All language subtitles for A.Time.to.Kill.S01E07.Murder.on.His.Mind.720p.WEBRip.x264-LiGATE[eztv.io]

This is an execution.

This was a planned murder.

The killer came
into this house

looking for Justin
and got Justin.

A brutal killing.

Justin Michael was
brutally gunned down,

and Angie Ver Huel
was unharmed.

It just didn't make sense.

A dark mystery
with shocking twists.

The motives
could be infidelity,

jealousy, is there some type of
love triangle gone bad?

He was face-to-face with
the guy that he could say,

"that's the guy that took
my girlfriend away from me."

Maybe it just kind of
picked a scab.

Maybe that's when
his anger toward

Justin Michael
began to build.

The truth will be revealed.

Most victims know
their killer.

You're almost always
gonna find a connection.

There's some tie
back to the victim.

The key to the investigation
is finding that tie.

Every day in North America,

dozens of people are murdered.

The key to solving
the toughest of these homicides

lies in the final 24 hours
of the victim's life.

To crack the case,

detectives must reconstruct
that critical timeline,

the minutes and hours
containing evidence

that can help unlock
the mystery

and catch the killer.

Some 15 miles north
of des moines, Iowa,

just off the highway and down
some gravel roads lies

the town of grimes --

though if you blink,
you just might miss it.

Grimes is a very small town,

surrounded by nothing
but farmland.

You have the old brick
downtown area,

and then out for
miles in every direction

you have farm fields.

Grimes is very quiet.

It has that midwestern charm.

It has low crime rate.

The last violent crime
was 42 years ago.

Most of the crimes are
property crimes,

thefts, burglaries.

But then one spring night,

the residents of this peaceful
farming community are awoken by

the sound of sirens.

When you get
a shots fired trip,

especially in the grimes area,

a lot of the times, it's just
people doing fireworks.

You get backfire from a car.

We've had
transformers blow.

Homicide?

Very rarely.

When you see a lot of
authorities on the scene

in grimes, Iowa,

you start thinking
this probably isn't just

a normal crime,
it's a lot more serious.

The victim is
30-year-old Justin Michael.

Justin was a good-looking,
bright young man.

Family and friends
loved to be around him.

He had a sense of adventure,
a great job.

Nobody had an unkind word
to say about him.

He was always willing
to lend a hand, um...

Just a good, good guy.

Angie and Justin were
engaged to be married.

Angie had bought
her wedding dress,

so it's heartbreaking to know
they were that close to

the wedding, and then
their lives were shattered.

Tasked with
investigating Justin Michael's

murder is detective
Robyn Bartholomew.

I was called out
roughly 3:30 in the morning

and was notified
of a shooting.

Once on scene,
I observed a white male,

early thirties, laying
on his back in the bed.

There was a significant
amount of blood.

He had four gunshot wounds,

three to the head
and one to the neck.

The victim appeared to be
gunned down in his sleep.

The person that
shot Justin was clearly

standing right over
the top of him,

shooting almost downward
into his head.

The bullets pass through
Justin, through the pillow,

through his mattress,

and one of the bullets
actually passed through

the wall and exited
the home.

Justin Michael's
fiancee, Angie Ver Huel,

was laying right next to
Justin Michael when he was shot,

and Angie Ver Huel
was unharmed.

Angie said
she was asleep in bed.

She heard several shots

and immediately woke
and saw what appeared

to be a dark figure
exiting the bedroom.

The description of
the intruder was so vague.

Average-size person,
unknown male or female,

dressed in
all dark clothing.

We have no idea
who we're looking for.

Detective Bartholomew must now

track down Justin's killer by

focusing on the last
24 hours of his life,

starting with the crime scene.

Shell casings were located

in the bed next to the victim.

I had never seen
the shell casings before.

They were tulammo,
which I later learned

is a Russian manufactured
steel casing ammo.

The weapon used was
a 9-millimeter automatic.

Whenever you have
a murder involving a firearm,

ballistics is a very important
forensic component of

an investigation.

Whenever you see a particular
brand of ammunition show up

that is atypical, that points
police in the direction of

a specific type of buyer.

That said, the more rare
a brand or a make or model

of ammunition,

the much smaller your
potential pool of suspects,

and they can be
much harder to find.

Police comb
through the house

looking for more clues.

It was a small,
well-kept house.

There was no signs
of forced entry.

The only thing
that appeared, um,

out of order was some
electronic equipment

that had been pulled from
an entertainment center.

Then something unusual
catches the detective's eye.

There was a piece of clothing
that was left there in

the living room that did not
belong to anyone in the house.

It was a construction
yellow hoodie.

I thought that was odd.

In the preliminary stages
of an investigation,

you can't rule out
a burglary gone wrong.

But after examining the scene,

nothing was missing
from the house.

The house wasn't ransacked.

To me, it was a poor attempt
to stage a burglary.

Staging is any
attempt by an offender to create

an alternate scenario,

to move things around in
a way to misdirect the police.

Whenever you see staging at
a murder scene or any

crime scene for that matter,

it will often reflect the fact
that the offender knows they're

going to be the prime suspect,

they have some personal
connection to the victim,

so by introducing staging, or
countermeasures as we call it,

it creates
an alternate scenario

to frame someone
in particular.

It did not seem
it was some type of a burglary

that was taking place.

It appeared that this was
a targeted attack.

This was somebody
that came into this house

looking for Justin
and got Justin.

It's very unusual that someone's
gonna enter a house,

gun down one person,
and leave witnesses.

In many cases,
leaving a witness behind

would have to have some
other pragmatic purpose.

In other cases,
we see

where an offender
will murder one victim,

because they have a very
specific motive.

That doesn't necessarily mean
they have it in them to

take the life of an innocent
bystander or a witness.

In reality,

some killers just aren't
that cold-blooded.

To get more answers,
the investigators turn

to the other witness
at the scene,

Justin's mother, Marie.

Marie Michael was in town
for wedding-planning purposes,

so she was actually staying
at the residence with Justin

and Angie.

Marie was in
a guest room across from Justin

and Angie's room.

At approximately 3:20
in the morning,

she was awoken
by the door opening.

Marie Michael told US

the gun that was used
had a laser sight on it,

and she was woken up by
the light shining in her eyes.

She obviously was very scared,
pretended to remain asleep.

At one point,
she took a peek,

and she sees a figure in
the doorway clad in all black.

You know,
nothing to indicate who it was.

In very short order then,
she heard four rapid gunshots.

911 calls came in
by Angie Ver Huel

and Marie Michael at

3:22 in the morning.

We were able to establish
that the homicide occurred

at approximately 3:20
in the morning.

But who would want to
kill Justin Michael, and why?

Justin Michael
was brutally gunned down

and Angie Ver Huel
was unharmed.

It just didn't
make sense.

It was something
that was suspicious.

Angie said as soon
as the shots happened,

she immediately jumped up
out of the bed.

The fact that, you know,
she didn't get blood on her,

you know, maybe from the way
the gunshots occurred,

all of the splatter went
opposite of where

Angie was lying.

It's not out of the realm
of possibility,

but that's incredibly unusual.

When you examine crime scenes,

and especially when you have
blood evidence,

it tells a story.

And with the lack of blood on
Angie Ver Huel,

to me, that was a red flag.

In these types of cases,
you really want to look at

the person closest to
the victim -- more times

than not, it's gonna be
a significant other

or a family member that is
involved in the homicide.

I want to take
a closer look at Angie.

With suspicion
swirling around Angie Ver Huel

in the brutal killing
of her fiance,

Justin Michael,

detectives bring her down to
the station for questioning.

Angie,

by virtue of being Justin's
fiancee and being at

the crime scene unharmed,
is a person of interest.

As detectives interview Angie,

she's surprisingly unemotional.

I have no idea.

One would think that you'd be
completely shattered that

your fiance was brutally
gunned down right next to you.

Angie was, very calm.

She wasn't upset.
She wasn't crying.

Her demeanor was
a little suspicious.

Um...

Everyone responds differently
to grief and distress.

So in order to calibrate
a person's response

to determine if it's
suspicious or not,

like we see in this case,
we would have to first get to

know every person of interest,

their background, their habits,
their associates,

to understand if a theatrical
response is out of character

or if that's actually how they
just operate day to day.

This was a planned murder.

Angie survived the shooting,
she's laying

right next to Justin
when it occurs.

So why is she still alive?

What's the motivation
behind this murder?

Detectives
question Angie about

how she and Justin spent
his last 24 hours.

The day before
Justin Michael was murdered,

they met for dinner at Justin
Michael's sister's house.

Angie said there was
nothing unusual.

Everything was normal.

They were busy
making preparations

for the wedding, planning.

They were happy,
and they got home about 10 P.M.,

and went to bed
at approximately 11 P.M.

Detectives press Angie
for more details about

Justin's life.

Trying to figure out why
something like this happens,

you start looking
at backgrounds,

you start looking at all of
the people that Justin knows.

There was no indication that
Justin was involved in drugs.

There was no indication that
Justin was involved in

gambling or any of the things
of that nature.

You always want to
look into, you know,

was there something in
Justin's background that was

the cause of this homicide?

There was really nothing.

And also, there was nothing
noteworthy in Justin Michael's

past relationships that would
indicate somebody wanting

to harm him.

Investigators look closer at

Angie's relationship
with Justin Michael.

They want to know if there
were problems between them.

Angie had met
Justin in 2013.

They hit it off so well,
she had moved in very quickly.

She described their relationship
as a great relationship.

There was no, stress,

fights, no issues.

They were both excited
to get married.

Angie said that
their relationship was solid.

People generally don't
kill people just for

the sake of killing people
unless they are

completely deranged.

Most victims
know their killer.

You're almost always going
to find a connection.

There's -- there's some tie
back to the victim.

The key of the investigation
is finding that tie.

With Angie still
in their crosshairs,

investigators dig deeper
into her past relationships.

During the course
of Angie Ver Huel's interview,

one of those things I asked
about is, you know, who are

your ex-boyfriends?

Who are the people that you've
been involved with that could

be responsible for this?

The first name she mentioned

was a guy by the name
of Andy wegener.

Andy wegener was
a funeral director here in town.

He was Angie's
ex-boyfriend.

It was a long-term
relationship,

and they were pretty serious
and lived together,

and eventually,
they broke up.

At that point, Andy's a person
of interest, he's somebody

that has

got a history with Angie,
so we need to know what he's

been up to, and we've got
to figure out where he was,

what he was doing, and see
if he has any motivation

to be involved in this.

When pressed on
who else might have wanted

to harm Justin,

Angie recalls
a strange incident

from a few months back.

Angie had talked
about an incident

involving her vehicle
where it was vandalized.

The windshield was cracked,
three windows were broke out,

and someone had keyed her car.

At the time,
it was thought that

kids in the neighborhood
had damaged her vehicle.

But after learning the amount
of damage to Angie's car,

it seemed very personal.

The vandalized vehicle
and the murder of

Justin Michael
could be related.

Detectives ask Angie
if she has any ideas

as to who might be
behind the vandalism.

She mentions that for a very
brief period of time,

she dated
this guy named Dave.

Angie talked about
meeting up with him

a half a dozen times,
but nothing serious.

It was just more
of a hookup.

According to Angie,

when she ended things
with Dave,

he didn't take it well and
sent her several angry texts.

So at that point,
Dave is on our radar,

but we still don't
know who Dave is.

For a period of time, she could
not remember Dave's last name.

I thought that was odd.

We were trying to ask more
details or something

that would help her
remember Dave's last name.

As we pressed forward,
out of the blue,

she comes up with...

We already had
Andy wegener's name,

so we're running a criminal
history check.

We're doing those things
with Andy wegener,

but now Dave moffitt is
somebody that we need to see

what's going on.

And then Angie said David and
Justin had worked together

at Wells Fargo.

Wells Fargo
is a huge company,

I mean, 10 plus thousand
employees in polk county,

and by pure happenstance,

David moffitt then gets
assigned to the very team

within the mortgage division
where Justin Michael worked,

and both of these guys,
Justin and David,

had dated Angie Ver Huel.

So he was face-to-face with
the guy that he could say,

"that's the guy that took
my girlfriend away from me."

Maybe it just kind of
picked the scab.

Maybe that's when his anger

toward Justin Michael
began to build.

This connection is
most interesting,

knowing that

Angie had a relationship
with David moffitt.

David moffitt has
a work relationship with

Justin Michael.

Is there some type of love
triangle gone bad?

Jealousy, in my mind,
could be the motive here.

Jealousy is one of the most
destructive emotions.

We need to find David moffitt
and Angie's ex-boyfriend,

Andy wegener --
we need to talk to these guys.

We had to determine
if they were

involved in the murder
of Angie's fiancee.

In the murder
of Justin Michael,

detectives are pursuing two
new leads

from his fiancee Angie's past.

Knowing that

Angie had a relationship
with David moffitt,

and Andy wegener is Angie's
long-term ex-boyfriend,

we want to dig
a little deeper

and find out everything
we can about them.

We're checking if David
moffitt has a criminal history.

Does he have
a weapons permit?

While checking on
David moffitt,

we learned that David moffitt's
vehicle was impounded

the same night
as the homicide.

I needed to find out why.

They learn that David moffitt

had an accident the night
of the homicide,

approximately five miles
from Justin Michael's home.

At 3:45,
shortly after the homicide,

within the same hour

David moffitt's
in an accident.

Having David moffitt's name
pop up at that time

in that location is not
something we expected to see.

This is the piece
of the puzzle we're looking for.

I was dispatched
to that car accident.

When I arrived on
scene, it was...

About 0400,
about approximately 40 minutes

after the homicide
took place.

On a gravel road,
I come up on a red Ford Taurus

that struck this
telephone pole.

The front end of the car
was smashed in.

When I give the plate
to dispatch, and they

advise me it belongs to
a guy named David moffitt,

I don't see anybody
in the area.

And as soon as I'm starting
to get back into

my car is when the white male
subject comes out of

the ditch from the north
and he says, "I need help."

He said his name
was David moffitt.

He just says
he was out for

a joyride, and he got
in a car accident.

Deputy tart was aware at
this time that, five miles away,

way have a ho -- active
homicide scene going on.

So while not immediately
apparent that these two things

could be related,

it certainly got
his suspicion up.

The first thing
I notice is just

how much sweat that
he's covered in, he's --

from head to toe,
covered in sweat.

I asked him
what he's doing

in the grimes area.

At that moment,
he became really defensive.

I couldn't find insurance
on the car.

So I made the decision that I
was just gonna impound the car.

My gut was telling me
that he knew more

about what was actually
happening, about the homicide.

So I got all the information
that we needed in case

we needed to come back
and talk to him,

which I felt, at some point,
we were probably going to.

David moffitt lives on
the other side of the county.

He lives 26, 27 miles
away from this area.

So, barring some
unusual circumstance,

there's really not much reason
for him to be over in that area

at four o'clock
in the morning.

This startling new information

that places David moffitt
both on the timeline

and near the crime scene
could be the break

investigators have been
looking for.

Knowing that Angie
dated David moffitt,

and David moffitt's
vehicle was impounded

the same night of
the homicide,

is that coincidence?

Maybe, maybe not.

There's just
too many coincidences

that start to stack up
in this case.

He works with the victim.

He's in a motor vehicle
collision near the scene

of the crime -- that creates
a nexus that is undeniable

and that merits investigation,
full bore.

So Dave goes from being
an interesting character that

we need to find out about
to the top of our list

in very short order.

Detectives head to
the scene of David moffitt's

car accident,

hoping to find evidence
that will connect him to

Justin's homicide.

We have a lead.

We can't get out there
fast enough.

Searching the area where
David moffitt crashed,

we found some
incredible items.

We found a shoebox that
contained ear protection,

a flashlight,
and camo makeup.

So a lot of things that
are associated with concealing

your identity and committing
a crime such as this murder.

As detectives continue
to comb the area,

they gather even more
crucial evidence.

We also find

a gun magazine with ammo.

It's tulammo.

It's a match
to the shell casings

found at the crime scene.

This is a big breakthrough.

But then,

detectives make
an unexpected discovery.

Along with the magazine,

ammo,
flashlight was a receipt

for an oil change
in the name of Andy wegener.

What in the world
is going on here?

Andrew wegener's
already on our radar,

because, you know,
he's Angie's ex-boyfriend.

We have to figure out how
in the world this receipt

ends up at the crash scene,

you know, where David
moffitt's crashed his car.

It just didn't make sense.

Did Andy wegener
kill Justin Michael?

Did David moffitt
kill Justin Michael?

Were they in
it together?

We've certainly seen
collusion in homicide scenes.

But, you know,
by all accounts,

other than the Angie factor,
that they had both dated her,

there's no reason
that David moffitt

and Andrew wegener
would have crossed paths.

We've got to figure out what

the connection is
between these two.

The discovery of
Andrew wegener's name

on a receipt at

the scene of
David moffitt's car accident

five miles from where Justin
Michael was killed has

turned the investigation
on its head.

These two are tied
to this crime scene.

Are these two guys
working together?

Are they working
with Angie?

I need to do
some digging.

While detectives wait
on a search warrant

for David moffitt's house,

they bring Andy wegener
in for questioning.

Andy wegener
and Angie Ver Huel

lived together for
three years.

When we interviewed Andrew
wegener, he had moved on.

He had a new girlfriend.

Andy wegener said
that he was aware that Angie was

engaged but did not know to
who she was engaged to.

We asked Andy wegener
if he knew David moffitt.

He did not.

Andy claimed that
after their breakup,

he didn't stay in contact
with Angie.

During interviews,

it's very common that
people minimize

and don't tell the truth.

Andy denies having
any involvement in the crime,

but detectives press on,
looking for answers.

When Andy was asked
about a receipt for

an oil change in his name,

he didn't really have
an explanation to

why or what had
happened to it.

He said he recalled getting
an oil change and thought

that the receipt was still
in his vehicle or at home.

When people are interviewed,
there's many reasons

why they may
be evasive.

Sometimes they're trying to
conceal information which isn't

connected to the crime

but maybe portrays
them in a negative light.

Sometimes they're taken
aback and they're confused by

the information that
they're being presented with,

not because they're guilty,
but just because that's their

way of responding when they're
in a stressful situation.

Detectives question
Andy about his whereabouts

during the time Justin
was killed.

Andy had talked
about leaving work about

4 P.M., he had went home,
took care of a couple things,

and then ultimately ended up
staying overnight

at his girlfriend's house.

She lives in another
community several miles away.

They had gone
to dinner that night,

and they hung out at home,

watched some TV,
and went to bed.

With Andy saying he's at

his girlfriend's at 9:00 P.M.

And Justin killed a 3:20 A.M.,

it's still possible that Andy
had opportunity to sneak away

from his girlfriend's place
and kill Justin.

We need
to establish that he was in fact

at his girlfriend's house,
but at this point,

Andy wegener is still
high on our list

as far as suspects.

In any circumstance
where you have two mutually

strong suspects,
you can't move forward

until one or the other
is eliminated.

As detectives are wrapping up

their interview
with Andy wegener,

they receive
the search warrant

for David moffitt's home.

David still lived
at home with his parents.

He came from a pretty
well-to-do family.

We were able
to conduct a search

at the moffitt residence.

No one was home.

Any time you conduct a search,

you're gonna look for any kind
of evidence that's related to

the crime --
we're gonna look for weapons,

we're gonna look
for ammunition,

anything that could lead US
back to that homicide.

Detectives quickly uncover

an important new piece
of evidence

in the basement,

we found a bill of sale
for a firearm,

specifically, a 9-millimeter
automatic firearm like

the one that is involved
in the homicide.

Interestingly, though,
on that bill of sale for that

9-millimeter gun,

the seller was a gentleman by
the name of drew bahlmann,

and the purchaser
on that bill of sale

was Andy wegener.

Why does Andy wegener's name
keep popping up in this case?

We've got this receipt
that we can't really,

you know, get a good answer
on that's found

at the crash site
for the oil change.

Now we have this bill
of sale for

a for a 9-millimeter gun
found in

David moffitt's basement.

Investigators find
drew bahlmann's address

on the bill of sale for the gun,

and they set off to pay him
a visit in the nearby town of

sigourney.

Drew bahlmann's the guy
that's gonna solve

this mystery for US.

He's gonna tell US who he saw
when he sold the gun --

if Andy wegener went down
and bought that gun

or if David moffitt went down
and bought that gun.

We met with drew bahlmann,

and he had
no criminal history.

He lived in a small town,
was a school teacher.

Drew, he was legitimately
concerned, very upset,

knowing that a weapon
that he had sold

was involved in a homicide.

He was very cooperative.

He was
a meticulous record keeper,

which was of
great value to US.

As part of the sale
of the weapon,

he prepared two copies
of the bill of sale.

So we found the one copy in
David moffitt's garbage can.

He had an identical copy
of that same bill

of sale signed by both him
and Andy wegener.

The other thing that
drew bahlmann gave US,

in addition to being
a meticulous note taker,

he is an avid target shooter.

And fortunately for US,

he actually had casings that
he had fired through

the 9-millimeter gun

that we believed to be
the murder weapon.

So we were able to match
the bullets from the crime scene

where Justin Michael
was killed

to the bullets that
were provided to US

by drew bahlmann.

Now we know that we have
our murder weapon

that was sold
by drew bahlmann.

Police are
one step closer to

uncovering the identity of
Justin Michael's killer.

We showed drew
a picture of Andy wegener,

and we also showed
him a photo lineup

with a picture of
David moffitt.

David moffitt
and Andrew wegener

look very,
very similar.

Drew bahlmann pointed
at the first lineup

and identified
David moffitt,

but he also pointed
to Andy wegener.

Drew wasn't 100%
sure who he had met with.

Witnesses are really
a double-edged sword for

any investigator.

You rely on witnesses
to move an investigation

forward, to prioritize
certain suspects,

to establish a timeline,
but at the same time,

eyewitness evidence is
notoriously unreliable.

With drew bahlmann

having ided both David
and Andy as

the purchaser of the gun
used to kill Justin Michael,

his fiancee, Angie, is
ruled out as a suspect.

But even with this promising
new lead,

the investigation
is at a crossroads.

And this case was odd,

because we couldn't
connect the dots.

You know, whoever was committing
this crime had the intention

of throwing US off base.

We don't usually have that,

where it's false leads,
for lack of a better term.

We're not sure
what's going on here,

but we're gonna find out
who did this.

In the murder of
Justin Michael,

detectives have two suspects
on their radar --

Andy wegener
and David moffitt.

They need to identify
which one is the killer.

In the nearby town
of sigourney,

they have one more piece of
evidence to look into.

It could be the key
to solving the case.

One of the requirements
that drew bahlmann had for

selling this gun was to make
sure that the sale took place

in a public place, so it would
be recorded should anything

go wrong.

One of the receipts
that we found at David moffitt's

residence was a receipt

dated may 4th from
a convenience store

out of sigourney, Iowa.

A lemonade was purchased
along with a candy bar

on may 4th at 6:13 hours.

That is the same date
and time

that drew bahlmann
sold the weapon.

Fortunately for US,
the inside of

that store had
a surveillance camera.

Detectives turn to
the surveillance cameras in

the hopes of spotting David
moffitt or Andy wegener.

After scouring hundreds
of hours of footage,

they find the missing
piece of the puzzle.

We were able to
positively identify

this person
as David moffitt.

At that point,
we knew that David moffitt

was the person who
purchased the weapon.

The critical value
of cctv or video evidence

is that it is
an impartial witness.

It can provide
a historic record

of a timeline that
is unassailable,

that is undisputable,

unlike eyewitness testimony
that is

subject to a lot of problems.

Detectives now know that

David moffitt
acted alone and was

posing as Andy wegener to buy
the gun that killed

Justin Michael.

They believe he's the killer,
but to prove it,

they'll need more evidence
tying him to the crime.

A second search was conducted

at the moffitt residence.

We found there was tulammo,

which was consistent with both

the tulammo found at
the primary crime scene,

as well as the ammunition
provided US to by drew bahlmann.

In the bathroom trash,

we found recon notes,
notes that were specifically

for Justin Michael's
neighborhood,

notes that would indicate
certain times that

neighbors were home,
what time lights came off,

things that would put David
moffitt there watching

Justin Michael's house.

Those notes indicated
that David moffitt

had put some planning
into this.

Then police come
across a possible attempt to

conceal evidence.

We'd found a tote
in the basement

that was not there
the previous day,

and inside that tote was
a laptop computer.

And the red tub
also contained about

two inches of water in
the bottom of it.

It appeared that it was
an attempt

to eliminate whatever
information was on the computer.

Fortunately,
our lab gurus were able to

get this laptop dried out

and in a functioning state.

We found a substantial
amount of evidence

that specifically tied
David moffitt to the execution

of this crime.

The first file that was found
on the computer was a forged

driver's license that had
David moffitt's picture on it,

but the license was created
in the name of Andy wegener.

The evidence
suggested that David moffitt

put a lot of planning
into this,

and this was all
an elaborate ploy

to frame Andy wegener.

So at that point,
once we find this computer,

it all makes sense.

Then Andy wegener is pretty
much exonerated in this case.

Stockdale: One may want to frame
someone else, say Andy,

for the murder
so he won't get caught.

And perhaps he wants to get
rid of all the competition

so that he's either
the last person standing for

Angie's affections, or he wants
to send a message to

Angie and everybody that
she's been involved with.

Detectives then
uncover even more revealing

evidence connecting
David moffitt to the crime.

Once David's laptop was
examined, we were able to look

at all the Internet web searches

that he had made.

You could see
during the forensic analysis

kind of the beginnings of
a search history of

David moffitt searching Angie
Ver Huel, David moffitt,

you know, typing in
the name Justin Michael,

things like that.

And then days prior to
the homicide, the search,

history ratcheting up,
in a sense,

we learned that
David moffitt had

searched how
to commit a murder,

what are the confession times
at a local catholic church,

and the craziest one was
the murderiest murder guide

you'll ever need.

The Internet searches
revealed that David moffitt

was trying to get away
with murder.

Stockdale:
What stands out for me is

the clear level of planning,

and forethought
that was invested

into committing
this crime.

This was not a crime of rage.

The level of planning and
plotting that this takes shows

that there's a level of
instrumentality here in

this offense.

With the evidence
now stacked against him,

David moffitt is arrested for
the murder of Justin Michael.

So when
we arrested David moffitt,

David moffitt
had a blank stare,

no reaction whatsoever.

It was like he'd been caught.

Looking over this case,

jealousy, in my mind,
is the motive here.

And David moffitt was
violently jealous.

Detectives are now
able to piece together

Justin Michael's
final 24 hours.

The night Justin
Michael was murdered,

they had all got home
about 10 P.M.

And went to bed
approximately 11 P.M.

Just after 3 A.M.,

David moffitt entered
Justin Michael's house

with murder on his mind.

On the night Justin
was killed,

the perpetrator is able to
make entry through

the back deck door.

We then believe he went to
the front of the house

and staged that area

to make it look as though
it was some type of

a burglary that was
taking place.

But this was not a burglary.

This was a targeted attack.

David moffitt
then came down the hallway,

entered the wrong
bedroom where

Marie Michael was staying.

At that point,
he realized that that was

not the person that he was
going after.

Moffitt then goes
across the hall to

the master bedroom where
Angie and Justin were.

Justin's laying in the bed,
Angie's laying in the bed,

and there's four shots
that go into Justin.

The bullets pass through Justin,
through the pillow,

through his mattress,

and one of the bullets
actually passed through

the wall and exited the home.

The killer was certainly
looking for Justin,

and the killer got Justin.

We believe, ultimately,

the gun had been thrown off
a bridge into a lake.

David moffitt's car
crash was his fatal error.

Looking back now, if he would
have never crashed,

he might have gotten away
with murder.

In July 2015,
David moffitt is

found guilty of
first-degree murder

and sentenced to life
in prison without parole.

It was absolutely tragic.

Justin certainly
didn't deserve this.

It just -- that's what
makes this hard.

You know, you can't reconcile
things like that in

your head and have it
make any kind of sense.

The only reconciliation
you get in a case like this

is getting a conviction
and holding

the person responsible.

I really feel
for Justin's mother.

As a mother myself,

I can't imagine
losing a child.

And so, your heart just breaks
for her when she's talking

about being there the night
her son's murdered

and, you know, seeing the crime
scene is just horrific

for any mother --

you don't expect to outlive
your children ever.

We may never
know why David moffitt

killed Justin Michael.

Was it in hopes that he would
get back with Angie?

He would get a second chance?
Or he was just pure evil?