All language subtitles for Episode 070 The Disappearance of Maureen Hale

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

The double jeopardy rule meant that

if you were tried and acquitted,

you couldn't stand trial for that charge again.

However, when the double jeopardy law

was abolished in respect of murder,

it became possible to do it.

The police sometimes will periodically go back

and look at cold cases

and they will review them to see if there are any grounds

for evidence to take them further forward.

In 2008,

nine years after Maureen went missing,

Colin got hold of the review,

looked at it and he was clearly not happy

at what he saw.

I mean, this was just a staggering piece of evidence.

His wife has gone missing two days before

and there he is offering a large sum of money

to use a crematorium,

an incinerator,

you know, the only use of those is to dispose of a body.

She disappeared and no-one knows what happened to her,

there was a lot of circumstantial evidence

against the husband.

I'd say he was shocked,

it was my opinion that he had no idea

that he was going to be arrested

or the police were even reinvestigating the matter.

The whole thing cost him his business,

it's cost him everything.

It was a crime of almost breathtaking...

The man who tried to kill her

will never be free to harm again...

The life sentence may provide some closure

for his victims' families.

Targeted young women unable to defend themselves.

Colin Sutton was a detective chief inspector

and senior investigating officer at the Metropolitan Police.

He led the investigations into some of the most complex

and high-profile cases ever,

bringing dangerous criminals to justice.

He showed his cowardliness...

Then the screaming...

..another 146 victims.

In this series,

we will take you inside those cases

and show you how he caught these criminals

using nothing but pure detective work.

This is The Real Manhunter.

Now been found guilty on all 25 of those charges.

The oldest victim, 89.

The officer in charge described it as a senseless tragedy.

The life sentence may provide some closure

for his victims' families.

Every SIO,

every murder squad in London carries a number of investigations

that are unsolved

and sometimes you get the opportunity

with new evidence or something turning up

that means it's worthwhile re-opening

one of these unsolved investigations.

There are a number of justifications for re-opening a stalled case,

an old cold case if you like,

quite often it's when advancements in science means

you can get DNA from the exhibit,

you couldn't get back at the time or another witness comes forward.

In the case of the disappearance

of Maureen Hale,

it was slightly more unusual circumstances.

It was a change in the law.

At the time,

her disappearance was investigated one would hope thoroughly.

Martin Hale was arrested

as prime suspect in her disappearance,

but it could never be established

obviously that she'd been murdered without a body.

That appeared to be no hope of taking the case any further.

So, her disappearance was literally chalked up

as a missing person.

Martin Hale and family continued their lives

without Maureen.

The double jeopardy rule meant that

if you were tried and acquitted,

you couldn't stand trial

for that charge again.

The fear with the Maureen Hale case was

if her husband Martin had been charged for murdering her

and was acquitted,

when her body hadn't been found,

at some point in the future,

the body might be discovered,

there might be really good forensic evidence on that body,

which will point to his guilt,

and it wouldn't be possible to take him to court again.

So, that's why it had been held back.

Colin and that team looked at the circumstances here

and decided that they needed to go with it,

and they needed to shake the apple tree

and see what dropped off.

And when we looked

at the circumstances

and when we were able

to kind of lay it out

and think about

what might have happened

to Maureen Hale,

it became an amazingly compelling case

and really it looked

even at the first review

as if we didn't need

any more evidence

that was discovered before,

but we did find some.

I joined Colin's major investigations team

during the case of the Levi Bellfield,

so I was part of the investigating team there

and I worked alongside Colin for a number of years after that

on other investigations.

I hadn't worked with Kev McSharry before.

but he had been around the CID in South West London for a long time

and a lot of people on the team had worked with him,

and when he became available,

kind of encouraged me to say,

you know, we should try and get him onto the team,

and not a single second of regret that I did that

'cause he was a very capable man,

he could be trusted through absolutely everything

and anything to a good standard.

And he did it all with a smile, a nice fellow too,

so he was a really valuable addition to the team at the time.

In 2008,

the Metropolitan Police decided to do a cold case review

on the disappearance of Maureen Hale

and that's when a fresh investigation

was initiated.

It was during the trial of Levi Bellfield

and obviously he was very, very stretched,

but he made sure he spoke to me every morning

because I was the case officer,

and my job was the day to day running of the investigation,

so we would discuss what was happening that day

and how we were gonna move the investigation forward.

We had to do the two simultaneously,

if we were going to really make some progress

with Maureen Hale's disappearance,

so that was why that was really given off

to another part of the team, and principally,

DS Kevin McSharry and DI Amy Perrot had a look at that

and once we were able then to finally disentangle ourselves

from the Bellfield investigation,

then Maureen Hale's disappearance

became a kind of priority focus for the team.

It was given to our team to revisit all the witnesses,

look at all the evidence and make decisions around

what direction that investigation would then take.

Maureen Hale was born as Maureen Weatherly,

and she got married at a young age, she was about 19,

she got married to a man called Agg,

so she became Maureen Agg

and they, together, had a son called Nathan.

And when that marriage split up,

she took Nathan,

he was still quite young then,

she took him with her

and then when she got together

with Martin Hale,

Nathan was adopted into the family.

And although they went on to have four more children,

Nathan was very much part of the family

and they always thought of themselves

as having five children.

Maureen Hale really fell nicely into her role

as sort of stock broker belt mother.

She didn't work, she didn't have to work.

Martin's business was booming,

and she spent her time looking after the children.

And then while the children were at school,

it would be coffee mornings and gym sessions

and socialising with the other women in the area

that were in a similar position to her,

and she had a lot of friends.

Martin Hale was essentially a self-made man.

He started off with the fruit and vegetables at Kingston Market

and by the '90s he had built up a business worth

over a million pounds

based at Western International Market.

It was wholesaling fruit and vegetables.

It was a lucrative and profitable business for him,

he employed two or three people.

And the profits from that meant

they could afford to live in Ember Court Road

in a five-bedroom detached house in the stock broker belt.

Maureen Hale didn't have to work,

she brought up the five children

and she became part of the local sort of mum's set

going to coffee mornings, making friends,

to all external appearances she had an idyllic life.

Martin Hale was a trader in here for many, many years.

He was one of the biggest wholesalers

in Western International.

I used to work opposite Martin,

did so for a number of years.

Very quiet man, just a decent sort of chap.

He had a very good catering business which did restaurants

and food service side that was very good,

he had the wholesale unit,

and then he had his retail unit as well,

which seemed to work very well.

Very hard working, very conscientious,

did everything right as far as the stand goes,

yeah, well run stand, good business.

But it did have its pressures for him though,

as it was a trade that works in the early hours of the morning.

It meant that for years he was getting up

at 2:00 in the morning six days a week,

and although he was home by lunchtime,

that sort of lifestyle puts pressure on anybody.

The hours are a bit off, it's got earlier and earlier.

It used to be a 5:00 start,

we're now here by 1:00,

some of the guys are even here at midnight.

There's two different sets to the business,

there's the wholesale business, then there's the food service.

The food services are 24 hours, they supply restaurants.

He would come home, and he would grab some sleep

and then he'd be back again

early hours of the morning

and it was a tough life in that way.

To the outside world,

they appeared to be a happy married couple,

living a comfortable lifestyle.

But in reality,

Martin and Maureen had a fractious relationship.

There had been suggestions

that he had assaulted her in the past.

Martin Hale working all the hours he can virtually,

Maureen's got her life with children,

taking children to school,

coffee mornings with the other mums and that sort of thing.

And it took a toll on their marriage

and then they started arguing

and that was when Maureen,

despite all the wonderful surroundings she had,

the home, the children and everything, thought,

you know, there could be more to life than this

and she started thinking about being with somebody else,

and that was what led her

into starting affairs outside the marriage.

Maureen being unhappy in her marriage,

feeling that she wasn't really getting

the companionship she wanted from Martin,

started to look elsewhere

and the first person

she turned to

was a man called John Potter

who was a local plumber

who'd done some work for them,

was friendly with them.

And that never came for her,

I think, she went out for a drink with him

and they might have had a quick kiss in his car,

but what happened was that for some reason Martin

had suspected something was going on between the two.

And he had put a recording device in Maureen's car,

and he had a recording of her with John Potter

and was able to confront her with it and she had to admit it

and it caused further conflict between them.

It's perhaps worth thinking,

you know, that most people don't feel

the need to put listening devices into their partner's cars,

there was obviously something going on,

some sort of suspicion in Martin Hale's mind

that Maureen was up to something or might be up to something,

otherwise he wouldn't have gone to those lengths

to record her in the car when she went out.

Clearly Martin Hale had a lot to lose,

if Maureen walked out the door and divorced him,

there were five children,

there was an expensive house,

there was a thriving business.

And she potentially had claims on all of those things

if they divorced.

So, the next time

she was a little bit more careful I suppose.

And she struck up a relationship with a man called Andrew Horton.

Now, Horton was a gardener,

he worked at the military cemetery at Brookwood.

And Maureen Hale had been there visiting with her friends

to look at the gardens and the flowers there,

got into a conversation with him

and they had exchanged phone numbers.

It's quite fair to say that

Andrew Horton was probably somebody you'd describe as a ladies' man.

He was not backward at trying to make new relationships

with women he encountered during his job.

Maureen, although she was absolutely devoted

to her children,

became disillusioned with the marriage.

And there were one or two episodes of severe arguments

between her and Martin, some domestic violence,

although not to cause serious injuries.

Maureen decided in 1999

that the marriage really wasn't gonna go anywhere,

and she needed to be out of it

and she was going to file for divorce.

This all came to a head on the 22 June, 1999.

It was the very day that Maureen Hale

had divorce papers served on Martin Hale,

and about 10:00 that night in their house here,

they had a terrible row.

Blazing noisy row that all the children heard.

Martin Hale's version of events was that at the end of that row,

Maureen Hale took up,

left the house and was never seen again.

The police sometimes will periodically go back

and look at cold cases and they will review them

to see if there are any grounds for evidence

to take them further forward.

In 2008,

nine years after Maureen went missing,

Colin got hold of the review,

looked at it and he was clearly not happy

at what he saw.

Maureen was still outstanding,

and the investigation had never come to a conclusion.

So, the Metropolitan Police decided there would be a cold case review.

When we started to re-open the case of Maureen Hale's disappearance,

the first thing we did was to repeat all those inquiries

that had been made nearly a decade before

when she went missing first of all.

So, we looked at her bank account,

her doctors, her dentist,

hospital records, all her friends,

all her family that we could trace,

and we got the same answers,

nothing, still no trace of her,

no brush with officialdom since 1999.

She disappeared

and no-one knows what happened to her,

there was a lot of circumstantial evidence

against the husband.

On the evening she was last seen,

she certainly had an argument with Martin Hale

and the children in the house gave evidence of this.

They heard a noisy argument

between the parents.

Coincidentally perhaps,

it was the day that Martin Hale had received

the divorce papers through the post

saying that his wife wanted a divorce.

It wasn't until 25 June, 1999,

some three days after Maureen Hale had disappeared

that her husband Martin Hale came here

to Kingston Police station to report her missing.

The missing person report was assessed

as they always are by a supervising officer

to see if anything else needed to be done.

No hide or hair was ever heard from her again,

she didn't attend dental appointments,

there was no money taken from her account,

she didn't take her son to a medical appointment,

which her friends found very strange,

and she missed out on not going to a concert

which she had tickets for

and had been eagerly looking forward to going.

For all intents and purposes,

she just disappeared into thin air.

And then finally in the middle of July,

so about two or three weeks after the missing report was made,

the police here in Kingston decided

to arrest Martin Hale on suspicion of murder.

They never had the evidence,

they knew they didn't have the evidence

to charge him with

unless he admitted it once he was arrested.

But it did give them the opportunity to interview him,

get his side of the story,

his account

and also to search both his home and his workplace.

The gist of the allegation was that Maureen

had wanted a divorce from her husband

and he didn't want to settle an expensive divorce claim

and lose his house and lose his children potentially,

and the argument was that he decided to kill her

rather than go through the divorce.

So, if Martin Hale were to be believed

and she just literally upped and left after the argument,

she'd done that without any

of the basic sort of necessities,

clothing, means of support, money,

means of communication,

means of transport.

No trace of Maureen Hale

existed officially after that moment,

she hadn't spoken to her doctor, her dentist,

hadn't used her bank account, hadn't used her mobile phone.

Everything was just dead.

There was no trace of her in any way.

She hadn't contacted any of her friends,

her other family and crucially

she hadn't contacted any one of her five children.

Everybody said that this was just completely out of character,

even if it had all got too much for her

and she disappeared,

she would still have maintained contact

with those children.

There were a number of things that were out of the ordinary

in relation to Martin Hale's business here

on the night that Maureen Hale went missing.

First, he called his manager and told him that he was unwell

and he wouldn't be in to work that night,

but the manager drove past Martin Hale's house

at 2:00am as he did every day,

and they used to sort of check

to make sure each other had woken up,

and he noticed that Martin Hale's BMW car

was missing.

So, he found this a bit odd,

and his boss had phoned him to say, "I'm not well.

"I'm not coming to work"

but when he went past his house in the early hours of the morning,

his car wasn't there implying that he was out somewhere.

You could say that was suspicious.

There were further circumstances which would have created suspicion.

When the manager got to work,

they found that there was a spade missing,

they had a spade that they use for clearing up the rubbish

and bits of old fruit and veg

and they had to find another way of doing it for a few days

and then Martin Hale brought the spade back to work

and he was not asked about it, and nobody said anything about it.

He was the boss.

He could do what he likes, but it was an odd thing

that he would want to use the spade at home for reason

during that period immediately after Maureen went missing.

Lastly, both Martin Hale as the owner of the business

and his manager had company cars,

but they were very different, Martin's was a 7 Series BMW,

whereas the manager had a little Ford Fiesta.

An employee of Mr Hale stated that on the night in question

when Maureen vanished, Martin,

Mr Hale had rung him

and said that he wanted to use his Ford Fiesta car.

He said, "Well, I just fancied a change,

"I'm allowed to change my mind,

you know, "they are both cars belonging to my business

"and I'm entitled to drive them,

"and I just fancied driving something different for a while."

During the course of the search of Martin Hale's house,

a briefcase was recovered

and within that briefcase was a list.

In his briefcase were the divorce papers

that Maureen had had sent to him,

and with them was a pad,

and on that pad,

in Martin Hale's own handwriting,

which he admitted to writing himself,

there was a numbered list of four choices,

"At sea, landfill,

"acid, by fire,"

and when he was asked why he had written that,

he said he'd been having some dark thoughts

and he thought about if he were to kill his wife,

how would he be able to dispose of the body.

And he had written that down as his brainstorming session

with himself, but of course he never meant it

and never come through with it

and never did go through with it.

He told the investigating officers,

the interviewing officers

that he was going through a black time at that stage

and that he used to make notes about absolutely anything.

He said, "Yes, I did write it, that's what they are,

"I was in a particularly dark place,

"but it doesn't mean I did it,

"I was just writing down dark thoughts."

Now, who knows why someone would have wanted

to write those things down,

but it could be argued

that it may be in the instance of disposing of a body.

When the double jeopardy rule was changed

and it became possible to try people twice

for the same murder,

then that really was the removal of the barrier to prosecuting him,

so that was why in 2008,

we decided to re-open the investigation thinking that

even if we couldn't find the body,

then we still had a chance for prosecution.

It's so difficult to search in this part of the world.

There's so many woods and forest and opens land,

we saw that in the Millie Dowler investigation

where Surrey police searched their county virtually continuously

for six months and still hadn't competed it,

there was no way that we could do a speculative search like that.

If we were going to search somewhere,

we had to be doing it on firm intelligence,

with a good idea that we were gonna succeed.

So, when it came to the searches that we were going to do

for Maureen Hale's body,

we had to be a little bit selective and the only place really

that we had any source of intelligence

or idea that it was a good place to look

was of course the family home.

They had a large garden

and we searched not only inside the house

and the building but the entire grounds

and that even meant as far as removing

a recently erected shed and looking underneath it,

we had ground penetrating radar there

to see if we can find areas of land

that had been recently turned open or disturbed,

and the whole thing took three or four days

and was quite a large operation.

But of course it came to nothing

and we found no trace of her there.

when the back garden was re-examined and that was dug up

to see if they could find a trace of her there which they didn't.

We dug up the patio

and we dug up areas of interest in the garden,

but we never found any body

or any bones or anything like that.

I don't think that they realistically

would have had any expectation of finding Maureen, wherein,

you know, lay the great problem with this case

because without her body

and the potential forensic opportunities

that might have thrown up,

it neither rules Martin Hale in as a definite suspect

nor rules him out as definitely being innocent,

at least in the eyes of the police.

During the course of the investigation,

we were contacted by a man by the name of Timothy Gilbert,

he was the manager of the Silvermere Pet Crematorium,

and he told us that around the time that Maureen Hale went missing,

he was approached by a member of the public

who asked to hire the crematorium.

There was another remarkable piece of evidence.

And Martin Hale was in the habit of drinking

in a sports club

which is effectively in the middle of Sandown Park race course,

but there is a bar and he used to go in there

and drink quite a lot.

And just a day or two

after Maureen had gone missing,

he is in the bar and he meets a man

he went to school with, went to primary school with

but he hasn't seen for 30 or 40 years.

And he's chatting to him and this man tells him

that he's now the manager of a pet cemetery

and golf course down in Cobham called Silvermere.

So, Martin says, "That sounds really interesting.

"I might pop down and have a look,"

and the man who he was speaking to,

the old friend thought that he meant the golf course

and he was interested in playing golf.

But Martin Hale turned up there the very next day.

And it wasn't the golf course he was interested in,

it was the crematorium.

He asked the manager

if he ever rented out the incinerators at the crematorium

and he looks at him, you know, aghast and said, "No,"

and Martin Hale then said,

"What if I were to offer you 20,000 pounds,

"would you let me borrow one for the weekend then?"

We found this quite interesting because it wasn't the norm

and we asked Mr Gilbert, "Was it the norm?"

And he said it was very, very unusual

for individuals to approach and ask to hire it,

not to cremate an animal,

so he found it very interesting,

and we also found it very interesting.

I mean, this was just a staggering piece of evidence.

His wife has gone missing two days before

and there he is offering a large sum of money

to use a crematorium,

an incinerator,

you know, the only use of those is to dispose of a body.

He just said, "No, that didn't happen,

"I went there, I spoke to the man in charge,

"who was an old friend from primary school.

"But I went there to look and talk about the golf course,

"not about the pet crematorium."

The legal position is when someone has been missing

and there is no proof of life for over seven years,

you can apply to the court to have them ruled

and deemed as dead

and that leaves you free to marry again

and also claim on any insurances or various other things.

You know, that the person is legally treated as dead then,

although there is no hard evidence of it.

As I understand it,

it was very shortly after that seven-year period was up

that Martin Hale made the application to the court.

The court had no option but to declare her dead

because there was absolutely no trace

of her being alive

since that day in 1999 when she was last seen.

Our thought was you know,

if you put everything we know about this case

in front of the jury, and you have got,

you know, Hale trying to lose his car

for a few days,

borrowing a shovel from work,

listing on a piece of paper

the ways which he might dispose

of his wife's body,

and then asking if he could pay a large sum of money

to rent a pet crematorium for the afternoon.

There's so much there

to build a circumstantial case

that I thought it was time we went to the CPS

and said, "What do you think?"

A file was eventually presented to the Crown Prosecution Service

and because he never had previously been charged

or taken to court and acquitted,

there were no double jeopardy issues,

and the CPS gave the go ahead for him to be prosecuted

on a charge of murder.

It didn't take the CPS very long

to come back to us

and say, "Yeah, we've looked

at this circumstantial evidence

"and we think there's a realistic prospect

"of conviction here,"

and that's the criteria they use,

"Go and charge him."

I was the arresting officer for Martin Hale.

Colin Sutton had decided that he wouldn't be arrested

at his home address

because we didn't want to bring any more pain

to his family.

So, it was decided he'd be followed away

from his address,

when he came to a stop,

we'd engage with him and he would be arrested,

unfortunately as we were following his car away,

the surveillance team lost sight of him,

and we bomb-bursted to all corners of Surrey

to try and find him.

I parked up in a Tesco's car park

and was reviewing what was said in the logs.

It said he left his home address with an orange carrier bag,

and as I sat in the car on my own,

I thought, "Halfords,"

so I drove to the nearest Halfords and his car was parked up there.

He came out of Halfords with another male,

as he approached his car,

I stopped him, introduced myself,

and formally arrested him and cautioned him.

I had never met him,

so I hadn't formed an opinion on him,

during the cold case review,

I met him on a number of occasions,

and I found him to be accessible,

he would always talk.

Pretty normal to be perfectly honest,

I didn't dislike him,

but I had a job to do and that's what I had to do.

GOOD EVENING

When Martin Hale was arrested, he was polite,

you know, he was a reasonable man.

He was a man who ran a business

and knew how to interact with people.

I'd say he was shocked,

it was my opinion that he had no idea

that he was going to be arrested

or the police were even reinvestigating the matter,

so when I formally arrested him,

the expression on his face I'd describe as sheer shock.

Martin Hale was arrested, interviewed,

and he denied knowing anything more than he had said before

about the disappearance of his wife,

that he had nothing to do with it at all.

So, we were always unable

to find Hale's body,

but nevertheless we went to court in 2008

and we were reasonably confident that we had enough evidence

that any reasonable jury

would look at all the facts

and conclude

that she must have been murdered by him.

The children didn't know which way to turn,

once we'd arrested him and charged him

because they've already lost their mother,

they've lived with their father growing up

into adults, most of them

and, you know, it was really difficult for us

to deal with them

because they wanted to be supportive of their father

and we sort of tried to deploy family liaison officers

to them as we would do

to the children of any murder victim.

But of course, the difficulty was,

the suspect was also very close to them,

it's a really unusual situation.

The children I'm sure were extremely traumatised

by losing their mother

and I'm aware that they supported their father

throughout the whole trial process

and didn't believe

that he could have killed their mother.

And perhaps even more so

because they'd spent the last seven or eight years

thinking their mother has deserted them

and they are living with their father,

so there is a lot of kind of conflict

and conflicted ideas and views

for those young people to understand.

It was something we were never

really able to come

to terms with satisfactorily,

the relationship that we had with the children

was always a little bit at arm's length.

It wasn't like

a normal family liaison relationship

because of that.

By the time the case came to trial in 2009,

Martin Hale had already had his wife, Maureen,

declared legally dead by the court.

Although we had to go

through the process of proving that

and making sure that we could find

no trace of her being alive,

I really don't think

that was an issue for the jury,

their sole issue was who killed her.

The defence case was clearly

that Martin Hale had nothing to do with it.

He couldn't answer anything more than he'd answered already,

he didn't know what happened to his wife,

she just left.

What they also did though

was they kind of exploited

the lover Andrew Horton.

Martin Hale was eventually charged with his wife's murder

and stood trial here in Kingston Crown Court

in January and February 2009.

What happened was that Andrew Horton who was Maureen Hale's lover

was called as a witness.

He gave a rather colourful account of his lifestyle

and his philandering and misogyny I suppose.

And he told the jury all about

how he would often have several lovers

on the go at the same time

and I don't think he really endeared himself to the jury.

And the defence then called a couple of his former girlfriends.

And the jury heard

that he had been violent towards them

and he threatened on one occasion to kill them.

There was some potential evidence against Martin Hale,

otherwise the case would never have been brought.

There was a note he'd written,

he didn't deny writing it,

in which he wrote about the various means of disposing of a body.

He'd gone to see someone about the potential

for using a pet crematorium.

There was the aspect of his fractured relationship

with Maureen.

There was some evidence that was never even presented

to the jury

in the sense that it didn't lead anywhere.

But Martin Hale had a reasonable explanation for

all of the evidence that was put against him.

The fact that his marriage broke down,

that kind of thing happens,

it doesn't mean that someone has killed somebody

or murdered someone.

It doesn't necessarily provide a motive

for killing his wife.

All that you need is a reasonable doubt

and all it needed was just a couple of members of that jury

to think this rather unsavoury character

who they see before them

could have been responsible for the murder.

It was a three-week trial,

and at the end of the trial he was found not guilty

and so allowed to go a free man.

It took the jury three hours to acquit him,

hardly anything in a long murder trial

as this was or a longish murder trial.

They must have been fairly certain

that there was not enough evidence to convict

and that he was therefore

not guilty of the crime,

the only way that could ever be changed now

is with double jeopardy laws and the discovery of a body.

I was sitting at Kingston Crown Court

waiting for the verdict

and it came rather more quickly than we might have expected.

And it's a fool's game really to try and read into that

because, you know, you can have guilty verdicts very quickly,

you can have not guilty verdicts very quickly.

But I guess given the amount of evidence

that I thought we'd presented to the court,

I kind of expected it to take a little bit longer

for the jury to deliberate through it,

and I was shocked,

I really was shocked

because I thought we had presented

a compelling case

and we'd worked hard at it.

And it was difficult really to see

if, you know, the jury accepted the evidence

that we'd discovered,

then I thought they were bound to convict him.

The children gave evidence in court,

saying there had been a row between their parents

on the night that Maureen vanished,

but their demeanour towards their father

was the all-important thing for a jury,

they would have been looking very carefully at that

and it wouldn't fail to register with them

that Martin's children were being supportive of him

in what must have been his darkest hour at that point,

facing trial for the murder of his wife,

their mother, a very difficult situation.

But the fact that the children didn't turn their back on him

would certainly have been a compelling factor in this case.

It's always difficult when you think you've got a good

and solid case and you go to court, and the jury acquit.

In this case, we had a mass of circumstantial evidence,

there was all the evidence about Maureen not having any contact

with officialdom with her bank,

doctors, hospitals, anything like that,

missing out on important family events,

walking out and never saying a word again

to five children.

You've also got the fact that on the night that she went missing,

Martin Hale borrowed a spade from his place of work

which he didn't take back for a few days

and bizarrely also at the same time swapped his 7 Series BMW

with his manager's car, which was a Ford Fiesta.

And he didn't swap that back

until after he had been arrested by police

and they'd searched the Fiesta.

But the fact is that

it is the prosecution who bring the case

and the prosecution have to prove it beyond any reasonable doubt,

if any member of the jury has a reasonable doubt,

they have to say not guilty.

It's always slightly disappointing when you get a non-guilty verdict,

but the evidence was put before 12 men and women

and they came back with a not guilty conclusion,

so we have to accept it and move on.

I think in this case,

there was a witness called Andrew Horton

who was Maureen Hale's lover.

What the defence then did was brought two witnesses

who were former girlfriends of his

who kind of painted a picture of him as this misogynist

and somebody who'd been violent towards them,

threatened violence to them,

and in one case actually threatened to kill her.

I remember watching Andrew Horton give evidence

at Kingston Crown Court during the course of the trial.

He was very confident,

and he came across as very believable

and that's a case of swaying the jury

with what he had to tell.

He had been involved in numerous affairs

and he had assaulted numerous ex-girlfriends,

but he was quite happy to talk about that.

I think it's easy to understand

how the jury didn't take to him

and the suggestion that it could have been him

and not Martin Hale that murdered Maureen Hale

was enough in some of those jurors' minds

just to provoke that doubt and that's all they need,

a reasonable doubt and they must acquit.

And I think it is the main reason

that the jury found there was a doubt

because the question was left hanging there,

you've got Maureen's lover at the time is this man,

who has a record of using violence towards women.

Is it possible, members of the jury, that he might have killed her?

I was surprised that the jury found him not guilty,

but our justice system means

that there only has to be a small amount of doubt

to go for a not guilty verdict,

so I can only assume that they thought

there was some reasonable doubt that he had not murdered his wife.

That's what happened.

Ultimately professionally,

you know, I did my job,

I got a team together to get the most evidence we could

and to put it before a court

and then the rest of that process kind of takes over.

Of course, during the trial,

the fact that Martin Hale

might have been in another relationship himself

was never put before the jury

and indeed it was difficult for us to work out,

we still really don't know

how long his relationship had been going on

and whether that was prior

to Maureen's disappearance

or something that occurred afterwards.

I think the depth and breadth of the evidence

that we presented to the court in this case

exceeded that in other cases that I had

where the defendant was found guilty.

At the conclusion of the trial,

the Metropolitan Police made a statement

to say that there was no further leads

for them to pursue at that moment,

so unless it goes back to another cold case review

or someone approaches the investigation

with some new information at this stage,

it's not being re-opened.

He seemed a very decent quiet chap,

yes, and still is a very level-headed,

calm sort of person,

that's as much as we know him.

The whole thing cost him his business,

it's cost him everything.

Yes, it's a very strange, horrible situation.

The law was served

and police officers in that position

have to expect that verdicts

are not always gonna go their way,

they may invest a long period of time,

a lot of resources,

they may spend weeks and weeks in terms of administration

that goes into mounting of a court case.

But at the end of the day,

it's a jury of 12 fellow peers,

the man and woman on the Clapham London bus

will decide whether a person is guilty or not quite rightly

and in this instance the world has to assume

that Martin Hale was innocent.

I'm overjoyed really,

it put some sort of closure on the case

and really I'd just like to thank my legal team, Richard Christie,

that's worked very hard on putting the case together

over the last few months.

There's not much really more to say on the matter at the moment.

I'm really just pleased to be out and there's some closure on it.

After Martin Hale's acquittal,

the Metropolitan Police re-assessed the case

and decided not to proceed with the inquiries any further,

the case effectively now is closed.

And one has to accept a course of a jury's decision,

but perhaps we're also entitled to look at why a case was brought

in the first place against a suspect,

there is still a mystery about what happened to Maureen

because her body has never been found.

We took every opportunity there was,

we found new evidence,

we found compelling evidence,

the only clincher may well have been

had we'd been able to find Maureen's body

because that may have given us some more scientific evidence

or its location might have pointed towards guilt or otherwise.

Martin Hale was found not guilty for his wife's murder,

so he is free to continue the rest of his life,

and in the meantime, Maureen remains missing.

It's increasingly difficult

in the 21st century

to disappear without trace

because everything has a record,

you know, your phone, money,

doctor, dentist,

all sorts of things like that.

And, you know, there was just simply no trace of Maureen Hale

from the day she was last seen.

Yeah, I'm sure she's dead.

It was the only case I did where there wasn't a body,

and it's also the only murder case

that I ever had that got before the court

and the defendant was acquitted.

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.