Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
He was by all accounts an ordinary,
nice, sensible young lad of 18,
growing up ready to make his way into the world.
Chris had been working at the shop at Tolworth
and his brother and a friend had met him there
and they were just walking home, in high spirits,
they were singing
and talking to each other, they weren't drunk.
They were just walking home together.
And then for some reason, nobody knows exactly why,
an incident sparks where a group attacked them.
When I opened the door instead of Chris and Phil,
there was two policemen, "Chris had been involved
"in a fight, he's seriously injured,
"we need to get you to Epsom hospital straight away."
I remember thinking this is not happening to us,
it's somebody else, they've got the wrong one.
It's not Chris.
What we needed to do was identify who was responsible.
It was a crime of almost breathtaking cases...
The man who tried to kill her will never be free to harm again.
The life sentence may provide some closure
for his victims' families.
..targeted young women unable to defend themselves.
Colin Sutton
was a detective chief inspector and senior investigating officer
at the Metropolitan Police.
He led the investigations into some of the most complex
and high-profile cases ever,
bringing dangerous criminals to justice.
He showed his...
Then heard screaming...
..another 146 victims.
In this series, we will take you inside those cases
and show you how he caught these criminals using nothing
but pure detective work.
This is The Real Manhunter.
Now been found guilty on all offensive...
..place charges...
The oldest victim...
The officer in charge described it as a senseless tragedy.
The life sentence may provide some closure
for his victims' families.
I found out about the case the morning after
it had happened, it was a weekend in May
and I actually had the following week
booked off for leave and I was meant to be
going on holiday for a week but,
you know, needs must
and they didn't have anybody else who could run the investigation.
I was asked by the assistant chief constable
to be the SIO for this murder
and he told me that an 18-year-old lad
had been murdered on the Ewell bypass
on the previous night and that at first the incident room
was at Epsom Police Station, so could I go along there
and meet the people who would be on my team
and of course in Surrey at that time,
there wasn't a permanent murder squad, if you like.
My name is Jack Regan.
I was a Detective Sergeant with Surrey Police.
I first met Colin Sutton as a result of this investigation.
Colin had recently transferred
from West Yorkshire to Surrey Police.
What happened was that you were appointed SIO
and then you were given sufficient staff
that were kind of selected from the various divisions,
so I didn't know...
But I hadn't been there very long anyway,
so I didn't really know anybody.
On the Saturday, I was up in the north-east
on a family do and I was contacted
and asked if I would travel back and assist
and manage the investigation into his murder.
I turned up in Epsom and found that the acting DI,
the DS who was going to be my number two,
and it was a fellow called Jack Regan,
and I'd never met him before, but he was one of these people
I just instantly took to really
and he was a very
different sort of character to me,
probably a bit more sort of sparky
and a bit more sort of expressive.
And then obviously on the Sunday morning,
I met with Colin
and I was updated on the investigation
and what had happened up until that point
and from then on, I was Colin's deputy
running the day to day management of the investigation for him.
This was the first occasion that I had met and worked with Colin,
and to be honest, I found him very open to ideas,
to new ideas, to suggestions both from myself
and from others of the team who were working this investigation.
I think it was one of those situations
where we had two people whose qualities kind of complemented
each other, and together,
we made quite a good team,
and it was great working with him.
Chris Donovan was a 18-year-old lad
unknown to the system,
the police had no knowledge of him previously.
Chris came from a family that were...
his mother and father, Ray and Vi, were very committed Christians
and regular church goers, and they had a daughter as well
as two boys and it was quite a close family.
There was something about Chris that was special, he was,
out of the four children we had,
there was something different
about him right from the start,
and he was very loving,
very kind to people,
very loyal to his friends.
Christopher had been a model son
really, and he had this ambition
after he got a little bit older that he thought he was gonna join
the police force, he was interested in becoming a policeman.
He wanted to join the army, I took him to Black Heath barracks,
he'd signed all the papers
and they found he had terrible asthma,
in fact they advised him to join the police, would you believe?
They said, "Join the police, do a few years in the police
"and when your asthma goes, we will take you on."
And he was looking forward to that,
he was really thinking about joining the police.
He was by all accounts an ordinary, nice,
sensible young lad of 18,
growing up ready to make
his way in the world.
Sometimes murder is like a lottery
and there is a chain of circumstances
where each individual circumstances by themselves
won't particularly lead to any damage or harm,
but when they all add up, those millions to one,
the coincidence, chance, they can result
in the most horrific events which destroy lives
and destroy the lives of those who love the victims.
The night of the murder was one of those situations
where you reflect on it and you think,
"This was so senseless."
At that stage he was working for a pizza company
and had been delivering pizzas and was managing a shop,
and to all intents and purposes, he was a genuine nice guy.
He was a hard worker as well, he'd work for 14 hours a day,
he worked for a local pizza company.
And one day he went in and found out there was a record
for the most deliveries in the day and he went,
"I'm gonna break that," and he broke it.
Chris had been working at the shop at Tolworth
and his brother and a friend had met him there
and they were just walking home in high spirits,
they were singing and talking to each other,
they weren't drunk
and they were just walking home together.
I asked him, "What happened, Philip?"
And he said, "We were walking along singing songs,
two boys stopped us and told us,
"You're singing the song wrong."
We had a laugh and a joke he said,
and they walked on, we walked on.
And then for some reason, nobody knows exactly what,
an incident sparks where a group attacks them.
And there's a hill, coming the opposite way on this hill
were 14 boys and girls, and they were drunk
and everything else and they opened up, he said,
to let us through, Phil walked through first
and the youngest one wanted to get respect from his friends punched him
so hard in the face, his nose ended up in his cheek.
This murder really was all about two groups of young people.
You had one group which came
from a party above the shops in this parade here.
They crossed the road and started to walk down
that side of the road.
The other group which included
Chris Donovan, his brother,
and their friend was walking down the road this way,
and it was when they were just about on that hill going up
the road there that they met.
And as they met, there was some sort of argument,
there was some sort of argument broke out,
it might have been about singing the words
to a song wrong, something as simple as that.
But of course, what you had is the group
that had come from the party, had all been taking drugs,
taking amphetamines,
they'd been drinking.
Sadly, events intervened in the form of this gang
of hooligans really, thugs, who were looking for trouble,
there was no reason to do what they did.
Whether there was a remark made, but it resulted
in what appears to be an assault on Chris and the other two.
Chris obviously tried to defend himself,
he was knocked to the ground and the witnesses describe
seeing him lying on the ground,
being kicked in a foetal position in the road on the Ewell bypass.
And you've got this fight going on,
it's midnight-ish on a Friday night, and it goes on for so long
that people in their houses hear it
and they come to their bedroom windows
and they're looking out.
That was very helpful for us as the investigation went on.
And all they see is this group of young people milling
about fighting each other.
And during that fight Chris Donovan
gets knocked unconscious,
he falls on the ground,
and while he was on the ground,
somebody kicks him in the head hard.
At that stage, it would appear
that the traffic lights
that are approximately 200 yards
down the road were red,
so there is no traffic travelling, they obviously changed,
went through the phase to green and then vehicles moved up the road,
the group dispersed that had attacked them,
leaving Christopher unable to defend himself
and in the road, and sadly he was then struck
by a passing vehicle.
He's unconscious at the roadway and there's a poor woman at
these traffic lights, she pulls away,
she drives up that hill and she sees what she thinks
is a bin bag or a bundle of rags in the road
and because there's another vehicle close to her,
she tries to straddle it with her wheels
and she drives over it and it's Chris Donovan.
And part of his clothing gets caught on part of the car
and she drags him along the road for 70 or 80ft
before she realises and stops and of course
that's caused him terrible injuries
in addition to the injuries he suffered from the assault.
The impact on the female driver was huge.
1:20 in the morning, our doorbell rings and I'm thinking,
"How can two boys forget their door keys?"
When I opened the door,
I was gonna give them a right mouthful
as you can imagine having to get out of bed,
opened the door and instead of Chris and Phil,
there's two policemen, they asked if I was Chris and Phil's dad
and I said yes, they said,
"We need to speak to you and your wife urgently,"
and I said, "What's it about?"
And they wouldn't tell us.
Vi got out of bed and they said
that Chris had been involved in a fight,
he is seriously injured, and we need to get you
to Epsom hospital straight away.
I remember thinking, "This is not happening to us,
"it's someone else, they've got the wrong one, this is not Chris."
We live about 13 miles from the hospital.
When we got there, Philip and his friend Richard
were in forensic clothing, Philip's face was all blooded,
as I'm talking to Phil, another policeman came up
and said, "You can't see Chris. We're operating on him."
And we just sat in that room, with Philip, holding him
and he was crying and shivering and shaking,
and it was like your whole world has just crashed in around you.
Then at 4:20 in the morning, we'd seen the doctors, the police,
the hospital chaplain, they didn't have to tell us,
their face told us, Christopher died that morning
because one 15-year-old coward wanted respect from his friends.
I ran out the door and I ran down the corridor
and I can remember a huge policeman coming towards me
and holding his arms out and he hugged me,
and he looked down and at me and said,
"We're gonna get them," and I remember thinking
"No, you're not."
We all felt that we needed to do the best job
that we could for Chris, his family and his parents,
Ray and Vi, who had obviously suffered immensely
as a result of what had happened.
Chris became what is known as property of the coroner.
He's not a crime scene, he's our son,
but we couldn't touch him, and I remember the policeman saying,
"I don't know how to ask you this, but is this your son?"
And I know a lot of young people disrespect the police,
but that man hugged me like a father that night
and cuddled me and cared for me, there is a human being behind
that uniform that we had to show people
that the police are not animals,
I have the utmost respect for them from that day on.
Two hours later, in walks another policeman,
his name is Colin Sutton,
as he walked in the room, the atmosphere changed.
I know that's hard to believe, the atmosphere changed,
and he just sits down on the chair, he didn't ask us to sit down,
he just sits down, looked me in the eyes,
didn't call me Mr Donovan, he went, "Ray, I will never lie to you,"
and the minute he said that he got my respect.
He then said, "I've put up an accident sign."
I said, "Why did you put up accident when its murder?"
And he said, "If I put up murder,
"no-one will come forward, trust me,"
and from that day to this, I trust that man.
So do you, don't you? Absolutely. Absolutely.
Something about him,
his personality, he's caring,
permeates a room when he walks in and it was the only thing
that we had that was strong,
we all felt so out of control at that time,
everything was taken away, everything you know
and hold dear is gone,
but this one person comes in
and they are strong and that is so amazing.
Being able to talk to Chris's brother and friend,
what became clear was that
these two groups didn't know each other,
there was nothing pre-arranged,
there was no history between the groups,
it was just something that happened
on the spur of the moment
as they bumped into each other on the street.
As soon as I was updated on what had happened
and the descriptions that had been given
by various members of the public
who looked out of their, mainly, bedroom, windows
because it was late at night to see what was happening.
It was clear that we had a group of assailants,
some of whom were responsible for the assault on Chris,
others who were merely standing by.
The fight happened and the place where it happened
was bordered on both sides of the road,
it's a dual carriageway, but there were houses
on both sides of the road.
And because the fight went on for some minutes
and there was shouting and noises,
quite a few of the local residents
were alerted by it.
What we needed to do was identify
who was responsible.
Quite unusually, I suppose we had a number of eyewitnesses,
people who could tell us exactly what was happening,
what they'd seen, and who was doing what
and that has become very, very helpful for us
as the investigation went on.
Another witness that we had was a very unfortunate lady
who'd been driving her car.
She was driving her BMW from Epsom towards Tolworth
and she left the traffic lights close
to where the murder happened, and by this time Chris Donovan
was unconscious and lying in the roadway.
This lady didn't realise it was a person,
she thought it was a bin bag or some rags or something,
and because there was another vehicle on her outside,
she decided that she would just sort of straddle it
with her wheels and drove over it.
And of course this inflicted horrible injuries on him
and this poor woman
was absolutely distraught,
and it completely wasn't her fault,
you know, it could have happened to anybody.
But that was another factor we had,
we had this lady who we were treating as a witness of course
rather than any sort of suspect.
It's a really unusual incident for that part of the world.
You don't get murders in Ewell really,
and people in the community wanted to help
and it didn't take very long for people
from the Watersedge Estate to be phoning in
and giving us the names of the youths
that were in this assailant gang.
And we had a range of youths from 15 years old up to early 20s,
it was one of those situations where the names were repeated,
different people phoning in had given us the same names
and so we were confronted
with the fact that the overnight team
had gone out and arrested them.
We had some people who had been arrested
on that Saturday morning as a result
of information coming into the police,
but what we didn't have
was clear descriptions of the clothing
that the offenders were wearing, and without having that clothing,
it would be virtually impossible to prove who was responsible
for the assault on Chris.
We had varying descriptions of tops, trouser bottoms,
we had baseball caps and we had descriptions
of at least one of them kicking Christopher
as if he was taking a penalty whilst he was on the ground.
We had all these people there, we could interview them
and try and get an account from them,
if they so desired
and if they were going to talk to us,
but ultimately, they were gonna have to be released on bail
and we were going to have to
have to carry on the investigation
until we found proper evidence
to justify their arrest again.
One of the difficulties as a result of Chris being struck
by the vehicle was that it was important
to identify to the court what killed Chris,
was it the actions of the people who assaulted him
or was it as a result of being struck
by the motor vehicle.
As a result, it meant that, unfortunately, further inquiries
and research had to be made into Chris' brain
to ascertain the seriousness of the injury inflicted.
While were outside, the coroner went,
"I've got bad news," and I said, "What could be worse than that?"
She said, "Because of the kicking and the car,
"I had to prove what killed Chris.
"To do that, I had to remove his brain,
"wait for an enzyme to come out, this takes 16 weeks,
"and you can't bury Chris for 16 weeks."
The injuries that Christopher suffered were quite extensive
and the pathologist was a guy
called Ashley Fagan-Earl,
he was very helpful in the sense that he was quite categorical about
what he said 'cause he looked
and examined every inch of Christopher's body
and he was able to say quite definitely
that the injuries he'd suffered from the neck upwards
were from the assault and the injuries from the neck down
were the abrasion injuries from being dragged under the car.
And crucially, he said,
"It's these ones,
"the assault injuries that killed him."
This therefore put the whole case on a murder footing.
One of the things that came out of the post-mortem
was that Chris had quite short hair anyway,
and they shave the head so that we can see more clearly any injuries
and on the top of his scalp,
there was a quite
a well-defined pattern of bruising
and it looked for the world
as if it were a print from the sole of a training shoe
or some sort of ridged sole from some footwear.
So, it looked like something
is stamped on his head
and we were little bit kind of confused by this
because if you imagine because it was right on top of his head
the circumstance in where somebody could
get to that position to stamp on his head would be
a bit difficult to envisage, you know,
if he was climbing out
of a manhole then you could do it.
But in the fight that's gone on,
we weren't quite sure
how that could have happened.
A lattice type of shape, or a shape, had been identified,
which the police initially thought
on scientific advice, forensic advice,
was from the sole of a training shoe.
And when we got the clothing and training shoes
from all the people that have been arrested
and started looking at them, there wasn't a pair of shoes
or pair of trainers that
just by observing it looking at it
matched this mark on Chris' head.
They arrested six suspects
quite shortly after Christopher's murder
and they took, obviously, the clothing
and shoes of the most paramount importance,
but none seemingly matched the imprint on Christopher's head
from the fatal injury.
It troubled me for a few days because I thought,
well, it's obviously that mark, that bruising is obviously something
to do with the assault, but it doesn't look like,
we thought, the stamp, and what I did was I went back
with Jack Regan two or three days
after the post-mortem
back to the mortuary,
and asked the mortuary attendant
just to let us have another look at Chris' head
because in my experience
sometimes bruising can come out more
and be more distinctive
after a few days have passed.
And then he lowered himself,
so he was looking at Christopher sideways almost face to face.
Pretty horrible thing to do unless you are that detective
who is looking for the opportunity to find that person's killers.
And in this instance, Colin got his moment of inspiration.
And it became obvious what this mark was,
it wasn't from the sole of a trainer.
It was from the in step.
It was the mark of where the laces have been
inter-crossed across the instep of the shoe.
Of course, that tied in perfectly with one of the witnesses
who described seeing somebody kick Christopher
"like a penalty kick,"
like they were taking a penalty, and of course,
it makes much more sense that if he's laying on the floor
then a kick like that would be easily land
on the scalp on the top of his head.
The difficulty with it was of course the way that your trainers
are laced up can vary each time and depends on
whether there's a foot in there or not
or the thickness of the socks you're wearing.
It wasn't possible conclusively
to compare the mark
on Christopher's head
with any one of the shoes we had.
It was then imperative that we identified the items of clothing.
One of the features of this investigation
was just the sheer amount of information
we were getting from the public, the public around here,
on the nearby estate, they wanted to help us.
And one of these snippets of information was that
two of the suspects had gone, before they went to the party,
by train to Clapham junction to score some drugs.
So, we came here to Stoneleigh railway station,
had a look through the CCTV and we had the two of them going out
towards Clapham Junction and then coming back later
just before the party.
Crucially they were wearing the same clothes, same colour,
same design as described by the witnesses of the scene.
So, that CCTV was added to the material
we were getting to try and work out who was who.
So, by working back from the time that we thought the assailant group
had gone to the party, we just kept going backwards and backwards
and backwards on the CCTV and eventually we find them,
all together in a group, walking towards the party.
One of the most important things
was trying to work out
who did what
and we had all these eye witness accounts
describing clothing and sometimes hair colour and saying,
"This person wearing these clothes
and with this colour hair punched somebody"
or "This person kicked somebody," but of course
none of the witnesses knew the identity of who that person was.
We trawled the local CCTV which gave us images both
in black and white and also in colour.
In particular one of the assailants was wearing a hooped top
which the definition in black and white was different
to the picture you got in colour,
so it clearly showed an additional line
on that polo shirt which the colour one
didn't pick up as clearly.
And we were able to really work out exactly what everybody was wearing
because they were all different,
people who had the similar colour shirts
on had different colour trousers on or something like that,
so they are all quite distinctive.
So, we then were in the position
where once we got all this information together,
we were then able to execute further warrants
on the people that we wanted to arrest
in relation to this and looking for specific items
of clothing and fortunately for us,
those items of clothing had not been disposed of.
When we had the CCTV evidence, they were re-arrested
and they started talking to us to a degree,
but each of them was doing that,
"Yes, I was there, but I wasn't involved,
"I didn't throw any punches, I didn't throw any kicks,"
what we had was like a matrix, like a spreadsheet
of all the witnesses across the top
and then down this side, the clothing they'd seen
and what they saw that person wearing that clothing doing.
And so they'd say, "pink shirt punched somebody,
"blue hooped shirt kicked somebody,
"plain blue shirt kicked and punched somebody."
We also had the situation where we had some accounts
being given in relation to certainly one of the offenders
wearing somebody else's top,
that it simply could not have been the case
because of the descriptions that we got
and subsequently we also got blood from Chris' brother
on a jacket which belonged to that assailant.
But the problem that I foresaw was that trying to express
that to a jury in terms of just giving them a spreadsheet
with Xs and ticks and things was just gonna be dry
and it was going to be difficult to convince them.
And we first had to be sure ourselves that we knew
who was wearing what
and what they did.
The issues we had were that this had happened late at night,
under sodium street lighting, so therefore that in itself created
some ambiguities in respect of light tops,
some people were describing a cream top
and some people were describing a white top,
it was obviously dependant on
where they observed it from in relation to the street lighting.
And I was just sitting down with Jack and we were just talking
it over like you do sometimes, just to how we'd do it,
and Jack made this throwaway comment where he said,
"What we try to do here is dress five tailors' dummies."
It became obvious that the best way to do this was to obtain
some mannequins, dress them in the clothing
that we had and take them back to all the various scenes
of the CCTV together with the scene on the night.
I discussed this with Colin, we looked at it and we thought
about it and Colin was in agreement that this was the best way forward,
it would give us a good visual image that we could use at court
that could be shown to the defence and would clearly discount
some of the minor ambiguities we had in witnesses statements.
So, what we did is we went to a local well-known store in Epsom
and they lent us six of their best brand-new mannequins.
We then got the clothing that we'd seized from the suspects
and we dressed each of the mannequins
in what we believed from the witnesses
that the suspects were wearing that night.
We didn't want to take anything for granted,
so although it was in September
as against the incident that happened in May,
we chose to make sure we had the right weather,
we had the same phase of the moon, we closed the Ewell bypass
and used the hydraulic equipment the fire brigade had,
so we were able to both video from the ground and from the air,
and at the same time, we then used video in evidence
from each of the witnesses' windows that they had viewed the scene
from to show that they had clear uninterrupted view
of what they had described they had seen.
This garage had, at the time,
a CCTV camera just above
where the cash machine is over there,
it may still be there or another one may still be there.
But it pointed out directly
across the forecourt
and effectively just across the road here.
And what we've then got is the group who ended up as the assailants
are walking towards the party on that side of the road
in that direction there.
And so we had that CCTV still, we brought the mannequins
with their clothes on, and we put the mannequins over there
and posed them in the exactly the same position as the CCTV still,
had still photographs taken and that gave us the two things
for the jury to compare.
Likewise, up in the shops up near where the party was,
there was a Thresher's off license and that's where the assailant group
had gone in to buy their drink before they went to the party.
Again, there was good CCTV there because it was indoors,
and it was well lit and it was in colour.
And again, we went back there with the mannequins
and posed the mannequins in the exact same position.
You know, we could literally have the still from the CCTV
in one hand and pose the mannequins
so they were in exactly the same position
and by doing it at night with similar lighting conditions,
it came out as something that could be compared quite easily.
What we did was have a police photographer
take still photographs of the mannequins
with the clothing on before we started
and we labelled them and said that these are clothes taken
from each of the defendants and put their names in,
but then after that, what we did was took further stills
from the same CCTV camera.
So, we were trying to recreate the conditions as best we could,
so the photographs were all taken in exactly
similar conditions, and it worked.
We didn't do this exercise with the mannequins
before we sent the clothing away to be examined
because obviously it was more important
to preserve any fibres or blood or any other evidence
that might be on these clothes.
And the only thing that came up
was there was a black jacket
which actually belonged
to one young man,
but he lent it to another young man
who was wearing it at the time, and they admitted this.
And there was a speck of blood on the sleeve.
And the lad that was wearing the jacket admitted
that he punched someone,
but he said he punched Phillip,
Chris' brother and during the melee,
he said he punched Christopher, the man who died.
He'd admitted to assaulting Chris' brother
because he felt that would put him away
from the assault on Chris, but clearly by doing that
he showed he was wearing the jacket which was then been described by
numerous members of the public and he was therefore at the scene
and involved in the assault on Chris.
Then he said to us, "If I arrest everybody in the gang,
"we could lose the case,
"let's just concentrate on the three boys
"that killed Chris, what the witnesses saw."
We went to a conference with the QC
that was going to be presenting the case
and he was of the view that the speck of blood
on the sleeve of the jacket,
because it related to the brother
of the victim and not the victim,
that we shouldn't proceed
against that individual.
And Jack was a little bit exorcised and excited by this
and he bubbled up and
was making an impassioned plea
to the lawyer and saying,
"You know, no, we've got them,
"we've got them," and it was
all very dramatic in some ways.
And then Jack subsided and I took the more considered view
and I just tried to take it
logically to the lawyer and said,
"We can prove he was there and we can prove
"that the blood means he punched somebody,
"it's a joint enterprise in the fight,
"he punches somebody and somebody he dies,
"even if it's somebody else,
he's still a murderer"
and as the best lawyers do, he saw my arguments right away
and said, "Yep, OK, I'm with you, Mr Sutton, we will leave him in."
We went to court a year later.
So, were there in witness protection,
Colin is there, liaison officers and Jack Regan is there,
everybody is there, and again
he's helping us through the situation.
And as we walked in, sitting with their parents in front of us
were the boys who murdered Chris
in this foyer, sitting right opposite us.
We had our friend from the church and one of the policemen,
one of the team holding us and they said,
"Don't move because he knew what we were thinking,
"you know, you just want to go up and smack them to be honest."
The eldest hadn't really come into much contact
with the police, he obviously had a difficult upbringing,
he lived with his mother and his siblings
and his mother tried her best.
In relation to the 16-year-old, he was someone who had started
recently come into contact with the police,
certainly he came from a good home,
his parents cared for him, they were concerned about him,
but it seemed at that time it was impossible
to divert him away from the group
that he was getting himself involved with.
And the story they had given was that they had gone
to purchase some cannabis,
but in fact what came out in the trial
was that they had gone to Clapham Junction
to purchase crack cocaine.
So, certainly, both of them that night had taken crack cocaine
and had also drunk alcohol
which is probably a good reason as to how this situation arose.
It was a stupid fight, weren't it?
Well, it wasn't a fight, it was an attack,
as two people fight, this was an attack.
It shouldn't have even happened.
It was just a senseless murder.
The trial was at the Old Bailey and it was in March/April 2002,
so it was 10 months afterwards.
The judge had applications
from the youngest of the suspects
of the defendants saying that
because he was so young,
could he be allowed to sit
in well of the court
rather than the dock
so that he could have access
to his lawyer at all times
and understand
the nature of proceedings,
and we thought
this was probably a ruse to try to separate him
from the older men who were in the dock.
The youngest, who was 15, he persisted
throughout the interview saying that he was not wearing his jacket,
which was the jacket that had the forensic evidence on it,
he insisted that he was wearing another member
of the group's jacket, that simply couldn't have been the case.
So, throughout the trial, the youths,
the defendants were kind of saying it was nothing to do
with them individually,
and while they weren't exactly pointing
their fingers at their friends,
that was kind of in the background, they were kind of like,
"I was there, but I didn't do anything,
"it was other people," it didn't matter ultimately,
it was a joint enterprise.
None of them accepted responsibility
in relation to this which is why we had a full trial,
each of them blamed each other and merely said they were present.
It was tough to sit and look at the boys who killed your son
and then lie for 6 weeks and lie and lie and you have to sit there
and just take that and say nothing.
The jury couldn't make their mind up, the end of the case,
it was a Friday, we were all sent away for the weekend.
We came back Monday
and they still couldn't make their mind up by lunchtime
and the judge said, "Get them out I a week."
They mumble in court a lot.
Then I think he said "I give
"2 out of 10 to two" went outside
and said "Should we go out and get a cup of tea, Colin?'
And he said, "No, they will be back in ten minutes
"and it will be a guilty verdict."
No-one was able to say who delivered the fatal kick,
but there was a cutthroat defence
with people blaming each other,
and three of the suspects were convicted of murder
under grounds of joint enterprise
and went to prison for a very long time.
They were all convicted duly of murder.
I think the judge in sentencing them,
certainly the youngest of the defendants
was given a recommendation of only six years
of his life sentence, I think the part he played,
the minor role he played in it was reflected in the amount
of...the recommendation given by the judge.
The sentence they got was, they got 15-year-old
who was 16 and he got life imprisonment 6 years.
The 16-year-old who's 17 in court got life imprisonment, 9 years,
and the 19-year-old got life imprisonment, 10 years.
No doubt that those thugs
probably never intended
to take his life, but their errant actions,
thuggery, and bullying really
because there were more of them as well,
ended up taking Christopher's life.
I think undoubtedly, on reflection,
the combination of alcohol and drugs
was probably the reason for this because none of them
had a history of violence as such and previously been involved
in this type of incident.
It really underlined the tragedy of this whole case
that it wasn't just one young life, Christopher Donovan, who was killed,
but three more young lives were touched by having
a conviction of murder
and it was all such a senseless tragedy
that it happened in the first place.
When you reflect on it, nobody wins.
We have a family that lost a son, we have three young men
who have blighted possibly the rest of their lives
and certainly spent a period of time
in custody as a result of their actions.
A lot of other people who had been touched
by this were members of the public
who woke up or looked out of the window to see what happened.
There was the poor lady
who was driving the car that struck Chris.
In court, I said to Vi, "Look at the families,
"take one look at them, there's no winners,
"we have all lost a kid today."
Ryan Seymour's dad came up and we were crying, we were crying.
It was so emotional, we didn't cheer, did we?
Like I said to Vi, no-one won here, we all lost a kid, we were crying.
And this man, this father walked up and he said, "I'm sorry"
and I just walked up and we hugged each other.
I think me and him had
the first restorative justice meeting
in this country with murder, and we talked and I said to him,
"Don't worry, no-one is gonna come up to your boy in prison,
"he knew we did prison work,"
I said, "No-one is gonna come up to your boy in prison.
"I just got what I wanted today, justice, that's all I wanted."
And Colin said afterwards, "I've never seen so much compassion
"in my life between two fathers."
Coming home that night in the car,
"I turned to Vi and said,
"You know what, we need to forgive the boys that did this."
I didn't want to forgive them, I didn't want to.
But what I did realise was actually
if you hold onto un-forgiveness,
it will just destroy you, it won't destroy them
'cause they won't care, they won't know.
So, I realised probably later on that it's about...
not about how you feel, it's just doing it,
it's a choice and you just do it and you keep doing it
and even today all these years later,
we're still doing that.
Christopher's family went on to use his death to try
and improve the lot of prisoners
and try to make the world a better place,
to try and make something positive come out of the negative,
which is a remarkable thing to do.
The remarkable thing about the Donovan family,
Ray and Vi Donovan, is how they reacted
to their son's death is that they are both committed Christians
and I think they have looked at the tragedy,
looked at the terrible situation they are in and thought
"How can we make the best of this,
"how can we turn this into a force for good?"
And with the Christopher Donovan Trust,
that's what they've done.
They go around to prisons, they go around to schools,
they talk about restorative justice,
they talk to people, to young people about their lives
and how they shouldn't waste them, and I've met people,
young men that they have spoken to who told me,
"If it weren't for Ray and Vi Donovan and their work,
"I would either be in prison or I would be dead."
They really have made a force for good out of the tragedy
that was the murder of their son.
The most important thing for us was that we felt
that we had done the best job we could
with the resources and the information we had
and that we were able, as best we could,
to show to Ray and Vi exactly what had happened on that night
and how Chris had died.
I think the fact that he allowed us to be kept in the loop
on everything as much as he could was really helpful to us,
you don't really realise, but when you look back,
you realise how helpful that was that we knew what was going on,
that they were doing this, doing that,
and it was so important to us, it was the one thing
we had to hold on to, knowing that we would eventually
get some justice for Chris.
Wherever we go around the country or around the world,
wherever we go, he's our story.
If it weren't for him, we wouldn't have got justice, I know that.
To put your whole life and your trust in that one person
is quite something when everything is out of control,
I can tell you, to know that they have got your back.
He really cared.
He wasn't a policeman "This is my job,"
he was a man who cares about the people he's working for.
It's an unusual gift, isn't it?
It's a wonderful gift, isn't it?
We don't know how grateful and lucky
we really, really are to have him,
you know, and goodness knows how many people
he has treated like that.
He's just always there, isn't he?
Absolutely, I think he will always be there,
he's part of our life.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.