Original subtitles

(soft somber music)

Downloaded from YTS.MX

Official YIFY movies site: YTS.MX

(heart thumping)

(clock ticking)

(foreboding orchestral music)

(Jimmy grunting)

(Jimmy weeping and yelling)

(fire crackling)

- [Susan] (chuckles) You're gimpy.

(playful organ music)

Oh but dad's goin' all crazy on us.

(cellphone ringing)

(soft somber music)

(soft serene music)

- How'd you sleep last night, baby?

- Fine.

- Your mom called,

so you won't have to worry 'bout catchin' the bus.

She's gonna pick you up.

- Okay.

- I'm glad you came over this weekend.

Hey, maybe next weekend we can go bowling.

- Sure, dad.

(car horn honking)

I gotta go. - Hey.

- I gotta go or I'll be late.

See ya in two weeks.

- Love you, too.

(soft orchestral music)

(cellphone ringing)

- [Susan] What do you want me to do, Jimmy?

- I want you to stop fillin' her head with that--

- Oh no, you are not gonna blame this on me.

I can't fix your relationship with her.

- There's nothin' wrong with our relationship, Susan.

- Maybe if you spent more time with her when she's there

and not hide in your office all day.

- I didn't have to work so hard to pay the alimony,

the child support and the car payment then maybe.

- No, I'm not gonna let you turn this around on me;

not this time.

(cellphone dial tone)

(soft orchestral music)

(birds chirping)

- Hey I know, Mark.

Look they didn't get their shipment, okay?

I told them to go ahead and call Ricky.

Hang on a minute.

Mark, I'm gonna have to call you back. It's my ex-wife.

Look I've got nothin' else to say about this, Susan.

I'm tired of listenin' to this stuff.

- Did you see the news? - What?

No, I just came home for lunch.

- Turn on the news, Jim! - What?

(soft somber music)

- [Reporter] Police say that the two young men

entered the school around nine o'clock.

They opened to fire on the inside,

shooting staffers of the school and students.

- Brittany. - Then eventually

committing suicide on the inside.

- Oh god.

- [Reporter] Authorities have been

surrounding the area and trying to make sure.

(somber orchestral music)

- Hi, Jim.

- Pastor.

- We thought you might be hungry, honey.

I can just put in the refrigerator; it'll keep.

(birds chirping)

- (sighs) How you holdin' up?

It was beautiful service.

Beautiful service.

Look, Jim.

- If you're gonna come over here

and give me the whole Brittany's in a better place thing,

just save it.

- Jim, times like these, it's perfectly normal to--

- To what, to question?

To ask why?

Look I know why you're here, Calvin.

I appreciate the food.

There's nothin' that you can say,

there's nothin' that you can do

and there's nothing anybody can do.

- Jim, I'm just tryin' to--

- You know every time somethin' like this happens,

you all say it's all in God's plan.

What about my plans, Calvin?

What about Brittany's plans?!

Don't they matter?

Why is it just some plans of some ghost that matter?

- Jim, I'm just-- - Look.

I know what your job is, Calvin.

You're to come over here and remind me

that God is in control and we aren't in control.

You're supposed to say the right things.

You're supposed to do the right thing.

- Jim.

- Just save it, Pastor!

Save it for someone who can use it.

Save it for someone that might find some peace in it.

(Jimmy sniffing)

It was a beautiful service.

Thank you.

And I appreciate everything that you did for Susan and me.

But honestly Pastor, you can just stop.

Thank you for the food, Carol.

- I think it's time we should go, Carol.

- If there's anything, anything at all

that we can do, would you let us know?

(somber orchestral music)

(Jimmy coughing)

(soft piano music)

- [Jimmy] For you, dad.

(foreboding music)

- [Dad] Why do you always have to light

one of those stinkin' candles?

- [Jimmy] Dad?

- What is it inside of you that makes you have this need

to light one of those scented candles

every time you think about me?

- [Jimmy] You're.

- Dead?

Yes I am, Jimmy.

What's it been, 17 years now?

Good to see you, boy.

15 years of service and all you get's a flag.

12 different posts, movin' you,

your brother and your mom 12 times

and all you get's a flag.

It don't seem right, does it?

- You never came home.

- Oh yeah, sorry 'bout that.

Jimmy, I can tell you're strugglin' with this.

C'mon, sit down.

- Dad,

what are you doin' here?

- Well Jimmy, I thought it was time

that you and I had a little talk.

- A little talk?

- [Dad] Yeah.

- You wanna talk? - Yeah.

- Now you wanna talk.

You never had time to talk before you--

- What?

You can say it, Jimmy.

I know where I am.

Before I died?

- You didn't just die, Dad.

You.

You.

- Say it, Jimmy.

- Why? - Because you need to say it.

You need to say it and accept it.

- I need to accept it?

- Yes, you do.

- You killed yourself, dad.

- There it is.

- You left us! - I know.

- You never said goodbye.

You never said anything. - You're right.

- Stop agreein' with me!

You were a coward.

You took a coward's way out.

- Is that what you really think?

- Yeah, that's what I think.

- So you actually believe it was easy

for me to pull that trigger.

- This, this.

I ain't havin' this conversation.

You're not real.

- Look at me, Jimmy.

Do I look real to you?

- You are a figment of my imagination.

You're a product of my grief,

plus this.

- Now that, that's somethin' I really miss.

- I ain't havin' this conversation.

You're just in my head.

- You're right I am in your head.

You see Jim, you and I we're really not so different.

Your escape there, that's the same way I used to escape.

Drinkin'.

It's easy, isn't it?

- What? - Your escape.

The world just gets too tough.

It gets too real.

It gets too scary.

But drinkin', that's an easy escape.

- Scared?

You?

You were never scared of anything.

- Oh, Jim.

Son, I was scared of everything.

Everything: the world,

your mom, you and your brother.

Well, I was terrified of my own self.

- No no, that's a bunch of bull.

You were a rock.

- That's just what I let you guys believe, all of you.

- Who says somethin' like that?

How can you be scared of mom and us?

- Your mom was a saint.

She was perfect in every way.

She loved everybody.

She saw the best in everybody, even me.

I didn't understand that, but she did.

Now how am I supposed to live up to that?

- She loved you, dad.

- I know she did and I didn't know why.

- No no, she loved you.

I don't get it.

You find someone like mom, someone that loves you.

Someone that wanted to give you everything and you?

- You can say it, Jim.

I know.

- You broke her heart, dad!

- I know.

- Why?

Why'd you do it?

Why'd you slap her around?

Why'd you tear her down like that?

- Because she was better than me

and I hated her for it.

But you know what's crazier than that?

I hated myself for hatin' her.

Jim, I was taught to always be the best,

no matter what.

At all cost, always be the best.

The Army taught me that way.

My dad taught me that way.

I mean it didn't matter about anything else.

Just whatever it was that I was doin',

I had to always be the best.

And when it came to your mother, I just could never do it.

- Do what, live up to her expectations?

- No Jim, live up to mine.

Live up to my expectations.

I could never be what or who she wanted me to be.

- All she wanted from you is to love her and to love us.

Just to be a good husband and a good father and you.

- I couldn't do it.

I couldn't do it, Jim.

You're absolutely right.

I couldn't do any of it.

I couldn't be what she wanted me to be.

I couldn't be what you guys needed me to be.

I just didn't have it in me.

I couldn't do any of it.

You're absolutely right.

It made me--

- What,

sad?

It made you feel sad, angry?

- Weak.

It made me feel weak and I hated feelin' weak.

- So to be the big man, you had to knock us around?

- [Dad] (chuckles softly) Oh, Jim.

- Ya think this is funny?

- What I think is funny, Jim,

is that you think that we're so different.

- I never laid a hand on anyone.

- It doesn't matter, Jim.

You're so stupid.

You think just because you didn't hit Susan and Brittany

that makes you a great dad and father.

You think just because you didn't hit them

that you weren't abusive.

- I never abused them! - You ignored them.

They weren't important enough to you,

so you just didn't bother. - I love my daughter!

- You love the idea of havin' a daughter.

You love the idea of bein' a father and a husband.

You love that, but you didn't want the responsibility

that came with it.

- You don't know what you're talkin' about!

- I know exactly what I'm talkin' about, Jim.

I know because I was the same way.

I felt the same way; I did the same things.

- If you hated us so much, then why'd you adopt us?

Why did you even bother?!

- Because of your mother.

She wanted you guys.

Your mother was best friends with your real mother

and she was there by her side in the hospital

after the accident and we agreed to take you guys.

- So she knew our real mother?

- We both did.

Your real mother didn't have any family

and she was scared to death that you boys

would wind up in foster care;

so we took you.

- So you really didn't really want us?

- Honestly, no.

No, I didn't wanna be a dad.

I didn't want the responsibility.

I was just like you, Jim.

You didn't want Brittany.

You don't have to deny it now, Jim.

You're just lyin' to yourself.

- All I know is that I hated you while you were alive

and I haven't given you a second thought since you died.

- Then why am I here?

- You're not here.

You're here.

- I've always been there, Jim.

You can say all you want that you haven't given me

a second thought since I died,

but you're just lyin' to yourself again.

I've been there the whole time.

- But why?

I knew you didn't care about us.

I knew who and what you were.

- Then why was I there, Jim?

Because you've always known that we're not that different.

- If we're the same, it's because you made me this way.

- Maybe, but maybe that's just the way you're wired.

- I want you outta my head.

- I don't think you do, Jim.

I think you've always needed me.

See, as long as I'm up there in your head,

you've got an excuse.

Everything you are, everything you've done

you can blame it on me.

You can blame it on me

and not take any responsibility for it.

As long as I'm around, you can justify what you are.

- That's not true.

- It is true, Jim.

For years you been usin' me to justify who you were.

- Get outta here!

- It's not that easy, Jim.

- I want you outta my head.

- It doesn't work that way.

- Get away from me!

- Only you can make that happen.

- Shut up.

I'm not you and I'm not gonna do that.

- Why not?

C'mon, Jim.

Your wife left you, your daughter's gone.

You hate your job, what've you got to lose?

- Just because you couldn't handle it

doesn't mean that I can't.

- Is that what life's all about is just handling it?

Yeah gettin' through another day; enduring the misery.

- It's my life, dad.

I'll handle mine my way, you handle yours yours.

- Oh yeah, you done a real good job of that so far.

Haven't you, son?

- What do you know?

- I know everything that you know, Jim.

- Right

'cause we're the same.

- You don't get it Jim, do ya?

I am you.

- You're not me.

- Who do you think you've been talkin' to, Jim?

Do you think I've really been standin' here

havin' this conversation with you?

You're thinkin' 'bout all this stuff

because it's in your head, Jim.

So son, please just go on and do it.

- I can't.

I can't.

- What, you don't think you have it in you?

I didn't think I had it in me.

Jim, this can all end.

All the pain, all the suffering.

You'll be right back with Brittany.

You could start makin' up for lost time.

- I can't.

I can't.

Can I?

(eerie orchestral music)

Dad?

Dad?

(Jimmy coughing)

- Do you like the pain, Jim?

The hurtin', not sleepin'.

That's not really livin', Jim.

If you're not really gonna live,

then why deal with the pain?

- I don't wanna hurt anymore. - I know, son.

You've listened to me one time in your life,

just listen to me one more time.

- I don't wanna hurt.

- Then stop the hurt, Jim.

Stop the pain. - Stop the pain.

It's time.

- It's okay, Jim.

It'll all be over soon and you won't have to hurt anymore.

- I don't wanna hurt anymore.

- You'll be with Brittany.

- I miss her so much.

(weeps) I love you, Brittany. - I love you too, dad.

(Jimmy gasping)

- Stay away from her!

(somber orchestral music)

- What are you doing, daddy?

- Oh, baby.

I love you so much.

I'm sorry.

- What's happening, daddy?

- It doesn't matter, it doesn't matter.

Just lemme look at you.

- Daddy, we need to talk.

- Okay absolutely, whatever you wanna talk about.

- No, not here. - What?

- In my dresser, second drawer.

There's a box.

I need you to get that box and bring it to me.

Please don't look in the box, daddy.

Just get it.

- Okay. - No, not here.

I need you to get the box and bring it to my spot.

- Your spot?

- I have a spot that you and mom didn't know about.

Go out the back door and up the hill.

Look for the ribbons.

- The ribbons? - On the trees.

- Honey.

- Please daddy, we need to talk.

- Brittany,

I just got you here.

- [Brittany] Please don't look in the box, daddy.

Just get it.

("I Don't Know What to Pray" by Stephanie Rabus)

♪ I don't know what to pray ♪

♪ I don't know what to say ♪

♪ So take these tears from my heart as my worship ♪

♪ All these fears in my mind I lay them down ♪

♪ I don't know what to do ♪

(leaves crunching)

♪ But to rest in you ♪

♪ I don't know how long I can be here in this place ♪

♪ The only thing I know to do is praise ♪

♪ 'Cause I don't know what to pray ♪

♪ I don't know what to pray ♪

- I built it about four years ago

when you and mom started fighting a lot.

It's just far enough away from the house

that I can't hear you guys.

I tried other places: the attic, the basement.

But the only place that it was really quiet is out here.

After mom moved out, there was fear.

You were at work or something, so I came out here.

- Why?

- To cry.

I came out here to cry.

You told me I need to be strong, daddy.

You told me that I need to handle this like an adult.

I'm not an adult, daddy.

I'm a little girl.

I'm a little girl that needed her daddy to hold her,

to tell her that it was okay to be sad.

To let her cry on his shoulder.

To be angry.

To be angry that she didn't have her mom and dad anymore.

- Brittany, I--

- You couldn't be that, could you?

I know, dad.

I know that's not who you are.

You wanted me to be a good little soldier

and just deal with it.

Just accept it, but I couldn't.

I didn't know how.

- Brittany, I know I've messed up.

I messed up big time,

but we have a second chance right now and I can do better.

I can say the right things and do the right things.

- It doesn't work like that, daddy.

- What?

- There's things we both need to say, things I need to do.

It's why I'm here now.

- Well then just tell me what I need to say,

tell me what I need to do just so you can stay.

- I can't stay, daddy.

- But I need you.

There's so many things I didn't say.

There's so many things I didn't do.

- I knew.

You didn't have to say it.

I know you have a hard time.

- No, no Brit.

I did have a hard time, but not anymore.

I understand where I've messed up

and I can do better this time.

You know, my father.

No, I'm not gonna blame him for this.

This is all me.

Look, all I know is I can make up for this.

I can do better.

Just gimme that chance now,

so you can stay.

- We don't have a lot of time, daddy.

- Maybe I can come to you,

that way you wouldn't have to stay.

I could come to you and we could get this worked out.

- No, dad.

If you do what grandpa tells you to do,

we'll never see each other.

D'you remember the trip we took to Florida, the beach trip?

- Yeah.

Your mother fell asleep and she was burned to a crisp.

What were you, seven or eight?

- And I just learned how to swim.

- You thought you were so grown up.

You wouldn't have anything to do

with those floaties your mom brought.

You said, "Floaties--" - "Are for babies."

- (chuckles softly) You were so stubborn,

thought you were so grown up.

- Now or from the past?

But do you remember what happened on that trip?

(birds chirping)

- Yeah.

I told you not to go too far out with the raft.

I took my eyes off from you for just one minute,

and I turned around and you were gone.

You were out past the break of water and you were so scared.

- Do you remember what we did?

- Yeah, I ran across the beach.

I jumped out in the water

and I swam out to get you and bring you back in.

It took you an hour to quit cryin'.

- You saved me, daddy.

I was scared, I was lost.

You saved me.

- I should've never taken my eyes off of you.

I can't even remember why I did.

- You and mom arguing 'bout something stupid,

'bout the sunscreen or something.

- I remember turning my head towards her

and then when I turned back, you were gone.

Honey, I am so sorry.

- It's okay, daddy.

Sometimes we turn our eyes away

from what we should be looking at, get distracted.

It only takes that second

for our attention to be somewhere else

for something bad to happen.

But you saved me, daddy.

I was scared, really scared.

I was lost.

You saved me.

- That's just what daddies do, honey.

- I know, but you need to know that

fathers is there to save, not to harm.

- Honey, I had no idea what was gonna happen at that school.

I had no idea what was gonna be goin' on.

- Is that what you think I'm talking about?

Do you think I'm here because of what happened at school?

Daddy, you can't stop the world from happening.

It doesn't matter what you did.

- But no Brit, but I should have.

- You loved me.

- I should've protected you.

- You couldn't have known.

- I should have, Brittany.

I should've felt something.

I should've been there.

I should've done something, anything.

- It's not your fault.

- But I should have.

I should've been a better father for you.

I should've been a better dad to you.

There's so many things I should've done.

No,

no no!

Brittany, please!

♪ Accept these tears from my heart as my worship ♪

♪ All these fears in my mind I lay them down ♪

♪ I don't know what to do ♪

♪ But to rest in you ♪

♪ Don't know how long I can be here in this place ♪

- Faith?

♪ The only thing I know to do is praise ♪

♪ 'Cause I don't know what to pray ♪

- Hope.

♪ I don't know what to pray ♪

♪ I don't know what ♪

- Love.

♪ To pray ♪

- This place was a mess.

- [Jimmy] Yeah, I couldn't bring myself to clean it;

so I just left it the way you did.

- Boy, I was a slob.

- Yeah, but you're my slob.

- Daddy, I have to go here in a minute.

- No no, not yet.

Just stay.

- But before I do, there's something we need to talk about.

- Okay, anything you want.

Just stay, okay?

- It's about what you said outside about being a better dad.

- Yeah, I'm sorry about that, honey.

I'm sorry I got so mad.

I just don't know how to handle this, you know?

- There's not a manual for it, daddy.

You have to grieve.

You have to let me go.

- Brittany, I can't let you go.

- Do you know where I am, daddy?

- Honey.

- [Brittany] Daddy, it's amazing.

It's so beautiful.

It's safe.

- No, you should've stay with me.

I coulda kept you safe.

It was not your time.

- We're not the ones that make that decision.

I see that now.

- Can I ask you somethin'?

Did you ever feel like I've used you?

- Like you hit me and stuff?

Of course not.

- No, that's not what I mean.

Did you ever felt like I didn't love you

or you weren't cared for?

- Daddy, I always knew you that you loved me.

I mean there were times, a lot of times

when you were there, but you weren't really there

if you know what I mean.

Do you remember Angela?

- Yeah, of course.

She practically spent her fourth grade year here.

- [Brittany] D'you know why?

- I just assumed she was one of your BFFs or something.

- It's because she didn't wanna go home.

She's afraid to.

- Why?

- Because her dad.

He used to--

- What are you sayin', Brittany?

- When her mom wasn't around, he--

- No no, David's not like that.

He wouldn't done anything like that.

- It's why she never said anything.

- He came over here all the time for cookouts.

- She didn't think anyone would believe her.

- He was practically a best friend of mine.

- She tried to stay here every chance she could.

She didn't wanna go home.

- How do you know this stufF?

You're just 11 year old girl.

- Because that's the world we live in, dad.

That's my point.

It doesn't matter what you do

or what do you think you should've done.

You can't stop the world.

You can't stop the world from happening.

You can't protect me every minute of my life.

You can't be there all the time,

just like you couldn't have been at school today.

It was just a Tuesday, dad.

Just another Tuesday.

All you can do is love,

trust and--

- And what? - Pray, dad.

Can pray that no matter what happens,

it's part of God's plan.

- You're not gonna go through that plan thing too, are you?

What about your plans?

What about your plans to become a nurse?

What about those?

- Veterinarian.

- Veterinarian?

When'd you decide to become a veterinarian?

- Since I was seven, dad. (sighs)

- Okay, what about those?

What about those plans?

- That was my plan.

Just like it was your plan to do what you do.

It doesn't mean it's God's plan.

- Okay so why is his plans more important than ours, huh?

Don't our plans matter?

- 'Course they do.

But they matter more to us because we think

that they're the only thing that matters.

God's plan is what matters the most.

- When did you become so smart?

- When you weren't looking.

(soft somber music)

- I should've been lookin' at you a lot harder

and I should've protected you.

- What good is protecting me my whole life

when I can't grow up to protect you?

- Protect me?

From what?

- From yourself, dad.

From where you're headed.

Daddy, I need you to listen to me.

I saw the look in your eyes upstairs

and what you're about to do.

You can't.

You can't use my death as an excuse to not go on living.

It isn't your time yet.

- My time?

- He isn't done with you yet.

If you do what you're thinking about doing,

there's no going back, no eternity.

'Least not the one that I've seen.

- What have you seen?

What's it like?

- It wasn't like anything that I've ever heard about before.

There's not a brilliant white light, no choir of angels.

There's a lot of people waiting to go through the gate.

- So St. Peter isn't standin' there

with the "Book of Life" then?

- No, nothing like that.

There didn't need to be.

I'd already made that decision.

There was no doubt of where I was going, but I saw him.

- Him?

- It's like my eyes were closed.

Then when I opened them, he was there

like 15 or 20 feet in front of me.

He was smiling with his arms wide open

like he was waiting for a hug or something.

It's like I didn't know who he was,

but also like I'd known him my whole life.

Daddy, I ran to him.

I ran to him without an ounce of fear and he hugged me.

It was the warmest, safest hug that I've ever felt

like being wrapped in a blanket in the middle of winter.

- That sounds beautiful.

- It is, daddy.

I want you to see it too.

(sighs) It's time, daddy.

- No, not yet.

- Daddy, there's someone coming to visit you.

When they do you have to listen.

Not just hear, listen.

- Okay anything you want,

just as long as I get to see you again, okay?

- It's up to you, daddy.

- Please don't go, not yet.

- I have to go.

You have to let me go.

- I'm never gonna let you go.

I love you.

(somber piano music)

(Jimmy sighing)

(door knocking)

Susan?

- Hey, Jim.

- Are you her?

- Her who?

- The Third.

She told me about The Third.

- Been hittin' the bottle pretty hard today, have we?

- Yeah. - Figures.

- So what're you doin' here?

- Honestly, I don't know.

I went home after the funeral and I couldn't stay there.

I just couldn't.

Everywhere I looked I saw her.

- So you thought comin' here would be better.

- I don't know what I thought, Jim.

I just got in the car and I was here.

- Can I get you somethin' to drink of somethin'?

Look Susan, I don't know what's goin' on.

- Just shut up, Jim!

Please, just.

- If you wanna talk. - She called me, Jim.

- What? - From the school.

But when the guy started shooting, she called me.

- She what? - She was terrified, Jim.

She was crying and she was whispering when she was hiding.

- What'd she say?

What did she say? - She was hysterical.

I don't know what she said.

Everybody was dying and I didn't know what to say.

I told her I loved her and the phone went dead. (weeps)

She was so scared, Jim.

- I didn't know.

- That's all I hear is the crying and saying I love you.

Static (sobs)

and I couldn't stop crying.

That's all I do now is cry.

- Susan.

(Susan sobbing)

(somber piano music)

- It's just like the place at my house.

Couldn't get her to keep up. (sniffles)

- Teenagers.

You know, she didn't get the chance to be a teenager.

She didn't get the chance to do anything.

- You know this is gonna sound strange, Susan;

but I think she's at peace.

- Peace?

What are you talking about?

She was shot in cold blood by a maniac.

She died terrified and afraid.

What's peaceful about that?

- With not what happened, Susan.

I'm talkin' now.

- Pastor Reichart stop by here, too?

I never took you for the kind that listen to that stuff.

- It wasn't Pastor Reichart;

it was something else.

I don't know that I believe in

all of this afterlife/Heaven thing,

you know, but I was just--

- Searching?

- Yeah, searching.

- I understand.

Jim?

- [Jim] Yeah.

- What happened?

I mean between us.

- God Susan, I don't know.

I've been tryin' to figure out a lotta things lately.

- Couldn't it have just been eazy?

- I never expected it to be easy.

- Doesn't have to be so hard.

- Right?

Exactly.

They never tell you how hard marriage is gonna be

or bein' a parent or just life in general.

I just wish I could've been better.

- Better what?

- A better husband, a better father.

Just a better man, period.

- You can't blame yourself for everything, Jimmy.

It's not your fault.

(Jimmy sniffling)

What's this?

- Susan, why are you here?

- What?

- Did you just come to reminisce

or talk about old times or somethin'?

- Maybe because a part of her is still here.

I mean I'm just sittin' here in her room.

I think to myself that she's gonna walk

through that door any minute.

Tell me all about her day. (weeps)

I could smell her, Jimmy.

I can feel her in here.

I mean I know she's not here, but yes.

Yes, she is.

I think a part of her will always be here. (sniffles)

You know after the funeral, I went back to my house

and I went into her room at my place.

I sat in her bed and I cried.

I buried my head in her pillow when I cried.

I could smell her, Jimmy.

I thought to myself, this pillow's only a year old.

I sit in here, this.

This is her.

This is her whole life.

I guess needed to just be here.

- I don't know.

I don't know what it is.

Where'd you find it?

- It was in her dresser.

She told me to go get it before I--

- What?

- I don't know, I just remembered from earlier.

- Were you expecting someone?

- What? - You asked if I was her.

Were you expecting someone?

- No.

I mean, yeah.

It's just been a really weird day, Susan.

- I know.

I can't believe she's gone either.

Maybe I should go.

- No wait, wait.

Did Brittany ever talk to you about her Christianity?

- Yeah, she went to Revival

a few months ago with her friend.

Said that's when it happened.

- Did you ever talk to her about it?

- No, but that didn't stop her from tellin' me.

- What did she say?

- Oh you know, just the same old stuff

they always fill their heads with.

Ask and ye shall receive, seek and ye shall find.

That kinda stuff.

- Did you ever believe any of it?

- Any of that religious stuff?

I don't know, not really.

I haven't really seen anything

that would make me believe in it.

And now with this,

I don't believe that.

You know, I should go.

(somber piano music)

Thank you. (stammers)

Do you mind? - No.

No, I don't mind.

- Thank you.

I just wanted to say thank you, Jim.

I needed, you know.

- Yeah, I know.

Don't worry about it.

You gonna be okay?

- You know if you ever need

someone to talk to that you could...

Well, you know.

- Yeah, I know.

- Maybe she wanted you to open it.

Maybe that's why she put it in your head.

("I Cry Out" by Eric Ashby)

♪ When loss and tragedy comes ♪

♪ And my heart and soul just wants to burn ♪

♪ And nothing is all on earth ♪

♪ Can get me through ♪

♪ Through the storm ♪

♪ I cry out to you Lord ♪

♪ I cry out and give my plea ♪

♪ Can you rescue me ♪

♪ And it's from your love ♪

♪ An infinite grace ♪

♪ That I find mercy in your embrace ♪

♪ Your embrace ♪

♪ I cry out to you Lord ♪

♪ Whoa ♪

♪ You rescue me ♪

♪ And it's from your love and infinite grace ♪

♪ That I find mercy in your embrace ♪

♪ Your embrace ♪

♪ Ooh ♪

- No.

No,

that's impossible!

- [Messenger] The impossible happens all the time;

you just have to believe that it can.

- Who are you?

- I'm The Third of the three.

- [Jim] The Third?

Now I know my father and I know Brittany.

But I don't know you.

Have I seen you before?

- That's exactly why I'm here, Jim.

'Cause there's a lotta people you don't know.

Think you know of them, think you know about them,

but you don't know them.

- But you look familiar to me.

- You see me as someone from your past,

but you don't know who I speak for.

- Well then please enlighten me

because I have no idea what's goin' on.

- He was smiling with his arms wide open

like was waiting for a hug or something.

- You're him?

You're Jesus?

- No Jim, I'm not.

I am but a messenger on his behalf.

- So you're real?

Jesus is real?

- Do I look real to you?

- I don't know.

I don't know anything anymore.

I don't know what's real and what's not.

- There are times when our eyes deceive us.

Sometimes we need to look with our hearts.

- I don't know what any of that means.

I don't know what any of this means.

- You have been sayin' the same thing for a long time,

wonderin' if he's real or not.

And people come up with their own conclusions

based on all sorts of things.

- Maybe if you'd make it so people could see you,

then maybe it would be easier for 'em.

- Jim, you can see him anytime you want.

You can see him in the birds in the sky,

in smile on a baby's face, in nature, in love.

He's everywhere.

- That's not what I'm talkin' about.

I mean, I went to Sunday School.

You know, I read about Moses and the burning bush

and Moses in Mount Sinai.

I mean he was there, he was visible.

He was right there in front of them.

- You ever been to China, Jim?

- No.

- But you know people that have.

- Yeah.

- You ever flown in outer space?

- No.

- But you got to meet Jim Adams a few years ago, right?

He's been to space.

- Yeah, how did you?

Yeah.

- There's a lot of things you haven't seen

and a lotta places you've never been,

but do you ever doubt there's a China?

Do you ever doubt that the world isn't really round?

You never seen any of these things with your own eyes,

but there's so much evidence

from people have done these things that they must be true.

Even though you haven't personally experienced them,

you accept them as true.

You believe even though you haven't seen them.

- That's different.

- Is it?

Believing without seeing is what faith is all about.

When you got married, you didn't have a crystal ball

to tell you the future or when you had Brittany,

you didn't have a crystal ball then either.

Did you believe you could successfully be married

or successfully have a child?

You did or you wouldn't have done either of these things.

Will you ultimately be successful?

Do you know that?

No, you don't.

But with faith in him and faith in yourself,

that what you can't see are still things

you can put your faith and confidence in.

- The marriage thing didn't turn out too well

for any of us, did it?

- [Messenger] Why do you think that is?

- I don't know.

I mean I guess she just wasn't who I thought she was

or the one I wanted.

I musta not been what she wanted.

- D'you feel like you really tried?

- Tried?

Man, that's all we did.

We went to counseling.

We talked to our friends.

We spent time apart.

We even called on our pastor

just to see what he would say about it.

- But you didn't talk to him; neither of you did.

- What?

- You didn't bring it to him.

So many times people think they can solve the problems

of the world by lookin' to the world for a solution.

But in a flawed world, your solutions can be flawed.

- Well at least it's an answer.

I mean people talk to Jesus all the time

and never get an answer.

- Just because it isn't the answer they want to hear,

it doesn't mean he doesn't answer.

You know how many times people pray

for what they want and how they want it?

Never take into consideration what they're praying for

is what they truly need.

They don't trust that he knows

what they need when they need it.

- Trust?

When we can't even see if Jesus

is gonna come through for us, you want us to trust in him?

- That right there is the very definition of faith.

- So why can't he just answer?

Why can't he just be heard?

- If everyone got everything they prayed for or asked for,

what would be the point of Heaven?

We've already established that the world is a sinful place.

And if the world was everything that Heaven is,

what would be the appeal of eternity?

Jim, salvation doesn't mean that everything in life

is gonna be great and easy and that you won't face

any trials and tribulations.

Salvation gives you a destination

once you face the trials and tribulations of the world.

- So we're just meant to suffer?

We're supposed to just suffer through this life

until we get to Heaven.

- The most worthwhile things in life require faith.

If you knew all the variables and never risked anything,

there would never be rewards.

If people never took a chance, there would be no success.

Now there might be less pain and failure,

but for sure there'd be no success.

And no success means failure and it's painful.

There are things in life that you simply

have to depend on faith.

There's a difference between knowing and believing.

Knowing is based on exhaustive knowledge.

But believing, it's putting your faith in something

with virtually no knowledge.

- Like the guy who didn't believe

that Jesus rose from the dead.

- Thomas?

Yes, he believed once he saw.

- So why can't you show me a miracle?

Show me a miracle, then I'll believe.

You bring Brittany back and I'll believe you.

- These are things that people have been dealing with

for a long time.

If believing isn't seeing, then faith is not seeing.

- Riddles.

Why do you all always talk in riddles?

Why can't things just be good or bad, right or wrong?

- If everything was always good,

would you really be able to appreciate

the majesty of eternity

or the greatness of what awaits you after this life?

- So I'm supposed to thank him.

Thank him for all of this, praising through the suffering?

You don't know this kind of pain.

- But he does.

He knows suffering, Jim.

- Yeah, the cross.

- No, not just the cross.

It's the pain associated with seeing something

you truly love turn away from him: humanity.

You lost Brittany to an evil man.

He's lost generations of Brittanys to the evil of man.

(mystical music)

Good afternoon, sir.

Can I ask you a question?

D'you know where you're going to spend eternity?

(door clanking)

- That was you?

- I told you.

I can be everywhere.

- Okay.

If you are who you say you are

and you say Jesus is who he is

and you all can be everywhere at any time,

then why didn't you stop it?

Why didn't you stop the shooting?

- Ah, the eternal question: why do bad things happen?

- I think that's a fair question, yeah.

- Sin's a terrible thing, Jim.

And it's prevalent everywhere in your society today.

Unfortunately, a lot of it gets passed off

as political correctness;

but I can assure you much of it is still sin.

When something like this happens,

the first question people ask believers is

where was God when this happened?

It's an easy excuse.

- Well, I can't blame 'em.

I've asked the same thing.

- You wanna know why he didn't get involved

when the bad things happened here?

At the same time, no one wants to admit

to that which is evident of him.

But here's the thing: He does get involved

with everything that goes on here, good and bad.

It's not that he allows it to happen;

it's that he allows people to make their own choices,

good and bad.

- No father should have to bury his own child.

And today, I had to lower my daughter's body

into a hole in the ground.

- You know what else you did today?

You finished the process of giving her to him.

She gave herself to him a few months ago,

but today her time on earth was finished.

You asked me a lotta questions today

and I've given you all the answers,

even the ones you didn't want to hear.

But why don't you ask the question

that you really wanna know, the real reason why I'm here?

- Alright fine, you want the question?

Why her?

Why an 11 year old girl?

She didn't even get a chance to live!

At least it could've been me.

I've already lived at least for some.

You want a question?

That's my question; why her?!

- Are you sure you want an explanation?

D'you really want to know why innocents suffer?

'Cause I don't think you do.

I think you're far better off with the than the answer.

- More riddles.

- What if you finally got an answer?

What if I gave you a satisfactory explanation?

What if the mystery were solved?

What if you asked why and actually got an answer?

- Well I don't know,

then maybe all of this would make sense.

- If this question were answered,

then you would be able to make peace

with the suffering of innocents.

Worse than innocent people suffering

is others watching the suffering unmoved

and that's exactly what would happen.

You'd no longer be bothered by their cries.

You would no longer feel their pain

'cause you'd know why it was happening.

If ya had an explanation, the pain wouldn't seem so bad

and you could tolerate the suffering

because you would know why it was happening.

- Well then what am I supposed to do?

- Look to him.

Don't look to the world to help to take your pain away

'cause the world can't do that, only Jesus can.

- So then everything just gets better?

- No, salvation doesn't excuse you

from the pain and suffering.

Salvation gives you a destination

after you've endured the pain and suffering.

Brittany knew this.

She knew this despite everything

that was going on around her,

and she knew where she was going.

- So she's in eternity?

That's what she mentioned.

That's where she's at.

- She is and she's waiting.

She's waiting for you.

- You mean I can see her?

- Yes.

Mankind is always saying that seeing is believing

and I'm telling you, you got to believe in order to see.

- I wanna believe,

but it's just been so long since I had him.

I just don't know if I can believe anymore.

I just,

I can't.

- You can.

In all that you been searching for and longing for

can't be found here on earth.

It can only be found through him, though salvation.

- I'm just so tired.

I am tired of fighting.

I'm tired of failing.

- Of falling?

- Yeah.

Can you take that away?

- I can't, but he can and you can rest, Jim.

You can rest in him and you don't have to be afraid.

You can stop being afraid.

You heard from your dad, now listen to your real father.

- [Brittany] He saved me, daddy.

I was scared, really scared.

I was lost.

He saved me.

- I miss her so bad

and I didn't even get to say goodbye.

- I know.

I know all that and it's not too late.

- I need.

I need.

- He knows what you need.

He knows everything.

What you need is him in your heart.

- Then just take it then.

Take away the hurt; take away the pain.

I'm tired of carryin' this with me.

Please, just take it.

- Rest in him, Jim.

- I have no idea what I'm doing

and they say that you are the one

that can relieve me of this pain.

♪ When life is not all that I hoped it would be ♪

♪ And my vision is so cloudy I can't see ♪

- If this is what it takes, then this is what I wanna give.

♪ Ooh so broken I fall to my knees ♪

- I'm sorry for the sin in my life.

I'm sorry for all the trouble I've caused.

♪ You rescue me ♪

♪ And it's from your love ♪

- If you'll just forgive me.

♪ That I find mercy in your embrace ♪

♪ Your embrace ♪

- (weeps) I can't do this on my own.

I can't do this on my own.

♪ And my heart and soul just wants to mourn ♪

♪ And nothing in all on earth ♪

- I need you in my heart.

I need you to guide me.

♪ I cry out to you Lord ♪

♪ I cry out ♪

♪ You hear my plea ♪

♪ You rescue me ♪

♪ And it's from your love and infinite grace ♪

♪ That I find mercy in your embrace ♪

- You've come back.

- What?

What are you staring at?

What?

Why are you staring at me?

What?!

- Okay I get it, Brit.

I understand.

- Okay?

- I'm just so glad you're back.

I didn't think I would ever see you again.

- Back?

Back from where?

Dad, what are you talking about?

- Back from there.

Back from him.

I mean I can understand why you wouldn't wanna come back.

I mean it's gotta be unbelievable.

- Dad, you're kinda freaking me out.

- Look, it all makes sense now.

I understand.

- I gotta go.

- Wait a minute, go?

- I gotta go or I'll be late.

- Go where?

- I gotta go to school.

See ya in two weeks. - Wait wait wait.

Just a minute, honey.

- Dad.

- Look, he's given me a second chance.

- I'm gonna miss my bus, what?

- He's given me a second chance to make it right.

- I'm not gonna make it to school, dad.

- You're here with me right now, okay?

And he's given me another chance to make this right.

- My bus.

- Don't worry about the bus, okay?

Don't worry about anything.

Hold on.

- [Dispatcher] 911, what's your emergency?

- Yeah I need to report something, a shooting.

- [Dispatcher] Report what, sir?

What's the emergency?

- There's a shooting at Liberty Middle School.

- [Dispatcher] There's a shooter at the school?

Are you at the school, sir?

- No, I'm not there.

The shooting hasn't happened yet, but it's going to.

- [Dispatcher] Sir, are you--

- Just get someone to the school now!

- Dad, what's going on?

- Hold on, hold on.

(inspirational piano music)

- [Brittany] What are you doing with that?

- Oh I'm sorry, honey.

I'm just so proud of you, you know?

- Whatever.

You gotta drive me to school.

- Yeah.

You know what?

We're gonna take the day off together.

- What?

- You're not gonna go to school

and I'm not gonna go to work.

- No school? - No school.

- Fine with me.

- You know what else, Brit?

Every day I promise you, you're gonna know

how much I love you.

Every day from here on out.

I love you.

So you wanna go get some breakfast?

- I'd like that, daddy.

Then maybe we can go rock climbing?

- Yeah, yeah sure.

Let's call your mom and see if she wants to go.

- As a family? - Sure, as a family.

("Stay" by Jeff Kunzel)

♪ Stay ♪

♪ With me ♪

♪ Just stay with me ♪

♪ Don't leave ♪

♪ Don't leave ♪

♪ You don't have to go ♪

♪ I'll be waitin' on those stairs ♪

♪ We don't have to turn (mumbles) ♪

♪ What will (mumbles) ♪

♪ Just stay ♪

♪ With me ♪

♪ Stay with me ♪

♪ Don't leave ♪

♪ Don't leave ♪

♪ Just stay ♪

♪ With me ♪

♪ Just stay with me ♪

♪ Don't leave ♪

♪ Don't leave ♪

♪ I know that you'll stay ♪

♪ I know life can be that way ♪

♪ I know the demons that you facin' now ♪

♪ I face mine every day ♪

♪ So why don't you stay ♪