All language subtitles for TrustWho.2016.720p.WEBRip.x264.AAC-[YTS.MX].eng

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal) Download
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

Downloaded from YTS.MX

Official YIFY movies site: YTS.MX

(faint ambient sounds)

(faint sound of children playing)

How many of you, put, have family

or close friends with cancer or have experienced cancer.

Put up your hands.

What about diabetes?

How about infertility?

Family or close friends.

Now I want those of you who put your hand up at least once

to put it up again,

for any of those questions, and look around you.

(music)

today every third person develops cancer.

Who will it be?

(Obama) Because if we want to protect Americans from

Ebola here at home, we have to end it over there.

H1N1, SARS, MERS

Universal health coverage is the single most powerful concept

that public health has to offer. We will not let the people down.

(radio static)

(radio static)

But after Fukushima, I think, you can

see that everyone knows that there's

a kind of official and high level cover

up and the WHO is involved in it.

The WHO's been criticised for reacting too slowly to the

outbreak, do you think any of that criticism is fair?

They don't have the money, they

don't have the capacity, they don't

have the leadership, they don't

have the courage to say 'let's go'.

I'm a filmmaker, I have a daughter, it is important

to me that she finds the world in good condition.

That is why I'm travelling to the WHO headquarters in Geneva.

The American journalist Robert Parsons lives here.

For 20 years now he's been writing about the WHO.

Until a few years ago, every Monday, the

opening day of the World Health Assembly

there was a sumptuous reception at the

WHO given by the Director General

that was the great centrepiece where

everybody met and talked. It was a

very good situation for pulling everybody

together in an informal setting.

(music)

Now, more than ever, that sort of thing

has been replaced by a private reception.

And they are organised by industry.

I'm particularly pleased to have two ministers of health.

And the industry spends a lot of money, for them

it's just part of the cost of doing business.

It's a way of making direct contact

with the people who back in their home

countries are making decisions to formulate

and implement public health policy.

It's extraordinarily expensive, you

can imagine it, if you have 1,000

people and you give 100 francs a person

it's 100,000 francs right there at least,

just to feed people who are already over-fed.

There's no limit on the champagne or the

wine and it's always very good wine.

Straight through if you can.

No you can't.

(narrator) What a promising start.

But originally it must have been about more.

The suffering of millions of human beings

in scores of countries will be alleviated

and many, many thousands of lives will be saved.

(applause)

WHO has positively changed everything.

Smallpox was completely eradicated which was the

first time ever that a disease was wiped out.

The world saves each year 1000 million dollars

on vaccines and care of the sick alone.

According to Robert Parsons, the WHO is

infiltrated by the industry from the very start.

Here.

This one's in English.

This is in the San Francisco examiner.

Anyway, WHO was not happy with my coverage

because it made them look less than good.

(music)

Ever since the 1950s, studies have

shown that smoking damages health.

But for decades the WHO does little

to oppose the tobacco industry.

(music)

How often does your job call you out

of bed in the middle of the night.

Well if you were a doctor it would be often

and generally there isn't much time to spare.

Coffee doctor?

Oh fine!

Have a Camel with your coffee

Thanks.

You know, this night work's kind of rough isn't it.

That's right,

but a Camel's always a pleasure.

The majority of politicians take no action

against tobacco advertising for decades.

Nothing is done to check the profits of the tobacco industry

until charges are brought against

it by its victims and the USA.

As late as 1994, heads of the tobacco industry

testified before the American congress.

Do you believe that nicotine is not addictive?

I believe that nicotine is not addictive.

I believe that nicotine is not addictive.

I believe that nicotine is not addictive.

The real issue is: Should cigarettes be outlawed.

Gradually the tobacco companies are obliged

to publish their internal documents.

These general requests are getting very broad.

No that's not broad at all Mr. Campbell.

Will you provide that information to the committee?

We're extremely concerned about competitive activity...

Yes or no Mr. Campbell?

I will do my best, yes.

Their strategies to combat the WHO are made public.

One example is the Boca Raton action plan from the year 1988.

Senior figures at Philip Morris met in Florida and drew up a

number of sophisticated strategies

to limit the power of the WHO.

The first and most important aim.

This organisation has extraordinary

influence on government and consumers

and we must find a way to diffuse this.

The WHO gets under pressure.

(speaking French)

The evidence show that tobacco companies had

operated for many years with the deliberate purpose

of subverting the efforts of WHO to control tobacco.

(music)

(applause)

One of these institutes is lead by

the American lawyer Paul Dietrich.

Philip Morris finances it with $240,000 a year.

At the same time Dietrich is a consultant

for the WHO regional office in America.

When his double role becomes known,

Dietrich moves into the finance industry.

And we bought back our own bonds, that

money never went back into the economy!

He won't agree to talk to me.

And the WHO report on the strategies of the tobacco

industry, 6 other consultants are mentioned.

The British toxicologist Frank Sullivan

for instance, claims that passive smoking

doesn't harm your health. His study on the

subject is financed by Philip Morris.

Hello, Frank Sullivan.

Hello Mr Sullivan,

oh (awkward laughter)

Good to hear you.

I tell you why I'm calling you.

I came across the tobacco scandal at

WHO and there your name is mentioned.

(Sullivan) My name?!

yes.

Oh I didn't know that.

(narrator) Were you a WHO consultant?

Yes I'm an (awkward stutter)

Yeah, I am

I, I, I'm a consultant for WHO, and I also used

to be a consultant in the tobacco industry.

There was a great long form you had to fill

in every time I went to a meeting at WHO.

(narrator) But did you declare in those forms

that you also consulted tobacco industry?

Yes, yes, yes.

And it was no problem for WHO?

No, no, no because (laughing) it wasn't a big issue.

From when till when were where you a WHO consultant.

Oh, I don't know when.

Did you stop after the tobacco scandal or not?

No, no, no.

(music)

In the year 2000, Sullivan's collaboration with the tobacco

industry becomes public, but he

still continues to advise the WHO.

I meet with two department leaders combating

tobacco under the auspices of the WHO.

We have a zero tolerance approach as I

said the Director General says, the

tobacco industry is our number 1 enemy

and we wear that badge very proudly.

(narrator) Is Frank Sullivan still a WHO consultant.

Absolutely not I mean...

They can't because the names of all those

persons are well known through the documents.

But did Frank Sullivan consult to

WHO in for example 2002 let's say?

Not that I'm aware of as well too, and again the

policies that are in place now is that all consultants

no matter whether they're working in

tobacco control or infectious diseases

or anywhere in the organisation, have

to sign a declaration of interest.

(narrator) But this means a lot of trust.

Don't you think they should be reviewed?

Trust I think that you should trust

until such a day you lack trust.

You cannot just start by already being suspicious

about people and their capacity to do things.

That's good.

Thank you so much.

We are not alone during the conversation,

three WHO staff are watching us and

the press spokesman conducts the person

I'm interviewing with silent gestures.

I would like to know about conflict

of interest forms and I would

like to see the conflict of

interest forms of Frank Sullivan.

I just am able to refer the question on to the

necessary people because that might be in the

archive of the organisation but in the role of

the reference library and that's what we do.

My official enquiry about Frank Sullivan's conflict of

interest form is a dead end despite countless phone calls.

(music)

The WHO and also Thomas Zeltner they always say ok we had

a problem and there was single persons who were corrupt.

This was Sullivan, Paul Dietrich and so on.

But I'm always doubting was it

really single persons and now it's

over or could you say that entire

segments of WHO are corrupt?

We have all the tobacco company documents

which show how major corporations operate.

And the pharmaceutical companies or the chemical

companies do not operate any differently.

Their obligation to their shareholders completely

overwhelms any consideration of public health.

So these are the people that are involved in the H1N1 push.

(tense music)

Swine flu, or H1N1, is presented by the WHO and in the

public media as a huge threat. Wrongly as it later emerges.

(newsreader) We are in the earliest days of the pandemic)

(news reports playing over each other)

Do you remember swine flu?

You were really frightened.

The numbers are staggering.

Well first of all, they are estimated by the

WHO to affect 2bn people worldwide with H1N1.

Joining us now from Cibolo, Texas,

Patrick and Robyn Henshaw. Their

family has been hit hard by this

Swine flu, good morning to you both.

Good morning.

My administration's taken several precautions to

address the challenge posed by the 2009 H1N1 flu virus.

If you've been diagnosed with probable or

presumed 2009 H1N1 or Swine flu in recent months,

you may be surprised to know this. The odds are you didn't

have H1N1 flu. In fact you probably didn't have flu at all.

WHO is very happy to be taking part in this hearing...

(several people speaking at the same time)

But I've heard no reason why.

Many countries including Germany,

Italy, France and Great Britain

concluded secret agreements with

pharmaceutical companies before the Swine

flu incident, which obliged them to

purchase Swine flu vaccinations.

But only if the WHO issued a pandemic level 6 alert.

(music)

The world is now at the start of the 2009 influenza pandemic.

Swine flu makes considerable profits

for the manufacturers of vaccines.

In first quarter net profit,

saving its Swine flu vaccine, Lantes, for the gains.

France's largest drug maker said it's net profit in the

quarter rose to 1.71bn euros, that's 2.26bn US dollars.

I tried to arrange an interview with the

person responsible for Swine flu at the WHO,

Keiji Fukuda,

he was often on television at the time.

But I get an appointment with the official press spokesman.

11 countries, officially reporting

331 cases of influenza A

H1N1 infection, with 10 deaths.

Were you aware of the contracts between

pharmaceutical companies and governments?

You have to be aware of this. Of course, you

have to be aware of everything that's going on.

And it is extremely easy to after the fact say, well maybe X

should not have done Y, and A should not have done B.

However, think about the opposite.

What would have happened if the influenza

killed 50 percent of the people

infected and there was no vaccine.

Then you and others would be standing here today getting

really mad at us for not having made vaccine a possibility.

Now in terms of an overall assessment

of the severity of what we are

seeing, it's probably fair to call the

situation something like moderate.

At the time I am pregnant and I avoid

airports, crowds and all forms of travel.

Public media exaggerates with words and

images, the danger resulting from swine flu.

(music and ambulance siren)

Could they have declared the pandemic

level 6 also with the old definition?

So this is er...

This was removed

before 2009, shortly before H1N1.

Of course, we would like to have a vaccine tomorrow.

We would have wanted to have had it yesterday.

In 2009, Miss Kieny is a member of

the WHO Swine flu working group.

Previously she had worked for the French

pharmaceutical company Transgene.

The press spokesman doesn't allow me to interview her,

so I try to approach her directly at a conference.

I ask Miss Kieny why the criteria of severity was

deleted from the definition of a pandemic phase.

(music)

The WHO working group on Swine flu consists of 13 external

consultants. Two of them report conflicts of interest.

Neil Ferguson declares consultancy fees

from GlaxoSmithKline, Baxter and Roche,

the manufacturers of the swine flu vaccines

and medications. Not a problem for the WHO.

In 2007, Albert Osterhaus loses his voting right on the

Dutch heath commission due to his conflicts of interest.

He declares to the WHO that he has shares in the pharma company

Viroclinics, which is suspected of profiting from Swine flu.

He also declares that he is the chairman of ESWI,

describing it as a group of independent scientists.

In fact it is partly financed by vaccine manufacturers.

Because I also did some research about H1N1,

could we also discuss this a little bit later?

Yeah?

I can tell you there's no scientific meeting today

organised that is not being sponsored by industry

and rightly so. Industry is making

the vaccines, it's not the national

institutes that are making the vaccines

any longer, industry is doing it.

(narrator) I'm very curious, are you still a WHO consultant?

At the moment I'm working more with the private sector

as well so I'm still consulting from time to time.

(narrator) Are you still working with this

European Scientists against Influenza?

Yes, I'm the chair of that particular organisation.

(narrator) Because I saw that you

declared this as a conflict of interest.

No no it's not a conflict of interest but I declare

also what might be perceived as a conflict of interest.

No but you have to be very careful there so at

least if you say that, people can hold it against

you yeah but at least I can always say and I have

always done that. At least you show what you do.

(narrator) It was written there

'independent group of scientists', when

I looked on the website I saw it's

funded by all the vaccine producers.

No no it's not funded by, some money comes from

vaccine producers but there's money coming

from many other sources as well and that's the

same with WHO and a lot of other organisations.

As long as you're transparent and show

what you're doing, it's fine I think.

(narrator) How is the percentage of funding?

I don't know exactly, but there is a substantial part of

the funding comes from elsewhere. From meetings, comes

from European projects, and there is a percentage coming

from industry as well and that's completely transparent.

It's fine to bring it up again but for me it's over.

I don't get any hard figures from Mr. Osterhaus either.

Without any facts, without transparency,

I can't make any progress here.

What about the WHO?

We didn't say anything - No, no

No, I wouldn't like you to use what I just

said but I'm happy to say something else.

Please don't approach people with a camera.

We have issues, please don't do that.

I ask and then it's fine?

If you ask and you set up the interview, that's ok.

At the country level,

I hear good news and I hear bad news

about engagement with non state actors.

We found out that there has been a big lack of transparency

with the pandemic alert experienced in 2009.

What did you do since then to have more transparency

concerning the decisions done, concerning the staff,

concerning the declarations of conflicts of

interest. How do you want to improve this?

I want to erm...

agree with you. There is no replacement

of transparency and accountability.

And that's the only way to hold people to account.

But in order to do that, we must recognise that in this 21st

century, no government can provide

everything to their people.

So you do need to work with the industry.

But work in a way that there is

no room for conflict of interest.

(road noise and music)

In the case of the pharmaceutical

industry, it's even more difficult for

the WHO to maintain it's independence

than with the tobacco industry.

On the one hand the WHO is dependent on the

pharmaceutical industries for research

and medication. But the industries financial

interests mustn't damage the WHO's

activities in the area of health.

One thing is clear, today the

pharmaceutical industry is part of

the health system, just like the

governments that control the WHO.

(applause)

Pfizer doesn't need a PR man, they've got the Prime Minister!

Secretary Clinton has a number of super packs

and in the last filing period reported

receiving 15 million dollars from Wall Street.

(booing)

My whole life I've been a business

man. I've contributed to most of them.

I've given to democrats, I've given

to Hillary, I've given to everybody!

Because that was my job.

I gotta give to them

because when I want something I get it.

When I call...

they kiss my ass.

Ok, it's true, they kiss my ass.

(cheering and applause)

Politics are losing power.

And that's also reflected in the financing of the WHO.

In the 1990s, all countries froze their membership

contributions in the wake of the financial crisis,

Desperate times do indeed call for desperate measures.

We are in a mess.

The financial crisis hit the world like a sudden jolt

and it hit the world where it hurts most... money.

Today UN organisations, foundations, NGOs and industry

contribute almost 40 percent of the WHO's annual budget.

The second largest source of finance right after

the USA is the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation.

30 years ago, in starting Microsoft we had a

very ambitious vision: a computer for everyone.

Now I join you in seeking to achieve an even more important

vision which is good health for every human being.

Today the WHO relies on voluntary

contributions like that from

the Gates foundation, but these are often linked to conditions.

Bill Gates declares,

'our priorities are your priorities',

not the other way around.

A Freudian slip?

Our priorities are your priorities.

(applause)

Today the WHO's annual budget amounts to about 2bn dollars.

Coca Cola spends twice that much on advertising alone.

And the hospitals around lake Geneva spend 6bn dollars a year.

When it was founded, the WHO could decide

how to distribute it's funds itself.

Now 70 percent of it's budget is tied to

particular projects, countries or regions.

If the WHO receives funding to fight malaria for

example, it can't use that money to combat Ebola.

(background chatter)

The Ebola interim assessment panel put it

in very precise words.

In present WHO does not

have the operational capacity or culture to

deliver a full emergency public health response.

(applause)

(narrator) What does the Director

General of the WHO think about that?

I want to ask her what constraints she is under.

I need that!

(laughing)

Newspaper?

No I'm doing a cinema documentary, I'm a filmmaker.

Ahh, ok, let's discuss the date.

You don't want July, August?

No August would also be possible.

July, August whatever,

not so hectic.

If that's better for you then ok I will adapt my schedule.

(music)

Since I can't get to speak to Margaret Chan,

I meet one of her close advisors.

(music and ambient sounds)

I think it's simply a wrong perception to think

there can be external independent review.

Because then you have to say who is selecting this independent

expert, and who is controlling their independence

and who is controlling the independence

of those controlling the independence.

There is no external entity as such independent.

Of course he's right, but he's wrong.

- You know, he's mixing everything up because - this world is as it is and you have to do

what you can to make sure that the independence

of the science is as good as possible.

It will never ever be perfect, he's quite right by that,

but he should be talking about his own. I mean he's from

Switzerland, he came straight from Switzerland which is a

country that is completely locked

in to a partnership approach

and he's in charge of partnerships at WHO.

So I know Gaudenz was very keen that any countries could

come in, as long as it was transparent he didn't mind.

This is our opposition to the non

state actors thing as it is, ok?

Namibia will be onside with us isn't it?

African groups generally are worried

about it. How many people are in?

Quite a few now.

Yeah quite a few, that's enough.

What's going on with them?

Next room - Next room

What's happening there is those industrialised countries

that would really like to expand their markets

into the developing world, they are finding a way to

let WHO allow these companies in to influence policy.

(speaker) The world in which the WHO

operates today is very different from

the world in which the organisation was

established more than 60 years ago.

Member states are also influenced by non state actors.

But since they are our bosses,

and they're sovereign member states, if it's a private

sector entity, if it's an NGO or whoever influences

them, as long as they make it a national position,

it's a national position and we accept it as such.

(music)

(children playing)

Professor Yamashita is

contributing to the trivialisation

of the risk of radioactive contamination in public.

Yamashita works together with the WHO

in cases of nuclear catastrophe.

Is the WHO downplaying the dangers of nuclear radiation?

Is it for example, keeping silent

about a rise in thyroid cancer?

There's a lot here about Swine flu

and almost nothing about Fukushima.

I would like to talk to the Director

General about this in person.

Maybe you can help me, how can I get

an interview with Margaret Chan.

(inaudible)

Very difficult.

I have to become friends with you, ok I see.

(man) She's very busy.

I know I know, this is why I'm asking.

Can we get you someone else?

No.

Look, no one can promise you interview with Dr

Chan because she really prefers others to speak.

So there are some circumstances where she

does it but nothing that can be guaranteed.

(music)

(children shouting)

It's difficult to find anybody who is allowed to talk.

The mayor of Matsumoto, Akira Sugenoya,

is also a doctor and has founded a convalescence

camp for children from contaminated areas.

Konichiwa!

As a result of experience after Chernobyl, the WHO

recommendations for issuing iodine were revised in the

year 1999 under the supervision of the British scientist

Keith Baverstock, a member of staff at the WHO.

(music)

Thank you Mr. moderator for that kind introduction, and

thank you for the invitation to come and present here.

I guess I... Ok I want to start this

presentation by saying a few words about lessons

learnt from a previous nuclear power plant accident,

namely the one in Chernobyl in 1986.

When I started my programme with WHO,

within a few weeks I learnt that

there was a claim that there was a

large number of thyroid cancers

in children and this ended up in the mission to Minsk. We saw an

astonishing number of children who'd

been operated for thyroid cancer.

Quite young children, so to see as we did

on that day possibly 1 maybe 12 cases in

one place at one time, all having been

operated was really quite extraordinary.

We took it from there.

And with our Belarusian colleagues

published two short papers in the

journal nature to draw attention to it.

After the papers were published, WHO asked

me to withdraw the paper from Nature.

A paper published with about 5 or 6 other

people, all agreeing on this position.

And he asked me to withdraw that paper from publication.

After it had been published.

Chrysler who worked at WHO

Geneva, yes. He threatened me.

How did he threaten you?

With my career.

He said your career will be shortened if you don't do this.

And was it shortened?

No.

I wonder why in Fukushima area it wasn't distributed.

I don't know.

I don't know, they should have given them.

Yeah.

They don't like to cause panic.

Did you have any contact with WHO after the TEPCO accident?

I still find it beyond belief that Naoto Kan was convinced at

the time that no radioactivity would emerge after the accident.

Just one day after the accident a monitoring

station of the organisation CTBTO

recorded raised levels of radioactivity

200km from the nuclear power station.

(music)

But who is right?

(chanting)

(applause)

What do you think today about iodine

intake after nuclear accident?

Well again it's more or less what was said in the video.

People are not taking iodine as of the moment the

Japanese authorities have no said that should be done.

They have distributed iodine tablets, pre-positioned

them but have not yet asked anyone to take them.

Taking iodine tablets in the absence of

iodine radiation is actually bad for you.

You need to match iodine, taking iodine to the exposure.

I understand but, from today's point of view was the

exposure given at that time in most affected areas or not?

You know, again, that's almost 5 years ago and I

can't remember the process from day to day and

certainly we would have adapted our recommendations

based on the information we were getting.

But there are these guidelines and

it's written in here you should

take iodine within the first 6 hours after nuclear accident.

It's in here and it's also clear

that it was not given in Fukushima,

it's also a fact, it's not something

you have to look up, it's obvious.

Ok.

I really think you are wasting your time on this topic.

And that we should move on to other topics

because I only have until 12 o'clock.

Is it that you can't say something

critical about the Japanese government?

I... WHO, work on the basis of facts

and if I don't have the facts

and the information at my fingertips

I am not going to speculate.

Yeah, but in general is it possible

for WHO to criticise nations?

I'm not going to say anything more about

this, why should I say anything more.

No this was a general question, not in relation to Fukushima.

Well let's move on to another topic.

Ok.

(music)

(inaudible)

Yeah yeah the speaker.

Well I know what is his role, not to

answer anything, it's to around, around, around, around...

This is the problem. One of the

serious problems of WHO is the media

policing because they are trying to

avoid any conflict, to avoid anything.

So they are not talking openly and transparently to the people.

So what struck me was that your

questions are odd and out of date.

No it's a great organisation, I'm the spokesperson

for the organisation I do this day in and day out.

I love the job.

Is it getting more difficult now that WHO has lost trust?

Who says WHO has lost trust?

Is that you?

(music)

(road noise)

I am Alison Katz, I worked for the

World Health Organisation myself for

18 years and since I have left I have

been involved in independent WHO

which works in the area of radiation and health

and we have been in front of the

World Health Organisation headquarters in Geneva for

7 years now and it is a permanent peaceful protest.

So that the world understands that somebody is witnessing

the victims of radiation which includes almost everybody.

The Japanese people are already talking and they

are reporting very serious health effects in

children that the WHO is ignoring. It's not

talking about, doesn't mention in it's report.

You know.

At the time of Chernobyl, the people couldn't talk freely.

(music)

The New York Academy of Science book, this one, comes up

with an estimate of 985,000 deaths, that is worldwide,

between 1986 and 2004. And of course that makes a

dramatic contrast with what the establishment says,

which is still around 50 deaths and

possibly 4000 cancers as a final total.

The other major omission is that the WHO has never

considered anything except cancer as a health effect.

(speaking foreign language)

(aeroplane noise)

Since January we know that there are other diseases

What other diseases?

Unfortunately, um yeah...

for example...

Cardiovascular diseases, infertility,

thyroid diseases other than cancer.

There's a book, maybe you heard about

it, of the Academy of Science.

Which was reputed by the New York Academy

of Sciences because it's so unsound.

But that's not true. - Yes.

If you read the statement from the New York Academy

of Sciences, in 2011 or 12 they repudiated the book.

Let me give you this.

This is from the journal of radiology

and it's a review of the New

York Academy of Science's book which

talks about all the flaws in it.

Ok, ok.

So I should also give you something.

A book review by independent WHO.

Yeah - Yeah

Ok we read this and then we meet again.

(phone dialing)

Hello, this is Lilian Franck.

What does it mean exactly that the New York

Academy of Science repudiate the Chernobyl book.

The editor tells me that the

Academy never repudiated the book.

He permits me to record the phone call,

but later he withdraws his permission.

Isn't he able to speak freely either?

When I try to confront the WHO press spokesman

with the statement, he doesn't take my calls.

So he doesn't take it.

Do you wanna try with my Italian number?

Why not, thanks!

Like mine? Ah yeah.

Hi Gregory, this is Lilian, good to hear you.

The press spokesman refuses to give me another interview.

I'm good and you?

He says he's spent enough time with me already.

I was wondering whether

we could meet again for another interview.

No? Why not?!

Perhaps the publisher of the Chernobyl book can help me.

(dialing tone)

(Sherman) Good morning

Good morning!

The original contact person at the New York Academy of Sciences

agreed to publish the book.

And then there was a big to-do at the

New York Academy and they did not

think was a good idea.

And I suspect that they were pressured by the

nuclear industry but I don't know for sure.

(music)

How big is the influence of the nuclear industry?

Here at home, nuclear power is also an

important part of our own energy future.

As you know I'm a big believer in Nuclear power.

(typing)

The international Atomic Energy Agency, IAEA,

wants to promote the safe and peaceful use of atomic energy.

Nuclear power will remain an important and viable option

for many countries as a clean and stable source of energy.

(muffled voices)

The WHO is concerned with health.

These are different priorities

but the two organisations are working closely together.

For example, together with other UN organisations they are

compiling a report about the

health consequences of Chernobyl.

I'm a critic of WHO and they tended not to invite critics

for their two reports, one on health one on the environment.

What kind of people are these?

Do you know some of them or?

Yes I know most of them.

There's certainly a good bunch.

But the trouble is that they are

outweighed by the scientists from IAEA.

And erm...

because they're the ones who ruled

the roost, who dictated the agenda.

The thing was that there would be a

whole series of informal meetings

going on between WHO and IAEI at quite

senior levels, very senior levels.

And they would predetermine what line they would take.

That's why they had a WHO / IAEI meeting

in Vienna in 2005, in October 2005

To put the line across, this is it,

this is what we're going to do.

The trouble was that many, many people came opposed to all this.

(music)

Maria Neira works at the WHO. She is responsible

for the risks of radioactive contamination.

I deliberately make an appointment to see her in

Paris. The press department won't get in the way here.

To make sure she agrees to see me, I don't tell her

what I want to talk about until we first meet.

(Neira) It's like Chernobyl, there is a book

saying that there have been 1 million deaths that

the WHO is hiding, how can you have 1 million

deaths, come on. Seriously, 1 million deaths.

And then the humanity will not, I mean 1 million.

Yeah but this is because they were looking

at the broader part of the world population.

Yeah but 1 million deaths, you think

that you can hide 1 million deaths?

Yeah but do you seriously think

Which records, do you have mortality records?

How can you seriously believe that

Chernobyl accident caused 50 deaths.

No we didn't say that.

But it's still on the WHO website!

(music)

So we wrote the other report

and the initials are TORCH which is torch.

We said right away that we expected somewhere

between 30 and 60,000 altogether worldwide

future deaths.

Because the plume from Chernobyl went right round the world.

The northern hemisphere.

And whilst the concentrations were low,

far, far away, it doesn't matter

because there were many, many millions of people.

There are 600 million people in Europe alone

and they were all affected.

Politicians who do not learn from

history are doomed to repeat it.

The purpose of this report was looking at the exposure

and the doses to which people have been exposed.

What is the risk that we can expect

and I think this is more human

than trying to predict how many people will die from cancer.

The other reason why we were not using cancer mortality

figures but rather incidents is because as you know

most of the cancers can now be treated and

therefore there was no mortality associated.

I don't know whether you have noticed but our

health risk assessment is only with the log of WHO.

But I mean if once heard of the experts belonged to IAEA.

This is kind of anticipating that those experts

from IAEA are not on the best of their

science, which is the case, I don't think

they were there to represent any interest.

I mean it was criticised that there was

no oncologist or no radiobiologist

also no scientist who published critical

articles on health effect of nuclear energy.

But when you need to do a scientific

report, it's not a question of

bringing an activist from the left

wing, an activist from the right wing.

It's a question of science.

What's happened is that there are groups outside that

they want to use those accidents to say you see nuclear

energy is bad, is dangerous, why we don't stop the

use of nuclear energy, which is a different cause.

Do you think it could also be the other

way round, that nuclear industry...

tries to not to tell the whole truth about the health impacts.

Absolutely, I have no doubt for sure.

(ambient sounds)

(eerie sound)

Of course we are not perfect but we are there

and we are doing the best we can and with

the support of everybody who recognises that

there is a need for a global public health

very heavy institution, heavy in the good sense, with weight,

institution, powerful institution,

it will be the best for all of us.

And I will fight for that for the rest of

my life. I'm a convinced public health

officer and I think my record accredits

that if we need to fight, I am not afraid.

A scientist in the United States this past spring

made the observation that this generation of children

is the first generation in modern history that

is not going to be as healthy as their parents.

That should not be.

What do I do with this knowledge now?

Go out on the streets together with

independent WHO, or just go home again?

First I have to speak to the Director General.

(dialing tone)

I was talking to Margaret Chan for an

interview during World Health Assembly.

She said yes she would like to give it

but I didn't get any answer so far.

I'm just concerned about WHO and it's image in the film.

It's really important that I could talk to Margaret Chan.

You know I'm very flexible, it doesn't have to take long time.

(voice on phone) It's not about time it's

about her physically being in the office.

Hello, this is Lilian.

Do you think we can do the interview tomorrow?

(man on phone) Mm probably not.

(ambient sounds and soft music)

The queue for demands for her is so long

that you'd be waiting another 5 years.

(soft music)

Am I at the end now?

Is there any real end?

Margaret Chan carries on.

But I don't know I mean she is very patient to

stay there because in my place I was goodbye.

You are destroying, this is your business, you

are... the organisation, I'm not going to help.

And probably at one point she has

to realise that she is helping

and serving the interest of the people giving funds to WHO.

(music)

So last summer, an editor from the WHO's official

journal world health bulletin invited me to write

an editorial on psychological impact of the Fukushima

accident on evacuees and I agreed to do that.

It was rejected on the grounds that

it contained criticism of WHO and the

Japanese authorities. Well of course it

did. I mean there were things wrong.

I think the editors words were: 'the world health bulletin will

not be a platform for such criticism, no matter how valid'.

(music)

So this year will you go to the World

health assembly to the UN building?

No.

I'm still not allowed in.

Why?

Because apparently I asked too many disobliging

questions, they won't renew my accreditation.

I've annoyed people.

And I have written about things

they don't want me to write about.

(music)

Why did you stop working at WHO?

I was fired.

I was a staff association representative and we organised

the first, it wasn't even a strike it was a go-slow in 2005

and it was to protest against the levels of corruption

in WHO. Nepotism, mainly nepotism. Corruption.

And of course they were absolutely

horrified, so it was a huge

success, but three weeks after that, my post was abolished.

Right, it's over to you folks, who'd

like to start the round of questions?

Is it on? Can you hear me?

Yeah, ok.

Lilian Franck, OVALmedia.

It's a question to Dr. Chan. We just learnt that refugee

health and climate change are huge global health challenges.

But I'm asking myself how can we meet

them if WHO is constantly losing power.

Important donor nations, they want a weak WHO, one

could even compare WHO to Titanic I would say.

So isn't it your responsibility Dr. Chan

to step down before the end of your second

term in order to signal to the world that

your organisation, you ship is sinking.

You ask an excellent question.

If I tell you

WHO as an organisation, only 30 percent

of my budget is predictable funds.

Other 70 percent I have to take a hat and

go around to world to beg for money.

And when they give us the money they are highly

linked to their preferences, what they like.

It may not be the priority of WHO so if we do not solve

this, you know, we are not going to be as great as we were.

(music)

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.