Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:03,770 --> 00:00:08,770
Provided by explosiveskull
https://twitter.com/kaboomskull
2
00:00:10,000 --> 00:00:16,074
Advertise your product or brand here
contact www.OpenSubtitles.org today
3
00:00:30,407 --> 00:00:33,267
September 12th, 2002.
4
00:00:33,269 --> 00:00:35,060
The 57th session
5
00:00:35,062 --> 00:00:38,407
of the United Nations General
Assembly opens in New York City.
6
00:01:17,200 --> 00:01:19,233
On behalf
of the General Assembly,
7
00:01:19,235 --> 00:01:21,750
I have the honour to welcome
to the United Nations,
8
00:01:21,752 --> 00:01:26,405
His Excellency
Mr. George W. Bush,
9
00:01:26,407 --> 00:01:29,716
President of
the United States of America,
10
00:01:29,718 --> 00:01:33,511
and to invite him to address
the General Assembly.
11
00:01:40,993 --> 00:01:43,647
Mr. Secretary-General,
12
00:01:43,649 --> 00:01:47,233
Mr. President,
13
00:01:47,235 --> 00:01:49,509
distinguished delegates,
14
00:01:49,511 --> 00:01:52,440
and ladies and gentlemen,
15
00:01:52,442 --> 00:01:54,509
we meet one year
16
00:01:54,511 --> 00:01:57,923
and one day
after a terrorist attack
17
00:01:57,925 --> 00:02:00,095
that brought grief
to my country,
18
00:02:00,097 --> 00:02:06,164
and brought grief
to many citizens of our world.
19
00:02:06,166 --> 00:02:08,750
All the world now faces a test,
20
00:02:08,752 --> 00:02:11,405
and the United Nations,
21
00:02:11,407 --> 00:02:14,302
a difficult and defining moment.
22
00:02:14,304 --> 00:02:20,267
Will the United Nations serve
the purpose of its founding,
23
00:02:20,269 --> 00:02:22,718
or will it be irrelevant?
24
00:02:42,925 --> 00:02:45,198
It's not the first time
25
00:02:45,200 --> 00:02:46,750
Secretary-General Kofi Annan
26
00:02:46,752 --> 00:02:49,373
has heard the UN
accused of irrelevancy.
27
00:02:52,269 --> 00:02:56,543
Right now, there are
60 nations fighting wars,
28
00:02:56,545 --> 00:03:00,302
and the UN has peacekeeping
missions in 15 of them.
29
00:03:00,304 --> 00:03:03,509
Iraq has tarnished the UN,
30
00:03:03,511 --> 00:03:05,991
but Annan's got
a much bigger problem:
31
00:03:05,993 --> 00:03:08,647
the Democratic Republic
of Congo.
32
00:03:08,649 --> 00:03:11,026
The UN and the Congo
33
00:03:11,028 --> 00:03:14,060
have been linked
since the beginning.
34
00:03:14,062 --> 00:03:15,578
... New York,
35
00:03:15,580 --> 00:03:18,440
where the future of
the United Nations lies at stake
36
00:03:18,442 --> 00:03:19,543
upon the Congo issue.
37
00:03:19,545 --> 00:03:21,336
We believe
that the only way
38
00:03:21,338 --> 00:03:24,060
to keep the Cold War
out of the Congo
39
00:03:24,062 --> 00:03:26,716
is to keep the United Nations
in the Congo.
40
00:03:26,718 --> 00:03:28,612
The speech is interrupted
41
00:03:28,614 --> 00:03:31,750
by a well-organized
demonstration in the gallery.
42
00:03:31,752 --> 00:03:34,060
The stage is set for a test
between the Free World
43
00:03:34,062 --> 00:03:36,543
and the Communist plot,
the most critical moment
44
00:03:36,545 --> 00:03:40,028
in the 15 years of
the United Nations' existence.
45
00:03:51,580 --> 00:03:54,095
Forty years later,
a five-year civil war
46
00:03:54,097 --> 00:03:56,440
in the Congo
is coming to an end.
47
00:03:56,442 --> 00:03:59,267
The result of the war:
48
00:03:59,269 --> 00:04:02,407
three-million Congolese dead.
49
00:04:13,890 --> 00:04:17,716
The United Nations is spending
600-million dollars a year
50
00:04:17,718 --> 00:04:20,474
creating peace in the Congo.
51
00:04:20,476 --> 00:04:23,233
Whether it will work
is uncertain.
52
00:04:23,235 --> 00:04:25,647
Hanging in the balance:
53
00:04:25,649 --> 00:04:28,649
the lives
of 55-million Congolese.
54
00:04:38,166 --> 00:04:42,129
The UN's mission in the Congo
is called MONUC.
55
00:04:42,131 --> 00:04:44,888
Comment ça va?
Comment ça va?
56
00:04:44,890 --> 00:04:47,716
MONUC's frontline
troops are military observers,
57
00:04:47,718 --> 00:04:48,957
"milobs."
58
00:04:48,959 --> 00:04:52,267
Milobs don't carry guns.
59
00:04:52,269 --> 00:04:55,131
They do get shot at.
60
00:04:57,407 --> 00:04:59,509
In the first phases
of the Congo mission,
61
00:04:59,511 --> 00:05:02,095
it was essentially
an observer mission.
62
00:05:02,097 --> 00:05:05,785
And so we gave the impression
that we had lots of troops -
63
00:05:05,787 --> 00:05:08,785
because we already
had 3,000 troops, 4,000 troops -
64
00:05:08,787 --> 00:05:10,819
which looks like a big number,
65
00:05:10,821 --> 00:05:14,302
but which were there
essentially to make sure
66
00:05:14,304 --> 00:05:17,371
that a helicopter
would not be looted,
67
00:05:17,373 --> 00:05:19,888
that an oil depot
would not be looted,
68
00:05:19,890 --> 00:05:21,888
protecting our own assets.
69
00:05:21,890 --> 00:05:24,060
But I think that a mission
70
00:05:24,062 --> 00:05:27,612
in a place like Congo that
is only an observer mission,
71
00:05:27,614 --> 00:05:30,716
that's a very dangerous
proposition politically.
72
00:05:30,718 --> 00:05:35,440
Because the gap that you open
between the expectations
73
00:05:35,442 --> 00:05:37,440
of the people and what you can
actually deliver
74
00:05:37,442 --> 00:05:39,269
is just unsustainable.
75
00:05:45,131 --> 00:05:48,026
The Congo has been
fractured by the civil war.
76
00:05:48,028 --> 00:05:51,957
The Western half,
a madhouse,
77
00:05:51,959 --> 00:05:55,336
controlled
by President Joseph Kabila.
78
00:05:55,338 --> 00:05:58,543
Its capital, Kinshasa,
79
00:05:58,545 --> 00:06:02,407
will be the site
of a transitional government.
80
00:06:17,304 --> 00:06:19,716
A thousand miles from Kinshasa,
81
00:06:19,718 --> 00:06:24,198
and still outside government
control, the Eastern Congo.
82
00:06:24,200 --> 00:06:28,095
The area is blessed
with gold and diamonds,
83
00:06:28,097 --> 00:06:30,166
and cursed by those who want it.
84
00:06:39,097 --> 00:06:42,543
One Eastern district
is particularly dangerous.
85
00:06:42,545 --> 00:06:45,440
It's called Ituri.
86
00:06:45,442 --> 00:06:47,371
Although outwardly peaceful,
87
00:06:47,373 --> 00:06:51,752
the region is controlled
by a dozen violent warlords.
88
00:07:06,821 --> 00:07:10,235
In Ituri, they make machetes
out of car springs.
89
00:07:12,890 --> 00:07:14,854
They're the favourite tool
of Ituri warlords,
90
00:07:14,856 --> 00:07:16,785
who traffic in minerals
91
00:07:16,787 --> 00:07:18,647
and death.
92
00:07:18,649 --> 00:07:21,578
If the UN is going
to save the Congo,
93
00:07:21,580 --> 00:07:23,856
it will have
to first save Ituri.
94
00:07:36,683 --> 00:07:41,026
New York.
95
00:07:41,028 --> 00:07:44,681
The UN's Department of
Peacekeeping Operations, DPKO,
96
00:07:44,683 --> 00:07:48,612
constantly monitoring
the situation in Ituri.
97
00:07:48,614 --> 00:07:51,028
The news from the ground
is not good.
98
00:07:56,649 --> 00:07:58,509
Good morning, General Diallo.
99
00:07:58,511 --> 00:08:01,060
Good morning, Miss Carey.
100
00:08:01,062 --> 00:08:03,543
I'm sorry we're somewhat
disorganized this morning;
101
00:08:03,545 --> 00:08:06,233
it's been a rough week
on our side.
102
00:08:06,235 --> 00:08:08,198
But we understand
103
00:08:08,200 --> 00:08:10,060
that you're chairing
the meeting this morning?
104
00:08:10,062 --> 00:08:11,509
- Yes.
- Ah, okay.
105
00:08:11,511 --> 00:08:15,233
As you see!
Okay.
106
00:08:15,235 --> 00:08:17,819
We have, this morning,
an incident.
107
00:08:17,821 --> 00:08:20,750
Two of our milobs
went out of their house
108
00:08:20,752 --> 00:08:22,785
to go to the spring for water,
109
00:08:22,787 --> 00:08:27,509
and they were attacked
by a group of eight individuals,
110
00:08:27,511 --> 00:08:31,509
in civics,
but armed with Kalashnikovs,
111
00:08:31,511 --> 00:08:33,509
machetes and knives.
112
00:08:33,511 --> 00:08:38,681
But for deadly - the team leader
who was driving, accelerated
113
00:08:38,683 --> 00:08:40,716
and managed to escape.
114
00:08:40,718 --> 00:08:45,854
I think that as long as there
is no agreement in Ituri,
115
00:08:45,856 --> 00:08:49,405
it will be very risky
to have military,
116
00:08:49,407 --> 00:08:51,681
military unit deployed.
117
00:08:51,683 --> 00:08:54,509
Our understanding
from talking to council members
118
00:08:54,511 --> 00:08:57,336
is that it's unlikely that
we're going to get a resolution
119
00:08:57,338 --> 00:08:59,509
for another two to three weeks.
120
00:08:59,511 --> 00:09:03,129
And apparently,
according to, uh...
121
00:09:03,131 --> 00:09:06,129
our interlocutor, so to speak,
it's tied to Iraq.
122
00:09:06,131 --> 00:09:08,991
Some of the rumours
123
00:09:08,993 --> 00:09:12,785
are that the U.S. Congress sees
the Congo as a French issue,
124
00:09:12,787 --> 00:09:15,991
and since the U.S. Congress is
not very happy with the French
125
00:09:15,993 --> 00:09:17,991
over their position on Iraq,
126
00:09:17,993 --> 00:09:20,198
they're not prepared
to do anything on the Congo
127
00:09:20,200 --> 00:09:21,647
until they settle Iraq.
128
00:09:21,649 --> 00:09:24,923
In the meantime, we will try
to make the situation there
129
00:09:24,925 --> 00:09:27,267
as public as possible,
with the Security Council,
130
00:09:27,269 --> 00:09:29,371
with the SG,
and in the press.
131
00:09:29,373 --> 00:09:31,371
So that if it does
get out of hand,
132
00:09:31,373 --> 00:09:33,890
nobody can say
that the UN didn't warn them.
133
00:09:43,787 --> 00:09:46,647
In the fall,
Ituri does not blow up.
134
00:09:46,649 --> 00:09:47,957
Just before Christmas,
135
00:09:47,959 --> 00:09:51,440
a code cable is received
at UN headquarters.
136
00:09:51,442 --> 00:09:55,440
A formal Congolese peace
agreement is finally ratified.
137
00:09:55,442 --> 00:09:58,543
There have been others;
138
00:09:58,545 --> 00:10:01,164
this one looks promising.
139
00:10:01,166 --> 00:10:03,060
We have just been
through a period
140
00:10:03,062 --> 00:10:05,578
where there was the role
of MONUC on the ground,
141
00:10:05,580 --> 00:10:08,233
monitoring the disengagement,
142
00:10:08,235 --> 00:10:11,509
and the question now is:
143
00:10:11,511 --> 00:10:15,026
How do you establish
the connections
144
00:10:15,028 --> 00:10:19,336
so that the international
community is not perceived
145
00:10:19,338 --> 00:10:21,612
as a sort
of a new colonial power?
146
00:10:21,614 --> 00:10:26,854
There is a core that is
the heart of the peace process:
147
00:10:26,856 --> 00:10:29,750
elections, security sector,
148
00:10:29,752 --> 00:10:32,336
rule of law, in essence.
149
00:10:32,338 --> 00:10:35,819
All the rest, it's important:
there needs to be good schools,
150
00:10:35,821 --> 00:10:38,060
there needs to be a good
health system,
151
00:10:38,062 --> 00:10:41,233
and everything -
and Congo needs everything.
152
00:10:41,235 --> 00:10:45,509
But it's not mission critical
153
00:10:45,511 --> 00:10:46,957
in the sense...
154
00:10:46,959 --> 00:10:48,890
of a peace process.
155
00:11:07,580 --> 00:11:10,233
Spring 2003.
156
00:11:10,235 --> 00:11:13,407
Peace in the Ituri
was too good to be true.
157
00:11:15,683 --> 00:11:18,026
Despite enormous UN pressure,
158
00:11:18,028 --> 00:11:22,267
the ruling warlords refused
to surrender their weapons.
159
00:11:22,269 --> 00:11:25,405
They crave instability;
160
00:11:25,407 --> 00:11:27,407
it's good for business.
161
00:11:43,925 --> 00:11:46,959
The Ituri schools close
due to increasing violence.
162
00:11:50,752 --> 00:11:53,750
The kids, easy prey
for the warlords,
163
00:11:53,752 --> 00:11:57,235
given an AK-47,
bullets and food.
164
00:12:03,683 --> 00:12:06,164
What the warlords
get in return?
165
00:12:06,166 --> 00:12:08,062
Ituri's gold.
166
00:12:21,062 --> 00:12:22,923
Kinshasa.
167
00:12:22,925 --> 00:12:26,474
The UN's MONUC headquarters
is worried.
168
00:12:26,476 --> 00:12:28,509
If Ituri blows,
169
00:12:28,511 --> 00:12:30,993
the entire Congo
could go with it.
170
00:12:33,131 --> 00:12:37,509
Good morning, sir.
Good morning, ma'am.
171
00:12:37,511 --> 00:12:40,095
Request for the morning brief.
172
00:12:40,097 --> 00:12:43,440
We have a couple of reports,
and first is from Bunia,
173
00:12:43,442 --> 00:12:45,198
where team has reported
174
00:12:45,200 --> 00:12:48,302
that there has been
a considerable movement
175
00:12:48,304 --> 00:12:51,957
and increase in the number
of Lendu combatants.
176
00:12:51,959 --> 00:12:56,336
Meanwhile, a number of
civilians, believed to be Hemas,
177
00:12:56,338 --> 00:12:59,647
have left Bunia town.
178
00:12:59,649 --> 00:13:02,854
- And the humanitarian affairs?
- Yeah. There has been fighting
179
00:13:02,856 --> 00:13:08,509
in Baralla between
the Mai-Mai and the RCDG.
180
00:13:08,511 --> 00:13:10,957
There's apparently quite a lot
of people who've been displaced
181
00:13:10,959 --> 00:13:12,198
as a result of that.
182
00:13:12,200 --> 00:13:14,198
We've actually received word
183
00:13:14,200 --> 00:13:15,991
from the Center
for the Prevention of Genocide,
184
00:13:15,993 --> 00:13:18,060
that they are also aware
185
00:13:18,062 --> 00:13:22,302
of the alleged massacres
that are actually taking place.
186
00:13:22,304 --> 00:13:26,233
In Ovira, the situation
stayed calm yesterday.
187
00:13:26,235 --> 00:13:28,854
I think it's enormously
important to understand
188
00:13:28,856 --> 00:13:31,440
the psychology
of some of the people
189
00:13:31,442 --> 00:13:33,302
that were inside the MONUC.
190
00:13:33,304 --> 00:13:37,060
The UN as a whole
has paid a terrible price
191
00:13:37,062 --> 00:13:41,440
for the perceived failures
of what happened in Srebeniza
192
00:13:41,442 --> 00:13:43,336
and what happened in Rwanda.
193
00:13:43,338 --> 00:13:46,302
We would do
everything that we could
194
00:13:46,304 --> 00:13:49,509
to make sure that we didn't have
another Srebeniza,
195
00:13:49,511 --> 00:13:52,371
we didn't have another Rwanda
on our watch.
196
00:13:52,373 --> 00:13:55,750
And that was the key thing;
that the UN couldn't take
197
00:13:55,752 --> 00:13:57,854
another disaster,
another genocide,
198
00:13:57,856 --> 00:13:59,854
while it was deployed
in the area,
199
00:13:59,856 --> 00:14:03,166
no matter how lightly deployed,
no matter how inadequately.
200
00:14:08,787 --> 00:14:10,612
In addition
to the warlords,
201
00:14:10,614 --> 00:14:14,612
soldiers from two neighbouring
countries, Rwanda and Uganda,
202
00:14:14,614 --> 00:14:17,442
roam the town.
203
00:14:19,821 --> 00:14:21,371
The two countries claim
204
00:14:21,373 --> 00:14:24,302
they're legitimately protecting
their borders with the Congo,
205
00:14:24,304 --> 00:14:27,474
but they also want
Ituri's wealth.
206
00:14:27,476 --> 00:14:30,683
They will kill for both.
207
00:14:41,993 --> 00:14:45,888
By the end of March,
early April, we were saying,
208
00:14:45,890 --> 00:14:48,302
"Please, members
of the Security Council,
209
00:14:48,304 --> 00:14:52,164
please, international community,
give us some time."
210
00:14:52,166 --> 00:14:55,785
MONUC had 4,500 people
in this enormous country,
211
00:14:55,787 --> 00:14:59,198
4,500 troops,
doing all sorts of things.
212
00:14:59,200 --> 00:15:02,233
We could not deploy ourselves
into Ituri
213
00:15:02,235 --> 00:15:05,060
to try to prevent the massacres
214
00:15:05,062 --> 00:15:07,787
that we expected
were going to take place.
215
00:15:14,235 --> 00:15:16,164
April 3rd.
216
00:15:16,166 --> 00:15:20,578
Jacques Greenberg's
worst fears come true.
217
00:15:20,580 --> 00:15:24,200
The village of Drodro,
near Bunia, is attacked.
218
00:15:27,028 --> 00:15:31,129
Several-hundred villagers,
mostly women and children,
219
00:15:31,131 --> 00:15:32,787
hacked to death.
220
00:15:40,476 --> 00:15:44,923
The victims, they're
of no strategic importance;
221
00:15:44,925 --> 00:15:47,993
they're minor pawns
in the warlord wars.
222
00:15:57,614 --> 00:15:59,267
Two weeks
post-massacre,
223
00:15:59,269 --> 00:16:01,888
the warlords
signing a peace accord.
224
00:16:01,890 --> 00:16:04,442
No one believes them.
225
00:16:11,166 --> 00:16:14,028
Les signataires
sont ici présents.
226
00:16:17,890 --> 00:16:20,681
The killings
will continue.
227
00:16:20,683 --> 00:16:24,440
But some day, as in Bosnia,
Kosovo, Sierra Leone,
228
00:16:24,442 --> 00:16:27,373
maybe there'll be
war-crimes trials.
229
00:16:43,235 --> 00:16:45,267
Five days later,
a team of UN investigators,
230
00:16:45,269 --> 00:16:48,198
heading for Drodro,
231
00:16:48,200 --> 00:16:51,787
site of the recent massacre.
232
00:16:57,235 --> 00:17:00,474
The investigation
is the first step
233
00:17:00,476 --> 00:17:03,131
in ending impunity
in the Congo.
234
00:18:44,580 --> 00:18:47,371
While Drodro
testimony is being taken,
235
00:18:47,373 --> 00:18:51,442
a young girl,
killed and mutilated.
236
00:19:00,511 --> 00:19:02,511
A taunt from the warlords.
237
00:19:04,235 --> 00:19:06,543
"Investigate if you want.
238
00:19:06,545 --> 00:19:09,304
Nothing will come of it."
239
00:19:37,649 --> 00:19:40,647
And in a jungle hospital,
more victims:
240
00:19:40,649 --> 00:19:42,649
the Drodro survivors.
241
00:20:37,028 --> 00:20:38,957
By day,
242
00:20:38,959 --> 00:20:41,509
the Ituri tribes often share
a local food market.
243
00:20:41,511 --> 00:20:44,856
At night, they hunt each other.
244
00:20:56,269 --> 00:20:59,578
Further down the road,
a village, Zumbe,
245
00:20:59,580 --> 00:21:03,026
guarded entirely
by child soldiers,
246
00:21:03,028 --> 00:21:05,511
with arms supplied
by the warlords.
247
00:21:07,856 --> 00:21:10,129
The village is suspected
248
00:21:10,131 --> 00:21:12,925
of perpetrating
the Drodro massacre.
249
00:22:13,718 --> 00:22:16,578
As they travel
about the countryside,
250
00:22:16,580 --> 00:22:19,856
the UN investigators are
protected by Ugandan troops.
251
00:22:23,752 --> 00:22:26,785
The Ugandans, it is suspected,
252
00:22:26,787 --> 00:22:29,200
helped the village of Zumbe
attack Drodro.
253
00:22:36,649 --> 00:22:38,543
Summer.
254
00:22:38,545 --> 00:22:40,578
The months drag on.
255
00:22:40,580 --> 00:22:44,336
The Security Council
is in a quandary over Uganda.
256
00:22:44,338 --> 00:22:47,543
Ugandan troops are keeping
the warlords in line.
257
00:22:47,545 --> 00:22:51,164
But they, along with Rwanda,
are also suspected
258
00:22:51,166 --> 00:22:53,993
of being behind
much of the Ituri violence.
259
00:23:00,511 --> 00:23:03,336
While there were
some Ugandan elements
260
00:23:03,338 --> 00:23:05,612
behind some of the insecurity
in Ituri,
261
00:23:05,614 --> 00:23:11,819
Uganda's presence there also
provided a degree of stability.
262
00:23:11,821 --> 00:23:16,923
The Ugandans had agreed that
they would withdraw from Ituri.
263
00:23:16,925 --> 00:23:19,405
The Security Council
wanted Uganda out,
264
00:23:19,407 --> 00:23:22,026
and it was because
of the necessity of pursuing
265
00:23:22,028 --> 00:23:25,509
the internal political
reconciliation within the Congo.
266
00:23:25,511 --> 00:23:28,923
There was a fear that,
267
00:23:28,925 --> 00:23:30,854
if and when the Ugandans left,
268
00:23:30,856 --> 00:23:31,888
Ituri would just
blow up into chaos.
269
00:23:31,890 --> 00:23:34,856
Ituri would just
blow up into chaos.
270
00:23:47,925 --> 00:23:49,957
The United Nations
has to be ready
271
00:23:49,959 --> 00:23:53,750
to quickly fill
the Ugandan vacuum.
272
00:23:53,752 --> 00:23:56,474
Finding First World troops
for any dangerous mission
273
00:23:56,476 --> 00:23:58,198
is difficult;
274
00:23:58,200 --> 00:24:02,578
for dangerous African missions,
it's almost impossible.
275
00:24:22,200 --> 00:24:24,647
The majority of the
contributors of Blue Helmets
276
00:24:24,649 --> 00:24:27,578
at present come from
the developing countries.
277
00:24:27,580 --> 00:24:30,474
Let me be clear: they cannot,
278
00:24:30,476 --> 00:24:32,785
nor should not be expected,
279
00:24:32,787 --> 00:24:36,405
to continue
to shoulder this burden alone.
280
00:24:36,407 --> 00:24:39,750
We fully recognize
that many armies are downsizing,
281
00:24:39,752 --> 00:24:42,474
and that defence budgets
are often dwindling.
282
00:24:42,476 --> 00:24:45,578
And finally, scars
283
00:24:45,580 --> 00:24:47,888
from experience in Bosnia,
Rwanda and Somalia
284
00:24:47,890 --> 00:24:49,785
have yet to heal.
285
00:24:49,787 --> 00:24:53,854
Notwithstanding, there is
an equally legitimate concern
286
00:24:53,856 --> 00:24:58,509
that the credibility
and viability of UN peacekeeping
287
00:24:58,511 --> 00:25:00,200
remains under threat.
288
00:25:10,028 --> 00:25:13,026
At my level,
we're discussing the possibility
289
00:25:13,028 --> 00:25:16,923
of how we could diplomatically
get the Ugandans
290
00:25:16,925 --> 00:25:20,647
to stay without ever actually
asking them to stay.
291
00:25:20,649 --> 00:25:23,026
At the same time,
292
00:25:23,028 --> 00:25:25,060
the Security Council
very much wanted
293
00:25:25,062 --> 00:25:28,474
all foreign forces
out of the Congo.
294
00:25:28,476 --> 00:25:31,750
What we did then was try
to establish with Uganda
295
00:25:31,752 --> 00:25:35,336
a slow and measured withdraw
296
00:25:35,338 --> 00:25:39,302
that would enable us to not only
monitor that withdraw,
297
00:25:39,304 --> 00:25:42,164
but enable us to,
in some instances,
298
00:25:42,166 --> 00:25:44,819
fill the vacuum,
as Uganda withdrew.
299
00:25:44,821 --> 00:25:48,854
Uganda wouldn't accept that.
300
00:25:48,856 --> 00:25:50,371
They wanted the United Nations
301
00:25:50,373 --> 00:25:53,129
to publicly come out
and ask Uganda to stay,
302
00:25:53,131 --> 00:25:54,785
which the United Nations
303
00:25:54,787 --> 00:25:57,235
would not and could not
politically do.
304
00:26:09,062 --> 00:26:10,509
Hold it! Hold it!
305
00:26:10,511 --> 00:26:11,854
Whoa, whoa, whoa!
306
00:26:11,856 --> 00:26:14,474
Bunia airport.
May 1st.
307
00:26:14,476 --> 00:26:19,991
Uganda has ordered
pulling out of Ituri.
308
00:26:19,993 --> 00:26:23,787
The Security Council,
pleading for countries to help.
309
00:26:25,373 --> 00:26:27,580
Only Uruguay accepts.
310
00:26:41,683 --> 00:26:43,233
So now,
311
00:26:43,235 --> 00:26:46,888
750 Uruguayan
guard troops
312
00:26:46,890 --> 00:26:50,578
are replacing 5,000
battle-hardened Ugandans.
313
00:26:50,580 --> 00:26:53,476
It's a very dangerous
changing of the guard.
314
00:27:11,821 --> 00:27:15,302
The Uruguayans have gotten
half to two-thirds deployed.
315
00:27:15,304 --> 00:27:17,474
The UPDF,
316
00:27:17,476 --> 00:27:21,026
the Ugandan forces, started
to depart via the airport.
317
00:27:21,028 --> 00:27:23,026
There was a day of quiet,
318
00:27:23,028 --> 00:27:25,233
and then immediately after that,
319
00:27:25,235 --> 00:27:28,131
the various militias
came streaming into town.
320
00:27:42,752 --> 00:27:44,854
As predicted,
Bunia is transformed
321
00:27:44,856 --> 00:27:46,890
into a war zone.
322
00:27:48,890 --> 00:27:51,580
Much of the town
fleeing into the forests.
323
00:27:54,959 --> 00:28:00,198
Thousands of others
turning to UN camps.
324
00:28:00,200 --> 00:28:02,405
They fled basically
in two directions:
325
00:28:02,407 --> 00:28:05,440
one of them to the MONUC
headquarters, which was in town,
326
00:28:05,442 --> 00:28:08,302
and the other one
to the airport area,
327
00:28:08,304 --> 00:28:11,405
where the Uruguayans
had established their base.
328
00:28:11,407 --> 00:28:14,750
I think at one point
329
00:28:14,752 --> 00:28:18,302
we had more than 3,500
of these IDPs
330
00:28:18,304 --> 00:28:20,267
gathered around
our headquarters,
331
00:28:20,269 --> 00:28:24,198
and another 3,000 or 4,000
at the airport.
332
00:28:24,200 --> 00:28:28,543
We were absolutely on the verge
of a humanitarian catastrophe.
333
00:28:28,545 --> 00:28:32,440
Food at the UN
compound running out fast.
334
00:28:32,442 --> 00:28:34,612
The water supply, cut.
335
00:28:34,614 --> 00:28:37,062
Cholera is reported.
336
00:28:44,993 --> 00:28:49,095
At the same time, I think
it was the Lendu militia
337
00:28:49,097 --> 00:28:52,026
that started to attack MONUC,
338
00:28:52,028 --> 00:28:56,612
and with the concentration of
IDPs around our headquarters,
339
00:28:56,614 --> 00:29:00,405
it became an enormously
dangerous situation.
340
00:29:05,993 --> 00:29:10,198
Heavy mortar and shell
landed inside our compound,
341
00:29:10,200 --> 00:29:14,509
killing, I think, a half a dozen
of the IDPs that were there,
342
00:29:14,511 --> 00:29:17,131
and injuring
a much larger number.
343
00:29:19,407 --> 00:29:22,233
On the third day,
MONUC forces, overwhelmed,
344
00:29:22,235 --> 00:29:24,578
retreat to their compound.
345
00:29:26,580 --> 00:29:29,371
The UN is losing its gamble.
346
00:29:29,373 --> 00:29:32,649
The warlords are unstoppable.
347
00:29:47,580 --> 00:29:50,750
A week after fighting starts,
348
00:29:50,752 --> 00:29:52,925
Bunia is a looted ghost town.
349
00:29:55,752 --> 00:29:59,095
UN staff and Red Cross workers
starting the recovery
350
00:29:59,097 --> 00:30:02,373
of some 250 corpses.
351
00:30:27,131 --> 00:30:29,819
The situation
had become so serious
352
00:30:29,821 --> 00:30:33,543
that it was now serious time
to think about deploying,
353
00:30:33,545 --> 00:30:36,509
or asking for a multinational,
robust force,
354
00:30:36,511 --> 00:30:39,405
to re-establish
some degree of order
355
00:30:39,407 --> 00:30:42,578
and normality in Bunia.
356
00:30:42,580 --> 00:30:45,440
New York,
357
00:30:45,442 --> 00:30:48,649
never anticipating
Bunia would fall.
358
00:30:51,614 --> 00:30:53,302
The big fear:
359
00:30:53,304 --> 00:30:57,716
the entire Congo peace process
will collapse.
360
00:30:57,718 --> 00:31:02,235
And if the Congo goes, all of
Central Africa is in jeopardy.
361
00:31:04,925 --> 00:31:06,750
In peacekeeping,
362
00:31:06,752 --> 00:31:09,026
you are confronted
to a kind of a dilemma:
363
00:31:09,028 --> 00:31:11,543
to look the other way
364
00:31:11,545 --> 00:31:13,854
and have to live for the rest
of your life
365
00:31:13,856 --> 00:31:18,681
with maybe the notion that
if you had really moved in,
366
00:31:18,683 --> 00:31:20,819
you would have made
a big difference.
367
00:31:20,821 --> 00:31:25,269
Or to move in, but maybe
with the risk of failure.
368
00:31:27,338 --> 00:31:31,405
At every step, I'll need to
convince the Security Council,
369
00:31:31,407 --> 00:31:34,854
and I'll need to convince
the troop contributors.
370
00:31:34,856 --> 00:31:37,233
If I don't get it right,
371
00:31:37,235 --> 00:31:39,888
then it's the authority
of the United Nations,
372
00:31:39,890 --> 00:31:41,854
it's the good name
of peacekeeping
373
00:31:41,856 --> 00:31:44,959
that will be compromised.
374
00:31:48,200 --> 00:31:51,233
During the Congo's
five-year civil war,
375
00:31:51,235 --> 00:31:54,095
the press was indifferent.
376
00:31:54,097 --> 00:31:56,957
Now, with new Ituri massacres,
377
00:31:56,959 --> 00:32:00,888
media attention shifts briefly
from Iraq to the Congo.
378
00:32:00,890 --> 00:32:02,923
This has been one
of Africa's ugliest wars.
379
00:32:02,925 --> 00:32:04,991
Bunia is Congo's
latest hellhole.
380
00:32:04,993 --> 00:32:06,923
50,000 people
are thought to have died
381
00:32:06,925 --> 00:32:08,647
in that part
of the country alone.
382
00:32:08,649 --> 00:32:11,923
It is a war in which children
are victims and combatants.
383
00:32:11,925 --> 00:32:14,888
The population
continues to flee.
384
00:32:14,890 --> 00:32:17,129
- It's not a nice place.
- A contingent of UN troops
385
00:32:17,131 --> 00:32:20,787
from Uruguay
has been powerless to intervene.
386
00:32:24,200 --> 00:32:28,233
One of the very important
contributions
387
00:32:28,235 --> 00:32:30,681
of the Uruguayan deploying
in Bunia,
388
00:32:30,683 --> 00:32:32,440
because they were there,
389
00:32:32,442 --> 00:32:35,888
they brought the attention
of the world media.
390
00:32:35,890 --> 00:32:38,509
Because you have a lot
of massacres in Congo
391
00:32:38,511 --> 00:32:41,129
where it's just too dangerous
to have any journalist,
392
00:32:41,131 --> 00:32:44,785
any reporter. So you don't even
know that they happen.
393
00:32:44,787 --> 00:32:47,957
It's very hard
for politicians to say,
394
00:32:47,959 --> 00:32:50,267
"Well, we just have
to look the other way."
395
00:32:50,269 --> 00:32:53,405
And so I think this change
in public opinion
396
00:32:53,407 --> 00:32:57,856
has an impact on the politics
of the Security Council.
397
00:33:08,235 --> 00:33:11,681
Two weeks
after fighting in Bunia begins,
398
00:33:11,683 --> 00:33:14,233
a brief lull.
399
00:33:14,235 --> 00:33:18,785
But military observers in
isolated outposts are worried.
400
00:33:18,787 --> 00:33:22,200
Militia in the hills are
preparing to attack the camps.
401
00:33:31,649 --> 00:33:34,129
As fighting in Ituri
intensifies,
402
00:33:34,131 --> 00:33:37,026
refugees are fleeing
to the capital, Kinshasa,
403
00:33:37,028 --> 00:33:42,131
squatting in buildings
abandoned during past wars.
404
00:33:47,925 --> 00:33:49,923
Not far away,
405
00:33:49,925 --> 00:33:54,474
Parliament is being readied
after years of neglect.
406
00:33:54,476 --> 00:33:56,785
But with fighting in Ituri,
407
00:33:56,787 --> 00:33:58,718
Parliament's opening
is questionable.
408
00:34:10,890 --> 00:34:13,164
The Congo,
tilting towards collapse.
409
00:34:13,166 --> 00:34:14,543
Jean-Marie Guéhenno,
410
00:34:14,545 --> 00:34:17,716
desperately looking
for a heavily armed force
411
00:34:17,718 --> 00:34:20,302
to save Bunia,
412
00:34:20,304 --> 00:34:22,819
a force outside the UN.
413
00:34:22,821 --> 00:34:28,060
The French,
still smarting from Iraq,
414
00:34:28,062 --> 00:34:31,164
one possibility
to lead the force.
415
00:34:31,166 --> 00:34:33,060
But the French are clear:
416
00:34:33,062 --> 00:34:36,647
if they accept, it's only Bunia
and the airport,
417
00:34:36,649 --> 00:34:39,440
and only for three months.
418
00:34:39,442 --> 00:34:42,509
With the French
sitting on the fence,
419
00:34:42,511 --> 00:34:45,336
MONUC, nervous.
420
00:34:45,338 --> 00:34:49,716
The French ambassador reacted
by saying that, "No, no, no,
421
00:34:49,718 --> 00:34:52,957
"there is no question
of anyone dealing with Ituri.
422
00:34:52,959 --> 00:34:55,819
This does not concern Ituri,
423
00:34:55,821 --> 00:34:58,923
this is merely concentrated
on Bunia
424
00:34:58,925 --> 00:35:02,578
and that we are not here to
resolve the problems of Ituri,"
425
00:35:02,580 --> 00:35:04,405
etc.
426
00:35:04,407 --> 00:35:07,716
The concept,
as I understand it,
427
00:35:07,718 --> 00:35:09,336
and maybe I am absolutely wrong,
428
00:35:09,338 --> 00:35:14,888
they want to have a compact
and manageable force in Bunia,
429
00:35:14,890 --> 00:35:17,198
which will consist primarily
430
00:35:17,200 --> 00:35:23,026
of something roughly around a
battalion size of French troops,
431
00:35:23,028 --> 00:35:25,474
with a sprinkle,
432
00:35:25,476 --> 00:35:28,509
sprinkle of other troops,
433
00:35:28,511 --> 00:35:31,991
to add flags to the coalition.
434
00:35:31,993 --> 00:35:34,957
And in a sense be thankful
for a member state
435
00:35:34,959 --> 00:35:36,371
who has come...
436
00:35:36,373 --> 00:35:39,854
willing to come
and rescue our troops.
437
00:35:39,856 --> 00:35:42,474
Because otherwise,
the point was last week -
438
00:35:42,476 --> 00:35:44,336
and we all know that -
439
00:35:44,338 --> 00:35:46,509
that they would have
to be withdrawn.
440
00:35:46,511 --> 00:35:48,060
We were very close to that.
441
00:35:48,062 --> 00:35:50,681
I think you heard
our position.
442
00:35:50,683 --> 00:35:54,819
Our position, as far as Ituri
is concerned, is very firm.
443
00:35:54,821 --> 00:35:58,129
The indications we have given
you are not changeable.
444
00:35:58,131 --> 00:36:02,440
We are warning you about the
situation in the entire Ituri.
445
00:36:02,442 --> 00:36:04,716
We are not here to be convinced
446
00:36:04,718 --> 00:36:08,267
that the problem in Ituri
is limited to Bunia.
447
00:36:08,269 --> 00:36:10,060
Okay? Otherwise,
448
00:36:10,062 --> 00:36:12,543
whatever member states
want to decide,
449
00:36:12,545 --> 00:36:16,267
whatever others want to decide,
is fine and dandy,
450
00:36:16,269 --> 00:36:19,785
but we are going to give you
the reports as we see it,
451
00:36:19,787 --> 00:36:22,166
we're going to analyze it
as we see it.
452
00:36:24,649 --> 00:36:26,647
But warnings, warnings,
453
00:36:26,649 --> 00:36:29,233
I'm very good about warnings
myself, as you know,
454
00:36:29,235 --> 00:36:32,750
and you heard my warnings
two weeks ago,
455
00:36:32,752 --> 00:36:35,509
about what may happen in Bunia.
456
00:36:35,511 --> 00:36:37,129
We assumed
that we were talking
457
00:36:37,131 --> 00:36:39,095
about a larger number
than a battalion.
458
00:36:39,097 --> 00:36:41,819
Thank you, and it's all
my fault as always.
459
00:36:41,821 --> 00:36:45,233
- Thanks. Thanks very much.
- No, it's not.
460
00:36:45,235 --> 00:36:48,302
If there is nothing else
to discuss,
461
00:36:48,304 --> 00:36:50,716
I'm adjourning the meeting
462
00:36:50,718 --> 00:36:53,681
and I don't want to adjourn
on this very sour note,
463
00:36:53,683 --> 00:36:57,612
which is developing.
464
00:36:57,614 --> 00:37:03,923
8:30 tomorrow,
New York time?
465
00:37:03,925 --> 00:37:06,440
Okay. Thank you.
466
00:37:06,442 --> 00:37:09,336
I don't like
these acrimonious things.
467
00:37:09,338 --> 00:37:10,993
I don't like these...
468
00:37:15,614 --> 00:37:19,267
May 10th. Bunia.
469
00:37:19,269 --> 00:37:22,750
Urgent calls received from
two isolated military observers
470
00:37:22,752 --> 00:37:26,545
in a town called Mongwalu.
471
00:37:28,614 --> 00:37:32,198
The milobs are very scared.
They want to be taken out.
472
00:37:32,200 --> 00:37:36,612
For three terrifying days,
the milobs wait,
473
00:37:36,614 --> 00:37:40,440
extracting them, impossible,
due to intense fighting.
474
00:37:40,442 --> 00:37:45,164
May 13th, a helicopter finally
dispatched to Mongwalu.
475
00:37:45,166 --> 00:37:48,545
Returning, empty.
476
00:37:51,442 --> 00:37:58,304
Three days later, what everyone
fears comes true.
477
00:38:18,235 --> 00:38:22,235
The deaths of the two milobs
hit MONUC headquarters hard.
478
00:38:24,580 --> 00:38:26,578
Rumours circulate.
479
00:38:26,580 --> 00:38:29,476
The rescue attempt was botched.
480
00:38:56,890 --> 00:38:59,923
- How's the mission doing?
- They're okay.
481
00:38:59,925 --> 00:39:03,166
They're okay?
But a little bit disjointed.
482
00:39:04,856 --> 00:39:09,440
We were in that room
and we got a call from Mongwalu.
483
00:39:09,442 --> 00:39:11,198
And this guy had phoned.
484
00:39:11,200 --> 00:39:13,716
Those military observers
were literally crying.
485
00:39:13,718 --> 00:39:15,993
They said,
"Take us out of here."
486
00:39:18,718 --> 00:39:21,890
I mean, two persons
in a location that's...
487
00:39:26,269 --> 00:39:29,612
There's still element
of mission
488
00:39:29,614 --> 00:39:32,302
being somewhat dysfunctional.
489
00:39:32,304 --> 00:39:36,681
There is no security assessment
in a proper way.
490
00:39:36,683 --> 00:39:39,888
People are thrown sometimes...
These team sides
491
00:39:39,890 --> 00:39:43,233
were established
in the most strange way.
492
00:39:43,235 --> 00:39:45,371
That's the reports I have.
493
00:39:45,373 --> 00:39:49,647
Now, when military observers
were just sent,
494
00:39:49,649 --> 00:39:53,578
without any support,
any previous resources,
495
00:39:53,580 --> 00:39:56,338
and put them in dangerous spots.
496
00:40:13,131 --> 00:40:15,888
So today, can you draft
the cable in consultation
497
00:40:15,890 --> 00:40:17,338
for François Dureau?
498
00:40:20,028 --> 00:40:22,336
Of extreme, most immediate,
499
00:40:22,338 --> 00:40:25,821
of extreme concern on the part
of this headquarters...
500
00:40:29,545 --> 00:40:34,198
that we want immediately,
by tomorrow,
501
00:40:34,200 --> 00:40:37,164
a threat assessment
502
00:40:37,166 --> 00:40:40,543
to all personnel,
civilian and military personnel,
503
00:40:40,545 --> 00:40:43,129
in the northeast.
504
00:40:43,131 --> 00:40:44,957
You spoke
to Germany yesterday?
505
00:40:44,959 --> 00:40:46,716
Can you speak
to Canada today?
506
00:40:46,718 --> 00:40:48,198
- Okay.
- Okay?
507
00:40:48,200 --> 00:40:50,888
Financial support
would be helpful.
508
00:40:50,890 --> 00:40:52,752
Although I don't think
they have much money.
509
00:40:56,683 --> 00:40:58,509
Eventually,
510
00:40:58,511 --> 00:41:00,474
there will be a high-level
UN investigation
511
00:41:00,476 --> 00:41:02,854
into the milobs' deaths.
512
00:41:02,856 --> 00:41:05,856
The report will be kept
strictly confidential.
513
00:41:09,890 --> 00:41:13,543
The Congo. It's always been
a difficult sell
514
00:41:13,545 --> 00:41:15,371
to the international community.
515
00:41:15,373 --> 00:41:18,612
The deaths of the milobs
don't help.
516
00:41:18,614 --> 00:41:21,474
But the crucial question
remains:
517
00:41:21,476 --> 00:41:25,543
What's the worth
of one failed African state?
518
00:41:25,545 --> 00:41:28,026
- Money.
- Money, you say?
519
00:41:28,028 --> 00:41:30,716
Money for the MNF.
520
00:41:30,718 --> 00:41:35,440
I think that's they key thing
right now, right?
521
00:41:35,442 --> 00:41:37,405
Frankly, there are
two key things right now.
522
00:41:37,407 --> 00:41:41,060
One of them is money
for this MNF limited deployment,
523
00:41:41,062 --> 00:41:43,543
and the other one
is this big bell
524
00:41:43,545 --> 00:41:45,336
that the mission is sounding
525
00:41:45,338 --> 00:41:48,890
and that I think we all agree
with, that Bunia is not enough.
526
00:41:50,476 --> 00:41:52,060
You know, I don't think
527
00:41:52,062 --> 00:41:54,233
that we're going to get troops
outside of Bunia,
528
00:41:54,235 --> 00:41:56,336
unless we put
our own troops out there.
529
00:41:56,338 --> 00:41:58,336
And I don't think
we have the capacity
530
00:41:58,338 --> 00:42:00,129
to put our own troops out there.
531
00:42:00,131 --> 00:42:03,612
I don't think that our troops
are capable,
532
00:42:03,614 --> 00:42:07,819
have the kind of equipment
and training to do that.
533
00:42:07,821 --> 00:42:09,509
I absolutely agree with you,
534
00:42:09,511 --> 00:42:13,371
but I think we have
to not only go down on record
535
00:42:13,373 --> 00:42:14,785
but just keep on thinking:
536
00:42:14,787 --> 00:42:17,405
Is there any way
that we can do something
537
00:42:17,407 --> 00:42:20,026
outside of the immediate
environs of Bunia?
538
00:42:20,028 --> 00:42:23,509
Because large numbers of people
are going to die.
539
00:42:23,511 --> 00:42:26,164
You've got
at least two declarations
540
00:42:26,166 --> 00:42:27,716
from the armed combatants
saying,
541
00:42:27,718 --> 00:42:31,095
"We are ready to canton.
Where's the money to feed us?"
542
00:42:31,097 --> 00:42:33,405
- Or whatever.
- Okay.
543
00:42:33,407 --> 00:42:35,888
You need to disarm them,
544
00:42:35,890 --> 00:42:38,440
and then you need to do
something with the weapons.
545
00:42:38,442 --> 00:42:41,233
So there has to be an agreement
of what we do with the weapons.
546
00:42:41,235 --> 00:42:44,819
And then we need to feed them
and then get them into projects,
547
00:42:44,821 --> 00:42:46,198
food for work or training,
548
00:42:46,200 --> 00:42:48,440
or whatever other projects
we have for them.
549
00:42:48,442 --> 00:42:51,716
But then, you won't get
the money from the donors,
550
00:42:51,718 --> 00:42:54,474
because they consider that
feeding armed combatants.
551
00:42:54,476 --> 00:42:56,580
Are there no other options?
552
00:43:05,407 --> 00:43:08,819
We have a plan
for Bunia and airport,
553
00:43:08,821 --> 00:43:10,923
and hopefully
the multinational forces
554
00:43:10,925 --> 00:43:13,336
are going to deploy there.
But there is the rest of Ituri
555
00:43:13,338 --> 00:43:15,371
and the many ways
556
00:43:15,373 --> 00:43:18,991
in which the rest of Ituri
could go badly wrong.
557
00:43:18,993 --> 00:43:22,716
And there we are caught
in a kind of dilemma,
558
00:43:22,718 --> 00:43:25,681
because if we flag the issue
too much,
559
00:43:25,683 --> 00:43:27,681
we might lose the hope
560
00:43:27,683 --> 00:43:31,957
that we have
of a real deployment in Bunia.
561
00:43:31,959 --> 00:43:35,716
If we ignore it,
it is just as bad,
562
00:43:35,718 --> 00:43:37,716
because we might be
surprised by it,
563
00:43:37,718 --> 00:43:40,991
and we'll be misleading those
who will deploy in Bunia.
564
00:43:40,993 --> 00:43:44,302
The dangerous scenario
is a scenario
565
00:43:44,304 --> 00:43:47,923
where we have
some improvement in Bunia,
566
00:43:47,925 --> 00:43:50,647
- but then there's just a shift...
- ...moves outside.
567
00:43:50,649 --> 00:43:53,681
A shift in the killings
to other places.
568
00:43:53,683 --> 00:43:56,750
If their people are cynical
and clever enough,
569
00:43:56,752 --> 00:43:59,095
they don't attack Bunia, no;
570
00:43:59,097 --> 00:44:01,578
they just commit horrors
571
00:44:01,580 --> 00:44:04,405
40 kilometres from Bunia.
572
00:44:04,407 --> 00:44:07,302
The international community,
573
00:44:07,304 --> 00:44:09,336
The French once again,
when it's...
574
00:44:09,338 --> 00:44:11,060
They protect certain people
and not others.
575
00:44:11,062 --> 00:44:12,129
They protect certain people,
576
00:44:12,131 --> 00:44:13,785
but they don't care
about the others.
577
00:44:13,787 --> 00:44:16,474
The other flip side
of the coin
578
00:44:16,476 --> 00:44:19,509
is that if Bunia
is a safe place
579
00:44:19,511 --> 00:44:23,854
and if things go badly
in the rest of Ituri,
580
00:44:23,856 --> 00:44:26,440
instead of having
12,000 refugees,
581
00:44:26,442 --> 00:44:29,198
you're going to have 50,000,
60,000, 100,000.
582
00:44:29,200 --> 00:44:35,750
You can have a colossal
à la Gomachaos developing.
583
00:44:35,752 --> 00:44:38,888
What I'm describing
could happen. It's not...
584
00:44:38,890 --> 00:44:41,164
If there's anybody
who has an interest
585
00:44:41,166 --> 00:44:43,336
in undermining the credibility
of the MNF,
586
00:44:43,338 --> 00:44:46,267
then that's the way to do it,
it's easy.
587
00:44:46,269 --> 00:44:49,991
So, I mean, there's one or two
things that can be done.
588
00:44:49,993 --> 00:44:53,854
One is to ask the French or
whoever is coming with them,
589
00:44:53,856 --> 00:44:56,474
to have a rapid-reaction
capability.
590
00:44:56,476 --> 00:45:00,819
They have the capacity to go in,
you know, and hit very hard...
591
00:45:00,821 --> 00:45:03,233
Yeah, that's why they need
attack helicopters.
592
00:45:03,235 --> 00:45:05,854
...and pull out without
casualties most of the time
593
00:45:05,856 --> 00:45:09,026
and without too many risks,
and make a point, you know.
594
00:45:09,028 --> 00:45:11,681
The killers
are not a massive force.
595
00:45:11,683 --> 00:45:16,233
They are thugs on drugs,
596
00:45:16,235 --> 00:45:18,474
who can be, I mean,
597
00:45:18,476 --> 00:45:21,543
scared and stopped
598
00:45:21,545 --> 00:45:24,026
by a relatively small
professional force
599
00:45:24,028 --> 00:45:26,647
when things go bad,
600
00:45:26,649 --> 00:45:29,959
if that force is there quickly
and decisively.
601
00:45:41,235 --> 00:45:43,785
In May, I decided,
602
00:45:43,787 --> 00:45:47,060
and the Secretary-General
supported that,
603
00:45:47,062 --> 00:45:49,233
to move toward engagement,
604
00:45:49,235 --> 00:45:53,371
because we felt that the risks
of loss of human life
605
00:45:53,373 --> 00:45:55,543
were just too high,
606
00:45:55,545 --> 00:46:00,267
and that maybe,
with the memory of Rwanda,
607
00:46:00,269 --> 00:46:02,991
the possibility did exist
608
00:46:02,993 --> 00:46:05,612
to convince the Security Council
to do the right thing.
609
00:46:05,614 --> 00:46:07,957
Will those in favour of...
610
00:46:07,959 --> 00:46:09,923
May 30th, 2003.
611
00:46:09,925 --> 00:46:14,888
The Security Council accepts a
French-led multinational force.
612
00:46:14,890 --> 00:46:17,647
...please raise their hand.
613
00:46:17,649 --> 00:46:20,474
The force
might possibly save Ituri.
614
00:46:20,476 --> 00:46:23,681
- Those against? Abstentions?
- But only in the short term.
615
00:46:23,683 --> 00:46:26,614
The draft resolution
has been adopted unanimously.
616
00:46:37,028 --> 00:46:38,474
June.
617
00:46:38,476 --> 00:46:42,233
The French-led force
on the ground.
618
00:46:42,235 --> 00:46:45,509
In Bunia, unhampered
by UN rules of engagement,
619
00:46:45,511 --> 00:46:48,991
the French
confront the warlords.
620
00:46:48,993 --> 00:46:50,923
Là-bas. Fais le tour l-bas.
621
00:46:50,925 --> 00:46:52,854
But in the hills,
622
00:46:52,856 --> 00:46:55,062
the murders, rapes
and kidnappings increase.
623
00:47:02,683 --> 00:47:04,267
Eh, dégage!
624
00:47:25,545 --> 00:47:27,026
In three months,
625
00:47:27,028 --> 00:47:30,716
the French
will pull out of Ituri.
626
00:47:30,718 --> 00:47:34,373
Then, it's up to a UN Ituri
brigade to secure the peace.
627
00:47:41,649 --> 00:47:44,440
Since the French
have agreed to deploy in Bunia
628
00:47:44,442 --> 00:47:46,854
only with a very clear timeframe
and a deadline,
629
00:47:46,856 --> 00:47:48,957
we have to be sure
630
00:47:48,959 --> 00:47:50,785
that by September 1st,
631
00:47:50,787 --> 00:47:53,819
our forces
are rolling in and operational.
632
00:47:53,821 --> 00:47:56,233
And that's in the hands
of the council,
633
00:47:56,235 --> 00:47:59,233
and the council
in the hands of their...
634
00:47:59,235 --> 00:48:02,095
of what will be
the U.S. decision,
635
00:48:02,097 --> 00:48:06,752
and there, every day that passes
will make me extremely nervous.
636
00:48:17,959 --> 00:48:21,957
The days
turn into weeks.
637
00:48:21,959 --> 00:48:24,991
The cost of an Ituri brigade:
638
00:48:24,993 --> 00:48:27,888
tens of millions of dollars
a year.
639
00:48:27,890 --> 00:48:32,474
There's only one country in the
world with that kind of money.
640
00:48:32,476 --> 00:48:35,198
Good afternoon,
ladies and gentlemen,
641
00:48:35,200 --> 00:48:37,750
generals and deputy SRSGs.
642
00:48:37,752 --> 00:48:40,026
The general left.
643
00:48:40,028 --> 00:48:43,095
The generals have left,
I can see.
644
00:48:43,097 --> 00:48:47,371
So on Friday, together
with several colleagues,
645
00:48:47,373 --> 00:48:49,336
we visited Washington
646
00:48:49,338 --> 00:48:54,026
and had a three-hour discussion,
647
00:48:54,028 --> 00:48:58,750
plus myself a rather bad lunch
in the State Department
648
00:48:58,752 --> 00:49:04,164
with the...
649
00:49:04,166 --> 00:49:06,647
interdepartmental group headed
650
00:49:06,649 --> 00:49:12,267
by Deputy Assistant Secretary
of State for Africa Bellamy,
651
00:49:12,269 --> 00:49:15,509
and they do appreciate
considerably the work,
652
00:49:15,511 --> 00:49:18,198
what has been done
by the United Nations,
653
00:49:18,200 --> 00:49:21,578
both on the ground
and in New York.
654
00:49:21,580 --> 00:49:25,854
But they would like
to have a better feel
655
00:49:25,856 --> 00:49:30,371
as a major financial
contributor, obviously,
656
00:49:30,373 --> 00:49:33,543
and a political lever,
657
00:49:33,545 --> 00:49:35,612
what is the end game,
658
00:49:35,614 --> 00:49:39,716
both in Ituri
and in the Congo as a whole.
659
00:49:39,718 --> 00:49:41,716
And when they see
660
00:49:41,718 --> 00:49:46,233
the proposed ceiling at 10,700,
661
00:49:46,235 --> 00:49:51,474
for them it's a real jump.
662
00:49:51,476 --> 00:49:55,474
As far as the deployment
of the brigade is concerned -
663
00:49:55,476 --> 00:49:58,888
and here I have no choice
but to make a comparison
664
00:49:58,890 --> 00:50:00,957
with NATO in the Balkans -
665
00:50:00,959 --> 00:50:04,164
How is it that a mere brigade
666
00:50:04,166 --> 00:50:08,681
is being questioned for the UN?
667
00:50:08,683 --> 00:50:10,612
The same thing could be said
668
00:50:10,614 --> 00:50:14,095
about what you mentioned
in Sierra Leone.
669
00:50:14,097 --> 00:50:19,405
In Sierra Leone, we suddenly
did agree to go to 17,500,
670
00:50:19,407 --> 00:50:22,888
because a disaster happened.
671
00:50:22,890 --> 00:50:25,991
So we should not wait here
until the disaster is opened,
672
00:50:25,993 --> 00:50:28,647
if you wish,
673
00:50:28,649 --> 00:50:31,647
because we do already have
a disaster on our hands.
674
00:50:37,097 --> 00:50:40,164
The Americans, obviously,
they are the biggest payer,
675
00:50:40,166 --> 00:50:42,129
so, I mean, I...
676
00:50:42,131 --> 00:50:44,681
whenever we increase MONUC,
677
00:50:44,683 --> 00:50:47,612
they will pay
the bigger part of the bill.
678
00:50:47,614 --> 00:50:49,750
At the moment,
679
00:50:49,752 --> 00:50:51,819
it's clear that in the council
680
00:50:51,821 --> 00:50:55,198
what we need to achieve
is to convince the U.S.
681
00:50:55,200 --> 00:51:00,612
to make a decision quickly,
because every day that passes
682
00:51:00,614 --> 00:51:04,200
means that our deployments
are going to be delayed.
683
00:51:13,338 --> 00:51:15,716
On the one hand,
many of my colleagues
684
00:51:15,718 --> 00:51:17,819
were working to give
the information necessary
685
00:51:17,821 --> 00:51:19,888
for troop contributors to
put together the kind of troops
686
00:51:19,890 --> 00:51:21,509
that we would need for Ituri.
687
00:51:21,511 --> 00:51:24,543
My job was more to try and
convince the Security Council
688
00:51:24,545 --> 00:51:26,750
we had a viable plan for Ituri.
689
00:51:26,752 --> 00:51:29,026
And I think one of the problems
with Council,
690
00:51:29,028 --> 00:51:31,129
and I think particularly
with the United States,
691
00:51:31,131 --> 00:51:34,785
was that they did not see
that there was really
692
00:51:34,787 --> 00:51:37,718
a political process in Ituri
worth investing in.
693
00:51:39,545 --> 00:51:41,060
The U.S. told us -
694
00:51:41,062 --> 00:51:43,198
and I think that they had
a legitimate concern -
695
00:51:43,200 --> 00:51:45,923
that they saw Ituri
as a Somalia.
696
00:51:45,925 --> 00:51:48,888
And so our job, really,
was try to convince them
697
00:51:48,890 --> 00:51:51,304
that there was
a political process.
698
00:51:56,614 --> 00:51:59,888
June.
Meg Carey, to Bunia.
699
00:51:59,890 --> 00:52:05,612
Her mission: find an exit
strategy for the Ituri quickly,
700
00:52:05,614 --> 00:52:08,062
one acceptable
to the Americans.
701
00:52:16,683 --> 00:52:19,509
The council met yesterday
in New York
702
00:52:19,511 --> 00:52:22,991
and have decided to give MONUC
a technical rollover,
703
00:52:22,993 --> 00:52:26,164
which basically means
no new mandated activities,
704
00:52:26,166 --> 00:52:28,923
just an extension of the date
of the mandate
705
00:52:28,925 --> 00:52:30,854
until sometime in July.
706
00:52:30,856 --> 00:52:32,233
But the first implication
707
00:52:32,235 --> 00:52:35,474
is that we will only get
a task force of one battalion,
708
00:52:35,476 --> 00:52:37,405
and that we would not have
any additional troops
709
00:52:37,407 --> 00:52:39,026
beyond one battalion,
710
00:52:39,028 --> 00:52:42,716
at the current date of exit
of the international force.
711
00:52:42,718 --> 00:52:45,785
That has major implications for
the work that we do in Ituri.
712
00:52:45,787 --> 00:52:48,888
So we have a lot of work to do,
to try to convince the people
713
00:52:48,890 --> 00:52:52,442
who pay the bills that it's
worth their investing in it.
714
00:53:00,511 --> 00:53:02,819
There was a time
that I did feel
715
00:53:02,821 --> 00:53:05,647
that none of the countries
of the world
716
00:53:05,649 --> 00:53:07,888
who could make a difference
really cared,
717
00:53:07,890 --> 00:53:11,026
and that nobody
was really seeing the lives
718
00:53:11,028 --> 00:53:14,269
that were being wasted,
and it didn't matter to them.
719
00:53:17,787 --> 00:53:21,819
You did feel personally
somewhat responsible,
720
00:53:21,821 --> 00:53:24,612
because you felt:
What am I doing wrong
721
00:53:24,614 --> 00:53:27,302
that I'm not being able to
convince these member states
722
00:53:27,304 --> 00:53:29,647
that they need to provide
the troops necessary
723
00:53:29,649 --> 00:53:31,095
to save these lives?
724
00:53:31,097 --> 00:53:34,233
You can't pull
these people out now,
725
00:53:34,235 --> 00:53:37,957
because then it'll make
the situation worse...
726
00:53:37,959 --> 00:53:39,543
And you also felt responsible
727
00:53:39,545 --> 00:53:41,129
for the United Nations staff
728
00:53:41,131 --> 00:53:43,957
that were putting their lives
at risk in Ituri.
729
00:53:43,959 --> 00:53:46,336
And there was a great deal
of pressure.
730
00:53:46,338 --> 00:53:50,959
It is once again the unilateral
action taken by the government.
731
00:53:56,166 --> 00:53:58,509
The best,
perhaps the only chance,
732
00:53:58,511 --> 00:54:00,509
of stabilizing the region:
733
00:54:00,511 --> 00:54:03,509
something called the
"Ituri Interim Administration."
734
00:54:03,511 --> 00:54:07,991
Whether it can expel Ugandan-
and Rwandan-sponsored fighters,
735
00:54:07,993 --> 00:54:10,235
that's anybody's guess.
736
00:56:03,890 --> 00:56:05,716
What Madam Buweka
is up against,
737
00:56:05,718 --> 00:56:08,442
is a warlord
named Thomas Lubanga.
738
00:56:11,097 --> 00:56:12,509
Lubanga controls Bunia;
739
00:56:12,511 --> 00:56:14,890
he is backed by Uganda.
740
00:56:17,200 --> 00:56:20,026
He has a degree in psychology,
741
00:56:20,028 --> 00:56:22,543
the support of hundreds
of child soldiers.
742
00:56:22,545 --> 00:56:26,198
And blood on his hands.
743
00:56:29,787 --> 00:56:33,026
Most peace processes
that we're dealing with,
744
00:56:33,028 --> 00:56:34,578
in Africa and beyond,
745
00:56:34,580 --> 00:56:38,440
the heads of factions,
to a greater or a lesser extent,
746
00:56:38,442 --> 00:56:40,716
are warlords,
747
00:56:40,718 --> 00:56:43,440
and have
very Mafioso-type tendencies.
748
00:56:43,442 --> 00:56:46,578
You have to deal with them.
749
00:56:46,580 --> 00:56:48,198
You may not want
to deal with them
750
00:56:48,200 --> 00:56:50,612
and they may have committed
all sorts of human-rights abuses
751
00:56:50,614 --> 00:56:52,716
but unfortunately,
you have to deal with them,
752
00:56:52,718 --> 00:56:54,578
because they're the ones
with the power.
753
00:56:54,580 --> 00:56:57,442
What do these military
leaders want?
754
00:56:59,511 --> 00:57:04,819
I think, if we talk about
UPC, the leadership of UPC,
755
00:57:04,821 --> 00:57:09,198
definitely Lubanga wants to play
a national role in the Congo,
756
00:57:09,200 --> 00:57:13,681
using Ituri as a pretext for it,
you know.
757
00:57:13,683 --> 00:57:17,198
- To bargain.
- So he has very big ambitions.
758
00:57:17,200 --> 00:57:20,647
So now, I think what we have
to see is how best we can
759
00:57:20,649 --> 00:57:24,095
try to see at a national level
what we can give him,
760
00:57:24,097 --> 00:57:26,336
even something very small, yes.
761
00:57:26,338 --> 00:57:28,923
If you continue discussing
with him, we can say,
762
00:57:28,925 --> 00:57:30,991
"Yes, you can play a role
at a national level."
763
00:57:30,993 --> 00:57:33,854
But what happens to Lubanga
after he gets to national level?
764
00:57:33,856 --> 00:57:35,923
He will leave everything
and go.
765
00:57:35,925 --> 00:57:37,854
And what happens to UPC
after Lubanga leaves?
766
00:57:37,856 --> 00:57:39,060
It will finish.
767
00:57:39,062 --> 00:57:41,750
You have to exercise pressure
on Lubanga.
768
00:57:41,752 --> 00:57:43,543
Maybe the Security Council
can issue a statement
769
00:57:43,545 --> 00:57:45,060
or something like that,
770
00:57:45,062 --> 00:57:48,543
naming them,
name and shame.
771
00:57:48,545 --> 00:57:52,750
So I think this is one
of the aspects of the problem
772
00:57:52,752 --> 00:57:54,957
- you have to look at.
- If we name and shame,
773
00:57:54,959 --> 00:57:57,923
will that put MONUC individuals
in any danger for reprisals?
774
00:57:57,925 --> 00:57:59,440
I don't think so.
775
00:57:59,442 --> 00:58:02,509
If it is done at the level
of the Security Council.
776
00:58:02,511 --> 00:58:04,198
- So that's the stick?
- Yeah.
777
00:58:04,200 --> 00:58:08,405
And now the carrot
is to try to bring him on board.
778
00:58:08,407 --> 00:58:09,888
Okay.
779
00:58:09,890 --> 00:58:14,060
And the reason that the fighting
started in Jugu and Mongwalu
780
00:58:14,062 --> 00:58:15,923
is because
this is the resource-rich area?
781
00:58:15,925 --> 00:58:17,336
- Yes.
- And that's also a place
782
00:58:17,338 --> 00:58:19,578
where the two tribes
are rubbing...
783
00:58:19,580 --> 00:58:20,819
It's very significant
784
00:58:20,821 --> 00:58:24,164
that our milobs have been
assassinated in the war.
785
00:58:24,166 --> 00:58:27,095
- It wasn't robbery gone bad.
- No, no, no, definitely not.
786
00:58:27,097 --> 00:58:30,440
No, I think they saw something
they shouldn't have seen.
787
00:58:30,442 --> 00:58:32,235
That's my take on it.
788
00:58:37,925 --> 00:58:40,888
While Meg Carey
looks for an Ituri exit strategy
789
00:58:40,890 --> 00:58:43,683
the Bunia jail is renovated.
790
00:58:56,097 --> 00:58:58,856
Local judges
will soon be reinstated.
791
00:59:00,787 --> 00:59:04,338
Rebuilding any society
starts with the rule of law.
792
00:59:06,993 --> 00:59:09,991
There was no functioning
793
00:59:09,993 --> 00:59:12,991
indigenous rule of law.
794
00:59:12,993 --> 00:59:17,440
The quandary that we were in
795
00:59:17,442 --> 00:59:19,440
is that we could not
hold people indefinitely,
796
00:59:19,442 --> 00:59:22,750
without turning them over
to a local judicial process.
797
00:59:22,752 --> 00:59:25,819
We could not also arrest people.
798
00:59:25,821 --> 00:59:29,440
We could detain people,
but we couldn't arrest people.
799
00:59:29,442 --> 00:59:31,819
And so what we needed
as quickly as possible
800
00:59:31,821 --> 00:59:35,336
was for the local police,
even if it was symbolic,
801
00:59:35,338 --> 00:59:37,336
to begin working.
802
00:59:37,338 --> 00:59:40,267
Now, on CIVPOL,
803
00:59:40,269 --> 00:59:43,647
an integrated Congolese
police force for Ituri
804
00:59:43,649 --> 00:59:45,578
is part of our exit strategy.
805
00:59:45,580 --> 00:59:49,336
And it's also part
of our strategy
806
00:59:49,338 --> 00:59:52,543
to strengthen
the Ituri administration
807
00:59:52,545 --> 00:59:55,233
and to get it to be doing
the work for itself.
808
00:59:55,235 --> 00:59:58,819
I've read your cable
for options for Ituri,
809
00:59:58,821 --> 01:00:01,612
but I really have to stress
810
01:00:01,614 --> 01:00:03,750
that anything that you send
to us in New York
811
01:00:03,752 --> 01:00:07,405
has to be realistic,
based on present capacities
812
01:00:07,407 --> 01:00:09,716
and based on a thorough
political analysis
813
01:00:09,718 --> 01:00:11,647
of what is acceptable
to the parties.
814
01:00:11,649 --> 01:00:15,405
Whenever you make a presentation
to Mr. Titov or myself,
815
01:00:15,407 --> 01:00:16,785
start with needs,
816
01:00:16,787 --> 01:00:20,612
not with your desires
for what you're going to deploy.
817
01:00:20,614 --> 01:00:22,543
I want to know
the needs on the ground,
818
01:00:22,545 --> 01:00:24,440
that's what I want to know.
819
01:00:24,442 --> 01:00:25,681
Bottom line at this stage,
820
01:00:25,683 --> 01:00:27,129
everything is needed,
because there isn't...
821
01:00:27,131 --> 01:00:29,336
"Everything is needed"
means nothing to me, Stephan.
822
01:00:29,338 --> 01:00:32,336
I'm a political-affairs officer,
I know nothing about police.
823
01:00:32,338 --> 01:00:33,474
I need details.
824
01:00:33,476 --> 01:00:36,957
What does "everything" mean,
okay?
825
01:00:36,959 --> 01:00:39,612
You have to treat me like a
child who knows nothing, okay?
826
01:00:39,614 --> 01:00:41,681
And explain it from A to Z.
827
01:00:41,683 --> 01:00:44,957
Can I just,
with all due respect,
828
01:00:44,959 --> 01:00:47,957
make a suggestion?
Never say you can't do anything.
829
01:00:47,959 --> 01:00:51,405
We will find ways of doing
if it has to be done, okay?
830
01:00:51,407 --> 01:00:53,509
Let's just find ways
of doing it.
831
01:00:53,511 --> 01:00:55,200
Okay. So, um... Sorry.
832
01:00:57,511 --> 01:00:58,856
Hello.
833
01:01:02,925 --> 01:01:04,750
So basically,
we've got to start,
834
01:01:04,752 --> 01:01:07,026
for purely political reasons,
835
01:01:07,028 --> 01:01:10,681
and not because of substance or
this is the right thing to do,
836
01:01:10,683 --> 01:01:12,923
but purely
for political reasons,
837
01:01:12,925 --> 01:01:15,545
I would like to start training
a police force now.
838
01:01:24,269 --> 01:01:27,890
Okay, no, no, no, it's okay.
I'll call Mr. Titov tomorrow.
839
01:01:30,028 --> 01:01:33,647
Before you hang up,
can you dial my home number?
840
01:01:33,649 --> 01:01:35,683
Thank you.
841
01:01:51,442 --> 01:01:53,129
Late June.
842
01:01:53,131 --> 01:01:55,062
The French declare
Bunia weapons-free.
843
01:01:57,131 --> 01:02:00,336
The Bunia child soldiers now
join the thousands of fighters
844
01:02:00,338 --> 01:02:02,957
camped in the hills,
845
01:02:02,959 --> 01:02:05,304
waiting for the orders
to attack.
846
01:02:43,028 --> 01:02:45,026
That Sunday,
847
01:02:45,028 --> 01:02:48,647
the people in Bunia
celebrate the town's liberation.
848
01:02:48,649 --> 01:02:50,233
The government in Kinshasa
849
01:02:50,235 --> 01:02:52,923
declares the war
officially over.
850
01:02:52,925 --> 01:02:56,371
The fighting may be over,
851
01:02:56,373 --> 01:02:58,923
but the peace,
it's not even close.
852
01:02:58,925 --> 01:03:01,819
Two weeks later,
the newly appointed judges,
853
01:03:01,821 --> 01:03:03,716
fearing for their lives,
854
01:03:03,718 --> 01:03:06,681
will flee Bunia.
855
01:04:06,959 --> 01:04:08,543
Bonjour.
856
01:04:08,545 --> 01:04:10,785
Comment ça va?
857
01:04:10,787 --> 01:04:12,614
CÇa va? Oui?
858
01:04:35,304 --> 01:04:39,129
Within hours
of arriving back in New York,
859
01:04:39,131 --> 01:04:43,028
Meg Carey, drafting
the Ituri exit strategy.
860
01:04:46,511 --> 01:04:49,819
The plan: several-thousand
additional UN troops
861
01:04:49,821 --> 01:04:52,750
to secure Bunia
after the French leave,
862
01:04:52,752 --> 01:04:56,060
and 150-million dollars
to pay for them.
863
01:04:56,062 --> 01:04:58,164
In a few minutes,
864
01:04:58,166 --> 01:05:01,302
Jean-Marie Guéhenno will try
to convince the Security Council
865
01:05:01,304 --> 01:05:02,925
it will all work.
866
01:05:11,235 --> 01:05:13,440
Amin, I need it now.
867
01:05:13,442 --> 01:05:15,509
Just e-mail it to me.
868
01:05:17,235 --> 01:05:18,890
You got it?
869
01:05:26,718 --> 01:05:28,131
Fine, thank you.
870
01:05:33,200 --> 01:05:35,612
- Okay. You send it to me.
- Yeah.
871
01:05:35,614 --> 01:05:39,509
Possibly to reinforce...
872
01:05:39,511 --> 01:05:43,854
detachments in north Kivu.
873
01:05:43,856 --> 01:05:45,336
CÇa va?
874
01:05:45,338 --> 01:05:47,474
Okay, although
this is primarily an allegation
875
01:05:47,476 --> 01:05:49,957
of the MLC.
Have we any MONUC?
876
01:05:49,959 --> 01:05:52,440
- They've apparently confirmed.
- Okay. Fine.
877
01:05:52,442 --> 01:05:54,957
However, the RCD
has put forth three demands
878
01:05:54,959 --> 01:05:56,233
that the DRC government...
879
01:05:57,649 --> 01:05:59,371
Can you take the message
for me, please?
880
01:05:59,373 --> 01:06:01,854
- Sure.
- I'll take it.
881
01:06:01,856 --> 01:06:04,474
Hi. Okay.
882
01:06:04,476 --> 01:06:07,750
- It's 11 pages.
- He said five.
883
01:06:07,752 --> 01:06:10,338
Tough shit.
884
01:06:13,062 --> 01:06:15,681
In the midst of 2003,
885
01:06:15,683 --> 01:06:18,474
there is a window
of opportunity, and you know,
886
01:06:18,476 --> 01:06:20,578
it's like stars
aligning themselves.
887
01:06:20,580 --> 01:06:22,647
There's a combination
of factors.
888
01:06:22,649 --> 01:06:27,129
There's a post-Iraq factor,
that's the sense
889
01:06:27,131 --> 01:06:29,716
that the Security Council
has to demonstrate
890
01:06:29,718 --> 01:06:32,750
that it can deliver
891
01:06:32,752 --> 01:06:35,235
and that it is not focused
just on Iraq.
892
01:06:38,235 --> 01:06:41,543
Thirty-seven floors
down to the Security Council.
893
01:06:41,545 --> 01:06:45,509
Jean-Marie Guéhenno's
made the trip 100 times before.
894
01:06:45,511 --> 01:06:50,302
He knows Council debates
are for public posturing.
895
01:06:50,304 --> 01:06:52,750
He's already made
the private phone calls
896
01:06:52,752 --> 01:06:54,991
to nervous embassies.
897
01:06:54,993 --> 01:06:58,198
What he doesn't know:
Will it work?
898
01:06:58,200 --> 01:07:01,129
The Secretary-General himself
is in close contact
899
01:07:01,131 --> 01:07:03,957
with Colin Powell,
with Condoleeza Rice,
900
01:07:03,959 --> 01:07:07,750
with the president himself, so
there are contacts at top level,
901
01:07:07,752 --> 01:07:11,681
from the UN
and from other countries
902
01:07:11,683 --> 01:07:14,716
which have good relations
with the U.S.
903
01:07:14,718 --> 01:07:17,991
and which made the case
for MONUC.
904
01:07:17,993 --> 01:07:19,302
The African countries
905
01:07:19,304 --> 01:07:22,612
tell the non-African members
of the Council, "Come on!
906
01:07:22,614 --> 01:07:25,474
"Do you care about Africa,
or don't you?
907
01:07:25,476 --> 01:07:27,923
And if you care,
how could you question
908
01:07:27,925 --> 01:07:33,198
that 10,800 troops
is too much for Congo,
909
01:07:33,200 --> 01:07:36,854
a country the size
of Western Europe?"
910
01:07:36,856 --> 01:07:40,302
One of the things
that we used on Council members,
911
01:07:40,304 --> 01:07:42,095
informally, was the guilt.
912
01:07:42,097 --> 01:07:43,888
If we needed to withdraw,
913
01:07:43,890 --> 01:07:47,026
and the Secretary-General would
have withdrawn that battalion
914
01:07:47,028 --> 01:07:49,991
if need be,
he would have had to.
915
01:07:49,993 --> 01:07:53,612
And if it had been a bloodbath,
it would have been
916
01:07:53,614 --> 01:07:55,957
on the shoulders
of the international community.
917
01:07:55,959 --> 01:07:59,129
Unfortunately, the press sees
the international community
918
01:07:59,131 --> 01:08:02,302
as being this blue building
in New York which is the UN.
919
01:08:02,304 --> 01:08:04,371
And so it's the fault
of the UN,
920
01:08:04,373 --> 01:08:06,681
or it's the weakness of the UN.
921
01:08:06,683 --> 01:08:08,440
They don't sort of extend
that to:
922
01:08:08,442 --> 01:08:09,957
it's a weakness
of member states
923
01:08:09,959 --> 01:08:12,474
who don't give the UN
the capability to do something.
924
01:08:12,476 --> 01:08:14,509
To succeed in these tasks,
925
01:08:14,511 --> 01:08:17,819
it is critical
that states in the region
926
01:08:17,821 --> 01:08:20,647
act cooperatively
to support the process
927
01:08:20,649 --> 01:08:23,095
of bringing peace
and stability
928
01:08:23,097 --> 01:08:27,888
to the people of the Democratic
Republic of the Congo.
929
01:08:27,890 --> 01:08:30,302
The Security
Council finally gives MONUC
930
01:08:30,304 --> 01:08:35,060
the money for an Ituri brigade,
and a Chapter 7 mandate,
931
01:08:35,062 --> 01:08:38,095
allowing the UN brigade
to shoot to kill.
932
01:08:38,097 --> 01:08:40,511
Mr. Solana, the United States
would like to thank you...
933
01:08:47,683 --> 01:08:52,267
Chapter 7 comes with a package
of troops, in terms of numbers,
934
01:08:52,269 --> 01:08:55,819
in terms of determination,
935
01:08:55,821 --> 01:08:58,405
and also a package
of political commitment,
936
01:08:58,407 --> 01:08:59,543
of key players
937
01:08:59,545 --> 01:09:02,164
to put the pressure
on all those
938
01:09:02,166 --> 01:09:05,164
who can make a mess
of the situation
939
01:09:05,166 --> 01:09:06,681
if they so decide.
940
01:09:06,683 --> 01:09:10,578
We have to make sure
that the troop contributors
941
01:09:10,580 --> 01:09:14,233
are prepared to draw
the consequences of that.
942
01:09:14,235 --> 01:09:16,302
There's a clear understanding
943
01:09:16,304 --> 01:09:18,923
that they're not getting off
the hook by giving us Chapter 7;
944
01:09:18,925 --> 01:09:21,026
it's not a favour
that they're doing us.
945
01:09:21,028 --> 01:09:22,612
It's a responsibility.
946
01:09:22,614 --> 01:09:25,026
It's a responsibility
that they're taking.
947
01:09:25,028 --> 01:09:26,681
Responsibility, too, in terms
of that arms embargo
948
01:09:26,683 --> 01:09:28,543
and stopping the arm flow
from Uganda and Rwanda.
949
01:09:28,545 --> 01:09:30,095
They have to take
that responsibility.
950
01:09:30,097 --> 01:09:31,750
- Yes.
- Only they can do that.
951
01:09:31,752 --> 01:09:33,925
- That is the package.
- That's the package.
952
01:09:43,097 --> 01:09:45,854
Fall, 2003.
953
01:09:45,856 --> 01:09:48,338
The Congo River once again open.
954
01:09:52,373 --> 01:09:55,164
But the weapons embargo
isn't working.
955
01:09:55,166 --> 01:09:58,716
Arms are travelling
from Ituri down the Congo,
956
01:09:58,718 --> 01:10:02,545
spreading violence
to neighbouring provinces.
957
01:10:04,856 --> 01:10:07,198
September 1st.
958
01:10:07,200 --> 01:10:09,543
On schedule.
959
01:10:09,545 --> 01:10:13,062
The French-led multinational
force leaves Bunia.
960
01:10:15,511 --> 01:10:20,095
At the same time, the newly
arrived UN Ituri brigade,
961
01:10:20,097 --> 01:10:23,302
made up of Pakistanis,
Bangladeshis and Indians,
962
01:10:23,304 --> 01:10:26,750
takes control of Bunia.
963
01:10:26,752 --> 01:10:30,509
This time, the UN brigade is,
by anybody's standards,
964
01:10:30,511 --> 01:10:32,856
a robust force.
965
01:10:38,511 --> 01:10:42,267
Almost immediately,
the UN brigade is tested.
966
01:10:42,269 --> 01:10:44,819
The warlords
are probing for weakness.
967
01:10:44,821 --> 01:10:47,819
But with a Chapter 7 mandate
968
01:10:47,821 --> 01:10:50,026
and the will to use it,
969
01:10:50,028 --> 01:10:52,856
Bunia is stabilized.
970
01:11:31,614 --> 01:11:34,267
Simultaneously,
the brigade,
971
01:11:34,269 --> 01:11:36,267
with attack helicopters
from India,
972
01:11:36,269 --> 01:11:37,991
starts extending its perimeter
973
01:11:37,993 --> 01:11:41,373
into the hills
once owned by the warlords.
974
01:11:58,338 --> 01:12:00,543
Kinshasa.
975
01:12:00,545 --> 01:12:04,129
The Parliament of Reconciliation
finally convenes.
976
01:12:04,131 --> 01:12:06,373
But it won't be easy.
977
01:12:09,614 --> 01:12:12,336
Armies from two
of the vice-presidents
978
01:12:12,338 --> 01:12:14,716
have recently been trying
to kill each other,
979
01:12:14,718 --> 01:12:16,716
and there have been
numerous plots
980
01:12:16,718 --> 01:12:19,097
against the life
of President Joseph Kabila.
981
01:12:21,718 --> 01:12:23,957
No First World country
is going to save the Congo;
982
01:12:23,959 --> 01:12:25,854
the Congo
is going to save the Congo
983
01:12:25,856 --> 01:12:27,716
and the Congolese
will save the Congo.
984
01:12:27,718 --> 01:12:30,612
And in terms of the national
political process,
985
01:12:30,614 --> 01:12:33,336
there are some key issues,
986
01:12:33,338 --> 01:12:38,440
and they are difficult issues
to get over.
987
01:12:38,442 --> 01:12:42,304
But it's not impossible to get
over with sustained support.
988
01:12:48,097 --> 01:12:50,854
October.
989
01:12:50,856 --> 01:12:52,819
As MONUC provides security,
990
01:12:52,821 --> 01:12:54,923
the first class
of the Bunia Police,
991
01:12:54,925 --> 01:12:58,890
the one Meg Carey wanted,
is about to graduate.
992
01:13:02,062 --> 01:13:03,543
In the class,
993
01:13:03,545 --> 01:13:06,580
cadets who not long ago
were trying to kill each other.
994
01:13:26,511 --> 01:13:27,612
AÀ droite.
995
01:13:27,614 --> 01:13:28,993
Droite!
996
01:13:38,649 --> 01:13:43,750
What is happening in Ituri
is at the forefront
997
01:13:43,752 --> 01:13:46,856
of what could be happening
in the country as a whole.
998
01:13:49,200 --> 01:13:52,474
We already have
the first nucleus
999
01:13:52,476 --> 01:13:54,854
of the integrated
national police force
1000
01:13:54,856 --> 01:13:57,578
that has been set up
in the town of Bunia,
1001
01:13:57,580 --> 01:13:59,681
and the training
that's been done there.
1002
01:13:59,683 --> 01:14:02,336
So it seems to me
that sometimes,
1003
01:14:02,338 --> 01:14:05,509
if you tackle the toughest
problems
1004
01:14:05,511 --> 01:14:09,336
in a concerted
and adequately resourced way,
1005
01:14:09,338 --> 01:14:11,819
and you make
real progress there,
1006
01:14:11,821 --> 01:14:14,233
it becomes a beacon or a model,
1007
01:14:14,235 --> 01:14:17,407
or at least a precedent, for
what can be happening elsewhere.
1008
01:14:29,511 --> 01:14:33,543
The risk, in a way,
is that as things look better,
1009
01:14:33,545 --> 01:14:35,509
and they are indeed better,
1010
01:14:35,511 --> 01:14:39,026
the sense of...
and the pressure,
1011
01:14:39,028 --> 01:14:42,750
the sense of imminent risk
is no more there,
1012
01:14:42,752 --> 01:14:44,819
which is a good thing
1013
01:14:44,821 --> 01:14:47,716
because it reflects progress
on the ground,
1014
01:14:47,718 --> 01:14:50,233
but which is a dangerous thing
1015
01:14:50,235 --> 01:14:54,164
because that progress
is not so solid
1016
01:14:54,166 --> 01:14:56,371
that there is no need
1017
01:14:56,373 --> 01:14:58,338
for continued,
very strong engagement.
1018
01:15:05,856 --> 01:15:07,854
Throughout the fall,
1019
01:15:07,856 --> 01:15:11,580
the Ituri brigade continues
moving outside Bunia.
1020
01:15:16,476 --> 01:15:19,681
Mongwalu, site of the murders
of the milobs,
1021
01:15:19,683 --> 01:15:21,647
is particularly dangerous.
1022
01:15:21,649 --> 01:15:24,854
There's a gold mine here,
1023
01:15:24,856 --> 01:15:27,476
gold to buy arms.
1024
01:15:31,407 --> 01:15:34,856
But even in Mongwalu,
things are starting to change.
1025
01:16:34,166 --> 01:16:36,164
Despite
what their leaders may do,
1026
01:16:36,166 --> 01:16:38,026
the Congolese child soldiers
1027
01:16:38,028 --> 01:16:41,373
will not turn in their guns
in the coming months.
1028
01:16:43,683 --> 01:16:47,821
No one has figured out
an incentive that works.
1029
01:17:06,476 --> 01:17:10,026
Every day, an old diesel brings
kids from the countryside
1030
01:17:10,028 --> 01:17:12,407
into Kinshasa, to beg and steal.
1031
01:17:14,856 --> 01:17:18,028
Each week, some of the kids
perish under the train's wheels.
1032
01:17:19,821 --> 01:17:22,095
Others die more slowly,
1033
01:17:22,097 --> 01:17:25,026
of hunger or despair.
1034
01:17:25,028 --> 01:17:28,474
If the Kinshasa politicians
and the international community
1035
01:17:28,476 --> 01:17:30,681
don't give them a future,
and soon,
1036
01:17:30,683 --> 01:17:34,442
there are plenty
of Ituri warlords who will.
1037
01:17:56,993 --> 01:18:01,716
In the following months, the
violence in Ituri does not stop.
1038
01:18:07,752 --> 01:18:10,923
Not far from Bunia,
1039
01:18:10,925 --> 01:18:13,923
the village of Kachele
is attacked in the night.
1040
01:18:13,925 --> 01:18:18,614
Sixty-five people killed,
including 40 children.
1041
01:18:41,235 --> 01:18:43,198
In the fall of 2003,
1042
01:18:43,200 --> 01:18:46,060
the UN itself becomes a target.
1043
01:18:46,062 --> 01:18:48,511
Several more milobs are killed.
1044
01:18:50,269 --> 01:18:54,371
But the worst predictions
have not materialized:
1045
01:18:54,373 --> 01:18:58,269
a massacre on the scale
of Rwanda has been averted.
1046
01:19:33,373 --> 01:19:36,856
Can you tell them
that he's on his way? Thank you.
1047
01:19:39,614 --> 01:19:42,269
Oh, so we've got movement.
1048
01:19:59,580 --> 01:20:01,371
It's been a mixed year
1049
01:20:01,373 --> 01:20:04,129
for the world's peacekeeper.
1050
01:20:04,131 --> 01:20:08,407
The Security Council failed
to stop the war in Iraq.
1051
01:20:10,304 --> 01:20:13,681
But Haiti, Burundi and Liberia,
amongst others,
1052
01:20:13,683 --> 01:20:15,545
are qualified successes.
1053
01:20:17,476 --> 01:20:19,198
And the Congo,
1054
01:20:19,200 --> 01:20:21,991
a country no one
wants to think about,
1055
01:20:21,993 --> 01:20:27,267
it continues its painful march
towards national elections.
1056
01:20:50,787 --> 01:20:54,681
Excellencies, we now see
with chilling clarity,
1057
01:20:54,683 --> 01:20:58,060
that a world
where many millions of people
1058
01:20:58,062 --> 01:21:00,026
endure brutal oppression
1059
01:21:00,028 --> 01:21:04,854
and extreme misery,
will never be fully secure,
1060
01:21:04,856 --> 01:21:08,957
even for its most privileged
inhabitants.
1061
01:21:08,959 --> 01:21:12,026
Once again this year,
1062
01:21:12,028 --> 01:21:15,785
our collective response
to events of this type
1063
01:21:15,787 --> 01:21:18,336
in the Democratic Republic
of Congo,
1064
01:21:18,338 --> 01:21:22,440
has been hesitant and tardy.
1065
01:21:22,442 --> 01:21:26,991
History is a harsh judge.
1066
01:21:26,993 --> 01:21:31,200
It will not forgive us
if we let this moment pass.
1067
01:21:53,399 --> 01:21:58,399
Provided by explosiveskull
https://twitter.com/kaboomskull
1067
01:21:59,305 --> 01:22:59,590
OpenSubtitles recommends using Nord VPN
from 3.49 USD/month ----> osdb.link/vpn
83186
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.