
768
00:35:50,853 --> 00:35:53,520
I have the right to redirect
the testimony of my witness,
769
00:35:53,589 --> 00:35:55,489
and in the course
of that redirection,
770
00:35:55,558 --> 00:35:57,624
my client will offer a new defense.
771
00:35:57,693 --> 00:35:59,493
What are you talking about,
Mr. Buchanan?
772
00:35:59,562 --> 00:36:02,563
Dr. Keller's new testimony
will contradict
773
00:36:02,631 --> 00:36:04,198
her prior testimony.
774
00:36:04,266 --> 00:36:06,633
So, she's willing to admit
to the jury, to the judge,
775
00:36:06,702 --> 00:36:08,168
that she perjured herself?
776
00:36:08,237 --> 00:36:10,337
She is. She just wants
to clear her conscience,
777
00:36:10,406 --> 00:36:12,573
and let the chips fall where they may.
778
00:36:12,641 --> 00:36:15,709
I agree in concept,
but first I'd like to know
779
00:36:15,811 --> 00:36:17,611
what this new defense is.
780
00:36:18,668 --> 00:36:20,981
_
781
00:36:20,983 --> 00:36:23,617
Tell the jury exactly what happened.
782
00:36:26,288 --> 00:36:31,191
Trey Franklin and I were
in the kitchen having sex.
783
00:36:32,394 --> 00:36:34,495
Then Luke walked in on us
784
00:36:34,563 --> 00:36:36,130
and shot his friend in the head.
785
00:36:36,198 --> 00:36:40,167
So, you didn't yell,
"Help! He's raping me"?
786
00:36:40,236 --> 00:36:43,170
- No.
- Did you make eye contact
787
00:36:43,239 --> 00:36:45,305
with Luke prior to him
pulling the trigger?
788
00:36:45,374 --> 00:36:47,076
No, I did not.
789
00:36:48,911 --> 00:36:51,578
Then what happened?
790
00:36:51,647 --> 00:36:54,148
What happened was I realized
791
00:36:54,216 --> 00:36:57,618
I didn't want my son to go to prison,
792
00:36:57,686 --> 00:37:01,922
so I told the police
that Trey had raped me,
793
00:37:01,991 --> 00:37:05,592
and Luke killed him to protect me.
794
00:37:05,661 --> 00:37:06,693
Oh, my God.
795
00:37:06,762 --> 00:37:09,029
- But that was a lie?
- Yes.
796
00:37:09,098 --> 00:37:11,665
And Luke knew
that you and Trey were involved
797
00:37:11,734 --> 00:37:14,902
- in a sexual relationship?
- Yes.
798
00:37:14,970 --> 00:37:16,637
How?
799
00:37:19,508 --> 00:37:22,876
One time, I saw him
watching us having sex.
800
00:37:22,978 --> 00:37:24,811
Okay, that's enough, honey.
We're gonna go. Let's go.
801
00:37:24,880 --> 00:37:26,413
No. I want to hear.
802
00:37:27,416 --> 00:37:30,184
What was your son doing?
803
00:37:32,488 --> 00:37:36,423
He was... he was in the doorway,
masturbating.
804
00:37:36,492 --> 00:37:37,925
[gasps and murmuring]
805
00:37:37,993 --> 00:37:39,059
You don't need to hear this,
sweetheart.
806
00:37:39,128 --> 00:37:40,961
Dr. Keller, are you saying
807
00:37:41,030 --> 00:37:43,597
your son has a romantic
attraction for you?
808
00:37:43,666 --> 00:37:45,199
Yes.
809
00:37:45,267 --> 00:37:47,301
It's not as unusual
as you might think.
810
00:37:47,369 --> 00:37:49,069
Yes, that's enough, honey.
I'm taking you out.
811
00:37:49,138 --> 00:37:50,237
Right now. Let's go.
812
00:37:50,306 --> 00:37:52,439
Luke, it's my fault.
813
00:37:52,508 --> 00:37:54,174
I should've taken better care of you.
814
00:37:54,243 --> 00:37:56,143
I should never have
gotten involved with Trey.
815
00:37:56,212 --> 00:37:58,879
I take full responsibility for this.
816
00:37:58,948 --> 00:38:01,114
- Come on, honey.
- Even though my son shot
817
00:38:01,183 --> 00:38:02,950
- and killed Trey.
- Luke, enough.
818
00:38:03,018 --> 00:38:03,984
Objection, Your Honor.
819
00:38:03,986 --> 00:38:06,553
Sustained. Mr. Buchanan,
any more questions?
820
00:38:06,622 --> 00:38:08,589
Um, nothing else, Your Honor.
821
00:38:08,657 --> 00:38:09,957
- We are adjourned.
- Your Honor, I want
822
00:38:10,025 --> 00:38:11,425
to cross-examine
this defendant now,
823
00:38:11,493 --> 00:38:12,659
today, while the jury is still...
824
00:38:12,728 --> 00:38:13,768
That's enough for today.
825
00:38:13,770 --> 00:38:16,730
We will resume tomorrow
morning at 9:00 a.m.
826
00:38:16,832 --> 00:38:21,832
♪ ♪
827
00:38:22,071 --> 00:38:24,638
She's burying her own son
to create reasonable doubt.
828
00:38:24,707 --> 00:38:26,673
Yeah, and she just might
get away with it.
829
00:38:26,742 --> 00:38:27,975
The jury's got to see
what she's doing,
830
00:38:28,043 --> 00:38:29,443
hate her as much as we do.
831
00:38:29,511 --> 00:38:31,345
Maybe.
But a few skeptical jurors,
832
00:38:31,413 --> 00:38:32,734
and she walks on a murder charge.
833
00:38:33,916 --> 00:38:36,116
Excuse me, Mr. Barba?
834
00:38:36,185 --> 00:38:38,418
Oh, it's all right. Show him in.
835
00:38:38,487 --> 00:38:40,220
I'm sorry to come down here.
I didn't know where else to go.
836
00:38:40,289 --> 00:38:42,122
- What is it?
- Luke wants to plead guilty.
837
00:38:42,191 --> 00:38:44,591
- Guilty? Guilty of what?
- Murder.
838
00:38:44,660 --> 00:38:46,360
But he can't even do that, right?
You gave him immunity.
839
00:38:46,428 --> 00:38:48,128
Qualified immunity.
840
00:38:48,197 --> 00:38:50,130
Listen, if he changes his story now,
841
00:38:50,199 --> 00:38:51,231
he starts lying
to protect his mother,
842
00:38:51,300 --> 00:38:52,499
that deal... that goes away.
843
00:38:52,568 --> 00:38:54,468
The judge may very well
accept his plea.
844
00:38:54,536 --> 00:38:57,871
Dr. Keller, this makes no sense.
What exactly is Luke saying?
845
00:38:57,940 --> 00:39:01,308
He now believes
he deliberately shot Trey,
846
00:39:01,377 --> 00:39:05,045
that deep down he knew his
mother was screwing his friend.
847
00:39:05,114 --> 00:39:06,394
She's spinning him upside down.
848
00:39:06,448 --> 00:39:08,048
She wants him to go to prison?
849
00:39:08,117 --> 00:39:10,951
In her deluded mind, Luke is
responsible for what happened,
850
00:39:11,020 --> 00:39:12,352
for her shame.
851
00:39:12,421 --> 00:39:14,321
He is the enemy,
852
00:39:14,390 --> 00:39:15,989
so taking him down...
853
00:39:16,058 --> 00:39:17,758
that's gonna make her
feel whole again.
854
00:39:17,826 --> 00:39:20,060
Even if it means convincing
her son he's responsible
855
00:39:20,129 --> 00:39:21,228
for a murder he didn't commit?
856
00:39:21,297 --> 00:39:23,897
Well, we can't let her do that,
so, Mr. Keller,
857
00:39:23,966 --> 00:39:25,132
where is Luke now?
858
00:39:25,200 --> 00:39:26,867
I'd like to talk to him.
859
00:39:28,971 --> 00:39:31,505
Hi, Luke. Thanks for meeting me.
860
00:39:31,573 --> 00:39:33,807
My dad said I had to.
861
00:39:34,977 --> 00:39:36,743
You hanging in there?
862
00:39:38,914 --> 00:39:41,381
How about maybe we could
take a drive?
863
00:39:41,450 --> 00:39:43,684
- Yeah.
- Okay.
864
00:39:43,752 --> 00:39:45,185
My car's right there.
865
00:39:53,562 --> 00:39:55,395
How about we go get something to eat?
866
00:39:55,464 --> 00:39:57,998
Actually, I'm not hungry.
867
00:39:58,067 --> 00:40:00,300
And I don't want people
staring at me.
868
00:40:00,369 --> 00:40:02,336
We can talk here, if that's okay.
869
00:40:02,404 --> 00:40:04,237
Sure.
870
00:40:04,306 --> 00:40:06,373
Okay.
871
00:40:06,442 --> 00:40:09,242
[takes deep breath]
872
00:40:09,311 --> 00:40:11,966
So, Luke, I know that you want
to help your mother,
873
00:40:14,216 --> 00:40:16,116
but you can't plead guilty.
874
00:40:16,185 --> 00:40:17,951
Why?
875
00:40:18,020 --> 00:40:19,252
I'm the one who shot Trey.
876
00:40:19,321 --> 00:40:21,988
Because she begged for your help.
877
00:40:22,057 --> 00:40:24,291
You told that to me
and Detective Carisi
878
00:40:24,360 --> 00:40:26,026
a dozen times, Luke.
879
00:40:26,095 --> 00:40:28,895
You were trying to save her life.
880
00:40:28,964 --> 00:40:32,866
Yeah, I know,
but I knew she liked Trey,
881
00:40:32,935 --> 00:40:35,469
and she was always real
talkative when he was around.
882
00:40:35,537 --> 00:40:37,671
Did you ever see
the two of them together,
883
00:40:37,740 --> 00:40:38,805
physically?
884
00:40:38,874 --> 00:40:41,041
- No.
- Okay.
885
00:40:51,487 --> 00:40:53,720
What my mother said about me...
886
00:40:53,789 --> 00:40:56,723
you know, watching... that's a lie.
887
00:40:56,792 --> 00:40:58,325
I know that.
888
00:40:58,394 --> 00:41:00,675
But I did hear her say that
Trey was really handsome once,
889
00:41:00,729 --> 00:41:04,164
so maybe I did know,
and I just didn't know that I knew.
890
00:41:04,233 --> 00:41:06,066
Luke, listen to me:
891
00:41:06,135 --> 00:41:11,071
what your mother did to Trey
and what she did to Ethan...
892
00:41:11,140 --> 00:41:13,707
that's a crime.
893
00:41:13,776 --> 00:41:15,976
It's called statutory rape.
894
00:41:20,215 --> 00:41:24,084
- I was trying to save her.
- I know that.
895
00:41:24,153 --> 00:41:26,286
You are a good son.
896
00:41:26,355 --> 00:41:30,090
And you are a very brave person.
897
00:41:30,159 --> 00:41:32,225
I shot Trey.
898
00:41:32,294 --> 00:41:33,927
That makes me a killer.
899
00:41:33,996 --> 00:41:38,131
Look at me.
You didn't intend to kill Trey.
900
00:41:38,200 --> 00:41:41,835
You know that. I know that.
901
00:41:41,904 --> 00:41:44,171
And your mother knows that.
902
00:41:48,577 --> 00:41:51,645
Your mother told me the hunting story.
903
00:41:51,713 --> 00:41:56,713
That... that you had a deer
right in your sights,
904
00:41:57,052 --> 00:41:59,686
and you couldn't pull the trigger,
905
00:41:59,755 --> 00:42:03,457
because you couldn't kill a living,
breathing animal.
906
00:42:03,525 --> 00:42:05,459
That's who you are.
907
00:42:07,729 --> 00:42:12,729
And it's not your job
to sacrifice your life for hers.
908
00:42:18,507 --> 00:42:22,163
♪ ♪
909
00:42:22,165 --> 00:42:24,578
_
910
00:42:24,580 --> 00:42:26,313
Mr. Barba,
are you ready to begin
911
00:42:26,381 --> 00:42:29,316
your cross-examination
of the defendant?
912
00:42:29,384 --> 00:42:31,918
No, Your Honor.
913
00:42:31,987 --> 00:42:35,222
I'd like to recall a witness:
Luke Keller.
914
00:42:53,175 --> 00:42:58,144
Luke, did you intentionally shoot
Trey Franklin because you were
915
00:42:58,146 --> 00:43:01,760
angry at him for being in a sexual
relationship with your mother?
916
00:43:15,631 --> 00:43:18,431
No.
917
00:43:18,500 --> 00:43:21,401
That's not true.
918
00:43:21,470 --> 00:43:24,938
I shot him because I thought
he was raping her.
919
00:43:25,007 --> 00:43:27,140
And why did you think that?
920
00:43:28,110 --> 00:43:30,577
Because she looked me
in the eye and yelled,
921
00:43:30,646 --> 00:43:33,046
"Help. He's raping me."
922
00:43:36,085 --> 00:43:41,085
♪ ♪
923
00:43:42,825 --> 00:43:44,825
Members of the jury,
have you reached a verdict?
924
00:43:44,893 --> 00:43:46,259
We have, Your Honor.
925
00:43:46,328 --> 00:43:48,161
What say you?
926
00:43:48,230 --> 00:43:49,996
On the charge
of second degree murder,
927
00:43:50,065 --> 00:43:53,166
we find the defendant guilty.
928
00:43:53,235 --> 00:43:56,937
On the charge of third degree
rape of a minor,
929
00:43:57,005 --> 00:44:00,073
we find the defendant guilty.
930
00:44:00,142 --> 00:44:02,642
The state of New York
thanks you for your service.
931
00:44:02,711 --> 00:44:03,710
Court is adjourned.
932
00:44:03,779 --> 00:44:06,113
- Luke! I love you.
- Nicole, no.
933
00:44:06,181 --> 00:44:08,648
And I forgive you!
934
00:44:08,717 --> 00:44:11,685
I do! Do you hear me?
Do you hear me?
935
00:44:11,754 --> 00:44:14,621
I'm still your mother!
936
00:44:14,690 --> 00:44:18,358
I'll always be your mother,
no matter what you've done!
937
00:44:18,427 --> 00:44:21,561
I will always be your mother!
938
00:44:21,630 --> 00:44:24,398
- Let's go.
- Congratulations, Lieutenant.
939
00:44:24,466 --> 00:44:25,866
You've convinced my son
I'm the devil.
940
00:44:25,934 --> 00:44:27,901
No, Nicole.
941
00:44:27,970 --> 00:44:29,903
You did that all by yourself.
942
00:44:39,115 --> 00:44:40,848
You okay?
943
00:44:42,184 --> 00:44:44,184
Look.
944
00:44:44,253 --> 00:44:46,954
He's a strong kid. He'll be fine.
945
00:44:47,022 --> 00:44:49,790
You really believe that?
946
00:44:49,859 --> 00:44:51,024
[sighs]
947
00:44:51,093 --> 00:44:52,993
Can I buy you a drink?
948
00:44:54,497 --> 00:44:57,598
No, thanks.
I got to go home to see Noah.
949
00:44:57,666 --> 00:44:59,399
I got to...
950
00:44:59,468 --> 00:45:01,535
I just want to be with my boy.
951
00:45:14,850 --> 00:45:16,985
♪ ♪
952
00:45:16,987 --> 00:45:20,443
- sync and corrections by Zac -
- www.addic7ed.com -
70681
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.