All language subtitles for Pope The Most Powerful s01e05 The Wartime Popes.eng

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian Download
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
en English Download
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian Download
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian Download
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American) Download
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

male narrator: One of the most powerful men on Earth

holds a position that has existed

for nearly 2,000 years.

As the world changes and faith evolves,

his authority remains.

What began with one apostle

has become 1.2 billion followers under one man.

He is the head of the Catholic Church,

the pope, and this is his path to power.

[dramatic music]

♪ ♪

In this episode...

choices in the face of war

leave an indelible mark on the papacy.

While the world debates sainthood

for one of the most controversial popes

of the modern era...

history is forced to consider:

did the Catholic Church do enough?

♪ ♪

[solemn chanting]

♪ ♪

Pope Francis is the third sitting pope

to visit a Nazi death camp.

On July 29th, 2016,

he makes an historic visit to Auschwitz-Birkenau in Poland.

[melancholy music]

♪ ♪

In this camp alone, the Nazis put

more than one million people to death.

♪ ♪

- According to Catholic teaching today,

anti-Semitism is a sin.

Jewish people are to be respected.

They are not to be converted.

They have their own relationship with God.

But this was a Christian society

that somehow was able to view Jews

as enough of an other, an outsider,

that they could live with this.

♪ ♪

narrator: Pope Francis' visit to Auschwitz

immerses the pontificate in a harrowing time

in both world and Church history.

♪ ♪

Faced with the haunting images of the Holocaust,

Pope Francis is confronted

by the legacies of his predecessors.

♪ ♪

- The question is not only what we think the pope did

during the Second World War and during the Holocaust

but what we think the pope should have done.

[cymbal shimmers]

[dramatic music]

narrator: Pope Pius XII is a polarizing figure.

Many praise his bravery in the face of fascism,

while others believe he could have done more.

- There's a controversial move to canonize Pius XII,

to have him declared a saint.

I think the real crux of the issue

is whether the actions of this pope,

in the midst of one of the great tragedies

of human history,

whether that's the stuff of the vicar of Christ.

Is that the stuff of a saint?

narrator: The controversy surrounding Pius XII

begins long before he ever becomes pope.

[percussive music]

From 1917 to 1929, Eugenio Pacelli,

the future Pope Pius XII,

serves as a papal ambassador stationed in Germany.

- Pacelli was tapped by the Vatican

to try to go to Germany to bring an end to World War I.

He didn't bring an end to the war,

but he stayed in Germany.

He was helping displaced persons,

injured persons.

Then the soldiers come back.

♪ ♪

- Because of World War I and Germany losing World War I,

Germany was in a state of chaos,

and as a result, there was political unrest.

There was revolution.

- You've got a bunch of young men who don't have jobs,

and they feel like they were betrayed by their country,

and there's this violence in the streets.

[man shouts indistinctly]

They start forming these organizations

that eventually morph into the Nazis.

[cymbal shimmers]

narrator: Oppressive government regimes

across Europe gain traction by blaming

outsiders, immigrants, and Jews

for the post-war economic and political crisis.

In 1922, Benito Mussolini leads

the National Fascist Party to a victory in Italy...

while Hitler and the Nazis rise to power in Germany,

where Pacelli is stationed.

New pope Pius XI is faced with unprecedented unrest.

- Pius XI was an interesting pope.

♪ ♪

A diplomat,

very experienced in international politics,

and he saw the evil of Nazism.

narrator: The Nazi Party stands firmly

as anti-religion,

putting Jews and Catholics

in their crosshairs.

Alarmed by what he sees happening in Nazi Germany,

Pius XI implores Pacelli

to be his eyes and ears on the ground.

- Hitler's in Munich, and the future pope Pius XII

is in Munich at the same time.

He sees Hitler seizing power,

and he's reporting back to Rome about what's going on.

[solemn piano music]

- Pius XI and Eugenio Pacelli

had a very unique relationship.

Pacelli was really, really critical in helping to steer

much of the major decisions that Pius XI made.

Pius XI asked Eugenio Pacelli

to become his secretary of state,

and so Pacelli becomes, effectively,

the second most powerful man

in the government of the Church.

narrator: As fascism explodes all over Europe,

Catholics become enemies of the state.

- The thing about Catholics in particular...

[boys singing]

Catholics had a relationship,

a devotion to something outside the government.

- There's gonna be conflict over the status

of Catholic youth groups

and whether these youth groups ought to be

brought under the umbrella fascist organization.

- There are some Catholic bishops who were beaten...

[cheering and shouting]

Who had their homes and their offices ransacked.

- The Church, of course, to be able to operate,

has to be physically secure.

narrator: The Vatican is faced with an extraordinary dilemma.

Because of his experience as a papal diplomat,

Pope Pius XI enlists Pacelli's help to negotiate

with the fascist Italian government.

The result is the Lateran Treaty.

♪ ♪

- Italy and the Vatican reached an agreement

to allow the Church to function,

allow the pope to feel secure

when he left the Vatican itself.

- 1929 was really a milestone.

The Italian government at this point is

a dictatorship in the hands of Benito Mussolini,

and the Lateran Treaty returns to the pope

territorial sovereignty, which meant independence.

- The Lateran Treaty made Vatican City into

an independent nation state.

narrator: In exchange for Vatican autonomy,

the pope agrees to halt all opposition

to Mussolini's regime.

The 1929 agreement sets a precedent.

The Church is willing to negotiate with dictators

in exchange for sovereignty.

[dramatic music]

narrator: In 1929,

the Vatican signs the Lateran Treaty,

an agreement with Mussolini

establishing autonomy for the Church

in exchange for political neutrality.

- It gave the Church a hold on Italian society.

♪ ♪

- From the pope's perspective, it's a major victory,

but there's a price to be paid.

I mean, Mussolini gets something

for having given something.

Part of the deal was that the Church

was to remain outside of politics.

narrator: With Church opposition out of the way,

Mussolini's fascist government flourishes.

- The Lateran Treaty is a major step

in the consolidation of a fascist dictatorship

because one of the things that Mussolini's able to do in fact

is turn to a population that is largely Catholic

and show that in fact he's made peace

with the spiritual leader of the Church.

narrator: While Mussolini and the Church

mutually benefit from their peace in Italy...

Adolf Hitler is elected Chancellor of Germany,

and Nazism becomes the law of the land.

- [speaks German]

- Jews were a target almost immediately.

- [speaks German]

- January 30th, Adolf Hitler becomes Chancellor of Germany.

The first anti-Jewish law is April 1st.

And the Nazi movement not only was anti-Semitic,

they were anti-communist, anti-socialist, anti-Catholic.

[men chanting]

For Catholics, suddenly, they couldn't join

their youth group organization

without fighting with the local Nazi youth.

Their schools would be confiscated.

Day-to-day violence was an everyday occurrence

from 1933 onward.

narrator: After the success of the Lateran Treaty,

Pope Pius XI looks again to Eugenio Pacelli

to help him defend Catholics in the face of another

increasingly troubling dictator.

In July 1933,

Pacelli negotiates another treaty,

this time with the German government,

called the Reich's Concordant.

- Like the Lateran Treaty, this was a defensive measure.

The State says, "Okay, we will allow

"the Church control over its affairs,

"but the price to be paid is that the Church

is not to be involved in politics."

It's a controversial agreement.

Some see it as sort of a pact with the devil.

It effectively takes the Catholic Church

out of the political realm at the moment

when opposition to an evolving dictatorship

was more needed than ever.

- It was a fatal stepping back from confronting pure evil.

narrator: Although the Reich's Concordant

officially prevents the Vatican

from working against Hitler,

many German Catholics refuse to stay silent.

- An anonymous woman in Dusseldorf

writes to Pius XI, and she says,

"I'm walking along in the streets day to day,

"and children are beating up their Jewish neighbors.

"How can we be good, moral-thinking Catholics

with this going on around us?"

narrator: Despite the tenets of the agreement,

Nazis continue to interfere in Catholic life.

Nuns and priests continue to be arrested,

and Hitler passes sterilization laws,

which stand in diametric opposition

to Catholic doctrine.

- Because, of course, Hitler was not a man

you could ever trust... and, of course,

you could never do a deal with Hitler.

- And yet the Vatican just stays on course.

"We have a treaty. We have a treaty.

We have a treaty."

- And so,

the oppression of the Church went on...

And it got worse.

Infinitely, horribly worse.

narrator: As the 1930s wear on,

Hitler's dictatorship becomes more and more violent.

A litany of anti-Jewish laws are passed,

including a boycott of all Jewish businesses.

Enemies of the state, including Catholic priests,

are put on trains to labor camps.

[train bell echoing]

- The concentration camp at Dachau--

some have described it

as the world's biggest seminary.

At one point in time, there were thousands

of Catholic priests there.

- 2,500 Catholic priests died at Dachau.

Not Catholics, Catholic priests.

At this point, there's no way

that the Church and the Third Reich

are gonna get along.

narrator: The Vatican writes more than 50 complaints

to Nazis about violations of the Reich's Concordant,

but Pius XI does not speak out publicly against Hitler.

- Latter part of the 1930s, Pius XI

began to prepare himself and began to prepare the Church

for some kind of direct confrontation

with the fascist regimes.

- He distrusted Hitler.

He was also opposed to racism.

He was personally not very friendly to the Jews.

He shared the very widespread Christian belief that the Jews,

as a people, had been responsible

for Jesus' death, but he thought

that that didn't mean you had a right

to invade their human rights... and, in fact,

wrote an encyclical condemning it.

narrator: In 1937, Pius XI enlists

Pacelli's help yet again.

He drafts an encyclical

regarding the situation in Germany.

- An encyclical is the most formal statement

from the Vatican.

It's the highest statement a pope can make.

narrator: Pope Pius XI calls his 1937 German encyclical

"Mit Brennender Sorge,"

which means "With Burning Concern."

In it, he condemns racism

from a theological perspective.

- It was talking about how it's foolish to think

that God would lock all of what is great in humanity

into a single race.

narrator: With the Nazis on high alert

for any subversive activity...

The Vatican uses a secret courier network

to smuggle the encyclical into Germany.

[suspenseful music]

♪ ♪

- It was read from the pulpits in Catholic churches

throughout Germany on Palm Sunday.

- It was the only time that the whole of Germany

heard a denunciation of the regime from pulpits,

an extraordinarily brave thing to do.

narrator: But the papal risk is a measured one.

Although the encyclical denounces racism,

it fails to mention Hitler or the Nazi Party by name.

- It's a document that bears Pacelli's hand.

He is ever mindful of the need and of the desire

to try to maintain a diplomatic relationship.

So it's an interesting sort of doctrinal statement

that perhaps lacks some of the political punch

that-that hour called for.

narrator: Regardless of its ambiguous language,

Hitler sends Gestapo into every German church

to confiscate the document.

- Anyone who said it, printed it, repeated it,

possessed it, was getting arrested

or getting beat up, or their property

was being seized.

That kind of fear of retaliation,

that's what Hitler played upon.

narrator: In 1938, Hitler's regime expands

into Austria.

More anti-Semitic laws are passed.

More Jewish homes and businesses are destroyed,

and still the Vatican remains publicly neutral.

But on the night of November 9th, 1938,

Germany will explode in violence,

marking a sinister shift in the Nazi agenda

that the world will not be able to ignore.

narrator: In the two years after Pope Pius XI

releases his anti-racism encyclical,

the Vatican remains publicly silent

about Hitler's growing fascist regime...

and on the eve of November 9th, 1938,

Nazi violence against the Jews reaches a fever pitch.

- Kristallnacht was the Night of Shattered Glass.

It's the night when the Nazis went to the Jewish businesses,

the synagogues, and smashed everything.

- 30,000 Jewish men were sent to a concentration camp.

♪ ♪

It was a very public, violent attack on Jews,

and after that, it was-- it was game over.

[dramatic music]

narrator: Bishops from all over Europe

write to the Vatican's secretary of state,

Eugenio Pacelli, demanding a response

to the violence in Germany.

- The Primate of the Catholic Church in England

wrote to Pacelli and said,

"We need to be clear that this is Nazi terrorism against Jews.

Can you make a statement?"

And Pacelli writes back saying, "Well, it's a difficult issue,

"and what we need to do is just issue

"a statement of general love

and concern and mercy for all in a universal way."

[fevered shouting]

narrator: In January 1939,

Hitler makes a bone-chilling speech,

threatening the annihilation of the Jewish race in Europe.

More men, women, and children

are sent to concentration camps.

Despite the Vatican's neutrality treaties,

Pope Pius XI...

can no longer remain silent.

- It's quite clear that when Pius XI was dying,

he was about to denounce fascism

in quite explicit terms.

[bell rings]

♪ ♪

narrator: Pius XI begins to draft "On the Human Race,"

an encyclical in which he condemns anti-Semitism...

♪ ♪

But he dies before it is ever released.

Now with Europe on the brink of another war,

the cardinals must elect a new pope.

- The conclave of 1939 comes, of course,

at a critical moment.

It's very clear that Nazi foreign policy

is becoming increasingly aggressive,

and so the election of a new pope

garners a great deal of interest

well beyond the Catholic world.

- Pius XI had clearly groomed Pacelli

to become the next pope.

narrator: After a conclave lasting less than 24 hours...

Vatican Secretary of State Eugenio Pacelli

is sworn in as pope.

He chooses to call himself Pius XII to honor his mentor.

- One of the things that made Pacelli the right choice

at this point in time was that all the rival parties

believed that he was in their camp.

He was, as it were, all things to all men.

- He was widely recognized for his diplomatic skill.

It was seen that-- given that the world

was in a state of such tension,

that a diplomat pope,

and one who had considerable experience

in international affairs,

might be in order.

narrator: As tensions in Europe continue to rise,

Pope Pius XII is faced with a daunting task.

He must navigate the role of a religious leader

in an increasingly secular world.

♪ ♪

- Compels popes to ask themselves

who they represent, and for whom should they speak?

- Pius XII was trained as a papal diplomat.

He deeply internalized the doctrine

that papacy functioned best as a neutral force.

But can the papacy really be neutral in the face of Nazism?

[dramatic music]

narrator: Six months after his election,

the Nazis invade Poland...

And World War II is officially declared in Europe.

[gunfire]

- The Nazi invasion of Poland in September 1939

is catastrophic for Catholics.

Poland is a Catholic country.

Polish Catholics were dealt with very harshly.

Priests were often murdered right on the spot.

Women were raped-- it was brutal,

and the Vatican was receiving

reports of this and cries for help.

- This was a war against religion,

against Jews, against Catholics,

against anything that was non-German.

narrator: Pius XII is forced to reexamine his commitment

to quiet diplomacy.

With the Church under attack,

it is up to the pope to defend the faithful.

narrator: Six months after Eugenio Pacelli

is elected pope...

The Nazis invade Poland,

catapulting Europe into World War II.

Despite pressure from Allied forces,

including U.S. President Roosevelt,

Pius XII's statements remain measured and neutral.

Meanwhile, Hitler's agenda only grows

in scope and horror.

- The Nazis started a program to eliminate

people with mental and physical disabilities.

That eventually morphed into the Final Solution.

- There was a decision to exterminate

every Jewish man, woman, and child anywhere in Europe.

narrator: In the 1930s, Nazis had sent Jews,

outspoken Catholics, communists,

and the handicapped to concentration camps...

♪ ♪

But in 1940,

Hitler opens Auschwitz-Birkenau,

the first and most lethal of what will be eight

Nazi death factories... camps engineered

for the systematic mass murder of Jews.

♪ ♪

By the end of the war...

more than 1 million Jews will perish

in Auschwitz alone.

- News, letters and cables

of exactly what the Nazi regime was doing

went to and from the Vatican daily by the hundreds.

- Many of his own reliable sources are telling him

that the Nazis are engaged in a particularly cruel

and unique campaign against Jews.

He receives one memo from a military chaplain

that begins simply,

"The Jews. Period. A dreadful situation. Period,"

which dates to 1942.

- The Vatican knew

precisely what was going on.

There was no better informed organization in Europe

than the Vatican.

narrator: As the horrific images

from Germany and Poland

spread across the globe...

♪ ♪

The devout look to the pope for guidance,

but ever the diplomat,

Pius XII worries that action against Hitler

might provoke more violence against Catholics.

- If Pius XII spoke out,

would it make things worse for Polish Catholics?

Well, you could actually hardly make things worse

for Polish Catholics.

- As he himself says,

"I have to watch what I say...

because I want to avoid a greater evil,"

but what he can do, he will do.

And a great example of the way

Pius XII dealt with this question comes

in the Christmas address of 1942.

[Pius XII speaking Italian]

narrator: In his Christmas address,

broadcast internationally

on Vatican radio,

Pope Pius XII makes one of his only

public statements about the war.

In it, he speaks for human rights and against racism,

but he fails to mention Hitler, the Nazis,

or the Jewish people by name.

- He made a very generalized statement

about the rights of people that he thought

was all he needed to say about the Jewish question.

- The bottom line was, even after violence

against Jews, the decision in Rome was,

"We're not going to name the Nazis,

"and we're not gonna name Jews.

We're just gonna offer universal love and charity."

So it's another opportunity that was missed,

and a critical one.

- He worried a lot about the consequences of speaking out.

One wonders, did he ever really think

about the consequences of not speaking out?

[cymbal shimmers]

narrator: Despite Pius XII's public neutrality,

Hitler's march towards world domination

reaches the pope's doorstep.

In September of 1943,

Hitler invades Rome.

- It was a situation where the pope thought

that they had an operating agreement,

did not think this was going to happen,

but about 2,000 Jews were rounded up.

[dramatic music]

- The day of the roundup,

the pope says he doesn't want to have to

come out and condemn, explicitly, Nazi behavior.

It's obviously a veiled threat to do precisely that,

but he says he doesn't want to do it.

So the threat of a public condemnation is dangled,

which tells us in fact that he and his men understand

the power and the value of the pope's words.

And repeatedly, consistently,

even as people were being rounded up,

he declines to utter that clear word.

[solemn music]

♪ ♪

narrator: As the war rages outside the Vatican walls...

Pius XII becomes a target.

[cymbal shimmers]

Rumors fly about a Nazi plan to kidnap the pope.

- Hitler actually got a general and told him to draw up plans

to invade the Vatican.

Pius XII gathered everyone together

and essentially released them

if they wanted to leave,

but he also submitted a letter that was his resignation

that said, "If I'm captured, I resign the papacy.

"So they will not capture the pope.

"They will capture Eugenio Pacelli,

but not the pope."

narrator: As bombs go off and Jews are rounded up

right under the pope's windows,

Pius XII must take stock.

His diplomatic efforts have failed,

and the Vatican is now directly in Nazi crosshairs.

[dramatic music]

narrator: In September 1943, Nazi troops invade Rome.

An imminent attack on the Vatican looms,

and more than 2,000 Roman Jews

are rounded up for deportation to extermination camps.

♪ ♪

They're held at the Military College of Rome,

mere blocks from St. Peter's Basilica.

♪ ♪

But despite the atrocities unfolding

right at his doorstep,

Pope Pius XII remains publicly silent.

- He takes the path of diplomatic caution

in terms of his public pronouncements,

but it's not that the pope was inactive.

♪ ♪

There is a view that the pope worked behind the scenes

to try to put an end to the roundup.

There is some evidence in fact that that actually worked.

♪ ♪

- They got several Jews released,

primarily because they were married to a Catholic

or they invoked the Concordant

to help some of them avoid deportation.

- He also then says, "Well, let's do

what we can to alleviate suffering on the ground."

♪ ♪

- There were some Vatican trucks

that would go around and take food

and take blankets and try to bring

additional supplies to where it was needed.

narrator: Some believe that Pope Pius XII's silence

is a cover... that throughout the war,

he is secretly involved with covert operations

with the Allies.

- The pope did secretly tape his conversations.

During the week of his election in 1939,

the Vatican's tapes show quite clearly

that he opted for public acquiescence

with the Nazis and at the same time deciding

that they must be resistant behind the scenes.

♪ ♪

Pius XII received information from a Vatican spy in Germany,

and he passed this information on to the Western Allies.

narrator: Some historians even speculate about

papal involvement in a plan to assassinate Hitler.

[ominous piano music]

- The key figure in the German resistance to Hitler

was Admiral Wilhelm Canaris,

the head of German military intelligence,

whom, as it happens, Pacelli had met in the 1920s

when he was in Germany.

Canaris reached out to his old friend Pacelli

and said, "Help me and help Germany

get rid of Hitler."

Canaris then had access to explosives.

♪ ♪

narrator: Between 1940 and 1944...

there would be three failed attempts

to assassinate Adolf Hitler.

Information about these plots

is still shrouded in conspiracy theory,

and documented proof of Pius XII's role

is almost nonexistent.

- For a long time, it wasn't known about,

because the pope knew if he kept written records,

it'd get people killed.

- To be really clear, the pope was not involved

in any of the details.

He does help to facilitate

these contacts plotting to remove Adolf Hitler,

and that's important.

It was risky.

It was something that he kept

from his closest advisers,

and it shows us that for all of our understanding of him

as very cautious and maybe too cautious,

he could, at times, take some very bold

and even risky actions.

♪ ♪

narrator: Despite the uncertainty surrounding

any papal involvement in a plan to kill Hitler,

the Church's role in hiding Jews during the war

is undeniable.

- There's good, reliable evidence

that Church institutions, religious houses

were used to rescue and house Jews.

narrator: There is even evidence

that Jews were hidden

on Vatican-owned properties.

- There's some fascinating photographs

where you see people not only sleeping

on the floors in churches,

not only in the hallways, but even on the staircases,

up and down the staircases, three across.

♪ ♪

narrator: Close to 6 million European Jews

perish during World War II...

but nearly 80% of the 12,000 Roman Jews survive.

♪ ♪

- A large percentage of Jews in Rome survive,

in large part because of the actions

of many of these religious houses.

- The debate around that is,

was there a central order to do this?

Did Pius XII remain silent during the actual roundup

but secretly issue an order

that as many Jews should be hidden as possible?

And we've never found an order from Pius XII

to shelter and hide Italian Jews,

and there were even some cases where he was displeased

because it put that particular religious order

or religious house at risk.

narrator: Despite more than 70 years of retrospect,

the pontificate of Pius XII is still veiled in mystery.

Who was he,

and does he deserve

to be called a saint?

[mournful singing]

narrator: To be canonized a saint is to be recognized

as one who shares an eternal life with God in heaven.

In the last 1,000 years,

only seven popes have been made saints.

Reigning for nearly two decades,

many Catholics see Pius XII as a prolific religious leader,

responsible for shaping the modern Church...

but as the world debates canonization

for the wartime pope...

we are forced to consider the holiness of his actions

during one of the most turbulent times

in world history.

- The heart of the controversy really is whether

his diplomatic caution saved lives.

Those who advance his cause

see that as an argument to make him a saint.

[dramatic music]

- Pius XII is often excused for not having condemned

the extermination of the Jews because,

as he himself said... had he done so,

it wouldn't have done any good,

and it might have made things worse.

But I think it's hard to avoid the feeling

that there was some kind of moral failure.

narrator: The crux of the debate

lies in the character of Pope Pius XII.

♪ ♪

Who was he,

and why did he make

the decisions he did?

- There are those who see in his reluctance

to identify the suffering of Jews in particular,

some see in that the strains of anti-Semitism.

- Eugenio Pacelli's time in Germany as a papal diplomat

is really critical to his formation,

his thinking about Germans and Germany,

and, one could argue, his thinking about Jews.

He describes meeting with Jewish officials,

who he describes as dirty communists

with slanted eyes.

We can see his negative stereotypes

about Jews in his writings,

and I'm not convinced they ever really exited his thinking.

- The whole of Pius XII's papacy

is dominated in our memory by questions.

Seems a bit simple to say

that there are evil people and good people,

because most of us aren't actually one or the other.

We're a mixture. It's much more complex.

♪ ♪

narrator: But the complexities of Pope Pius XII

are yet to be unraveled.

Questions about what he did and did not do

during the Holocaust remain unanswered.

- We don't yet have access to all of the wartime archive,

so we don't really have a full historical record for Pius XII.

- Once they are available, and scholars

can make a determination

of exactly what he did or didn't do,

then we can say definitively

what the record of Pius XII was,

and before we can do that,

it would be premature to move forward with sainthood.

[melancholy acoustic strumming]

♪ ♪

narrator: Until the records are released,

the world can only speculate.

♪ ♪

Polarized opinions color the emotional debate

over the canonization of a deeply controversial

historical figure.

- If in fact he wanted to protect his own church

and his own coreligionists

in the face of the Holocaust,

that decision had consequences.

I think Pius XII was a human being who made mistakes,

and maybe he didn't make

the right decision in this case,

and maybe that's a lesson for this church,

that sometimes we don't make the right decision,

and we need to atone,

and we need to correct ourselves,

and we need to do better in the future.

♪ ♪

narrator: In 2016, as Pope Francis

walked through the shadows of Auschwitz...

♪ ♪

He must face the legacy of his predecessors.

♪ ♪

He prays for the mistakes he has inherited

and for the lessons that will carry the Church forward.

♪ ♪

- Pope Francis is a radically different kind of pope

than the Catholic Church has seen for a long time.

He has the rule of love. That's it.

Love your neighbor, and if you're doing that,

then you're a good Catholic.

narrator: Modern popes engage in politics

at the highest level...

regularly meeting with world leaders

and taking meaningful stands

against atrocity and injustice.

John Paul II worked tirelessly to end communism

and help the African continent heal

in the wake of colonialism and apartheid.

Pope Francis continues in that brave legacy,

a champion for human rights,

unafraid to fight for the freedoms of the oppressed.

- Francis and John Paul II have moved us on

very significantly.

They opened the door.

Now the Vatican is actually a player in world politics,

particularly in humanitarian aspects,

and that's been an enormously important aspect

of its ministry.

During the Second World War, there was this sense

that the Church was very different from the world.

The pope was isolated.

- I'm a lifelong practicing Catholic

who has worked for 17 years at the Holocaust Museum,

and I'm a historian.

[melancholy piano music]

And so it's difficult to just look clinically

at a document where a Ukrainian Catholic shooter

is taking a Jewish child by the neck

and shooting them while their mother watches

and then going to church the following Sunday.

♪ ♪

To see that Catholics have the capacity

to set their faith to one side

and be part of the Holocaust

that destroyed 6 million families,

and to this day these families come to the museum,

and you can see that it goes generations deep,

it makes one question--

what is the point of my faith at all?

What is the point of a pope leading a church

where love and mercy is not paramount?

And it makes you wonder.

♪ ♪

narrator: In times of tragedy...

♪ ♪

Humanity continues to wrestle with faith.

♪ ♪

The world looks to the pope for guidance and comfort...

and in the darkest of times,

lessons of the past must light his way.

Repair and Synchronization by Easy Subtitles Synchronizer 1.0.0.0

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.