All language subtitles for Panorama.2021.04.12.The.River.Polution.Scandal.1080p.HDTV_Eng

Tonight, on Panorama,

the scandal of our polluted rivers.

Get ready, it's coming.

Oh.

Here we go.

You can smell it.

You can see the steam
coming off of it.

We capture evidence of untreated
sewage being dumped.

It's just started to flow.

Just as I'm stood here talking now,
I've just heard it start.

We see the damage sewage causes...

That is disgusting!

Ugh!

..and we expose the water
companies breaking the law.

All of this is illegal.

Wow!

And this is a month's worth of data.

We're looking at them
spilling untreated sewage

for over half a month.

The Thames is
a world-famous river,

and it's a central
part of London life.

But despite its importance,
parts of the river are being

used as an open sewer.

This is Barnes,
in South-West London.

Now, the river's pretty low
at the moment, so I'm standing

on what you might think
is the riverbed.

Except, it isn't.

It's a mound of wet wipes.

Ugh!

It's just...

Look at these.

It's just wet wipes after wet
wipes after wet wipes.

It's just everywhere, you know?

How can we live like this?

Debbie Leach runs a river
charity that's campaigning

to clean up the Thames.

It's about the size
of two tennis courts.

And who knows what's
down there in the river?

This is just what we can see.

You don't really realise what it is
until you get down in this...

Yeah.
..and you start really

prodding around it.
Yeah, yeah.

I mean, every time the stick goes
in, wet wipes come out.

And when you're standing up
there on the riverbank,

you assume this is just
mud and sand, but it's not.

It's an artificial construct.
Yeah.

We call this the
Great Wet Wipe Reef.

This is thoroughly
depressing, isn't it?

It's shocking, it really is.

Debbie, where are all
these coming from?

It's coming from the sewage system.

These wet wipes are being
flushed down the loos,

getting into the system.

Wet wipes shouldn't be
flushed down the loo,

and they shouldn't end up
in the river.

This is raw sewage.

This is everyone's excrement
going into the River Thames.

The river that people love
and want to enjoy and picnic by.

It's absolutely obscene.

Thames Water says it's spending
£4 billion on a new super sewer

for London, and that it will deliver
a huge reduction in discharges

into the Thames when it's
completed, in 2024.

At the moment, the system relies
on pipes like these.

They're called storm overflows.

Sewers don't just carry
sewage from our homes,

rainwater pours into them too and,
sometimes, that combination can

overwhelm the system.

These pipes are designed
to act as release valves

in very wet weather,
allowing water companies

to dump untreated sewage
directly into the river.

The problem is that storm overflows
are being used much too frequently.

In 2020, the water companies used
them 403,000 times in England alone,

pumping out sewage for a staggering
3.1 million hours.

The water industry says it's trying
to use them less often.

In periods of high ground water,
intense rain and storms,

there's a risk that the sewer
network simply gets overloaded,

and we absolutely can't have sewer
flooding in people's homes

and businesses, so overflows
allow it to be released

into the environment.

But this isn't exceptional, is it?

This is commonplace.

There's more monitoring than ever,
and that's going to give us more

data than we've ever had before,
and companies are committed

to reducing the use
of overflows into the future.

Some of the storm overflows are
located at sewage treatment works.

You might think treatment works
treat all the sewage that comes

in but, in wet weather,
they're also allowed to dump

untreated sewage in the river.

This is the
River Wharfe, in Yorkshire.

Mark Barrow has been filming
underwater here for years.

The last ten years of my filming
around the UK in the rivers,

I am seeing more and more sewage
entering the river.

And I would say now 95% of my dives,
I will encounter sewage,

or wipes, or sanitary towels,
some form of waste product that's

been flushed down the toilet.

I'm in the river and then,
all of a sudden, you've got this

wall of silt that literally hits
you straight in the face.

And you know immediately what it is,
because it's mixed in with sanitary

waste, and then I have to get out.

And it's not uncommon for me to get
out of the water and literally be

draped in these products.

It's vile.

One of the culprits
is Wetherby Treatment Works.

Yorkshire Water says some sewage
debris entered the river here,

but faults were quickly repaired
and clean-ups followed.

It says Wetherby
is operating legally.

But we don't think that's true.

Mark filmed the works
dumping untreated sewage

on a dry day last year.

It's the 5th of November...

and we literally have had no
rain whatsoever today,

and we've got sewage spewing in.

In fact, it hadn't rained for two
days, so the dumping looks illegal.

Mark also filmed sewage being dumped
on several other days last year.

It literally started flowing
about five minutes ago.

We've had rainfall during the day,
but nowhere near has this been

exceptional rainfall.

It's just been what
I call normal rain

and, yet again, this is flowing.

But we've discovered Yorkshire Water
didn't report any of this.

The company told the Environment
Agency that Wetherby didn't dump any

untreated sewage last year.

Yorkshire Water told
us - if it happened,

it was a single data anomaly.

It will investigate and submit
correct data if there has been

an unreported discharge.

When we film with Mark,
the overflow starts

dumping sewage again.

It's just started to flow.

Just as I'm stood here talking now,
I've just heard it start.

We're in flow.

It's starting.

I mean, that shouldn't be flowing.

We've got sunshine.

The rain we had today
was just a shower.

You explain that to me, because
I can't get my head round it.

It's that smell.

It's...

You don't even have to see it
to know what it is because it just

hits the back of the nasal cavity.

Yorkshire Water says it aims to help
deliver good ecological status

for the whole river by 2027.

It is a complex issue,
which requires significant

investment over a long
period of time.

The company says it's committed
to reducing environmental harm

and is working closely
with the Government.

The Government has set up
a Storm Overflows Task Force

and is promising new laws to help
stop sewage pollution.

This is something that,
historically, has been

going on for a very long time,
but that's something that both

the water companies and government
now are tackling with a great deal

of speed and urgency,
and rightly so.

As the Environment Minister,
I'm making this a priority.

So, I take what you say,
it is serious, it needs

tackling, we're tackling it.

Six out of seven rivers in England
are not in good ecological health.

There are many causes of pollution.

Sewage is one of the worst.

Untreated sewage is normally
screened and passed through storage

tanks before it's dumped,
but that doesn't remove

the harmful pollutants.

You can smell the approach.

Yeah, I can, there's a definite
whiff of sewage in the air.

I've come to a Thames Water plant
at Witney, in Oxfordshire.

Ashley Smith wants to show me
the storm overflow.

And that's coming out
of that square, out there.

You can see the...

Oh!
..the water billowing.

He says it's been dumping untreated
sewage for the past 14 days.

And this really shouldn't be
spilling, except for

exceptional circumstances?

If there's an exceptional
rainfall - heavy rainfall,

or heavy snow that's melting -
then we'd expect to see that coming

out for a short period of time,
but not for days, and not for weeks.

Wow!

And it's definitely
coming out today.

We can see the sort
of current and the swirls.

Yeah, sure.
Yeah, you can, yeah.

That water that's coming out
of there is that classic,

signature sewage grey.

Thames Water says the sewage
is partially treated -

because it's screened and settled
in storage tanks - but you can see

what it does to the river.

You can see the fungus here already,
just in that margin there.

You see that?
What do you mean, fungus?

See that gooey, grey, browny-grey
gloopy stuff sticking to it?

Yeah.

That is sewage fungus?
Yeah.

It's actually a bacteria,
but it's called sewage fungus.

It's absolutely battered with it.

Now, this might be the most
disgusting thing I've done

in a while, but I can't resist
having a closer look at this,

so I want to just see if...
Yeah.

..I can get a bit out.

The whole thing is smothered
in this gunk and this slime.

Yeah, yeah.

I have to say, the smell gives
you a clue of what's causing it.

Yeah.
And there's so much of it.

I mean, it is just deep here.

Absolutely tonnes of it.
Look at all of that.

That is disgusting!

Ugh!

Thames Water says the sewage
spill at Witney was due

to very wet weather,
and it's planning a major increase

to the treatment capacity
of the sewage works.

give

It's the Environment Agency's
job to police water

companies in England.

It only prosecuted water
companies for dumping sewage

four times last year.

The Agency declined to be
interviewed, but told us

the regulations are clear
and are enforced robustly.

The Environment Agency has a duty
to police this space.

They have to do the checking,
they have to do the monitoring

and they do the enforcement.

Do you think that enforcement
is up to scratch?

If more needs to be done,
they must do more.

If sewage is going into our waters
when it shouldn't be,

and there is evidence and data,
some action has to be taken.

That is...

That is how we keep the environment
clean and well looked

after and sustainable.

But some water companies
are breaking the law.

This storm overflow
is on the River Usk, in Wales.

There's loads of paper,
toilet roll, sanitary towels

in the trees over there.

Up, and off you go again.

Look at that.

Absolutely foul.

So, this...

This is how we treat
our protected rivers.

Local resident Angela Jones has
recorded untreated sewage

being dumped several times a day.

I can't tell you what this
is doing to the wildlife.

The Usk is a protected river.

It's a site of special scientific
interest and a special

area of conservation.

Angela swims in it every day.

For me, wild swimming
is very much who I am.

I wouldn't know anything else,
and it feels the most natural place

in the whole world to be.

This is my office and my playground.

Nature has big arms to put around
you and embrace you.

But it also has a stony toe
to remind you who's boss.

Storm overflows are
supposed to have permits.

But we have discovered Welsh Water
doesn't have a permit for the one

Angela has been filming.

So the dumping here is illegal.

Get ready, it's coming.

Oh!

Here we go.

Ugh.

You can smell it.

You can see the steam
coming off of it.

Look at it spewing, look
at the colour it comes out.

It's a horrible grey colour.

I can see bits of - floating bits.

I presume that's some
sort of toilet paper.

There's toilet paper
and stuff in it.

I can't quite believe this.

This is just...

I don't know, I feel so distressed
and upset that we've got a protected

river that we really,
really aren't protecting.

This is really not good enough.

It's not.

You know?

And you can hear it now,
it's just starting to go,

and I'm sure we're going to get
another surge of sewerage

coming out now.

Welsh water is a not-for-profit
company and says it has invested

more than £1 billion
in its waste water network.

It says it hopes to have a permit
for the overflow by July.

But right now it is illegally
dumping untreated sewage

into a protected river.

Water companies do take these
matters extremely seriously.

That's why they are spending over
£1 billion over five years

to tackle this challenge.

Would you be happy to swim
in a river where untreated

sewage is being dumped?

I think I would want
to know that the river

was safe from every aspect.

Including how much untreated sewage
is there that might make you ill?

I'm a keen swimmer.

I absolutely would want
to know that it was safe.

Everyone wants to see
our rivers cleaner.

They are not clean enough
at the moment, and everybody

is working hard towards that goal.

We think we can show that some
water companies have been

regularly breaking the law
at sewage treatment works.

They can only legally dump
sewage at these sites

if two conditions are met.

Firstly, there has
to be wet weather.

And secondly, the treatment works
has to be dealing with a lot

more sewage than normal.

There are about 9,000 sewage
treatment works in the UK and most

of them will have one of these.

It's a permit from the regulator
which specifies how much sewage must

be treated before the treatment
works can dump untreated

sewage into a river.

But we found sites that
are spilling before they reach

the specified level.

They're dumping sewage
they should be treating.

So on the left-hand side
we have the flow going

into the works in litres per second.

And on the right we've got some time
stamped data telling

us when it is spilling
into the river.

Retired Professor Peter Hammond
is a campaigner for clean rivers.

He's analysed data from Thames Water
and converted it into graphs.

So this example right in front of us
now, which treatment works is this?

This is Stanton Harcourt.

Data from 2019 and
2020 shows Stanton

Harcourt in Oxfordshire dumping
untreated sewage into a tributary of

the Thames.

It's illegal because the works isn't
treating enough sewage

to allow it to legally
dump in the river.

So the blue line's representing
the amount that's being

treated at the sewage
treatment works.

The red line indicates the minimum
level at which they should

be treating when they're spilling.

The deal is if you're ever
going to spill sewage into a river,

that blue line has to meet
the red line?

Yes.

Peter's added a black line on top
to show when the works is spilling

untreated sewage.

So when we see these black
lines here that's when

the blue lines should
be above the red line.

But it isn't.

It's always below.

So all of this is illegal.

Wow.
And this is a month's worth of data.

We're looking at them spilling
untreated sewage, in fact,

dumping untreated sewage here,
for over half a month.

And it gets worse.
Really?

It gets worse because
if you then look

at November and December
it's spilling every day

throughout those months.

And then we go into January 2020.

Spilling, you can see the black
line, and then February and

then March.

So in other words, it spills
for six months almost

continuously.

And you can imagine what effect
that will have on quite

a small river that this sewage
treatment works discharges into.

Wow.

Thames Water says that the issues
at Stanton Harcourt will be

addressed by an upgrade in 2025.

You've done this for
a number of works.

How often are you seeing
examples like this?

Unfortunately, quite regularly.
This is not a one-off.

And the evidence is that it's
happening elsewhere in the country.

This is one of the worst offenders.

The giant Mogden Treatment
Works in London.

It treats waste from more
than 2 million people.

Remember, the site is only supposed
to dump if the amount of

sewage being treated exceeds
the level stipulated in its permit.

So the blue line has
to hit the red line.

But it doesn't come close.

And yet the black
line shows the giant

Mogden works was regularly dumping
untreated sewage anyway.

This treatment works
dumped untreated

sewage on 43 days last year.

We've looked at the
data and believe it

breached its permit on every
single one of those days.

That's billions of litres
of sewage illegally dumped

into the Thames.

Thames Water says that Mogden
and a small number of

its sewage works have struggled
following periods of heavy rainfall.

The company says it's investing
heavily and hasn't paid shareholders

for three years.

It says it has "firm commitments
to provide the required

additional capacity."

"Putting untreated
sewage into rivers is

unacceptable to us, even
when legally permitted."

We wanted to find out
what was going on elsewhere.

So we sent environmental information
requests to the other ten water

companies in England and Wales.

We've spent months going
through the figures to work out

exactly how sewage was being dumped
in our rivers.

Our research makes one thing clear,
the big water companies are

regularly breaching their permits.

Our data suggests that seven
of the ten companies has sites that

have dumped sewage illegally.

Water companies in
England and Wales have

been breaching their permits.

The matter of permits
and any breaches

is a matter for the regulator.

But be assured, water companies
will take that extremely seriously.

They are committed to the highest
possible standards.

Why are they breaking the law?

Nobody wants to see
discharges in the river.

But this is potentially
criminal, isn't it?

Water companies, they won't
always get things right.

Where there is an issue
they deal with it.

But that's not what we found.

Take Welsh Water.

Our data shows three of its
treatment works have also dumped

sewage illegally.

One of them is Aberbaiden.

The plant is only allowed
to discharge untreated

sewage when the blue
line hits the red.

But the black line shows it was
dumping illegally for days on end

last December.

It's happening on the same river
where we filmed the storm

overflow without a permit.

Once again, Welsh Water is dumping
untreated sewage into the protected

River Usk.

They shouldn't go black
when the blue line is that low.

I've come back to show river swimmer
Angela Jones our evidence.

So what we're seeing
here, zoom into the

3rd and the 4th of
November, for example.

Yeah?

It is nowhere near,
100%, the red line.

Yeah, I can see.

So from the 3rd to the 4th they're
spilling for 25 hours into

the River Usk untreated sewage.

Oh, my goodness.

Let me take you to the next month
at that site, so this is

the Christmas just gone.

The spill just goes on and on.

On and on and on and on.

Exactly.
Crikey.

All the way through to the 30th.

25th, Christmas Day.

Were you swimming in
the river on Christmas Day?

Oh, my goodness, of course I was.

I mean, every day.

What a Christmas treat
for the river, eh?

I know so many people
who swim up that area.

It's just appalling,
absolutely appalling.

I can imagine the work that's
behind-the-scenes that you've

put into this to get this out there,
and it's absolutely...

To look at this on my
screen and what you've

come up with today is
absolutely staggering.

We can see by these graphs
clearly that they are

releasing sewage into the water
when they are not allowed to.

Welsh Water says its
Aberbaiden works is

experiencing some bedding in issues
following an upgrade.

These should be sorted
out by December.

The company says it works
with regulators to fix problems.

It does "not accept it's
operating illegally"

at any of the sites.

It says it continues
to "invest significantly"

and works hard to "comply
with all environmental regulations".

If we are finding
they're breaching their

permits, which they are,
and illegally dumping sewage, what

should happen?

Well, we have a due process
to follow about how the

systems have to operate
to keep our water clean.

And that's what should happen.

Are you going to get tough
with the water companies now?

Isn't it the case
they've got away with

too much for too long?

I have already got off
the water companies.

I called them all in to
a roundtable, so I am not

messing about with this,
and nor is the government.

But our evidence shows some rivers
aren't being protected.

Just think of everything
you've put down your

sink, your toilet, your shower
and everything else.

This is going into
the river untreated.

Does anyone think that's
possibly a good idea?

We need to change.

The companies need to alter
what they're doing and

get their act completely cleaned
up once and for all.

The water companies say
they are investing.

But surely it's time they stopped
dumping so much untreated sewage.

Time they stopped breaking the law.