All language subtitles for RBG 2018 DOCU

af Afrikaans
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bn Bengali
bs Bosnian
bg Bulgarian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English Download
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
km Khmer
ko Korean
ku Kurdish (Kurmanji)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Lao
la Latin
lv Latvian
lt Lithuanian
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
ne Nepali
no Norwegian
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt Portuguese
pa Punjabi
ro Romanian
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
st Sesotho
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhala
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
te Telugu
th Thai
tr Turkish
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
or Odia (Oriya)
rw Kinyarwanda
tk Turkmen
tt Tatar
ug Uyghur
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:00:06,000 --> 00:00:12,074 2 00:01:03,780 --> 00:01:07,873 MICHAEL SAVAGE: This witch. This evildoer. This monster. 3 00:01:08,014 --> 00:01:10,137 MARK LEVIN: She has no respect for the traditions 4 00:01:10,173 --> 00:01:11,884 of our Constitution, none. 5 00:01:11,920 --> 00:01:15,939 DONALD TRUMP: An absolute disgrace to the Supreme Court . 6 00:01:15,975 --> 00:01:18,863 RICK WILES: She's one of the most vile human beings. 7 00:01:18,899 --> 00:01:20,307 SCOTT LIVELY: She's very wicked, yeah. 8 00:01:20,342 --> 00:01:22,045 MICHAEL SAVAGE: She's anti-American. 9 00:01:22,081 --> 00:01:23,399 BILL O'REILLY: She's a zombie. 10 00:01:23,453 --> 00:01:26,108 The woman's a zombie, Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 11 00:01:32,826 --> 00:01:36,178 RUTH BADER GINSBURG: I ask no favor for my sex. 12 00:01:36,615 --> 00:01:38,865 All I ask of our brethren... 13 00:01:39,584 --> 00:01:42,865 is that they take their feet off our necks. 14 00:01:43,439 --> 00:01:47,431 ♪ ♪ 15 00:01:48,470 --> 00:01:53,095 ♪ ♪ 16 00:01:54,525 --> 00:01:59,017 ♪ ♪ 17 00:02:00,954 --> 00:02:06,040 ♪ ♪ 18 00:02:08,116 --> 00:02:13,530 Twenty-six, 25, 24, 23, 21, 20, 19 19 00:02:14,173 --> 00:02:19,071 ♪ ♪ 20 00:02:22,376 --> 00:02:25,110 ANNOUNCER: Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 21 00:02:25,786 --> 00:02:28,914 [CROWD CHEERING] 22 00:02:30,032 --> 00:02:33,344 ♪ ♪ 23 00:02:34,662 --> 00:02:39,208 - NINA TOTENBERG: How's your health? - Uh, I'm feeling just fine. 24 00:02:40,715 --> 00:02:43,123 Here now to comment is Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 25 00:02:43,240 --> 00:02:45,505 [CROWD CHEERING] [LAUGHING] 26 00:02:45,647 --> 00:02:48,990 TOTENBERG: It's an amazing thing to see somebody in her 80s 27 00:02:49,030 --> 00:02:52,388 - become such an icon. - Do you mind signing this copy? 28 00:02:52,707 --> 00:02:56,186 I am 84 years old and everyone wants to take a picture with me. 29 00:02:56,498 --> 00:02:59,482 She is really when you come right down to it, 30 00:02:59,647 --> 00:03:01,755 the closest thing to a superhero, I know. 31 00:03:02,254 --> 00:03:06,004 ♪ ♪ 32 00:03:06,677 --> 00:03:09,670 They call her Notorious RBG, that's her rap name. 33 00:03:09,759 --> 00:03:11,392 - Notorious R... - RBG. 34 00:03:11,474 --> 00:03:16,000 Yeah, no, no, RGB... RBG right. 35 00:03:16,296 --> 00:03:17,616 ♪ The notorious... ♪ 36 00:03:17,824 --> 00:03:18,892 NEWS ANCHOR: Supreme Court Justice, 37 00:03:18,927 --> 00:03:20,894 Ruth Bader Ginsburg getting a lot of attention 38 00:03:20,930 --> 00:03:23,113 after she delivered a scathing dissent. 39 00:03:23,149 --> 00:03:25,566 Whether you agree with her or not, you got to acknowledge 40 00:03:25,602 --> 00:03:27,269 she's been a force on that Court. 41 00:03:27,305 --> 00:03:29,210 Liberal hero, Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 42 00:03:29,246 --> 00:03:30,675 As much as people admire her, 43 00:03:30,711 --> 00:03:32,111 they don't even know the half of it. 44 00:03:32,888 --> 00:03:34,820 KATHLEEN PERATIS: She was the queen. 45 00:03:34,914 --> 00:03:36,263 HARRY EDWARDS: Ruth knew what she was doing 46 00:03:36,298 --> 00:03:37,855 in laying the foundation. 47 00:03:38,117 --> 00:03:41,867 ARTHUR MILLER: To put women on exactly the same plane as men. 48 00:03:42,023 --> 00:03:43,370 TOTENBERG: Ruth Bader Ginsburg 49 00:03:43,406 --> 00:03:47,008 quite literally changed the way the world is for American women. 50 00:03:47,234 --> 00:03:52,891 Twelve, 11, ten, nine, eight, seven, six, five... 51 00:03:53,531 --> 00:03:56,607 JOE BIDEN: Today the Senate judiciary committee welcomes 52 00:03:56,643 --> 00:03:58,410 Judge Ruth Bader Ginsburg, 53 00:03:58,960 --> 00:04:01,225 the president's nominee to be associate justice 54 00:04:01,261 --> 00:04:03,508 of the 'United States Supreme Court'. 55 00:04:04,075 --> 00:04:06,630 ♪ ♪ 56 00:04:14,633 --> 00:04:18,292 Judge do you swear the testimony you are about to give 57 00:04:18,328 --> 00:04:20,668 will be the whole truth and nothing but the truth, 58 00:04:20,704 --> 00:04:21,742 so help you God? 59 00:04:21,895 --> 00:04:24,422 - I do, Mr. Chairman. - Thank you. 60 00:04:26,104 --> 00:04:30,086 I am a Brooklynite, born and bred... 61 00:04:31,234 --> 00:04:34,945 a first-generation American on my father's side... 62 00:04:35,609 --> 00:04:38,611 barely second-generation on my mother's. 63 00:04:39,774 --> 00:04:42,915 What has become of me could happen... 64 00:04:43,364 --> 00:04:45,297 only in America. 65 00:04:46,024 --> 00:04:47,524 [PIANO MUSIC] 66 00:04:47,680 --> 00:04:52,219 ♪ ♪ 67 00:04:53,825 --> 00:04:57,318 RUTH: Neither of my parents had the means to attend college, 68 00:04:57,818 --> 00:05:01,066 but both taught me to love learning... 69 00:05:01,980 --> 00:05:03,915 to care about people... 70 00:05:04,552 --> 00:05:09,497 and to work hard for whatever I wanted or believed in. 71 00:05:11,669 --> 00:05:15,012 RUTH: My father was from Odessa 72 00:05:15,048 --> 00:05:17,082 and during his growing up years, 73 00:05:17,279 --> 00:05:20,719 Jews were no longer admitted to the Russian schools. 74 00:05:21,755 --> 00:05:24,189 Education was terribly important. 75 00:05:25,786 --> 00:05:28,943 My mother was loving but also very strict, 76 00:05:29,536 --> 00:05:34,154 making sure I that I did my... homework, practice the piano, 77 00:05:34,251 --> 00:05:37,310 didn't stay out jumping rope too long. 78 00:05:37,346 --> 00:05:38,603 [LAUGHING] 79 00:05:39,860 --> 00:05:41,818 I loved to do the things that boys did, 80 00:05:41,854 --> 00:05:43,099 when I was growing up. 81 00:05:43,599 --> 00:05:46,529 One of our favorite things was climbing garage roofs 82 00:05:46,822 --> 00:05:48,981 from one roof to another, leaping... 83 00:05:50,125 --> 00:05:51,292 leaping over. 84 00:05:51,974 --> 00:05:54,591 Justice Ginsburg, we cannot call Ruth. 85 00:05:54,927 --> 00:05:56,888 - Right. - We call her Kiki. 86 00:05:57,902 --> 00:05:59,182 ANN KITTENER: She was beautiful. 87 00:05:59,380 --> 00:06:02,336 Big beautiful blue eyes, which you really can't see 88 00:06:02,372 --> 00:06:06,224 very well behind her glasses, very soft brown hair. 89 00:06:07,099 --> 00:06:09,458 She had this kind of quiet magnetism 90 00:06:09,795 --> 00:06:11,919 even though she was not effusive. 91 00:06:11,974 --> 00:06:14,298 HARYETTE HELSEL: You always thought that she wasn't listening 92 00:06:14,333 --> 00:06:16,505 and that she didn't know what was going on 93 00:06:16,579 --> 00:06:18,443 but she knew what was going on. 94 00:06:18,551 --> 00:06:20,700 - She didn't do small talk. - No, no small talk. 95 00:06:20,736 --> 00:06:23,891 And she didn't do girl chat and she didn't get on the phone 96 00:06:23,927 --> 00:06:26,512 and talk with us about what happened on the weekend. 97 00:06:26,548 --> 00:06:28,185 She's a deep thinker. 98 00:06:30,013 --> 00:06:31,207 - She's an only child. - No... 99 00:06:31,243 --> 00:06:33,978 She had a sister, I didn't know her sister. 100 00:06:34,380 --> 00:06:36,349 - Her sister passed away. - Right. 101 00:06:37,107 --> 00:06:39,380 HELSEL: But she and her mom were very close, 102 00:06:39,521 --> 00:06:41,233 very, very close. 103 00:06:42,411 --> 00:06:46,038 RUTH: My mother died when I was 17. 104 00:06:47,036 --> 00:06:49,990 I wish I could've had her... longer. 105 00:06:53,138 --> 00:06:56,341 Well, her mother must have been a very steely person 106 00:06:56,377 --> 00:06:59,450 because she had cancer a long time 107 00:07:00,082 --> 00:07:01,818 and... and lived 108 00:07:01,966 --> 00:07:05,357 trying to get her child through high school. 109 00:07:06,599 --> 00:07:09,466 KITTENER: We were supposed to be at graduation. 110 00:07:09,849 --> 00:07:13,610 And then the night before we got a message 111 00:07:13,646 --> 00:07:16,266 that she would not be able to be part of this. 112 00:07:16,302 --> 00:07:19,107 We knew then that her mother had passed away. 113 00:07:20,341 --> 00:07:26,111 RUTH: She had two... lessons that she repeated over and over. 114 00:07:26,876 --> 00:07:28,513 "Be a lady..." 115 00:07:28,979 --> 00:07:31,281 and "be independent." 116 00:07:32,005 --> 00:07:36,446 "Be a lady" meant don't allow yourself to be overcome 117 00:07:36,482 --> 00:07:39,625 by useless emotions like anger. 118 00:07:40,693 --> 00:07:43,228 And by "independent," she meant... 119 00:07:44,536 --> 00:07:47,789 it would be fine if you met prince charming 120 00:07:47,825 --> 00:07:51,002 and lived happily ever after. But... 121 00:07:52,449 --> 00:07:54,521 be able to fend for yourself. 122 00:07:56,896 --> 00:08:02,102 In my lifetime, I expect to see three, four, 123 00:08:02,138 --> 00:08:05,927 perhaps even more women on theHigh Court bench. 124 00:08:06,404 --> 00:08:09,240 Women not shaped from the same mold, 125 00:08:09,646 --> 00:08:12,123 but of different complexions. 126 00:08:13,740 --> 00:08:17,200 I surely would not be in this room today... 127 00:08:18,224 --> 00:08:20,466 without the determined efforts 128 00:08:20,943 --> 00:08:26,338 of men and women who kept dreams of equal citizenship alive. 129 00:08:28,357 --> 00:08:32,043 I have had the great good fortune to share life... 130 00:08:32,565 --> 00:08:34,154 with a partner. 131 00:08:35,138 --> 00:08:38,450 Truly extraordinary for his generation... 132 00:08:40,419 --> 00:08:44,267 a man who believed at age 18, when we met, 133 00:08:45,120 --> 00:08:47,188 that a woman's work, 134 00:08:47,333 --> 00:08:50,560 whether at home or on the job... 135 00:08:51,259 --> 00:08:54,904 is as important as a man's. 136 00:08:56,794 --> 00:09:00,605 I became a lawyer... in days... 137 00:09:01,485 --> 00:09:03,500 when women were not wanted 138 00:09:03,536 --> 00:09:06,378 by most members of the legal profession. 139 00:09:07,990 --> 00:09:12,435 I became a lawyer because Marty supported that choice... 140 00:09:12,743 --> 00:09:14,083 unreservedly. 141 00:09:14,665 --> 00:09:15,828 [PIANO MUSIC] 142 00:09:15,864 --> 00:09:19,208 ♪ ♪ 143 00:09:20,393 --> 00:09:22,419 TOTENBERG: So what was it about Marty? 144 00:09:25,665 --> 00:09:28,172 [CROWD LAUGHING] 145 00:09:30,599 --> 00:09:34,368 RUTH: Marty and I met when I was 17, he was 18. 146 00:09:34,818 --> 00:09:36,615 I was in college. 147 00:09:39,216 --> 00:09:41,911 Cornell was a preferred school for... 148 00:09:42,352 --> 00:09:43,685 for daughters. 149 00:09:44,462 --> 00:09:47,086 ♪ ♪ 150 00:09:49,224 --> 00:09:54,529 In those days, there was a strict quota for women. 151 00:09:55,099 --> 00:09:58,463 There were four men to every woman... 152 00:09:59,849 --> 00:10:03,990 so for parents, Cornell was the ideal place to send a girl. 153 00:10:05,263 --> 00:10:08,275 If she couldn't find her man there, she was hopeless. 154 00:10:08,320 --> 00:10:10,594 [LAUGHING] 155 00:10:10,801 --> 00:10:16,029 My first semester at Cornell, I never did a repeat date. 156 00:10:16,250 --> 00:10:18,304 [LAUGHING] 157 00:10:18,938 --> 00:10:21,492 [APPLAUSE] 158 00:10:22,310 --> 00:10:24,615 RUTH: But then I met Marty, and there was something 159 00:10:24,651 --> 00:10:26,865 amazingly wonderful about this man. 160 00:10:27,880 --> 00:10:32,164 He was the first boy I ever knew who cared that I had a brain. 161 00:10:32,825 --> 00:10:36,185 Most guys in the '50s didn't. 162 00:10:38,121 --> 00:10:41,071 One of the sadnesses about the brilliant girls 163 00:10:41,107 --> 00:10:45,122 who attended Cornell is that they kind of suppressed 164 00:10:45,552 --> 00:10:47,107 how smart they were. 165 00:10:47,942 --> 00:10:52,438 But Marty was so confident of his own ability... 166 00:10:53,263 --> 00:10:55,427 so comfortable with himself, 167 00:10:55,849 --> 00:10:59,841 that he never regarded me as any kind of a threat. 168 00:11:00,818 --> 00:11:05,388 We all were struck by the tremendous difference 169 00:11:05,427 --> 00:11:08,255 between Marty... and Ruth. 170 00:11:09,333 --> 00:11:14,240 Marty was the most gregarious, outgoing, life-of-the-party. 171 00:11:15,581 --> 00:11:18,349 Ruth was a really quite... 172 00:11:19,310 --> 00:11:20,912 recessive in a way... 173 00:11:22,474 --> 00:11:28,349 shy, quiet, soft voice but they worked, they worked. 174 00:11:39,363 --> 00:11:41,531 Oh, he's so young. 175 00:11:43,877 --> 00:11:45,672 RUTH: Meeting Marty... 176 00:11:45,708 --> 00:11:49,372 was by far the most fortunate thing that ever happened to me. 177 00:11:50,068 --> 00:11:53,240 Marty was a man blessed with a wonderful sense of humor. 178 00:11:53,693 --> 00:11:55,677 I tend to be rather sober. 179 00:11:59,505 --> 00:12:03,911 In those days, it was not a great time for our country. 180 00:12:04,396 --> 00:12:07,880 There was a red scare abroad in the land. 181 00:12:08,184 --> 00:12:09,833 Are you a member of the communist party 182 00:12:10,104 --> 00:12:12,629 or have you ever been a member of the communist party? 183 00:12:13,318 --> 00:12:15,883 It's unfortunate and tragic that I have to teach 184 00:12:15,919 --> 00:12:18,499 this committee the principles of Americanism. 185 00:12:18,535 --> 00:12:20,246 CHAIRMAN: That's not the question. 186 00:12:20,403 --> 00:12:22,458 RUTH: I had a government professor 187 00:12:22,544 --> 00:12:26,427 and he wanted me to see that our country was straying 188 00:12:26,463 --> 00:12:28,730 from its most basic values 189 00:12:28,965 --> 00:12:30,375 by some of our politicians 190 00:12:30,411 --> 00:12:33,465 who were seeing a communist in every closet. 191 00:12:33,784 --> 00:12:35,539 But that there were lawyers, 192 00:12:35,575 --> 00:12:38,997 who were defending the rights of these people to think, 193 00:12:39,036 --> 00:12:41,825 to speak, to write freely. 194 00:12:42,367 --> 00:12:44,296 CHAIRMAN: Stand away from the stand! 195 00:12:44,332 --> 00:12:46,218 Fight for the bill of rights you're trying to destroy. 196 00:12:46,253 --> 00:12:48,386 CHAIRMAN: Officer, take this man away from the stand. 197 00:12:50,012 --> 00:12:53,682 RUTH: And then I got the idea that you could do something 198 00:12:53,839 --> 00:12:57,175 that would make your society a little better. 199 00:12:58,856 --> 00:13:01,862 My family had some reservations about this... 200 00:13:02,862 --> 00:13:07,667 but then when I married at the end of college, 201 00:13:07,737 --> 00:13:11,523 my family said, if she wants to be a lawyer let her try. 202 00:13:12,245 --> 00:13:14,345 If she can't succeed... 203 00:13:14,716 --> 00:13:17,495 she will have a husband to support her. 204 00:13:21,000 --> 00:13:23,469 That's me waiting to get my diploma, very happy. 205 00:13:24,004 --> 00:13:27,231 - Yeah, see? That's a nice one. - That's cute. Yeah. 206 00:13:27,832 --> 00:13:30,994 So, we have a whole slew of pictures. 207 00:13:31,434 --> 00:13:33,794 They took them from every possible angle. 208 00:13:34,620 --> 00:13:35,840 You know who that is? 209 00:13:36,616 --> 00:13:37,049 No. 210 00:13:37,084 --> 00:13:40,934 - It's Dean Minow. - Oh. Dean Minow is so small. 211 00:13:41,288 --> 00:13:42,856 We're the same height! 212 00:13:42,892 --> 00:13:45,051 She's not that small, she's probably taller than you. 213 00:13:45,087 --> 00:13:46,224 There's somebody in there. 214 00:13:46,260 --> 00:13:48,703 CLARA SPERA: My brother and cousins and I all call her bubbe. 215 00:13:48,739 --> 00:13:51,450 It's the Yiddish word for grandmother. 216 00:13:51,544 --> 00:13:54,028 It's what we've always called bubbe. 217 00:13:54,201 --> 00:13:56,028 - SPERA: Bubbe! - Yes? 218 00:13:56,203 --> 00:13:59,840 SPERA: Do you know if you have fake sugar like Splenda 219 00:14:00,019 --> 00:14:03,481 - or sweet and low? - Yes, it should be someplace... 220 00:14:03,677 --> 00:14:04,848 SPERA: That's helpful. 221 00:14:05,280 --> 00:14:06,366 I feel like I have 222 00:14:06,434 --> 00:14:09,468 my grandmotherly relationship with her but also somewhat 223 00:14:09,504 --> 00:14:12,739 of a student scholarly relationship to her as well now. 224 00:14:12,981 --> 00:14:15,221 She taught me that the way to win an argument 225 00:14:15,256 --> 00:14:16,536 is not to yell. 226 00:14:16,614 --> 00:14:19,945 Because often that will turn people away more so, 227 00:14:19,981 --> 00:14:21,629 than bringing them to your table. 228 00:14:21,737 --> 00:14:24,304 SPERA: I don't know what that says... 229 00:14:25,064 --> 00:14:25,731 I can't tell if... 230 00:14:25,766 --> 00:14:29,083 for extraordinary dedication to the Harvard Law School 231 00:14:29,197 --> 00:14:30,833 and efforts on its behalf. 232 00:14:30,926 --> 00:14:33,434 You know, this was the 200th year of Harvard. 233 00:14:33,715 --> 00:14:36,973 So, it took 200 years for us... We were the first class 234 00:14:37,009 --> 00:14:38,642 that was 50/50 women. 235 00:14:39,278 --> 00:14:41,715 So 50 percent men... we were the first class. 236 00:14:42,273 --> 00:14:44,419 It takes 200... no. Yeah. 237 00:14:45,765 --> 00:14:46,765 [PIANO MUSIC] 238 00:14:46,934 --> 00:14:51,835 ♪ ♪ 239 00:14:53,137 --> 00:14:55,928 MILLER: Women did not come into the Harvard Law School 240 00:14:55,963 --> 00:14:57,997 until the very early '50s. 241 00:14:58,793 --> 00:15:02,134 Two percent was about what it was back then. 242 00:15:02,887 --> 00:15:06,762 How did it feel to be one of nine women in a class of... 243 00:15:08,415 --> 00:15:10,238 over 500 men? 244 00:15:14,473 --> 00:15:17,216 You felt you were constantly on display. 245 00:15:17,777 --> 00:15:19,718 So if you were called on in class, 246 00:15:20,301 --> 00:15:22,902 you felt that, if you didn't perform well, 247 00:15:23,488 --> 00:15:26,725 that you were failing not just for yourself but for all women. 248 00:15:27,340 --> 00:15:29,328 You also had the uncomfortable feeling 249 00:15:29,363 --> 00:15:31,324 that you were being watched. 250 00:15:32,432 --> 00:15:33,819 American antitrust policy... 251 00:15:33,855 --> 00:15:35,000 BRENDA FEIGEN: Harvard was a Socratic method. 252 00:15:35,035 --> 00:15:36,769 So the professor would ask a question 253 00:15:36,804 --> 00:15:39,340 and then you would be called on to answer. 254 00:15:39,785 --> 00:15:42,209 The way it worked with women was they didn't call on us. 255 00:15:42,245 --> 00:15:43,989 I think they were afraid, we would sort of wither 256 00:15:44,024 --> 00:15:46,553 if we were subjected to that kind of questioning. 257 00:15:47,887 --> 00:15:50,613 RUTH: When I was sent to check a periodical, in Lamont Library 258 00:15:50,649 --> 00:15:53,678 in the old periodical room. 259 00:15:54,313 --> 00:15:55,396 There was... 260 00:15:55,670 --> 00:15:58,420 a man at the door and he said, "you can't come in." 261 00:15:58,631 --> 00:16:00,967 "Well, why can't I come in?" "Because you're a female." 262 00:16:01,163 --> 00:16:05,545 There was nothing I could say, this was a university employee, 263 00:16:05,599 --> 00:16:08,358 you can't come into that room. 264 00:16:09,459 --> 00:16:11,830 RUTH: And then there was the Dean's famous dinner 265 00:16:11,866 --> 00:16:13,906 for the women in the first year class. 266 00:16:14,639 --> 00:16:18,959 He asked each of us to stand up and tell him what we were doing 267 00:16:19,464 --> 00:16:20,810 taking a seat... 268 00:16:21,498 --> 00:16:23,577 that could be occupied by a man. 269 00:16:25,338 --> 00:16:27,639 RUTH: There were many indignities 270 00:16:27,678 --> 00:16:31,397 that one took as just part of the scenery the way it was. 271 00:16:37,489 --> 00:16:38,690 When I got to Harvard Law School 272 00:16:38,725 --> 00:16:41,010 and I'm really intimidated first year, 273 00:16:41,046 --> 00:16:42,064 Marty was saying, 274 00:16:42,100 --> 00:16:44,681 "Oh my wife. She's going to be on the 'Law Review'." 275 00:16:44,717 --> 00:16:48,764 There was a woman in the class ahead of mine and she said, 276 00:16:49,491 --> 00:16:51,713 "this husband of yours is boasting" 277 00:16:51,749 --> 00:16:53,045 that you're going to be on the 'Law Review', 278 00:16:53,080 --> 00:16:54,780 "you look like a little twerp!" 279 00:16:55,467 --> 00:16:58,392 To make the' Law Review', in those days you had to be 280 00:16:58,428 --> 00:17:04,209 in the top 25 academically, of 530, 540. 281 00:17:05,077 --> 00:17:07,936 Her second year she makes the 'Law Review'. 282 00:17:08,357 --> 00:17:12,663 So the mere fact marked her as something special. 283 00:17:14,313 --> 00:17:15,639 RUTH: It turned out, 284 00:17:15,936 --> 00:17:19,638 that I did very well the first year and I attributed 285 00:17:20,209 --> 00:17:23,609 to having something very important in my life 286 00:17:23,644 --> 00:17:25,944 that wasn't the law books. 287 00:17:28,686 --> 00:17:32,920 I came to Harvard as the mother of a 14 month old child. 288 00:17:34,020 --> 00:17:36,303 I'd go to school... 289 00:17:36,856 --> 00:17:38,314 study as hard as I can, 290 00:17:38,350 --> 00:17:41,994 in a very concentrated way, I didn't waste any time. 291 00:17:42,733 --> 00:17:45,772 Four o'clock in the afternoon our babysitter left 292 00:17:46,100 --> 00:17:47,366 and that was... 293 00:17:47,936 --> 00:17:50,530 my child's hours till she went... 294 00:17:51,404 --> 00:17:52,413 to sleep. 295 00:17:54,504 --> 00:17:56,249 Playing with my daughter 296 00:17:56,803 --> 00:17:57,985 gave me a respite 297 00:17:58,021 --> 00:18:01,631 from the kind of work I was doing at law school... 298 00:18:02,615 --> 00:18:05,030 and I think made me more sane. 299 00:18:09,025 --> 00:18:11,021 MILLER: We knew that Marty was ill. 300 00:18:11,795 --> 00:18:14,727 We just knew he had his own battle 301 00:18:15,444 --> 00:18:19,295 and Ruth is now caring for both Marty and Janey. 302 00:18:21,053 --> 00:18:23,811 RUTH: Marty in his third year of law school 303 00:18:24,418 --> 00:18:26,194 had a virulent cancer 304 00:18:27,053 --> 00:18:29,994 in days when there was no chemotherapy, 305 00:18:30,030 --> 00:18:32,155 there was only massive radiation. 306 00:18:34,850 --> 00:18:36,618 He'd go for the radiation, 307 00:18:37,232 --> 00:18:38,828 wake up about midnight 308 00:18:38,864 --> 00:18:41,975 when the only food that he ate for the day 309 00:18:42,851 --> 00:18:44,567 he could manage. 310 00:18:46,163 --> 00:18:49,995 And then I started typing the notes that his classmates 311 00:18:50,030 --> 00:18:51,697 had given me from his classes, 312 00:18:52,358 --> 00:18:56,384 reading whatever cases I would read for the next day 313 00:18:56,420 --> 00:18:59,116 and maybe I got two hours sleep. 314 00:19:00,239 --> 00:19:01,784 TOTENBERG: She did her own work, 315 00:19:01,820 --> 00:19:03,405 helped her husband with his work, 316 00:19:03,545 --> 00:19:06,413 organized his friends so they could help him with his work 317 00:19:06,506 --> 00:19:08,670 and took care of her two year old child. 318 00:19:09,615 --> 00:19:11,772 Fortunately Marty lived... 319 00:19:12,303 --> 00:19:15,944 but it's when she learned how to burn the candle at both ends. 320 00:19:17,096 --> 00:19:21,533 ♪ ♪ 321 00:19:24,681 --> 00:19:29,369 ♪ ♪ 322 00:19:32,725 --> 00:19:35,188 JIM GINSBURG: One of the memories of my childhood would be 323 00:19:35,224 --> 00:19:37,002 waking up in the middle of the night 324 00:19:37,038 --> 00:19:39,627 and there mom would be spread out over the dining room table 325 00:19:39,663 --> 00:19:45,314 with her legal pads, uh, and, uh, the coffee in one hand, 326 00:19:45,350 --> 00:19:47,117 and the box of prunes at the other. 327 00:19:47,499 --> 00:19:52,891 She will work until two, three, four, five in the morning 328 00:19:52,926 --> 00:19:55,561 sometimes even, uh, later, 329 00:19:56,124 --> 00:19:58,416 then she will get up, she has a sitting 330 00:19:58,452 --> 00:20:01,233 she would have to be at the Court before nine, 331 00:20:01,900 --> 00:20:03,936 and then she sleeps the entire weekend. 332 00:20:05,023 --> 00:20:06,286 So she catches up. 333 00:20:06,322 --> 00:20:07,681 [LAUGHING] 334 00:20:09,069 --> 00:20:11,643 LISA FRELINGHUYSEN: The sweet thing about working for a justice 335 00:20:11,678 --> 00:20:13,189 who works extremely hard 336 00:20:13,225 --> 00:20:16,428 is that we saw Marty come to chambers often... 337 00:20:16,964 --> 00:20:19,032 to lure her home. 338 00:20:19,952 --> 00:20:23,322 He would say, "Ruth, it's time to come home to dinner." 339 00:20:23,874 --> 00:20:27,178 She sometimes had to be physically brought home. 340 00:20:30,139 --> 00:20:33,232 MILLER: Marty graduated from the Harvard Law School 341 00:20:33,631 --> 00:20:36,602 and was going to a firm in New York. 342 00:20:37,288 --> 00:20:40,014 That was when Ruth finished her second year, 343 00:20:40,761 --> 00:20:41,761 given Marty, 344 00:20:41,842 --> 00:20:45,319 given his recent illness, they had to remain together, 345 00:20:45,379 --> 00:20:47,212 and the logical place was New York 346 00:20:47,247 --> 00:20:49,381 and the best option was Columbia. 347 00:20:52,014 --> 00:20:54,319 RUTH: When I graduated from Columbia law school 348 00:20:54,355 --> 00:20:55,874 in 1959, 349 00:20:56,553 --> 00:21:00,147 not a law firm in the entire city of New York 350 00:21:00,299 --> 00:21:01,686 would employ me. 351 00:21:03,163 --> 00:21:06,564 MILLER: Four of us from my class, Marty's class, 352 00:21:06,600 --> 00:21:07,866 went to the same law firm 353 00:21:08,475 --> 00:21:11,342 and two of us went to the hiring partner 354 00:21:12,108 --> 00:21:13,538 and said... 355 00:21:14,030 --> 00:21:16,174 we had somebody on the Harvard Law Review 356 00:21:16,209 --> 00:21:18,710 that we think is the cat's meow, 357 00:21:18,999 --> 00:21:21,592 we think this firm should hire her. 358 00:21:22,709 --> 00:21:25,491 As soon as I used the "she" pronoun... 359 00:21:26,881 --> 00:21:29,786 the senior partner looked at me and says, "young man..." 360 00:21:30,374 --> 00:21:32,444 you don't seem to understand. 361 00:21:32,975 --> 00:21:34,795 "This firm doesn't hire women." 362 00:21:35,508 --> 00:21:37,975 She hadn't quite figured out, 363 00:21:38,190 --> 00:21:40,235 why it was that there were these barriers. 364 00:21:40,271 --> 00:21:43,368 It wasn't until later that this all came together 365 00:21:43,403 --> 00:21:46,138 - and became her life's work in, - yes. 366 00:21:46,399 --> 00:21:48,896 In fighting these injustices. 367 00:21:50,451 --> 00:21:53,599 RUTH: Being a woman was an impediment. 368 00:21:57,516 --> 00:21:59,151 FEIGEN:We did not have equal rights 369 00:21:59,186 --> 00:22:02,654 and equal recognition in the law at all. 370 00:22:03,801 --> 00:22:07,491 TOTENBERG: There were not hundreds but thousands of state 371 00:22:07,527 --> 00:22:11,691 and federal laws all over this country that discriminated 372 00:22:11,732 --> 00:22:12,965 on the basis of gender. 373 00:22:13,000 --> 00:22:16,268 Typical laws of the time like, 374 00:22:16,770 --> 00:22:23,108 "the husband is the master of the community." 375 00:22:23,660 --> 00:22:27,488 He shall choose where the family will live 376 00:22:28,069 --> 00:22:31,965 "and the woman is obliged to follow him." 377 00:22:32,482 --> 00:22:37,317 ♪ ♪ 378 00:22:54,805 --> 00:22:57,474 There's no aspect of American life 379 00:22:57,715 --> 00:23:00,045 in which you were not treated differently. 380 00:23:00,301 --> 00:23:01,762 The idea was that... 381 00:23:02,488 --> 00:23:05,645 men were the breadwinners that counted 382 00:23:06,087 --> 00:23:07,707 and women were... 383 00:23:08,454 --> 00:23:10,145 pin money earners. 384 00:23:10,923 --> 00:23:14,872 So women woke up and complained. 385 00:23:14,912 --> 00:23:15,981 [JANIS JOPLIN] ♫ 386 00:23:16,017 --> 00:23:21,177 ♪ One of these mornings ♪ 387 00:23:21,400 --> 00:23:29,400 ♪ You're gonna rise, rise up singing ♪ 388 00:23:31,520 --> 00:23:37,554 ♪ You're gonna spread your wings, ♪ 389 00:23:37,644 --> 00:23:43,358 ♪ Child and take, take to the sky ♪ 390 00:23:43,460 --> 00:23:46,570 ♪ Lord, the sky ♪ 391 00:23:46,973 --> 00:23:51,270 There came to be such a mass and a majority of women really 392 00:23:51,551 --> 00:23:55,239 who understood that they were not crazy, 393 00:23:55,278 --> 00:23:56,703 the system was crazy. 394 00:23:56,739 --> 00:24:00,070 GLORIA STEINEM: Now, thanks to the spirit of equality in the air, 395 00:24:00,106 --> 00:24:03,241 I no longer accept society's judgment 396 00:24:03,424 --> 00:24:05,379 that my group is second class. 397 00:24:07,122 --> 00:24:09,447 WENDY WILLIAMS: But marching and demonstrating 398 00:24:09,483 --> 00:24:11,168 just wasn't Ruth's thing. 399 00:24:11,770 --> 00:24:15,497 Her thing was to use the skills she had and put them to work 400 00:24:15,922 --> 00:24:18,028 and those were her legal skills. 401 00:24:18,184 --> 00:24:22,094 In 1963, she started at Rutgers as a law professor. 402 00:24:22,613 --> 00:24:25,079 And really inspired by her students, 403 00:24:25,137 --> 00:24:26,707 she agreed to teach a course 404 00:24:26,801 --> 00:24:29,201 in this new subject of gender and law. 405 00:24:29,236 --> 00:24:30,936 RUTH: In the late 60's, 406 00:24:31,676 --> 00:24:35,278 some of the students wanted a course in women and the law. 407 00:24:35,876 --> 00:24:37,840 WILLIAMS: That's also when... 408 00:24:37,997 --> 00:24:41,580 she began dealing with sex discrimination cases. 409 00:24:42,231 --> 00:24:46,062 And that was her entré into becoming a litigator. 410 00:24:46,848 --> 00:24:49,965 ARYEH NEIER: The emergence of a women's rights movement 411 00:24:50,207 --> 00:24:54,707 had the possibility of playing the role in the 1970s 412 00:24:54,778 --> 00:24:58,029 that the black civil rights movement had played 413 00:24:58,064 --> 00:24:59,262 in the 1960s. 414 00:24:59,575 --> 00:25:03,869 And so I was particularly eager to create a special project 415 00:25:03,904 --> 00:25:05,762 dealing with women's rights. 416 00:25:05,918 --> 00:25:09,707 I got a call from the WACLU asking me if I would consider 417 00:25:09,747 --> 00:25:11,461 running the women's rights project 418 00:25:11,497 --> 00:25:13,661 with professor Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 419 00:25:13,864 --> 00:25:15,814 Whom I had heard of but I did not know. 420 00:25:16,450 --> 00:25:18,457 I met Ruth the first day I was there. 421 00:25:18,551 --> 00:25:23,188 She seemed very polite and quiet and reserved. Not a firebrand. 422 00:25:23,918 --> 00:25:27,661 NEIER: She wouldn't speak up a great deal during meetings. 423 00:25:27,879 --> 00:25:30,715 She always addressed whatever point there was. 424 00:25:30,770 --> 00:25:34,012 There wasn't any peripheral element of it. 425 00:25:34,590 --> 00:25:36,590 - BETSY WEST: No small talk. - No small talk. 426 00:25:37,003 --> 00:25:38,450 None that I can recall. 427 00:25:40,072 --> 00:25:42,109 FEIGEN: At that point in time, 428 00:25:42,145 --> 00:25:45,143 Ruth was developing her philosophy to take cases 429 00:25:45,178 --> 00:25:46,645 that would make good law. 430 00:25:46,997 --> 00:25:50,176 If the case is going to be on its way to the Supreme Court, 431 00:25:50,450 --> 00:25:53,185 we wanted to be involved and we wanted to... 432 00:25:53,220 --> 00:25:55,453 Frankly, take over the case. 433 00:25:56,205 --> 00:25:57,573 TOTENBERG: She was following in the footsteps 434 00:25:57,608 --> 00:25:59,958 of the great civil rights lawyer Thurgood Marshall, who was 435 00:26:00,395 --> 00:26:03,528 the architect of the battle for racial equality 436 00:26:03,840 --> 00:26:06,298 basing it on the clause of the Constitution 437 00:26:06,333 --> 00:26:09,403 that guarantees equal protection of the law. 438 00:26:09,918 --> 00:26:13,801 She wanted it to apply to equal protection for women. 439 00:26:15,442 --> 00:26:18,465 My first argument before the U.S. Supreme Court 440 00:26:18,745 --> 00:26:21,418 was in Frontiero v. Richardson. 441 00:26:21,799 --> 00:26:26,337 ♪ ♪ 442 00:26:29,161 --> 00:26:33,317 SHARRON FRONTIERO: I was, way back in the 1970s, a... 443 00:26:33,848 --> 00:26:35,629 second lieutenant in the air force. 444 00:26:37,504 --> 00:26:40,899 I went in the military because I needed the money. 445 00:26:41,809 --> 00:26:44,375 AIR FORCE AD: Who says a woman has to settle for a routine job 446 00:26:44,411 --> 00:26:45,918 just because she's a woman? 447 00:26:46,012 --> 00:26:49,754 Discover the United States air force and you'll discover the world. 448 00:26:50,309 --> 00:26:53,421 FRONTIERO: I was newly out of college, this was a new job, 449 00:26:53,457 --> 00:26:56,497 I had just married, so it was the start of 450 00:26:57,106 --> 00:26:58,351 new everything. 451 00:27:00,739 --> 00:27:05,507 It became clear pretty quickly that the men I was working with 452 00:27:05,543 --> 00:27:07,742 who were married got a housing allowance 453 00:27:07,778 --> 00:27:10,328 and I wasn't getting paid a housing allowance 454 00:27:10,363 --> 00:27:12,106 'cause I was a woman. 455 00:27:13,332 --> 00:27:15,200 I assumed it was a mistake 456 00:27:16,020 --> 00:27:20,411 so I went off to the pay office to correct the mistake. 457 00:27:21,145 --> 00:27:23,341 "You're lucky we let you in here at all. 458 00:27:24,028 --> 00:27:27,979 You're lucky that the air force allows you to serve," 459 00:27:28,528 --> 00:27:31,239 was what I heard right off the bat. 460 00:27:31,418 --> 00:27:33,250 It took me aback and then I figured, 461 00:27:33,286 --> 00:27:37,968 well you know, here's one bigot, so I'll just keep asking around 462 00:27:38,004 --> 00:27:39,958 and it became very clear very quickly 463 00:27:39,993 --> 00:27:42,193 that there was no different story. 464 00:27:42,942 --> 00:27:46,351 So we went to see a lawyer and I still thought it was 465 00:27:46,387 --> 00:27:49,520 a matter of getting a lawyer to write a letter for me. 466 00:27:49,731 --> 00:27:52,031 Just write a letter, have the right information. 467 00:27:52,067 --> 00:27:54,817 I'm clearly in the same category as these other men. 468 00:27:55,343 --> 00:27:56,641 The lawyer said to me, 469 00:27:56,676 --> 00:27:58,848 "this isn't an administrative error." 470 00:27:59,098 --> 00:28:00,126 This is the law 471 00:28:00,473 --> 00:28:02,879 and it's going to have to be rectified with a lawsuit 472 00:28:03,121 --> 00:28:05,424 "and if you're willing, we'll take you on." 473 00:28:05,997 --> 00:28:08,090 FEIGEN: Ruth and I heard about it 474 00:28:08,457 --> 00:28:12,324 and immediately let the lawyer for Sharron frontiero 475 00:28:12,359 --> 00:28:13,817 know we were interested. 476 00:28:13,957 --> 00:28:17,067 It was very important to us to have a part in that case. 477 00:28:17,855 --> 00:28:19,695 FRONTIERO: Nice girls didn't file lawsuits. 478 00:28:19,731 --> 00:28:23,902 Particularly after they had been let into the service at all. 479 00:28:23,937 --> 00:28:25,500 You know, what more did I want? 480 00:28:25,536 --> 00:28:28,231 Well, I just wanted to be treated like everybody else did. 481 00:28:28,278 --> 00:28:31,231 But there was the sense and there still is the sense, 482 00:28:31,301 --> 00:28:33,122 that nice girls don't speak up, 483 00:28:33,507 --> 00:28:35,707 nice girls don't make demands. 484 00:28:37,416 --> 00:28:39,303 Ah well, 485 00:28:40,207 --> 00:28:41,293 too bad. 486 00:28:42,467 --> 00:28:45,036 It went to the District Court in Alabama. 487 00:28:45,325 --> 00:28:49,728 We lost and the next Court to go to was the Supreme Court. 488 00:28:50,426 --> 00:28:53,786 FEIGEN:Ruth and I set to work to write the brief. 489 00:28:54,028 --> 00:28:57,046 I would write a section and Ruth would take it 490 00:28:57,082 --> 00:29:00,832 and it would come back in a wonderfully brilliant fashion. 491 00:29:01,090 --> 00:29:02,984 Every word of it was carefully... 492 00:29:03,020 --> 00:29:05,668 I mean Ruth went over every single word. 493 00:29:08,984 --> 00:29:11,965 What we wanted was a review of cases 494 00:29:12,348 --> 00:29:15,253 that the Court would say, sex discrimination doesn't work. 495 00:29:16,028 --> 00:29:19,059 And it would be a broad command basically to legislatures 496 00:29:19,179 --> 00:29:22,793 to get rid of statutes that discriminate on the basis 497 00:29:23,023 --> 00:29:24,957 of... of gender. 498 00:29:25,442 --> 00:29:29,489 But she also added to make the point much more poignant, 499 00:29:29,567 --> 00:29:32,028 the history of women and the way we were treated 500 00:29:32,078 --> 00:29:34,872 throughout America and its beginnings. 501 00:29:35,783 --> 00:29:43,408 ♪ ♪ 502 00:29:45,439 --> 00:29:51,369 ♪ ♪ 503 00:29:53,407 --> 00:29:56,343 She captured for the male members of the Court 504 00:29:56,379 --> 00:29:58,465 what it was like to be a second class citizen. 505 00:29:59,736 --> 00:30:07,736 ♪ ♪ 506 00:30:13,670 --> 00:30:16,059 WILLIAMS: Frontiero went to the Court. 507 00:30:16,575 --> 00:30:18,616 Ruth Ginsburg, for the first time, 508 00:30:18,651 --> 00:30:20,231 made an oral argument. 509 00:30:20,316 --> 00:30:22,585 She split her time with the lawyer, 510 00:30:22,661 --> 00:30:25,786 the man who had begun the case in Alabama. 511 00:30:28,984 --> 00:30:31,262 RUTH: It was an afternoon argument. 512 00:30:32,049 --> 00:30:34,012 So I was first up in the afternoon 513 00:30:34,048 --> 00:30:36,994 and I didn't dare have lunch that day. 514 00:30:37,704 --> 00:30:39,286 FEIGEN: She seemed nervous. 515 00:30:39,363 --> 00:30:42,160 Her eyes were wide with sort of anticipation. 516 00:30:47,090 --> 00:30:52,848 It's very intense and austere and important 517 00:30:53,386 --> 00:30:54,593 and very male 518 00:30:54,629 --> 00:30:56,286 and it's the whole thing feels like. 519 00:30:57,176 --> 00:30:59,754 I was... I was really kind of scared. 520 00:31:01,418 --> 00:31:03,466 We sat down at the counsel table 521 00:31:03,770 --> 00:31:06,364 and had all these huge casebooks 522 00:31:06,399 --> 00:31:08,566 for me to help her with cites. 523 00:31:08,965 --> 00:31:12,036 And the Court began with the " Oyez! Oyez!" 524 00:31:12,072 --> 00:31:14,391 and the "here we are." 525 00:31:15,106 --> 00:31:18,582 COURT OFFICER: Oyez! Oyez! Oyez! 526 00:31:19,217 --> 00:31:20,629 All persons having business 527 00:31:20,665 --> 00:31:22,562 before the Supreme Court of the United States 528 00:31:22,598 --> 00:31:25,450 are admonished to draw near and give their attention 529 00:31:25,485 --> 00:31:27,348 for the Court is now sitting. 530 00:31:29,918 --> 00:31:33,458 - CHIEF JUSTICE: Mrs. Ginsburg. - RUTH: I was terribly, terribly 531 00:31:33,494 --> 00:31:35,293 nervous but then I looked up 532 00:31:35,777 --> 00:31:37,293 at the justices 533 00:31:38,332 --> 00:31:41,379 and I thought, "I have a captive audience." 534 00:31:42,222 --> 00:31:44,623 I knew that I was speaking to men, 535 00:31:44,770 --> 00:31:46,804 who didn't think there was any such thing 536 00:31:46,840 --> 00:31:49,307 as gender-based discrimination. 537 00:31:49,950 --> 00:31:53,653 And my job was to tell them it really exists. 538 00:32:00,784 --> 00:32:03,853 RUTH: 539 00:32:51,075 --> 00:32:55,615 There was not a single question. I just went on speaking 540 00:32:55,942 --> 00:32:57,927 and I, at the time... 541 00:32:59,099 --> 00:33:00,462 wondered, 542 00:33:00,498 --> 00:33:04,474 "are they just indulging me and not listening" 543 00:33:05,536 --> 00:33:07,396 or am I telling them something 544 00:33:08,044 --> 00:33:09,620 they haven't heard before 545 00:33:09,656 --> 00:33:11,591 "and are they paying attention?" 546 00:33:13,685 --> 00:33:16,419 FEIGEN: The justices were just glued to her. 547 00:33:16,696 --> 00:33:18,161 I don't think they were 548 00:33:18,271 --> 00:33:21,318 expecting to have to deal with something as powerful 549 00:33:21,357 --> 00:33:26,391 as a sheer force of her argument that was just all-encompassing 550 00:33:26,427 --> 00:33:28,641 and they were there to talk about a little statute 551 00:33:28,677 --> 00:33:31,541 in the government code. I mean, it was just... 552 00:33:31,615 --> 00:33:35,200 we seized the moment to change American society. 553 00:33:37,021 --> 00:33:39,250 RUTH: In asking the Court to declare sex 554 00:33:39,285 --> 00:33:41,386 a suspect criterion... 555 00:33:42,274 --> 00:33:47,302 we urge a position forcibly stated in 1837 by Sara Grimke, 556 00:33:47,922 --> 00:33:49,189 noted abolitionist 557 00:33:49,853 --> 00:33:52,234 and advocate of equal rights for men and women. 558 00:33:53,118 --> 00:33:54,151 She said, 559 00:33:54,273 --> 00:33:57,371 "I ask no favor for my sex." 560 00:33:58,313 --> 00:34:00,453 "All I ask of our brethren" 561 00:34:01,236 --> 00:34:04,797 "is that they take their feet off our necks." 562 00:34:11,119 --> 00:34:13,021 FRONTIERO: We were told about the decision 563 00:34:13,057 --> 00:34:14,703 when a reporter called us up 564 00:34:14,739 --> 00:34:17,488 and said, "it went in your favor today, how do you feel?" 565 00:34:17,911 --> 00:34:20,489 I said, "I feel fine, thank you very much!" 566 00:34:20,590 --> 00:34:22,407 We were both happy that we won the case. 567 00:34:22,443 --> 00:34:24,629 Let's be clear about it, we won the case. But... 568 00:34:25,380 --> 00:34:28,849 we lost the standard of review that we wanted by one vote. 569 00:34:29,614 --> 00:34:32,513 WILLIAMS: She tried to make the case, 570 00:34:33,114 --> 00:34:34,906 that sex discrimination should be treated 571 00:34:34,941 --> 00:34:36,357 like race discrimination. 572 00:34:37,146 --> 00:34:40,745 Four justices signed onto that idea. 573 00:34:41,077 --> 00:34:42,950 The problem was you need five. 574 00:34:44,166 --> 00:34:45,349 RUTH: I said... 575 00:34:47,185 --> 00:34:48,886 it's too soon. 576 00:34:49,955 --> 00:34:52,497 My expectation, to be candid, 577 00:34:52,810 --> 00:34:55,677 was that I would repeat that kind of argument... 578 00:34:57,662 --> 00:34:59,669 maybe half a dozen times. 579 00:34:59,958 --> 00:35:03,935 I didn't expect it to happen in one fell swoop. 580 00:35:04,654 --> 00:35:08,583 I think generally in our society, real change... 581 00:35:10,224 --> 00:35:13,529 enduring change, happens one step at a time. 582 00:35:13,669 --> 00:35:17,148 The legal strategy of one step at a time in the '70s 583 00:35:17,183 --> 00:35:19,282 was a conservative strategy 584 00:35:19,318 --> 00:35:22,997 but the goal was equality and civil rights 585 00:35:23,474 --> 00:35:26,318 and that's who she always was and who she is now. 586 00:35:33,427 --> 00:35:37,701 FRELINGHUYSEN: She is very disciplined but she has passions 587 00:35:37,737 --> 00:35:39,888 that she really enjoys. 588 00:35:40,663 --> 00:35:41,943 She loves the opera. 589 00:35:44,833 --> 00:35:46,982 SPERA: She goes to multiple opera festivals 590 00:35:47,018 --> 00:35:49,154 and the whole family will go with her. 591 00:35:50,068 --> 00:35:52,774 I think it is a place of tranquility 592 00:35:52,810 --> 00:35:56,193 that is outside of the demands of her job. 593 00:36:11,131 --> 00:36:14,221 RUTH: When I am at an opera... 594 00:36:14,894 --> 00:36:16,774 I get totally carried away. 595 00:36:17,573 --> 00:36:21,276 I don't think about the case that's coming up next week, 596 00:36:21,391 --> 00:36:23,589 or the brief that I'm in the middle of. 597 00:36:26,935 --> 00:36:30,979 I'm overwhelmed by the beauty of the music, the drama. 598 00:36:32,263 --> 00:36:34,619 And the sound of the human voice... 599 00:36:35,370 --> 00:36:38,386 it's like an electric current going through me. 600 00:36:38,808 --> 00:36:42,619 ♪ ♪ 601 00:36:47,945 --> 00:36:51,345 ♪ ♪ 602 00:36:52,322 --> 00:36:55,634 [CROWD APPLAUSE] 603 00:36:56,420 --> 00:37:00,862 RUTH: Justice and mercy, they're all in opera. 604 00:37:01,344 --> 00:37:03,722 Very grand emotions. 605 00:37:04,268 --> 00:37:09,033 ♪ ♪ 606 00:37:13,751 --> 00:37:16,370 RUTH: A young man had a tragic experience. 607 00:37:17,089 --> 00:37:20,206 His wife Hadan entirely healthy pregnancy, 608 00:37:20,440 --> 00:37:24,011 and he was told that he had a healthy baby boy 609 00:37:24,047 --> 00:37:26,081 but his wife had died. 610 00:37:27,042 --> 00:37:29,764 STEPHEN WIESENFELD: The problem was amniotic embolism 611 00:37:29,800 --> 00:37:32,917 and at that particular point nobody had ever survived that. 612 00:37:33,323 --> 00:37:35,542 They did keep her alive for about four hours 613 00:37:36,022 --> 00:37:37,956 but by 3:30 in the afternoon, 614 00:37:38,042 --> 00:37:40,534 the code blue came along and she died. 615 00:37:44,129 --> 00:37:46,769 Jason was a very easy child. 616 00:37:47,651 --> 00:37:50,276 My attitude towards raising a child is that, 617 00:37:50,526 --> 00:37:53,550 a child is not there for me, I'm there for him! 618 00:37:53,773 --> 00:37:55,394 And that's what my job was. 619 00:37:55,667 --> 00:37:57,408 RUTH: He determined that he was going to be 620 00:37:57,443 --> 00:38:00,120 a care-giving parent to that child. 621 00:38:01,073 --> 00:38:03,764 He went to the local social security office 622 00:38:03,800 --> 00:38:06,636 and asked about the benefits he thought... 623 00:38:08,026 --> 00:38:10,386 a sole surviving parent could get. 624 00:38:11,167 --> 00:38:12,034 And he was told, 625 00:38:12,070 --> 00:38:14,269 "well, that benefit is called a mother's benefit," 626 00:38:15,514 --> 00:38:17,299 and he didn't qualify. 627 00:38:18,096 --> 00:38:20,464 So, he wrote a letter to the editor 628 00:38:20,503 --> 00:38:22,581 "of his local newspaper. And he said," 629 00:38:22,628 --> 00:38:26,104 "I have heard a lot about women's lib. Let me tell you my story." 630 00:38:26,940 --> 00:38:28,089 WIESENFELD: "To the editor." 631 00:38:28,125 --> 00:38:30,075 It has been my misfortune to discover 632 00:38:30,323 --> 00:38:32,743 that a male cannot collect social security benefits 633 00:38:32,778 --> 00:38:33,894 as a woman can. 634 00:38:34,019 --> 00:38:35,948 Had I been paying into the social security system 635 00:38:36,026 --> 00:38:39,317 and had I died, she would have been able to receive a benefit. 636 00:38:39,484 --> 00:38:41,017 But male homemakers cannot. 637 00:38:41,302 --> 00:38:43,792 I wonder if Gloria Steinem knows about this. 638 00:38:47,511 --> 00:38:52,612 Ruth took a case in which a man was discriminated against 639 00:38:52,648 --> 00:38:54,081 in order to show... 640 00:38:54,761 --> 00:38:58,792 the depth and the importance of sex discrimination. 641 00:38:59,741 --> 00:39:01,976 Very intelligent thing to do. 642 00:39:02,979 --> 00:39:06,573 WIESENFELD: We appeared in the U.S. Supreme Court in 1975. 643 00:39:08,144 --> 00:39:10,581 When we got to the courtroom, she sat me down 644 00:39:10,616 --> 00:39:11,917 at the table with her, 645 00:39:12,448 --> 00:39:15,401 she just wanted a male presence to be at that table 646 00:39:15,464 --> 00:39:18,190 so that the justices would have something to identify with. 647 00:39:18,745 --> 00:39:20,628 That was a part of her strategy. 648 00:39:21,065 --> 00:39:22,565 She was trying to convince 649 00:39:22,908 --> 00:39:24,862 members of the Supreme Court who 650 00:39:25,237 --> 00:39:29,323 were mostly white, male, privileged class at that time. 651 00:39:30,814 --> 00:39:34,917 RUTH: 652 00:39:48,615 --> 00:39:50,616 She knew exactly what she was doing 653 00:39:50,698 --> 00:39:52,761 and it was a very shrewd strategy. 654 00:39:53,992 --> 00:39:59,030 RUTH: That case resulted in a unanimous judgment 655 00:39:59,065 --> 00:40:01,532 in Stephen Wiesenfeld's favor. 656 00:40:02,100 --> 00:40:04,115 His case was the perfect example 657 00:40:04,151 --> 00:40:09,276 of how gender-based discrimination hurts everyone. 658 00:40:10,433 --> 00:40:13,537 KATHLEEN PERATIS: Ruth's conception of the strategy led 659 00:40:13,573 --> 00:40:16,667 to a whole string of litigation for the next decade. 660 00:40:17,729 --> 00:40:23,167 NEIER: She wanted to build the idea of women's equality 661 00:40:23,214 --> 00:40:26,819 step by step to use each case 662 00:40:27,495 --> 00:40:29,979 to move things forward. 663 00:40:30,206 --> 00:40:32,706 It was like knitting a sweater. 664 00:40:33,783 --> 00:40:38,017 ♪ ♪ 665 00:40:44,042 --> 00:40:46,651 RUTH: 666 00:41:01,159 --> 00:41:04,428 RUTH: 667 00:41:15,707 --> 00:41:16,941 RUTH: 668 00:41:17,386 --> 00:41:18,357 They didn't get it. 669 00:41:18,393 --> 00:41:21,145 They didn't understand the issues that women were facing 670 00:41:21,181 --> 00:41:23,914 or they didn't see them as issues. 671 00:41:24,440 --> 00:41:27,511 'Cause women had, in their minds women had a place 672 00:41:27,878 --> 00:41:29,211 and it wasn't... 673 00:41:30,026 --> 00:41:33,104 where Ruth Ginsburg was suggesting that it ought to be. 674 00:41:33,525 --> 00:41:36,425 RUTH: 675 00:41:46,112 --> 00:41:48,339 WEST: When they would say things like this, 676 00:41:48,374 --> 00:41:50,261 how did you respond? 677 00:41:50,347 --> 00:41:53,477 Well, never in anger, as my mother told me. 678 00:41:53,565 --> 00:41:56,113 That would've been self-defeating. 679 00:41:56,148 --> 00:42:00,317 Always as an opportunity to teach. 680 00:42:00,776 --> 00:42:03,287 I did see myself as kind of a kindergarten teacher, 681 00:42:03,323 --> 00:42:06,183 in those days, because the judges... 682 00:42:07,144 --> 00:42:10,354 didn't think sex... sex discrimination existed. 683 00:42:11,722 --> 00:42:15,003 Well, one of the things I tried to plant in their minds was... 684 00:42:15,886 --> 00:42:19,436 think about how you would like the world to be 685 00:42:19,472 --> 00:42:21,464 for your daughters and granddaughters. 686 00:42:22,062 --> 00:42:27,633 RUTH: 687 00:42:30,261 --> 00:42:33,714 One of the things that I'm struck by, as I look back on it, 688 00:42:33,964 --> 00:42:37,688 is how unprepared the defendants were to fight back. 689 00:42:37,886 --> 00:42:40,487 We won because the strategy was brilliant, 690 00:42:40,565 --> 00:42:44,225 we won because we were smart and prepared and we fought hard. 691 00:42:44,261 --> 00:42:47,598 You couldn't miss what Ruth was doing during the '70s. 692 00:42:47,784 --> 00:42:53,667 She was creating a legal landscape. 693 00:43:01,683 --> 00:43:04,886 She was doing something that was... 694 00:43:05,450 --> 00:43:07,065 incredibly important 695 00:43:07,101 --> 00:43:10,519 to American women whether they knew it or not. 696 00:43:14,729 --> 00:43:17,690 Just the thought that I might catch a glimpse of her is... 697 00:43:17,896 --> 00:43:19,196 overwhelming. 698 00:43:19,471 --> 00:43:21,717 I have a mug of her in my room it says, 699 00:43:21,753 --> 00:43:22,904 "her story in the making." 700 00:43:22,940 --> 00:43:24,584 I have her sticker on my computer! 701 00:43:24,620 --> 00:43:26,479 I just ordered tons of merch. 702 00:43:26,808 --> 00:43:30,464 Notorious RBG. We're here to get our books signed. 703 00:43:30,808 --> 00:43:33,440 SHANA KNIZHNIK:I think it's easy to take for granted 704 00:43:33,542 --> 00:43:38,912 the position that young women can have in today's society. 705 00:43:38,948 --> 00:43:42,901 And that's a lot in thanks to justice Ginsburg's work. 706 00:43:44,440 --> 00:43:47,658 IRIN CARMON:Who is more disdained or told to go away 707 00:43:47,693 --> 00:43:48,815 than an older woman? 708 00:43:48,870 --> 00:43:51,962 But here's an older woman who people really want to hear 709 00:43:51,997 --> 00:43:53,800 everything that she has to say. 710 00:43:55,472 --> 00:43:57,390 AARON SAIGER: I have been given questions from the students 711 00:43:57,425 --> 00:44:00,037 about what it's like to be justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 712 00:44:00,550 --> 00:44:02,253 - Do you have a smartphone? 713 00:44:02,490 --> 00:44:06,248 Yes, the answer is yes. 714 00:44:06,284 --> 00:44:09,139 I had, in fact, two until they took 715 00:44:09,448 --> 00:44:11,443 the BlackBerry away from me saying, 716 00:44:11,479 --> 00:44:13,009 "nobody uses that anymore." 717 00:44:13,182 --> 00:44:14,182 [LAUGHING] 718 00:44:14,383 --> 00:44:17,347 Uh, what do I use it for? Not for selfies. 719 00:44:17,705 --> 00:44:19,712 [LAUGHING] 720 00:44:20,124 --> 00:44:22,287 You have said in public many times, 721 00:44:22,323 --> 00:44:24,828 that the ideal number of women for the Supreme Court 722 00:44:24,863 --> 00:44:26,430 of the United States is nine. [LAUGHING] 723 00:44:26,535 --> 00:44:28,042 Yes, of course... 724 00:44:29,166 --> 00:44:30,808 - SAIGER: Uh... - Why not? 725 00:44:31,050 --> 00:44:35,172 Nine men was a satisfactory number until 1981. 726 00:44:35,722 --> 00:44:39,065 But the change in the federal judiciary as a whole 727 00:44:39,101 --> 00:44:40,972 has been enormous. 728 00:44:41,479 --> 00:44:43,180 But it wasn't until... 729 00:44:43,440 --> 00:44:45,308 Jimmy Carter became president, 730 00:44:46,112 --> 00:44:48,752 he looked around at the federal judiciary, 731 00:44:49,308 --> 00:44:50,370 and he said, 732 00:44:50,708 --> 00:44:52,604 "don't they all look like me?" 733 00:44:53,292 --> 00:44:57,292 "But that's not how the great United States looks." 734 00:44:59,112 --> 00:45:01,897 EDWARDS: When president Carter was elected, he said, 735 00:45:01,933 --> 00:45:04,428 "there are almost no women and there are almost" 736 00:45:04,464 --> 00:45:07,026 no African Americans on the federal bench 737 00:45:07,065 --> 00:45:09,573 "and I am determined to change that." 738 00:45:10,972 --> 00:45:14,175 Justice Ginsburg and I were two of the people 739 00:45:14,783 --> 00:45:17,112 who benefitted from that promise. 740 00:45:19,104 --> 00:45:22,854 Ruth was nominated in 1980 and we became colleagues 741 00:45:22,956 --> 00:45:25,892 on the U.S. Court of appeals for the DC circuit. 742 00:45:26,994 --> 00:45:29,463 WOMAN: Judge Ginsburg did you always want to be a judge? 743 00:45:31,572 --> 00:45:36,166 The law is something that I think I deal with well. 744 00:45:36,499 --> 00:45:37,499 Uh... 745 00:45:38,119 --> 00:45:41,438 I don't have the kind of talent that could make one say 746 00:45:41,473 --> 00:45:43,822 a great opera singer. 747 00:45:44,541 --> 00:45:46,033 [OPERA MUSIC] 748 00:45:46,182 --> 00:45:52,056 ♪ ♪ 749 00:45:52,849 --> 00:45:56,016 RUTH: I wanted to be active in the law. 750 00:45:56,541 --> 00:45:59,580 The law is a consuming, 751 00:46:00,152 --> 00:46:01,152 uh, 752 00:46:01,801 --> 00:46:03,505 love for me. 753 00:46:04,841 --> 00:46:06,809 EDWARDS: When she first started on the bench, 754 00:46:06,845 --> 00:46:10,392 after we hear cases we go into a conference room 755 00:46:10,447 --> 00:46:13,556 and the three judges confer and we think about 756 00:46:13,872 --> 00:46:15,739 how we should decide the cases. 757 00:46:16,572 --> 00:46:19,853 Ruth was sufficiently confident in herself in the early days. 758 00:46:20,236 --> 00:46:22,775 "She would say," this is a very straightforward case. 759 00:46:22,900 --> 00:46:24,915 I have a prepared judgment for us" 760 00:46:24,950 --> 00:46:28,298 and this was before we conferred on the case 761 00:46:28,400 --> 00:46:30,753 and initially, we were all taken aback like, 762 00:46:31,111 --> 00:46:33,228 "no wait, wait, Ruth, you can't do that." 763 00:46:33,691 --> 00:46:34,491 She was always right, 764 00:46:34,526 --> 00:46:36,527 the judgments that she had prepared were right. 765 00:46:37,369 --> 00:46:40,544 But we said, "no, we have to go through the motions" 766 00:46:40,580 --> 00:46:44,134 of talking first before you give us the result." 767 00:46:45,359 --> 00:46:48,562 RUTH: When I was appointed to the DC circuit, 768 00:46:48,658 --> 00:46:51,239 "so often people would come up to me and say," 769 00:46:51,275 --> 00:46:54,755 "it must be hard for you commuting back and forth to New York." 770 00:46:55,248 --> 00:46:59,502 They couldn't imagine that a man would leave his work 771 00:46:59,852 --> 00:47:02,072 to follow his... his wife. 772 00:47:03,377 --> 00:47:07,291 He... had been extraordinarily successful 773 00:47:07,326 --> 00:47:09,908 as a practicing lawyer in New York. 774 00:47:10,229 --> 00:47:12,083 There were people who would say, 775 00:47:12,119 --> 00:47:14,864 he was the best tax lawyer in the city of New York 776 00:47:14,900 --> 00:47:17,181 and believe me, that is saying something. 777 00:47:17,370 --> 00:47:18,662 He was... 778 00:47:19,837 --> 00:47:21,900 okay playing second fiddle. 779 00:47:22,064 --> 00:47:24,963 In fact, he would make a joke of it always, he would say, 780 00:47:25,384 --> 00:47:28,178 "I moved to Washington because my wife got a good job." 781 00:47:28,673 --> 00:47:31,486 WOMAN: How much advice do you give each other? 782 00:47:33,330 --> 00:47:36,345 [LAUGHING] 783 00:47:38,336 --> 00:47:39,503 Well... 784 00:47:41,142 --> 00:47:44,094 Marty was the funny one in the family and she loved it 785 00:47:44,884 --> 00:47:47,831 and you could see the twinkle in her eye when he would do 786 00:47:47,866 --> 00:47:49,838 his funny little quips and jokes. 787 00:47:49,968 --> 00:47:51,223 As a general rule, 788 00:47:51,259 --> 00:47:54,822 my wife does not give me any advice about cooking 789 00:47:54,861 --> 00:47:57,541 and I do not give her any advice about the law. 790 00:47:57,884 --> 00:48:00,634 This seems to work quite well on both sides. 791 00:48:00,736 --> 00:48:02,134 [LAUGHING] 792 00:48:02,189 --> 00:48:06,294 My father was very outgoing, very fun person, 793 00:48:06,330 --> 00:48:08,400 and I think he helped, uh, 794 00:48:09,001 --> 00:48:12,666 temper some of mom's seriousness at times which I think was 795 00:48:12,702 --> 00:48:14,052 to everybody's benefit. 796 00:48:14,088 --> 00:48:16,560 We used to keep a book called mommy laughed. 797 00:48:16,735 --> 00:48:19,478 Which had parsimonious entries. 798 00:48:20,689 --> 00:48:22,365 You are giving me constant advice. 799 00:48:22,401 --> 00:48:24,931 It's starts calling about, uh... 800 00:48:25,861 --> 00:48:30,056 7:00, it's time to come home for dinner and then 7:30 801 00:48:30,572 --> 00:48:35,312 and somewhere between 7:30 and 9:00, we generally make it. 802 00:48:35,955 --> 00:48:38,259 And the other thing is time for you to go to sleep. 803 00:48:39,159 --> 00:48:40,778 Those are the daily... 804 00:48:40,814 --> 00:48:42,564 um, that's the daily advice, 805 00:48:43,442 --> 00:48:44,275 that I get. 806 00:48:44,361 --> 00:48:47,958 Well, it's not that bad advice you have to eat one meal a day 807 00:48:47,993 --> 00:48:49,853 and you have to go to sleep sometime. 808 00:48:49,923 --> 00:48:50,770 [LAUGHING] 809 00:48:50,861 --> 00:48:55,832 EDWARDS: He allowed Ruth to be who she was, that is, 810 00:48:56,330 --> 00:49:00,439 a relatively reserved, serious person, 811 00:49:00,916 --> 00:49:04,556 who focused on her law work and loved doing that. 812 00:49:04,736 --> 00:49:07,711 And the relationship was just magnificent to watch. 813 00:49:08,424 --> 00:49:11,814 RUTH: And when Marty was starting out in law practice 814 00:49:12,084 --> 00:49:13,825 and eager to make partner, 815 00:49:13,861 --> 00:49:16,019 I was responsible for the lion's share 816 00:49:16,055 --> 00:49:17,814 of taking care of the home. 817 00:49:18,377 --> 00:49:21,658 But when the women's movement came alive and Marty appreciated 818 00:49:21,693 --> 00:49:24,736 the importance of the work I was doing, 819 00:49:25,134 --> 00:49:29,433 then I became the person whose career came first. 820 00:49:29,728 --> 00:49:31,392 WEST: What was she like as a mom? 821 00:49:31,428 --> 00:49:32,463 Exigent. 822 00:49:32,517 --> 00:49:33,841 WEST: What do you mean by that? 823 00:49:33,877 --> 00:49:38,549 "Do your homework, clean your room, don't disappoint us." 824 00:49:41,838 --> 00:49:44,252 JIM: Helping a lot with, uh, schoolwork, 825 00:49:44,616 --> 00:49:47,250 commenting, pulling out the red pen. 826 00:49:47,963 --> 00:49:51,388 MARTY GINSBURG: Our dear daughter Jane, all smiles, 827 00:49:51,547 --> 00:49:53,744 volunteered to the press. 828 00:49:53,963 --> 00:49:58,439 She had grown up in a home in which responsibility 829 00:49:58,797 --> 00:50:00,595 was equally divided. 830 00:50:00,720 --> 00:50:03,869 Her father did the cooking, she explained, 831 00:50:04,041 --> 00:50:06,228 and her mother did the thinking. 832 00:50:06,345 --> 00:50:08,376 [CROWD LAUGHING] 833 00:50:09,056 --> 00:50:11,475 WEST: So is she really such a horrible cook? 834 00:50:11,650 --> 00:50:12,919 - Yes. - JIM: Oh yeah. 835 00:50:12,955 --> 00:50:14,947 To this day I still can't eat swordfish... 836 00:50:15,603 --> 00:50:17,322 after what she did to it. 837 00:50:18,017 --> 00:50:20,250 It wasn't until I was 14 that I encountered 838 00:50:20,285 --> 00:50:21,533 a live vegetable. 839 00:50:22,564 --> 00:50:25,488 MARTY:Ruth is no longer permitted in the kitchen... 840 00:50:26,502 --> 00:50:29,994 ...this by the demand of our children, who have taste. 841 00:50:30,455 --> 00:50:32,189 [LAUGHING] 842 00:50:32,705 --> 00:50:33,705 [PIANO MUSIC] 843 00:50:33,760 --> 00:50:39,626 ♪ ♪ 844 00:50:41,627 --> 00:50:44,330 This is a book that Tata, 845 00:50:45,150 --> 00:50:47,444 he collected letters about me 846 00:50:47,588 --> 00:50:48,924 for my 50th birthday. 847 00:50:49,283 --> 00:50:51,799 - Tata organized all this. - It was his idea. 848 00:50:52,117 --> 00:50:54,584 Tata, my... her husband, my grandfather, 849 00:50:54,619 --> 00:50:56,231 he was especially doting, 850 00:50:56,267 --> 00:50:59,456 so they almost had a bad cop, good cop relationship, 851 00:50:59,491 --> 00:51:01,258 when it came to the grandkids. 852 00:51:01,634 --> 00:51:04,603 Tata was more often the good cop I would say, 853 00:51:04,720 --> 00:51:07,664 uh, mostly because bubbe was often buried in her work 854 00:51:07,699 --> 00:51:09,192 so if we really wanted something, 855 00:51:09,228 --> 00:51:12,236 we felt like we could nag tata more often for it. 856 00:51:13,237 --> 00:51:14,283 "Dear Ruth," 857 00:51:14,533 --> 00:51:17,541 I have little doubt that you are proud, rightly so, 858 00:51:17,955 --> 00:51:20,400 of all you have achieved as a judge 859 00:51:20,447 --> 00:51:22,799 and as a spouse and a parent as well. 860 00:51:22,845 --> 00:51:24,581 But I conceive no way you can take 861 00:51:24,616 --> 00:51:28,452 "greater pride than I do. Love, Tata." 862 00:51:28,487 --> 00:51:30,205 - Nice. - Very nice. 863 00:51:31,861 --> 00:51:34,384 - Do you read these often? - No, I never read them. 864 00:51:34,447 --> 00:51:36,593 You should, they are very nice, if you ever need a boost 865 00:51:36,628 --> 00:51:38,150 of self-confidence. 866 00:51:38,994 --> 00:51:41,164 So much of the shape of America is a work 867 00:51:41,199 --> 00:51:42,236 of the U.S. Supreme Court 868 00:51:42,272 --> 00:51:44,049 and so the makeup of that Court 869 00:51:44,158 --> 00:51:45,739 is one of the enduring legacies 870 00:51:45,775 --> 00:51:48,916 of a president who has an opportunity to appoint justices. 871 00:51:49,002 --> 00:51:50,794 And tonight this new president 872 00:51:50,830 --> 00:51:53,380 has his first chance to make it a Clinton Court. 873 00:51:53,416 --> 00:51:57,214 This president has a very clear idea of what he wants in this justice. 874 00:51:58,080 --> 00:52:01,322 BILL CLINTON: I really did want to put Governor Cuomo on the Court, 875 00:52:01,939 --> 00:52:04,283 but he didn't want to do it so I started looking around. 876 00:52:04,611 --> 00:52:08,330 He kept moving from his favorite person of the week 877 00:52:08,377 --> 00:52:10,267 to the next favorite person of the week 878 00:52:10,650 --> 00:52:13,553 and judge Ginsburg was sort of old 879 00:52:13,589 --> 00:52:14,998 to be a nominee. 880 00:52:15,189 --> 00:52:17,463 She was in her early 60s. 881 00:52:17,963 --> 00:52:19,989 Most people, I think, thought 882 00:52:20,025 --> 00:52:22,049 she was out of the running for that reason 883 00:52:22,408 --> 00:52:24,975 and Marty was just not gonna accept that. 884 00:52:25,010 --> 00:52:27,525 MILLER: We're talking about Ruth 885 00:52:27,806 --> 00:52:30,313 and we must remember how shy she was. 886 00:52:30,908 --> 00:52:36,525 I can't think of anyone less likely to toot her own horn 887 00:52:37,172 --> 00:52:38,330 than Ruth. 888 00:52:40,279 --> 00:52:43,611 So Marty had to play the New York Philharmonic. 889 00:52:44,564 --> 00:52:46,408 [ OPERA MUSIC] 890 00:52:46,580 --> 00:52:54,533 ♪ ♪ 891 00:52:55,573 --> 00:52:57,255 RUTH: No question about it, 892 00:52:57,291 --> 00:52:59,650 people who observed at the time, said, 893 00:52:59,759 --> 00:53:01,595 "well, Ruth would have been on a list," 894 00:53:01,631 --> 00:53:04,361 "maybe she would be 22 or 23" 895 00:53:04,843 --> 00:53:07,299 but it was Marty who made her number one. 896 00:53:09,455 --> 00:53:12,916 He had a little book of people that he contacted. 897 00:53:13,351 --> 00:53:14,424 They were... 898 00:53:14,502 --> 00:53:16,020 [LAUGHING] 899 00:53:16,056 --> 00:53:19,094 TOTENBERG: He had lots of contacts in the business community, 900 00:53:19,336 --> 00:53:21,667 lots of contacts in the legal community, 901 00:53:21,703 --> 00:53:25,402 in the academic community, among the women she had helped. 902 00:53:25,937 --> 00:53:30,190 And he... I don't even know all the things he did. 903 00:53:30,226 --> 00:53:34,289 He was so in love with his wife and so respected her 904 00:53:34,805 --> 00:53:37,347 as a real giant in the legal profession, 905 00:53:37,382 --> 00:53:38,862 he felt it would be an outrage 906 00:53:38,898 --> 00:53:40,961 if she wasn't seriously considered. 907 00:53:41,140 --> 00:53:43,854 And look, he wasn't the only one that was campaigning 908 00:53:43,889 --> 00:53:45,488 for somebody to be on the Court. 909 00:53:45,765 --> 00:53:47,445 He had some pretty stiff opposition... 910 00:53:48,344 --> 00:53:50,906 but it was her interview that did it. 911 00:53:51,361 --> 00:53:54,126 ♪ ♪ 912 00:53:54,758 --> 00:53:56,917 We arranged for her to come to the white house. 913 00:53:56,953 --> 00:53:58,672 I wanted to see how her mind worked. 914 00:53:59,027 --> 00:54:00,793 So I engaged her in this conversation. 915 00:54:01,273 --> 00:54:03,690 And all of a sudden, I wasn't the president interviewing her 916 00:54:03,726 --> 00:54:06,237 for the Supreme Court anymore, we were two people having 917 00:54:06,273 --> 00:54:08,912 an honest discussion about what's the best way 918 00:54:09,305 --> 00:54:12,789 in the moment and for the future to make law. 919 00:54:13,750 --> 00:54:17,469 TOTENBERG: Ruth Ginsburg, as quiet and kind of withdrawn 920 00:54:17,883 --> 00:54:21,558 and almost timid as she can be, she is a performer 921 00:54:22,187 --> 00:54:24,484 and she walked in that room and he fell for her. 922 00:54:24,531 --> 00:54:27,063 Literally, within 15 minutes, I decided 923 00:54:27,098 --> 00:54:28,464 I was going to name her. 924 00:54:28,500 --> 00:54:31,039 [APPLAUSE] 925 00:54:32,797 --> 00:54:35,570 CLINTON: I'm proud to nominate this path-breaking attorney, 926 00:54:35,726 --> 00:54:39,209 advocate, and judge to be the 107th justice 927 00:54:39,680 --> 00:54:41,844 to the United States Supreme Court. 928 00:54:49,851 --> 00:54:53,320 RUTH: When I was nominated back in 1993, 929 00:54:53,359 --> 00:54:55,656 senator Biden chaired the committee. 930 00:54:56,219 --> 00:54:59,663 The leading republican member was Orrin Hatch. 931 00:55:00,305 --> 00:55:01,865 MAN: Do you have any concerns right now? 932 00:55:01,900 --> 00:55:03,116 There are always concerns 933 00:55:03,152 --> 00:55:05,519 because these are very important positions. 934 00:55:05,555 --> 00:55:08,195 And so there will be a lot of questions asked. 935 00:55:13,297 --> 00:55:16,713 Day two of the Ruth Bader Ginsburg confirmation hearings. 936 00:55:16,748 --> 00:55:18,526 Judge Ginsburg did something 937 00:55:18,562 --> 00:55:21,058 no recent High Court nominee has done, 938 00:55:21,094 --> 00:55:24,242 spoke at length about her support for abortion rights. 939 00:55:24,680 --> 00:55:28,953 It is essential to women's equality with man... 940 00:55:30,070 --> 00:55:33,945 that her choice... that she be the decision maker. 941 00:55:35,101 --> 00:55:38,578 This is something central to a woman's... 942 00:55:39,336 --> 00:55:41,204 life, to her dignity. 943 00:55:41,859 --> 00:55:44,805 And when government controls that decision for her, 944 00:55:45,336 --> 00:55:49,211 she is being treated as less than a fully adult... 945 00:55:49,714 --> 00:55:51,601 human responsible for... 946 00:55:52,748 --> 00:55:54,549 her own choices. 947 00:55:55,117 --> 00:55:57,624 She was put on the Court by a liberal president, 948 00:55:58,490 --> 00:56:01,234 uh, as a liberal justice. 949 00:56:02,039 --> 00:56:04,239 And that's the way this country works. 950 00:56:04,687 --> 00:56:06,529 ORRIN HATCH: I disagree with you on a number of things, 951 00:56:06,564 --> 00:56:08,665 and I am sure you disagree with me. 952 00:56:08,700 --> 00:56:10,273 But that isn't the issue, is it? 953 00:56:10,422 --> 00:56:12,130 And frankly, I admire you. 954 00:56:12,656 --> 00:56:14,175 You've earned the right, 955 00:56:14,211 --> 00:56:16,531 in my opinion, to be on the Supreme Court. 956 00:56:16,877 --> 00:56:18,750 She was confirmed 96-3. 957 00:56:18,890 --> 00:56:21,664 Now, you could argue that it was not as partisan a time 958 00:56:21,700 --> 00:56:23,734 as it is now but it was pretty partisan. 959 00:56:24,025 --> 00:56:29,892 ♪ ♪ 960 00:56:36,679 --> 00:56:38,714 NEWS ANCHOR: Promising to defend the Constitution, 961 00:56:38,805 --> 00:56:41,131 pioneering women's rights advocate Ruth Bader Ginsburg 962 00:56:41,166 --> 00:56:43,099 has been sworn in as the second woman, 963 00:56:43,134 --> 00:56:44,901 on the U.S. Supreme Court bench. 964 00:56:45,287 --> 00:56:48,055 I will well and faithfully discharge. 965 00:56:48,273 --> 00:56:51,180 The duties of the office on which I am about to enter. 966 00:56:51,750 --> 00:56:55,612 The duties of the office on which I am about to enter. 967 00:56:55,953 --> 00:56:59,148 - So help me God. - So help me God. 968 00:57:02,484 --> 00:57:04,711 PERATIS: It was extremely exciting 969 00:57:05,015 --> 00:57:08,101 because this powerful little woman 970 00:57:08,211 --> 00:57:09,562 was going on the Supreme Court, 971 00:57:09,627 --> 00:57:12,328 and that meant there were going to be two. 972 00:57:12,486 --> 00:57:17,564 ♪ ♪ 973 00:57:18,720 --> 00:57:22,735 ♪ ♪ 974 00:57:23,953 --> 00:57:27,180 The standard robe is made for a man, 975 00:57:27,258 --> 00:57:31,681 because it has a place for the shirt to show and the tie. 976 00:57:32,390 --> 00:57:36,190 So Sandra Day O'Connor and I, thought it would be appropriate 977 00:57:36,226 --> 00:57:39,633 if we included as part of our robe, 978 00:57:39,846 --> 00:57:42,469 something typical of a woman. 979 00:57:44,337 --> 00:57:46,180 During my long tenure here, 980 00:57:46,279 --> 00:57:48,367 I was not the most quote, 981 00:57:48,484 --> 00:57:50,238 liberal justice on the Court. 982 00:57:50,492 --> 00:57:53,219 From the beginning, I think what she was looking for 983 00:57:53,404 --> 00:57:55,523 was to build consensus. 984 00:57:56,586 --> 00:57:58,597 Even though chief justice Rehnquist 985 00:57:58,633 --> 00:58:01,558 and Sandra day O'Connor were conservative justices. 986 00:58:01,594 --> 00:58:04,479 They were still justices with which, 987 00:58:04,515 --> 00:58:06,633 Ginsburg was able to find common ground. 988 00:58:07,452 --> 00:58:08,828 That was her style. 989 00:58:09,039 --> 00:58:12,489 She really wanted to be able to convince her fellow justices 990 00:58:12,703 --> 00:58:14,789 to move her way even if it means 991 00:58:15,023 --> 00:58:17,680 conceding certain things and compromising. 992 00:58:18,666 --> 00:58:23,759 ♪ ♪ 993 00:58:32,023 --> 00:58:33,367 To start out, 994 00:58:33,461 --> 00:58:36,890 I thought you might like to know a little about the 995 00:58:37,226 --> 00:58:39,328 gentlemen who are surrounding us. 996 00:58:40,156 --> 00:58:43,242 These are the first set of chief justices 997 00:58:43,278 --> 00:58:44,742 of the Supreme Court. 998 00:58:45,711 --> 00:58:48,375 John Marshall is the 4th chief justice and 999 00:58:48,753 --> 00:58:50,011 what he said was, 1000 00:58:50,261 --> 00:58:52,312 that this Constitution 1001 00:58:52,896 --> 00:58:54,964 is the highest law of the land. 1002 00:58:55,750 --> 00:58:57,203 The 14th amendment 1003 00:58:57,680 --> 00:59:00,312 has a clause that you all should know about 1004 00:59:01,161 --> 00:59:04,039 and I'll read it to you. It says... 1005 00:59:06,210 --> 00:59:09,883 "And nor shall any state deny to any person 1006 00:59:10,640 --> 00:59:13,953 the equal protection of the laws." 1007 00:59:14,885 --> 00:59:17,265 So if Congress passes a law 1008 00:59:17,570 --> 00:59:20,703 or the president issues an executive order 1009 00:59:20,937 --> 00:59:23,336 that is in conflict with the Constitution, 1010 00:59:24,094 --> 00:59:27,469 the Constitution must prevail. 1011 00:59:29,799 --> 00:59:34,751 ♪ ♪ 1012 00:59:39,775 --> 00:59:45,884 ♪ ♪ 1013 00:59:48,265 --> 00:59:51,867 FRELINGHUYSEN: VMI was a 150 year old, 1014 00:59:52,354 --> 00:59:54,812 all-male military college. 1015 00:59:55,648 --> 00:59:59,562 It had a tremendous endowment, well-connected alumni, 1016 00:59:59,597 --> 01:00:01,237 four star generals. 1017 01:00:01,273 --> 01:00:04,390 When you came out of VMI that was something. 1018 01:00:04,453 --> 01:00:06,465 BRYANT GUMBEL:Virginia military institute was the last 1019 01:00:06,500 --> 01:00:08,409 all-male state supported school in the country. 1020 01:00:08,445 --> 01:00:12,805 157 years of school tradition as an all-male military academy. 1021 01:00:13,035 --> 01:00:14,902 [CROWD CHEERING] 1022 01:00:15,101 --> 01:00:18,425 TED OLSON: Boys can be troublesome, full of hormones and so forth, 1023 01:00:18,461 --> 01:00:21,718 and I don't mean to make general gender characteristics 1024 01:00:21,815 --> 01:00:25,269 or generalizations here but for some young men, 1025 01:00:25,320 --> 01:00:28,609 at that time of their life they need discipline, 1026 01:00:29,031 --> 01:00:31,128 they need hard work and they need 1027 01:00:31,164 --> 01:00:33,664 not a lot of extra time to get into trouble. 1028 01:00:33,898 --> 01:00:35,672 And VMI provided that. 1029 01:00:35,711 --> 01:00:37,937 MAN: Look at the men which stand before you! 1030 01:00:37,992 --> 01:00:40,851 They represent the essence of VMI! 1031 01:00:42,109 --> 01:00:46,042 A female high school student wanted to attend VMI. 1032 01:00:46,078 --> 01:00:50,367 So she brought a case against Virginia, claiming that 1033 01:00:50,422 --> 01:00:53,273 the all-male admissions policy violated equal protection. 1034 01:00:54,286 --> 01:00:55,956 It actually went from the District Court 1035 01:00:55,992 --> 01:00:58,750 to the appellate Court before it came up to the Supreme Court . 1036 01:00:59,359 --> 01:01:03,914 This was an extremely important case for justice Ginsburg. 1037 01:01:04,163 --> 01:01:09,225 It was her first women's rights case on the Supreme Court. 1038 01:01:10,286 --> 01:01:12,300 COURT OFFICER: The honorable chief justice 1039 01:01:12,336 --> 01:01:15,070 and the associate justices of the Supreme Court 1040 01:01:15,106 --> 01:01:16,839 of the United States. 1041 01:01:17,442 --> 01:01:21,081 OLSON: I was very much aware of justice Ginsburg's history 1042 01:01:21,117 --> 01:01:25,011 with respect to gender excluding women from an institution. 1043 01:01:25,047 --> 01:01:28,394 I was very much aware of that and I was trying to fashion 1044 01:01:28,430 --> 01:01:32,055 an argument that would penetrate that. 1045 01:01:43,361 --> 01:01:47,198 RUTH: 1046 01:01:54,111 --> 01:01:57,446 OLSON: 1047 01:02:01,785 --> 01:02:02,852 RUTH: 1048 01:02:03,211 --> 01:02:05,221 OLSON: 1049 01:02:06,047 --> 01:02:11,960 I was dealing with a very worthy and formidable force 1050 01:02:11,996 --> 01:02:14,130 at the other side of that bench. 1051 01:02:14,165 --> 01:02:18,901 RUTH: 1052 01:02:21,505 --> 01:02:24,373 OLSON: 1053 01:02:27,258 --> 01:02:30,836 That was my pitch. As you know it didn't work. 1054 01:02:39,185 --> 01:02:42,054 RUTH: 1055 01:03:03,513 --> 01:03:06,616 ...to aspire, achieve, 1056 01:03:07,086 --> 01:03:11,453 participate in, and contribute to society... 1057 01:03:12,222 --> 01:03:14,524 based on what they can do. 1058 01:03:15,156 --> 01:03:18,269 NEWS ANCHOR: The for-men only tradition of VMI became history 1059 01:03:18,305 --> 01:03:21,578 with the arrival of women entering as first year cadets. 1060 01:03:21,719 --> 01:03:24,400 MAN: Cadre, take charge of your rats. 1061 01:03:27,724 --> 01:03:30,105 KELLY SULLIVAN: I was in the first class of women. 1062 01:03:30,820 --> 01:03:34,351 We were here not to break tradition not to ruin history 1063 01:03:34,631 --> 01:03:36,336 but to help grow it. 1064 01:03:41,530 --> 01:03:44,519 For those four years I worked extremely hard, 1065 01:03:44,555 --> 01:03:46,389 to be the best person I could be 1066 01:03:46,424 --> 01:03:48,359 and to represent women as a whole. 1067 01:03:48,672 --> 01:03:51,093 I wanted to be that person that stood in front of the men 1068 01:03:51,128 --> 01:03:52,687 and said, "I can do it, too." 1069 01:03:58,268 --> 01:04:00,820 GENERAL PEAY: It's most appropriate that we welcome today 1070 01:04:00,856 --> 01:04:02,797 a member of our nation's highest Court, 1071 01:04:03,119 --> 01:04:04,469 a notable example 1072 01:04:04,734 --> 01:04:08,242 of a citizen with a lifelong dedication to public service, 1073 01:04:08,515 --> 01:04:10,513 justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 1074 01:04:10,572 --> 01:04:11,572 Thank you. 1075 01:04:11,661 --> 01:04:14,517 GENERAL PEAY: Welcome to the Virginia Military Institute. 1076 01:04:14,922 --> 01:04:17,553 VMI fought very hard to keep women out. 1077 01:04:18,156 --> 01:04:21,394 I had an alumni walk up to me, and he says, 1078 01:04:21,430 --> 01:04:23,220 "I'm not going to shake your hand. I want to know" 1079 01:04:23,255 --> 01:04:24,788 why you're here, 1080 01:04:25,500 --> 01:04:28,264 "um, and why you decided to ruin my school." 1081 01:04:28,875 --> 01:04:31,570 I know that there were some people who did not... 1082 01:04:32,797 --> 01:04:37,206 react well to the change and my response to this was, 1083 01:04:37,656 --> 01:04:41,617 "wait and see, you will be proud of the women 1084 01:04:41,913 --> 01:04:45,250 who become graduates of VMI." 1085 01:04:49,125 --> 01:04:52,862 It wasn't just about VMI, it was about the notion 1086 01:04:52,898 --> 01:04:57,933 that you cannot exclude women just because they're women. 1087 01:04:57,969 --> 01:04:59,703 You cannot say categorically, 1088 01:05:00,177 --> 01:05:02,054 "they can't handle this." 1089 01:05:02,320 --> 01:05:04,834 It's way beyond VMI, way beyond. 1090 01:05:05,484 --> 01:05:08,838 And she pulled some of the justices of that Court 1091 01:05:09,515 --> 01:05:15,125 over to see that you start, you start with an assumption 1092 01:05:16,289 --> 01:05:19,719 that you have got to treat both genders equally. 1093 01:05:20,961 --> 01:05:24,933 FEIGEN:That majority opinion, was the culmination of Ruth's 1094 01:05:24,969 --> 01:05:28,578 dedication to the concept of equality for women. 1095 01:05:30,722 --> 01:05:33,258 RUTH: Those are current cadets. 1096 01:05:36,219 --> 01:05:40,648 One wanted to be a nuclear scientist, the others engineers. 1097 01:05:41,371 --> 01:05:44,523 All very well adjusted to life at VMI. 1098 01:05:51,681 --> 01:05:53,461 So, you can see... 1099 01:05:54,578 --> 01:05:58,562 many varieties there are more up on top. 1100 01:05:59,258 --> 01:06:01,453 This is the latest one I've gotten. 1101 01:06:03,515 --> 01:06:04,985 WEST: So people just send them to you? 1102 01:06:05,020 --> 01:06:06,453 Yes. 1103 01:06:08,832 --> 01:06:10,156 What's in this one? 1104 01:06:11,086 --> 01:06:15,404 Oh this one was given to me by the University of Hawaii, 1105 01:06:15,642 --> 01:06:17,078 with French lace... 1106 01:06:17,911 --> 01:06:19,867 and the beads are from the beach. 1107 01:06:22,601 --> 01:06:27,055 It is a gift from law clerks, a few terms back. 1108 01:06:27,551 --> 01:06:29,633 And this is what I use... 1109 01:06:30,087 --> 01:06:32,758 for announcing majority opinion. 1110 01:06:33,402 --> 01:06:36,898 And this one is for dissenting opinion. 1111 01:06:43,567 --> 01:06:46,890 RUTH: Every day before we sit in the Court, 1112 01:06:47,039 --> 01:06:49,508 the first thing we do is, we go around the room 1113 01:06:49,906 --> 01:06:52,992 each justice shaking hands with every other. 1114 01:06:53,922 --> 01:06:56,987 We know that collegiality is very important 1115 01:06:57,023 --> 01:06:59,382 to the effective working of the Court. 1116 01:07:00,219 --> 01:07:04,781 So we better respect each other and even like each other. 1117 01:07:05,430 --> 01:07:07,009 She did something I'm not sure I could have done, 1118 01:07:07,044 --> 01:07:09,484 she made real friendship with Scalia. 1119 01:07:09,523 --> 01:07:13,240 TOTENBERG: They are the leading voice of opposite points of views 1120 01:07:13,276 --> 01:07:15,062 on the United States Supreme Court. 1121 01:07:15,125 --> 01:07:17,125 Why don't you call us, the odd couple? 1122 01:07:17,250 --> 01:07:19,562 [LAUGHING] 1123 01:07:19,695 --> 01:07:22,906 He is a very funny fellow. 1124 01:07:22,969 --> 01:07:24,386 She is a very nice person, 1125 01:07:24,422 --> 01:07:26,711 she likes opera, what's not to like? 1126 01:07:28,328 --> 01:07:30,937 Except her views of law of course. 1127 01:07:31,016 --> 01:07:33,211 [LAUGHING] 1128 01:07:33,336 --> 01:07:35,094 HELEN AVARE: Justice Scalia believes 1129 01:07:35,130 --> 01:07:37,307 that one should read the Constitution 1130 01:07:37,343 --> 01:07:39,995 according to its plain language, 1131 01:07:40,031 --> 01:07:44,026 according to the meanings that were ascribed, uh, 1132 01:07:44,062 --> 01:07:48,065 to those words when those words were enacted. 1133 01:07:48,101 --> 01:07:50,339 But you're saying is, let's try to figure out 1134 01:07:50,375 --> 01:07:53,320 the mindset of people back 200 years ago, right? 1135 01:07:53,570 --> 01:07:55,444 Well, it isn't the mindset, 1136 01:07:55,480 --> 01:07:58,151 it's - it's, what - what did the words mean 1137 01:07:58,187 --> 01:08:00,245 to the people who ratified the bill of rights 1138 01:08:00,281 --> 01:08:01,777 or who ratified the Constitution. 1139 01:08:01,813 --> 01:08:03,940 As opposed to what people today think it meant? 1140 01:08:03,976 --> 01:08:06,548 As opposed to what people today would like. 1141 01:08:06,584 --> 01:08:08,461 I see the Constitution, 1142 01:08:08,578 --> 01:08:11,562 as striving for a more perfect union. 1143 01:08:11,898 --> 01:08:15,124 Who were we the people in 1787? 1144 01:08:15,508 --> 01:08:17,995 You would not be among we the people, 1145 01:08:18,031 --> 01:08:21,063 African Americans would not be among the people. 1146 01:08:21,664 --> 01:08:24,144 GENE SCALIA: She's this supposed famous liberal, 1147 01:08:24,180 --> 01:08:26,144 he's this supposed famous conservative. 1148 01:08:26,180 --> 01:08:29,271 She's a Jewish, he's, uh, catholic. 1149 01:08:29,765 --> 01:08:33,430 She's retiring at times, and he almost never is. 1150 01:08:33,898 --> 01:08:38,136 And yet as with many great friendships there's chemistry 1151 01:08:38,172 --> 01:08:40,542 that maybe you can't entirely explain. 1152 01:08:40,578 --> 01:08:43,917 That's thing about Ruth is that she can compartmentalize 1153 01:08:43,953 --> 01:08:46,889 better than I do. She is able to have a close friend 1154 01:08:46,924 --> 01:08:48,969 who had these outrageous views, 1155 01:08:49,429 --> 01:08:50,176 um, 1156 01:08:50,358 --> 01:08:53,063 about women and about gays and lesbians. 1157 01:08:53,573 --> 01:08:54,840 I have a little bit of trouble with that. 1158 01:08:54,875 --> 01:08:56,922 I don't have close friends who are right wing 1159 01:08:56,958 --> 01:08:57,604 nutcases. 1160 01:08:57,640 --> 01:08:59,558 Even though they had differing points of view, 1161 01:08:59,594 --> 01:09:02,104 they were dear friends. I'm sure they were... 1162 01:09:02,508 --> 01:09:04,273 picking at each other the whole time. 1163 01:09:04,338 --> 01:09:06,225 But they kind of enjoyed it. 1164 01:09:06,570 --> 01:09:09,484 RUTH: Justice scalia would whisper something to me. 1165 01:09:09,609 --> 01:09:12,956 All I could do to avoid laughing out loud, 1166 01:09:12,992 --> 01:09:15,284 so I would sometimes pinch myself. 1167 01:09:15,351 --> 01:09:16,776 People sometimes ask me, 1168 01:09:16,812 --> 01:09:19,603 "well, what was your favorite scalia joke?" And I said, 1169 01:09:19,639 --> 01:09:21,633 "I know what it is, but I can't tell you." 1170 01:09:21,703 --> 01:09:22,976 [LAUGHING] 1171 01:09:23,014 --> 01:09:24,919 They enjoyed going to the operas together, 1172 01:09:24,955 --> 01:09:27,750 and they enjoyed discussing particular operas 1173 01:09:27,801 --> 01:09:30,718 and of course, they appeared together in an opera. 1174 01:09:32,813 --> 01:09:35,484 TOTENBERG: What's the most fun thing you've ever done together? 1175 01:09:35,520 --> 01:09:38,039 Was it being on that elephant together in India? 1176 01:09:38,631 --> 01:09:40,758 RUTH: That was a rather bumpy ride. 1177 01:09:40,984 --> 01:09:44,578 ANTONIN SCALIA: Some of her feminist friends gave her a hard time 1178 01:09:44,712 --> 01:09:47,747 because she rode behind me on the elephant. 1179 01:09:47,852 --> 01:09:50,062 - And that's wha... - I'm not kidding. 1180 01:09:50,117 --> 01:09:53,422 It-- it was... the driver explained it was a matter 1181 01:09:53,457 --> 01:09:55,257 of distribution of weight. 1182 01:09:55,446 --> 01:09:56,969 [LAUGHING] 1183 01:09:57,320 --> 01:09:59,728 Washington has a reputation as being a hard town 1184 01:09:59,763 --> 01:10:01,190 to make good friendships. 1185 01:10:01,226 --> 01:10:04,140 And the Supreme Court itself is a place where your colleagues 1186 01:10:04,176 --> 01:10:06,578 on any given case are also your adversaries. 1187 01:10:06,914 --> 01:10:09,906 It was very gratifying to see the two of them together 1188 01:10:09,942 --> 01:10:11,806 and know that they had their disagreements 1189 01:10:11,851 --> 01:10:14,594 but that my father had this just really wonderful friend. 1190 01:10:16,883 --> 01:10:18,862 PETER JENNINGS: The presidential election is over. 1191 01:10:18,898 --> 01:10:22,492 George Bush prevails by one vote in the Supreme Court . 1192 01:10:23,812 --> 01:10:25,883 George, this effectively ends the election. 1193 01:10:25,919 --> 01:10:27,120 It has ended the election and Peter, 1194 01:10:27,155 --> 01:10:30,031 literally one of the closest elections in American history. 1195 01:10:30,164 --> 01:10:33,542 600 votes approximately separated Gore and bush 1196 01:10:33,578 --> 01:10:35,894 in the state of Florida, and now by one vote 1197 01:10:35,930 --> 01:10:38,133 on the Supreme Court, this election is over. 1198 01:10:38,765 --> 01:10:41,562 Look at the dissents and the strong language in the dissents. 1199 01:10:41,598 --> 01:10:43,722 Justice Ginsburg, "the Court's conclusion" 1200 01:10:43,758 --> 01:10:46,120 that a recount is impractical, is a prophecy 1201 01:10:46,156 --> 01:10:49,245 the Court's own judgment will not allow to be tested. 1202 01:10:49,280 --> 01:10:51,183 "Such an untested prophecy..." 1203 01:10:51,219 --> 01:10:54,250 ...should not decide the presidency 1204 01:10:54,518 --> 01:10:56,219 of the United States. 1205 01:10:57,159 --> 01:10:58,328 I dissent. 1206 01:11:00,698 --> 01:11:03,300 CARMON:She was never supposed to be the great dissenter 1207 01:11:03,336 --> 01:11:06,383 but that's the course that history took her on. 1208 01:11:08,195 --> 01:11:12,167 George W. Bush was able to appoint two justices. 1209 01:11:12,859 --> 01:11:16,703 The addition of Samuel Alito and John Roberts on the Court 1210 01:11:17,074 --> 01:11:18,898 pushed it far to the right. 1211 01:11:19,695 --> 01:11:24,179 FRELINGHUYSEN: The role of an individual justice can change dramatically 1212 01:11:24,215 --> 01:11:25,614 as the Court changes. 1213 01:11:26,031 --> 01:11:28,751 With the departure of justice O'Connor 1214 01:11:29,328 --> 01:11:33,480 and with more conservatives joining the bench. 1215 01:11:33,516 --> 01:11:38,094 She found she had to really exercise her dissenting voice. 1216 01:11:40,640 --> 01:11:43,599 RUTH: Of course I prefer to be in the majority 1217 01:11:43,634 --> 01:11:45,901 but if necessary... 1218 01:11:46,461 --> 01:11:49,695 I will write separately in dissent. 1219 01:11:55,906 --> 01:11:57,569 Lilly Ledbetter: I went to work one night 1220 01:11:57,605 --> 01:11:59,484 and someone had left me a note. 1221 01:11:59,672 --> 01:12:05,281 It had my name and three men. We four had the exact same job. 1222 01:12:05,873 --> 01:12:09,275 My pay was 40 percent less than theirs. 1223 01:12:09,508 --> 01:12:12,440 I had been shortchanged for no other reason 1224 01:12:12,476 --> 01:12:16,492 than I had been born the wrong sex, I was a woman. 1225 01:12:17,476 --> 01:12:20,383 The jury found that I had been discriminated against 1226 01:12:20,437 --> 01:12:21,993 but of course, Goodyear appealed 1227 01:12:22,029 --> 01:12:23,305 and then we were notified 1228 01:12:23,340 --> 01:12:26,414 that we would be heard in the Supreme Court . 1229 01:12:28,411 --> 01:12:30,344 I looked at the Court makeup, 1230 01:12:30,531 --> 01:12:34,164 that's when justice Alito had just gone on the bench. 1231 01:12:34,328 --> 01:12:38,140 Justice Ginsburg at the time was the only female left. 1232 01:12:38,344 --> 01:12:40,402 Justice Alito read the opinion, 1233 01:12:40,859 --> 01:12:41,776 he said, 1234 01:12:41,812 --> 01:12:43,889 "I was definitely" discriminated 1235 01:12:43,994 --> 01:12:47,593 against but I had not filed my charge timely, 1236 01:12:47,789 --> 01:12:50,780 "that I'd waited too late to file my charge." 1237 01:12:56,005 --> 01:12:59,674 RUTH: 1238 01:13:25,183 --> 01:13:28,619 She's hit the nail on the head because she definitely said, 1239 01:13:28,655 --> 01:13:31,807 "they do not know what it's like in the real world." 1240 01:13:32,436 --> 01:13:35,811 RUTH: Today, the ball again lies in Congress' Court... 1241 01:13:36,483 --> 01:13:40,716 "...to correct the error into which the Court has fallen." 1242 01:13:41,092 --> 01:13:44,575 She was laying down a marker for Congress and in fact 1243 01:13:44,748 --> 01:13:47,482 federal law was changed because of her dissent. 1244 01:13:47,653 --> 01:13:50,747 Three fifths of the senators having voted in the affirmative, 1245 01:13:51,196 --> 01:13:52,575 the bill has passed. 1246 01:13:57,551 --> 01:14:02,527 BARACK OBAMA: It is fitting that the very first bill that I sign, 1247 01:14:03,083 --> 01:14:07,727 the Lilly Ledbetter fair pay restoration act is upholding 1248 01:14:07,763 --> 01:14:10,591 one of this nation's founding principles... 1249 01:14:11,380 --> 01:14:13,549 that we are all created equal... 1250 01:14:13,903 --> 01:14:16,552 and each deserve a chance to pursue 1251 01:14:16,680 --> 01:14:18,880 our own version of happiness. 1252 01:14:29,364 --> 01:14:31,667 MARTY:Ruth and I were in New York City 1253 01:14:31,702 --> 01:14:33,402 to see the play proof. 1254 01:14:33,739 --> 01:14:37,208 And as we walked down the aisle to our seats, 1255 01:14:37,247 --> 01:14:41,716 what seemed like the entire audience began to applaud, 1256 01:14:42,012 --> 01:14:45,059 many stood, Ruth beamed. 1257 01:14:45,581 --> 01:14:48,951 I beamed too, leaned over 1258 01:14:49,153 --> 01:14:51,434 and whispered loudly, 1259 01:14:51,708 --> 01:14:56,192 "I bet you didn't know there's a convention of tax lawyers in town." 1260 01:14:58,138 --> 01:15:01,773 Well, without changing her bright smile, 1261 01:15:02,044 --> 01:15:04,700 Ruth smacked me right in the stomach. 1262 01:15:05,513 --> 01:15:09,583 I give you this picture because it fairly captures 1263 01:15:09,723 --> 01:15:13,273 our nearly 50-year happy marriage. 1264 01:15:13,309 --> 01:15:16,220 During which I've offered up an astonishing 1265 01:15:16,256 --> 01:15:18,438 number of foolish pronouncements 1266 01:15:18,521 --> 01:15:21,179 and Ruth has ignored almost every one. 1267 01:15:21,281 --> 01:15:22,757 [CROWD LAUGHING] 1268 01:15:22,875 --> 01:15:25,218 [APPLAUSE] 1269 01:15:27,857 --> 01:15:29,320 Well, I think part of the time 1270 01:15:29,356 --> 01:15:31,622 when he was sick, she was in denial. 1271 01:15:32,067 --> 01:15:34,700 He just became weaker and weaker. 1272 01:15:35,153 --> 01:15:37,513 The way people get sick when they're... 1273 01:15:37,983 --> 01:15:39,719 close to dying, but... 1274 01:15:41,247 --> 01:15:46,028 she somehow knew how to turn off those tear ducts in public. 1275 01:15:46,776 --> 01:15:48,684 She steeled herself for it. 1276 01:15:50,346 --> 01:15:53,582 RUTH: I found this letter... 1277 01:15:54,083 --> 01:15:56,669 next to Marty's bed in the hospital. 1278 01:15:57,553 --> 01:15:59,254 "My dearest Ruth," 1279 01:15:59,942 --> 01:16:03,325 you are the only person I have loved in my life, 1280 01:16:03,997 --> 01:16:07,817 setting aside a bit parents and kids and their kids. 1281 01:16:08,973 --> 01:16:12,234 What a treat it has been to watch you progress 1282 01:16:12,716 --> 01:16:15,020 to the very top of the legal world. 1283 01:16:16,466 --> 01:16:18,828 I have admired and loved you 1284 01:16:18,864 --> 01:16:21,638 almost since the day we first met at Cornell, 1285 01:16:21,822 --> 01:16:23,968 some 56 years ago. 1286 01:16:26,450 --> 01:16:29,544 The time has come for me to take leave of life... 1287 01:16:30,186 --> 01:16:32,341 because the loss of quality... 1288 01:16:32,922 --> 01:16:35,872 now simply overwhelms. 1289 01:16:37,481 --> 01:16:40,356 I hope you will support where I come out... 1290 01:16:41,564 --> 01:16:43,927 and I understand you may not. 1291 01:16:46,202 --> 01:16:48,145 I will not love you... 1292 01:16:49,505 --> 01:16:51,640 "a jot less." 1293 01:16:54,802 --> 01:16:58,247 MARTY:We met on a blind date in 1950. 1294 01:16:58,458 --> 01:17:03,169 The truth is it was a blind date only on Ruth's side. 1295 01:17:03,484 --> 01:17:05,187 [LAUGHING] 1296 01:17:05,356 --> 01:17:07,067 MARTY: I cheated. 1297 01:17:07,187 --> 01:17:08,492 [LAUGHING] 1298 01:17:08,677 --> 01:17:13,169 MARTY:I asked a classmate to point her out in advance. 1299 01:17:13,575 --> 01:17:17,666 "Oh, ho, she's really cute," I perceptively noticed. 1300 01:17:18,309 --> 01:17:22,216 And then after a couple of evenings out, I, uh, added, 1301 01:17:22,252 --> 01:17:25,684 "and boy she's really, really smart." 1302 01:17:26,372 --> 01:17:30,677 In the intervening 53 years, nothing changed. 1303 01:17:39,121 --> 01:17:40,329 Where are we headed? 1304 01:17:40,365 --> 01:17:42,633 We're headed to these outdoor sculptures, 1305 01:17:42,677 --> 01:17:44,381 and all the sculptures are done by contemporary 1306 01:17:44,416 --> 01:17:45,583 native American artists. 1307 01:17:46,411 --> 01:17:50,132 SPERA: After a period of very justified mourning, 1308 01:17:50,403 --> 01:17:52,567 she sort of relaunched herself, 1309 01:17:52,629 --> 01:17:54,755 into her work and filled the time 1310 01:17:54,791 --> 01:17:56,359 that she would have spent 1311 01:17:56,395 --> 01:17:58,516 with my grandfather, with work 1312 01:17:58,552 --> 01:18:00,031 both to distract herself I think 1313 01:18:00,067 --> 01:18:02,844 from his absence but also to honor him. 1314 01:18:03,403 --> 01:18:07,315 WOMAN: This is her son, James, and this is her grandson... 1315 01:18:07,950 --> 01:18:09,672 TOTENBERG: Marty was her life. 1316 01:18:09,708 --> 01:18:12,421 And her children and grandchildren who 1317 01:18:12,456 --> 01:18:14,289 have a life of their own. 1318 01:18:14,622 --> 01:18:16,658 She's very much interested in arts 1319 01:18:16,693 --> 01:18:18,677 and loves to go to those things. 1320 01:18:18,934 --> 01:18:21,716 And then she goes home at the end of the evening 1321 01:18:21,824 --> 01:18:23,524 and works until four in the morning. 1322 01:18:23,747 --> 01:18:27,403 These two pieces are by a creek artist. 1323 01:18:27,481 --> 01:18:29,591 RUTH: And what is she called, that one? 1324 01:18:29,665 --> 01:18:31,001 TOUR GUIDE: She's called a woman warrior. 1325 01:18:31,036 --> 01:18:34,591 Any kind of battle you bring to her, she's ready for it. 1326 01:18:38,419 --> 01:18:41,031 It's considered one of the most important pieces 1327 01:18:41,067 --> 01:18:43,731 of civil rights legislation ever passed, 1328 01:18:43,778 --> 01:18:46,555 but by 5-4 the U.S. Supreme Court today, 1329 01:18:46,591 --> 01:18:49,898 took the teeth out of a law enacted nearly 50 years ago. 1330 01:18:49,934 --> 01:18:53,255 REPORTER:Voting rights act has policed voting discrimination 1331 01:18:53,302 --> 01:18:56,434 but today's decision effectively puts it on hold. 1332 01:18:56,567 --> 01:18:58,227 REPORTER 2: Chief justice, John Roberts, 1333 01:18:58,263 --> 01:19:01,536 summarized his opinion with four telling words, 1334 01:19:01,571 --> 01:19:04,106 "our country has changed." 1335 01:19:07,104 --> 01:19:11,106 RUTH: 1336 01:19:13,014 --> 01:19:15,809 "...is like throwing away your umbrella..." 1337 01:19:16,622 --> 01:19:18,056 "in a rainstorm..." 1338 01:19:18,497 --> 01:19:20,528 "because you are not getting wet." 1339 01:19:20,934 --> 01:19:25,645 She called out the majority and said this makes zero sense. 1340 01:19:26,028 --> 01:19:30,427 The entire reason that racial discrimination in voting 1341 01:19:30,825 --> 01:19:35,367 is not happening is because we have this very important law. 1342 01:19:35,403 --> 01:19:39,239 I was righteously angry right alongside with her. 1343 01:19:39,395 --> 01:19:43,036 Her dissent was the introduction for many young people 1344 01:19:43,161 --> 01:19:45,927 about how important the Court is to our everyday lives. 1345 01:19:46,223 --> 01:19:48,183 I just pulled up Photoshop and did the design 1346 01:19:48,218 --> 01:19:49,356 in like 15 minutes. 1347 01:19:49,411 --> 01:19:51,062 AMINA SOW: I came up with a couple slogans 1348 01:19:51,098 --> 01:19:53,161 but the one that kept coming back to me was, 1349 01:19:53,204 --> 01:19:56,071 "you can't spell truth without Ruth." 1350 01:19:57,116 --> 01:19:59,344 KNIZHNIK:A friend of mine posted on Facebook saying, 1351 01:19:59,380 --> 01:20:01,364 "Wow! Justice Ginsburg, sure can write" 1352 01:20:01,407 --> 01:20:02,797 # NotoriousRBG 1353 01:20:03,388 --> 01:20:07,035 So I started a Tumblr and I called it Notorious RBG. 1354 01:20:07,770 --> 01:20:09,825 NOTRE DAME: She is known to fans the world over as, 1355 01:20:09,861 --> 01:20:12,106 the Notorious RBG. 1356 01:20:13,142 --> 01:20:16,473 BIGGIE SMALLS:Yeah... This album is dedicated to all the teachers 1357 01:20:16,509 --> 01:20:18,552 that told me I'd never amount to nothing. 1358 01:20:18,622 --> 01:20:22,851 I do know where the Notorious RBG came from. 1359 01:20:23,402 --> 01:20:28,252 It... it was the rapper the Notorious B.I.G. 1360 01:20:28,633 --> 01:20:29,664 [RAP MUSIC] 1361 01:20:29,805 --> 01:20:33,969 ♪ ♪ 1362 01:20:34,263 --> 01:20:38,270 People ask me, "don't you feel uncomfortable being" 1363 01:20:38,847 --> 01:20:42,231 with a name like Notorious B.I.G?" 1364 01:20:43,206 --> 01:20:46,200 Um... why should I feel uncomfortable? 1365 01:20:46,661 --> 01:20:48,536 We have a lot in common. 1366 01:20:48,641 --> 01:20:49,672 [LAUGHING] 1367 01:20:49,735 --> 01:20:52,602 [APPLAUSE] 1368 01:20:54,098 --> 01:20:55,785 First and foremost... 1369 01:20:56,228 --> 01:20:59,309 we were both born and bred in Brooklyn, New York. 1370 01:20:59,407 --> 01:21:00,609 [LAUGHING] 1371 01:21:01,208 --> 01:21:03,425 SOW: Young people are really craving 1372 01:21:03,460 --> 01:21:04,793 different kinds of icons. 1373 01:21:05,153 --> 01:21:07,095 Realizing that somebody like RBG 1374 01:21:07,130 --> 01:21:09,950 has been doing her job for decades 1375 01:21:10,098 --> 01:21:12,801 and being forceful and speaking truth to power 1376 01:21:12,836 --> 01:21:14,436 kind of blows my mind. 1377 01:21:14,903 --> 01:21:16,538 DON LEMON:A big win for conservatives 1378 01:21:16,573 --> 01:21:18,388 in the hobby lobby case. 1379 01:21:19,204 --> 01:21:23,359 ♪ ♪ 1380 01:21:24,050 --> 01:21:26,754 ROBERTS: Justice Ginsburg has filed a dissenting opinion. 1381 01:21:27,432 --> 01:21:30,566 RUTH: 1382 01:21:38,475 --> 01:21:42,234 We were all so hungry to hear from Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 1383 01:21:42,270 --> 01:21:44,199 Every time justice Ginsburg wrote a dissent, 1384 01:21:44,234 --> 01:21:45,461 the Internet would explode. 1385 01:21:45,497 --> 01:21:47,766 MAN 1: Justice Ginsburg has filed a dissenting opinion. 1386 01:21:47,802 --> 01:21:50,242 MAN 2: Justice Ginsburg has filed a dissenting opinion. 1387 01:21:50,278 --> 01:21:52,239 RUTH: My dissenting opinion. I dissent. 1388 01:21:52,275 --> 01:21:54,180 Dissent from today's decision. 1389 01:21:54,216 --> 01:21:56,510 CARMON:You just had to put the words Ruth Bader Ginsburg 1390 01:21:56,546 --> 01:22:00,005 into something and it would be shared compulsively. 1391 01:22:00,227 --> 01:22:07,445 ♪ ♪ 1392 01:22:08,274 --> 01:22:11,289 ♪ ♪ 1393 01:22:11,458 --> 01:22:17,799 TOTENBERG: She's become such a rock star and she enjoys it. 1394 01:22:18,500 --> 01:22:19,329 To see 1395 01:22:19,365 --> 01:22:22,013 people wear Notorious RBG t-shirts 1396 01:22:22,049 --> 01:22:25,288 or other paraphernalia with her face on it. 1397 01:22:25,475 --> 01:22:27,133 It's weird honestly. 1398 01:22:27,169 --> 01:22:29,310 She gives her RBG t-shirts to people. 1399 01:22:29,513 --> 01:22:31,313 EDWARDS: She called and laughed did you get the birthday gift? 1400 01:22:31,348 --> 01:22:33,448 I said I did I'm wearing it. 1401 01:22:33,483 --> 01:22:35,802 - Tattoos! Yeah. - Lots of tattoos. 1402 01:22:35,990 --> 01:22:38,253 CARMON:I had a picture of one of the tattoos 1403 01:22:38,294 --> 01:22:41,091 and I showed it to her and she goes "uh!" 1404 01:22:41,383 --> 01:22:43,591 Why would you do something so permanent?" 1405 01:22:45,209 --> 01:22:47,740 Here now to comment is Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 1406 01:22:47,906 --> 01:22:49,625 [CROWD CHEERING] 1407 01:22:50,953 --> 01:22:52,587 Alright! Justice coming in hot. 1408 01:22:52,623 --> 01:22:55,804 I'm ready to rumble Mayweather, Pacquiao style. 1409 01:22:56,115 --> 01:22:58,707 I float like a butterfly, sting like a bee, 1410 01:22:58,742 --> 01:23:00,779 I clean myself like a fly. 1411 01:23:00,954 --> 01:23:03,141 [LAUGHING] 1412 01:23:03,546 --> 01:23:04,797 JIM: It's so unlike mom, 1413 01:23:04,833 --> 01:23:07,949 but I don't think mom... an accurate imitation of mom 1414 01:23:07,984 --> 01:23:09,724 would be that funny. 1415 01:23:09,896 --> 01:23:11,857 BETSY: Do you think she watches them? 1416 01:23:11,958 --> 01:23:13,388 I don't think she ever has watched television. 1417 01:23:13,423 --> 01:23:15,090 Yeah, I'm not sure she knows how to turn on... 1418 01:23:15,125 --> 01:23:17,435 No, no, she watches the NewsHour while she's working out. 1419 01:23:17,560 --> 01:23:19,995 Yeah, but that's at the Court, does she know how to turn on 1420 01:23:20,030 --> 01:23:22,107 - the television at home? - I don't think so. 1421 01:23:22,740 --> 01:23:27,068 Here to explain is Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. 1422 01:23:27,103 --> 01:23:28,803 Is this' Saturday Night Live'? 1423 01:23:29,599 --> 01:23:34,042 I like my men like I like my decisions: 5-4. 1424 01:23:34,077 --> 01:23:36,711 That's a third-degree Gins-burn!! 1425 01:23:37,296 --> 01:23:39,530 [LAUGHING] 1426 01:23:47,295 --> 01:23:49,826 It's marvelously funny. How did they... 1427 01:23:50,466 --> 01:23:51,912 JULIE COHEN: Remind you of yourself? 1428 01:23:52,677 --> 01:23:54,146 Not one bit. 1429 01:23:57,800 --> 01:23:59,367 Except for the collar. 1430 01:23:59,849 --> 01:24:01,102 What about the state of the union 1431 01:24:01,137 --> 01:24:02,607 where you were caught sleeping? 1432 01:24:02,654 --> 01:24:04,739 No, I wasn't sleeping I was just giving in 1433 01:24:04,774 --> 01:24:06,716 to the weight of my glasses. 1434 01:24:06,984 --> 01:24:08,898 [LAUGHING] 1435 01:24:11,315 --> 01:24:12,650 SPERA: Watching the state of the union 1436 01:24:12,685 --> 01:24:15,758 and I notice that her head is drooping a little bit 1437 01:24:15,794 --> 01:24:19,646 and she might have dozed off for about a minute or two. 1438 01:24:19,880 --> 01:24:21,790 After that happened, I called her up and said, 1439 01:24:22,246 --> 01:24:24,241 "you know, bubbe, you were asleep during the state of the union, 1440 01:24:24,276 --> 01:24:25,204 you can't do that." 1441 01:24:25,240 --> 01:24:26,920 TOTENBERG: You went to the state of the union 1442 01:24:26,955 --> 01:24:28,187 and you fell asleep. 1443 01:24:29,858 --> 01:24:31,599 As I often do. 1444 01:24:32,099 --> 01:24:34,243 The audience for the most part is awake, 1445 01:24:34,279 --> 01:24:37,446 because they're bobbing up and down all the time... 1446 01:24:37,771 --> 01:24:40,723 and we sit there, stone faced... 1447 01:24:41,044 --> 01:24:43,211 sober judges. But we're not... 1448 01:24:43,638 --> 01:24:46,443 at least I wasn't, a hundred percent sober. 1449 01:24:46,516 --> 01:24:48,531 [LAUGHING] 1450 01:24:49,263 --> 01:24:53,021 TOTENBERG: She does look vulnerable, she is this tiny little person 1451 01:24:53,107 --> 01:24:55,190 and that is somehow in contrast with being 1452 01:24:55,225 --> 01:25:01,248 the ferocious defender of minorities and women and... 1453 01:25:02,064 --> 01:25:03,780 certain kinds of ideals. 1454 01:25:03,816 --> 01:25:05,833 There's always I think the concern that can she 1455 01:25:05,873 --> 01:25:07,779 continue to keep up this pace? 1456 01:25:07,815 --> 01:25:10,671 Well, she's now been through 1457 01:25:10,707 --> 01:25:12,419 two different types of cancer 1458 01:25:12,455 --> 01:25:14,341 without missing a day on the bench. 1459 01:25:14,826 --> 01:25:19,514 RUTH: I had my first cancer bout in 1999, 1460 01:25:19,549 --> 01:25:21,249 Colorectal cancer. 1461 01:25:21,654 --> 01:25:24,552 It was the year of first surgery 1462 01:25:24,587 --> 01:25:26,888 and then chemotherapy. 1463 01:25:27,490 --> 01:25:30,302 Ten years later, I had pancreatic cancer. 1464 01:25:31,005 --> 01:25:33,828 I think what it has left me is... 1465 01:25:34,388 --> 01:25:38,767 an enhanced appreciation of the joys of being alive. 1466 01:25:39,270 --> 01:25:41,837 What I need you to do is just grab them and just pull. 1467 01:25:42,154 --> 01:25:44,852 - Just standing up straight? - Just pull, don't lean back. 1468 01:25:44,888 --> 01:25:49,248 Good, just pull, pull, okay? Arch that back. Good. 1469 01:25:50,716 --> 01:25:52,927 - This is light. - I know, I know, 1470 01:25:53,449 --> 01:25:54,716 I got a heavier one. 1471 01:25:54,912 --> 01:25:56,985 Since it's too light, I got a heavier one 1472 01:25:57,607 --> 01:26:00,818 BRYANT JOHNSON: I started training justice Ginsburg back in 1999. 1473 01:26:01,162 --> 01:26:03,212 She had just come out of chemotherapy 1474 01:26:03,248 --> 01:26:06,732 and she wanted to build muscle and get stronger. 1475 01:26:07,747 --> 01:26:08,880 She's like a cyborg. 1476 01:26:08,994 --> 01:26:11,594 And when I say cyborg, she's like a machine. 1477 01:26:11,813 --> 01:26:12,813 [OPERA MUSIC] 1478 01:26:13,063 --> 01:26:19,531 ♪ ♪ 1479 01:26:20,849 --> 01:26:24,060 Lean back. Good, yeah, and pull yourself up. 1480 01:26:24,514 --> 01:26:26,281 Exactly. Good. 1481 01:26:26,539 --> 01:26:30,031 ♪ ♪ 1482 01:26:30,419 --> 01:26:32,987 Alright, bring chest down to the ball, good. 1483 01:26:33,271 --> 01:26:35,757 They're real push-ups right, they're not girl push-ups. 1484 01:26:35,854 --> 01:26:39,481 No, th... they are... very real, yes. 1485 01:26:39,579 --> 01:26:40,579 [LAUGHING] 1486 01:26:40,724 --> 01:26:43,231 HELSEL: I've heard that she's does 20 push-ups, 1487 01:26:43,266 --> 01:26:44,533 three times a week or something. 1488 01:26:44,568 --> 01:26:46,281 I mean we can't even get off the floor. 1489 01:26:46,317 --> 01:26:47,900 We can't even get down to the floor. 1490 01:26:47,985 --> 01:26:49,539 [LAUGHING] 1491 01:26:49,602 --> 01:26:51,140 That's true. 1492 01:26:51,693 --> 01:26:55,443 RUTH: I always feel better no matter how tired I am, 1493 01:26:55,931 --> 01:26:59,123 at the end of that hour, I'm ready to go again. 1494 01:26:59,688 --> 01:27:01,445 ♪ ♪ 1495 01:27:02,185 --> 01:27:06,208 She definitely embodies the larger than life nature 1496 01:27:06,256 --> 01:27:09,390 of the "notorious" title... 1497 01:27:09,691 --> 01:27:10,892 more and more as she gets older. 1498 01:27:10,927 --> 01:27:13,774 She's become much more public, much more vocal. 1499 01:27:13,810 --> 01:27:15,496 Especially in a time when our politics 1500 01:27:15,531 --> 01:27:17,474 are just so garbage. 1501 01:27:17,724 --> 01:27:20,168 REPORTER 1: Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg spoke fearfully 1502 01:27:20,203 --> 01:27:21,787 of a Donald Trump presidency. 1503 01:27:21,880 --> 01:27:24,704 REPORTER 2: An unusually candid political outpouring 1504 01:27:24,740 --> 01:27:26,423 calling Trump a "faker." 1505 01:27:26,459 --> 01:27:28,158 Justice Ginsburg, uh, 1506 01:27:28,194 --> 01:27:30,575 made some very, very inappropriate... 1507 01:27:30,611 --> 01:27:31,974 statements toward me. 1508 01:27:32,015 --> 01:27:33,466 I was flabbergasted. 1509 01:27:33,662 --> 01:27:37,286 It surprised me that she would comment in a derogatory way 1510 01:27:37,322 --> 01:27:40,896 about any candidate for president. It's... 1511 01:27:43,592 --> 01:27:44,692 it's inappropriate. 1512 01:27:44,728 --> 01:27:46,828 It's not just a matter of decorum... 1513 01:27:47,005 --> 01:27:49,931 it's a matter of her not understanding 1514 01:27:49,966 --> 01:27:51,297 her Constitutional role. 1515 01:27:51,333 --> 01:27:54,282 She has just come out and issued an apology. 1516 01:27:54,318 --> 01:27:57,305 You released a statement that read, "judges should avoid" 1517 01:27:57,341 --> 01:27:59,990 commenting on a candidate for public office." 1518 01:28:00,248 --> 01:28:03,645 But do you really regret the substance of what you said? 1519 01:28:03,680 --> 01:28:05,271 I think in the best, 1520 01:28:05,318 --> 01:28:08,185 the wisest course would have been to say nothing. 1521 01:28:08,482 --> 01:28:11,586 Is it wrong for Supreme Court justices to... 1522 01:28:12,052 --> 01:28:14,722 uh, to occasionally make a mistake? No. 1523 01:28:14,757 --> 01:28:16,060 They're human beings 1524 01:28:16,130 --> 01:28:18,407 and she's a human being and she apologized for it. 1525 01:28:18,443 --> 01:28:22,857 It is quite possible that many, many executive orders 1526 01:28:22,990 --> 01:28:27,029 or other things that a president has supported or done 1527 01:28:27,107 --> 01:28:29,399 are going to come before the Supreme Court 1528 01:28:29,435 --> 01:28:33,044 and that now we have a sitting justice indicating, 1529 01:28:33,107 --> 01:28:35,777 that the person has a deep antipathy, 1530 01:28:35,812 --> 01:28:38,479 uh, against the lawmaker. 1531 01:28:38,514 --> 01:28:39,781 The notion that I... 1532 01:28:40,044 --> 01:28:42,750 I don't comprehend that my job... 1533 01:28:43,107 --> 01:28:46,076 is to interpret the law fairly... 1534 01:28:47,021 --> 01:28:49,935 that I'm going to vote one way... 1535 01:28:50,809 --> 01:28:54,185 based on who I might have voted for president is just... 1536 01:28:57,264 --> 01:28:58,779 none of us... 1537 01:28:59,958 --> 01:29:01,585 even if we wanted to... 1538 01:29:02,208 --> 01:29:05,216 could be successful if that's the attitude that we had. 1539 01:29:18,951 --> 01:29:20,922 ROBERT LONGBOTTOM: You look marvelous. 1540 01:29:21,090 --> 01:29:24,404 Knowing that we were opening on the Saturday after the election, 1541 01:29:24,646 --> 01:29:27,943 I wanted somebody who was a Washington insider 1542 01:29:28,130 --> 01:29:30,832 to play the 'Duchess of Krakenthorp'. 1543 01:29:31,037 --> 01:29:34,037 "The best of the house of Krakenthorp..." 1544 01:29:34,216 --> 01:29:38,612 RUTH: There are very few operas that have speaking parts 1545 01:29:39,042 --> 01:29:42,076 and the Duchess of Krackenthorp 1546 01:29:42,290 --> 01:29:45,357 is one such part. So I wrote... 1547 01:29:46,105 --> 01:29:49,581 basically my own lines for the Duchess of Krackenthorp. 1548 01:29:49,983 --> 01:29:51,741 [CLASSICAL MUSIC] 1549 01:29:51,777 --> 01:29:55,522 ♪ ♪ 1550 01:29:55,725 --> 01:29:58,123 [CROWD CHEERING] 1551 01:29:59,214 --> 01:30:02,526 "The best of the house of Krakenthorp" 1552 01:30:03,029 --> 01:30:06,698 have open, but not empty minds. 1553 01:30:07,175 --> 01:30:08,908 No surprise then 1554 01:30:09,456 --> 01:30:13,241 that the most valorous krakenthorpians 1555 01:30:13,276 --> 01:30:14,691 "have been women!" 1556 01:30:14,829 --> 01:30:15,829 [LAUGHING] 1557 01:30:15,969 --> 01:30:18,242 [CROWD CHEERING] 1558 01:30:18,745 --> 01:30:21,093 "A lady Krackenthorp" 1559 01:30:21,816 --> 01:30:25,319 at all times must conduct herself 1560 01:30:25,354 --> 01:30:28,189 with dignity and grace. 1561 01:30:28,667 --> 01:30:32,620 We now request certain essential documents. 1562 01:30:32,735 --> 01:30:33,735 [LAUGHING] 1563 01:30:33,929 --> 01:30:36,761 "Have you brought your niece's birth certificate?" 1564 01:30:36,868 --> 01:30:39,233 [LAUGHING] 1565 01:30:45,319 --> 01:30:46,506 [LAUGHING] 1566 01:30:46,757 --> 01:30:50,300 "Ours is a family wildly trumpeted," 1567 01:30:50,862 --> 01:30:54,218 hence we must take precautions against 1568 01:30:54,801 --> 01:30:56,409 "fraudulent pretenders." 1569 01:30:56,476 --> 01:30:57,999 [LAUGHING] 1570 01:30:59,334 --> 01:31:01,435 [CROWD CHEERING] 1571 01:31:13,472 --> 01:31:16,838 Justice Ginsburg, I think everyone expected you to retire soon. 1572 01:31:16,874 --> 01:31:17,948 I mean, you're 83. 1573 01:31:18,003 --> 01:31:21,058 Yeah, you're damn right. I was gonna retire. Ugh! 1574 01:31:21,283 --> 01:31:22,428 But not now. 1575 01:31:22,464 --> 01:31:24,745 Not now, now I gotta stay alive and healthy. 1576 01:31:24,780 --> 01:31:26,647 Damn it. Give me my thing. 1577 01:31:27,026 --> 01:31:29,167 Excuse me, I gotta take my vitamins. 1578 01:31:30,143 --> 01:31:32,570 COLIN JOST: Oh my god, that's... 1579 01:31:33,754 --> 01:31:35,909 JOST:...That's... that's a packet. 1580 01:31:36,335 --> 01:31:37,678 [LAUGHING] 1581 01:31:42,438 --> 01:31:45,741 TOTENBERG: Justice Ginsburg, let me ask you a tough question. 1582 01:31:45,878 --> 01:31:50,550 There were liberals who publicly urged you to retire, uh... 1583 01:31:51,473 --> 01:31:52,733 two or three years ago, 1584 01:31:52,769 --> 01:31:55,909 so that president Obama could name a replacement. 1585 01:31:56,776 --> 01:31:59,245 Any second thoughts about not doing that? 1586 01:32:01,769 --> 01:32:04,237 I have said many times that I will... 1587 01:32:05,042 --> 01:32:06,342 do this job... 1588 01:32:06,774 --> 01:32:10,690 as long as I can do it full steam. 1589 01:32:11,364 --> 01:32:13,466 And when I can't... 1590 01:32:14,500 --> 01:32:16,058 that will be the time, 1591 01:32:16,639 --> 01:32:18,373 I will step down. 1592 01:32:20,691 --> 01:32:23,691 MILLER: She has found her voice on the Court. 1593 01:32:24,207 --> 01:32:26,175 She is a center of power... 1594 01:32:27,042 --> 01:32:29,284 on the Court and off the Court. 1595 01:32:29,394 --> 01:32:31,295 TOTENBERG: When the history books are written, 1596 01:32:31,331 --> 01:32:32,980 an enormous amount will be about 1597 01:32:33,015 --> 01:32:36,167 what she did as a very young lawyer. 1598 01:32:36,581 --> 01:32:39,537 PERATIS: There would not have been the legal status 1599 01:32:39,573 --> 01:32:42,730 of women today had it not been for her work in the '70s. 1600 01:32:42,932 --> 01:32:45,420 She changed everything. 1601 01:32:45,456 --> 01:32:49,401 RUTH: The gender line helps to keep women not on a pedestal 1602 01:32:49,944 --> 01:32:51,110 but in a cage 1603 01:32:51,620 --> 01:32:55,436 Ruth's work made me feel as if I was protected 1604 01:32:55,472 --> 01:32:58,230 by the U.S. Constitution for the first time. 1605 01:32:58,441 --> 01:33:00,841 RUTH: Men and women are persons of equal dignity 1606 01:33:00,876 --> 01:33:03,941 and they should count equally before the law. 1607 01:33:04,034 --> 01:33:07,782 She may be small but she's got a firm backbone. 1608 01:33:08,269 --> 01:33:10,326 CARMON: It's been a long road for her 1609 01:33:10,362 --> 01:33:13,542 and she's fought really hard all the way down it. 1610 01:33:13,923 --> 01:33:15,489 She's not done fighting. 1611 01:33:15,980 --> 01:33:18,559 RUTH: Looking back over my long life. 1612 01:33:19,128 --> 01:33:21,948 Yes, we may be in trying times... 1613 01:33:23,231 --> 01:33:25,332 but think how it was. 1614 01:33:25,714 --> 01:33:27,849 RUTH: When I went to college... 1615 01:33:28,151 --> 01:33:31,439 there was a big red scare in our country. 1616 01:33:32,042 --> 01:33:35,462 Some people in our Congress saw a communist in every closet 1617 01:33:35,498 --> 01:33:37,322 and in every corner. 1618 01:33:37,566 --> 01:33:40,348 But it impressed me, that there were lawyers reminding our Congress 1619 01:33:40,383 --> 01:33:43,276 that we have freedom of speech and of the press. 1620 01:33:43,390 --> 01:33:47,194 So I thought that that was a pretty good thing to do... 1621 01:33:47,736 --> 01:33:49,001 ♪ ♪ 1622 01:33:49,731 --> 01:33:52,237 To help keep our country in tune 1623 01:33:52,273 --> 01:33:56,300 with its most basic values. 1624 01:33:56,634 --> 01:33:58,180 ♪ ♪ 1625 01:33:58,683 --> 01:34:01,275 Now is the busiest season for the Court. 1626 01:34:01,311 --> 01:34:04,894 All dissenting opinions have to be... 1627 01:34:05,823 --> 01:34:07,191 circulated. 1628 01:34:07,636 --> 01:34:11,245 And I have a few of those still to go. 1629 01:34:11,995 --> 01:34:15,916 One of the world's greatest jurists, judge learned hand... 1630 01:34:16,386 --> 01:34:19,304 said, that the spirit of Liberty 1631 01:34:19,340 --> 01:34:23,925 that imbues our Constitution must lie first and foremost 1632 01:34:24,094 --> 01:34:26,531 in the hearts of the men and women 1633 01:34:26,926 --> 01:34:29,223 who compose this great nation... 1634 01:34:29,558 --> 01:34:34,776 a community where the least shall be heard and considered 1635 01:34:35,004 --> 01:34:38,386 side by side with the greatest. 1636 01:34:39,414 --> 01:34:43,230 I will keep that wisdom in the front of my mind 1637 01:34:43,386 --> 01:34:46,213 as long as I am capable of judicial service. 1638 01:34:47,003 --> 01:34:52,764 COURT OFFICER: Oyez! Oyez! Oyez! The Court is now sitting. 1639 01:34:55,813 --> 01:35:01,562 ♪ ♪ 1640 01:35:02,335 --> 01:35:05,149 ♪ When you feel you're taking all that you can take ♪ 1641 01:35:05,287 --> 01:35:08,055 ♪ And you're sure you're never gonna catch a break ♪ 1642 01:35:08,214 --> 01:35:11,821 ♪ And the tears are rivers running down your face, ♪ 1643 01:35:12,256 --> 01:35:16,508 ♪ Yeah When your faith is low and you've got no strength left ♪ 1644 01:35:16,778 --> 01:35:19,946 ♪ When you think you've gone as far as you can get ♪ 1645 01:35:20,164 --> 01:35:23,586 ♪ And you're too undone to take another step ♪ 1646 01:35:23,891 --> 01:35:28,313 ♪ Oh I will take up the struggle ♪ 1647 01:35:30,499 --> 01:35:34,352 ♪ Oh I know it's a fight ♪ 1648 01:35:35,275 --> 01:35:41,531 ♪ So I'll fight, fight that war for you ♪ 1649 01:35:41,661 --> 01:35:47,438 ♪ I'll fight, stand and defend you ♪ 1650 01:35:47,515 --> 01:35:51,047 ♪ Take your side, ♪ 1651 01:35:51,150 --> 01:35:53,586 ♪ That's what I'm here to do ♪ 1652 01:35:53,622 --> 01:35:56,231 ♪ I'll be there to be strong ♪ 1653 01:35:56,725 --> 01:36:03,382 ♪ Oh I'll keep on, keep on the fight ♪ 1654 01:36:06,789 --> 01:36:09,563 ♪ When it's dangerous, takes another piece of you ♪ 1655 01:36:09,599 --> 01:36:12,488 ♪ Everybody takes all they can get from you ♪ 1656 01:36:12,594 --> 01:36:16,360 ♪ Till you're left with almost nothing left of you ♪ 1657 01:36:18,273 --> 01:36:21,507 ♪ When each night is like a battle you can't win ♪ 1658 01:36:21,591 --> 01:36:24,274 ♪ And the pain is like a weight you're carrying ♪ 1659 01:36:24,395 --> 01:36:27,811 ♪ I will be the one to help you carry it ♪ 1660 01:36:27,987 --> 01:36:33,313 ♪ Oh I will take all your troubles ♪ 1661 01:36:34,548 --> 01:36:38,726 ♪ Oh I know it's a fight ♪ 1662 01:36:39,473 --> 01:36:46,390 ♪ So I'll fight, fight that war for you ♪ 1663 01:36:46,489 --> 01:36:51,858 ♪ I'll fight, stand and defend you ♪ 1664 01:36:52,023 --> 01:36:57,789 ♪ Take your side, that's what I'm here to do ♪ 1665 01:36:58,131 --> 01:37:05,039 ♪ I'll be there to be strong Oh I'll keep on, keep on the fight ♪ 1666 01:37:05,214 --> 01:37:10,821 ♪ I'll help your back when your backs to the wall ♪ 1667 01:37:10,909 --> 01:37:15,610 ♪ I'll catch the tears when your tears fall ♪ 1668 01:37:15,719 --> 01:37:20,571 ♪ I will give it all I won't give up the fight ♪ 1669 01:37:20,863 --> 01:37:26,664 ♪ So I'll fight, fight that war for you ♪ 1670 01:37:26,905 --> 01:37:32,700 ♪ I'll fight, stand and defend you ♪ 1671 01:37:32,892 --> 01:37:38,819 ♪ Take your side, that's what I'm here to do ♪ 1672 01:37:38,855 --> 01:37:44,788 ♪ I'll be there to be strong Oh I'll keep on, keep on ♪ 1673 01:37:44,824 --> 01:37:50,608 ♪ The fight I'll fight, fight that war for you ♪ 1674 01:37:50,644 --> 01:37:57,541 ♪ I'll fight, stand and defend you... ♪ 1674 01:37:58,305 --> 01:38:04,347 135620

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.