Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
A modern-looking skeleton
discovered by German scientist,
Hans Reck, in Olduvai Gorge, Tanzania,
in 1913, was controversially claimed to date to
1.15 to 1.7 million years ago.
This made it the oldest
anatomically-modern human skeleton ever discovered.
Later, carbon dating by Reiner Protsch,
a professor at Frankfurt University,
found the fossil to be much younger.
However, Protsch was subsequently dismissed
from the University,
and some researchers dispute his findings
upholding the original dating.
Over 30 miles long and about 300 feet deep,
Olduvai Gorge is an ancient site in the Great Rift Valley,
in the Eastern Serengeti plain, Northern Tanzania.
Deposits exposed in the sides of the gorge
cover a vast period,
beginning around 2.1 million years ago
and ending about 15,000 years ago.
The deposits have produced the fossil remains
of more than 60 human ancestors,
thus providing the most continuous known record
of human evolution,
over the past 2 million years.
The site has yielded abundant animal fossils
and stone artifacts
preserved in the well-dated stratigraphic sequence.
Olduvai Gorge was made famous by paleoanthropologists,
Louis and Mary Leakey,
who conducted numerous digs at the site
in the mid-20th century.
The couple's fossil discoveries at the site
prove that human beings were far older
than had been previously believed,
and that human evolution was centered in Africa
rather than in Asia
as earlier research had suggested.
Long before the Leakeys,
Olduvai first became known to the scientific world
in 1911, when a German entomologist professor,
Kattwinkle, who was collecting butterflies in the area,
discovered the gorge accidentally.
He came upon various fossils in the gorge,
including teeth of hipparion,
and took them back to Berlin,
where they stimulated a great deal of interest.
He gave the site the name, Oldoway,
later to be changed by the English to Olduvai.
The finds were believed so significant
that a German expedition
on behalf of the universities of Berlin and Munich,
and under the leadership of geologist and paleontologist,
Professor Hans Reck,
was sent to Tanzania in 1913
and spent three months at Olduvai.
The most spectacular find from these 1913 excavations
was a modern-looking skeleton found embedded in rock
on an east-facing slope of Olduvai Gorge.
Reck claimed this skeleton was about
half a million years old,
the age of the deposits in which it had been discovered.
This was the first discovery of prehistoric human remains
in the gorge,
which was to become the scene of major discoveries
in later years.
With Reck's training as a paleontologist,
he was used to working with fossils.
The fact that the bones he discovered
were in a highly compacted deposit,
persuaded him that they were of great antiquity.
In fact, the deposit was so hard
that the bones had to be removed with hammers and chisels.
This belief in the apparent antiquity of the find
was supported by his analysis of the geological sequence
in the gorge.
The skeleton, which lay in the crouch position,
typical of late stone age burials
he had seen in east Africa and elsewhere,
was removed from what he had labeled Bed II,
which he dated to over 150,000 years ago.
The skeletal remains discovered by Reck
included a complete but damaged skull,
containing 36 teeth rather than the usual 32.
Reck understood this as a primitive,
and therefore, early feature of the skeleton.
Fossils of an extinct elephant were also discovered
in the sediments below the level of the skeleton,
which led Reck to conclude
that the deposit was dated to the Middle Pleistocene period,
now known as Chibanian,
between 770,000 and 126,000 years ago.
Reck knew that the discovery of Homo sapiens
remains in a deposit of this date
would be extremely controversial.
So, he attempted to establish whether the skeleton
could have belonged to a later burial.
In the end, he was unable to discover evidence
for a dug hole into the layer,
at a later period,
that might have been a grave cut.
Reck's skeleton, now called Oldoway Man
or the Oldoway Human Skeleton,
soon became notorious throughout the scientific world
as its age could not be satisfactorily verified.
Reck was unable to return to the site
due to the 1914-18 war
which put a stop to any further work at Olduvai,
as the gorge was in German East Africa,
where fierce fighting took place
between the British and German forces.
It was partly due to the controversy
surrounding Reck's discovery,
that the young Louis Leakey
became fascinated with the Olduvai Gorge.
Although initially skeptical
of Reck's controversial assertions,
when Leakey visited the site with Reck,
he was soon persuaded to agree with him.
The pair, then co-authored a letter
to the British journal "Nature"
reporting the new evidence,
which apparently supported Reck's original theory.
As late as 1931,
reports were circulating
that it was almost beyond question
that the skeleton of a human being found by Reck in 1913
was the oldest known authentic skeleton
of Homo sapiens.
However, from the very beginning,
there were many academics who disagreed
with Reck's dating of the skeleton.
Their main objection was that his work
was undertaken at Olduvai,
without any understanding of archeological stratigraphy.
In 1932, English geologist, P.G.H. Boswell,
carried out heavy mineral analysis of Bed II
and of the deposit near the skeleton,
and came to the conclusion that the skeleton was a burial
and intrusive to Bed II.
Although the deposit in which the skeletal remains
were discovered, was indeed of Middle Pleistocene date.
Geological analysis of the material
surrounding the skeleton,
showed it to contain red pebbles and limestone chips.
Such material is not found in Bed II,
but occurs higher up in the sequence,
which indicates that it is later than that.
This would make it certain that the skeleton was intrusive
in that layer.
In other words,
the skeleton lay in a grave cut down from a higher layer.
Eventually, Reck himself came to accept the explanation.
The case for a much more modern date
for the Oldoway Man Skeleton appeared to be closed,
when in the 1970s,
radiocarbon dating of the remains
showed them to be no older than 19,000 BC.
This apparently proved
that the remains belonged to a post-ice age man
of the capstone culture,
and that they had become embedded in layers
dating from the early Pleistocene.
The radiocarbon dates were apparently obtained
by German anthropologist,
Professor Reiner Protsch Von Zieten,
of the University of Frankfurt.
Unfortunately, in February 2005,
it was revealed that the 30-year long career
of this distinguished academic
had come to an abrupt end,
due to the fact that he had been systematically falsifying
the dates on numerous Stone Age relics.
Thomas Terberger, the archeologist who discovered the fraud
said, "Anthropology is going to have to completely revise
its picture of modern man,
between 40,000 and 10,000 years ago."
Professor Protsch's work appeared to prove that,
anatomically, modern humans and Neanderthals had coexisted,
and perhaps even had children together.
This now appears to be rubbish.
The academic scandal was only discovered
when the professor was caught trying to sell
his department's entire chimpanzee skull collection
in the United States.
Further inquiries later established
that he had also authorized fake fossils as real
and had plagiarized other scientist's work.
An important Hamburg skull fragment,
which once believed to have come from
the world's oldest German,
a Neanderthal, was actually only 7,500 thousand years old,
according to Oxford University's Radiocarbon Dating Unit.
The unit also established
that other skulls dated by
Professor Reiner Protsch von Zieten
had been wrongly dated.
Some of the professor's other hoaxes were more extreme.
One of his more sensational finds, Binshof-Speyer Woman,
was dated by him to 21,300 years ago.
But, in fact, lived in 1,300 BC.
While Paderborn-Sande Man,
date by the professor to an incredible 27,600 BC,
only died a couple of hundred years ago in 1750.
Professor Ulrich Brand,
who led the investigation into the nefarious activity
said "It's deeply embarrassing."
"Of course, the university feels very bad about this."
"The professor refused to meet us,
but we had 10 sittings with 12 witnesses."
"Their stories about him were increasingly bizarre,
after a while, it was hard to take it seriously."
"You had to laugh, it was just unbelievable."
"At the end of the day, what he did was incredible."
Investigators also discovered that some of the
12,000 skeletons stored
in the university department's bone cellar
were missing their heads,
apparently sold by the professor to friends in the US,
and various dentists.
The professor, who lived Mainz with his wife, Angelina,
refused to answer questions by reporters.
Merely saying that he was the victim of an intrigue
and that, "All the disputed fossils
are my personal property."
So, where does this leave Oldoway Man?
The radiocarbon dating by the remains
by Professor Protsch cannot be taken seriously,
until full proof of radiocarbon dating is performed
on the skeleton,
Reck's original hypotheses
that he had discovered the remains
of the oldest known skeleton
of Homo sapiens
cannot be dismissed out of hand.
A skeleton dubbed Little Foot,
discovered in South Africa in the 1990s,
is claimed to be the most complete ancient hominin
in the fossil record.
The results of recent analysis into the skeleton
have caused controversy,
as researchers claim that Little Foot
actually lived some 3.67 million years ago,
about a million years earlier than previous claims.
And that the fossil probably represents
a previously unknown species
related to humans.
In 1994, Ronald Clark,
a paleoanthropologist at the University of Witwatersrand
in Johannesburg, South Africa,
was examining boxes of fossils at a field laboratory
at the Sterkfontein Caves,
about 25 miles northwest of Johannesburg.
The collection had previously been thought
to contain nothing but ancient monkey bones.
When he came upon a group of small bones in the collection,
he immediately realized that they belonged
to an early hominin.
Clark later established that the bones
seemed to have belonged to an ancient species
of ape-like hominins
that were present in Africa
between about 4 million and 2 million years ago,
before the human genus, Homo, became dominant.
In 1997, Clark came up on more bones
from the skeleton at a nearby medical school,
and decided he would search for more
of the Little Foot skeleton,
in the cave itself.
But it was to take until 2012
to locate and remove all traces of Little Foot
from the cave.
Study researcher, Robin Crompton,
a musculoskeletal biologist at the University of Liverpool,
in the United Kingdom,
said that the excavations proved much more difficult
than at first thought.
This was mainly because the bones themselves
were softer than the rock surrounding them.
Once in possession of the remains though,
even more difficult work lay ahead,
Clark said of the recovery of the skeleton,
"We used very small tools, like needles, to excavate it,
that's why it took so long."
"It was like excavating a fluffy pastry out of concrete."
In December 2018,
it was finally revealed that after 20 years of excavating
in South Africa,
researchers had completely recovered
and cleaned the most complete skeleton
of an approximately 3.67 million year old hominin
nicknamed, Little Foot.
Initial theories were that the Little Foot fossil
is a female who exhibited some of the earlier signs
of human-like bipedal walking.
Fascinatingly, she may also belong to a distinct species
that most researchers haven't previously recognized.
The nickname, Little Foot,
came from the small size of the foot bones
that were among the first parts of the skeleton
to be discovered.
The newly discovered Little Foot specimen
is more than 90% complete,
which far exceeds the amount of remains
of its more famous cousin, Lucy,
whose skeleton is about 40% complete.
The skeleton's relatively small build
and certain skull features
suggested to the researchers
that it was probably a female of advanced age,
with a brain size of about 408 cubic centimeters,
about 1/3 the size of modern human brains.
The woman seemed to have suffered a forearm injury
early in life
and her comparatively long legs in proportion to her arms
means that she had similar proportions
to those of modern humans.
Little Foot is the oldest known hominin
to have this feature,
which suggests that she probably walked upright
more than she swung through trees.
Researchers stated that Little Foot was probably 4"3' tall
and also vegetarian.
According to Robin Compton,
"My analysis of her skeleton
shows that she,
and the rest of the local population of her species
at that time,
were under active natural selection
for an ability to walk efficiently,
fully upright, on the ground over medium to long distances."
Examination of the skeleton remains showed that Little Foot
had sustained an arm injury early in life.
However, this injury had healed long before
she fell into the cave
where she was found and died.
"The fatal fall may have been during a struggle
with a large monkey,
as the skeleton of one was found
very close to her." said Crompton.
Based in part on the examination of her teeth and hips,
researchers believe Little Foot represents a new species.
The name had previously been given to
a hominin skull fragment found in South Africa in 1948,
but it was withdrawn after researchers decided
that the skull probably belonged
to an unusual africanus.
However Lee Berger,
an archeologist at the University of Witswatersrand,
who was not involved with the latest research
into the skeleton,
but is working on publications about Little Foot,
stated that if Little Foot is actually
a newly identified species,
which he is far from convinced is the case,
then she should have a new species name
and not reuse an old undefined one, but Compton disagreed.
After the Australopithecus africanus specimen
was properly named,
Clark began using that name for the bone fragments
found in the cave.
He said on the naming issue,
"It's a bad practice
and against the International Code
of Zoological Nomenclature
to create new names where a valid name already exists."
"A no-good argument for separation
into a different species exists."
So, as Professor Clark did not have evidence
that Little Foot
was part of a different species,
and he continued to use that name for the fossils
in the published scientific literature,
it was entirely appropriate
that he used the existing and valid name.
Berger is also concerned about the lack of solid information
in the recently published papers
on the Little Foot skeleton.
He believes there should be more detailed measurements
of the fossil bones.
For instance, there's no data.
"There are almost no measurements of the fossils." he says.
Berger hopes, one day, to provide the missing data
in his own publications.
Although, he is still at an early stage of the analysis.
The researchers suggest that these specimens
are potentially an ancestor of a group of hominins
called the Paranthropus four,
which coexisted with early Homo species
for about a million years.
Much more controversy has arisen
over the dating of the Little Foot fossil,
based on the age of the sediments around the fossil,
the researchers have dated Little Foot
to around 3.67 million years ago,
about a million years earlier
than previous dates for the skeleton.
This would mean Little Foot was alive
about 500,000 years before Lucy in Ethiopia.
The date would mean that our ancient ancestors
were almost certainly scattered across Africa.
Some researchers are unconvinced that the skeleton itself
is as old as the sediments in which it was found.
Fred Grine, a paleoanthropologist at Stony Brook, New York,
quote, "We buried a dead squirrel in our backyard
in November, 2014,
but I think the sand surrounds it
dates back to the last glacial retreat on Long Island."
He argues that millions of years after the sand crystals
washed into the cave,
a larger opening could have formed
allowing an ancient human ancestor to fall in.
Darryl Granger, however, is aware of the dating problems,
"Dating cave sediments and their fossils is difficult."
"We know so much about the timing of hominid evolution
in East Africa,
because there are many dateable volcanic ashes
associated with the fossil sites."
"In places like South Africa,
there are no volcanic ashes to date."
"The cave sediments themselves can be very complicated,
with sediment falling into multiple entrances,
collapsing into lower sections, and overlapping each other."
In March, 2020, it was reported in the media
that a high resolution micro-CT scanning
of the skull of Little Foot
has revealed some aspects of how this species used to live
more than 3 million years ago.
The work was undertaken by
University of Witswatersrand team,
which included lead researcher, Dr. Amelie Beaudet.
By comparing the Little Foot with other fossils
from South and East Africa,
as well as living humans and chimpanzees,
the team showed
that it was capable of head movements
that differ from modern humans.
In the summary of the paper,
the doctor states,
"In particular, the nearly complete atlas of Little Foot
has the potential to provide new insights
into the evolution of head mobility
and the arterial supply to the brain in the human lineage."
"Our study shows that it was capable of head movements
that differ from us."
"This could be explained by the greater ability of them
to climb and move in trees."
"However, a Southern African specimen
younger than Little Foot,
probably younger by about a million years,
may have partially lost this capacity
and spent more time on the ground, like us today."
One aspect of the new research appears to
contradict to some extent
earlier conclusions about Little Foot's movement.
The new study found that the overall dimensions
and shape of the atlas,
the topmost bone, sitting just below the skull
of Little Foot
are similar to living chimpanzees.
More specifically, the ligament insertions
and the morphology of the facet joints linking the head
and the neck,
all suggests that Little Foot was moving regularly in trees
rather than mainly on the ground
as was previously believed.
A spectacular recent find from Kenya,
by Meave Leakey,
of the National Museum of Kenya and her colleagues,
has caused controversy in the scientific world.
The find, a damaged but almost complete skull and face,
is claimed to be 3.5 million years old
and belonged to an entirely new breed of early human.
However, many scientists have objected
to this identification
due to apparent damage to the fossil.
And the debate over whether it is indeed a new species
is still continuing.
Born on the 28th of July, 1942, in London,
English paleoanthropologist, Dr. Meave Leakey,
is part of a family that has gained
worldwide renown for decades,
of pioneering hominin research in Eastern Africa.
She is the daughter in-law of Louis and Mary Leakey,
and wife of Richard Leakey,
the famous paleontologists
who have made several significant hominid finds
in the last 50 years.
In 2002, Meave Leakey, along with her daughter,
Louise, was named an Explorer-in-Residence,
by the National Geographic Society.
In 2007, Leakey was a lead author of a study
in the journal "Nature"
that went against the predominant view
of the ancestral lineage of Homo sapiens.
Namely, that the species Homo habilis
evolved into Homo erectus,
in linear succession.
Currently, Dr. Leakey is a research professor
in the Department of Anthropology, Stony Brook University,
New York, Director of Plio-Pleistocene research
at the Turkana Basin Institute, Kenya.
Explorer-in-Residence at the National Geographic Society,
and co-leader with her daughter,
Louise, of the Koobi Fora Research Project, the KFRP.
In 2001, Meave and her daughter, Louise, and colleagues,
reported on the discovery of a 3.5 million year old skull
that they believed belonged to a previously unknown hominin
genus and species, the Kenyan Flat-face.
Research assistant, Justus Erus,
had made the find two years earlier
while working with members of the Leakey family,
near the Lomekwi River in northern Kenya,
the almost complete skull was battered and weathered,
but for the Leakeys,
cleverly represented a new breed of early human.
It is the oldest near complete human skull ever found.
For the previous two decades,
scientists had believed that
a species better known as Lucy,
named after the partial Ethiopian skeleton
discovered in 1974,
was our single common ancestor.
Meave and Louise's discovery
apparently demonstrated that humans
did not descend from Lucy
and that, rather than a neat ancestral line
linking us to chimps,
there were likely numerous species of hominids
living at the same time.
According to Meave,
"The find was significant
because it showed us that the situation
was a lot more complex than we thought."
Whilst Lucy was able to walk upright,
she had an ape-like projecting mouth and heavy brow.
The newly discovered skull,
the only one of its kind so far identified,
however, has a much flatter face
and raised cheek bones.
The brow is smaller
and teeth are intermediate,
between typical human and typical ape forms,
with fairly small molars
compared to Lucy and her later relatives.
Dr. Leakey said, of the huge importance of the find,
"This shows persuasively
that at least two lineages existed
as far back as 3.5 million years."
"The early stages of human evolution
are more complex than we previously thought."
Kenyan Flat-face Man still had a long way to go
in terms of brain power.
However, possessing a brain cage,
no bigger than a modern chimp.
The new find is said to come from a completely new genius.
Though this new group may,
according to some researchers, already have two members.
They have noted that the features exhibited
look very similar to those of a skull discovered in 1972,
on the Eastern shore of Lake Turkana,
in the Kenyan Rift Valley
by Meave Leakey's husband, Richard.
The skull, named 1470 Man,
had a very human-like face,
flat rather than protruding like an ape,
and with small teeth.
The age of 1470 Man was controversial for many years,
it's believed by most researchers to be around
1.8 million years old,
and is assigned to the species Homo rudolfensis,
usually regarded as a very primitive member
of our own lineage.
However, a few people believe the skull
should not be attributed to Homo rudolfensis
and needs to be reexamined.
In Leakey's studies of the finds published in 2012,
she stated that the specimen from Lake Turkana
is a different species from the early Homo varieties
previously known to have inhabited the area.
These were Homo habilis, handy man,
the assumed tool user,
conventionally seen as the earliest known Homo species,
and Homo erectus,
the upright man,
thought to be a direct ancestor of our own species.
According to Leakey,
"With these new fossils,
we can definitely say there are two groups of non-erectus
living side by side
at Lake Turkana."
"As opposed to other species of Homo,
which had rather protruding faces,
what would've struck you
was how flat and broad the face was."
"Their brain case is beginning to get
a little bit of a forehead
because it's quite a big brain in there,
but nothing like the brain of Homo erectus,
which likely arose later."
The study team wanted to avoid the previously proposed names
for the flat-face species, Homo rudolfensis,
as the relationships between the fossil specimens
and the species names is still uncertain.
The study team wanted to avoid the previously proposed name
for the flat-face species, Homo rudolfensis,
as the relationships between the fossil specimens
and the species names
is still uncertain.
One fascinating question
is how the three early humans would've coexisted
without friction over food supplies, for example,
existing between them.
According to physical anthropologist, William Kimbel,
given the facts that they were all terrestrial bipeds,
of one sort or another,
differences in how the three species made a living,
and where they chose to live,
would've come down to diet
as opposed to say climbing ability.
Perhaps it may just be
that these early human species
simply had no problems getting along with each other.
"Modern primates are generally very good
at living together." Leaky commented.
"You can see troops of monkeys
composed to at least two species, if not more."
The study of the origins of man
is understandably a controversial and complex area.
Since Meave Leakey's initial discovery,
the picture has been complicated
even more by the identification in 2000,
of a hominin now called Orrorin tugenensis.
This creature could represent
an entirely new group of hominids,
and is claimed to be the oldest human-like creature
known to science,
taking our lineage back
to an astonishing 6 million years ago.
In 2000, the research team of Brigitte Senut
and Martin Pickford
discovered fossil material
consisting of a partial humorous, femur, and mandible,
a distant thumb bone, and some teeth
in the Tugen Hills of Kenya.
The molars were covered with thick enamel,
like those of later hominins,
and were small, like our own.
The discovery was nicknamed at the time, Millennium Man,
due to its discovery date,
and was dated to 6 million years ago,
and given the taxonomic classification Orrorin tugenensis,
Original Man from the Tugen Hills.
Initially, paleoanthropologists were skeptical of the find
with many remaining so to this day,
especially as the fossils were not made available
to the scientific community.
Although there is still a heated debate over the fossil,
it is increasingly presented in published texts as hominin.
Millennium Man lived around the time when
genetic analysis suggest,
our oldest hominin ancestor
split from the oldest ancestor of the great apes.
This means there's a chance that Orrorin tugenensis
could be the fabled missing link,
or at least one of them.
In March 2003,
paleontologist, Tim White,
of the University of California, Berkeley
questioned the heritage of Meave Leakey's find.
He argued, that it was more likely
to be a Kenyan variant of Lucy.
White based his assertion on the fact
that the cranium
was cracked and distorted when discovered,
making it possible
that some of its apparently unique features,
including its flat face
and tall vertically-oriented cheek bones,
could have been caused by geological processes.
Fred Spoor of the University College, London,
who was part of the team that found
the Kenyan Flat -face Man fossil,
disputed such objections
and made a new detail study of the skull.
From examining computed tomography scans,
Spoor concluded that the upper jaw
had suffered much less distortion
than the rest of the cranium.
So, he focused his studies on that bone
correcting for the distortion present,
and concluded that Leakey and her colleagues
had been correct
in designating the fossil
a new species.
Ancient hominin in bones discovered in Northern Spain's
Atapuerca Mountains have pushed back the arrival
of humans in Europe
to roughly 1.2 million years ago,
around 500,000 years earlier than once believed.
Fascinatingly, only about 1/10 of the site's total area
has been excavated,
which means there may be many more
important discoveries in store.
One mystery of the site,
the archeologists have so far been unable to solve,
is how the remains of 32 individuals accumulated
at the bottom of a narrow cave shaft
at the site.
The discovery of Atapuerca,
Atapuerca is the site
of a number of limestone caves
near Burgos in Northern Spain,
known for the abundant fossil record
of the earliest human beings in Europe,
dating back almost 1 million years.
The sites at Atapuerca
have been known since the end of the 19th century,
but it was not until the 1950s
that any details of the site became known
when the Edelweiss Caving Club,
ECC of Burgos, Northern Spain,
began to catalog and map Cueva Mayor at Atapuerca.
In 1962, ECC members reported fossils in the railway cutting
to the local authorities.
A decade later,
the ECC discovered the Gallery of Flint.
And in 1976, they located hominid skulls
in the Pit of Bones.
Paleontologist, Emiliano Aguirre,
began investigating sites at Atapuerca soon afterwards.
And in 1978,
put together a research project
for the first excavations there,
which he led until 1991,
when he retired and handed over the leadership
of the Atapuerca Research Project.
In March, 2008,
it was announced that Spanish paleontologists
had unearthed the remains of a 1.2 million year old
human-like inhabitant
of Western Europe,
in the caves at Atapuerca.
According to the researcher,
the fossil find demonstrates
that members of our genus, Homo,
colonized this region
far earlier than previously believed.
The primitive hominin
is represented by a fragment of jawbone
bearing a few teeth.
Although stone tools of a similar age to the fossil jawbone
from about 1.2 to 1.5 million years old,
had previously been discovered in France, Italy, and Spain.
This is the first verifiable human material of this date.
This lends support to the theory
that the tools found in the vicinity
were made by primitive humans.
According to Chris Stringer,
of the Natural History Museum in London,
when combined with the emerging archeological evidence,
it suggests that Southern Europe began to be colonized
from Western Asia,
not long after humans had emerged from Africa.
Something which many of us would've doubted
even five years ago.
One of the sites that Atapuerca, Gran Dolina,
contains human remains
which have been dated to about 800,000 years ago,
as well as some of the earliest tools
ever found in Western Europe.
But perhaps the most fascinating discovery at Atapuerca
was a cave called the Pit of Bones,
where 43 feet down
more than 1,600 human fossils,
including several nearly complete skulls were found.
The materials in the pit
dates back to between 600,000 and 300,000 years,
and represents about 28 individuals
whose brain sizes are within the range
of both Neanderthals and modern humans.
This represents the world's largest collection
in any one place of ancient human fossils.
Compared to modern humans,
these people were short, stocky, and had smaller brains.
It has been estimated
males were about 5"7' tall
and weighed around 170 pounds.
Whereas females stood around 5"2'
and weighed 125 pounds.
The skeleton's exhibit a number of characteristics
unique to Neanderthals,
including a projecting mid-face,
long and narrow pubic bones,
and thick finger bones.
However, unlike later Neanderthals,
they do not fully express
the characteristic Neanderthal form.
The site also contained a 430,000 year old fractured skull,
which has been interpreted
as the earliest evidence of interpersonal violence in Homo.
Also discovered in the pit
were the bones of cave bears,
it's believed that the bears
fell down the shaft by accident,
probably while seeking places to hibernate.
But what the human bones were doing there
can only be imagined,
no signs of tool butchery
or other food remains were discovered.
And a single stone hand ax
was the only tool discovered in the pit,
fashioned from a type of stone
not known in the area.
Researchers have proposed various hypotheses
to explain how the fossils got there.
According to one theory,
the bodies may have been purposely dropped
by their relatives
in some kind of ritual burial.
This would push back the origin of mortuary practices
in humans substantially.
Thus far, the earliest accepted burials
only occur after 130,000 years ago,
among Neanderthals and Homo sapiens.
However, other researchers believe
it is more than likely that the bodies
were deliberately dropped there after meeting violent ends.
The hominins may also have been dragged there by carnivores,
carried by flood waters, or even being trapped
after venturing too far.
In August, 2016,
a study of the human remains from the Pit of Bones
was published in the "Journal of Archaeological Science."
It identified trauma on eight skulls from the pits.
Part of the abstract to the study reads,
"The fractures found in 17 crania from SH
display a postmortem fracturation pattern,
which occurred in the dry bone stage
and is compatible with collective burial assemblages."
"Nevertheless, in addition to the postmortem fractures,
eight crania also display some typical perimortem traumas."
"Interpersonal violence as a cause
for the perimortem fractures
can be confirmed for one of the skulls,
cranium 17, and also probable for cranium five,
and cranium 11."
"For the rest of crania,
although other causes cannot be absolutely ruled out,
the violence-related traumas
are the most plausible scenario
for the perimortem fractures."
"If this hypothesis is confirmed,
we could interpret that interpersonal violence
was a recurrent behavior
in this population from the Middle Pleistocene."
It would appear from the results of this study
that at least some of those in the pit
suffered a violent end
at the hands of other members of the population in the area.
However, this still doesn't explain how
and why the dead bodies were taken into the cave chamber.
Perhaps the perpetrators wanted to hide their victims
or maybe relatives interred the corpses in the pit,
we shall probably never know for sure.
In December, 2013,
it was revealed that a thigh bone from the Pit of Bones
had yielded 400,000 year old DNA,
by far the oldest human DNA ever sequenced.
Previously, the oldest human DNA sequenced
came from bones that were less than 120,000 years old.
Astonishingly, the results suggested that the thigh bone
belonged to a previously unknown human species,
which some researchers believe
may even be a missing link between Neanderthals
and their mysterious cousins, the Denisovans.
Paleontologists believe this result
brings us nearer than ever before
to understanding who our own common ancestor
within Neanderthals was.
According to Chris Stringer,
the genomes we have up until now
are really very recent.
This takes us at least a few hundred thousand years back
towards our common ancestor with other hominins.
The researchers had expected the DNA
to resemble Neanderthal,
but it proved to be quite distinct,
most closely resembling that of the mysterious Denisovans,
a species known only from a finger bone
and two teeth discovered in a Siberian cave.
Stringer admitted that they were somewhat baffled
by this result.
And there is no evidence that the Denisovans ranged
anywhere near Atapuerca.
One possibility considered by the researchers
is that the fossils belong to the common ancestor
of Neanderthals and Denisovans,
and some of their descendants later traveled east
and became the Denisovans.
The genome recovered from the Pit of Bones
is particularly relevant
as it is from a period
that is extremely close to the origin of our human line.
The archeological evidence indicates
that these early humans were developing important
new ways of behaving.
Though, they were still using fairly primitive stone tools
like the crafted hand ax,
which researchers have nicknamed, Excalibur,
that was found in the pit.
But the bones also suggest more sophisticated traits.
One of these traits is the use of the pit
as an early burial site,
part of a very simple funeral rite.
Chris Stringer has even suggested that Excalibur
may have been some kind of tribute to the dead.
The discovery in the pits of the deformed skull of a girl,
who lived to be about 12 years old,
also reiterates this more modern behavior,
suggesting that the tribe cared for her.
"There's a hint of something human,
caring for the disabled." says Stringer.
In March, 2016,
a paper was published in the journal "Nature",
describing a DNA study
which, to the surprise of many,
identified the remains of the pit bones as Neanderthal.
Using this information,
the researchers were able to push back the date
when the separation between our family branch
and that of Neanderthals
to some time between 550,000
and almost 800,000 years ago.
In 2019, a comparative study was published
of the dental evolution of a number of human species,
including the Neanderthals of the Pit of Bones,
these results revealed that the divergence
between modern humans and Neanderthals
must have occurred at least 800,000 years ago.
A woman's skull,
the oldest known human remains ever found in Antarctica,
discovered lying on Yamana Beach,
at Cape Sheriff, in Antarctica's South Shetland Islands
has become one of the continent's biggest mysteries.
No surviving documents have ever been discovered
to explain how or why
a young woman came to be an Antarctica during this era.
But now, new evidence may have finally been found
to solve the case.
Antarctica is about 5.5 million square miles in size
and thick ice covers about 98% of the land.
The continental ice sheet
contains about 7 million cubic miles of ice,
making up about 90% of the world's ice
and 80% of its fresh water.
Although Antarctica has a fascinating history
of human activity in the region,
it extends back only about 200 years.
Indeed, the majority of what is known about Antarctica
has been discovered in the last few decades.
Remote, inaccessible, and hostile,
Antarctica was the last continent to be discovered
and acknowledges the south polar region
was collected slowly.
The real nature of Antarctica
was shown for the first time,
as long as the 18th century,
by the second voyage of the English navigator,
Captain James Cook.
Mariners who followed Cook into high southern latitudes
of the icy continent,
did so because of his reports of huge numbers
of whales and seals.
On the 16th and 17th of November, 1820,
American seal hunter,
Nathaniel Brown Palmer,
then 21 years old,
commanded the 47 foot long sloop, Hero,
which entered the Orleans Strait
and came very close to the Antarctic Peninsula.
Palmer and his men became the first Americans
and the third group of people
to discover the Antarctic Peninsula.
While there, Palmer met Russian captain,
Thaddeus Bellingshausen, on a major national expedition
that circumnavigated Antarctica eastward.
The highly controversial question of
who was first to site land in Antarctica
has never been resolved.
British, Russian, and US ships were all present
in the Antarctic Peninsula area in the early 1820s,
when the first sightings occurred.
However, the first documented landing of the continent
was not until decades later,
on January 24th, 1895,
when the Norwegian whaling ship, Antarctic,
landed a party at Cape Adare on the northern Ross Sea.
From the late 18th
to the mid-20th century,
whalers and sealers operated in the rich seas
surrounding the continent.
From the mid-20th century onwards,
scientific investigation replaced whaling and sealing
as the primary year-round human activity in Antarctica.
These days, around 1,200 people
spend the winter in Antarctica.
All of these are scientists and their support staff.
Yamana Beach is an ice-free beach
located on the west coast of Cape Sheriff,
in the north extremity of the Ioannes Paulus II Peninsula,
Livingston Island in the South Shetlands of Antarctica.
Sometime in 1985,
human remains were discovered by chance
the remote Antarctic beach,
by Chilean biologist, Dr. Daniel Torres.
According to Torres,
"On the afternoon of January 7, 1985,
I was doing a census of mammals
and also collecting marine refuse
on Cape Sheriff, Livingston island."
"On the beach, I saw a big plastic container
and an enormous plastic orange buoy."
"I went to the buoy first to collect it,
and as I headed along the beach,
I noticed that among the very dark volcanic stones,
there was one very white stone."
"But when I got closer,
I saw that on the surface of the stone,
there was a series of lines that looked like a human skull."
"Obviously, I stopped and went up closer
and I was able to establish that it was a human cranium,
half buried in this very thick, volcanic sand,
40 meters away from the shore."
"I started very slowly separating the pebbles
until I could pull out the top part of the cranium,
and as the upper jaw bones were missing,
I was looking for the other remains until I found them."
Subsequent analysis of the skull
at the Chilean Antarctic Institute,
revealed that it belongs to a young woman of 21
at the most.
But who was she?
And what was she doing in this remote spot?
In January, 1987,
part of a human femur was found inland from Yamana beach.
And in January, 1991,
another part of a femur was found close proximity
to the site of the earlier 1987 find.
It was later revealed
that the remains were of an indigenous female
from Southern Chile,
who's believed to have died between 1819 and 1825.
This makes the woman's bones,
the oldest known human remains ever found in Antarctica,
but how did she get there?
The traditional canoes of the indigenous Chileans
could not possibly have managed such a long voyage
through extremely rough seas.
Fascinatingly, the girls' dates
match up with the first known landings on Antarctica.
Though, the location of the discovery was unusual,
at a beach camp made by sealers,
female sealers were absolutely unheard of at the time.
One theory is that the girl was an indigenous guide,
translator, or navigator to the sealers traveling
from the Northern Hemisphere
to the Antarctic islands.
But women taking part in such expeditions
to the far south in the early 19th century was unlikely,
though, not impossible.
Another much darker theory
is that the girl was taken by force from her home,
in what is now Southern Chile, by sealers
and abandoned in the area
where her remains were found 175 years later.
Perhaps we will never know,
there are no surviving documents explaining how or why
this young Chilean woman
came to be an Antarctica at this time.
Her bones marked the start of human activity on Antarctica,
and were a hugely significant discovery for archeology,
but they are also of vital importance
to the history of Antarctica as a whole,
as they could be proof that Chile,
which lies about 620 miles away from Antarctica,
made the first known landings on Antarctica.
It must be added that this is disputed in some quarters.
Some researchers believe that in 1819,
officers, soldiers, and seamen
of the storm-damaged Spanish ship, San Telmo,
the flagship of a Spanish Naval squadron bound for Peru,
may have been the first people to land on Antarctica.
If any crew members survived
the initial sinking of the San Telmo,
north of Livingston Island,
and managed to get to Antarctica,
they would've been the first humans in history
to reach the continent.
Indeed, some remnants and signs of wreckage
were later said to have been found on Livingston Island
in the South Shetland Islands,
by the English Captain William Smith
on board of brig, Williams,
who arrived at the island of Livingston
in October of the same year.
The Antarctic Treaty System was first signed in 1959,
but in 1998,
a protocol on environmental protection was added,
stating that Antarctica is to be a natural reserve,
devoted to peace in science,
and forbids all activity
relating to the Antarctic mineral resources,
except as is necessary for scientific research.
But significantly,
this is the part of the treaty
that could come under some review in 2048,
50 years after it was signed.
On that date,
the prohibition on mining resource extraction
could be changed or scrapped completely.
According to Klaus Dodds,
Professor of Geopolitics
at Royal Holloway, University of London,
"There is a huge political storm coming
connected with Antarctica."
"Lots of people just don't understand
that there's a darker side to Antarctica."
"What we're seeing is great power politics
play out in a space that a lot of people think of
as just frozen wastes."
The reason 2048 looms large
is because if certain countries feel
that the prohibition on mineral exploitation
is no longer to be respected,
people worry that the whole thing could unravel.
Seven nations laid overlapping claims on Antarctic land
when the treaty was adopted,
Argentina, Australia, Chile, France, New Zealand,
Norway, and the UK.
The treaty holds all these claims in place
and prohibited any new ones from being established.
The treaty also puts any expansions to territorial claims
to Antarctica on hold.
But the big players,
usually China and Russia,
are thinking about this particular episode
around 2048 and planning ahead.
Of course, when human remains like the Chilean girl
or objects are found in the ice,
it ignites feelings of territorial naturalism.
If Chile could use these remains to demonstrate
that it had people living in Antarctica
earlier than other nations making land claims,
well, then they would be
in a much stronger position in negotiations.
A number of countries are now subtly trying
to help their claims in Antarctica in differing ways,
such as financing scientific research,
historical investigation, and constructing research bases
around the continent.
It looks like the future of this remote, icy continent
may be more complicated and controversial
than anyone could have ever imagined.
Randy Haas,
an anthropologist from the University of California,
was working with his colleagues at a high altitude site
in the area
known as Wilamaya Patjxa,
in Southern Peru,
when they found six burials
dating back almost 9,000 years,
which contains the remains of six individuals.
During their work,
the team collaborated with the local Aymara community.
Teenage female huntress buried with her tools.
One burial pit was not like the others,
based on the hunting toolkit found with the deceased,
the team initially thought that the burial
was of a male hunter.
However, the bones of a very slender, light,
and appeared to be those of a female.
Science quotes one of the team members,
bioarcheologist, Jim Watson as saying,
"I think your hunter might be female."
Indeed, the grave contains the remains of a young woman
who died between the ages of 17 and 19.
Her gender and age were determined
based on an analysis of proteins in her teeth.
Anthropologist, Randy Haas,
has told Sky News that the female hunter had been buried
with "Stone projectile points for felling large animals,
a knife, and flakes of rock for removing internal organs,
and tools for scraping and tanning hides."
The stone points would've been attached to shafts
and used to spear throwers,
and hurled at animals with great force.
A pigment chunk was also found with her,
which was used in the treatment of hides.
Was the discovery an outlier?
The female hunter was found near the grave of a male
who was also buried with a hunting toolkit.
The team of researchers also found evidence
of animal bones in the sediment of the burial ground,
including Andean deer and vicuna.
Haas told "Science News", these two animals
"Were the main targets of ancient hunters
in that part of the Andes."
However, many believed that the find was a one-off
and that the female big-game hunter was an outlier.
"Science" quotes Meg Conkey,
an archeologist who didn't take part in the study,
as stating that, "Skeptics may say it's a one-off."
Moreover, the presence of hunting gear in a grave
does not necessarily mean that the deceased was a hunter.
Haas and his team set out to prove
that there had once been other female hunters
in the Americas.
Haas and his colleagues were prepared for this
and conducted an exhaustive study of the research literature
on 107 burial sites in the Americas,
all of these sites are between 6 and 12,500 years old.
In total, the researchers found 10 women
who had been buried with hunting toolkits.
Their research has led them to conclude
that women routinely participated in big-game hunts.
The researchers wrote in "Science Advances" that,
"The findings are consistent
with non-gendered label practices,
in which early hunter-gatherer females
were big-game hunters."
Based on their study of other sites,
the research team believes that
"Females accounted for between 30 and 50%
of ancient American big-game hunters."
reports "Science News."
They're convinced that the evidence is strong
for their theory.
The researchers also consider that archeologists
did not recognize that females were big-game hunters
in the past,
because of sexism.
"Gizmodo" quotes the researchers are saying that,
"Modern gender constructs
often do not reflect past ones."
In other words, just because women in the recent past
were not big-game hunters,
this does not mean that there weren't any female
big-game hunters in the Americas 9,000 years ago.
Up until recently,
the, man the hunter, hypothesis was widely accepted.
According to "Science."
This held that women did women's work,
and that males engaged in activities
such as hunting,
and as a result were the dominant gender.
This was based, in part,
on modern studies of hunter-gatherer groups,
such as the Hadza of Tasmania.
Inspired by their groundbreaking discovery in Peru,
the researchers argue
that this was not the case.
Big game hunting would've required teamwork,
a group of people working together,
and a great deal of labor.
Therefore, women would've had to have cooperated with men
to ensure success in hunting expeditions.
Quoted in "Gizmodo",
the researchers argue that,
"There was a broad participation
from both females and males
in the hunting of big-game."
Ashley Smallwood of the University of Louisville,
in Kentucky, tells "Science News,"
"That it's time to stop thinking of ancient female
large-game hunters as outliers."
The discovery of the ancient female huntress in Peru
could transform our knowledge of gender roles in the past.
If women hunted,
this would imply that there was more equality
between the genders
in prehistoric societies.
However, some have argued against these findings
and state that the researchers cannot prove their arguments
about female hunters
because the sample that they investigated
is simply too small.
However, the research is aligned with recent discoveries
that challenge the traditional assumptions
about gender roles in prehistory.
Archeologists have found evidence
of a 5,000 year old female warrior in California,
while other finds suggests
that there were female fighters
in both Mongolian and Viking societies in the distant past.
A team of Spanish researchers theorizes,
based on grooves and nicks on the teeth of Neanderthals,
the gender roles among that species
was similar to gender roles of modern Homo sapiens.
Neanderthal men prepared the cutting tools and weapons,
while women saw to the leather garments and clothing.
But there was at least one duty
that men and women may have shared,
Neanderthal women,
these researchers think,
hunted big-game with the men.
Almudena Estalrrich, a researcher
at the Spanish National Museum of Natural Sciences,
said, "We believe that the specialization of labor
by sex of the individuals
was probably limited to a few tasks,
as it is possible that both men and women
participated equally in the hunting of big animals."
Another researcher on the project, Antonio Rosas,
along with the museum, told phys.org,
"The study of Neanderthals
has provided numerous discoveries in recent years."
"We have moved from thinking of them as
little evolved beings
to know that they took care of the sick people,
buried their deceased, ate seafood,
and even had different physical features than expected:
there were redheaded individuals,
and with light skin and eyes."
"So far, we thought that the sexual division of labor
was typical of sapien societies,
but apparently that's not true."
A study of ancient DNA by other researchers
showed a mutation that may have resulted in red hair
and light skin among Neanderthals,
according to the Smithsonian Museum of Natural History.
An article on the Smithsonian's website
says two Neanderthals,
one from Spain and one from Italy,
had a mutation in a gene controlling skin and hair color.
The mutation changes an amino acid,
making the resulting protein less efficient.
Modern humans have other MCR1 variants
that are also less active resulting,
in red hair and pale skin.
The less active Neanderthal mutation
probably also resulted in red hair and pale skin,
as in modern humans.
Phys.org says that,
one of the main conclusions of a study of
99 incisors and canines of
19 Neanderthal people
showed that their communities divided work according to sex.
The study, by the Spanish National Research Council,
was published in the "Journal of Human Evolution."
The Neanderthal's teeth came from sites at El Sidran:
Asturias, Spain: Spy, Belgium,
and L'Hortus, France.
The study said grooves in the teeth of women
appeared to follow the same pattern,
the pattern of the grooves in women's teeth
differed from that in men's.
Analysis shows that all Neanderthals,
regardless of age, had grooves in their teeth.
"This is due to the custom of these societies
to use the mouth as a third hand,
as in some current populations,
for tasks, such as preparing the furs,
for chopping meat, for instance."
The researchers found that the grooves in men's teeth
were longer than women's,
and made the assumption from this,
that the tasks the two sectors performed differed.
Also, they found tiny nicks in the enamel and dentin
of the upper teeth of men,
and in the lower teeth of women.
Researchers are unable to make rock solid conclusions
about which tasks men performed,
and which tasks women performed.
But they said in modern hunter-gatherer society,
women typically prepare furs and other garments,
and men retouched the edges of stone tools.
They say this
may have been how it was
among the Neanderthals they studied.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.