Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
[Music]
[Applause]
Charlotte villains I'm here for one
reason that is I am a celebrity you see
but I'm a celebrity is fascinated in
what these guys do and I think that
they're dealing were the most
interesting things that you can possibly
deal with and they're here to tell you
about some of them today and I don't
know they're their labels so they should
I think they should just explain to me I
mean starting with Bruce Bruce Grayson
who are you anyway professor no but just
keep talking I'm professor emeritus of
psychiatry and neurobehavioral sciences
at UVA and former director of the
division of perceptual studies neuro
behavioral sciences I'm gonna let handle
that okay
let's find it then we go Jim Tucker yes
I'm Jim Tucker I'm a a child
psychiatrist at the division of
Professional Studies and I'm the current
director okay Emily Kelly I go there's
something wrong with the my Kevin no it
was always a trouble with Mike's don't
worry but teetley in the afternoon we'd
never get a microphone away in the
afternoon so there's a nice embarrassing
pause now if we don't get embarrassed
away yeah I'll take this one
okay I'm Emily Kelly and I'm a research
assistant professor in the same division
of perceptual studies and Kim Penberthy
compan Buffy yes I am NOT British I'm
American I'm a clinical psychologist in
the division of perceptual studies and I
am currently being blinded by that light
so forgive me if I'm squinting at you
I'm not winking I promise
q I'm Emily's husband and also a
professor in adop's and an experimental
psychologist
[Laughter]
still the chairs are excellent aren't
they they've got really really good
chairs together here and they put them
they they've spaced them nicely - the
thing about tonight you see when I'm
talking to an audience I usually love to
have some idea of what the audience is
like and by that I mean you know what
you know and what you're not likely to
know what's likely to make you cross and
what's likely to make you interested but
with you like I haven't the slightest
idea whether you were very open to these
ideas or convinced that there's
something going on that the materialist
reductionist scientists don't think is
possible all whether you are here to
shoot us down in flames but anyway it's
gonna be it's gonna be great fun I think
you should just start with Bruce Bruce
tell us what you're doing at the moment
what are you looking at what are you
trying to find out about thank you John
thinking more clearly than ever before
while your heart has stopped and there's
no blood going to your brain looking
down and seeing your body on the
operating table and noticing details
unexpected details that you're searching
later verifies for you
meeting deceased loved ones family and
friends who you thought were still alive
meeting deceased people who you don't
know but later recognize from family
photos all these are things that happen
in some new death experiences that may
have some bearing on the question of
whether we survive death of the body
which is our topic for tonight is it
possible that our consciousness or our
mind survives bodily death there's a
wide range of human experiences that
suggest this is exactly the case
near-death experiences occur to us when
we're on the threshold of death and
therefore they raise the possibility
that they may teach us something about
what happens after death now I've been
collecting and analyzing near-death
experiences for more than 40 years and I
have detailed information about more
than thousand of these cases
each one is unique filter through the
individuals background and personality
but there are some features that they
all share in common and some of these
common features have important bearing
on the question of whether we survive
death and whether some part of us does
and if so what what part is that one of
these features that may have some
bearing on the question of survival is
enhanced mental functioning thinking
clearer than ever seeing more vividly
forming more detailed memories at a time
when your brain is seriously impaired
now how is that possible it seems to
defy common sense and yet it happens
James was a 25 year old nurse who got
deeply depressed and decided to end his
life he took some medications from the
hospital where he worked took an
overdose and lay down in his bed
expecting to die he didn't in fact he
became sicker and sicker very nauseous
with painful stomach cramps and decided
maybe he better call for some help so he
roused himself tried to get out of bed
and get to a telephone but by this time
the drugs had kicked in and were making
him very unsteady he had trouble
standing trouble walking not only that
but the drugs were making him
hallucinate and he was seeing little
people all around his bed making it hard
for him to get to the telephone at this
point he told me he drew up out of his
body and was several feet above his body
and behind him
thinking very clearly then he looked
down at his body staring up staggering
around looking very confused
he remembered being in the body and
hallucinating but from where he was up
above he couldn't see these little
people now that convinced James that his
mind in his body were not the same thing
and it suggests that I need to think
about that also are they the same thing
another feature comment and ease that
makes us question whether we survive is
seeing things accurately from some
visual perspective not in the body this
too defies common sense heckling you see
if you're not in the body and yet it
happens out was a 55 year old truck
driver who went to the emergency room
with irregular heartbeat in the Opera in
the emergency room during diagnostic
testing his heart condition deteriorated
rapidly and he was rushed to the
operating room for what eventually
became quadruple bypass surgery in the
middle of this operation he felt himself
rising up out of his body and floating
weightless above it he looked down and
to a surprise saw himself there lying on
the table with a sheet over his body and
you saw his surgeon down there looking
very perplexed and as L described it the
assertion was flapping his arms as if he
was trying to fly l didn't understand
that and frankly I didn't either I've
been working as a doctor for more than
40 years nostrils I've never seen a
surgeon do that I later talked to Al's
doctor and asked him about this and he
acknowledged that yes he had done that
that were he had trained in his home
country to be a surgeon he developed
this habit when he walks into the
operating room all scrubbed in with
sterile gloves on in his residents and
it in a tent and in turns his assistants
are starting the operation he doesn't
want to risk touching something not in
the sterile field with his clean hands
so he puts them where he knows they
won't touch anything sterile and then he
instructs his interns here come over
there go back over there
so what Alfa was trying to fly was just
instructing his assistants on how to do
the operation now how did I'll know this
how could he see this this is not an
isolated case a recent survey of more
than a hundred near-death experiences in
which people reported seeing things from
an out-of-body perspective found that
more than 90 percent were completely
accurate in what they said another
common feature that people report in
NDEs is seeing deceased friends and
family now many of us would expect to
see deceased loved ones when we die so
that's not so surprising but sometimes
more surprising things happen for
example people sometimes see deceased
loved ones that they thought were still
alive
Eddie was a nine-year-old boy who was
hospitalized in a coma from meningitis
he was a coma for about 36 hours before
his fever finally broke his family were
erected around him by the bedside all
night long and finally about 3:00 a.m.
he opened his eyes and excitedly told
his parents that he had just been to
heaven and it seemed his dead
grandfather and Auntie Rosa and uncle
Lorenzo and then you said they also saw
my sister Teresa
we're told me I had to come back now
Teresa was this older sister who was in
college in Vermont and as far as anyone
knew was perfectly healthy later that
morning when his parents went home they
immediately called the college and they
found that choice to have in fact been
killed in a car accident just after
midnight how did Eddie know about that
Jack was a 25 year old electrical
engineer who was hospitalized with
pneumonia one day as his young nurse
Anita was fluffing up his pillow she
mentioned him that this weekend was
going to be her 21st birthday and she
was going to be gone for a few days
visiting her parents shortly after she
left
Jack's condition went downhill and he
had trouble breathing he eventually
stopped breathing entirely he then had a
near-death experience you know what she
saw nurse Anita surprised to see you
there he said what are you doing here
and she said I've come to fluff your
pillow up one more time and I'd like you
to go back and tell my parents that I
love them and I'm sorry I wrecked the
red sports car when Jack recovered he
told the nurse about this experience she
started tearing up and left the room in
me Utley later Jack learned that Anita's
parents had an effect surprised her with
a red sports car for her birthday and
excited to try it out she raced down the
highway and crashed into a concrete
barrier dying instantly the hakka jack
notice how could any novice how can
these things happen and finally there
are some people in near-death
experiences who meet what appeared to be
deceased people who they don't know Levi
was a 35 year old man who was born in
Holland who had a cardiac arrest his
heart stopped
he had a near-death experience saw his
grandmother who had died and then saw a
man who didn't recognize us but who
looked at him very lovingly he didn't
over this was didn't know what to make
of it
so he didn't talk to anybody about this
ten years later when his grandpa his
mother was on her deathbed she confessed
to him that her husband who are raised
Levi as his father was not in fact his
biological father
Levi's biological father was in fact a
Jewish man who had been captured by the
notches when they came into town taken
to a concentration camp and never seen
again and then his mother showed Levi a
photograph of his father which he
recognized immediately as the man from
his near-death experience so we have in
near-death experiences heightened mental
thoughts when your brain isn't
functioning we have accurate perceptions
from outside the body we have meeting
with deceased loved ones who you didn't
know had died
we have decease meetings with loved ones
who he didn't know period and we don't
have a good physical explanation for
this
so all these things should make us think
about is there something about us that
survives the bodily death and if so what
is that thing
when I started getting interested in all
this nonsense some time ago I I was
reading a lot about out-of-body
experiences which are obviously not
necessarily connected with dying now-u
don't mention them is there any reason
for that because they're very similar
they are they are an out-of-body
experience where you feel you're leaving
your physical body
it's something that often happens as
part of a near-death experience but it
can also happen under other
circumstances as well and the reason I
chose just to talk about the near-death
experiences is because we have some
other information about what's going on
with the body at that time so it's a
little easier to study what's going on
with it fascinates me any body
experiences there's almost a better
chance of being able to check what
happened you know people I know woman on
the operating table bad car accident who
said she left her body and went into the
waiting room and saw her parents there
right and her brother was there and his
sister arrived late and Gilligan's
Island was on me on the television and
when she recovered consciousness and
started talking to her family of course
it it scared them and she stopped
talking about but those kind of things
are particularly fascinating because
again how did they get the knowledge
right right go on what were you gonna
say I was going to say that that what
makes the near-death experience
out-of-body experience so much more
interesting to me is that we know the
brain is not functioning very well with
us when this is happening so we know
that it is more than just the brain
imagining this something that is
happening when the brain is not
functioning right right good Jim
well I'm going to talk about children
who report memories of past lives and
this was work that has been going on at
UVA for over 50 years
division for sexual Studies officially
started in night
67 so we've now celebrated 50 years but
Ian Stevenson who started our division
actually started studying these cases in
the early 1960s and we have continued on
even after he is no longer with us
and we've now studied over 2,500 cases
from around the world basically of young
children who reported memory of a past
life and what they typically do is
describe a recent ordinary life that
often ended violently or ended when the
person was young and Ian spent many many
hours and traveled many miles trying to
find these cases and mostly found them
in Asia because in cultures was a belief
in reincarnation people talk about the
more but now with the internet and was
people known but our work we hear from
American families all the time so I'll
give you a couple of examples and this
first one is one that we talked about
yesterday so there's we got a letter one
day from this mother in Oklahoma and she
said that she and her husband were just
ordinary people her husband was a police
officer and her she worked in the County
Clerk's office
but for the last year their
five-year-old boy Ryan had talked about
a past life in Hollywood and he would
cry about Hollywood wanting his mom to
take him back there so to try to help
him kind of process this stuff she
decided to go to the public library and
check out some books on Hollywood and
they were looking through when one day
when they came to a picture from an old
movie called night after night and Ryan
pointed to one of the men in the picture
and said hey mama that's George we did a
picture together and he pointed to
another one of the men and said and mama
that's me I found me well the first
person he pointed to was George Raft who
was quite a well-known
back in his day but the other man he
pointed to that he said he had been was
an extra with no lines in the movie so
Ryan's mom wrote to me to see if I could
help figure out who this guy was so I
went to Oklahoma and I talked with the
parents I talked with Ryan and then
afterwards as we were trying to figure
out who this person was Ryan's mom was
emailing me sometimes on a daily basis
with all these details that Ryan was
given about his past life he was
describing quite a life that to be
honest I thought was rather unlikely for
an extra with no lines in a movie
eventually with the help of a Hollywood
archivist we were able to figure out who
this guy was this archivist she went to
the library of the Academy of Motion
Picture Arts and Sciences got all the
materials on the movie night after night
and there was one picture that included
an identification of this guy and he was
a fella named Marty Martin who died in
1964 it turned out that Marty Martin did
have quite a life so Ryan said how he
had danced on stage in New York and
Marty Martin danced on Broadway Brian
said even went to Hollywood and worked
in the movies which Marty Martin did
mostly working on dancing in movies he
said that he then worked for an agency
and Marty Martin started a successful
talent agency in fact Ryan said is an
agency where people changed their names
and then it Marty Martin worked at a
talent agency Ryan said how he had seen
the world from big boats and talked
about visiting Paris Marty Martin and
his wife went to Europe on the Queen
Mary and we have pictures of them in
Paris Ryan said he had a big house with
a swimming pool which Marty Martin did
and Ryan said that the street address
had the word Rock or mount in it
and Marty Martin lived on north Roxbury
Ryan also said one time that he didn't
understand why God would let you get to
be 61 and then make you come back again
as a baby which is sort of an
interesting philosophical question on
its own but we got Marty Martin's death
certificate which said that he was 59
but then I talked with his daughter and
with his stepson who both said no he was
actually 61 so I looked into it and I
found three census records to marriage
listings in a passenger list that all
gave ages for Marty Martin that meant in
fact he was 61 when he died and not 59
and all together we verified that over
50 of Ryan's statements matched with
Marty Martin's life another example that
I will tell you about is a recent case
that I studied a little boy that I'll
call Steven he was also five years old
when he started talking about how he had
been a soldier who died in a war and
that it was in the jungle and his
parents asked him if it was Vietnam and
and he said yes and then he gave a last
name which was an unusual last name and
the state where he was from so his mom
went on to Vietnam Memorial website and
found that in fact there was a soldier
killed with that name from that state
who had been killed in Vietnam she
pulled up pictures of a bunch of the
people who had been killed and when she
got to the one of him the little boy
said that's me so she didn't do any more
research she wrote to me and to let me
know what what Steven was saying so then
I did do a little more research online I
got a subscription to a online newspaper
collection did a little sort of
detective work and when I went to see
the family I brought some pictures
with me now I didn't want to overwhelm a
five-year-old little boy with lineups of
pictures so what I did was show in pairs
of pictures where one of the pictures is
from this man's life and the other one
wasn't so for instance I showed him a
picture of the man's high school and
then a different high school and he
picked the correct one I showed him
pictures of two houses and again he
picked the correct one so then after
that visit I continued to do online
detective work I also wrote to the man's
sister and I heard back from his niece
the sisters daughter and she sent me
some family photos so then I sent some
more pairs of pictures to Stephens mom
and the good thing about these tests
when when she showed them to Steven was
that she didn't know which was the right
picture either so there was no chance
that he was picking up on cues from
anything as he looked at the pair's
now all together we showed him eight
pairs of pictures a couple of them he
didn't make a choice on but for the
others he was six out of six now along
with the knowledge that these kids
seemed to have about a past life a lot
of them also show emotions and behaviors
that seemed linked so I mentioned Ryan
crying about Hollywood and we hear this
all the time of kids sometimes crying on
a daily basis about missing their family
begging to be taken to their family for
the kids who where the previous person
died violently a lot of them will have
nightmares repeatedly about that death
so there's an a well-known American case
for a little boy from the time of his
second birthday started having horrible
nightmares multiple times a week of a
plane crash and as the case developed it
became clear that that he had memories
of a particular pilot who was killed
during World War two also it's a violent
death cases a lot of them will the kids
will show phobias intense fear toward
the mode of death
and this seems particularly true in
drowning cases where these kids will
just be intensely afraid of being put in
water and also there are cases where and
and Ian Stevenson was really interested
in these and studied several hundred of
them there are cases where the children
will be born with birthmarks or even
birth defects that match wounds usually
fatal wounds on the body of the previous
person so for instance there was one
little boy where the previous person had
been killed by a shotgun blast to the
side of his head at the man's neighbor
said he mistook his neighbor for a
rabbit and shot him in the side of the
head
with shotgun and then this little boar
he was born with this just a stump for
an ear and underdeveloped right side of
his face
Ian also listed 18 cases where the
children were born with two birthmarks
ones that matched both the entrance
wound and the exit wound on the body of
the previous person so with all this
these cases you know I think provide
pretty good evidence that something is
going on that there is this carryover
from the past life but I have never
argued that these cases mean that we all
reincarnate that we all come back here
in fact you can make the case that these
are exceptional cases because the
previous person typically died violently
or died young came back quickly with
intact memories so maybe that the usual
pattern for most of us is not that we
come back here but we may have all kinds
of different types of existence after we
die but regardless I do think that these
cases contribute along with near-death
experiences and the other things to a
good body of evidence that there are
times where consciousness does survive
after the body dies and and in these
cases attaches to it too new like and
anything has a new life here that's what
I
[Applause]
I'm fascinated by the idea that they
might happen to some people and there's
a correlation with bad endings bad
deaths isn't there but that's not always
the case because in this one with the
agent there's a 40-year gap between the
guy dying
and the child being born so it's a
little bit more about that yeah and with
that World War 2 case and there's a
fifty-year yeah there but the average
interval is only four and a half years
so it's it's typical that they come back
very quickly I mean there are always
exceptions pretty much to anything but
it does seem that for many of the cases
it's or you can make a reasonable
argument that the previous person had
sort of unfinished business and that it
might have led them to stay attached to
this room or this world and then be
reborn and start another life very good
thank you thank you Emily give us give
us a picture of what you're interested
in okay well um I hope this new one
works alright you know and hear me okay
good
several years ago I did a survey asking
people whether they had ever experienced
any of a number of the kinds of things
that were interested in near-death
experiences past life memories
out-of-body experiences apparitions that
sort of thing and I learned about a lot
of really interesting experiences that
way but maybe the most interesting thing
I learned was that the single most often
reported experience was being at the
bedside of a dying person who seemed to
be talking with and seeing someone who
was not physically present usually
someone who had died earlier such as a
spouse parent a sibling there's been
virtually no systematic research done on
these so-called deathbed visions and so
I really had no
about how common they might be but in
addition to the survey I've also over
the years talked to a lot of hospice
workers who tell me that these
experiences in fact are quite common in
fact one hospice doctor told me that he
has learned that when such visions start
it's time to call the family and make
sure they're there in addition to the
dying person sometimes people at the
bedside will also have unusual
experiences sometimes shared by the
dying person sometimes not shared by the
dying person and this actually happened
in my own family my grandmother had had
a stroke and she was at home dying she
was in a coma and her son-in-law was
sitting beside the bed with her he
himself as a physician and all of a
sudden he saw standing at the foot of
the bed my grandfather who had died
about seven years previously with his
arms outstretched to my grandmother and
calling out her name and a few moments
later my grandmother died
another kind of experience that actually
has been studied quite a lot over the
years is something that we call crisis
cases and these are experiences that
happen not at the bedside of a dying
person but some distance away and often
quite a long distance away typical
experience of this kind is one in which
a person hasn't sees a vision sees an
apparition of a particular person and
then later learns if that person had in
fact died at about the time of the
vision there have over the years there
have been reported literally thousands
of these experiences reported and
investigated thousands of these
experiences and I learned about a few
more in my survey some very interesting
ones but one in particular that I found
very interesting
was not natural vision but involved a
physical event and I wanted to just read
to you the description that the woman
who had the experience sent to me
because she expressed it a lot better
than I could the day my grandma died I
was headed out to work about 3:00 a.m. I
knew she was very sick and I had planned
to fly to New Jersey later that day to
see her because I knew time was short as
I went to put the key in the car I felt
this overwhelming presence and all of a
sudden my driver window shattered and I
thought to myself grandma just died as I
got to work I could not shake the
feeling of Grandma right next to me the
phone call came grandma died at the same
time I felt her and that the window and
the window shattered I felt this was
grandma's way of telling me she's gone
now I don't have any idea how often car
windows shatter spontaneously but I
don't think we can tribute this
experience to chance there's still
another kind of experience that we are
particularly interested in learning
about and we call these revival cases or
terminal lucidity cases and these are
involve people who are suffering from
Alzheimer's or other forms of dementia
and who seem to recover their mental
faculties shortly before they die again
I learned about some of these in my
survey one woman in particular wrote to
me about her grandmother her grandmother
had had Alzheimer's and for quite some
time she had not recognized anyone but
shortly before she died she seemed to
recover and the woman actually had a
conversation with her a normal
conversation in which they sort of went
over family affairs family events things
that had been happening the woman told
me she said it felt like I was talking
to Rip Van Winkle another experience
like this it was a similar one that was
reported was actually reported in US
issue of Time magazine that came out
several years ago it was reported by a
physician named Scott Hague and this
special issue of time was devoted to
talking about the mind brain problem
mind brain issues and nearly all of the
issue really all the issue was taking
the position that is the predominant
position in science today which is that
the brain produces the mind produces
consciousness and that therefore
consciousness is totally and wholly
dependent on the brain
well dr. Haig wrote a little essay that
took quite a different position and he
what he did was he described a case of
his a patient of his named David who was
had brain cancer that had literally been
eating away much of David's brain so
that toward the end of his life he was
completely unresponsive one night doctor
Haig went home and he knew that David
was gonna die that night and he did he
died that night when dr. Haig got back
to the hospital the next morning the
nurse came up to him and said you know
last night David woke up and was able to
talk to his family before he died
now these experiences these sort of
revival cases I think are extremely rare
we have we know about a fair number of
them but I think they are extremely rare
but they're also extremely important
because they suggest that as the brain
is shutting down the mind is somehow
being freed as dr. Haig put it he said
David's that night David's mind somehow
broke through his diseased brain so that
he could say goodbye to his family as I
said earlier there's been practically no
systematic research done on these sort
of deathbed visions and and revival
cases and cases of this sort there's
been a doctor in a physician
in the UK has started doing some
research over there in connection with
hospice and nursing homes over there but
there's still so much that we just basic
information that we don't know about
these experiences things like how often
do they happen to whom do they happen
under what circumstances do they happen
one of the most important questions that
we know very little about is what's the
relationship between drugs and these
deathbed visions we do have some
preliminary information that suggests
that drugs may actually inhibit the
experience and not cause them but again
this is something we just know very
little about at this point so we here
our group wants to start a study here in
Charlottesville and I'm now in the
process of looking for funds to support
this but as I don't know how many of you
all were here last night but as John
said last night funds for this kind of
research ain't easy to find so but I'm
optimistic that we'll be able to find it
and maybe in a few years we can come
back to the tomtom festival and give you
an update on what we found
this is fascinating to me at any rate
including here's to you and now we've
had three people talking I think it
might be fun to Stonebridge out to the
audience for a bit before we come back
to Kim
otherwise the just the repetition of the
shape of this might become helps cause
people to lose their concentration do we
have some questions there's a microphone
there
we've got people I think yes yes
so can you stand up and shout oh that's
good just working yeah cool so this is
more of a philosophical question than it
is maybe a scientific one but let's say
based on the premises of the stories
that you guys have told we believe that
there is some form of experience or life
after death what then becomes I don't
know the point of a corporeal existence
versus whatever else you guys have
experienced or seeing people experience
after death and did you hear that I'm
sorry do you mind again I think the
shorter way of saying that is if we have
life after death what is the point of
life itself
right
thanks for the easy question that was
can we postpone that there's a softball
for you Ed
[Laughter]
I remember my good friend Peter Cook who
was a genius in the chameleon he was
much more concerned with whether there
was sex after death it's an interesting
question Wells I mean what is the point
of any of it do you sort of anything you
can ask you that at any point but the
point is this is um this may be the way
it is at least for some people and if
anything's accomplished this afternoon I
hope it's that that people are curious
because many people in the scientific
communities don't have a theory so they
say it couldn't have happened which is
not really terribly impressive Stan Stan
Grof they gave her the recounted and
experience to Carl Sagan at the end of
which Sagan said it couldn't have
happened you know that's an odd what can
I say defense so what I'm hoping we'll
do today is not convert you to some new
situation but cause you to be more
curious about this kind of stuff just so
that you begin to read the literature
because one woman who was a very hot had
a very high position in the American
Statistical community she was a famous
statistician she she pointed out how the
amount of evidence there is for this it
was unarguable from a status
statisticians point of view that the
odds were that this was a great deal of
truth in this stuff and she commented
that the extraordinary thing is that
many of the people who felt strongly
that it was imagined early or something
to do with fraud or something like that
that they hadn't read any of the
literature and yet they still felt they
were in a position to say this is
nonsense it couldn't have happened so
all I'm saying to you start reading the
literature because after a time it's
very very hard I think for me to accept
anything other than the idea that
something
as on after we die and if if quantum
physics is is incomprehensible
as it is and that's the best way we have
at the moment of of describing reality I
don't see that life after death could be
any simpler than that so the key is does
it happen not whether do we have a
theory to explain it hi first I'd like
to say thank you to mr. Cleves for
coming to our small town it is a small
town I've lived in a lot of big cities
but each of you so far have spoken about
very segmented things do you find have
you encountered people who have multiple
experiences because I've experienced
some rather strange things in my life
but one is I tend to get visits from
other people's relatives when they pass
and I'll know about it
before I get the phone call before they
get the phone call I've had family
members that experienced I have
experienced the my step grandmother died
of glioblastoma and she had the clarity
before she passed away and she was able
to have a conversation
my roommate some years later had the
same experience with her father very
severe case of glioblastoma in both
cases both died and six months and they
had no cognition whatsoever and her
father woke up was able to have a
conversation with her and her brother
and we were all adults that when in both
of these cases and very clear and he was
able to kind of rectify some things and
just kind of say goodbye peacefully but
I feel like I've been exposed to a lot
of these kinds of things I'm wondering
do you find that there are certain
people who are sensitive or where there
are multiple experiences there
definitely are and it differs with some
of these different experiences I know
with near-death experiences people who
have near-death experiences often do not
have hist
of unusual events but after the nd after
the near-death experience there opened
up and the door doesn't close and they
often have many experiences after that I
think it's somewhat different with the
reincarnation memories well it is
although there do seem to be some
families where the reincarnation
memories actually it's almost like a
genetic thing but to answer your
question I think in general there are
people who report a number of different
kinds of experiences and you know some
people seem to be basically sort of more
psychic than others and they can have
all different kinds of things I will say
I think I think ed can speak to this
better than I can but there is a fair
amount of experimental evidence showing
that people who do well in experimental
tasks have certain personality profiles
so in addition to the what you're
pointing out that people do have I mean
you having just one-off experience it's
not very common most people do have
multiple ones but I think there is a
definite personality profile of some
sort that that contributes to that my
question is related to past death
experiences my mother always had a near
phobia regarding necklaces turtleneck
sweaters and always jokingly said I
think I was strangled in past life my
father of course told her that it was
probably more likely in her future
[Laughter]
[Applause]
he was a character well I guess I have
two questions one I mean it sounds like
that's very typical to things that
you've heard elsewhere and I would like
to reassure her of that and also
reassure her that if that's the case
maybe she's safe in the future well as
far as so you're suggesting she's
suggesting that as a memory of a past
life that then led to this unexplained
phobia basically and that's certainly
possible I mean with our child cases
typically the kids lose the memories and
lose the fears as they get older but
there are certainly exceptions and you
know the question is how much do we
generalize from our cases where people
have actual intact memories of a past
life compared to people who don't so you
know with an unexplained phobia we
certainly can't say for sure that it's
connected to past life experience but
it's plausible that it could be and as
long as she doesn't have other
precognitive abilities you know
hopefully she can be rest assured that
she's not actually seeing her future but
more likely to be seen her past sorry I
know it's hard to hear through this I
have an extremely rare form of
paroxysmal dyskinesia if you're familiar
with that basically I have what appears
to be grand mal seizure but I mean I've
attained consciousness and one thing
that I've noticed in that is I can be
completely paralytic for up to 16 hours
but my friends have found that they can
snap me out of it by being wrong and
making me angry so I was but I'm an
English literature major they'll start
talking about bacon ism and things like
that
yeah the English majors get it yeah or
saying that early modern literature is
not relevant to the modern life but I've
noticed that what you were saying about
mind when the brain is not fully
functional because I've probably
experienced neural storm more closely
than any person with a functioning brain
at this point has so with the mind being
able to get me out of a paralytic state
that's one kind of example that we're
definitely interested in I mean a lot of
a lot of the stuff we study cases
near-death cases in particular we have a
lot of that occur under conditions like
deep general anesthesia or cardiac
arrest heart stopping which basically
abolish --is the conditions that most
neuroscientists think are required for
anybody to have a conscious experience
and yet people are not only reporting
experiences but the most intense
transformative experiences of their
entire lives so this is another example
of that sort of thing okay so with the
children who have these memories from a
previous life and children stop
remembering things you know they don't
remember things before they're what
seven or eight or something like that um
do they lose this recollection and also
I'm curious the families of the dead
people do they engage with them and
really relate to them after this all
kind of comes out well most of the well
almost all the kids stop talking about
the past life as they get older and and
usually around the time or six or seven
and many of them seem to lose the
memories and as you say that's when all
children lose memories of their early
hood but we have learned that a fair
number of them if you go back you wait
long enough and energy than when they're
adults they say they do still have some
memories so they have stopped talking
about it gone to school tried to be
normal or whatever but it may be that
some of those memories still stay now in
a lot of cases the two families do meet
and it varies the amount of connection
some of them establish a big connection
and the the previous family will visit
the child or vice versa
repeatedly as the child gets older
sometimes actually the previous family
develops more of an attachment for the
child and the child has for that family
often with the kids once they meet the
previous family see the previous place
they see that their memories are
validated but they also see that time
has moved on and it seems that the
emotional intensity from their
standpoint lessens even though for the
previous family of course it may get
more intense as they see the child okay
we won't add any more to this queue
we'll go back to him and head after
these we've done these gentlemen the
blue stripes hi as someone that was
raised in a fundamentalist family I'm
someone that came from a history of you
know blind belief I've gone back and
forth between both sides I'm dealing
with a lot of skepticism these days I
have two questions I'm only gonna ask
one and I was very I was very torn on
which one I wanted to go with because
one is very positive and I'm I would
love to talk with you guys about that
more later right now give you two mister
please thank you you're my hero
okay first well I I've been working with
a theory for a long time and I just
wonder I would love to hear your opinion
on it that the idea for life if if
reincarnation is true or if we are able
to live many many lives is this idea
that the only way human beings could
ever live together in a perfect after
after
is if there was such a thing as perfect
empathy and the only way you could ever
experience perfect empathy is if you
would actually experience what it was
like to be everyone else and I love to
think that it's possible that when we
become who we are it's actually just an
obligation of every single possible
experience so we're still ourselves but
we still know what it's like to be
everyone else and I just wonder if you
guys have talked about that or if you
thought about that are you you time that
should reincarnation I wasn't clear I'm
sorry were you tying that um it could be
reincarnation it could be parallel
universes it could be all kinds of
different ways that it would all come
together well you may have a more
positive point of view on life than I do
per house but I I tend to think of it
more it's just a naturalistic process
where consciousness exists and it
continues to exist after the physical
body and brain die and it continues to
have experiences but it is whether
there's sort of an intention to it there
there is hope that there is the
potential for progress that even if we
don't come back with intact memories
hopefully our consciousness or whatever
you want to call it is affected and that
we do learn or like you say we have
empathy because we experience different
viewpoints so hopefully through all this
course of different lives we do grow and
make progress
the white shirt mr. Cleese I've always
wanted you to ask me my name so that I
could respond by saying some call me Tim
[Laughter]
I know I know that the talk is only half
way over and I don't mean to minimalize
or generalize anything but I'm trying to
get a certain grasp on certain sort of
thematic intention for all of your
studies it does it have some have
something to do with closure a lot of
what we've been talking about has kind
of focused in on a way to close the book
and all of what everyone else is talking
about is kind of opening so that there
is an opportunity to close the book and
I just wanted some sort of elaboration
on that I'd rather respond to that
actually by talking about the two books
sounds good lists there I look forward a
little bit I will say though that
science is not really about closing the
book it's about opening it up and
getting more and more better better
questions I think Woody Allen said I
don't believe in an afterlife but I am
taking a change of underwear thank you
very much gentlemen blew your negative I
am unworthy but uh okay so what I've
heard so far the thing that I feel most
skeptical about and that's hardest for
me to understand is this idea that
there's some kind of physical carry over
into the next life I had never heard
that before the idea that something
could mentally carry over it makes a lot
of sense to me or emotionally but the
idea that you were killed by a gunshot
wound and then you're killed you're born
with birth marks I can't even begin to
imagine any kind of reason for that or a
mechanism that would create that do you
all have any theories for that or any
explanation for that yeah no I will say
that was sort of a big pill for me to
swallow also when I got involved with
this work and we know from other
research that sometimes mental images
can produce very specific changes in the
bodies so for instance there are cases
of in hypnosis where you tell someone
you're burning them with a hot poker
whatever and they'll develop as a burn
purely from the mental image of being
burned so in these cases I don't think
it's literally the physical wound the
shotgun to the head but it may well be
the sort of the mental image of that the
mental experience of being killed that
is obviously a very strong experience
that if the consciousness does continue
it continues with it almost in a PTSD
kind of way and then rather than like
hypnosis producing a temporary mark in
these cases the consciousness if it does
in fact to enter a developing fetus it
would then lead to a similar wound that
would be permanent on the child so it
wasn't literally the physical injury but
more the mental aspect of it that
produced the mark J made an interesting
point to me couple of days ago when you
pointed out that it was a very strange
way for karma to work as someone who has
been killed
seems the you know they're continuing
what do we say they're continuing
experience seems like a punishment for
having been killed yeah so you know a
lot of these cases came from places for
instance with with Hindu beliefs where
karma is a big part of that and I'm a
karma is certainly a a more subtle
philosophy than we often know about but
in any case that the idea of of karmic
retribution would lead you to think that
if somebody's murdered than the murderer
would then be reborn with the injury
that he caused but in fact that's not
what we see it's the victim that comes
back with the wound so again it seems to
be I would view it as a naturalistic
mental trust experience that that leads
to that gentleman in the white shirt
just
comment and a question the gentleman who
first came up and asked what's the point
of it all why bother being human and I'd
like to offer that hmm maybe the
hokey-pokey really is what it's all
about so my question is where any of you
non-believers or highly skeptical before
you started this research and what one
or two of you care to comment on what
might have changed your minds I don't
know that we've changed our minds I
think we all are fairly skeptical about
these things were experience we're
investigating and it certainly opened
our minds see these things in fact one
of the most profound things that open my
mind to seeing the way these experiences
affect people hmm
the profound and long-lasting
after-effects of near-death experiences
for example persuaded me that these are
not a type of mental illness they're a
real event that people are going through
I still I'm very simple about how we
understand them what their meaning of it
is yeah and I would agree that I think
we're still skeptics in the sense that
every case that I approach I approach in
some ways looking for the defects in the
case so I mean obviously we're open to
this stuff or we wouldn't be devoting
much of our lives to it but as I think
we do approach it with the scientific
point of view that I could speaking for
myself I'm trying to find out for myself
what all this means I'm not trying to
convince anyone of a particular
religious belief or whatever but but
just trying to see really put where the
evidence takes me okay I was just gonna
say I think we would all raise our hand
and that that's a big part of the
scientific approach to it that we don't
come in with our mind already made up
that we really are curious about this my
dad that we're all just a poor empirical
scientist down in the trenches for the
most part and
don't claim to have any kind of special
expertise about what it might all mean
and we're open to the possibility that
it is all about the hokey-pokey I mean
it occurs to me that when the founder of
physics room Niels Bohr said about
quantum physics that if as you approach
it you are not shocked then you haven't
understood it and trying to understand
this these these things in in terms of
any kind of physics after Einstein is
what why should this be easier to
understand why that's why there should
there be a simple explanation if the
main description of reality at the
moment seems to be quantum theory shows
[Music]
no relation at all to the life we lead
on on this planet you see what I mean
lady in the blue can you go through the
near-death experiences that you have
discussed tonight or seem rather
Pleasant do you have people reporting
near-death experiences that are not so
pleasant uh yes we do have unpleasant
near-death experiences the ones be
collected a very tiny minority less than
1% are unpleasant however it's very hard
for people to talk about unpleasant
experiences so there may be a lot more
than we're aware of but we have so few
that we've been able to study that we
can't say with any certainty why some
people have unpleasant ones and other
people don't it's certainly not the case
that nasty people have unpleasant
experiences I know some quite nasty
people who have blissful experiences
and there's certainly lots of reports
about Saints throughout the ages who
have unpleasant experiences so there's
no simple answer to it well we are
trying to look at that question now this
is a bit unfair but I did say earlier
that I wanted to come back to the panel
so you guys are in that order when we
restart do you see what I mean but I'm
gonna go now - Kim what what are you
interested in what are you working on
well I am the new kid on the block so I
have not been here as long as these
folks and I feel very fortunate to be
part of this group I'm a clinical
psychologist and a professor in the
Department of Psychiatry and as part of
my work I see patients and I do research
and I teach and a lot of the patients I
see that I'm doing psychotherapy on I
all stars started doing mindfulness
based therapies and recognizing the
impact of the meditation and the
mindfulness treatments that I was
providing and the the positive impact on
symptoms was wonderful however I kept
hearing over and over again from my
patients that they were experiencing
other things and so that's where I
really began exploring and getting
interested in what was actually
happening and I'll give you an example
very quickly I had a gentleman with very
severe depression an attorney
very bright 52 year old had just been
left by his wife very bad alcoholic he
had tried so many times to stop drinking
he had tried so many times to to stay on
his treatment for depression and he
couldn't and I worked with him to start
practicing mindfulness meditation to
help reduce the cravings for alcohol it
didn't work but he kept trying he kept
meditating and then one day he came to
me and he said I'm not going to drink
again and I said okay sure
all right that sounds good let's let's
let's keep an eye on this but I didn't
believe him and he is not how to drink
to this day I asked him what happened
and he had what we call Clara
clairaudience experience while he was
meditating a voice of a woman came and
said beat him up I mean talk about a
negative experience this this voice told
him to quit it what the hell was he
doing he was killing himself and he said
you know it sounded like my mother but I
am not sure if it was but he he said it
resonated with him and no one else heard
it it wasn't you know a real person
he wasn't delusional but it worked he
had he had perceived that this came from
somewhere and it worked and I saw this
over and over again in my patients with
personality disorders when they would
meditate when they would get in touch
with this this thing changed the state
of consciousness and what I began to
realize is that more and more of them
were reporting what many of you will
know as cities these are actually to be
expected sort of experiences that people
have when they're practicing some of
these what are now modern traditions but
come from ancient traditions where this
was to be expected that you would have
extraordinary experiences gifts and
powers these are things like
psychokinesis where you might be able to
influence the environment physical
environment or what we might call SCI
psycho a psyche psychic sort of
abilities where you might be able to
predict something in the future or
remember something that you couldn't
possibly remember from the distant past
and so the research I am moving into now
is really
more methodically exploring this and I'm
building on research with my colleague
who John also knows Cassie Beaton at the
noetic Sciences and she's in California
they did a study that looked at just a
survey of eleven hundred people or so
and they were meditators who had done
some significant meditating and they
asked him about these specific
experiences and it was absolutely
astounding they found over 50% endorsed
experiencing some of these things one or
more 50% reported experiencing some of
these cities some of these extraordinary
experiences things like precognition I
mean I don't know about you but that is
mind-blowing to me and and so they
followed up with some additional
research looking at this most of the
people 60% were significantly impacted
by this in a positive way which again is
pretty profound so they didn't say wow
it's no big deal
it was very significant to them
psychologically emotionally spiritually
so we're building on that research now
and looking at can all the things we've
talked about here can we make this
happen on purpose and and what will that
look like how many people will
experience these things and who
experiences them or it
are they certain kinds of personalities
are they people that need special
training do you need to be a monk I hope
not
and the idea is can we access these
out-of-body experiences these phenomenal
experiences and learn from them what we
see that these other people have learned
on purpose and what would that look like
to tap
into that human ability that level of
consciousness if we all did that Wow I
think we we might have some hope
I just wanted to comment on one thing
before we come to add which is that I
was reading something a week ago that
suggested that if we could all part now
- to the required extent we could all do
this now obviously maybe the difference
is that some of us can quiet our minds
better than others and I tie-dyed him
with another idea which is years ago I
read the the William James lectures at
Edinburgh and we was talking about
religious conversion experiences and
they all seem to come at moments when
people's lives was so bad that they kind
of gave up right it's it's suddenly you
stop relying on your brain and then
something comes in that makes it Edie
you can take a lot of laughs tonight in
what do you want you I want to tell you
a bit about two parts of my own career
in psychical research and I I've been in
it since the early 1970s but I've only
been a top since 2003 and the kinds of
things that I have been involved in kind
of bracket the main part of the dops
research portfolio you know most of the
OPS's work has been focused on very
detailed case studies and field
investigations of various kinds that
you've heard about but I'm like him an
experimental psychologist by training
and I actually got started in this
direction late in graduate school
because of some personal experiences I
encountered the literature of
Experimental Psychology and while I was
working on my dissertation read enough
of it to become convinced that there
really seemed to be something there I
mean these people were using the same
kind of methods that I was being taught
to study paranormal phenomena
and the other thing was that it was
clear that if these things existed it
was extremely important because I mean
the whole point about these phenomena is
that they challenge widely held views
about what's possible you know all of we
use a generic term sigh for things like
ESP extrasensory perception which has
several subcategories
psychokinesis or mind over matter direct
influence on the environment not using
your motor system and all that and the
whole point of both kinds of phenomena
is that a person or an organism is
exchanging information with the
environment despite the presence of some
kind of a barrier that conventional
classical physical principles would say
should prevent that from happening and
it's very easy it turns out to set up
experiments to test whether these things
can't happen and of course at that time
the main Center for experimental
parapsychology in the US was Durham
North Carolina where JB Ryan had set up
a unit in the psych department at Duke
and so I began corresponding with Ryan
and decided after a while that I throw
caution to the wind I had friends who
were telling me you're ruining your life
here but nonetheless I went down and I
began working for Ryan at the usual the
usual terms $400 a month six-month trial
period a steady stream of idealistic
volunteers most of whom didn't survive
very long anyway I also had the great
good fortune after I'd been there for
about a month a guy showed up who turned
out to be probably one of the best
subjects ever to walk into an
experimental parapsychology laboratory
this guy could do essentially anything
we asked him to do they worked with him
for over a year just to give a couple of
examples we had a special electronic
sight testing machine it involved he had
four targets for lights the machine
would pick one you're supposed to guess
which it would be the Machine and
absence of the subject instantiated the
laws of probability to perfection same
with most persons but the guy who built
this thing had spent a couple of years
looking for people who could do
systematically better had found a couple
of people who could do a couple of
percent better on demand ok well this
new guy who came down came into the main
meeting room of the Ryan lab sat down
with this machine who was telling us his
life story would occasionally reach over
and push a button and in the course of
an hour he had over 35% hits and over
500 trials which would happen something
of that sort or better by chance
something like 1 in 10,000,000 times so
we might have sat there for something
like 10 million hours waiting for that
to happen by chance and the inventor of
the devices eyes were getting very big
as this process wore on anyway the same
person I've seen him do as well as 50%
on that machine for hundreds of trials
at a time he could also guess playing
cards it's something like three times
the expected rate with large numbers of
excess number hits as well and there
were things well let me just stop there
and give you one of the what I hope will
be a primary take-home point of this
talk these phenomena the SCI phenomena
in my opinion and I'm talking now not
just in terms of my personal experience
with this guy but the whole accumulated
literature of case studies and
experimental studies of which there are
now thousands published in peer-reviewed
journals
these phenomena exist as facts of nature
and science is going to have to
accommodate to their existence it's
going to have to expand in some way to
accommodate them now at that time I like
most parapsychologists I think hoped
that the changes would be kind of small
what has time has gone on I'd become
more and more convinced that the changes
are going to have to be much more
radical than I had imagined at the
beginning
and I'll get back to that in just a
moment but to continue on with the
experimental part one of the big things
that happened during that period I work
I worked at the Rhine lab for about a
year and a half but then migrated over
to the Department of Electrical
Engineering at Duke the reason being
that I had become convinced particularly
because of experiences with this guy
that it would be productive to study SCI
phenomena in a from a psychobiological
kind of point of view and in particular
what we wanted to do was to measure
brain waves while people like him were
performing in these tasks in hopes of
learning something about what state the
brain was in when he was about to make a
good guess because if we had that kind
of information we could do all sorts of
useful things with it and so we started
this program and went at it diligently
for almost 10 years
poorly funded the whole time made enough
progress the feel we were on a good
track but eventually the funds ran out
and I had to abandon ship basically
started working in conventional
neuroscience at UNC Chapel Hill all the
enemies
but I'm happy to report that since
coming here together with some
colleagues we've managed to create a
really good neuro imaging lab where we
can do the kind of studies we could only
dream about years ago and one of the
things I hope to do in talking to you is
to encourage some bright undergraduates
or early graduate students who working
in areas like psychology or neuroscience
or biomedical engineering maybe to come
visit because we can provide you with
lots of interesting opportunities and
we're also interested of course and
hearing about people who either have
skills themselves or know people who do
because that's really the main obstacle
to carry in this program forward is
finding people with the appropriate
kinds of skills anyway that's maybe
enough on that front now shift years and
they're not here now but the two books
at the far end of the book list there
those were the major products of a
project that went on for about 15 years
through esslyn John talked about it a
little bit last night that's where we
met John actually in the early early
2000s and I have to give you a little
bit of background to this and in talking
about all this stuff what I hope to do
is to situate the work that we do at
DAPs
right at the center of a very big
something that is just now taking shape
it's what I believe will prove to be a
major inflection point in Western
intellectual history that's a big
mouthful let me try to explain what I'm
talking about the background to this
whole project is that a great majority
of mainstream American scientists today
Western scientists really in general
particularly in areas like the
behavioral sciences psychology
neuroscience and also areas like
philosophy of mind hold either
explicitly or implicitly a view that's a
kind of a modern
sanitised philosophical version of what
used to be called materialism in
previous centuries
it's called physicalism now and it's I
mean it comes in a lot of subtly
different variants but the the basic
common idea is pretty straightforward
and easy to state the basic idea is that
all facts are determined in the end by
physical facts alone reality consists at
bottom of some kind of ultimate stuff
little bits of that stuff flying around
and fields of force in accordance with
mathematical laws everything else has to
come from that we human beings are
nothing more than exceedingly
complicated biological machines
everything in mine and consciousness is
generated by physiological events and
processes in our brains it's an
absolutely inescapable corollary of that
picture if it were true that there
cannot be any such thing as post-mortem
survival because when you die the
machinery that generates you disappears
on a more cosmic scale people who hold
these views see no sign of any kind of
final causes or teleology in nature
nothing transcendental no spiritual
realm the whole scheme of things is
without meaning or purpose and that's
literally what probably 95% of
mainstream scientists currently believe
at least while doing their day jobs
it's a bit surprising that a sizeable
fraction estimated on the order 30 to 40
percent also have some kind of a
spiritual practice going and how they
reconcile these two things might be a
little difficult anyway Mike Murphy
how did Esalen Institute was acutely
aware of this and he also was aware of
various groups including in particular
US adopts who have been doing research
on post-mortem survival and developing
what appears to be evidence suggestive
of its existence as a fact of nature so
he convened this group and we began
reviewing all this evidence and we
gradually the project kind of morphed
whether we we became convinced early on
we were all convinced that we are not
physicalist and hatched this plot to
destroy it and find something better to
replace it with
so to summarize to summarize the whole
process all too quickly we developed
these two books the first and they're
not there they're not showing up at the
exact moment anyway irreducible mind was
intended to be our version of an assault
on physicalism and in it we basically
pulled together from a wide variety of
sources a whole lot of empirical
phenomena well established that we feel
are difficult or in some cases
absolutely impossible to explain in
classical physical terms you know the
size phenomena and evidence of survival
right at the top of that list but that's
not the only they are not the only
things that point in this direction a
lot of mainstream scientists of course
they hate all this stuff and hope that
it can be sort of quarantined to put in
a room somewhere by itself because we're
succeeding at everything else and
therefore we can do that but it's not
true there are plenty of phenomena and
we catalog a bunch of them in
irreducible mind that are equally hard
to explain including things like
geometrically shaped hypnotic blisters
emily has a great chapter on extreme
physiological phenomena of that sort
aspects of human memory that are totally
explain that present despite a huge
literature about it wanted to me one of
the most important parts of the evidence
is the stuff that Bruce is working on
near-death experiences and in particular
those that occur under these extreme
physiological conditions we also talked
about stuff like extreme forms of genius
and mystical experiences which have been
widely ignored by contemporary science
but which we argue cannot be ignored
because they're telling us important
things about how things are anyway just
to summarize that whole exercise and I
have to tell you this book is like eight
hundred and thirty pages long so it's
not easily summarized but from a
psychological point of view the really
crucial thing about it is for me anyhow
it established as a viable possibility a
suggestion that William James had made
over a century ago talking about the
correlation which everybody admits
between mental things and physical
things you know we know you get hit on
the head or drink too much and something
mental changes you might think well I
decide to raise my arm and the damn
thing goes up in the air isn't that
mental causation well physical it says
you've just misunderstood because ideas
in your mind are really just patterns of
activity in your brain physical causes
physical no problem well the way to
attack that point of view is to show
things that cannot possibly be
accomplished by the brain itself and
that's what irreducible mind tries to do
James pointed out that even though most
mainstream scientists interpret the
correlations between mental and physical
as evidence of their production point of
view mental produced by physical period
you can think of it the other way that
the mental and the physical sort of
coexist the mind operates in connection
with the brain the stuff in it is not
produced by brains processes but its
activity is conditioned by the state of
the brain
to me the arguments and evidence that we
develop an irreducible mind were
sufficient to show that that point of
view is viable and it totally changed my
personal attitude toward survival it
provides an opening to overcome this
biological objection to the possibility
of survival if the way the system really
works is the way I described that a mind
can be something somehow independent of
the brain but operating together with it
I believe we can explain all the
conventional evidence used by physical
is to support their point of view and in
addition some of these things that we
study adopts just as James had argued
over a century ago okay well that was
stage one that was the easy that was the
easy part I mean it was just a huge
clerical job basically to pull all this
stuff together from a vastly dispersed
mostly biomedical literature there's all
kinds of stuff out there that challenges
the physicalist point of view but has
never been really assembled in a way to
show that clearly okay but now comes the
hard part what can possibly replace the
physicalist point of view ah right on
time beyond physicalism that's part two
that was published in 2015 and the basic
strategy in in trying to put that
together was we looked around for a
whole bunch of systems that we had
access to through our membership so it's
somewhat selective in that regard but we
specifically wanted to look at people
and systems that had deliberately tried
to figure out how the world must have to
be in order for the kinds of phenomena
we had cataloged in irreducible mind
could occur we found quite a few of
these things
a very strange set of bedfellows for one
book we've got chapters in there by
several physicists for example
contemporary physicists quantum
theorists cosmologists several
from the we had a big membership of
scholars of religion and some of the old
mystically informed religious
philosophical systems have also taken
the existence of these fun phenomena for
granted and tried to explain them and
there were several Western philosophical
traditions also like lightness for
example and Charles Sanders purse and
Alfred North Whitehead so we pulled all
these things together and tried to sort
of inter animate them and we have a
final part of the book in which we try
to figure out where is this all headed
and the basic what I want want to convey
to you is that even though we don't have
any sort of final position that we're
all agreed upon by any means there is a
definite central tendency of all this
stuff and it's a tendency toward what
amounts to the exact opposite of
contemporary physicalism which takes the
view that consciousness far from being
an ineffectual by-product that things
going on in the brain is in fact at the
source of everything and we're going to
have to somehow figure out how our
experience of ourselves as being in a
shared external world comes into being
and I will tell you also that at at this
very moment I know of at least three
books being generated by people who are
deeply familiar with developments in
modern physics all driven by mystical
experiences of their own who are
attempting to formulate their particular
systems of that sort and I firmly
personally believe that something of
this sort will emerge in the not distant
future as the new sort of received
wisdom the new generally accepted
scientifically based worldview and I
also would echo Kim in saying to John
that this may be our best and perhaps
only hope to save ourselves from the
very
katastrophe cigarette described
let's let's just take a few seconds for
people who need to leave who have planes
to catch or children to punish
what do you have to pass
all right the very patient lady there
the front of them is it working okay so
in my extremely imperfect understanding
or dalliance at all in in like Eastern
philosophies I've always thought of like
communal consciousness as something that
either pre-existed our corporal like
being and and maybe existed afterwards
maybe that's why babies do have that
lack of a sense of separation between
themselves and others that they then
kind of grow into and get the ego and
then you go kind of you know caps out
somewhere in whatever the 40s 50s and
then towards death the ego is is dropped
and that's sort of from what I've
understood a lot of times with
mindfulness and whatnot at the key to
avoiding psychic pain is the dropping of
the ego but a lot of what you've
explained in the near-death experiences
and other things seem to maintain a very
individualistic existence post our
bodies and I'm just curious if you have
any thoughts about that or do you think
that that's almost because they're so
close to a earthly life or do you really
or do and you you sort of had you gave
an example of like a dialogue between
two souls or whatever you want to refer
to them as is it in your minds or maybe
think separately is it a communal
consciousness or do you think it
continues as a single standing
consciousness thank you this is a very
complicated question
if you ask a near-death experience
they're just set to tell you what
happened in their experience they will
often start by saying I can't put it
into words there are no words to explain
this we say great tell me about it
so they forced it into English words
knowing that it's a distortion to do
that so when they say I saw my body it's
not like they were seeing with eyes they
knew where the body was they knew things
about the body and the only way they can
convey to me is by saying I saw it so
when they talked about personal things
we know they're using a metaphor to
explain it to us
maybe that will say that in their
near-death experience there was a cup of
a dual consciousness they were aware of
themselves and also we're being part of
something much greater than themselves
and they can't explain it to us because
it doesn't go into English words I think
it's also true that there's a lot in the
mystical literature about this about
people who have mystical experiences and
retain that sense of self but conversely
are also losing that sense of self and
again like print like the near-death
experiencers say they can't really
explain it although they try but that
that sort of paradoxical maintaining and
losing the sense of self happens in
mystical experiences
oh yes it's true when do we have to
finish we have to finish in five minutes
so let's talk there is a resource that
would be very quick
the children who remember previous lives
they obviously had adult skills in those
lives language music smells any of that
carry through sometimes there are cases
where children seem to learn things more
quickly than other children do there are
occasional very few but occasional
prodigy type cases I've got one where a
it's a bit of a long story and we've
only got five minutes but he basically
remembered being the life of remember
the life as a golfer a professional
golfer Bobby Jones people they know this
kid was definitely a golfing prodigy I
mean from the age of three on he was
winning golf tournaments so there do
seem to be times for skills do carry
over I have two things to say one I did
have an I think it would be a mystical
experience you might say and you and the
blonde pretty girl I want to say I do
have a key because of the first 43 years
of my life were a living hell I couldn't
figure out how to do life so I I lost my
children I did get them back but I came
to the end of myself I didn't know what
to do and I said [ __ ] it I don't care if
there's a hell I'll go there I don't
care because I can't do it anymore so I
had this encounter and I'm not going to
tell you all of it you can look on my
website or whatever but here's the key
the first thing I heard when I went into
the trance on that day in my own in my
in the house that I was being evicted
from when I went into the trance the
first thing I heard was because the guy
told me I had to go to church and I said
I've already tried
and then he said ma'am you already know
about God and as soon that's when I went
into the trance as soon as he said that
and then I went into the trance and the
very first thing I heard was going back
to the altar because he told me I had to
go back to the altar and the first thing
I heard was going back to the altar
means starting all over with everything
that you think that you know about life
and I said I won't know anything I mean
I'll really be stupid right and but
there was this flutter of fairies around
me going yes yes yes so I made an
agreement that I would surrender
everything that I thought that I knew
that obviously wasn't working today I'm
a successful business owner eight years
in the home healthcare field
alive and healthy and I have the keys to
life I know exactly what you're talking
about
and for you and here the reason I'm up
here I didn't want to come up here but I
felt pushed and I said give me a sign
like give me something bright yellow
because that's my favorite color and I
look around the room and I see bright
yellow and the light bulbs which they're
usually white but these are bright
yellow so I said I've got to come up but
here's for your fundraising you're
talking about are they using drugs for
people that are crossing over patient
after patient they all have an encounter
before they cross over so for your
fundraising I would say single a find
out people that own home care agencies
which I'm one and let us give you a
report for free so that you can know
what these people are actually
experiencing would you not say that that
is a really good first hand way of
knowing is I would never like it's a
very good idea and we have people here
will be able to say you have 4 seconds o
matter yeah what are your thoughts on
and do you have any studies regarding
mediumship medium here
well we yes I did a study of mediums
several years ago I
I since we have so little time I won't
go into any details about it I did a
study with a number of mediums did we
did two blind readings with the mediums
and again I can't great details but it
was it was one of the mediums protected
was which was it was extremely
successful and then ed and Kim are now
they've got a proposal for a mediumship
study to to be done here also so yes we
are interested in that yeah last one
thank you thank you it's release Dobbs
thank you for this evening my question
is in your research have you run into
any cases with children in which they
have taken on the personalities of the
past lives of apes name a head or like
as they have grown older have they grown
older have they taken on those
personalities well it's seen with each
case we we coded on a bunch of different
variables and put it in the database and
that includes some personality features
and what we see is that there is a
correlation between personality features
in the previous person and the child
it's certainly not one-to-one I mean
they are different individuals and of
course we know personality is affected
by genes and environment and everything
else but there's a correlation there so
it seems that there is is some carryover
but it's also subject to be changed by
the other aspects of life okay well I
just wrap this up with something I found
this also this book which Dean Radin
engaged to me a couple of weeks ago
real magic he justs at the end
sorry at the beginning of the chapter on
scientific evidence which seems to be
really the 101 of this stuff he talks
about a woman who was the chair of the
Statistics Department of the University
of California at Irvine and in a
presidential address to that to the
aasa' speaker the meeting attended by
successful statisticians
she said something she said for many
years I've worked with researchers doing
very careful work in parapsychology
including a year that I spent working
full-time on a classified project for
the United States government to see if
we could use these abilities for
intelligence gathering during the Cold
War and then she concludes at the end of
that project I wrote a report for
Congress staging what I still think is
true the data in support of precognition
and possibly other related phenomena is
quite strong statistically it would be
widely accepted if it pertains to
something more mundane I think that's
really interesting Thank You Charlotte
[Applause]
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.