Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Downloaded from YTS.MX
Official YIFY movies site: YTS.MX
Emily: THE MILITARY WOULD BE ALTERED IF WE WEREN'T A PART OF IT.
WE PLAY A BIG ROLE.
FIRST OFF, YOU HAVE NO IDEA HOW MANY OF US THERE ARE.
THERE'S NO REAL COUNT, SO THERE'S ONLY ESTIMATES,
BUT IT'S A VERY LARGE NUMBER.
Chris: ARMY, NAVY, AIR FORCE, MARINES.
WE COME IN; WE DO OUR JOB; LET'S GO HOME.
YOU KNOW, MISSION FIRST; ANYTHING ELSE SECOND.
Brandon: WE'RE ALL FIGHTING FOR THE SAME THING.
Emily: THERE ARE WAY MORE OF US THAN THEY THINK.
AND WE'RE WORKING RIGHT WITH THEM.
WE'RE EVERYWHERE.
Rachel Maddow: FOR THE FIRST TIME SINCE 1993,
DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL WILL BE DEBATED AT A SENATE HEARING.
THE SENATE ARMED SERVICES COMMITTEE WILL HEAR TESTIMONY
FROM DEFENSE SECRETARY BOB GATES
AND THE CHAIRMAN OF THE JOINT CHIEFS OF STAFF, ADMIRAL MIKE MULLEN.
Carl Levin: THE COMMITTEE IS NOW GOING TO RECEIVE TESTIMONY
ADDRESSING THE DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL POLICY
ON GAYS IN THE MILITARY.
MR. CHAIRMAN, SPEAKING FOR MYSELF, AND MYSELF ONLY,
IT IS MY PERSONAL BELIEF
THAT ALLOWING GAYS AND LESBIANS TO SERVE OPENLY WOULD BE--
- ( static ) - NO--
Chris: I'M A NAVAL PETTY OFFICER, FIRST CLASS.
I DO RADIO COMMUNICATION FOR THE ARMED FORCES.
Matthew: I'VE BEEN FLYING HELICOPTERS FOR ABOUT 12 YEARS NOW.
I'M GOING ON DEPLOYMENTS AGAIN TO THE MIDDLE EAST.
Josh: I'M AN E6,
OR WHAT THE NAVY CALLS A FIRST CLASS PETTY OFFICER.
Mike: AM I PATRIOTIC?
YES. ( laughs )
THAT'S AN EASY ANSWER.
Emily: I LOVE MY COUNTRY.
AND I WANT TO FIGHT TO SERVE, TO PROTECT, TO DEFEND IT, YOU KNOW?
EVEN IF IT'S NOT GOING TO DO THE SAME THING FOR ME.
Chris: I'VE HAD SEVEN FRIENDS DISCHARGED UNDER THE POLICY.
ONE WAS A CULINARY SPECIALIST, THIRD CLASS--
CS3 IN THE NAVY.
THIS GUY HAD MADE THE NAVY HIS LIFE, JUST AS I HAVE.
AND WHEN HE WAS FACING DISCHARGE,
HE WENT DOWN TO THE GUN RANGE,
RENTED A GUN AND TURNED THE GUN ON HIMSELF.
THAT WAS THE LOSS OF A GREAT SAILOR
AND AN AWESOME FRIEND.
ONE OF THE MOST CRITICAL CONTRIBUTIONS
TO THE AMERICAN REVOLUTIONARY WAR
WAS MADE BY A GAY PRUSSIAN CAPTAIN NAMED CAPTAIN VON STEUBEN.
VON STEUBEN WROTE A TRAINING MANUAL
ABOUT DISCIPLINE AND ORDER IN THE U.S. MILITARY
THAT GEORGE WASHINGTON SAID WAS ABSOLUTELY CRITICAL
TO THE SUCCESS IN THE REVOLUTIONARY WAR.
Aaron Belkin: THE MILITARY HAD SPENT A BILLION DOLLARS
ON PSYCHOLOGICAL CASUALTIES OF THE FIRST WORLD WAR.
AND AS THE COUNTRY MOBILIZED FOR THE SECOND WORLD WAR,
MILITARY LEADERS WERE LOOKING FOR A WAY
TO AVOID SOME OF THE PSYCHOLOGICAL AND MEDICAL COSTS.
AND SO, IN THEIR MINDS,
BECAUSE HOMOSEXUALITY WAS A SIGN OF EFFEMINACY AND WEAKNESS,
THEY SHOULD KEEP GAY SOLDIERS OUT OF THE MILITARY.
BECAUSE IF GAYS ENTERED THE MILITARY,
THEY WOULD BECOME BAD SOLDIERS, PSYCHOLOGICAL CAUSALITIES,
AND BECOME A BURDEN FOR THE ARMED FORCES.
THEY WERE FOCUSED ON THE STEREOTYPE,
AND THAT'S WHAT DROVE THE POLITICS.
THEY DIDN'T APPRECIATE THAT, FOR THE MOST PART,
GAYS AND LESBIANS IN THE MILITARY
ARE INDISTINGUISHABLE FROM THEIR STRAIGHT COUNTERPARTS.
Nathaniel Frank: IRONICALLY, WORLD WAR II WAS THE MOMENT
THAT THE MILITARY BECAME ZEALOUS
IN ITS ANTI-GAY SENTIMENT,
AND AT THE SAME TIME, THAT GAY IDENTITY BEGAN TO EMERGE.
PART OF THE REASON WAS THAT, FOR THE FIRST TIME IN MANY CASES,
MEN WHO ENJOYED THE COMPANY OF OTHER MEN
FOUND THEMSELVES TOGETHER.
Gore Vidal: THERE WERE 13 MILLION OF US TAKEN AWAY FROM HOME.
AND THEN SAME SEXUALITY FLOURISHED.
I WENT IN THE ARMY AT 17
AND ENDED UP IN THE PACIFIC FOR THREE YEARS.
AND NOBODY QUESTIONED IT.
YES, THE AUTHORITIES DID;
OFFICERS WHO HAD NOT GONE OVERSEAS WERE VERY STRICT.
PEOPLE WOULD SAY, "HAVE YOU HEARD WHAT'S GOING ON DOWN IN TARAWA?"
"YES, I'VE HEARD," YOU KNOW? "SHOCKING, ISN'T IT?"
Reporter: THE CELEBRATION WENT ON FOR THE END
OF THE GREATEST WAR IN HISTORY.
Belkin: AFTER THE WAR, THE MILITARY WAS TRYING TO DOWNSIZE.
AND ONE OF THEIR STRATEGIES WAS TO GET RID OF PEOPLE
WITH SOMETHING CALLED BLUE DISCHARGES.
IN OTHER WORDS, A DISCHARGE FOR BEING CRAZY.
A LARGE NUMBER OF GAYS RECEIVED THESE DISCHARGES
AND THEY WERE PUT ON SHIPS AND SIMPLY DUMPED AT PORTS
SUCH AS SAN FRANCISCO.
THE EMERGENCE OF GAY IDENTITIES IN CITIES
IS DIRECTLY ATTRIBUTABLE TO OUR MILITARY.
IN WORLD WAR II, AFTER PEOPLE LEFT THE SERVICE,
GAY COMMUNITIES GAINED ENORMOUS STRENGTH.
AND IN FACT, THE VERY HEART OF THE CASTRO IN SAN FRANCISCO,
AND OF THE VILLAGE IN NEW YORK
IS BECAUSE OF VETERANS WHO POPULATED THE CITY AT THE TIME.
( crowd chanting ) WHAT DO WE WANT? GAY RIGHTS!
WHEN DO WE WANT THEM? NOW!
WHAT DO WE WANT? GAY RIGHTS!
WHEN DO WE WANT THEM? NOW!
WHAT DO WE WANT? GAY RIGHTS!
WHEN DO WE WANT THEM? NOW!
Lawrence Korb: WE KNEW THERE WERE GAYS
WHEN I WAS IN THE SERVICE IN THE '60s. WE KNEW.
BUT OUR THING WAS, OUR LIVES ARE DEPENDENT HERE,
YOU KNOW? WE CAN'T BE WORRIED ABOUT THESE SMALL THINGS, YOU KNOW?
WHAT DOES HE DO IN HIS PRIVATE LIFE?
I DON'T CARE. ALL I WANT TO KNOW IS CAN THIS GUY FLY THE PLANE?
AND SO WHAT HAPPENED WAS SOME PEOPLE WERE THROWN OUT FOR BEING GAY;
SOME PEOPLE WERE KEPT IN. IT WAS REALLY UP TO THE COMMANDER.
WELL, ONE YOUNG MAN WHO GOT THROWN OUT
SAID, "WELL, WAIT A SECOND. THEY KEPT THIS OTHER GUY IN." SO HE WENT TO COURT.
Reporter: IT WAS IN 1975
WHEN AIR FORCE TECH SERGEANT LEONARD MATLOVICH
DECIDED TO CHALLENGE THE POLICY
WHICH PROHIBITS HOMOSEXUALS FROM SERVING IN THE MILITARY.
HE TOLD HIS COMMANDING OFFICER THAT HE WAS GAY.
THE 12-YEAR VETERAN WHO SERVED TWO TOURS IN VIETNAM
AND WHO EARNED A BRONZE STAR AND A PURPLE HEART
WENT BEFORE A REVIEW BOARD
WHICH GAVE HIM A GENERAL DISCHARGE.
Belkin: MATLOVICH WAS THE FIRST TO COME ALONG
WEARING THE UNIFORM AND TAKE THE MILITARY TO COURT
AND SAY, "I'M GAY;
I'M A MEMBER OF THIS ORGANIZATION;
I WANT TO BE TREATED WITH DIGNITY LIKE MY STRAIGHT COUNTERPARTS."
Leonard Matlovich: A LOT OF PEOPLE HAVE COME UP TO ME AND SAID,
"REALLY, RIGHT NOW I CAN'T GO PUBLIC OR I CAN'T EVEN TELL MY PARENTS.
BUT YOU'VE GIVEN ME CONFIDENCE THAT-- TO KEEP ON FIGHTING."
THE 1970s WAS THE BIRTH
OF THE MODERN GAY-RIGHTS MOVEMENT.
AND SO WHEN LEONARD MATLOVICH,
WHO HAD BEEN ON MAGAZINE COVERS AS A WAR HERO,
CHALLENGED THE POLICY IN THE MILITARY,
IT BEGAN A NATIONAL DISCUSSION.
GAY RIGHTS! WHEN DO WE WANT THEM? NOW!
WHAT DO WE WANT? GAY RIGHTS! WHEN DO WE WANT THEM? NOW!
Steinman: WITHOUT ANY KIND OF CONTACT TO REAL GAY PEOPLE,
IT'S VERY EASY TO SEE A POPULAR MUSIC GROUP
MAKING A NICE TUNE ABOUT THE NAVY.
BECAUSE THE REALITY OF WHAT IT'S LIKE
TO BE A GAY OR LESBIAN SERVICE MEMBER
IS ABSENT IN THE LEADERSHIP.
FINALLY, I GUESS SOMEBODY WISED THEM UP AND SAID,
"YOU KNOW, THIS IS A GROUP THAT'S, YOU KNOW--
MMM-- YOU KNOW, IS POPULAR IN THE GAY WORLD AND SOME OF THEM ARE GAY."
AND SO OF COURSE THEY IMMEDIATELY STOPPED IT.
Chaplain: WE HAVE GATHERED TO HONOR OUR FALLEN--
THOSE WHO SERVED AND DIED
TO DEFEND OUR NATION AND OUR FREEDOMS,
EVEN IF THOSE FREEDOMS WERE NOT ALWAYS GRANTED TO THEM AND TO US.
SOME LIKE LEONARD MATLOVICH WERE FAMOUS,
THE GLORY OF THEIR TIMES.
OTHERS, PERHAPS MOST,
WERE KNOWN ONLY TO THOSE WHO LOVED THEM.
WE HONOR THEM ALL.
Man: "WHEN I WAS IN THE MILITARY,
THEY GAVE ME A MEDAL FOR KILLING TWO MEN
AND A DISCHARGE FOR LOVING ONE."
Nathaniel Frank: RIGHT AFTER THE MATLOVICH CASE,
YOU BEGAN TO HAVE THIS CLUSTER OF COURT CASES
IN THE FEDERAL COURTS WHERE SERVICE MEMBERS SAID,
"THERE'S NO BASIS FOR THIS.
THIS IS A VIOLATION OF CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS."
Margarethe Cammermeyer: I WAS DISCHARGED WHEN I WAS HONEST
IN A TOP-SECRET SECURITY CLEARANCE
AND SAID THAT I WAS A LESBIAN.
IT REALLY DIDN'T MAKE SENSE
THAT I WAS GOING TO BE DANGEROUS TO THE MILITARY
AFTER SERVING IN VIETNAM AND EARNING A BRONZE STAR.
NOBODY KNEW WHAT IT MEANT TO BE GAY.
THERE WAS STILL THE STIGMA OF YOU'RE MENTALLY ILL
OR A PREDATOR
OR ALL SORTS OF MISINFORMATION.
AND SO YOU FELT VERY VERY ISOLATED AND ALONE.
GOVERNOR CLINTON, I'M COLONEL CAMMERMEYER.
I WAS DISCHARGED FROM THE MILITARY SIX WEEKS AGO
BECAUSE I TOLD THE DEFENSE INVESTIGATOR THAT I WAS A LESBIAN.
Cammermeyer: WHEN CANDIDATE CLINTON RAN FOR THE PRESIDENCY,
I ASKED IF HE WOULD OVERTURN THE BAN ON GAYS SERVING IN THE MILITARY.
I'M WONDERING IF YOU WOULD CONSIDER DOING THAT IN 1993
WHEN YOU BECOME PRESIDENT?
- YES. - ( applause )
THIS WOMAN SERVED HER COUNTRY FOR MORE THAN TWO DECADES
WITH GREAT DISTINCTION
AND SHOULD NOT HAVE BEEN PROHIBITED FROM DOING SO.
I, WILLIAM JEFFERSON CLINTON...
BILL CLINTON AS A CANDIDATE SAID THAT HE WOULD DO IT
LIKE PRESIDENT TRUMAN HAD DESEGREGATED THE MILITARY--
WITH THE STROKE OF A PEN, AN EXECUTIVE ORDER.
Belkin: HE FACED A COALITION OF OPPONENTS
THAT NO PRESIDENT WOULD HAVE BEEN ABLE TO SURMOUNT.
IT'S NOTHING TO DO WITH GAY VERSUS NON-GAY.
IT HAS TO DO WITH WHAT'S BEST FOR THE DEFENSE OF THIS COUNTRY.
Belkin: THE MILITARY DIDN'T RESPECT HIM.
HE WAS SEEN AS A HIPPIE, AN ANTI-WAR PROTESTOR, A POT SMOKER.
AND HE WAS SUCCESSFULLY DEPICTED AS BEING ANTI-MILITARY.
WE SHOULD LEAVE THE BAN ON GAYS ON ACTIVE DUTY--
SERVICE WITH THE MILITARY IN PLACE.
I DO NOT BELIEVE THAT WE CAN ALLOW POLITICS
TO DESTROY THE GREATEST ARMY THAT THE WORLD HAS EVER KNOWN.
Harry Smith: PRESIDENT CLINTON HAS SAID HE WILL STICK TO HIS PROPOSAL
TO LIFT THE BAN,
ALTHOUGH ALL FIVE MILITARY SERVICE CHIEFS SUPPORT IT.
HE UNDERESTIMATED THE FIERCENESS
OF THE RESISTANCE OF PEOPLE IN THE MILITARY,
OF SOCIAL CONSERVATIVES AND OF THE RELIGIOUS RIGHT.
AND ALL OF THESE FORCES GOT TOGETHER VERY QUICKLY.
AND HE HAD A FIGHT ON HIS HANDS.
I PLEDGED LAST FALL IN A DEBATE ON THE FLOOR OF THE SENATE
TO HAVE THOROUGH HEARINGS ON THIS SUBJECT
IN THE ARMED SERVICES COMMITTEE THIS YEAR.
WE INTEND TO HAVE HEARINGS ON IT.
THE COMMITTEE WILL COME TO ORDER.
SENATOR SAM NUNN SPEARHEADED OPPOSITION IN THE CONGRESS.
Sam Nunn: UNDER CURRENT REGULATIONS,
GAY MEN AND LESBIANS ARE NOT PERMITTED TO SERVE
IN THE ARMED FORCES OF THE UNITED STATES.
John Warner: WE ARE ABOUT TO LOOK AT A POLICY
WHICH WOULD COMPEL THE U.S. MILITARY
TO ACCEPT OPENLY AND ACKNOWLEDGE THE EXISTENCE
OF A CLASS OF PEOPLE WHOSE LIFESTYLE
IS FOUND BY MANY AMERICANS TO BE UNACCEPTABLE.
PART OF ME WANTS TO GO DOWN TO THE RECRUITING STATION
AND SAY, "DON'T JOIN." YOU KNOW, "YOU'RE NOT ENLISTING IN THE MILITARY;
YOU'RE SENTENCING YOURSELF TO FOUR YEARS IN A GAY BATHHOUSE."
OPEN HOMOSEXUALITY IN UNITS
IS NOT JUST THE ACCEPTANCE OF BENIGN CHARACTERISTICS
SUCH AS COLOR, OR RACE, OR BACKGROUND.
IT INVOLVES MATTERS OF PRIVACY, HUMAN SEXUALITY,
THAT IN OUR JUDGMENT IF ALLOWED TO EXIST IN THE FORCE
WOULD AFFECT THE COHESION AND WELLBEING OF THE FORCE.
ONE OF THE ANALOGIES WE MADE WAS THE DISCRIMINATION,
BASED ON RACE.
HE SPECIFICALLY SAID, "OH, NO, THEY ARE VERY DIFFERENT.
RACE IS A BENIGN CONDITION."
I DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT MADE US-- A MALIGN CONDITION.
IT GAVE COVER TO PEOPLE WHO WERE ABLE TO THEN SAY,
"THIS ISN'T LIKE RACIAL INTEGRATION, AND COLIN POWELL SAYS SO."
THAT WOULD END THE CONVERSATION.
Dan Coats: DO ALL OF YOU AGREE WITH THAT?
THAT SKIN COLOR IS A BENIGN,
NON-BEHAVIORAL CHARACTERISTIC
AND SEXUAL ORIENTATION IS BEHAVIORAL?
- DR. MARLOWE? - I WOULD AGREE, SIR.
- DR. HENDERSON? - GENERALLY, I AGREE WITH THAT, YES.
DR. KORB?
I THINK THE RESEARCH SHOWS
THAT PEOPLE BASICALLY ARE BORN WITH THIS
RATHER THAN BEING A LEARNED BEHAVIOR.
Lawrence Korb: A LOT OF REPUBLICANS WERE QUITE ANNOYED
BECAUSE I HAD A MILITARY BACKGROUND
AND I HAD WORKED FOR PRESIDENT REAGAN IN THE PENTAGON,
AND HERE I WAS SUPPORTING PRESIDENT CLINTON.
SO I WENT UP TO TESTIFY.
AND USUALLY A HEARING LASTS AN HOUR OR TWO. THIS LASTED FIVE HOURS.
AND THE OTHER PEOPLE WHO WERE UP THERE
WERE SAYING THINGS THAT JUST MADE NO SENSE AT ALL
AND WEREN'T SCIENTIFICALLY PROVEN.
IT WAS VERY TRAUMATIC.
THE SAME ATTRACTIONS OR TENSIONS THAT EXIST
BETWEEN MALE AND FEMALE EXIST BETWEEN TWO HOMOSEXUALS,
OR TWO OR MORE, IF THEY HAVE AN ATTRACTION.
WELL, I THINK THERE'S A BODY OF EVIDENCE
THAT SHOWS THAT NOT EVERY GAY MAN
IS ATTRACTED TO EVERY OTHER MAN.
HOW DO YOU VIEW THAT HAVING LOOKED AT THE MILITARY OVER THE YEARS?
Charlie Moskos: I DISAGREE WITH THAT STATEMENT
PRECISELY BECAUSE THERE ARE HOMOEROTIC TENDENCIES IN ALL MALE GROUPS.
Nathaniel Frank: CHARLIE MOSKOS CLAIMED THAT HE WAS THE ARCHITECT
OF DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
HE IS KNOWN AS HAVING COINED THE PHRASE, "DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL."
THIS IS EXACTLY WHY THE BAN-- I THINK I WOULD TURN THAT AROUND
AND SAY EXACTLY WHY A STIFF BAN, YOU KNOW, WOULD HAVE TO BE IN PLACE,
BECAUSE ONCE THESE HOMOEROTIC TENDENCIES ARE OUT--
THE CAT'S OUT OF THE BAG,
THEN YOU HAVE ALL KINDS OF NEGATIVE EFFECTS ON UNIT COHESION.
- UNIT COHESION. - UNIT COHESION.
- UNIT COHESION. - UNIT COHESION.
- UNIT COHESION. - UNIT COHESION.
- UNIT COHESION. - UNIT COHESION.
Belkin: THEY HAD TO COME UP WITH A REASON THAT SOUNDED RATIONAL,
AND SO THEY CAME UP WITH THIS IDEA OF THE UNIT COHESION
TO JUSTIFY THEIR HOMOPHOBIA.
THEY CAME UP WITH SOMETHING THAT SOUNDED REASONABLE--
THE IDEA THAT THERE WAS SO MUCH DISLIKE
OR EVEN OUTRIGHT HATRED, THAT THE MERE KNOWLEDGE
OF THE PRESENCE OF A GAY PERSON IN A UNIT
WOULD DEGRADE UNIT COHESION AND IMPAIR COMBAT READINESS.
Nathaniel Frank: SEVERAL OF THESE OFFICERS SUBSEQUENTLY TOLD ME
AFTER THEY RETIRED THAT IT WAS SOMETHING
THAT THEY BASICALLY DREAMED UP
WHEN THEY FOUND THAT THERE WAS NO OTHER EXPLANATION FOR THE BAN.
I NEVER RAISED THAT AS AN ARGUMENT--
THAT UNIT COHESION IS THE MAJOR THING.
IT'S A QUESTION OF PRIVACY RIGHTS.
IF ONE WANTS TO HAVE OPEN GAYS AND STRAIGHTS SHOWERING TOGETHER,
THEN YOU SHOULD SAY, WHY NOT HAVE MEN AND WOMEN DO THE SAME THING?
WHY NOT MAKE THE ARGUMENT THAT LET'S HAVE PEOPLE
WHO ARE MENTALLY DEFICIENT COME INTO THE ARMY?
WHY NOT HAVE OVERWEIGHT PEOPLE? WHY DO WE HAVE THESE RULES
ABOUT YOU CAN'T HAVE EXCESSIVE TATTOOS?
Barney Frank: I HAD ACTUALLY RAISED THE ISSUE OF BAN ON GAYS IN THE MILITARY
WITH COLIN POWELL AND DICK CHENEY,
AND THEY BOTH ADMITTED THAT THE ONLY REASON TO HAVE IT
WAS THAT OTHER PEOPLE WERE PREJUDICED.
I MEAN, THEY SAID THERE IS NO SECURITY-CLEARANCE ISSUE;
THERE IS NO-- THE GAYS AND LESBIANS ARE PERFECTLY GOOD MILITARY PEOPLE.
THE MILITARY'S OWN RESEARCH ALREADY SHOWED
THAT GAYS WOULD NOT POSE A PROBLEM.
THE RAND CORPORATION DID A MULTIMILLION-DOLLAR STUDY
DURING THE 1993 DEBATES.
AND THE RAND CORPORATION, WE HAVE TO REMEMBER,
IS A THINK TANK THAT WAS CREATED BY THE AIR FORCE.
RAND FOUND THAT ALLOWING GAYS AND LESBIANS TO SERVE OPENLY
WOULD CAUSE NO PROBLEM FOR READINESS OR MORALE
OR UNIT COHESION OR ANY OTHER ASPECT OF MILITARY PERFORMANCE.
THE QUESTION OF GAYS IN THE MILITARY HAS BEEN STUDIED TO DEATH.
WORD HAD CIRCULATED THAT THERE WAS A REPORT
THAT THE MILITARY WAS TRYING TO PREVENT FROM BEING PUBLISHED.
AND ONE DAY A COPY OF THE REPORT JUST SHOWED UP.
AND IT WAS SUBSEQUENTLY LEAKED TO THE PRESS.
THEY SAID, "THE POLICY OF KEEPING GAYS OUT DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE."
AND SO THE PENTAGON TRIED TO BURY THAT STUDY.
AND THE NAVY DID A STUDY IN 1957 THAT SAID THE SAME THING.
Belkin: THE CRITTENDEN REPORT IS THE FIRST KNOWN STUDY
ON SEXUAL ORIENTATION IN THE ARMED FORCES.
AND THE CRITTENDEN COMMITTEE CONCLUDED
THAT GAYS AND LESBIANS POSED NO SECURITY THREAT,
WERE NOT A RISK,
AND COULD SERVE AS EFFECTIVELY AS STRAIGHT PEOPLE.
Nathaniel Frank: THERE HAS NEVER BEEN ANY RESEARCH
SHOWING THAT GAYS UNDERMINE UNIT COHESION
OR MILITARY EFFECTIVENESS.
BUT THE MILITARY HAS AN IGNOBLE HISTORY
OF BURYING THE RESULTS OF THOSE STUDIES
WHEN THEY COME UP WITH A CONCLUSION THAT'S AT ODDS
WITH THE HISTORICAL ANTI-GAY SENTIMENT IN THE MILITARY.
I COME HERE BEFORE YOU, UM, A PROUD AMERICAN.
AND I WOULD CONTINUE TO BE SERVING IN THE MILITARY
IF I HADN'T TOLD THE TRUTH.
Cammermeyer: THERE WAS A WALL THAT YOU COULD SEE GOING UP.
IT WAS ALMOST LIKE YOU WERE REVEALING
THAT YOU HAD A CONTAGIOUS DISEASE.
IT COMES DOWN TO THIS--
PEOPLE WHO GO IN THE MILITARY-- AND I WAS PRIVILEGED TO SERVE--
WE ALL HAVE TO GIVE UP SOMETHING.
IT WAS EXTREMELY HUMILIATING
TO HAVE TO SIT IN FRONT OF THESE ELDER STATESMEN,
THEIR PONTIFICATION ABOUT ME
AND ABOUT MY SEXUAL ORIENTATION.
WE HAVE TO GIVE UP SOME OF OUR CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS;
WE HAVE TO GIVE UP A DEGREE OF PRIVACY.
IF YOU FEEL THAT INTENSELY AND THAT PATRIOTIC
THAT YOU WANT TO SERVE, THEN GIVE UP A LITTLE SOMETHING.
- Cammermeyer: WE HAVE, SIR. - LET ME JUST FINISH.
I THINK I INTERRUPTED JOHN WARNER PROBABLY 20 TIMES
IN THE COURSE OF THE TIME
THAT HE WAS TRYING TO TELL EVERYBODY HOW BAD WE WERE.
TO DEAL WITH THIS IN SUCH A MANNER-- LET ME JUST FINISH ONE POINT
AND THEN I'LL YIELD THE REST OF MY TIME TO YOU.
Cammermeyer: AND FOR HIM TO FINALLY SAY,
"COULDN'T YOU JUST BE QUIET?"
IS IT TOO MUCH TO ASK THAT YOU JUST SERVE HONORABLY,
QUIETLY, AND EFFICIENTLY?
AS LONG AS THE REGULATION ISN'T THERE--
I'LL COME TO YOU IN A MINUTE, DOCTOR.
BEAR WITH ME. GIVE IT UP.
AND I REMEMBER I JUST KEPT MY MOUTH SHUT
BECAUSE IT WAS SO PAINFUL.
PEOPLE WERE STRUGGLING A LOT.
Joe Lieberman: IN THE TIME IN WHICH I WAS GROWING UP,
AN UNACCEPTABLE FORM OF DISCRIMINATION WAS RACE
OR ETHNICITY OR RELIGION;
NOT SEXUAL ORIENTATION.
HERE WE ARE TODAY
AND WE'VE BEGUN TO TRY TO WORK OUR WAY THROUGH
QUESTIONS OF DISCRIMINATION
IN REGARD TO SEXUAL ORIENTATION.
IT WAS THE FIRST TIME I HAD EVER ACTUALLY DEALT WITH THIS ON THE FEDERAL LEVEL.
I WOULDN'T SAY THAT I'M TOTALLY OPEN-MINDED,
BUT I-- I KNOW THAT I HAVE NOT REACHED A CONCLUSION.
Man: SENATOR, GLAD TO HAVE YOU ONBOARD.
Reporter: THEY'VE ALREADY HEARD FROM JUST ABOUT EVERYBODY ELSE,
SO TODAY THE SENATE ARMED SERVICES COMMITTEE
VISITED THE FLEET TO GET THEIR VIEWS ON GAYS IN THE MILITARY,
AND THEY GOT AN EARFUL.
WE'RE TIRED OF HAVING THE MILITARY USED
AS SOME SORT OF A SOCIAL THERMOMETER FOR THE REST OF THE COUNTRY.
ARE YOU AFRAID THERE WILL BE VIOLENCE?
YES, SIR, I DO.
HAVE YOU HEARD ANYBODY SAY THAT?
A LOT OF PEOPLE, SIR. IT'S A LOT OF TALK. A LOT OF PEOPLE FEEL,
"HEY, IF THEY LOOK AT ME THE WRONG WAY, I'M GOING TO KNOCK 'EM OUT."
DISCRIMINATION IS A DOMESTIC ENEMY.
I SWORE TO DEFEND FUNDAMENTAL VALUES OF AMERICA.
THESE VALUES ARE IGNORED BY THE CURRENT POLICY.
YOUR LIFESTYLE IS NOT NORMAL.
IT'S NOT NORMAL FOR A MAN
TO WANT TO BE WITH A MAN OR A WOMAN WITH A WOMAN.
Reporter: EVERYWHERE HE WENT, SAM NUNN REMINDED THE SAILORS
THAT HE MIGHT JUST TORPEDO THE PRESIDENT'S PLANS TO LIFT THE BAN.
SO THE PRESIDENT HAS THE RIGHT TO ISSUE AN ORDER
AND CHANGE THE POLICY
AND ALLOW GAYS AND LESBIANS TO SERVE OPENLY
IF HE CHOOSES TO.
THE CONGRESS HAS A RIGHT TO OVERRIDE THAT BY LAW.
Les Aspin: LADIES AND GENTLEMEN,
THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES.
AHEM. THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
THE POLICY I AM ANNOUNCING TODAY IS IN MY JUDGMENT
THE RIGHT THING TO DO AND THE BEST WAY TO DO IT
BECAUSE IT PROVIDES A SENSIBLE BALANCE
BETWEEN THE RIGHTS OF THE INDIVIDUAL
AND THE NEEDS OF OUR MILITARY
TO REMAIN THE WORLD'S #1 FIGHTING FORCE.
THIS IS A MAJOR STEP FORWARD.
ONE: SERVICEMEN AND WOMEN WILL BE JUDGED
BASED ON THEIR CONDUCT, NOT THEIR SEXUAL ORIENTATION;
TWO: THEREFORE THE PRACTICE NOW SIX MONTHS OLD
OF NOT ASKING ABOUT SEXUAL ORIENTATION
IN THE ENLISTMENT PROCEDURE WILL CONTINUE.
IT IS IN MY JUDGMENT
AN HONORABLE COMPROMISE.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH.
Lieberman: GIVE PRESIDENT CLINTON HIS DUE.
HE WAS REALLY TRYING TO LEAD ON THE GENERAL QUESTION
AND CHALLENGE OF GAY RIGHTS IN 1993.
BUT DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL FOR THE FIRST TIME
REALLY PUT INTO LAW THE BASIC INEQUITY
WHICH WAS, IF I MAY PUT IT THIS WAY, UNAMERICAN.
"DON'T ASK" IS A MYTH.
WE ARE ASKED ABOUT OUR LIVES EVERY DAY.
YOU KNOW-- "WHO ARE YOU GOING TO THE MOVIES WITH THIS WEEKEND?
WHO CALLED YOU? WHY AREN'T YOU MARRIED?"
THESE ARE THE DAILY QUESTIONS THAT WE ALL GET ASKED.
Man: WHENEVER YOU MEET SOMEONE NEW IN THE ARMY,
YOU WANNA KNOW IF THEY'RE MARRIED;
YOU WANNA KNOW IF THEY HAVE KIDS;
YOU KNOW, YOU WANNA KNOW WHERE THEY'RE FROM;
YOU WANNA KNOW ABOUT-- ABOUT THESE PEOPLE.
Matthew: PEOPLE ASK ALL THE TIME,
"WHAT ARE YOU DOING THIS WEEKEND?"
PEOPLE JUST WANT TO KNOW.
PEOPLE START WONDERING WHY, AS A FIRST LIEUTENANT
OR A CAPTAIN, ARE THEY NOT AT LEAST ENGAGED
OR AT LEAST CONSIDERING GETTING MARRIED AND STARTING A FAMILY?
AS THE YEARS GO ON, IT'S GOING TO BE TOUGHER AND TOUGHER
TO ANSWER THOSE KIND OF QUESTIONS.
Man #2: I'VE GOTTEN DISCIPLINED.
I'VE HAD SENIOR OFFICERS TALK TO ME
ABOUT BEING ANTISOCIAL
BECAUSE I DIDN'T WANT TO PARTICIPATE
IN OUTSIDE ACTIVITIES.
Josh: IF YOU CAN IMAGINE WHAT IT WOULD BE LIKE
TO HIDE A SPOUSE-- HOW DO YOU ACCOMPLISH THAT EVERY DAY?
Woman: EVERY HOUSE WE GO TO-- IT HAS TO HAVE A HIGH FENCE
'CAUSE I DON'T WANT ANYBODY TO BE ABLE TO SEE INTO OUR BACKYARD.
I WANT TO HAVE SOMEWHERE WHERE WE CAN BE OURSELVES
OTHER THAN INSIDE OUR HOMES.
I'M CONSTANTLY AFRAID OF OUTING HER.
IF WE RUN INTO PEOPLE IN PUBLIC THAT SHE DOES KNOW FROM WORK,
I'LL JUST KEEP ON WALKING LIKE I DON'T EVEN KNOW HER.
Erik: IT ACTUALLY GOT TO THE POINT
WHERE I THOUGHT SERIOUSLY ABOUT HURTING MYSELF.
AND I HAD REALIZED
THAT I WAS IN A PRETTY DANGEROUS SPOT,
BECAUSE I COULDN'T TURN TO ANYBODY.
Marcus: MY FRIENDS AND I KIND OF SAY
THAT WE LIVE IN THIS SORT OF CONTINUUM OF NEAR MISSES, YOU KNOW?
THAT WE ALWAYS HAVE THIS CONSTANT MISSED SHOTS
THAT ALMOST HIT US.
Man #3: TO-- TO KEEP YOUR JOB, TO KEEP YOUR SANITY,
NOT TO BE PARANOID, YOU KNOW,
WONDERING IF SOMEONE IS GOING TO TURN YOU IN OR--
YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT PEOPLE'S INTENTIONS ARE.
YOU KNOW, SOME PEOPLE CAN SAY, "OH, I'M COOL WITH IT."
BUT THE NEXT DAY THEY CAN GO IN AND REPORT YOU,
AND, YOU KNOW, YOU'RE GONE.
DIXON OSBURN OF THE SERVICE MEMBERS LEGAL DEFENSE NETWORK JOINS US.
HE IS PART OF AN ORGANIZATION THAT OPPOSES THE POLICY.
ANY POLICY THAT DISCRIMINATES OR TREATS LESBIANS AND GAYS
DIFFERENTLY THAN HETEROSEXUALS I THINK IS RIFE WITH PROBLEMS.
Dixon Osburn: THE PHONES WERE RINGING OFF THE HOOK FROM SERVICE MEMBERS.
"IS IT TRUE THAT WE CAN SERVE OPENLY NOW?"
THEY WERE LEFT OUT ON A LIMB.
NOBODY THOUGHT ABOUT WHAT WAS GOING TO HAPPEN
TO THE SERVICE MEMBERS EXCEPT FOR THE PEOPLE WHO FOUNDED S.L.D.N.
THEY KNEW THAT SERVICE MEMBERS
WERE GOING TO GET TRIPPED UP WITH THIS LAW.
DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL WAS SUPPOSED TO MEAN
THAT IF YOU DIDN'T VOLUNTEER THAT YOU WERE GAY OR LESBIAN,
YOU WERE OKAY BECAUSE THEY COULDN'T ASK YOU.
WHAT WE THEN GOT WERE A LOT OF MILITARY PEOPLE
ASKING, IN EFFECT-- DOING INVESTIGATIONS,
CHECKING PEOPLE'S EMAILS, WATCHING WHO WENT TO A GAY BAR.
Aubrey Sarvis: S.L.D.N. IS A LEGAL SERVICES ORGANIZATION
THAT PROVIDES QUALITY FREE LEGAL SERVICES
TO MEN AND WOMEN WHO ARE ON ACTIVE DUTY, IN THE RESERVES,
WHO HAVE BEEN ADVERSELY IMPACTED BY DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
Osburn: I KNEW BACK THEN THAT THIS WAS GOING TO TAKE
A 20-YEAR EFFORT TO GET THIS LAW UNDONE.
SO WE STARTED TELLING STORIES OF SERVICE MEMBERS
WHO WERE BEING TURNED IN BY THEIR PSYCHIATRISTS,
'CAUSE THERE'S NO CONFIDENTIALITY IN TALKING TO YOUR PSYCHIATRIST.
WE TOLD STORIES OF PEOPLE BEING TURNED IN BY THEIR PARENTS,
BECAUSE THEY HAD COME OUT TO THEIR FAMILY AND THE FAMILY REACTED BADLY TO IT.
WE TOLD STORIES OF BEING TURNED IN BY YOUR BEST FRIENDS.
WE TOLD STORIES OF PEOPLE HAVING THEIR DIARIES TAKEN
AND THEY'D USE THAT AS THE BASIS FOR THEIR DISCHARGE.
WHAT WE FOUND IN THE FIRST YEAR UNDER DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL
IS THAT THE MILITARY CONTINUES TO ASK,
IT CONTINUES TO PURSUE AND IT CONTINUES TO HARASS.
Osburn: I REMEMBER ONE SERVICE MEMBER IN HAWAII
WHO WAS CAUGHT IN A WITCH HUNT.
AND HE WAS SO SCARED EVEN TO CONTACT S.L.D.N.
AND HE DESCRIBES HAVING TO GO TO THE LIBRARY ON THE BASE
AND LOOK UP IN THE WHITE PAGES TO TRY TO FIND OUR NUMBER.
AND HE WENT BACK TO HIS ROOM
AND HE PULLED THE SHEETS OVER HIS HEAD
AND HAD A FLASHLIGHT ON THE PHONE
AND THE PHONE NUMBER AND CALLED US IN WHISPERS.
Nathaniel Frank: IT'S A POLICY THAT WAS DESIGNED TO MAKE SEXUAL ORIENTATION
INTO A KIND OF NON-ISSUE, AND IT WAS SUPPOSED TO END WITCH HUNTS
AND END PURSUITS.
BUT INSTEAD, DISCHARGE FIGURES SHOT UP.
Reporter: THE SERVICEMEMBERS LEGAL DEFENSE NETWORK
REPORTS THE PENTAGON IS KICKING GAYS OUT OF THE MILITARY
AT A RAPID PACE DESPITE THE DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL POLICY.
THE GAY-RIGHTS GROUP SAYS THAT'S A FIVE-YEAR HIGH.
Belkin: WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE EVIDENTIARY REQUIREMENTS
THAT ARE BUILT INTO THE LAW,
IT TURNS OUT THAT ANY EVIDENCE WHATSOEVER
CAN BE USED TO PROVE THAT SOMEONE HAS A GAY IDENTITY.
WALKING IN THE WOODS WITH A PERSON OF THE SAME SEX
CAN BE USED TO PROVE THAT YOU'RE GAY.
IT COULD BE A BUMPER STICKER. IT COULD BE AN EMAIL.
Steinman: A STATEMENT, A TELEPHONE CALL...
ANYTHING WHERE YOU INDICATED THAT YOU HAVE,
CURRENTLY DO, INTEND TO, OR EVEN HAVE A PROPENSITY
TO ENGAGE IN HOMOSEXUAL ACTS GETS YOU KICKED OUT.
PEOPLE HAVE BEEN DETERMINED OR FOUND TO BE GAY BY MILITARY JUDGES
FOR ATTENDING THE DINAH SHORE GOLF TOURNAMENT.
AND SO BEHAVIOR WHICH HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH SEX
BECOMES LEGALLY EQUIVALENT TO A CRIME.
WRITTEN INTO THE LAW IS SOMETHING CALLED
"A QUEEN FOR A DAY" PRESUMPTION,
WHICH MEANS THAT IF YOU ARE CAUGHT HAVING GAY SEX
BUT YOU CAN PROVE THAT YOU'RE NOT GAY--
THAT YOU DON'T CARRY A GAY IDENTITY,
THAT THIS WAS A HOMOSEXUAL EMERGENCY,
THAT THIS WAS AN ACCIDENT,
THAT YOU WERE IN EFFECT A QUEEN FOR A DAY,
THEN YOU ARE NOT PUNISHED EVEN THOUGH YOU HAVE HAD GAY SEX.
Reporter: WINCHELL WAS BEATEN TO DEATH WHILE ASLEEP IN HIS BARRACKS
IN THE EARLY MORNING OF JULY 5th.
HE WAS KILLED WITH A BASEBALL BAT TO HIS HEAD.
Osburn: BARRY WINCHELL FACED ANTI-GAY HARASSMENT
EVERY DAY FOR FOUR MONTHS PRIOR TO HIS MURDER.
AND HE EVEN CONFIDED TO FRIENDS OF HIS-- "WHAT DO I DO?
I'M AFRAID TO GO TO MY COMMANDER BECAUSE IF I TELL MY COMMANDER
I'M BEING HARASSED BECAUSE PEOPLE THINK I'M GAY,
THEY'RE GOING TO KICK ME OUT AND THE ARMY'S THE ONLY THING I HAVE."
Belkin: IF YOU'RE GAY OR LESBIAN AND YOU'RE HAVING A PROBLEM,
YOU CAN'T GO TO THE PEOPLE
YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO BE ABLE TO GO TO AND SAY, "I NEED HELP.
I'M FACING ANTI-GAY HARASSMENT.
WHAT CAN I DO? HOW CAN YOU PROTECT ME?"
BECAUSE SIMPLY HAVING THAT CONVERSATION
MEANS THAT THE PERSON YOU'RE TALKING TO COULD TURN YOU IN
AND YOU COULD END UP LOSING YOUR CAREER.
Nathaniel Frank: THIS IS BIGGER THAN JUST GAY RIGHTS.
IT'S SOMETHING THAT CUTS TO THE CORE OF WHAT AMERICA IS,
WHAT AMERICA IS FIGHTING FOR, AND IS A REMINDER
THAT WHEN ONE GROUP'S RIGHTS ARE TRAMPLED UPON,
THE ENTIRE CULTURE IS DIMINISHED.
- I, GEORGE WALKER BUSH... - William Rehnquist: DO SOLEMNLY SWEAR...
DO SOLEMNLY SWEAR...
I'M FOR DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
AND I THINK IT'S UP TO THE MILITARY
TO MAKE SURE WE ENFORCE IT.
THIS IS A POLICY THOUGHTFULLY PUT INTO PLACE.
Korb: WHEN OTHER COUNTRIES, OUR N.A.T.O. ALLIES,
ALLOW OPENLY GAY PEOPLE TO SERVE,
PEOPLE WOULD SAY, "YES, BUT THE BRITISH DON'T,
AND THEY ARE THE MOST LIKE US."
WELL, THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
BASICALLY IN 1999 SAID, "YOU WANT TO BE IN THE EUROPEAN UNION,
YOU'VE GOT TO LET THEM SERVE."
SO THE BRITISH ALLOWED OPENLY GAY PEOPLE TO SERVE
AND DIDN'T HAVE ANY PROBLEMS.
OH SHIT!
WE KNOW THAT INTELLIGENCE INTERCEPTED PRE 9/11
WAS NOT TRANSLATED UNTIL AFTER 9/11
BECAUSE OF A SHORTAGE OF LINGUISTS.
THE ARABIC LINGUISTS THAT HAVE BEEN DISCHARGED UNDER DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL
CERTAINLY COULD HAVE HELPED FILL THOSE SHORTAGES.
TWO PHRASES IN AN ARABIC... ( speaks Arabic )
WHICH MEAN, "TOMORROW IS ZERO HOUR. THE MATCH BEGINS TOMORROW,"
WEREN'T TRANSLATED UNTIL TWO DAYS AFTER 9/11.
AND TO ANYONE WHO SPEAKS ARABIC,
YOU KNOW, THOSE ARE TWO OF THE EASIEST PHRASES TO TRANSLATE.
Belkin: THE PREVALENT FEAR IN THE CULTURE
WAS THAT TERRORISTS FROM AL QAEDA
WERE GOING TO SLIP A NUCLEAR WEAPON INTO AN AMERICAN CITY.
THE FEARS WERE INCREDIBLY INTENSE.
SO WHEN WE BROKE THE STORY, IT WAS A VERY POWERFUL "AHA" MOMENT
IN WHICH PEOPLE SAID, "OH MY GOD." LIKE, "ALL RIGHT,
THERE'S THIS GAYS IN THE MILITARY THING, LIKE, WHATEVER,
BUT WE'RE DOING SOMETHING WHICH COULD ALLOW A NUCLEAR WEAPON
TO BE EXPLODED IN AN AMERICAN CITY? LIKE, THIS IS RIDICULOUS."
REGARDLESS OF WHAT YOUR FEELINGS ARE ABOUT GAYS IN THE MILITARY,
YOU DON'T WANT CABLES TO SIT UNTRANSLATED.
Nathaniel Frank: STARTING IN 2001,
GAY DISCHARGE NUMBERS WENT DOWN EACH YEAR
BECAUSE COMMANDERS IN THE FIELD
KNOW GAY PEOPLE DON'T UNDERCUT THEIR MISSION.
Patrick Murphy: I WILL NEVER FORGET BEING A YOUNG FIRST LIEUTENANT
AND FOLKS WHO DIDN'T WANT TO DEPLOY
WOULD COME IN AND BE LIKE, "WELL, I'M GAY."
AND, I WOULD SAY, "WELL, YOU'RE DEPLOYING."
Nathaniel Frank: THERE ARE COUNTLESS EXAMPLES OF COMMANDERS
WHO WERE TOLD BY SOMEONE, "I'M GAY,"
AND THE COMMANDER SAID, "NO, YOU'RE NOT, GET BACK TO WORK.
YOU'RE GOING OVERSEAS ANYWAY."
HE SAID, "LISTEN, IT'S NOT A POLICY I AGREE WITH.
AND WE NEED THESE SOLDIERS."
Steinman: THE RESERVE COMMANDER'S HANDBOOK SAID,
"IF A RESERVIST HAS ORDERS FOR DEPLOYMENT
AND HE OR SHE MAKES A STATEMENT THAT THEY ARE GAY,
SEND THEM ANYWAY AND DEAL WITH IT WHEN THEY COME BACK."
HOW THEN CAN YOU ARGUE THAT THEY ARE A DISRUPTION TO UNIT MORALE,
UNIT COHESION OR COMBAT READINESS?
YOU'RE SENDING THEM TO COMBAT KNOWING THAT THEY'RE GAY
AND THEN WHEN THEY COME BACK,
AFTER THEY PUT THEIR LIFE ON THE LINE, THEN YOU KICK THEM OUT.
DOESN'T MAKE ANY SENSE AT ALL, DOES IT?
Korb: THEY KEPT LOWERING THEIR STANDARDS.
AND THEY WERE GIVING PEOPLE MORAL WAIVERS,
INCLUDING SOME WITH FELONY CONVICTIONS.
AND WE'RE THROWING PEOPLE OUT
FOR NO OTHER REASON THAN THEIR SEXUAL ORIENTATION?
Korb: LET ME GIVE YOU AN EXAMPLE OF SOMEBODY WE TOOK IN.
THERE'S A YOUNG MAN, A FORMER ARMY PRIVATE BY THE NAME OF STEVEN GREEN
WHO'S NOW SERVING A LIFE SENTENCE IN KENTUCKY.
WHEN GREEN TRIED TO JOIN THE ARMY IN TEXAS IN 2005,
HE'S A HIGH-SCHOOL DROPOUT;
HE HAS THREE MISDEMEANOR CONVICTIONS;
HE'S GOT SOME PERSONALITY PROBLEMS--
THEY GAVE HIM A WAIVER WHEN THEY TOOK HIM IN--
SENT HIM TO IRAQ.
HE ENDED UP WITH TWO OTHER PEOPLE
RAPING A YOUNG LADY,
THEN BURNING HER BODY AND HER FAMILY'S.
SO TO ME, IT WAS HURTING NATIONAL SECURITY.
I MEAN WHO WOULD YOU RATHER TAKE,
HIM OR SOMEBODY WHO IS GAY OR LESBIAN
WHO'S GOT A PERFECT RECORD, HIGH-SCHOOL GRADUATE,
STELLAR PERFORMANCE ON THE APTITUDE TEST,
NO MORAL PROBLEMS?
Josh: THE FIRST THING WE'RE TAUGHT IN BOOT CAMP--
BEFORE WE'RE TAUGHT TO STAND AT ATTENTION,
THEY TEACH US HOW TO SAY VERY LOUDLY,
"HONOR, COURAGE AND COMMITMENT,"
AND WHAT THOSE THREE WORDS MEAN.
Man: YOU WANT THOSE OF US THAT ARE HOMOSEXUAL TO HIDE OURSELVES.
THERE'S NO HONOR IN THAT. THERE'S NO INTEGRITY.
Matthew: DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL FORCES YOU,
AND ACTUALLY TELLS YOU AS A GAY PERSON,
THAT YOU NEED TO BE UNTRUTHFUL AND DISHONEST.
Diana: HOW CAN I BE MYSELF
AND HOW CAN I BE TRUTHFUL AND HONORABLE IF I HAVE TO LIE?
Emily: ESSENTIALLY WHAT THEY'RE ASKING ME TO DO
IS LIE ON A DAILY BASIS TO THE PEOPLE I LOVE THE MOST,
TO THE PEOPLE I WOULD LIKE TO BE HONEST WITH.
Erik: AS A LEADER IN THE MILITARY,
IT INTERFERES BECAUSE THE INTEGRITY,
THE HONESTY ISN'T THERE. AND THEY KNOW IT.
SO IT UNDERMINES THEIR TRUST IN ME.
MY FAMILY HAS A RICH HISTORY OF MILITARY SERVICE,
Man: WE ALL TOOK THE OATH...
MY FATHER IS A RETIRED SENIOR OFFICER FROM THE AIR FORCE.
Man: ...AND WE ALL WEAR THE UNIFORM...
I HAVE SEVERAL OTHER UNCLES WHO RETIRED FROM THE MARINE CORPS,
FROM THE ARMY.
...BUT THE SPIRIT OF A SOLDIER?
THAT'S NEVER CHANGED.
THAT'S NEVER GOING TO CHANGE.
Almy: I HAD BEEN SERVING IN IRAQ WITH MY UNIT.
I HAD WRITTEN A SERIES OF EMAILS TO FAMILY AND FRIENDS
NO DIFFERENT FROM WHAT ANYONE ELSE WOULD WRITE
TO THEIR LOVED ONES BACK HOME.
SHORTLY AFTER I HAD LEFT IRAQ,
THE UNIT THAT REPLACED MINE-- SOMEONE WAS DOING A ROUTINE SEARCH
AND SOMEHOW OR ANOTHER STUMBLED UPON MY PRIVATE EMAILS
AND PROCEEDED TO READ THEM.
AND THEY SEARCHED APPROXIMATELY 500 EMAILS
AND PULLED OUT MAYBE A DOZEN OR SO THAT WERE DAMAGING.
AND THEN MY COMMANDER CALLED ME IN HIS OFFICE.
HE READ ME THE MILITARY'S POLICY ON HOMOSEXUALITY.
I HAD NO CLUE THAT ANY OF THIS WAS HAPPENING,
SO IT COMPLETELY BOWLED ME OVER.
AND I TOLD HIM I WOULD NOT MAKE A STATEMENT
UNTIL I HAD FIRST CONSULTED WITH A LAWYER.
SO RIGHT THEN AND THERE MY COMMANDER RELIEVED ME OF MY DUTIES.
I WAS GIVEN A POLICE ESCORT FROM THE BASE
AS IF I WERE A COMMON CRIMINAL OR A THREAT TO NATIONAL SECURITY.
IT WAS VERY INTENSE.
IT COMPLETELY DISPELS THE NOTION
THAT AS LONG AS GAYS AND LESBIANS ARE QUIET
AND DON'T MAKE ANY WAVES FOR THEMSELVES
OR DON'T MAKE A STATEMENT, THAT THEY'RE GONNA BE JUST FINE.
BUT THAT'S NOT THE CASE.
HEY, GUYS, HOW ARE YOU? I'M PATRICK MURPHY.
Reporter: OF THE NINE IRAQ VETERANS RUNNING FOR CONGRESS THIS YEAR,
MOST OF THEM ARE ANTI-WAR.
CAPTAIN PATRICK MURPHY SERVED SEVEN MONTHS IN IRAQ.
Patrick Murphy: I AM STRAIGHT. I HAVE TWO KIDS. I HAVE A BEAUTIFUL WIFE.
BUT LISTEN, I TAKE AN OATH AS A CONGRESSMAN,
JUST LIKE I DID AS AN ARMY OFFICER,
TO SUPPORT AND DEFEND THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES.
LISTEN, IF YOU WANT TO TAKE A BULLET FOR YOUR COUNTRY,
SIGN UP, GRAB A RIFLE AND SERVE.
THAT'S WHAT IT'S ABOUT.
- IS THAT THE-- - OH NO.
I ALREADY GOT IT-- GOT THE CALL IN.
EVERY DAY WE'RE UP ON CAPITOL HILL,
OVER AT THE PENTAGON OR AT THE WHITE HOUSE
URGING REPEAL OF DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
I'LL PROBABLY BE BACK IN ABOUT AN HOUR AND A HALF.
Murphy: WHAT WOULD BE THE GREATER THREAT TO OUR NATIONAL SECURITY
AND MILITARY NECESSITY--
LEAVING A TERRORIST DOCUMENT UNTRANSLATED
OR HAVING A GAY SOLDIER FIGHT ALONGSIDE A STRAIGHT ONE?
Elaine Donnelly: WE NEED PEOPLE WHO ARE GOOD LINGUISTS,
BUT NOT NECESSARILY SHOULD THEY BE GAY.
I MEAN THAT'S A STEREOTYPE--
RIGHT, BUT LET'S BE STRAIGHT HERE. LET'S BE STRAIGHT.
THAT'S WHAT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WANT.
WE HAVE LET GO 12,000 AMERICAN MEN AND WOMEN SOLDIERS,
NOT FOR SEXUAL MISCONDUCT, BUT BECAUSE OF THEIR SEXUAL ORIENTATION.
58 OF THOSE ARE TRANSLATORS.
WE COULD REDUCE THIS NUMBER TO ZERO
IF THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE DROPPED DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL
AND ENFORCED THE LAW PROPERLY.
WE SHOULD NOT BE TRAINING PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT ELIGIBLE
TO BE IN THE ARMED FORCES.
WELL, THERE'S ALREADY RULES IN PLACE TO ADDRESS SEXUAL MISCONDUCT,
WHETHER IT'S HOMOSEXUAL MISCONDUCT OR HETEROSEXUAL MISCONDUCT,
AS COMPARED TO YOUR ORIENTATION.
AND WE NEED MORE GOOD PEOPLE WHETHER THEY'RE GAY OR STRAIGHT
TO JOIN OUR MILITARY AND TO SERVE HONORABLY.
DO YOU THINK THAT THERE WOULD BE MORE PEOPLE
WILLING TO JOIN THE SUBMARINE FORCE
IF THEY KNEW THAT PROFESSED HOMOSEXUALS WOULD BE ON SUBMARINES?
- I DON'T THINK SO. - WELL, MISS DONNELLY, YOU KNOW, I HAVE FAITH
- IN THOSE 18-, 19-YEAR-OLD SOLDIERS-- - ( Donnelly continues talking )
OKAY, I LET YOU ASK ME A QUESTION. I'M GOING TO ANSWER IT.
YOU KNOW, USUALLY IT COMES FROM THE OTHER SIDE OF THE DAIS, BUT...
Reporter: THE PENTAGON CONFIRMED TODAY
MILITARY LEADERS ONCE PROPOSED BUILDING A SO-CALLED GAY BOMB.
Reporter #2: "ONE DISTASTEFUL BUT COMPLETELY NON-LETHAL EXAMPLE
WOULD BE STRONG APHRODISIACS,
ESPECIALLY IF THE CHEMICAL ALSO CAUSED HOMOSEXUAL BEHAVIOR."
A GAY BOMB, SO-CALLED,
THAT WOULD RENDER ENEMY FORCES SO SMITTEN WITH ONE ANOTHER,
THEY WOULD FORGET ABOUT FIGHTING.
Belkin: THE IDEA WAS THAT BECAUSE HOMOSEXUALITY
IS THE SAME AS WEAKNESS AND EFFEMINACY,
THAT IF ONLY WE COULD MAKE THE TROOPS OF THE OTHER SIDE BECOME GAY,
THEN WE COULD PREVAIL ON THE BATTLEFIELD.
IT SHOWS THE EXTENT OF THE SILLINESS
THAT SURROUNDS THE ISSUE OF SEXUAL ORIENTATION
IN SOME PEOPLE'S MINDS
WHEN THEY'RE IGNORANT ABOUT THE ISSUE, BASICALLY.
IT BASICALLY IS A REFLECTION OF IGNORANCE.
Sarvis: I'M GOING TO BE RUNNING OUT OF THE OFFICE.
I'M GONNA ASK KEVIN TO GET BACK TO YOU
AND WORK WITH YOU ON THIS.
I JOINED THE MILITARY BECAUSE I COME FROM A MILITARY FAMILY.
MY FATHER WAS IN THE AIR FORCE FOR 20 YEARS.
MY MOTHER WAS IN THE AIR FORCE.
I'VE BEEN IN THE AIR FORCE FOR 18 AND A HALF YEARS NOW.
ON 9/11 I WAS ONE OF THE FIRST ALERT CREWS
FLYING OVER WASHINGTON D.C.
MY FIRST COMBAT MISSIONS, DROPPING BOMBS IN IRAQ,
WERE THREE, FOUR DAYS BEFORE THE WAR ACTUALLY STARTED,
BEFORE ANYBODY SAW BOMBS DROPPED ON TV.
DECORATIONS-- NINE AIR MEDALS AND ONE FOR HEROISM;
FIVE AIR FORCE COMMENDATION MEDALS;
A NAVY MARINE CORPS COMMENDATION MEDAL;
AND THEN THREE AIR FORCE ACHIEVEMENT MEDALS.
THE WORST DAY OF MY LIFE WAS MAY 16th, 2008.
THAT WAS THE DAY THE AIR FORCE SAT ME DOWN AND SAID, "HERE'S WHAT WE GOT.
WE'RE GONNA LAUNCH AN INVESTIGATION.
YOU'LL PROBABLY GET THROWN OUT OF THE AIR FORCE FOR THIS."
Woman: LADIES AND GENTLEMEN,
PLEASE JOIN ME IN PRESENTING THE BARRY WINCHELL COURAGE AWARD
TO LIEUTENANT COLONEL VICTOR FEHRENBACH.
LAST MAY WHEN I CONTACTED S.L.D.N.
AND TOLD THEM I HAD MADE THE DECISION TO GO PUBLIC,
I WAS SCHEDULED TO APPEAR ON "THE RACHEL MADDOW SHOW" ON TUESDAY,
BUT THERE WAS A CATCH.
IT WAS FRIDAY
AND I HADN'T EVEN COME OUT TO MY FAMILY YET...
...LET ALONE TOLD THEM I WAS GETTING THROWN OUT OF THE MILITARY,
LET ALONE TELL THEM I WAS GOING ON NATIONAL TV TO TALK ABOUT IT.
I DROP BOMBS FOR A LIVING...
...BUT I'M PRETTY SURE
THESE WERE THE THREE BIGGEST BOMBS I EVER DROPPED.
MY FAMILY ALL AGREED--
NOT ONLY SHOULD I DO THIS, BUT I HAD TO DO THIS.
IT WAS A DUTY AND AN OBLIGATION.
Sarvis: BECAUSE VICTOR FEHRENBACH AND MAJOR MIKE ALMY
WENT BEFORE THE AMERICAN PEOPLE,
THEY MADE A HUGE DIFFERENCE IN THIS DEBATE.
BETWEEN THE TWO OF THEM,
THEY HAD BEEN DEPLOYED TO IRAQ AND AFGHANISTAN MORE THAN 10 TIMES.
VICTOR FEHRENBACH--
THE AIR FORCE HAD INVESTED MORE THAN $20 MILLION IN HIS TRAINING.
AND THEY WERE GETTING READY TO THROW THAT OUT OF THE WINDOW.
WHEN YOU HAVE OVER 13,000 SERVICEMEMBERS DISCHARGED UNDER THIS LAW,
IT ISN'T WORKING.
WHEN YOU HAVE EVEN MORE WHO HAVE RESIGNED
BECAUSE THEY DID NOT WANT TO SERVE ANYMORE
UNDER DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL, IT'S NOT WORKING.
WHEN YOU HAVE A GENERATION OF YOUNG PEOPLE
NOT EVEN CONSIDERING THE SERVICE BECAUSE OF THE STATUTE,
IT'S NOT WORKING.
Barack Obama: I HAVE STATED REPEATEDLY
THAT DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL MAKES NO SENSE.
WHY WOULD WE NOT WANT ABLE MEN AND WOMEN
WHO ARE WILLING TO SACRIFICE ON OUR BEHALF--
WHY WOULD WE TELL THEM NO?
John McCain: I BELIEVE THAT DISCRIMINATION IN ANY FORM
IS UNACCEPTABLE IN AMERICA TODAY.
NOW HAVING SAID THAT, I HAVE TO TELL YOU
THAT I SUPPORT THE DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL POLICY IN THE MILITARY.
Murphy: I WAS ONE OF THE FIRST GUYS FOR BARACK OBAMA.
ONE OF THE THINGS THAT HE TALKED TO ME ABOUT
WAS TO REPEAL DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
AND I TOLD HIM HOW I SAW SO MANY GREAT LEADERS GET THROWN OUT
JUST BECAUSE THEY HAPPEN TO BE GAY,
NOT FOR ANY TYPE OF MISCONDUCT, AND HOW WRONG I THOUGHT IT WAS.
AND HE SAID HE AGREED WITH ME.
I, BARACK HUSSEIN OBAMA, DO SOLEMNLY SWEAR...
I WILL WORK WITH CONGRESS AND OUR MILITARY
TO FINALLY REPEAL THE LAW THAT DENIES GAY AMERICANS
THE RIGHT TO SERVE THE COUNTRY THEY LOVE BECAUSE OF WHO THEY ARE.
Murphy: ONE OF HIS FIRST MEETINGS WITH THE CHAIRMAN
OF THE JOINT CHIEFS OF STAFF AND HIS SECRETARY OF DEFENSE,
HE SAID, "GUYS, YOU KNOW, THERE'S A PROBLEM.
YOU KNOW, THIS DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL IS UNAMERICAN AND IT'S WRONG.
AND WE GOTTA CHANGE IT."
AND SOON AFTER, WE BEGAN TO WORK AND DO JUST THAT.
Barney Frank: THERE'S A BIG FIGHT TO GET THE VOTES.
THE RIGHT WING WILL TRY TO PORTRAY THIS AS THE END OF THE MILITARY, ETCETERA.
THE SENATE'S NOT ENGAGED ENOUGH AND WE HAVE TO FIND A WAY
TO ASK EVERY SENATOR TO STAND UP
AND STATE WHERE THEY ARE ON REPEAL--
REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS AND THE INDEPENDENTS.
WE'RE TRYING TO HARNESS THE MOMENTUM GAINED EARLIER THIS WEEK...
- RIGHT. - ...AND RIDE IT.
OKAY, SO THAT'S D.O.D. AND THEN S.L.D.N.'S NUMBER...
Joe Lieberman: THE THING THAT HAPPENED HERE DIFFERENT FROM '93
IS THE GAY RIGHTS MOVEMENT WAS ORGANIZED
AND EXTREMELY EFFECTIVE.
I MEAN SOME OF MY COLLEAGUES,
REPUBLICANS AND DEMOCRATS, WHO ENDED UP SUPPORTING REPEAL
OF DON'T ASK DON'T TELL
DID SO BECAUSE THEY WERE VERY EFFECTIVELY LOBBIED.
AND THAT'S TOTALLY DIFFERENT THAN EXISTED IN '93.
- SOUNDS GOOD. - AWESOME.
- LET'S GO WITH IT. - THANKS.
Rachel Maddow: JOINING US NOW IS DAN CHOI.
Dan Choi: I AM AN INFANTRY PLATOON LEADER
IN THE NEW YORK ARMY NATIONAL GUARD.
AND BY SAYING THREE WORDS TO YOU TODAY-- I AM GAY--
THOSE THREE WORDS ARE A VIOLATION OF TITLE 10 OF THE U.S. CODE.
FUNDAMENTALLY, I AM A TROUBLEMAKER
WHO AGITATED A SITUATION
BY SAYING THREE WORDS.
ARE YOU WORRIED YOU COULD LOSE YOUR JOB?
POLITICS IS WAR WITHOUT BLOOD.
WAR IS POLITICS WITH BLOOD.
IN WAR WE RECOGNIZE THAT THERE ARE CONSEQUENCES.
WHY IS IT THAT IN POLITICS, PARTICULARLY FOR GAY PEOPLE--
WHY IS IT THAT WE REFUSE TO WIELD THE SWORD OF CONSEQUENCE?
ONE PARTICULAR MEETING REALLY INSPIRED ME TO ACTION,
AND THAT WAS WHEN I MET WITH LIEUTENANT DAN CHOI.
HE SAID THAT, YOU KNOW, WE ARE ASKING THESE MEN AND WOMEN
TO LIE EVERY DAY. AND IT WAS SO POWERFUL TO ME
BECAUSE I COULDN'T EVEN IMAGINE THAT FOR A STRAIGHT OFFICER.
SO WHY WOULD YOU ALLOW IT FOR A MEMBER WHO'S GAY?
SO I THOUGHT IT WAS TIME THAT I PROVIDED LEADERSHIP.
I WROTE A BILL TO REPEAL THIS POLICY.
ONCE I WROTE THE BILL, I STARTED COUNTING THE VOTES
AND I DIDN'T HAVE QUITE 60.
BUT BECAUSE I WAS SO CLOSE,
THE FEW SENATORS WHO WERE UNDECIDED SAID,
"I FIRST NEED TO SEE LEADERSHIP FROM THE MILITARY."
AND SO I WENT TO THE CHAIRMAN OF THE ARMED SERVICES COMMITTEE,
CHAIRMAN LEVIN, AND I ASKED HIM--
I SAID, "WOULD YOU PLEASE HOLD A HEARING
ON DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL?" AND HE SAID YES.
Carl Levin: WHAT I'M HOPING TO DO IS TO PERSUADE COLLEAGUES
TO REPEAL THE DISCRIMINATORY PROVISION.
AND IN THE MEANTIME, SUSPEND DISCHARGING PEOPLE
WHILE THIS ISSUE IS BEING RESOLVED.
Man: A NEW ARTICLE IN THE PENTAGON'S OWN TOP SCHOLARLY JOURNAL,
"JOINT FORCE QUARTERLY," WRITTEN FOR THE JOINT CHIEFS OF STAFF
BY AN AIR FORCE COLONEL HAS CONCLUDED THAT,
QUOTE, "THERE IS NO SCIENTIFIC EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THE CLAIM
THAT UNIT COHESION WOULD BE NEGATIVELY AFFECTED..."
IN THIS ARTICLE, AN ACTIVE-DUTY AIR FORCE COLONEL
WORKING IN THE PENTAGON
MAKES THE POINT THAT DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL IS UNNECESSARY.
WE DON'T NEED IT. IT'S NOT GOING TO DEGRADE
UNIT MORALE, UNIT COHESION OR COMBAT READINESS.
AND HE PROVIDES A VERY FORCEFUL SERIES OF ARGUMENTS
TO PROVE HIS POINT.
I'M GONNA CALL CHAIRMAN LEVIN'S COUNSEL NOW
TO LET HIM KNOW THAT YOU WILL TESTIFY.
THE HIGHLIGHT OF THE HEARING WAS ADMIRAL MULLEN
TESTIFYING ON DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
I WAS SO EXCITED.
I WAS SITTING THERE WATCHING ADMIRAL MULLEN AND I WAS OVERJOYED.
MR. CHAIRMAN, SPEAKING FOR MYSELF AND MYSELF ONLY,
IT IS MY PERSONAL BELIEF THAT ALLOWING GAYS AND LESBIANS
TO SERVE OPENLY WOULD BE THE RIGHT THING TO DO.
- ( all cheer ) - YES! UNBELIEVABLE.
Sarvis: I THINK MY HEART STOPPED FOR MORE THAN A MOMENT.
FRANKLY, I-- I HAD TO AVOID A TEAR.
Mullen: NO MATTER HOW I LOOK AT THIS ISSUE,
I CANNOT ESCAPE BEING TROUBLED BY THE FACT
THAT WE HAVE IN PLACE A POLICY
WHICH FORCES YOUNG MEN AND WOMEN
TO LIE ABOUT WHO THEY ARE
IN ORDER TO DEFEND THEIR FELLOW CITIZENS.
FOR ME, PERSONALLY, IT COMES DOWN TO INTEGRITY--
THEIRS AS INDIVIDUALS, AND OURS AS AN INSTITUTION.
I HAD TEARS IN MY EYES.
IN FACT, I HAVE TEARS IN MY EYES NOW BECAUSE I'M THINKING ABOUT THAT--
A SORT OF CATCH MY VOICE. IT WAS A VERY EMOTIONAL MOMENT.
Lieberman: I THOUGHT THAT WAS A CRITICAL MOMENT
IN THE WHOLE EFFORT TO REPEAL DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
ADMIRAL MULLEN SPOKE REALLY FROM HIS HEART.
Levin: SECRETARY GATES.
WE HAVE RECEIVED OUR ORDERS FROM THE COMMANDER IN CHIEF,
AND WE ARE MOVING OUT ACCORDINGLY.
I HAVE APPOINTED A HIGH-LEVEL WORKING GROUP
THAT WILL IMMEDIATELY BEGIN A REVIEW OF THE ISSUES
ASSOCIATED WITH PROPERLY IMPLEMENTING A REPEAL
OF THE DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL POLICY.
I'M DEEPLY DISAPPOINTED
IN YOUR STATEMENT, SECRETARY GATES.
I WAS AROUND HERE IN 1993 AND WAS ENGAGED IN THE DEBATES.
YOUR STATEMENT OBVIOUSLY IS ONE WHICH IS CLEARLY BIASED.
THIS IS A LETTER SIGNED
BY OVER 1,000 FORMER GENERAL AND FLAG OFFICERS
WHO HAVE WEIGHED IN ON THIS ISSUE.
A MAJORITY OF THOSE FLAG OFFICERS ARE IN THEIR 70s;
SOME ARE IN THEIR 80s.
SOME OF THE PEOPLE'S NAMES ON THERE ARE DEAD.
McCain: I THINK THAT WE ALL IN CONGRESS
SHOULD PAY ATTENTION AND BENEFIT
FROM THE EXPERIENCE AND KNOWLEDGE
OF OVER 1,000 FORMER GENERAL OFFICERS AND FLAG OFFICERS.
THEY WANT THE MILITARY TO BE THE WAY IT WAS
WHEN THEY SERVED.
SOME OF THEM WERE IN THE RANKS
WHEN THE MILITARY SERVICES WERE SEGREGATED.
YOU ARE SAYING IT'S NOT WHETHER THE MILITARY PREPARES
TO MAKE THE CHANGE, BUT HOW WE BEST PREPARE FOR IT.
WELL, I'M HAPPY TO SAY THAT WE STILL HAVE A CONGRESS
IN THE UNITED STATES THAT WOULD HAVE TO PASS THE LAW
TO REPEAL DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL DESPITE YOUR EFFORTS.
Sarvis: EVEN WITH SENATOR McCAIN'S CHALLENGE,
IT WAS EXTRAORDINARY.
WE'VE NEVER HEARD THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES,
THE SECRETARY OF DEFENSE AND THE CHAIRMAN OF THE JOINT CHIEFS
ALL IN A MATTER OF A FEW DAYS
CALLING FOR REPEAL OF DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
SO IT'S AN EXTRAORDINARY DAY FOR US AND FOR SERVICEMEMBERS
WHO WANT TO SERVE THEIR COUNTRY OPENLY.
Jeh Johnson: I KNEW THAT WE WERE STEPPING INTO
A VERY EMOTIONAL POLITICAL ISSUE
THAT DIDN'T GET TALKED ABOUT A WHOLE LOT AROUND THE PENTAGON
OR AROUND THE ENTIRE MILITARY.
WE WERE GONNA REALLY BE STIRRING THE POT.
WE SET OUT TO SYSTEMATICALLY ENGAGE THE FORCE.
THAT MEANT A SURVEY TO 400,000 SERVICEMEMBERS,
WHICH WAS PROBABLY THE LARGEST SURVEY
EVER OF THE U.S. MILITARY, ASIDE FROM THE CENSUS.
WE SURVEYED 150,000 MILITARY SPOUSES.
WE GOT 72,000 EMAILS.
WE WENT AROUND THE COUNTRY. WE WENT OVERSEAS.
AND WE CAME FACE TO FACE WITH ABOUT 25,000 SERVICEMEMBERS.
AND THIS WAS A TOPIC THAT THE YEAR BEFORE NEVER GOT TALKED ABOUT
IN A GROUP LARGER THAN THREE OR FOUR.
Man: THERE'S NOTHING SERIOUSLY HOMOEROTIC ABOUT A SUBMARINE.
THERE'S THE OLD JOKE THAT, YOU KNOW,
100 GUYS GO DOWN AND 50 COUPLES COME UP.
BUT THAT'S REALLY NOT THE CASE.
THE SHOWERS ARE ALL ENCLOSED. THE RACKS HAVE CURTAINS ON THEM.
I'VE NEVER SEEN A NAKED PERSON ON A SUBMARINE.
IT'S BASICALLY A MOVING NUCLEAR POWER PLANT.
AND THERE'S NOTHING SEXY ABOUT A NUCLEAR POWER PLANT.
Erik: SINCE I HAVE BEEN IN THE MILITARY,
I HAVE HAD ONE INSTANCE OF TAKING A GROUP SHOWER
THAT EVERYONE SEEMS TO BE TERRIFIED ABOUT.
Marcus: IT'S LIKE THE ASTRONAUTS THAT HAVE TO ANSWER,
"HOW DO YOU GO TO THE BATHROOM IN SPACE?"
IT'S THE SAME LEVEL OF JUST, YOU KNOW, COME ON.
YOU KNOW? ( laughs )
Steinman: IF YOU'RE A GAY GUY IN THIS COUNTRY,
YOU'RE IN THE SHOWERS WITH STRAIGHT GUYS YOUR WHOLE LIFE.
AND SO FOR A GAY GUY,
IT'S: BEEN THERE, DONE THAT. NO BIG DEAL. WHO CARES?
BUT FOR A STRAIGHT GUY
WHO IS ALMOST NEVER NAKED IN THE SHOWER WITH A WOMAN,
IT'S A QUITE A UNIQUE EXPERIENCE
AND WOULD BE SEXUALLY TITILLATING.
SO YOU CAN SEE HOW HE WOULD PROJECT THAT ONTO THE GAY GUY,
AND THINKING THAT THE GAY GUY WOULD REALLY BE SEXUALLY ATTRACTED TO HIM--
TO THE STRAIGHT GUY IF HE WAS NAKED IN THE SHOWER TOGETHER.
AND SO YOU HAVE TO SORT OF TALK ABOUT THAT.
YOU'VE ALREADY BEEN IN THE SHOWER WITH A-- YOU KNOW, WITH A GAY GUY;
YOU JUST DON'T KNOW IT.
THE ISSUE ISN'T WHETHER OR NOT GAY AND LESBIAN AMERICANS
ARE SERVING IN THE MILITARY;
IT'S WHETHER OR NOT WE TALK ABOUT IT.
SO HOW ARE YOU GOING TO GET THEIR INPUT IN THIS SURVEY?
ALL RIGHT. ACTUALLY, I MEAN, MY TAKE ON THAT IS...
WELL, HANG ON A SECOND. UM...
I THINK THAT-- THAT WE WOULD HAVE TO...
LOOK VERY CAREFULLY AT HOW WE WOULD DO THAT.
DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL SHIELDS ITSELF FROM SCRUTINY,
FROM STUDY, FROM EXAMINATION,
BECAUSE IT PREVENTS GAY SERVICEMEMBERS FROM TELLING THEIR STORIES.
J.D. Smith: SOMEONE WAS BLACKMAILING ME
AND A BUNCH OF MY FRIENDS FOUND OUT ABOUT IT.
AND THEY GOT VERY UPSET ABOUT IT, SO THEY CREATED A WEBSITE
TO SHARE STORIES ABOUT PEOPLE BEING BLACKMAILED
OR IN BAD SITUATIONS.
AND WHAT WE DID WAS WE CREATED A HIDDEN FACEBOOK GROUP
TO CONNECT PEOPLE ACROSS THE MILITARY.
YOU'D HAVE TO BE INVITED OR BE REFERRED TO GET INTO THIS GROUP.
AND THAT'S HOW PEOPLE ARE ABLE TO SEE EACH OTHER,
TO CONNECT WITH ONE ANOTHER.
John: ONCE YOU MEET ONE OR TWO,
YOU MEET HUNDREDS OF OTHER GAY MILITARY.
Marcus: IT'S JUST THIS GEOMETRIC EXPANSION
OF THE WHOLE NETWORK.
ONCE YOU GET TO KNOW ONE GAY PERSON IN THE MILITARY,
THERE'S REALLY KIND OF A WHOLE LITTLE INFORMAL NETWORK
BUILT UP THERE OF PEOPLE WHO ALL KNOW EACH OTHER.
J.D. Smith: THE D.O.D. WAS GOING TO DIFFERENT BASES
TO TALK TO PEOPLE ABOUT HOW THEY FELT
ABOUT THE DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL POLICY.
BUT IF YOU WENT TO THESE BRIEFINGS,
YOU WERE TOLD NOT TO IDENTIFY YOUR SEXUAL ORIENTATION.
ANYONE THAT WAS STRAIGHT WAS ABLE TO VOICE THEIR OPINION VERY OPENLY,
BUT IF YOU WERE GAY, YOU COULDN'T OPENLY SPEAK ABOUT THE POLICY AT ALL.
SO WE WROTE THIS LETTER TO SECRETARY GATES.
WE WERE EVENTUALLY BROUGHT TO THE TABLE AT THE PENTAGON WORKING GROUP.
Man: AMENDMENT #79,
OFFERED BY MR. PATRICK MURPHY OF PENNSYLVANIA.
McCain: THIS IS A BLATANT POLITICAL PLOY
IN ORDER TO TRY TO GALVANIZE THE POLITICAL BASE
OF THE OTHER SIDE WHICH IS FACING A LOSING ELECTION.
THE MOTION IS NOT AGREED TO.
Sarvis: SENATOR McCAIN HAD THE VOTES FOR A DELAY.
AND THAT'S WHAT THIS VOTE REPRESENTS.
IT'S A STANDOFF AND TIME IS THE ENEMY.
David Martin: THIS WAS NOT THE LAST CHANCE
TO REPEAL DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL,
BUT IT MIGHT HAVE BEEN THE BEST CHANCE FOR SOME TIME TO COME.
Gwen Ifill: POLITICAL AFTERSHOCKS ECHOED IN WASHINGTON
AND AROUND THE COUNTRY TODAY AFTER REPUBLICANS
SCORED RESOUNDING VICTORIES IN THE MIDTERM ELECTIONS.
YOU KNOW, A LOT OF PEOPLE FRANKLY SAID THAT,
YOU KNOW, I LOST MY RACE BECAUSE I LED THE FIGHT
TO REPEAL DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
GOOD GIRL. DROP DROP DROP.
I'M NOT SURE IF IT-- IF IT'S TRUE OR NOT,
BUT AT THE END OF THE DAY,
MY JOB IN CONGRESS WASN'T JUST TO GET REELECTED.
YOU KNOW, MY KIDS, ONE DAY, WHEN THEY'RE GOOGLING THEIR DADDY
AND WHAT HE DID WHEN HE WAS IN THE CONGRESS--
YOU KNOW, WHAT DID HE STAND FOR? WHAT DID HE FIGHT FOR?
I WANT TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY KNOW
THAT THEIR DADDY FOUGHT FOR WHAT HE THOUGHT WAS RIGHT FOR OUR COUNTRY.
AND I WANT THEM TO BE PROUD.
Sarvis: THE MIDTERMS MADE IT MORE IMPORTANT
TO GET IT DONE THIS YEAR.
IT'S CHALLENGING ENOUGH IN 2010 TO DO THIS,
AS YOU HAVE SEEN FOR THE PAST 18 MONTHS.
YEAH. IT WILL BE EXTRAORDINARILY TOUGH.
BUT LOOK, WE DIDN'T COME THIS FAR TO GIVE UP TODAY.
THERE'S YET ANOTHER BREAKING STORY TO TELL YOU
ABOUT A FEDERAL DISTRICT COURT JUDGE IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
RULING THAT THE MILITARY'S DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL POLICY
IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL UNDER THE FIFTH AND FIRST AMENDMENTS.
Johnson: THE LOG CABIN REPUBLICANS' CASE
SENT US INTO, FRANKLY, A REAL PANIC
BECAUSE ON OCTOBER 11th,
WE HAD A LAW THAT WE WERE ENFORCING ON A DAILY BASIS.
THEN ALL OF A SUDDEN ON OCTOBER 12th,
A DISTRICT JUDGE TELLS YOU, YOU MUST STOP.
YOU HAVE TO TELL A FORCE OF TWO MILLION PEOPLE,
STOP ENFORCING THIS LAW ON A WORLDWIDE BASIS.
THAT HAD A REAL IMPACT ON SECRETARY GATES.
NOW THAT WE HAVE COMPLETED THIS REVIEW,
I STRONGLY URGE THE SENATE TO PASS THIS LEGISLATION
AND SEND IT TO THE PRESIDENT FOR SIGNATURE
BEFORE THE END OF THIS YEAR.
I BELIEVE THIS IS A MATTER OF SOME URGENCY
BECAUSE, AS WE HAVE SEEN, THE FEDERAL COURTS
ARE INCREASINGLY BECOMING INVOLVED IN THIS ISSUE.
THE DATA ALSO SHOWS...
Belkin: IT WAS A VERY POWERFUL MOMENT
FOR THE MILITARY IN ITS OWN VOICE TO SAY
WE CAN HANDLE THIS TRANSITION WITHOUT PROBLEMS.
AND THAT ACTUALLY MOVED A LOT OF PEOPLE
IN THE SENATE AND THE HOUSE.
Sarvis: IT'S A VERY IMPORTANT DAY.
17 YEARS AGO, PRESIDENT CLINTON SIGNED DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL.
NOVEMBER 30th, 1993.
NO KIDDING.
HOW IRONIC THAT THIS REPORT SHOULD COME OUT 17 YEARS LATER?
Gates: IN SUMMARY, A STRONG MAJORITY
OF THOSE WHO ANSWERED THE SURVEY, MORE THAN TWO-THIRDS,
DO NOT OBJECT TO GAYS AND LESBIANS
SERVING OPENLY IN UNIFORM.
Mullen: THESE ARE THE THINGS THE STUDY TELLS US.
NOW LET ME TELL YOU WHAT I BELIEVE.
I BELIEVE OUR TROOPS AND THEIR FAMILIES ARE READY FOR THIS.
MOST OF THEM ALREADY BELIEVE THEY SERVE
OR HAVE SERVED ALONGSIDE GAYS AND LESBIANS.
AND KNOWING MATTERS A LOT.
WELL, I COULDN'T DISAGREE MORE.
WE SEND THESE YOUNG PEOPLE INTO COMBAT.
WE THINK THEY'RE MATURE ENOUGH TO FIGHT AND DIE.
I THINK THEY'RE MATURE ENOUGH TO MAKE A JUDGMENT
ON WHO THEY WANT TO SERVE WITH.
WHY WOULDN'T WE JUST ASK THE QUESTION?
BECAUSE I, FUNDAMENTALLY, SIR,
THINK IT'S AN INCREDIBLY BAD PRECEDENT
TO ASK THEM ABOUT--
YOU KNOW, TO ESSENTIALLY VOTE ON A POLICY.
I CAN'T THINK OF A SINGLE PRECEDENT IN AMERICAN HISTORY
OF DOING A REFERENDUM OF THE AMERICAN ARMED FORCES
ON A POLICY ISSUE.
ARE YOU GONNA ASK THEM IF THEY WANT 15-MONTH TOURS?
YOU GONNA ASK THEM IF THEY WANT TO BE PART OF THE SURGE IN IRAQ?
THAT'S NOT THE WAY OUR CIVILIAN-LED MILITARY
HAS EVER WORKED IN OUR ENTIRE HISTORY.
PROBABLY THE ONE INSTITUTION-- CENTRAL INSTITUTION IN OUR COUNTRY
THAT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE STILL HAVE TRUST IN
IS THE AMERICAN MILITARY.
Sarvis: JOHN McCAIN--
FRANKLY HE'S BEING A BIT OF A BULLY HERE.
AND THE CLOCK IS RUNNING OUT.
WE STILL DON'T KNOW WHAT'S GOING TO BE THE OUTCOME.
WE HAVE TO MEET THAT THRESHOLD OF 60 VOTES IN THE SENATE.
AND WE'RE-- WE'RE AT THE BRINK.
AND WE-- AND WE LITERALLY DO NOT KNOW.
Reporter: AN EFFORT TO LIFT THE MILITARY'S BAN
ON OPENLY GAY TROOPS HAS FAILED TO GET OFF THE SENATE FLOOR.
THE LAST-DITCH EFFORT THURSDAY FELL THREE VOTES SHORT.
THE MEASURE WASN'T A VOTE ON THE POLICY,
BUT A PROCEDURAL MOVE THAT NEEDED 60 VOTES TO ADVANCE.
David Hall: I THINK WHAT I ALWAYS DO IS YOU ALWAYS LOOK AT AUBREY.
BECAUSE IF HE LOOKS UPSET AND IF HE LOOKS LIKE--
LIKE, "OH MY GOD," THEN I WOULD BE WORRIED. BUT HE DIDN'T HAVE THAT LOOK.
AND I REMEMBER HIM, LIKE, "LET'S LOOK AT THE PROCEDURES.
HOW DO WE GET A BILL FROM THE HOUSE TO THE SENATE
WHERE IT DOESN'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH COMMITTEE,
BUT IT CAN BE DONE IN DAYS?
BECAUSE, LIKE, WE'RE OUT OF TIME."
Steinman: MOST PEOPLE DON'T KNOW THAT WHEN THE CRUNCH CAME,
AUBREY SARVIS CAME UP WITH THE IDEA
TO HAVE A STAND-ALONE BILL VOTED ON IN THE HOUSE AND SENATE,
AND WORKED WITH SENATOR LIEBERMAN AND CONGRESSMAN MURPHY
TO MAKE THAT HAPPEN.
OKAY.
AND THEN WE'LL MAKE A COPY OF IT
AND THEN YOU CAN GIVE IT BACK TO ME.
ANYTIME I STARTED QUESTIONING MYSELF
WHETHER OR NOT WE COULD ACCOMPLISH IT,
I THOUGHT BACK TO AN EMAIL I GOT
FROM A COMPANY COMMANDER IN KABUL, AFGHANISTAN.
AND HE SAID, "I'M ON MY 4th DEPLOYMENT. I LOVE SERVING IN OUR MILITARY.
BUT NEVER IN A MILLION YEARS
DID I THINK WHAT HAPPENED TONIGHT WOULD HAPPEN TO ME.
THE PROBLEM IS THAT I HAPPEN TO BE GAY.
AND MY PARTNER, AFTER FOUR DEPLOYMENTS, JUST COULDN'T DO IT ANYMORE.
AND HE WROTE ME A LETTER AND LET ME KNOW
THAT HE WASN'T GONNA BE THERE WHEN I CAME HOME.
AND I FELT SO ALONE. AND I HAVE NOWHERE TO GO.
I CAN'T GO INTO MY COMMANDER'S OFFICE. I CAN'T GO TO THE CHAPLAIN.
I CAN'T GO TO A BATTLE BUDDY. SO I'M SITTING HERE
AND I'M CRADLING MY 9mm WEAPON
AND I'M THINKING ABOUT BLOWING MY BRAINS OUT.
BUT THE ONLY THING THAT GIVES ME HOPE
IS THAT KNOWING THAT ANOTHER IRAQ WAR VETERAN
NAMED PATRICK MURPHY FROM PENNSYLVANIA IS FIGHTING FOR ME."
SO HE JUST SAID, "KEEP FIGHTING.
JUST KNOW THERE'S SO MANY OF US THAT ARE COUNTING ON YOU."
ON THIS VOTE, THE YEAS ARE 250;
THE NAYS ARE 175.
THE MOTION IS ADOPTED.
MY WORK KIND OF FRANKLY WAS DONE.
WE GOT IT DONE IN THE HOUSE AND NOW IT WAS IN THE SENATE.
Sarvis: IN THIS CONGRESS, WE RAISE OUR VOICES AS ONE
AND SAY, "SENATORS,
KILL THIS LAW. KILL THIS LAW BEFORE YOU GO HOME."
DON'T GO HOME! DON'T GO HOME!
DON'T GO HOME!
DON'T GO HOME. DON'T GO HOME.
DON'T GO HOME. DON'T GO HOME.
DON'T GO HOME...
I'M-- WELL, I'M MORE THAN HOPEFUL.
I'M REASONABLY CONFIDENT WE-- WE HAVE THE 60,
UNLESS SOMETHING HAPPENED LAST NIGHT
THAT I DON'T KNOW ABOUT, OR THIS MORNING.
SO WE'RE FEELING GOOD. BUT NEVER TAKE IT FOR GRANTED.
SO WE'RE STILL CHECKING IN TO MAKE SURE THAT THE VOTES ARE SOLID.
UNFORTUNATELY, THE MAJORITY IS USING THE LAME-DUCK SESSION
TO PUSH AN AGENDA.
Lieberman: It's not a Republican
or a Democratic idea; it's an American idea,
consistent with American values.
WE HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY NOT JUST TO RIGHT A WRONG,
BUT TO ADVANCE THE VALUES
THAT THE FOUNDERS OF OUR COUNTRY ARTICULATED
IN OUR ORIGINAL AMERICAN DOCUMENTS.
TO THOSE WHO ARE PUSHING THIS PROCESS,
IT IS NOT APPRECIATED.
Gillebrand: THIS IS A POLICY THAT IS CORROSIVE.
YOU ARE ASKING MEN AND WOMEN WHO WANT NOTHING
BUT TO SERVE THIS COUNTRY, TO GIVE THEIR LIVES FOR THIS COUNTRY,
TO SAY, "NO, YOU CANNOT BECAUSE OF WHO YOU LOVE."
THE AMERICAN PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN,
AND YOU ARE ACTING IN DIRECT REPUDIATION
OF THE MESSAGE OF THE AMERICAN PEOPLE.
Evan Bayh: THE QUESTION NOW OCCURS IN THE MOTION TO CONCUR
IN THE HOUSE AMENDMENT TO THE SENATE AMENDMENT
TO HOUSE RESOLUTION 2965.
THE YEAS AND NAYS HAVE BEEN REQUESTED.
THE YEAS ARE 65; THE NAYS 31.
THE MOTION TO CONCUR IS ADOPTED.
Murphy: THE PHONE RANG AND I SAID, "HELLO?"
AND HE SAYS, "PATRICK?" AND I SAID, "YES."
AND HE SAID, "IT'S BARACK."
I SAID, "HEY, MR. PRESIDENT, HOW ARE YOU, SIR?"
AND HE SAID, "GOOD." HE GOES, "HELL OF A JOB."
HE SAID, "CONGRATULATIONS. WE GOT THIS DONE."
AND I SAID, "WELL, THANK YOU, SIR."
AND I SAID, "THANKS FOR ALL OF YOUR HELP."
I SAID, "WE DID IT." HE SAID, "YOU'RE SURE AS HELL RIGHT WE DID."
Barack Obama: AND NOW IT IS MY HONOR TO SIGN THIS BILL INTO LAW.
THE STORY OF DON'T ASK, DON'T TELL
IS THE STORY OF GAY RIGHTS IN THIS COUNTRY.
HOW CAN ONE POSSIBLY JUSTIFY ANY KIND OF DISCRIMINATION
IN ANY OTHER PART OF OUR SOCIETY
IF THE MILITARY SAYS IT'S OKAY FOR GAYS TO SERVE?
WHEN YOU PUT YOUR LIFE ON THE LINE FOR YOUR COUNTRY,
HOW CAN YOU THEN BE DISCRIMINATED AGAINST
IN HOUSING OR JOBS OR ANY OTHER SILLY THINGS
THAT UNFORTUNATELY THE GAY COMMUNITY STILL HAS TO SUFFER FROM?
Brandon: YOU KNOW, BEING GAY OR BEING BISEXUAL
OR LESBIAN OR WHATEVER, YOU KNOW, YOU'RE SERVING IN THE MILITARY;
YOU'RE SERVING FOR YOUR COUNTRY;
YOU KNOW YOU'RE POSSIBLY GIVING YOUR LIFE,
YOU KNOW, FOR THE FREEDOM OF THE PEOPLE.
Marcus: BY THE TIME THIS WHOLE THING AIRS,
I'LL PROBABLY BE IN AFGHANISTAN.
AND, YOU KNOW, IF ANYTHING HAPPENS TO ME OVER THERE
AND I DIDN'T COME BACK, YOU KNOW,
WHEN SOMEBODY'S DOWN ON ONE KNEE PRESENTING A FLAG
ON BEHALF OF THE PRESIDENT AND THE SECRETARY OF DEFENSE
AND A GRATEFUL NATION, I JUST WANT MY PARTNER--
I WANT IT TO BE HIM GETTING THAT FLAG.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.